Skip to main content

The Bridge: Journal of Educational Research and Theory Vol 3

Page 1

Journal of Educational Research and Theory

Vol.3 Spring/Summer 2026 1


Journal of Educational Research and Theory Vol. 3 Spring/Summer 2026 Published by The Bridge

Education Consultant to The Bridge Dr Karen L Taylor

The Bridge Wellington College Dukes Ride Crowthorne RG45 7PU Email: thebridge@wellingtoncollege.org.uk Web: thebridge.wellingtoncollege.org.uk Follow us on: LinkedIn Phone: +44 (0) 1344 444 238


Introduction Vol.3 Karen L. Taylor Welcome to the third volume of The Bridge: Journal of Educational Research and Theory! This journal seeks to build a vibrant community of inquiry that explores the interconnectedness of educational theory, research, practice, and purpose. We aim to foster meaningful collaboration between classroom practitioners and university researchers in a dialogic space of mutual exchange—one that challenges hierarchical notions of knowledge and promotes a shared, transformative understanding of learning and teaching. Together, we contribute to a growing body of knowledge that addresses the complexities of contemporary education. The articles in this volume offer a wide range of provocative insights into teaching and learning across diverse contexts. Collectively, they invite us to reexamine our principles, values, and practices as educators. We hope these articles stimulate reflection, dialogue, and continued inquiry into the pressing challenges and possibilities in education today.

Exploring Signature Pedagogies to Innovate Teacher Education and Work in Africa “Recognizing culturally grounded methods enhances teacher engagement and supports the adoption of innovative pedagogical approaches.” In his article, Abdeljalil Akkari examines the potential of the concept of “signature pedagogies” to enrich international debates on teacher education and professional practice in Africa. By foregrounding culturally rooted teaching methods, signature pedagogies offer a pathway to reconnect schooling with Africa’s rich cultural traditions. The legacy of colonial education has often produced rigid, decontextualized institutions that struggle to convey meaningful learning. Akkari’s study proposes integrating signature pedagogies with the principles of African teaching to foster more relevant, engaging, and transformative educational practices.

Beyond the Quick Fix: Culture, Agency and Sustainable Change in Education “Sustained improvement depends on leaders’ ability to create virtuous cycles of growth.” Kathryn Taylor’s article offers a solution to the problems schools face in embedding new initiatives by synthesizing research on organizational cultural dynamics and professional learning. Taylor provides a vision that empowers leaders while maintaining accountability. Rejecting both top-down and laissez-faire autonomy, Taylor advocates for democratic and deliberate curation of organizational learning and professional flourishing.

Exclusion by Design? School Exclusion and the Right to Education: A RightsBased Critique of Policy and Practice in the UK “Exclusion is not simply a disciplinary response to behaviour, but is embedded within wider accountability-driven education systems that generate and sustain exclusionary practices.” Christine Haslett’s article exposes the contradiction between international human rights obligations and domestic policy by highlighting persistent gaps between legislation, policy and practice, as well as the perverse incentives that shape decision-making in schools. Haslett 3


argues that exclusion cannot be meaningfully reduced without addressing its underlying structural drivers, including poverty and systemic inequality.

Defining and Cultivating Teaching Excellence: A Contextual Model for an International School in Shanghai “Excellence is culturally mediated.” Kay Yang and Jenny Lou’s findings highlight the contextual nature of excellence, challenging one-size-fits-all frameworks and advocating for culturally responsive definitions. Their proposed model offers actionable strategies for teacher development, evaluation, and school culture transformation, emphasizing collaborative reflection, student voice, and iterative improvement. Bridging theory and practice, their research contributes to global conversations on teaching excellence.

Leadership Competencies in International Schools: A Survey Study of Employee Perceptions Using the School Implementation Leadership Scale “The implementation of evidence-based practices requires changing systems, modifying behaviours and convincing practitioners.” Jordan Benedict’s study contributes to international education research by providing the first validation of the School Implementation Leadership Scale in international school contexts, establishing a baseline for future research and leadership development.

4


Contents

Page

Exploring Signature Pedagogies to Innovate Teacher Education and Work in Africa Abdeljalil Akkari, University of Geneva

7

Beyond the Quick fFx: Culture, Agency and Sustainable Change in Education

21

Dr Kathryn Taylor, Work Collaborative Exclusion by Design? School Exclusion and the Right to Education: A Rights-Based Critique of Policy and Practice in the UK

33

Christine Haslett, Wellington College International, Lagos Defining and Cultivating Teaching Excellence: A Contextual Model for an International School in Shanghai

45

Kay Yang, Wellington College International Shanghai Jenny Lou, Wellington College International Shanghai Survey Study of Employee Perceptions Using the School Implementation Leadership Scale Jordan Benedict, Paris American International University

59


6


Exploring Signature Pedagogies to Innovate Teacher Education and Work in Africa Abdeljalil Akkari, University of Geneva Abstract This article examines the potential of the concept of “signature pedagogies” to enrich international debates on teacher education and professional practice in Africa. By foregrounding culturally rooted teaching methods, signature pedagogies offer a pathway to reconnect schooling with Africa’s diverse cultural traditions. The legacy of colonial education has often produced rigid, decontextualized institutions that struggle to convey meaningful learning. This study proposes integrating signature pedagogies with the principles of African teaching to foster more relevant, engaging, and transformative educational practices.

Key words: Signature Pedagogies, Africa, teachers, basic education Introduction Introduced by Shulman (2005a), the concept of “signature pedagogy” refers to practices that are particularly structured, coherent, and influential in shaping the ways in which a profession teaches and learns. This article explores the potential of applying the concept of signature pedagogies to innovate teacher training and professional practice in Africa. For decades, the teaching profession on the continent has faced persistent challenges, and there is broad consensus that, without a fundamental rethinking of the profession, meaningful improvements in the quality of basic education are unlikely. While international cooperation and African governments have addressed issues such as funding, professional development, and the recruitment of teachers, the nature and quality of teaching itself have remained a largely neglected pedagogical dimension of the debate.

The conceptual framework of signature pedagogies The concept of signature pedagogy was originally introduced by Shulman (2005a) to describe distinctive forms of teaching and learning that define how knowledge and professional expertise are acquired within a given field. Shulman illustrates this with the example of clinical rounds and bedside instruction in medical education, where the pedagogical approach shapes both skill development and professional identity. According to Shulman, signature pedagogies comprise three interrelated dimensions: (a) surface structure (observable teaching strategies), (b) deep structure (assumptions about knowledge and learning), and (c) implicit structure (underlying professional beliefs and values). The surface structure encompasses the concrete, operational aspects of teaching and learning, including demonstrating, questioning, interacting, or strategically withholding engagement (pp. 54–55). The deep structure refers to the implicit assumptions regarding the most effective ways to transmit specific knowledge, skills, or experiences. Finally, the implicit structure embodies the beliefs, values, and professional dispositions that the pedagogy seeks to instill (p. 55). A defining characteristic of signature pedagogies is their deliberate selection over alternative approaches due to their proven capacity to shape emerging professionals. Ideally, this choice is guided by both empirical research and accumulated experiential knowledge. 7


According to Shulman (2005a), signature pedagogies in a profession refer to the ways in which future practitioners—such as pre-service teachers—are educated to think, perform, and act with integrity, in alignment with the standards and practices of their field. This raises critical questions for teacher education: What mental, physical, and emotional habits are essential for the teaching profession? How can these competencies be effectively cultivated? Signature pedagogies address these questions by introducing students to the essential dimensions of professional work. They structure learners’ experiences to familiarize them with the core habits of mind and practices expected in their discipline, thereby shaping both competence and professional identity. Shulman’s conceptual framework can be enriched by linking it to three well-established constructs in the social sciences: communities of practice (Wenger, 1998), theory of practice and habitus (Bourdieu, 1977), and ethnotheories (Harkness & Super, 1992). Communities of practice are defined as “groups of people who share a concern, a set of problems, or a passion about a topic, and who deepen their knowledge and expertise by interacting on an ongoing basis” (Wenger et al., 2002). Wenger (1998) emphasizes that such communities are pervasive and often informal, yet they offer rich opportunities to rethink institutional practices. They encompass four dimensions—meaning, practice, community, and identity—and provide newcomers with both competence and engagement, allowing them to incorporate skills into their professional identities. A well-functioning community of practice also fosters innovation and the creation of knowledge, as mutual engagement around a shared enterprise encourages experimentation within a supportive structure (Wenger, 1998, p. 214). Viewed through this lens, signature pedagogies can be seen as tools for cultivating “communities of pedagogical practice,” with teacher education serving as a space for professional socialization. Bourdieu’s concept of habitus (1977, 1980) provides a complementary perspective. Lenoir (2007) proposed habitus as a framework for understanding teachers’ “practical relationship to pedagogical practice.” Habitus comprises the internalized schemes, dispositions, and patterns of perception through which individuals engage with social and organizational structures. It shapes the logic of practice, guiding teachers’ actions while reflecting both personal interests and broader social conditions. For Bourdieu, habitus constitutes the collective internalization of cultural and social structures, producing a shared worldview and set of dispositions that shape how individuals perceive and act in the world (Bourdieu, 1977, p. 86). In Shulman’s terminology, habitus closely aligns with the deep structure of signature pedagogies. From a sociocultural perspective, drawing on Vygotsky (1978) and Wertsch (1994), learning and action are viewed as processes that transform individuals into fully participating members of society. Cultural artifacts—both intellectual (concepts, symbols, habitus) and material (tools, resources)—mediate these processes, shaping reasoning, thought, and behaviour. Teacher education, therefore, involves equipping learners with the cultural and intellectual tools necessary to participate meaningfully in social and professional practices. Finally, the concept of ethnotheories (Harkness & Super, 1992) is particularly relevant in the African context. Ethnotheories represent shared cultural beliefs about child development and socialization practices, linking developmental goals to culturally informed behaviours. While originally applied to parental beliefs, the concept can be extended to teachers, who may hold professional ethnotheories that connect pedagogical practices to culturally grounded norms and values. In this way, signature pedagogies can integrate professional training with the cultural expectations and practices of the communities in which teachers work. 8


In summary, Shulman’s concept of signature pedagogies offers a powerful framework for linking teacher education to professional, social, and cultural dimensions of practice. By connecting signature pedagogies to communities of practice, habitus, and ethnotheories, we gain a richer understanding of how teachers learn to act, think, and engage in meaningful professional work. This multidimensional perspective underscores the potential of signature pedagogies as a source of inspiration for rethinking teacher training and professional practice in Africa.

The crisis of teacher education in West Africa The teaching profession in Africa has been experiencing a multifaceted crisis for decades. In this context, signature pedagogies offer a promising framework for rethinking teacher education, particularly in West Africa. Classroom observations in Niger, conducted by Akkari, Sagayar, and Saibou (2024), reveal a striking pattern: teachers are highly active, performing routines such as writing on the blackboard, consulting textbooks, and addressing individual students, while students remain largely passive, mechanically repeating teacher instructions. Language barriers—particularly the use of French as the medium of instruction— and dominant memorization-based methods exacerbate students’ difficulties in learning. Teachers often lack adequate resources and rely on repetitive procedures without assessing actual student learning. In this environment, signature pedagogies are particularly relevant because they counter teaching approaches that inhibit meaningful student learning, including passivity, invisibility, anonymity, and lack of accountability (Shulman, 2005b). The current structure of initial teacher training in West Africa typically consists of theoretical coursework, methodological instruction, and brief practical internships, arranged sequentially with minimal interaction between teacher educators and prospective teachers. Shulman’s insights into signature pedagogies offer three particularly pertinent points for this context: 1. Systematic yet flexible preparation: While teacher education benefits from structured preparation through signature pedagogies, it should avoid a narrow or mechanistic approach to professional training. 2. Engagement with uncertainty: Signature pedagogies require active student-teacher interaction and prepare novice teachers to make professional judgments under uncertainty—a daily reality in African classrooms. 3. Affective and ethical development: Signature pedagogies influence learners’ values, dispositions, and professional character, fostering the holistic development of teachers (Falk, 2006; Shulman, 2005a). Shulman (2005c) further emphasizes that effective teacher training requires powerful, consistent models of practice that learners can study, reflect on, and engage with deeply. Traditional student teaching, in contrast, often disperses candidates across multiple sites, creating uncertainty about what they observe, do, and how their learning is monitored—a pattern common in African teacher education. Rethinking teacher preparation through signature pedagogies, therefore, requires providing future teachers with models of practice tailored to resource-constrained classrooms. One strategy for achieving this is the development of communities of practice (Wenger, 1998). By creating networks of teachers, school leaders, and stakeholders, these communities facilitate collective development, sharing, and refinement of teaching practices that integrate both academic knowledge and local cultural contexts. Signature pedagogies, as core methods of teaching that shape thinking patterns, skills, and values, can be adapted within these networks to suit African classrooms. 9


The process begins with identifying and documenting local signature pedagogies. Teachers can observe classrooms, interview colleagues, and analyse cultural practices to capture surface structures (observable activities), deep structures (cognitive processes), and implicit structures (values and norms). Practices such as storytelling, role-play, garden-based learning, and community projects can be formalized through case studies or instructional videos. Recognizing culturally grounded methods enhances teacher engagement and supports the adoption of innovative pedagogical approaches (Makgato & Mji, 2017). Next, forming collaborative teacher networks ensures ongoing professional development. These networks—whether local, district-level, or virtual—enable peer learning, reflective practice, and intergenerational knowledge sharing, strengthening both confidence and the adoption of signature pedagogies (Wenger, 1998). Integrating local resources and contextual knowledge is critical to linking pedagogy to students’ lived experiences. Teachers can use accessible materials, such as seeds or recycled items, and implement outdoor and community-based learning projects to teach mathematics, science, and art. Incorporating local stories, folklore, and traditions into lesson plans reinforces cultural relevance and improves engagement, critical thinking, and problem-solving skills (UNESCO, 2015). Reflection and critical thinking are essential for moving beyond imitation toward conscious pedagogical development. Journals, group discussions, and video review sessions allow teachers to analyse classroom interactions and evaluate methods critically. Reflective practice encourages teachers to consider both student responses and the broader social impact of their teaching, refining the “doing” and “thinking” dimensions of pedagogy (Shulman, 2005a). Mentorship and peer coaching further sustain professional growth. Pairing novice teachers with experienced practitioners, co-teaching, and reciprocal coaching reinforce deep and implicit pedagogical structures, demonstrating how values and reasoning are embedded in classroom practice (Kraft et al., 2021). Leveraging technology and social media can connect geographically dispersed teachers and accelerate knowledge sharing. Platforms such as WhatsApp, Telegram, or Facebook, as well as mobile instructional videos, provide opportunities for discussions, lesson sharing, and problem-solving, especially in rural settings where professional isolation is common (Mungai, 2019). Engaging stakeholders beyond teachers—including parents, community leaders, and education authorities—helps create a supportive ecosystem for signature pedagogies. Community projects linking classroom learning to social responsibility, along with policy advocacy supporting locally grounded innovation, reinforce the relevance and sustainability of pedagogical practices (Chireshe, 2013). Finally, evaluating and disseminating impact ensures that effective practices are validated and scaled. Monitoring student outcomes in academic performance, critical thinking, problem-solving, and social values, alongside teacher reflections on classroom changes, provides evidence of effectiveness and encourages wider adoption (Bansilal, Shalem, & Mkhwanazi, 2018). In sum, signature pedagogies offer a comprehensive approach to rethinking teacher training in West Africa, linking professional knowledge, local cultural practices, and reflective engagement to enhance the quality of education under challenging conditions. 10


Exemplary teachers produce signature pedagogies Some researchers use the term “effective teachers” to denote those who consistently demonstrate best teaching practices. In practice, the notions of effective teachers, exemplary teachers, and those producing signature pedagogies overlap, reflecting educators who distinguish themselves through their professional competence and educational leadership. The literature on best teaching practices, often framed in terms of effectiveness (Bissonnette, Richard & Gauthier, 2005; Carette, 2008; Hattie, 2012; Talbot, 2012), has largely been produced in the global North, although research in the African context also exists (Altet, Paré Kaboré & Sall, 2015; Kouraogo & Ouedraogo, 2009). Terminology varies across studies: expert, experienced, effective, equitable, good, excellent, outstanding teacher, or leader. Beyond standardized test outcomes, researchers have sought to identify the typical characteristics of effective teachers (Hattie, 2012; Talbot, 2012; Kouaraogo & Ouedraogo, 2009; Bru, 2002; Bressoux, 2001). According to Hattie (2012), the most critical element of teaching effectiveness is the visibility of teaching by students and of learning by teachers. Based on this principle, he and others identify five characteristics of exemplary teachers: • • • • •

Organization and use of knowledge: Effective teachers structure and plan learning activities, adapt instruction to context and student needs, and present content clearly (Talbot, 2012). Classroom climate: They create a positive, low-stress environment that promotes teacher-student interaction (Talbot, 2012; Fofana, 2011; Kouaraogo & Ouedraogo, 2009; Carette, 2008). Assessment and feedback: They continually evaluate student understanding before, during, and after learning, providing timely and constructive feedback. Beliefs and expectations: Effective teachers maintain high expectations for all students, fostering motivation and growth (Carette, 2008). Learning-focused assessment: Assessment is used to support learning rather than as an end goal (Carette, 2008).

A good teacher adapts to classroom context, innovates beyond routine, and adjusts practices based on ongoing reflection and evaluation. Carette (2008) found that teacher intention toward students is a decisive factor in promoting classroom performance. Kouaraogo and Ouedraogo (2009) distinguish between exemplary teachers and best practices: the former exhibit personal traits such as enthusiasm and dedication, while the latter consist of observable and modellable practices such as classroom management and instructional organization. They identify three key characteristics of exemplary teachers: • • •

Control: Mastery of classroom dynamics, pedagogical knowledge, and professional role. Initiative: Encouragement of student autonomy and initiative. Interpersonal relationships: Positive interactions with students inside and outside the classroom, influencing engagement and performance.

Bressoux (2001) emphasizes the need to evaluate teacher effectiveness through both behavioural observation and cognitive outcomes, highlighting that teaching efficiency emerges from the interaction between teacher practices and student learning, rather than as an inherent attribute of the teacher.

