Page 1

тАл     тАм тАл   тАм

тАл  тАм тАл   тАм тАл тАм тАл╫Р ╫Р тАм

тАлтАк2013тАмтАм


โ€ซุงุณโ€ฌ โ€ซุงุนโ€ฌ

โ€ซุงโ€ฌ

โ€ซ   โ€ช....................................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช9โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง ู‘ ุงูˆู„ โ€ช :โ€ฌุง ุข

ุง ู‘ ู‘ ู„ ุง  ุฑ โ€ช.............................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช13โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช -โ€ฌุง

โ€ช..........................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช13โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุฃ ู„ ุง ูˆ  

โ€ช.......................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช25โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ   ุง ูˆ  โ€ช...............................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช26โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ  ุง  โ€ช............................................................... ATCEโ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช33โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ โ€ช#$โ€ฌุข

! ุง ุฑุฌ โ€ช.........................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช39โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุฃูˆ&โ€ช %โ€ฌุง)( ุฏ โ€ช....................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช40โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุฏโ€ช ,โ€ฌุขโ€ช* +โ€ฌู„ "โ€ช.................................................. "0 1โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช43โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุงูˆุฑุงุช ุงุฑโ€ช............................................................  23โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช48โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง ู‘ ุง ู‘  โ€ชู‘ :โ€ฌู ุง ุข

ุง ู‘  ู‘ ู„ ุง  ุฑ โ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช $%โ€ฌุงโ€ช !"#โ€ฌุฑ ุง   โ€ช....................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช53โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง  ุง 

& โ€ช + , :โ€ฌุช ุง *ู‘)( ุช ูˆุง โ€ช*/โ€ฌุงุช ูˆุงโ€ช -0#โ€ฌูˆุง โ€ช-./โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซูˆุง โ€ช - 4โ€ฌุง ุง โ€ช -โ€ฌูˆุง  ูˆโ€ช 2 3 -โ€ฌู… "โ€ช................. "0 -6โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช69โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ โ€ช#โ€ฌุงุกุฉ ุฑโ€ช.................................................................  3โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช73โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุง>โ€ช )$โ€ฌู† ุงุงู† ูˆุง ูˆู† < ุง;ู‘โ€ช 9โ€ฌู… ุง( โ€ช#1 (1:71โ€ฌู‡ ู† โ€ชBู‘ (1โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช (2โ€ฌุฃโ€ช #F11โ€ฌุง>โ€ช )H (3 # Eโ€ฌู† ุงโ€ชHIโ€ฌุฏ โ€ช (5 + > 1 0 (4โ€ฌู‡ู‰ โ€ช1โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช Mโ€ฌู† โ€ช (7 & O>; (6โ€ฌุฑ ุงโ€ช Q1 3โ€ฌุฑ โ€ช (8โ€ฌุฑ ุงโ€ช(9 0โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ*( ู† ุง;  โ€ช (10โ€ฌุงโ€ช HIโ€ฌุงุงู‡โ€ช 2 # H (11 Uโ€ฌุงโ€ช X (12 Vโ€ฌุญโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช3โ€ฌโ€ฌ


โ€ซุงโ€ช 3โ€ฌุงโ€ช (13 (3#Eโ€ฌุงโ€ชY  + 2$โ€ฌุฑ โ€ชZ! ู‘$ (14โ€ฌุงุฏ ุงโ€ชู‘$โ€ฌุงุช โ€ชO ) (15โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุง)โ€ช (16 [3#โ€ฌูŠ โ€ช 2โ€ฌุฑูƒ โ€ช X (17โ€ฌุญ ุงโ€ช _ X (18 ^ &1 3โ€ฌุงโ€ช& $โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช 2 (19โ€ฌุงโ€ช 3โ€ฌุง`โ€ช3#โ€ฌูŠ โ€ช (20โ€ฌุง;>โ€ช# 1 Oโ€ฌุงุฏ โ€ช 2 (21โ€ฌุงโ€ช $โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช  $! (22 * 3#โ€ฌุง ;โ€ช (23 aโ€ฌุงโ€ช aโ€ฌุฐ โ€ช (24 B3 1โ€ฌุง> !โ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช (25  Hโ€ฌุง

ุฏูŠ ุงโ€ช#aโ€ฌูŠ โ€ช ู‘$ (26โ€ฌุง ( ูˆูŠ โ€ช (27โ€ฌุฑุคูˆู โ€ชc Yโ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุฑูˆ*โ€ช Y (28 %โ€ฌุงโ€ช0โ€ฌูŠ โ€ช X (29โ€ฌุญ ุงโ€ช  3โ€ฌูˆูŠ โ€ช ู‘$ (30โ€ฌุง

ุฏูŠโ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช (31 F3#โ€ฌุง

โ€ช#3 Yโ€ฌุฉ โ€ช )f (32โ€ฌุง ุฑูŠ โ€ช (33โ€ฌุข ู„ โ€ชB3 1โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช ู‘$ (34โ€ฌุงโ€ช ู‘;& 1 &  (35 ; a1 Hgโ€ฌุช โ€ชู‘*   (36โ€ฌุงุฏ โ€ช(37โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ ! โ€ช 7โ€ฌุงโ€ช (38 +ู‘ 2$โ€ฌุง

ุฏูŠ ุงโ€ช (39 Y ู‘;$โ€ฌุง ุฒุฑูŠ ุงโ€ชู‘$โ€ฌุงุฏ โ€ช2 (40โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช ,3#Fโ€ฌุง`ุงุฏูŠ โ€ช (42 _ X 1 ู‘$ (41โ€ฌุงโ€ช#$ 1 + 2$โ€ฌุฒ โ€ชู‘$ (43โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ;โ€ช fโ€ฌุฑุฉ โ€ช (44โ€ฌุฑ ุงโ€ช` 3โ€ฌูˆุจ โ€ช (45โ€ฌุฑุคูˆู โ€ช O0โ€ฌุงโ€ช (46 Vโ€ฌุข ู„โ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช `$โ€ฌูˆูŠ โ€ช (47โ€ฌุฑ ุงโ€ช #> (48 ! Fโ€ฌุงโ€ช H 1 3โ€ฌุฉ โ€ช (49โ€ฌุงโ€ช+ 2$โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุง(ุฑูŠ โ€ช # ; (50โ€ฌุง(ู‘โ€ช 2 (51 (3โ€ฌุง`  ุง`; โ€ช#  (52โ€ฌุฉโ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช $ (53  2 aโ€ฌุง> ุฏู‚ โ€ช (54 0 0*1โ€ฌุงโ€ช + fโ€ฌุงู‘ู‡ ุฑ โ€ชู‘ (55โ€ฌูˆุฒ โ€ช1โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ (โ€ช (57 #l O ) (56 kโ€ฌุง>ู‘โ€ช X 2$โ€ฌุฑุฉ โ€ช , 0H (58โ€ฌุงโ€ชู‘#Fโ€ฌุงูŠ โ€ช(59โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช $โ€ฌุงุฑ   โ€ช 1 m 2 (60โ€ฌุฒุขโ€ช#โ€ฌูŠ โ€ช (61โ€ฌุฒู‡ โ€ช #โ€ฌุง  โ€ช (62โ€ฌุง`โ€ฌ โ€ซุง[ โ€ช 2 2* (64 ; ;H1 ู‘$ (63 Hโ€ฌุงโ€ช#fโ€ฌุงโ€ช (65 (01โ€ฌุข ู„ ุง`ุงโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช (66โ€ฌุฑ ุงโ€ช 3โ€ฌุง  โ€ช ู‘$ (67โ€ฌุงโ€ช `Iโ€ฌุงโ€ช$โ€ฌุง โ€ช M OH3 (68โ€ฌู†โ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช )f (69โ€ฌุงโ€ช !#โ€ฌูˆูŠ โ€ช (70โ€ฌุฅโ€ช

3โ€ฌุจ ุงโ€ช aโ€ฌูˆุด โ€ช m 0 (71โ€ฌุงโ€ชู‘$ (72 7 #โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช & (73 m Fโ€ฌู„ ุงโ€ช (74 O3#ู‘aโ€ฌุงูโ€ชq)f> (75 OH3 1 $โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุง ุฑูŠ โ€ช$ (76โ€ฌุฏ ) ุญ โ€ช (77โ€ฌู€!โ€ช mโ€ฌุงู‘โ€ช 3โ€ฌุฏูŠ โ€ช ู‘$ (78โ€ฌู€ุงุฉโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช _ X ู‘$ (79โ€ฌุง`ู€ โ€ช#1โ€ฌูŠ โ€ช X (80โ€ฌุญ ุงโ€ชู‘0 9 )* (81 ^ &1 3โ€ฌุดโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช  (82โ€ฌุฏ โ€ช 2 (83 Q fโ€ฌุงโ€ช  1 O fู‘0โ€ฌุฑ โ€ช 0 & (84โ€ฌุงู€ู€ &โ€ช#โ€ฌูŠโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช ู‘$ (85โ€ฌุฑ& ุก !โ€ช *#โ€ฌุช โ€ช ;* (86โ€ฌู† โ€ช (87 ,โ€ฌุฑ โ€ช, 0H (88 2 Yโ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุง>;

& โ€ช ู‘$ (90  H 1  H (89โ€ฌุฑโ€ช Yโ€ฌุฏ โ€ช.................. s E01โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช75โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ูˆ&^ &   ูˆ!โ€ช 3#Fโ€ฌูˆุฅ   ุง  ูˆ< ุง ูˆู† 

โ€ช1996 ;Hโ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช !0โ€ฌุน  ุง;ู‘โ€ช 9โ€ฌู… โ€ช...................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช118โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุง ูˆู† ! ุง! ุน  "ูˆุง< ุง*โ€ช#โ€ฌุงู… โ€ช 3#$0 Bโ€ฌุช ูˆโ€ช[$โ€ฌู‚โ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช (tโ€ฌู†  ู„  ุงโ€ช 0โ€ฌุช โ€ช........................................... 2005โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช123โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช4โ€ฌโ€ฌ


โ€ซ ุงโ€ช  tโ€ฌู† ุงโ€ช + &Iโ€ฌุง ูˆู† ูˆุงุงู† โ€ช............................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช124โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง ู‘ ุง ู‘ุงโ€ช : 36โ€ฌุงโ€ช<=7โ€ฌุงุฏุงุช ูˆุง  ู‡ ุช  ุง โ€ช 8โ€ฌุช ุงโ€ช 6 7โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุง )( ูˆุง โ€ช........................................................... = +โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช149โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง  ู‘ ุง  > โ€ช :โ€ฌุงโ€ช0#โ€ฌู… ุง ู‘=  )ูˆุข  โ€ช Bโ€ฌุง!โ€ช 2v [3#โ€ฌุก โ€ช ; -โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ" โ€ช "7Bโ€ฌูˆ" โ€ช - "21Bโ€ฌุงโ€ชtโ€ฌุฐุง ุงโ€ช -  ;Qโ€ฌุฅุฐุง ุงโ€ช 2ู‘aโ€ฌุจ โ€ช -โ€ฌุงโ€ชtโ€ฌุฐุงโ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช -  ! [Mโ€ฌุงโ€ชtโ€ฌุฐุง ุช ุง` โ€ช "La Presse" ) $X - 3โ€ฌูˆ"ุง>โ€ช("! $โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช195โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง ู‘ ุง ู‘ ุฏุณ โ€ช :โ€ฌุงโ€ช0#โ€ฌู… ุง  ุตู‘ โ€ช..................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช203โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ *;โ€ช.......................................................................... m2โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช203โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ( โ€ช............................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช213โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุงโ€ชtโ€ฌุฐุง ุช ุง โ€ช............................................................ Xโ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช215โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุง>ู‘โ€ช O$โ€ฌุง โ€ช............................................................. ู‘Xโ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช217โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ โ€ช ! $Xโ€ฌุงโ€ช*gโ€ฌุงุจ โ€ช.............................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช220โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง ู‘ ุง ู‘ โ€ช : 36โ€ฌุง )!< ุง ู‘โ€ช .8โ€ฌุง  ู…  > โ€ชB CD,โ€ฌุฑุฉ โ€ช.  14โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช 2011โ€ฌูˆโ€ช 6 /โ€ฌุง โ€ช - 8โ€ฌุง โ€ช -โ€ฌูˆุง=ุจ ุง  ู…  โ€ช Cโ€ฌุงโ€ช0#โ€ฌู… โ€ช....โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช225โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุง&

ุช ุง  โ€ช..............................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช225โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุง;[ โ€ช........................................................................... 1โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช227โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุงโ€ช0HIโ€ฌุจ ุง ู… โ€ช m0โ€ฌุงโ€ช)  tโ€ฌุงโ€ช m 0lโ€ฌุงโ€ช................... ( tโ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช234โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ข ุงโ€ช....................................................................... %3aโ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช235โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ข โ€ช O 3โ€ฌุงโ€ช.............................................................. 7 [$โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช239โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ข ุง โ€ช......................................................................... ,โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช240โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ข ุงโ€ช

3tโ€ฌู… ูˆุงโ€ช............................................................ E 2โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช241โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ข ุงโ€ช $gโ€ฌุฒ โ€ช......................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช243โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ   ! ุงุขโ€ช #Mโ€ฌุง>โ€ช  )$โ€ฌูˆุงโ€ช ู‘Fโ€ฌุจ ุงโ€ช 3wโ€ฌูˆุง ุฅโ€ช qโ€ฌุง*โ€ช#โ€ฌุงู ุงโ€ช 1 Fโ€ฌุชโ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช  gโ€ฌูˆุงโ€ช  0 0lโ€ฌูˆุงู‘โ€ช..................................................  3aโ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช245โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุฃโ€ช0Hโ€ฌุจ ุง โ€ช x1 < mโ€ฌุง>โ€ช :  )$โ€ฌุงโ€ช#ytโ€ฌุงุก ูˆุงโ€ช*gโ€ฌุงุก ุง;ู‘ โ€ช..... ,โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช246โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช5โ€ฌโ€ฌ


โ€ซุง ู‘ ุงู‘ โ€ช :โ€ฌุงู‘ุช ุง ุฏุฉ  ู† ุง ู‘ โ€ช.........................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช247โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง ู‘ ุงู‘ โ€ช ู‘  :โ€ฌุง "ู‘ ุช ุง!ู‘  โ€ช..........................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช255โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง ู‘ ุงโ€ช : #$%โ€ฌุงโ€ช#โ€ฌุงโ€ช /0โ€ฌุง)  โ€ชู‘.โ€ฌุน ' โ€ช ,โ€ฌู‚ ุง*)ู† ูˆ'&โ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช........................................................................... / )0โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช261โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง ู‘ ุงุฏูŠ '!โ€ช#3 : #โ€ฌู‚ ุงโ€ชู‘#โ€ฌุฏ ' โ€ช 2โ€ฌุงุช "ุงโ€ช#567โ€ฌุฉ" ูˆ' โ€ช 2โ€ฌุง*'&ู…โ€ฌ โ€ซุง โ€ช 0#โ€ฌูˆุง)โ€ช%โ€ฌุฏูŠ โ€ช.............................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช267โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุง '!โ€ช : #โ€ฌุงู‘โ€ช ู‘ 7โ€ฌุงโ€ชู‘.โ€ฌุฑูŠ ุงโ€ช# 5ู‘.โ€ฌุงโ€ช........................... 3โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุง ู‘โ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช275โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซุง ู‘ ุงู‘; '!โ€ช : #โ€ฌุง*'&ู… ูˆุง โ€ช%โ€ฌุฑ< )ุข ุง  ุง ู‘ุฃูŠ ุง(โ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช277โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ ุง ู‘ุขุฑ "ุง  ุง ุฒูˆ" โ€ช............................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช285โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซ โ€ช%โ€ฌุข ูˆุง ู‘โ€ช $โ€ฌูˆ ุฏุง! โ€ช....................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ ุฑุง& ุง '& โ€ช................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ โ€ช" *+ ู‘$โ€ฌุง ุจ" โ€ช% ู‘-โ€ฌุข "ุง ู‘โ€ช "$โ€ฌูˆ!ู‘ ุง ู‘โ€ช 0โ€ฌู… โ€ชู‘-โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุง *ุข โ€ช.........................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช297โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช 1 +โ€ฌุขุข โ€ช...................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุฃโ€ช %โ€ฌุง ู‘ โ€ช.................................................................. 2โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ!โ€ช 67โ€ฌุง โ€ช................................................................ 345โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช9$:โ€ฌู† ! โ€ช4โ€ฌุง ุง โ€ช 0โ€ฌู… )โ€ช 42โ€ฌุง ;ูŠ โ€ช&   -โ€ฌุข ุช โ€“ > โ€ฌ โ€ซุง @;? โ€“ ุง  โ€ช Aโ€ฌุง * ูŠ โ€ช.......................................... (...โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุฃโ€ชB %โ€ฌุฑ โ€ช......................................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช Cโ€ฌุง โ€ช Aโ€ฌุฑูŠ โ€ช...............................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช Cโ€ฌุข;โ€ช.................................................................. 4โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุง โ€ช ู‘Fโ€ฌู‡ โ€ช................................................................ D;*4Bโ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ!โ€ช) G9B DB 67โ€ฌุง โ€ช................................................ ( HIู‘Jโ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ> โ€ช................................................................... D;*4Bโ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ชH+โ€ฌุญ ุง โ€ช D9โ€ฌุง โ€ชKโ€ฌุฑ& โ€ช......................................................โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ>โ€ช......................................................................... MB N4โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซุงโ€ช >Pโ€ฌุฐ *ู‘ โ€ช............................................................ ู‘?2โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซ *ู‘ ุง โ€ช................................................................. 7Aโ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช6โ€ฌโ€ฌ

โ€ซโ€ช299โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช301โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช302โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช303โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช305โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช306โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช309โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช311โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช314โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช316โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช318โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช323โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช324โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช326โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช327โ€ฌโ€ฌ โ€ซโ€ช330โ€ฌโ€ฌ


‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬ ‫‬

‫> م ‪> DB‬ر‪............................................................... D9‬‬ ‫‪+‬ري ا ‪ Q‬ري ‪..............................................................‬‬ ‫  ‪ ? DB‬رك ‪................................................................‬‬ ‫ *ّ ا‪2‬ة ‪..................................................................‬‬ ‫‪ 42‬ا ;ّي ‪.................................................................‬‬ ‫آ ل ا ‪K‬و‪................................................................ B‬‬ ‫را‪ -‬ا اوي ‪............................................................‬‬ ‫ *ّ ‪J‬ا  ‪...................................................................‬‬ ‫‪ V‬رق ا @ ‪...................................................................‬‬ ‫ ‪ Q‬ر ا ‪............................................................... 9F‬‬ ‫ا ‪W‬ر ‪................................................................... +‬‬ ‫‪.................................................................. ;% XK:‬‬ ‫‪HY‬ل ا *?‪.................................................................. X‬‬ ‫‪ ?2‬ا ‪ J9J‬ا ? رو‪........................................................ %‬‬ ‫ ر ‪................................................................. Zّ4‬‬

‫ ‪ Y :‬ا ?'ري ‪................................................................‬‬ ‫ *د ا ‪ّW‬وادي ‪................................................................‬‬ ‫ *ّ ‪9 +B‬ي ‪................................................... ّ ?2B‬‬

‫‪7‬‬

‫‪331‬‬ ‫‪334‬‬ ‫‪335‬‬ ‫‪336‬‬ ‫‪339‬‬ ‫‪340‬‬ ‫‪341‬‬ ‫‪342‬‬ ‫‪343‬‬ ‫‪344‬‬ ‫‪345‬‬ ‫‪346‬‬ ‫‪347‬‬ ‫‪348‬‬ ‫‪349‬‬ ‫‪350‬‬ ‫‪351‬‬ ‫‪352‬‬


             ! "#

%  ' (    !  ) # $ %  & !  +& ,  -   ' .%)  "  " .2011 &   %  /0  -) 1 &/   4/  ., %1 ' +/  ++1  3)  8" 2011 ,)%  ' ) -)  56& $7  3"  9,6  -   ' ! $ %  '  - : ; 6 ( .+<)  = > 6   & "  "  +   / .&    -   )%  <? '@ 01 ./ ,  # $    $,) && # % (<?) 8" ! 'B $)?  .  A"#   (/  8" )0 ) . C ) D% ) '  8 '&   + ' + '06 - @ <  $  E+   F  )  '?, $# G ' ., 9+)   9?+ " =  =+& ) G $))/ . ! ' 3" (1  '? $&  "@ C ) D%  6 '% .))+ .9 %  &?      H) 1 - #   A"# ' - '@ ,H #9+) < =    H) # $ ! 

$<%   = +  ' 3"): H) '!  + & I ))/ )  =  $# )+  .)! = 3"  < E+ 9)& '  = ? $  1 ' ; 6 ! &/<& 9


(,&   1 & 4) I H) $( '    ( <+ (& =  H)   =@ / )    1 9  '  . .! = ( 1 '? < . H) &?& 0  < % ' ? ! ? < =@ - 9+)  +)  , & 0%)     A"# '@ ;) <  96F D,) ! =1 & H) & % ' &< "6 .   + = 6 ' 3" (    H) D,) 9&@ '!L    E J =K)  .K, 1 : K .H1 

 = ( @   A &  '!L "N & # & " '&"     J K   / = OF P  J ) D% 4 ./ <   0 "6 4 " ' Q!  & "

! = -  D) ")?  " &O '  D% .ATCE % 6   )  0 'OL )  J  ' "N & # & " <& <& B&  ) & "9? '& 00< & " -! @ (% 6 'PK

O&  &! Q!  K6 6F "# I&  %  .(") 8" ")  1" "8  1" - @ .   6) ) 6 0 = - J& "/ ;1&  " -! <&  J 1O  = -  -! '!  $2004 ) 1 K  (&& &  O O = 3" 4 80& - J& 6   , ? < <& !1@ L(TU# + '! & & 9& VO < ' ! <& %  ' O '& )K '1 ; 6 +K <&  6 ' 3" D)  ')J +1 . 1 4/ 56&   ! &/   6 ' () O) ? < .! 1 10


! E/ )%  6 ' ( O  % 6 6  J& K- "#   ! A   J 1O  (  E? " .O  J   E/  '6 ! % 6 E/ =  W!1 .%   &? (K) H1 L $"# -6 '  J 1O  D  '  %@ K1  J '   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ;1& 1 X 1 8) '  6 . + â&#x20AC;&#x201C; )1 %F â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  ) '1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  -P â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (% ) &

'P # (...   ' ) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 3 '&  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ,)  1 < <K . 0 ' ATCE ' 9&)Y +  D) ! ' ... % 6  6O HK)  4 O%  &! O 5 1 '! ATCE 9G .1 : = O <  6 ' 3" " '&"  .H) -6  K ? < 4% !# Q! ' 0 &@ â&#x20AC;¢ '&< '0"Z &  G  ) 4% ) -6 &<K APL 1) ' &O DO  V  ' Q! O' $D) / " '& . O ; 6 L O L K)B (& +  ,1O . + 0, . +,  6 ' " '&"  â&#x20AC;¢ .0%)J [+1! '  ' !  =  & "+)! )  J O6 +  %  /  . % 4%  /& G ) 1 % 1 % 6 <  &)\ <  #  .+)  ]) ) ,K  2004 .&6) " '&" I  2002 )  I+)  â&#x20AC;¢ '! 2014 ) .&6) I  >+ ' < &/ ' () 4 2009 -6 &/ ' E%@ Q1 K) = 6O  J  H '  O& I K -6  5K6  ? < 01  & O . !K 11


 &  " '&" #O  ""+)J"    &  3"  %  <& 6 .,!  .) .)! )# ' $+K+1  .0%)^ G 4 .   + 8  4% "8O1" P .O  .)O!L

 =<  ,0 <) O ? < . ! %& â&#x20AC;¢  J 1O  .% .,! " '&" 1 %   J '   ? < ! 1 Q! 9/J  -6& (ATCE 9G .1) HK) _% )+  / 6   ` <& 6  J  =) =1 6O  +? ; 6   1 1 4 &O 0\ ' <& E%@  1  6 ' L0L & D  1  a  %O  =+& ) ' (O#P O +&O &6)  (% & +) 4% ",)& .A G &+L 6  D) + 1F ) (  D  1 K- O< . 1 ')J +1 K- =+& â&#x20AC;¢ 4)L  .K, ' 8) '0K   b +, .K, A 

 &)&  $) 4%& 6O  J   @ O  1 % (& .%  +& @ ",K) O % 9 1 6  J )C ' ,0 &6 )&  & +< .&+<  A%K  1K+)  % # $ % D  ! ' K)  < H) , !< .A  @    1 0% O 1 O5) 8F +, 

        

12


 :â&#x20AC;Ť×? ×?â&#x20AC;Ź  â&#x20AC;Ť×?  ×?  ×?â&#x20AC;Ź (Agence Tunisienne de Communication ExtĂŠrieure)  J  K!1 c56 d0% K) I?K .K, 1 ! A"#

J 4 '<K&) 6  3" '! 9    1) (O%L (1 $% 6 'PK 0 4 )K& ; 6   ( ^ O< .> 6 .#%K  ./ 0)  ' !1@ ' O & O .O)!@ '   & ATCE .)! / &! 1O = #",) &  6 '  J  = O O #% 4 $D) 6 O56 O< 8 & <O  =  -/ .& +& - <K TU# \! K  @ K6 ",) %\ '0" DO  / QH  W+K+U1 .0%)J !& " K D)" ')< ' % = - "# +1 ! L< $" '& '&< .OP '  4 )%F ')K 'K  ' J ' .<% >  J <)  D) .1) 3" O6 &)%F b< ')J +1  1 .O 1 L'U?  &! #0 & &  &  '& ,&  D)  4 O ' '! )    + &  +)  G ' & & + @   F     +< . % 4%  < !  ? b< +   & < .(')J +1 . 1& 6  .H1  =@ J .K, ' < 5O1, <& '!L "# : ATCE 56& 13


; 6& J a) &  < .P  #T (1 ' $ ) '   2006 )  .0% $, e&& ATCEZ )K 0,  "J OP !" '! # < .P O# STB 3)& ()  ) ' 2 e&& !" a) &  '#T)

... STAR CTN T.TĂŠlĂŠcom .!  BH BNA  J  -6 <& 6? )0  & ATCE + (2 6 0! K 4 < 91) -6& )O ) , 4 )& ; 6& + & 9 D) =@ V <  )F  a &  . + Q! =

!) &  '1  !K& O@  O   J 3" $&  &%@ a K 4) =@ F   '@ "# $ K&  I?K&  "!K&  4 )K& (%) =@ ATCEf .<   ! 9 %@ # O6 40K  .&O DO   J  '"@ <& 'F !1 HK) L6 (&)%  ))  ) Q! 0   O + (3 GB& 3" $DO  6 4?& TK< .+1L\ # @ ) O6 . @ .1, ) ' .+1 A"# '!& 8 J  O :   ! "# $ %

 

 ) - 15

" RĂŠalitĂŠs" K%  1 K%  1

 ) - : 10

"Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Economiste MaghrĂŠbin" "g&" ,1  '+1

 ) - 12

"Le Temps" (2007 8 3)

14


V & L0%)T  ; 6  D)  .,P  & ,! (4   O +  6 ' 3" $(%0  &O DO   4 ((%K .)   )) 0%)J = U  ',KP ..,KP A"# ' &<L   9)/\ 4 a  = U  : (.) ' K  1) & )" ! 4%& DO  + <& O  + & ATCE ./ â&#x20AC;˘ ÂŤ Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;ĂŠpopĂŠe illustrĂŠe de la (&! ' 6T) 500 9)/& "% ' .< ! . 0 '  = <0 Tunisie Âť ! 0%)B& .K,! $    . ,1 &)& 2010 .  â&#x20AC;˘ & <   .<K  '& =" ()) & D  %0 1 3000  "8# ? - " ))&K ! . &&  8" "1

.  38.500 .0#) ,!& 6) OPZ < Z "Z1 '& Z)" .O+ ) â&#x20AC;˘ <& 0%)@ =   & 2008 ,)% 4  ÂŤ Jeune Afrique Âť .O $(  ' & 8" " La Tunisie dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;aujourdâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;hui " ! ' % O'  $  - 75 &+L 6) 3000 9)/& ATCE &/ '   40 O =F (<&  ! ' 6) 3000 .)/\ ' & ATCE .< .OP '  = )+  F ,! /  ;)" ! ' 6T) 200 ATCE .)/  D,)  â&#x20AC;˘ ."O  -O)" / < <% " '&   <    O .) (%K& "O1 8 0"   .O â&#x20AC;˘ Non Delanda Carthago : " ()) " K" D) 1 ! 0%)J

= , !" ' ()! 4 $"Carthage ne sera pas dĂŠtruite < 9?+ D) =@ )  ' + ()&J () + ( ATCE1 ., 15


             

(5 &)             ! " # $  %  0 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; " $ . /  " + , â&#x20AC;&#x201C; '&   &  %  & * "  2002  3 4  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1  & !   & 2   " â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    6*  &   5  & 1 ! " # $ & (     !

6* ) $     & 7 89       & 1:  ;8  & / % : â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  &  !  & * $ & $ 4  &    $ >  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 7  *!  <  2=% $ 2005  1!  ?! 0 & 6 !  7@ 1:"  !  +   >    # ATCE    ; (...  0 &     "    C 1  "1 . 7 " . ! '  B

>   /:     %  8 41 14  > !   6* :   / .!  E1  ,; $ ATCE & : .7 $ . D*  "*  6

 C * . .4   . % $ F%G             

  *  . D  G =% $  !9  62*  68  $ GH G D   72  > !  $ G* 9  7 $ . D* 6

"   $   ."C $ " 6I !  *     : 1   !  *  . <  1 1 7 .> " ! " # $ = ATCE  7  8 6   1!  / %  %

   " 1!  . 1% 6*1 (: & 1 ") > : 1  $   J1<

L 

  "*  . 1% M  .$   . 1 N% (1 "*   E # $># O7 $ !      4   /  E1 P   /    D / O   " %  Q:  . ."*  R,;  %0 %  16


 ? < # ) #0%)i  . + = O   @ (2 -1 9&)F . !&  8   -6 + Q! =  ; 6 .D)& ')J +1 . 1 4? = O% ; 6& 0 &J & 1J !1@ &)% ,1 50 ' ! ?\ (3 .+ '?1 D) < 4+ '" ) 4% 9) ' J& O% 1J (4 &)%F & <  J  ' G ' 'O1! !  ., 80,    &  .  H)  6 ' 3"   J E/ 1 .) )  !& = 6 4/ 9)@ (5 .D) D) 1 .% &  .K, ) O6 @ )0  (6 .&)%F . % -1&   4?& LT a & Kh& )<  "@ 0, .)/ 4 ) (7 #   1 a & ;)@ " '&"DO  / H  D)  ')J +1 4/ 4 3" + &  )  @ .6   4 $&  +  D)& +<  !, . 1 )! = %  ; 6& ? < ( 0  = O  1 &) '# &" A  8 1 a) & : ) ")6 /0  ' " ? < & '& " ( 3  2005 &) 1  « ANB » )/ = "D& " ? " A  )+ D,) = 8 1 a) & / "%1 #" "N / "  ' g " " ) '1" "%/ -)" ( 3  &"  J A  8 1 a) & / « ANN » )/ = 8 1 a) & .( « ART » « New TV » )/ , "'&+< 0%)J ) &« « BBC ) , « LCI » )/ 4 ) (8 .D) 1  @ .? 17


/"NBN" / "& <") &)% . "@ .?,& . 6 H)

(9

" & ' )" ' Q!  ("Deutsche Welle" /"New Tv" /"ANB" ..."D& '# &" "%/ -)" "  &1" " ? " . . ) ! 5 /     ) (10 O% 4? D)& K ?K) 0 &J " K" .0%)B& - <K ...  O< ')J +1 . 1 4/ O +& " )" )+& ',1   ,1 0!   @ (11 .+  !    +T  ) 0K)& ATCE : 2   : O 0 * 1  18 678   9 # -;5  ) 4% ' '  '1 ' @ ',1 )% (1 &)% .? =  1 a & &)  !  )% ') 6&  ?1& 9 3" (" ") " '&"  .&! ' 4T "80  >" "%/ -)" "D& '# &" : + ?) , "N & '& " "  &1" "  !&&" " ) '1" "  ' g " "%1 #" " ? " " & ' )" .(( ) "'&+< &" (' F) "+ N & " (')&) "  D)"  @ & 1J &)%  O ' ',1 ? (2 4&"  <& D) .&! =  J , ! 0 a) & ." &) ' &  & .?,& D) 1  @ .? 40 (3 .) & "BBC World" ) , "LCI" )< ' J ) 4% ) ' ')< 4 .9+ H) (4  = O  ,!& #O &)%F  J  =@ h1 ) % 18


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hristian Mollard"  1 1  9  ; ,# @ ,- ! ATCE 91 $% R )% # (   2009 !( 8 .B E 19


!(  % )21 6! !  /= 2! GE! ,!9 (9 .K  !# !( >   7 7 :;! !   ! !( I ( 8! % ,- 2  $% #  % ##%< ,!9 (10 ;P T =! Associated Presse! UIP! Reuters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


& #(" C  $% "&  %" 1 # : 1  [ ;P C %! + 61  " 27"! " / B#!"  E #!# ! " / !!    "!" 1 P /! " " B $% #!#  .Reuters B#  Z7 ,  "# %! " \  #( #% : 2  [  7# , O6!  ,-  R .-  /= %= "Le Monde" Z7 ,.  !  N R 2( \ ,.- &.;  # #= ATCE .1 61 /A!   ##%> K    7 7 E ATCE # ;P   V#  ( $. ! !  ,<  /! ! $% # ! > +!9 2!   6! B# %  .? 7 2    !   P# 7# B E! G +A (14 7 7./  P#! ,-. $%   ,P  G . ? 7 , %! ,   ! , /( # ! %>! 

9  89 G    ? 7  5!   1 G +A (15 # ! #   ! ? 7 & ! 1  #> G  6!

.  )21

G ! ! 89  7#  /   U G  A (16 ! %! (  9 ##%= - ( / M / )  9  ) ,%> B )# $% C A !  .! ' K!  ' ! !  !   F ,    - 9  ! " " 89 $= , L(   P 5Q  #! )8!  # & 89 B E! #9   +. . " " 89  %F G9) " =" K 7(! 21


  !( % "&!2N" )P $= P( I= , . !( ! )P !( #. 8 !( > +!9 % D# !.      S $%   8 . !( ! B29   !( 1  9 !( N./ !  ,  S $% , L(  N/ ( RQ/  %  D!2! $= + .  , ,-   !(   E!.   7 !(   !( 91 G2! C .  , . !( / IS!  D1  !( ! L!  ,- "I#!" )9   PE! #( G V# /! 2  N  . !( N./ #.  !(   # = I2%( #( G !( , (... & 2= !(   !(  9 /  ! ! !(   )21 $% 7#  ! & ] A (17 ,-. U-  6! B ! $= BI> RQ/   U C# !( &;  !  !( #    %! 7# ;P V.5\! #) & " ! " N  ! ("! "6 P "  S $% ! G ... "^ # % "! " !/% C ! R !E! +  6)  &A7  ! .1 (18 .2!. ! #!# ! 89 .   L#  9  C ' ,!9 (19  $2  .) =!  /=  BE & !  !  .(:;  " N " E=! & ! "&!" G! E< .1 (20 B Z7  (!  7J  ! ( 2 G! P! 8 ) - !  ) ! # 8! G ! B( ! ,. ! 9.5!   M # > ;P ! O'7 L(   0 !# B#!    8 G!    5.  1.  !   ."  !Q #" 1  S $% ! PEA 22


www.changement.com : G! : 

.9#   !9   B   M # (21  M # ! &P > ! L /  9 ##%< ,!9 (22 . E=  P  )21 C   7 $% 5Q  $% ATCE  (23 !! ,12  ; 2  C  R!/     7 . //  , N ! , ! ,# P  :  8 _  "L#  " !%#   "ANN" B .5 #%

, O"%  " ,- $%      ;P ! 2006 ! ;P G   ,#% N P - 1 ATCE    B9 B #< . 8   ; % B9 #9  OR !.  '9= S % 5Q.  G C  '2  9   0 ,# ! #%!!    ;P .V % ."6! " $%    N !( _  L  7=  9 V  B9 G +1. 8  9  , #! G  18 K ;  +  6)  &7 # (" R%!2! ! ,! ) " N  ! (" !  7#  G " !  .("-" C G  9 1.  , >  E  IE # ,!9 (24  .   P#!E 7   !.  . 8! ,%>  / #%!! /.  #!! +)5! V#Q ! P / #  %> ? 7  6! B ! G  :;!  !.  V#!  P-.  " PRP " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (6  ) "Image 7"  / G !  1  : 5) .((B P9) " Arab Média " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (') " AZ Consulting " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (! ) %!  %= @ E<   ##%  ATCE ,!9 (25 News "! "ANN"! "NBN"! "Anb"  S $% )21 C G ! 

23


'? -& 3" ("81  O1" )/) "+" " )" "TV .% 6  J& D) 0O ?1 : <  =8 & D) +O O& <  ) .O?, &\/ ' 0%)L . 1 X + & %)  . %& K< 4? 1 1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <F ) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; )) /  (# J 6 X&01 O<K (... = +&K â&#x20AC;&#x201C; '?K)  %  (1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; % 6   4 (... &<K 8O  O 1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; IK â&#x20AC;&#x201C; )K 4% ) +K ( !   1 J ! 4 ')< ',1 V<& -! (... " OO !&&" ") '&  " "D& '# &"  G = ) -6  ) 4% O #H  0, .++1 = ) 0%)T .++1 # $  + ' ' (& <)  . % )K J "#  O $'   =  ) 0,K -  ' D = 3" ) 6 !  4 1 ) 'O 4  ) 1 , %   + 0%) 0,K .++1  .) 6 &/ '  .6 ,  G = O1 . /  " " ! LD!< + a & .%)! â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  J 'O& )< â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <K â&#x20AC;&#x201C; '? â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  & ) .D)& 1  ?1 < â&#x20AC;&#x201C; K  &)%F  J  =@ .1? (%  O ?/ <& .')J +1 . 1 4?& +K< 4? -6&  0, .)/ = .1  h1F !   :   I  h&  G = $2008 8 ,  "'  %" !1 56& France 24 "   O" )/ = "8" !" 1 (O%L .Anb )/ = "<& ," 1 (O% 6: 24


ATCE      +K &6F  ;)J 6? )0 ) ATCE LL  /   . % 4%   ,1O . + .O .K1 -6 = EO0 K +  %  1 = ( ' K  1) . + A"# EO0    : K O  1 1 &6 (%0 &O DO  )  â&#x20AC;¢ .#<& #F + .0%)J O#C& !"K )F -6  â&#x20AC;¢  +    &) ' 4& > !") ) .)! 9 .&)  > !" =1?F , 8 ) )  (...    % = ) +  (&  O   < K .&6) )   (8&) ? &&  (2009 )  J +  ' + #H  G 2005 )  ! < DC! H) X 2001 )  <F H))

D! I K â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2004 1994 ) + !  Y +  DC! H) â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; &F <F â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2006 2002 1998 .) + ! < O/ ' ) 90% H)) %)!  (... &K  ) 2010 ) ... (2005 ) D)& .< 4% ..O% L\! &6 ) â&#x20AC;¢ = ) ")L" HK) #L &<  -1 .)+ .  I? â&#x20AC;¢ .(2009 ) " 0%" )/ O? KH)L O% 1 O'  G <) 'K" ; 6  '? < (%O   I? = 5 1 â&#x20AC;¢ ."   9 " & "*   " &<& & HK) 25


: D = ')< C! O ., <   4+ "# ATCE     

  

50

  

100

 

200

   

320

! "# $%& # %

,- 150

 ')*+ #

,- 290

.* $  /0  + .  $)

,- 800

 % ,-  / 2 .324

,- 800

5 / # 6 3% 7 .-4

 3000

89 8: ;* 3% +

 8 / 50

82< 3= !* 4

:  

  -  2009 ) ! 4 ')<  / ,

26


<% 6  *

# > /  = ATCE @ /9?

# 2

$ . 39.935

E B* % @ C>&D  UPI  9! 2DD / $6 : ) / ,+ 5 3% + (1 ."/ " G:    = I  JK (2  / ! "#  .,"! /  = 3  9! K  50 + (3 .2009  ) ATCE ,-  + / 8,4 (4 .324  % %  9!  $% + (5 "# !* $   / !&* $  L% ! .5 / = $* - 2D #

    % ) (5 UIP

$ . 13.770

>9? K ! 7+  .3% $K

     (8 /!*)

$ . 12.980

" 3  K 7+  (1 .M "/ $K % $-  (2 .$"  & N*

  (8 /!*)

3 

$ . 19.583

# 7+  (1 .M "/ " O 0 N* $K 3%  (2 .$"  & .2009  K 60 /  + (3 27

   (8 /!*)


<% 6  * $ . 24.974

$ . 41.397

$ . 48.220

# > /  = ATCE @ /9?

# 2

,-   + / 8,4 (1 .324  ATCEP ")0 %0"  7 .-4 (2 . %K

   ( !*)

.&* ?  K 72 + (1  6 ;"! $K + (2 .Q  / "# $ ,-  / 2 (3 .324  %   0" 3% !   (4       /!*) ." DM!0 3% 2) "$   )4 M"0 "? ("/# >" .(".# " * / " 3% !   (5 "? ." DM!0 3% 2) "R .("8 Q" / /!* "0 #) ) K 280 + (1 %" "/ " @ .("/ ,-   + / 8,4 (2 .324  E   0 + (3 .  $) .* %0" %K  # (4 .")0 6 ;"! ,& $K + (5 8: 8,!*  ;"! "" ."9"P > 28

! "  (/!*)


<% 6  *

# > /  = ATCE @ /9?

# 2

$ . 9.126

("  &" .-+ $) + . %  9! 2009  K 44

  !

( !*)

$ . 6.601

$ . 3.883

$ . 7.119

 9! 2009  K 51 + .ATCE

 %  9! K 36 + $) .* $-C 2009 . !  $U"V 

 %  9! K 24 + $) .* $-C 2009 . !  $U"V 

  #  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; /!*) 8)4 9  , 9 59&  /

S" $6S ("J& $   0 > T/!*) 9    9 8)4 ( ,  %     > T/!*) 8)4 9  , 9

  7+ (2011 /! 14

$ . 10.352

/ « anb » 3% 7 .-4 .5

$ . 48.434

 ) K 320 + (1 . %  9! 2009 &  $K   + (2 29

& '( (/!*) )  (3% /!*)


   !"

      ATCE   

 

"# ""  " #$ % "$ &' )  ")* % "$ +,# &'  "0 ") '- ." $ 6)2" 6) ("$12 ) 3'!4

) " "$7 8  9:" " "2 42  "6 "$ 9:" " $ "  $ => ... " "1;) " .#$ 22: ?   $2   "  "A7 8) B" "@" -"  ." 19" " "  'C"

' @")7 " "#   6)2D (3 .8 "D 9 : ":" ' E9  " (4 ." , ?9! E9 " "#  " (5 . $2: 2 2009 2 FC  $ B (6 "+ 9   2  :" " 8)  "" $ ' FD G.: @> 

! ' $" 8 "?' $ ' 8 I.: @>  "H "  .("6' J"" 8  9! "  (7 .6)$ 9D  ATCE - ,# 56 B

+ . 14.639

+ . 9.790

(1

.2009 2 FC 8  9! "  (2 .6)$ 9D  +   $ K "- : B (1 Transcription des )

-9! 30

  (-9!)

  


<% 6  *

# > /  = ATCE @ /9? 8&  / (confĂŠrences de presse .(, 0 % U ,: @6 $# / $? (2 % ,Z9W C / $K .(J= / @" 3)

# 2   (/!*)

$ . 47.000

$K

<  #

$. 14.573

$K

'    

$. 13.860

$K

  

$ . 12.941

$K

 $  

$ . 11.805

$K

    

$ . 11.647

$K

=4   ! 

$K

!   

$ . 10.780

$K

 >  

$ . 9.680

$K

   

$ . 9.593

$K

#   

$ . 9.458

$K

+  

$ . 9.411

$K

 ? 

$ . 9.240

$K

  <(

$. 9.020

$K

$ 0 *

$ . 8.470

$K

 @  

$ . 8.400

$K

# % #

$ . 8.360

$K

  

$ . 8.360

$K

*  

$ . 8.310

$K

  A

$ . 10.780

31


<% 6  *

# > /  = ATCE @ /9?

# 2

$ . 8.250

$K

*  

$ . 8.235

$K

   

$ . 7.920

$K

  !

$ . 8.092

$K

 <  0 B

$ . 7.719

$K

7B  7

$ . 7.590

$K

  C

$ . 7.480

$K

8 D 

$ . 7.285

$K

  7

$ . 7.119

$K

   

$ . 7.087

$K

& C

$ . 7.087

$K

.D   &

$ . 7.040

$K

* 

$K 

3  $ 0 > T8) , 9   &  7+ (2010

$ . 7.040

) ! 4 ')< K6 -  E% .& "# .6 -?& 1J ')<&   963.384 1 2009 ;)@ 9 < J   J 'P 9&   J  < .) ) ;)@ 8 & < ;)@ ) !  . + . %  9& F ')<&   106.616 @ -?T $%   

32


( 7 2009  ) ATCE

    

(! '  . J   I)   . % 1 ')   8,474

[ -= ) , .&*  (,  5   % ,-4

1

  9,500

 7<) Q  / ,-4 $#   &S 43 $2     5 I ,-+ 0 4 N&* C ( = &* /

2

  9,047

9 $) .&* / ,-4  2 7<)  * # 8)4 - D   $&S  B ( ,-4 ,)+

3

 .0 737

&# $6)# $%- @ #  " Image 7 " : Q  *K $  AZ " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (%) " PRP " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (5) " Arab MĂŠdia " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (.) "Consulting ... (2)

4

  1,818

" :$2: &82= /*K # !% )+ * - )+ * - !* 376 8   6+   %)

 + !* % 6+ ($ U% .* (- ) ) >9? . , : 2009  $2: 820  )4 ? *  \ ] \ 33

5


. / $"  . # 0 O? S . #- 9 $ K .2009  7 $K! -

 .0 64,607

 < 29) Q  $< .% / " 0  $ ,#" 2009 $  " ] 0 %- $2: (...

