Licensing and Regulation of the Cannabis Market in England and Wales: Towards a Cost-Benefit Analy

Page 73

and arrest leading to a court appearance. In the latter case, we assume arbitrarily that the

additional preparatory work increases the average time to 12 constable-hours plus 4 sergeanthours.

For the formal cannabis warnings which have been in operation since 2004, May et al (2007) assume an average time of 80 minutes to carry out eight steps, including the stop-and-search, police checks, completing a stop-and-search form, inputting details to various information

systems and transferring the seizure to the property store. It appears that the 80 minutes time

was not increased to allow for involvement of two officers in the action. To allow for this, we have increased the assumed time to 140 minutes. We assume the same time for the use of a Penalty Notice for Disorder (PND), which involves on-the-spot imposition of a fine.

For the time required to deal with an arrest for supply offences, we are in the realms of

guesswork, since we have found no relevant evidence in the research literature. We assume that

all arrests for supply and production offences involve preparation for a possible court case and that, on average, the process involves costs equivalent to 24 hours of constables’ time, 12

sergeant-hours and 10 inspector hours. These figures should be seen as an arbitrary illustration only: they have been chosen to give a unit cost figure close to the Brand and Price (2000) estimate of over £3000 per case.

Table 5.1.2 gives the resulting unit cost estimates, which range from £150 for a warning or PND, to £3,420 for an arrest for a supply offence. Since these figures are so uncertain, we also provide

a judgemental high-low range for each unit cost, which we are confident will contain the true

figure.

Table 5.1.2 Assumed times and unit costs for police actions

Activity Cannabis possession: formal warning or PND Cannabis possession: arrest and caution Cannabis possession: arrest and preparation for court Cannabis supply or production: arrest and preparation for court

Illustrative calculation of police time 140 constable minutes 8 constable hours + 2 sergeant hours 12 constable hours + 4 sergeant hour

20 constable hours + 8 sergeant hours + 8 inspector hours

Unit cost (mid estimate) £150 £660

High-low range £100-200

£400-£1000

£1060

£700-£1,500

£3,420

£2,000-£4,800

Note: calculations rounded to the nearest £10.

Official statistics on the volumes of drugs offences dealt with in various ways lack some of the

detail we would like for analysis of drugs policy. In particular, the specific substance (or

substances) involved in a particular detected drug offence is not recorded in a proportion of cases, and published data are often aggregated within the three official drug classes, so that

- 62 -


Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.