OUR COMMON FUTURE
Bold Leadership for Clean Renewable Energy in Massachusetts
! $ " " $ $ " ! $ ' ! $ $ $ " ! ! ! # " " ! # ' # $ ! % # $ ' $ % #% # $ ! ! $ $ $&
! !
$ # &%%+ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ( * &* + 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 5 " ! "(' 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 5
$ # $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ * (& (- (#&/ * &* + 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 8 - & $ " #'' ) ' " )$$#&(1 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 8 #+ ( & 1 ' " " "( * ' 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 9 ) (#&- " 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 : + $$&# (# ) ( #" 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 33 + # #& ( ( ' 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 34
$ # " $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &( ,$ " #)& '#)& ' " " ( #&( # # 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 36 # &" . ( & 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 37 "* &#"! "( )'( " ) ( 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 39 ) " ' " & "'$#&( 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 3: ,$ #& " * #$ + "# # ' 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 42
$ # $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ '& ) " & " $ ' 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 43 #'( & " !# & - + ( + ) (#&- # 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 43 '( & & "' ( #" (# " " + " & - 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 44 "')& " " & - %) (- 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 44 ) " #( " & - %) & ! "(' 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 45 " " !##( & "' ( #" 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 45 $ #
&%%+ $$$$$$$$$ ') " # ' # - 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 46 )& #!!#" )()& / & "' #&! ( * !$ ( # " & - #" ( #!!#"+ ( 000000000000000000 47 " #( ' 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 48
2 1 4336 + '+ , ! ! ) ! ! !% # " ! # # # ! # & ! % ! #
!% " $ " # $)( ! !# %
! " $ ,% -& $ %*' " $ $ ' . & " ) ( & # # " & ! # # # % -% )' $ ) $ %*' %## )# $) )% $+ '%$# $) " !*()
# .% & ) %$%# $ )( , ) $ %*' ' %$0 /% %() ' $ ' . #% ' .# # *' (+# ! # ! 0% * " #%' ' ( " $)0 $)' " / 0 " )' $ ' ()'* )*' ! & 52 %$)' *) )% ) " # ) $ (%"*) %$ ! % %
3 # " $
! % ! ! ! $ % ( # " # ! ! ! ( # # # %' # %(
) 72;
# % % 4252 322; % 4272' ( " ! " ! ' ! (
4 !
! ! ! & ' ! % # ! ' ! ! % ! ! (
# % 322;' # # ' ! , # (
5 % ! % ! ! #' # % " ) $ ( % % # " ! % ! (
042 ! ! % %' (
6 $ $
! % # ! " # # % ! ! ! # % 4242(
# ! % ! ! ' # # ! # -* ! +.' ! % " ' ! ! % ! ! " ! ! " (
7 ! % ! !
$ " $ ! % ( ! ' # # & # ! ! ! %(
! ' $ % ! # ! % ! % 4247(
8 !
# % 322;' # # ! # (
' # ! # # ! ! !
! % # !
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
$-# "+ " " # #$" $ * % $ ! "$ $ % $ $ # / 0* ' " #$ $ !% $ " #$ ) " !" !! %! %$ #)#$ $ $ # '# $ ! $ $ $" # $ $ " ' " ) " $ $ & " $ !" $ '+
&# 0, # % ! # * * ' $ # % !( # ! * )% $ ! $
$ ! # ! ! $ " ! " !" ) " ! " ! & " ! # ! ! $ " ! " !" ! &) $ ! ! ! & ! ! " # ! ! ' $ # ' ! ! ! & # ! & $ " # ! ! ) ! # & ! ! ! # ! ! $ ! ' ! ! ! & ./-- ) " ! ! "! ! ' $ # # ! *./--+ ! ! &' ' "! & ! ! ( • " "! !& !" , % ' ! $ " ! # ! ! !$ ! !$ ) • "! ! $ ! ! " ' ! "! $ ! " , " ! & " ! * !! ) • "! ! !" ! ! " !" # ! ! ! " ! ) $ # # ! & "! ! # " ! ! ! ! $ " ) $ # ' ! "! ! ! # ! " ! ! !& ! # " ! ! ! ! $ ) & # ! # ! # " ! " ! ! ! $ " " ) ! & & ! ! ! ! $ ! & $ ! ! !) & # # ! ! $ # ! ! ! ' " ! # ! ! ! ! $ " $ $ ! ! & * ! " ) ! & & & " $ ! ! & !) " & ! ! !
