Dialogue Forum I - Slideshow

Community of Practice For Supply Chain Resilience in Canadian Health Care Systems:

Dialogue Forum I Thank you to our host and strategic partners for supporting this event

SCAN Health © 2022

Land Acknowledgement Alberta Innovates respectfully acknowledges that we are situated on traditional territory of the treaty 6, treaty 7 and treaty 8 first nations; home to Métis settlements, the Métis nation of Alberta, and regions 2, 3 and 4 within the historical northwest métis homeland. We respect the histories, languages, and cultures of first nations, métis and Inuit whose presence continues to enrich our vibrant community. We offer this land acknowledgement as an important component of reconciliation between nonindigenous and indigenous peoples of Canada.

Welcoming Remarks: Urgency for a Community of Practice for Health Supply Chain Resilience

Laura Kilcrease CEO, Alberta Innovates

Dr. Anne Snowdon Scientific Director & CEO, SCAN Health

Community of Practice There is an urgent need for platforms to enable knowledge sharing, collaboration, and coordination among supply chain teams and stakeholders across Canada to support healthcare delivery. The overarching goals of the Community of Practice partnership strategy include: ●

Advance supply chain resilience across Canadian health and community systems to strengthen post-pandemic recovery in Canada and globally

●

Strengthen workforce sustainability in health and social systems to support a robust and sustainable health workforce, to advance economic recovery

●

Design, implement and scale supply chain strategies that leverage expertise and knowledge across jurisdictions, and support domestic supplier networks across Canada to strengthen self-reliance and economic recovery

SCAN Health © 2022

4

KEYNOTE: KEY FEATURES OF ALBERTA’S SUCCESSFUL PANDEMIC RESPONSE

SCAN Health © 2022

Francois Bouchard Senior VP, Industry Relations and Community Engagement, GS1 Canada

Jitendra Prasad CPO, Contracting, Procurement & Supply Management at Alberta Health Services (retired)

Presenter

Key Features of Alberta’s Pandemic Response Jitendra Prasad Former Chief Program Officer, Contracting, Procurement & Supply Management

7

Overview and Approach ▪ Precursor Initiatives ▪ A Quick Look at Supply Chain Evolution ▪ Key Features – Data Availability and Predictability Models – Engagement – Collaboration

– Structural System Enabling Support to all Sectors

▪ Domestic Suppliers ▪ Conclusion 8

Precursors to Alberta’s Response ▪ Planning experience for disaster management ▪ Availability of stockpile for PPE and other related items including equipment ▪ Centralized ERP system

▪ Dedicated Emergency Disaster Management program area ▪ Experience in managing large scale disasters – Slave Lake and Ft. McMurray Fires, Calgary Flooding, etc.

▪ Single organizational design enabling provincial planning ▪ Build in collaborative and engagement models

▪ Availability of data – both clinical and non-clinical ▪ Experienced management and staff

9

What is Supply Chain?

▪ According to Council of Supply Chain Management Professionals (CSCMP), definition of supply chain and logistics are provided below: – Supply chain management encompasses the planning and management of all activities involved in sourcing and procurement, conversion, and all logistics management activities.

Importantly, it also includes coordination and collaboration with channel partners, which can be suppliers, intermediaries, third party service providers, and customers. In essence, supply chain management integrates supply and demand management within and across companies (healthcare systems) – Logistics management is that part of supply chain management that plans, implements, and controls the efficient, effective forward and reverses flow and storage of goods, services and related information between the point of origin and the point of consumption in order to meet customers' requirements (evolution of health care supply chain to be logistics providers)

10

Evolution of Supply Chain

AHS Journey 2010 onwards

Source: https://transportgeography.org/contents/chapter7/logistics-freight-distribution/evolution-supply-chain-management/

11

Supply Chain in the Public Eye ▪ Canadian hospitals playing 'supply chain whack-a-mole' with key materials ▪ "We are told by our hospitals that they're seeing upwards of 600 individual product disruptions every week, and that has been their experience since early spring 2021,“ ▪ "It's a game of supply chain whack-amole … basically, if you don't have a stockpile of every single thing that you would use in a year, you're likely going to experience a disruption."