6

 .0 241,316

 % @ # $ N) ... )+ !*

7

: 

+, 4/ ' T D)  ')J +1 1 ?    4K  & !  0 & $. 1 + 4+  LK<T b ./ 6 K @ AO &<K 8O  O 1 ' &! b& 1O ( : % 6  J 4 <K > = O ,1O )  ! = /  & + ; 6& ) ) , -! D) 1 ;   ; 6& ) !  &! 1&  .  ,& 3"& < .O  &)%F . "J .?,& ')<  '&) ' J ',1 ' &!   )% &)%  "@  0, .)/ > '  ; 6 D) ' ATCE 4

@ ' (0% O K ' $(0%)@ (H) " '&" ' E .D) ' &  < 6 'C 8F :    D  & 0) "  )" ' Q! 6 O '& "" " ? " (+& F . 1 ')J +1 < 34


1 .<& (" Jeune Afrique " %) "& G " ,1 O& "D) + 0%)@ ( =K) =K1 ')J +1 ' EO ) &O  K- .1 ' , '? < <) !   5K6  01F   O  "&+ 6  '&" +&   6)   " !" 01C& :  ) )    )0 C ; 6  ? < =

) D) IK  ) HK) 8+)L O? "   O1" K)  1 ".& ")" ' Q!  6) X & F 1K  4 O+ 3  +) %  "&)F 1" "/ & I" "1&  " .(; 6&  , ? < #0 1 K .< 4% ? < 01 O     (O1  3! .)! '@ =K1) & < Q!   -H 4 K   J  3 1  6 ' 4 F .&) ./F   .< : & O1" + A, 8" "D& '# &" (& 9% 8" &6 <&   . ! '  ) - 48 A /  & (%0 " &6   O "%) V1 4 '? 1"  !  ) , .&! -1   &!  + 2006 ,)% 20  "g&"  % .+) ATCE ' 0<B&  H)K =@ "& %) 1" ?)& OL !  %&   .< O1  n  ' 3" $' '6^ O) )& (PDP) +K  + 01  2010    '), = )O .9  ( +)    ' & ( 35


'  &/ & %& "& "  H) ' 01 -/ 0 &@ 4  6 ' "PDP"Z& K '& "# ATCE .K $D) V  =

3" ) !   &   ' (0+)  =@ (%  <&) (O) 40

 ( (& + 40K  $IK& O !  KH) \& .KH) 4% ("& % " "& %) 1") A0  01 .! F 1K .   "D )!" 9?   4 )< -1 . "J .?, 9&)F . !   ' =K1 ! " '&" H) = E&  < .1& &)%  / \ .') ' J V<& : &  "J P ' ) )+  &) ,1   56 O (1

) @  h&  .  & Anb )/ 0 () 0, 0 &J  !&  J 9?, "#    &  &6 = )+ &) & O  .0%)J& - < &O D  . & . , ? < ' .< O+  ) !J 4/ <&& ATCE + (2 .D) ) ' ") 6" !  4 )K&   (3  < ',1 '  J .P 1 '  1 90@   00<  ?1 < D) !& , < '&  & + -1 V<& " 0%" )/ 6 & +  " 9J" . 1 &+& ) && # ?1 9) ! + $; 6& ? < ' .K,  a &   +  < & 1J /@ '1 = 5 1 )L <K 0 &T D)  . 1  !1 H)  4OT .0  b ' ., 4% '& < b< G & ( ! (/+1& 36


,K@ )  ()) 2006 + ! < DC! &)& (4 4  2006 D)" ')<&  @ ? BBC )/ .K& ATCE 4 8 @ 9)& & = D) )#  = 0K!  ? # "&+ .1 .& ? LCI )/ .K& ! "# ."87/11/7"  ") &+ IL) "')" .!O 1 8 " '&" H) ' EO (5 = 3 1 K6 ! . ('? < (& T.<)L 8" &O HK) ! 1 '! Google Earth Wikipedia 4/  .) )  !& :  . J  D)& 56 >1 1 : WIKIPEDIA .) ,  < 4/ 0+)   1 4 D & 6 :  ! )+ 6 : GOOGLE Keyhole

4/ - < .< !& 0!  : ; 6 &)& â&#x20AC;¢

D,)  D)  6 ' )<  % </   Markeup Language  6 < 0@ -& 3" $D) = 1 .H1  '! E J % ' () .H1   &) 4/ - < . @ ! .)<  % 4/ = I  4 '<& ")" L &<T  . J %1 : 6O &)& â&#x20AC;¢ .,)  6 %1 ' )< I #0!  "')" ' &< ' 8    h& 0%)@ â&#x20AC;¢ .Dailymotion Youtube </ = O6 4) # J 1 K& ,K! ATCE L 1 0!  (6 ) -O  01! ! 1 -) "'&# @" ?K) ! 1 ) & @ .(A 6 ' / '< "&# @"   ,1 . + 1 <& : 1 A"# O O# * # J E? 1 .?, &  a & .) )  &  37


0!  '   + .  1 <& 4 ) -  .)  V   &)%F .H) 6 #< h1& # J E? 1 ; 6& H)  '1 '1& 1, .-  ATCE ' 56 3  1 = -  : - J *

,CK  + V<&  J 9?/  ) & %)L > 6 .9,!  & .1  ')< ATCE   =   4+ .< 4% )  ! '? < ) ,1 '< J "#  4/) ; 6  < .(ATCE 4 )< & H) + )/ # $. &  ANB )/ : 1 ) *

  .#%  .  # 1   . !"  @ .3" F K K! % . !"  @ 4 -O K # J 1! .#F ." &)%F  + 1 .+1  @ .<  !  ; 6  .) ?1 6 . 0) )< - F . 0 -6 4 )K  +K ' 7) = 1 % ' (4% ) 'P % 6

 .< =@ ?@   .  h1& . + .,! #  <? ; 6& .) 56&

38


:   ATCE      )%F 6 ; 6   J 3 1K a & ! O<T . )%F A" 6? )0 K6T !1 01 + H) :    ! 3O 1 a) & = & D   2006 8 ,   . K . 0 'C .1 + = =)&) ! F 1 .  DO  & + I? -& 9< ' J ' ' < USA : . %  O   -/ " '&" .&01 O<K â&#x20AC;¢ .# J -O K "&) )O IK â&#x20AC;¢ .D)   %  8/  g%K) â&#x20AC;¢ .< O/ &)& ; 6  ? < AO   Q! V1 â&#x20AC;¢ .2005 )  6 D)  +<) .+O  .KH) 4 '<K 00< â&#x20AC;¢ .D) 0 !  .6   â&#x20AC;¢

39


        !"# " $%     ".-   ')*" , 9 8# 3%  %- % 3) (2010  3 / &S T"M  32 " /)4 -

&+ !& /1@ 4/ ATCEZ& '< ',H G X1 L O+T 1) ?@ 4 F OP  )pU?+ )!  O  . ) 300 1& + &+ O &L G &! .k!& '<K ',KH  X2 $"))& O1" $"' -" $"DO& '# &") ?J O V<&& (... "  &1O" : & O  1) = ' O1 "DO& >" (%0 "DO& '# &" (1  e& ' ()! O / ANB )/ .K+1L ' L4+T  ) 2500 # / &+ K)  L T!" K  0 ' &! .<&  ) 5000 LAL / .& (,K! K\ .O .O 9+ /O , +) e& = O1 "  &1O" (2 O  6 e& E% 0% $.0% 9  Q1 9 ! K\ . ) - 45 1 2010 ) ' =F !  1 =@ '/ =   - 150 e& 1 O (3 K  0 ' &! .< = 9)&   "Gango Investments" .<) " Marco Gannouna " O  O56 e& # $.1? ' . K  %  !  1 (K) ,T .) )  !&  (1 K 40


& D  1 ; 6  )L  Q! &/   ATCE .  V < # ) '!  ., ' < ("1 3" ' $(%0 '!  "=  -" .! @   )& + "!  " ()! , F& )< 56& .< K - F  O $#q\<L  G = (Les adresses IP) ) !  .& 1 ATCE 4 < K< 3&, .) )  4/ 1  (1& ATCEZ (  .("'%  !" &F 0& L \T &!  I)  'p?+ ')< '  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;3 > &") < .k) ! -6& .k! %Y < > $" / '& %" $" '1  O1" $" O)" $"+ (... "! K #K" .? 0)& /@  ') .1 &! -  % â&#x20AC;&#x201C;4 . 6  & " ' ? ! O< J "80 %)" K <& â&#x20AC;&#x201C;5 K) D% 4 ./ < K & ,K!  0 ()< O 8" ")?    J 'PK& -K! "   ' 1" / '  D%

 & 2010 '% 17 D6  1& 3" ATCEZ& J  '   @  4% = - J& J D,) ' '  1O 0!  ' ) && '06 ' > 6 (&!& .)! -  > & ,&   4)&  A"# 4% - @ J / O ' ) =@ < A"# 4& / $! ; 6 +) <& & E,)  0 " O< .6& -K!  @ ' ! <   @ ?+ K & <  J .9 %J E&K ' "%K  ]O P 11/010  &6 O 1) - J &/ .1  %  / .(K  0 "80 %)" (& = 8K" 2010 '% 23 41


:        "    "   &  '  ( * +' ,) " $%"   !# .(  .( ,/ 0% &' +'  $) "%  " &3  % 2( +' ) "1 (  " .(4 .( 6% +' ) "/ , ' 5" &8,' $84  (9    9  ;<= 8= 1) "%  " 4 > ?  3 >@ #  ((3 .2005  $' ,' (A B  !' C

 3@ ,  ATCED C4  "1 # " 9  ;<= ' "1 #  " C$ 9 A ,   !89 ;' C/8 8EF 64'' "8 "   C (3  (8   &  C6 &8, L9 !89     ? GH I &4' J' I, K' CG$ C !89 C  M'NH  &'=8 4' .ATCE L'  (@   ;<= .( C K  9  '  $'  6 <  MON GH . 8  4P J 4 . 6%9 3    ATCE  1    (8  : ()   

9 ") " =  " ,( 'H  2009  3 ' #F 8 I  ( ("Q 8 (  '" "& 8 #  8 '$ "C R " '8 > "4  "  '8   C+' .  &3 /  '$   *@    42


: ATCE * +) "() *" $ &

 A2 . ATCE $ / * ' * ) (   + /0  

3%

#

1992

%!  

9 , ? T 7

1993

Nicole Ladouceur & Luc Dupont

La Tunisie une dĂŠmocratie naissante Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Euro-Mediterraneita della Tunisia di Ben Ali Ben Ali, Ă lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;enseigne des grands dĂŠfis

1995 2002

Gateana pace

( 4 !) 

# 7+ > /  ! # : $] 3 /) ( K

1995 1997

#- > *

,   0 #  

1999

Les dĂŠfis de Ben Ali

2005

$ #   I  7+

1997

/ .!

5 / / K

1997

/ .*

Tunisie, Le destin recouvrĂŠ

1998

@#  

!*#  / # Un rĂŞve plus loin- Carnets

1998 1998

tunisiens Salvatore Lombardo

Un printemps tunisien

(Art-Sud   )

( # 7+ I )

2000

La revanche de Carthage

2007

Chroniques Tunisiennes

1999

Ben Ali et le modèle Tunisien

2002

Valentin Mbougueng

43

La Tunisie en Afrique


 

3%

#

2006

(/%)

Instiutions et vie politique en Tunisie La Tunisie ĂŠmergente une voie

2009

pour lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Afrique

1999

/,  2 8 - 

1999

/- / 

 5

1999

.- /    ')*

  / 

1999

(*) 8* ,

* # /  5

Ben Ali, lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;ĂŠthique au service politique

& % T  0

2001 2001

  

4 - : /  5

1999

# /

 & :  * 5 4 0

2000

()   ^

/   # 

2000

 &  & /# 0)    (/

,K .6   T/  ^, >D

2000

(/6) .* /

O  %# / 

2000

/)! ? > * T/6 /!*)  , & /)4 (/%

2000

ATCE -

2000

Marceau BigĂŠni

] 5    !=  7 5 La Tunisie Ă lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;orĂŠe du nouveau millinaire DĂŠmocratie et Droits de lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Homme en Tunisie

44


 

3%

#

2001

RenĂŠ Blanchot & Marceau BigĂŠni

La Tunisie de Ben Ali et le partenariat Euro-MediterranĂŠen

2001

John Marks & Mank Ford

Tunisia : Stability and growth in the new millenium

2002

/ 0

 @* /  ! 

2004 2002

_   #  

, / *# *= 5 / 

2002

!: 2

#= 5= : ] , 3 7+  3  [=

2004 2002

$  /

, /   ')*4

]

2002

# >  % ($4)

/   #  59

2003

Pour un dĂŠveloppement solidaire, lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;expĂŠrience de la Tunisie

Vincenzo Paracasi

Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;approccio tunisino alla solidarita

2003

/6 .* 2003

La Tunisie de Ben Ali, les dĂŠfis de lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;ĂŠmergence

Yves Brissette Luc Dupont

La Tunisie, exemple de pays ĂŠclairĂŠ Tunisia, a journey through a country that works

2000 2003

Georgie Anne Geyer

2004

Tunisie, un pays qui avance

45


 

3%

#

2003

- #  .

/  59 % / ?

2003

5& 3% 

Z.A. Ben Ali, les grands changements

2004

(*) 82 0    

7+    0  9

2004

!S  

Ben Ali, lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Homme des promesses tenues

2004

2005

2005

2005

2006 2006 2007

+  %-   : 5 0

8) " -- , (/ /  3%) 30 E  (" ,"  !*)   . '!%"  / ) (" /#   ) % 8* ( * "=" !* 9)  0  "%0"   59 ( *

-  ' /  '

 #

/ .

# / / *6K Q 

(/6 /#)

/   #  , /

3    

Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;ĂŠpopĂŠe illustrĂŠe de la Tunisie

Sergey Filatov

Le miracle tunisien : Les rĂŠalisations et les rĂŠformes du PrĂŠsident Z.A. Ben Ali

(/ 3%)

46


 

3%

#

2007

() 5 

/  % / @  

2007

() :0 -

QZ0 ' : /  5

2007

!*) % 8* ( * "="

#  : 5

2008

: ' O 

$  / (/!*)

$6-+ ]  / U6

  ,#

2008

'! 

De la dĂŠrive au sursaut : La Tunisie de Bourguiba Ă Ben Ali

2008

Laura Lathan

Ben Ali Ă lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;enseigne des grands dĂŠfis

2009

Robert Khayat

Z.A.B.Ali, bâtisseur de la Tunisie moderne

2008

François Becet

Tunisie, porte ouverte sur la modernitĂŠ

2007

Antoine SfeĂŻr

Tunisie, terre de paradoxes

Andrew Borowiec

' *6 \5

(/%0 /!* 3%)

( K)

2009

47


ATCE    

 ,-  ./ 0 $

',1 '  , &  .  H) = ATCE .& = O  .)+ )+ 3"   / &! &) ! &/ ',+ V1 6K ,! .?,  + HK) ' EO O,! ? < "4%"  ( " '&"  ( ()C ' "1" 8 %  ."H)" +K .6K ' )O  %& &  0 & & O  .O)+ = &  , .  H) 4+ 'K" O : ATCE &/ ' 3"& ,! ) .?,  

  

       

        

   ! "  ! # $ %

  &'

     "(



48

(1 (2 (3 (4 (5 (6 (7 (8 (9 (10 (11 (12 (13


 

 )    )  !  % * '

+  , (/)   -' 1  2

      3 $

   24  ) 5 2 '

6   ,  2'

(14 (15 (16 (17 (18 (19 (20 (21 (22 (23 (24 (25 (26 (27

   

1(  &  7    5 18  & 1 4  

(28 (29 (30 (31



9 7  "  4 1  :

4   

  -'

(32 (33 (34 (35 (36



   ;   2   <   

(37 (38 (39 (40



49


 

   '    #    1!    

!(     

=( -  > "? -  "  4  97(@ - 

!  A) > : - 

?  1(  B( 

?  1(  B( 

(41 (42 (43 (44

 7 (45 2 / (46

)< 6& ATCE + $& K . O A"# ?1 <& "#  ) 1 6  "# '!  1 a &  !  &O  '< .?, 4 )K <& hO1 56 4? 1 .< : & "'  !" ") '&  " " ? " ' Q! 6   (K& O ANN ?, = 8 1 a) &  !  "&  &/@" .IL  \  ' D) L0OL  A 1 2007 ,)%   &)%F & <  J  =@ 'O1  / 1  'O  G 'O ) 2009 )  .K1 .<  @ =@ 6K& ,! ! .1 / '" (ATCE 9/ '& '  < '&" DO  . 6 '& HK) g%) 0 &@ -& . "J .?, /   J   /+1  ?+  (& + "

+ 9 @ O $O  ./ < )% =@   + â&#x20AC;&#x201C; '!   ' + ! 1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4O%K)  01F ' 'O1&  + 1K  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 8 O 1K  %  01 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; &< 1 01 .(O+K ?6 01 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 81 50


       

ATCE    

% &" # $  '( # # %) #

â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 

    ! 

% .!/ 0 '( # # %) #

â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    â&#x20AC;&#x201C; *#   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "   ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; +  "! â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   "# â&#x20AC;&#x201C;     ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  , â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   -' %",  !

% # 4 0  #5 (

+  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;     ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; *  1  * / â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 3#  ! 2 "  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; -!  .#  ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 

.!5 % 0

2009  

  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ! %  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;     !   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; '  7 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  6

"# â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; *#

%  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; -' %",  ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  , â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  *  %  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    % , â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (

% # 4 0   (

 ' % # 0  '; % # 4 0=  ';  '

*  %  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  ! 8  " 9! â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  8 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ,   9# â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 

 9 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;     â&#x20AC;&#x201C; , 9: â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ,  %<   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; -< %8 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  

# # +<  0

  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (RCD)    7 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (PSL) $

0 1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (PUP) ,  , â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (  6(  ;) " ;  %! # â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (("  +) #  (MDS)

% &" # $  -7  '

â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  !  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; - -! â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   # ,

&" # 4 $  -7  ' %

 / â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4 @ # â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 3#  ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; " 6  "

51


       

" , 8 =% 0= -  8 (0

ATCE     2009    â&#x20AC;&#x201C; A8    â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 6%

 9:  ! , â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 68 % â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  ! +, â&#x20AC;&#x201C; +, â&#x20AC;&#x201C; B ,  C. â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ,  , â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ,  $, â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  !  8  96$  ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  % 6 8 2  6( 9 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; *  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; A $   â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  !   3 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  , , â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %% (*

)  67 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; D  % â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  ,  (6 ) +4 

* " +! 0=

â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %  7 %% â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "  ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %  %7 ()  7    0 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; EF$  EF$  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 9 $! (  6 ) â&#x20AC;&#x201C;      â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    7   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; -! * (& ) $! A,

52


 :‫א  א‬  ‫ א א א‬    ‫אא‬ -1O )\ 1  &K -!   ,! E, \ 4 -1O F 6O I& $".) ) " ? ,  ) %) . J . ' srCL )K .K % !& ATCE 9G .1  %  &  J  K!1 .OP 1 =@ &K)& I& 8K" < J 40  ! K!1  +\ ' O1 8K" &/ = K -O && ,1O .(@ '/O   J 51 40 K,  ? D+ G  ' =  . GJ +L O  .)! ATCE O'B $< !K& O  J E    6)   K 9  ( D)C = 51 A"# 40  = ! - T h1 $DO  LAO1L 8" 0, .)+ =  D)& %  &)%F ) . ) -6 # H) 9  )% ! 4 '<K )% 9 @ 4 $. "J & & 6 ? < -1 = ? K O $40K &)  > &!  . K)  .)0K H,1  < J 51 # .#  H) <%  '1 )% .1 / ' & + 56 "#  K6 ' : (<%& 3" -1O = < J 40 D+ = , J &) <%& g + "# < 0 .K6 $O )K : ,& -1O 4% = EO0 %60 (&) O / OF $'/ 53


g + "# .?  J  O' K @ $%40 (&)  ( K6 O )!@ 4 < 40K = 9+&J & D  ' .& 8 0 > O   1O   ? D+    HK) - = # &  ' ATCE .)K! D+ # $ K) < O#P 1 % # & &   .1 +& 8" < J I = EO  # > = < 8" -1O > + -)< 8  # > &  O  ! + H) > )  6  1 >  )< <K , . O H) 1 .!  ) < H  J

& &  % D (<& 8" K- "# 4 80& %    &  . K)  &1 4+ () '"B& (K)B Tunis Air 6 < .P &/ ' #  ' # )% 9)/&

â&#x20AC;&#x201C; '1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; , !") V   '< ./,K ATCE 4 ?T  .(... 56 @ &+  e& 4 )< 6 . K) O' =@ J J "#  '!L HK) VG 4 &%J  )  !1 H) 6 ATCE ' ! =H1 < 8  @ )C '   %  4/ .& '

J &)   4 K&  J  D  &1& # G 6K 4 3" #  = H,1 #1&  ) @ ) < .< .OP &/ ' #  ' &! .! 9)/\& %   :   #    /'  "# 4 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; I  % < &)& < J 51  %   : ) <O    J  .K % 54


  5    (1

       2010  



    . 676

() La Presse

. 468

Le Qoutidien

. 676

( ) Le Renouveau

. 676

(  ) Le Temps

. 676

( ) 

. 572



. 676

(  ) 

. 520



. 468



. 364



     

. 65

Tunis Hebdo

. 65

Tunisia News

. 104

 

. 104

 

. 43



. 146

!

. 113



. 195

"#

. 48

$

. 104

#%$

. 41

&

. 156

'

. 52

*%

. 83

+,&, 55


       2010  



. 52

Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Observateur

. 52

Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Expression

. 52

-. /

. 32

0#

. 32



. 32

## 

. 32

1,.

. 32

/% ,

   

. 28

Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Economiste Maghrebin

. 7

Tourisme Info

. 8

La Gazette Touristique

. 24

,. 02&34 3    

. 6

La Gazette du Sud

. 24

Manager

. 26

Nuance Magazine

. 60

Nos Enfants

. 7

Profession Tourisme

. 24

Sciences Plus

. 9

Tunivision

. 15



. 12

02

. 12

## /

. 9

/.%

. 6

. -

. 12

6 5#

56


       2010  



. 12



. 24

0 3 

. 18

, 07

. 48

 ,

. 30

Livret SantĂŠ

. 18

..% 

. 18

Femme de Tunisie

#. 100

(1,3  #) Univers sport

#. 36

(13  ,.) Planet Magazine

. 9

# 

! "#$ %&    

. 15

,

. 30

$ 

. 12

'.  -.

. 9

The Tunisian Digest

. 30

59: ''  

. 6

;#

. 2

<=

. 14

#> ?

:   "Le Renouveau" " 1 "  % O' H1 L % <% & ( )  ? , K)B .<& /F  % ' K) G  (4% ') 0%  @ &)& 'H1 # < .OP 4%& "g&"  % O' ! $9O + > % !F > 6F   % 57


")    < J O1  4 & H1 "Le Temps" .&O DO   "8  6 O1" &/ ' # )  9)/ &6" " &6F"Z!  & ,1 O' h1 > 6 % ' !& O  O  )F = 0K!  "&K &6" " % -1 ' !& /    J 51 O'B < 8O  ?+ ' < '&! 'K "' J"  "h1"  G = > 6  & &01 +)  ' , '? <  O% HK)  . + 1O  J  .< O E)  O0, !& !O 1 .8    O &+L J H) < J& < 4?6 , '   ( :  % +      !     ATCE

%

# ## / .# 950

( # 1 %# # @ , ) 

# ## / .# 1250

(##  , ) ## 

# ## / .# 625

(  @  %#  , ) /% ,

# ## / .# 625

($ 0#  , ) 0#

# ## / .# 1250

(  1 ! 2 , ) 

"')"  % < J 51 ' O< 9/@ (; .(PDP) "-/" (!) 'O STB CTN Tunis Air  G = ) .OP  ( .) @ ) = < &O DO   +K  &G  ( & ) '& ' " # T  % A" ?@  ! Planet Magazine %& .(< < J 1 ) ; 6) & D  )&\ "

58


          ! (   & ' '  " ("$" %" ) "! . "" :        (2 * "  +,"  2006 & :      : '   " "/  " !01  &-        ATCE



  604.000

  

  46.000

  

  56.000

   

  116.000

" "  

  121.000

""  

  59.000

 !  

  55.000

#$  

  63.000

!  

  60.000

% &  

  60.000

 #  

  1.240.000

 

: 

8"   !" (% 6 ! 7 - )  5 "34 $"" !0 (2  %    ! '   &" "' ! 5 " $" !  .ATCE 5  20.000 =8 3 ! 5   9 ;  & $<   59


' %90 ' ! 2010 ) "D) . " # &) .& ( .) . "^ &)& < J / :    ' -  29 (3    .? 51 40 O 2006 ) :    C :  ! 6 < ) .0, &K)&

   /'  "# % ATCE *  ) 1.571.000  ) 39.000  ) 654.000 (2007 )   800.000 I&)

  2.264.000

 

7 + 21 +

' D

:  ' %100 ' ! 2010 ) "D) . " # &) .&

)+ &)& %75 "21 D)" "<&)1" )+ &)& < J / ." 7 D)" : E #    /'  "# 4 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; II =@   < J 51 6F .)  .0 : =@ O6 3" 4%  $&)%F  J  .ATCE < <  &)%F  J  </ 4O .1 < '<K 4+  .K % -1O 4 8)O /<K   .2 . O  ,& 60


HK) 6 O < . %  % .)+  9&@ .3 .8 @ &+& + K  !  !   O "# O& / : !1& 3" % 6 . F =@ O =@ . 1K ,! E,  .1  /   < .P   O&6  ! .2 .ATCE A% #  =

.OP  5K+ 56 E+ .#   .3 .56K .O !1& ATCE O < ' < ATCE '& )O ./,K  ' < + O / "# .K, 1  !  ,1 4  0%)B& 0  &)%F -1O 4+ $'O<L 8 @   &+ ; 6  " '&" H)  6 . + D)& < .OP > a  ./,K& '1F ' <   V<& 4 ) ./,K + = L &%T  Tunis Air > 6 K,!&  , !" &  , 56 @ ' B& &)%F -1 .'1K& : !" '!L ATCE 4 )< .K % ' Arabies, Arabies Trends, Editions : Arabies  % .K % 

.(  120.000 A / 8 @  & 4) h1 <) , Autres temps ... h1 $ $& <  $ < $  : . )  Afrique-Asie % 

(/ 8 @  & 2005 ) 4K) Jeune Afrique K%  K% (-! O! 1) ' ,  ) ( !1 ) . 323.300 "# $() . 18.800 (/ 8 @  & 4K) Afrique Magazine 61


=  & '<K ' !" 'K% O'B $ O "# =   .P . 0  .!   ' &) & D) 6 a K

, )  ) 19.500 J.A , )  ) 285.000 1& < +) !" !  4L  ) 200.000 (/ Tunis Air 4 '< 4 A.M .'% , '1 @ 1& 'H1 (" #O0 ") " RĂŠalitĂŠs" "F " %  104.000 )  ) 52.000 K = ) )  ) 156.000 # /

.()  ) / @ O1& 4K : ("')&% )&" # ) "" K%    Tunis Air ' 6 .0& 4K 4 )  ) 159.000 !   ) 15.000 +)  ) 65.000)  ) .00080 (/ 8+) e& .('1 , !" /'  "#  '5 E 5  G$ 1 * '5

(2009  ) *+ , %-  #  ! 

!   

    

)

      43)   "Arabies"        400 "  # "    ! "Trends" $  .("%&! ' *"

" Arabies "  (     )

1

-      

" /$ 0! * 1    236 ."

Afrique "  " Magazine (+  & ,)

2

62


*+ , %-  #  ! 

!   

    

   240

" Afrique Asie "  (' & )

.9 -$ <!  - 

.&   670

" Jeune Afrique "  (&!  0  &)

   -  .  & # -$1

.&   119   30 +

 .& ??1 $

 -    2 01&$ /$ 0! -$1 +3 04     5  #  & 6 . $  + 7 : 8 1 9!:  2

)

3

"La Tunisie : Pourquoi ça marche ? "

   -    & # -$1   4   1$ ) 2 " " , 2009 ' 7  4 ' A 3 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; B < @ â&#x20AC;&#x201C; " " 0!

 # " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; $ B $  , 3 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; " $ '    â&#x20AC;&#x201C; C&! 0 *$ 04  +'$ # /$ D (... <  

& . 110

63

4

IC "  " Publications African Business â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ) New African â&#x20AC;&#x201C; The

5

( Middle East (=&  -)

"& * "  & â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "& * " ) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "," â&#x20AC;&#x201C; " &3 " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "$@ " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "/ - " A =& " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; " 6 " ("'

6


*+ , %-  #  !    500  C@  ? ?E$  9 '$ 9  /4 =$ 04  0! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2009    1$ ) ' $  5' â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <    ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; B â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  7 F@G   H$ â&#x20AC;&#x201C; $   &&'$ â&#x20AC;&#x201C; /$ (...     15  05 D=&$  ) /$ 0! (ATCE 

!   

    

)

"%& ! "  & "%& ! " ) & . 400

"Monday Morning" "La Revue du Liban" (+@ +!)

7

& . 50

"  &D  " 

8

& . 35

"0 6  & *$5 " 

9

    33  2 ./$ 0! =* 1  -  2 /$  4 0!  ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ' B 7

"  4 I  (... 0$ & â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "

.&   240

"' 9  "  (' B&!) &" D!$ /4) (" &

10

0!     30   4   1$ ) /$ â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2009  '$  J$, " " ? (...

& . 110

"C"  (  C:)

11

0!     38  .  & # /$

64


              !# 22  2009   $  %  & '  -" * ++ ,

."/ 0/ !, $ +  

- 177)    ,  + â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  #,1

2   #,1 &  3- 4-  * & 56 ,  7*  .(2009 - 12 89    + 37   - ,   8+  #,1

 ATCE -1  , 2 6/%   '

3  3,, .0#1: &; -

   

   

 . 20

" "  (  )

 . 66

partenariat " 

"Maghreb Europe



12

13

Challenge " 

$.   50

"Hebdo ( /)

14

(2010 ) ATCE          '(&

"#$ (!

 

"-3 " (MBC /)

  600



"ANB TV" (< 5-)

  300



"ANN TV" (: $3) 65

'(& ) !

"#$ %!

&

.6 2,525 

-: $ !,


  '(&

"#$ (!

  300



"+, " (<    )

  150



"New TV " (#  =  - )

  100



(7 &) "  "

   75

(<- 7-) "NBN"

$.   48

"Radio Soleil" (-  -/)

$.   28

"#$ %!

&

  83 

-: $ / >%

3,745  

$  #

-:

Radio France " "Maghreb

(  4 5)

   24 <' ($.   33)

" Radio MontrĂŠal"

$.   150

Radio Tounes " "Bledi

   400

"Arabies" /

$.   670

Jeune Afrique

  400



? 

  240



Afrique Asie

  236

 $.   180   200 +



'(& ) !

Afrique Magazine

"&3 " $ @

$.   240

-3 4 

  110



"B-" 

66




'(& ) !

 '(&

"#$ (!

  110



" # "  

$.   119

IC Publications

   68

II Dialogo

   66

Partenariat Europe Maghreb

   50

Middle East Online

   60

Tunisie Plus

$.   50

Challenge Hebdo

   50

   

   20

00216 Magazine

 C 5

/  C

 C 10

-,'

 C 10

 :

 C 10

-3

 C 10

   15

   20

 C 10

   15

 C 10

 C 10

 C 10

 2500

 C 10

 C 10

   35

 -:

D-:



# 2 

   <



 

-3 2#

 '

  0+,

6 :

67

"#$ %!

&




'(& ) !

 '(&

"#$ (!

 C 5

 C 10

 C 5

 C 10

 C 5

 C 10

 C 5

 C 5

 C 5

   30

 C 10

 C 5

   15

   20

 C 10

   35

   20

   30

 C 10

   25

   20

 C 10

   20   12.8



 :

-3 6 %

   

  0+,

#



E  : $# # / -3 F !'

-3 D-:

Prestige  





 /:   #,1

-+,

E 

G 2 4

0 :

4

?

   60

Oxford Business Group

"#$ %!

&

( -) E !

6,353      9,500

  ,

  .2010 

68

 


 :‫א  א‬   ‫ 

 א אא א‬   ‫א א א אא‬  " !"‫ מ‬ :  / $1O  J & K .K,  E% 5O1,& ) < )K  J  '!& K & ' '! '&"  "&/ &" 'O  8  .K $O6  .)!  $ &

t O%L  LAL % O  1 # HK)   & "

K & -K! !1 ! 6O 0 (P 4O&   L4?6 D% K) D% 4 ./ < K  0 O  ^ O &!) )K !  %  & 1O  J  ('  K  & < . "J .)+ .0\ h1 $% 6 K  ma)  % &  = O6 . "J .)+ .& '1  $HK)  ' ()O? & O 4  &    ./,K A1  K6 .#0% '! 9 1 6 &<K O 1 _+L .9 @  W

J .O   8 & <O 9?, L !1 O .)! ' .K % -1O ' &!  %  J 1O = % (K)B (@ K<  O6 (< )< H) 4 + %L  #  1 O' .K, 4%  6 ' '& $O K- 4 <K + & LD  #   1K 6 1) ' K+ G &! 1O  O6 $    %K ' 'K! K,  + = " &/ !1@ 'O< O56  ! . K) 4% 4 <&  O ?+ E+  #KH # 1 K%  6 ' 3" ( O 69


/  . 1)\  &O . P ' "I" O,6 #  J .1  '! O   J O' &  = ) O56 E+ O6 OD .((& 4%  K!1 K O + O 1O  J  - C&   .K, ' / ) "# ,)% 14 &/  ! ) '1O  O' L'O& (K)B  %  & O1 =@ V<& =@ &K)& . )< 1 + ')+ ' 2011  =) ! $ ,O 0%   &  ' 4) '%O .9 %J '  J E+     '&GO   ' J . "@  .?   h<&& +K< 3  . K) B& +K< O $ KL , + !  1 K% .)! h1 $O6  J  =+& 8O% >1 O8 ' (G  K   3) 6 )6 '" !1 01 HK) & %    O % .)% Q!& O&<L  ? O 1  @   %1 .)! 1O K%

 E )  && .)!  ++1 )K ' G =  L%  J O .<, 4% . h1 $"O 1  !" 1K X ',1 &+))  J ! -6 ) .6K HK) (  &# ? (-1O 8  ) <% X ' K) u&& '!O "- F" '1 '! $K% A"# & &O 'O? % ')/ O' =@ 4KK  # / / 6 )  .< = 1  /+1 '? O "% + .1 @ =@ 4K)+ 56 K H) 9@ =@ K 4  O  = H1 ' )K!L  ]) K =@ 8 & <O  ^ O 1 # h1@ &+< O1 =@  K 1O  % O1 ' -6 ' <& &! . 1 &O (K)# =@ VO <) 8" 1O ')/ =   > 6 % '

O1  .0 b< .K % -1O Q% .)! + $+1 + 70


E+ "# = O !1J  K =K& =< 8K" HK) ' <\& 51 ' / â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   5+)  & ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; a K  .&<) (...  )6  q 'O< 8  1 a)& < J&  O - C& % < ) 1 V < = E K &  O& <K . %  % Q! O' H1 L $1O  J  " " "&" . + ) =@ =< 1O = #   )? QH  3" $+& !1 01 ' '  () <L O HK) O% .O 9)  &<K  1 1 ')/ G HK) ? . ? < -1 G O'B $3" 4 80K& -<? O< F  )  = / G <% O&!  &O K ?K %) &6  =@  ' )K! < / ' %) " &/ ' &! = (L  .)!  =@ ?@ 

H) %)  .+? / 6K  .  V<& ' O6 'K)+ < J &  8" O   3 = + &O . J H)   '  01F   I)\   '    -1O G ' I?K (K)B  % .K,  6 ' "#  & 1O  J  .9 @ (  1   1 K6 ,) >C) =K1 #0%  ) 1 '!L   V\ ,   % . O& =H1 =K1 "6P  K ' #  1 B& : &  J  D =@ O%  % D ' .<&  % ' "O%1 I" #  56  "I "  %  4/ O & 81 '& K) 4% #H )" =@ VO < + )& gO ." %  %,) KL ' ()C ' O '  6O 2009 '% 14  6O P &O DO  =@ O% K!" 1 

 +   '& D) O &6 9&)Y +  D) ! Kh& @ 71


O' K @ $-1O G &/ ' ,1 &6 "#  .O )K % ' .<& O + =F 1,O  &6 # )  !1& ?<& ") 8" &  J  &/ ' #,  &O DO  O,L  # $("I O" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "Le Temps" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "g&O" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "'&" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; " ") .) -1O = K O? & VO <  "DO& '# &" ,1O & DO    "g&O"  %   = ( + 1  # &   5K6  ? < ,< 6: +  D  I O ! $9F ,<? "" ? < ."  %<" ")   ! & " '? < =

 J A  &/ ' &O DO  O% !" 1    5K6  56 E+ 1 "6P O (K)B "N& #& " : Z& K< . + # )   J! $ 5K6  ? < ) V<& 6? (1 )& '? < V<& ) J 3" )  %\  ) V<& .(2007 ) 1%  .)?, @ & +1 ' E ) &  0 V<& % g@ (2 KH)  .O 1 ) D%  K ) < 1   ')J V<& 4 . 1 ) O<  .1 & 9 ^ ... O ,< +& H1 ?K) ! 1 ./  G =  ? '? <  " ,<% '& =,"  "! D6"  "/0  -)" O  ... "O O1"  "O& O1" ."4%K" =@ & + & VO <K (3 .< J 40 ,!& K<  ATCE % (4 "(K & # & " +&  0 4 > 6 K!"  X @ a) ' ATCE  + (0   6 % & D  =@ 72


"&%J"  + 1 -1  .,K) 8" 6 1 <&     H) ., 'O< ) "&O" ( ! K1 ) .(# ) =

K< K! "&" . + &  4+ (K) K!" A"#  6 ' H1 : Z& F .!1 #  0 +)  &+)  1K  &  KH)  <% =@ # 9 @  .) ? = ) < 8O   ' ()C '  % E? =@  K  (... < 9 G $ <F E,  $& 4?  G & < 1K  =@  ? < =@ &%@ + & V <K  ...  1K =@  I  ) =1  ( ? V < 4 ,1 1 )  .( .<%  &   &+) h1   *'   *#  /9  /0 * '  *0  (1 : "/ *"   *  0   7E *95  :   J % * ' &) #  J U W " '&" !1 =F .)O  6 '? < '/+1 ',1 V<& A&  4 =   '  O 1 ) .H) .<% 9) ' J '< '  .!1 O ; 1@ ' (6 &  &+K)) 73


     ATCE     !" # $%& ' ()* +,  ) -( .  /  0)" 1 '2 +   ) )&  +/    . &+ ()* 3-+) , :  67 , 8 9 : 1     1991 -5 -( @ )  >'<" 3 9 #< $ " < 1*" - ;<        @,  % (@ 5"  - B  C -9   DE  9 +F -(  )   9   0)G 9   (  $+,  #, >'<" # :  &+ ()* 3-9  

 



 

. 150

( )   *

"!# $"   

)   +,

%&   '(

*  - ( (

  

( )   * . 100

 $ ) 5   60 (

. 80

 



  

+   /.0  12

 

34 . 

  

( )   8 5(9

%&   '(

65 : 5$

 4 5

74

& 7

1

2

3


*95  *'   *#  *0  *  5 1 * ' & * 

: (/9) +$  * A (1 H) $( !   1 @ = + / / 1   (&+ <&) ATCE .<% ., # $'K D $ !F  &O DO   4 (K (SOTETEL 4 ) (<? .?, = . 1 &) .) ?1& (,K! ; 6 6 $HK) O? -+ ' Q! %& E ?  "ANB"  " 0%"  G =

 6 ' &  Q!& " &) ' 4&" ! ' EO (,H O ! .> 6F . K) .K %   O6 "g&"  %& ( + ATCE (, (6 H)  .O  ' <  (C! .O 

 !    @   (+ 3" ') D  ' .<& (  '%" A 1 "O1 "  J AO< " 0%" )/ = a) & + 56  )!B& 1   @ /  ?) ! 1 ' # / O  1) (K+ K!P\  K "D)  <  @ 01 ()! 4 ATCE 4 )< ANB )/ .K+1L ' L4+T  ) 2500 0 ' &! .<&  ) 5000 LAL /  e& '  D,) 1 .(& (,K! K\ .O &+ K)  L T!" K  4/ 0%)J 1 + ATCEZ / ) !   J  )  % " =@ ( 6 ' =< "+1" ()) .) )  =  8 &6@ 1 ( < ! O )  J &O DO  P u)  J -1O0 ' O1  L#L O 0\   +O .(ATCE  +  9% !) "-O   &O DO   <& .&)   ()< O  K6  (K) V<&  f OT6 =K1 $.+ . %  V<&  !1 75


')J +1 <   ()< :  ) !1 \&  ) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; #+) & F â&#x20AC;&#x201C; & < <  % E%  F . 1 .(2008 ,)% = &)%F .)+  0,K ( 6 (&!  6 ' 4  1& +? O .)! '" ? < 0 O? HK) ?/  %   K1  % =@ /+1 )   !, #?/

)/ = "& %) 1" O? (K6 : ) "( 5K6  G 9)" '& " ,1 ' EO& 3"): -K! 2009 &) 4  BBC .("3 & 1 '? < 4   . K 9 %@ O& -K!   J (H)   6)  .0&  G@ HK)    ?K) ! 1 ' 9? C& (K $"  &1" (&+ : ) %<" 8+& (K  G =  % & = E K  " K) 1" V <& )O D,)  ( K $2008 ) "   $( ... (+@ ' D) =@ ( '? &+ (  K ATCE O + ; 6 '! < D)& 0O%L 56 ! ' ()!

.(& U_&T ! O+L K  -)!  (  8K  ? < 1 .<   &%@ & +  "#  () 1    +& ATCE  $HK) O? !O 1 Q! 9+  ( 1  &  & D  = & ? 4+ % . &6 ! &   < : & :  & ATCE  B& / 2008 &  (1 "8 ) ? " (%0 " O1" V < K+ = O\ â&#x20AC;¢ 1"  .!   ) ,   . !K '  ) - 48 76


=@  ) 2000 (/ & K K) ,? $"%) V1 4 '?K h1   !1) "   " "D!& #," 

. /&& H,1\ (2008 -O  " ,<% 'Z& =,Z" V <Z Z&+L >Z1 +) â&#x20AC;˘ .2008 ) ) , !   01 P  6 "Bertrand Delanoe" ?/ 4  >! + "  &1"  ^ (? 1 â&#x20AC;˘ ( H)  K6 (K+1 ' ()! "'  '& " O? 

' .! +& K!L 'K" '1 L =K1 3" $"!"  & .6 a) &  "D& '# &" !  &O DO  \&/ 2008 8  (2 ."'1 '& #K" V < &1 ")K 1" )/  8 1 ) )+ 1 = "D& '# &"  J   ' '!  h1F   &O V 1K ) ' <&   ? /   , 3  D)  h1Y )+  +  =@ @ ) D) (  = ( ! (%) V1 +)& E?F K& .K\ .D)  ')J +1 . 1 4? +) ) ,  J  8?K)& ( K >1,& ATCE  B& / 2008 &!  (3 () && 1992 ) ?/ !1 Q1) )C& + "&&!  " =@ <  (&G ' (   8" (+& H1 "?)" ! 1 D  ' .<& O h1 &%@ (, "D& '# &" 6 '! $D) .() b,K K-! A , 0% (1) : I LM L K3 8  L ' Q! =   ,< "g&O"  %& U \T) +  (UW \  DO  I $")   ! & " "  %<" +& 'p? < .3" = & 77


5K6  01F "I "  %   = 6: +  A+)\  O $9F -<?& K " ? <" )6  ,K)  +&  .&O DO  ' .<& + "# = 3"! I "Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Observateur" " " /5  + ) ; 7& (2 : ("$% " 9 /0 , ' "!& "   +  - < F& )< 'B 6O 0  K .< 1  V<&& < (/ O6 K  L&q Q!& O 9  ( % (0)\& .'%6 9 ,O -/ = E ATCE (&+ "D& '# &"  G =  & H)    + ) = 5 1 # " '&" H) O  J  6 ' K% A" O#   = 1 &+L "H1 " (K%& -/ ' <%  . 1  ! & (,! =@ ?@ "# $< ., K6K&  & ?1  6 ' 3" O  "6 4? O : & 18 > !"  D  6   " )" )/ = (!  X

. &) ' 4& '%  " 0%" )/ = "D!< A% " a) &  (!  X "<  " 0F ' %) .& ? " # 1 +1  2008 ( T/ & & & D  &/ ' !  A"# = + .O /  h1Y . @ ' a) & b# = ( @ '!L  8 =

.(D)  %) V1 h1  G = ) & < +) # 13 7 & vhL& "France 24" )/ = a) &  , (!  X

A ?1 D)   &/O  .) )  4/ %1 0 1 2010 8 ."O%1 " "& O1" "  " 78


D " ()) "A%& ' g " &1 !  B& / X ")?  " 2010 ) -6 8" "80 %)" O' K @)"&+ .(%)  <%  =@ ;1 ! O' > ATCE D =

O6 K KH) 9?  V<& 4 0OL ./ <& &  X ) &+K) O? 6F "# C   &!   < " %  O & " .2009 )  8)O # P 9@ / '1O : ("F" "  /9)  E * 9 (3

 # @ = .   O  0#% . + 9?@ \&/



." '&" ' .<& " "  %   = (B& # )  J : & .')J +1 ' E ) &  1 + (1 "... K 6 # /)" : ')<& + (2

@ ) "w... )K+1  L\)"L ' 4 I) "" : ')<& + (3 ?/   .&  & F ) &  ? "  ' @" =@ .(D) =@  0 >1@  6 ')J +1 ' EO ) &  < 1   &+K) 4? ' O% +/ .<& D  O    , )< 4% 1 1  +& (1 K ) .1K  .D)& .).& <   ()< ATCE ' 0<B& O  : ("F" "  /9) / GN  (4 % . + " K"  %& "&)&" "9&" )!  UW ! 