" ! ! $ " ! ! ! ! ! ! " ! !) $ ! ! " ! " ! # $ & ! " " ! ! ' ! * " ) " ! & % # !& $ ! ! ! ! & # " # & ! ) ' "! ! $ ! & ! " ! & )
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
" $ # ' "
"$ # ' $ # # ' % ' # # % " % # # & â&#x20AC;¢ % !
â&#x20AC;¢ " ! â&#x20AC;¢ !
" â&#x20AC;¢ $ " â&#x20AC;¢ !
$
â&#x20AC;¢ ! ! %
)* â&#x20AC;¢ # # " $ " " & ! % " $ # ' & " # & (
& ! % â&#x20AC;¢ ! $ $ ! " $
&
â&#x20AC;¢ + !% # - $ $ $) $ $ $ & ) # $ ' $" " % # " $ # #+ # " , $# $" $ $ $ # %"#% ## . " ) # %" $)/ # $ $ $ ) " & " " ## ) $ ' )# $ %" " ) #% ), " ( + $ ) ) # "# ) " " " ) # $ % $ $ # $ $ ) $ #' $ " %"# " )# ) " 0 $ $ & ") $ $ $ ' #)#$ # " ) #$ " ) $ # # $ , - ' # # " ) " % & '+ $ & ) $" ) $ %$ $ #+ " $ $ $ ' " # $ # ' $ " '$ " ' # #$ $# , â&#x20AC;¢ " $ " $% $ $ %# . " % /+ ' # " $ $ # $ ' " , â&#x20AC;¢ $ $ # ' $ ## & #% & #$ $# % $ " % ## % " $ & $ % $ " %" $ * # ( ## & " #+ #$" $ $ $ $ ) " " %$ $ " # " "# $ %$ $ %$%" $ ' $ , $ $ # & "# %" " # $ $ " & $ %# " + ' ' # %" # "& $ "$# 1 %# " ' # $" % %" $ $" #$" $ # ' !% # ) $ " #$" $ 2 â&#x20AC;¢ ! ' # $ " #$# " " $ $ ) " # $ ' # & " $ + $ "$ $ " )+ $ "$ $ $ $ " "+ $ "$ $ $ $ $ ($" #$ ## % & $ #, â&#x20AC;¢ , ' # % ) 457 %" " ) #% ) $ ), ) 5353+ " ' $ 637+ $ 4337 ) 5363, ## %# $$#+ ' & ' "$ $ " 1 2 $ $ ' $ $ %# $ 637 " 5366, # % $ " $ 4337 5363,
# # %"" $ " % $ %# # $ $ " #$"% $%" # " ' " $ $ # + % " $ %$ $ . $%" )/ " ' " , ) ' " " # " %# ## " ' " ) " % " # "+ , $ " ' " # %$ & $# %# % ##, # " # $ $ " $ #+ # $ " $ " $ " $ ## % ## $#+ # $ !% $ ) #% "$ ( # " ' " ) " #$"% $%" + # $ %$ %# #$ $" $ " " # $ " + # $ $ !% $ " # # #$ " $)+ $ " # "$ #,
"
" ' ! " & # " # ) ! $ ! ! % # $ + $ , ( ! ) # ! ! ! ! % ! $ % ( (& " #
# # " ! % # # ! ! # ! $ # $ $( # #
% # ! % " ! ) ! $ % ! " % # * $ # % ! ' â&#x20AC;¢ " #% â&#x20AC;¢ $ " # $ ! &
â&#x20AC;¢ ' $ " #$ + " $" * " , â&#x20AC;¢ , â&#x20AC;¢ , â&#x20AC;¢ $ $ # $ " ## $ #, â&#x20AC;¢ ! " ) # ' -