12

Supply Chain Disruptions – Simplified

13

Recent Examples of Events ▪

Working from Home – significant demand for computers, laptops, routers, etc. resulting in chip shortages and long

▪

2021 Suez Canal Obstruction – impact to global supply chain of around $10B and impacted medical devices,

▪

Pandemic – impacts already known – exponential demand, limited production, redirection in use of raw materials.

▪

Geo-political Events – Brexit, Russia- Ukraine conflict, China-US and Shipping Channels

▪

Environmental Regulation Impacts – impacting products that require Ethylene Oxide sterilization in the US – major

▪

Manufacturing Recovery Events – major changes to production lines, mergers and acquisitions and product

▪

Natural Events – Resin shortages and price escalation continues – respiratory, blood collection, IV catheters, equipment, bottles, plastic bags, packaging material, etc..

lead times. Chip shortages also aggravated by few manufacturing sites. This resulted in impact to other products that use chips – medical devices, equipment, cars, etc. paper products, etc.

An example that maybe familiar would be Chemo Gowns

impacts to products that are sterilized – IV Catheters, trays, sets, etc. rationalization e.g. Infusion, Airway management, etc.

14

What was different?

▪ Exponential increase in utilization ▪ Public facing discussion on supply chain ▪ Length of pandemic ▪ Government response included supply chain and procurement ▪ Unpredictability leading to planning challenges

▪ Focus beyond healthcare ▪ Public panic……….

15

Using Data to Plan

16

17

18

Master Projection Model ▪ Scenario Inputs: – Infection rate (Mild, Medium, Extreme) – Hospitalization Rate – ICU Admissions – Ventilator Utilization

▪ Utilization based on number of PPE changes/day for different areas – ICU, Acute Care, EMS, ER, Homecare, LTC, Community Physicians, Other non-healthcare areas ▪ Output – utilization profile over a 16 week timeline adjusted for length of stay of 10 days to factor in residual carryover ▪ Ability to escalate utilization or decrease

▪ Model drawback – assumption of normal distribution with peak occurring between weeks 7 to 9 – had to account for a left or right shift in timeline planning (previous slide)

19

Example of Summary Output Estimated COVID PPE 16 Week Normal Distribution

3,000,000 2,500,000

2,000,000 1,500,000 1,000,000 500,000 0 Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Week 5 Week 6 Week 7 Week 8 Week 9 Week 10 Procedure Masks (Patients)

Procedure Masks (Staff)

N95 Respirators

Exam Gloves

Isolation Gowns (disposable)

Goggles

Week 11

Week 12

Week 13

Week 14

Week 15

Face Shields- Single Use

22

Week 16

Using the Data

23

AHS Supply Planning Model Number of SKU=

AHS PPE Supply

90 Day Buffer Supply

Number of Units =

Dollar Value of SOH=

System: Oracle

Consolidated Provincial Demand Planning (in collaboration with Alberta Government)

Number of Units = Federal Stockpile Allocation

Dollar Value of SOH =

System: TBD

Number of Units = AHS Operational Inventory Dollar Value of SOH =

System: Oracle/MediTech/VAX

24

Client Based Demand • •

All AHS Facilities Third Parties (>1700): – Addiction and Mental Health Compounding Pharmacists – Continuing Care and Supportive Living Contracted Emergency Medical Services Covenant I Lamont – Disability Services – Homecare – Indigenous Health – Lodges – Midwifery – Public Health – Rehabilitation Service – Self Managed Care – Shelter & Vulnerable Sector Supervised Consumption Site Saskatchewan Health Authority Contracted DI – Obstetricians and Gynecologists Pediatricians – Primary Care Network – Specialist – Dentists (N95 Masks) – Funeral Home (N95 Masks) – Respiratory (N95 Masks) – Municipal First Responders (N95 Masks) – Anyone else requiring N95 Masks – Others as directed (RAT and Masks for Schools, etc.)

