Good night Sleep tight rest in peace
We were born small, weak, and helpless
As we grow up, we begin to understand and appreciate life
Until the day we go back to sleep...
I
Table of Contents
II
I
Table of Contents
01
Introduction: Short Story
02
Phase 1: The Concept of Dying
05 06 08
Our Humble Beginning Life After Death Phase 2: A Good Death
10
Which One Would you choose?
12
What Defines a Good Death
14
After all, is death a bad thing?
16
Euthanasia Statistics
18
How long has it been
20
Dr. Jack Kevorkian’s Quote
22
Phase 3: Rest in Peace?
24 26 28
Where do we go? Where we say hello, is also where we say goodbye Bibliography
“ I’m not afraid of being dead. I’m just afraid of what you might have to go through to get there
“
- Pamela Bone
01
A
woman in her 70s was sitting anxiously in outside a hospital ward when a man in a white suit came out to break the news. The dainty woman leapt up from her seat in excitement as the dcotor gestured her to enter the hospital room. The room smells like lavender. There in the bed laid a woman in her thirties with a small fragile human being wrapped around her firm hands. The little human’s held her hands up against his chest. His little head emerged from underneath the soft fabric that bundled him up. With joy, the woman that held the baby handed him to the elderly woman. Now, she could feel the
The woman took some time to stare at the tightly shut little eyes of her grandson’s as she started contemplating. Unlike the newborn that just embraced life, the woman might not live any longer. The newborn embraced life, and before her eyes, she felt as if he’s taking the portions of life away from her. She’s going to let go her life anytime soon, while the newborn still has years to live on. Death will soon pick her up, uninvited. She is just counting down the days. Slowly, she leans down to her grandson’s ears and whispered. “Enjoy your life before death takes you away, the way it will for all of us.”
Phase 1
The Concept of Dying “No one can confidently say that he will still be living tomorrow.� - Euripides
04
05
Our humble beginning
L
et us say that vital pro-
gone. On the other it might be a
op or maintain themselves. These
cesses are those by which
momentary event. This event might
processes include chemosynthesis,
organisms develop or
be understood in three ways. First,
photosynthesis, cellular respiration,
maintain themselves. These
it might be the ending of the dying
cell generation, and maintenance of
processes include chemosynthesis,
process—the loss of the very last
homeostasis. Then death is the end-
photosynthesis, cellular respiration,
trace of life. Call this ‘denouement
ing of the vital processes by which
cell generation, and maintenance of
death’. Second, it might be the point
an organism sustains itself.
homeostasis. Then death is the end-
in the dying process when extinction
ing of the vital processes by which
is assured, no matter what is done
an organism sustains itself. However,
to stop it. Call this moment ‘threshold
life’s ending is one thing, and the
death’. Then death is the ending
condition of having life over is an-
of the vital processes by which an
other. ‘Death’ can refer to either.
organism sustains itself. However,
Let us add that ‘the ending of
life’s ending is one thing, and the
life’ is itself potentially ambiguous.
condition of having life over is an-
On one hand it might be a process
other. ‘Death’ can refer to either.
wherein our lives are progressively
...let us say that vital processes are
extinguished, until finally they are
those by which organisms devel-
06
Life after death? We - as human beings should be - are always curious. We always wonder what lies beyond what we see physically. Where do people go after they die? Religions or beliefs have been foundation of life to most people. Therefore we can say what our beliefs say about death have shaped the way we think about death in our own beliefs.
CHRISTIANITY Christianity believes in an afterlife in Heaven or Hell depending on one’s conduct on earth and belief or disbelief in God. The believers face death without fear and gain eternal life in Heaven in the presence of God. It is believed that the body itself is also a gift from God. Thus, it has to be celebrated and honored.
JUDAISM “All go unto one place; all are of the dust, and all turn to dust again.” While this implies there is no afterlife, another view appearing repeatedly in the Torah says the virtuous are reunited with their ancestors after death (the wicked are conversely “cut off” from their people), suggesting some form of life continues.
