Plant Engineering 2025 JanFeb

PLANTENGINEERING.COM

Electrical system trends | 8

Motors and drives | 22, 30

Personal protective equipment | 34, 37, 41 Maintenance for expansion joints | 45

PLE2502_MAG_COVER_V3msFINAL.indd 1

1/27/25 4:37 PM

AC drives that won’t drive up your cost Get affordable VFDs for any application from AutomationDirect!

Plus a vast assortment of VFD accessories!

AutomationDirect carries a full line of AC drives, from basic micro drives to full-featured high-performance drives boasting flux vector control and built-in PLCs. So no matter the application or environment, AutomationDirect has an affordable drive solution for you!

Micro VFDs

General Purpose VFDs

High Performance VFDs

Washdown VFDs

With sizes as small as 55mm wide, these drives provide the needed motor speed control without taking up large amounts of panel space.

General purpose drives offer great value for a wide variety of applications including conveyors, pumps, fans, HVAC systems, and elevators.

High-performance AC drives are top-of-the-line drives that are usually specified when a high degree of precision in speed control is required or when full torque is needed at very low or zero speeds.

These NEMA 4X, washdown-duty drives are built to withstand harsh environments including food and beverage processing and water treatment facilities.

Starting at $119.00

Starting at $147.00

Starting at $232.00

Starting at $242.00

Research, price, buy at: www.automationdirect.com/ac-drives TOP RATED

Order Today, Ships Fast! * See our Web site for details and restrictions. © Copyright 2025 AutomationDirect, Cumming, GA USA. All rights reserved.

AutomationDirect_C2.indd 2

BY CUSTOMERS

1-800-633-0405

the #1 value in automation

1/22/25 3:08 PM

Cut your costs, Bulk up on savings Order your cut-to-length and bulk cables today and save with AutomationDirect’s affordable pricing - No gimmicks. No hidden charges.

A wide variety of cable available in bulk or cut-to-length sizes and shipped fast!

Cut-to-Length Cables with NO Hidden Fees All our multi-conductor cables can be ordered cut to your specified lengths without added cutting charges, hidden fees, or inflated shipping costs found with other suppliers.

With AutomationDirect you get: • UL certified re-spooling facility ensures that our cut-to-length cables maintain their UL certifications • Low price per foot starting at $0.18/ft.

• Free, fast shipping (typically 2-day delivery)* • Easy online, phone or email ordering

• Low minimum cut lengths • 45-day money-back guarantee* (yes, even custom cut cable)

Newest Additions

Starting at $0.33 /ft. (20 ft. min) Helukabel® unshielded “extra hard use” 600V SOOW and 300V SJOOW portable cord is used in applications with portable equipment such as power tools or temporary installations such as work site lighting. EPDM thermoset rubber conductor insulation material and a black CPE thermoset rubber jacket provide excellent resistance to abrasion, hot surface contact, harsh conditions, and extreme temperatures.

• Available in 18 AWG to 6 AWG sizes • 2, 3, 4, or 5 conductors • Cut to length in 1-foot increments • Complies with NFPA 70 Articles 400 & 501.140 (Haz-Loc)

• Carries the appropriate UL, CSA, or MSHA ratings so they can be trusted to work in the harshest environments

Bulk Electrical Hook-up/Building Wire AutomationDirect has a large selection of quality electrical MTW, THHN, DLO, TFFN, AWM, and HAR wire in pre-spooled lengths that meets all NFPA and NEC requirements at great prices.

Research, price, buy at:

www.automationdirect.com/multi-conductor-cable www.automationdirect.com/wire TOP RATED

Order Today, Ships Fast! * See our Web site for details and restrictions. © Copyright 2025 AutomationDirect, Cumming, GA USA. All rights reserved.

AutomationDirect_pg1.indd 1

BY CUSTOMERS

1-800-633-0405

the #1 value in automation

1/22/25 3:08 PM

Are you ready f

SECURE YOUR DOMEST

NOW

Weldbends_Sprd_2_3.indd 2

1/28/25 10:44 AM

y for the Tariffs?

MESTIC SUPPLY CHAIN

NOW!

We are the ONLY

Domestic carbon steel

manufacturer

of both

fittings & flanges

that uses

NO Chinese raw material in any of our products

weldbend.com Weldbends_Sprd_2_3.indd 3

1/28/25 10:44 AM

WE TAKE THE HEAT SO YOU DON’T HAVE TO. When the pressure’s on to get the job done, our lubricants help keep your operation running strong. Mystik® Greases contain shear-stable thickeners and a proprietary combination of high-performance additives that provide superior protection in severe duty steel mill applications.

MADE TO MAKE IT LAST.

CITGO Mystik_pg4.indd 4

1/22/25 3:10 PM

Vol. 79 • No 1

Contents JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2025

12

VIEWPOINT

SOLUTIONS

7 | The best way for professionals to advance their careers

30 | How to use energy-efficient motors and drives to save money

Continuing education via B2B resources is the fastest way to gain knowledge.

Variable frequency drives (VFDs) and switched reluctance (SR) can offer manufacturers energy savings and environmental benefits.

INSIGHTS 8 | Is your facility watching these powerful electrical system trends?

These powerful electrical trends could reshape the way plants are designed.

SOLUTIONS 12 | Balance in high-output manufacturing with low energy Manufacturers face a dilemma: boost production while minimizing energy consumption.

18 | Energy-efficient manufacturing with smart technology Smart manufacturing can cut energy consumption, pollution and improve efficiency.

22 | How to ensure reliable motor operation with VFD There are some best practices when it comes to variable frequency drives (VFDs), which ensure reliable motor operations.

ON THE COVER:

The GA 450 FD 2400 VSD+ Smart AIR solution combines high-efficiency compressors with intelligent control systems, optimizing energy use and reducing operational costs for large industrial facilities. Courtesy: Atlas Copco Compressors

p. 18 p. 30

34 | How to select PPE to protect against airborne hazards Airborne hazards in your workplace may make specialized personal protective equipment necessary.

37 | Fall protection focus: What to know about body harnesses When it comes to fall protection, fit and personalization are critical to harness selection.

41 | Here are the facts and myths about appropriate PPE

p.34

Choosing the right personal protective equipment (PPE) means seeking out the proper fit and making sure it meets regulatory standards.

45 | How to build a maintenance program for expansion joints Expansion joints require a reliable maintenance program given the vital role they play in accommodating thermal expansion and other piping system movements.

PLANT ENGINEERING (ISSN 0032-082X, Vol. 79, No. 1, GST #123397457) is published bimonthly by WTWH Media, LLC; 1111 Superior Ave., Suite 2600, Cleveland, OH 44114. Periodicals postage paid at Cleveland, OH and additional mailing offices.

POSTMASTER: Send address changes to PLANT ENGINEERING, 1111 Superior Ave., Suite 2600, Cleveland, OH 44114. Scott McCafferty, Co-Founder. PLANT ENGINEERING copyright 2025 by WTWH Media, LLC. All rights reserved. PLANT ENGINEERING is a registered trademark of WTWH Media, LLC used under license. Circulation records are maintained at WTWH Media, LLC; 1111 Superior Ave., Suite 2600, Cleveland, OH 44114. E-mail: pe@omeda.com. Publications Mail Agreement No. 40685520. Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to: 1111 Superior Ave., Suite 2600, Cleveland, OH 44114. Email: pe@omeda.com. Rates for non-qualified subscriptions, including all issues: USA, $120/yr; Canada/Mexico, $150/yr (includes 7% GST, GST#123397457); International air delivery $260/yr. Except for special issues where price changes are indicated, single copies are available for $30 US, $35 foreign. Please address all subscription mail to: PLANT ENGINEERING, 1111 Superior Ave., Suite 2600, Cleveland, OH 44114. Printed in the USA. WTWH Media, LLC, does not assume and hereby disclaims any liability to any person for any loss or damage caused by errors or omissions in the material contained herein, regardless of whether such errors result from negligence, accident or any other cause whatsoever.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_TOC_V4msFINAL.indd 5

January/February 2025

|5 1/28/25 3:15 PM

ELEVATE YOUR PLANT MAINTENANCE PROGRAM...

WITH LUBRIPLATE ® 100% SYNTHETIC ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY LUBRICANTS. Lubriplate’s ultra-high-performance, 100% synthetic lubricants have been engineered to provide unsurpassed performance in the most demanding plant environments. They provide a wide range of benefits designed to make your plant run better. Benefits include: extended lubrication intervals, lubrication consolidation through multiple application capability, reduced friction, extended machinery life and reduced downtime. Products include...

HIGH-PERFORMANCE SYNTHETIC GEAR OILS SYNTHETIC AIR COMPRESSOR FLUIDS SYNTHETIC HYDRAULIC FLUIDS HIGH-PERFORMANCE SYNTHETIC GREASES NSF H1 REGISTERED FOOD GRADE LUBRICANTS ECO-FRIENDLY SYNTHETIC LUBRICANTS SPECIALTY LUBRICANTS Scan the QR Code for More Information About Lubriplate’s Products and Services.

INCLUDED AT NO ADDITIONAL CHARGE

Lubriplate’s

ESP

Complimentary Extra Services Package

Newark, NJ 07105 / Toledo, OH 43605 / 800-733-4755 To learn more visit us at: www.lubriplate.com

Lubriplate_pg6.indd 6

COLOR CODED LUBE CHARTS & MACHINERY TAGS PLANT SURVEYS / TECH SUPPORT / TRAINING LUBRICATION SOFTWARE / FOLLOW-UP OIL ANALYSIS

1/22/25 3:20 PM

CONTENT

INSIGHTS

CONTENT SPECIALISTS/EDITORIAL

VIEWPOINT

AMARA ROZGUS, Editor-in-Chief ARozgus@WTWHMedia.com

SHERI KASPRZAK, Managing Editor SKasprzak@WTWHMedia.com MICHAEL SMITH, Art Director MSmith@WTWHMedia.com AMANDA PELLICCIONE, Marketing Research Manager APelliccione@WTWHMedia.com SUSIE BAK, Staff Accountant SBak@WTWHMedia.com

EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD H. LANDIS “LANNY” FLOYD, IEEE Life Fellow JOHN GLENSKI, Principal, Automation & Digital Strategy, Plus Group, A Salas O'Brien Company MATTHEW GOSS, PE, PMP, CEM, CEA, CDSM, LEED AP, Senior Vice President, CDM Smith

CONTRIBUTORS WANTED Are you a subject matter expert in one of these topics? Would you like to write an article on one of the topics below? If so, please submit an idea to: https://tinyurl.com/PlantEngineeringSubmissions • EV charging systems • Expert Q&A: Asset management • Expert Q&A: Hazard protection, hazardous environments • Fall protection • Fluid performance • Lubrication • Motor calculations • Predictive maintenance

WTWH Media Contributor Guidelines Overview Content For Engineers. WTWH Media focuses on engineers sharing with their peers. We welcome content submissions for all interested parties in engineering. We will use those materials online, on our Website, in print and in newsletters to keep engineers informed about the products, solutions and industry trends. * https://tinyurl.com/PlantEngineeringSubmissions gives an overview of how to submit press releases, products, images and graphics, bylined feature articles, case studies, white papers and other media. * Content should focus on helping engineers solve problems. Articles that are commercial in nature or that are critical of other products or organizations will be rejected.

(Technology discussions and comparative tables may be accepted if nonpromotional and if contributor corroborates information with sources cited.) * If the content meets criteria noted in guidelines, expect to see it first on the website. Content for enewsletters comes from content already available on the website.

All content for print also will be online. All content that appears in the print magazine will appear as space permits, and we will indicate in print if more content from that article is available online. * Deadlines for feature articles vary based on where it appears. Print-related content is due at least three months in advance of the publication date. Again, it is best to discuss all feature articles with the content manager prior to submission.

LEARN MORE AT: https://tinyurl.com/PlantEngineeringSubmissions

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_INSIGHT_VIEWPOINT_V3msFINAL_converted.indd 7

What's the best way for manufacturing professionals to advance their career?

Continuing education via B2B resources is the fastest way to gain knowledge.

I

safety updates, these resources deliver n manufacturing and industritargeted knowledge directly to your al operations, staying ahead often inbox or desk. comes down to one thing: knowledge. With advancements in technology, shifts in regulations and the Webcasts, education growing emphasis on sustainability Webcasts have become a powerand efficiency, professionhouse for learning. These als at every level must cononline sessions bring experts tinuously learn to remain right to your office or plant, effective. offering in-depth presenHere’s the good news: tations on everything from continuing education has motor troubleshooting to never been more accessible, energy efficiency strategies. thanks to business-to-busiThe best part? They’re often Amara Rozgus, ness (B2B) media. Yes, this is interactive, allowing you to Editor-in-Chief a shameless plug. ask questions and engage Think about the challenges you with peers facing similar challenges. face daily — streamlining processes, reducing downtime, improving Technical articles safety protocols and meeting cusand case studies tomer demands. How do you stay on B2B websites are treasure troves of top of it all? The answer lies in leverinformation. Articles and case studaging the wealth of resources. From ies give you quick, digestible insights newsletters and articles to webinars into real-world applications. For and in-depth training sessions, B2B instance, learning how another facilmedia offers tailored, actionable ity reduced downtime by upgrading insights that can help you navigate its compressed air system could spark these challenges. ideas for your own operations.

Here are some of the key ways to get continuing education: Investing in your education Continuing education isn’t just about staying current — it’s about Publications and newsletters improving your performance, Magazines and enewsletters advancing your career and driving remain go-to resources for many in innovation in your facility. Take the the field. Why? Because they’re curatfirst step today: sign up for a newsleted with industry-specific information ter, register for a webcast or explore you can trust. Whether it’s a technia trusted B2B website. The tools you cal deep dive into predictive mainneed are out there. PE tenance or a roundup of the latest January/February 2025

|7 1/28/25 10:54 AM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS POWER

Is your facility watching these powerful electrical system trends?

New trends in power systems will change the ways in which plants are designed. Our panel of experts weighs in on the electrical trends you need to know about.

General electrical and power systems Question: What’s the current trend in electrical and power systems for industrial and manufacturing facilities?

Learning

Objectives

u

•U nderstand how current

trends in electrical and power systems will impact manufacturers in the year ahead.

• D etermine how future key

trends will shape the ways in which manufacturers design their plants.

• L earn about the factors impacting electrical system efficiency.