11


Meta-analyses confirm that learning-centred, explicit teaching methods are highly effective (Bissonnette, Richard & Gauthier, 2005; Talbot, 2012). These methods involve clear demonstration, group and individual exercises, and systematic review, consistent with cognitive psychology research. Bru (2002) further distinguishes the characteristics of individual teachers from those of teaching practice itself, proposing stability over time as a key indicator for identifying exemplary practices. Large-scale initiatives such as the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation’s Measures of Effective Teaching (MET) use student assessments, questionnaires, and observations to identify and refine effective teaching practices (Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, 2015). In the African context, several additional factors shape effective teaching. Classroom size, language of instruction, and resource scarcity are central considerations. Fofana (2011) notes that large class sizes in Côte d’Ivoire necessitate collectivized teaching strategies, repetitive chains of participation, and classroom-level valorisation of student contributions. Likewise, using national or mother-tongue languages enhances student engagement, interaction, and comprehension compared to instruction solely in French (Kouraogo & Ouedraogo, 2009; Clegg, 2005; Maurer, 2010). Mother-tongue education has been associated with improved academic performance, higher attendance, and greater inclusivity, particularly for girls. Our research in Burkina Faso, Senegal, Chad, and Niger (2014–2024) sought to identify exemplary teaching practices and signature pedagogies under conditions of adversity: overcrowded classrooms, limited teaching materials, students’ limited comprehension of French, and unwelcoming infrastructure. The profile of the exemplary teacher that emerged can be summarized as follows: • • • • • • • • •

Adapts instruction between direct teaching and facilitation, depending on class size (50–90 students) and activity type Ensures equitable educational practices, giving all students, including girls and weaker learners, equal opportunities Maintains high expectations for all students Demonstrates expertise in teaching processes, ensuring comprehension of learning objectives Fosters a pleasant, respectful classroom environment, free from fear or violence. Adapts didactic activities to classroom context Links time on task directly to learning activities Ensures clarity and organization in lesson presentation Employs diversified assessment methods, combining written and oral evaluations, individual and group assessments, to monitor progress effectively.

This portrait highlights the complex interplay between individual teacher traits, classroom context, and adaptive practices necessary to achieve excellence in West African classrooms. The table on the next page summarizes the portrait of an exemplary African teacher:

12


Level of recruitment, training and experience

Professional ethics

•

•

•

•

• • • • • • • • • • • • •

Long teaching experience Continuous professional development using the local professional environment (inspectors, directors, and colleagues) as a source of inspiration Regardless of the level of initial training and recruitment, the exemplary teacher may be the graduate of a teachereducation institution or recruited without training as a “community teacher”

• •

•

Interpersonal relations

Commitment to • the profession despite unfavourable working conditions and low salaries • Love and passion for the profession/ vocation • The importance of teacher conscientiousness regardless of the number of students and adverse teaching conditions (overcrowded classes) Ongoing evaluation of students.

Regular, cordial, respectful and appreciative relationship in school Helping other colleagues and students Involvement in the life of local communities

Conduct of teaching

•

•

•

Adherence to the national curriculum while adapting it to the local learners’ environment Importance of satisfactory results in national examinations Use of the local language when students do not understand French

Level of recruitment, training and experience Professional ethics Interpersonal relations Conduct of teaching Long teaching experience Continuous professional development using the local professional environment (inspectors, directors, and colleagues) as a source of inspiration Regardless of the level of initial training and recruitment, the exemplary teacher may be the graduate of a teacher-education institution or recruited without training as a “community teacher” Commitment to the profession despite unfavourable working conditions and low salaries Love and passion for the profession/vocation The importance of teacher conscientiousness regardless of the number of students and adverse teaching conditions (overcrowded classes) Ongoing evaluation of students Regular, cordial, respectful and appreciative relationship in school Helping other colleagues and students 13


• • • •

Involvement in the life of local communities. Adherence to the national curriculum while adapting it to the local learners’ environment. Importance of satisfactory results in national examinations. Use of the local language when students do not understand French.

A crucial question arises: can teachers be trained to become exemplary and implement signature pedagogies, or are these qualities primarily the result of personal attributes? Evidence suggests that while personal commitment and inherent qualities play a role, the development of signature pedagogies can be actively supported through practical experience, as well as initial and in-service teacher training. Structured professional preparation, combined with reflective practice and engagement in communities of practice, can cultivate the knowledge, skills, and dispositions necessary for teachers to embody exemplary practices in diverse classroom contexts.

Signature pedagogies for improving the quality of teachers’ work The concept of signature pedagogies was popularized by Shulman in the early 2000s, particularly in relation to professional education in fields such as law, medicine, engineering, social work, and education. Signature pedagogy refers to the distinctive forms of teaching and learning characteristic of specific professions or disciplines. These methods embody the values, skills, and knowledge fundamental to professional practice, shaping how students think, perform, and act with integrity in their field. In education, signature pedagogies have become a highly influential framework for understanding teaching and learning across professions. However, the concept has been primarily explored in the Global North, with limited literature addressing its application in the Global South, particularly Africa (Amadasun, 2021). Reflection on basic education in Africa can be guided by two complementary avenues: 1. Revisiting traditional African teaching, to identify cultural anchor points relevant to contemporary educational challenges 2. Exploring alternative pedagogical approaches, such as Freirian pedagogy, to rethink the conception and purpose of schooling. This dual approach requires a decolonial perspective, breaking with the colonial legacy that continues to influence African education. While educational reforms in other regions have adapted to local cultural contexts over time, in many African schools, colonial schooling remains a foreign model. Adams and Coulibaly (1985) identify principles of traditional African learning that provide a foundation for culturally sensitive education: • • • • • •

Active pedagogy: Competencies are acquired through participation in meaningful activities Productive pedagogy: Learning generates products or services of social or economic value Status reinforcement: The “one who knows” holds a superior social status, reinforced through respectful interaction Affective engagement: Learning involves personalized teacher-learner relationships High motivation: Learning is driven by social and economic needs, with minimal external incentives Modelling: Knowledge is acquired indirectly through observation, imitation, and 14


• • • •

participation Integrated learning: Learning a skill concurrently exposes learners to other domains of knowledge Peer-group learning: Age-based groups facilitate mutual instruction through discussion and demonstration Oral transmission: Knowledge is primarily conveyed orally, fostering memory development Mastery learning: Tasks are appropriate to learners’ levels, with sufficient time allocated for mastery; achieving competence is the primary goal (pp. 277–278)

Far from being nostalgic, these traditional methods connect schooling to African cultural heritage, a connection also supported by signature pedagogies. Mansilla and Chua (2017) argue that signature pedagogies contribute to learning in several ways: 1. Encouraging teachers to cultivate deep, relevant, and lasting learning beyond mere information acquisition 2. Echoing culturally relevant practices, enhancing students’ ability to recognize and apply knowledge outside school 3. Integrating students’ experiences into a holistic learning journey, moving beyond fragmented activities to active participation 4. Positioning teachers as professionals capable of informed judgment, able to respond to emergent situations, technologies, or observations on student learning. In African basic education, signature pedagogies shape how students learn not only academic content but also practical skills, thinking patterns, and social values (Shulman, 2005). At the surface level, these are the observable teaching methods and classroom activities. Teachers often employ storytelling, songs, chants, and role-play to engage students, while group work and peer teaching encourage cooperation (Makgato & Mji, 2017; Chireshe, 2013). Lessons frequently involve direct demonstrations and outdoor activities, such as planting in school gardens or exploring local markets. Teachers creatively use local resources—sticks, seeds, stones, or recycled materials—to teach mathematics, science, or art (Mungai, 2019). For example, students may count with seeds, observe plant growth, or dramatize folktales to convey moral lessons. These activities constitute the visible “doing” part of learning. Beneath these visible practices lies the deep structure, shaping how students think and reason (Shulman, 2005a). In mathematics, students learn to estimate quantities, recognize patterns, and solve real-life problems, such as calculating marketplace prices (Bansilal et al., 2018). Literacy instruction emphasizes comprehension and oral expression, encouraging students to retell folktales, reflect on characters’ decisions, and discuss moral lessons (Njoroge, 2017). Science lessons foster observation, prediction, and experimentation using familiar phenomena such as plant growth, water cycles, or solar energy (UNESCO, 2015). The deep structure cultivates problem-solving, critical thinking, and the ability to apply knowledge meaningfully. Underlying both surface and deep structures is the implicit structure, which conveys unspoken values, social norms, and professional dispositions (Shulman, 2005). African classrooms often emphasize respect for elders, teachers, and peers, as well as community responsibility, honesty, and resilience (Chireshe, 2013; Makgato & Mji, 2017). These values are communicated subtly through daily interactions, classroom routines, and culturally relevant stories or proverbs. For example, students maintaining a school garden develop cooperation, responsibility, and pride, while teachers model respectful discussion and ethical behaviour. 15


Effective pedagogy in this context also relies on cultivating mental, physical, and heart habits (Kraft et al., 2021). Mental habits involve reasoning, reflection, and problem-solving. Students are encouraged to ask questions, predict outcomes, and compare solutions to practical challenges, such as designing water collection systems or analysing local farming techniques. Physical habits encompass practical skills, including writing, measuring, planting, building, or dramatizing stories (Mungai, 2019). Heart habits involve emotional and social competencies, such as empathy, perseverance, collaboration, and pride in local culture (UNESCO, 2015; Njoroge, 2017). Consider a fourth-grade science lesson in a rural African school: students plant seeds, predict growth, observe results, and explain their reasoning. At the surface level, the teacher guides the activity and facilitates discussion. At the deep level, students engage in analytical reasoning and problem-solving. Implicitly, they cultivate responsibility, patience, and respect for life. Simultaneously, mental, physical, and heart habits are actively developed. This integration exemplifies how African basic education fosters holistic learning, blending knowledge, skills, and character development.

Conclusion I consider Shulman’s concept of signature pedagogies to be a particularly useful and appropriate tool for rethinking the role of teachers and pedagogy in West Africa. One of its main strengths lies in its reversal of the conventional approach to educational theory and innovation. Traditionally, pedagogical models are derived from psychological or philosophical theories—such as those of Piaget or Rogers—and then translated into teaching methods, for example, active or socio-constructivist pedagogies. In contrast, signature pedagogies adopt a bottom-up approach, grounded in the actual practices that teachers implement in real classrooms. This perspective values intuition, creativity, and the practical resolution of complex problems, recognizing that the most effective pedagogical ideas often emerge from direct classroom experience. In the West African context, this approach has particular significance. Teacher education in many countries of the region has long been dominated by theoretical instruction, rigid curricula, and short practical internships that offer limited opportunities for meaningful engagement with real classrooms. By focusing on existing effective teaching practices, signature pedagogies provide a framework for teacher trainers to identify and formalize approaches that are already successful in local contexts, including strategies for managing large classes, integrating mother-tongue instruction, and engaging students with limited resources. They offer a means to bridge theory and practice, helping pre-service and inservice teachers internalize not only the “how” but also the “why” of effective teaching. Developing signature pedagogies in West Africa also involves recognizing the cultural and social foundations of learning. By observing and reflecting on what exemplary teachers already do—how they organize classroom interactions, nurture student participation, and transmit social values—teacher educators can design training programs that are contextually relevant, culturally resonant, and capable of fostering holistic learning. This process transforms teacher education from a prescriptive, top-down endeavour into a collaborative and reflective practice, where prospective teachers learn through modelling, guided practice, and mentorship within communities of practice. Ultimately, the signaturepedagogies approach not only improves pedagogical quality but also redefines the professional identity of teachers in West Africa, equipping them to respond creatively and responsibly to the complex challenges of their classrooms. Signature pedagogies can be effectively used in African basic education—even in 16


overcrowded classrooms—by emphasizing structured peer interaction rather than individual teacher–student exchange. Drawing on the work of Lee Shulman, signature pedagogies focus on helping learners think, act, and engage like practitioners in a subject. In large African classrooms, this can be achieved through group-based learning, choral responses, peer explanation, and role rotation, which allow all learners to participate actively despite limited resources. These approaches align well with communal and oral learning traditions common across many African societies, turning large numbers into an advantage rather than a barrier. Research and policy emphasize that learner-centered pedagogies—such as collaborative problem solving, discussion, and inquiry—are particularly suitable for low-resource and high-enrolment contexts when they are well structured and supported by student leadership. By using permanent groups, local materials, and formative group assessment, teachers can maintain pedagogical depth while managing workload, ensuring that quality learning occurs even in classrooms with very high student–teacher ratios.

References Adams, M. N., & Coulibaly, M. (1985). African traditional pedagogy in a modern perspective. Prospects, 15(2), 275–280. Akkari, A., Sagayar, M., & Saibou, H. (2024). Observations des apprentissages scolaires à Niamey. Niamey: UAM. (Rapport de recherche) Altet, M., Paré-Kabouré, A., & Sall, H. N. (2015). OPERA: Observations des pratiques enseignantes dans leur rapport avec des apprentissages. Paris: Agence Universitaire de la Francophonie. Amadasun, S. (2021). Is the signature pedagogy still worthwhile? An empirical study of field practice experience among social work students in Nigeria. Social Work Education. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/02615479.2020.1771300 Bansilal, S., Shalem, Y., & Mkhwanazi, T. (2018). Mathematics education in Africa: Towards social justice. African Journal of Research in Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 22(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1080/10288457.2017.1402321 Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. (2015). Seeing it clearly: Improving observer training for better feedback and better teaching. Washington, DC: Author. Bissonnette, S., Richard, M., & Gauthier, C. (2005). Interventions pédagogiques efficaces et réussite scolaire des élèves provenant de milieux défavorisés. Revue Française de Pédagogie, 150(1), 87–141. Bourdieu, P. (1977). Outline of a theory of practice. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Bourdieu, P. (1980). Le sens pratique. Paris, France: Éditions de Minuit. Bressoux, P. (2001). Réflexions sur l’effet-maître et l’étude des pratiques enseignantes. Les Dossiers des Sciences de l’Éducation, 5, 35–52. Bru, M. (2002). Pratiques enseignantes: des recherches à conforter et à développer. Revue Française de Pédagogie, 138, 63–73. 17


Carette, V. (2006). Recherche des caractéristiques de la pratique de l’enseignant pouvant favoriser la construction des compétences des élèves à l’école primaire (Doctoral dissertation, Université Libre de Bruxelles). Carette, V. (2008). Les caractéristiques des enseignants en question. Revue Française de Pédagogie, 162, 81–93. Chireshe, R. (2013). The role of indigenous knowledge in primary education in Africa. Zimbabwe Journal of Educational Research, 25(3), 1–15. Clegg, J. (2005). Moving towards bilingual education in Africa. In Language and development: Africa and beyond (pp. [pages if available]). Proceedings of the 7th International Language and Development Conference, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 26–28 October 2005. Falk, B. (2006). A conversation with Lee Shulman – signature pedagogies for teacher education: Defining our practices and rethinking our preparation. The New Educator, 2(1), 73–82. Fofana, A. (2011). Typologie des interactions dans les grands groupes: Exemple de l’enseignement du langage oral au cours préparatoire. Revue Électronique Internationale de Sciences du Langage. SudLangues, 16, 51–81. Harkness, S., & Super, C. M. (1992). Parental ethnotheories in action. In M. H. Bornstein (Ed.), Parental belief systems: The psychological consequences for children (Vol. 2, pp. 373–392). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Hattie, J. (2012). Visible learning for teachers: Maximizing impact on learning. New York, NY: Routledge. Lenoir, Y. (2007). L’habitus dans l’œuvre de Pierre Bourdieu: Un concept central dans sa théorie de la pratique à prendre en compte pour analyser les pratiques d’enseignement. Documents du CRIE et de la CRCIE. Sherbrooke, Canada: Université de Sherbrooke. Kouraogo, P., & Ouedraogo, N. M. (2009). Exploring educational quality through classroom practices: A study in selected primary school classes in Burkina Faso. Journal of International Cooperation in Education, 12(1), 51–69. Kraft, M., Dougherty, S., & Schueler, B. (2021). Teacher habits and pedagogical change: Insights from the global south. Educational Research Review, 33, 100402. Makgato, M., & Mji, A. (2017). Culturally responsive teaching and learning in African classrooms. Journal of Social Science, 52(1–3), 55–66. Mansilla, V. B., & Chua, F. S. (2017). Signature pedagogies in global competence education: Understanding quality teaching practice. In Educating for the 21st century: Perspectives, policies and practices from around the world (pp. 93–115). Maurer, B. (2010). Les langues de scolarisation en Afrique francophone: Enjeux et rapport pour l’action (Rapport général). Paris, France: Agence Universitaire de la Francophonie. Mungai, N. (2019). Learning through local resources: Practical approaches to primary science teaching. International Journal of Education and Development, 64, 12–21. 18


Njoroge, W. (2017). Storytelling and moral education in African primary schools. Journal of African Cultural Studies, 29(2), 145–160. Shulman, L. S. (2005a). Signature pedagogies in the professions. Daedalus, 134(3), 52–59. Shulman, L. S. (2005b). Pedagogies of uncertainty. Liberal Education, 91(2), 18–25. Shulman, L. S. (2005c). The signature pedagogies of the professions of law, medicine, engineering, and the clergy: Potential lessons for the education of teachers. Paper presented at the Math Science Partnerships (MSP) Workshop, Teacher Education for Effective Teaching and Learning, Irvine, CA. http://www.taylorprograms.com/images/ Shulman_Signature_Pedagogies.pdf Talbot, L. (2012). Les recherches sur les pratiques enseignantes efficaces. Questions Vives, 6(18), 2–11. Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. UNESCO. (2015). Global education monitoring report: Education for all and inclusive learning in Africa. Paris: UNESCO. Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Wenger, E., McDermott, R., & Snyder, W. (2002). Cultivating communities of practice: A guide to managing knowledge. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Wertsch, J. V. (1994). The primacy of mediated action in sociocultural studies. Mind, Culture, and Activity, 1(4), 202–208. https://doi.org/10.1080/10749039409524672

19


20


Beyond the Quick fix: Culture, Agency and Sustainable Change in Education Dr Kathryn Taylor, Work Collaborative

Abstract Despite heroic reform efforts in the education sector, schools continue to struggle to embed initiatives. Cycles of well-intentioned but short-lived initiatives frustrate leaders, exhaust staff, erode trust and drain resources. Innovation, motivation, research-evidence and leadership effort do not sufficiently mitigate chronic misalignment between organisational cultures and the lived realities of leaders’ and teachers’ work. This paper synthesises research on organisational cultural dynamics and professional learning (PL) to present a vision that empowers leaders and teachers while maintaining accountability. Rejecting both top-down compliance and laissez-faire autonomy, we advocate for democratic and deliberate curation of tailored organisational learning and professional flourishing. Without such a shift, the sector risks continued stagnation and decline.