C!&  8" & D  '1& ( + .H1 $" '&" H) + ) <& ( & ()"@ 3" ' $.O  ' <  F& )< U !)\ 2005 &! 25 7 & " "  % .1, = F& )< 79


+ ' ) 1  = bK ; 6& ? < . 1 ( '"J $@ V & D)& 2005 ) +<) .< 4% < 28 7 &  " "  %& U \T) + <& A !&  J A 

 +  O  (  +& K " '&" DO  O'" ( 9% 2005 ,)% ."1%) O  D)   %  HK)  O ( + H) +K +1   =  f O1



.(  H) " '&"  : (/9) M * / (5 = " '&" H) =  & 4 "D& '# &"  G =  V<&& (,!  6 ' O6 " K" "I O"  %   ' 1@   & =H1 # & .? = , . 6 (!  <& . 6 . 1 A"#  ! & (,K!  ATCE &/ .KH) K & K .+1 ' <  =@ # ) &/ .O%L ? < 1 &!  . +   8O  9&@ E K  DO   J  = ? <  ATCE . K)& '"J &/ :   OL H) !1" ')<& + V 2008 & 17 7 & + HK) V < $" ,<% '& =," O O? (O% +) "(&1 .+ "# ) = +&  J  D ") 8"  / (+& '1 / E K  & D  = V <T ( + 4%



  E  /' O0 7 .&)    . + A"# " '&" ? < %& () EO  HK)   # )  5K) H) . 1  ? =@ & O  ' Q! %&  , 01F .D)  ')J +1 80


: $  

   

 



 " "            ! #  $% & '( : & ) & ' $$   ",'./$  0" *+,- .#

"" 2006  1 17 

*(+) 

 $ 1 $  2 $% 3 $   & 4 !$  '$ $ $ & 51 67  & '( .) & $$ $% "" !

"" 2006  7 15 

&

6< &* "9;"  3 = $  $  +'0$  # >/$ '0) 

"" 2007 3' 0 20

*(+)

:  $ 

$     &   ? $% !/$ $  $ &  $ @A $

"" 2008 3' 0 24

&

D  C 

&

*(+) 

&

+$ C 7    ? D  E >$  $ ! F  ?$ @' #0$ )  >$   : 6$  '0 ! 57 &3 "'>/$  0E" !F : #/3$  #/3$  3?(  $% " >/$ & 0$" C$ #; F D<!%

"" 2008 B3 ! 28 "" 2008 # ! 12 "" 2008 &0 26

H& $ & I!%   "" B 0 #7 $% $ C$ #; ! F '0J$ $  $   '= C $ 2008 !' 28

.  C   O0 7  (+) 81


:   )K 0,K OP& 2009 8 , O G  F& )< )\ O . 1 .+1 '  % @  B& (,! /< ,& g T/T HK) 6 ("& 8K" % H) (<% 0 < )K 0,K OP& (/1@ 4 ,1L! 9&)Y +  D) !& (%@ . (O<? '1 =K) =K1 : (ATCEQ '  0 ) *  * 6A (6 "#   . ! 1) "N & # & "Z&  K =  .( 6F

)+   K6& ,! @  &O HK)  ! .   2006 &!  ?O < 3" ' $? < 8K& 3" D)& CNN

/  1 ) ") + #" F   ,1 =< '  0%)J D) =@ )+ '  0 9) "   )" ? < ..++1K Q! % D)  O .K)   !  O  8)O P  !  3" ') &O HK) =@ 9J . 1 8" 2007 8 15 =@ 12 ' &\& +<) 1 O < ' K) ',1 &! '  A ?1 $ J ?/ '  ) Q! &)% =@ D) ' ( 3  $'<% ,1O .KH) 9P  ) <%) "1& " (O D)  "@) "80/& ? " ' .((')K ',1 <%) " ) " (ATCE â&#x20AC;&#x201C; : % G (7 = 'P + ) (O# O &O HK) ( & - < ,1 / (& (&  8" "(K & # & " O6 &O HK)   J 82


3" '! ' IO%  ') %&C& D)  , 2008 ) ()<& .) O% 'PK 0 K6 3"):  '! 8" "(K & # & " ' !0&

@ O#  @ .P O<& ( ? =@ ?@ "# $(% 6 ) " 1" "Le Renouveau"  % !1 "La Presse"  % p& ) 0, D = ()< \p& =@ ?@ $& !1 01 .D && D) )/ K6& (,! ?1 .&) ' <  ATCE (1 / > 6 % ' .HK) ' EO &)% .? = 0, . 1 : ("MosaĂŻque"  8. )  - *  (8  ) 7  2003 ) =@ 1995 ) ' " "  %& ,1  .# L  "MozaĂŻque"  "@ h& .& HK) -/  , (O1 ( & - L   & <  O  .&6)  @ 2009 &)  O+   "J  , g O (%& (   )O? & D  =@ ) ! 0,& () '  O&< $  &6)  1  !  "MozaĂŻque" /0  7 - R $  I 8. - R 57N .&6)  A"#  DO  .";5 "    : ( 6 & +& '  D% ? $<O%) /  , (9 = 0, . 1 ?1 .&) ' <  ATCE (1 / & K . O   (!  <& HK) ' EO &)% .? ..?, & O  .)+ '+ %  KH) K : /  *  (10 $" '&" H) ' E 0,K &) . 1   3  & O  .)+ '+ %  ATCE KH) &  .   3  ..?, 83


."N & # & " 4  %  & +1  ' & ! SA  ' E (11 D)  "ANN"   O0G  "7 D)" )+   K6  " ANB" )+& &  K)  1   (  && A 6 O = O1 ! .&  '  "@ B& -KxT! ATCE 4 )<  .6 H) 2003 )  "J '  8&< 8 0% .HK) , # (/'$ / ) T   (12

 1 &)  3  & < .?, = . 6 ( ." '&" H) = E / ; * U (13 .? O = " '&" H)   1 &)  3  .&)% (/'$ / ) "  M (14 , +1 ) <% ? ) <% )F  (  .(# J 1? ) <% D  +& '&K '1 <% +)& ( 6 .K <% . #HK   3   ."O " "\)L"    >  ; 6& ? < E 1 &)  3  & < .?, = . 6 (  H)  O% -1O V<&& . + ( . T) ! $" '&" H) =

.< 4% /  6 " '&" = '< 0 & ' '! !1 .(D) -)%) ) =F 84


-)%) ')J +1 F )% < %  (!   6  "/0  -)" !O E" +)&  (O% ?1 =+ (2002 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ."?K)" ! 1 9&)F . ! ,1 .G & !  -/ ' <    +)  LQ   # J 1? ) <% & O "8 K) O1" "8 ) ? " & <  '? < ' Q! ."8 O0 (K & " "81 6"

1  (0 ' O  ?J  /  2002 ) '<  1? ,1 G &  "O O1" ?+ <& " &" D) =@ +   '" ') '1 O? O 9&)F . ! ."  " & &O HK) OD . 1 Q! ? < 8K ATCE (K  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1997)  < '1 1K . P  (!    6 ' 3" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1999 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1998 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1996) '1 O 1K  (.. 2003 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2000 ')J +1 F )%K O< .% (.. 2002 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2001 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2000 # =  &)& W KT! ' ')J +1 +   )%K ( 1 ,) . 1 &O HK) & q +T K .KH) %& .')J +1 .< 4% < O+  &O HK) 6& 0O  . ?1K  ' &  3   p0%&

 D = V L K) +& O+ 2010 % 19   - < K g J ! 1 : D)  1 H)" ())  J ."0%)J ' -K/K : (/'$ / )  $  N0 $ (15 .ATCE ' (%&  , ? < ( + V<&  >O  85


V <L 1 ' g 1 (K) 2004 %  (1 9%  4+ (6L  6 (?O < && 3" '1 1K < %  6 .%  -+@  O&  # $HK)  "+ &" ?+& - <L   +& !1 01 )  ."?)" .+ K  4&  .O%L V  *  %   ' + ) /9 G9 (16 : (  29   8#  N RCD '" +  

' +& &1 >! "N & # & " =@ <% ,KH (O% 1  ) <% C& (&  (0% && F& )< O?  <%  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <% ,H 4% = 'C !  /,  ')/ â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <%  %  +  % '& ? < 1 4% 8" "& V " % â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "    " , O '%  .&1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ; 6& . ?<K ? F ?/  <% I 4 & ',! '1 (... , : ("La Presse" ) 3  !  (17 (@ H) "8&< 8" 0% = 2006 ) O1 X   &%J (!  " &) ' 4&O !" 0 &@  ,1 .&O HK) 6   !, O .K) .9+K : (  *  M 7  R + ) =  * U (18 " 1"  %  ! + +1   = 1 X .  % . + O' K @ $"&+ D " ()) "  !&&" &1 &! U0%) X ATCE D = ")?  " 2010 ) -6 8" "80 %)"

.   .?@ (& %  %)  ,<? ! O' > 86


("W "  )   W  (19 O? ( % .1, Q " '&" DO  ' ' X ."E6" % ; 6   , ? <  "(K & # & " =@ &! (O% 2002 . 27  X K!P   % =@ "I " 1 ( UDUW \ &O DO   J  J '! '  ?& +K< .K ",) = "  6 ' < (K) $"/ * * ' *2 M +  "  /0 ' 6  ) 9)&  H< A  +K %& ' <  DO  l &@" & $"(   A !F ( ( (% '? <& (0\ 1 D) 'C&" ( 9 O& "(K & # & " &  ! ."  1 K @ AL \!)L 8K"  A   " '&" DO  )% =@ (K (+& "!! mL1% m1% : ("+ 5 " "V " / ) ! 22'  (20 $. &F +&& ) + 8 @   &!C& "h1" ( % =H1 X .T+ . + '   = !   . + ' ()O?  && . %& ' Q! ? < +) ( % K6 / "?K)" ! 1 Vp U =  6 ' >   . + ) 4 ')J +1 . 1 ./ 6  O0,  & '? < 

'& ' $80) F& )< O'B 6O 0 1 X F& )< & (O% ')  (0) K!P    # $5" *   I7 (6 = (O ! = A ! D  $'0)  ',1 Q! & HK)  K) 91  9 GJ  ' =@ VO < ' &   (1 &/ '! F& )< O' L "@ O6 .4+ ?K 87


: ("  &"  & M )   * G (21  !F "&"L ()! 6O 0  + (1   X 0 1986 ) 0: <% (  9)   !F =K)& h1 &! ")L  W 6) "?)" ! 1 1988 ) "0 O1" &F OF . +O 8 O 4%  1988 ."&/ &" '   &! <  J  2000 ) +)\ X ( O !K &O D  =@ O% ( >1@   X '&" K  $V,6) <& 1& ' & /  1?& V  <+& ."%! &  K)%"  1 &!&  = "

: ("F" " ) /    (22 (&  '! (K) 6O 0 > K .< , X )% CK  =)\ (K) (1 9% ! $+ (O%&  < . \ 4 4&K + ) ; 6& ? < % " K"  %& "&)&" '!  X (  = 90% ()K! 8" H)  & =H1 # $ J  9) & ")  1" ' 6 <& O 3 = 1  V  </ e ' .+& !1 01 < 'F : (ATCEQ '  0 ) "   0 (23 O ( &6F /  1  ) ) 0,K P& . X K '<K )K& O6 ,! .)! h1 ATCE !& /1@ .?, A"# = ')K 'O1  K 4 &)%F .?, 4 a & 0%)@ )& ,! 4  = Kh& O< a & ;)@ % O% "<&K)1" )/ a &  B& ,! :  ) O6 0,K .(" 0%" )/ 88


(&+ . ?1 $() "N & # & "  & =H1 X ' L'O& !) .&) ' <  ; / +&   =)&& (&!& .(" '&" Z\ &O  J & 6 . &+ . ! ATCE ' 8  % = 2009 ) %  1 L1 X

0,K OP ' ?@   1) =  ()  ) 1.509 A / D,) ' ) I) = ?@ ()  ) 1.142 # / )K O 8 K 6 O'B K& $()  ) 1.954  % OP .()  ) 2.813 0% : (/ ) + * / 8 " (23 K<  O6 &O HK) -/ ' .< . + !  G  =K)& $')J +1 ' E ) &O  Q1 ?+& .E? 1 ')J +1 < 0 O  -/ . 1 : (M 7 /9) ' /0  (24 UD\ " '&" D  =@ + &!@  & 2009 %  O+ ."; / 1" +)& )! V  </ ' ()!  (  "G$ !" ' + ) !" !  (25 ( C! $1)K& (& .O A% (   && A+) 4/ .O <% P  =K  ,  (&?) (  =

 <%& (?< $" Harmonies " K% @  (&G  &%  .(HK) 9     K  6 K  0 D.. "La Presse" 9  + ) !  $ (26 : (  J X 0. +  7 ' 4& .&"Z& +& ( ITT  = '< '  DO  IK  ) ! ." '&" H  D) "E<@" =  " &) 89


2008 %  '/ &  6 ' 2009 )   .&6)  "E6"

.&6)  (1  ?1 )% DQ  2008 . & D  &+  J  . K . J '



 ? A & & <O & < ! =@ 1988 ) ( 0  6 ' P (,&) 1992 )    < $ J P KH) 9 0 P ?  'O ,6@  (KH) A"#  . P )K - F '  % & "#    &   J O % 6 0 'O ' B! )& <% 8" 9K $ J (O%K ." . , 3   G  G /  (,[)T : ("U  "   ) I Y" GN (27 O  ' ( O 3" ' $& H) 6 % 8 6O  X   + ) K)&  6 ' ATCE 9) & <  n  ' '6^  H)K =@ "& %) 1" ?)& OL !  %& ,)% 20  "g&"  %   = + "# ) O / $'

 D  8" &O D  '1 ! 1 A"# ./  $2006 . F& )< !&  J + 6O 0& 6 I  + 1 > 6 % ' X DĂŠfi Media !  ! (,& ()! 2007 8 ,   (1 9%

  !  & /  ! '  + g&  4% !  0< E   8   ' ()! D)& ! F ,O& O 4%   H) .K,  @  K A0%)@ (OP /) O56 E+ ' ' ) 4% ' 9) '1&  %& +1 # ) O $& < ! F ./ <& &   ."Le Temps" "g&" 90


  ' E  ",) O / (K) =@ .< D,) , $"# . O ))+ 56 Qm = O1 G "Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Expression"  ) : (F    8# D..) !' /%" (28 $)% 2010 ) a1 3) 9k& & D  &/ ' ( '"J <& .') ' !& (O%    8.      F 2) ! ' * U (29 : ('

'0"Z '6 9F " " u& 6  '), ' =@ & (O%  < ')  ' <  (&T ! $" '& '&< .&O DO  : /7 !  $ (30 >   K6 % ,F & .)<K  6  X . % D '&&  J K  %  0O &! ./ !& ( X :  ) 0O .< !& ! (O#    <& & < a6   & EK G  J &/ ' 1990   6  ()! (/ / " %," ,1 <? D && "?K)" ! 1 .!O 1 56& 1999 ,)%  ( O& 8" ÂŤ La Rousse Âť OP& '  &! 1C&

#%) Q!& D) D  0OL '! 56 OP < '

.(& K  6&    + &L + & D!,& & D  (O% X & < '&  J 4/ 1 O 1O  .O% 1 6F A"# 9  U .1 + 4 ")" .&! 6 (xQ\&) ."?K)" ! 1 .!O 1 O6 ; 6  ? < .!O 1 8K 91


: ("La Presse"  %& ,1)  /"  (31 &L () K +& ') ',1 <%& d? X  &O DO  ' .<& -KT! (O% HK) I ' EO& (& K  ,1 .K) . P  ! & .&) ' < &/ ' A 6 3" ') " '&" E   ( 6)   ' (,/ 8" 1 O < 8)O P  !  &O D  ?/ '  ) 8" 2007 8 15 =@ 12 ' &\& +<) .( J O (K) 3" ' $% 6 K  ! 4 '< m ,1 X   <% h1& 0%)J D & =@ 2010 && 20 ' & O1

  (1) ATCE   ")?O  " '  $  3 O O  .K) . P ?1& (0\ &+ ) ,& (/@ 9)  K  &  )   ATCE () &  . K  9 %@ D) .!&K   ?<!  < ',1 1K\    'C! (, .1O& +K< O ' ()! ATCE =@ J .O &O DO  ' .<& "# .   K '   3000 /   8"  J & < P ?1   =K+ 2008 .  X  J  (O% (K) K @ $)O D,) ' &&   6 D && +<) ' <& 3"  '  O & C + !&  %  & . P "# ?1 "/0  -)" !O O' (& : (  /9) ! ' /9- (32 ! ( L,L "N & # & " =@ &! (O% 2002 &) 12  () 0\ H<   ( D) = ( G" )L ' (K) ()O A% 'O&@ (#&) ., +   D) OD  Q! ' &6 O  ?& 92


P 4/ 0, 1 h&  @ O  ! F "" )& D)" )/) " " ) 4" # ?1 '& ' !" )& H)F  ! ' hO1 )+ &/ ' (?  6 8" (+& "7 ."D)& + H) ' !K  6O O< $ !< & <   J - J  + F& )<    # .!  = O !"' = G A & H) 9" D) : + *  7 (33 . .  <% 8",)  X X " " X " )F" X "8O ") ) -L1L O<&  X ("Le Temps" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; " 6 g&" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ">O" X " &  g&O" X "g&" ) ") & <   +) D)  "BBC" )+    ! ."& <  #F"  %   1992 . .) ATCE 4 '<



' '! " '&" D  ' &)%F  J   4  2004 ) O  .&6)  " '&" I  & ) '" F

1 OL  &6 ) ' O '! ! $(1999 ) .&6) <& &) 9) (%& &01 0!  )%K P @ '<%K & & &%@ + & K1 2004 ) O  .&6) I K " '&" ) .9K) "# <&  J  ." LAO  = . + &)   O  "/0  -)" !O  "3 & '& " ?/  O "&)%F ) &  "   O1" "8  D6" "'  '& " .')J +1 ' EO 93


:   (34                 %&  ' (* "#  + ,) !"#

 $

(2008 - "2 "  1   2009  " 10 0  /     .1 -( & 5  8 "6 -!   !7" 4&  5 #' "   !   " "   )    (35 : (# #' A B7 0 @  4 A : >"! ?@" : ; < =  " "A C D  /!  "   E  1 ? @ F""

.G / -( # HA  @IJ

%&' *& + , "$ "   )    (36 : (!-  5 2009 !/  #" /( KB  " " B!  ."  @ /  # & I '  * " B! L! ;/@ " 

M/  " : HIJ

A " ; 2008 !/ <C =  #B ! 1@ "!O 5 8 " " G/ -( , 7 1! E/! N%= !" 

!' @ M=) "H@    "" P *  @ "5   " /!  " : ?@ ' // >IJ   

.("20071987 "Q ! ER ,!' SQ "// " 8A  "!J ATCE A  1 H   .G / HD! A  1 "   D! //  $B @ M'

94


: (TH-Com  $ N M ) M$ F0 (37 QH  D) .1%) 0 &J (K 8K" ÂŤ Leaders Âť 4/ C) *2"    /0 * 9 *A  2& ' '! $" '&" DO  .2009   $    /0 "/ * * '

: ("' "   /9L) /" 5 !  (38 .ATCE 4 '< $<O% X &O HK)  4OT h1 .++1 0%)@ = 5 1 X K)  O O .1 J 8O<K  La) H)! AL0 &T  " '&" & + 4 4   1 U\/ O 1 <% &01 ... -O K + '  % 4 . 1 "& <" )/ , > % 2007 8 ,  X  F 56& ATCE 4 & ,K  <& D)  9 0 .1 

, O  < K .&6)  & 2009 &!  / X .&O HK) 6 &%@ + & "& <" )/ '  9 9 /0 7 /9 M 7)  $ !2  (39 : ("* " "&/ &" H) +) .)<&O 6  ,1 ( & ")



"Le Quotidien"  " La Presse"  %  (1 & . + ! ."Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Action" O + ' (1984 ,)%) "0&6" h1 <& & )  =@    6 ' " '&" H) .)) 6  O& +) $,, D  ) ' ) ,&  O /   '!  "RĂŠalitĂŠs" K%& O ( + ? < -,  .)<K  6 !& ) $1991 ) =@ 1988 95


p,1& . T)  ( +  6 ' D)   4+ +) ) ,&  9%K = 1 $') , "Le Figaro" "LibĂŠration" .D)  'F % .1 (<? <& ' A<& ' '  "Le Soir" !%&  1  1997 )  O1" ' C&  + "# '! $" '&" K- =@ (?) ? < "1 '& &" "&/ &"   % 6 'PK 0 "8 ."J.A" K% 1 O6 ? < E" +)& , 3 ") ( + .K  ' "N & # & " =@ O%   1  O&  ' ^ ' " F L $V < )  LA # 8" ./ ' K () .g, B6 "# .<& "." !   J  & .6 O+  7  O%   .)   (/@ !1& ; 6  '? <

()  $&O  J  ")  O1" =@ 2008 & (O+ 8" < H) ( ! / D  > (, 6K& (  ' '! $(!)& )  ,) & K6 ' ()!& HK) .!)& D)  , F& )< '<& K " " '&" % Le "  Z%& + Z! " '&" Z &6Z)  Z1  Z6  "La Tunisie, La dĂŠrive de lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;extrĂŞme gauche" ())   "Temps "/0  -)" !O ( (% %) & France 24 ?,& ?1 ! .D)  . 1 4/ '  HK) ' ( 4 + @ (K) 3" ' "(K & # & " 4 ATCE 4 '<  "Le soleil"  %& 2005 &! 19 7 &  " '&" H) 1 & Le Canada doit ĂŠviter tunisien" ') .1 (QuebecZ& ) )!

+& O  = ATCEZ <  4 ,K\ "de cautionner le rĂŠgime .O  OF .< ' ()! <& O4\L 8 96


D) =@ (+) - & ATCE .K,! 2000 .   3" ( ) 3000) &O@ &#" D) =@ )  ' ()&@ () / + "# 1& '" 8" E?   % D  <& ()Z) A0%Z)@ Z& F& )Z< '! Z! = +&! e& ! # "Non Delanda Carthago : Carthage ne sera pas dĂŠtruite" 8 0" ( 6 ' +) D && "La Roche" & 2002 ) K) > H) < U & + ' ( 4 ; 6  ? < "O1 (&T ! "(K & # & " 4 '<K& ! "# 0%)@ O $" '&" '! h1 D!,   ' 6F "# =@ O% O   % G  &L $&  J  D   "O1 8 0" (&! '! '  (&G  (6 A9 " '&" )& (< (&! O% (   >1@   1 ! (K) 3" ' $(  <OL + : 2006 '% 11  "(K & # & " =@ D!,& " Par ce livre, mon objectif premier et final consiste Ă restaurer lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;image de marque de notre pays et de notre PrĂŠsident"

: !  7  (40 \ T "' J" " "  %&   1 < a 6  # & / ' $') ',1 <% B& < (&/ 4+ ) .O !1 01  +&  %  '+& ( @ 1 O .O% &?)  ."' J" " " .DF "# = ATCEZ& (&) O  : (  *  *9 ' + ) W  * $ (41 O) O "(K & # & "  J  4 O )< '< ( '! h1 $HK) 6 <%  A% 6 (  '

97


,1 O% 1 <% 1  &! Q!& K<  K6&  +& ',1O ' O   J 6 O? -/ 1 ' Q! 1 < 56&  %  &  J  =@ O% A  + ' J .3" =  6 A0%)@ ( 'O< & A @  ( (1 +L :  5 Z' 5 $ !" # $

%&'

   

2000 # ! 21 L    0$ + 4 0=  M K  !" "   & & 3" &N 2 $ 9 &  1 >/     0$ O  $ ' &N P$ "B$  & + 0'" "B ! $ # 0" "B $ !" & 37$ 5 $  ' ' &<( O    0 &  "D>$  ? O 2000 B  3Q$ !$ ! 7$  $ $

$  7 $ 1 $ RP$ "& $ & 37$ " 5 . '   = 5 &% > S  # "B$  !" C 0 0 & 9$P  >$ ! / K . 0$ + T  W? O 2 "V  + ;$ "  U K : I . 7$  <(  M>$  2 " 6" &! 5 * R 0  0$ #6 & R  &   # D /* 5I "9  &  !" D  7 BP$ 40$ +2% 5  &  #>?   7 ? H+2( 93 D '6% C=  1  ;  0$ +  > 42$ ! 3 ; FIJQ$ .& 37$ & 4 ! '0$ 

$ ' ) 4 0Y # B$ (  / * .(2000 # ! K ; $) + $ & 37$  >= C $ 98

# ! 22 2000


!" # $

%&'

   

%, - $. /0 !-  /. 1 2- 3- + K C=  \# O'$ H4 $  4 $   5 .  ] $  '= +*7 T ' B P 3' 5  "V  + ;$ "  K .D! &  0$ 3 7$ 5$ #<? 7   0$ T ' &  !( K   !   !>$ C<$  <( ! & >$   1   & 37$ $   $ # /$ . $   % # / ;  0$

2002 B  11

B>P$ "B

 & $ U<7 "# 7>=  $  $ 'Y K /$  $ & 37$    D  + &   7$  0$ B'$  >$ W ! >S  <( .2000 B  3 5

;  0$ >  "V  + ;$ "Q$ W K

; $  0%  # $  D'A " &" @ 1$  .& 7$ "B

 & $ U<7" & 2 "# ? O!" &    K "^$ 7 & " # H# 7>=  3>$ $ @  >$  0$ 4 2 B  $_ >?$  $  0  37$ R ' O HB'$ ;    B>P$ >'$

  &  $ M 7$  7 & >P$ "La Presse" . >$

2002 B  13

# D0 &A #$ ! ` S & &A  K .5 `>'$ O  0 ( #

>$ R 0> !  0$ H 0$ 2 "' $  " 37$   >$ > 



 0 %  5 "^$ 7 & " + 93'Y  B>P$ . *7 99

2002 B  13 (& a S b )


!" # $

%&'

   

>`'$ @' 43$ D% ' &  ?) P; & >  H  7 ?$ )    D<>Y 5 H $$ 3 $  " $8    3 # 98" --46 /0 D>'c! . 8   $ :" -   2  $ #?>$ "D>$  + ;$ " & @ - $Y :  ' C  7 & & >P$ 5;P d & 37$ & 37$ & ^7* $ 1   ! D>' >) : ; - , (1 .($$ '  ! &  3$ & R    0$ c # ) 2-$ % - (2  $  5 ;  *7 5 ; "&<("  0 ! D'  0$ @ 1 U6Y 6 .$$ 5 $ +$ . 0$  D6 $%  'J$  !Y @' $    "U 7$"    I  37) :  $ (3

$ * ' $ RP;   7! 5 e  6

>$ & C' 6  1 $% ; O!   # $ $%  0% 5 H   .( 0$

2002 B  13

! H $  0$ @ 1 $% 42$ O! : 

.& P$  0$  2 C 2    2    >$ @3' ! "^$ 7 & " @$Y K D' #7E! BP$ D $%  /  c "B$  !"  0$  37$ +' > 9$P H  0= &_/$  !!  3' M2 &   P$

: 2 * M (42 .ATCE  O# ) UK+ X  "N & # & " =@  K6& &    + ! X  O) (/ ' + .< .%) ' O&<  / DP ! .% 6 D)   J % & 100


 9 I % "  $" * I0 V$ $ A  :   .  /0 *  Z' : ("0  " " la Presse "   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; SNIP D..)  -% $ (43 . 1 4? = ATCE ' -!& ( %  6 ' 4 X  & = ( 1 3" ' $" '&" DO  H) QH  ')J +1 &!  (<% 9+  6 !" . %  D) O% .K  Laurent " ) , ]K D% ? " Josette Durrieu" Z& 2007 D% ) & <%& O 'PK )%K    ! "Pfaadt .&  (K) ( 6 '  K & -K! 0 =@   + (O% ' & X G 2008   12  "O -P " ,1O AO  + )  O / 1" O/ 6 (? < && "La Presse"  %   = A ) 8 ' !1 .&& H) 8"  81 O ; / 9+  6 "D)

' A "1 = A!C 4 $-)< E? 1 2008   11 =@ "+)@ !,K )%" 9?  1 A & & " -P " ,1 . + ."La Presse"  % : M *  (44 <& ATCE (  "Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;ĂŠpopĂŠe illustrĂŠe de la Tunisie" ! -K .OP . 0 &/ ' (,KP ' 6) 500 9)/& D  + .!  50 <& <  $ N â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Sun-Media 7"   ) T G GN (45 ( 5R

1 (OP (O  O56 1 + " '&" =@  & O+ 4& 21 > !" &)& (<0 O 8" 1987 &) 7 <&  .0%)@ 101


O5)  (& @ 4 "Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;expression" K% "g&"  % 4 &) ' O+K A% 0 &@  ^ 1  ' 0 @ (0 ' O  ." '&" DO   QH  D)  OK : !  7 (46   + ! F& )< O'B $ J  - C& + 1 X ) =@ (#&)@ ., D   J  ")  O1" =@ O 

0,K  "J P .   .,H &/ ' %1 9  #H .)K

)/ = "/0  -)" !O A ?1 a) & (&! @ X > & < <  'F % " ( ? ?, " 0%"  J  =@ (O% !  +) $"<K 6  (# ' +))  1 g / "/0 " !O K6  9%  &O D  . K6 #%  "!1" ,/ D)  O " (!   (+@  !,K   ( O    "/0  -)" !O HK,1 -+@ '  +,  0 ' h1& (K) 1? .& h1 $(&% ."., ( '/ ' -< %  (  <L : /0 7 , (47 "g&O"   =@ =) O "Jeune Afrique" K%& ,1L 

.("Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Expression" K%  1 D )  ')J +1 . 1 <? "J.A" %& ( + V<&  +) ( ?6&" +&O (,/ K "g&O " F ()& (K) K @ D) .OP ' % 6 -  OP 3 D . K6 K  =) ! 4 6K & '<K A< >& 1 9+ < O = "g&O " @ ' ,)L !& % 6 : 3" ' ! '  O =

102


 . + )&) "Le Temps" ,1  (&! < = '<K  .(DO  HK) I ' ATCE ( (L1\ + /  "O6 (+ &" O K A<  .4? .&)%F 1O& ( K  6  4? h1 ')   H) = '<K  .('!  h1 ' HK) 4? O+ O   +&  %  &  J  qL '!  (/ !& ' (< O  &   ! 1 <  J 22  (<% &+  6 (K) 3" ' $"J.A" K%& ( &)& <% 

!& & D   J  ")  O1" 4 2007 %  (& % ' #O  6K .H1  V<&& AO 6F "# ! F &O 0!  O# '  ! F &O 4 '<K

0  -<? 90@ +/ D)   3 1  =

=@ ?@  K!" V<& = #O   < ) % 6 'PK ."+"  &  <& ')K '&K V<& 1\ #H ' +/ F& )< O'  J  - C& K   6 ' 'O& ! ' $&O HK) ,T  .< ' <  %   K '! ,&  ^ 2007 8 21  ]O P  +& D!, & #O 3" D% D   + " 0%" ? /@ 56& #K+ <&    "'6J" H)& 6F "# / <& 3" &  " ,)6 gO?"  @ "Le Temps" "g&"  %  ! ' & (K)  h1 $  La dĂŠrive intĂŠgriste " ( ? ("8 1&  ") < B& A? +

)+  = "'6J"H) )# C =@ ( O  "dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Al-Jazira . !" 103


.< ' <     ,&  J  K ! V<& 1  + LTDH &O  .G && #O  G = > 6F ' <  O&  Friedrich Ebert H)  G = /+1 .KH)

  I O A< " '&" DO  &! A + ' .&) ") =< I& "! ? " ' ")  O1 H1  &O HK)  %  OP ' O +K =@ "g&"   =@ (?)  (&G & 1 8O D!,& .< ' < !& @ x L .& A  +  V  g / / < A"# O  = 5 1 4 < K / F& )<   2007 % 22  & D  =@ (< 8" .& HK) 6 .)!  (% &  ( &  '!J : ' * *  (48 3" ")" ')<&  ) ! ,1 2009    h<&   !" ! " '& D  &+ a) & ,   6)" .& D  =@ & (O% ')  K  * "  + ,) !  M (49 : (  -[ I  J

(*)

" Guido Dorso" <% D ()  O

"8  6 O1"  g / $<% A"# 0% ) 6 " D = () D = 3" 1O K) 0% &K)& .g + = 0% )% .+ ")0"  "@ "g&

   

    1970   "Guido Dorso"   (* !  #$  %&'$ (  ) *  + , -  (... !% $'  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; % 0) ( . &

104


: (D)  )F 9&)F !  L) / $  (50 )<L  &6@ ) !@ </ ATCE '  & 2009 ,)%  C) ."Tunis Press Network" AO : /   (51 K%   1 D ! (</ ( 6 ' HK) &! .6 O+L X ."4)<) 1"  O ,1O "& < " 1 ) 0#% . +  &+& ATCE , 0%) X ! (2009 ) 1 + 72) " 0%" ? 1 ; 6& ? < # J 1 ! 8   +K   # '&" ".1K '0 )K  " p&! '  &+&  f K,! X #? "' -" ,1O ,K '&! #) "7 K  ) 

.(" ; %" "-<  " '))&K ' J K =

4/ # "' ) " 4/ ")& 6" (%0 + 0%) X  &  &O HK) 6 O% P  D) 1 1 8 &6@ ATCE      #< " '&" H) )K 9 

H) 4/ "#   O / $&O DO  . 6 + )   ' (&1 '!& HK)  ( L K O+ .6 . ) - : 3 (/ 8  : ("/  " /9 2 K9) / "  (52 4 '<K @  ) !  "' ) !" K% = -  1 ! AO< 8" 8 K  +K  @  &+& # ATCE .# J 105


: (/'  8  &)  F   (53 = E &)%F . )& . +  ! $ATCE Z 

' "Middle East Times" K%  (&! 3" ' $( 6 & D  " &) ' 4&" .0%)@ .1%) 0 & . + ATCE ' (%& ) < = .0%)J A"#  3K!L ' Q! = O   6 ' 1 . +O g J : ("RĂŠalitĂŠs" )  A$2 M- (54  %  '< '  % .&T) ? 5O1,& X â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "Imprimerie Maghreb edition"- "RĂŠalitĂŠs" : O?) "Maghreb Media" 6  0 (,& ") 8" =@ % 4/ ("Maghreb formation" >!& K< K) '& "N & # & " =@ ) 6) (% A & 8" :   '!K (@ ) 8" " #0 "  %  ? ."m'0" ) G  ()!



&6F  O  # =  ' O +K 1 $'OL



 4? V  ()!& #,L '? < (&+ 9) $/ 6 + & .O +) 8< ' g  80%  & & (/ <& =#&



.)1 =  .0 = 1&  + N &  KC '! ' '!L (6 .  3 () b1 9   b<



."RĂŠalitĂŠs" K% 6 ' < .)1 ) = /   (& / ) =@ <



.K%& . J O ' .0 = 1 < " 'O < 106




.K% &% I  D =@ <



DO6" " ,<% '& =," ' Q!& "& " ./ (



."K+& " "8 K %K 01 D  %K) .1  A ) O  ' A , ) X ) ( 4 $.&6)  ))+  K 1 ) @ "# & 1" =,"  ?1 A0 &@ . + 9) <% , <%  6 ) # "'1& =" 4 1 A ) <& $ ) " ,<% '& ") 8"  J  K! $ J  1 HK) < )6

 0 &@ = L5 1 # $ +  9G .1 3O 1 (K% O' .HK) 6 )L  ++1 (! 4O%K 9 @ ' ? < .&6)  I K &F D  "RĂŠalitĂŠs"  ! B& ) X ." '& '&< '0" D     AC ' & <L 2009   .< O/ +)\ ' Q! +)& "RĂŠalitĂŠs" K%  6 ' / X .1& "" 3 =@ +) O1 ' ! D)& 2005 ) +<) ()) (   H)  % D =@  !  (O% X >) @  (K% KH)  . #HK a & (& =H1  ( .(ATCE)   &/ '   ) ' % O O1 B  K% ) .K)  ATCE (  $&+  X !" =K1 . &+  -? /@ - )    J .( ,O

107


: & * =>  ATCE  &  95 ? <@  @ <

5A

0 $ <

&   ATCEQ$

 3-

 '  $ 18

 '  $ 48

2007

 '  $ 40

 '  $ 80

2008

 '  $ 40

 '  $ 80

2009

2009 ) ' )   6 % . #H .H1 "# X

 9 0 &/ ' 6 1  6 ' D  ' 6  & - 20 A /    * /0 ,.  K% .<K ! $!1 . ) (% &/  %   " #0 " '! &+  X .!0  .&K '   +& (% .) .9   1 "+1" "RĂŠalitĂŠs" K% 5O6 8 J  O / X :  ! ,L )  ) - 156 "1 " 0

"RĂŠalitĂŠs" 0

<.- 1000

<.- 2000

7  # &

7  # &

( ' . 52 $)

( ' . 104 $)

: (/'  8  &) 3  * 2$2 (55    ( 6) O+L  '  " '&" D  =@   (O% 1K&  ) ".1K 4  <" 2014â&#x20AC;&#x201C;2009 &6)  a) & +) +& ' 4 a) & "# ' )K OF ' 1 &%J O< .a) & 108


: ( 9 L /  M 7) , G9 (56 ( + ) V  < " 1" ,1 .1& 2002 ) X %O  &+< A+)\ ,6 = 3" "' '& 6" F '  + ",) ." 0%" )/ = KhL& a) &  ' (<)  / '! K< (  & ATCE =@ !& (O% X ?O 1 '< ' % ' 0<B& '! !"  %& ( + ) 8" " '&" DO  (< -< $A? 1 O' ")  " 7 ." ?6 -, "   3 1K& ATCE  !O) <  .1 ! B& 2004 ) UKT X K ( (K =K O  % ' J ( > ("80 +" #0  $2005 8 6  "?K)" 4/ = . T) (O & 8   4/  .   A+) 8" ")  " =@ " ?6F -, " (O% (  6 ' (/ = V 1K& AO@ K "-," "- @" ! 1 ?+ = (  ) 4% ',+ =@ .9) &)&

1  %" ! &! ' O & ) & 9?+    ."9O 3K,"Z& "&# J"Z& ")  " , "O  <& A  DO  O' ( G ) K .< ,T &! = A  ' 6& 3" 1 A"# = 8K" ! 1 (?  .( + M \ /0 2  K 1979    *)   /$ (57 (' ;5  : 6O 0 @ 1 <% (  'O&@ (1 9% X & < 1K " ")K  K &K 1K" , ()



."D) ."'!O  '&+K) O" E& ' ()! 109




D%& ')J +1 ' EO )K &O & ( 6)



..O 1 ) ' <  '<%K &K =  &O HK) = (O%



..&) < K 1" <% ?<& 2006 '%  ( ?



."< ' 'K< "')" ,1 G )% = -  K6& 4? ' &   O O1 $".O 1 < % '  +O `!K" 1 ' ."'  '& " !  ) !  "!" K%& &6F '& =,"Z& F& )< / K "D& '# &" Q\  / (&+ $"'  '& " ,1& "K!K" 01  ' " ,<%  /+1 O .O%& =)< .) ) 4/ 0%)J (< '<K& .D) :  6 ' HK)   A<\ = F& )<    < % '  + !" 01 9?  '  3 1 (1 .01 ' +  = K1 ".O 1 4 -)% D &  .H) 4 ; 6  . K 9 %@ (2 .& <  , . 1 ')J +1 4? D)  HK)  lO ,K& ( I ' ()C ' O  OP& (&)\   &! & D   $A&)  % ' A  @  )Y .ATCE O" = (<? .  ) ' K '& ( =

 K) @  ATCE  <& J "#  0\  ."   O1"  -   ) !  ? ' ) !  "!" K% ' (+\ &F (<   '0)  '  4 '%  <" (K)  .O 1 ) D% 110


K "'  '& "  =  D)  /+1  'O '" K .+? .O1 K $')J +1& % 00&\ & K\

6  \ 4 &)%F F  \ 1& % =@ @ VO < ."& )  @  .1) <% &K '<) Middle East on-line 4/ = 2008 D  15    ) , &)% .% '  =K+ "'  '& " O' (ATCE 4 (") 8") D   J   / .  ' -) '& "Z&  <  @  "  &1" .@   ."'  a & . + ' <  ? < +) HK) = 4  "Afrique Asie" K%& z+ : 1  ) %0 "'  '& " O6 ) 0) & .K ( (O% 2009 8 , O G 7 &   6  "La Gazette du Maroc" ,1& z+ : 2   X !" .()K D,) +) 2008 &   + = 2009 8 12 7 & ))&K " &6F" ,1& t 

O& +) + HK) = 4 h1 " 1" 8  ,1 ."& a) &  HK) ' (%& 2009 &&  3  ! $"?)" ! 1 ... " 0%" ? % 5O6 "<&K)1" )/ = "<& " " ' !&$ " "U $ " G F /9L) ! $7  (58 : (" ' M' " "M 5"  &" H)  O ) !  "O"  % 2008 &  C) X .ATCE 4  K  ()< (0\ H) (C! .O $" '&" DO  =@ (O% !  6 ' O / 2008 D    X   ) (&!& &) ' 4& E  HK) (?<& &O ) (<? = O' =K1 (  & $&   -1O E    &O D  6  6 ' 3" <  %  111


- 500 (/ & /O   &K OP  K A0%)@  G  '"J& 3" = E6 D   / .3)& ' &  ) "   E? )&& " , %)" 8/  A  .A0%)@  G  8" E   .&< 29   8# M " M7 F   M 7) /   (59 : ( 

.&6) (1  g%)@    (</ ' # $" '&" ) .2009 : !72 *  (60 "+ , -, "Z ,6 ) 0,  "J &<  =   .&6)  & D  I  g%)@    (</ ' # .2009 ) : /%' A2 (61

&! !& =)& ATCEZ& < <K& <%K 1O& 

O @ =@ < ; 6  " '&" 8OP '  4 ./ < ' ."  D)" " '&" 1  @ . ) ! &&  J 1O ' A<&@ <& () ,< DO  '  6O P -<   6 '  )& (&!  , 96  J (<?  HK)& (   ! ( ! '" 2009 '% 9  <& 6 0 && )!&   ' 0 '" ()&@ &+ '? ,& ."; 6&  O  'C 3  ! E& ' : (+ UIP J E  7  ) /  /' (62 0 &J UIP ! , #0%)L  ./ & >1 ATCE 4 O) . + &+& 0%) D) , " '&" +K+1  .0%)  ! 112


)  ) - 39 0% '<K "# ' &+ =K+  , ? < O? .2009 : (/9)   $ (63 = 1 . + ' < &+& ATCE , 0%) X $O 1K ' < " 0%" ?, 1?,  , ? < (")& 6" ,1) )< "' ) !" K% <% & K,! ! .# J 1 ! 8 K  +K  @  #L '! - 48 (/ 8O &+ = ATCE , (6 H) O1 X .2009 )  ) : (9) /  -  (64 = 1 . + ' < &+& ATCE , .0%) .1 2009 ) + 44) " 0%" ?, 1?,  , ? < .("))& O1" ,1O - @    / $ * $   K/9) /   7 (65 : ("D$2  N0" $ 5%N + $ 0 /0 #

? < = 1 . + ' < &+& ATCE , 0%) - @ .1 2009 ) + 51) " 0%" ?, 1?,  , .("))& O1" ,1O    / $ * $   K/9) /  *  (66 *$L $ K"T  M A " /#  "    #

: (2010  /50 K-  8#  $ N  ? < = 1 . + ' < &+& ATCE , 0%) ' EK) "# <% & ,K! '! " 0%" ?, 1?,  , . + ' < O  ! $"<)/F"  )& )T  3 O6 . + .(2009 ) + 36) ,6 .9?B& )K .K % -1O& . T) 113


 / $ * $   K/9) /  E $ (67 : (#   ? < = 1 . + ' < &+& ATCE , 0%) ) + 24) ,6L .9?B& ) 1& . T)   , .(2009 : (M 7 /9) *  G  (68 + 320) &+& 1K . + ' < ATCE , 0%) =   + " 0%" )/ a & =  ) (2009 ) 1   4 '<K& 3" ... ' , '? <  H a & . + 6" "b @" "8 < ," '  -KC '&! ' ! AO<T .)! 8" 8   +K  # ! $"! O1" "/  K%) "' ' !" % >1 <% & &+& -KT! ! .# J 1 ) -1 >1 <% & (")&K 6" Z )< ) !  6 & 1J )%F '1 C = - J&  & .D)& /@ 8" ".1K '0 )K  " !) '&! 2009 ) 0%) X "7 K  )  '&" ! "-<  " ))&K  J (? .(" ; %" ))&K ! A? 8" 48 (/ &+ = ATCE , (6 H) 2009 ) O1 X

. ) - ] F% Q (71 ] S " M . (70 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ! 0' /9- (69 : (*9)  7 $ (72 -" ,1 ( -     '&! ATCE 4 ')< .? <& O . + 0%)J "'

114


: (/9) G5"   (73 # (2009 ) + 56) &+& . +  ATCE , 0%) .D) =@ / ) & 1â&#x20AC;&#x2DC; )%F ',1 C  : (Tunis Hebdo  ) G  * R (74 $' ! D J = (OP& .   ? ( .KL . O ' < J ' O 1 ')+  ? A"#  (0& " '&" D   ( & &! O / .O? =)1)\ &/  & HK) ; 1 / 4? 8  V6 <& (%&  J  D = ( '  D  & A )  = " . %   E? 8 ) &/ : !  C9- (75 )O? " '&" D  =@  (% $ + = (1@ <& & D  . 6& J %& -   9  9 . &

.( @ .1 < EO    <  /0 /  V  KIV * '  7) U 9  (76     M^_ *7 97 /0 V I K/'$ K $  %'

: (M;  F" * /0 5  5 /0 + /0  

De la dĂŠrivĂŠ au sursaut : La Tunisie de Bourguiba Ă " ! -K

1   ATCE +,) = ! "# ' 6) 3000 4& O $"B.Ali . ) 3000 / O 1) ' -KP '! = : ! $2 0 (77 6\ @ 2007 8 ,  &O DO  =@ O%    K! A<\ Q1)  + 8 O 4%K 0!  )%K  115


<, " '&" D  6    & < K! (0  K  ." +O ) F g "Z& O  O5) 1 : (  *7 " *-  7   *&)   $ (78 ) ) !@ 4/ = - ^ ATCE &/ ' (\ .O A% (,/ ' &<K "h1" ,1 O6 . &F V<&  . + ' + ' !   O&< % .9)& (O% h1 ; 6& ? < +)  .K,K ' )< '  &<K O / )+ ." &   +O" ) )!& ( + 1  , 4 $.6 : !  W  $ (79 ! 2005 ) + & <   0% = )< 1 @ .' < g . &<& A  " '&" D  56 % + M 7   +  M 5 + ,) =  * U (80 + ) - -%   (82 /(9) S5 9 (81 / (  B)  $ * G-5  (83 /(7+   J E -"  : (!29 /  +   ;)J ; 6J  )  1K > = )< D  6 ' .,+L >1 &) ' 4& 21 > !K" 1 80, 8 O 4% 81K P  (&6 ' 2007 &) 7  . + : (  *  M 7     ) !   (84 )   .&6)   6 " '&" D  1K  \& .)  " '&" D & 1K  3 ' ) 5)  . O&  2009 . +  .&! ! $1 O 9)&  O  1K (   .  0 & 116


: (/  M 7  B)  0 J  $ (85 ."N & # & "  0    1996 ) U_L $)K % 6 'PK 0 '  & .(Agence de la Francophonie) )!) , !& '?K )K 

.0%)@ = ( 0K! 8" "2000 D)" ())   ) ! ." '&"   D) ( 1 ' 1999 ) " '&" D  =@ O%   O& " &) ' 4&" % ")  ?1 .1 J& (@ (6 ()   " " ! ' E  '),! (</ ' J (1 $D && & < < < J ((6 ) D) I   () .3" ( '! /   (88 / (* 50) "  (87 / ( ") % *  (86 : (/ ) ' * / (89 / (    B) )  " !  (%) 8%  + V  J )< '&" D  ) @  3" ")" ()) "), 40 ;)^ .2009 &!   6 % & .&6)  I  "

: ( 5 295  $ N F B) V;  " $ (90 & ')J ), $'&< )" E  O ! 1 ."'O0

117


  70 . '  = /0  .  % F  5  5'  59 * D 0$ /0 1996  ' * '5 1% : *# ] 8 < 00< &

K1

7 '& )

K2

)) ?