25

Leveraging Supply Chain in Planning Assumptions

26

Engagement/Collaboration ECC (Provincial and Zones)

Provincial & Federal Government

AHS Executiv e and SLT

Infection Control and WHS

PPE Task Force and Physicians

CPSM

Public and Media

Unions

Vendors (New & Existing)

Third Parties Health Canada

Collaboration with other Provinces critical to response

CPSM Staff

30

Structural Benefits ▪ Centralized Structure (Clinical and Supply Chain) ▪ Enabled provincial planning including other sectors as well ▪ Consolidated procurement and supply chain model ▪ Ability to scale and support

▪ Single point of entry for all supplies without ability to divert supplies ▪ Acting as a distributor for the province ▪ Internal allocation models

31

Domestic Suppliers ▪

Increased focus on Canada’s “lack of manufacturing” capacity

▪

Alberta introduced the Bits and Pieces program

▪

The Alberta Bits and Pieces Program is a way for businesses and citizens to submit unsolicited offers of products and service s to help others during an emergency or disaster. Originally established during the Second World War, the program coordinated innovative production and procurement efforts from across the country to support the war effort. The program has since evolved to provide critical support to Albertans during emergencies and disasters, including flooding, wildfires, tornadoes and more recently, COVID-19.

▪

Offers resulted in the establishment of a mask manufacturing facility in Calgary and a 2-year commitment.

▪

Great product but too many issues with other manufacturers and distributors requesting equal treatment at a lower cost

▪

Challenges

https://www.alberta.ca/alberta-bits-and-piecesprogram.aspx#:~:text=The%20Alberta%20Bits%20and%20Pieces,during%20an%20emergency%20or%20disaster.

– Cost versus risk mitigation versus economic impact – Long term sustainability due to market share and lower acquisition costs

– Fairness to other vendors – Competitive processes and contracting methodology – Change management

32

Looking to the future

33

34

35

Impact of Lead Times ▪ Lead times are at 85% higher than pre-pandemic due to the following: • Labor – Shortages of skilled and unskilled labor in manufacturing and distribution continue to impact output and capacity.

• Raw material and component shortages – Raw material availability is improving but continues to be heavily impacted by the Russia-Ukraine conflict and China’s economy. Semiconductors (chips) remain in short supply, and many experts do not believe this will ease until 2024 • Transportation – While there are positives signs that port backlogs and truck availability are improving, we are still nowhere near pre-pandemic levels, and lead times and price for container shipments remain extended. Driver retention is an issue that is resulting in longer transportation timelines

• Demand – Consumer demand remains strong in all segments we serve

• Significant shortages being seen in construction and utility categories – this in turn impact manufacturing and construction projects 36

Supply Chain Disruptions Supply chain disruption is an interruption in the flow of process that involves any of the entities associated with the production, sales, and distribution of specific goods or services

37

Supply Chain Severity ▪ Low – short term impact due to a singular event e.g. computer downtime, ordering error, etc. Easy and quick to resolve.

▪ Medium – disruption related to a manufacturing event and can last from weeks to months e.g. QA and ISO requirement audit failure (Pfizer), revamping production lines, etc.

▪ High – long term events such as geo-political disruptions, major events such as the pandemic, unprecedented demand

38

Healthcare Supply Chain ▪ The Pandemic exposed healthcare supply chain specialists (including pharmacy) to a “once in a lifetime event”. This resulted in recognition of the critical function supply chain plays in delivery of care ▪ From a paper bag to a complex medical device/equipment shortage resulted in impact to providing care, including providing meals to clients.

▪ Supply chain played a huge role in ensuring supply continuity for front line professionals – from procedure masks to drugs to gowns to complex medical supplies – procurement worked 24/7 to secure supplies ▪ This recognition and importance needs to continue as we navigate the issues that still persist and as we prepare for future events that will definitely result in issues of supply

▪ Collaborative efforts with front line professionals, executive, physicians, government needs to continue in the foreseeable future as initiatives to secure supply certainty continues.

39

In conclusion…..

▪ Without supply chain management in healthcare patient care will be at risk ▪ Supply chain issues will continue to impact our ability to deliver care ▪ Recognize that impact to supply chain occurs very early in a manufacturing cycle and is impacted by events that may not be easily recognizable to front lines

▪ Work with all stakeholders to mitigate impacts to health care delivery ▪ Understanding your data and using it to plan your supply chain is essential ▪ Each external event has an impact to delivery of goods and services

▪ Supply chain is the backbone of this globalized environment we live in

40

Thank you!

