Please note that the following is a digitized version of a selected article from White House History Quarterly, Issue 83, originally released in print form in 2026. Single print copies of the full issue can be purchased online at Shop.WhiteHouseHistory.org No part of this book may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. All photographs contained in this journal unless otherwise noted are copyrighted by the White House Historical Association and may not be reproduced without permission. Requests for reprint permissions should be directed to rights@whha.org. Contact books@whha.org for more information. © 2026 White House Historical Association. All rights reserved under international copyright conventions.
O P P O S I T E A N D A B O V E : J O H N F. K E N N E D Y P R E S I D E N T I A L L I B R A R Y A N D M U S E U M
“And Some Day A BEAUTIFUL China Service” First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy’s Unrealized Plans for a State Dinner Service LAUREN McGWIN
when 31-year old jacqueline kennedy stepped into the role of first lady, one of her first priorities was the restoration and preservation of the White House. In three short years she managed to transform the Executive Residence into a living museum, establish a fine arts committee and the first curator position, oversee the creation of the first White House guidebook and the White House Historical Association, and restore the interior rooms with historic furnishings. With these immense tasks, ordering new White House china understandably did not take precedence. She determined it would be best to use the historic china in collections storage for State Dinners and official functions.
white house history quarterly
75
76
white house history quarterly
J O H N F. K E N N E D Y P R E S I D E N T I A L L I B R A R Y A N D M U S E U M
J O H N F. K E N N E D Y P R E S I D E N T I A L L I B R A R Y A N D M U S E U M
this spread and previous spread Relying on historic White House china for both official and private events, First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy chose to put her many ambitious projects ahead of ordering a new State China Service when she arrived at the White House. The green-rimmed Truman State Service, one of her favorites, is seen (right) on tables set for a February 1962 dinner. She also chose the Truman State Service for a dinner in honor of President Truman himself (page 74). She enjoyed using the Lincoln State Service in the President’s Dining Room (opposite) and is seen holding a cup and saucer from the Franklin D. Roosevelt State Service during a reception in 1961, (page 75).
Chief Usher J. B. West wrote in his memoir about the first time he showed Mrs. Kennedy the collections storage located off-site in Maryland:
discover some remaining pieces of the Polk service, the Harrison service, and even some Lincoln pieces during her warehouse tour.
What she did find was china—and she was delighted. Following the 1929 law, every broken piece of china or silver had been stored in a special cupboard in the White House butler’s pantry until inventory time at the end of the year. When they were duly recorded as broken, we ceremoniously carted them off to the carpenter’s room, where we smashed the broken or chipped pieces with a sledgehammer. We then sent a butler to toss the pieces off Hains Point, into the Potomac River.
“Oh, Mr. West, we can use these in our upstairs dining room,” she whispered excitedly, wiping the dust off the Lincoln plates with her hand.1
Only after enough plates were broken and dumped in the river were we able to order new Presidential china. We couldn’t replace the broken pieces, because the manufacturer always destroyed the mold. So when the White House no longer had enough dishes to make a complete “set” for the State Dining Room, we retired the remaining pieces to the Fort Washington warehouse. As the Kennedys had no State china of their own choice, Mrs. Kennedy was happy to
After discovering the china already in storage, Mrs. Kennedy brought out the historic dinner services—including those ordered during the Abraham Lincoln, Rutherford B. Hayes, and Benjamin Harrison presidencies—for luncheons and everyday functions. She even tried to have some American china companies replicate the James Monroe State Service plates, but to no avail, stating “the results always looked more like hotel china.”2 Instead, for formal events such as State Dinners, President and Mrs. Kennedy opted to use the more contemporary dinner services. Their favorite combination was the green-rimmed Harry S. Truman State Dinner Service with the gold-rimmed service plates from the Dwight D. Eisenhower State Service.3 Public interest in a new service remained, however, even though the first lady had decided to use pieces currently in the White House Collection. The
white house history quarterly
77
Except for Service Plates ordered during the Eisenhower administration, it has not been necessary to buy new china.—February 2, 1961 Unfortunately, Mrs. Kennedy will not be studying the subject of a new chinaware design for the White House for some time to come. There are many more pressing matters to deal with first.—February 9, 1961 The White House china services are intact at the present time and she does not expect it will be necessary to order an additional set in the near future.—February 21, 1961 Mrs. Kennedy will not be ordering this china for some time to come.—February 23, 1961 She feels . . . it is too early to consider such a design at this particular time.—April 20, 19618 The message was clear: it was not the time to be ordering a new china service. The historic china already in the collection was believed to be sufficient, and restoring the White House interiors came first. Work on the interiors, including the Ground Floor, State Floor, official and private