K3

%1 I

K4

8 ! 

K5

 )

K6

: *'   *9 ] 8 / + P

K1

A%& ' g 

K2

8 % %

K3

& D)

K4

8& %)

K5

1 '& 

K6

8 ' g 

K7

%/ -)

K8

' -

K9

 &1 K10 ' / 1 K11 & % % K12 118


: *  ] 8&< &  1

K1

% , ")

K2

1O & ' ;

K3

.O1 P

K4

O '& 0)

K5

7 ?

K6

 ' J N /0  % F  5  5'  59 * D 0$ /0 1996  ' * '5 1% (. & <%) 8 0 -)

K1

(-1 8  <%) 1 )%

K2

(D) . <%) & +< 

K3

( %  ') ' E <%)   ,)

K4

(.  9) <%) ;1& 1

K5

( %  E <%)    D #

K6

(21 D) ) <%) ;  ;1& 

K7

(1 & 9& <%) 0  '& D@

K8

( %& ') ) <%) & -,<

K9

( ) % ' ) < <%) 6 &  1 K10 ()   ) 1 ) ! 0 K11 ('& '1 <%)  &1 K12 (') ?+ <%) )&   K13 119


( F &  H)) + I K14 ( % ,  ) 8" ! K15 ('1  ) #& # & K16 (')  ) 1 &1 K17 (') ! 1) I '& ) K18 : B   + H) ' E  / &6) '! 1996 ) '+ &? 4/ )  1 = O  . + 5) G  6 ' D)  ' 0<B& 3" $D)  ')J +1 . 1 4? O? 3"): )  .)% ') '/+1 9) HK) )% =@ )! 'O < O' THU1 L '+  C&   !1&   ) <& +1  ! 4/ 1996 ) & .&6)  6 0 & (K1 -6  6 " '&" H)  : 2009 2004 1999 .) < K O  ;1&  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 8&< &  1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 8 < 00< & (1 .'  ,&  %  & T)_L : ;  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1 )% â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1 &1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; & % % â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ! 0 (2 .&  0 +1 1 :  '& 0) . ! .0& D)  'OL % , ") (3 : K)&   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 7K& K) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; D #K â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ' - (4 . . @ D = )

)%K â&#x20AC;&#x201C; & +<  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; & -,< â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 6 &  1 (5 .) D% 9?  RCDZ 0!  )%K 9?  : 1 120


.< < 0 ' D 'L : )) ? (6 56   : %/ -) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; A%& ' g  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %1 I (7 . 0 & -1 @   7 ? â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1 & ' ; â&#x20AC;&#x201C; % , ") â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 8&< 1 (8 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  &1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; #& # & â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  '& 0) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; .O1 P â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <  # 51 ' )!& &1 .O '1 .... 8K" ! ' !) 'O1 '<%K ' # & & < .OP =

.() . 20.000   1% *8 * 5 *# /0  % 0 * 1  21 678   0 * 1  A8    (StĂŠ Ben Duran)  '& - & (1 (" <"  %) ) 1 (2 (" "  %) 1  1 & (3 (ATCE <  D ) )?   (4 (ATCE) )6  1 (5 ("21 D)" )/  )  81 (6 ("' J"  %) 00 %) 1 (7 (80, a) ,1) 8 1& , (8 (" #%"  "@) - ;1&  (9 (" &6"  %) # '& - & (10 (4%& & -!) 1 '& 81 (11 ("7 D)" )/  ) & 8 , 1 (12 () 0, P <  D ) 80/& ? (13 121


("30"  "@) & ' ) (14 ("<"  %) ) 1 (15 ("&"  "@) /  , (16 ( ^ < ) 8  ' g  (17 ("& &6" "I "  %) %1 I (18 (+  "J) 8 < ' 0 (19 () - F 0!  ) '</ 8 1 (20 (" La Presse "  %) ) ) (21 ()  "J )  8 (22 ("h1"  %) 8 % 00< & (23 ("& < " %) )% % & (24 ! 1 (25 ()  "J P <  D ) 8< / (26 ('  D%) 8  &1 (27 ("Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Economiste Maghrebin") 8  8# (28 (9&)Y +  D) ! <  D ) 8 1 (29 ("'&"  %) +)  (30 (" La Presse "  %) ) # (31 (")0"  "@ ) '  ! (32 ("H1 " %)  !&& (33 (ATCE) I =, (34 (80, ) ,1)   (35 (" 1"  %) 80 %) (36

122


  1% *8 *  *# /0  % 0 * 1  21 678   0 * 1  ,9    ("I "  %) ) '& 

(1

(" "  %) + -P  &

(2

  1%  * D 0 /0 *2 /0 ATCE -,  % C E   + /0 * # F G /0 ' /  ' 1  (# J 1? ) <% D $1)  &1 (1   (2 ! '  (3 (1) .O1 P (4 ' '& ># (5 & +<  (6 8& '@ (7 0  '& D (8 00 0 (9 b  ) (10 8  8 (11 (1) 8" ! (12 (D && +) N -6 & (13 (')J +1 < ) $V/) 66 ' % (14 () !) Valentin Mbougueng (15 () ,& + ) 4%  )) DesirĂŠe Belaiche Haddad (16 123


  /0 * ' & *  M E *# /0  &  % * ATCE 1  '  5  7"  G 

: ("M' " ) =' * I K/ *  & (1  & H1 "La Presse"  <&& " <" ( % 4& 4+



.< J ' &< %) 6O O & VO < )<   %  .& + & D)& : (  "< a"  ) G'   (2 +  G = " '&" H) 1 &%@  + O . ) X )   $&< !  <  +" ()) "%& O " '&" & % ( . + # $"D)  F . 1 ." #O0  : =@ )+ 4/ ' D) .)"  " '& =" ) 0 &J K% ' 2008 '%  .6 X  . K D)& 2008 D   & <   >) =  @ &)& .0K  O .<  ATCE 8" ".O1K '0 )K  " ')<& ! B& .? X ."' -" )K ! ,1 (,K & <   P +<) &)& ATCE '  & D) . 0 X )    &)& ) & 0     .O%L 2008 D   .2008 ("Arabies"  ) Julien Hawari (3 - 300 A /  @ !    "Arabies" (% =K+  .)   124


"%)" (% 40 56  ' ()!& F& )<   .O  = 1 (   ()< H) (  4 () %) D)& .D)& 8 @ )   8 % 56  4/ 1 &%J  +  "Arabies Trends" (% . )  D  h1 4 " '&"   D)  ')J +1 . 1 50 > !"  6 1 !  56 , .  ! $(%0 &

9)& D)  < %   )K K6"Z& ( .  +  #  = &) A"& $" )K =+ +1 1  '  = )% %   ' ! 40 ATCE 4 )K& .! &/ ' & A0 O + + ! F .6 " '&" D &  &%J ( +& "Julien Hawari" 0  .2009 ) &6)J (1 &)& : (FIJ , *- 9 *9 M) / - ' (4 "D+ E "Z& 2007 D   (O ! $" '&"Z 9F ' X  !K "# & ' 8",) &! E%  FIJ &/ ' (9 )  (%& ( ) ) " '&" D  "D+ E "  O< (K)  .' A% (,/ !& 3O 1K ') ',1 &+)   )K H) '  X .". "  <& &+K) ), O   5K+ <& 3" ? .6K '  4 1K .   ' % > % X -/ 00< & < < &   ,1O .O<%  J '? H) = "1" .)!  )< 1 1 D) ) ..  < (  &)%F O  ()!L  <  (/ !&  / ! O/ X .D)  H) 6  : ,/ = CK & K  125


: (":4  "" 0$ 3- C " ) 1'  (5

.,K $& D  H) H  D) ' &%@ O% -/  X '0  +<" ()) " '&" 1 &! % 6 K  ! '  & .",< & &) ' 4& > !"    = ATCE .& X ./@ - & ,!  , !" 2006 ) ) , O &/ ' K\ ?/ ++1 .% X

:Z& -95 " / < a) & )    G ,&  K+ â&#x20AC;¢ ' O1& '<,) ' O / '? @   h1 $"J 8;  L O'B ">" ,1 1)  .!  56 6 / < ,K) ' @ " 9  +  =@ / < ,K) 4& + O1 "'1 O"  (H) 4 / 9+ )%F ' . % .KH) 01 ' V& () 8/  1 4  O (0L 3, A% / 9 "4)<) 1" @ )?    I .O? / $(  ..((<&  ()06  (<0&  ,K) .! &  I &/ ' & ) ATCE .) & ? .,6& / â&#x20AC;¢ .(  - 240 e& 4& ) ,& &% g1B&  2006 &   6 ATCE  & .K X ) =@ 2000 ) ' D)  /@  = 1 =   ?/  < +1 8" ) , 9?+ > & H  3" 2003  ,O ' <)& / 8"  ? 4 '  K "9" &+ ,)" .<? _T  "& < " K%  ! F& )<   O (K) (& < 2003â&#x20AC;&#x201C;2000 , ' /@ /& 1 K)! 1999 ) ") D)  ) = =@ 1 2004 )  /@ /& ' )! O / .2009 126


/J /& ' )!& & = & D   / "# . O 3  6 D)& + '!  K) G !" , ')<& &G ' 2007 %  ATCEZ <  D  . O& X

, 6 ,   = 9F  5 6  = 1  + K) (&%& .&T ) , . (+ 3" "& < " %  '  G  .)! $D)  .) ") &% .9F 5 6& .+& &% .) 6O = & ?& 9 I   "# 5 6  = 1  G  .)! : $E  7"#  /@ O O' '1  D)  +L! 8 6K ,& &% 9F . 1 )O  4&   0%  9F 5 6  I)  HK) 1  =1 : /   7"#  &1 O'B (D)  < OPL!) "& < " K% , &% & 8 % &% ))+  K 1 OP h1B& T+  K .< <  D  ' (O%  K6&  + 1 )C&   X D ")% % & " ' +) 3" (")?  ") ATCEZ   - 500 (/ O3 = .O1 K) "& < " %  1  & A% D) -/  CK /  / < .O ' '1&" 4 6 $; / / 4 ./ <  % ' 'F D% =" 4 0O "4)<) 1" / & & 3" "&  .&!   J F  & 6, "&  O 4 < "4)<) 1" ,1 '!  + D,)    X % : 00  " ! ) = &+& (  "00  " / < ."?/ 127


4   O< ))   4 / = K)   ! X - 300 A / e&& 56  &1    C K) $D)&  6 .)) A"#  A K   .6 4  % .)  D,) 1 F& )< X .,K) E/ O56 '  ") D)  < % =+  "4)<) 1" K% 4K :  ! , $)  ) - 249 /  O < J ' 1& :  .< J 1 )  ) - 192 X ."% D)" 4 '< /, ' C )  ) - 30 X .P = ? , .!   6 )  ) - 27 X .< : ("Le Figaro Magazine" ) Michel Olivier (6 "Michel Olivier "m #  O  ATCE E.. ?1& X  1 K% AO< K- @  " '&"Z  ) = # O 8O   +! A0 &T & DO  6 1 &%@  (O 4 (  / IK,L 8  D = (&!  ( ) ) , < K!,L D = A / +1& (  /  O\ D = "&/ &" / 7   D = ; / +& .&  +& (  / OCL .(' D  =  + (   / "* 2 " 9 M  K/%  Z ') 2 2 ' (7 : (* ? < 0 V<& #+  ; 6& ? < . 1 O X . &6 O T ; 6& ,6 8 !O 1 .9 O@ K) = ) .) , 128


+1 . 1 4/ 1 &  + ) V (K) ATCE  X .& 1 '%  &  + ) (&/ &+L $D)& ')J %  (/   O< (K)  $ 0 O  X &  &   D) ,  @  ? O/ !  J ' Q+ e&& < J & O ' '!L 8 &+& 3" ' ""   =   ()! h1 )  ) - 220

) )!L '"  < '1 KT! ' /0  ' J "%/ -)" "  &1" ") '&  " "D& '# &" % & D  ' E .?,  1 &) 9    # G .(& +L (H) : ("Afrique Asie" ) '   (8 (&& D) g%) O' >  # & D  ' 9F '  -/ ' EO DO1 # & D  & .& + >PO  ! 8 =  ( 1 4 ' Q!  & + O D) .0%)@ ( V <  + A ) 3" ' $ =  D) = 1 & DO  & «A.A» K%   >1@ - G  IK K ."D) (% OG 8" %O  $ '&" ))

! " '&" D) 1 .K, . + O U  W) .1987 &) 7 <& .0%)J .  ATCE '  & 2009 )   .&6)  &)&  6) - 43 4& O $D) /  " '&" g%) 1 6 K, (K% .6 =  < '& -6  . O0 D)& .%O < "# ' "   1 0%)@ ATCE '  & O 0 & O)   @  .) , ' -6& 3!F .%&   .+K<& < 129


!  K% ' ;t  < 4&  @ ATCE E.. g /  C 3 8 $()? "2009 X  '&" &6)  a) & ! ; @ ! . 7 9  K1 !& &O HK) 4 ! )< "<) %" >&   &  J  ! &O DO  () .O  ' < . % .ATCE &/ '  ' ( g +L  Q! )& O1 L   " E "   K! /9)  7   (9  9 N $ M   "   &" 5  +  : (   D    %   /0 0%) ATCE  & &) ' 4& ' < > !" &)& X ."+< & ... D)" ! ATCE .)/ $& D  ' '"B& $! ;  # X

.<0 .K ! "# ' 6) - :(/ 5 *   /0 M  K/ b 579L M 7) + 0 *  (10 0%) ATCE  & &) ' 4& ' < > !" &)& X ." '& !  4% " ! ATCE .)/ $& D  ' '"B& $! ;  # X

.<0 .K ! "# ' 6) - : (! /9)  Z (11 ( && & $"X F !  ... 81 D)" ! 0%) .1+)K  6J ATCE .K6 6 (+,) = 6) 2000   7K) ' -KP V< 6) 1000   &K  @ 5K) =

.(+,) = <& 130


D) ! &! ,& L0 &T %    ! IK+T)



 0 &@ 0 .%1 &T G %) 8 ! )  " K"  D)& .+K+1  .1 J  " '& '&< '0"Z 8  00<  < 4% 9)&  <K ! >1 1 . '<K /  ) & 9 @ /  ) + X F !  00<  " '&" % 0 &@ =@ ?@ '? . : ("France 3"   /9) Christian Molard (12 ")?  " ATCE E.. ' <& O 2007     .1 9 %@ (  !@ (& 1J ( + D) =@ AP   1 h1 3"):  &  J  D ")  1" '& ()&  &6@ O ' ()O? ' '!  &+ "Fr3" )/ a & 56& D  =  D K!"  9%  +) (% D) 1 !1 ?,& .+K+1  .1%K) ! = 0!  =@ (&  . 6 .&" .&@ 3"! " '& '&< '0" D  O& / ."'F '& 1 ))J '?K # J! O1  O  (&!  !"  1) (,? &/ ' &% ")  O1" + .((@ : (7 "C E " 9 ) A # A  (13 .& H) -/ = 4  D)&  !1 H) ) . + O 2007 )   ." '&" H) H  L (+& + O5) 'O? )< 1 & D  =@ >#  & + # $" '&" D  / .1 D) .+K+1  .0%)J& ."=F" (,1   = A ) ' 131


"?< &)"Z + = O  ! "'" ,1& + )  "# = A !& & D  '" / ."&" & D) ( .<) .O  : (/  /.) '- !2 c (14 &  6 ' .6  , >, ATCE 4 '<



.))&  J 1 = " '&" H) 1 &%@ . + )& 9) . OT/    1 %  ) O1& > %



& (<K <  &  $ ) - 41 Z& <& ; < -  )0 1 = ! (% -  5 6& ,!K O + 1 . %  : ("Valeurs Actuelles"   + ) FrĂŠderic Pons

(15

'&" H) D) A% & ,/&  <   % A"#  ."

 (&G ' & <L ATCEZ& #  1 D K 2007 )  ATCE e& "'"  % 'F .O/ 8O 1 1 + 0%)@

=@  )   =@ .&%J )T ' D =   % ATCE .K,! / .,O  9F 1 ' ') ') 'P

'  0 ")  V 1"  & F ' &%J& .3"):   (" Jeune Afrique "   '  ) Danielle B. Yahmed (16 . + )& "J.A"  t+ 8 J  O & 2007 ) O X : = )K ,K  56 "#  O / $H)  .K, .1 8O1 D) 1 56 K- 0%)@  132


. % ' J 50 > !" 1 56 K- 0%)@  ' 4& 20 8 !" 1 1, 100  56  0%)@  . &) .D)    1 56  0%)@  0  H) 0 =@ 9J ()C '  Q! ) ' E)   .D) 1 &%@ . + )& D   Q/F = ) .O  4 K% - G 56  G .k%, 8, ()C '  #) +K+1  > &! .0%)^  & .(#9O / & .< ' % &  O : &+L 3" '! ? )  ) ' 1.370 =@ < J /  4   - 670Z& + 2007 ) &/ % & 4 .)!  1 '

.( ) 1000 ' "J.A"  < .P .!  1 , ? 

- 156 ' ?  ) - 312 # / ) ,T!&) 6) 2000 =@ .( )  ) - 140 +&) Tunis Air 4 '<K > = <  .( ) - 70 ' ?

' & 8K" ! ' % <& 0%)@ = ATCE    3000 9)/ 4 $"La Tunisie dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;aujourdâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;hui" 2005 ) % ( 

6) 3000 9)/ ATCEZ & (K)  $(  - 75) ! ' 6) '  = )+  F ,! 40 + (6)  ! ' .< .OP 133


: ("Afrique Magazine" 5 )    2 (17 ' 3" $&+L\& '<K -! ATCE = g / $2007 ) X :  6 . % ' J 50 > !K" 1 56 K- )  3  4 &) ' 4& 20 > !K" 1 56 K- )    .0%)J O#F O%  '1 6  1 ATCEZ .&O DO  .+ . ) 1 56 K- )  K  4  )F 0%)@  # K% <  .! !)   - 236 # / )0  & ATCE 0 &+  . @ !  ÂŤA.MÂť K% , ( ) - 400 ' .2009 )   &6)  1  D  ) X : (/  & * / 0 M 7) Antoine SfeĂŻr (18 Tunisie, terre de " "./ ,  & $D)" ()) &! 

   )K & +& i @ (O  .9% ! # $"paradoxes -KP K! / $)& % / F& 3"   4 " K" ") D) ! $" )  D)  + 1 'O? # " '&" DO  '" = 1 #:  - F V<& .+)" = (&!  6 ' O D) (L<&K 8K" % K  + K .6 ,  D) ."'O  'F 6 O% <   ' ()!& !  @   ! (  ATCE O' 

.)/\ ! $D)& %) O 8+) = O  1) (%& 4%  .(O6 ) ) &    O0 ! ' 6) 2000 134


  + ! 2009 ) " '&" D  &6)  1  6



La Tunisie, rempart contre la dĂŠferlante " ()) ) ÂŤLe FigaroÂť  %&

.&O DO  .& +& (  ("intĂŠgriste dans la rĂŠgion : (" Daily star " 9  +  K/  )   (19 +1 . 1 4? 1 & . + ) (,1 &  )" ) ? < B& ) . + )& ' D)& ')J ."   ' = D) 0  %  1 D    ATCE .O%  (&1  % ' ,1 + ( @ (/@ (+) - & ,! . &) ' 4&   .0%)J -6 1 .++1 9 %J & . + ) ' O1 = ,1 P 4 ,K  O



' -!K = (< ,K  O ! $O  ) K1 '? 4 D) 1 (+& .) /  .& + .0%)J D  O% &%@ . + ) .D) A? ATCE (O  8 + ,1O . ) O0 @ &  ' ) 50 <& D) ! ' ( hO1 "1& " <% ." " <& 6  +  e&  @ 1& ATCE 4 )< &+!  % 4K  .)  - 50 : ( " AE "   + )    & (20 % @ ' (&L  ) + +1   = O1 (,/ (& AO)   ! 8" " '&" D  / H  D)& ." #F"  %   = (0%)@ 135


M K "   G &" "   + ) 7  (21 : (*  *

." '&" H) ) = 5 1 ATCE 4 '<  - 400 (/  @ !    = 1 &+   .)  . + O )& 2009 )   (1  6 " '&"    .!  " &"  %  &O D  1 &%@   ' ( " '&" D  ' # 2009 .  =K+  .. && D) ,   "/' + "   + ) * - !   (22 : (* D) = 1 .)&  . + ) ' ( ) ATCEZ K!  ..O%  &6  . ! ./ & )& A9,! " '&"

  & ') ',+ 8 . + )& (&1  ' O&  ( % 40 Z< <& ATCE 0@ &+L "& < D+"  % .D)& "Z& (<% &+  2003 &  D) =@ 0  6  (,OC ' O& % 6   ! <  D  ")?  ' a K > = "& < D+"  %  V <  .&<O  6  O& O O ! !& #  6 6C  0%1  6 =@ (#&) ., 4 .&<O A"# "& )?O   LAUU  / . &!  .& 81   40& gO 4+ ' . 1 Q!  (K) .3"& 0\ / $? 1 136


: ( 5 " $ " 5 9) '  *0 (23 & DO  .& +&  6 ' IO%&   . +  Q! 4 O< ATCE A  O /  8 @   &+L 3" . % 4%  .K% , : ( 5 " " 5)  $ (24 )   .&6)  I K &+ " '& '&< '0"   .  (K% .1,&  E6 DO  1 -  6 ' 2004 D  ' .< = 9)& "N & # & " &/ ' A ! O $2001 .& : ("" 5  KE   9) *  (25 ' , !") ATCE ' &<L )   .0& 4K 8 @ O! &+ K% a  Tunis Air 4 '< /, â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Tunis Air $ 0O  @ +& K% 4K ! (...)  ) - 30 (/ H) 6 / '  + ' # 90% 6& &+  + # .&O :     29  "N & # & " =@ (O% ! 1 .  O?   & <O !&K D & <% 9+  (K) 2010 h& 4 ,1 &)& France 24 TV5 )/ MontĂŠcalo .1 / X  & < a6  ! = MontĂŠcalo !&K @ 4 '<K : I, D) =@ 0 9 6F "# =

$ F& )<    (% ATCE > K6 ' = & < A< >& / &+  %  +) =@ VO <K  () .& .3" 137


: ÂŤ The international Herald Tribune Âť 9 (26  C 1) O%  .K, . +  . ) X .1&  1 J g " 1 K-  )& ' $D)& %)

  !" ( ? + $"1987 &) 7 ") !1 H)   56 <& D)   J  O" ( ? 6: ") ... " 1 a & -! 8 & < E+  @ . + A"# -H& ?+ & D  ' .<& X .&! 6 1 &/ '   O + 0  !  !89  K!  /.) Guy Mettan (27 : (G *   +  M  G /0  

/ $& H)  4OT . + )  ATCE 4 '<  2009 8 , 6 5 7 &  8 + )& J "#  / La Tribune de " ,1 4/ =  "Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;AGEFI"    ,1 "# < $D) = /+1 .H) V<& 1 (   "Genève ((+& 9%  1) D) ' 6 , G .%& 1 .H)" O' ,? $".)!J 1 G O% .0%)@ a) .++1" .",/  0O1 +) HT D) = 1 O : (  9) * '  (28 4& 15 > !" &)& ART , 6   ATCE .%) ( 6 0!  O "'&+< &" <" ! %) & 'O? $ &) ' ." '&" .0%)@ 0 &T  4/ =

Middle 1% M  K* L /%  /.) !2 A (29

: ( east online -  8"  8 &6J 4/  6 ' 2002 ) ") >& . 1  6    3  # ATCE 4 ! )< (

138


&+L )  - 50 A /   2009 ) 1 =@ =+ &6)  1987 &) 7Z <% E  -# 1 &%@ . +  ) ." '&" .0%)@ 1 " Image 7 " 7" (30 @  '< /,K %&  O )  ATCE 4 '< .)   &O   D)  '1 D = &? )0 : & .6K &! '  9 } E \ " Image 7 " 0%)@ (1 . / '#"  HK)  1 / D) 56& ) , '<& "6C K  3O 1K % \  @ )   KP 6K) .E \  "# a) & \  "Alain Pouzillac" > 6K& "Anne Meaux "  O< (2 )& ') ; 6 O% ) ,  "J 0,K .! K 4% D HK)& ( <%O  .OP A"# = A",) D L ! (Fr24 TV5 RF1 ')J +1 .O 1 <? 1 ,/ 56  Fr 24 6 .D)  : "NBN" "ANB"  % (31   & H) -# 6 ATCE &/ ' ,H O ; 6& ? < = O  O -/ I? 0 O6 )& ' HK) ?#) ,/ e& '? < # &) I,  .)+ =  .&O : & ATCE KH)  =F ,1 K) ! % & (1

'+& ' 0 ' Q!  3   4O% "81K" P &)& 139


A+ 8K" 6 >1 I? 3" "8 !K &" " K,H #0" . P g  " '&" DO  :  ! ANB )/ 4 '<K (2 m ) ,1 ,B& )+ = &  &6F ) -H X 3" $&   &6F +,  1  P 1 . & =@ H) .    ? !& ) 8  1K K6 (% -&   $"b#O <F" ) ,1 = 6  O : H1 ) $3"): '  "@  D)  ANN   O0G  & 7 D)   ' -! "# = +& ! ANB )/ @ .  / .(( +)Z . && !" ,1 /@ .+,) 1& A L )+ = Kh&  & 8 1 a) & 0%)B& gO X

  -/ . + O#F 1 V < "D& '# &"  J D) -/ I? 4 &)%F &  )  J   & 6O < 8O  O  4? ?+ '  G !& J ' ? < = O  ' 'K!L .& &)  6 ' % 6 ? < 0 V<& 9   6 ' D)   @ O< %& 0%)@ ' a) & O' < 4 "# $H)  01F ' 6& .! (1 + 8" ./  (K& ANB =K ATCE ;)@ : +$ M 5b7  5 (32 500 = 81 Paleya O  )   & ! 0%)B& /

."H .   '& '&< '0" ()) & D  1 1, : (/ 0 M 7 /9) François Becet (33 &! 2009 )   .&6)  &)& -K ATCE 4 '<& « la Tunisie, porte ouverte sur la modernité» ()) &O HK) I 140


: Robert Khayat (34 &! 2009 )   .&6)  &)& -K ATCE 4 '<& .ÂŤ Z.A. B.Ali, bâtisseur de la Tunisie moderne Âť ()) &O HK) I : (G"X  -# '   M 7) Enzo Orlanducci (35  F +)  O  !1 1   ) H) .D)  !1 H)&   "8  &1" 4 '<K& : (" Financial Times " 5) Laura Lathan (36 1 &%@ + 2009 )   .&6)  &)& . )  ." '&" D  1%K) .& + H  D)& 8/  ) &! 2009 )   .&6)  &)& .,K ATCE 4 '<&  "Ben Ali Ă lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;enseigne des grands dĂŠfis" ()) &O HK) I . ) - 40 (/   .& : (/ 7 /9) Valentin Mbougueng (37 : # $" '&" H  D) 1 !  - X La Tunisie ĂŠmergente une voie pour lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Afrique (1 Ben Ali et le modèle Tunisien (2 La Tunisie en Afrique (3 Institutions et vie politique en Tunisie (4 ATCE 4  ! '< &6)  ( 1  " '&"  ! ) 

&%@ ! a  !1 H) ' E 0, . 1  H .& D  '

141


:   1 1 RF1 )/ = a) &  2008 . O G 7 & K6 +1 .O 1 <? '  HK) ' EO "8 ) ? " /+1  (% ' + ("O1") <L \& (K6 '! $D)  ')J .ATCE ' g / 5 +  -.  7&  $ N   ) Gaetana Pace (38 :(* # F  -# - $ $ ' E  -$  0   .2001 ) ')J +1 O 0% (& " '&" .O ! X G H) &G '  ^  & ) , =@  .O/ X '?  A)B& " '&"  !  Norman Academy !1 .(Knight of solidarity) 9   K/7& M 7 /9) Andrew Borowiec (39 : ( ; - /0 "The Washington Times"  6 ' < '<K  (&G ' % 6 J !   2009 ) -)   "O1K" D) ' 0+) & ! 0%)@

# / % ,!& "21 ' + )  D)"  "g%) / XD)" ())

. 50 0%)J  1 . 50)  )0 =  ) - 100 OF ')< 6 4 ! 0%)@ = D   "# .( & /    < &   +  'F 1 (6 O ) .(')J +1 '?K & % 6 6O 

142


ATCE J %& *9 /0  %

("T  M A " '  "/ ,  &" A2&) 

 

%

    



 

  



  

  

 

 

 

$

! " # 

 &

% 

'! )

  



*! 

,

# +

# ./ 0% !

 % - 

1 2

%  

 .,

3/ 



4,% 

)

5) 

# ./ 0% !

 % "%

0

! *67

'!

8 %9!

 : !

% 

ANB

 +#

%

 

 : !

 +%

143




    





5# %

*<'

## ;,

0

 :

./

, /



/ '

%

1 % 

=%

 

NBN

   %

New TV

1 

/

2 

*

  

ARTE

< >



22 



52 5#



/

?  :@

- 

 *) â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  

-  %

5

%   

# ./

1  

Middle East Online

2 A

2

22 

ANN

% 2 6

ANN

B *

 /

 6 2

ANB

+6 

%

#6

%

144




    



ANB

 C)

Middle East

  1

Middle East

Anver Versi

Hommes dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Affaires

) 

Hommes dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Affaires

Stephan Day

Jewish Telegraph

Paul Harris

House of Lords

Tom Mac Nally

./

/ 2,

 

D  D 

'

.< ?= 

E

 % *@%

    -%

@< 

F2)

5/

+!  2

#%/

 *=

5G %7

Fr2 H ! I'%

GĂŠrard Klein

Le Figaro Magazine

Joseph Mace-Scaron

Fr2

Françoise Laborde

Le Figaro Magazine

Bruno Seznec

Paris Match

Jean-Marie Bourget

TV5

FrĂŠderic Mitterand

Valeurs Actuelles

GĂŠrard Gachet

Arabies

J 

Le Figaro

Michel Schiffres

Le Figaro

Alain GĂŠrard Slama

%

8!



%,

145




%,

    



LCI

Jean Claude Dassier

Radio France

Patrice Gelinet

Fr3

Christian Malard

Nouvel Afrique Asie

?% )

Trends

Julien Hawary

Arabies

 

Radio Orient

Faouzi Chalak

TV5

AmobĂŠ MveguĂŠ

Fr2

K2 @

TME

L *)

Les Cahiers de lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Orient

Antoine Sfeir

2)

Michel Kik

RFI

Zohra Sotty

La dĂŠpĂŞche du Midi

Jean Jacques Rouch

Art Sud

Salvadore Lambardo

Dernières nouvelles dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Alsace

GĂŠrard Cardone

France TĂŠlĂŠvision

GĂŠrard Sabagh

Agence Act MĂŠdia

 ) 

 .,

4%% 

TĂŠlĂŠ Matin

William Lemergie

AFP

'%2 

Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Alsace

François Becet

Le Figaro Magazine

Thierry DĂŠransart

Partenariat Europe-Maghreb

Huges Wagner

Le Nouvel Observateur

Josette Alia

146




    



Marianne & Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Observateur

#  2

Le Point

Claude Imbert

Radion Classique

GĂŠrard Bonos

Le Parisien

USA

% %

Motvalon Bernard de la

M6

!)

Dominique de

Villardière

Nouvel Afrique Asie

Simon Malley

PME-KMO

Alain Deladrière

Femmes dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Aujourdâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;hui

Christelle Gilquin

Canal Z

Raphael Piret

Trends tendances

Jean-François SacrÊ

Regards revue Juive de Belgique

Denis Baumerder

The Washington Times

Andrew Borowiec

M;

Georgie Ann Geyer

%    <% +F

Lucien Meysels

La Razon

Pedro Canales

Tramite Parlementario

Luis Suarez Gonzales

147


 :â&#x20AC;Ť×?  ×?×?â&#x20AC;Ź â&#x20AC;Ť×?×?×? ×?   ×?

×?â&#x20AC;Ź â&#x20AC;Ť×?×?â&#x20AC;Ź 1994    

             :     ! "#$ %& '( ! )   & *) &  2  "  + , - .  /  % '(  0  (1

 %+  "% ) )  ) 4" &  56 "%34  . 0!  '(  7  %&  8 9-(  *     >  ? -   "%+  "< 90+# =! (2 ) ) 6" %6!  2-? & (1994  30 %& A )   C  "% )" ,0-  9  ) D   ("La Presse") "C!&  +    )#? 3 *) 0   ) FGFFG  6! 80 "D ? E0# 1994  )?  H/3  3 8     ) D  ) 6!  .   8  "C!& ) ) 6" "#$ ' "% )" ,0-  9  +#  %6!  I?  + ) 6!  5 8 C D "=  '("  C   C  ) E+-" %  0  + ) "% J )  " ) & !  C 0K %0  * "La Presse"  ) %0' A& "Tunisia News" ) "  C! 1994  19 12 )  &G  &  +& /-? %6!   ."% ) 7  )&" -

149


W" 1   N 2001  # 

2004       /0 I "/ *"

(&6) )  " '&" I  K OP O%  J . 1 O'@  +) &<T / 2009 1999 1994 1989 .)  %   !1 01 (   @ 4/ QH  IK K " " QH K @ $ '<?6 '    J  A  .!1 RCD Z 0!  )%K  / 4 &! (O%  J %K O'

IK ! " '&" 6& K< 2001 &&  # P ' &) =1 2004 )   .&6)   ( !1 01 1 6  0) =@ <K&   &! C ( '! D) /  D,)& " '&"  K& O <& =) ! 9, <& ,    =@ >O O O +  !1K < .H) /  $O  G =   "& " ' 0 .O6 ) ' -6 ' O ./ & '  O! =  < <% ) O  %  D! = .   .% I  ' &< !  .)!   % -6& &? H) Wp1  )%  + !1 01 !# ) .KH) .<% - : ) ',1 ',+ ' <  + 4 % + $(@  0!  4 '   F %  '?  ')), '<% "F # " '&" I  t' O6L =1 #C )  -1 4%  6)  % 56 $  < 4 &<  J O' &<  : 'P O#

150


 

-D E 

 

3-$

Enjeu dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;une perspective dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;avenir

6/  ())

'! 18 2001

Le

Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;excellence en acte

#/ )

'! 18 2001

La Presse

% / % *'!  @

) 

'! 18 2001

./

8A , # %  ?'! ?'6

) J

(J )

'! 18 2001

, 

3%   +F +%'  ? %

  # (  )

'! 18 2001

, 

   @ @%

  ())

'! 19 2001

, 

*<' *)  +%'

())   +

'! 19 2001

, 

4) +%' *)  8 *) : *) P  

%G2  ( )

'! 19 2001

./

Justesse de vues

/ 6/

'! 19 2001

La Presse

Scruter lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;avenir avec optimisme, assurance et dignitĂŠ

46 %A (1! )

'! 19 2001

Le Renouveau

2 %   4 $/ 6 

!  (!% )

'! 19 2001



Pourquoi Ben

G2 *%

'! 7 2001

La Presse

Ali ?

( /)

151

Renouveau


 

-D E 

 

3-$

' *)  5 " %  A

46 %A & (1! )

'! 1 2001

, 

! .#%   < B' .

% 5!/ ( ;/ , )

'! 1 2001



J/   8'%> 4)' %) 5 : 2004

L  ! (- )

'! 10 2001

- 

 :   4  7 '

%G2  ( )

'! 10 2001

- 

*)    4 0% *'! #<

K! "

'! 10 2001

- 

* %   4 5!  '

 1 % (*  *))

'! 10 2001

- 

) >

*)) +! 1 % (* 

'! 10 2001

- 

%' 

< 1 (5% +) @ )

'! 10 2001

- 

Ben Ali, pour poursuivre lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;oeuvre

 

'! 10 2001

Le Renouveau

  " -  #

3') 6< / ()

'! 18 2001



 J/' %% 3 

%! : @ ( 6 ! 5 >) J â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( !)    â&#x20AC;&#x201C; â&#x20AC;&#x201C; () 5) 

'! 9 2001

$ @

152


 

-D E 

 

3-$

 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; //  " ' @, â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  #, â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (8  ) (0 ) %  * , : @ â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1)' %, ) ( !) 5<  " #   %  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( !)  J/' %% 3 2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( 6 ! 5 >)  ( 6 ! 5 >) 2) ()  . â&#x20AC;&#x201C; â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ()    >)  1 %7 () %%,  > @     *) : #/% +% â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( 6 ! 5 >) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; () $ )  %  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   *)    4 % )% â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 8  +%' *) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 62  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 22  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; / %%,) 2 ( â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  1 %7 R  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 8' ', 153

$ @ '! 30 2001

'! 19 2001

 


 

-D E 

 

3-$

J/' %% 3  

+F) @  1 %  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (@ ) ) ) D 2  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (6 @ (@ ) 2 >  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (@ *;) 4,) ) 1#  % +% â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (*<A  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; () $ ) *) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( ! )    â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( !) 8! ( 6 ! 5 >) 3 %)   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2 ' â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( ! ) (@)

'! 16 2001

$ @

/   0%

@ )' ) ( F) %'

,% 1 2001

./

  ' @

J  % (%' 5'! =')

,% 4 2001

./

*)    4 +%'

@ %%, #/%    : %# 2 ' â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (%%,) 6# +%

'! 26 2001

 

% â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   5 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; G2 #/%) / (@   

154


 

-D E 

 

3-$

,% 6 2001

S 

E

& â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (%,) 6  2, S R (%,) G 2  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (A)   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( /) # D  3') 5# 5)%    R ($')   R ( !) ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( ! 5) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (@)  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (  ) ) +7 (  ) 1/ ' (5'!) J  % â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ('!)  #,

,% %   J/%

(#/%)    # 3') 5#  A / *) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; () )  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (%,)   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( /) A .  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ( 7) (%,)

+%' 4 * '

) 22 

,% 7 2001

 '6> $@ : *='  , 8

7 82)%7  

D   .,'  (   % )

,% 6 2001

155

: 


 

-D E 

 

3-$

Pourquoi je suis fier de vivre en Tunisie?

Erich ALAUZEN

' 27 2001

La Presse

P?T% P? % 14 !' ?, .A% .?

< 8 5'! *!) (+%' ) 22 

,% 7 2001

E

,% 7 2001

E

P6:   ; 82)%7 1U @

1  

@   *<'

+6 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;)  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; @L ) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; -   % â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4%H  V â&#x20AC;&#x201C;:)% 2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; HH 1 (@) 2HH)

'! 23 2001

./

%6 F#' "' *<' "

<  (*  *))

'! 17 2001



*)    4 +%'

 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  A! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %< 2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %' *) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %) % 1 % â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 

) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 8, % â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  #, 2G â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2L 1# . , â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  S â&#x20AC;&#x201C; )  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %%,) 62 )  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (A

'! 12 2001

 

156


 

-D E 

 

3-$

2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4%  V 5) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; K/ % â&#x20AC;&#x201C; JF  J/' %% 3 ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; % 2  *  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %/   7 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; !/ (@)

! 24 2001

$> @

 <' 2 4 *) %# < 82)% 5!

! )% (  +%)

'! 27 2001



) 8)% B' 4')

 5 (+6  3X   )

'! /% 2001

# W

 %' 7 " 

(1<A)   2

'! /% 2001

# W

" J/' % 8'%  " 2004 % F

%/  (# W ) ) #< 

'! /% 2001

# W

' â&#x20AC;&#x201C; / *! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; J %! â&#x20AC;&#x201C; % ' â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2) 2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; â&#x20AC;&#x201C; !  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ' %/   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (@) .,' â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (  )  C) /%  (2 ' I'%

157


 

-D E 

 

3-$

# W

+/ ) ) (5%)  J

(*%< ) ) 2)  # â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2) ) ) () Z ! "7 +%'  * +%' [3 ... 

  ) * < @ (+6  37 ,

'! /% 2001

B '>

%/  (# W ) )

'! /% 2001

# W

Ben Ali ou la quĂŞte de lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;excellence

''% * , 5#   +F) (INNH 5 

'! 24 2001

Le Renouveau

+%' *-' "' )% A! C3%

   (F% C)

'! 24 2001

, 

. 2004   $/

 @ 2

'! 24 2001

./

'! 24 2001

La Presse

La Tunisie entre de bonnes mains

Jacob Petrus VAESSEN

(%) A')

 ) ')   ?,# +F

%2  %

'! 24 2001

- 

2 $2   )  '> +%' ' % 0@

1  *) (8% 5'!)

'! 26 2001

./

158


 

-D E 

 

3-$

% '' "=' . * F $

)   

'! 26 2001

, 

Pour la consĂŠcration des valeurs du changement

 '  (5'! ))

'! 26 2001

Le Renouveau

Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Ĺ&#x201C;uvre Ă parfaire

()) ) -,

'! 11 2001

Le Renouveau

Un appel du cĹ&#x201C;ur

'  % ()

'! 31 2001

Le Renouveau

La lĂŠgitimitĂŠ du bon sens

\/   % () 3')

'! 25 2001

Le Renouveau

Pour que lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;ĂŠlan ne soit pas brisĂŠ

,  (2 ' C)

'! 28 2001

Le Renouveau

Une volontĂŠ politique gĂŠnĂŠrĂŠe par les ambitions dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;un peuple

#%,    P) 3') (INPH E

'! 31 2001

Le Renouveau

 2  Ben Ali lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;appel de la raison ($')>  , '!)

'! 12 2001

Le Renouveau

Ben Ali, le choix de lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;avenir

$2  *!