Key words: Professionalism, Organisational leadership, Organisational culture, Professional learning Introduction In this paper, we explore developments in the landscape of organisational change in the United Kingdom, which is also relevant to English International school contexts. We draw upon our review of literature in the field of organisational cultural dynamics, and, in turn, how these relate to PL. We draw upon our experiences of working with teachers and leaders navigating change in schools. We recognise the inherent interplay between individuals and their contexts as essential to the exploration of human social phenomena (Priestley et al., 2015). For context, we highlight that, since the late 1980s, macro-level policy and accountability structures and assumptions concerning teacher professionalism have influenced thought and practice in this sector (e.g., HM Government, 1988). We also acknowledge the powerful influence of past experiences on individuals’ perceptions and organisational identity within this ‘macro-narrative’. This paper will be useful to school leaders concerned with promoting lasting change whilst avoiding the temptation to seek ‘silver bullets’ that both frustrate and fatigue teachers. Enhancing sector-wide appreciation of the dynamics of organisational change supports understanding of why so many initiatives fail (Mannion, 2025). Difficulties sustaining organisational change is a persistent, complex and ill-defined, or ‘wicked’ problem, without discrete cause or single solution. Repeated, frustrated attempts to change school cultures has both financial and human costs; we stand to pay a high price if this wicked problem is not addressed. In setting out the barriers and opportunities of cultural change dynamics, we seek to disrupt cycles of short-termism and steer thinking in the sector towards virtuous cycles of systemic change (Taylor, 2025). We consider these themes salient to understanding this issue: 1. The dynamics of complex organisational cultures: strategic and organisational learning 2. Changing and change leadership in schools 21


3. Implications of school culture for teacher PD and PL 4. Perceptions of culture as a pre-condition for change (agency, empowerment and psychological safety) These themes offer windows into the complex, interconnected cultural dynamics that can influence or inhibit genuine, well-intentioned change initiatives in educational settings.

The dynamics of complex organisational cultures: strategic and organisational learning Leading sustained and meaningful change in schools is highly challenging. Schools are highly complex and inter-connected social systems making it impossible to cleanly isolate the factors influencing cultural change dynamics (Daly et al., 2020; Priestley et al., 2015). They are subject to both internal and external socio-political influences and assumptions, including structural and policy considerations (e.g., Hall, 2013). Teachers’ professional identity formation (e.g., Buchanan, 2015; Mockler, 2011) and discourses about professionalism in education (Evans, 2008; 2011; Sachs, 2001) add to the complexity of leading sustained change. Within these contexts, educators’ dynamic, contextualised interactions generate and iterate what is commonly described as school ‘culture’ (Stoll, 2000). Culture is a complex concept, loaded with assumptions (Taylor, 2025), but broadly defined, school cultures bound and curate the membership and behaviours of a school community. School cultures are dynamic and complex because of members’ simultaneous, negotiated multiple group memberships, through which individuals establish and understand their ‘place’ (e.g., Eslamdoost et al., 2019; Wenger, 2008). Community members are not homogeneous; individuals and sub-groups are influenced by intersections between the stated aims of the organisation and its members’ nationalities, regionalities, religion, gender, sexualities, ethnicities, academic status, and domain expertise (e.g., Gao, 2010; Kompf, 2005; McChesney, 2017; McNess et al., 2015; Quan et al., 2019). Consequently, powerful sub-cultures emerge both within and beyond organisations (Schein, 2017), e.g., professional, union, and subject-specific affiliations. The dynamic nature of school cultures appear to render notions of structure and steering highly challenging, but it is important to note that structure also brings group members a sense of stability and belonging. This brings strength but it also brings challenges to anyone wishing to engineer change (Schein, 2017). Although leaders steward and steer cultures, they may experience limited freedom to choose the course, and their agency is determined by contextual influences (Leithwood and Day, 2008; Gu et al., 2020). Some leaders seek steady improvement, whilst others are obliged to respond to shocks (e.g., poor inspection or academic results, accidents, complaints or whistleblower’s intervention – even pandemics!), which require swift, decisive interventions (Schein, 2017). Cultures are sensitive to norm enforcement – that is, group members co-regulate their behaviour to within established social expectations (Flanagan, 2005), and these rules may be both explicit and tacit (Schein, 2017). Cultural norms can range from core working hours and dress codes to expectations about parking spaces and coffee mugs. This has a stabilising effect on organisational culture, making change difficult (Schein, 2017; Slay and Smith, 2011). Acknowledging this complexity requires that leaders remain mindful of the ecosystems within their organisations, and those in which they are nested, when considering reforms (Bunnell et al., 2020).

22


Schein (2017) highlights the need for leaders’ positive action in mitigating the challenges inherent in facilitating organisational change; vision must be predicated on identification and acknowledgement of contextually relevant problems. Acknowledging significant policy, regulation and governance differences between organisations, leaders benefit from developing a deep understanding of the school’s reality as it is. Without this clarity and contextualisation, vision is abstract and nebulous, making sustained meaningful change unlikely. This clarity must be communicated to all stakeholders and regularly ‘sense checked’ to ensure that goals remain appropriate to organisational needs (Learning and Lerner, 2025; Mannion, 2025). This is essential because without challenge and refinement, innovation stalls (Edmondson, 2023; Epstein, 2019).

Changing and change leadership in schools Leading change in complex organisations would be challenging enough even if school leaders had the freedom and resources to implement initiatives according to their best judgement in their contexts. In reality, many leaders operate in highly regulated and resource-poor systems. School leaders’ activities are professionally and legally regulated, subject to governance and inspectorate scrutiny. They entail myriad and diverse duties, obligations and accountability to multiple stakeholders (Maak and Pless, 2006; Stone-Johnson, 2014). Policy bound and locally accountable leaders’ individual autonomy can feel restricted (Hall, 2013). Effective leaders curate three broad and interconnected domains: culture, content and structure (Postholm, 2019). Deficiency in any of these is associated with reduced system improvement capacity (Earley, 2020). Consequently, they must act as both gate-keepers and catalysts as they navigate dynamic cultural ecosystems (e.g., Daly et al., 2020; Postholm, 2019; Tubin, 2015). Increasingly, the importance of culture curation (Coyle, 2019), team dynamics (Crome, 2023), psychological safety (Edmonson, 2019) and systems thinking (Stroh, 2015) have gained popularity, challenging traditional ‘top-down’, autocratic hierarchies. This shift represents a challenge for some leaders, especially (but not exclusively) in globalised and multi-national contexts, where hierarchical expectations between stakeholders may diverge from local expectations, and within groups (Mayer, 2015). At the same time as the shift in the concept and role of leaders as curators of culture, research into relationships between cognitive science and pedagogy has enjoyed increases in range, volume and accessibility. This evidence-base has become the ‘golden thread’ of many teacher development courses (e.g., Department for Education, 2024). The ‘democratic’ dimension of teacher professionalism, in which the metacognition of pedagogy is made explicit has begun to challenge ‘traditional’ professional paradigms, which tend to conflate experience with expertise (Sachs, 2001). Still, the ubiquitous managerial professional paradigm (grounded in measurement, standardisation and compliance) pressures leaders to demonstrate efficiency, and is characterised by performative accountability and technicalisation, leading to deprofessionalisation and, often, teacher resistance of change initiatives (Ball, 2003; 2016; Evans, 2011; Hargreaves, 2000; Sachs, 2001). These kinds of tight managerial change enforcement processes undermine group-members psychological safety, causing risk-aversion, burnout, moral injury (Oberg, 2025). Ultimately, many teachers working under these conditions choose to exit the profession (Perryman and Calvery, 2020). The tensions between traditional and managerial professional paradigms have real-world consequences for teachers, leaders and, ultimately, students. Indeed, this issue appears to be one of the significant drivers of the present teacher retention crisis; when teachers and leaders are unable to resolve the cognitive dissonance caused by feeling pulled in conflicting directions, people burnout (Ball, 2008) or they leave (Perryman and Calvert, 2020; Smith and Ulvik, 2017). The evidence of harm though moral injury to those operating within these systems 23


is becoming increasingly clear (Oberg, 2025). Leaders seeking to build democratic professional cultures built on shared understanding of a rich evidence-base must tread a very narrow path as their curate a culture that is simultaneously compliant, research-informed, and that protects and promotes teacher expertise, especially the prized dimensions of teacher agency and autonomy. We should not underestimate the magnitude of this challenge. It follows that well-established evidence base of ‘what works’ (e.g., Rosenshine, 2012) and positive associations of such practices with improved student outcomes (e.g., Kraft and Papay, 2014) must be supported by high-quality, sustained teacher PL. Without this, teachers’ skills, knowledge and practice cannot keep pace, let alone become refined and contextualised. This highlights leaders’ duty to prioritise ongoing teacher PD through the delivery of highimpact, high-quality activities (Boylan and Demack, 2018; Matthews, 2009). We recognise that ‘silver bullet’, ‘quick fix’ trends are worthy of critique and scrutiny, both in terms of the misapplication of techniques (e.g., Hendrick, 2025) and poor implementation (Mannion, 2025). We therefore encourage leaders to pay careful attention to the emergence of vicious cycles that can emerge within culture when change is too rapid or, conversely, if it stagnates (see figures 1 and 2 below). We argue that, even when school leaders initiate change with evidence-informed, benevolent intent (as opposed to choosing a tight, managerialist model of compliance and control) vicious cultural cycles can emerge and undermine progress towards sustained change. Vicious cultural cycles contribute to unintended consequences and change resistance, as illustrated in loose and inconsistent democratic cultural cycles, as illustrated in figures 1 and 2, below (Taylor, 2025):

Figure 1: Loose democratic implementation – a vicious cultural cycle that inhibits organisational change.

24


Figure 2: Emerging or inconsistent democratic implementation – a vicious cultural cycle that inhibits organisational change. We argue that sustained improvement depends on leaders’ ability to create virtuous cycles of growth by diagnosing genuine organisational needs, reducing learning anxiety through psychological safety, and designing collaborative, contextualised PD, grounded in shared purpose. This virtuous cycle (shown in figure 3) can be described as a tight democratic cultural dynamic and is associated with increased the teacher capacity for professional learning needed for sustained change (Taylor, 2025).

Figure 3: Tight democratic implementation – a virtuous cultural cycle that promotes teachers’ capacity for professional learning, thus supporting organisational change. 25


We argue that appropriately selected and well implemented teacher PD and PL are the cornerstones of sustained change. Correlations have been noted about the efficacy of virtuous systems, and the cultural dimensions that they support which sustains PL. Further, a growing body of evidence indicates the positive impact on high quality PD that leads to PL on teacher wellbeing (e.g., Skaalvik and Skaalvik, 2020; Sullanmaa et al., 2023). It is both prudent and a moral imperative that leaders must support teacher PD and PL through accurate diagnostic analyses and priority setting, vision-building and on-boarding colleagues in supportive, respectful and inclusive ways (Postholm, 2019). Learners must be ‘activated’ and be persuaded that the new learning is necessary and safe (Edmondson, 2019; Schein, 2017). If the need for rapid change arises, clear starting points and credible solutions are essential to bring direction and purpose to collective sense-making activities (Schein, 2017). This is collaborative professionalism (Hargreaves and O’Connor, 2018), and it emphasises social aspects of PD which strengthens a shared belief in groups’ capacity to achieve change (Keddie et al., 2023). Leaders play an essential role in curating PD content. They must prioritise the resources and structures necessary to support distributed leadership and empowers teachers to engage with PD and contribute meaningfully to collegial learning opportunities (Louws et al., 2020; Postholm, 2019). It is tempting to conflate PD with workload – and poorly implemented PD often does feel like workload! Leaders should not underestimate the importance of deimplementation counter-initiatives to support teachers’ understanding of what less impactful practices can be stopped, and when. Without explicit de-implementation guidance, teachers may heroically continue to undertake all initiatives (and burnout) or decide for themselves which practices should be maintained or stopped, leading to inconsistent and unsustainable initiatives (Hamilton et al., 2024; Schein, 2017).

Perceptions of culture as a pre-condition for change (agency, empowerment and psychological safety) We have provided arguments, evidence and theorisation illustrating what works. However, it is also incumbent on the author of any credible persuasive argument to set out the mechanisms of how and why these suggestions work and should be taken seriously. By way of grounding our argument in theory, we draw upon Giddens’ (1984) structuration theory to conceptualise ‘cultural evolution’. Structuration theory describes the dynamic relationships between human reflection on artefacts and data, and the actions and events that flow from these interactions. These can be consciously curated or unfold organically, but structuration processes are always present. Loosely conceptualised, structuration theory holds that causal and correlative events may be simple and direct and may be intended or incidental. For example, I may turn on a light disturbing a prowler, who flees. Collective individual acts can have a ‘composition effect’, for example, like-minded people seek each other out, forming sub- or countercultures, or cliques. Structuration processes also drive complex institutionalised practices and assumptions (e.g., if teachers feel disempowered to admit to mistakes, they may hide them leading to serious, complex failures – Edmondson, 2023) (adapted from Giddens, 1984, pp.10-14). Schools are complex, interdependent cultural ecosystems, where competing professional assumptions and high stakes accountability systems generate tensions that inhibit PL and undermine meaningful and lasting change. The structuration lens illuminates how cultural socialisation and routines (or ‘the way we do things around here’) interact with data and artefacts to derail evidence informed initiatives.

26


This characterisation of culture as an evolutionary process offers ‘real-world’ application, because it combines sociological theory with the interactions between ideas, actions and the generation and reflection on artefacts, which perpetuates new artefacts and, thus, change (Giddens, 1984; Tubin, 2015). Artefacts emerge organically or intentionally, but leaders can harness structuration processes to curate artefacts and synthesise them through organisational vision and values, intentionally ‘steering’ cultural development. Structuration processes also explain why high quality, carefully curated PD is essential for teacher PL, and central to organisational change. Reactive, inappropriate PD that fails to meet genuine organisational needs risk unpredictable outcomes (at best), and counterproductive or damaging consequences at worst. Leaders must remain mindful that change is not synonymous with progress, but all interventions are catalysts for change, indicating structuration processes. Gidden’s structuration theory explains why poorly implemented, decontextualised PD does not reliably deliver the intended reforms. Without a theory of change to underpin leaders’ vision, the scope for ‘lethal mutations’ (superficial, shallow, compliancedriven impressions of pedagogical practices replicated without reference to the evidence that underpins them), or outright rejection of interventions is vast. Unintended consequences can be far-reaching impacting individuals, teams or whole cultural systems.

Implications of school culture for PD and PL Attempts to change professional or operational practices demands that leaders navigate the tension between teachers’ fear of temporary incompetence and associated punishment or damage to identity or reputation (learning anxiety), and operational threats, including to safety, financial stability, success, or reputational damage (survival anxiety) (Schein, 2017). In schools, poor inspection reports, declining student numbers or academic underperformance represent sources of survival anxiety, which inhibits teacher PL. Whilst it is true that standards of education today have improved in comparison to those up to and including the 1980s (Leckie and Goldstein, 2017), it is also the case that four decades of compliance cultures have often led to performativity, professional fear and risk-aversion and high levels of learning anxiety, burnout, emotional fatigue and moral injury (e.g., Ball, 2003; 2008; Oberg, 2025). Drawing upon lessons from the corporate world, it seems that raising the threat of survival anxiety is a less successful strategy for meaningful change than taking steps to mitigate learning anxiety, which requires leaders to create psychologically safe conditions (Edmondson, 2019; 2023; Schein, 2017; Scott; 2017). We advocate for the development of leaders’ implementation protocols that support teacher PL and democratic, collaborative professionalism. Change must not be merely for change’s sake, and the reality that there are no ‘quick fixes’ must be acknowledged. Well-managed change in schools must not only meet genuine organisational needs but also design in structures to support and empower teachers in co-construction and contextualisation activities (Hargreaves and O’Connor,2018). Only then will teachers become truly empowered and enabled to synthesise PD using their professional judgement and engage in the deep learning that sustained change depends upon (Taylor, 2025; Vähäsantanen at al., 2017). This emphasises social aspects of PD which strengthens a shared belief in groups’ capacity to achieve change (Keddie et al., 2023).

27


Concluding comments and a call to action Change in the education sector is more pressing and rapid than at any time in the past. Pressures are high stakes and the ‘goods’ we seek, and the proxy metrics by which they are measured, are often incompatible with the realities of structural limitations. Competing pressures mean school leaders responsible for PD design, realisation, and accountability have complex problems to solve. We argue that existing systems and assumptions about educational leadership and hierarchical structures no longer meet the emerging needs of the sector. As Gidden’s (1984) structuration theory suggests, significantly loosening our grip on compliance replaces the predictable misery of performativity with the unpredictable divergence of misimplementation and voluntary non-compliance. We therefore advocate a middle way that enables school leaders to curate the change they need in the way they want by steering structuration processes in ways that empower teachers and embed deep, collective PL. ‘Middle way’ models can be conceptualised and enacted in various ways. For example, Leaning and Lerner’s (2026) Double Diamond model emphasises the importance of collaborative thinking that intentionally zooms in and out as interventions progress. Mannion’s (2025) approach to implementation processes provides a comprehensive manual for the change management arc. The team leadership protocols provided by Crome (2023) offer a practical guide to getting the best out of busy people in school contexts. Importantly, as these examples have in common, leaders must intentionally create collaborative, purposeful and democratic work that is perpetually curated to meet the evolving needs of the school and its stakeholders in context; change is a process, not an event. We acknowledge that this is a wicked challenge; change initiatives must demonstrate impact, cost efficiency, and be accepted by a critical mass of teachers to effect sustained change. Student outcomes must be demonstrably improved by accepted measurable proxies (e.g., exam results), supporting organisational financial security (Leckie and Goldstein, 2017). Devolved managerialism (Hall, 2013) has manifested as performative compliance cultures, detrimental to both teacher wellbeing (Ball, 2003) and eroding recruitment and retention (Perryman and Calvert, 2020). Poor implementation has often undermined trust to the extent that, even with democratic, inspirational intent, rushed or unfocused PD is rejected by teachers. Vicious cycles such as this exacerbate demands of meaningful change because the starting point has moved from neutral to negative (hostile, in some cases). Nevertheless, the costs of inaction are greater than the challenges of courageous change. We encourage leaders to use implementation protocols that are laser focused on genuine organisational needs. These must entail support and collaboration structures designed to empower teachers and communities in co-construction and contextualisation activities. This enables teachers to synthesise PD using professional judgement and engage in the deep PL that change depends upon (Leaning and Lerner, 2025; Taylor, 2025; Vähäsantanen at al., 2017). This work was derived from the lead author’s EdD thesis (Taylor, 2025) which was conducted in line with BERA (2018) ethical guidelines. This paper was commissioned and funded by Work Collaborative, a not-for-profit subsidiary of Education Leaders Ltd., supporting communityled change in education.