07
HINDUISM According to Hinduism, the oldest known religion in the world, death is a natural process in the existence of a soul that takes several births and reincarnations on the basis of karma.It explains the body like a set of clothes covering the soul. Hence, the soul changes bodies like one changes clothes. Hindus think of prolonging one’s life artificially as interfering with karma and hence does not encourage it.
ISLAM Islam believes in continued existence of the soul with transformed physical existence and a Day of Judgment (similar to Catholicism) deciding eternal destination of the human beings to Paradise and Hell. Thus, when one approaches death,
BUDDHISM Buddhist funeral traditions tend to vary because there are different types of Buddhism. Buddhists also believe in rebirth, which is influenced by the state of mind in which a person dies. While dying, a Buddhist is surrounded by family member, friends, and monks who chant mantras and recite Buddhist scriptures to help the person leave the mortal body in a peaceful state of mind.
the family and friends give comfort to the individual and recite from the Qur’an, thereby reminding one of God’s mercy.
Phase 2
A Good Death “You see. No shock. No engulfment. No tearing asunder. What you feared would come like an explosion is like a whisper. What you thought was the end is the beginning.� - Harold Beldon (The Twilight Zone: Nothing in the Dark)
Poi
uthanasia
W h i c h
w a y
S
isoning
Murder w o u l d
y o u
c h o o s e ?
uicide
12
What Defin
D
eath always finds a way. We will eventually die. Young, old, ill, healthy. Death will come at any time. Death is inevitably the most fearful phase in a human’s life. The fear emerges from what we see physically and what we know according to our knowledge: that death marks the end of life. We will no longer exist once death engulfs us and takes us away from our beloved ones. SLOW, PAINFUL DEATH In addition to that, we often see how the phase of death begins with pain. How painful the pain is going to be? It depends. People assume the more painful it is, the closer those people are
to death. The closer to death, the more fearful they have become. Another aspect that draws the fear during this phase is that, people face uncertainty. Pain can be slow and the slower it goes, the more killing it will feel. It is during this moment people are uncertain whether or not death will take them away, or life will reclaim them. It will be as if facing an intersection. Unlike in intersection where you can surely make up your choice where to go, people will feel as if they’re on an endless, swinging pendulum, waiting for either life or death to claim them. Life sometimes cooperates. If life allows, the pain will be taken away, replaced by breath of healthy air. However, if the pain is no longer endurable, the person will succumb to it and
13
nes a Good Death? NO MORE UNCERTAINTY For those who face that phase of uncertainty, hanging for their life or waiting for the death to claim, they might find a good shortcut. A shortcut is there to help decide the fastest way to skip the uncertainty. If life doesn’t cooperate and only sit there without doing anything, the best way to do it is to invite death in a gentle way. A quote from The Twilight Zone: Nothing in the Dark, is enough to sum up what other form death might be. Instead of slow, painful, torturing, death will take you away in your sleep, before you know it. For those who are facing this uncertainty, death will take away the pain and pick them up at instant, reducing the pain. A simple action as
pulling the plug helps one to reduce the aching physical pain. It is not a suicide. It’s an act of helping people have a better way out. Life can be a bit harder to deal with in this, while death can just sit there and wait to pick up the next person. Pulling the plug, injecting a deathly medicine to give one a shortcut to death, are no suicide. They are simply ways to help people get over the unendurable pain they are experiencing, which is an act of sincerely, an act of helping. Besides, spending more money for more medicines to keep one alive is not effective.
