Page 66


The great submarine leak

T By Sarosh Bana APSM Correspondent

he wide-ranging data leak on India’s French-origin Scorpene submarines hosted on its website recently by the daily broadsheet, The Australian, on two consecutive days clearly undermines New Delhi’s sensitive submarine construction programme. The 22,400 leaked pages detailed the combat capabilities of the 1,565-tonne 61.7-metre Scorpene 2000 SSKs (dieselelectric hunter/killer submarines). Six of these submarines are being built under the Indian Navy’s Project-75 (P-75) under a Transfer of Technology (ToT) agreement between DCNS, the European leader in naval defence, and the Mumbai-based state-owned shipyard, Mazagon Dock Limited (MDL). The first of this series, construction on which began at the MDL yards in December 2006, is being launched in September, its commissioning scheduled a year thereafter, with subsequent boats delivered at intervals of nine months. The programme is running four years behind schedule, its original contract cost of US$2.63 billion in 2010 having spiralled to US$3.8 billion. The cost includes a US$1 billion Technical Data Package for MDL to gain competence in submarine construction, especially in the field of hull fabrication, outfitting, and system integration. While the question is whether India’s security is under threat as a result of the data leak, another question concerns

66 | Malaysia & Singapore Security Magazine

the motive of the morninger, owned by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp Australia and published out of New South Wales, in exposing a friendly nation’s defence agenda. The paper has been described as one that acts more like a propaganda sheet for the rightwing of Australia’s Liberal party than a broadbased sounding board for big ideas and public policy. Canberra in April awarded the same French defence contractor, DCNS, an A$50 billion (US$38 billion) contract to design and build 12 next generation submarines. It is speculated that the expose could have been the consequence of corporate espionage, as competition is fierce in the global military sweepstakes. Variants of the DCNS Scorpene operate with the Malaysian and Chilean navies and will soon also be deployed by Brazil from 2018. The uploaded sets of documents contained the entire design plans, specifications and stealth capabilities of the Scorpene, as also detailed operating instructions for its underwater warfare system and revealed too was the range of technical specifications of the sonars and at what degrees and frequencies they would function. Almost the entire Operating Instruction Manual has been detailed, with explanations on target selection for weapon configuration and firing, among a host of critical minutiae. Of the leaked information, 6,841 pages elaborated on

Malaysia & Singapore Security Magazine - Special Edition  
Malaysia & Singapore Security Magazine - Special Edition  

This special introductory edition of the Malaysia & Singapore Security Magazine has been compiled from current, as well as recent articles p...