28


References Teachers Should Know. The Education Digest, 78(3), 30–40. Sachs, J. (2001). Teacher Professional Identity: Competing Discourses, Competing Outcomes. Journal of Education Policy, 16(2), 149–161. https://doi.org/10.1080/02680930116819 Schein, E. H. (2017). Organizational Culture and Leadership (5th Edition). Wiley. Scott, K. (2017). Radical Candor: How to Be a Great Boss Without Losing Your Humanity (First published). Macmillan. Skaalvik, E. M., & Skaalvik, S. (2020). Teacher Burnout: Relations Between Dimensions of Burnout, Perceived School Context, Job Satisfaction and Motivation for Teaching. a Longitudinal Study. Teachers and Teaching, 26(7–8), 602–616. https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2021.1913404 Smith, K., & Ulvik, M. (2017). Leaving Teaching: Lack of Resilience or Sign of Agency? Teachers and Teaching, 23(8), 928–945. https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2017.1358706 Stoll, L. (2000). School Culture. Set: Research Information for Teachers, 3, 9–14. https://doi. org/10.18296/set.0805 Stone-Johnson, C. (2014). Responsible Leadership. Educational Administration Quarterly, 50(4), 645–674. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013161X13510004 Stroh, D. P. (2015). Systems Thinking for Social Change: A Practical Guide to Solving Complex Problems, Avoiding Unintended Consequences, and Achieving Lasting Results. Chelsea Green Publishing. Sullanmaa, J., Pyhältö, K., Pietarinen, J., & Soini, T. (2023). Teacher Agency in the Professional Community and Association with Burnout: A Longitudinal Person-Centred Approach. Research Papers in Education, 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1080/02671522.2023.2178028 Taylor, K. (2025). De Ball, S. J. (2003). The Teacher’s Soul and the Terrors of Performativity. Journal of Ball, S. J. (2003). The Teacher’s Soul and the Terrors of Performativity. Journal of Education Policy, 18(2), 215–228. https://doi.org/10.1080/0268093022000043065 Ball, S. J. (2008). Performativity, Privatisation, Professionals, and the State. In B. Cunningham (Ed.), Exploring Professionalism (pp. 50–72). Institute of Education, University of London. Ball, S. J. (2016). Subjectivity as a Site of Struggle: Refusing Neoliberalism? British Journal of Sociology of Education, 37(8), 1129–1146. https://doi.org/10.1080/01425692.2015.1044072 Boylan, M., & Demack, S. (2018). Innovation, Evaluation Design and Typologies of Professional Learning. Educational Research, 60(3), 336–356. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131881.2018.149335 2 BERA. (2018). Ethical Guidelines for Educational Research, fourth edition (2018) | BERA. https:// www.bera.ac.uk/researchers-resources/publications/ethical-guidelines-for-educationalresearch-2018 Buchanan, R. (2015). Teacher Identity and Agency in an Era of Accountability. Teachers and Teaching, 21(6), 700–719. https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2015.1044329 Bunnell, T., Fertig, M., & James, C. (2020). The Institutionalisation of Schools and the Implications for Identity of Experienced Teachers: The Case of International Baccalaureate World Schools. Cambridge Journal of Education, 50(2), 241–260. https://doi.org/10.1080/0305 764X.2019.1661972 Coyle, D. (2019). The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. Random House Business. Crome, S. (2023). The Power of Teams: How to Create and Lead Thriving School Teams. John Catt. 29


Daly, C., Milton, E., & Langdon, F. (2020). How Do Ecological Perspectives Help Understand Schools as Sites for Teacher Learning? Professional Development in Education, 46(4), 652–663. https://doi.org/10.1080/19415257.2020.1787208 Department for Education. (2024, March 21). National Professional Qualification (NPQ) Courses. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/national-professional-qualification-npq-courses Earley, P. (2020). Surviving, Thriving and Reviving in Leadership: The Personal and Professional Development Needs of Educational Leaders. Management in Education, 34(3), 117–121. https:// doi.org/10.1177/0892020620919763 Edmondson, A. C. (2019). The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation, and Growth. Wiley. Edmondson, A. C. (2023). Right Kind of Wrong: Why Learning to Fail Can Teach Us to Thrive. Cornerstone Press. Epstein, D. J. (2019). Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World. Riverhead Books. Eslamdoost, S., King, K. A., & Tajeddin, Z. (2020). Professional Identity Conflict and (Re) Construction among English Teachers in Iran. Journal of Language, Identity & Education, 19(5), 327–341. https://doi.org/10.1080/15348458.2019.1676157 Evans, L. (2008). Professionalism, Professionality and the Development of Education Professionals. British Journal of Educational Studies, 56(1), 20–38. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.14678527.2007.00392.x Evans, L. (2011). The ‘shape’ of Teacher Professionalism in England: Professional Standards, Performance Management, Professional Development and the Changes Proposed in the 2010 White Paper. British Educational Research Journal, 37(5), 851–870. https://doi.org/10.1080/014 11926.2011.607231 Flanagan, F., M. (2005). Chapter 19: Dilemmas of Democratic Education. In P. Denicolo & M. Kompf (Eds), Connecting Policy and Practice Challenges for Teaching and Learning in Schools and Universities (pp. 190–196). Routledge. https://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ulaval/ detail.action?milDocID=26756 Giddens, A. (1984). The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration. Polity Press. Gu, Q., Rea, S., Seymour, K., Smethem, L., Bryant, B., Armstrong, P., Ahn, M., & Knight, R. (2020). The Research Schools Network: Supporting Schools to Develop Evidence-Informed Practice. Education Endowment Foundation. Hall, D. (2013). Drawing a Veil Over Managerialism: Leadership and the Discursive Disguise of the New Public Management. Journal of Educational Administration & History, 45(3), 267–282. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220620.2013.771154 Hamilton, A., Hattie, J., & Wiliam, D. (2024). Making Room for Impact: A De-Implementation Guide for Educators. Corwin. Hargreaves, A. (2000). Four Ages of Professionalism and Professional Learning. Teachers and Teaching, 6(2), 151–182. https://doi.org/10.1080/713698714 Hargreaves, A., & O’Connor, M. T. (2018). Solidarity with Solidity: The Case for Collaborative Professionalism. Phi Delta Kappan, 100(1), 20–24. https://doi.org/10.1177/0031721718797116 Hendrick, C. (2025, December 11). The Lethal Mutation of Retrieval Practice [Substack.com]. The Learning Dispatch:Exploring the Science of Learning. https://carlhendrick.substack. com/p/the-lethal-mutation-of-retrieval HM Government. (1988). Education Reform Act 1988 [Text]. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ ukpga/1988/40/contents 30


Keddie, A., MacDonald, K., Blackmore, J., & Gobby, B. (2023). Teacher Professional Autonomy in an Atypical Government School: Matters of Relationality and Context. Oxford Review of Education, 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1080/03054985.2023.2236941 Kompf, M. (2005). Chapter 13: When Angels Dance With Devils: What is Sacred and Profane in the University? In P. Denicolo & M. Kompf (Eds), Connecting Policy and Practice Challenges for Teaching and Learning in Schools and Universities (pp. 128–136). Routledge. https:// ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ulaval/detail.action?milDocID=26756 Kraft, M. A., & Papay, J. P. (2014). Can Professional Environments in Schools Promote Teacher Development? Explaining Heterogeneity in Returns to Teaching Experience. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 36(4), 476–500. Leaning, S., & Lerner, E. (2026). Change Starts Here: What If Everything Your School Needed Was Right in Front of You? Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003596141 Leckie, G., & Goldstein, H. (2017). The Evolution of School League Tables in England 1992-2016: ‘Contextual Value-Added’, ‘Expected Progress’ and ‘Progress 8’. British Educational Research Journal, 43(2), 193–212. https://doi.org/10.1002/berj.3264 Leithwood, K., & Day, C. (2008). The Impact of School Leadership on Pupil Outcomes. School Leadership & Management, 28(1), 1–4. https://doi.org/10.1080/13632430701799718 Louws, M., Zwart, R., Zuiker, I., Meijer, P., Oolbekkink-Marchand, H., Schaap, H., & Want, A. van der. (2020). Exploring School Leaders’ Dilemmas in Response to Tensions Related to Teacher Professional Agency. Professional Development in Education, 46(4), 691–710. https://doi.org/10 .1080/19415257.2020.1787203 Maak, T., & Pless, N. M. (2006). Responsible Leadership in a Stakeholder Society – A Relational Perspective. Journal of Business Ethics, 66(1), 99–115. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9047-z Mannion, J. (2025). Making Change Stick: A Practical Guide to Implementing School Improvement (1st ed). John Catt Educational, Limited. Matthews, P. (2009). How Do School Leaders Successfully Lead Learning (p. 43). National College for School Leadership. https://dera.ioe.ac.uk/id/eprint/254/1/ download%3Fid=23637&filename=how-do-school-leaders-successfully-lead-learning.pdf McChesney, K. R. (2017). Investigating Teachers’ Experiences of Professional Development Within a Major Education Reform in the Emirate of Abu Dhabi [Thesis, Curtin University]. https://espace.curtin.edu.au/handle/20.500.11937/57566 McNess, E., Arthur, L., & Crossley, M. (2015). ‘Ethnographic Dazzle’ and the Construction of the ‘Other’: Revisiting Dimensions of Insider and Outsider Research for International and Comparative Education. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education, 45(2), 295–316. https://doi.org/10.1080/03057925.2013.854616 Meyer, E. (with Saltus, K.). (2015). The Culture Map (Unabridged). Recorded Books. Mockler, N. (2011). Beyond ‘What Works’: Understanding Teacher Identity as a Practical and Political Tool. Teachers and Teaching, 17(5), 517–528. https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2011.60 2059 Oberg, G. (2025). Moral Injury in Teaching: The Systemic Roots of Ethical Conflict and Emotional Burnout in Education. Educational Review, 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131911.2025.250452 3 Perryman, J., & Calvert, G. (2020). What Motivates People to Teach, and Why Do They Leave? Accountability, Performativity and Teacher Retention. British Journal of Educational Studies, 68(1), 3–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/00071005.2019.1589417 Postholm, M. B. (2019). The School Leader’s Role in School-Based Development. Educational 31


Research, 61(4), 437–450. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131881.2019.1677171 Priestley, M., Biesta, G., & Robinson, S. (2015). Teacher Agency: What Is It and Why Does It Matter? In J. Evers & R. Kneyber (Eds), Flip the System: Changing Education from the Ground Up. Bloomsbury Academic, an imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing, Plc. Quan, T., Bracho, C. A., Wilkerson, M., & Clark, M. (2019). Empowerment and Transformation: Integrating Teacher Identity, Activism, and Criticality Across Three Teacher Education Programs. Review of Education, Pedagogy, and Cultural Studies, 41(4–5), 218–251. https://doi. org/10.1080/10714413.2019.1684162 Rosenshine, B. (2012, November). Principles of Instruction: Research-Based Strategies That All veloping an Ecological Analytical Framework for the Exploration of Teachers’ Lived Experiences of Professional Development and Professional Learning in Five UK Secondary Schools. [IOE, UCL’s Faculty of Education and Society, UK]. https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10208734/ Tubin, D. (2015). School Success as a Process of Structuration. Educational Administration Quarterly, 51(4), 640–674. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013161X15569346 Vähäsantanen, K., Paloniemi, S., Hökkä, P., & Eteläpelto, A. (2017). Agentic Perspective on Fostering Work-Related Learning. Studies in Continuing Education, 39(3), 251–267. https://doi. org/10.1080/0158037X.2017.1310097 Wenger, E. (2008). Communities of Practice: Learning, Meaning and Identity. Cambridge University Press.

32


Exclusion by Design? School Exclusion and the Right to Education: A Rights-Based Critique of Policy and Practice in the UK Christine Haslett, Wellington College International, Lagos Abstract The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) establishes a legally binding framework for all ratifying states, including the United Kingdom, requiring the protection and progressive realisation of children’s rights without discrimination. As duty bearers, UK governments are obligated to implement these provisions in full. However, the devolution of education policy across the UK has resulted in significant regional variation, meaning that children may experience their rights differently depending on where they live. This article presents a critical, policy-based analysis of exclusion from education in UK schools, focusing on the implementation of UNCRC Article 28. It examines how legislative and policy frameworks across the UK intersect with issues of inequality, particularly for children with protected characteristics and those from lower socio-economic backgrounds. The analysis argues that exclusion is not simply a disciplinary response to behaviour, but is embedded within wider accountability-driven education systems that generate and sustain exclusionary practices. By exposing the contradictions between international human rights obligations and domestic policy, the article highlights persistent gaps between legislation, policy, and practice, as well as the perverse incentives that shape decision-making in schools. It argues that exclusion cannot be meaningfully reduced without addressing its underlying structural drivers, including poverty and systemic inequality. The article concludes by identifying potential avenues for reform and outlining priorities for future research, contributing to ongoing debates on inclusive, rights-based education in the UK.

Keywords: UNCRC, Rights, Education, Exclusion Introduction The right to education is widely recognised as a fundamental human right, enshrined in international legal frameworks such as the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC, 1989). As a ratifying state, the United Kingdom is obligated to respect, protect, and fulfil this right for all children, ensuring access to education on the basis of equality and non-discrimination (UNCRC, 1989, Arts. 2, 28). However, the extent to which this right is realised in practice remains contested, particularly in relation to the use of exclusionary practices within schools (McCluskey et al., 2019; Daniels et al., 2022). School exclusion, whether fixed-term or permanent, represents a critical point of tension between the protection of children’s rights and the operational demands of contemporary education systems. While exclusion is positioned within policy as a measure of last resort, evidence consistently demonstrates that its use is uneven and disproportionately affects children with protected characteristics, including those with disabilities, from minority ethnic backgrounds, and those experiencing socio-economic disadvantage (Graham et al., 2019; Daniels et al., 2022). These patterns are not incidental, but indicative of deeper structural inequalities within the education system. This article adopts a critical, policy-based approach, drawing on existing literature, statutory guidance, and international rights frameworks rather than empirical data. It argues that exclusion should not be understood solely as an individualised response to behaviour, but as 33


a systemic outcome shaped by political, economic, and institutional pressures. In particular, it examines how accountability-driven education systems, coupled with broader socioeconomic inequalities, contribute to the persistence of exclusionary practices that undermine the realisation of children’s rights under Article 28 of the UNCRC. The analysis proceeds in four parts. First, it outlines the legal framework surrounding the right to education. Second, it examines the implementation of this right across the devolved jurisdictions of the UK. Third, it critically analyses the drivers, mechanisms, and consequences of exclusion in practice. Finally, the article considers potential avenues for reform and identifies priorities for future research, with the aim of strengthening rights-based approaches to education.

The Right to Education Article 28 of the UNCRC holds that: States Parties recognise the right of the child to education, and with a view to achieving this right progressively and on the basis of equal opportunity, they shall, in particular: •

Make primary education compulsory and available free to all;

•

Encourage the development of different forms of secondary education, including general and vocational education, make them available and accessible to every child, and take appropriate measures such as the introduction of free education and offering financial assistance in case of need;

•

Make higher education accessible to all on the basis of capacity by every appropriate means;

•

Make educational and vocational information and guidance available and accessible to all children;

•

Take measures to encourage regular attendance at schools and the reduction of drop-out rates.

2. States Parties shall take all appropriate measures to ensure that school discipline is administered in a manner consistent with the child’s human dignity and in conformity with the present Convention. 3. States Parties shall promote and encourage international cooperation in matters relating to education, in particular with a view to contributing to the elimination of ignorance and illiteracy throughout the world and facilitating access to scientific and technical knowledge and modern teaching methods. In this regard, particular account shall be taken of the needs of developing countries. - (UNCRC Article 28, 1989) 3. Implementation Across the UK: Legislative and Policy Context The right to education, as articulated in Article 28 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), is not realised in isolation, but through a complex and interconnected system of legal, institutional, and social structures. Its implementation is shaped by the interaction between multiple duty bearers, including education systems, health services, government, and wider social policy, as well as the lived realities of children and their families. As such, the realisation of this right is contingent not only on legislative commitment, but on how these systems operate in practice (Lundy, 2018). Within the United Kingdom, the devolution of education policy has resulted in significant regional variation in how children’s rights are interpreted and enacted. While Wales and Scotland have taken steps to incorporate the UNCRC into domestic law through the Rights of 34


Children and Young Persons (Wales) Measure (2011) and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act (2024), England has not adopted equivalent legislative measures. Northern Ireland, while expressing commitment to the principles of the UNCRC through the Children and Young People’s Strategy (2020–2030), has similarly not incorporated the Convention into domestic law. These differences create uneven legal foundations for the protection of children’s rights across the UK. This divergence is particularly evident in approaches to school exclusion. England has been identified as having some of the most punitive practices (McCluskey et al., 2019), granting head teachers extensive powers to exclude pupils, including for behaviour occurring outside of school, and positioning them as the final decision-makers in permanent exclusion cases (Department for Education, 2024). Mechanisms for redress also vary significantly across jurisdictions. In England, for example, Independent Review Panels are unable to overturn decisions to permanently exclude, limiting meaningful challenge and raising concerns about procedural fairness. Across the UK, processes are often complex, difficult to access, and insufficiently supportive of children and families (Edwards et al., 2021; Bridgeman, 2024). The principle of non-discrimination, as outlined in Article 2 of the UNCRC and reinforced through domestic legislation such as the Equality Act (2010), is similarly inconsistently realised. In Northern Ireland, partial incorporation of equality legislation results in weaker protections for disabled children, relying instead on the Disability Discrimination Act (1995) (Equality and Human Rights Commission, 2014). While England, Scotland, and Wales formally recognise protections against discrimination, national data reveals persistent disparities in exclusion rates, disproportionately affecting children with disabilities, from minority ethnic backgrounds, and those experiencing socio-economic disadvantage (Paget et al., 2017; Graham et al., 2019; Martin-Denham, 2020; Daniels et al., 2022). These inequalities are further obscured by inconsistencies in data collection and reporting across the four nations. The absence of standardised approaches, alongside the lack of reliable data on informal or unlawful exclusion practices, makes it difficult to fully assess the scale and nature of the issue (McCluskey et al., 2019; Duffy et al., 2021). As a result, the evidence base underpinning policy responses remains incomplete. Concerns regarding these disparities have been raised at both national and international levels. The Equality and Human Rights Commission (2014) highlighted insufficient legal protections for disabled children in Northern Ireland, while the Children’s Commissioner for England (2022) identified disproportionately high exclusion rates among children with special educational needs and disabilities. In its concluding observations on the United Kingdom’s combined sixth and seventh periodic report, the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2023) reiterated concerns regarding discrimination and the overuse of exclusion, particularly for vulnerable groups. The Committee’s recommendations emphasise the need for improved data collection, stronger safeguards against informal exclusion practices, and greater access to advocacy and legal representation for children and families. It further calls for exclusion to be used only as a measure of last resort, and for systemic efforts to address the underlying causes of inequality and marginalisation within education systems. Taken together, these findings suggest that while the UK maintains a formal commitment to children’s rights, their implementation remains fragmented, inconsistent, and, in some cases, incompatible with the principles of the UNCRC. This uneven realisation of rights provides the foundation for a critical analysis of how exclusion operates in practice, including the mechanisms through which it is enacted, the justifications used to legitimise it, and the structural conditions that sustain it. 4. School Exclusion in Practice: Policy, Drivers, Mechanisms and Consequences 35