41

COVID-19, MULTI-SECTORAL COLLABORATION, AND THE HEALTH SUPPLY CHAIN: A PAN-CANADIAN PANEL

SCAN Health © 2022

A Pan-Canadian Panel

Ron Johnson - Panelist Vice President, Eastern Health

SCAN Health © 2022

Scott MacNair - Panelist

Col. Natasha Singh - Panelist

Executive VP, Business Operations, Provincial Health Services Authority

Director Health Services Logistics at Department of National Defence

Karen Sullivan - Moderator

Angelique Berg - Panelist

Senior Director, Academic and Health System Partnerships, Shoppers Drug Mart

President & CEO, Canadian Association for Pharmacy Distribution Management

44

Supply Chain Experience During a Pandemic Ron Johnson, VP Innovation & Rural Health

45 Photo Credit: Newfoundland and Labrador Tourism

Formal Role About Eastern Health About Me

Managing & Controlling PPE • Hazard Awareness • PPE Utilization • Delivery & Logistics Processes • PPE Security & Audits • Donations from various partnerships PPE Acquisition

Logistics & Transportation

46

46

Photo Credit: Newfoundland and Labrador Tourism

Challenges & Opportunities

Market Conditions

Challenge

Opportunity

Opportunity

Task Force NL

Kindness

Local PPE Manufacturing

Opportunity

47

47

Photo Credit: Newfoundland and Labrador Tourism

Critical Next Steps( Resilience)

01

Maintain domestic manufacturing capacity at strategic levels

02

Identify the potential sources of disruption, as well as challenges that could emerge during a crisis

03

Building redundancy into the supply chain

48

48

Photo Credit: Newfoundland and Labrador Tourism

A BC Provincial Perspective Scott MacNair, Executive Vice President, Business Operations Provincial Health Services Authority COVID-19, Multi-Sectoral Collaboration and Health Supply Chain: A Pan Canadian Panel Oct 20, 2022 49

Role PHSA Supply Chain played in distribution of PPE & Vaccine roll out across BC • Supply Chain team owned 100% of PPE sourcing, contracting, and logistics across

the healthcare system for BC • Increased dialogue and exposure as all products managed centrally • Ministry of Health and Regional Health Authorities

• Provided all provincial vaccination supplies, partnered with CDC for cold chain

vaccine deliveries to both public and pharmacy channels

50

Supply Chain opportunities & challenges – during the pandemic • Global supply issues & shortcomings of existing Supply Chain • Centralization of procurement in BC, using local vendors

• Ongoing Critical disruptions (i.e. Contrast media) • Supply Chain visibility challenges (daily changes) • Rethink our Supply Chain – led to transformation plan 51

Critical next steps to create Supply Chain Resilience • Build sustainability actions into our operations and processes • Key learnings from the pandemic

• Know our capabilities & where investment is needed (i.e. systems) • Build predictability & work closer with vendors/suppliers (upstream visibility) • Robust & rotatable inventory levels

• Value centre vs cost centre • Innovation, digitization of Supply Chain

52

CHIEF OF MILITARY PERSONNEL | COMMANDEMENT DU PERSONNEL MILITAIRE CANADIAN FORCES HEALTH SERVICES | SERVICES DE SANTÉ DES FORCES CANADIENNES

Supply Chain Resilience in Canadian Health Care Systems: Dialogue Forum I Colonel Natasha S.M. Singh, CD, RPh Director Health Services Logistics

53

Role During the Pandemic • 8 Biomedical Equipment Technologists deployed to PHAC in support of Medical Equipment Testing • Support to Public Services and Procurement Canada for procurement of 100 bed hospitals • Stand up of 5 temporary Forward Medical Equipment Depots (FMED) to distribute PPE to members deployed to domestic locations • 53 CAF members seconded to PHAC in support of Vaccine Distribution, including 2 Health Care Practitioners • Airlift Assistance to PHAC for PPE, Vaccine and Freezer distribution • Delivery and administration of COVID-19 vaccine to Global Affairs Canada staff outside of Canada

54

54

Challenges • • • •

Limited Health Human Resources Dispersed Health System Multiple Tasks Availability and Quality of PPE

Canadian Forces Health Services 14th Health Jurisdiction

* Designed and Resourced to support CAF requirements

55

55

Opportunities • New Health Canada agile regulatory measures • Increased investment in Canadian domestic biomanufacturing capacity including vaccines and therapeutics • Increased awareness and better preparedness

