12/5/12
In L’Aquila, Italy, Lessons for Rebuilding From Storm - NYTimes.com
HOME PAGE
TODAY'S PAPER
VIDEO
Subscribe to Home Delivery
U.S. Edition
MOST POPULAR
U.S.
N.Y. / REGION
BUSINESS
TECHNOLOGY
ART & DESIGN
BOOKS
SCIENCE DANCE
HEALTH
MOVIES
MUSIC
Help
Search All NYTimes.com
Art & Design WORLD
cross3...
SPORTS
OPINION
TELEVISION
ARTS
THEATER
CRITIC’S NOTEBOOK
STYLE
TRAVEL
VIDEO GAMES
JOBS
AUTOS
EVENTS
Log in to see what your friends are sharing on nytimes.com. Privacy Policy | What’s This?
In Italian Ruins, New York Lessons
REAL ESTATE
Log In With Facebook
What’s Popular Now Despite Bob Dole’s Wish, Republicans Reject Disabilities Treaty
Jewish Congregation Applauds U.N. Vote on Palestine
Samuele Pellecchia/Prospekt, for The New York Times
Repubblica square in L'Aquila, Italy, after the earthquake in 2009. By MICHAEL KIMMELMAN Published: November 30, 2012
L’Aquila, capital of Abruzzo, in central Italy, is a long way from the Rockaways and Staten Island, but its struggle to recover from an earthquake may provide a cautionary tale for New York, postHurricane Sandy.
FACEBOOK TWITTER GOOGLE+ SAVE
Connect With Us on Twitter Follow @nytimesarts for arts and entertainment news.
Arts Twitter List: Critics, Reporters and Editors
A sortable calendar of noteworthy cultural events in the New York region, selected by Times critics. Go to Event Listings » Enlarge This Image
Get DealBook by EMail Sign up for the latest financial news delivered before the opening bell and after the market close.
cross3@sva.edu
Change Email Address | Privacy Policy That earthquake, in April 2009, killed EMAIL hundreds and left tens of thousands SHARE of L’Aquilans homeless, shuttering the PRINT city’s graceful and extensive historic REPRINTS center, which was its cultural and MOST EMAILED MOST VIEWED economic heart. “Temporary” housing 1. To Stop Climate Change, Students Aim at was constructed: “new towns,” as College Portfolios Italy’s prime minister then, Silvio MORE IN ART & DESIGN (11 OF 50 ARTICLES) Berlusconi, boasted about the sad, 2. Removing ‘Sacrifice’ From ‘GlutenFree’ Museum Review: Bursting With isolated, cramped and costly Science, Some of It Unsettling apartments he ordered for displaced L’Aquilans along Read More » nowhere stretches of the city’s outskirts, cut off from mass 3. Cheering U.N. Palestine Vote, Synagogue Tests Its Members transit and civic life. There was no infrastructure created or public consensus reached about combating sprawl, or what 4. OPINION to save or sacrifice and how.
New Love: A Short Shelf Life
Since then Italian officials have kept promising to restore the city to its former self, but fewer than a dozen buildings have so far been repaired among the hundreds damaged in
www.nytimes.com/2012/12/01/arts/design/in-laquila-italy-lessons-for-rebuilding-from-storm.html?ref=d…
5.
DRAFT
The Art of Being Still
1/4
12/5/12
In L’Aquila, Italy, Lessons for Rebuilding From Storm - NYTimes.com
the center, which is a virtual ghost town. Never a tourist mecca, despite its pretty churches and squares, L’Aquila was a working town of some 75,000, home to a university and to many families with local roots dating back to the Middle Ages.
6. Pushing Science’s Limits in Sign Language Lexicon
These days, tourists arrive to gawk at the rubble. Ruin porn has become the new local industry.
7.
BOOMING
A sign of progress came in October, when President Giorgio Napolitano arrived for the opening of a new concert hall designed by Renzo Piano in a park in central L’Aquila, one of the few urban initiatives since the quake. Mr. Napolitano criticized the “new towns” for diverting attention and resources from the primary challenge of returning life to the city center.
8.
WELL
Robert Stolarik for The New York Times
Hurricane Sandy caused major flooding and fires which burned nearly a hundred homes in Breezy Point Queens.
The regional government has now gained control over recovery efforts from a succession of failed authorities in Rome. But magical thinking remains a problem for residents and politicians, as usual after a disaster, while memories of the quake are fading outside the region.
