VOL 15 No. 51
FREE
October 21, 2015
mystery solved Cumber confesses to murder
William J. Cumber led authorities to the body of Sabine Musil-Buehler, after admitting he killed her and buried her on an Anna Maria Island beach eight years ago. BY TOM VAUGHT SUN STAFF WRITER | tvaught@amisun.com
HOLMES BEACH – A plea bargain in an eight-year-old murder brought law enforcement officers to the beach at 81st Street to dig for the victim’s remains Thursday. That evening, they found one of Sabine MusilBuehler’s Converse tennis shoes she was reportedly wearing when she disappeared. They secured the site for the night and the next morning, they found her skeletal remains, ending a bizarre mystery that baffled detectives and friends Musil-Buehler of the victim for years. During a pre-trial hearing for William Cumber, who faced second-degree murder charges in the disappearance of Musil-Buehler eight years ago, Cumber confessed to murdering the German citizen and Island businesswoman with whom he was involved. She was last seen by many at a Halloween party at Haley’s Motel in Holmes Beach, which she owned with her estranged husband, Tom Buehler. Public Defender Franklin Roberts made the offer to State Attorney Arthur Brown on Tuesday, Oct. 13. It called for 22 years in prison in exchange for Cumber’s confession, which would be reduced to 20 years if Cumber would lead authorities to where MusilBuehler was buried. On Thursday morning, law enforcement officers brought Cumber out to the beach in shackles to the 79th Street entrance. He walked to a cabana on the beach and told them he buried her there.
KATIE FIELD | SUN SETH MATTHEWS | SUN
Above, crime scene technicians painstakingly sift through sand as they excavate the remains of Sabine Musil-Buehler Friday at a site beneath a beach cabana, inset, off 81st Street in Holmes Beach. The map at right shows the grave location, circled in red, and Haley’s Motel, in yellow, the business Musil-Buehler owned with her estranged husband.
see sabine, page 22 google maps
INSIDE NEWS OPINION Sun survey football fever outdoors weddings sports real estate
4 6 7 20-21 26-27 28-31 32 36-41
BAYFEST draws
10,000 plus to Anna Maria for food, fun, art and music. 14
Anna Maria Island, Florida
dogs RULE THIS WEEKEND IN THE SUN’S CANINE HALLOWEEN COSTUME CONTEST. 3 WATERLINE development breaks
ground in Holmes Beach. 5
The Island’s award-winning weekly newspaper
www.amisun.com