2016:8
Labor Pains, H-2B, and the Odd Politics of Immigration Reform Craig Regelbrugge
Horticultural employers across America report that it’s tougher than ever to recruit, train, and retain a qualified and dedicated workforce. This is true for both entry-level laborers and supervisory or technical staff. We can rant about many contributing factors: the lack of a well-developed work ethic in many young people; a too-generous social safety net that make it easier for some to stay home; too little focus on vocational education and trades. Meanwhile, demographers tell us that some of our labor woes are “baked in” for the foreseeable future based on population trends already established thanks to birth and retirement rates. In fact, the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) recently reported that the U.S. can expect a long period of slow growth, averaging not more than 2 percent, in the coming years due to a generalized aging of the workforce, and the departure of many baby boomers who decide to retire. According to CBO, if we wanted to hum along at a more comfortable 3 or 4 percent growth rate, we’ve got to maintain a reasonably welcoming immigration policy. While temporary visas are not technically “immigration,” nor are they a panacea, they do play a key role meeting overall labor needs. That’s especially true in this strange political time where the chance of Congress stepping up to the plate and hitting a common sense immigration reform home run or even a double is pretty much nil. Connect: An AmericanHort Member Benefit
So for the short term, preserving the temporary visa programs we’ve got—H-2A for growers and H-2B for the service sector—is important. Yet even the H-2 programs have become as polarized as our politics generally. This polarization is not exactly a new phenomenon though. For years now, the contours of every immigration reform battle have been drawn around proponents—a broad middle of business, agriculture, high tech, mainstream faith groups, and those advocating for immigrant rights— and a “strange bedfellows” opposition dominated by the extremes—anti-immigrant restrictionist groups on the far right, and labor unions on the left. more on page 10…
What’s Inside: Labor Pains, H-2B, and the Odd Politics of Immigration Reform 1 Labor, H-2A, and the Convenience of Insanity 2 Hiring and Training Seasonal and Temporary Employees
4
Determining Insecticide Residues in Plant Pollen & Nectar
6
Seed Your Future
8