14
ARGUMENTS BASED ON RIGHTS People have an explicit right to die
PRACTICAL ARGUMENTS It is possible to regulate euthanasia Death is a private matter and if there is no harm to others, the state and other people have no right to interfere (a libertarian argument)
A separate right to die is not necessary, because our other human rights imply the right to die Death is a private matter and if there is no harm to others, the state and other people have no right to interfere (a libertarian argument)
Allowing people to die may free up scarce health resources (this is a possible argument, but no authority has seriously proposed it) Euthanasia happens anyway (a utilitarian or consequentialist argument)
PHILOSOPHIC ARGUMENTS Euthanasia satisfies the criterion that moral rules must be universalisable Euthanasia happens anyway (a utilitarian or consequentialist argument)
15
After all...
is death a bad thing?
16
54
percent of medical practitioners that support Euthanasia
4
places openly and legally authorize active assistance in dying (Oregon, Switzerland, Belgium,
86
Netherlands)
percent of public support euthanasia for the terminally ill / on life support
55
percent of terminally ill patients die in pain
17
8
years, Dr. Jack Kevorkian served in prison for Physician Assisted Suicide
28
percent of Americans supported Euthanasia
47
percent of Democrats support Euthanasia
100,000
people of largest group (Right-to-Die) have paid supported Japanese of rights to assisted suicide
18
How long has it been?
5th Century B.C. -1st Century B.C. Ancient Greeks and Romans Tend to Support Euthanasia
1st Century A.D. (Late Middle Ages
1828
During Middle Ages Christians and Jews Tend to Oppose Euthanasia
First US Statute Outlawing Assisted Suicide Enacted in New York
17th-18th Century Renaissance and Reformation Writers Challenge Church Opposition to Euthanasia
19
The history of Euthanasia dates back to before Christ. Such practices have encountered controversy but at the same time, philosophers and some groups of people believe in the benefits euthanasia brings.
1946
May 20, 2013
Committee of 1776 Physicians for Legalizing Voluntary
Vermont Becomes Fourth State the Allow Physician-Assisted Suicide
Euthanasia Founded
1915
1990
Dr. Haiselden Allows Deformed Baby to Die Rather Than Give It Possibly Lifesaving Surgery
Jack Kevorkian Participates in His First Assisted Suicide Surgery
I believe there are people who are healthy and mentally competent enough to decide on suicide. People who are not depressed. Everyone has a right to suicide, because a person has a right to determine what will or will not be done to their body. -
Jack Kevorkian, MD, who has aided over 130 people in ending their lives
Phase 3
Rest in peace? “The real question of life after death isn’t whether or not it exists, but even if it does what problem this really solves.” - Ludwig Wittgenstein
24
25
Where do we go?
T
he next thing you ask is, where do we go from here? Sure that euthanasia has often accused as an act of murder rather than an act of helping. Activities of euthanasia has been strictly limited only to specific geographical areas across the globe. However, keep your faith to people out there who are still doing this sincere practice as a way to help people get over their pain without having to wait any longer. Euthanasia is a device that helps people
deal with uncertainty and in situations where life sometimes refuses to cooperate. As long as we have good intentions, euthanasia will not be a crime nor sin. The goal is to give the best for those who are in pain, to give them faster access to eternal life. So where do we go? What do we do? When will we die? How will it feel like? It is inevitable to say that death itself remains a mystery to ordinary people like us. The ultimate answer lies when we exhale our very last breath.
Where we say hello... is also where we say goodbye...
28
Bibliography
29
“Assisted Suicide - Information on Right-to-die and Euthanasia Laws and History.” Assisted Suicide - Information on Right-to-die and Euthanasia Laws and History. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Aug. 2013. <http://www.assistedsuicide.org/>. “Top 10 Pros and Cons - Euthanasia - ProCon.org.” ProConorg Headlines. N.p., 18 May 2012. Web. 02 Aug. 2013. <http://euthanasia.procon.org/view. resource.php?resourceID=000126>. “Exit International (Assisted Suicide/ Voluntary Euthanasia).” Voluntary Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide Information by Exit International. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Aug. 2013. <http://www.exitinternational.net/>. Pictures are from Flickr.com