4.1 How Schools Exclude: Policy, Practice and Variation Comparative research across the UK demonstrates that, while all jurisdictions retain exclusion within legislative and policy frameworks, there are significant differences in how exclusion is enacted, including variations in processes, motivations, and the use of alternative provision (McCluskey et al., 2019; Power & Taylor, 2024; Duffy et al., 2021; Duffy et al., 2024; McCluskey et al., 2024). These differences have resulted in notable disparities in the number of recorded ‘official’ exclusions, raising questions about consistency and equity in implementation. Across all regions, exclusion is embedded within wider behaviour policies, with responsibility for maintaining acceptable standards typically placed on head teachers and governing bodies. In principle, exclusion is to be used as a measure of last resort, when all other strategies have been exhausted (McCluskey et al., 2024). However, the continued prevalence of exclusion suggests a disconnect between this policy position and its application in practice. The most frequently cited reason for exclusion—‘persistent disruption’—illustrates the ambiguity inherent in current systems (Graham et al., 2019). This broadly defined category can encompass a wide spectrum of behaviours, ranging from minor infractions, such as uniform breaches, to more serious incidents of physical aggression and assault. Such variability creates scope for inconsistent interpretation and application, raising significant concerns about proportionality, fairness, and the extent to which exclusion is used in line with its designation as a measure of last resort. Evidence from recent studies highlights cases in which children have been excluded for relatively minor infractions (Power & Taylor, 2024), further underscoring the gap between policy and practice. Furthermore, while exclusion is often justified as a necessary behaviour management strategy, there remains limited evidence to demonstrate its effectiveness in improving behaviour or preventing future exclusion (Samaritans Cymru, 2019; Oxley, 2020; Down et al., 2024; Thompson et al., 2021). Instead, exclusion may contribute to cycles of disengagement and escalation. Professional capacity also plays a significant role. Evidence suggests that some education professionals may lack sufficient training in behaviour management and children’s rights frameworks, limiting their ability to implement alternatives to exclusion effectively (Graham et al., 2019). This concern is reflected in recommendations from the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2023), which call for greater emphasis on children’s rights education within both school curricula and professional training. Taken together, these factors suggest that exclusion is not simply a clearly defined or consistently applied practice, but one shaped by ambiguity, variation, and limitations in professional knowledge. This further complicates efforts to ensure that exclusion is used proportionately and in line with rights-based principles. 4.2 Justifications for Exclusion: The ‘Best Interests’ Principle Despite its harms and inconsistencies, exclusion continues to be justified through reference to the ‘best interests of the child’. This principle is typically invoked in two ways: first, to protect the learning environment and the rights of the wider school community; and second, to suggest that exclusion may, in certain circumstances, benefit the individual child, for example by preventing escalation to permanent exclusion or enabling relationships to be reset (Department for Education, 2024). While such justifications may be framed as pragmatic, they risk obscuring the extent to which exclusion serves institutional needs rather than the rights of the child. In practice, the language of ‘best interests’ can be mobilised to legitimise decisions that remove children from mainstream education, including through informal or coercive processes that circumvent formal safeguards (Duffy et al., 2024). This creates a significant ethical tension. As Gillett-Swan and Lundy (2022) argue, children’s rights are held at the individual level and cannot be overridden by majority interest. The use 36


of exclusion to protect the collective therefore raises serious questions about whose rights are prioritised, and on what basis. In this context, the ‘best interests’ principle risks functioning less as a protective framework and more as a rhetorical device that enables exclusionary practice. 4.3 Systemic Drivers: Accountability and Perverse Incentives The persistence of exclusion cannot be understood solely in terms of individual behaviour or school-level decision-making. Rather, it must be situated within the broader accountability frameworks that shape the operation of education systems, particularly in England. Highstakes accountability measures, including performance tables, attendance data, behaviour metrics, and inspection regimes such as Ofsted, place significant pressure on schools to demonstrate measurable outcomes within tightly defined parameters. Within this context, exclusion functions not only as a disciplinary tool, but as a mechanism through which schools manage institutional performance. A growing body of evidence highlights the use of practices such as internal exclusion, isolation, part-time timetables, and off-rolling, whereby pupils are removed from the school roll in ways that may not be formally recorded (Graham et al., 2019; Thompson et al., 2021; Duffy et al., 2024). These practices reflect the presence of what have been described as ‘perverse incentives’, in which the prioritisation of attainment and performance data can conflict with the principles of inclusion and the rights of the child. This dynamic is particularly evident in England, where schools operate under intense professional scrutiny. Within this context, education systems are frequently characterised by a sustained focus on closing the attainment gap as a primary mechanism for supporting vulnerable learners. However, this focus coexists with disproportionately high rates of exclusion among the same groups of children. This reveals a fundamental contradiction: the very system designed to support disadvantaged pupils may simultaneously contribute to their marginalisation. As Martin-Denham (2020) argues, low attainment functions both as a driver of exclusion and as one of its most significant outcomes, reinforcing cycles of disadvantage. Taken together, these dynamics demonstrate that exclusion is not merely a failure of implementation, but is structurally embedded within accountability-driven education systems (Done & Andrews, 2020; Thompson et al., 2021). In this sense, exclusion becomes a predictable outcome of policy design, rather than an unintended consequence. Schools operate within a system in which the pressures to maintain standards, protect inspection outcomes, and manage performance indicators can make exclusionary practices both rational and, at times, incentivised. These dynamics also raise fundamental questions about the purpose of education. While current practices may suggest a prioritisation of academic attainment and measurable outcomes, the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) articulates a broader and more holistic vision. Article 29(1) emphasises the development of the child’s personality, talents, and abilities to their fullest potential, alongside respect for human rights and preparation for life in a free and inclusive society (UNCRC, 1989). The contrast between these competing conceptions of education further highlights the extent to which current systems may diverge from a rights-based framework. In this context, exclusion cannot be viewed simply as an operational response to disruption, but as a systemic outcome of policy choices that privilege efficiency, standardisation, and measurable outcomes over relational practice and inclusion. As long as these structural conditions remain in place, efforts to reduce exclusion are likely to be constrained, and the gap between rights in principle and rights in practice will persist. From a rights-based perspective, these dynamics raise serious concerns about the extent to which current education systems uphold the principles of the United Nations Convention 37


on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), the central international framework governing children’s rights. The disproportionate exclusion of disadvantaged pupils challenges the principle of non-discrimination under Article 2, while the systemic conditions that produce exclusion call into question whether the best interests of the child, as outlined in Article 3, are being consistently prioritised. Furthermore, where exclusion contributes to cycles of low attainment and disengagement, it undermines the realisation of the right to education under Article 28, and highlights the interdependence of this right with broader socio-economic conditions addressed in Article 27. In this sense, exclusion is not only an educational issue, but a matter of children’s rights. 4.4 Consequences of Exclusion: Impact on Children Children who are excluded from school experience significant and well-documented longterm harm, including reduced educational attainment, poorer health outcomes, and increased likelihood of social and economic marginalisation (Martin-Denham, 2020; Obsuth et al., 2023). Exclusion is also associated with higher risks of substance misuse and involvement with the criminal justice system, reinforcing cycles of disadvantage. Beyond these measurable outcomes, children’s lived experiences of exclusion reveal profound emotional and relational impacts. Many describe feelings of isolation, injustice, and a lack of care or respect, often reporting that they felt unheard and misunderstood within school systems (Murphy, 2022; Power & Taylor, 2024). Exclusion can reinforce negative selfperceptions, exacerbate trauma, and deepen existing attachment or relational difficulties. These outcomes raise fundamental questions about the compatibility of exclusion with a rights-based approach to education. While the UNCRC requires that school discipline be administered in a manner consistent with the child’s dignity, exclusionary practices are frequently experienced as stigmatising and punitive. The persistence of such practices therefore reflects not only a gap between policy and practice, but a deeper contradiction between rights-based commitments and the lived realities of children. 4.5 Alternative Provision: A Contradictory Response Alternative provision (AP) represents a key mechanism through which education systems respond to exclusion. While intended to ensure continued access to education, its role is both complex and contradictory. Many children report positive experiences within AP settings, citing reduced pressure, greater autonomy, and stronger relationships with staff (Murphy, 2021). These features often stand in contrast to their experiences in mainstream education. However, access to such environments is frequently contingent upon prior exclusion or failure within mainstream settings (Duffy et al., 2024). This creates a systemic paradox: the conditions that enable success for some children are only made available after exclusion. At the same time, similar approaches within mainstream schools may be viewed as inappropriate or exclusionary, highlighting inconsistencies in how inclusion is conceptualised and enacted. Critics argue that alternative provision may reinforce social segregation, as children are grouped with others who share similar experiences of marginalisation (Oxley, 2020; Murphy, 2022). Concerns also remain regarding the variability in quality and oversight. As such, while alternative provision may mitigate some immediate harms of exclusion, it does not resolve the underlying structural issues that produce exclusion in the first place. 4.6 Managed Moves: Relational Alternatives or Displacement? Relational factors are widely recognised as critical in preventing exclusion (Mills & Thomson, 2018; Down et al., 2024). Where relationships between children and schools break down, managed moves are often presented as an alternative to permanent exclusion. When implemented effectively, these moves involve collaboration with children and families and can provide opportunities for re-engagement (Down et al., 2024). 38


However, their effectiveness depends on the extent to which they are genuinely voluntary, transparent, and centred on the rights of the child. Where these conditions are not met, managed moves risk functioning as a mechanism for displacing responsibility rather than addressing underlying issues (Duffy et al., 2024; Thompson et al., 2021). In such cases, they may replicate the dynamics of exclusion in less visible forms. This reinforces the broader argument of this article that, without addressing the structural conditions that give rise to exclusion, alternative approaches such as managed moves may mitigate its effects but are unlikely to prevent its recurrence. 5. Implications for Rights-Based Education The analysis presented in this article demonstrates that current approaches to exclusion are difficult to reconcile with a genuinely rights-based model of education. While the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) establishes a framework grounded in dignity, participation, and non-discrimination, exclusionary practices reveal a persistent misalignment between these principles and their realisation in practice. In particular, the disproportionate exclusion of children with protected characteristics and those experiencing socio-economic disadvantage raises significant concerns regarding indirect discrimination. These patterns suggest that exclusion is not experienced equally, but is structured along existing lines of inequality, challenging the extent to which education systems uphold the principle of equal access to education. Moreover, the influence of accountability structures and performance-based measures complicates the application of a rights-based approach. Where schools are incentivised to prioritise attainment and measurable outcomes, the rights of individual children may be subordinated to institutional imperatives. This creates a tension between collective performance and individual entitlement, calling into question whether the best interests of the child are consistently prioritised within current systems. Taken together, these implications suggest that the realisation of children’s rights in education cannot be achieved through policy alignment alone. It requires a deeper reconsideration of how education systems define success, distribute responsibility, and respond to difference within increasingly complex social contexts. 6. Rethinking Exclusion: Structural Pathways to Reform Addressing exclusion requires reform that extends beyond school-level practice to the structural conditions within which education systems operate. Efforts focused solely on behaviour policy or professional practice are unlikely to succeed without confronting the broader accountability frameworks and socio-economic inequalities that shape decisionmaking in schools. A rights-based approach to education, as articulated in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC, 1989) and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD, 2006), positions schools as institutions responsible not only for access to education, but for the protection of dignity, the promotion of participation, and the development of the whole child. Realising this vision requires a shift away from narrowly defined performance metrics towards more holistic and inclusive measures of educational success. There are indications of movement in this direction within parts of the UK. Legislative incorporation of the UNCRC in Wales and Scotland has begun to reframe policy discourse towards rights, inclusion, and participation (McCluskey et al., 2024). However, these developments also highlight the limitations of reform that focuses solely on legislative change or professional practice. Without addressing the systemic pressures created by accountability systems and assessment frameworks, exclusionary practices are likely to persist. 39


This raises important questions about the scope of what schools can reasonably be expected to achieve within existing policy environments. As argued by Done and Andrews (2020), inclusion cannot be reduced to the technical capacity of educators, nor can schools alone mitigate the effects of broader social inequalities. In this context, the aspiration to create fully inclusive education systems must be understood in relation to the structural constraints within which they operate. Crucially, meaningful reform must engage with the wider social and economic conditions that shape children’s experiences of education. Patterns of exclusion remain closely aligned with poverty, disability, and marginalisation. As such, the realisation of the right to education under Article 28 of the UNCRC is inextricably linked to the state’s obligations under Article 27 to ensure an adequate standard of living. Without progress in addressing these underlying conditions, reforms within education systems are likely to have limited impact. At the same time, the current policy landscape presents opportunities for change. Developments such as the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act (2024), alongside broader political shifts towards social investment, may create conditions in which more coherent and rights-based approaches to education can emerge. Taken together, these considerations suggest that reducing exclusion requires a reconfiguration of the relationship between education systems, accountability structures, and wider social policy. Without such systemic change, exclusion is likely to remain an embedded feature of the education landscape rather than an exceptional measure of last resort. These priorities also point to the need for further research that engages more directly with the structural dimensions of exclusion. In particular, there is a need for comparative analysis across UK jurisdictions, greater attention to the lived experiences of children and families, and more robust investigation into informal exclusionary practices. Crucially, future research must address the broader social and economic conditions that shape exclusion, recognising the relationship between the right to education and the right to an adequate standard of living. 7. Conclusion While the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) clearly articulates the right to education and the development of the whole child, this article has demonstrated that its realisation in the UK remains uneven and, for some children, significantly compromised. Exclusion emerges not as an isolated response to individual behaviour, but as a systemic outcome shaped by accountability structures, policy design, and wider socio-economic inequalities. In this context, the disproportionate exclusion of children with protected characteristics and those experiencing disadvantage raises serious concerns regarding indirect discrimination and the extent to which current systems uphold the principles of equality and non-discrimination. Crucially, the persistence of exclusion reflects broader structural conditions that extend beyond the education system itself. Without addressing the underlying drivers of poverty, inequality, and unmet need, the right to education cannot be fully realised in practice. The continued reliance on exclusion therefore challenges the extent to which the UK can be said to fulfil its obligations as a duty bearer under international law. If education systems are to reflect the principles of the UNCRC, exclusion must be repositioned as a measure of last resort within a system that is structurally oriented towards inclusion. Without such change, exclusion risks remaining not an exception, but an enduring feature of the education landscape.

40


References: Barry Down, Anna Sullivan, Neil Tippett, Bruce Johnson, Jamie Manolev & Janean Robinson (2024), What is missing in policy discourses about school exclusions, Critical Studies in Education, 65:5, 494-512, DOI: 10.1080/17508487.2024.2312878. Council for Catholic Maintained Schools (CCMS) (2015) Scheme for the Suspension and Expulsion of Pupils. Daniels H., Porter J., and Thompson I., (2022), What Counts as Evidence in the Understanding of School Exclusion in England? Front. Educ. 7:929912. doi: 10.3389/feduc.2022.929912. Department for Children, Schools and Families (2010) The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child: How legislation underpins implementation in England. Department for Education (2013) Alternative Provision: Statutory guidance for local authorities. Department for Education (2016) Behaviour and discipline in schools: Advice for headteachers and school staff. Department for Education (2024) Children missing education: Statutory guidance for local authorities. Department of Education (2021) Interim guidance on the use of restraint and seclusion in educational settings. DE Circular 2021/13. Department of Education (1999) Pastoral Care: Guidance on the Use of Reasonable Force to Restrain or Control Pupils. Circular 1999/09. Department of Education (2024) Pupil suspensions and expulsions in Northern Ireland 2022/23: Official statistics in development. Department for Education (DfE) (2019) School exclusion: a literature review on the continued and disproportionate exclusion of certain children. Department of Education (2021) Suspensions and expulsions arrangements for pupils in grantaided schools in Northern Ireland. DE Circular 2021/04. Department for Education (2024) Suspension and permanent exclusion from maintained schools, academies and pupil referral units in England, including pupil movement: Guidance for maintained schools, academies, and pupil referral units in England. Department of Education (1990) Temporary exceptions from the statutory curriculum and assessment provisions for individual pupils. Circular 1990/45. Duffy, G., Robinson, G., Gallagher, T., & Templeton, M. (2021). School exclusion disparities in the UK: a view from Northern Ireland. Emotional & Behavioural Difficulties, 26(1), 3-18. https://doi. org/10.1080/13632752.2021.1900998. Duffy, G., Gallagher, T., Lundy, L., Robinson, G., & Templeton, M. (2024). ‘The political economy of school exclusion in Northern Ireland: the intersection of perspectives from mainstream education, alternative provision and an official education body.’, Oxford Review of Education, 50 (6), 876-892. Education Authority (2015) Scheme for the Suspension and Expulsion of Pupils in Controlled Schools. Education Authority (2024) Attendance Matters: Practical guidance to improve attendance together. Elizabeth J. Done & Mandy J. Andrews, (2020). How inclusion became exclusion: policy, teachers and inclusive education, Journal of Education Policy, 35:4, 447-464, DOI: 10.1080/02680939.2018.1552763. Equality Act 2010. 41