' ' ' " " %" %$ $ # " $ - " " $ & $) $ $# % %# $ & %# "' " + " $ " $ %# - %$ ' $ ( $ $ $ " & #$"% $%" ' $ $ & # " ' " $ " #$ ) %$- %" %$%" + " ' " ) 2 #$" %$ " ## $ #$ $ " $ " $ $" $ ## & $" * $# 2 ' " !% " %# $ # " $ " # * " # $ " $" & " ## %# $$#/ %# # %# ## #- # "$ $ # $ $ " " . # " % $ + %$ $ # ' " $ ) #%" ' $ " $ ) $$ " " ' # " $ $ " $#+ " & # "& " $)+ " $ " ## % " #$"% $%" - $ 829: " ) " " ' # $ $ %"" $ # + $ 7: " ) "- $ $+
$ # + ' $ $ $ ( # %$ $ - + " # $ $ ' ' " " $ "# ## $ + " $ ) $ ' $ $ %$ $ # " $ $ # ) $ # " & ' " $#+ #$ ' & " ## % - )+ $ ) ' " # # ) $ $ " " )." $ " #$"% $%" " %" $#+ $ $ $ & )+ ' " ' $ ( # $ % " $ %# - 0 # ) /$ # ' ) " $ $ $"% ) $ $ & " ## ' ) % & $ $ # "$ #$"% $%" +1 $ - 0 $/# " $ $ $ 5%$ $)6 ) $ $ '" $ # $ + # $ 3" !% #$ " " " # 4+ # ' ' # $ # % # -1 %#$ " " " $ # " #)#$ - # & " "+ ' #%" $ $ ' -
. - ,
" ! $ " $ " ( % " ! ' $ ! % %
" $ " " $ " ! ' ! % " ! " ( $ " '
" $ " " ( $ ' & â&#x20AC;¢ $ $ $ $ ,++%+++ " ! 1%/++ ' â&#x20AC;¢ $ *,, $ -'02 ' â&#x20AC;¢ $ .'.2 ! " ' â&#x20AC;¢ ( " *0+%+++ $ ' " " " " " $) " # " $' $ " " $ $' *#% & !#) " #%* % ' !' % " " $ % $ $ ' $ % " $ 0+2 $ " " -+ $ ' *.1, ! $ # " $' ' (%% "' ! " &'% ' #" & '%+ " '# # ' !$#&& / '# '(%" ' # #" ' "# # + " & $ % ' '& %#! ' & &'#% " !! "& + $#* % ( '% "& ' #", * # "#' ) '# #* '# ' "& " '+ #* " %#! & " '#". ! $ $ $% $ " % ! " $ $' ! ! $ $ % $ " '
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
% , ! ! ! ' %
# ! # " " " $ " # # % % ! * + " ! , $ # # % 01/&/// )" ( ' # # " % ! ( ! % & # )" " # ! % !& ! ( " ! " ! ! ! ! ! "
# & ) " # % # # )# % ! # # ! )! ( ! # ! ! - . " # )# % # # " $ " " # ( % ((( ! ! ! " ) (
!& # " )( ' ! " "
! % "
+ ! % !% % % , # - $ % $ " ' ! # % % ( % # % ! # " ( ! # ! ! " " ( ! ( ! ! # $ ! 300 # ' ! ) ! ' 200 # . /(" ' " # ' ! % " ! # ! " $ ! % " ' 1(2 # . /( ! " # ! ! ! " % % ( %" ! $
%' ' # ' # & ( % , # - ! # " & # ! ! ($ ! " & (
% ! # " " % # ! * ! & ' ! , -$ ' ( ! # ! ! % ' ! % # ! & ! % ! ! (