Critical Next Steps • Application of due diligence in management of allocated resources to build strategic stockpiles and reduce costs of limited shelf-life products • Review of existing and future infrastructure • Continued work with industry partners to develop, produce and/or license Medical Countermeasures within Canada (e.g. Imvamune®)

58

58

Health Care Products Distribution COVID-19 Multi-Sectoral Collaboration

Angelique Berg, President & CEO, CAPDM

Pharmaceutical Supply Chain Raw Materials Sourcing

Manufacturing

Finished Product

Distribution

Dispensing

Patients

>95% of Drugs in Canada

Pharmacies + Hospitals

Patients

Packaging

Majority Outside 30% Consumed Here Canada Are Made Here

60

Supply Chain Stakeholders Manufacturers (Hundreds)

Distribution (15,000 SKUs) Primary Wholesalers

Self-Distributing Pharmacy Chains 3PL

Specialized Distributors

CPDN

Select Channel

Dispensing (11,500+ Pharmacies + Hospitals) Any Pharmacy or Hospital

Own Pharmacies

Owned clinics Direct-to-Patient

Any Hospital from select Manufacturers

61

Distribution Regulations & Capacity Primary Wholesalers

Self-Distributing Pharmacy Chains

Specialized Distributors

+ Medical Devices + OTC Products

Acts & Regulations Food & Drugs Act Controlled Drug & Substances Act Cannabis Act Licensing Drug Establishment License • Different categories • GMP and GDP • Provincial Pharmacy Colleges Medical Device Licence Natural Health Product Licence Dealer Licenses • Narcotics • Controlled Substances • Precursors • Cannabis

Capacity 37 Distribution Centres 8,000 Employees Short-Term Buffer Stock 15,000 SKUs Infrastructure & Tech CDS and Precursors Cages Narcotic Vaults (Illicit Value) Cold Chain (5C) Frozen (-20C) Ultra Low Temps (-60C) Temperature Mapping Temperature Logging

62

Product Distribution • • • • • •

Product valued at over $30 billion Evergreen inventory turnover Deliver next-day coast-to-coast Provide short-term shortages buffer Execute drug recalls and returns Also: Implement manufacturerdirected allocations in supply chain disruption or product shortages • Deliberate slow-down or re-direction

October 2022

PRODUCT FLOW

ORDER FLOW 63

Primary Wholesale Distributors

Self-Distributing Pharmacy Chains

Specialty Distributors

3PL Pharma Service Providers

Plan for Demand • Communicate and collaborate • Salbutamol inhalers • Propofol

• Holistic, realistic longer-term view • • • •

Image from KidsHealthllc.com

Small market in a global marketplace Plan for demand shifts Share data across the supply chain Consider the costs-to-serve

65

Leverage the Asset • Leverage distribution infrastructure and expertise • Think: flu vaccines • Government-private sector partnerships • Licensed, ready, expert distribution network

• Most cost-effective, efficient, and secure solution

October Click to2022 add meeting or date,

66

Invest for Sustainability • Drug price and upcharges are controlled

• Distribution funding is a function of drug price

• Funding for distribution has been eroded

• Generic prices fell 70% since 2007 = $50M/yr • PMPRB may cause another 5% = $20M/yr

• Operating costs continue to rise

The cumulative impact of policydriven price compression and higher regulatory and operating costs is estimated to be $100+ million per year, challenging the sector’s fiscal sustainability

• Regulation • Automation and innovation (e.g. frozen) • Inflation, fuel, labour rates, labour shortages

• Few options to remedy shortfall

• Significant impact to patient access

October 2022 Click to add meeting or date,

67

Contact

Angelique Berg President & CEO angelique@capdm.ca

68

ACHIEVING EQUITY IN CANADIAN HEALTHCARE: A SHARED VISION

SCAN Health © 2022

70

What is health equity?

WHO Definition of Health of Equity Equity is the absence of unfair, avoidable or remediable differences among groups of people, whether those groups are defined socially, economically, demographically, or geographically or by other dimensions of inequality (e.g. sex, gender, ethnicity, disability, or sexual orientation). Health is a fundamental human right. Health equity is achieved when everyone can attain their full potential for health and well-being. (https://www.who.int/health-topics/health-equity#tab=tab_1)

Supply Chain capacity makes it possible for health systems to deliver care, ensuring the products are available to those who require care.