Lee Ward: There are generally two schools of thought: Investment in renewable power generation sources or expansion in the cleaner fossil fuel generation sources. There is ongoing risk discussion around grid reliability vs. investment in self-sufficiency as a risk mitigation strategy. In addition to those topics, the over-arching specter of the cybersecurity challenge and how, if not given the true deference it deserves, cybersecurity risk can have a major impact on the business.

Lanny Floyd: Higher energy density.

Question: What future trends should engineers, plant managers and designers expect for such projects? (Looking ahead one to two years.)

Ward: Regardless of the generation genre, it is essential for them to harden their cybersecurity to reduce system vulnerabilities at the grassroots level, making the facility not only serviceable but also well-defended. My main concern is that when it comes to plant investment, expansion, or greenfield projects, a greater emphasis is often placed on capacity and the overall outcome of the project

8 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_INSIGHTS_QA_POWERELEC_V2msFINAL.indd 8

rather than prioritizing the core control infrastructure, which poses the highest risk.

Floyd: Equipment with reduced exposure to hazardous electrical energy, increased capability for condition monitoring to enhances safety and reliability.

Question: What are the most critical power system maintenance practices that facility managers should prioritize to minimize unplanned downtime and maintain system reliability?

Ward: Asset visibility is the most overlooked practice. Other than routine mechanical operations, the digital information provided by equipment is often overlooked. Condition monitoring typically only occurs when a failure is imminent, but your equipment can be telling a story long before a catastrophic failure occurs. Runtime hours, duty cycles, incremental sensor readings all contribute to this valuable insight. Prioritize new analytics and predictive models to prevent unplanned downtime and avoid catastrophic capital equipment failures.

Question: Are you incorporating electric vehicle charging stations and if so, what power pros and cons have you come across?

B.J. Hanson: Yes, we are incorporating EV charging stations but are not seeing large-scale adoption yet, at least on larger installations. However, we do expect the NEVI initiative to help increase that adoption. Electric vehicle (EV) charging stations and EV's in general, certainly offer several benefits, including reducing greenhouse gas emissions, supporting the adoption of clean energy and improving air quality. They provide convenience for EV owners and can integrate Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:49 PM

with renewable energy sources for a sustainable charging option. However, challenges include high installation costs, particularly for fast-charging stations and the need for significant infrastructure upgrades to handle increased demand. In certain locations charging stations can also strain the power grid, especially during peak hours, requiring smart grid solutions. Additionally, the environmental impact of local electricity generation and battery disposal must be considered to ensure overall sustainability.

Question: Is your facility implementing microgrid or renewable power systems? Describe the project.

Ward: Rockwell Automation has a microgrid controller application that is based on its PlantPAx® process controls platform. It is designed to monitor, manage and dispatch generating assets, as well as curtail loads when necessary. In addition, it provides visibility into asset operations and maintenance, equipment availability and performance insights. Notably, PlantPAx® is designed with security as a top priority and offers flexible configuration options along with extensive scaleability.

Question: What techniques have you used to mitigate harmonics in a facility?

Hanson: We have helped customers install lineside power quality products, such as line reactors, passive and active harmonic filters, dc link chokes.

In doing so, we aim to help customers meet Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Standard 519 (IEEE-519) for total harmonic distortion within their facility.

Ward: Equipment that tends to create harmonics typically includes devices that modify the regular sine wave, such as inverters or variable frequency drives (VFDs). If such devices are already in use or if we are supplying new equipment, then using active front-end VFDs or 18-pulse VFDs with line reactors and filters can help mitigate these disturbances. For existing equipment, either active or passive line filtering can be used to address the issue.

Question: What are some key trends in power distribution and automation that facility managers should be aware of and how might these trends impact future investments in electrical systems?

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_INSIGHTS_QA_POWERELEC_V2msFINAL.indd 9

Floyd: Equipment with reduced exposure to arc flash and electric shock hazards, enhanced capability of condition-based monitoring.

Ward: The biggest trend in power distribution is twofold: enhancing asset visibility regarding power quality data and critical measurands and protecting the power system from malicious intrusion.

Participants

Electrical and power systems (efficiency) Question: What are the key factors influencing electrical system efficiency?

Ward: Key factors influencing electrical system efficiency include understanding how to manage loads in relation to operating conditions and selecting the appropriate generation source at any given time.

Modern technologies, such as artificial intelligence, can help in the decision-making process, as there are multiple dynamic factors at play.

Floyd: Managing power quality, which includes harmonics and voltage balance.

Question: How does power factor correction impact overall system efficiency?

Hanson: Power factor (PF) correction improves system efficiency by reducing the reactive power, which does not contribute to useful work. Power factors closer to 1.0, lowers the total current flowing through electrical systems, thus reducing energy losses in transmission lines, transformers and equipment. By improving the PF, there is less heat generation from the equipment, as well as less stress and wear. It also helps optimize capacity, allowing for better use of existing infrastructure without overloading. Additionally, some utilities impose penalties or charges when PF drops below 0.90, therefore, correction of PF may reduce demand charges or penalties from utilities leading to cost savings. Overall, PF correction enhances voltage stability, improves power quality and ensures more effective use of electrical resources, increasing overall system efficiency.

Floyd: It improves efficiency by reducing nonproductive losses in power distribution equipment.

B.J. Hanson

Energy Solutions Business Development Lead Werner Electric Supply Appleton, Wisconsin

Lanny Floyd

Owner and Principal Consultant Electrical Safety Group Inc. Elkton, Maryland

Lee Ward

Industry Sales Manager Process, Mining, Cement and Power Generation Rockwell Automation Marlborough, Massachusetts

Question: Can you explain the concept of demand-side management and its role in improving system efficiency?

January/February 2025

|9 1/22/25 3:49 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS POWER

‘

Using artificial intelligence in decision-making processes provides owners and operators with valuable insights into plant and equipment operation.

’

Insights

u

Power and electrical insights u Industrial power

generation sources could be shifting towards renewable sources or investments in cleaner fossil fuels.

u Manufacturers are

developing techniques to mitigate harmonics in facilities.

u Facilities are seeking

out way to enhance overall equipment efficiency.

Hanson: Demand-side management (DSM) refers to strategies that encourage consumers to adjust their energy usage to improve system efficiency. This can include reducing overall consumption, shifting energy use to off-peak times, or using more efficient equipment. DSM helps balance demand with supply, reducing the need for additional generation capacity and lowering peak demand. By optimizing energy use, it also minimizes system losses, reduces strain on infrastructure and lowers operational costs. DSM improves grid stability, reduces emissions and lowers consumer energy costs, playing a crucial role in enhancing the overall efficiency and sustainability of the energy system.

Question: How can we optimize the efficiency of electrical motors in industrial applications?

Hanson: The first and easiest way to optimize the efficiency of electrical motors in industrial applications is to ensure they only run when needed. Additional controls can monitor motors and shut them down motors when they're not needed. Utilizing variable frequency drives (VFDs) can adjust motor speed based on demand, reducing energy consumption.

Regular maintenance, such as cleaning and lubrication, ensures smooth operation and reduces friction losses. Use high-efficiency motors with better insulation and cooling designs to minimize energy waste.

Additionally, optimize motor control systems and improve load management by avoiding motor overloading. Finally, ensure proper alignment and balance of motor-driven equipment to reduce mechanical losses and enhance overall motor performance.

Ward: Using intelligent motor control with modern devices, such as electronic overloads, soft starters and VFDs, provides operational and situational data that can deliver real-time motor conditions and therefore encourage efficiencies and awareness of anomalies.

Question: How can predictive maintenance and advanced monitoring systems enhance the efficiency of power systems?

10 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_INSIGHTS_QA_POWERELEC_V2msFINAL.indd 10

Hanson: Advanced monitoring systems, like steam trap and compressed air leak monitoring, enhance power system efficiency by detecting inefficiencies and enabling timely maintenance.

Steam trap monitoring identifies failed traps, preventing steam loss and optimizing heat recovery. Compressed air leak monitoring detects leaks that waste energy, ensuring the system operates at peak efficiency. These systems provide real-time data, allowing for proactive repairs and minimizing energy waste. By improving system reliability, reducing energy consumption and lowering operational costs, advanced monitoring systems help maintain optimal performance, extend equipment life and contribute to overall energy efficiency in power systems.

Ward: This trend uses intelligent devices to enhance operations. It is much more cost-effective and efficient to plan and manage asset outages, making sure the right parts and resources are available for maintenance activities, rather than responding reactively to unexpected downtime events.

Question: What trends or technologies can significantly increase electrical system efficiency?

Ward: Using artificial intelligence in decision-making processes provides owners and operators with valuable insights into plant and equipment operation. This leads to better management of profits and costs, as well as enhanced efficiency and, in many instances, extending an asset's operating lifecycle.

Hanson: Emerging technologies like artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning and advanced system controls are poised to significantly boost electrical system efficiency. AI-powered monitoring systems can analyze vast amounts of real-time data to predict and optimize energy consumption, identify inefficiencies and enhance decision-making. Smart grids enable dynamic load balancing, demand response and integration of renewable energy sources, improving system flexibility.

IoT-based sensors offer continuous performance insights, while automation and predictive maintenance reduce downtime and optimize asset management. PE

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:49 PM

*Based on current (March 2024) efficiency data published in accordance with the Compressed Air and Gas Institute (CAGI) third-party verification program.

CELEBRATING 60 YEARS OF PERFORMANCE.

NOW AVAILABLE IN TWO-STAGE COMPRESSION HitachiGlobalAirPower.com/Industrial ©2025 Hitachi Global Air Power US, LLC. All rights reserved.

Sullair (Hitachi)_pg11.indd 11

1/22/25 3:33 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND MANAGEMENT

Jayme Leonard, Atlas Copco Compressors, Rock Hill, South Carolina

Finding balance in high-output manufacturing with low energy consumption As manufacturers face rising global demands for efficiency and environmental responsibility, they encounter a dual challenge: how to boost output while minimizing energy consumption.

I

n manufacturing, companies are under increasing pressure to enhance efficiency and productivity while simultaneously minimizing energy consumption. This dual challenge is driven by the need to stay competitive in a global market and comply with stringent environmental regula-

FIGURE 1: Atlas Copco's air quality monitor provides real-time monitoring of air purity, ensuring compliance with quality standards and enhancing operational efficiency in compressed air systems. Courtesy: Atlas Copco Compressors

12 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_MAX_ATLASCOPCO_V4msFINAL.indd 12

tions. As the world grapples with climate change, energy conservation has become a critical component of both environmental and economic sustainability.

Global energy and climate initiatives, such as the Paris Agreement, are pushing industries to reduce their carbon footprints and adopt more sustainable practices. For manufacturers, this means finding ways to maximize output while reducing energy usage. This is not only important for compliance but also for gaining a competitive advantage in an increasingly eco-conscious market.

One of the most significant energy challenges in manufacturing is managing energy-intensive processes like air compression, which powers pneumatic tools, conveyors and assembly equipment.

These systems often account for a substantial portion of a facility’s energy expenses, particularly if they are not optimized for efficiency.

To address these challenges, manufacturers are turning to advanced technologies, process innovations and renewable energy sources. By embracing these strategies, they can achieve sustainable productivity that benefits both their business and the environment.

Understanding energy consumption in manufacturing To effectively minimize energy usage, it’s essential to first understand where energy is being consumed across the manufacturing industry. In manufacturing facilities, energy is typically directed toward several key areas, including machine operations, lighting, climate control and compressed air systems. Among these, air compression alone can represent 10% to 30% of a facility’s energy costs, depending on the sector and scale of production.

According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), the manufacturing sector consumed approximately 19,436 trillion British Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:51 PM

thermal units (Btu) of energy in 2018. This consumption is distributed across various subsectors, with chemicals, petroleum and coal products, paper and primary metals being the top energy consumers On average, manufacturing facilities use 95.1 kilowatt-hours of electricity and 536,500 Btu of natural gas per square foot each year.

High energy consumption in manufacturing not only leads to increased operational costs but also has significant environmental impacts. The manufacturing industry accounts for about 20% of global greenhouse gas emissions. Reducing energy consumption is critical for both financial savings and environmental sustainability. By implementing energy-efficient practices and technologies, manufacturers can lower their energy bills and reduce their carbon footprint, contributing to global efforts to combat climate change.

By identifying these high-energy areas and deploying targeted solutions, manufacturers can establish more efficient workflows and reduce unnecessary power consumption.

Advanced manufacturing technologies: pathways to efficiency Technological advancements have enabled manufacturers to boost productivity while reducing energy demands. By combining automation, data analytics and smart systems, facilities are now able to achieve precise control over energy consumption, tailoring use to real-time production needs.

Key technologies in this domain include: Automation and robotics: Modern automated systems and robotics have transformed assembly lines, offering faster production with greater accuracy. These systems can operate only when needed, conserving energy during idle periods.

For example, integrating compressors with automation allows them to function only when tools are active, reducing unnecessary energy use. Automation also helps reduce human error, streamlining production and conserving power by minimizing unnecessary processes.

Data analytics and machine learning: Data-driven insights are invaluable in detecting inefficiencies, predicting equipment failures and optimizing schedules. In compressed air systems, for example, data analytics can highlight periods of peak usage, detect minor leaks and identify points where system pressure may be unnecessarily high.

These insights allow facilities to adjust, lower presPlant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_MAX_ATLASCOPCO_V4msFINAL.indd 13

FIGURE 2: Atlas Copco’s energy recovery systems capture heat generated by compressors and repurpose it for facility heating, like showers or radiators, reducing both energy costs and environmental impact. Courtesy: Atlas Copco Compressors

‘

sure or schedule maintenance before energy losses Manufacturers accumulate, leading to cost savings and improved compressor longevity. are turning to Additive manufacturing: In sectors that have adopted 3D printing and other additive manufacadvanced techturing technologies, there is a noticeable reducnologies, process tion in both energy and material waste. By creating parts layer by layer, these methods eliminate the innovations and need for complex tooling and excess material, which traditionally require significant energy for renewable energy processing and handling. Additionally, additive manufacturing often reduces reliance on air-powsources. ered equipment, contributing to lower overall energy consumption.

IoT and smart factories: Internet of things (IoT)-enabled factories use connected devices, sensors and smart equipment to monitor energy use in real-time. Air compressors equipped with IoT sensors can monitor their own performance, adapting pressure levels based on demand fluctuations.

This dynamic control results in significant energy savings, especially during periods of low activity.