# # ! " ! % ! + ( â&#x20AC;¢ #* # # # % ! ! ' ! ! ! ! â&#x20AC;¢ " # % â&#x20AC;¢ # # â&#x20AC;¢ ! # â&#x20AC;¢ " " # " ! ! ! # ! " % % % ! ! % % ' , & % " ! )
" ! ' ! ! % # % ' ' ! ! ' # ! # %) % ' " ' " # ! % % ! ) ! ' # % ! % # " ! " # " % ) $ ' # ! % # ! ! ' " ! ! ! " ! # % ) ! ! ' # ! ! ' ! ) # % & ! ! ! " ! ! # ! ! # # # ) ! " ! ! # # # ! ! "! ! ! ) ! % ! # " ! % ! ! " % ! )
"" $ ! "#!$ #$! # #$! " $ # " # ." ! ) "/+ " # " # # "" $ " ! $ ! !# ! " # " ! # '#! # ! "" * # "* # #! " "" " # # # % ! ( ! " ! " " ( ! ! # " # " & $# ! #" % ! +
# ( # % ! ! " # # # ) " ! % ! # ! " ! "" ! "# # ! #+ ! # ! " # . ! "" ! "# # " # ! & # $ & ! " 36 % # ! $ "+ ( ! "(+ ! ! " % $# $"#! " & # # ! " ! "" ! "# # + # ' " " ! ! " # 2405* & # ! +/' % ! ! " # # # ! % ! " " # .% ! # !! # !(/* ! " $ # # # ! $# $"#! " # " ) + " # # ! ) # ' "# " ! ) " # +
! $ ! $# #" ! $ "" $" ##"+ ! # $ #( ! % "$ "" % % # " $## ! # # ( & ! " ! ## !( "# ! "# # & "# "+ # "# # -" " ! & # # " $ ( % * # & # $ " " # # ' !# & ! # # & "#* $" ! ! # "# # " # " $# & * # ! ( # " #" ' !# ! ! $# # # & # + # $! #! " !# # "("# # , $# #! % " & ! # ( ! $ # # #" # ( $ # " # ! & ( ! "("# "* # " ! " ! !# # ( & $ # " !+ # & ! ! ( " & # # & ( # "+ ! " " $ % !" ! # ! "#" 1 ! ! ! "" % " # " !% # % " 1 # # & $ ! ( ! % ! ( ! % !( & #! $ ! ! * " # # # "# ! " ! ! ( $ # # ! (+ & !!( # # # " & $ % # % # " " $" "" "* $# & $ #$! # # # # ( ! " % # # " " .#! " # % / # # & $ "" "# % !( & # # "#" "("# "+ # ! $ ## # & !# # # $ # " 1 " ( & ! " 1 ! % # $ # % # # & "("# ! ! $! & # # # #" ! % % # $" +
# " ) %# # ' " " $ " $" $) $# #$" %$ - %$ $ ' + $" ' " ) #% # ) 467 %" $ $ " ) %# - 447 # #% $ % # 357 $ $" # "$ $ # $ "- ' $ 0# ( #$ " " # $ $ " ## % " ) # "& $ & $" %$ $ # $ " & $# " ## $ #$ $ -( $ # " " # $ $ % + $ " # " $ $ - " ( + # & $ & # " " ) ) " ' " ) " & $# " & $ " "$)+ $ " # $ " - " " " "$ # " 3125+ $ # $ " % % " 4 ) "#- $ " #
# $ " " + $ & $ #$ - $- " ) % # # % # " #% " " #+ %$ $ # % $ $ #$ $ $ &- " $% ) $ %$ #% " " # - " " # % ) # $ " #%" " ) !% $) # ' $" # $ $ 2117 " ) " ' #- " ( + ' ) # % '. # #$"% ' $ %$ $ # #$# " " $ % $# ' " # $# # ) # ' ) & # " ## $ & $ " " ) # "& $ #%" # ) ' " ) #$#/
$ "# " " # $ " $ %$ $ " % " # # $ $ " ' " ) " $ ) " $ # $ # ) # ) $ & #$ $ "$% $ # - # ' " $ " # " " & $ $ , " ) "# " & $ ) ' # " % $ , %# $ # " $ ) " # $ #$ $ $ #$ $ % * " - ## %# $$# # ' $ " !