71

SCAN Health © 2022

What is the Role of the Health Supply Chain in Advancing Equity The de-stabilization of the health supply chain results in supply shortages, necessitating the allocation of scarce critical resources. Decisions must be made on who gets those critical resources and who doesn’t. ●

What are the approaches to allocation of critical products that can advance equity, rather than deepen inequities?

●

How can health supply chain be the strategic asset to advance and strengthen Equity in healthcare?

72

SCAN Health © 2022

Health Legislation to Redress Inequities (I) Jordan’s Principle & Joyce’s Principle Jordan’s principle: Jordan's Principle makes sure all First Nations children living in Canada can access the products, services and supports they need, when they need them. (https://www.sacisc.gc.ca/eng/1568396042341/1568396159824)

Joyce's Principle: aims to guarantee to all Indigenous people the right of equitable access, without any discrimination, to all social and health services, as well as the right to enjoy the best possible physical, mental, emotional and spiritual health. (https://principedejoyce.com/en/index) 73

SCAN Health © 2022

Outcomes of COVID19 of note ●

81% of COVID-19 deaths in Canada were seniors living in long-term care facilities (CIHI, 2020; CIHI, 2021), with 17,177 resident and 32 staff deaths due to COVID-19, accounting for a staggering 43 percent of Canada’s overall COVID-19 deaths (July 2022, National Institute on Aging).

Australia had 28 deaths among their citizens living in long-term care (CIHI, 2020).

74

SCAN Health © 2022

How can the Community of Practice advance Health Equity? ●

Equity begins with understanding multiple and varied perspectives, experiences and value. Our panel today sets the stage for examining Equity from very diverse perspectives:

○ ○ ○

●

Citizen experiences and views of equity and what it means for Canadians: Judy Birdsell Indigenous led Businesses and Procurement: Matthew Foss Decision making structures in Indigenous communities: Bonnie Healy

The Community of Practice is committed to the co-design of equitable, person-centered, and just supply chain solutions.

These supply chain solutions will focus on an “economy of needs” over an “economy of profit.”

The Community of Practice is committed to the co-design of equitable, person-centered, and just supply chain solutions.

These supply chain solutions will focus on an “economy of needs” over an “economy of profit.”

75

SCAN Health © 2022

Panelists and Moderator

Judy Birdsell - Panelist Chair, IMAGINE Citizens Network

Dr. Anne Snowdon - Moderator Scientific Director & CEO, SCAN Health

Matthew Foss - Panelist Matthew Foss, VP of Research & Public Policy, Canadian Council for Aboriginal Business

Aapooyaki - Bonnie Healy - Panelist Health Director, Blackfoot Confederacy

Introduction to Imagine Citizens Network (ICN).

To enable and mobilize citizens’ ability to influence and

become valued partners in improving healthcare experiences and outcomes for all.

ICN Board Retreat October 13/14 2022

SCAN Health © 2022

77

SCAN Health © 2022

78

Experiences with Covid and Implications for Supply Chain

SCAN Health © 2022

Theme

Description

Lack of Trust

Government (Some lives more valuable than others) Confusing messages

Information and Communication

Lack of clear consistent messaging.

One size fits all approach

Changes made without consideration for people in different situations

Citizen input and Involvement

Involvement would have helped mitigate one size fits all

Pre-Existing Health System Issues

Systemic racism, lack of cultural competence, stigma

79

Our Role: Creating a ‘People’s Forum’ to work within the Community of Practice to encourage and support consistent attention to ensuring our collective efforts provide benefit to ALL those who live in Canada.

What’s Next: •

Invite individuals with diverse experience and backgrounds with commitment to ensuring attention to equitable processes and outcomes to form ‘People’s Forum’ Steering group

•

Recruit and support individuals to work within each working group and participate in regular meetings of the ‘People’s Forum’.

•

YOU can help by identifying individuals who fit this criteria and would have interest in participating

Please connect: Don McLeod, Director, Citizen Engagement don@imaginecitizens.ca Judy Birdsell, Chair Judy@imaginecitizens.ca

SCAN Health © 2022

80

Our Role: Creating a ‘People’s Forum’ to work within the Community of Practice to encourage and support consistent attention to ensuring our collective efforts provide benefit to ALL those who live in Canada.