'! 7 2001

Le Renouveau

Le cĹ&#x201C;ur et la raison

 2 

' 27 2001

Le Renouveau

Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;appel du cĹ&#x201C;ur Ă lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;âme

 / 3'

,% 4 2001

Le Renouveau

Ben Ali, une vision ĂŠquilibrĂŠe

/  #  (ISHMN  P))

'! 7 2001

Le Renouveau

159


 

-D E 

 

3-$

5< 0 , 2

# % 2 (1<A)

'! 26 2001



    #

 " (1<A)

'! 21 2001



0%  

! -, ( & )

'! 11 2001



< !' F

 #, 2! %) @ ) (4)'

'! 31 2001

*! ., 5/ 0% ' 

G2  (1<A)

'! 25 2001



  6 %! ]

8%)  )% (  )

'! 30 2001



  

'! 28 2001

:)=% 0 * 4 2'>

4   (*  *))

'! 29 2001



  %'` 3

  (  )

'! 29 2001



 5 

'! 14 2001

2  L% B7 8% / #  ]< 8%  ] _

"7 0 ) V 0% L' *#







7  %6 

/ 6  %' '> +F) (    

'! 07 2001



< * Z ! *)  

6/ / (1<A)

,% 1 2001



160


 

-D E 

 

3-$

,% 4 2001



%   4    %

  2! %) @ ) (4)' G  ( , +%)

Pour mieux prĂŠparer lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;avenir

, !  *< 4   2

,% 6 2001



 -  

,% 6 2001

Le Renouveau

Acte de foi

'  

' 28 2001

Le Renouveau

Ben ali pour un nouveau mandat

  (6< #/%)

'! 11 2001

Le Temps

La Tunisie dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;aujourdâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;hui a su faire son choix

%%A @ "  +) +F) (* ' 

' 28 2001

Le Temps

 " # 

' 27 2001

Le Temps

) 5

,% 6 2001

Le Temps

6  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ' @, //  " â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (8@)

'! 21 2001

, 

3  . ())

'! 11 2001

, 

  .,' . ())

'! 11 2001

, 

  (*  *))

'! 11 2001

, 

Dans le sens des attentes de la Nation Ben Ali le choix du cĹ&#x201C;ur et de la raison

  ' @ < 4  " "  4 *)  ?=! ?# +%'   +F *<' J/ @    .<'  %# 1

161


 

-D E 

 

3-$

4 /  ' *'

 S () / )

'! 25 2001

, 

)' )  , L' 

5#  A ())

'! 16 2001

, 

* ''   4 %' 

  

'! 30 2001

, 

'<A %'    %a

2 ' (.  5 >)

'! 28 2001

, 

 @ --

</  2 (.  5 >)

'! 28 2001

, 

 *) 4 *3 0% 0#

##6 , . ())

'! 9 2001

, 

.<' *;   %#

  " #   , E) 8 8> '> ( 

'! 12 2001

, 

    #< 

# D  ( /)

'! 12 2001

, 

 )' *<'

  

' 27 2001

, 

'> %@  )% S)

M   ;, ())

,% 1 2001

, 

 '' "' ! 

8>   (.  5 >)

,% 4 2001

, 

<'` 2`

 J  (. 5 >)

,% 4 2001

, 

162


 

-D E 

 

3-$

+%'   L' # @

  (.  5 >)

,% 6 2001

, 

 ' +F

'! 22 2001



'! 21 2001

: 

 6 8/% 4)' *! 4') 8%! " +F % "

/'> +) '  )' % @ '  4 '% @ '%  +F "7   J/% F 8'%> <

 $, -% 8#7 B'

'! 30 2001

: 

T% 5 [3 ,   J/' 2004

/  (*  *) A')

' 28 2001

: 

' 6

(  ) +%  *!

' 28 2001

 :

  %/ 3

 + 5) # +  *) + %% ! 6

'! 6 2001

 )

Le sens dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;un choix

22  '

'! 11R4 2001

RĂŠalitĂŠs

La Constitution : Expression suprĂŞme de la volontĂŠ dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;un peuple

?<   ) +F ) (@

'! 17R11 2001

RĂŠalitĂŠs

163


 

-D E 

 

%<'  

 J

'! /% 2001

?  > $/  B%'` : * ' 

:  :

(%,)

'! 31 2001

./

 %3<%  ... % K='

L .,' ()

'! 25 2001

./

8)    8 ,

,!   ( A')

'! 28 2001

./

@  *<'

   (  )

' 27 2001

./

!G %  > +%' *<' F 0% +%' P*'

+    (*  )

,% 1 2001

./

5# 5 [3 J/'   2004 8'%>

3 @ ( /)

,% 6 2001

./

!   3<% 0,

#!   (5  /)

,% 6 2001

./

  $/ 'A << 

 + 46

,   2, ( ')

,% 6 2001

./

J/  <#%   

%#  (5/)

'! 6 2001

./

Ben Ali, une vision dynamique de lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;entreprise La chance sourit aux hommes lucides

G2 *% ())

,% 6 2001

La Presse

#/   3'

,% 1 2001

La Presse

164

3-$ *%<


 

-D E 

 

3-$

Le temps des bâtisseurs

)6 1 % (  )

' 27 2001

La Presse

La force de la Tunisie

5 .,' (Communicateur)

'! 26 2001

La Presse

Pourquoi sommesnous pour Ben Ali ?

/% 1 ())

'! 14 2001

Le Quotidien

Le sens dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;un hommage

)  *)

' 27 2001

Le Quotidien

'! 27 2001

5/

   )   J/' F 8'%  2004

   ) %'

*)   4 %! :

 L'

  

'! 16 2001

0@

%   +%'

6 C  

'! 16 2001

J 

5/ 7

6 C  

'! 9 2001

J 

#< [ 8 '% %' @

% 

' 28 2001

5

  ...    "

% 1;  ())

'! 23 2001

J 

  *%

,% 1 2001



               

165


"/ *" +  *  *  /0  % 2004   $     

166

  

(1

  

(2

 

(3

    

(4

    

(5

 

(6

   

(7

  

(8

    

(9

 

(10

   

(11

 ! "

(12

# $ %

(13

&' ("

(14

) 

(15

 *   

(16

%#  +

(17

* &

(18

 + 

(19


167

) ,

(20

-  .  -, 

(21

/   0$

(22

  %

(23

1 2

(24

3 

(25

 (1  

(26

4  "$

(27

56 - 

(28

  

(29

  2

(30

 7 -# 

(31

   8

(32

  9

(33

-  4 

(34

# #  

(35

  +

(36

 & 

(37

:  2

(38

7 -%2

(39

 7 "#

(40

4  

(41


168

   #$

(42

$ $; < 

(43

 ) - + 8

(44

=  

(45

 

(46

  7 7>

(47

 + (0 

(48

  2

(49

-   - 

(50

"  

(51

  7

(52

 # #$

(53

=% 

(54

4$  1

(55

?7 4 

(56

  7

(57

 ) 

(58

   

(59

  7

(60

# ! 

(61

1 - 

(62

  4

(63


169

  

(64

 @

(65

 76 ?'

(66

 ' A 

(67

  4#$

(68

  B 

(69

 ? "

(70

2 .   2

(71

4  

(72

, ("

(73

  "

(74

-7 

(75

  

(76

   B 

(77

C  +

(78

,  7

(79

 ? 

(80

 1  '"

(81

  # $

(82

  4'

(83

 ""  

(84

 4

(85


170

 4& 4

(86

 &1 3+

(87

4"' 4 

(88

 ") B,

(89

  7 1 7

(90

 B $

(91

D '1'  8

(92

 

(93

  '

(94

( 42

(95

  

(96

 - )

(97

(  ('

(98

7 +  ?$

(99

 '

(100

1 41 E%

(101

 B 

(102

 B   ( "

(103

 ;  

(104

  4

(105

 

(106

)# 4F 

(107


171

 4 F 

(108

 % 42

(109

 % 4

(110

% ;

(111

4 '1 B 

(112

  4

(113

1  &   2

(114

  - +

(115

  -

(116

  ) -

(117

  

(118

  4

(119

;0 7 

(120

4$ 

(121

 7) 4'

(122

 - +

(123

  

(124

?   

(125

    8

(126

  3G&

(127

 ;7 ;

(128

7 4'

(129


172

-   7

(130

 4&

(131

+ 

(132

  7 B $

(133

 '7 4E

(134

  

(135

-%  ; 

(136

 76  

(137

4  - 

(138

  

(139

?# 4 

(140

'  

(141

   

(142

$ + 

(143

7  

(144

 

(145

   

(146

  7$ 

(147

7 ) 

(148

  ("

(149

= 1 4

(150

   +

(151


173

"  

(152

  &

(153

=%   

(154

6  ( 

(155

 &   #

(156

 

(157

 ? 7 

(158

$ %  

(159

 "$

(160

 (  %

(161

 & '

(162

 " 7

(163

 

(164

 7 (0; 

(165

 6 

(166

4  ?$#

(167


"/ *" +    -  J 97 /0  % 2004   $     

(4# #J /   # + -  ) 'H 7

(1

( L ?) -  ? ) ( 

(2

 5    -# 7   F)  E &

(3

(  %#  ( "M#J /  %# )  7) 7 &

(4

(%#  4#  7)   

(5

(  %#   5    -#  7)  

(6

(%#  4#  7)  #% 

(7

(N$#     4$ )E  7) 7 

(8

( L ?) $   1)   -# 

(9

(4 4% + )  ' 

(10

(:# 47% 4 &) C7 < 

(11

(4  ) 4 ("

(12

(6 #  7)  

(13

( 2 ) =% 3

(14

( "#, 3  F)  3'"

(15

(4 ; /  8  M# F) - + H' 

(16

( ;  M#  4M#  7)  - 

(17

174


"/ *" +    -  J 97 /0  % 2004   $     

(  -, ) 6  # -   M#J (1 (,  + )  #  4 " #  M#J

(2

(    )  "  4,' #  M#J

(3

(# 77) 4M# 2   M#J

(4

"/ *" +    -   ' /0  % 2004   $     

(=  -,C) +  

(1

(4    ) B   

(2

(47 (" )   B   

(3

4  "  

(4

(%  )  '   

(5

"/ *" +     ' /0  % 2004   $     

(  3 )"4"  6 # <+M 4M# 4

(1

( E  -# )   4# 4# 4H

(2

(- " ( ) @+#  P $; 4# 4MH

(3

(7  ( )  #J  &# #  M#J

(4

175


(; H')   / MH M#  #J

(5

(%   ) $'%   M#J

(6

(! "    ) #  #%  M#

(7

($ "  ) 4M# 4 'M 4 4MH

(8

(3  + ) 4 4M  4 4MH

(9

( 1  M ;)  ) # :M# 4 4H

(10

() ) #;  M 4MH

(11

(%# ;) 4M# 4$ M % 4H

(12

( +  8) 4F M 4M 4MH

(13

() ;) / +;Q 4M# 4

(14

(! "  ;) M# '" 4# 4

(15

()  %) 4 "#J 4#' 4$6

(16

(4 - ) #    4

(17

(?7    8)  ,   B 2 4

(18

( ' )     4# 4

(19

(/% ) -    4

(20

(77   4%7)    &# 4

(21

(   ) ' ?) 4# 4

(22

(  ;) 4F  4M 4  4M# 4

(23

(" 3'")  "M#, 4# 4

(24

( " 7) ;# F   / #Q 4# 4

(25

176


(7 2) N$M# 4# 4

(26

(4 F   4)   9 -M# 4# 4

(27

( )  7 M# 4# 4

(28

(77 ) /J "#J $ 4% / 1 4# 4

(29

($   )  #J P $ 4# 4

(30

(  - ))   4# 4

(31

(7 ? " ) 4 - 4# 4

(32

(  )   ) 4# 4

(33

(#, -  )  M .  3   4# 4

(34

(3'"  B %7) :   -  4# 4

(35

(    ) %  6 M#  <+ 4# 4

(36

()' (') / M 5   4  4# 4

(37

( MC 2 .) % 3& 4# 4

(38

(  ) 4 ; /  ; 4

(39

(? 1  4) 4# 4# 2  F M  4

(40

( 7) 4# 4M# 2  2 4

(41

(6 -  .)  ,+ 4

(42

(7 47$) 21 # 4F  4

(43

( M# 2)  9# 4

(44

(.  ) /  "M#J 4 

(45

(,&'  ) 4 4,; 4# 4

(46

177


( 1 3 ) 4 4, 4 4$6

(47

(7 4+7)  &M#  4# 4# 2 40

(48

( -% ) 4+ 4M# ( % 40

(49

(1  ) ' /" 4

(50

(, 4') . 1  #  P $ 4# 4

(51

(@ & .)  6 "  

(52

(-  ) 4  - 4# 4

(53

(.$   A,") P #J - 4M# 4

(54

(    ) #%  )E 4# 4

(55

($   ) ;  &# 4

(56

"/ *" +  *  *' *-  /0  % 2004   $     

(4 S :;M# 4  P' &) =% 3

(1

(;  :;M# 4  P$ F)  (0 

(2

(")  :;M# 4  P$ F)  % ! "

(3

(;#  :;M# 4  P$ F)  - 

(4

(4  :;M# 4  P$ F)   ?$#

(5

(4 :;M# 4  P$ F)  - 

(6

(7  :;M# 4  P$ F) " (0 

(7

(' :;M# 4  P$ F)   

(8

178


(  :;M# 4  P$ F) 7  ;

(9

(4' :;M# 4  P$ F)  ? 

(10

(  :;M# 4  P$ F) "  ?$#

(11

"/ *" +  *  *9 /0  % 2004   $     

(#  #%  M# F T ) ! "   

(1

( ) )  0$

(2

(# %) #)  

(3

(# %) 47 (

(4

(# %)   

(5

(# %) ,% 

(6

(  # %)   

(7

("A " "  T # % '")   

(8

(# %)   &

(9

(4# %)   1

(10

(#  #%  M# 4F & â&#x20AC;&#x201C; # %)     E

(11

(  # %)   7

(12

(F ) " .   ) 

(13

(F )  E  

(14

(F ) U   A,"

(15

179


(F )   $ H

(16

(F )  " 4

(17

(F ) H' H$ 

(18

(F )   .$

(19

(F )  ' 3'"

(20

(  F ) %   

(21

(F )   ! " 

(22

(F ) " 

(23

( ) :" -, 

(24

( ) 4 

(25

( ) C7 ("

(26

( ) 76 

(27

( )   '

(28

( ) "  

(29

( )  (

(30

( )  " 

(31

( )  ) 2 

(32

(C7  - 4 W4)#  ) C7 V

(33

( )   4

(34

( )  ) @  NM 

(35

(  )  +)  

(36

(2)  

(37

180


(5   )  7$

(38

(4;# 42)    

(39

( ) 4  

(40

()   

(41

(# %  ) 4 1

(42

( )  6  +

(43

(4;")   4 )  2

(44

(4;")   &) ; 3

(45

(4;")   &) M# " M

(46

: 2009     * C- : 2014]2009 /  <  C E -5 '   (1 : '5 Y  -  M C  : )%K A"# .O?

181

8< /

(1

,1 #

(2

+K) O

(3

&+ )

(4

8 "1 1

(5

G  %)

(6

8  8

(7


/& % &

(8

 !&&

(9

1   !

(10

 ?

(11

7& !

(12

: 2009       /0 * 9 *A  (2  &    I% )' L "7 '%> % 



E 0 %@

  "%" %6 

 ',

(1

) 3' %#  $. d

B 5%2

(2

% 1

(3

C'% $#' 5%) 5@' V < %) \/

$#< , C I'% e

, 2 -%'  <A    < %% 

8 3 $. .

 6/

(5

7 +%' %6 $.

 %   #

(6

2  1! )

</ 

(7

  #L=' 8% .A=' * <FA #/)  4) )' "7 8% 46 " %  %'!> 

182

/! 1 %& (4


 &   



/  * !' %%  *! 5) ? " 5%) .e

86  8  ' .%  < P

'! 2,

(8

%  <    5'!

 2

(9

: 5'! 1; "Tunisie, porte ouverte

E 0 %@

François BECET (10

sur la modernitĂŠ"

'6 8'< ATCE

'#/% #7 ,

 *< 5'!  

Le " ) " "H  , !/ " Figaro % , +%' * .1%)  

Antoine Sfeir (11

ÂŤ France 3 Âť H  

Christian Malar (12

%%=  5<%

!  (13

)7 8>< "@ " " F  , B/ P?-% 8

 * % ? P , ')7 ' "" '%6 "ANB"_

+) @ PV /'

   (14

, 2'  %  

% 4') , #/%

, 2'  %  

% 4') , #/%

183

6 *6 (15  K 2 (16


 &    3 2)%7 ,  .%' "5" 46 1'  %<=' ' F  6  6 .?-% " "  " 5'! 2)% "\'  %  F  6  6 .?-% " " "@ *< , / 8   , ." "    .%' '%> <  2!' < B') '%>

 ,L) !/ 5

6

,  2 (17

%%= ,  5<%

!  (18

 * 5'!

 C) (19

  ' +F " "

  (20

  ' +F " "

 #  (21

 2 $.

    (22

*  *)

% 

5 % 5

":"

%  0@, .% '%> <

%     )

@ #a' *    / S! 8-'

E 0 %@

  (23 *W 22  \/ (24  %    (25

%#  5'! ' 5/ #<

 ! (26

%#  5'! 4)' # -%

*! 7 (27

/ -%  '! F%

 7 (28

184


 &   



F' P  +) @  *  *)  80@, /' '! '%> 2' I%  7 '%>  (AA ) 5# 2' F % , !/  7  # !)  , #/%  ' 8%'%> ) 3' / C @   ' 8>< %H! H@ ) 3' 46 La Presse) (Tunis News "@] *< , / ) ' +F  8 ] , "'!" . +F )7 8>< 5'! ) ' +F  , / " " . +F @ <'% 8>< 5'! C   e  @ 6 @   46 ' +F  Middle east online 8%'%> " " +%' 8)% ."

185

E 0 %@    * (29

 +, (30

J 0 (31

  # (32

?<   % (33

.6 ) (34

*!  (35

2 A (36


 &    :)% *   /% , %' )' " " Z*  e  ?') 8'', .VL , )7 8  . 8F@, , )7 8  . 8F@, )7 ><   ] % -% : 5'! * + "La Tunisie ĂŠmergente une voie pour



E 0 %@

  ' +F " "

%  (37

 

+  (38



"  (39

%!  

Valentin Mbougeng (40

lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Afrique"

" )7  "France 24" %6 A animĂŠ une  confĂŠrence de presse et publiĂŠ des tribunes Ont toujours adoptĂŠ une attitude positive Ă lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;ĂŠgard de la Tunisie

J  (41 PrÊsident du club Suisse de la Presse Genève

Guy Mettan (42

 ) +F La Gazette du "

 *! (43

" Maroc Challenge " 

" Hebdo 35H %  +) @  *  *) 5% . 186

 * (44    (45


 &    *2% 1G ,' ,! 8%/ 8'  ,' 8 *2% 1G ,'

 *  *) La Fourmi 8#

Laico *2%

E 0 %@ / * ) (46 K )% (47 2 % ) (48

*2% 1G ,'

% 

*)  (49

8 ,'

0  +F 

 %  (50

, ,' *2% 1G ,' *2% 1G ,' *2% 1G ,' ', ,' *2% 1G ,' 1G ', ,' *2% *2% 1G ,' *2% 1G ,' *2% 1G ,' 8 , ,' ', ,'

Range Tour

*'/ *2%  *2%  Bizerta Ressort Travel Ways Songo Tataouine Tunisie Voyages et Hannibal Tour Skanes Thalassa *2% Village

 *2% Diplomat *2% Voyage 2000 Coralis

 # CTKD $.  )% B/! 1   EG ) %

(51 (52 (53 (54 (55 (56

   * (57 *G2  (58  / +    %) *@,

(59 (60 (61 (62

*2% 1G ,'

+% Oasis +/ *2% +< 1! *! *2%

*2% 1G ,'

Gafsa Palace

*2% 1G ,'

1! 1 *2%

)   (66

*2% 1G ,'

1! %  *2%

// J (67

*2% 1G ,'

187

)% / (63 6  D  (64 ! )% (65


 &   



*2% 1G ,'

1! Venerria *2%  / *2% 8  Marilia *2% 8 1! 2 *2% "%" 67 "%" *2%

*2% 1G ,' *2% 1G ,' *2% 1G ,' *2% 1G ,' *2% 1G ,' 8 ,' ' ,' *2% 1G ,'

!/ $#' 8  , f%)

5'! EA ,' \% 8>W ,' +!, 2)  ' 82)' ,' 5/ ! 250 ,' 4,  ' 8>W ,'  # W ,' #L@ e6

Avant-garde

5  '/ SNDP $. . STIR $. .

E 0 %@ '  (68  5 (69 '  % (70   K  %#     "   + / /  )    

(71 (72 (73 (74 (75 (76 (77 (78 (79

. , (80 %%,

Meublatex

Media-diffusion Electro Ben Ayed

,  # ,  % %  !/ 6 5

(81 (82 (83 (84 (85

'  3% (86    % (87

! V  6

   5)% (88

SOTETEL

   (89

!/ 5

%  2 (90

188


 &    *<% ' ,' <F % 0 ,' 8/



E 0 %@

SOTUDIS

2 -, (91

SFBT

4   (92   (93

8) 1G ,' 03G .  ! ,'      ,'  < W 8/ ,'  ' #  e WAP SMS 2)% 7

Ambassadeurs *2%

   % (94

  .

!  (95

CAMU

  (96

SARRA CARD

   '% (97

8> '" !/ /' "+%'

/! 3  (98

46 2)%7  ' ATCE A A  % .%   !/ 5

'%> < <' 4@ 8 B'/     5  ?'6) 5'! (D  , 8 1! 5'! STBH 1-  4)' 8) 5/ -% .  2'     #L'  % 

$. .  . %' 2 ' ;

189

  C, (99 2 +% (100

# " #  (101

/  (102

) + (103


 &    <'  7 -%' % 8@  3 %' ,  % %) I% -%' ,   <A  #/%'     3 -%' ,   <A  #         0<'% -%' ,   <A     46 3L' 4 3 %' ,  % %) I% 2         # ) 2 -%' 2   46 3L' #  3 %' ,  % %) I%  46 3L'

 !   F *L/' %#

E 0 %@ 1  (104

;/ 2  )

 2   (105

5=/  37 

6/   (106

%#  3 

  (107

4)'  1!

 *)  (108

Le )  Renouveau

G 5)% (109

"" ) 

2 )% (110

SNIP !/  

%  % (111

190


 &   



4@ ,  %#     P'! P  I% 5/ 3 %' ' .%' g %  < 8-' -% . -%' . 20 %  "0," "0," . .%' <  #/% 5/ ) 5% '%> +  @ F' ,  5/ 8  -%'   !/ 5

) 2! *A  . 8  -%' ) 2! ,<A 2

E 0 %@ '   (112

5<   2 (113

2'  (114

  1; (115 8, 0) (116

*<%' 6 7

*  *)

< .2'

 ' 3'

B 1F (118

B')

) '

) 2 (119

0@  .% ) @

  ! 5

  # (120

"" ) 

8 2! #7 8> '> E

1% %W (121

8)%!' 

; 

%G 0% (122

,  

 % $.

*    (123

   F  I%  '%>

[    .$. % F 2 #7 ,<A ) 5% +%' 191

/ * ) (117

'  .2 (124 # .# (125 %)  (126


 &   



-% /   +%' 8 ' /     1! 7 < #/%' 6  // 8) 

## 6 +F %' %# '> #7  ; 5

< ) #/%'   3 ' 8> ,' ,6 " *; 5%) ,6 " *; */ ',< .% ',< .% @ 1A! #/%  % #/%  h ' 1A! F' , 2'  /

E 0 %@ %)  (127  0) (128 5 .,' (129

$/ 5

K/ 1 % (130

 ' 2 #7  ,<A 2!  2 8)%!' 2 #7 * '>  7 ' 4)' #< ; "+! 1 %"

 %  (131

% <  . F 2 "    0 d " 2  

1/ *) (132 ) ) (133  ! (134 5) # (135 +! 1 % (136  G2 ', (137 5) !/ (138   (139 *<  (140

*% / )

/  (141

 < / 5#

#) % (142

/ )  5'!  < 

' * (143

192


 &    @ 1A! #/%  % F' , !  / F' , !  ' # " 1/   !  46 ' 8   8F@  )7 8 ) .%' 8 %

 '% / ) '> )  5'! 8-%  ) +F /  S'%   2  "*%" %6 "5" ) ' 4)' #< ": "  5

+F  ,@7 [ # %

E 0 %@ #< * , (144   

(145

%  (146  S)% (147 !  (148 6  (149 #  (150 :  ' +F (151 ' +F (152 Le Temps

./   F% C /' +) @ "S;" )  ./ J  La Presse

  8'< /' % +F 



193

  (153 22 5)% (154    (155  @ (156 < 1;  (157 ) J (158  %  !/ (159 8%)  )% (160


 &   



E 0 %@

- 

L  !  (161

E

) 22  (162

J 

5 %   (163

TAP

! + (164

TAP

,  # (165

) ' +F " .," ) 3 %'   8    <% +F %' Afrique )  

Magazine

" 1/   !  46 ' 8   8F@  )7 8 ) .%' 8 %

%) )  (166 +%  *! (167 !  *) (168  2 (169

Arabies ) 

Julien Hawari (170

+%' ! +F  #7

Gaetana Pace (171

2 ' C I'%

/ 2% (172

"*%" %6

 S)% (173

"5" )

!  (174

' 4)' #<

6  (175

194


 :â&#x20AC;Ť×?  ×?â&#x20AC;Ź    â&#x20AC;Ť×?×&#x17E;×?â&#x20AC;Ź "21 " "7"   

                       " #$ " "La Presse" ! #$          ! "# $# % &  '  !(   ) *+ *,! -#. - .3 # "$#! "! 2" )! /0 : ()  

    (1 5 -6 7. 7    -&+ 5 $ '8  9 #

:! ;- 8 <+. =#  > ? *! - * *# 5 *! # - *(# &  ;- *'  )  *!

;- @+   8 AB&5 >C     "  D 

*$!   E +  *  <#6 (' *E *#  5 >! 0# *!+ :! * *5 "8 5 F6 *B <-7E *&+  ! * , -  *I6 ) (# G0 2 H. .(L' <M G0 * , H) J-#E . ;# 8 P- + )' % ""O! 8 -- 2.  C! % ; , J-#E 

Q5 >)  5 *-6 8% * % * HS 2  *!HE 2 -- 5  & B - # 5 J-#E R! *7.    B *& J-#E --'5 >+  AB7 5 "!' " T . J-#S5 RB ) :! >* + 5 T-6 - %  % +  AB7 5 ;$  8 ! # ' P. A % * !U I *7.  9 8. ." V &  ,   195


:  

       ""   !#$   65 I5 8 &5 (1 ') 3  '> )?65 1/&  2005 )3 0 .(B  3 +  B "F " @E (2 .2006  -   B/ & 4 (3 @  '% 4J ?& , .' 

      ""     .2006       (1 .2008   !    (2 .2002    " #"  (3 ." ' " $%&   & (4   )* +, -/  0/' (5 .2007 .12 *3 &  4 (6  0 )% 4 (7 .UGTT 7 8  )56 4 7 8 '  4 (8 )6 )79  )  :'    ) 1 )3 '  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; *  3 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  < -  = 0  > 0* ? (   :'   @9  >, 1, -% 4  @ '  '      ... A4 9<   B & "4"  (9 1/&  )3 0 3   .2005  B  3 + E  "@59  D  " C  (10 - 5 F   C*  @ '  2005  "$ A5  " G3 *'  H3 .% & H , 3 )3 5 

196


:   h1 '  &6 '1F   h& &)%F 9&)F . ! (1 )1  6C&  . 0 &6 h&  "."Z &/ D) 

% ./ &  1 4+ ".% & " O !   48 =@ 3  'P &G 1 ) G  @  J  - C& . )O <& @ KhU&T  . 0 '  .)& O6  %  /  &6F (2 3" # ) O ' ?6F 9? H)\ 4+ O .P V<& .?,?, )% 9+&@ &O )% ' 6 <& ) ) 4% .)O! ? <  01F ) (3  P  )F 3 &%J )%) 01) +)\ ,& O@ ! O'B .)& .G & O $+)T  #1 #   .() =?    8% !& #0 & :  2 5

D) ! '! '1 40 L0 &L : "  " /0     .K,  6 ' H1 (K) K @ $,1 E+ K &! 9&)Y +  ( 6 ! "N & # & " &O  J & 6 '! !& ',1 &/ O' = Q O $!&   ',H  .9  '! )  D O' $a &L G )1  !& .. 6K  +O< . O ) "/,9 $ " D,  @ 9&)Y +  D) !  F& )< ) 4/ : (.)K 'OL O 80!  +& 2009 && 28  ( & % 6 H) (+@ O (K) K @ $2009 &! 8  UI\T 8" ' + ! =   197


      ..         !!  "    # !!  !!$%!   "   &' .2009  () &* +,*) -   /       :    1 /   "  " ! 3 """ " 0!- 1 /   6* 7 &' 6!8     "4 5*) 6* !- 9 %; <) 1  =  >!   " !) =' ?@   !6   ."&6 +

6" &# A B     â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   (2  , ?@ 0&# A 6 +*  &' / 14   @C * !    !$   <) $ D / * C/ 7 % !    ! &   - &' "* &  " $ E = %) F*6 +

/ .  " @G "    ! " @A 21 7 > 7! H 6 ' " I B@C <) J- # A 7   * , D! K' 0 6 G  !)%  6 L!  6M  6  7!E N OP = M   ! 3  &' * ! 7 *  5!, *, ( , ;! "4  +/   7   ?  <  ?@ 6 "#!  .# A &' *   ! *> : 

6!) #$ L%! )* 21 7 > & % ! N H 7  ) Q %R  0S +,* <) 7!   L 6M  # A 7    !  B   =*$  8 <) & T N   ) !! %!M &' 6!, 7   +   0!  L !' D*   4!   <G .!  ,  <) "#!    G 3)$ , 6  %'  198


V<&  &6J . ) + =  6 & h& =+& "# # & "Z   & ' < ') +  ), 51 .("&!O  #" $"+ , -, " $"8 1& ,") "N &

;$ % F  0G ' 90 <

04  8

I H % F  0G '

; #,$'

5) / 7 8' R I% E  )=' " ) *  . 2 [@ .") "

   E 4% 46 "B ." I% 0% +F  8' F  "  F %%<  .'' * #U I% 5)  ' R  . ."*#" "3 @" #/% i  4#< E  F ?, 8 L 8% !! "A"   37 I% )'  ' R  3 #=/%  5 B3 " " 4@ " [2!' 8F  5#<''  ') /' 5 <  ' , #=/% % 16   .%W< 8j

H   F  0G ' 5 ;$ 4 

I "B ." I% 4<"L 2" #=/%  5A!  ?'' F , *  ) %  07 $ #  E *6  %%<  F ? 4#'') %%< F  ,  ,' # 4@ . +F "7 '! E *6 ? 3a  .(I%

:  =  A"# = E K  )   1  J  8&T ? < 9 V<& =+& ATCE 4 )& ' 1 9+) '1 199


 G = ) 56 =1 <  J  H ' ! <)  ) "& %) 1" "F " ,<% '& =," . "/0  -)" . '& " "8 ) ? " (%0 " 1" "& % " ... < ',< =1 @ ') ?K) ! 1 0 ! "'   D)  . "J .)+  H ' K& <) ' ) <% .(&)%F .)+ 4& '    + ' @  <  5 295   8# (& .K, V<& <%  8!K V < V<& = 9)& 'O<  : Z& +K< , h1 $ & '/< '? < ' F <?  (1  = .)   / ' +&) < A"# '! 8!K V<&     '" ' F V<&     .0%  =@ K  4& (O% $   K+1 ' ' 6: ' 1 ))+ ." )"  J 'PK   ;  ./  H) .&) ) 8 J - K (2 '<& K< K- 3"  (,H 6 )@ +  ,H ' 0, P L =+ 1  "& +< " + 4 O< . O#P &  & & /< A & & )J   K .O  # =  ' .<& '<K "# '! / K6 . -  (3 = ) ',H V<&  1 '!   .0  (4 1" ")1 -P  & " "8 1& ," " "  G '& &1" "3 & '& 8 !" "  1  " "&!  #" " G& "& +< " "8 < @" "1 :" "&  " "0 1 (..."+ , -, " 200


( ( '&@ "+ , -, "Z 8   - K 9 (5 .)K 0,K  "J OP& 4O%K ) &<K D   + ))+ 'O 0% '" P& '<  E,  (6 .'%   . 0,  "J P % F ')+ (7 "Cactus Production" 7"   29 % (8 = "8 , " #   "Cactus Production" !  .& : K  + 3" ) 0, , a &  ;)@ O<& 80, +) 1 & ) 0, P K,! * ./ 5 6& Cactus Prod !  ,! ' = / 1 6 J 6 !& Cactus Prod !  E,) *  ) 0, =@ 1  .  a & !  1 .A<& a) & &/ h&T  .) J 6& ,! :   "3 3" "  / 6:" a & &)&  D,) ;) O (1 !" "1 !" .  " '," "3< 1" "3+)  8) " ."e)!" "2 !  .& Cactus Prod !   G =  2010 '%  (2 (& D  ] '&@) " '& 80 '&  " &1 "', " a) & ' )  0%)@   56  "!  " L 

) 3 & .0\& ))& MTV )/ = 0%)L ) 80, T )+  F ) 0, T) "8 , "Z  ' < 4 $(1  6 J .<& ;)J ,! %) !  .  <& a) & ",)  O'  (K) K @ $+& H1 !  201


: "0  " "La Presse" 9 (M ',1 '# )  6 )% '! 2008 D  26  O ?  '& ' " La Presse " Z "+)J !,K )% \  x & +< .%%1  ,6 = 3" " 0 * * 9 " ,1 &+ G < - H &&  # ) ' ,1 ( V < =@  O1 =@ . + 8 + ( &/O   & K  !! % .<K/K& +K< . +  6K .1&  ,1 4? # =@ &F A"# 4% .O / -1 0  % &&   )F &6F %1 = H)& (O% .1&   % = .  1 . + $!1 01  L  '1 = 9 Q! O'C& E)/J =@ P G + &   &6  %    +  _ ! ' 6  & O' .8/ 

202


 :â&#x20AC;Ť×?  ×?â&#x20AC;Ź    â&#x20AC;Ť×?×&#x17E;×?â&#x20AC;Ź : $  295   (1 "'5"  % : $& .) <& K& & 2003 8 , 13  & %K K& )\  & <" !  ÂŤ Tuni-Media Âť !  =@ < !  .(& D  %0& # / (&    % ) " ) O! ' 'O& (  O ! ,1% .&& )+ 1 O+  HK) O' G !K ! F& )<Q O' "<&K)1" )/ K-&  +K< .0%K  ' HK) OVG . 4% = A  & .)K O 4  & /,K  )&  6& 6 :    & ) 0, %)  .  a &  ' ()! . )+& 56 Kh& hC P <  D  ' " ) & <"  2006 ) 5 ' ,P % 6  1 ' )% ()! )K 0,  "J

$< 1?& . %   O   3"  ! 0%  = +& '"   & D  =@ E? "# 4 &

0,  "J P O' < 4)  ) - : 5 A /  e& 4 &+ .(1   ) - : 10Z& .0%K A"# 9 ! = .& 1  a & ; @ ' )+ '!  2007 8 ,  & D  (O%  &%  K<& 3" )+ % &   &6@ 203


.O%&  )+ 0\ O  K! $ J   '&  & /,K\  O5) -6L  # $ J " '&" D  a & )+ Kh&  = 4K   O5)  )K O )+   " & D  %  "# $ & ."  &6@ A !"  J A  '  ,K  O5)&  !" , .)O 6:  E?&  &< O - H& O  )+ ' K! 2007 D   % '  ! $   -<?  H)   3)& > 6K & ? ' 9, J   K UD\ $  &6@ . ) Kh&& Kh& < ' )+ 9, @ 2008 ) ' )K -) ' & )O .2007 &)  xu& % , ? F STEG 6 ' 90% ' ()!& & O1 =@ F (&  -

)/ ()/ O' ) ERTT  G =  1 .  ' &) E/& .O6 : Z&  2010 8 20  .0\ # $)+K .O<  & K<  &% .0\ â&#x20AC;¢ .OP I)T  )O ;)J  O6 .OP L5O6T .0,K <O ;)^ < ! ) « AVIP » (!  .<K / = 4% K%   5) .0 & )+ <&K (8 & + = .9F ) < 4 ' 9, J& +K< .    H)  D    <  .0%K &)& ? .D) /,K  ' 28 ,   5) J 4 ' 9, J â&#x20AC;¢ 3 (O 9, @ ' )+ .,\ ' & ' <& )K  4 ? 204


') O ( ) ' 6 1) O ,  ? 4 ' .) - 940 1) 80,  "J  ^ ) ' .+1 4 ' .( ) ' K+1 ' ()/ '! "D) . K\" > 6K â&#x20AC;¢ .( ) - 460) SMS Z < J < = ()+ 5O6  O 0 â&#x20AC;¢ ' O6 .OP > K6K )+ , O ' 1) 56  ."<&K)1" )/   @ . 1 0%)@ = <% % .,1O <  ?  &  K 56  ' )+ 9, @ â&#x20AC;¢

&<& &! .&K A"# E% = &O DO  K / "# = )+ &K)& ?J  @  "!! &+L '& 1 & &" .HK)  4 >  .&<O " &O DO  '  2008 &)  < "Cactus" !  ) "8 , " 4) )& ' (? < '< '1 ') ')+ 4 /<K ' () 0,K 4  1 .()+& I9 &" ' &! & < K "# ' (&?G &O D  >& / ."  =8 4 /0 "

' ) &% J ' A9, @ O%  2010    X (& % 4 $')< "& 2009 ) (<  E%  4 (. 2) )+ ;)^ )+K   & +< &% .0  ' ()!& < $/ /  ')<&  ) - 60 e& 4& (& <& 8 & <O OP '   ( 5O6 8 J  O > '1  ! ."D) . K" 205


: 

!& '! %O  O' K!P ' (K)B " ) & <" .& 1 .+1 4 ' 5K 8  )+ 4? A&)  ., 1 ! ' 9, J  O' h1 /,K  5) (    ? ' O ): / )/ h<& (& 4 '0 ? F h& < 4 ' J 4  &6@ . ) ;)@ (& ("  <&K)1")   )/ ("D , <&)1") . &!  )+  & .)!@   0, 9  )K !K   6 ' 1? '! + &+  '& / < O' &O DO  =@ " ) & <" & (O%  < ! I&O  (G OF $ G <,) 1 / .)! ' K 6 0, )/ h<&  56    ' (  4 (G ) 6 $( OP  J  4) 4 ()C ' O  '! 4% < O+ D) '?1\ 4 '0 )+ h&  ) O' .) 0%  .<

206


: "5 % "    9 2  E  / 5 * $  

   

   

   

   !" #

  ' ..2008" $ %    * + ), "( )   "!/ 0 " -

# "2 #"1 %

3( 4   5*"  .36(2

  

2008  27

 '82 9% (: ; 2008 '    , ) < )   ' 3"  + =2 >?(

 9*"   (

.' @

 0 3 

2008  12

'7"/ '"

5 %      B"  '%0 # + D 7" :5  <;+ 7 > B E "*+ #   7  7 "!/ 0 " -0 F%7 G" "2 '  '8 <;+ 7 '%0 9>" 7  (: ! "3 , 3"A 4 H =2 9  .'2/ 

'%02 "/(

!" *(    ; H>(E -E* 8 9 " ! # F"/ 0( " 9 + '2

!! "'> "

22 H>(E

2009  >A 24

;+ 7

7  # )"2

207

2009 7  10


   

 

   

0 " *7 " > '   5  (E J( # "!/ 57 5 # '2

5 0 =2 5K0  > "! " " 5  E8 !! B E #

#" "   .! : "2

2009 '2  18

L M    0(2 "2 #" F(2 !

5  <5 '2 * # ."9"( )7 N0"

' ' 9+

2009

2009  > 22

2009  > 24

M-M    (: ; : 5  "2 # " "

... 1987 7  7  " ."3    B"(2 ATCE 2 '

O"/P+ "! " !, "% -EK 4 A L "'0 " "  36(2 *%K   !

'"A '(2,A ) *LP   (

<  ! / # ( Q P

 #A "!/ 0 " =( <G" " =% 

'  ! : 5" (E ) 5  6  > .ATCE 2

"! " ! "/(

'

2009  >A 22

0 5  " > '  ! : * K   ' ' 'KE '2 '0 !A '(6 -0 ) <2010 (2 ' "

 =2 !  / # !! " 9 + '+

23 H>(E

2010 7  29

7  # )2

208


:  2 5

:  '  2 5 (& ))+ O<K h1 ' O 4 ? /,K & 0   X K & -K! 0 4 / )+ 8  1K K6 a & > =

O "#  . 6J '  % &O D  =@ O% K!"  : O#  ) = 0! K) ?O  a &  J )+ O< (1 '& .   .% " ?  ! 8K) '& . 0K) .( , . %  a &  !& % , ' h1& J (2 )  %  ?O  a &  '1  3  (3 (...)< 1 $1 '& ) $E O0 &? G <    6 ' J O<& /,K   6 (4 ' ! 4& (.   <&K)1) 1   & (21 ,) K, .(20 ,) 1 '<  J .1 ' %30   /$, M$5 : $   2 5 (M -K! 0 "6 4 " < K < .K,  6 ' 4 ' O K O< " ) & <" O' I?K & D  =@ K & .O6 ()/ = 1  ?  5) )O J 5 6& O (& )< ))/  .O<& + F& )< O< $O 4  & /,K\ & :  6 ' $& O? O K )6  O 209


!  'F 9! K '& )+  D 40 \)  (1 7000  2009 D  19  .,K& 3" $ )+ K " )"

" ) %)" ('F 9! K 1) " ) >" ()&@ '& ,) O1 .!! (, = H1 4 8 %K %O& 3" % ( Q! K  48800  A !  .,K& / ! ! ' %& 3" (;)^ "" !   D ' %75.08) :  %; < 

<  5

â&#x20AC;&#x201C;    â&#x20AC;&#x201C;       â&#x20AC;&#x201C;     â&#x20AC;&#x201C;       )   â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  

( 

0 4

 42300  /. 100

1

    4230 

      !"

 /. 100  650

2

    650 

L '! " ) & <"  O +  .< A"# . K / . ) ' 2 # / ) @ 4& "%& &" "& K '" O' 'O& .,K K-  6 ' '< &/ "" !   '# )!  (" ) & <" %0) " )" !  &K)& " G" &<T !  A"# O' $@ 

)/   56 K /,K\& ))/  / (K) h1 )+ K .)K O 4 ? "<&K)1" /,K  ' 33 32 ', '!  1K) A"# ' ./ 6 K = 1 .&% +1   O8 9 %@ )!@  = O) 210


&! + ' " )" ! & +K< 3"  & ,K     6 ' (/ 6 =@ " ) & <"   # $)K O +&  @ & K  '  =@ K !  51  .,K O H)\  D  % &! K ' K/ Q!& )! .,K )& '&  D 40  @ > <    =K1) &! O .('F 9! K D,) 6  ? ' (  4 ' O K  " ) & <" '! O C&  B&   ) ) e& 4 < ,6 <K â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2006 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2005) )+ h<& =F .)O  ) AP, @ 4/  ) U\,p x ' <& (K) K @ $(    % D ' .<& (2007 &K)& 4O& (&L )  $ , A"# ! '  ) ' 6 e& 4 '  &O DO  =@ < K!"  6 ' $A 2009 2008 p) =

'! (K)B ( 1 e& 4   (K)C& 2009    &F 3" )+  K '" < .K 1 I  O ? '?@ ' ') O J 4 ' 9, J& ?+L O+ $O     0%)B& O<K &+L )+& < O& 300 I   &+ ' 28 ,  9%  (? K!P $2008 ) '?   6 !!  F0  !& K A ,& *& F /  $ 4  & /,K\   J !1 > ?/ + O1 "<&K)1" )/ h && F   '<K  ^ O< J =F 0  0 O? O' G 3" /,K  ' 28 ,   5) J    O)?  /@ # $> O 4 7  1 7 & '! /,K\  A9?@ . J   & /< + %& ! K '& 6K 1 K- "#    6 ' O% '& ' % \ & & ("") ;)J !  (" )") )+ K <&   ()+ K !   K" l J " ) & <" 211


E&  ;)^ "" !  \& < -O K + K) 8 O %0 " '& =" + )&@) " ) & K '"Z 1 G  & '! K '& 6K 1 .&T  O O'B (" ) & <" '&@ O56  )+ (/ &) +< 1  . &6  + 3" "" !  '& ,6 6K  3K % LE & ... !)& V + (De jure) ))+ !  " )" !  (De facto) <, ! K O? ?/ 4  '!  ')< 'K" 1& 0 '!  # O1 & \& "" ;)J !  &J >  !  " ) & <" +& 0 ) )< ." 4   ))+ O   ? .O &/ '  5K6 L '!K : 1  4 '  K =@  K Q!& " ) & <" < = Q O %)  '!  51  .,& 1 <)  ? ?/ + â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <  I &  â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  D  ()&@ %0 1/@ ' 0< K!" 4 , D,)  (K)B (... J     '< :  6 . &! %1 ' m'  9)& â&#x20AC;&#x201C;1 + 9 ! ,T!& 2004 && / " K <&K)1" )/ h<& â&#x20AC;&#x201C;2 ' J ' & )  ) - 1225 / Nilesat  )  .(& %K h& '  <& .&%1\  '  )/ #) SMS : 2  & <"    )+ O '&  & /,K  +& 4? !  +& +& ATCE O = d &% 6F "# O'B " ) .6& O 8 H)\  1 (% &  @ O K 8)  212


: 3       "   "      $% &' ( )   *  +#% ,$- .      !#  &/.  & $    0 1 !  0     )%  ." 9) 75 "   " , 23  &03  4  %5 $6%!  = > <  6  0 2011 ;  23 * &   %!  ("$/ ",/@"  ,? 0 @  0 AB ;$6 >$ !  # >$ & $ C    >$ D@/ $$ /E A /C 4 D 0(  %! . ! , 6!5 2 D2 +! F. $6 0.! $? .G : 4  " ' " I   !2 &' 3 ,@   ; ! 0/# "   !% @ " ! .# (" @." "@   "   @ ) .!! " % " : " "  :  

.2009  23 . 2 E /  $ ,  # . 01 C "+2 + K ,"  22/C 01$  Quinta Communications & /    M    L,1 %50 

 1@  Mediaset 1C " %    "    I $ . 0 ;  "1 ;$"  ( ."+!0 @." 2  *(  G/$1   2 # -

213


ATCE * * '5 -  -. /0 : /  C F 95 $ " "  % (ATCE) %   

" " 3 5  

4 < ,   I  ! 6 (1 $ %  &  ' *# (1  : ! J "! " 7

.     5  " + , -* .   K 2!  ! 0 +12!  !* (2 4 ! 5  I  ! 6 (2 $ " 712! 8 9: "4 ! 56! " "* " L * " !  > . :;

 "'    ! 56 "   >)  <  =   *> (3 . *!6  .(CNSS)  *!6  ( 

 ! ?  %  @; (4 A B8 ' %  * 0 $ ! &   + ' ." " -* 4 <  5 ! '"  (5   >  ' C " A#   "  0= "  ?"  ! D*; : "  *1

!"" A 5 !   @  !?)  ' < - ! @ " 

  -* 1991    D*E   $F  & !  1997 $!6   ; 7' ?  )   4 0 5,D  .(2003 ! - > GB" G ? -*  ' * (6 Star Academy »  1 H  $ ! 100 4 -* % @ « Maghreb ? : 5 =  :   

214


(ATCE) %   

" " 3 5   7 4 < 5 ! @ 1 ! % @

@A 4 -* $2!   @  12! =M 5=    N

    225 N -*   !

.( : 5 / . 1.1)  :  , O -*  ' 0 !! (7 !; 0"  5,M G1*>  "$ " , (    . 2) 5   3 P!= < G1*>   ' *   2QR! 6  <B"  ' = !* $ " 0"=   ! 6 0  B  B F 2Q " J  !   ?! .,= 

: $    8# (2 ÂŤ MosaĂŻque Âť  8. : $& " & ' )" ,1 #  2003 &) 7  & )\ (1 !1 O O  -/ K)&  , (O1 ( & - L 8" .+&  F ' &) "&  '1&" & D   L3 (2 . "J   ! & & P g  Kh& 6 ' )! (3 .O ' .+&  6  "@   6 &1  ,!  $O 4 /,K 9?@ ,L   "J K-  % (4 . "J ! 51 40 215


"A"  8. :   )  ' & $<O% $"- ;1& ' )" #  .-!& %  "J  &K  "@  : "7 *a 2 "  8. :   6 O1" & D    & ) (O% ."  "@

(1

.2007 && 13  & )\ "8  " "'  !" <% =@  &/  @ .) (2 &/ 'OL 8" +& )  "J .)+    J ?1 .) 'P  0 / OC&  1"  "J DOP O '& /,K\ 4/ ,  3)# D (3 ."8  6 "FM +""  8. : '  10  <K/   /,K =?+& 1@ = + .O (1

.2010 && 27  & & 2010 .