Moreover, IoT data can be aggregated and analyzed u to fine-tune equipment settings and identify fur• Understand the role ther optimization opportunities across the facility. of energy efficiency in By leveraging these advanced manufacturing manufacturing. technologies, companies can significantly enhance • Explore advanced technologies for their energy efficiency while maintaining high levsustainable manufacturing. els of productivity. These innovations not only help • Examine regulatory and in reducing operational costs but also contribute to financial incentives for a more sustainable manufacturing process. energy efficiency.

’

Learning

Objectives

January/February 2025

| 13 1/22/25 3:51 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND MANAGEMENT

reduce the need for frequent start-ups and shutdowns. For air compressors, this approach means maintaining a steady, lower-pressure output rather than continually ramping up and down.

By implementing these efficient processes and redesigning workflows, manufacturers can significantly reduce energy consumption while maintaining high levels of productivity. These strategies not only help in lowering operational costs but also contribute to a more sustainable manufacturing process.

FIGURE 3: Atlas Copco's GA 450 FD 2400 VSD+ Smart AIR solution combines high-efficiency compressors with intelligent control systems, optimizing energy use and reducing operational costs for large industrial facilities. Courtesy: Atlas Copco Compressors

Efficient production processes A well-designed workflow is essential for achieving sustainable productivity. By examining and rethinking how processes are structured, manufacturers can find multiple points of improvement that reduce energy use while maintaining output levels.

Lean manufacturing focuses on waste reduction, aiming to cut out unnecessary steps and resources, including energy. In lean environments, equipment such as air compressors are programmed to operate only when required, reducing energy usage during inactive periods. By setting parameters around operational needs, lean manufacturing eliminates unnecessary energy consumption.

Air compressors and other heavy equipment generate substantial heat, most of which goes to waste. By capturing and redirecting this heat, facilities can warm office spaces, pre-heat water or use it for other on-site applications. Heat recovery is particularly beneficial in colder climates, where offsetting traditional heating costs can make a notable difference in energy costs. Manufacturers can install heat exchangers to funnel compressor-generated heat into facility-wide heating systems, creating an efficient loop that repurposes waste energy Continuous production processes generally consume less energy than batch processes, as they

14 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_MAX_ATLASCOPCO_V4msFINAL.indd 14

Renewable and alternative energy sources Renewable energy adoption is a powerful strategy in the quest to reduce energy costs and environmental impact. By harnessing solar, wind or geothermal power, manufacturers can power their facilities and processes sustainably.

Solar and wind energy: Facilities equipped with solar panels or wind turbines can offset energy used for lighting, climate control and even air compressors. In this setup, smart control systems can prioritize renewable energy sources, switching to grid power only when renewable generation is insufficient. For example, a study by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory highlights how advanced manufacturing technologies can integrate renewable energy to power processes, thereby reducing reliance on traditional power sources.

Biomass and geothermal energy: Biomass and geothermal energy are also viable options for manufacturing facilities. Biomass can be particularly useful for energy-intensive industries that require high-temperature heat, such as the chemical and metal sectors. Geothermal energy, while less common, provides a stable and continuous energy source that can be used for both heating and electricity generation.

Benefits of renewable energy integration Integrating renewable energy sources into manufacturing processes offers several benefits: • Cost savings: Reducing reliance on traditional energy sources can lead to significant cost savings over time.

• Environmental impact: Lowering greenhouse gas emissions contributes to global efforts to combat climate change.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:51 PM

‘

A well-designed

• Energy security: Diversifying energy sources enhances energy security and reduces vulnerability to energy price fluctuations.

Smart equipment and high-efficiency machinery The development of smart equipment and high-efficiency machinery marks a significant shift in the manufacturing industry, enabling companies to reduce energy consumption while maintaining or even increasing productivity. These innovations are driven by advancements in technology, including the industrial IoT (IIoT), artificial intelligence (AI) and robotics.

Industrial internet of things: The IIoT involves a network of interconnected machinery, tools and sensors that communicate with each other and the cloud to collect and share data. This connectivity allows for real-time monitoring and management of equipment, leading to improved efficiency and reduced energy consumption. For example, IIoT-enabled air compressors can adjust their operation based on real-time demand, minimizing energy waste during periods of low activity.

AI and machine learning: AI and machine learning algorithms analyze data collected from IIoT devices to optimize production processes and predict equipment maintenance needs. This predictive maintenance approach helps prevent unexpected breakdowns and reduces downtime, ensuring that machinery operates at peak efficiency. AI can also identify patterns and trends in energy usage, allowing manufacturers to implement energy-saving measures more effectively.

Robotics and automation: Robotic process automation has revolutionized manufacturing by taking on repetitive and dangerous tasks, improving product quality and reducing defects. Robots can perform tasks faster and with greater precision than human workers, leading to increased productivity and lower energy consumption.

For instance, robots integrated with IIoT sensors can optimize their operations based on real-time data, further enhancing energy efficiency.

By adopting smart equipment and high-efficiency machinery, manufacturers can significantly reduce their energy consumption and operational costs.

These technologies not only enhance productivity but also contribute to a more sustainable manufacturing process.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_MAX_ATLASCOPCO_V4msFINAL.indd 15

workflow is Energy regulations and incentives Government regulations and incentives play a cruessential for cial role in promoting energy efficiency in the manufacturing sector. These are designed to incentivize achieving companies to adopt energy-efficient technologies and practices, thereby reducing their environmental sustainable impact and operational costs.

Environmental regulations set standards that productivity. manufacturers must meet to reduce their energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions. These regulations often include mandatory energy audits, efficiency targets and reporting requirements.

For example, the European Union’s Energy Efficiency Directive requires member states to achieve specific energy savings targets through various measures, including improving industrial energy efficiency. Similarly, the U.S. Department of Energy has established energy efficiency standards for industrial equipment, such as air compressors, to ensure they operate more efficiently.

To support compliance with these regulations, governments offer various incentives and subsidies.

These can include tax credits, grants and low-interest loans for companies that invest in energy-efficient technologies.

For instance, the U.S. federal government provides tax incentives for businesses that implement energy-saving measures, such as upgrading to high-efficiency motors and installing renewable energy systems.

The benefits of these regulatory measures and incentives are manifold: • Cost savings: Companies can reduce their energy bills and operational costs by adopting energy-efu ficient technologies.

• Environmental impact: Lower energy conEnergy insights sumption leads to reduced greenhouse gas emisu Meeting energy goals sions, contributing to global climate goals. requires integrating • Competitive advantage: Companies that invest advanced technologies in energy efficiency can gain a competitive edge by and sustainable practices that not only streamline reducing costs and enhancing their sustainability operations but also profile. contribute to long-term savings and compliance • Innovation: Regulations and incentives drive with climate-focused innovation in energy-efficient technologies and pracregulations. tices, fostering a culture of continuous improvement. u Learn strategies to By leveraging government regulations and incenbalance high-output manufacturing with low tives, manufacturers can enhance their energy energy consumption efficiency, reduce costs and contribute to a more susfor overall sustainable tainable future. productivity.

’

Insights

January/February 2025

| 15 1/22/25 3:51 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND MANAGEMENT

FIGURE 4: Atlas Copco's ZR 315 VSD compressor, combined with the Optimizer four.0, delivers energy-efficient, oil-free air with smart monitoring capabilities, enabling optimized performance and reduced energy consumption in industrial applications. Courtesy: Atlas Copco Compressors

Challenges in implementing energy efficiency regulations Implementing energy efficiency regulations in the manufacturing sector presents several challenges. These obstacles can hinder the adoption of energy-efficient practices and technologies, despite the potential benefits. Here are some of the key challenges: Financial barriers: One of the most significant challenges is the high upfront cost associated with energy-efficient technologies. Many manufacturers are hesitant to invest in new equipment or upgrade existing systems due to the substantial initial cost. Although these investments often lead to long-term savings, the immediate financial burden can be a deterrent, especially for small and medium-sized companies.

Lack of awareness and information: Another major barrier is the lack of awareness and information about the benefits of energy efficiency and the available technologies. This knowledge gap can prevent companies from taking the necessary steps to improve their energy performance.

Technical challenges: Implementing energy efficiency measures often requires specialized knowledge and technical expertise. Manufacturers may lack the in-house capabilities to assess their energy use and identify opportunities for

16 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_MAX_ATLASCOPCO_V4msFINAL.indd 16

improvement. Additionally, integrating new technologies into existing systems can be complex and may require significant modifications to current processes.

Market and economic barriers: Market conditions and economic factors can also pose challenges. For example, fluctuating energy prices can impact the perceived value of energy efficiency investments. When energy prices are low, the financial incentive to reduce energy consumption diminishes. Additionally, the availability of financing options for energy efficiency projects can be limited, making it difficult for companies to secure the necessary funds.

Balancing high productivity with low energy use is a critical challenge in modern manufacturing. As industries strive to meet increasing production demands while minimizing their environmental impact, the adoption of energy-efficient technologies and practices becomes essential. This balance not only helps companies comply with environmental regulations but also enhances their competitive edge in a market that increasingly values sustainability.

While the initial investment in efficient technologies and processes can be substantial, the long-term benefits far outweigh the costs. Financially, companies can achieve significant savings through reduced energy consumption and lower operational costs. Environmentally, these practices contribute to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and the conservation of natural resources, aligning with global climate initiatives.

Competitively, manufacturers that prioritize energy efficiency can improve their market position by demonstrating a commitment to sustainability, attracting eco-conscious consumers and partners.

The journey toward energy-efficient manufacturing is not without its challenges, but the rewards — financial, environmental and competitive — make it a necessary and worthwhile endeavor. By embracing advanced technologies, optimizing production processes and fostering a culture of continuous improvement, manufacturers can achieve sustainable productivity that benefits both the business and the planet. PE Jayme Leonard is a Digital Marketing Specialist at Atlas Copco Compressors.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:51 PM

Decarbonize with Confidence From figuring it out to getting it done, Air Products is making decarbonization real.

The world’s largest hydrogen producer and a first-mover in the low- and zero-carbon hydrogen economy, Air Products is helping boiler manufacturers navigate the complexities of decarbonization with highefficiency, low-emissions combustion technologies and safe, reliable clean hydrogen solutions.

With a $15 billion commitment to near-term clean energy projects, we’re ready to help you harness the full potential of clean hydrogen as we empower you to decarbonize efficiently, sustainably, and confidently— leading you from now to net zero.

Call Air Products today to see how we can tailor our production, operations, logistics, and applications expertise to your unique needs . . . 800-NEED-GAS (800-633-3427).

airproducts.com/decarbonize

GENERATING A CLEANER FUTURE © Air Products and Chemicals, Inc., 2023 (46201)

Air Products_pg17.indd 17

1/22/25 3:07 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND MANAGEMENT Adam Mullen, Plex, Detroit

Energy-efficient manufacturing with smart technology Smart manufacturing can help manufacturers reduce energy consumption, waste and pollution while improving operational efficiency and product quality.

FIGURE 1: Plex programming can be easily accessed on the plant floor. Courtesy: Plex, by Rockwell Automation

Learning

Objectives

u

• Learn the role of smart manufacturing in improving energy efficiency.

• Understand the impact of manufacturing on energy consumption in thSe environment.

•S ee the benefits of smart manufacturing for overall operational performance.

G

lobal energy consumption continues to grow at a steady rate of a few percentage points annually. Compounded over time, this trend has led to an explosion of energy use over the past several decades. One of the primary drivers of this consumption is the industrial sector.

According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), the industrial sector accounted for 37% of global energy consumption this past year. This qualifies the industry as one of the largest contributors to greenhouse gas emissions. Given the manufacturing sector's central role within the industrial sector, its energy-intensive processes significantly contribute to overall energy consumption.

To address these trends, regulatory bodies and the federal government have enacted policies targeted at reducing emissions and waste across various industries. For example, the Inflation Reduction Act aims to reduce the United States’ production of carbon emissions by 40% ahead of 2030 while the Federal Buy Clean Initiative prioritizes the purchase of lower-carbon construction materials in federally funded projects. The shift to carbon-conscious production is evident through

18 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_MAX_PLEX_V2msFINAL.indd 18

these overarching policies and places increased pressure on manufacturers to enact reduced energy consumption practices throughout production.

As manufacturers refocus their initiatives to prioritize reduced energy consumption and increased control over greenhouse gas emissions, they must work simultaneously to maintain output and quality. This means that manufacturers will likely explore innovative solutions to better manage and monitor their industrial ecosystems. This includes investing in energy-efficient equipment, optimizing production processes and adopting renewable energy sources.

Additionally, organizations may consider implementing robust energy management systems to identify and address areas of inefficiency. By prioritizing energy efficiency, manufacturers can contribute to a more sustainable future while ensuring their products meet the highest quality standards.

Smart manufacturing for energy use monitoring and reduction Smart manufacturing connects machines, equipment and systems to enable real-time data collection, analysis and decision making that provide Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:53 PM

‘

As manufacturers

significant benefits in terms of energy efficiency and operational output. Specifically, when it comes to the reduction of energy consumption, smart manufacturing is instrumental in improving: • Waste reduction: Achieving zero-waste manufacturing requires a level of data analysis that traditional methods cannot provide. While advanced equipment is essential, it's only part of the solution.

By combining new technology with precise process monitoring and control, manufacturers can make significant strides toward minimizing waste.

However, this requires the advanced digital tools of smart manufacturing software.

Energy consumption: Traditional manufacturing often assumes a consistent energy consumption pattern. However, smart manufacturing software reveals fluctuations in energy use throughout the day. By identifying energy-intensive processes, manufacturers can optimize operations and reduce their overall energy consumption by having smart manufacturing manage heating, ventilation and air conditioning and environmental conditions more efficiently with real-time monitoring and automated adjustments.

• Pollution control: Sensors and advanced analytics play a crucial role in smart manufacturing, enabling automation, optimization and pollution control. By monitoring and analyzing production processes, these technologies can identify and address issues related to wastewater, carbon emissions and other sustainability metrics. This proactive approach helps reduce pollution and energy usage. Providing real-time data and alerts allows manufacturers to identify potential problems early on and take steps to prevent more significant damage or delays.

Dual benefits: energy use reduction and improved performance Just as these smart manufacturing capabilities benefit energy consumption monitoring and reduction, they also increase operational efficiencies to deliver a competitive edge. Digital data plays a central role in mitigating waste and emissions but also reveals new opportunities for increased productivity.