When They’re Grown, the Real Pain Begins
For Athletes, Risks From Ibuprofen Use
9. Study Raises Questions on Coating of Aspirin 10. For Second Opinion, Consult a Computer?
Go to Complete List »
Show My Recommendations
What’s the relevance for the New York area? Notwithstanding the need for big change and straight talk in the face of hard science about rising sea levels and increasing storms, public officials have mostly followed the Italians’ lead, promising devastated homeowners to reconstitute ravaged neighborhoods in harm’s way. They have all but conceded that a policy of retreat and relocation is a political impossibility. I’ve gone to L’Aquila several times since the quake, the first a couple of days after it struck, most recently before the opening ceremony for Mr. Piano’s hall, to see it under construction and to speak with residents and the city’s planning chief, Pietro Di Stefano. “We went into a labyrinth of the absurd,” he told me. “We needed a new plan.” Then he talked about retrofitting a few buildings here and there in the city center. He seemed resigned to the futility of arguing for the demolition of homes and for new construction while owners were still petitioning the state for money. That didn’t sound like much of a plan to me. I mentioned Mr. Piano’s project. Conceived by the architect and his friend Claudio Abbado, the conductor, as a way to bring some culture and night life back to the center, the 240seat concert hall links multicolored cubes, pavilions made of spruce from Trent, the northern Italian province that sponsored the project. (The hall was not quite finished for the opening ceremony and, as so often happens in Italy, was shut right afterward. There are supposedly plans to finish it and organize concerts next year.) An anomaly in L’Aquila’s historic city, the hall was partly engineered as a prototype for the sort of recyclable, quakeresistant wood construction that could handsomely and cheaply replace damaged stone houses in the center, so people might finally move back there. Per square foot, the hall cost a fourth of what the “new towns” did.
Ads by Google
what's this?
Experienced Architects Professional Architectural Services Design & Construction Services
www.ArchitectsRule.com
At the suggestion of wood buildings, Mr. Di Stefano stiffened. He started to pet the nearest stone building as if it were the family Labrador. “Impossible,” he said. “This is a city of stone,” he insisted. “These homes were built by families here over hundreds of years, and they have their histories. What would Florence be without Giotto, or Pisa without the tower? The buildings are who we are.” Is a city the assortment of its buildings or the life that happens in and around them? L’Aquila has fine architecture, including Baroque churches and early20thcentury Rationalist office blocks. These could be retrofitted and reopened, and a couple already have been. But it is really the public spaces — the streets and piazzas — that make the city
www.nytimes.com/2012/12/01/arts/design/in-laquila-italy-lessons-for-rebuilding-from-storm.html?ref=d…
2/4
12/5/12
In L’Aquila, Italy, Lessons for Rebuilding From Storm - NYTimes.com
special. Officials charged with saving the center, fixated on buildings instead of urbanism, seem not to realize this, and let L’Aquila die a little more each day. And so now, in the main square, old men gather on sunny mornings, driving from miles away. They stroll the main street, as they did before the quake, then scatter by day’s end to their farflung new homes. Antonio Antonacci, a retired lawyer, chatted in the empty Piazza Duomo with three friends when I stopped by. “It’s still the only city center we have,” he told me. New Yorkers aren’t particularly married to old stone houses. The city has a history of audacity and adaptability. Both have fueled the region’s prosperity. But heedless planning in the last century has also made many people skeptical about largescale infrastructural change. That said, some stormravaged New York homeowners have already made known that they’re contemplating resettling in safer neighborhoods, and Shaun Donovan, the United States secretary of housing, whom President Obama appointed to spearhead federal relief efforts after Hurricane Sandy, seems open to big ideas. A calamity can also be an opportunity, for ambitious politicians, and not least for a secondterm president, now liberated to think decades ahead. Although L’Aquila may be unlike New York in most crucial ways, its last few years suggest that a disaster doesn’t just destroy homes and take lives. It tests a city’s, and a nation’s, imagination and capacity to change. Follow Michael Kimmelman on Twitter, @kimmelman. A version of this article appeared in print on December 1, 2012, on page C1 of the New York edition with the headline: In Italian Ruins, New York Lessons. SAVE
EMAIL
SHARE
Get Free Email Alerts on These Topics Earthquakes
L'Aquila (Italy)
Area Planning and Renewal
Hurricane Sandy (2012)
Ads by Google
what's this?
Nikon Official Site Buy Direct from Nikon for Huge Savings on Cameras, Lenses & More!
www.NikonUSA.com
INSIDE NYTIMES.COM DINING & WINE »
OPINION »
HEALTH »
BOOKS »
OPINION »
U.S. »
Editorial: Rigging the Financial System
GlutenFree Dishes Become More Tempting
Invitation to a Dialogue: How to Treat A.D.H.D.
For Athletes, Risks from Ibuprofen Use
Professor Who Learns From Peasants
Will authorities really hold banks and bankers accountable for manipulating interest rates?
www.nytimes.com/2012/12/01/arts/design/in-laquila-italy-lessons-for-rebuilding-from-storm.html?ref=d…
Penn Museum Pushes for Broader Public Appeal
3/4
12/5/12 © 2012 The New York Times Company
In L’Aquila, Italy, Lessons for Rebuilding From Storm - NYTimes.com Site Map
Privacy
Your Ad Choices
Advertise
Terms of Sale
Terms of Service
Work With Us
www.nytimes.com/2012/12/01/arts/design/in-laquila-italy-lessons-for-rebuilding-from-storm.html?ref=d…
RSS
Help
Contact Us
Site Feedback
4/4