78
rooms on the Second Floor, and certain areas of the West Wing continued during Mrs. Kennedy’s time as first lady.9 Throughout the Kennedy years individuals and companies preemptively offered their services and ideas on a design for a new china service, including Tiffany & Company, Lenox, and Castleton China. One writer, a jeweler from Middletown, New York, suggested using Pasco Bavarian China in the Monarch pattern, a simple service with a gold band around the rim, because he believed the royaltyinspired name was “fitting” for Mrs. Kennedy, but she declined at the time.10 When Tiffany & Company sent a sample plate with the Presidential Seal in the center saying it would make “a marvelous full service for the White House and replace that awful Lenox china that has accumulated there over the years,” Mrs. Kennedy was open to exploring Tiffany’s service at a later date if using the old china services was not successful. Even though the sample plate was cracked during its delivery from France, Mrs. Kennedy was impressed enough with it to ask whether a limited edition run of three or
white house history quarterly
SHUTTERSTOCK
White House Social Files at the John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum include letters from the public inquiring about presidential china. Mrs. Ade from Grafton, Ohio, for example, wrote on January 16, 1961, asking what happens to the china when the White House has a new president. Letitia Baldrige, the first lady’s social secretary, explained that china is used from president to president “unless through breakage” additional pieces would need to be ordered. She continued to make the point that a new service was not needed since President Eisenhower had ordered the goldrimmed service plates in 1955.4 The first lady was inundated with hundreds of letters requesting to purchase extra presidential dinnerware for personal collections, home decor, and art groups.5 The typical response from Baldrige was to say the request would be impossible since the White House china is government property.6 Furthermore, White House policy states that when pieces of White House china are no longer usable or beyond repair, they are to be destroyed.7 The Social Files also contain many letters pertaining to ordering new china. With each letter, a typed response from Baldrige on behalf of the first lady was sent, all with similar answers:
opposite China is stacked in a White House storeroom, 1961. Compotes from the Lincoln State China Service, a favorite of First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy, are seen on the floor just in front of the lowest shelf. right
A L L I M A G E S T H I S PA G E : W H I T E H O U S E H I S T O R I C A L A S S O C I AT I O N
Lenox, an American manufacturer of fine china from 1889 to 2020, suggested Mrs. Kennedy consider its bone china for a Kennedy State China Service. The company had previously produced (clockwise from top left) the Wilson, Truman, and FDR services, all of which were frequently used by Mrs. Kennedy for official events.
four plates could be made for the President’s Office and possibly one hundred or more as Christmas gifts. An estimate was requested for piecemeal pieces, but it is not known if they were ever made for the White House.11 Doing so could have possibly been too costly. The letters continued to come, and by October 1961, an Alberta Trimble from Kokomo, Indiana, even wrote to ask if a new dinnerware service was “top secret” and that was why there had been no announcement. Baldrige candidly replied, “Indeed, we would be able to tell you the dinnerware chosen by Mrs. Kennedy if she had already selected her
pattern. Nothing has been done on this as yet.”12 A turning point came in May 1962 with a letter Jacqueline Kennedy wrote to Henry Francis du Pont, collector of Americana and chair of the Fine Arts Committee for the White House, about his thoughts on ordering a new State Service.13 Mrs. Kennedy was ready to consider the prospect. Lenox, a longtime supplier of White House china, including the Woodrow Wilson, Franklin D. Roosevelt, and Harry S. Truman State Services, approached the first lady in June 1962 offering samples of its recently developed bone china, a durable yet lightweight clay body made with bone
white house history quarterly
79
80
white house history quarterly
T O P : W H I T E H O U S E H I S T O R I C A L A S S O C I A T I O N / B O T T O M : J O H N F. K E N N E D Y P R E S I D E N T I A L L I B R A R Y A N D M U S E U M
As Mrs. Kennedy began to consider the idea of creating a new china service, she hoped to find a color that would work in the State Dining Room with such gilded objects as the Monroe Plateau (seen below with the Truman State China Service). She observed that “the green Truman and unmatching gold Eisenhower plates are really not right with the Monroe bronzes,” and that “the plates should be Empire in feeling.” She considered the colors and motifs in sample pieces supplied by Sèvres (top) and a Greek key design embellished with a presidential seal featured on a sample supplied by an unknown American manufacturer (opposite).