While smart manufacturing software tracks production, inventory, waste and labor, the data outputs can be two-fold. These results often provide a Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_MAX_PLEX_V2msFINAL.indd 19

clear picture of where manufacturing efficiencies can improve. With improved data sources connecting the entire enterprise, organizations can make improved decisions that minimize waste and material usage. Ultimately, this leads to a more agile, profitable and competitive company.

Various aspects of smart manufacturing technology can be leveraged to track energy use but also improve performance. For example, the following technologies serve both overall operational performance measurements but can also reveal potential opportunities for waste reduction: • Manufacturing execution systems: Monitor and document the transformation of raw materials into finished products, providing real-time production oversight to enhance enterprise-wide compliance, quality and efficiency. With insight into production data, organizations can optimize processes, reduce waste and minimize energy consumption.

• Production monitoring: Offers direct communication with factory equipment, providing realtime insights into operational performance, such as overall equipment effectiveness. This data can help identify underused or inefficient equipment that may be consuming unnecessary energy.

refocus their initiatives to prioritize reduced energy consumption and increased control over greenhouse gas emissions, they must work simultaneously to maintain output and quality.

’

FIGURE 2: The Plex interface can be commonly used throughout the day via a desktop option. Courtesy: Plex, by Rockwell Automation

January/February 2025

| 19 1/22/25 3:53 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS PPE ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND MANAGEMENT

• Supply chain planning: Integrates data from various departments to align demand and supply planning, enhancing inventory accuracy and production management. Ensures that inventory levels are aligned with demand, reducing the need for excessive storage, which can consume energy. u • Asset performance management: Integrates process, operational and machine-level data to proEnergy insights vide comprehensive insights into machine and u This will review how plant performance. Provides insights into the enersmart manufacturing is revolutionizing gy consumption of individual machines and equipenergy efficiency in the ment. This data can help identify inefficient assets industrial sector, driving sustainability while that may be consuming excessive energy. enhancing operational A recent report revealed that the overwhelmperformance. ing majority (98%) of manufacturing organizau Plant managers can tions maintain some form of environmental, social learn how advanced technologies and dataand governance policy. Of these respondents, the driven insights empower majority report energy management as the most manufacturers to reduce important motivator for these policies (35%). Howwaste, energy providing FIGURE 4: optimize Jarred Richter training on arc flash PPE safety. use and maintain a ever, based on the overlap of smart manufacturing Courtesy: Hedgehog competitive edge inTechnologies a technologies and their capabilities, it is no surprise rapidly evolving energy landscape. that product quality ranks second (33%).

Insights

PLE2502_MAG_MAX_PLEX_V2msFINAL.indd PLE240201-MAG.indd PLE2402_MAG_PROTECT_V4msFINAL.indd 46 46 20

other isolated equipment. Like fall protection requirements, If any damage is spotted, employThe relationship between energy efficiency and ees should tag it, remove the PPE from service, overall output and quality cannot be ignored. It is and report it to management. evident that achieving both sustainability goals and Training is another crucial factor. Ensure improving overall efficiency requires a strategic the team follows a detailed and regular training approach that leverages smart manufacturing techschedule to educate on the hazards associated nologies to enhance energy management and prodwith arc flash and how to properly use the equipuct quality. ment.

This is aenergy good landscape place to revisit thetoequipAs the global continues evolve, ment selection criteria, especially after there has manufacturers face increasing pressure to reduce their been any upgrades or changes to the electrical environmental impact while maintaining operationalsystem. efficiency. Smart manufacturing offers a promisa company towards ing Lastly, solutionfostering by leveraging advancedculture technologies and safety can greatly improve employee safety. data analytics to optimize production processes. Each person is theirsmart own manufacturing safety critic and having safe By adopting practicoperations top ofcan mind is going to mitigate es, manufacturers enhance energy efficien- the risk of serious or death on any job site. PE cy, reduce waste injury and improve overall operational performance. This not only contributes to a more sustainable future but also strengthens the competiJarred Richter is an electrical technologist tiveness of businesses in the global market. Pat E Hedgehog Technologies, a CFE Media and Technology conAdam Mullen is Group Product Manager for Plex, tent partner.

by Rockwell Automation.

1/22/25 3:53 PM 2/8/2024 2/6/24 2:24:36 2:23 PM PM

ADVER TI S EMENT

T

.om Poczekay, Vice President of Engineering at Hitachi Global Air Power (HGAP), has always had an interest in how things work.

As a mechanical engineer, Tom channels his lifelong curiosity for building, improving, and solving challenges into his role leading the North American engineering team at HGAP.

Growing up in Michigan City, Indiana, Hitachi Global Air Power—formerly Sullair—was always a part of Tom’s life. “My grandparents’ farm was within sight of the Sullair facility,” he recalls. “I never planned to go into compressed air, but it feels like it was always in my path. I started at a competing compressed air distributor,

then transitioned to Hitachi Global Air Power, and it’s been a perfect fit ever since.”

At HGAP, Tom leads the North American engineering design and program management teams, focusing on new technology development and custom solutions for customers in the field. “What I love most about working here is solving customer problems,” Tom shares. “We get to work on fascinating technologies that are always evolving.”

Under Tom’s leadership, HGAP’s engineering team has achieved significant breakthroughs, including the Sullair TS Series rotary screw air compressors featuring an all new two-stage air end with patent-pending interstage cooling and best-in-class efficiency.

“We’ve pushed the limits of what’s possible in compressed air efficiency,” says Tom. “I couldn’t be prouder of our team and the creative engineering that went into this ground-breaking product series.”

Tom Poczekay Vice President of Engineering at Hitachi Global Air Power (HGAP)

The team has also revolutionized portable air compressors with the new Sullair E1035H electric portable and on the stationary side with the new DS Series oil free air compressor line. The DS Series involved a strategic collaboration with Hitachi; Tom’s team combined proven Hitachi technologies with HGAP ingenuity to meet the specific needs of customers all over the world.

“ Our mission is clear: make our products more efficient and easier to use — without losing an ounce of the reliability we’re known for.

From design to field support, we’re focused on creating smarter, environment-forward solutions that help our customers succeed. ”

Telephone: 1-800-SULLAIR

pe202502_execVoice_sullair R1.indd 1 21 Sullair_Hitachi_Exec Voice_pg21.indd

america.sullair.com

1/17/2025 4:18:03 PM 1/22/25 3:34 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS MOTORS, DRIVES

Taha Mohammed, PE, and Cole Casteel, PE, CDM Smith, Fairfax, Virginia

How to ensure reliable motor operation with variable frequency drives A variable frequency drive (VFD) is the industry’s standard technique for controlling the speed and torques of induction motors.

To ensure reliable operation of motors with VFDs, the user must consider various measures and best practices.

I

nduction motors use the principle of electromagnetic induction to convert electrical energy to mechanical energy to rotate or turn the motor shaft. And although a variable frequency drive (VFD) can be integral to efficient motor operation, there are many factors to consider before you install one.

VFDs can be used to adjust the frequency and voltage of the alternating current (ac) power applied to the stator and then control the speed, torque and power of the motor. There are two main control methods that VFDs use to control the operation (speed, torque, power) of an induction motor: vector control and scalar control.

While the vector control provides more precise speed control, it is more complex and adds additional feedback devices monitoring the shaft rotation. Thus, the most common and widely control method used is scalar control, also known as volts per hertz or V/f.

The main components of a VFD (see Figure 1) are: • The ac-dc converter, which converts the incoming 60 Hz ac signal to direct current (dc) using rectifiers or insulated-gate bipolar transistors (IGBT).

Learning

Objectives

u

• Understand the fundamental components and operations of induction motors and VFDs. • Recognize the key factors for selecting motors and VFDs. •G rasp important factors for VFD and motor installation.

FIGURE 1: Variable frequency drive block diagram. Courtesy: CDM Smith

22 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_MOTOR_V2msFINAL.indd 22

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:55 PM

• A dc link that smooths the dc signal using capacitors.

• A dc-ac converter that takes the dc and converts it back to ac at the desired voltage and frequency using pulse width modulation (PWM) technique with IGBT transistors.

As energy saving and more operation controls are desired, VFDs are becoming more widespread for driving motors in industrial and commercial facilities. When using VFDs, there are extra factors and considerations to be taken for a reliable facility and system operation. Understanding and applying these factors will help prolong the lifespan of the motors and VFDs as well as minimizing shutdowns due to unexpected equipment failure.

The following are key factors and best practices to consider when selecting or using motors with VFDs.

How to coordinate VFDs with the driven equipment For the equipment to operate reliably and properly, it is essential that the motor characteristics and application be coordinated with the driven equipment during the motor and VFD selections. In addition to voltage and phase compatibility of the motor and VFD, the VFD needs to be compatible with the motor and the driven equipment.

One main characteristic is the torque application, for example centrifugal fans and pumps are variable torque application and a normal duty VFD is adequate, while conveyors and positive displacement pumps are constant torque application and require heavy- or severe-duty rated VFDs, which have higher overloading capability.

An additional application to be discussed is the lowest speed the load will be operating at and making sure the motor turndown ratio can accommodate that application and can be safely operated at that low speed without overheating and compromising the operations. For example, a 10:1 turndown ratio for a 3,600 revolutions per minute (rpm) motor is 360 rpm.

Another important item is the motor full load amperage (FLA) and making sure the VFD can provide equal or greater current than the motor FLA. The motor horsepower should not be used to select the VFD and the motor service factor should not exceed 1.0.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_MOTOR_V2msFINAL.indd 23

Choosing the proper environment for VFDs, motors and drives Like with anything else in industrial facilities, such as structural supports and pipes or other electrical equipment, motors and drives must be suitably rated for the environments in which they are installed. Process areas in industrial facilities can be subject to physical damage, sprayed or standing water, high humidity, dust, corrosive chemicals and extreme temperatures, all of which can damage or rapidly degrade VFDs containing sensitive electronics.

The VFDs can be protected from their environment with a properly rated National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA) enclosure, such as 4X stainless steel. However, these enclosures come with their own drawbacks. They have larger footprints, add additional cost and make it harder to remove excess heat generated by the VFD. For these reasons, it is recommended to install VFDs in dedicated, climate-controlled electrical rooms (see Figure 2).

When it comes to electrical and mechanical equipment, one of the biggest reasons for degradation of equipment is heat. The power electronics that make up VFDs generate heat and if this heat builds up within the VFD enclosure, the components can be damaged, operate inefficiently or cause the VFD to shut itself down for protection, forcing equipment downtime. Most VFD enclosures are equipped with fans and air filters to ensure the flow of clean air across the components.

FIGURE 2: Variable frequency drives installed in environmentally controlled room. Courtesy: CDM Smith

January/February 2025

| 23 1/22/25 3:55 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS MOTORS, DRIVES

‘

There are multiple causes and symptoms involved with power quality issues from the VFD outputs, so there are multiple tools to address them and the best ones will depend on the

’

situation.

As with home air filters or on-facility heating, ventilation and air conditioning equipment, the air filters will become clogged with particulates and dust, inhibiting airflow. Even when the VFDs are installed in an air conditioned space and the heat cannot escape the VFD enclosure, the damage will be done.

It may seem like a small thing, but changing the air filters on VFD enclosures regularly, as well as verifying the functionality of the fans and ensuring a clear space around the vents can extend the longevity of the VFDs. When a VFD is installed in a harsh environment, it is important to remember that the NEMA-rated enclosure only provides protection when used and maintained appropriately.

For example, a NEMA 3R outdoor enclosure protects the VFD from rain, but if the door is left ajar, it may as well have a NEMA 1 enclosure rating.

Enclosures that provide stronger protection (3R, 4X, 7), tend to have more and heavier duty latches and bolts to keep the doors closed.

These are the areas where the environment can do the most damage to the VFD, so it is crucial for the longevity of the drive to make sure the doors stay closed, ensuring the integrity of the enclosure is maintained.

FIGURE 4: Cutaway view of an induction motor. Courtesy: ABB

24 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_MOTOR_V2msFINAL.indd 24

The importance of disconnecting contacts Safety disconnecting means are required for each motor to be located within sight of the motor location, per NFPA 70: National Electrical Code Article 430.102. However, a code exception is included that allows for the elimination of the motor disconnect if it is impractical or would introduce additional hazards, with an informational note clarifying that motors associated with VFDs meet this condition.

Despite the exception bypassing the need for a separate disconnect, many facilities’ operational staff still prefer to have them, as they can provide a safer working environment allowing technicians to open the disconnect and maintain visuals on the disconnect while they service equipment.

A consideration when including local motor disconnects for motors driven by VFDs is to include auxiliary “break-before-break” or “early break” contacts within the disconnect switch to connect to the VFD and send a signal to the VFD immediately to shut down before the switch is opened. When the motor load is abruptly removed from the load side of the VFD while running, transient voltage and current spikes are created that can damage the transistors in the drive.

Rarely, the damage can be rapid and catastrophic, destroying the drive, but more likely the surges will wear down the VFD electronics, lowering their lifespan. The addition of these auxiliary contacts allows the drive to shut off its output immediately before the load is lost, saving it from unwanted transients. For existing installations without early break contacts, it may be worth stopping the VFD before opening the local disconnect (see Figure 1).

Gauging VFD and power quality Harmonics in electrical systems are high-frequency sinusoidal currents that get added to the main power wave at multiples of the power frequency (60 Hz). They are created when ac power is converted to dc, which is the first stage of a VFD. The concern with harmonics is often on their upstream effects, such as increased heating of transformers, nuisance tripping or issues with the electric utility provider. With VFDs, there are also concerns with power quality downstream. As mentioned above, the ac output of a VFD is constructed from the dc bus by PWM, rapidly turning the output tranPlant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:55 PM

sistors on and off. The high-speed switching interacts with the inherent inductance and capacitance of the cable feeding the motor and the motor itself to create what are known as standing waves or reflected waves. The standing waves cause the cables and motor to experience a higher voltage than normal, sometimes higher than the rating of the insulation, causing premature breakdown of the insulation.

There are multiple causes and symptoms involved with power quality issues from the VFD outputs, so there are multiple tools to address them and the best ones will depend on the situation. To minimize reflected waves, it is best practice to keep cable runs between the VFD and the motor as short as possible.

Added length of cable increases the inductance and capacitance, also increasing the magnitude of the reflected waves. The high-frequency noise carried by the cables creates electromagnetic interference (EMI) that can affect nearby analog signals runs with power cable, like pressure or level transmitters signals. Using multiconductor, shielded VFD cable, especially when installed in cable tray or PVC conduit, will make sure those adjacent analog readings are not impacted by the EMI generated in the VFD cable.