Equality and Human Rights Commission (2022) Restraint in schools inquiry: using meaningful data to protect children’s rights. Equality and Human Rights Commission (2015) What equality law means for you as an education provider: schools. Gillett-Swan, Jenna & Lundy, Laura, (2022). Children, classrooms and challenging behaviour: do the rights of the many outweigh the rights of the few? Oxford Review of Education, 48(1), pp. 95-111. Gillean McCluskey, Sheila Riddell & Elisabet Weedon, (2015). Children’s rights, school exclusion and alternative educational provision, International Journal of Inclusive Education, 19:6, 595607, DOI: 10.1080/13603116.2014.961677. Graves, K.A. (2023). Restraint and Seclusion: A Review of Practices and Policy, Intervention in School and Clinic 2024, Vol. 59(5) 347–353. Highland Council (2023) Exclusion policy: Included, engaged and involved: Management of exclusion in Highland schools. Hood R., Goldacre A., Jones E., Martin E., Clements K., Webb C., (2024). ‘Factors associated with the school exclusion gap for children with social work involvement: A retrospective cohort study using national administrative data’ British Journal of Social Work (2024) 00, 1–19 doi. org/10.1093/bjsw/bcae179. IFF Research Ltd, Mills, M. & Thomson, P., (2018). Investigative research into alternative provision. Jemma Bridgeman (06 Nov 2024): Parents’ perceptions of power in the school exclusion process examined through Arnstein’s ladder of participation, Educational Review, DOI: 10.1080/00131911.2024.2418918. Julie Sealy, Elizabeth J. Abrams & Tom Cockburn, (2023). Students’ experience of isolation room punishment in UK mainstream education. ‘I can’t put into words what you felt like, almost a dog in a cage’, International Journal of Inclusive Education, 27:12, 1336-1350, DOI: 10.1080/13603116.2021.1889052. Jull, S.K. (2008). ‘Emotional and behavioural difficulties (EBD): the special educational need justifying exclusion’, Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 8(1), pp. 13–18. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-3802.2008.00097.x. Marnie Best (2024), The complex and contradictory nature of alternative education provision, Cogent Education, 11:1, 2413208, DOI: 10.1080/2331186X.2024.2413208. Martin-Denham, S. (2020). ‘An investigation into perceived enablers and barriers in mainstream schooling: The voices of children excluded from school, their caregivers and professionals.’ Project Report. University of Sunderland. Martin-Denham, S. (2020). ‘A review of school exclusion on the mental health, wellbeing of children and young people in the City of Sunderland.’ Project Report. University of Sunderland. McCluskey, G., Cole, T., Daniels, H., Thompson, I. & Tawell, A. (2019). ‘Exclusion from school in Scotland and across the UK: contrasts and questions’, British Educational Research Journal, 45(6), pp. 1140–1159. doi: 10.1002/berj.3555. McCluskey, G., Duffy, G., Power, S., Robinson, G., Tawell, A., Taylor, A., Templeton, M., & Thompson, I. (2024). ‘School exclusion policies across the UK: convergence and divergence.’ Oxford Review of Education, 50 (6), 760-776. https://doi.org/10.1080/03054985.2024.2376609 Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council (2017) Pupil exclusion from schools handbook 2017-20. Northern Ireland Assembly (1998) Schools (Expulsion of Pupils) (Appeal Tribunals) (Amendment) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1998, SR 1998 No. 256. 42


Northern Ireland Assembly (2006) The Education (Northern Ireland) Order 2006, No. 1915 (N.I. 11). Northern Ireland Assembly (1994) Schools (Expulsion of Pupils) (Appeal Tribunals) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1994, SR 1994 No. 30. Northern Ireland Assembly (2011) The Education (2006 Order) (Commencement No. 3) Order (Northern Ireland) 2011, SR 2011 No. 191. Northern Ireland Commissioner for Children and Young People (NICCY) (2022) Statement on children’s rights in Northern Ireland 3: Main report. Northern Ireland Executive (2020) Children and Young People’s Strategy 2020-2030. Obsuth, I., Madia, J.E., Murray, A.L., Thompson, I. & Daniels, H., 2023. ‘The impact of school exclusion in childhood on health and well-being outcomes in adulthood: Estimating causal effects using inverse probability of treatment weighting’, British Journal of Educational Psychology, pp. 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjep.12656. Office of the Children’s Commissioner (2013) Always someone else’s problem: Office of the Children’s Commissioner’s report on illegal exclusions. Paget A., Parker C., Heron J., et al. ‘Which children and young people are excluded from school? Findings from a large British birth cohort study, the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC)’. Child Care Health Dev. 2018;44:285–296. Power, S. & Taylor, C. (2024). ‘Classroom exclusions: patterns, practices, and pupil perceptions.’ International Journal of Inclusive Education 28 (12), pp. 2698-2712. 10.1080/13603116.2022.2121434. Power, S. & Taylor, C. (2021). ‘Rights, rules and remedies: interrogating the policy discourse of school exclusion in Wales.’ Rick Murphy (2022). How children make sense of their permanent exclusion: a thematic analysis from semi-structured interviews, Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties, 27:1, 43-57, DOI: 10.1080/13632752.2021.2012962. Scottish Government (2021) Included, engaged and involved Part 2: A positive approach to preventing and managing school exclusions. Scottish Government (2024) Statutory guidance on Part 2 of the UNCRC (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024. Scottish Government (2024) United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024. Thompson, I., Tawell, A., & Daniels, H. (2021). ‘Conflicts in professional concern and the exclusion of pupils with SEMH in England’. Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties, 26(1), 31–45. https:// doi.org/10.1080/13632752.2021.1898769. Thomas Popkewitz & Sverker Lindblad (2000). ‘Educational Governance and Social Inclusion and Exclusion: Some conceptual difficulties and problematics in policy and research’, Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 21:1, 5-44, DOI: 10.1080/01596300050005484. Thompson, P. (2017) Written evidence submitted to UK Parliament Committee. School of Education, The University of Nottingham. Tilson, J., & Oxley, L. (2020). Children’s moral rights and UK school exclusions. Theory and Research in Education, 18(1), 40-58. doi.org/10.1177/1477878520912509 United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2023) List of issues prior to submission of the combined sixth and seventh reports of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Welsh Government (2019) Exclusion from schools and pupil referral units. 43


Welsh Government (2016) Inclusion and pupil support. Guidance document no: 203/2016. Valdebenito, S., Eisner, M., Farrington, D.P., Ttofi, D.P. & Sutherland, A. (2018). ‘School-based interventions for reducing disciplinary school exclusion: a systematic review’, Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 8(1), pp. 13–18. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-3802.2008.00097.x.

44


Defining and Cultivating Teaching Excellence: A Contextual Model for an International School in Shanghai Kay Yang, Wellington College International Shanghai Jenny Lou, Wellington College International Shanghai Abstract This study explores the conceptualization of teaching excellence within the unique context of Wellington College International Shanghai (WCIS), integrating perspectives from teachers, students, and contemporary research. Through thematic analysis of interviews with 31 teachers and 24 students (Years 3–13), we identify four key domains of excellent teaching: (1) dynamic adaption, (2) holistic development, (3) inclusive environments, and (4) accountable outcomes. These domains are underpinned by three foundational pillars—commitment to the profession, learners, and subject expertise—which collectively foster sustainable teaching excellence. Our findings highlight the contextual nature of excellence, challenging one-size-fits-all frameworks and advocating for culturally responsive definitions. The proposed model offers actionable strategies for teacher development, evaluation, and school culture transformation, emphasizing collaborative reflection, student voice, and iterative improvement. By bridging theory and practice, this research contributes to global conversations on teaching excellence while providing a scalable blueprint for international school communities.

Keywords: teaching excellence, international education, action research Introduction At Wellington College International Shanghai (WCIS), we believe that teaching excellence is not an abstract ideal but a lived practice—one that must be clearly articulated, collaboratively understood, and continually refined. This project was born from a pressing need: to develop a shared vision of what excellent teaching looks like across our diverse community, ensuring consistency in expectations while empowering educators to elevate their practice. By establishing this common language, we aim to enhance instructional quality and, ultimately, transform student learning outcomes. As a decade-old institution partnered with a leading UK brand school, WCIS serves a uniquely international student body. Our learners hail from 45+ countries, each bringing distinct cultural and academic perspectives. This diversity is mirrored in our faculty, with educators from 25+ nations—primarily the UK and other English-speaking regions—working alongside local Chinese teachers who deliver our robust Mandarin program. Academically, we blend the best of global curricula: the UK National Curriculum (adapted for Years 1–9), followed by IGCSE and IBDP programs (Years 10–13), ensuring our graduates thrive at universities worldwide. To capture the nuances of excellence within this context, we embarked on a two-month qualitative study, centering the voices of those who experience teaching daily—educators and students alike. Through interviews, focus groups, and thematic analysis, we sought to answer: How is excellent teaching conceived, enacted, and sustained at WCIS? The insights that emerged now form the foundation of a dynamic model, one that honors our community’s diversity while providing clear pathways for growth. In an era where education paradigms are rapidly evolving, this project transcends internal benchmarking. It offers a case study in how international schools can define excellence on their own terms, bridging global research with local realities. The following sections detail our methodology, findings, and the actionable framework that resulted—a blueprint for teaching excellence as multifaceted as the community it serves. 45


What researchers say about excellent teaching? The quest to define teaching excellence has long eluded consensus, with scholars acknowledging its inherent complexity and contextual nature. This section synthesizes key debates and evolving conceptions, revealing a dynamic interplay between pedagogy, culture, and institutional priorities. 1.

The Elusiveness of Excellence

Teaching excellence resists singular definitions. Scholars describe it as a “conceptual chameleon” (Zou et al., 2022), shaped by ideological, cultural, and institutional norms. Wood & Su (2017) critique narrow framings that reduce excellence to classroom performance, arguing this overlooks critical dimensions like curriculum leadership and reflective inquiry. This ambiguity, however, is not a weakness but a reflection of teaching’s multifaceted nature— what constitutes excellence in one context may falter in another (Ismail & Groccia, 2022). 2.

From Transmission to Transformation: Shifting Paradigms

Historically, excellence was synonymous with teacher-centered instruction—authoritative knowledge delivery and disciplined classrooms. Contemporary research, however, paints a more nuanced picture: •

Student-Centeredness as a Core Principle The 21st century has seen a paradigm shift toward student agency and deep learning. Keeley et al. (2016) position excellence as prioritizing students’ holistic development— knowledge, skills, and well-being—over mere content coverage. This aligns with Turner & Gosling’s (2012) “learning-focused” model, where teachers act as facilitators rather than transmitters.

•

Beyond the Classroom Walls Excellence now encompasses curriculum innovation, assessment design, and professional collaboration (Kreber, 2002). Wood & Su (2017) highlight how excellent teachers engage in the scholarship of teaching—researching their practice to drive institutional improvement.

3.

Cultural and Contextual Variability

Global studies underscore that excellence is culturally mediated. Chen et al. (2012) caution against exporting “best practices” across borders; a technique lauded in Finland may flounder in Shanghai. For instance, while Western literature champions student voice, collectivist cultures might emphasize communal learning structures. This variability demands contextualized definitions—excellence must be locally negotiated (Ismail & Groccia, 2022). 4.

Pillars of Excellence: Research-Backed Principles

Despite contextual differences, three principles recur in international literature: •

Pedagogical Content Mastery Excellent teaching requires more than subject expertise—it demands pedagogical content knowledge (PCK), the ability to tailor instruction to learners’ needs (Zou et al., 2022).

•

Relationships and Environments Trust and motivation flourish in classrooms where teachers demonstrate empathy and passion (Keeley et al., 2016). Students excel when they feel safe to take risks—a finding consistent across cultures.

•

Holistic Impact Excellence transcends test scores, fostering lifelong learning and transferable skills (Turner & Gosling, 2012). This aligns with Kreber’s (2002) view of teaching as an intellectual, not just technical, endeavor. 46


Implications: Toward Contextualized Frameworks The literature converges on one truth: standardized metrics fail to capture excellence’s richness. Zou et al. (2022) advocate for institutional self-definitions—schools must engage stakeholders to articulate excellence in their unique contexts. This aligns with WCIS’s mission to blend global research with local realities, as explored in the subsequent sections.

What WCIS Teachers and Students Believe as Excellent Teaching Methodology: Capturing Voices, Defining Excellence To bridge the gap between theoretical frameworks and lived experiences, this study employed a qualitative approach, centering the perspectives of teachers and students at Wellington College International Shanghai (WCIS). The methodology was designed to systematically uncover how stakeholders conceptualize excellent teaching, while grounding findings in actionable domains for practice.

Research Design and Participants A Thematic Framework Analysis (Ritchie & Spencer, 1994) was adopted, enabling iterative exploration of how participants’ experiences aligned with or challenged existing literature. Data collection spanned January–February 2025 and included: •

31 Teachers: 16 primary and 15 secondary educators, identified by peer and leadership nomination as exemplars of excellent teaching.

•

24 Students: Purposively sampled from Year 3–13 to ensure representation across age groups, subjects, and learning profiles.

Data Collection: Semi-Structured Interviews Guided by open-ended prompts, interviews explored three core questions: For Teachers: •

“What does ‘excellent teaching’ mean to you, based on your experience?”

•

“How do you recognize it in practice?”

•

“What attributes distinguish consistently excellent teachers?”

For Students (adapted for age-appropriate clarity): •

“Describe a lesson you remember as excellent. What made it stand out?”

•

“How do you know when a lesson is excellent?”

•

“What suggestions would you give teachers to better support your learning?”

Interviews were dynamic, allowing follow-up probes (e.g., “Can you elaborate on how the teacher adapted to your needs?”). This flexibility surfaced nuanced insights beyond scripted questions.

Analytical Process: From Data to Domains Data analysis followed a five-stage framework: 1. Familiarization: Immersion in transcripts and field notes to identify initial patterns. 2. Thematic Framework Development: Coding data against literature-derived constructs 47


(e.g., “student agency,” “cultural responsiveness”). 3. Indexing: Systematically tagging data to themes by reading repeatedly 4. Charting: Synthesizing findings into thematic matrices for cross-participant comparison. 5. Mapping and Interpretation: Patterns and relationships were identified, with particular attention to divergent cases. Validation Strategies: Triangulation: Comparing teacher and student responses to identify convergences/ divergences. Peer Debriefing: Collaborative analysis with a second researcher to mitigate bias.

Emergent Domains of Excellent Teaching (Figure 1) Analysis distilled four empirically grounded domains, each reflecting shared priorities across stakeholder groups: •

Dynamic Adaptation

Key markers: Real-time adjustments to pacing, scaffolding, tailoring resources and representations based on student needs. •

Holistic development

Key markers: Fostering curiosity, growth mindsets, and transferable skills beyond content mastery. •

Inclusive Environments

Key markers: Psychological safety, relational trust, dialogic learning, effective collaboration, and culturally responsive practices. •

Accountable Outcomes

Key markers: Transparent goals, aligned assessments, and feedback-driven progress. These domains were not static categories but interconnected dimensions, observed in tandem during exemplary practice (e.g., a teacher’s adaptive scaffolding [Domain 1] relied on dialogic learning [Domain 3]). Figure One: four domains of excellent teaching

48


Ethical Considerations •

Anonymity: Participants were de-identified; pseudonyms replace direct quotes in narratives.

•

Power Dynamics: Student interviews were conducted by non-teaching staff to encourage candid responses.

What Teachers and Students Say About Excellent Teaching A Narrative Synthesis of Key Themes The voices of teachers and students reveal that excellent teaching is not a static set of practices but a dynamic interplay of understanding, adaptability, and intentionality. Through their stories, four central themes emerge—each weaving together the lived experiences of educators and learners into a cohesive vision of what makes teaching truly exceptional. 1.

The Heart of Teaching: Knowing and Adapting to Students

At the core of excellence lies a teacher’s deep understanding of their students—their needs, cultures, and ways of learning. •

Adjusting for Engagement

Teachers described the delicate art of calibration: challenges must be neither too easy (“just ticking boxes”) nor too daunting (“losing interest”). One educator likened it to “reading the eyes of your students,” adjusting explanations when confusion arises or slowing down when students need more processing time. Students echoed this, recalling moments when a teacher’s perceptiveness transformed their learning—“If something is not going in the planned way, the teachers adapt and help students in a way our brains work. When the teacher understands the students, they provide a simpler way.” •

Cultural Bridges and Personal Connections

In a multicultural setting, relevance is key. Teachers shared strategies for making content resonate, from redesigning projects around local landmarks (“Shanghai’s skyline, not London’s”) to involving parents in creating culturally familiar case studies. Students, in turn, spoke of lessons that “felt real” because teachers connected concepts to their lives. As one noted, “When you see yourself in what you’re learning, it sticks.” 2.

Where Learning Thrives: The Power of Environment

Students spoke most passionately about the classrooms where they felt safe, valued, and energized—a testament to the environment’s role in excellence. •

A Safe Space for Risk-Taking

The best classrooms, students said, were those where mistakes were welcomed. “No one laughs at you here,” shared one, describing how a teacher’s encouragement to “take leaps” boosted confidence. Teachers reinforced this by modeling vulnerability—admitting their own errors and framing challenges as growth opportunities. •

Joy as a Catalyst for Learning

Laughter and enthusiasm were recurring motifs. “You can’t learn if you’re bored,” a student remarked, contrasting monotonous drills with lessons where teachers’ passion was palpable. Educators agreed, noting how their energy set the tone—”If I’m not excited about poetry, why should they be?” •

Dialogue Over Monologue 49


While teachers rarely highlighted questioning techniques, students celebrated classrooms buzzing with discussion. “In history, everyone asks questions and we have chances to answer rather than the teacher himself,” said one, other student echoed “I enjoy group discussions like in English. My teachers don’t put pressure. I don’t feel judged. So, I can engage in. not feeling nervous or worried.” 3.

Beyond Content: Cultivating Skills and Mindsets

Excellence, teachers argued, transcends mere content delivery, focusing instead on equipping students for lifelong learning. •

Teaching “How” Over “What”

Many educators rejected rote memorization, prioritizing skills like critical thinking and selfadvocacy. “I don’t just teach all articles—I teach how to analyze the articles,” explained an English teacher. Students recognized this approach, valuing lessons that gave them “tools to explore on their own.” •

Feedback That Fuels Growth

Here, a disconnect emerged: while students craved “specific, actionable feedback,” few teachers mentioned this. One student’s plea—”Tell me how to improve, not just ‘good job’”— underscored the need for more robust assessment and feedback literacy. 4.

The Invisible Backbone: Planning and Reflection

Behind every great lesson lies intentional design—a theme teachers emphasized but students seldom saw. Like one educator said “you need to be well prepared for a lesson. Doesn’t matter how good you are.” •

Clarity from the Start

Educators stressed backward design—”If I don’t know why we’re doing this, neither will they.” Sharing objectives upfront (“Here’s what you’ll master by Friday”) helped students grasp purpose. •

The Reflective Practitioner

Excellence, teachers noted, demands continual self-reflection: “After each lesson, I ask, ‘What worked? What didn’t?’” Yet, this reflective practice remained largely invisible to students.

Implications: Bridging Voices and Visions These narratives reveal both alignment and dissonance. While teachers and students agreed on the importance of relationships and relevance, gaps persisted—particularly around assessment and student voice. Addressing these could help to refine WCIS’s model of excellence, ensuring it resonates not just in theory but in every classroom interaction.

The Pillars of Excellent Teaching: A Narrative Synthesis of Teacher Attributes What distinguishes teachers who consistently excel in the classroom? Through interviews with educators at Wellington College International Shanghai, three foundational pillars emerged— each representing a constellation of attributes that collectively foster teaching excellence. These are not isolated traits but interconnected commitments that shape how teachers engage with their profession, their students, and their subjects. 1.