Citizens Forum

Sourcing & Procurement

SCAN Health © 2022

Leadership & Policy

Digital Supply Chain

Domestic Supplier Network

Workforce Sustainability

Supply Chain Security & Sustainability 81

Presentation to Supply Chain Resilience in Canadian Healthcare Systems

82

About CCAB

•

Established in 1984

•

National, Indigenous-led, member-based organization

•

Non-profit and non-partisan – receives no core government funding

•

Over 1,800 members, including 65%* Indigenous-owned

•

Key programs – PAR™, CAB, TFAB, Aboriginal Procurement Marketplace, Research, and Public Policy

* As of August 31, 2022

83

83

Indigenous Economy “Closing the socio-economic gaps between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people in Canada could lead to a $27.7 billion annual contribution to the Canadian Gross Domestic Product.” National Indigenous Economic Development Board ⮚ Indigenous peoples are Canada's youngest and fastest-growing demographic ⮚ The 2021 Census counted 1.8 million Indigenous people, or 5% of the total population ⮚ 350,000 Indigenous youth will reach the age of 15 between 2016 and 2026, at which point they will be eligible for the labour force. ⮚ Four out of every five First Nations reserves have median incomes that fall below the poverty line ⮚ Indigenous children in Canada are more than twice as likely to live in poverty than nonIndigenous children

84

84

Indigenous Inclusion Healthcare is the largest business sector in the world ⮚ Indigenous businesses tend to be quite small. There are over 62,000 self-employed Indigenous people in Canada (2016 Census)

⮚ One in three Indigenous businesses (33%) create employment for others (2016 Census) ⮚ Indigenous entrepreneurs continue to build businesses across a wide range of industry sectors ⮚ Indigenous businesses recognize the importance of innovation. More than half (54%) Indigenous businesses either introduced innovations in the forms of new products or services (43%) or new processes (32%) or spent on R&D (25%) in the past three years.

85

Procurement Part of the Answer Federal, Provincial & Territorial Governments have targets in place for Indigenous Procurement ⮚ Indigenous businesses are underrepresented in federal and provincial supply chains despite having the capacity to supply more than 24% of federal procurement needs ⮚ Targets of 5% Indigenous procurement target are achievable ⮚ Healthcare supply chains are a major opportunity to advance Economic Reconciliation

⮚ Some measures that will help the achieve this target: ⮚ Effectively communicating procurement opportunities

⮚ Ensuring compliance with minimum requirements ⮚ Developing skills to promote growth of Indigenous businesses ⮚ Stimulating Indigenous subcontracting through minimum requirements in primary contracts with non-Indigenous companies

86

86

COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE FOR SUPPLY CHAIN RESILIENCE IN CANADIAN HEALTH CARE SYSTEMS Achieving Equity in Canadian Healthcare: A Shared Vision October 20th, 2022 Healy

Aapooyaki Bonnie Blackfoot Confederacy Health Director

87

Panel Overview

Achieving Equity in Canadian Healthcare: A Shared Vision Session Description: The absence of supply in health supply chain is not just a logistical concern but a moral one as well, bearing on such issues as distributive justice and health equity. From a supply chain perspective, achieving equity in healthcare requires both ensuring that the distribution of critical supplies supports the health and wellbeing of historically disadvantaged, excluded, and vulnerable populations and that voices from these populations are included, from the outset, within the design processes of supply chain solutions themselves. As the COVID-19 pandemic made very clear, it is too late to wait until a crisis is unfolding to include citizens and the marginalized as active participants in our pandemic supply response. To ensure that its co-design strategies are equitable, the Community of Practice must engage with and receive input from the communities it wishes to serve.

Objectives:

• Orient Community of Practice participants to principles of equity, diversity, and inclusion, with a special focus on supply chain challenges for rural, remote, and marginalized communities.

• Identify some of the ways in which Community of Practice partners can work to address critical issues of equity.

• Explore how decisions are made between health systems and Indigenous communities, and the key considerations for co-creating solutions.