% " $# " " % % $ # # #$" $ % $ $ & % $ ' # $ # $ $ + ' $$ "- $ " $ &- " $ "% # # $ $ $ #$" $ " ) #+ ' $ ) $ ' # $ #+ " ) $ % " $" $#- ' & ) # % # $ $ " ' ( $ " % " #+ $ # # # " ) #$" $ $ $ " & % " ) # & # " ## $ #$ $ -
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
"" $" ##" " # " # ! # "# ! " ! $ % !" # " # & ! * $ $! "# # "("# + ! % $# & " "# !# ! & " $ ! ! # & " $# " ! ! ( ! # ! # + ! ! # ! " # / # ! ! $ ! " ' "# # " ! ( $" ! $ # $ #!( ! $ # & ! # # & " $ # + ! ' * & $ $" "#! # # $" & "# # ! " & ! &"* #$! & % ! (* $ & " " " ! ! & " ! $"# & # !#$ # " & # % # "# # ++ % # ! " $! " # "# # " $ " $!! ! # ! # "$ !# * " ! ! # ! " ! % # # " # ! % # "+
0 / ( " % " $ & " "$ "# # # % !' # " $ #( # ! ! ' !# # "# "( & # # ! * $"#) 2* #&' % " % , !# % ,( $## "$ !"( " & ! & ! $ !" & # ! # " ! 0. ! "$ !"/1 # # # ! $! ' # # % "( ( !#% % & "'. "'% - . '% " % &'%( '(% $ # " !# ! ! ! # ' # ! $ "# ! +! # "!$ # " # # !! ! "# # ! #" 3* +$ " #(% " " % , % &#(% & $# # ! $ # !' "$ !# ! "" $ + " ! "#!$ #$! # # ! $! #' # % # ! % $! % " 4* $ ' #"#! " '& * ' " #(% % #" & ! "" ( $ $! ! & "#! # " 5* +$ " ' &# . ") %#"! "' " ' " '& # " # " # ! "#! # # $ # "# # * * # 0 $!! # ' & ! ( ! ( " ( " # "" $" ##"1( # "#! # " # $ # " # # & # $ " "# "* #( ' # ! "#! # -" " & ! ! # ' "# # " # * * # * ! " # !& ! ( $# "# "# ! ! & " & # # $" # ! * & & & # # ! , #&' % " !# % , * ' * ( '#%, # & "# !# ' ! % ! $ # !' !! !" # # " !# " $# #' ! $ # * & ) 2* !#) ' #+ & %#! " #(& (',( $ $ $ $# # " % ! + & ( & #! " $! & ! ! 3* % #(% $ %'! "' # ( ' ' & '# " #(% % " * & %#*' ( ! $ ! ! & + " & ! # ! & ! 27 ! ' ! # 5+67 ! ' !( ! # " " # # & ! % ! " & # " ! + " $ " 4* (%" % ( ' #" ($& #*"( ! & ! $# # " & # ' & '" # # # # # # ! # " ( & "$ !# ! ! "( # ! % "#! $# #& ! ! #' 5* ! " ' " ' ! ' % " % &'% ' #"& # # ! " & # # "" $ # ! # % " $" # $# # " -# & # # # # " # ! & $"#!'