WHITE HOUSE HISTORICAL ASS OCIATION
ash that promised to be “thinner, more translucent, and whiter than any other bone china made anywhere in the world. I believe, with the more sophisticated taste now in the White House, that a Kennedy presidential service could be developed with the new bone china that would be ‘out of this world.’”14 Mrs. Kennedy, still weighing her options, kept the sample on hand for later consideration. Castleton China, located in New Castle, Pennsylvania, and makers of the Eisenhower service plate, first offered its services to Mrs. Kennedy in November 1961 and again the following year in February 1962. Corresponding with the company over the next few months, Letitia Baldrige set up a meeting with consultant James S. Plaut on July 18, 1962, at the White House, where he took a tour and viewed the china on display. Afterward Plaut wrote that Castleton was working on some design suggestions for Mrs. Kennedy.15 It appears the first lady continued discussions with Castleton China the following year, and on March 4, 1963, Castleton China wrote to request a meeting to make selections from its design studies.16 By July 1963 Mrs. Kennedy had already been
considering a new service for more than a year since she had written to DuPont. In a memorandum to Chief Usher J. B. West she mentioned how her friend Jayne Wrightsman was looking into a few details for her about projects she would like to have done in the future. Under “China” she wrote, “A proposed service which you and I will look at and discuss and won’t order until we have the money— and, we will see if it is prettier and less expensive and able to be reordered than the plates I saw in Washington.”17 Mrs. Wrightsman had started looking at china as part of her research for the first lady and was told they would discuss what she found together that fall.18 Surviving color samples made by Sèvres Porcelain Manufactory show that Mrs. Kennedy was reviewing various shades of yellow and orange glazes and Empire design elements. As she told Henry du Pont, she was searching for a “warm yellow, almost melon” color and a simple Empire design so as not to clash with the James Monroe furnishings.19 A porcelain plate made from an unknown American manufacturer also submitted to Mrs. Kennedy provides the best glimpse of what her service might have looked like. It features a simple yellow border with a gilded Greek key pattern around the outer rim and gilded Presidential Seal at the top. However, there were still budget concerns, and while Mrs. Kennedy had started planning a new china service, other projects were considered more necessary. In a memorandum to Clark Clifford on November 3, 1963, she wrote about “two projects ahead I really care about—and then it will all be done—and the White House will be all I ever dreamed for it.”20 The two projects were new curtains for the East Room and curtains and chairs for the State Dining Room. On the last page of the memorandum she wrote: And some day a beautiful china service for State Dinners—as the green Truman and unmatching gold Eisenhower plates are really not right with the Monroe bronzes that we used on the table at state dinners. The plates should be Empire in feeling. . . . I am in the process of going over and approving designs for a state service, but maybe we’ll never get around to that and I’ll have to look for someone to donate it. I seem to have used [up] all donors I know. . . . But I will wait to hear from you when I can
white house history quarterly
81
B O T H P H O T O G R A P H S T H I S PA G E : G E T T Y I M A G E S
Mrs. Kennedy brought to the White House a cultivated interest and appreciation of historic and fine china. Her expertise would certainly have been reflected in the design of the Kennedy china, had the project been completed. She is seen here leaving the Navillus and Skull Antique Shop in London’s Fulham Road (top), where she purchased twenty pieces of antique British-made china in 1962. Below she visits the Vienna Porcelain Manufactory Augarten in Austria, 1961.
82
white house history quarterly
notes 1.
J. B. West, with Mary Lynn Kotz, Upstairs at White House: My Life with the First Ladies (New York: Grand Central Publishing, 1974), 241.