With the prevalence of VFDs, industry leaders and motor manufacturers have designed motors with more robust insulation to be used with VFDs, as described in the NEMA MG1 standard and are labeled as inverter-duty.

The VFD output also induces stray currents in the rotor that discharges through the shaft and damaging bearings, causing vibrations bearing failure. To prevent stray currents and the unnecessary vibrations, heating and damage they cause, motors should be equipped with shaft grounding straps, insulated bearings or both.

Whether some of these extra measures are necessary will depend on individual circumstances, such as the VFD manufacturer and technology used, facility layout, motor size and process criticality. Proper protection will curb the negative effects from the PWM output of the VFD and extend the life of the motor.

Other filtering equipment such as sine wave and DV/DT filters may be used to eliminate transients between the VFD and the motor and protect the motor windings from voltage spikes. It is important to consult the VFD and motor manufacturer for recommendations on the proper filtering selection based on individual applications and setup.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_MOTOR_V2msFINAL.indd 25

Monitoring and protecting VFDs and motors Similar to VFDs, heat buildup is an issue for the motors. The flow of electrical current is resisted by the motor windings, converting the electrical energy to thermal energy. In a motor, a fan blade is attached to the rear of the shaft to expel hot air while the motor is spinning. This kind of motor construction is called totally enclosed, fan-cooled (TEFC) (see Figure 3) and it works well to remove excess heat from the bearings and stator at rated speed.

However, when used with a VFD to reduce the speed of the motor, as the fan is attached to the shaft, it will spin slower, which reduces the effectiveness and allows heat to build up. Generally, it is not recommended to operate TEFC motors below 25% of rated speed without additional cooling or verifying the rating of the motor.

For motors driven by VFDs especially, monitoring the temperature can help identify problems before they do too much damage. The most basic

FIGURE 3: Totally enclosed, fan-cooled motor on variable frequency drive with winding thermal protection and safety disconnect.

Courtesy: CDM Smith

January/February 2025

| 25 1/22/25 3:55 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS MOTORS, DRIVES

method is to install thermostats constructed from Routine VFD and motor bi-metallic switches around the stator windings. maintenance considerations As the two distinct types of metals heat up, they All equipment deteriorates over time, so it is expand at different rates, eventually breaking concrucial to test and maintain it regularly to ensure tact, letting the control circuit know the motor is it remains in good condition. Performing proper getting too hot. maintenance is another key item that enhances the u However, this discrete signal occurs only after reliability of motors/VFD operations. This includes reaching the setpoint and provides no additionpreventive maintenance and visual inspections, Variable frequency al diagnostics. Another method is using resistance cleaning filters and vents from dust and debris. drive insights temperature detectors that continuously vary their Motor and VFD inspections include checking for u VFDs are gaining widespread popularity resistance as the temperature changes, which can proper ventilations, unusual noises and smells, corfor driving motors be sensed and monitored remotely, giving more rosion and excessive vibrations. Some preventive in industrial and opportunity for proactive intervention to extend maintenance measures include applying lubricacommercial facilities due to their efficiency. the life of the motor. tion, tightening connections and replacing parts. u It’s important that the If the facility has a supervisory control and For detailed maintenance and testing promotor characteristics data acquisition system that allows the networkcedures, consider following the manufacturer’s and application are coordinated with the ing of VFDs via Ethernet or fiber, the additioninstructions and adhering to the recommenddriven equipment during al VFD parameters, signals and statuses can be ed maintenance guidelines from the InterNational the motor and VFD remotely monitored, such as real-time voltage, curElectrical Testing Association and NFPA 70B: Stanselections. rent, power, output frequency, motor speed, motor dard for Electrical Equipment Maintenance. PE u Monitoring the temperature can help torque and runtimes. This kind of data is valuable identify VFD problems for operators and maintenance to ensure the health Taha Mohammed, PE, and Cole Casteel, PE, are before they do too much damage. and longevity of their equipment.

Smith.

24_015015_Plant_Engineering_FEB Mod: December 27, 2024 2:01electrical PM Print:engineers 01/13/25 with pageCDM 1 v2.5

Insights

π SHIPPING SUPPLY SPECIALISTS

KEEP YOUR BUSINESS ROLLING CONVEYORS, BOXES AND MORE

ORDER BY 6 PM FOR SAME DAY SHIPPING

COMPLETE CATALOG

24_015015_Plant_Engineering_FEB.indd 1 PLE2502_MAG_MOTOR_V2msFINAL.indd 26

1-800-295-5510

uline.com

1/13/25 4:28 PM 1/22/25 3:55 PM

ADVERTISEMENT

The Importance of a Proper Lubrication Program David Reh | Director of field engineering and training services, Lubriplate Lubricants Company

Proper lubrication is essential to maintaining the bottom line, but starting a lubrication plan can seem to be an overwhelming proposition. Not having an effective program can result in hundreds of hours of downtime and lost production. Where does one begin faced with such a daunting task? This article will discuss methods to implement a comprehensive lubrication program, or how to possibly improve one already in place.

The first thing that should be done is to define the program’s goals and objectives.

Many plants want to consolidate inventory, reduce costs, and to ensure that the correct products are being used in the right places, especially in regard to any applicable legislation or food grade lubrication requirements. A qualified lubrication expert can assist with each of these goals, and advise you on what may or may not be a practical plan based on their experience.

SCAN QR CODE FOR SMARTPHONE ACCESS

Even a seemingly small accomplishment can be crucial. Some examples might include consolidating multiple gear oils into a single one, inventory reduction, or identifying an opportunity to save money through the advantages of using a superior lubricant. A few successes like these along the way help to keep the ball rolling.

Implementing a color coding plan, tagging equipment, and employee training are also smaller sized goals that can be accomplished fairly quickly with a moderate effort and reap much larger benefits in the long term. Another example of this is oil analysis. Oil analysis can be a good place to start, because it can be started on critical equipment without a lot of effort, and carries with it a potentially large return on the initial investment.

With each small part of the project that is completed, employees become more invested in the continuance of the program as it builds towards the conclusion a comprehensive lubrication program that saves money in the long run.

Lubriplate provides it’s customers with a complete extra services package.

These services include a technical support hotline and e-mail, complete plant surveys, customized, color coded lubricant tags, lubrication maintenance software, plant user training and no charge oil, fluid and grease analysis. For more on this subject and customer assistance call 1-800-733-4755 or e-mail LubeXpert@lubriplate.com Download the paper at: www.lubriplate.com/Resources/White-Papers/

202402pe_whitePaperCon_lubriplate.indd Lubriplate_Whitepaper_pg27.indd 27 1

www.lubriplate.com

12/4/2023 5:04:00 PM 1/22/25 3:44 PM

CONDITION MONITORING MADE EASY Simplifying Data-Driven Decisions for Outsmarting Downtime Easily view and understand critical machine performance Quick and easy setup gets you monitoring without delay Readily scales to accommodate changing needs Insights delivered anywhere, anytime with Cloud Data Services

Read more at: bannerengineering.com/pdm

BannerEngineering_pgs28_29.indd 28

1/27/25 4:33 PM

BannerEngineering_pgs28_29.indd 29

1/27/25 4:33 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND MANAGEMENT Mike Daugird, ACS, Verona, Wisconsin

How to use energy-efficient motors and drives to save money To cut costs and reduce carbon footprints, manufacturers have turned to variable frequency drives (VFDs) and switched reluctance (SR) motors, which offer energy savings and environmental compliance benefits.

FIGURE 1: Advanced industrial motors and drives are at the forefront of energy efficiency in manufacturing, helping facilities reduce power consumption.

Courtesy: ACS

30 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_MOTOR_ACS_V3msFINAL.indd 30

T

he manufacturing industry is undergoing a significant transformation, increasingly focused on improving energy efficiency and reducing the carbon footprints of the motors and drives essential for daily operations. As manufacturers seek to lower costs and meet sustainability goals, the need for more efficient power generation and distribution systems has become a priority.

Whether you're responsible for maintaining motor-driven systems in heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC), or in conveyors, pumps or other equipment, enhancing energy efficiency is key to staying competitive in today's industrial landscape.

Meeting the demand for energy-efficient drives Manufacturers are being driven by rising energy costs, environmental regulations and the need for operational efficiency. Industrial motors, which account for a significant portion of energy consumption in manufacturing environments, offer an opportunity for improvement. One of the most effective ways to achieve energy savings is using variable frequency drives (VFDs). These drives control motor speed and torque in response to the specific demands of the task at hand, allowing motors to operate more efficiently and consume less energy.

VFDs are particularly effective in applications where motors run at less than full capacity for extended periods. For example, pumps and fans in HVAC systems often operate below their maximum output and adjusting motor speed using a VFD can lead to significant energy savings. With energy consumption representing one of the largest operating costs in manufacturing, these savings can add Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/23/25 3:18 PM

Learning

Objectives

u

•U nderstand the importance of energy efficiency in manufacturing for cost reduction and environmental sustainability.

• I dentify key technologies, such as variable frequency drives (VFDs) and switched reluctance (SR) motors that improve energy efficiency in industrial operations.

•R ecognize the challenges and benefits of upgrading to energy-efficient systems and the role of incentives in facilitating these transitions.

up quickly. As companies aim to meet stricter environmental standards, VFDs are also helping reduce carbon emissions by lowering the overall energy demand of industrial operations.

Switched reluctance (SR) motors, though based on an older design, are also emerging as a leading technology due to advancements in cost-effective electronics. Unlike permanent magnet motors, which rely on rare-earth materials and come with environmental concerns, SR motors use a simpler, magnet-free rotor made from shaped iron. This design makes them highly efficient and robust, capable of producing up to twice the power of traditional alternating current motors. Their rugged construction and efficiency make them ideal for electric vehicles and with electronics now more affordable, SR motors are being viewed as a strong alternative to induction motors, particularly in high-demand applications like compressors, pumps and industrial systems.

The benefits of energy-efficient motors and drives The push for energy efficiency is not just about cost savings; it's also about reliability and long-term sustainability. More efficient motors and drives offer several benefits for those who work in manufacturing environments, including: • Reduced operating costs: Energy-efficient motors can lead to significant reductions in electricity usage, which translates into lower energy bills. This is especially important in large facilities where motors run continuously.

• Extended equipment lifespan: Motors that operate efficiently experience less wear and tear, leading to a longer operational life. This reduces the need for frequent repairs and replacements, saving both time and money.

• Improved system performance: VFDs and other motor control technologies allow for betPlant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_MOTOR_ACS_V3msFINAL.indd 31

FIGURE 2: Real-time energy monitoring enables manufacturers to track power usage, identify inefficiencies and adjust operations to lower energy costs.

Courtesy: ACS

ter control over system performance, improving the accuracy of operations and reducing waste. This leads to more consistent production processes and higher-quality outputs.

• Environmental compliance: Many industries are facing stricter regulations around energy consumption and emissions. By upgrading to more efficient motors and drives, manufacturers can meet these standards while minimizing their environmental impact.

Addressing the challenges of upgrading industrial power systems While the benefits of improving motor efficiency are clear, the transition to more energy-efficient systems presents some challenges. One of the main hurdles is the initial cost of upgrading equipment.

Although the long-term savings from reduced energy consumption can offset these upfront costs, many manufacturers are hesitant to make the investment without clear financial incentives or regulatory pressure. Additionally, some facilities may face technical challenges when integrating new systems into existing operations.

FIGURE 3: Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) in HVAC systems allow for flexible motor control, reducing energy use and extending equipment life.

Courtesy: ACS

January/February 2025

| 31 1/23/25 3:18 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND MANAGEMENT

FIGURE 5: Lower emissions and cleaner facilities are becoming the standard as manufacturers adopt more energy-efficient equipment. Courtesy: ACS FIGURE 4: Engineers evaluate motor systems to ensure seamless integration of energy-saving technologies in industrial operations. Courtesy: ACS

Insights

u

Energy insights u Energy-efficient motors

can save manufacturing facilities electricity usage, which translates into cost savings.

u Switched reluctance

(SR) motors are highly energy efficient and capable of producing up to twice the power of traditional alternating current motors.

For example, older motors may not be compatible with modern VFDs, requiring additional upgrades to ensure smooth operation. This is particularly relevant for SR motors, which can experience high torque ripple due to phase switching, complicating their integration with legacy systems.

Ensuring that these upgrades are properly planned and executed is critical to minimizing downtime and disruptions to production.

Government incentives, such as tax breaks or grants for energy-efficient technologies, can help offset the cost of upgrading industrial systems.

Additionally, utilities in many regions offer rebates for businesses that invest in energy-saving equipment. Taking advantage of these opportunities can make it easier for manufacturers to justify the cost of upgrading to more efficient motors and drives.

The future of energy efficiency As the manufacturing industry continues to evolve, energy efficiency will remain a key focus for those who work with motors and drives, including SR motors. Technological advancements, such as improved VFDs and the development of smart motor systems, are expected to drive further efficiency gains. These systems, along with the inherent advantages of SR motors — such as their durable, low-maintenance design and enhanced thermal capabilities — will offer improved moni-

32 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_MOTOR_ACS_V3msFINAL.indd 32

‘

Technological advancements, such as improved VFDs and the development of smart motor systems, are expected to drive

’

further efficiency gains.

toring and control, allowing for real-time adjustments that optimize energy usage even further.

Workers responsible for maintaining motor-driven systems must stay informed about the latest technologies and best practices. Understanding how to implement and maintain energy-efficient systems can make a significant difference in the overall performance and sustainability of your operations.

The path to more efficient power systems is a critical one for all industries. By investing in energy-efficient motors and drives, facilities can not only reduce costs but also contribute to a more sustainable future. Whether you're operating equipment in an industrial plant or managing systems across multiple facilities, the steps you take today to improve energy efficiency will have lasting benefits for your operations and the environment. PE Mike Daugird is an engineering manager with the ACS facility engineering group.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/23/25 3:18 PM

Italian machine builders are set to showcase their cutting-edge ‘Breaking Necks’ solutions and technologies

Italian machine builders are the key to unlocking your strategic business potential.

How are end users leveraging Italian machinery to advance their operational goals and address significant industry trends? Machines Italia’s Spring 2025 issue will explore key trends across various sectors utilizing Italian machinery, including advancements in automation, environmental sustainability, and the increasing demand for flexible and adaptable machinery.