" $ $ ! ! ! ! ( " $ ! $ ! # & ! ) 2* " " ! % ! ! ! +! # !( ! " ! & ! !& " ! / ! ! " ! & ' " !" !& ! " $ " !" ! " ! " ! ! ! & ! " *0 3* $ ! ! ! " " ! ! ! ! * 4* ! ! " ! # ! 5* ! $ ! % " $ ( % " ! $ ! ! ! ! ! ! " 6* # ! ! ! & $ -,.,* " !! $ " ! & # ! ! ! "! 411(111 ! ! & 3136( "! ! # !! ! ! ! & 22(111 "! ! ! &* ! ! ! ! $ $ " # ! # 52(376 / 226 &0 ! %! # & * & # ! ( ! % ! #& !* & -! # , # ! # ! ! # ! "!" + " ! & . $ " " ( "! ! & ! ! ! " $ # $ $
" " !& ! " ! ! & ! ! $ $ ) 2* ( ! ) . . $ # ! ! $ ! ! $ & ! ! ! ! & ! 3* # $ & "& & # ( ! ( " ! ! ! 4* $ " ' ! + (
" " & ! 5* $ ! ! ! $ + ! ! ! ! ! * + 6* # ! " % $ ! ! ! ! ! ! ! " ! " ! " ! " !"
1+ $ ! " % ) % ' ' " # " % ' " !) " ' !! $ !# " ! % " " % % $ # " !# # +
% ! $ % ' !# " $ ! " !# " " " % " ! ! " " !" " # " ' $ ! # $ "' * -+ % " " ! ' !" " % " " ! " # % # # ! .+
" # # !) !) # " $ % #" "' /+ ' ' $ ! ! 0+ # # !" # "# ) !" #" ! " ! ! " " % ' !"# "! " & ' !! " # " $ ") # " % ! % % " " ! " " !# " " % ! ( " # " # % #"# + -+ % #!" ') $ ") # $ ! " !) # " ( ! # ! " !! !'!" ) " # !" ! # ' " " " " # " "' !"! $ # % !, ! '+ # " % # & $ " ! " * â&#x20AC;¢ # % ! â&#x20AC;¢ " " " "" ' !" "' " # "% ! â&#x20AC;¢ !" $ "! % " "% .+ % , # % ! !" # "# " ! " ' ! "," "! % ! /+ # $ " ! " ! " " ! ' ! 0+ % " ) $ ! !" " "
3 2 6557 $ % ) % / # $ ! ! " # ! ! ! $ # ! ! ! # # $ ! "! " ( ( !" ) * - * ) %, (3 $ ! ! ! # ! $ ! ( ! & ! # !( $ ! ! $ ! ! ! ! $ ! ! ! " !) !" ! &( " " ! " # . $ ! & ! $ ! ! ! " ! ! # & * " ! ! ! " "! ! ! . ! # ! # ( ! ! !( ! !& ! ! ! ! ) " ! ! ! ! ! $ # ) !+ ! # ( "! $ ! ) " 1/0/ # ( , ! & # ! ) ! & +!)-% # ! # ! # &( $ ! !& ! # $ ! # & " &( " $ ! & ! # ! # ! ! " ! ! )
$ )+## (/1 ) %, ($%( % * ) %##%$- "* - "" &+()+ 2 â&#x20AC;¢ %( " ( $ - " )4 ) &%- ( %( , (/%$ â&#x20AC;¢ $ .&"%) %$ % ( $ - " $ ( / !% )1 " ! ! " $ â&#x20AC;¢ * " 0 " *( */ %)*)( " ! & ! â&#x20AC;¢ , () %$%#/( $ ! " $ $ ! ! ! " ! ! $! ! ( ! *! â&#x20AC;¢ "* ( %# ) $ %##+$ * )1 - * "%- ( +* " */ %)*) â&#x20AC;¢ ( $* )# "" +) $ )) $ # $+ *+( $ ) *%()( $ ! ! ' & ! " ! $ ) â&#x20AC;¢ +""/ " *( *( $)&%(* * %$ $ ( )*(+ *+( 1 " " ! $ & " â&#x20AC;¢ ( '+ " */ $ &+ " "* #&(%, # $*) ! # â&#x20AC;¢ + * %$) $ %+( ( %$ #& *) *% . * ( ) * ( *)( ! ! " ! &
& ( " ! $&
! $ # ! # $' $ & $& % & ! $ ' " $ # & " *+, $ ) ! $ $ ' "
$
" & ! ! $ # " $ & ! "
" ! $ " " ! $ " ' " " $ " ' ' ' ! " " & " !