2. Jacqueline Kennedy to Lady Bird Johnson, April 8, 1966, White House Famous Names, Correspondence Files, Mrs. John F. Kennedy, Lyndon B. Johnson Presidential Library and Museum, Austin, Tex. (hereafter White House Famous Names, LBJ Library). 3. William G. Allman, Official White House China: From the 18th to the 21st Centuries, 4th ed. (Washington, D.C.: White House Historical Association, 2025), 183. 4. I. Ade to Jacqueline Kennedy, January 16, 1961, and Letitia Baldrige to I. Ade, February 2, 1961, Papers of John F. Kennedy, White House Social Files, Subject Files: China (Presidential), box 0118, John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum, Boston, Mass. (hereafter White House Social Files, Kennedy Library). 5. Reference to hundreds of letters found in letter from Letitia Baldrige to Mrs. Richard A. Jensen, October 23, 1962, White House Social Files, Kennedy Library. 6. Ibid. 7. Constance Carter and Betty C. Monkman, “Lady Bird Johnson’s Official White House China Dessert Plates: The State Flowers,” White House History Quarterly, no. 63 (Fall 2021): 52. 8. Letitia Baldrige to I. Ade, February 2, 1961; Baldrige to Kathryn H. Somers, February 9, 1961; Baldrige to Austin E. Gray, February 21, 1961; Baldrige to N. J. Arrayet, February 23, 1961; Baldrige to Frederick J. Cuthbertson, April 20, 1961, all White House Social Files, Kennedy Library.
WHITE HOUS E HISTORICAL AS SOCIATION
Although First Lady Lady Bird Johnson considered Mrs. Kennedy’s unrealized vision for a State China Service, the state flower illustrations she chose for the Lyndon Johnson State China Service were very different from the classical motifs Mrs. Kennedy had in mind.
order the dining room redone—and if I can’t find a donor for the china—when I ever can order that.21 That “some day” for Mrs. Kennedy’s “beautiful china service” never came. Nineteen days after she wrote to Clifford, President Kennedy was assassinated. Years later, Mrs. Kennedy wrote to the new first lady, Lady Bird Johnson, that she had been working on a new State Service but lacked the funds to complete the order. She believed a simple Empire design would match the gilded furnishings purchased by President James Monroe and not clash with the different flowers throughout the year.22 Mrs. Johnson replied, “Your letter was so sweet and your knowledge and love of the White House china [come] through in everything you say. . . . Thank you so very much for all your thoughts and they will be in my mind as we work.”23 Lady Bird Johnson went on to order a service in her own style, as did other first ladies in the years that followed. Had Mrs. Kennedy’s china service come to fruition, it would no doubt have been a timeless design—one that presidents and first ladies decades later could have used as a historic service, as Mrs. Kennedy once did when she first entertained guests at the White House.
9. James Archer Abbott and Elaine Rice Bachmann, Designing Camelot: The Kennedy White House Restoration and Its Legacy (Washington, D.C.: White House Historical Association, 2021), 53, 56. 10. Austin E. Gray to Jacqueline Kennedy, January 28, 1961, and Letitia Baldrige to Gray, February 21, 1961, White House Social Files, Kennedy Library. 11. Walter Hoving to Jacqueline Kennedy, November 16, 1961, and Letitia Baldrige to Hoving, November 22, 1961, White House Social Files, Kennedy Library. 12. Alberta C. Trimble to Letitia Baldrige, October 8, 1961, and Letitia Baldrige to Trimble, October 19, 1961, White House Social Files, Kennedy Library. 13. Jacqueline Kennedy to Henry Francis du Pont, May 1, 1962, quoted in Allman, Official White House China, 183. 14. John M. Tassie to Letitia Baldrige, June 21, 1962, White House Social Files, Kennedy Library. 15. W.P.C. Adams to Jacqueline Kennedy, November 6, 1961; James S. Plaut to Jacqueline Kennedy, “Cross Reference Sheet,” February 24, 1962; Letitia Baldrige to James S. Plaut, March 30, 1962; Plaut to Baldrige, July 20, 1962, all White House Social Files, Kennedy Library. 16. Allman, Official White House China, 183. 17. Jacqueline Kennedy to J. B. West, July 9, 1963, Jacqueline Bouvier Kennedy Onassis Personal Papers, J. B. West Memos, Kennedy Library (hereafter Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Personal Papers, J. B. West Memos, Kennedy Library). 18. Jacqueline Kennedy to Jayne Wrightsman, July 9, 1963, Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Personal Papers, J. B. West Memos, Kennedy Library. 19. Quoted in Allman, Official White House China, 183. 20. Jacqueline Kennedy to Clark Clifford, November 3, 1963, Clark Clifford Personal Papers, Correspondence with Jacqueline Kennedy, 1961–1965, Kennedy Library. 21. Ibid. 22. Jacqueline Kennedy to Lady Bird Johnson, April 8, 1966, White House Famous Names, LBJ Library. 23. Lady Bird Johnson to Jacqueline Kennedy, May 9, 1966, White House Famous Names, LBJ Library.
white house history quarterly
83