For more details, visit machinesitalia.org.

machinesitalia.org MachinesItalia_MARCHissue_9x10.875_Vs2.indd MachinesItalia_pg33.indd 33 1

1/24/25 11:14 12:05 AM PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS SAFETY AND PPE

Russ Bowman, EXAIR, Batavia, Ohio

How to select PPE to protect against airborne hazards If airborne hazards are a respiratory concern, learn about the PPE available.

stance in question. If the contamination is a result or byproduct of an operation, air sampling of the actual environment or objective information from similar operations may be necessary.

t may sound counterintuitive that the least-effective control is the one many people think of first. It is, however, the one the user will ultimately be most familiar with, so it’s critical to know if — and when — different personal protective equipment (PPE) will provide adequate safeguards for airborne hazards.

Per Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) 1910.134(d)(1)(iii), the responsibility for this rests with the employer: The employer shall identify and evaluate the respiratory hazard(s) in the workplace; this evaluation shall include a reasonable estimate of employee exposures to respiratory hazard(s) and an identification of the contaminant's chemical state and physical form. Where the employer cannot identify or reasonably estimate the employee exposure, the employer shall consider the atmosphere to be immediately dangerous to life or health.

Manufacturing safety personnel should assess the nature and magnitude of respiratory hazard(s) that personnel may be exposed to. This includes hazards present during normal operations, as well as those that may be the result of accidental releases or emergency situations. It will also identify the physical state, such as gas, particulate or both and chemical form, including toxin, corrosive element, carcinogen and biohazard, of the contaminant(s).

Oftentimes, the contaminant is a substance that’s used by the worker. In those cases, OSHA publishes a Hazard Communication Standard, which mandates hazard identification on safety data sheets. This is a valuable tool and is largely considered to be the primary source of information for any hazards associated with the sub-

Respirator selection for air contaminants The next consideration will be the factors that might influence the selection of which specific kind of respirator is required. These factors include: • Physical constraints of the jobsite. This typically won’t be an issue if a simple mask or cartridge filter-type respirators are to be used, but if the environment calls for an independent supply of breathing air, hose fed breathing masks may be needed in tight quarters. Consequently, the use of respirators with air hoses could be limited if there are obstructions in the area and could be downright dangerous around moving machinery. In those cases, a self-contained breathing apparatus will be the better option.

• Certain medical conditions. Many common respirators are classified as negative pressure devices. This means that the wearer must draw air in through a restriction (like filtration media or chemical cartridges), which means it takes more effort than just “normal” breathing. These aren’t suitable for everyone — for example, they present a very real risk of undue pressure to the heart for someone suffering from lung diseases such as asthma or emphysema. Positive pressure respirators provide a restriction-free flow of breathing air and need to be used in those cases.

• User comfort. It’s not good for anyone to burden workers with awkward or unwieldy PPE of any kind. That can lead to lost productivity, high turnover and possible legal action for the employer and myriad mental and physical stresses for the employee. Fortunately, technical and material improvements continue to make safety equipment lighter, easier to don, softer on the skin — and many times even more effective than before.

I

Learning

Objectives

u

•G ain resources from regulatory bodies regarding the use of respiratory protection products.

•K now situations in which respiratory protection should be used, and the different types of respiratory protection that are suitable for those specific situations.

34 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_PPE_EXAIR_V4msFINAL.indd 34

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:56 PM

FIGURE 1: Here are three examples of air purifying respirators. Top: High-efficiency P100 cartridge-type respirator for organic vapors, chlorine, hydrogen chloride, sulfur dioxide or chlorine dioxide. This respirator can also be used for hydrogen sulfide but only in an emergency to escape from the contaminated area. Bottom: Two particulate mask-type respirators for general purpose use.

Courtesy: Exair

• Required level of protection. Sanding drywall and cleaning up after an accident at a chemical plant present vastly different breathing hazards, and hence, need vastly different levels of protection.

Agencies like National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) and OSHA, as well as the American National Standards Institute, all have many standards and publications on this subject.

Know what PPE to select for airborne hazards Once the appropriate level of protection is determined, users can select a suitable respirator from two basic categories: air-purifying respirators and atmosphere-supplying respirators.

Air-purifying respirators are self-contained devices that remove contaminants from the air to make it safe to breathe. Different kinds can remove particulates, vapors or both. They are all classified as negative pressure devices, so they may not be suitable for use by someone with medical conditions as noted above.

Particulate respirators capture airborne particles in small spaces between the fibers that make up their construction. These include simple masks that cover the mouth and nose and are typically considered disposable. They also come in a rigid frame with replaceable filter elements. As particulate accumulates in the fiber, these become more effective after some use but take care to replace them when any resistance or breathing difficulty is noted.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_PPE_EXAIR_V4msFINAL.indd 35

‘

Once the appropriate level of protection is determined, users can select a suitable respirator from two basic categories: air-purifying respirators

’

and atmosphere-supplying respirators.

Vapor respirators use chemical filters (usually in a cartridge or canister) which absorb the vapor.

There are different specific types for different vapors; NIOSH has a color-coding system for them: Black: Organic vapors Bright green: Ammonia White: Acid gases Yellow: Organic vapors and acid gases Olive/brown: Organic vapors, ammonia,acid gases Magenta: High-efficiency filter, P100 filters Black, magenta: Organic vapors and high-efficiency filter, P100 filters ellow, magenta: Organic vapors, acid gases Y and high-efficiency filter, P100 filters

January/February 2025

| 35 1/22/25 3:56 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS SAFETY AND PPE

‘

Proper selection and use of respiratory

’

protection is critical to your health and safety.

• Olive/brown, magenta: Organic vapors, ammonia acid gases and high-efficiency filter, P100 filters

Combination respirators have both particulate and vapor filters. These are especially popular when working with pesticides, as well as other chemical or biological agents that create airborne particulate and vapor contaminants.

Insights

u

PPE insights u Personal protective

equipment (PPE) is critical for worker safety.

u Air quality regulations

are important considerations for the types of PPE required for worker protection.

Specialty respirators as PPE Atmosphere-supplying respirators provide clean breathing air from an outside source, usually an air tank or compressed air system. They’re used when a high concentration of contaminants could foul particulate elements or expend a vapor cartridge quickly. They may also be needed in areas where the oxygen level could drop below safe levels, such as confined spaces that cannot be adequately ventilated with fresh air. They’re also used for emergency situations to allow personnel to safely evacuate an area where the atmosphere is unexpectedly fouled with smoke or other pollutants.

All atmosphere-supplying respirators provide protection against particulate and vapor contaminants and come in three configurations: • Air-supplied respirators consist of a mask (usually full face with straps to cinch it up for an airtight seal), with a short, low-pressure hose connected to a regulator, usually made to clip on the wearer’s clothing, belt, etc., which is fed with a hose rated for the supply pressure that has a quick connect for use with breathing air manifolds.

These manifolds will normally be strategically located in facilities where contaminated atmospheres require their use. Advantages include their light weight and ability to provide clean breathing air for long periods of time. Disadvantages are limited mobility (the wearer can’t go any further than the supply hose length from a supply manifold) and failure due to hose damage.

36 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_PPE_EXAIR_V4msFINAL.indd 36

• Self-contained breathing apparatuses have the same masks designed for an airtight seal but are fed with breathing air from a pressurized tank.

The wearer has greater freedom of movement — they’re not restricted to the supply hose length of an air-supplied respirator — but they do have time limits.

– Open-circuit types provide breathing air that the wearer breathes right back out to the atmosphere. These are typically good for 30 to 60 minutes, because the larger the tank gets, the more cumbersome it is for the wearer to carry around.

– Closed-circuit types recirculate exhaled air through a chemical-activated “scrubber” that removes carbon dioxide and generates oxygen. These are also called “rebreathers,” and some are good for up to four hours.

• Combination atmosphere-supplying respirators combine features of the other two types. The primary supply comes from an external source (like the air-supplied ones), but they also include an air tank (like the self-contained ones). The tank is generally smaller on these, as its main purpose is to provide air while the user exits the area. They’re commonly used in confined spaces without adequate ventilation and when working for extended periods in atmospheres that could be immediately dangerous to life and health.

Proper selection and use of respiratory protection is critical to your health and safety. Additionally, it’s important to your company’s bottom line.

In 2021, OSHA recorded 2,521 violations of respiratory protection standards. This was second only to fall protection violations that year. The associated fines are commonly compounded per person and per day.

Know and understand the hazards you and your employees will be exposed to. Familiarize yourself with the different respirator options. Conduct regular training so everyone knows how to protect themselves and others. Fit testing of respirators should be an integral part of that training. PE Russ Bowman is an application engineer at EXAIR.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:56 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS FALL PROTECTION

Philip Jacklin, Diversified Fall Protection, Virginia Beach, Virginia

Fall protection equipment focus:

What to know about body harnesses

The proper fit for fall protection harnesses can help employers better protect their employees when falls occur.

F

alls are the third leading cause of injury and fatality among general industry workers. Additionally, fall protection violations have been the most cited Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) violations for the last 14 years.

According to the National Safety Council’s most recent data from 2022, 865 workers died in fall-related incidents with more than 80% of those deaths occurring after falls to a lower level. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics has shown an average increase in fall fatalities since 2010.

While many organizations have joined OSHA’s efforts in raising awareness of the risk of workplace slips, trips and falls, the current data suggests that more must be done to decrease the number of falls that occur. If fall injuries can be mitigated or prevented, then unnecessary deaths can be avoided.

There are many strategies organizations can employ to make their workforce safer. This article will highlight how focusing on training employees on how to properly fit, inspect and use their fall protection harness is an effective strategy to protect their workers.

Ensuring a perfect fit for fall protection Many harness manufacturers advertise body harnesses with a universal size, but each person must ensure their harness is properly adjusted to their body. Every OSHA and American National Standards Institute (ANSI)-approved fall protection harness will have five points of adjustment — two leg straps, two shoulder/torso straps and one chest strap.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_PPE_DFP_V3msFINAL.indd 37

The leg straps should be adjusted tightly enough to remain stationary on the user’s leg but not so tight as to cut off circulation. One common rule to determine leg strap tightness is called “flat hand, not fat hand.” This is where a user’s extended palm (flat hand) but not their fist (fat hand) can comfortably slip under the leg strap when tightened.

The shoulder and chest straps should then be fitted in unison. Users should ensure their shoulder straps fit snugly by pulling on the tensioners located near their torso. The user should feel slight tension on their shoulders from these straps and they shouldn’t be able to slip off while moving around.

If the shoulder straps are properly tensioned, they should help the chest strap sit in its proper place, which is aligned with the creases created by a user’s armpit when they hold their arms flat against the side of their body.

It is important to have the chest strap set at the proper height. If it’s too high, the user risks being choked by the chest strap, as it may elevate when the user is suspended during their fall arrest. A strap that’s too low could cause the worker to not u remain upright during fall arrest. If a user is not properly positioned upright during fall arrest, the • Discover the proper fit user’s spine may incur more force and resulting in techniques for fall protection harnesses. a greater risk of severe injury. Most chest straps • Find out what two are adjustable and should be tensioned to sit flat inspections are required against the user’s chest.

by Occupational Safety and Health Administration for fall Proper tension is crucial to ensuring a workprotection equipment. er remains safe during fall arrest. A properly ten• How to conduct presioned harness encourages the user to maintain a use inspections for fall proper, upright posture. It keeps the body stationprotection harnesses.

Learning

Objectives

January/February 2025

| 37 1/22/25 3:57 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS FALL PROTECTION

‘

Fall protection manufacturers

must ensure no more than 1,800 pounds of force are felt by a

’

user in their harness.

FIGURE 1: Rooftop worker with personal fall protection system.

Courtesy: Diversified Fall Protection

ary during fall arrest, which best mitigates the fall forces that the harness can partially absorb during fall arrest. If a harness fits loosely, the harness will suddenly become very tight in crucial areas, like the groin or pelvic region. This sudden tightening of the harness can cause unanticipated injury and will not properly absorb forces from the user.

Fall protection manufacturers must ensure no more than 1,800 pounds of force are felt by a user in their harness. However, this can only be performed if the user wears the harness correctly, according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

Conducting pre-use inspections to ensure workplace safety While proper harness fit is one of the most important things users can check while donning the equipment, OSHA also requires users to inspect their harness before every use. This is often referred to as the pre-use inspection. These inspections do not have to be documented each time they occur, but the existence of them and training workers to perform them should be documented in the organization’s fall protection program. In these inspections, users should check inspect three main components of their harnesses:

38 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_PPE_DFP_V3msFINAL.indd 38

• Product tag • Deployment indicators • Damage and defects First, users must ensure the harness’s original product tag is intact. If no manufacturer tag is present, OSHA does not permit the harness to be used. On most harnesses, this is located under an enclosed pouch either on a front torso strap or one of the back straps. After locating the tag, users must make sure the tag is legible and in good condition.

The tag should contain confirmation that it complies with the latest OSHA and ANSI standards, date of manufacture and make and model of the harness. While it’s not required, it is best practice to write the date of first use on the product’s tag.

Second, users must ensure the deployment indicators do not indicate a fall has occurred with the harness they are about to use. All pieces of fall protection equipment — anchors, body harnesses and connection devices — are only rated for one fall.

After they experience a fall, they must be removed from service and replaced with new equipment, per OSHA and ANSI requirements.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:57 PM

‘

When it comes

Most harnesses now have two deployment indicators on the two back straps of the harness. They typically look like a piece of the webbing stitched over itself in a “Z” shape with stitches that are rated to break after about 400 pounds of pressure are applied, which is common in any fall arrest.

Many manufacturers conceal a small tag that is revealed once these stitches break apart, which communicates that the harness should be removed from service. In the odd case that these stitches tear and the user has not experienced a fall, the harness still must be removed from service.

This can suggest the harness has somehow been exposed to extreme forces and may not perform as expected during a fall. When it comes to fall protection equipment, being prudent can be the difference between life and death.

After the user has confirmed the product’s tag and the harness’s deployment indicators are still intact, they now must inspect the entire harness for any physical damage or defects that could hinder its performance during fall arrest. Users should check for any tears, cuts, holes, burns, burrs or damage done to the harness webbing. Harness webbing should have a smooth, sheen feeling to it if it’s in proper condition.

Overexposure to sunlight’s ultraviolet rays will not only discolor the harness but make the webbing more brittle, give it a rougher texture and erode its elasticity. If the webbing becomes too brittle, it won’t stretch properly during fall arrest and run the risk of breaking. If a harness strap breaks during fall arrest, the user could be accidentally ejected from the harness and suffer severe injury.

