6
YUKON NEWS
OPINION
EDITORIAL
WEDNESDAY, JUNE 11, 2014
INSIGHT
LETTERS
COMMENTARY
Watson Lake Hospital failed Teresa Scheunert Chandre Burchell, Crystal Thomas and Wanda Zimmerman
F
irst of all we would like to thank the coroner’s service and their council for their efforts during the inquest into the death of Teresa Scheunert. They have made this inquest publicly accessible, and open. We were also grateful for the expert witnesses that came to testify. What we were surprised by, however, was how adversarial the process became. We found that strange since an inquest is designed to not find guilt or blame. We did find, however, that there are certainly numerous ways to improve public safety. There was no clear care plan for Teresa’s main symptoms causing pain and discomfort, (problems with her abdomen, spine, numb and tingling legs, swelling, possible infection, anemia, edema, etc.). Patients in hospitals should have clear care plans. We regret there seemed to be considerable focus by hospital and physician lawyers on making Teresa look bad rather than learning from the “system gaps” about improving care. A physician testifies that Teresa had alcohol on her breath. This is hearsay, and the physician did not document it. If prescribing narcotics, the presence of alcohol should be documented. If alcohol was suspected, extra vitals and monitoring would have been warranted. There was no alcohol detected in the autopsy. We think Teresa’s death is an issue of public safety. There was no clear treatment plan, lack of consistency with standards of care, poor charting, (some by exception, some things not noted at all, only recalled later) and doctors’ notes were al-
most non-existent. The few doctors’ orders for vitals and blood sugar levels for diabetes were supposed to be done four times a day, yet those orders were never done four times a day, and several days not done at all. There was inadequate charting and monitoring of Teresa’s symptoms of back pain, abdominal distention and numbness and there was no plan at all for monitoring the side-effects of the several opioids she was prescribed and administered in hospital. Hospital policies for fentanyl were not followed. They did not document where the patch was applied on the body, or if and how the location was changed. The proper protocol for disposal of high potency narcotics was not followed, and disposal was not documented on the medical administration record or anywhere else in Teresa’s chart. This is an extremely unsafe practice by both physicians and nurses in Watson Lake’s hospital. Watson Lake had access to a 24-hour on-call pharmacist, but the available pharmacist was not called, nor consulted, regarding the multiple sedating opioid medications prescribed and administered in hospital. Doses of narcotics, or any interactions or adverse effects they may have on one another, were not reviewed by a pharmacist. We discovered that physicians and nurses at the hospital did not seem to see the importance of pharmacist oversight in their facility. We feel that was an extremely important and dangerous oversight. Policies in place that stated medication should not be left at a patient’s bedside were also not followed or enforced. Indeed, witnesses appeared to have no awareness of several policies they should have been following. We also feel that there was Publisher
Community Newspapers Association British Columbia & Yukon
2010 WINNER
Yukon News, 211 Wood Street Whitehorse, Yukon Y1A 2E4 (867) 667-6285 Fax: (867) 668-3755 Internet: www.yukon-news.com Classifieds: wordads@yukon-news.com
Reporters
Mike Thomas
Jacqueline Ronson
mthomas@yukon-news.com
jronson@yukon-news.com
Published by Black Press Group Ltd.
Editor
Wednesday & Friday
Photography
ISSN 0318-1952 Second Class Registration #0586277
a conflict of interest having a fellow staff registered nurse as a patient in hospital at that time, and Teresa was too compromised to leave on her own. There was no investigation of Teresa’s elevated heart rate, nor her bloodwork that had suggested she may have infection or inflammation. We found it troublesome that instead of immediately ordering for Teresa the MRI and subsequent tests (ultrasound, a better CT scan) she required, the doctor first blamed WCB, and then testified she advised Teresa to seek her own treatment in the private sector and pay for her required tests out of her own pocket. Regardless what the final outcome of this inquest may be, there are still many issues that need to be fixed. All Yukoners are entitled to consistent, safe care that this inquest shows Teresa Scheunert did not receive in Watson Lake Hospital. We hope that whatever the outcome is, that there will be recommendations not only made, but enforced for the safety of all. Thank you very much, The family of Teresa Scheunert.
John Thompson johnt@yukon-news.com
Alistair Maitland alistair@yukon-news.com
Sports Reporter
Tom Patrick tomp@yukon-news.com
Jesse Winter jessew@yukon-news.com
Ashley Joannou ashleyj@yukon-news.com
Sam Riches sam@yukon-news.com
Operations Manager
Stephanie Newsome stephanien@yukon-news.com
LETTERS Given Yukoners’ propensity to take advantage of the relatively short Yukon summer to spend time outdoors, to leave town, to take holidays The good news that the select comand to pay scant attention to politmittee studying hydraulic fracturical events, it is more than conceiving has listened to Yukoners who able that these hearings examining wanted a public dialogue on this hydraulic fracturing will not receive issue and will visit most Yukon com- the participation and attention they munities is tempered by the timing so clearly need. of the visits announced to date. Doesn’t common sense, along The first hearings are scheduled with an honest desire to consult with for Monday, June 23 in Watson Lake Yukoners and a sense of fair play, and run through until Thursday, dictate that these public hearings, or June 26 when they conclude in at least those that are still unschedDawson. The remaining hearings, uled, be held after the summer break including Whitehorse, have not been when schools are back in session, scheduled yet, but it seems likely Yukoners have returned from holithat the committee will be making day and attention is focussed again haste to finish them during July or on important territorial issues? August so they can complete their report for the Yukon legislature. Rick Griffiths Therein lies the rub. Whitehorse
Delay the public hearings on fracking
Quote of the Day “I really want people to see that the city of Whitehorse isn’t blind to this and sees the importance of putting this resolution forward.” Jocelyn Curteanu on why Whitehorse City Council supports a national inquiry into missing and murdered aboriginal women. Page 5
Reception/Classified Ads wordads@yukon-news.com
Advertising Representatives
Creed Swan creeds@yukon-news.com
Rebecca Nelken rebeccan@yukon-news.com
Kathleen Knight kathleen@yukon-news.com
Creative Services Manager
Louise Stewart Creative Department
Marce Nowatzki Jolie Patterson Heidi Neufeld D’Arcy Holt Production
Rob Goulet Justin Tremblay Nathan Doiron
SUBSCRIPTIONS YUKON ADDRESS £ÉÜii Êf£äÎÊUÊÓÉÜii Êf£ CANADIAN ADDRESS £ÉÜii Êf£££ÊUÊÓÉÜii ÊfÓ£{ U.S.A. £ÉÜii Êf£Ç{ÊUÊÓÉÜii ÊfÎ{ä INTERNATIONAL & AIR MAIL RATES AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST Canadian subscriptions please add 5% GST.
MasterCard
Sorry, balances under $50.00 non-refundable
AUDITED BY