@ D% D # " '& ' " & D  )&@ (2 .(Tunisia Broadcasting) )+  & !  : "Express FM"  8. :   &! 21  & & 8/  'C  6  "@ # (1 .2010 56 & "b/ 1" ! '&@ "b/  " ! (2 .& D 

216


:   4 </ ./,   1   "J 0, .)+ 4% (1 a & h& ;)@ ' <) & g % & <& O1  O .   O6 ,& ) , 0,K  "J 56 K G (2 1" $" '& ' " $" ) & <") () '& + & D  

= ( 1 3" (... "8 1" $"b/  " $"8  6 . & <  J  '? Q! &/ 

& % I  J E/  1  &GO  '!   (3 # &+ I& & 4KK 0 ' '& + '! .)!  +& O6 O% .+)  . ! ' <& O ) < 8O  ?  %  ; 6  ) 4+  . 1 (!1 & D  4  &GO  =@ ?J& "# $ &<K 8O   1 <? O6 < + ' ) 90% +<) &)& 6 " '&" D   .D)  .< 4%   G (3 : (  W ) "W " : $& &/ ' ? . + ) HK)  1, ( % C& U t O V F 3# ' 'K!T (6 ") '&  ")  % ,1 .) ./ 6  1\ <& K K : (! 22' ) "V " :   ) 1 &!) HK) ' 6 8   &+ "h1" ,1  OF O56 .1& (. &F 4%& ) + < J ' .V F OD '6K O1 ? < 0  217


: (22 M $) *# :   4 O  8O  ',6  O  "h1"  % 8% D) . J  < : (; 7 &)  5 : '  ,1 '? 1 = 4  8 1K  a)   &) ' & # . J  6  &G '! 8" ." '"Z & ' h1& "8  6" 3 = .1&) U $ :   : ( (&+   < /,K =?+& ',1   2008 ) .  X 4 =)  # (Convention de pige) + 1& 5 6 = <+& (/+1 &C& 4KK ' ,1  1 &! 1 !  /,K  (... CNSS â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 8  K ) . +  6 ' V F 3#  O %  . 6) X .. + A"# )OL O# ' "D& '# &" &< HK) = 4 : (  * G )   & :  % %   . +& -1 ' # G  G = . 6) . , ? < : (/   ) F5" : ' . + # ; 6& ? < A%   . + )& .1

 = < ?  G = (< ' ")?  " 'UU<W 218


')< ',1 9?B& " "   = # )& '"J   J (.. ) '&  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; F ',) : (G  * $ )  E  Tunis Hebdo :    6 '  >O HK) '! $P O% .&! '@ 1 ( ) K)  1 4 O $) < J 4)& ?K "<&K" 1 -, =@ (  (  ' @ =@ D J 1 =@ ' 0 D  = O% -<    1  3" ' O& / !!   ' 8 +   + 8 ) <&  6 :  A L  &O DO  4K\ KT! (K) 'O& $.K,  6 ' HK) 1 &%@ + = &)%F .K %  -1O   J   #1C& ) ; 6& ? < +) & +  D   (K)B (... ; 6& 9?+  (  ; 6& b, 1 ()! '  J ' )< ) -1O >1@ = (+) + K)&& '"J 4+ +K< # G  ! ! O +) 4+ (K) !  =@ J =@ 3"! J ' )K -1O =@ &)%F -1 ' '? <& . !, ! ')+ I?  6  #  :   = T) " Tunisie/ Terrorisme et opportunisme" ()) + =@ 22 ' O "La Gazette du Maroc" ,1 ' 503 <   -/ 6 ' K"1 ? < & + & VO < 2007 ,)% 25

"F "/0  -)" !O 1  @ ) '? < V<& -)< '    6 ' ("'  '& " ,1 "8 K) ? " 219


% & &O D   / $,O . % V<& &\/ ' a) "Le Quotidien"  " ,1& A  =@ @ ' A ) + 4/  G = .) )  4/ V<&& "Le Temps" g&"  1 )K 6O 0 '  g +L = 9)& 3" "-!&" ."/ ;1&  " &O : M 2E 0  (4 1 '! ' '!L '! $  + 8 1 G  .)) EO)  6 & 01F < P  O%  )!@ 01F - 6 =  & !1 01  % %)  )  (# >  J 1 &!)  .)!J /< ' "Le Renouveau"  " 1" 3" G  8 & O   ( -1 4%& ) +  @ .6 / $< 1 AL T) & (&   1 >1 '!<  % < G 6K) ) .6K 1, .1 ' % .(0%)@ ' h1 HK) :   )   .&6)  OF .<  @  $2007 ) 1, 56 =@ ,1O .< $<O%K 1O 9 J $2009 '<% " ',1   % ' ',K+ 6K) .# )  6 ' ')) '1  '?   .6 '1& 9& .&K ) h1F .?+L& K< 6 &!  % I  . 6 & - <K +& !1 "4%" 01 L < g%) < )  .O% 4  ,K & D   ?1 .(% & "4O%" .O%  220


&1 X &+ " : & %K A"#   W 6)\ ' '& ') %) 1 X G0 V X ) '1 1 X  ,6 X D <& ' g  X %1 O1 X ' - X  '&  X & ' 0 X  ") X ) ' 0 X & -P  & X A%& 8 % % X /  ) X 8& 1 X & 00< & X 8 < X 8 "1 1 X ) '&  X % ,<% X  &1 X V X 8 / + P X D  1 X 1 %) X ) ) % X  + %& X 1 '& 81 X +& '& ' ) X < '& 1 X + 1 X   % X 1 0  & X ! X b< -P 1 X & <&  X  # & X !  X '

1 X  =1 X 1& < X  ! ' X '&< '0 1 8 !& ' 9& X  ! X )) ? X & &  X 8 % X ) 1 &&1 X   X b  &1 X 800 & '1 X %) X   6 X % #% X G0 1 X ) )# !&& X 8 + I 1 X 9? '& 1 X & - X 8& + & X )1  < X '1 =, X D  1 X ;6 & X & , X  / '6 &) X 8< '0 & X ) ;1& !&& X 8< 80 X  & D6 X  1 X 5 g, 0 1 X E/   X ! & %) X 8% 0  1 X  X , 1 X 8<  X 1 ;  X    X / X / ;1   & X   8% X D&& ? X 1 '& #0 .(8% H1 X '1 1 X D& '# & O'B K) D%  K ? < 01 56  O 01F 1 O   ' O / G 1& =H1 .)! ,1 >& ' +  O !) < J ' 3"! O / G 51& 221


> = !1  !J =+& $ J H) )? . K) 6& =+&   J& ,! O & '! 8" )?  ) .("L!W 1 Lp6" # !1 01 4 h  9  %) ( 5K6 )  K ? < -1L ' H1T   J  .9 J % .)! K)B " '&" DO    01 &% 3" ') % 6  D) 6  , ? < 8K O+K ?6 01 '!   ' + ! 1 &< 1 )  %  &  J    81  +O 1K  . 6  %) 0 &@"  6 ' ; 6  ? < = O  / 2009 .(" & O  +  .)O K " '&" DO   = ITT   "&K" )6  -1O A"# G . 6) ! .  3" = F "8 &)"  J& ( :   #  K! O " 1"  % -) <& 2003 &&   K) ' " '&" D  =@ O% !   "1& O1" .O 1    O  DO  . 6 %  </ ' " O  '  '!  (&01 ,1 O' !" "')J +1 )  + ]) ' O  ( && " '&" D  A K  " 8" D  A + ()) ' (   O&< " O) 9 } O<& LI K! ,1O 7   ? +T) &<L 1& K% = O !" DO  . 6 %   ,&  6)   1K F 01 6 ." ?1 D  +& c0< d 6" (K) O  6  "1& O1" !" ( !C 4 #  '! A% DO ! K (6  " '&" 222


( L )T K u& ' 4%  " '&"    + ' "D  . 6 %  ^ O AK)% ' A &< 4  K ' '!L   J O >1 1 P =@ x1L  # ' #    9%  QH  &<K 1 01  % # K w!! (B& +K) 01 

 ! b< ? < -1 G O' H1T > 6 % ' .+?   < 9 G a K -<? 4% DF& 8 && = / G O@ <%  # $< J  !1  O = ?J TK+1T K)  ("'" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "&+" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "") #  H) .' J ;)   ',1O  > = "')" "-/"  -1L .H1 > 6 % '  O +  < J ' ' 1 .+?K G    .8 :  ,5   HK) &/ ' 1 =@ PDP 1 ' "-/" ,1 .?O < . &<K  1 ' +& +  1 .<O&  1 K # & & 1& 2007 &&  . K O O' H1T + .K, 1 80!  AO + ' (% 6@ 1 4 % PDP .O +  ))/ + ' (<) (%  O< .9?, Q!  G@ . 1 )% =@ .<  '1, '9? ( % 01 I& ' <& 3" (9+    O  +  % ' ?) ) 4% "  %  "&K %) 1" &% O $F < I? ' g, E%  ?@  6O = 01 < )F "& % 01 )6   ' 4% K = 1 O = O? <K .~& (/ 223


-1O 4& 3! 1 #  =@ .O .  "# & (2007 &&) "-/"  % ' 419 < 4& ' ,6

 (1 && 3" $.<% ! EO0 =@ < E% B& .'p& ? > =@  )? \   $.KH) 1 ' O .(  "<K" ,1) .)!J K G ,1 < : $ A  = O  J )F < '& !K 6K H1 L 4% @ ATCE O' 3" ' $!1 01 ( K!1  ])  +&   ,&  J  <%  ) 'Y O< J =K1  J )F 6K   ) L<T  & O< 1 1 .DF&  , ? < O? ?+ (1 .< 4% &/)  +K A"# 4%  0! K 4+ : =

.!1 01 ) > &! .&) <O%K .<  <%

)F

? <

)

&/ 

 -

?+ <% ) = 6 0! K) &  & K /+1 ',1 &+) ')J +1 ' EO ) &  '1 1K (... <K % ) =  & 1K  < 1 

224


 :‫א  א‬   ‫א אאמ‬  2011 14   !! ‫"א!! א‬#  : 2011 /9  14 %  5 0 $ $ '  $5 : $& ,1  O' .K,  6 ' 'O& / 6  9 /   "@  1 (& & % .)) 6 1 =@ .)<&O  6 b

,)% 14  1 =@ .)<K O  ,1O & () +L .O g,)  & % V%@ 1989 ) .&6) <& & O h1 $2011 4/ $ J K O '& 3"): O E O %)  J - H @  !1& 3K && "?K)" ! 1 ' -6 && 4? / <   1)  1 . !& K &  /\ +K< !  ' 4% K (... '  4? / 0%  ,1 ! 4%& ? < .\  . 1 O' .O 1&

% ,F & .)<K 6  #H A"# ./, $O%

?< ') .1 # J O? O  1& - <L  H 4 = ?K 0 O '! 8" # J + O % ATCE % . H $9O O1 = ,1 < =  ? <

% 6 'PK 0 6O 0  %  & O O .! 1 Q  +O 8 O 4%K K  0 (. ,O)  'O<  9 1 6 a &   "9 K" ',1 & < O   ! D)  & 4? "# '! $#0% .> 6F 225


:  ,5 * & 8 , 14  +<)  <  J 9 0 D% K-  6 ' â&#x20AC;&#x201C;1  )0,K  "J ?, Kh& u& +" @ O' L%) 2008 .)O? / $ < 6O 9 0 D% ' & '! "& < +) #1  +/O G 4) .0J &O? ' )  + A"# < H) â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  %   â&#x20AC;&#x201C; # J :  G = ?,? .1) ) 0O  O / )  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; & < '?K â&#x20AC;&#x201C; < 1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; = ?  K/   + A"# .)! (... I %K& )O O 1 b# 1 = 1 4+  4  J  . &<K 10  #9?@ .K\ D) ' K!C # J K-  6 ' â&#x20AC;&#x201C;2

G # J 1! O % ?< ')+ 2003 & # ^ O K 4 %) ?/  .!1 V<& (% F < #% # $) O     C& () K<  O6 .,1O = / G (< () O6) )  J +& + " V<&  O% . 1 V<& .)! $1O 8  &K 6 0% O &/ ' / Q1  J .OP V<&  ? < -1L 1 ; 6  % !1J "/ 6K " ?K 1 .<\ K ? <  / 4 IK  ) D)  4) !1J "))+" ?K 51 40 <% â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  %0 !1 ' 1O K%  9%  &  ./,\   , ,1%   4? â&#x20AC;&#x201C; O & < J &% .9 , ./ &? â&#x20AC;&#x201C; . "J .?,   (.... "J .?, =

. "J .?, V<& H -1O ') O< G  0%   J  G (& .O% 8" 6  ) O'B $O6 226


HK) E)6& ,! 1 O 4O   O   &K &O ' 6} 8  a) 9/@ =@ < O% + & O81: 8 ) O D)   J KH ' ? < .6K V<& 4)  6 A%K  ,KHL < (O%L / G #&  @ O   J <% < ) h1F& K<  O6 " / +" + & 1   +K K  T 4/ &)% .< '!  & $O ' & ( -6& '! 8"  ^ Kb ! 0 &  !C  H $!1 01 .K6  A O  O   L .9 J E)  K+ .?@ '& 11 6O  J 1&O  '? ." 4?  ?  ), 4?  ') ' < <% O (,1O '? 1 = J) -1O . "J .?, =@ '%K )K  J ' % I  (O% & & & .!<)\ ' 3"   4 $&)%F .K % O # G )% .&+  ." 3  -O K .)/ =@  % O@ '#%K   3" .!<)\ O6 &K 'K+ '  = K -\ g O 4 O1 =@ . ) -O K #H H& â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2003 ) & %& "& " h1) O ' !  & .OP >   #H ,&  (... 2006 ) 6  ' h1 ' )< #H # $) 4% = 6 . )&& ')% &O .!<)\  ' &<T 2011 ,)% 14 <& !1 O & .  &/ Kb#  @ H) : * 5 *0    :   : + O G ] &   # ') '1 <% .)! &+K) DC &/  + (&T ! HK) m !# ' & <% A"# .)! $'1 '\  =@ O% "'0& 80" "I '& 1" p 227


 #U9  K!P )?  .)!  $" '&" DO  ' J ()O?  =@ ?@ $ J  a &  <%  =   &!  <% !  O# 1?, .)L '  +K A"# ) O + O  .&6)  =@ I K &/ &O D  ' 2001 .2004 ) 1 7   "- F" '1 ' < &G  8O< O 1  @  ' K1 L 1 <K ?/ 6 D)&  ) ')K '1 <% Q1 2008 ,)% 12 7 & O $ + 8)< 8 O  .   ')K '1 &+) DC 2008 ,)% 13  &+K) A" 8",) !  6)\ K / $<%

7   1 % <) '1 ' < &K)& O# 6  1 ,1 < 4 O < %  & D)  ,1 ) =  &+K) A"# ) % O%& O = \1 &! h1 & ") .1  # $; 6  ? <  /F 0F % .'1O  & >)  &+K) h<& ! V%@ ) ,F  I& ! "# O'B $&+K) .K,& .)& ' K  1 1  1O L &< 8K" &O HK) &/ '  O% / - H !1@ O   < O ]) ' 0 O   AO? O%  . 1   1\ =@  O % 6 '! =K1  O O & 'PT K u& #  !& &<K 8O  9&@ O 1 .&O DO  T6  K @ L% T  +& :  5  5- $A& (M E+ !# .+)\ &+K) h<& ')K '1O <% Q1&  g ()C '  # $ K% =@ .<% ')/ ' ,1O <,  I ' E K6K = T+ <, % 4& : O# Q< .&K ' % &+K) .& & ") $',1 228


4/ 4 %) G # & & 1 K%  HK)  @ (1 =@ ?@ ' 6F ' <  %)!K . O1K <& ,1 <&  &  )   ',1   &! KL 8" )? ,1 .&% 1  =  h1 &+< & 8 %O0 ",1" H, O'B % '?  1@ 1) (/+1 ' E ' H,   '1  $31 30 ',  K% !  + '    .(.O  7 " O%1L" O  15 "-6" O  17 "'%O"  30 "/<" D = K / < 1 "'<" & <K 9@ (2 . 1 ))+ +<

 /  & K  = F D%    4 (3 .HK) 9  7O T  '<K  / ' ? 6)  :  5 1  $  ' (B "# 91 O .1 &+K) 8",) ! O 6) 1 ") $" ) " / # / )0 /    6 ' ! %) O' K @ $1%)J ) )K K & ,K! 0 .<

K!" = &O DO  ()O ! " &O6" .)! .&6)  ."8 G& %)" / g%)& ( J (@     J   <& 0 .< + %K) A"# G  = &) O '  6 ' 'K! %  4? = < DO  &+K) L   / '! = <  6 ' ! 6 4? ',1 <&  ' 'O! "g&"   ,1O "% '& '," # L

0 &/ '  0<J ) 1) & K  .  + < O &6) P +  &+K) Q1 =@  ? ) 8OP  # K  .) 229


1 =@ F 8",)K !  & ") 0 .< ! ) 0,K P 4& "<  " ,1 < (1 ."8 G& %)" / =@ ) 8 O 4O%K H1 &+K) 8",)K !  & <& HK) 1 6 V GF (,H  + & A ,)\  + + 1O O 1 = 8)  +K 1  $'+& !1 01 . 1 <? O  A  @  %   & O + : " '&" D  = Ug\ T/T $  ? +  ',1 <&   & ))/ ,& &+K) ! Q1 O@  1 '!L ") 0" ,1 # 4&O  &% d'? )  ) C& %1 ) L(L&+\ ")  O1" 3"): 4% < 'F O ))+ (  &+K) ! '+ =@ 8OPL ' ()C '  (,6 .( O '!L % ! 6) ) P  O A)

+K 1 ' 6)   L O % +<  O O@  '? O ' = $% ) P  J % ! ' ! ' ') +& 4O%K 1 ' ' 6) = 0! K 'K .% ) 1 0,  "J P 9&)Y +  D) .)K Q1 " '&" D  6 / "# %)" &+) 8K ,! # !1  O   8K" !  #  1 < /& ' /& <% .)! ' <& "8 G& / <&  9?+ !" 6 &  ? .)! % & .1) ' <& $ ? 0 &+) h<& 4% 4 C ' ') ' < %  L&L h1& # % &+K) -# O# ' O' IO? =@ 1  1 ' O O  h1 O % '   ',1O <O ' '! -# # 8O% !&  1 A"#   - H '? 230


              ! "## *   + $%  !#&   '(   ' ' )    + ,- .   /     .0 ! % 0 . $   '1  2 /33#  .  0  43 $ +/ 67 '0    ' ''/ .& 80 #3   9 3&  (2008 = 3) . : 3  /;# ! "  8-    * @A B( -  "3/ ='/ " 4 9 (2009 = 3)

 '7D *%3 "   "- .0  "=C 3" #3 @A  "A3" *  43 F    ''  " '$,  +"3 E1  =  G3 H  '#! " % " " 3-1 '-"  C  # I% #  " $J ! $J $) 43   % 0  K J +   *  #3 E $ 3 L2 ( #3 3& =3 : /#3 F  83$ FJ%3 $ # B( LA ' / 1 .B1

N A3&    '# $ 43   %0 O  L' ' K J $ E7  E # E $ E03  #3 =J%3 E $  '# =J%3 E $ G2   P 2  #& E 2 "    JF '# L '  '# E $ .1 ' P- 9 ' / #  E- 2  !#& 7$  8  # 2009 8 15  ')  +.0  %$ L 7  '   *! F) 0  .( #3 Q. L  !   .1' 2! *2 C B(   L'' 8$  "  JF 8# ' JF : .B1  #3 E $  .A  '(   . ' .B1  E $ .-! 7  (1 82  /!  #3 /  8%   ' B( .%0   231


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


',1 &+) P 9@  O /" (K) ("H1 " %  !" -? ! ."2009 &! 28 7 & A+ O ' H) ' 8" ')K ' &+ % 3  '" K 1K < 'F '  D,) KH)  - K ) !@ 1 &)%  @  4 '< ."!K "& K  O &+K) = !1 %# K K- 1 0 & )  +K H)\ '! $ "K,) .%  ?6J  +\  '!L (K) O6 $%) 1 O'   } &6 9% 8"  .+ ( & < 6) &+K) ! 3  /  M7 $& d '  /  M7 1  ' 97 ( : ML W6) &+K) ! 1 ) P + <& 2009 .  4 (&%  && "8 G& %)" (O  8" 2008 ,)% 13  % ! K  % K & -K! 0 6 4 U+W $HK)   %B& 3" HK) ' (& + (1 -) O% 6 @  .< (<  &%@ '! <  =K1 O  (+   . P ' &) &+K) !   =@ 0 .< "# :  K () "8 G& %)" ! ' 1 O   #  2009 - 100 A /  e&& ',1 '& 0kK )   (1 . ) . ) - 150 A /  e&& &+K)      (2 <% +&O &+) .0%  ',1 .& V<&   (3 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; .) ) & & â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ?,6) ., <& -# 6 6 +)) ++1 '

(... &+K) )! 4  <, 233


 " '&" D   J  ") 8" O' 

 & !  I &O <  "6 1" = #,  1) V   ! (% '  O ' &+) '!&  % .( K!" O5) = ()O + /0 /# '  ' M E :   KH) %)L & )K  J   ?K "W 6K\    < 8 ! H) . )\  @ .OP )  '? . O 1 1 H / @ < 9?, h ,O0 &6F     &  J ) /O  ?1 ?K O A"# g%) O  : 'p  ( @ .1 < '  % .A )  A  = )  6 ' :  6  (1 "# 4 )  PT  6 ' : D - /0 * ' 6  (2 ./O  .F Q! .!J . 1 <& } A"# " '&" H) O /

0 # OT O6 0% &  J  -,% K+ A& ' !& ' K!L (O6 I O< J) 6O  %  &  J  ' C& '!O 1 '" ',1  %  & O  ' (ATCE 3 1& % & T"K,)T ) .(6O 0 3 1& % & T"K,)T ) 1 !K" & = 6 $) -1O . K /

O " " " % &6" "I O" "' J" "h1"  % -0 (K '& g   ' (O+T &  J ?K ' O  # $& J g?, 01)\  <K . +1 ") + HK) 4  -1O 6 = .%  / 6 .)+ 234


+O -)< % 4& .%)\ h1 $O =@ " '&"  )<  .  V<& 8 @   &+L K- / 6F .-1O A"# 1F : I"5 M & (& ) % & <    .&6)   1991 ) ")L . 1 ATCE ./ 'O 6 O? (K #H .0 & 1994 #F .9 / + ) ( 6 O? O%  J "O W ! '1F V<&  <K U9  ' )6!  6 ' # O ,& . 1 A"# . ...  J   9 L  'O  5K) ' -!K 4 $ K &/  1 =@ E+)\ '    ? < 3O 1 0 / )  /@ #H Q! 4 K .; 6 : & O ! &,L ".!"  F 1991 ) ' J ,1 a  X . 1 ?  - 4 )% "! '? < V<& =@  / # -1O V<&& K &! ' )   X '? < O  -1 V<& .,  " G) &" &! 00< & " ,1 "+ F "& O56 / $< ' OD ( @ 4 3"  "' J"  %  1  '! ") "8 % ' 6} ',1O V<& () =K+ / $"DK) Q!" "h1"  % )#@ =@  -  1/  +  O (%< ' . &

.K" 4& <& K )6& '? < ' '/+1 "# O'B 9?+ =@  K . 1 1? V<& 9% G  , $= )1 K &!  %L ( +\  !1& '! 0% 235


 . + 8 O 1 ',1O '! / 6  ) E0 8F  G .9  +< ' K . J HK) 6& V_ < .9?@ G K . + ' / G  5O1,& H1 . + A"# O' O +L & V Y ! 1 %K 5K) K! A"& '< V<& -KT!  K) 0#% /  O@ -1O . .K)& ' #  1& -1O D) 6 ) 4% .!O 1 = O (K )    >1@ = K6 '  ,1 I  = < O !  ; 6&  ..) )F .1, = T) '!   + = &+<  .?, : " 4 *  9-L : & (  )  

   



. / "  -" %& -!,*  01 ! . *2 3 34   562* - !" 7   !* /' ! . 7  $* %,* !/ 86/** 7 ' !,9 3 !:; 3 < 86 /* 7 ! + %& 6 = %,* ! ,> ." !*? 0

" !"     "'" # $  %&

!* +** * (,*

 

01 A 6  %: G   A 9 5#  5 ,* .  "H  * ." 6

5 ,* A  & / *'* * )   *   A   (? :B + * C A  D/ # .  B E: * !* F   B*7 . F   236

(2005   5)

 , (2005  26)


(  )  

   



%&  , I: .  B*7 4B =  .2004  /* = -;&" :    L K  A :C = 6  F : # - /,  %& J # :  1 34B G 6; G N B  ,O  6& "...  6 5O ,* E#" - ! *   LB  Q" = / " *  ! ... *   ... R A< D6/* 3 "J , +B"   "  5# "  *'6   +F = * $ A* ' ' 9  A,< 0! . 

J #, :  A :C

 

. :,* A - /,  =& #  9

  28) (2005

"J , +6B" . '6*  

P (2007  5)

1& # ) O ; 6& ? < O?  . + '  ) 0%  .< 4% < + &)&) &! G <& 3" ( &) ' 4& 18 > !K" &)& D)& +<) :  J 1  &/ ' <%   T) "F '," A?) " K 6 # /)" : +



<& D  'O / $(12 5 2005 &! 27  " " ,1& ."'1" H1  + = (  " K D! -"%" : + 237




" '& 3!" : +



" +#  " : +



 O 1997 .  '&)  "G-5  7"   :   = .1  @ O% KH)  @ . 1  6 ' 2001 &) D)  . 1 ')J +1 <?  +) -1 6F "# & = K!" V O h1 "" Z& "& "   - > (  ( "-K !" O? 3O 1 K6   &O DO  : 1  O# '& ' < 8O  )< &? #, "'\&)"   ' , .<   X ; 6 <& (  4 "& " < 1  (%0 &/ ' F& ./ & (!  '  "' J" "h1"  %   = &6 "# ) g / X ()) E? 1 ) +  @ 4  J O 4 ' ."%O  .&  )" = 1 ' )F .1 'K! =@ -1O  J X = ( A ! "-K !" =@ " ) 1" V < ' (O% D!  " 4 +  9+ =@ ( A  "'?)"   (! 1 .'  4% &K!  & 3" 00< 4 $")  <T 5) )!  . +  A&)  .,  O01" X "'/1" X "" 4&" :  G = 1 %<L ' . &

X "/0 L" X " " X "&" X "'," X ")6" X ",)  . 1" X " "/ O" X "   ?&" X "'+) .1" X "# 4&" X "'& O0" X "-% F "!F a " X "! 'F" X ".9 " X ",6 -#F" X "&6 .G" X "#& &<K" ... "'!!O" X ".)1" X "&6 )F" X "KH 1" X ")&% 238


(& 8" K6 4&K  .)/ - .)! ) . 1 D,)

)/    " 0%" ") 1" .)/  G = O ."K+"  - ;  F  G2 M & (M  6  "&L !! 5) G ',1 9 P# T- 1 -0K "! ' EO K   ,1O ) ./ 6F I? O# )O<L .% I < &! O' & & + . ' & >C) ?/ )1  ' K 'K ATCE 6O 0 .<& : & -4& F   B

B



'0 = ) # . / # * B (  -'   '  / '  : â&#x20AC;&#x201C; .   /S ) J * -& â&#x20AC;&#x201C; =  /    4BC . 

6"   5 C <C   F! .& " 6& -  - & A :C %C =   '  2005 +  9 A : = ' 3-'  .'   

 

A 9

/*

-

 ,    /S =9 . 6  $ .O*  : / # .= *

<' A0 ' : = /   : " "   %& 1 O R  = 1 O*  C  !! D9 .* .1 O,*  %&

 $6* %C  &6 <C

 *S 2005 +  4 -   : "=  "  & %&  /  =  < ? /* * .  / $*  = ? *&7 -6 * 3+ * D/ %& =9 . 6  .# / T  =  239

+  10) (2005

    29) (2005   (2005 +  6)


/# '5 M & (B  @ J   O# &6   -1O O<  6 ' . &6 > =@ =/  # h1C! @ J : & 0 ')J +1 ' EO )K &O  0 4 <K  I,& gO ()C '  # .<K ' !& D) & < 1K  .O%  .< + &)%  @  % %) V1 +)&  %  %%1  ! 1    h1F ++1 D& 4? =@ J& 9,!  .!1 ' #   '" & '  '  0< # )! =@ J .)! ! 1 O' '1  $ . &)% > 6 &+) -  ! 1   K+1& & '" '& ' . % '  + ..9  &1 .& # G  = O%1 ?  3!\& D   K (<0 O 8O  ) <&  =? G + .&! (2002 '% 25)   K 1O?& ."O&T/ O&1 ' ')& "!# $ J  1" ())

2005 D  O G  "& O1" /+1 1 +  <& 

&< 4 $) '% 4/ 1 .) )F = A ) + && 4 !1  L1 '   '1 ) ' ') ?+ <%  6 ' &6 .K) (2005 D  2)    V   '& @ &<K ? 1   D)& &  !1 ?/ O' =@ J . !" '& @  <% 8",)K ! EO  , '

  .&6)  I  "/0  -)" !O ' @ )  +  D) ! '  (&O  ' 1@ &6 ), O $1994 ) .CK D% = 9&)Y 240


  .&6)  &/ @ =@   % . 1 O< @  & & , #KH A"#   % O1 1 2004 ) '&K .!1 O< #KH 1, G   %  E?F 8  0!   O< ) -1 &/ ' #H - O + '/ 1  G 1 + . ) (1994 &! 9)    ++1 && =

' 6 75 `+T .)! /  ),O": ()) '& '  + ), ."&  70 )&  O1" ' Q! O  Côte dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;AzurS ' .6 /  @  '   "! ) O <  "& K 0<" "&  O !  O' ( 9% ("!K 4%  L !) ?/  H)F ' ,6 <& 8 9)& ( B& / '&)% &/ ' LAL ?1@ 8F O  8 % ' ()!&  +& 8" !  = O   "# ) O $9)& (B& K,! '" '6K 3"  '& ( 56 $) , « Le Figaro »  %&    = O  $(%" = "!K & .<T)  O5)  9%  = &O D  + <& 3" .?+  ,  "'1& " )K 6) &6 = <K   O< h1 O# G 2007     6 ')J +1  .)  J  4%  3" J : ;    # M & ( 6 56F   7,K) 4/ 6?  3" =K%

  KH) QP  @ 6) (%0 O & LDO  $1 1" "&  '1&" A  (<% ) &)& & < ! h1 $6?K "# ' ', D = 'O< "8  6 .& e <& ?,K .1 J . + 1 241


: & : 1   &6)  1  *$ G  = L<& 'J '! / .& J    e& 2004 ) & DO  = /

A* '



-  ... = $  ,* "

 9 = 

 

"N    ,  . # $*

(2004  *' 3)

(N  $  %C  C) ?  "V & = .6 # 0 "

E # =  

"& =" +F W* W

 # (2004  *' 4)

- W& W, %,#    W ,Q' " : A* '   P -  (L) /  6  8* '   & ,' E*X " ? ,  -*Q 10S : Y2 =4Z :  C ) /  F /  /,** =0 .(1987   7 = [  & : & = + *"

J 4' 

"5 = =9   = / ="

 # (2004  *' 19)

  /

-'  &, +6[

  (2004  *' 22)

."& =

242


: 2   1 " "  %& 2005 ,)% 28  "+ -P  & " ! 1 L% $& '!  < 8   = O&! " :   " '&" K @ (/ Y $m9) 1 )@  , +)&   &< O (K) < )

'  < 9 O0 ' 1 # $E K   K @ (   <& "... ./ !   ! < 8" : 2  M & (QA  3" '! h1F   01)  =@ ',1  UUU

 G = )  %   - F  O<  .&) " '&" D  01)  K! &)& O ' $< K O  .&6)  .4/ ++1  AO O : & : 1    7 1 O

-4& 

RCDH   # %& 6 * .* W*# =  ' & L#B* %C 8!;) "\4 &  \C" = & .(  +F

(1999 * 3) E# "  E #" :   A* '

=" ]  F &  . : = & .* 2004   B*7 "& ."B + *"

=4&

 = 6    5# $ .Q * "_ & A 1  &" = . /* 4&C $* '     '

  F .  B*4 "& =" E* . *6 /* -,*  2004

5#  ^'

243


: 2   ) O  <  .&6)   J K   1 : (,  "J a & â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ) -1O) 2004 %96 .&   .&6)   &) :     .<  .&6)   + %4 &+ .&   .&6)   &) :       .<  .&6)   + %11 &+ %89 !1 -1O  T!  % ' %78 &)& H1 RCD  .O6 -1  %69  . H '1  %98.3 &)&  % .  D    .%1.7 &)& (%& ) )1 O1 1& 1)   () : 

1  J  -    ' K  ) H1 L  & 0O  ?+ O# ' L &<T  J ?K C O' )\ ? h1 $2011 ,)% 14  &/ D)  AO  J = K &/O   J + 4  J E+ O #KH A"#

O 1 1  0 &  ") O '+ ',1 -1 .) -  / 6F &? )  +& 0L K+ :  O6 L 6 K .#   G  4/ / (1 9,!   < 9F =   + 1 K,6 (2 LK)%L O $ ? G . + )  J ' =F - 1F !"& .9 &1 244


O ? <&  &<K 8O   1 9G .1 K (3 .')J +1 9) . : <% O 01)   & =@  J  1 (4 .'#"F & C .  *8 M 57  *9 $A& /0    % / 0 : "5  ,      7 G 

245

 !&&



8 ! ' %



& ' )



8 % 00< &



%1 I



#& 1



 =,



8 %< 



1  1 &



+ -P  &



 % &



F ',



8 !< ' %)



D& '# &



) '& 




J c# : *#  *0  Z' 1  ' /0 -$ M & : /# ' /0 " 5 J  " & = O ')+ .< K < O < =@ ?@ 9 GJ  3"! .< + ' J =   J  . C K! ' J 4 ,6L )C& " K) 91 "  .+)  8, HK) : 3" '  $'  !) !1 (&  !1 )  '<K (1 (... N & # & $)?  $%1 I)  I) (V  4/ $+) < .& (2 (... D& '# & $8 % 00< &

.'O1 ' @ '1 .< I) (3 .'P &! 4 . % .9+ ?1  O (4 'CK H) @ ; 6 ; < ) .9} ' .9, J (5 .1O . /F  9)&Y  O I) ' V<& '! (6 : 3"  .K .O  %F K)  .5 , P!   0K  ?+

)F

!

-6&

.+?

.O?  .<%

.(1O K%)  J 4 K 

246


 : ‫א  א‬  "‫  א‬# ‫א‬$% ‫א‬ $1O K% ' + 6K) '  ! ') ',1 =)

.) < '% O1 =@ . )<   . K) B& +K< .9 %J '  ! ) !  K -O && 1O K% .)! $O6 . "J .0,K  .1&C 8O% >1 8 ' (G   J  3) O .()% 6 # K6 " '&" H) &    O %  J #&  6O 0  4?6 % . J .)!  & .,K) 8  "" 4 = 0 / & & $K) F $ & ./& $ $.K%L $  .O ) $!)  G  G (... . % $.K % $.+K< 'O<  ) 8 @  56 K (K)B 1O ')/ 1 "# :  O6 K $E+ KH)T  / .9 %J ' % E&K &%L 4?6 8K" 6 0 (KT 8K" ))+  (1 .# G ' ^ &K)& 0%< .9 %J -&  & .,K) Q! (@ 4?6 8K" ))+ EJ (2 1 E+ H) /  EJ "# I&L $+& )? &/  <& 6O 0 "@ $O < (O%K 6 J <?  &O? '  &6 81 / O ) 8 0%1 1  ^ < O \  ( % !) < 0 =K < HK) , !< )C "K" J ' P O? < > O 3 1  1 

0 6O 0)   - F A"# .0% 9?+ = (1@ 247


=K1 L  = L4K ' O '! ( % !  J& ,! ./  & ,6   0K  9 %J "6K\ ' 'K! $9 ' ' (<) 9 '  J  6O 0 KT G Q! O' h1 $O A"# & +& 6 #  "# O'B K& ) ; 6 & G ,   < =+&  %  K% @  T\  1O K% ' 13 , O' 6 $ F A& ' =? & K @ ' 0@ .)& = 6O 0 =@ O+  J L 5)K = -K/ %K "# $8 %K %O  %K   '! )& + + 6O 0 (O+T 8" & " )&"Z& H  & =+&) 8 %K O  '& V!O   & )# ' $ J .(& ") 4)  / "6F 6O 0  <   .O ) @  '&GO  0%<K  K ' (K) ! $) O (/+1& <KL  K)  '! ' 13   % +1 A"# ' ' 1 ' ',+ ' &!   O' 1 ')/  1 ')/ =?+& #O? )J& ?/ !1  %) ..<%  OP  )% '!& U'\" ' &O DO  & $"# A%K  1O K% IK+) ')/ E  O5) G #  % ( )C& K) -1O @ &)& L! T /  <F '   %  J A  .O? "9? '& 00< & " 56 A  Q ) "-  ' g "  %   < ! "(K & # & " " ,H #0" '+& 9 0 ")?  " ATCE   .O< / (" HK) & 1" 8 O D% D  "'&< " .O 1 '  '? 8K" O g    K% O' )%K <  K TH)K &<K 8O   1! $O< )  , $F â&#x20AC;&#x201C; )% %) < 0% ')+ u& 1? / 6 !1 ' 248


 " HK) & 1" ?1 '! / ( O X0% .9 %J K%  .O    O . !J ! & & + '%K A"#  C =@ 1L  # $+& 8 O D% +& 1O ')/  O .K) ' .&O <  D% "# .  /  + D% ! && #   O K 1O ')/  + ))+ : !" '! 8 O :  '    " & F (1 Q! - <& L\0L 8K" ')+ (?+ !  % O - < 

$C6 (TC 4+ / 1 VG  D&T Q! 4 ()C ' , <  %

1  6F = 9 \  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; < HK)  : 1? G  % ' -O K  8 )< 0 = / ! ) â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  & ')/  6 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ! #, A"# C O O < % 3  O ... )O O&< / < HK) &  &<L  $ & =  (K) '1  $9 ... < 8O  )@  &  % / ./  ()

: D 0$ F /, 5  !& F (2 '!L .<O& 1   (K) = K% ' 37 , O5) O 8 - H  - F 4% E <& F  H) K !1 &/ #  / '! $  K O 4O&K E?  O -+@ O +T '

 + 1 ",)K -/ -)  O' G $/ ",)K -)  .))+   1 /0 895     * 5 F9  (3  \  b- ' / E  ' $*& c L  4

. '   

.  Mc& /0 /E  9  35" * 3 87 9  (4 :    % (5 249


 ,K @& = 0!  8 % !1 < 1959 



6O 0 K% 1)  .1 O  '<K )  $O '&  ) 8",) #  >O< J A"# O' H1 L ",)  # J ') # > / T   $?/ !  '1 .  +  '<K 9 P# -  ' ?/ &/  =) ' -L1O ! G  /  '<K O -! ""  V = K) .1  =K1 , .1 O A"# $))/  ,& < G   -& '%  =  ?+K O  ?+ O .!1 )  EO  K1! .)? <  4?& & \ > 1  % 1 O'B " .E?  ?+ O %@ 8 )< '  1  && <&)  / @ K% ' 25 , =?+& ()!L 6 0   O &)%F .,KP ' %  6@  ) ( J 0 8 "6 .<K =  !,  ' E) # $ O G      0% , '  = 81 K%  <   G = )  O .#< g 4 V <  %  /  +1& 56 O  ')J +1 1  1 L V   D)  ./  (... + 9 } !F % ' !1 O%1 +1K  +& &/O  ./ )& .&+<&  ) +1  .+< &L    O .#<  A"# O' < 4 <& + O ' 32 , ) 1 ')+ = ?, .< K #<L& ))J : Z O !L 9% + 1 ')/ O'B " $ &6F .<   1 / @ (1 250


$ J  -6 '& 5 , P! / @ (2 .-K, 8O< $(0) $O 1  @  ' 1 / @ (3 'O? % ')/ =@ '<K "9 " ',1 <%  # 8 % ' ,1O 9 4)  O  1 + .1 @ ./ 6 )  /    -K! 0 6O 0 9&@ <& (K)B .K, 1 (K) < 4 ' 1 K)B $ ) O8 @  56 K 56&    J&  &/ '  8O  9&J  %  =@ ! .K, '<  'p"K $!  )% @  DO  ))+   J .A  8"  + "6K\  % D =@ F 0 < CK 1 1 K% ' 13 , O' & "# O' ! $ 1F  9 @ ' L)K .1  6O ' K  ' '!L  =@ T    O1 %: \<L  , $O '&     =+& ' '!L D  A"# =  $( 

.'CK "#  +L L 6O 0 .1& K& : 1    V<&  % 1 1  & =

 .?    . ) J '1 ',+ & O+ 

  @ K, ! G K) <  >  ' ' . "@ : )< I&

251


       

 

  

  

 

   



    

"'("  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; # ! $ % 

! "

7 

  )

"*" 

*+ *

"$ " 

,  

"Femmes" 

 + - ."

"FM (+" 

/01      2

" 4"  " 4" *

- - 3!



*4 

"1  " "

# *  %

: 2  

 %&  + D    1 D ")  1" + "Le Journal" â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "  %") ' & J & !1 "La Presse"  (  & ()! G ' O& 56 ))+  (1) O  (& =@  V & 4%  $"D  .O% 8OP" ' (?

'& # '& / O1" = L '%O& ( !1 8?) 4 9F  .()% ) 20Z& ( !1) "&<% O1 : 3   O1" &/ ' .<L 2008 '% 17  6O P K!" 1 "# !" " '&" D    J  (,& ")  252


" '   @ 1 )K 6O 0 = .  (K) 6F ) , & < 'K&    ) @  A?+& LG  "'  '& '+& ' @ ' J .! <& h  @ # $"!" \ 1 .2004 1999 ) F& )< & .O+  K) D,) J    / 4 '0  J O' ")  O1"  H1  "# ' J  G = 3" 2009 ) <    .&6)  ! 2004 1999 ) &) D,)  +&  @ '0 '" '+& .\  # 6  ) '  F V<&  F& )< O' H1 + " $ O 1 1   4) ()! ) )K HK) O1 .+) (O%  K)  56 K = +  &  % D = g / G) ))+  K m- G A & &  J ' .!O & '& " '!  K& ( F& )< 8 %K %O ' '?  =1  K) @ )!L ()& 8"  J  ' "'  ))+ )O = 1  & &) 9?+ K!K =@ %  .(6O 0 =@  J l& ,L 8" ,1 O'  $A  g +L = & D   "# ."!"  ) @ 56  = 1 !"