88

Health Equity from an Indigenous Lens • Understanding Inequities from Indigenous Worldview • Expressing experiences in Indigenous Language • Understanding the Legislation Landscape – Indigenous relationships with Canada’s Health system • Covid-19 and Indigenous populations in Canada

89

Jurisdictional Framework for First Nations Health within Canada is a patchwork of laws Aboriginal/Treaty Rights – Medicine Chest Clause Treaty 6

First Nation Laws

Federal Laws- Canada Health Act/Indian Act (excludes health)

Provincial Laws – Alberta Health Act (of general application)

Agreements - First Nations Contribution Agreements

Policies - 1979 Indian Health Policy 90

What is an Indigenous Health Legislation distinction based approach in Canada?

A distinction-based approach means that the Province's work with First Nations, Métis, and Inuit people will be conducted in a manner that acknowledges the specific rights, interests, priorities and concerns of each, while respecting and acknowledging these distinct Peoples with unique cultures, histories, rights, laws ... https://hir.harvard.edu/indigenous-healthcare-in-canada/

91

Examples:

– Collaborative process – Goal is to identify topics communities are interested in or would find useful – Topic ideas to be brought to AFNIGC 92

Closing the Gap In Alberta Life Expectancy for: Non-First Nations – same as Sweden, Singapore and Australia First Nations – same as Cambodia, Guatemala and Paraguay

93

ACCESS Access to care is an issue that contributes to poor health outcomes for First Nations.

In the recently released First Nations Regional Health Survey (RHS), respondents identified a number of health care barriers that include: • • • • • •

the inability to cover childcare costs, difficulty arranging and paying for transportation costs, excessive wait times, inadequate and culturally inappropriate care and difficulty finding practitioners.

94

Blackfoot Confederacy Covid-19 Medicine Line Vaccine Clinic

95

Equality vs Equity

96

BREAKOUT SESSION: REFINE WORKGROUP PRIORITIES

SCAN Health © 2022

Breakout Session Participants Leadership & Policy & Workforce Sustainability

Digital Supply Chain

Domestic Supplier Network Sustainability

Supply Chain Security & Sustainability

Sourcing, Procurement & Collab. Stockpile

A. Snowdon A. Berg, CAPDM H. Deehan, PHAC K. Sullivan, SDM L. Golding, Fasken M. Foss, CCAB K. Graham, AHS E. Rafferty, IHE J. Birdsell, citizen CBS S. Carswell, CBS K. MacMillan (virtual) C. Smith, AB Gov

C. Metge F. Bouchard, GS1 T. Murphy, AI D. Wolitski, IHE V. Somasundaram, PwC N. Pakieser, HIMSS

R. Johnson S. Armstrong, citizen L. Scott, HealthPro K. Shannon, MH Care L. Kilcrease, AI B. Hunt, CAPPEM C. Stevenson, AHS

C. Leuprecht A. Guitouni, U Vic K. Sokol, AHS N. Singh, Cdn Armed Forces J. Kosche, PHAC A. Duval, GS1 A. Schuster, CBS Z. Zwayyed, SCANH

J. Prasad S. MacNair, PHSA S. Mraiche, MH Care E. Dalia, SDM D. McLeod, Citizen V. Diano, CBS K. Frey, HealthPro S. Klimachevskaia, AHS

K. Cox, SCANH

To ensure even distribution of expertise and participation in each breakout group, we may have moved you from the group you originally requested. If you do not see your name, please select a group of your choosing.

SCAN Health © 2022

REPORT BACK ON WORKGROUP KEY PRIORITIES

SCAN Health © 2022

Breakout Sessions: Refine Workgroup Priorities

Jitendra Prasad CPO,Contracting, Procurement & Supply Management at Alberta Health Services (retired); Sashnap Consulting

DomesticRon Supplier Network Johnson Vice President, Eastern Health

Dr. Colleen Metge Associate Professor, University of Manitoba

Dr. Anne Snowdon Scientific Director & CEO, SCAN Health

Dr. Christian Leuprecht Director, Institute of Intergovernmental Relations, Queen’s University

Thank You for Your Participation Share your feedback with us!

103

If you have any questions, please e-mail us at info.SCANHealth@uwindsor.ca To learn more about us, visit www.SCANHealth.ca and find us on social media. @SCANHealthNCE @SCAN_Health @SCAN Health SCAN Health

Supply Chain Advancement Network in Health | 401 Sunset Ave, Windsor ON N9B 3P4

SCAN Health © 2022

104