Commitment to the Profession and Community

Excellent teaching begins with a dedication to the craft itself—a willingness to grow, collaborate, 50


and contribute beyond the classroom. •

Reflective Practitioners, Lifelong Learners

The most effective teachers described themselves as “perpetual students of teaching,” driven by research and relentless self-improvement. One educator shared, “We’re all human—not every lesson is perfect, but reflection turns missteps into growth.” Others spoke of stepping outside comfort zones, whether by teaching new year groups or experimenting with technology. This mindset of curiosity and humility resonated across interviews, with many emphasizing that “excellence isn’t magic; it’s deliberate practice.” •

Collaborators and Community Builders

Isolation stifles growth; excellence thrives in community. Teachers highlighted the importance of sharing resources, co-planning units, and leaning on colleagues’ strengths. “Team culture, learn from others and lean on each other’s strength,” noted a veteran teacher. Beyond the staffroom, this commitment extended to parents and external experts. One science teacher’s partnership with university professor designing real-world projects exemplified how community engagement enriches learning. •

Authenticity and Passion as Catalysts

Students consistently linked excellence to teachers’ genuine enthusiasm. “You can’t fake passion—it’s in their voice, their gestures,” observed a Year 10 student. Educators agreed, with one admitting, “one hundred percent there when you are in class”, “No shame to say, ‘I don’t know this, will come back another time’. This passion and authenticity build trust. As another educator put it, “we’re all learners together.” 2.

Commitment to Learners: Seeing the Whole Child

At the heart of excellence lies an unwavering focus on students—not as abstract “learners” but as individuals with unique needs, cultures, and potential. •

Relationships as the Foundation

“Connection comes before content,” asserted a primary teacher, capturing a universal theme. Teachers described intentional efforts to know students deeply: memorizing names and interests, noticing subtle shifts in mood (“Who had a bad night?”), and even redesigning lessons based on informal feedback. Students reciprocated this investment, recalling how a teacher’s empathy (“She didn’t just teach—she listened”) transformed their motivation. •

Cultural Responsiveness in Action

In an international school, excellence demands cultural agility. Teachers shared strategies like adapting case studies to students’ backgrounds or inviting parents to co-create culturally relevant examples. “My German and Chinese students shouldn’t have to decode British contexts in design class,” argued one educator. Students affirmed this, valuing lessons where “the teacher make sure everyone’s voice fit.” •

Empathy That Empowers

Beyond academic support, teachers emphasized emotional attunement—”seeing the child behind the grade.” A secondary teacher’s policy of “no shame in needing more time” exemplified this. Field trips and informal interactions (“Seeing them outside class reveals new dimensions”) further cemented bonds. 3.

Commitment to Subject Expertise: Mastery with Purpose

Content knowledge alone is insufficient; excellence requires pedagogical finesse to make subjects come alive. •

Depth and Breadth of Knowledge 51


Teachers stressed the importance of “knowing your subject inside out”—not just to deliver facts but to connect concepts and anticipate misconceptions. A physics teacher’s analogy resonated: “You need enough mastery to improvise, like a jazz musician who knows the scales cold.” •

Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK)

The hallmark of expertise, PCK—the fusion of subject mastery and teaching skill—emerged repeatedly. Educators described tailoring methods to content: using Socratic seminars in literature but hands-on inquiry in science. “A PhD doesn’t guarantee you can teach,” remarked one teacher, underscoring the distinction. •

Assessment as a Learning Tool

While this area showed gaps, standout teachers used assessments diagnostically. “Rubrics shouldn’t just judge—they should guide,” explained a humanities teacher who co-created criteria with students. Others leveraged peer feedback, though many admitted needing more training in this domain. Figure Two: Three pillars (excellent teachers attributes) to support excellent teaching

Synthesis: The Interdependence of Commitments These pillars are not siloed; they interact dynamically. A teacher’s subject expertise (Pillar 3) means little without relationships (Pillar 2), just as passion (Pillar 1) falters without pedagogical skill (Pillar 3). The most compelling narratives came from educators who embodied this integration—like the math teacher whose cultural responsiveness (using local architecture in geometry lessons) stemmed equally from content knowledge, empathy, and collaborative planning. This holistic view challenges reductionist evaluations of teaching excellence, arguing instead for a model that honors the full complexity of educators’ roles.

What beliefs about learning underlies all these commitments and practices? The following learning principles should be established as common beliefs and understanding at WCIS to align with excellent teaching practices. Principles of learning •

Students are in partnership with adults to shift and steer their learning journey. 52


•

Learning goes beyond just academic success, aiming to develop skills, attitudes, and values that support sustainable growth.

•

Teachers, peers, parents, and the community all play vital roles in shaping and inspiring students’ learning.

•

Engaging with relevant, real-world contexts and actively interacting in a safe setting enhances learning.

By integrating these beliefs and understandings, the excellent teaching practices and learning experiences that inspire and empower students to reach their fullest potential will be fostered.

The Soil That Nurtures Excellence: How School Culture Shapes Great Teaching Excellent teaching does not flourish in isolation—it is deeply rooted in the culture of the school. When teachers at Wellington College International Shanghai reflected on what enables them to thrive, their stories painted a vivid picture of an ecosystem that either sustains or stifles excellence. Through their voices, four key cultural pillars emerged as essential for fostering the commitments that define outstanding educators. 1.

A Collaborative and Transparent Environment

Excellent teaching thrives when teachers feel safe to share, observe, and grow together. •

Open Classrooms, Open Minds

Many teachers spoke of the power of breaking down barriers—literally and figuratively. “The doors should be kept open, the culture should be ‘not be afraid of having someone in your classroom’”, shared one educator, “Not as critics, but as curious colleagues.” Students, though unaware of these behind-the-scenes dynamics, indirectly benefit from this cross-pollination of ideas. As one teacher noted, “When I borrow a strategy from a colleague’s lesson, it’s my students who gain.” •

Trust Through Transparency

Teachers emphasized the need for leadership to model vulnerability. “When admins share their own challenges, it gives us permission to do the same,” reflected a department head. This transparency extends to decision-making; staff valued schools where “the ‘why’ behind policies is explained, not just dictated. 2.

Well-Being as a Priority, Not an Afterthought

Stress is the silent saboteur of excellence. Teachers highlighted how systemic support for wellbeing directly impacts their ability to teach at their best. •

Time and Space to Breathe

The most passionate educators can burn out without structural safeguards. “You can’t innovate when you’re drowning in busy daily working,” admitted one teacher. A secondary teacher’s comment captured a universal need: “We’re not machines. Even small things—like protected planning time—signal that our humanity matters.” •

Holistic Support Systems

From mentorship programs to accessible counseling, teachers valued schools that “see us as whole people.” One newcomer described how a buddy system helped her adjust: “Knowing I had someone to ask ‘silly questions’ made all the difference.” 3.

Autonomy and Ownership

While collaboration is vital, excellence also requires space for individual creativity. •

Freedom Within Frameworks 53


Teachers resisted scripted curricula, advocating instead for “guardrails, not handcuffs.” A veteran educator explained, “I need the flexibility to pivot when a lesson isn’t landing—but I also need quality resources to start from.” This balance empowered them to tailor instruction without reinventing the wheel. •

Professional Agency

The most satisfied teachers described feeling “trusted as experts.” Whether leading PD sessions or piloting new technologies, opportunities to “own initiatives” fueled their motivation. “Nothing kills passion like micromanagement,” remarked one. 4.

Growth-Oriented Professional Development

Meaningful learning for teachers mirrors what works for students: relevant, engaging, and sustained •

Beyond “Tick-Box” Training

Teachers critiqued one-off workshops in favor of “ongoing, job-embedded” learning. A science teacher’s example stood out: “Our AI working group meets monthly—it’s messy, but we’re actually applying ideas, not just hearing about them.” •

Career Pathways That Inspire

Staff stayed energized in schools where “growth isn’t just vertical.” Opportunities like crossdivisional projects or action research allowed them to grow.

The Structure of the Teaching Excellence Model By synthesizing the discussions above, the excellent teaching model can be illustrated as follows: Figure three: excellent teaching model for WCIS context

1.

The Ceiling: Four Domains of Excellent Teaching

Observable in classroom practice, these domains—dynamic adaptation, holistic learning, inclusive environments, and accountable outcomes—define what excellence looks like in action. 2.

The Middle Layer: Three Pillars of Teacher Attributes

These pillars—commitment to the profession, learners, and subject expertise—serve as the foundation for enacting the domains, representing the skills and dispositions teachers cultivate to sustain excellence. 54


3.

The Base: Learning Principles

Grounding the model are shared beliefs about learning (e.g., student agency, real-world relevance) that align instructional practices with WCIS’s educational philosophy. The Ecosystem of Influence •

School Culture: Acts as the backdrop, shaping how domains and pillars manifest (e.g., collaborative cultures amplify dynamic adaptation).

•

External Community: Parents, external partners, and global networks contribute resources and perspectives that enrich teaching practices.

From Theory to Practice: Leveraging the Model for Transformative Impact The WCIS model of excellent teaching is not merely a descriptive framework—it is a catalyst for systemic growth. By aligning stakeholders around a shared vision, redefining evaluation practices, and fostering a culture of collaborative learning, this model has the potential to transform not only individual classrooms but the entire educational ecosystem. Below, we explore its multifaceted utility. 1.

Creating a Common Language for Excellence

The model serves as a lighthouse for the school community, translating abstract ideals into concrete practices. •

For Teachers: It demystifies excellence, offering clear markers to guide self-reflection and goal setting.

•

For Leaders: It provides a coherent lens for observations and feedback, moving beyond checklist evaluations to holistic appraisals.

•

For Students & Parents: It articulates what to expect—and celebrate—in impactful teaching, fostering transparency and trust.

2.

Reimagining Teacher Evaluation

The model challenges traditional evaluation paradigms by advocating for: •

A 360° Approach: Excellence is assessed through multiple vantage points—peer observations, student surveys, parent feedback, and professional portfolios. This mirrors the interconnectedness of the model’s pillars (e.g., commitment to learners cannot be judged through lesson snapshots alone).

•

Growth-Oriented Cycles: Evaluations become iterative dialogues, not high-stakes audits.

•

Student Voice as Data: Pupils’ perceptions of “psychological safety” (Domain 3) are weighted alongside test scores, honoring the model’s holistic ethos.

3.

A Compass for Professional Growth

Beyond evaluation, the model maps pathways for development: •

Personalized PD Plans: Teachers align goals with model domains—e.g., a design teacher focusing on “cultural responsiveness” (Domain 3) might partner with a colleague to audit curriculum materials.

•

Mentorship and Coaching Networks: Novices are paired with veterans who exemplify specific pillars, creating targeted learning partnerships (e.g., a mentor renowned for “dynamic adaptation” coaching peers in real-time differentiation).

4.

Strengthening the Learning Ecosystem

The model’s ripple effects extend beyond classrooms: 55


•

Leadership Actions: Scheduling “protected planning time” addresses Domain 1’s adaptive planning needs, while open-door weeks foster Domain 2’s collaborative culture.

•

Resource Allocation: Budgets prioritize tools and resources that enable domains development.

•

Community Engagement: Parents can be invited to workshops on the model, aligning home support with school priorities (e.g., growth mindset language used consistently).

Charting the Path Forward: A Phased Implementation Strategy The WCIS teaching excellence model is not a static artifact but a living framework—one that demands deliberate implementation, iterative refinement, and sustained commitment. Below, we outline a phased action plan to translate theory into transformative practice. Establish shared understanding: Present the model to the senior leadership team for approval and disseminate the approved version across the entire school community. Ensure everyone has a common understanding of the model’s principles and implementation strategies. Data collection and reporting: Begin implementing the model to collect pertinent data for the November and May academic subcommittee reports. This involves tracking progress and assessing the impact of the model on teaching practices and outcomes. Continuous feedback and refinement: Throughout the year, gather feedback from stakeholders including teachers, students, and administration to refine the model. This ensures it remains relevant and effective in practice. Regular review cycle: Establish a regular review cycle every two years to keep the model updated and aligned with evolving educational needs and standards. Overall, this process ensures systematic implementation and continuous improvement of the model, supported by structured data collection and feedback.

Conclusion: Excellence as a Collective Journey Teaching excellence is neither a static destination nor a solitary pursuit—it is a dynamic, collective endeavor shaped by the interplay of individual commitment, institutional culture, and shared vision. This study, grounded in the voices of Wellington College International Shanghai’s teachers and students, has illuminated a model of excellence that transcends universal prescriptions, offering instead a contextualized framework rooted in four observable domains (dynamic adaptation, holistic learning, inclusive environments, accountable outcomes) and three foundational pillars (commitment to profession, learners, and subject expertise). The WCIS model challenges reductionist evaluations of teaching, arguing instead for a holistic understanding that honors the full complexity of educators’ roles. It repositions excellence as a process of continuous growth—one that thrives in cultures of trust, collaboration, and reflective practice. Crucially, the model’s utility lies not just in its diagnostic power but in its capacity to catalyze systemic change: by aligning stakeholder expectations, reshaping professional development, and fostering ecosystems where both teachers and students flourish. As WCIS starts using this new framework, we must stay alert and avoid falling back into old habits. Regular reviews, responsive feedback mechanisms, and celebratory storytelling will be essential to sustain momentum. Ultimately, the true measure of this model’s success will be its invisibility—the day its principles become so deeply woven into the fabric of daily practice that they are no longer a framework to reference but the very air the school breathes. In an era of global educational flux, the WCIS model offers more than a local roadmap; it 56


invites international schools worldwide to engage in a dialogue about how excellence is defined, nurtured, and sustained—one classroom, one community, at a time.

References Chen, J. (2016). Exploring middle school students’ and parents’ conceptions of excellent teaching. Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 36(4), 570–582. https://doi.org/10.1080/02188791. 2015.1005052 Danielson, C., Furman, J. S., & Kappes, L. (2025). Presenting the latest iteration of the Framework for Teaching-the most comprehensive tool yet for teacher self-assessment and reflection, observation and feedback, and collaborative inquiry. Education Policy Outlook 2024. (2024). OECD. https://doi.org/10.1787/dd5140e4-en Hall, D. K. (n.d.). An Introduction to The Framework for Teaching By Charlotte Danielson Frameworks for Teaching Trainer. www.danielsongroup.org Kreber, C. (2002). Teaching Excellence, Teaching Expertise, and the Scholarship of Teaching. In Innovative Higher Education (Vol. 27, Issue 1). Keeley, J. W., Ismail, E., & Buskist, W. (2016). Excellent Teachers’ Perspectives on Excellent Teaching. Teaching of Psychology, 43(3), 175–179. https://doi.org/10.1177/0098628316649307 OECD Teaching Compass (123rd ed., OECD Education Policy Perspectives). (2025). https://doi. org/10.1787/8297a24a-en Ritchie, J., & Spencer, L. (1994). Qualitative data analysis for applied policy research. In A. Bryman & R. G. Burgess (Eds.), Analyzing qualitative data (pp. 173–194). Routledge. Teaching for the Future. (2018). OECD. https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264293243-en Unlocking High-Quality Teaching. (2025). OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/f5b82176en Understanding innovative pedagogies (OECD Education Working Papers, Vol. 172). (2018). https://doi.org/10.1787/9f843a6e-en Ismail, E. A., & Groccia, J. E. (2022). Foreign- and US-educated faculty members’ views on what constitutes excellent teaching: Effects of prior graduate training, rank, and teaching experience. New Directions for Teaching and Learning, 2022(169), 47–64. https://doi. org/10.1002/tl.20482 Turner, R., & Gosling, D. (2012). Rewarding Excellent Teaching: The Translation of a Policy Initiative in the United Kingdom. Higher Education Quarterly, 66(4), 415–430. https://doi. org/10.1111/j.1468-2273.2012.00530.x Zou, T. X. P., Harfitt, G., Carless, D., & Chiu, C. S. T. (2022). Conceptions of excellent teaching: a phenomenographic study of winners of awards for teaching excellence. Higher Education Research and Development, 41(2), 577–592. https://doi.org/10.1080/07294360.2020.1842337

57


58


Leadership Competencies in International Schools: A Survey Study of Employee Perceptions Using the School Implementation Leadership Scale Jordan Benedict, Paris American International University Abstract International schools face unique challenges regarding implementing evidence-based practices due to turnover, varying accrediting bodies, and decentralized governance. This study applied the School Implementation Leadership Scale, validated by Lyon et al. (2022), with N = 126 responses across five regions. The composite mean was M = 1.59 (0-4 scale); Vision/ Mission was the lowest subscale, and Supportive the highest; all subscales were 1.00-1.72 points below Lyon et al. (2022) norms. This study contributes to international education research by providing the first validation of the SILS in international school contexts, establishing a baseline for future research and leadership development.

Keywords: Implementation Science, International Schools, Leadership Competencies, Evidence-Based Practices, School Implementation Leadership Scale Introduction International schools operate in unique circumstances, differing significantly from those of local and national education systems. Students carry with them a wide range of cultural diversity and linguistic backgrounds. The curricula in international schools often follow multiple frameworks, and the schools themselves are accredited by a wide variety of accrediting bodies. While in local and national curricula, systems, policies, and standards tend to be consistent, in an international school, they must balance a host of policies set by local and international authorities and accreditation bodies (Macur & Macur, 2025). This leads leaders in international school environments to face considerable challenges in creating consistent structures. Of particular challenge in international schools is turnover. With high staff turnover, progress made can be lost or stalled. New employees have to be onboarded to the current practices and schoolwide goals, while bringing with them a wide variety of experiences, education, and preparation. In turn, adapting practices to a culturally diverse group of students is also a difficult necessity (Dolby & Rahman, 2008; Sankaranarayanan, 2023). School leadership has a strong, well-documented influence on whether or not evidencebased practices are installed with fidelity and sustained. School leaders have the ability to set priorities, influence culture, and allocate resources for preparation and support. In international school contexts, these demands are magnified when employees bring a disparate set of skills and experiences. Leadership skills in flexibility to shifting circumstances, providing reliable resources and information, and helping members feel a shared sense of purpose and direction are of particular importance (Leithwood et al., 2020). This study focuses on one core framework: the School Implementation Leadership Scale (SILS) as a way to measure perceived international school leaders’ implementation competencies. It was introduced specifically to measure these competencies and behaviors and validated in education settings (Lyon et al., 2022). The School Implementation Leadership Scale is a 21-item survey, assessed on a 0-4 Likert scale, with 7 subscales: Proactive, Supportive, Knowledgeable, 59


and Perseverant leadership behaviors, as well as competencies in Communication, Vision/ Mission, and Availability. Even though recognition of evidence-based practices as a way forward to improving student learning outcomes is growing, international schools may lack the leadership structures, training in implementation, and institutional continuity to install and maintain evidencebased practices with fidelity. The cycle in Figure 1 below illustrates how turnover, fragmented professional development, and reduced fidelity compound one another in the absence of sustained implementation leadership.