253


 :‫א  א‬  "!'%‫א‬$ %& ‫  א‬ :   9+) O K .KH)& +K< .K, 5O1,& ("F" " ) " E * 9 " /9 : $& ' ) & D  =@    + 4 = F& )<   4/& O   ' O) 1 'O? (  D   = .6 4%& +< .< 4%& @ '  D)& &+K) ( P 6) UGTT )F  % .<  4% &+K) 1O = ) O6 &+K) . !K ' 6F "#  / = Q  # ./ ' K"L  ,) # !O 1 G  < ' ()K! ) #O?  O , < .  ' A0 ,T  .   .,1 &<  + ! 1 )T <% & ' .  0 & (1  & 3O ' ()< & UGTT  ? < & + .(K KH) 6 )0 +  + =@ HK)& O6  &+K) !  ( & & D  !" ,1 )L ! .g%K) ) 6K (+ UGTT .&6) 6 1K  #0 :   (2006 &) ) P &/ < &+K)  /O (T1 .&+K) 1O   C '&+K) '& ./ < 56& (%) : "/ $   " 5G :   F-L *) & D  =@ !" 2007 % 20  !  1O = .0 & (K)  9% (M7 /0 J  7 "I" C . J 0 " 255


O    . %   K & #H ) &+K) H)  0 0 =@ - -/ #H ' 3" A0   &+K) < =

' 8 O g J ' KH) -/  )) A0%<& " '&" .('  D% ' 2004 .&6) & D  I    & " =@ K  4& ")&1  " (O% / "#  )K! O )< K)  K1 O  )< .!   (/ " % "6K  6 ' H)  "4 "Z UGTT !# 6 4/ g! '   %  O  +  &+ O 6 ! -/ .) ! DO  K6& %<K  K ")&1  " 1 Q1  H)) UGTTZ 0 ) &+) KH) '!& '"J  6 ' &O       (1 F& )<    D)  1K $&+K) ! 1 "+)@ '!L =K1 3" " "      8" H)  " O 8)< 8  O D@ 4 "#       + %  "()*"  

! #$ %&'  '0  / / . % I& &,)  -. * ! ( $ .(!  9%  1) : UGTTQ    " :   9 .1 ?) !  ,K) O< <% .  ." &)" O 2008 8 ,  6    ) UGTT D  '  9 @ Q! =@ " %   & " E?6 =@  &  &/ ' UGTT  ' = (&)K 6F "# ' .<& O + $& .<% 6O . K) A"#  h<& 4% < "9? '& 00< & " =? ' 3" ' O %) ' '!  # G ) .&+K)  + ..0% 256


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e %@  K!1   &+) -  #+  .<K .&K ' -,6K   & " 1K  < 'F %   O6 $&+K)  +   =@ #% (  / %C .+ A"# 4 K < + " % . * P <& 257


G57 ;" /   5 !895 M7 ,' J 5 (1 : (2005 '% 28) "" $" #  '&" D  O'    %   O' 6F "# &  '&+K) )! 0O0 O ( + '? (! 1K  &    "

<K O< &+K)& 6 '% 'O  '&+K)& ) + '< P   + #C& 1K   ' E)/@ 1 =@   $8)   4 $ P ?1K - )   6 ' .0 9)J UGTT .g + "& " %  O & " E)/@ 1& '!L z< ) d ) ") O1" O' "b  " >   ' (/  )!  HK) &+   $O &/ ' ( <K . 6F "# &G = 9)&  K6 =@  #! K6 G57 ;5" / 5  '  5 !895 M7 ,' J 5 (2 : (2005 '% 30) "!  *  " /' D -  8) <K E/   &+K) .<K 6F "# 4%  ,H& -K! 1K  8",)K ! ? "< %)" 01  =@ < &+) 8",)K ! /   1)  '  ) -K6 O < ! 8? ' Q! -/ %0 J "#  +) $8) 1K   ' ?1  ?/)) "& 0& ? " "&+< -)" .((&G 9) (%) E/ ') "8% '" O' "b  " >   &+K) K6   A%K  O &/ ' ( <K '!L z< d )

. \% % # $)

& ' & 0 "b  " .)K! # G .9+K A"#  1 8",)K ! ?< % '1K  '&+K) O# 1 ! 258


"N 3 & !" "8 < +&" "- <" "< !"  G =

"#O0 -)" "&< '1" " <)" "&)% 8" ... # G "8  8)1" "1 6" " )  & " 'F  G = 1K  P  + ! 9?  ?1 + 4 "%) <" "'? '&  " '&+) " %   & " & < ... "& 0& ? " "&+< -)" "1 ) & " -$  UGTTZ !895 M7 % :  < 1K  6F . P ' +&) ",)K ! QH  O O - C& K .K, ' / ) 'O& $ ) AK!P  # O 4  %  'P 0 4 ! A"# %) " %   & " U&\/ ' & DO  =@ O% ' < !K  Q!  6 ("& <   < &+K) 1K   ' UGTT  ') .&+K) . #HK Q! @ ) ) .&) "*" $" / 5 *   5 : ' 4/ ' <  "' + O1" &+K) ) 2009 D    #,& K< UGTT J O% .K  '  % ) !  / " !" 0) e e& = (6 1K  < 'F "1) ( 9  &+  @  6 ' '&+K) V<& """ 9  A0!  (   k ' PK / < =& + 8" 1   ) A)@ / . ' '&+) ) ,  V + . %  ' C F  " & < 'F '  0) 1 , .!   ,K .(1K   ' 6) .!  ' ")&1  =@   UGTT  ' " %   & " (O% "# .+ "# = & O  D   259


 :‫א  א‬ 

:

 (‫)א‬# *+"! ‫"א‬,‫אא‬



% 1 <&) ") K ')J +1 ' E )K &O  .)!  , O< . 1 4? +) '  " ? 8" HK) !1 2006 ) 9?+  ' '! $D)  ')J +1  1 >

< O% ?/  HK) '1 =@ &O  P + -+B& K<   /

     /   ,)  .O K O? '& "#  @  $",  6" 1 3"):    &O  1 O'  &O  Q1  !,K O A   P + = 6F  = 1 )  E&K& K  G = #O?  @ V 2006 8 13 7 & g&O  %&  +  9% ! &)%F ?O, O K ,O =@ O% ",  6" 9?@ 1 + .; 6 ' .  = 1 D)  & F  &O  +   %@  HK) . 1 .)! )# ' 8!   #  ' #1 # '  1) K<& +@ 4 &)% -  I 6 =@ / 0) > 6 V GF ') .)O<L 01 .)% 6 ')J +1  < 0 -/ 0  % ,/ 6  J =K)& / "# ' ')J +1 ' EO ) &  0 ' +& ')J +1   =K)& !1 -/  . + )& =,! $1  % .# ) &/ & D   4 H) G . + '1F ' C # "& " 0 '! = .0K! < 0 O' (& < '& E0) ' & # 6 - 6 '! "'& " G O 6 <  'O<  &O      .O1 -  261


A"#  O 1/@ ' )O! -6 '& K&  6  =

O' ",  6"  & &    >  '1  $C .O L&& 0F & 0 "'&< " -KT! + K .K, 1 "# 4 )K K- "# <&& %   .  ) <  4 ~ '&  J (&O H)  ) "#& # & " 1 4/ 108 '&& - <  # "'& " V<& &/ ' =? O (1  K KH) )& 3O 1 6  6 ' &O  ! _6 A @ :  .'&  @ 1   .(?@ 1   .)  J 1 1   <& )% h<& (<, '& = ? E , 4% 1   ."'&< "   4& (,) "#& # & "    J 0% OD 8" , # E? "#  )O  h1 "'&< " 4 )& "#& # & " &/ ' +  @ O + "'&O " V<& (& (O% 8" 9K)& K< "# ' d# " ())

&/ ' A+)  + - 1) LTDH # -O  ' &O  "+)J D  !0 <& $E?  !1 1 ' ,) "'& " ,1 (? ' = " "  %   = A )&  () & A"#   HK) 4K "F '," & ,1 6 O) + .( (1   $1 "D) '& "" "F 'B > 6 % ' ' '& 3 < K! &   4? 8  9  )! &Y &  - 6 ' ')J +1  'P& ',! ! F , 262


A"#  '&& "'& " O'B 3" G  $0  &  # 6 .'! F &/ ' G )": '% 0F =+& & H) 4 < '! 8" 1 "# 8 1 1 O  -/ D,) # ( % &O  D ",  6" & .& = "8 ! &" - @   ')J +1 < 0 "% O 1 & O& /  .O  &O  O' (& < $ , O< .O 1 E? "<K .K, ' -/ '& && ) D)  ')J +1 9) =  < O .)! h1 D)  ')J +1 4? 1 < .KH)  +  K  .6 ,1% +& !1 HK) # &< K

263


  & 7 70 & - $ d  5   : 0 7 B" V . & & 1^  ) 2006 '%13  "'&< " O/ ' '! "# K (+&  !1 .  & D  (  LTDH :   ) (... ) ! $8O0 ))  ' K+  % & (1 ! &O  "+)@ 1)" )) "&   + < ? " &!& ."#& # & " 1& T&  (K+  %) <& # Q! ' "? F" 1 &O  .9?^  A"# 4% (2 .1  A"#  '0 & "'<L%K" .9?@ ' K 4 $.% (% 4 (2006 . / %) ) E% '&O    (3 "#& # & ") &O  9+ "? F" = '? !   (% (... "& & &1O" "  '& O1" "O ! '1O  & " .+& K6C   &   } ) O56  @ E%  "#  6 O (4 =@   . + $"+)J  ? + K6 =  - 1) # & " I  4 K/P & T LTDH +   Q1 1 O?  %  ! =K 8K"   Â&#x20AC;)W "#& .&L "'<%K"  4 "8O0 )" K1) E , 9P  )O :Z& K/P  -K!T (5 $) P  J  $9)F  &O    264


 &O  9/ 4 . K  Q!& + ,1 ) +  .; 6  6O LT $.!K .K,    "K/P " L  \ &T (6 .  J .K, 1@ O +  +  '   ; 6 =@ . 0 = A G "80 )" 4% (7 &O 

%

? F&

'O1

 ,

.6K

.KH)&

E% " .  +& 'O1 ")  E% " &/ 3" .9?J& "#& # & " -! 4 "# $ P +<) p&/ 3" ")  %  $E , '& +)K $; 6 =@ ,)  .  & (...  "'<%K" 6@ 4 $)  P +<  / 7  &? (8 .&  %   -! +&  1  A"#  :   K+ !  % h1B& & ' ()O?   ) "#  I?, ; 6& K #O?  L \ &O  O? K! aK) +1    =K1 &O HK) d! # ...! .(+  &O  3!) A  @  OL%  # h1& O+ (1    ) -# ' '! /  .K+  % 4  & O 4 O@  ' &O 

265


- $ -  # 2   5- : ("* '" F  " * U) +1 > 6 <% h1B& "  '& O1" O =@ J (1 = (< ,K  4 "Freedom House â&#x20AC;&#x201C; . 1 " =O ')J .(3" "  '& O1" \&/) 'OP 9? F <% h1@ & '  + ,1 ) 6F "# H) (2 '& A & & (!O 1 F #  '  1) &O  K< # K!P ()  + O 4 '< ) "+)^ OP 1 &  C !1 mE O8 O D (K)C& 3" V , q<K < O O'  . 1 & &/ ' O< .O 1 ')J +1 ' EO  O# %:  /  <% A"& -   "'&< " '1 / .( ' (1 / 8" F  ) g%) ' HK) 4+& K, E@  F 6 LTDH # % <& )  ) "# -#  K& &+  A"# O%  !K! L0 K &)%F .KH)  .) P + !

266


 :*-‫א  א‬  "!0‫"א‬$‫ א‬.*‫)א‬,  -‫מא 'א‬1*(‫א‬.* : "2 "  % C $ F- : $& &  .+) ' Q!  # &) " 0%" )/ I,  &  '/+1 ' O% ' ) <   4  J K . "J &) = KH )!B& '!  '" '? < '  % )+ I  $O6 =K1 ) < 1 .0, QH  ,/  : ' &<K &O HK) &/ '  , A"# -/ 4 4+ &< Q! -6 8 Q! V & LK 6  @ 4/   Q!&  8K O% ; 0  ?, A"# .)! + $O  . K < Q! <& 6 & -! 3O 1K   '

a & &?& +O) H) . 1& O ./ / "# . 1 .)! $ 0% ? C 5+ G #",)& ATCE O< 6     < 4+& )+ A"# & 1  6 ' % 4/ ;) #  ; 6  " 0%" +)  . & Q! ) 8 & !1 .O  ,) (  & < <  (&  @ .  +& : & # & " ) F "8O "  %  1 D +) @



.K $,1   = +  6 ' " 0%" ?, ". G0 (/B& ,! D) 0 (  ,1 "& K  + ATCE .)< )+ 8 / (< PTK 1  A , !" 267


<" 8 0% ,1   VL 2006 % 



 8"  J  '? " 0%" ? &/ ' < "%  .D) =@ ( 0  6 "80! " &O ) , D  ) .&  @ . 1 O !" )+ O? D) .K)



A"# = %%1 1O& D) , G O1 =@ F  2000 . )+ : M  E   9

h1Y   6 " 0%" )/ O'  J  > 

-

L+,  La) +1  9,6@ =@ L< D)  .O%  G  ' .< 9+& ,! h1 '0K  ?  ) & HK) #  -  '  ,0 &6 )& .1%) K+1T D) >  ' #P  & = 1L O  /1 ' ) - F A"# 6 =< )+ O' $& L _/ .0%)\

)/ = )T $ .&@ &"! &6 ' ()%O  &   6 .,1O &O +1 hO  ' n  ' 0% \U @ K6 +& La) )+ '  J  + &1 > 

-

3"  J O) = . K &? O6 )% =K)& K) $O L <  O 4 4+ % 4/ V  1T )O<L I 6 .& <  ? .9 @  + O<     < )+

-

.& < O V<&  O  +  #  = H) '? <  ? )+ O<

-

< .)+  ?1 ' ' ) '/+1  .6  . 1 9 @ ' ' ) 0,  "J ) 6 <& ) & ; 6  !O 1 O  4+ 6 1 3" #O? + . % -1 .)+ V 1  1 ! 268


7 ' Q! ( VO < '!  # $; 6& ? < 0  G =

" ,<% '& =," O "/0  -) O1 ." ")  " # G "+& " "3 & '& " "&)% !" "& %) 1" ... ! :  eb% "2 "   !    

&) Q! &/ " 0%" )+ 8 ,! a & O<T ATCE .)! p&T/ $D)& H) 4+ &  /@   )  > &! ) O D '! O 2010 & 6:  1& $ < C&  -) h1  & ' ) O . $& % 1  &O ? .+) ' '! 'F .O/ &< . '& )6 .%  +)  O1 .   .% A"# ' O1   " 0%" G %   .< %) V1 )  0& 8 HK) = < +1 !"   &!   " 0%" .&< / $ & )   <O (  &O D  = 6 !1 01 =  #H && . #H '  & (   $) '& + A  )& (</ = %%1 (,)  1 8" "800 & 1" K ! 1 &  & 6 .% G 4/  <K  ?G '! & %,) $8) '0   + '  5 , <) ' b ' ()< 1 # &)  % .1  " 0%" )/ ) #H # A D  < ' & '! + $ ? ' '/+1  ^ O+& . #H 4+ )F .+ (< 9 B& H  .%%1  '! 0 &T  9 B& 9 J 9  ) ( W . 1 )! =  O  . !O 1 '& " . 1 # +) 4+ DO   / $ < V GF " 0%" )/ &/ '  4+ 0< 6 " 0%" )+ 8K -K! 3 1K& ATCE O "#  & .a) D,)  <  > 6F &)%F .?, ! 269


' 5+K  6 ' ATCE .1  3 1 K6    : # 1 &) '< '" '? < C ' " 0%"   : / $ # ' C : I . "J 4% < .)+ . = V <  (1 )! = <  &6 !  +) .%%1  6 < .4/ D!< K" . 1 56& O6 "<&)1" )/ 1 " ) & <" 4 h1&K (2 / ./  O ' '! " 0%" ? I?, ()/ = a & 0%)@ ".& ")" "D& '# &" "   O1" ' Q! !  = ,K  >& ! ." 0%" )+ '1? ' 1 0%)J (UGTT) ") O1" 8 h1 = 9? K .++1 0%)J A< " ) & <" .'&K V<& 0< h1C! #0 & 0& D,) 1 6 ")" )/  "8 + &)" 4 h1&K (3 " 0%" )+ '1? ' 1 0%)@ = (< ,K  O h1 $E? .'&  '1 ?1& "30"  "@  " & 'O )"  J& K  O (4 ./ ./  & 6 (&% .)! V  D,)  O6 &!  & <O  J  GC& K  (5 .1K )<& #O E?& 1 )<& HK) <?6 ) .KH)  01F O (6 1 ,/ " 0%" )/ O? ) .)&  J < & D)  .KH) 01F A"# V 1 ')K ' < '< Q! O? .ATCE & #  <& .)& A"# Kh& 4 $)6& , 270


: /  # ' C : II AP AFP &)%F 9&)F . !  & ATCE .\ (1

#0K)  ?& 0   ?&  (&) DPA Reuters . !" ,  D)&  % h1F 4 <K  ,1O 1 + & <  J   K) . + .O  (2 .,6 " 0%" -/ 9)&) & < .?, = . 6L    B& ./ (3 .D)& h1F 4 )+ A"# < + & )K (" 0%" & 27 7 & ?, .)+ = KH) . 6 :   : 2010 



France 24

   

    

  

    

  

 

()  

TV ! â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  

()  

& )+ A"# .0\ $"& <" )/ ATCE '& (O% ) <& $"# O '+1\ 1 , 3   .)!  D)& h1Y )0 /<K -)& ATCE 0\ &+ $6O )& / ,  h1    ") (+< O 8" $)  ) ' 1 (/ < 8 J .2010 271


,; #   I &  C  5 $ F- :   : '$  ; G$  1K  )   /+1 .H) 3O 1 =   1996 ) -1O V<& O'B $; 6& ') '/+1 V<& ) & F V<& ( VO < & )K . + O )& ./ < &  ?  .  .9  .+? ' ') '/+1 ' #  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; /+1 ) 4)) # &  A+ 8" O )&   # , .0% 0%1 )     %1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; <   +? â&#x20AC;&#x201C;   .&6)  I K K1 ' <) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; . 1 ' 1  J & # ! )   56   â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  

1 ')+ +& &)%F -1& ,/ = &< ' &1 .(... % E%\ +  2002 8 ,  E? ) O 1 A"#  Q! A ?1 "(K & # & " & D  >  0 (Q   " DO  O  "8 1"  ^ O ! ' "H,1 1" ")? " ATCE ! <  "/ ;1 :  K = ,K  O h1 O  D)  !1 G .KH) .<% '  1 (1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; D) . H)) < &  -1O < -/ =

<% '1 ') . â&#x20AC;&#x201C; %& ') ' E H)

) H) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ') ! 1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; '& '1 .<% ?+

F &  H) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; )   ) 1  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ; 6& ') â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  ) % ' ) < <% â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1 & 9& <% â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (...  %  E H) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; -1O 8  <% >9   &O ,6 )% '  1   -! (2 .')J +1 .O 1 %  <O &  '! ' Q!& HK) 272


       ! (3 ."#  .  *+ $$,- /0,1 $ % &'( ') % (4  9 $5"8) " $5   '45' &  6" &% /$ $$,2 (5 .(": <)  , (  $'  ,  '  ! 5 (6 .(> " $$, ATCE &6 9   $=%) C', ? BD  !   C', ?  :4 @06A $5  B+ 6 &G  C', /> C', E F 9 C', >) &  6  5 %' ' H5 /$, >  0,2 '  >$>A I0) 

. $5

273


 :* ‫א  א‬  ,‫א‬# !‫א‬-‫א א‬ : /-  ! $ 15 M2    (1

J  & O& +& !1 01 T&?  . K 8  =@ D&/  ' O%   3" ' $< .OP 4O%K     E? 56  %  J I (@ (O% ! = 9)& 3" 2010 ) &K)&  + 8 O O '  +&  !" +& !1 01 < 'F ' 60 D = ) 01     =@ ' J 'P  & 4%K

.(=  @ Q!  ) '& 6K  6 ' O 6& O&L 4%K &? ! "# '<O%K 'P ' < E G !1 01! A0% OP = L'L  O6 ()!@ =  O<L "4%K" '! = +& .< .OP `  J  J   O = 1 4O%K  + (2 : +&  %  & 1O  +K >1, .K6    % D = 4%K V <  'O? K (+) '% 'O< K! =     K  J Q!  6 ) )% Q! # 4% & .O%L h1 ' A O )F .1 '& ' &6  I? 6  6 ' H1 L $  .)K '% O6 ()/ & + 4O%K O'  +K A"# 4% <& 'O& :+ ! (... 9&  'K .&/  .<&) (6 L  Q!  & 275


4 )K& 1 O1 4/ K+, &/  . 0 H)&  .'F -+ '   + 4  .%& &+K) .<K &/   .#9  $ ?+ $'1) . P .+ . %  <&  (... /+1 .KH) .<% /O 0! K 4 " H1"  ? < 01F 4% &/   / " P" / "!" / "?K)") + HK) 1 +T  01F =

.("PDP" / "POCT" $.KH) $.<%) ')J +1 .KH) ' ' O0 Q! <&  . K\ !O 1   (... '1 .+ <& ? < 0 <&  .#    1 . J <& 

O1 &6& '0 & &K O6) & K 1O <&  (...'<% "F <& 4 0  0 -,  # C&

276


 :*2‫א  א‬  "3 ‫מא‬1*(‫א‬  (56‫א‬-7‫!!"א  א‬8) -6 8O  4/  O#  1   6O 0 .&< ' ')  J  O'B $& D  H) = 1 ! 8 & ./ / (ATCE  ^ < J K  0   (&01 A  (  " '&" ' K) . 1 Q! %  8 #% ") .1& )  %  &   4 )K& 3" '! 'Y < J 4 ( J  D - @ .1 2004 ) % 6 'P 0 4 (6 0& 6 I) ) '%) +& !1 01  6 4 (; 6& . ) . ,) .(... <` $'  $RCDZ )K 8 Q! 4/ !1@ &  '  U  Q!& .1 / .; 6&  6O& 3" '! 9   O1 ? < Q! -6   ) &! 1  J  4% . K6 ' '! %L &O DO  AO +L 8" K O?  ' % <    )& -6 8O  1 V  =1 .O 

(... # G /+1 .KH)) O   # ! 8P ' # )  1 .)+ .K % -1O 4% .< K) 3" ' :  6 '  @ ? <  ? ; 6  < '<  J !& O ? <  . + - : ) V  (1

9"& 9)O "&  O1 =@ )1  + & -6 8 1

"+ '& g  - .<) ,& / 6  &) . & '?&  & ...# J -O  0)  0  )6 +1 277


 !  . + )  6 ' V Y V <K O1 =@ - ! &,L )! )0  ?  .6& )T 3&1       %0 '? < O6 1  6 ' VO < ""K '& .1   - ' 3" K6  4 6K /  a  <  6 '@ . O6 < )O0 K" 4& ... F V& 1F % . O6 4% H) ., ? < 1 Q! @  @ . 1 O' (2 '1F V<&  $D)  ')J +1 O< . 1 <? O . 1 A"# 0!  $)   &) O8  / ) 3" &O1 = (.K % -1O 4%   =  , D,)  O'T)  % '1F V<& ) . +  1  HK) 9 < ',1O V<& 'K), 8O  ,6 .K (% =@  6 ' VO <K 4+ (?B& 9,! 

%  6 ' /+1 0  ; 6 ' #& .  K+& 4+ 'K, &! 1 1& '" ')J +1 . 1  ?&  9  '< '? < .<%  0)  @  &  K $+O? 6 4) = 1 &+ &)%F& 9+    '?1 ) 0,K .)+ O6 -1O .K % 4% . 6) / &!& 3" ATCE J & ? < 7 +&  < '<  .,L  - F A"&  6 ' O)L .<K + )T  + $" !K" O" " KH" "O " "#<" "0<" . %&  J  : O% - 6 G -1K = L\Â&#x201A;+T )L  1   6   +1 4/ -0 D) = %K "! 4/ %  a & >PL G   /,6@ #0%  & 4 " / $&)%F =@ 9%   6 ' % 6)  < ?, 4 .KH) 4% O  ' !  @   J . 1 .  ? < - Y "#&" . 1& )K ) .<, ) 1 V < ' .)O  "#  4% ) .'  ' OD 278


 ; 6& ? < = ./ D,)  O'T  . 1 K!P   %J& 9  <K 4   KP  1 DO  <& .(O " F %@ '! '! '@ (K) $&   6 ' a)L "# -6 8  1 %  " Le Renouveau " " 1"  % +& O' H1T (K)B +& " + 8  4%" ) # & &  K 9  1) '  O,  '@  . % -1 01) = O +  # $( % ' ?) '  ? (% ) 3"  L = 3O 1 h1 $HK) KT! %@ ,& 6O  J ' " ( % & D  # &< ' 3 1 1K <K ; 6 < D)& % %  =@ ; 6 '1&) $) +& '< &)%F  J  &K)& O $"=H< )6 8T  .1& 8 %K #  = 9)& ? <   +K ) K)B < . %C    . + &+ , .  ATCE ' =+ h1 -F& ) '6K g+& <, . + A"# .O / (1 ' 4 ' Q! ; 6 D)   , ? < 0 G 1&+ .')J +1  . 1 4/ +K)& VO <  8  !

  $ %  &  J    O' < 4 . % -1 % = # )& ' C  ! &, . + =

+ ; 6& '? <  ( K 0  $V < )&& # # <% &)) "<)/F"  ) H  O#   &< V < ' Q!  ? "', &6" (") ,& D) 9/" <%  )   = O6 ; 6  ? < A )  = O  HK) ' '?O < ' ) .)! $"+& "  - L K "Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Audace" 4&  # OT '" '? < =@ 6 1 '   .  6 ' )6   < / 6F , 0)  00&   279


 D ' Q! = V <T ' )  + .)! $A   4& "N & # & "  J  D  "/ ;1&  " &  ' ()   6J ("  ' )" A  <& K,!  &G) <% 1 / (& %  1 5+)@  % .?B& . 1 9C& &G #P @ 4+   & 5/ ! = .  1 g / 3" ') 6 h1 = </ ' 1 ,? ?  B& "0 1"Z& < E? hC  K . + A"# ! .(9#Y + # 6 4+ ( ',1 +)   (%  # G ' ! O '" 56  O :  $HK) 8  )% 8O  1F E"  .("I O" " "  %&  . +) ") '&  "  1" " ,<% '& =," ' %#) "8 %1 #" 1  .("& %) .("I " ( % .1   .%) "O%1 I" 

 %& "H1 " %&  .%) "  !& &"  .("I " La "  %& "A lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;encre de vivre" '! ) "< '& 0)" <% 

.("Presse .(" )6" + â&#x20AC;&#x201C; " "  %) "&  H1" 

O& #+) O "'  '& " 4  ) "  &1"  .("I " " "  %& .("I "  %& "1 !" '! ) ") N & "  .("I "  %& "-/" '! ) " , 6"  .("g&"  %& . + O ) "D& '# &"  280


.(" )F"  %) " # '& 8 1"  .("I "  %& ".)P" '! ) " =,"  D)" '!  "h1"  % .1) "8 % 00< & "  .("> 6F .("h1"  %) ") I"  .("Le Temps"  %) "6 -P "  .("I "  %) "%1 0"  . ("Le Renouveau "  %) "b   ! & "  %  &6 E%    6 ,1) " ) " .  ? < +) $. 1 ) D%  & h1& ')J +1 .(" "  %& D% ?  MDS  ') "   O1" V <  . (  K,   ' <& ; 6  ? < +) $+& '  ? < +) $'  D% ? ) "1 P" 1  .(" 1"  %& O  ' ! .(" %"  %) "  '& -)"   D)  )  56  ? < 01 0 O' ! + & D   & #0O %) $" !" ? <& .O&T $)O6  + # )  6 ' ; 6& ? <  ? 1  ' +  O   =  ' &  # + = H1 =K1 3" 8  ? <  ?   6) / $< K6 = H1&  +) ) -1   .%# (K)  6 ' "   O1" &<  1 ' A K  + H)  g ; 6  '? < . %   1 b# 281


 %C &)% ,1 'B 6 1 =@ ?@ :  ) ? < %  . 6) (6 & '& ')   )6 .K .O% )K -1 ' O1 Q+ . +  ; 6& : 1   & = ) !") $, A" .! "C E " ,1  .  " E " ,1  .))& "F" " ,1  : "7 " , ' I  C Wb- $  59 : ('5"  M2   *&) "" $" :1 5G '  U  " '&" D  =@  2009 D  O G  (O%  # DO  '   ' &<K 1 01 LAL%  ())\ A ! .+K+1  .0%)J ' EO = 01 0 K!P $()  KH)   # 6& " '& =" K) $D  !1 O && ." & /  =K1" 1O  & D  )L & <    M2 !89 M7 ,)  B  *  : 2 G : ('5"

'  O&  & D  =@ F& )< (O% 1999 )  ! (O ' (, @ )!@ 56& .1 . @ ' (O6 ' (6 (O  O5) 1) 3" O  $" . O&  ) 4%  -)< h1 1 ((&01 ') " 1"  %&  + .!<) .%& <& ? &+  6 .O% +  7 f*" I5& I    /0 " B  * " 78 !! " '5 F- $'      J  * g * I5& "/ *" 282


тАл  ╫Р   тАм тАл?  ?тАм


"      "   ) LTDH ')J +1 ' EO ) &  D  (1994 8 , X 1989 ACHR ')J +1 & < )%K D  CNLT D)& . 1 ) D% & O  K)  Congrès pour la " " % % ' P" 01 D 

+ (O 8" 2011 ,)% 14 &/ (& - < G) "RĂŠpublique .(2001 % 24  ',+ '/+1 '  % ' ( 7  2000 %  O1 =@ & K O!& "  .D)& < "/0  -)" !O O' LI?K O - F  6 ' .+?K G O !O U/ ' 0U & ' " '&" !1   '! 

 K

 J

. 1

?+

.O?

)F

=/  ) (/+1 ' () 1 A? ?+ -< $(

 ' () 1 % 6 D) 6 ( & &/  .%  ' () 1 +& ! .O   A , 0%   . ,  & ) () @  9 . ?1 . P ' < ?1 =@ /0  ! V < ! ./+1 () @   !F <  .+? .  ' % Â&#x201A;.W  -H ' ,  =,& (  '! 8"  % K / G O1 =@ . ' Q! O? O  '!  . O? A? ( . 1 (% 4/ ! $)6 <& (K  . 1 # $(&)% =@ -W/U  () 4 ! ' ( @ / < % 6 'PK  0 ATCE % .,! 4) 4 !1  )  &  O& D)& (,P  4) .. + ' A )  (&!  Q! a  285


 M  "/%2 G " 7$ / ,5 Y   5- $AE 45L    / $ G"E /0 F  * I ' $

     



&  '  "!# $% # "   *# 0&   (LTDH) *& ( ) *+ ,-

â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1989  1994 

.1994  4  1&2   5+ "!# $% # "  % * 4 6    7  5 # % 4 829: 8 <+: *#    4 1994  5  ; > < ?= 8##% LTDH &2 *# 0& 9 @  *# 8 * 6"-+ *" 2 & # &2 & (   *# 4  @B #) ?= A *<+:

&& 0 !C D-+ ># $>  #%  B 7# 4= > < ?= EF   #& '=  H 68&  I "-+ *" 2- # B# G 6 -  && 7#B#  #% H : 8  8 # % # & "-+ *" 2- 8B * * 0   J#& <> *# GA &2 > < ?= *# *4 8  K > 9 -B#- ) 8= +  0!

! ?=# DL * 1#B &2 ?=   6 - B# @&M *#  0   -B# *# 2 30  0!- *#  0   -B# @ +   *   * *   #  # +# 7#B D-+ *#1 A (7#B )   @ E& "*4#B" GA - B# @&M 7#B .(' *<+: N&# D-+ 4 D-+ '-& % A

1#B &2 8& ?= "!# $% # " 

286

1994  5


     



2&  , #- O4 7  6"-+ *" & # , #- =P *  %  4#& -# <+( "$# " 5B )' *+ 4# %  0  .1994  11  (PDP *&) D: # 0 'K =   BC % #

&2- ?= "!# $% # "  *<+: N&#

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etour à lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;envoyeur) "8- 287


     



2 B 9#  C V>-#)  BC % O4# 7 #   JB  D: 5=:  " A" 5+ (  BC >  "!# " G 4  $% W .  , # D: 1 # 4 =  @ C 9 #

  '  &  @ C 9  X D-+  '&C )= @   Y#  2 !B  . &   4 Reuters

% *#  7# %   9# -&-&

&  "La Croix" 5B 6  &( "Diario 16" .  &9 "El Pais" 5B $% # "  $( -4 % RA 7#B 

'-Y# > = #1 1994 # 24  "!# ) '-&  H 6 2  '-& )    $A  "!# $% # "  B *   « BBC » 8  # L  % D-+ '> =I 5 G-  J &  

% <> *# # D-+ 8#B1 4 %> 4 * *& ( ) B#  ) B ?%  &9 ' Z -&  %  #& 4  #& 0'>  (  ,)  4 #L # 8% # D  1   6     *& ( ) 7     *<+:  $U  0& *# *

& &2 > < 8& ?= "!# $% # "  5  )  D-+ 8:  A .1994  @ [     > A  .1994 "8- + 0 +"  '  > R # > V   

288

# â&#x20AC;&#x201C;  1994


     



)% " 7# *4 1#B &2 <+( 52  2 .G A F 4 ! "*4= 8 B& "!# $% # "  $: 4 5=# * *# 4 G 1994 # 24  '-&#

L 

 

8 #\+

*A

*% 

<B#  $% +  "-+ *" 2-   <> *#  #L # *# 4  #  BC )<': 4  *+ )  G   +    %: 5 ! ATCE A 6"!# $% # "  J & >  =  RA W * --  1B ->  .&  0     0B# "!# $% # "  D-+ ] \ Q 

1994 -B 13

"J% " #  > D: 5=( # '= J & # = ÂŤ RĂŠalitĂŠs Âť -B# "La Presse"  8  + %# *#  #-+" :  # = D-+ 0 I# *#   "!# $% # " & D-+ M# ] (   0-' B& GA   2 9 ## )   ."OY  8## 8  $% # "  J & )<': >     *  .  BC $%  7&  )' D-+ "!# 4 ]> D: & "!# $% # "   &  0  5Y# *# 84 #   6*B&   *# 8B> 84# 2  ) * -> D-+ R& ! B 5%I# G-& RB 0-E 1 1994 # 1= A # # D % 4 1 N= *# 2 ! > 7! =  @  .4 L 

289

1994 -B


     



7 4 R& ! B *# 8 #  

&   4  E .B   R& ! B "!# $% # "  4& * 4

1996 # 19

A #= * D: 8 +   % <&9 + & # ! B *# *## ' #  !# @I B(

#" "4B * D'%#" 5&  X D-+ & "4 #" " < ##" "&# #+" "##1 4= +  %: D: + # 6"*& * 1&" 5&  &#- 5 4I  *B&# 7#B #= + . && 5 &## ' # R= + D-+ % * A '-&  &      + > H   +  ' % .@ [ # (1999 * B 5 & ) ,&C 1 -'+  5# D: -  4& "!# $% # "  * #4  @: 0#   (

-& 9) 4 $L  *#C   *# 8+   60A4 # 8 & )<': 6& 4#  *# 5# RM: 6 #X  GA D: 5=: D  * 1999 * B 7 * E9  .&  <+(

'-& W#  *# ] I Q   +9 *   ?    1&Q <# *# -&-& *# 8 ''>    A "&# #+" &  6CNLT &&M#

-> D-+ 84# )- 1999 # 1= <> RM+& -: 5Y# *# 84 # 7# CNLT_ += X '=  Z+Z A "!# $% # "   6 #%4  

290

1999 * B 5


     



5Y# *# 7 I# A  ;> 1  : 7# 0&   ) 4

B- )- >C RA E  .< 1&2 `B# 0Y & D-+ ( #) *& ( ?B 0A4 # #4  @: & # *+ #  8 + ] ( '#  GA    8+   . ' ")= " 5B  $L 8  Q   -  ' -B#  %:

1999  23

 B  &2  4= > 9 1 #  $% # "  E#  0& ## .1999  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; "5 " 5B   > 0&) 6 @  # "!# .(*  $% # "  *# 2000 # 1=   

2000 #

 & 4   #  5%# 4 R! B *# "!# . # $% # " - D &  Reuters_  0& H  & 4 4 5# C   0  5Y# "!#

9  = &  - Dab * - D:  5+ #  "&# )F  " 1  + 5 # * - D-+ 'Y - #C 5# 9- C < GA ' #  D:    D &  '-&

' # 14   )' 1&2  !: <> *# 1 #      1 #  *& ( ) %>  #C   C 9    *  =  .(5 # - "4  " % #) 5# > *2 '-& *   "!# $% # "  A <> *# * O4 D-+ '-&# 'Y  *# &

$1 ''> O4 ,B:) '& 9!  *# -#B GA * @'=  *# - + D: & ! B 291

2000 * B 22


     



)" % 0  : -   BC -# 4 %> (2000 #  * # 42 5# 4' *+ "G * 9F *  @   ! # *&& *B&# $9F *  K )- N 0& B: '  *# * 4 *>F .*   *#<&( *# 1-X 6  # 9 N "!# $% # "   # A GA 6   YI A &  L - C = *# V->  0Y-   5+&# ;+ .#<&(

&2 1 B# 5  % RA @B 1 #  5  *' =  D: "-+ *" 5! 1#B .  7# V%>  8#L  1B#  9 #C 2 "!# $% # "  + : "-+ *" L + 4 "* - " G A F ÂŤ Le PrĂŠsident Clinton, ne devrait pas soutenir un rĂŠgime qui est lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;antithèse des valeurs que nous partageons tous Âť

 I !4 8  8#-  "!# $% # "  

-# *' =  5! 2000 * B *# >C ,&C .  #L #  *M&# O4 *# 5=K) #<+: -# G % RA E:   "!# $% # "  4  ("8- + 0 +" . BC @ &9 

>  #4  *   "Human Rights Watch" #L # -+ D: * B 28  *# 1 *& "!# $% # "  5 # 82: 7# *' =  2000 -B 2  .2000 * B 30 4#B

292

2000 * B 25


     



5& 7# )&  , # 4# ATCE  B .*' =       *& ( ) 4   9 5  =

2000 -B 27

$% # " - $E# G   BC <+( 2&  & '-&  D:  B# A  "!#

- A&N 8-#+ *# 21 8-% <> *# 8-+ ) 

% ! *#   GA * * D-+ && 0' ." 1# 1 " )& D-+ J &   "!# $% # "  :

2000 # 18

$-# %#   2 9 ##  B -B# 1 V># X 4#B L9 cB *#   4 1 N= *#  @& *+ 2 ! > W (CNLT) .GA *+  ! # L 4 L  %

 B 52  # "!# $% # "  E#

2000 #& 30

@# 9 B *# 1= 8)  B& 4 8-+      > W B *# 1= 4 1 V># X 4#B

  82: $ 2&9   10 81#: 7# ( 2 ! .J &  # 7#B# && $-># *# %>= + "!# $% # "  *+ ,-  '

B E4 1   B *#  B&

& 8-+  E: $( 1# $K '# 7# 6 %  4#B    <+ * 1&" *#    J & )<'K R B 4 .GA 7# 5 ! # *c# "5+ # ##" "*& *2  "5+ ]B" 1& 

B- RA  & 0&) " " "! " C *# 293

2001 -B 7


     



 5% 2 !B # "> " 5B  # .(2001 -B 8 *# -E 4#   "!# $% # "  % 0! &N *+ 8  -+ *E#  *4#B  *

2001 -B 24

->  5 ! $  -# , : 7# " 1#B B *# #M# " .8  0! W#  ?  '=   8 V>- : *  %: 4 5=#    "!# $% # "  D-+ $1 ''> 7'

â&#x20AC;¢

."!# V->#" 8= . && 8! # #  #  # ! .B 8! @ +  *# 8 ! 7 #

â&#x20AC;¢ â&#x20AC;¢

# D-+ 2000 #&  C *# %# 4 $% # " - "  & ! B"_ 8#& ?-Z'%Z 1= 12 5# *B& d  8 N=  % "!# 5#  # 8 *# #  < 5Y# 8-+ B#  'Y 6 && 0' -  *# #   & 5 &  2 D-+ *C * # 0   *# 4 (  D: 5! D-+ Qb# ) "Jacques Chirac" G A F & B   7 % "-+ *" ; >  X \ \ % \ * * "!# $% # "  D-+ '-&# 5Y# 8 J#&     $ 2&9 ## *+  .'=   *  

# ")= " % !I 4(   & # RA1 D-+ 8  2001 # 30  # =  &  <4- * 9" 1  8 @B *C 0   $ # RA @ B % 4 *c4\ & &    * 5B ."  D: "G =" 5! <> <4

294

2001 # 30


      &  D: & "!# $% # " - D &

 2001 #& 8

&  D: Q N " 8   H - ;K - *# 8-% 7 * 4 #4- # : && @B- 0-' &  % 84# R B     ."  8-#+ &  + A: 8E 2001 #& 12  Alain Renon

M  8#-I ) ]> *# 8 % & 8   14= - *& ( )  ' #    0-X  * 4   0 &#  e 2# 8  ?  @ E& 6L   8E (' E# 82 ) 04= .& *# *=4## *!1 9 O4 $

# D: "!# $% # "    +

2006 #& 7

#&" A&C # "+ ##"  *B& 5!   "+ #&" 5A&C  "A> -&" %  "#+ *  - @ +<  4 )   #B# *# +#B#  B .*#C   GA * 6 +#B# D-+ #  D-+  # D: "!# $% # "  

2008  16

 &   6*& ( ) 4

B- *#   ."8- + =  ## &"  # 2  *# ]- *# +" & '=  N   &      7 <> *# 1'Y 5! 4# "-+ , #  = I #    "!# $% # "  . 9 ">C " 7#  # %  $% # "  & N&# E  A ."-+ *" 0 Y&  # 2  *# "!# <+( 5 ! B> *M= 5 ! # 0+  7' #  ()=#   & )' *+) & 295

2010 -B


     



 "  *# "!# $% # "  - 0 *&" & O4# 1-#  "= - C '-& 7# )&  & <+( ! G 6" 4 7' 14& 0& 5A# =    )-X 7 R< "!# $% # "   + 7# 60 6(Persona non grata) & 8 0X# X %>= "*# #[ * D" 8   7 # &  # .& "f ' # # * "  D-+ 8 A>M# *+ & ! 0+ A L  &  #&# R1= 0& "!# $% # " ."&C =" 10  "-+ *" 2 0-' & $# A @ !: *+ = 8B "8- + 0 +" *# 2010 -B 1  & '-&- B> *M= ! )' .">C " 1# D-+

296


             !   #$ %  " '& '&< '0" K6 'O& $- F  6 ' #  =K1 ?  / . "?K)" ! 1 A% \ <\ 8 ' O ,&  J (O%K 8" <& 4 < ',< K1 '  L1 h1 ") % O '" ') # &  O1 =@  +1T # & ; 6 O T &K"L  '%O& ) - } UE\ ) . %  OF aK) ' & (K) ! 1 4+ 8L K K) E&K& 'O& HK) <  . O 1989 ) < K .&6)  0   4O%K ' <   #% ( +& K! 8K" 01 "# 4 +& !1 =K1 <+ !1 HK) 4 O 3O 1K %  $ +O 8 O = !1 01 ' bO<  "." " '&" DO  H1  J 9?+ 'F     ' ,! .% .)! $</ ( 9?+ (1 &) &# @ O<! #0 &@ "?K)" ! 1  .A 6 9  ! .+ ' 0 &  '% O 1991 ) ' & .)! $'   ; 6 b< % = 6:  &%@ ?K) "<K E) 4&  4 .+ G = O% / )%O !1F + O1  !) '%O 6 & !)K ! 1 '% =

. & '+ ')%  . +    '<J 4/ + '%O ; 6 O +< EO  = +  %    ! 1 4 ',<  V â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ! 1 4 ',< "F '   ) #%K     +1  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ) < . 1   X '<% 297


= 1 )% 8K K! ) +1 ' ) 1 (... ,O 0%  1 =   %  .  8O1"  G = '1O  ' '% 1 .O ! 1" "  %<" "8 O0 (K &  "V <  " "&% .O+ &F +, '%    &G 9?/ G "V& 1, 0  K1 ' ) 1 4  ,) .)0)0  ?<&) L& 4+& 1  <& <% HK) O< ! (... -1 <  " 9  : ) ) +1  +?  4 $ 0O  A () U;\  '% ( 0 O  ' (9 'F &/ ' "V < .(.!O 1K A"#   8K   '% =@ E% J&

298


: " #( # " &' (K  O6  J O &/ ' 5) O  @ O & < )K < 8O  > "?K)" ! 1  F 8+ 0 &J ! 4% . ' 5) # $  @  !    > U \&T T 8K" "K)  " "F = O6 ,& .0K! K)B $! 1 A 6 ' /K 'O< "O " $"&# @" 2011 ,)% 14  O1 =@ .(  A !F 8K "&# J" () (6 0  1) (+1  (O+ E+&& A% &)&) < 



,)% 6  6O P  %  &  O K!" 1 & '& -) '& O1" F) 8< 6O 0 ) O'B 2007   & 2007 ,)% 3  VO & D) ,& ,# K ("00< 6 (K) K! h1 $( ',K ' 8<O  K =@ ")  " 6 , +& 1O ' / " 0%" )+& O6 KH) Oa1 1 '? ' (K) ,? )F O > O% /O  ' -6 / & ) & = Oa1 3) ( <& & (1  4+ <O  9+&& ( IL   < !& 1 +K) = &+ (  < 4+ ' =@ (6 &/  ,O +& )O? .)& =  & 9,!  .&  :   



"&# J" 4) O (K) & D) , . 2009 &! 31  ! 1 U&\/ ' ( .O%L   <& 8 O  K 6 ' ")  " 1 "/+K 1" G > !"& ,1  )  " J %" .# ! 299


 ' A L&L O % = =K1  O .O .?   "# .')& =@ ' D)&   , 9  O " '&" DO  ' .<& $  .O -/ = A ! % 6 'PK O ! U&\/ & -/ # C '   -/ ' 6F "# A h1 .x I" 1  ")  " : "?)" ! 1& '+ /

: " ! !  " ! ! I" =@ ")  " (O% 2002 &! 24  ./   9,% <& 3" ! 1 ' ( O + (K)  (L<L : =@   O5)  9% ! ! 1 ' " ! !"  & 4%  .8 K ! 1 a) " ! ! I"  0)L a) = )!) 8+< - 1)   O?& ! 1 (K

  .( < 

.&! )< 01F =@ 9)  ! 1 Q1 =@ ( 



' K '& / < A"# K "<)/F"  ) .K > 6 % ' ' (G .O + 1998 ) )  6 ' KK "# a%C m<& + 9+&  () &G  ")  " 7K '! ' hO1  J  &/ &1" ?K) ! 1  8+ 0  ! 1 ' <& " ! ! I" !1& 3" " ! !" 'T  +& O) , O< . &6   ")! 4) 3" 9  ' # '! $) , 'F& 0O ")!" /

( ? ,  &% /J 4  !1 = 1 ' " ! ! I" .)   300


: ! 1 O? HK) K6 "?K)" ! 1 O? " <" ,1 O?/ " ATCE    2002 . 31  6O P K!"  + 4+ " <" ,1 O? ?/ .< "?K)" ! 1 ' ")?O  && 3" 2003 ) ' =F   F  <  % # J .!&& / <& # J   ?& ! 1 ,1O .K

 & "?K)" ! 1  G@ = ATCE . 1 + V  $(< 56& "9 &6" "" '  E&  8" ) & ?+ . ./ +& 3" ,1O &/ ' O% .K  =@ % 6 K  ) ! .O/ + K!" 1 "# ( &   1 ) . +  '  K  " <" 1 / O? (< 0 ' C) + =@ ?@ ! 1 &# @ ) .D)& ( !1 6:  6 ")  " =@ O% K = < 6O  0 ' 1& %<K ! .& ! ' '!  56& &)% - F K &+ .<  Q! $.% 7  &/ 3" $# J   ?  "?K)" ! 1 ' < O1? ) & 1O ') ' ) & 9?+ '! 4 ! 1 D 4)  '& / 1987 ) ! 1 &) &# J .&  6 '

301


 ) : )& '   . +& )< - O .)% A"" ; < 9 O ' "6K "W" ()!& (,  "D! " ! '& (%0  g /   ! (,C   &  (<0 )% G (%   I%)  " O /&" "a)" .A G !F g?, ()& .'O0 " ?6"Z E   ( %K % (6      #K" . )  %K 1) (#%K  9) !%&& "D ,)" &  ) & " '& #K" 4 4?& .(u + (% % @ 4+ # 4 !  1F %& )  =@ (& # <& ( %   ) J 8 K D 1 0%& % "#  (&  4 $"' '& " . 0%& 1  J . % "N 01"  % '&  ,K ) K6  ")  " ? <& A #H  .' K  1 ) &%  % "3&" ',)  4 AP  .! !

