FIRST JAPAN’S COAL PLANTS UNDER RENEWED SCRUTINY

Japan remains the third largest importer of coal.

Japanese policy remains keen on ensuring long-term energy security and competitively priced hydrocarbons imports with coal fitting the bill for decades, according to APAC Energy Buzz by Wood Mackenzie Asia Pacific Vice Chair, Gavin Thompson. This follows on from a report that the Japanese government is planning to suspend many of its least efficient coal plants by 2030.

Japan today remains the world’s third largest importer of coal. Wood Mackenzie’s Dr. Frank Yu noted that there has been no formal change to the existing policy announced, and its achievability and whether it would really represent a U-turn on coal should be considered.

The speculation around what plants may be closed has been focused on Japan’s pre-1995 coal-fired fleet but it is more likely that all lower efficiency plants could be targeted, the report said. This shows a significant proportion of the current mix, with around 24GW of currently operating coal plants being considered as "low efficiency" plants.

Should these plants close by 2030, then Japan’s power mix has little option but to become more reliant on nuclear and imported liquefied natural gas (LNG). ‘Lost’ coal generation could reach around 160 TWh by 2030 whilst nuclear would have to be increased and gas would fill most of the resultant gap.

By 2030, up to an additional 13 Mt of LNG could be required to help fill the gap. Any issue with nuclear restarts and LNG demand could be higher still and will inevitably push generation costs up significantly.

Japan is also expected to build over 50GW of renewables capacity out to 2030, including a major increase in offshore wind. However, high costs in Japan could make an accelerated rampup challenging.

Despite this, Thompson noted that Japan is one of the few countries in the G20 that continues to develop new coal-fired power plants. Around 6.1GW of ultra-supercritical and integrated gasification combined cycle coal plants are currently under construction.

Higher operational efficiencies, paired with a significant volume of newer units, would clearly support a continued role for coal in Japan’s power mix. This would also allow the government to continue to push towards its existing 2030 targets to reduce the share of coal in the energy mix to around 25%.

With a mature economy and falling population, Japan’s carbon emissions in the longterm are slated to decline, but are still not falling quickly enough to meet the country’s Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) under the Paris Agreement. Japan’s NDC goal is to reduce emissions by 26% below 2013 level by 2030. This target is unlikely to be met without a significant and sustained shift in the energy mix towards zero-carbon energy.

Thompson adds that a more aggressive push to close ageing and less efficient plants would mean Japan will have to ramp up gas, nuclear and renewables, but at what pace and what magnitude of switching remains unclear and would be determined by the timing of plant closures. This would come at huge cost and is likely to also face acute opposition from Japanese industries.

xxx Reliance on coal has led to price surges

Asian Power talked to YTL Power International The Philippines could see cheaper electricity prices Berhad’s CEO Tan Sri Francis Yeoh about the and a more competitive and reliable power sector company’s largest projects. in a post-pandemic era, if it switched its reliance on coal power for renewables and if the country Tell us about the company’s most stellar could create a transition plan through auctions, power projects to date and where they are according to an Institute for Energy Economics located. and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) report. At present, we are constructing the first oil shale The report found that the focus on baseload mine mouth power plant with a capacity of 2 x coal and reliance on imported fuel have led to 235 MW (net) utilising the circulating fluidised price surges for consumers that can only be bed boilers (CFB) technology in the Hashemite tempered if force majeure is invoked. Without Kingdom of Jordan. The project is located at force majeure, per kilowatt-hour rates would rise Attarat um Guhdran which is 110 km southeast of Amman. At a total investment of US$2.1b, it is the largest private sector project in Jordan to date 15% in Luzon and 5% in the Visayas. IEEFA’s energy finance analyst Sara Jane Ahmed explained that, although Meralco and is expected to meet 15% of Jordan’s annual attributed the recent electricity instability to a electricity demand. Attarat Power Company spike in residential power consumption due (APCO) which is the project company has entered to rising temperatures, it may have instead into a 30-year Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) been due to an over-reliance on intractable with the Jordanian national utility and single fossil fuel plants that are not flexible enough to buyer, NEPCO for the sale of the entire electric meet consumer needs. Ahmed suggested that capacity and net electrical output. The other the Department of Finance and the National project we are currently developing is in Cirebon Economic Development Authority could push Regency, West Java, Indonesia. The 2 x 660 MW for an economic recovery by strengthening the (net) coal-fired power plant will utilise state-ofcountry’s electricity market with efficient new the-art ultra-supercritical technology. The project renewable energy technologies, whilst reducing company, PT Tanjung Jati Power Company has the cost of electricity. executed a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) IEEFA recommended reforms, such as modular with PT PLN (Persero) in December 2015. We systems/grid upgrades, implementing the Green are always on the lookout for new opportunities Energy Tariff, a moratorium on new inflexible in generation whether it is bidding for existing power, expediting the launch of Energy Virtual assets or investing in new projects. One-Stop Shops, and introducing competition.

The increasing viability of the technology as looking to batteries and large-scale storage facilities a complement to renewable energy has seen as a long-term solution. Green hydrogen would be substantial growth opportunities for the green a viable alternative as it can act as a form of energy hydrogen sector in Australia over the coming years, storage for excess renewables generation. according to a report from Fitch Solutions. The Furthermore, this could also be exported to other rapidly-falling costs of renewables is said to push markets, which would create additional demand production costs of hydrogen down and drive for renewables, unlocking more capacity growth adoption of the technology. previously bound by domestic market constraints.

As a result, Australia has a high potential to The development of clean hydrogen production, scale up the development of green hydrogen and an export hub and investments into R&D and reach cost parity given the growth in its renewables demonstration projects is also backed by funding capacity, which has already depressed electricity and support from the government on both the prices in recent years. Green hydrogen will also federal and state levels. support Australia’s ongoing renewables growth At present, Australia has one of the world’s momentum, particularly as the sector has become largest electrolyser pipelines, at over 11GW, which increasingly saturated. continues to expand.

Regulators have warned of grid stability problems Whilst most of these projects remain in if renewables capacity continues to increase the pre-construction/planning stages, Fitch’s substantially over the coming years. They have outlook remains bullish given ongoing progress mooted several different solutions but they all and continued support from the government, remain contentious. particularly as many states remain keen to support

The Australian Energy Market Operator is now renewables growth.