3 & & % "! "& % % " $ ! ! & -4 "
"!) & , ! - =;<B0
&&#/55)))0
%%0 "(5 5 ! $ +1'& & %1 !1& 5 ! $ +1 % " $ 5 %%1 ! $ +1#$" 5
&&#/55)))0% $"! 0 "
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
Bob Massie Policy Series - Our Common Future: Energy
Massie Administration Plan to Move Rapidly to a Sustainable Energy Economy FOSTER DEMOCRACY WITH A NEW REGULATORY MODEL 1 End undue influence of the utilities
End utility control of ISO-New England, which controls the energy grid
2 C harge our Department of Public Utilities Increase renewable-based power target from 1% per year to 4-5% per year to encourage renewables growth 3 Turn DPU regulation upside down
Reward utilities when they lower the total capital in the rate base, while supporting microgrids, maintaining and improving distribution network reliability, with a new framework in place by 2020
4 Eliminate net metering restrictions
hange these and other constraints on renewables growth that are slowing the adoption of fossil C fuel alternatives
ACCELERATE THE TRANSITION 5 M ake multiple awards to offshore wind developers
Commit to staging long-term development, creating industry certainty, encouraging cooperation and expanding our local economy.
6 C oordinate full build-out of key renewable infrastructure
Encourage early construction of shared undersea cables and interconnects to landside transmission for offshore wind
7 F acilitate development of an onshore service hub
Encourage construction of a hub in a gateway community to support and service offshore projects
8 I nvest more in energy research at state universities
Focus supported research on solar and wind, and expand our partnerships with nations and international firms that are far ahead of us
9 C onvert the state vehicle fleet to all-electric fleet by 2030
Take steps to achieve target of 300,000 electric cars in this state by 2025. To date, the Governor has done so little that there are only 11,000 on the road. I already drive an electric car – why doesn’t Governor Baker?
ENSURE ECONOMIC SECURITY 10 Support the “transition dividend”
Establish a carbon price in which families receive cash benefits to switch to renewable energy after the installation of carbon pricing system
11 P rovide energy transition-related support Provide tax adjustments, job retraining and support for domestic solar projects for low- and middle-income families 12 M odify our Commonwealth’s electric car Modify the program so that is income-based, allowing lower-income households to acquire rebate program all-electric vehicles 13 W ork with other New England and Mid-Atlantic states
Implement a regional greenhouse gases cap (similar to RGGI) targeted at transportation
14 A lign gas tax revenues with actual infrastructure needs
Adopt gas tax credit for economic hardship to offset impact, with a planned transition to mileage and congestion pricing that supports full and responsible maintenance of our infrastructure
15 D rive renewables jobs into our gateway cities
Provide aggressive support of offshore wind that will help New Bedford and Fall River
DRIVE DOWN ENERGY CONSUMPTION 16 P ursue net-zero targets for new public buildings
Provide non- financial and/or financial incentives to drive all new state and municipal public buildings to a net-zero energy rating
17 Accelerate changes in the building code
estore stretch energy code applicability to renovation work and encourage broader adoption of R stretch energy codes, adding jobs, and further driving down utility bills; support further changes to “green” building codes
18 Create a tax rebate system
Foster energy efficiency conversions
19 Involve our students
Get students (and more families) involved in greening our building infrastructure, distributing infrared cameras through high school libraries so that they can be easily borrowed by students to explore energy loss in the built environment, including their own homes
MANAGE TRANSITION TO THE FUTURE 20 Create an Energy Innovation Roundtable D raw from industry, government, and universities to bring our best ideas quickly to the forefront and explore innovations to reduce peak power loads, integrate electric car battery storage capacity into grid, foster microgrid developments with a leaner network backbone, explore new technologies 21 Implement funding innovations
Introduce a Green Bank and forward-funding of renewables infrastructure to offset any short-term impacts on low and middle income families
22 Create a coordinated curriculum
Align vocational training and public college courses with need for training technicians in energy fields