The user should check all the metal components of the harness, like the D-rings, buckles and grommets, for any rust or signs of corrosion. And while it is uncommon, they should pay extra attention to any area where metal comes in direct contact with webbing material because over time, the friction could deteriorate that portion of the webbing. They should also ensure all connections and fasteners function properly before donning the harness and going to their elevated work location.

If a harness or any piece of equipment fails its pre-use inspection, the item must be taken out of service and delivered to the organization’s “competent person,” defined by OSHA as someone who has the knowledge, training and experience to identify and correct hazards in the workplace. The user would then have to be provided with anothPlant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_PPE_DFP_V3msFINAL.indd 39

er piece of equipment before their at-height work can safely be performed.

Here’s why annual inspections are critical for safety In addition to pre-use inspections, OSHA also requires annual inspections of all fall protection equipment. These inspections must be documented when they occur and be performed by the organization’s designated competent person.

Annual inspections should note the date of manufacture, serial number, manufacturer and model and indicate whether the equipment passed or failed the inspection.

These inspections can be performed by a third party, and that third-party inspector must be trained to a competent person level. This person assumes liability for the proper functioning of the system if used according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

In theory, if users perform diligent pre-use inspections of their fall protection equipment, the competent person should have almost no equipment fail their annual inspection. High failure rates during annual inspections can indicate to safety leadership that workers should be retrained on what to look for during pre-use inspections.

Workers using defective, damaged or faulty equipment could be subject to injury but might think their equipment will protect them.

to fall protection equipment, being prudent can be the difference between life and

’

death.

Best practices can ensure u fall protection safety Focusing on best practices for fall protection Fall protection insights harnesses is just one strategy organizations can u Ensuring best practices deploy to better protect their workers from falls. for fall protection The simple reinforcement of corporate safety polharnesses will protect workers from catastrophic icies and encouraging workers to use their equipaccidents. ment properly is extremely effective in keeping u Employers need to know workers safe. about the minimum Studies have found that employees are eight times Occupational Safety and Health Administration more likely to use fall protection equipment if they requirements regarding believe their employer requires it. If we educate workbody harnesses and how to encourage workers to ers on the hazards they will encounter in their workuse these harnesses to place, provide them with the resources to work safely protect themselves. and empower them to use their equipment every u When employees know time, we can prevent falls — and avoid tragedies. PE how to use their fall

Insights

Philip Jacklin is the continuing education program manager with Diversified Fall Protection.

protection harnesses and feel confident in their safety, they can do their jobs without fear.

January/February 2025

| 39 1/22/25 3:57 PM

S U M M I T

&

E X P O

EVENT OVERVIEW: The Advanced Automation Forum (AAF) is a two-day event designed to accelerate digital transformation in manufacturing through collaboration between system integrators, end users and product manufacturers. Taking place on April 30th and May 1st, 2025, this forum will offer hands-on, practical insights into the future of manufacturing, focusing on real-world strategies, successful case studies, and actionable solutions. During the event, we will recognize the important contributions of top system integrators.

KEY FOCUS AREAS: • The practical implementation of smart manufacturing • Data-driven decisions • Securing connected devices through collaborative cybersecurity • IT/OT alignment • Upskilling the workforce • Overcoming integration challenges • The tools required to support sustainability initiatives

ADVANCEDAUTOMATIONFORUM.COM

Sponsorship opportunities are available for future DeviceTalks and Robotics programs.

For more information, contact Colleen Sepich. 857.260.1360 | csepich@wtwhmedia.com

AAF25_HouseAd_11-24_Vs3.indd AdvancedAuto_House Ad_pg40.indd5640

11/18/24 1/28/25 11:41 4:39 PM AM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS SAFETY AND PPE

Gayle Nicoll, PhD, REP, ASP, CSP, Jensen Hughes, Milwaukee

Here are the facts and myths about appropriate PPE Understand critical factors for selecting and using PPE to ensure you’re choosing the right equipment that meets regulatory standards and protects workers from hazards.

M

ost people understand the critical importance of personal protective equipment (PPE) in protecting workers from hazards that cause serious injury and illness. But with all the products available on the market today, many environmental, health and safety (EHS) practitioners don’t know where to begin or feel overwhelmed when it comes to choosing PPE. According to the U.S. Occupational Health and Safety Administration (OSHA), employers should have PPE programs if PPE is used at their facility. PPE programs are ultimately responsible for addressing the hazards present in the workplace; the selection, maintenance and use of PPE; the training of workers on its use; and the monitoring of the program’s effectiveness.

Choosing the right PPE equipment and making sure it’s used properly is one of the most important things a company can do to protect itself and its workers. One barrier to selecting PPE is a limited understanding of how to choose the most effective equipment for the workers and facility. Which PPE is chosen can depend on various factors, such as the hazards workers are exposed to, the preferences of the workers and the availability of PPE equipment.

In many cases, though, decision-makers choose PPE based solely on cost without adequately considering the workplace hazards or other factors that may impact their use. What’s worse, decision-makers may rationalize their choices through various PPE myths. Dispelling these misconceptions and understanding the critical factors impacting PPE selection and use will ultimately help PPE

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_PPE_JH_V2msFINAL.indd 41

programs and practitioners choose the right PPE equipment that meets regulatory requirements and protects workers from hazards.

MYTH NO. 1: PPE is the first line of defense to protect workers from hazards.

PPE is actually the last line of defense for protecting workers from hazards and should only be used after all other options for preventing exposure have been exhausted. In fact, PPE programs should be part of a much bigger hazard identification and risk reduction program, where a comprehensive approach is used to identify risks and protect workers. Programs should: • Conduct a job hazard analysis or task hazard analysis to identify the hazards associated with each workplace process and activity.

Learning

• Use the hierarchy of controls to determine u if the hazards can be eliminated, substituted or engineered out. A matrix can help identi• Recognize that personal fy potential mitigation actions and the type of protective equipment (PPE) PPE based on the hazard. For some examples is the last line of defense in protecting workers from of how to implement the hierarchy of controls, hazards, not the primary see Table 1. mode.

Objectives

• Evaluate and recommend PPE necessary to mitigate any residual risk that cannot be eliminated, substituted or engineered out.

MYTH NO. 2: All PPE is created equal.

PPE supplied by different vendors varies in quality, style, rating and functionality. K-95 masks are a

• Understand that PPE selection should be based on the risks associated with a task.

• Identify appropriate PPE to stock at your facility based on the diversity of the workplace as well as the facility’s unique hazards.

January/February 2025

| 41 1/22/25 3:59 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS SAFETY AND PPE

‘

PPE is actually the last line of defense for protecting workers from hazards and should only be used after all other options for preventing exposure have been

’

exhausted.

great example of this. During the COVID-19 pandemic when N-95 masks were in short supply, people started using K-95 masks even though K-95 and N-95 masks are not made to the same standard.

K-95 masks are made to the Chinese standard, while N-95s are made to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health standard. What’s more, some masks looked like K-95 masks but were not manufactured to either standard.

PPE should be carefully selected based on the identified hazards at the facility, making sure it conforms to appropriate standards (e.g., OSHA, American National Standards Institute, American Society for Testing and Materials) rather than looking for the lowest-cost items. Choosing lowcost PPE options cost more money in the long run.

Remember the saying, “You get what you pay for.” PPE that costs less per unit quantity may also be low-quality, which may be more prone to failure. If PPE fails more frequently, workers will use more, which will ultimately cost more. Frequent failure can lead to more incidents and accidents and a higher OSHA recordable incident rate, all of which will result in more money spent on medical expenses.

Poor-quality and inappropriate PPE can also impact worker acceptance. Workers have their own requirements for PPE comfort, perceived effectiveness and durability. If they don’t like the PPE, don’t trust it or feel it hinders them from doing their job, then they won’t wear it. And if

they don’t wear the PPE, the facility’s accident incidence rate and medical costs may go up.

MYTH NO. 3: Workers not wearing PPE causes many accidents.

This is an insidious misconception that blames workers for incidents rather than seeing it as something the facility can change or control. A good root cause analysis doesn’t blame the worker and instead digs deeper to find out which process failed and what can be fixed or changed to prevent the accident from recurring.

When asked why they weren’t wearing their PPE, workers will often say they forgot, which doesn’t get to the core of the issue. When encouraged to explain further, many cite a host of underlying issues, including poor quality, unreliability or they just don’t like it. PPE needs to be acceptable to workers in the following areas: • Comfort. PPE must be comfortable for employees to wear. A facility PPE team can sample different PPE and make recommendations on the most comfortable options. Diverse representation is critical because what’s comfortable for one size, gender or body shape may not be comfortable for another.

• Quality and reliability. Workers become frustrated by PPE that consistently fails and breaks.

Collect data from your facility on PPE failure and reordering rates. Then, interview employees

Table 1: Examples for implementing the hierarchy of controls Hazard

Eliminate

Substitute

Engineer

Noise from compressor

Do you need the compressor inside, or can you remove it from the building?

Is it an old compressor? Can you use a newer, quieter model instead?

Hazardous chemical splash while filling tank

Hard pipe chemical feed into tank so personnel aren’t manually filling the tank

Is there a safer chemical that could be used in the batch instead?

Design an automated system that opens a valve once all connections are made to the tank, removing personnel from being exposed.

Goggles or face shield, gloves, apron

Toxic gas inhalation during sampling

Is there a way to collect a sample without exposing personnel, using a robot or automatic means?

Do you really need toxic gas in your process? Is there a different, safer chemical that could be used instead?

Perform sampling under a hood or in a well-ventilated area.

Respirator

1. Place the compressor in a dedicated compressor room.

2. Hang noise-reducing blankets around the compressor.

PPE Ear plugs or muffs

TABLE 1: This shows examples of how to implement the hierarchy of controls. Courtesy: WTWH Media

42 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_PPE_JH_V2msFINAL.indd 42

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:59 PM

Table 2: Glove protection based on type, rating and material Protection Type

Rating*

Rating Explanation

Standard

Material

Cut Resistance

A1 to A9

A1=Least resistant A9=Most resistant

ANSI 105

Leather, chain mail, para-amid (i.e., Kevlar), HPPE

Punction Resistance

0 to 5

0=Least resistant 5=Most resistant

ANSI 105

Para-amid, HPPE

Abrasion Resistance

1 to 6

1=Least resistant 6=Most resistant

ANSI 105

Leather, para-amid, HPPE

Impact Protection

1 to 3

1=Least protective 3=Most protective

ANSI 105

Thermoplastic rubber

EN 374

Latex, Nitrile, Neoprene, Rubber, Butyl, LLDPE, PVC, Viton, PVA

EN 374

Latex, nitrile, rubber

1 to 6 Chemical Resistance A to C

Biological Activity Protection

Bacteria, Fungi, and/or Virus 0 to 5

N/A

ASTM F1060

1 to 4

1=Least protective 4=Most protective

EN 407

Class 00 to 4

00=Least insulating 4=Most insulating

ASTM D120

regarding their perceptions about the PPE quality. Ask them about their PPE concerns and the kinds of PPE they would prefer. Finally, conduct an analysis of the data and evaluate whether a better PPE selection should be offered.

• Flexibility. Workers will be consistently unhappy if PPE interferes with them doing their jobs.

Convene a PPE team consisting of representatives from every area of the facility. Ask them what they want in terms of PPE and what their current concerns are with existing PPE options.

• Size. If the right sizes aren’t available, workers won’t be able to wear the PPE. Make sure you order a variety of sizes (i.e., XS to XXL) to choose from.

• Style. Workers often use PPE to express their own uniqueness and style. If they perceive the PPE as ugly, clunky or boring, they won’t use it.

Try offering PPE in a variety of colors, brands and form factors. A brand or style that works well for one worker may not work well for another.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_PPE_JH_V2msFINAL.indd 43

Chemical Permeation: A=Most protective C=Least protective

0=Least protective 5=Most protective

Heat Protection

Electrical Insulation

Breakthrough Time: 1=Least protective 6=Most protective

Leather, terrycloth, aramid, acrylic, aramax

Rubber

MYTH NO. 4: One glove is as good as another.

Gloves are designed for specific hazards. A cut-resistant leather glove, for example, will do little to protect employees from impact hazards. Before purchasing gloves for your facility, identify the types and severity of hazards. Then, select gloves that appropriately protect personnel from those hazards (see Table 2).

TABLE 2: Learn about the different types of glove protection on the market. Courtesy: WTWH Media

MYTH NO. 5: One size fits all (or most).

People come in a variety of shapes and sizes.

There’s no such thing as “one size fits all.” Even hearing protection comes in different sizes for dif- u ferent-sized ear canals. Workers are more inclined PPE insights to wear their PPE if it fits properly, is comfortable u There are many and is perceived as body-flattering. considerations for when personal protective PPE suppliers are stepping up and offering a variequipment (PPE) should ety of shapes, sizes, proportions and colors. be used in the workplace.

PPE suppliers are also recognizing that PPE u PPE should be selected designed for men does not adequately fit all genbased on identified hazards at the facility. ders. Best practice is to order and stock multiple u It’s important to sizes for each type of PPE so employees can find consider workers’ body a size that fits their body. This applies to safety shapes and sizes when vests, gloves, hearing protection, smocks, aprons purchasing PPE.

Insights

January/February 2025

| 43 1/22/25 3:59 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS SAFETY AND PPE

‘

A manufacturing or industrial

Table 3: Eye protection

Protection

Description

Type

Example Uses

Impact

Protection from flying solid objects

Z87 or Z87+ (high impact)

Woodworking, grinding, machining, sawing, drilling

be part of a much bigger hazard

Chemical

Protection from splashes

D3

Lab environment, degreasing, chemical exposure

identification and risk-reduction

Dust

Protection from suspended dust

D4 or D5

Sanding, woodworking, buffing

U = UV protection

Outdoor work

L = Visible Light

Blue light protection with high computer use

W = Welding

Welding

Light

Protection from light-emitting sources

TABLE 3: Eye protection is a requirement in many industrial and manufacturing facilities. The type of products manufactured or systems used will dictate eye protection.

Courtesy: WTWH Media

and safety shields/glasses. If your facility provides pants, shirts, coveralls or other types of clothing, make sure your facility orders appropriate sizes and styles for the entire workforce.

MYTH NO. 6: Safety glasses protect your eyes from all hazards.

