opinion Page 8 · Richmond Review
the richmond
REVIEW
A DIVISION OF LMP PUBLICATION LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
#1 - 3671 VIKING WAY, RICHMOND, B.C. V6V 2J5 • 604-247-3700 • FAX: 604-247-3739 • RICHMONDREVIEW.COM
PUBLISHER PIERRE PELLETIER, 604-247-3702 publisher@richmondreview.com
EDITOR BHREANDÁIN CLUGSTON, 604-247-3730 editor@richmondreview.com
Friday, April 17, 2015
EDITORIAL: The misuse of recall
E
lections BC has approved two recall campaigns against MLAs — one a sitting BC Liberal who has won four elections, and the other a twice-elected BC Liberal who is sitting as an independent while awaiting a chance at a federal Conservative nomination.
The overlap of the two campaigns and the pledge that more are to come is a misuse of recall legislation — but that doesn’t mean that it needs to be scrapped or changed. In both cases, the petitioners have 60 days to gather the signatures of 40 per cent of people who were on the voters’ list in each riding, at the time of the May, 2013
election. That is an enormous hurdle. As has been proven in past recall campaigns, it is almost impossible to get to that point. While petitioners may be able to get the signatures of enough people to reach the 40 per cent threshold, they almost invariably find that a significant number of those who signed are ineligible. They may have lived in the riding at the time of the last election and not been on the voters list, or what is often more likely, they did not live in the riding at that time. The recall legislation was brought in by the NDP government when Mike Harcourt was premier. It wasn’t its top priority, but the government was being pressured by intense citizen cynicism about politicians which had played a big role in the defeat of
Social Credit and the NDP’s election in 1991, and in the rise of the Reform Party federally. The 40 per cent threshold was meant to be high, because while the ability to recall an MLA is important, it also needs to be difficult, in order to rule out simple partisanship. Reaching a 40 per cent threshold of voters who were on the list in the last election will likely only be achieved when an MLA has done something that is repugnant to a large number of constituents. BC Liberal MLA Paul Reitsma came close to being recalled for authoring phony letters to the editor, praising his ability as an MLA. He was in opposition at the time. Reitsma resigned before the campaign concluded. Successful recall campaigns must go beyond what an MLA’s
party is doing, either as government or opposition. They need to have a strong personal element as well. In the case of Richard Lee of Burnaby North, he is being targeted for the policies and actions of the BC Liberal government. Marc Dalton of Maple Ridge-Mission is being targeted not only for BC Liberal actions, but also for staying in office as an independent while seeking a federal Conservative nomination. That’s personal, but it is not something which will repulse most voters. These two recall campaigns and others targeting government MLAs are likely to fail, but the safety valve of being able to recall an MLA needs to remain. It is one of the few restraining devices available to voters between elections. —Langley Times
STAFF REPORTERS MATTHEW HOEKSTRA, 604-247-3732 mhoekstra@richmondreview.com MARTIN VAN DEN HEMEL, 604-247-3733 martin@richmondreview.com DON FENNELL, 604-247-3731 sports@richmondreview.com
ASSISTANT ADVERTISING MANAGER ELANA GOLD, 604-247-3704 admanager@richmondreview.com ADVERTISING COLLIN NEAL, 604-247-3719 collinn@richmondreview.com KIMBERLEY LIM, 604-247-3709 kimberley@richmondreview.com JANE ILOTT, 604-247-3707 jane@richmondreview.com
CIRCULATION MANAGER/AD CONTROL KRISTENE MURRAY, 604-247-3711 circulation@richmondreview.com CIRCULATION ROYA SARWARY 604-247-3710 circulation@richmondreview.com LITO TUAZON, 604-247-3710 circulation@richmondreview.com
The Richmond Review is a member of the B.C. Press Council, a self-regulatory body governing the province’s newspaper industry. The council considers complaints from the public about the conduct of member newspapers. Directors oversee the mediation of complaints, with input from both the newspaper and the complaint holder. If talking with the editor or publisher does not resolve your complaint about coverage or story treatment, you may contact the council. Write (include documentation) within 45 days to B.C. Press Council, PO Box 1356, Ladysmith, V9G 1A9. For information, phone 888-687-2213 or go to www.bcpresscouncil.org Published every Wednesday and Friday by LMP Publication Limited Partnership
It is only because of Kerry Starchuk’s persistence that the “Chinese Only” signs situation is slowly making it’s way through city hall.
Sign crusader is the best of the best Editor: Re: “City to probe construction noise,” April 10. We Richmond citizens owe a huge debt of gratitude to Ms. Kerry Starchuk for her dogged persistence in pursuing the wilful destruction of our neighborhoods by inconsiderate builders and developers. She has continued to do this despite the attitude from Richmond City Hall which has
been at best, indifference, and at worst, hostility. Only her genuine love for our city has prevented her from “take the money and run” advice she has received from one insensitive councillor, in other words, quit bothering us. The election of two new councillors, Carol Day and Alexa Loo, seem to have woken the existing councillors up from their
deep slumber and they are now slowly making it`s way through staring to give Ms. Starchuk the the morass of molasses that respect that she deserves. The exists at City Hall whenever she feeble excuse that this council shows up to challenge them to “ likes to use of “we don`t know wake up and smell the coffee.” these things unless you tell The Review is doing their “Best of us” is astonishing, considering Richmond” campaign, so I am votthat they all live here and must ing for Ms. Kerry Starchuk, as the “Best of the Best” that Richmond is see what the rest of us see! so lucky to have among us. It is only because of Ms. Alan Halliday Starchuk’s persistence that the Richmond “Chinese Only” signs situation is