OPINIONS
THURSDAY
april 4, 2013
PAGE 5
the daily orange
IDE AS
technology
Hacking for public benefit valid initiative, but masks policy problems
A
s hacktivists and open-data advocates continue to find themselves on the wrong side of the law, the idea of “civic hacking” aims to redirect young programmers away from breaking things and toward rebuilding them. Code for America has deemed itself a kind of “Peace Corps for Geeks.” The fellowships program, which uses technology to solve infrastructural issues, closed its application process on March 31 for city governments seeking to take advantage of the program. Cities that apply for the fellowships would be assigned a team of programmers, developers and designers for one year that would then devise creative solutions for the problems facing the area. One project that fellowship developers launched was the BlightStatus site in New Orleans. This site allows citizens to see blighted properties in the area in order to help the city rebuild. While it sounds nice to program for the public good, it will be difficult to convince young programmers it’s worth working for a nonprofit when the private sector can offer a much more lucrative salary. Projects like Code for America can also seem like a potential waste of money, as there are some problems facing our cities that technology can’t actually solve. Apps aren’t magic wands, and pouring more taxpayers’ dollars into technology that few will use doesn’t seem like the right answer to more complex problems like obesity or growing crime rates. But at least it’s a start. Code for America is working with other nonprofit groups, like Random Hacks of Kindness and Rally for Impact, to sponsor the governmental initiative, “The National Day of Civic Hacking.” The event is scheduled to take place nationwide from June 1-2 in a bid to coax techies away from the dark side of hacktivism. The initiative will attract more than 15,000 participants at about 67 locations using “publically-released data, code and technology to solve challenges relevant to our neighborhoods, our cities, our states and our country,” according to the official website, hackforchange.org. The irony in this little branch of the
News Editor Editorial Editor Sports Editor Feature Editor Presentation Director Photo Editor Copy Chief Art Director Development Editor Enterprise Editor Social Media Producer Video Editor Web Developer Asst. News Editor Asst. News Editor Asst. News Editor Asst. Feature Editor
Casey Fabris Rachael Barillari Chris Iseman Chelsea DeBaise Lizzie Hart Chase Gaewski Maddy Berner Micah Benson Dara McBride Debbie Truong Danielle Odiamar Allie Berube Chris Voll Nicki Gorny Jessica Iannetta Meredith Newman Claire Dunderman
K AT SMITH
virtually real hope and change rhetoric is that the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act has allowed for an overbroad definition of what the government considers to be criminal activity in the digital world. Therefore, those who join these kinds of “good guy” initiatives may do so more out of fear of prosecution than unflinching support for the public good. If government officials were really concerned about transparency, they would be less concerned with public relations initiatives like “The National Day of Civic Hacking” and more focused on changing overbroad policies like the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. This act has allowed government officials to decide at whim which kinds of public application programming interfaces are considered criminal or not. In addition, the act allows the government to trap anyone who might “exceed authorized access” to a computer. This ambiguous statement has been used to prosecute open-data activists like Aaron Swartz. Hackers are being seen as vigilantes committed to civil disobedience, when many are just dynamic problem-solvers looking to participate in the systems that affect our lives. The point of a democracy is that all citizens should have a say in the decisions that affect their lives, and gaining more access to data that is already publically available will help us become active participants in a healthy government. Our governmental processes are evolving and, in an age where surveillance within a police state seems like an inevitable reality, we must continue to protect our rights. Kat Smith is a senior creative advertising major. Her column appears weekly. She can be reached at kesmit11@syr.edu, on Twitter at @WhateverKat or by telepathy, if possible.
Asst. Feature Editor Asst. Sports Editor Asst. Sports Editor Asst. Photo Editor Asst. Photo Editor Design Editor Design Editor Design Editor Design Editor Design Editor Design Editor Asst. Copy Editor Asst. Copy Editor Asst. Copy Editor Asst. Copy Editor Asst. Copy Editor Asst. Copy Editor
Kristin Ross Jacob Klinger David Wilson Sam Maller Luke Rafferty Marwa Eltagouri Beth Fritzinger Becca McGovern Ankur Patankar Cheryl Seligman Michelle Sczpanski Phil D’Abbraccio Avery Hartmans Trevor Hass Joe Infantino Brendan Krisel Dylan Segelbaum
SCRIBBLE
SU community united by Orange success Syracuse’s trip to the Final Four for the first time in a decade brings an electrifying buzz to our campus that no one can ignore. This Saturday, when Syracuse plays Michigan in Atlanta, almost every Syracuse University student will become a basketball fan. Some of us have dreamed of this moment since 2003, when we watched Carmelo Anthony bring the Orange to victory on television screens in our parents’ living rooms. It became the reason many of us came to SU. And for newer fans who found their love for the Orange and school spirit after first setting foot on campus, this time prevails as a reason for pride and celebration. In a matter of weeks, a team arguably less talented than last season’s and cast off by many has brought the university together as a community of individuals united by faith in the team.
EDITORIAL by the daily orange editorial board The team has instilled a sense of pride and camaraderie here in Syracuse that everyone should be grateful for, as it has made this weekend about more than purely basketball. The Syracuse basketball program has found itself in the national spotlight for more than a year for off-the-court reasons, from the allegations surrounding former associate head coach Bernie Fine to issues with academic eligibility. Now, the team is being recognized for their prowess in reaching the pinnacle of the sport. As a community, we need to appreciate the rarity of a team making it this far in the tournament, especially in the face of much adversity. Though SU is a consistently strong team with a
t h e i n de pe n de n t s t u de n t n e w spa pe r of s y r acuse , n e w yor k
Mark Cooper EDITOR IN CHIEF
Laurence Leveille MANAGING EDITOR
General Manager Peter Waack IT Director Mike Escalante IT Assistant Alec Coleman Advertising Manager William Leonard Advertising Representative Jeanne Cloyd Advertising Representative Mike Friedman Advertising Representative Carolina Garcia Advertising Representative Emily Myers Advertising Representative Elaina Powless Advertising Representative Paula Vallina
rich basketball history, entering the tournament as a No. 4 seed and rising to the top makes Syracuse’s run a memorable surprise. On campus, we the students have become part of a legacy only we can truly know and share. Here in Syracuse, we unite with friends, fellow students and community members. The campus will reflect for years on the joy and excitement brought here by a team on a Final Four run. At this stressful time in the academic year for many, the Final Four game has become an ideal outlet. Let yourself get swept away in the excitement this weekend, whether you’re watching from a Marshall Street bar or a residence hall. Though we can’t all be in Atlanta, the campus is buzzing. It might be the best place to watch a potentially historic game.
Advertising Representative Sam Weinberg Digital Sales Representative Ruitong Zhou Special Sections Coordinator Runsu Huang Advertising Design Manager Abby Legge Advertising Designer Olivia Accardo Advertising Intern Gonzalo Garcia Business Intern Tim Bennett Circulation Manager Harold Heron Circulation Alexander Bush Circulation Chris Freeman Circulation Alexandra Koskoris Circulation Matt LaFlair Circulation Arianna Rogers Circulation Suzanne Sirianni Circulation Charis Slue Job Coach/Circulation Charlie Plumpton Street Team Captain Justice Jones