Just as with gloves, different eye protection is designed to protect employees from different hazards. If your employees routinely work with liquids, safety shields are probably not the best choice, as they do not protect from liquid ingress on the top or sides. Better choices would be goggles or a face shield. The ANSI Z87 standard is what OSHA cites in 29 CFR 1910 for eye and face protection, which includes goggles and face shields.

Identify the types of face and eye hazards at your facility and then identify the appropriate type of safety glasses, goggles or shields to protect workers from those hazards. Keep in mind that different types of safety glasses may be needed at different locations within the facility (see Table 3).

MYTH NO. 7: Workers know which protective shoes to buy.

Workers may be overwhelmed walking into a shoe store and seeing the variety of brands, styles and safety ratings. While employers often allow workers to purchase their own foot protection and be reimbursed for it, many employers do not clearly communicate the expectations for the type of foot protection that employees should be purchasing.

A variety of options can help address this problem, including:

44 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_PPE_JH_V2msFINAL.indd 44

facility’s PPE program should

’

program.

• On-site visits from shoe companies. Some shoe companies offer “shoe-mobiles” or other means of offering a curated selection of work shoes that meet the employer’s requirements. That way, workers can only select from approved footwear.

• Provide visual guidance. Many companies provide useful written instructions for purchasing shoes that include the standards and ratings.

However, workers may not bring this guidance with them or fail to recall the full instructions.

For example, they may remember that the shoe must be ASTM-rated but not recall the specifics. Best practice is for employers to supply a picture of the label on the shoe so that workers can use that picture to match it at the store.

A comprehensive PPE program A manufacturing or industrial facility’s PPE program should be part of a much bigger hazard identification and risk-reduction program. The PPE program should identify the residual hazards in each process that have not been mitigated via elimination, substitution or engineering.

The EHS practitioner should be one member of the PPE team, which meets periodically to evaluate PPE offerings and identify the types of PPE offered to employees. The representatives of the PPE team should listen to the concerns and input of others in their work area and bring those concerns to the PPE team as a means of continuous improvement. The PPE offered to the workforce should be based on the hazards as well as on employees’ sizes, shapes, styles and preferences. PE Gayle Nicoll, PhD, REP, ASP, CSP, is a process safety services expert with Jensen Hughes.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/22/25 3:59 PM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS MAINTENANCE

Angelica Pajkovic and Nelson Kavanagh, Teadit Group, Pasadena, Texas; David Wahl, Dominion Energy, Richmond, Virginia

How to build a maintenance program for expansion joints It’s essential to develop a robust and reliable maintenance program for expansion joints, which require diligent upkeep as they play a vital role in accommodating thermal expansion, vibrations and other movements in piping systems.

T

o maximize the lifespan of an industrial component, each asset must follow a standard operating procedure and adhere to a specific maintenance program. These programs involve regular inspections and timely repairs to prevent unexpected breakdowns and costly downtime. By implementing a comprehensive strategy, companies can extend the lifespan of their equipment, improve safety standards and enhance overall productivity.

Maintenance programs can generally be categorized into three types: preventive maintenance (PM), condition-based maintenance (CBM) and corrective maintenance (CM).

• Preventive maintenance: This type of maintenance is time-based and scheduled at regular intervals, such as monthly, annually or biennially. It involves routine inspections and servicing to prevent equipment failures.

• Condition-based maintenance: CBM relies on monitoring the condition of equipment to decide when maintenance should be performed. Techniques such as vibration analysis, thermography and acoustic testing are used to assess the health of the equipment.

• Corrective maintenance: This approach addresses issues as they occur, focusing on fixing problems after they have been identified during regular operations or inspections. [/h3] It is recommended that each piece of equipment have one or more of these dedicated maintenance programs. This approach ensures Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_EMISSIONS_TEADIT_V3msFINAL.indd 45

maintenance tasks are performed regularly and consistently.

Preventive maintenance’s role in maintenance programs Unlike other equipment, expansion joints are often maintained under CM programs, where issues are addressed as they arise.

Implementing PM programs can significantly improve operational reliability by moving from a reactionary approach to a prevenFIGURE 1: Examples of tive one. Not only does it improve performance, expansion joints monitored but operators can achieve better resource allocaunder preventive maintetion, maintenance staff can focus on proactive tasks nance programs. Courtesy: rather than constantly addressing emergencies and Teadit Group the frequency and duration of unplanned downtime can be reduced.

When developing maintenance programs, it is important to consider the types of equipment and their operating parameters. A comprehensive inventory of all equipment and machinery must be established, including detailed records of specifications, operating conditions and maintenance history. u Once established, the development of an asset-specific maintenance program involves three • Understand the three key criteria: types of expansion joint maintenance programs.

• Determining equipment criticality. Identify • Grasp the best practices and prioritize equipment based on its importance for maintenance programs. to the operation. Critical equipment that has no • Develop a robust redundancy and can cause significant downtime if expansion joint it fails should receive more attention. maintenance schedule.

Learning

Objectives

January/February 2025

| 45 1/28/25 11:02 AM

ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS MAINTENANCE

1. Identify equipment and assign criticality.

List all the equipment, including expansion joints and assign a criticality rating based on factors like redundancy and impact on operations.

2. Determine applicable maintenance types.

For each piece of equipment, decide on the appropriate maintenance type. For expansion joints, this may include:

FIGURE 2: Examples of expansion joints monitored under preventive maintenance programs.

Courtesy: Teadit Group

• Visual inspections during scheduled outages.

• Thermographic inspections to detect hot spots and leaks while in operation.

• Real-time condition monitoring for critical expansion joints, which can involve sensors to detect temperature and pressure changes.

FIGURE 3: Examples of expansion joints moni-

• Following manufacturer recommendations.

Follow the maintenance guidelines provided by the equipment manufacturers. These recommendations are often a part of environmental or operational permits.

• Identifying operational conditions: Consider the equipment's operating environment, including temperature, pressure and the type of fluids being handled. This helps determine the appropriate maintenance actions and intervals. [/h3]

3. Establish a maintenance schedule. Develop a schedule that outlines when and how often each type of maintenance should be performed. For instance, visual inspections might be conducted bi-annually during plant shutdowns, while thermographic inspections could be quarterly.

4. Consult experts and manufacturers. Engage with subject matter experts (SMEs) and manufacturers to ensure the maintenance program is comprehensive and current. This can involve reviewing new technologies and methodologies for monitoring and maintaining expansion joints.

5. Implement and monitor the program. Roll out the maintenance program and continuously monitor its effectiveness. Adjust the program as needed based on inspection feedback and condition monitoring data.

Adhering to the manufacturer's recommendations is necessary to meet regulatory requirements. They also provide insight into some signs operators should watch for once the asset is installed in a plant or refinery. Therefore, to ensure an expansion joint PM program is as comprehensive as possible, it’s best to consider SME recommendations for each type of expansion joint.

Steps to build a maintenance program for expansion joints Five things must occur when building a maintenance program.

Maintenance for metallic versus nonmetallic expansion joints There are two primary groups of expansion joints: metallic and nonmetallic. These categories

tored under preventive maintenance programs.

Courtesy: Teadit Group

46 | January/February 2025 PLE2502_MAG_EMISSIONS_TEADIT_V3msFINAL.indd 46

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/28/25 11:02 AM

‘

If the bellows of metallic expansion joints rupture or

encompass a range of products designed to meet various industrial needs and applications.

For nonmetallic expansion joints, the best maintenance practice involves replacing the bellows (fabric belt) and thermal insulation pillow in case of a rupture. Regular visual inspections of the bellows are crucial and, in some cases, a thermal camera inspection can be beneficial to detect issues early.

If the bellows of metallic expansion joints rupture or leak, the entire expansion joint must usually be replaced. Regular maintenance and inspection can help prevent such occurrences and extend the joints' lifespan.

Preventive maintenance for installed expansion joints Once the expansion joint is installed, operators should perform regular preventive maintenance checks. For nonmetallic expansion joints, frequent visual inspections should include: • Ensuring the outside bellows are free of material deposits that could obstruct air circulation.

• Checking for any missing bolts in the clamping bars.

• Looking for signs of rupture or leakage in the bellows.

• Observing any localized changes in the color of the outside bellows, which could indicate overheating or other issues.

For metallic expansion joints, preventive maintenance should involve: • Checking for ruptures or leaks in the outside bellows.

• Monitoring the bellows’ pitch or movement indicator to identify any unexpected movements.

• Checking bellows’ convolution spoilt or local deformities.

• Checking leakage between bellows’ redundant plies.

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

PLE2502_MAG_EMISSIONS_TEADIT_V3msFINAL.indd 47

leak, the entire expansion joint must usually be replaced.

Regular maintenance and inspection can help prevent

’

such occurrences and extend the joints' lifespan.

• Checking pipe anchors and guides (can cause expansion joint unexpected movements).

• Comparing the theoretical fatigue life to historical expansion joint life and planning the expansion joint exchange.

When an expansion joint issue is detected, it’s wise to contact the manufacturer for assistance.

They can provide guidance on the criticality of the repair and suggest the appropriate course of action.

Prompt communication with the manufacturer ensures issues are addressed correctly and efficiently, minimizing downtime and maintaining the system's safety and functionality.

A robust maintenance program enhances expansion joint performance Building a robust maintenance program for expansion joints involves understanding different maintenance types, assessing equipment criticality and following manufacturer recommendations.

By shifting from a reactive approach to a preventive and condition-based maintenance strategy, facilities can enhance reliability, reduce costs and maintain safety standards. Regular inspections, condition monitoring and expert consultations are key components of a successful maintenance program that ensures the long-term performance and safety of expansion joints.

Furthermore, well-maintained machinery operu ates more efficiently, reducing energy consumption and operational costs. Investing in industrial Expansion Joint maintenance not only safeguards the longevity Maintenance Insights and reliability of assets but also fosters a proactive u The three types of maintenance programs approach to addressing potential issues before they include preventive, escalate, ultimately contributing to the sustainabilicondition-based and P ty and competitiveness of the business. E corrective.

Insights

Angelica Pajkovic is a client specialist at Teadit Group. Nelson Kavanagh is a mechanical engineer at Teadit Group. David Wahl is a site manager at Dominion Energy.

u Expansion joints are

maintained under condition-based programs.

u The two types of

expansion joints are metallic and nonmetallic.

January/February 2025

| 47 1/28/25 11:02 AM

Publication Sales VP, Sales Matt Waddell Sales Account Manager Brian Gross

®

COMPANY

Advertisers' Index PAGE#

WEB

ABB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C3 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.abb.com Advanced Automation Forum . . . . . . 40 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.advancedautomationforum.com Aitkin Products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.aitkenproducts.com

Sales Account Manager Richard Groth Sales Account Manager Robert Levinger Sales Account Manager Dean Morris

Air Products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.airproducts.com Sales Account Manager Judy Pinsel

Automation Direct. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C2 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.automationdirect.com Automation Direct. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.automationdirect.com Banner Engineering . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28, 29 . . . . . . . . . . www.bannerengineering.com

MWaddell@WTWHMedia.com 312-961-6840

BGross@WTWHMedia.com 847-946-3668

RGroth@WTWHMedia.com 774-277-7266

RLevinger@WTWHTMedia.com 516-209-8587

DMorris@WTWHmedia.com 513-205-9975 847-624-8418 JPinsel@WTWHmedia.com

Citgo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.mystiklubes.com Hitachi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11, 21 . . . . . . . . . . www.HitachiGlobalAirPower.com/Industrial Machines Italia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.machinesitalia.org Mapcon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.mapcon.com

Publication Services Patrick Lynch, Senior Vice President, Sales & Strategy 847-452-1191, PLynch@WTWHMedia.com

Lubriplate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6, 27 . . . . . . . . . . . www.lubriplate.com Royal Products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.mistcollectors.com

McKenzie Burns, Marketing Manager MBurns@WTWHmedia.com

SEW Eurodrive . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C4 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.seweurodrive.com Uline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 . . . . . . . . . . . . www.uline.com Weldbend . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2,3 . . . . . . . . . . . www.weldbend.com

Courtney New, Program Manager, Content Studio CNew@WTWHMedia.com Paul Brouch, Operations Manager 708-743-5278, PBrouch@WTWHMedia.com Rick Ellis, Director, Audience Growth 303-246-1250, REllis@WTWHMedia.com

Easy to Use. Powerful Software. Priced Right.

Michael Rotz, Print Production Manager 717-422-3622, mike.rotz@frycomm.com Custom reprints, print/electronic: Matt Claney, 216-860-5253, mclaney@wtwhmedia.com Information: For a Media Kit or Editorial Calendar, go to https://www.plantengineering.com/advertise-with-us.

GET ON THE BEAT

Letters to the editor : Please email us your opinions to ARozgus@WTWHMedia.com. Letters should include name, company and address, and may be edited.

Keep your finger on the pulse of top industry news

WWW.ICSPULSE.COM

(800) 922-4336 • mapcon.com

48 | January/February 2025

2023_ICSpulse_Square.indd 1

PLE2502_MAG_AD_INDEX_V1msFINAL.indd 48

1/26/2023 11:51:50 AM

Plant engineering — www.plantengineering.com

1/28/25 10:38 AM

— Baldor-Reliance® SP4TM motors Revolutionizing the motor industry – again Leading the way in energy efficiency yet again, ABB Baldor-Reliance® SP4TM motors give you a shortcut in energy savings, lower operating costs and total cost of ownership. SP4TM motors achieve NEMA Super Premium® efficiency across-the-line, independently of a drive. Whether DOL or inverter duty, these motors run cooler, longer and quieter – now with a 48-month warranty. new.abb.com/motors-generators/sp4

ABB_C3.indd 3

1/27/25 4:31 PM

What’s the cost of a superior system?

A lot less than an inferior one.

At SEW-EURODRIVE, we engineer the highest quality drive automation solutions. What truly sets us apart is our unwavering commitment to customer support, long after the sale. We go above and beyond to ensure your business stays on the move with exceptional service at every turn. Upgrade everything.

JOIN US AT: SCAN TO START A CONVERSATION

g PACK Expo SE Atlanta, GA Mar. 10-12 Booth# 523

g ProMat Chicago, IL Mar. 17-20 Booth# 6727

g Robotics Summit Boston, MA Apr. 30 - May 1 Booth# 212

SEWEURODRIVE.COM \ INDUSTRIAL DRIVE AUTOMATION \ ENGINEERING \ SERVICE SEW Eurodrive_C4.indd 4

1/22/25 3:32 PM