302


   $ .)<K  6 "<)/F"  ) ( $'? < ' A ! : )& '  . +& >1@   &) 8% '! ()! = A O O + (1 .3" ")  " V G +   O O1 =@ 3" 0% $ +1 "O  .,& L(W <) m' + (2

"K (/ '! !C 4 $")% "K" "" ,K& (,  (, = +     0 &6! 1K F& (,H ")  " 4 &# J . % 4 O &  ")"   ' A)K! &   O  1  6 ' ') ' @  +   G '  "?K)" ! 1 +1  F % &+  #%K    4  .+1 & & 3" @ "?K)" ! 1 D (,K! / .)  O   (& ;O0 A  '"K "0 O1" " )& 1" ? ( .%  ) , . &6 (+  6 ' ) ,  9% ! $&   ) .! 1 ',)    (  .. O6 "/O "  O   F& )<& ;O0 O (K) + ..+   9K) 4  1 "K ' h1&& (, h + (3 A .O  ' %6 "D&" ()&@ O' ( 9% 4& + (4 (& 1 O 9K) <%? '   1 "K '  h1&& )1 .(+ = )% 9  1 =@ 1" 'B Middle East On-line 4/ 1 > 6 % ' K) )O& )K ? < =@  .+)\ 2008 ) (O% " K) = /  a) & L+, $& a &  D &<  / L3 .!1 a) & H) 303


' 'O& +& H1 "?K)" ! 1 = %# )< O' ! +& !1 01 4    ?/ O' 1991 ) -!\ (K) ( 6 ! 1 A"# O'@ & $L ! 1 = \  p%U# U%U# O&L H)& K< 1 & .K6 K + K D,)& 1991 ) & +)\ 1 .K6 .1987 ) +& '% 16  6O P ATCE '  K!" + J D,)  7 & "D& '# &"  J& ,# K F& O)< O' 9% + 2008  ( O& 8" ")  " ' ! (K+& ( J 2008 '% 15 K<  " & 0%" )/ =@ & = K .1 K ' ( '

4% K AO@   $& +) . 1  O  > O6 ! 1 )C& D!< .)! (1  O' ( K!" 1) " )" K! / $(,/  O&  .HK) 4 +,& & 4+ ' ' .&1 ' "&" -/  -  ' &%@ < O H) '! ()! DO& '# &"  ^  (&G ' &\ < " & 0%" )+ (1  @ )K !1  ."D& '# &" > (,# / 3  D) =@ < : H1 

< ' ()! 8 , 0% ' " K) 1" '!  O & < .<K 9@  6 ' 3" ( V&+ 9+@ ' D) =@ (<?  =@ (  D)& (1 ) AO?  b,K ) 4+  () b,K K-! O' h1 $%  3"  (  < 4 8 "6K   1, K- 9+&B& ' / K)@ () & ,<& (0 ( ) A) ++1 H =K1 F& )<& +K< ?+   / 4 (%) O 8" K D,) #) +& + HK) 6  -HK .("&!  " V <

304


*+*  ,% O  h&  ) J& "O  " ( "@ & / X 1 -  2002 &) 7  ' & "TĂŠlĂŠ-LibertĂŠ" 0,K ()+ HK) 8K "Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Audace"  )   = ( h1  9%  "<K 4+ #H Q! . !O Q! & 1 )K "80" O1  D)   K ? < +) <K .  ) $ .&1 ,  . P E? HK)   #  "'  '& " "/0  -)" !O ' Q!& &+  #O) .')J +1  1 % ' ?) . 1& VK) % ' 

(% F& )< O?  @ 1 O' 4/ 2003 )  .? h& "O  " O6 ( "J (  && AO? 8! .Mecca Cola E? @ "'<  ,H"  @ .)O1 +@  "J A"# ) / < ATCE .< "#   8 & <O D% %  "Michel Boyon" '<   ' K-  @ O ! 4 / / (&  8" # (CSA) )  6 %    O )  2007 8  (@ (O%L ! &/ ,6 =  &O< O  &1 '! ,6 = $"O"  "J h& Kh& DF ( 1 <& ) , ')+  6 ( "@  6 ' AO<  "@ Kh& -+@  6 ' K " CSA D % ' '! $ "J  "@ 9 @ <& 2007 && 2  (Med-Fm) D &  "O" Med-" 4 h& O + .)! ' <&  ! Kh& K1 "Radio Soleil" ."Fm .ATCE &/ ' 3 1K "# &O DO  '1 ' '!

0 =@ &! D)&  < , .O% > 6 % ' X 8 =K+ F& )< '!  6 ' , / & % 6 'P Q!    =  D)& (/  = 5 1  < ' .  .< ' 305


โ€ซ  ู†  ุง  ุงู…โ€ฌ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


0 /& 1 )& ' &O DO  =@ .&K <& O+ +  J : 2010 % 14  6O P 1 )K 6O 2003 ) ( O 8" < ., 1C& (++ 



6"Z& (& /  ,6 = 8 !< =,&  &! < ' .".! " (++  1 / < &)%  <



.' F  ".! .A , 0% %  )O &/ ' () .0%L1 6K ! ' )1T I 

 

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


' ()!  O "&!  " V < $&K)& :  3" ( V&+ 9+@ ' D) =@ < ' ()! 8 , 0% (1 ) AO?  b,K ) & < .<K 9@  6 ' $%  3"  (  < 4 (<?  =@ (  D)& 9+&B& ' / K)@ () & ,<& (0 4+  () b,K K-! O' h1 =K1 F& )<& +K< ?+   / 8 "6K   1, K- D,) #) +& + HK) 6  -HK ( ) A) ++1 H .(" K) 1" V < 4 (%) O 8" K : "81  O1" (5 /K F 4 )% ) 20Z& &G ( !1 O 1986 )



. +) =@  ,& 'O1

"6K 1 .9 %  .\x  ,<& 4K 1988 )

 .AO?

>O h1   <& O  OF D) =@  1998 % 



 J %  < +L '  +) =@ # @ 4% ,6 0 .(<& "K+" )/ 1 "K+"  ) %K  '?/) '1 & &O HK)& (/ .0O )< 6 '&)% ' -/ g?   > 6 )1 )K )1 =@ ?@ $+O? 6K & O & '& I? F& . 1 '& g?   "&"K& .K K "?K)" ! 1 ' (,/  % > 6 . 1  +K  IO .O?  %J ! $() &O D     " '&" H) '  /  &+ .+&  J  4%  =   1 % (K6

308


  $ ("/% " ' /0 /- *X   ) .! 4&C& (<)  & . +& "<)/F"  ) ( : ) # J   6) &  )K O  .& $"0 O1" 4 1F  %K  (1 & 6 .  < O "3&" ',)  , 1 .+, &  ' #  &  ) , .O h1& 4 $)&  &# @ . ' '% # & & #  6 ' "D !" < &# J& #& (/ (2 )O O > 6F "# ( O ' <& $)   ( V&  .'O& A% 'C (J #O '!  ""  J . &6 4 ()< (3 (P  6 '  ( < !1& &  & ), + .!O 1& .+&O )F ,)% 23 7 & O #  ), "g&"  % (K  O1  ), + =      A&  <& 2006 O  & )K 6O 0 ) K)& 1": ()) +  K &6 "# )K " K"  % .+) "   . &6 <  .2006 ,)% 25  O #  (O ' (&+  O O (    , (O&1 (0) (4 ' D) ()6 D && A  + @ ) ,     . &6 &/ &+  & # G '" '? < E&F '  % 6  6 309


 " " , ")" "+& " #) D) O? ( 1  ( 9  .("8< ."E "   ' (%0 / 6F A (5 :   , ? < -,  " K)& 1" & =H1 K O#Y  H) . + '  % ( .? L  &O DO  9 + $; 6&  O  ' K) &/  E K  "<)/F"  )& # ) 40 K !! ? < . + '? " K)& 1" -  O5)  

310


. # / 0 LTDH ')J +1 ' EO ) &O  D ) X

( !) ! ?  1999 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1994 , ' ) D% ?  MDSZ 8",)K

.')J +1 O D% D 

 -   K  1) E  /' I Z$'  $A& ] I : (+& 1O  J ' +1K   9B& (K\ <& (+  O 1996 8 18   Philippe " !%& 1 =@ (%0 !& D! '  (%  6

 11 Z& ( !1 "   O1" &)& -K!m " Chansay Wilmotte .&)%  , D%K % ' )% F  C% )%   5Z& ( !1 O 1996 %   (O<? = & D!<) 1 E%  ?@ =@ 1996 && ' =F .(=,O (   0%  ' ! I&) 1  / %& F& )< = ; J O 1996 &    . K g O  1 ( ' <& D%& A<+  W+W 1997 % 17   & K) &/ ' ?J . & 40 # @ O K) D%& . O? O !1F K ,6 = D%& (? %& O ?/   (<O& +   )  =@ %# 1997 )  . K1 ?/ )K ?+ .O  & 

311


/' $, #   ATCE I % !58 /# 35 ] II : E  . F& )< # ?1   1 .+1 4% <& â&#x20AC;˘ ."8  D6"  ) -1  . + .  @ â&#x20AC;˘ :  "8 % 00< & " A O 1 "h1" ,1   = T) + (1 &  ()) $ %  & 1 "  'O )" (O  h&6 ' .!O = =@" : I&L ')<  O "!! '6  8 O": O# & .<)  %& "8 " ( U\`T + # $"!w .&!)<  " 0)  ", K /" ') , < " +" )6 '" ')K Q! OIL " # $() )% 1  4 "9& .+  9% ! "@ () ' 'PO & D6" (&! ( qL  " K"  %&  + (2 l & & UKHT) ')J +1 1 9+  (!  <& ( "8  .& F 1K  &/ ' 1997 '% 11 7 &  1 D "Salvatore Lombardo" J &/ ' (% (3 0) & ( (K   + (1 4 8" ATCE  Art-Sud K% +1 1 E% 1998 '%  A ?1 &)& 3" '! $< .) ,   )& H) ')J

0% )@ 1997    O + + )F 9&)F ! 1 (4 4 ,) "Abe Nathan"  J =@ l & )& ')J +1 < )K ) -1&  @ 1 O' O / $"8  D6" ) )O  6 90& &6 = K &O DO  O' ! $ 0% A"& ."!!  & ' + (\" : )F 9&)F ! &6 =  1 312


. !     . +& "<)/F"  ) ( (5  ./ D,)  ) , )F . <  <& (,   ( ') , + 00#  O& O ( '! F 9 G@ + = ( T/ .)! " +,  0" ' (1&  4% (O&1 (0) ' .O1 ! )" A  "N & # & "  1 ' AO? O% . +  ."K) +1 "+ .<) 4&C& (, 9 1 /  "  ' :  .+? 9 " 1 (%0 , 0% L .O 1996 &)   .-)%& /+1 ) ?1 .1 O 3" '%O& A% 9) "-  "8  -P " D) (++ 'F +  1999 % 5   .O& " & (1O K O< ) !   ) (& =) $&O O D F (?O < ( T) h1 "&"! 9&) ) "! 8" '!& ) E%  (1  && <  ( 0 V<& < ! ' &# ' KCL  (1 O1 & & 0 .( ) ' 200Z& . O/ !L1 O +1K O" = (+@ O h1& O" = (& H,1  <& ' ,0 &6 ) % ' 1999 % 29   O '%& (

&& 2   , ()C   O $< HK) , !< )C .('  <&) 1999

313


+ / 0 (  *  F -  +  M ) : $E D,

) =?/   3 O '%& ( !1 1997 && 29  O ' &"! .< ) < HK)& K ,6 = 3"   22 (K\  6 ') ')+ ,6 = ') V 1 && @ )C O 1 ' O1& ')J +1 ) ' +) .9 %@ "6K& !1 . &< : D, 1 #  '   

" "  

5 +&# ATCE #  *  '    = *#  - *+ ] U  4

B- ." -& #>"

4 " -& #>" + E:  $% +  R& ! B 5%# #L #  4#B + ]> <> *# -#4 LTDH %> 

# <+( 2& = Z    <+( 2& !4(    . 

--  9# =  # *# " -& #>" 1 1= ] U  4

B- *    @B H 6*>  #4 RI &I L    %  " -& #>" *+ 0&  *# # 9# *& ( ) @'= 7#  #  *B1#  %: D: L  14B  $( #>" *+ ] U 5+-    8 <+ 9 4  D: * *+ 0 # % 7 " -&   4 " -& #>" 0% # 5A&C  "!!# $% # ." *

-> D-+ @B * *   LTDH ##" " %   " "% ="  8-#+ *# #C  4# % + 7#B * + # " & 0B

.(SNCFT) ##4 = ;: 7#!# *# * A *B1# JB (

 #  5&# <> *# 0Y# 8#L  * 9  : 6'   5&  # D: 8B  V> O  E *& G-# .5&# RA L 

314


: /  D,

O +& &! AO? .< $)   "! D6" % 9)  .&G\ 1 & )% b 1K % ' ! &  1 )% b 1  (% !  HK) O  "! D6" ? 1? = )<  ( 56 &/ ' G    10 ()%& ?+ F& )< = &G !1 !1 .   6C& K 1 A"#   O $ ) - : 5 (/ e&& (6 ) .)& B& &O  .!O 1 1 A"# &+L $ @ F& )< .& G OP G 4/ = 0K! 8" HK) O? : V  D,

1 . P ,6 = "! D6" O?  @ 1 O' O G ) , D  >1B& ()&@ % ' ()K!  F  .&<O  A  ' O (K! : & (45) 2000 && 20 7 & "H1 " %& + (1 + -1 >1B& )  J  0%)@ ' + (2 "w ' O8C& w &+L 8C&" : ')<&

315


1+ 23 : $E D,

-+@ O 8O  -6 Q! +?  HK)  @ 

 .O  $ ! 1  / % ' "'1& #" V < & '  H)" "',1 1 <%" , ' O  O)  J .-+J & 1 "1 : / 5 D,

"D& '# &"  J   2008 8  (K) ATCE . <& ' ")K 1" )/  = 8 1 a) &  !  D)  h1F   &O V 1K ) ' " )+ 1  , 3  D)  h1Y )+  +  =@ @ ) (  = ( ! (%) V1 +)& E?F K& .K\ .D)  ')J +1 . 1 4? +) ) ,  J  '? < = ) A +& "'1 '& #K" O / &+  4%  3" '! K< , 3  D)   .O  h1F (   F H<) ()/ 4 ')<  - H =@ = % & - F V<&   . & ;) .)! %) V1 h1 56& .( )+ 0%)@ ' . # +)&  1 G : ' (ATCE @ 1) "D& '# &"Z O& ! 295 A$  C  7 D- "/ 5   "  %  ' (1 .  !&$    5 %  O 4 <& ./ /@  F& )< &G (2 )< -/ ) 2007 8 12  9+K O) .ATCE  & 9+  316


=  6 ,O % .H)K ' F .! 1 ' F& 1" ()/ &) = '?K) A9  K< $1 ) ! !C 4 $" KH ,/" I?  1  6 ' (1& ")K

)+ a &  'O1  'P ' ( Lg +L ' ? A< $? < -/ = O  O .& + I? D) .1%) 0 &J ' J .  4 /  )+ (%) 8" K  () 9&@ >1 = &O DO  E K <& "# ("'" ?/  'O  '  6 =%  " : V   ATCE K!" =  1 'O 9+K .K- H,1&  "()+ /  "'1& #K" : "7& 18" G  * "*  A 5- " G% K &! 18" ()) .) )  = (<0& / O5)  V<& -1 "'1& #K" +) "6 K D&  : O+K  +O   ' + <% " A & & "?K)" ! 1 4 O >+  &! 18  F &%J ! 1 V%@" ()C ' O ") )! + ' 0)  .  % K "%)6" =@ . 1  ."(/C&  -1 !  .OC K

317


( 6  ) 4 1 ,% (+ "La Croix" 9  ) : 2000   ,% : $& 4  2000   3 ") E%  ?@  "3 & '& " 6 

  42 O E%  ?@  ' )  =@ O1 2000 8 A , 0%  D)  ,1O < ' (<) = %%1\ 3" .!)& TK< 4? 1 !1 HK)  . + A  1 ,6 =

.D)  ')J +1 : "3 * F0" /9 $,  5    A ?1 ) -)<& <K '  ? )< = 'F 9   ("'  '& " !) ) " &O"  (< ,< H) ,1 ) .  3 O K)   G@ O $ %" "& /" "8 ) ? " '1 = 9   '& "Z 2000   27 7 &  0 ) " I O1" " & @ '1 )  .  / $O6 O1& 3"): + "3 & '  ?J  /@ 4 HK) <+ . & )K )& 9 \  "# 4  ! G 4 &   2000   28  !1& < .'< O? ?/ )< ( 0 @ -)<& " '&  " /+1 = 9   . F&

318


:"3 * F0" $, 0  , 45 

 

 



%    ! "! &

2000 $ 2

   

         )   !"# .(" 

84072

%    ! "! &

2000 $ 2

   '*          +, )   !"# .(" 

84073

 8 

2000 $ 3

/0 1% 02 .3%! 4+5

-

 8 

2000 $ 3

6  1% 02 6  /0 %%  7   1 * .7  

&1 2000 && 7  D) =@ "3 & '& " / :  D & ("Hélène Flautre" "Desir Harlen") & F 1K  ' & " ?6" 01 ' ?  ("Robert Menard") "1 & ' " H) 0%   ' ',1 '  % ("Daniel Cohn-Bendit") "Le Figaro" "Le Monde" -1) &)%  @  '  ' 6: .("France 2" 0, " Libération" "France Soir" "Le Parisien" 319


: $ 9 

  

   

/ +  /* ;' 9 (           #  )* $  ( ) /* "   "     .<   !# $  %     " 6 "5/>" ' 4 :    &  '  ( $)(#  ." ?@ Le Figaro â&#x20AC;&#x201C; LibĂŠration  *+    A  ATCE 9/  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Le Parisien â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Le Monde â&#x20AC;&#x201C; France/*  A+  #  /* ,(-  Soir â&#x20AC;&#x201C; La Croix

.  9 / 0 (    ), 1) (... (  Nicolas Beau 1&/ BC 4 :  Le Canard enchainĂŠ  '  

     LTDH ,   

Le dissident dessonant : 8  

4# / "   " * $

)?"

$(  

0 

 D C

4

.$)/*

" <" % /E 5  :F "$( ,  7("6   " *"   5  0 9 G Le Figaro  '  .8# ),# )/*  " ( .2000 5  #'   9/  ;'     (  /  $     ( ) ( Grenoble    ;' 75  ATCE  5  9/  "  "  !# H5 I  2000 0 10 7 .&'  :) $   )# 5  $( ) ( (  #'

J #   4/   )# % K  )  "$  " :F  ( .1&%   "  " 

 + 

)C

!#

 

$ 75  ( )/* #'  A+ L/  5    8 / # +     9 4>+ .("8 M   ") A+ ,  320


  

   

IN   9 7> 4F( $    BN $ 4+ - $ # E F %' I CJ  7# , $  8  $> $(( 5  0E / (  B(/)  *  . #  5 

7#

B 9

4/

# 

(Robert Menard ) "  / > (" 4>+  O IN >N ,  7 %'  E  $  4/   J ;? - $ # # I 4#  9  N  J  *# :    4 L  P / 7  Q7# 75  "8   BH " $>  ( R  (   /* B@J   .-

:     , * O?/ d!1 "3 & '& " + "3 & '&  %" '   3" $(,H ( &  6 ' ' = 9 & (K\ @  3 (O ."3 & '& " =)! O +  <  K& %  6 : 2010   ,% :   $2010 ) )%  6Z& "3 & '& " ,1O = !1 <& 2010 D  19 7 &  538 #  "-/" ,1   

'& " = .1 / O O' ( 9% "3 & '&  %" (++ T) + 321


'%& A% @ 3" $  '  % &+ () ,< & "3 & .)& &+ 9?+ 0 g +L  9%  =K)&   g + = 9)& "# T) ) -1O& I? ) < O + ')J +1 < F& )< ' IO? "-/"  %& 9%  K),L ) ?/  ) = ( \  .K  K1 ?/  (O  % ' '% . O& ? 1@ 1  6F& O . &<&  (O%

322


   (*  F    9      M & /0) ')J +1   ,  &6) 9 <& .O &6 = <K O $&)%F  J  Q!  2007     6 h1& O   J h !   )  J  4% 

O O' O ! $('? < "')" "-/" ,1 9)&) .+1 .   F& )<&   . 1

323


       18         !  # $ % &%  ' ()  *  $  + , " " *&.   "   " ( .    * %/ 0123 45)  - '  7 8 $9 :  ; *  6(   ( .   %   ( * '

   < !8  .  .+%8   %   .  '  )? >@ 2009 '  >+) B+("  (  $   A  "# "   ' 2009  24      C#- 5D  &* 5)9  E 6E  "  *  F G  &(  .   HI% * $&  A '  )? D  (  J(  BI  $ 4*D  $ >(  '  ? .'  )+

: 5)&  # ' K(  EA  5) L5 * H

 5   

( > * -  .   &/ â&#x20AC;¢  I  EA $ > ( 6 C.  $ "# "   $ '? (? N/ .+I%9 5 H9 6E  ",   P" &*O 5     

â&#x20AC;¢

* H   * + 5 * !.9   HA- * H2  ? D  P  */ O #+  'N8 E ) D  >  ( .

   K * Q5.  A $ L   !  G+8   * BI L5 N  &G  EA

 , &G ? L 5)&  # > * I  'N8 R() L5 D5%  DJ&   D/  1 O G&#

  .  > * .*+8 324


O1 "H1% >)" = F& )< - L > 6 % ' %  (# .C  8" 1990 )  ))+ 56 K =

O $.)<K &  "?K)" ! 1 4 +&O O % @ () 1  L?  &! )  1 U+ (K) K @ 2004 ) () >) -)C DO  =@  (% " % ' g " ( & 1 O AO +   )K  'CK O K  = >) 5 1  IU? ("?K)" ! 1 6 < & G @ ) -  8 6 (,H A "% ) -)< +  QO % ?< = 8K)  4 <& DO  =@ O  A"# @ O $("'" h1 <& O6)  !, <  & D  "  )"Z& " %" .<% &+ "  '< - " ()!  6 K! F . 1 ')J +1 % ' ()< O -  O8 4 h1& O< (K) ", J&" (K) A< K!P ) (+1  V 3" "+" ()  1 1 .8K) )  !  ' "?K)" ! 1 &) - F <&J

325


  ("Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Audace" " M ) . +& '? < ' A G  G = "<)/F"  ) ( :  9%  O#  = O< 4 O I&O  dg)U%  ) 80) ()!  ( , =1  A O0& '! h1 $=&O ")  00&  /J  = 1 ) , (%0 00&& / $ %& (/

=@ ( % ) &   "+1" K% @ . = = ( O '" " K)& 1"  "0 O1"  O0& 1984 ) D) 8 0" '  & A&+ ' <& O  =@ 6O  K O 6 3" ; 6& '+ "?K)" ! 1 ' ./ O0& ! $"O1  " ! 1  0 4!  ' '! "Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Audace"  )   = A ) & I <& ) O &  O  .9+ (& (<% 8" ") ."?K)"  /F   K)

! J& x& . + = 0! K& 9) 0! A   .  O  (O )6 (/

(", F = @ 4& D) & %") )6& (<)  .) ,  D& <

326


   "POCT" "PDP" "?)" ') ? < 75 1 /  1 #1 1 ", O? ? " )) + 4/& (... " P" "O< F 1 = .  D! #",) 56F V<&  " ' 6K&" 9?+  +T) $D)  O  #H ) .?O < V    @  + 4 )  $"') +1 1  (&%& + "O& O1" 1 '! '  J  IO% &O D  =@ .? < A"#  @ 9  1  8 O?/ % ' 2005 ) F& )< '% O  : ' F& )< 9?+ (O% h1 !1 O     O& O 1 )  ( 0 = -)<& 9  (1 +1 ?/  '& ?/ '1) !1 '   )&  ? .(AO? E@ /&    6 = '!O Kh1 ?+ O O? & 9  (2 '&" ()) .) )  = + "O& O1" a  = 9)&  & ')/ D  ) !1   ,6 = F& )< AO  $"'  â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 

< O+ ?1 "'   " &O )O '! 9 0 ' >  $D)& ) 0%  3"): +<)  .< .%)! ., <% h1 ' "' "Z& () +& " '&" 56 = ( 6  ( O & m& / .?,)  4/  &6 / 8 ! : # !) 1K +  9?+ > h1 $(O  O = h%& /    %  ,KH O .OP K1  1O '  D .9 O .?+ O 327


: * 

.(2005 D  2) ') ?+ <% 8",)K ! '& X -/  ) (!1 9) )< '1  C X < /  Z1" = 9 & K 0 <% O (K, =@ : "(/  G = ) /+1 .KH) 'O 'H1  ' < K6 X +1 ' '< 1 O P IFEX CNLT LTDH $(  (&@ ,6 = "O& O1" 1 -+@  +) (')J O 1 <) &&  )< !1 '! = .)& .0K! h1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ! F !1 )& ' &)%  !# K6) D)  8  (... . 1 ) D% â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ')J +1 .# : "& O1" O? K) O  O%  J 1 =@ -+ ' F& )< O? ) -1 4%  1 (1  J   E? =@ J ' $'1 .KH) ' (&)% . & < : &       

 

*(+) *&

D: *## O4 %  # + .D   g % " B" (" # +" %- #)

8-+ 4-'

!B : * #E *4#B *## .-+ * +

328

 )= (2005  29) )= (2005 # 3)


      

 



8-+ 4-'

  2 9 ## 5 

# D-+ @ +9 * & . ##

J%

*&

B *# *4#B *## * : 5##

1# # *  -+

%# &2 +-  . !B (  0&#- *#E

8-+ 4-'

Attachement Ă la primautĂŠ de la loi et Ă  lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;impartialitĂŠ de la justice

(2005 # 3)

 (2005 # 3)

Le Renouveau (2005 # 3)

.      + : (*)

O? 1 = O  0+)  ) ,& ) !@ O5) 40 (2 : ()) "& O1" "Y ) " Femmes contre la violence, Women against violence. Qui essaie de blanchir Mohamed Abbou, lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;avocat qui a brutalisĂŠ sa consoeur."

C .     F- *    , I (3 .D, /0 5 E G -E

: $,g  "F )&   <& ) " "  % . ) 2007 8 22  !! O "# = ,1  4/ $"& O1"

329


   (   2 KZ ') +) ) , "Marianne" ,1 4 "  O1" A % 1 <&  &O A 0 ' " '&" ?G $D)  . 1 4/ ( 'O ' <& (6& (1& "N & # & "  J A  ÂŤ Le mort vivant rĂŠapparait Âť + K6 K!" O5) = &! .(" K O1"Z @ )

330


     $ /- +  R  / $ F- 5 ) (7  "7" "     @ & ?+ .O ' C& 2001 '%  .+T T  .< ) -"+&  .K (% @ 3" $)  '  % .6 '  .+? "8   " %0 =   .   6 ' ' ) +&   6K &/  <&) 'F &/ ' <) $!O 1 ,/& K)  J (& < O V<&   9?+ (... "!"  h1@  56 K ' "!" K% @ .(  !1) :  "& < D+"  %& 2000 8 , 14 7 &   + 1  <% , " "Jean François Poirier"   )K 'F O'B ')& &%@ 4 « Aloès »  )   D)& ))J < = F <&  4+ ' 90% 3" '! $(< #/< 7 = < <K 0 4 !  !" "F O  « Aloès » . ) ( .?O < ."'  '& " /+1 K) - O ("H1 " K% ) "  !& &" ' 3 1&  ,1) " ) " ,1O &/ ' 2009 & 6  F& )< 8" (.O 1 ) D%  & h1& E%    6 .  .! ( I?, ! @ = (  ATCE '  " ! <  '"J& 3" = DO   "'  '& " .'O<  9 %J ")?O  331


&1" ,1O / "D& '# &"  J ' 3 1&  .1, = ( + (&!  & K ?/ +1 & "  (& 1 O ')J +1& % 00& & K h1 $.) )  .) !  "!" K%  1  ' +   J  . K O  @ F& )<& K O  : #, .< : ' Q! ' 1) K+ (1 "Fondation Hambourgeoise pour les persĂŠcutĂŠs politiques" "Pen Club Deutschland"

â&#x20AC;˘ â&#x20AC;˘

)+ ) "Pen International" KH) ' K6& K) =@ O1 (2 ) ] D% ' + 1)& <K )C& /@  )!J & 4K 1) A"#) # & &/ ' O   )! K<& Graz .()& ' '  'O  @ .< A"#   " '&" DO  ' .<& O h1  / = " 0! K& "'  '& " /+1 .!O 1& K )! )  F& )< !  4 )0 3" '! "#&  )F Bad Boll )& ) & )! <&K . O ! 4 .2009 8 , 24 23  &/ ' 'O =@ ,O ' ' ) / =   & X )O ? F =@ 6O  =K) + 3" G  $& "# . $'O& .&6)  &/  "  ! 0! " / '? @   )

'&/ & 3!1  <& ?+   /  4 3" '0 h1  K!" : ) "  ! 0! " , 56  4 'O   14  D  =@ O% "(K & # & "  J  .(2010 332


: "'  '& " ' &O HK) -/ )< 56&  ' K  1 &O HK) >  X H) 9O +  % .KH) <& & & . L K) F& KH) "O ,<" KH) "1 & ' " KH) #) " '&" KH) ')J +1 .&  O  , "<K ?#) < #& ) ) 4 ./ <   (1O O 1 & < Martina " "Robert Menard"  G = )  G  G &)% > 6

"Vincent Geisser" "Daniel Mermet" "Astred Frohloff" "Baurle (... "Helène Flautre" "Nicole Pignon-Peguy" "Antoine Madelin" a  =@ < 1O? H& KH h1F ! & 0O K) # ) 4% = ? , .+?K& O ." .9 O K), O 0<  , .<? V<&& #  .O 1 E? .D) = 'O #+1 IO%  ) #9 O K- = 0! K& O 00&  O ' E) .  X '?" <% .K,!) )C& 2002 ) /@  6 /+1  V  = 'CK    1) ' )!& "' .()+  + 9 !  ,  .K) ." @  2007 ) K)& .+1 X 'K+ 3" ) 6 .  4) )% / .K X O"Z  %J  F& )K  < =@ 2003 ) O1 &+   0   & 9+  &)%F - F& / -H 4 ("'1 .D) =@ 9^ )< A"# -H

333


!  (  /- + ,) 1   &/ ' A0%1 O 2001 && 24 7 &  =@ ,O ' (<Z) A , 0Z% 3! O ; / D) & ."&/ &" D  1 >)  3  '! ' Aix-en-Provence ) =@ 4%   .<O& Q1 )< '!& -+J < 4/  .< = 1 "8 K) ? " (1 O'  2000 1997 8 " , %1 ++1 &F 4%  $?+ A"# 56& .. 1 ) D% L () =@ "& & .E? "# =@ VO <   J  O' =@ J L L% 

334


"  ! )@ ()C '  Q! ' "3 & '& 6" V < h1& !1&  +1 (!) ?/ 56  "<K ?#) )% > & HK)  G = . O1 =@ 8 ? < "<   K >) ')J )& '   . +& )< - O (A G ".! & " "?K)" ! 1 /  O?  J  & ',! 1 ()!& (, ' & ) +1 I && (&)  " O  +" 1 ' A &< % " ) ,   O?    ?+ -& -! ?+ 0% HK) 1 ()! = +  "& + & a <K $"8 / .("Myope" ()! =@ @ ) 

335


#   (  , ' *7 " *-  7   *&) .) .  (&) &)% % , % && (+@ O   & \ O,L  = < (0) b, <& O =@ ( O% ?+  e& &+ .)! &K !1 4  A& O  & O .D)& F& )< K  1 0!  56 (,# 4/ O  K g O& (< <&  1 O $( 0 4)  &% /J .1 (<? (0) = O ) .  = %%1 1998 '%   6 E%  ?@  6O (& .'F &/ ' @ VO <  ))@K  ))/K  : (Z; /0 50  59 * %- ) /# 35     

  

(  !)

(   )

 1995   9E  4>+ ATCE 7L $         *N    #  +  /* $  9 (  / 5  ?9 F' IN  7  # ; "  /"6 F #( 7> 4F( $  + ">" "T /" "S *" F' $ ) "La Presse" "/*" "7# 0E" "Le Renouveau" "/" "Le Temps" "5/>" "7-" " " 

" "

$   U49 "RĂŠalitĂŠs"  "B#" "B#" F' P*+ ; "" L /  $ ">" "" /  99 *   ?  336

.A+ $ L/ %,  4 L 


   

  

(  !)

(   )

O> ,>  ( :F I  ; &VH !# E I Q  4 L  ( H  N # 9V F'    ( :F 4 +  7> F 4 L  . @* $ /  I 8 ?/ %E !/ W 7 T/ Q8 *  MX  &  >N O %E 4 L  8     %N MDS6 $ , :' %E B?/  75 ' 7?    9   E (  #   1987   7 # 7#   8' ) .0

#  $,  A/ / "  ( $(F Y    P*  ( :F IN "$ & ( "$  " VE Q  H

>N

>< (

$>

.  9 F  /*

:  

01   F& )< O? ?/ (% O 1996 8 ,   .- O e - 6 = &< L

HK) ( .)<K 1   ' , '? < ' A !  O' ( 9% O5) )& ' "<)/F"  )   = .U T)  5)& &+ / )& ), 1C& ,? 1997 ) 9  0) F& )<   4  9?/ ' ()!& (  ! 8" ")  " 7K ' ")"  &+  6 $"'O" 56  + 6 337


0!O  () <% (K) ; 6 6O& ) ? < 91 (,? $3" &+L O#  . ' ()K!L &  O  ? < &!F "K)" .<T) ")O0 KF"Z& + "#  "  " .<) O <   x6 (#) ,K  "# O' =@ J .O &# J& '  % & #  + ) D) < (  , ? <

 O0# 1 + "# ' - =+& $.<K "!F .D)  < 8O  > "   O1" ")  " '? <

338


$  .U T)  5)& HK) ( '? < ' A !    F& )< O' ( 9% + )& ' "<)/F"  )   =

O1 "80)" + 1 # $) 15 O'  ) 4+)  (  ' Q! =@ D && )K )+   4& (<% 8K" 9K  4% <&  )<    A9  '  8" $"0 O1" " )& 1" D) < ( 1 6 A)% &+   (  K ' 1 I ' F A"& 'K! / $()   (< 3"  ' HK) +)  '), ' I& $D && Evreux %& / < .; 6  O   D) % ) 6  F& )< + ?/  > 6 % '  ' A  1 O 8" l & O'B < ,H  (% <& ) 2001 1 < ' (&G .&  < (< ' "(K & # & " &/    & 7 & O<  K h1 ' . PK ' < . 1K A0 &T !) O56 (&1&    (@ 1  .! .(l & F 5K) = "(K & # & " 6 

339


 %  &' +  /0 * # F    9 , ' @ <& $')J +1 < ' ^ 62 > !" &)&



I) (K+  !1 G P) "')J +1   ' 0! " +1  F !& D (,& "&)% !"Z 0!  0% = V L '<& D) , &/ ' <   + 4 O $')J %< 6K % 6 'P 0 (< =  8" " '&" D  '6& &)% ! , $ 0% !" V < I) 9@ / .(&!) (,   K . + <& "<)/F"  ) (



... ) , . &6 4 < 0  / 6F , <&

340


 % ( # 3"  O  E%  ?@  .6 2003 &! 15  K ) bO 1 =@ (1  1) K! + ?O < ,6 =

. .)K <& +?  &+  /+1 .KH) ' < -< ! 1 A"# @ ./ .ATCE / )K 1O  #O? 9%# 1 .K)T

341


)  "% M " + $  /0  2 M  $ 5 /  ) (  $  2 C E  2 / * I' $A& .! 4&C& (<)  & . +& "<)/F"  ) ( : ) # J   6) & h1& 4 $V&F /O   %K    !&  O K X 1     ? A & & - "#  &F )%   .(? <  # !,  ) 'Y <  " )& 1" 4 1F  %K  X 2 ',)  , 1 .+,  )K O  .& $"&/ &" 

h1& 4 $)&  &# @ & 6 .  < O "3&" ' '% # & & &  ' #  &  ) , .O . .   . &6 4 '<K X 3 '<) '%6 & = IK K) 0)  X 4 .F 4% ('!

342


' *+   @ '? < ! ATCE <& @  2008 &&   E  3"): )!& + "!  " V < 0  ,T .< D & ! . $Nilesat .)/ >1@ = "?" 0,   h& (6  C (#&) ., % '  ) + "# @ D% <& "# $ !" V < )  Nilesat !&  8F 1 4? =@ <& A% 1  + .< A"  ) + @ ), :  6 ' 3" Eutelsat (' 1&) Noorsat ' ) ' + 8"  ) + # 1 % )   9 %@ (1 $"!  " (6 $ ) + " ! !  4 ) (2 (1 I? "!  " I? / Nilesat !    (3 .!& % ? =  .) )  = V < " ! <& ' -! (4 .( 8 .?, .ATCE 3O 1 &O D  '1 "# (5

343


,+ ! (* # F * D 0   -  + ) (& = I  ,6 =  @ 1& ( O 2007 8 ,  0 "Z& (K   . +  6 ' 3" ".& ')"  )& ' '!": + ,  6" ()) + )& ' " + ?+& A ) O "' @  < V D)  6K 1K . & > 1F

  = O + ") '&  " ,1 9?B& "I O" ,%& .() <% " &) ".& ')"  )

344


, % = .U T)  5)& HK) ( '? < ' A ! = O  .K   + & ( .! K $"<)/F"  )   D) .!) 56& #?  !)  )K .)& ( 1 : . + A"#     '& ' $')J +1   K $. O6 a  3   )   ( ?  V<& ) 1 .< ' ()K! h1 )   O 'Y <& .( % 1 &+ ) ,  K = &  ' 0% ')K 1" 4 ( )6 ', ") )! .)%" = T 0%< ( <  ." K)

345


% - %    % ' )% ' &C& ( !1 O 2000 8 , 19  )   ' (<)  / (/ 6 <&   G + & 1 ) ..) 5 O -!& ) '% =@ D)& ) '% ' (+T) O # @  1994 ) ( & !1 ) .) ' +& O 9?+ . K g O %& (1   @ 4+ ' &/ -) ') ) =?/

346


- &

    ' & * /-  75 /  M7 ,) (  "*- " 9  +  && 29  « ANB »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


  ))$  8   6 N & # &<& F& )< .<% &+L @ :  & gO  $1991 ." '&" D & (&% @ A + (1 . J  4 '<  K  A< (2 & (O% " '&" D  ! 1 &%@ + ) A< (3 .) < =@

    0 4 &%@ 1 9 %J A< (4 .!1 1 56& 1 + 1997 ) F& )< ) $"# .D)   + <)

348


./$  % : #1  9%  . +& ( (& "<)/F"  ) Â&#x201A;.,  .#K"   ) + & % !& & (K (1 . %K A"# ' <%  F ' ) & 6 , A (2

349


 0 % (  *  *9   + ) & ? 1O  J  -  & K -/ : h1

 %  1 D '& 2008 ,)% 30  . % &+  6 (1 ,1 +& ') ',1 &+) D  " /& % & " "1" : 6F "# K! "8 & %)" . K  +K  1  " '&" DO  O'! (K)  =@ &K)& 1 #  HK) !  ',1q &+) &< (K)  . ) < 1  1 ) H) ? < -  (& .O+ 1 + V (K)  . J O 1 < V A!C& ",)% 18"  % = % D! (K)  ."D) " 1 = &)% -  4 &+K ) =

"6 4 " &   0  + .< A"# = 9)& A ,& "8 & %)" &+& ( g )!@ +&  % D '   %) = ,K  &+K) ) < 6  HK) / .< < +  O& &+K) / O56 &O D   J  "6 4 "  > 6 % ' (2 %)" O' 2008 &! 16 7 & <% ,# !  ") 8" .(,/ <& % (& L "8 &

350


 /   01 =)    0) " ,1L  6O 0 1  A  & $3" % ' !1 +& H1 )  K < .1993 ) @ < ' &/ 1991 ) "La Presse" & ,1! ( '  1  O HK) ?#) V < ' < =?  ')J +1 . 1 '1 &+) CK  '? 2004 ) (@    , ! 6& ')K ') "-/"  %& . + V<& ! "1"  %&   .(« PDP » 1  J  6O 0 '& )K&  / ' (<& .O  (K & " 8?K) '%O () @ 3" ' -!K  %  & .<K ' (& ?@  "8 O0

351


/     8& K <  ( =   2008 8 ,   (Ecole Louis Pasteur de

"& &"   & - < 56

8& K   =F  O )O O% / ) '? Tunis) "; +& O  " OP  6 ' " '& ="Z "8 %K" 8 & O1" .1   9%  = O  $& ") D) 10J I ' @ ") % I&  .&<O / < K! 8" "& &  ")  O1" g / $O6 & K " '& =" OP : +) O#  @ 3O 1 K6 " '&" D  = &O  J  %  @  K    @ 1  6 ' 3O 1K (1 K O6 (  "& & 8 & O1" AO  . + ' -1O 0<J O  %  &  J  &/ ' #  1 4+ :  ! . + A"# ) )<           !"

 



  

"$   %&  " :  

1

         " "   

"-! " ; 

 !#  $  %  &' $   (() # -#!  **+ * +  , (()  ./& 0% * 1% $  2    ' 3($4   (() 5 67 8  9 : ; :  (()  .( (  (  "$ ./ 

 ( )* +,  -" :  ' 

"7C" ; 

? (()  ( " " =  9 : > > #  @ (  67 A   B $$ 6 ;   352

2


         !"

 



  

0/@    @  D! B 3E +  ($ .F%!  $ F7+  * +  (   (  F  (  /7    G  : .> > 4 & + D # !  ' D  H " " ,I % DJ  (   9 : *+ K+   3J$ 0  3 # -) DA $ 9# ( ? (4$ & ( (M 67# %   3 $  1#( (() !   ?   0 (O D$($ ,I % ." "

3

    /7      : .> > 4 + $ 5 *"R  HC "0" B6 (  D# 0( " " (()  #P  (()   ?   ,!P  2@

 " $'    M     /7!   =$  4@I  *6C 0#( E D$ .!  Q         -(!   :

4

: $  lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;excellence Âť

5

" % " ; 

"5* " ; 

"Le Quotidien"

ÂŤ Entre

la

mĂŠdiocritĂŠ

;/ (O  HC .", %  ("

"-! " ; 

$ $!# 

et

  !  ' .% F     8% 9$ .ÂŤ Le Monde Âť ;   $#

"T$  ( (  .>       " : $ 

 # 4  H   "!#    '$" 4%*  $ F6  9H F ) %" 0#P 9# D   E E +  ($  4%*  F  F  !$  F 6 /  "   *   + "W   '$" # U ,/ * + T   $  V (2008 T  4   V % 30#!  G  2J 0(%  0 %*  +( F7(I "7(C" B 2   353

6


         !"

 



  

 P   =  # F%  P  #+  FM T) 9# V +  ## D  $:   % ($4   V+ 9# F*%   ($4  E D$   ($  #(#  #%  F+  B G  GA  H:  (4$ % ($4   (M D&  G ; @ % D    H% H   9# F*%# @ ($ , D     .*+ B $

!" & K 0 AO  "0K $0  <)" ()) + ) (2 > 1K )& 1) ' "& &" P  &O )% ( 9?B& "I "  %& K) + )& O  D  a#) "  .,1 1

 Z%& "; Z+& O  " , 8 @ ' @ ) (3 8 & O1" @ =   % D,) # ) , "Le Monde"   E  D J HK) .  ' ( O" I & "& &

O 1 D  1F )   K,! 4 $D)& "Louis Pasteur" . %  &  J  () .O  8K" ' J "# 9?B&

 %& # ) & K 0 ATCE '& !    @ (4 O & K< $D && D) , &/ ' ?@ <& ) , "Le Monde" .A )  ), "& &" (& gO   =

354

''livre noir'' sur le système de propagande de Ben Ali  

''livre noir'' sur le système de propagande de Ben Ali

Read more
Read more
Similar to
Popular now
Just for you