Figure 1: Cycle of Implementation Failure in International Schools This study’s response to the challenges faced in implementation leadership in international schools is to utilize the School Implementation Leadership Scale (Lyon et al., 2022) to quantitatively measure perceived leadership competencies. By utilizing a validated instrument to draw conclusions about the current perception of implementation leadership, this study provides a baseline measurement and set of recommendations. The primary research question of this study is: to what extent do employees in international schools perceive implementation leadership behaviors in their school leaders, as measured by the School Implementation Leadership Scale? This question is intentionally designed to produce a quantitative baseline of perceived implementation leadership in international school contexts, filling a specific gap in the literature. The secondary research question of this study is: how do perceptions of implementation leadership vary across the seven School Implementation Leadership Scale subscales proactive, knowledgeable, supportive, perseverant, communication, vision/mission, and availability? This question allows for subscale comparison, leading to the conclusions and recommendations in further sections that can support school improvement planning and school leadership development.

Background Studying the effectiveness of implementing evidence-based practices began from a practical crisis. Federally funded programs in the United States in the 1960s and 1970s regularly underperformed their expected results, regardless of the strength of the design of the practice (Fitz, 1994). Fitz (1994) describes Implementation Science as “born out of adversity.” This led researchers to ask the question: Why do practices with strong or promising evidence fail to 60


be implemented with sustained use and results? This question of why rigorously evidenced practices still fail to change results, the research-to-practice gap, is what implementation scientists continue to study today (Fixsen et al., 2005). When Implementation Science entered the education sector, three persistent concerns were prevalent, namely fidelity, adaptation, and sustainability. Researchers learned that implementation of evidence-based practices requires changing systems, modifying behaviors, and convincing practitioners (Blase et al., 2015). While the field appears to be maturing in the 2000s, there is an ongoing fragmentation of implementation, lacking a common language and structure, which impedes progress across contexts (Century & Cassata, 2016). There is still promise across a variety of contexts and even in international education settings, as Malin et al. (2020) explored how intermediary organizations have helped bridge the research-to-practice gap, providing a way forward to systematize and generalize implementation progress, and proposing a solution to the fragmentation. What has become certain in successful implementation in education, as the field of Implementation Science progresses, is the key insight that program design alone does not pre-determine successful outcomes. Further, leadership and leadership behaviors - how leaders support, resource, communicate about, and sustain practice - have become critical variables. In Fixsen et al.’s (2009) Scaling Up brief, the argument is made that to sustain evidence-based practices in education, we must develop infrastructure for implementation, with implementation leadership seen as indispensable. School leadership behaviors have been shown to be empirically linked to student learning outcomes (Leithwood et al., 2005) and should therefore be attended to, developed, and measured. Much like the origins of Implementation Science frameworks, to be able to understand the present state of implementation-specific leadership behaviors, measurement instruments were first designed in healthcare, not education. The Implementation Leadership Scale (ILS) was developed to address this gap and support empirical examination (Aarons et al., 2014). The Implementation Leadership Scale is a 12-item instrument comprising 4 subscales that measure proactive, knowledgeable, supportive, and perseverant leadership behaviors. The scale was validated with 459 clinicians in mental health contexts and provided a basis to understand strengths and gaps in implementation leadership. Later, the Implementation Leadership Scale was tested in education, along with the Implementation Climate Scale and the Implementation Citizenship Behavior Scale. The instruments were adapted for a sample of school-based mental/behavioral health consultants, and their findings were that the original factor structures held, with the exception of the Rewards subscale from the climate scale (Lyon et al., 2018). What this shows us is that measurement instruments, such as the Implementation Leadership Scale, can be applied in other settings, but context needs to be taken into consideration. The Implementation Leadership Scale created space for a School Implementation Leadership Scale; however, before the instrument was fully developed, and recognizing context as an important factor, Lyon et al. (2019) examined the importance and feasibility of implementation strategies by surveying 200 school-based consultants. The results from the healthcare-derived Implementation Leadership Scale survey shifted when rated by school practitioners, demonstrating a need and providing the impetus to create and develop the School Implementation Leadership Scale (SILS), which is now a fully developed and validated instrument for understanding leadership behaviors in education contexts (Lyon et al., 2022). The School Implementation Leadership Scale, adapted from the original Implementation Leadership Scale, was validated with 441 public school teachers, utilizing 21 survey items across seven subscales: proactive leadership, knowledgeable leadership, supportive leadership, perseverant leadership, communication, vision/mission, and availability. The survey showed strong psychometric results (CFI = .995, high inter-item reliability α = .91–.96) and provided a validated implementation leadership instrument where none had existed (Lyon et al., 2022). 61


In an early application, Shapiro et al. (2019) used the ILS in a pilot with 45 teachers implementing a Social Emotional Learning initiative, finding that the teachers’ perceptions varied meaningfully both across schools and across the academic year, with the proactive leadership subscale the most meaningfully varied. In this study’s research, the Shapiro example is a direct precedent for using the School Implementation Leadership Scale to interrogate teacher perceptions across international schools; however, it will be important to remember the limiting condition of context. How implementation competency frameworks function is affected by cultural, geographic, and language contexts (Schultes et al., 2021); we can expect the tools to manifest differently in international school settings, creating a research need that this study contributes to filling. Not only do international schools exist abroad, but they also operate in distinctively different contexts. Decentralized governance, variation in accreditation bodies, diverse populations with cultural and linguistic diversity, and high staff turnover are features of international education. Without central governance, international schools operate as isolated entities, and in terms of implementing evidence-based practices, each school navigates processes independently (Macur & Macur, 2025). With the unique context and high variability, there is also a limited research scope in international schools (Dolby & Rahman, 2008), which, if rectified, could support implementation leadership. While isolated, international schools are not a small collection of entities. The definition of these schools is often cited as “institutions delivering curriculum wholly or partly in English outside an English-speaking country,” (ISC Research, 2021) and present figures show that they number over twelve-thousand worldwide, growing 15-fold from the early 2000s (de Meijia, 2002; ISC Research 2020), and as OlsonWyman (2023) states, outpacing the research base that might inform leadership practice. An example of practitioner-led literature, instead of rigorous empirical research, examines the implementation and found the importance of leadership behaviors in implementing an evidence-based practice, specifically standards-based grading, in three Asian international high schools (Prairie, 2020). As a case study, it provides precedent and promise to the examination of implementation-leadership competencies in international schools; however, it is a single qualitative study, with a specific design and case examination. Prairie’s work demonstrates that studying implementation leadership is worth empirical analysis to answer future questions at scale. Similarly, another study on instructional coaching in international schools confirms the same pattern. It showed that instructional coaching in international schools, a specific support structure for evidence-based practices, is largely a new phenomenon with most schools reporting their programs are 0-4 years old, frequently unclear in purpose, and loosely affiliated with implementation goals and student learning outcomes (Benedict et al., 2025). These two studies show the gap in implementation standards and the necessity for implementation leadership in international schools to be researched and cultivated. The sector of international schools has begun asking the necessary questions around implementing specific evidence-based practices, and this study aims to establish an empirical baseline for further understanding.

Methods A quantitative, cross-sectional survey design was employed to examine international school employee perceptions of implementation leadership behaviors using the School Implementation Leadership Scale. This study employs the School Implementation Leadership Scale, a validated 21-item instrument used to ascertain leadership behaviors in school contexts (Lyon et al., 2022). The SILS was derived from the Implementation Leadership Scale (ILS), which was developed and validated in healthcare contexts (Aarons et al., 2014). Both scales contain subscales with a priori higher-order factor structure (Aarons et al., 2014; Lyon et al., 2022). The seven subscales in the School Implementation Leadership Scale that measure four key dimensions in leadership for implementation are: 62


1. Proactive 2. Knowledgeable 3. Supportive 4. Perseverant 5. Communication 6. Vision/Mission 7. Availability A convenience sample was collected using online professional communities for recruitment, resulting in a sample size of N = 126. Recruitment materials were posted in well-established professional online communities serving international school educators. Van Quaquebeke et al. (2022) established the methodological appropriateness of using social media and online professional communities for research recruitment, finding that online surveys delivered on social media channels, such as the ones used in this study, constitute an effective means for recruiting niche sample populations that may not be able to be as successfully recruited through traditional site-based access due to geographic dispersion. The recruitment in this study utilized a total of 3 international educator community groups on Facebook, as well as a dedicated LinkedIn post, reaching a potential of more than 80,000 combined exposures. Using the participant’s reported international school, responses were grouped into five regional groups for analysis: Africa, Asia (East & Southeast), Asia (West & South), Europe, and the Americas. The frequency of each region, ordered from the greatest number of responses to the least, is in Table 1 below. Table 1: Frequency of responses by region, in descending order Region Europe Asia (West & South) Asia (East & Southeast) Africa The Americas (North & South) Total

n 45 31 27 18 5 126

Freq (%) 35.7 24.6 21.4 14.3 4 100

Data was analyzed using descriptive statistics, confirmatory factor analysis, and normative comparisons. The study adheres to established ethical principles governing research involving human participants. As the study relies on voluntary survey responses from school employees, informed consent is a foundational requirement. Participants were clearly informed of the study’s purpose, the voluntary nature of their participation, and their right to withdraw at any time without consequence. No personal identifying information was collected, and all responses remained confidential. The anonymity of participants is further protected through the aggregation of data at the subscale and instrument level, ensuring that no individual response can be traced back to a specific participant. This multi-layered approach to permission reflects the researcher’s commitment to transparency and respect for the organizational contexts in which participants work (British Educational Research Association [BERA], 2024; Creswell & Creswell, 2023).

63


Results Both first-order and second-order models, CFI and TLI, demonstrate excellent fit, being above the > 0.95 threshold, consistent with the Lyon et al. (2022) benchmarks. However, both the RMSEA and SRMR were outside the threshold. Elevated RMSEA values are a known artifact of WLSMV estimation of ordinal data at smaller sample sizes, and therefore, are not an absolute reflection of misfit. Xia & Yang (2019) demonstrated this inflation effect empirically, and recommended CFI and TLI be weighted with more importance as models of fit in complex models since they were shown to be less sensitive to sample size and a more meaningful and stable validity signal. This study, given that RMSEA (0.149) and SRMR (0.118) exceed the threshold at N = 126, being consistent with Xia & Yang’s (2019) documented inflation effect, therefore, uses CFI and TLI as primary fit indicators. Further, all standardized loadings exceed Lyon et al.’s (2022) benchmark of λ > 0.55. In this study, standardized loading was calculated in the range of λ = 0.713 to 0.979 (for first-order) and λ = 0.704 to 0.978 (for second-order). These results provide structural validity evidence for the School Implementation Leadership Scale in international school contexts. Table 2 shows the fit indices of the data set. Table 2: Fit Indices for First- and Second-Order Confirmatory Factor Analysis of the School Implementation Leadership Scale (N = 126) Factor

Threshold

First Order CFI > 0.95 TLI > 0.95 RMSEA ≤ .08 SRMR ≤ .08 Second order CFI > 0.95 TLI > 0.95 RMSEA ≤ .08 SRMR ≤ .08

Result

Within or Threshold

= 0.991 = 0.989 = 0.149 = 0.118

Within Within Outside Outside

= 0.985 = 0.983 = 0.185 = 0.138

Within Within Outside Outside

Outside

All seven subscales of the School Implementation Leadership Scale had Cronbach’s alpha values above 0.70. The range of 0.720 to 0.957 is psychometrically qualified as “acceptable” to “excellent” levels of reliability (George & Mallery, 2003), demonstrating internal consistency across the subscales. Table 3: Cronbach’s Alpha for Each of the Seven Subscales Subscale Proactive Knowledgeable Supportive Perseverant Communication

a = 0.774 = 0.957 = 0.930 = 0.756 = 0.720 64


Subscale Vision/Mission Availability

a = 0.779 = 0.921

The overall composite School Implementation Leadership Scale mean was M = 1.59 (SD = 0.77), indicating that implementation leadership behaviors were perceived at a slight-to-moderate extent on the 0-4 SILS Likert scale. Means of the subscales ranged from M = 1.17 (SD = 0.84) to M = 2.01 (SD = 1.00), indicating meaningful variation in the subscales. The rank-order, highest to lowest, of subscales by mean is: Supportive (2.01), Availability (1.93), Knowledgeable (1.91), Communication (1.50), Proactive (1.42), Perseverant (1.21), Vision/Mission (1.17). Table 4: Subscale level means and standard deviations SILS Subscale Proactive Knowledgeable Supportive Perseverant Communication Vision/Mission Availability

n 126 126 126 126 126 126 126

M ± SD 1.42 ± 0.78 1.91 ± 1.21 2.01 ± 1.00 1.21 ± 0.66 1.50 ± 0.67 1.17 ± 0.84 1.93 ± 1.09

Figure 2: Bar graph of means and standard deviations of SILS subscales.

While the means of the seven SILS subscales ranged from M = 1.17 (Vision/Mission) to M = 2.01 (Supportive), when compared to Lyon et al. (2022), the difference in subscale means ranged from -1.00 to -1.72, with the largest gap being in the Vision/Mission subscale and the smallest gap being in the Availability subscale. Side-by-side comparison of subscale means is in Table 5 below. 65


Table 5: Subscale Mean Comparison: This Study vs Lyon et al. (2022) Subscale Proactive Knowledgeable Supportive Perseverant Communication Vision/Mission Availability

This Study M 1.42 1.91 2.01 1.21 1.50 1.17 1.93

Lyon et al (2022) M 2.82 3.10 3.09 2.85 2.81 2.89 2.93

Difference -1.40 -1.19 -1.08 -1.64 -1.31 -1.72 -1.00

Note. Lyon et al. (2022) N = 441. Difference = This Study M − Lyon et al. (2022) M

Discussion The overall composite mean of M = 1.59 on the 0-4 SILS Likert scale indicates that respondents believe that implementation leadership competencies exist at a “Slight” to “Moderate” extent. These results are consistent with Moore et al. (2024), whose findings were that leaders are often at a deficit in relation to the knowledge and skills of implementation science, identifying “a critical need to increase school leaders’ knowledge and skills related to implementation science.” Without implementation leadership skills, the chance of successful Evidence-Based Practice implementation is severely diminished (Century & Cassata, 2016). The lowest subscale mean in the study is the Vision/Mission subscale, M = 1.17, which is below the original validation study in the USA by 1.72. On the SILS Likert scale, this result is interpreted to mean that respondents perceive implementation leadership skills tied to the Vision and Mission of the school to “Slight” extent. Possible explanations could be the high turnover and fragmented governance structures of international schools (Macur & Macur, 2025), or as Lee, Hallinger, & Walker (2011) found in the Asia-Pacific region, leadership’s ability to build visible and shared commitment to program principles is greatly connected to implementation challenges. A potential solution from interviews with international school leaders is to derive leadership structures and implementation from guiding statements and stakeholder input (Macur & Macur, 2025) to deliberately connect to the Mission & Vision of the school. Another low mean and gap is the second lowest subscale, Perseverant, with M = 1.21, a difference of -1.64 as compared to the original validation study. The inability to sustain implementation, leading to implementation failure, is more often about sustaining “skilled, consistent, and committed use” over time (Klein & Knight, 2005). Locke et al. (2025) found that EBP implementation degrades without active leadership support, which would be significantly more challenging in international school environments where turnover, including leadership turnover, is higher. On the other end, the relative strengths in the subscale means were in the Supportive subscale, M = 2.01, and Availability subscale, M = 1.93, interpreted on the SILS Likert scale to fall on the “Moderate” extent perceived by respondents. These results are consistent with Shapiro et al. (2019), who showed less variation between the Supportive and Availability subscales as well. Instead, they found the largest variability, and therefore a potential driver of implementation success, in the Proactive leadership subscale. This suggests that relational leadership is a baseline, but strategic leadership is a differentiator in implementation success. Opdenakker & Van Damme (2007) in their study of secondary school leadership found that structural conditions, not leadership dispositions alone, predicted success. This profile, where international school leaders are rated lowest on Vision/Mission and highest on Supportive 66


and Availability, suggests that these contexts are providing clear relational support, but not exhibiting the strategic foundation for the implementation. Duda & Wilson (2015) help by providing leadership behaviors that improve implementation phases and they found that Vision/Mission is most critical at the exploration phase, while relational supports such as those measured in the Supportive subscale, are most critical in later stages when sustaining becomes the focus. One of the clearest observations in this data set is the gap in all seven subscales from Lyon et al. (2022), ranging from -1.00 to -1.72 below the norm set by the validation study. The difference is likely contextual, and not methodological. Lyon et al. (2022) was a survey of U.S. public school teachers who do not experience the decentralized governance, high turnover, or multiple frameworks challenges of international schools. International schools lack the policy infrastructure of national systems that can support strong implementation practices (Hayden & Thompson, 2008). This difference is meaningful in the validation of the instrument, showing how the SILS is sensitive to unique contexts, confirming that implementation leadership and competency frameworks function differently across varied cultural and organizational contexts (Schultes et al., 2021). The subscale pattern points to the need for targeted professional development for leaders on specific subscales in the SILS rather than generic leadership development. Professional development for leaders that is transformative and successful requires behavioral skill-building and not purely conceptual knowledge building (Klimoski & Amos, 2012). Leaders should also be trained on successful implementation strategies, such as instructional coaching, which has shown a direct and strong link to implementation over time (Reinke et al., 2014).

Conclusion This study validates the School Implementation Leadership Scale for use in International School contexts, and establishes a baseline, relative to the original validation study by Lyon et al. (2022). The subscales establish a variable profile of international school contexts to support the identification of areas of growth in these unique contexts. The CFA results are consistent with Lyon et al. (2022), building on and extending the ILS study by Shapiro et al. (2019). This study addresses the gap in international education research, identified by Dolby & Rahman (2008), by providing perceived implementation challenges linked to international schools. As a consequence of this study, three practical recommendations are presented: 1. Leaders require targeted professional development, specific to subscales of the SILS. Our subscale analysis showed a direct need for training to improve the perceptions on the Vision/ Mission subscale and the Perseverant subscale. The best method of delivery for this leadership training would be through evidence-based leadership design and coaching (Reinke et al., 2014; Klimoski & Amos, 2012). 2. Accreditation bodies common in international schools (IB, CIS, NEASC, etc.) should consider the use of implementation leadership frameworks in self-study processes. Implementation leadership is not separate but deeply intertwined with school development needs, which inform leadership structures (Macur & Macur, 2025). There is a need for leadership readiness derived from structured preparation frameworks that accrediting bodies can inform and evaluate (Schmidt, 2025). 3. Now that the tool is validated and demonstrates cross-contextual functionality, International school networks should adopt the SILS for implementation, leadership development, and planning. Locke et al. (2025) demonstrated that measuring and targeting implementation competencies directly produced measurable benefits. However, these competencies are not universally applied and must be adapted in contextually appropriate ways (Cook et al., 2019). The SILS can therefore be an appropriate tool to use as a diagnostic within specific environments to understand their unique context. 67


While this study presents a baseline, validating the SILS for international school use, several limitations presented themselves to warrant future research. This study was a single point in time, perception-only, convenience sample using social media recruitment, with a large number of responses coming from specific regions. Social media recruitment, while garnering large audiences, introduces algorithmic selection bias (Van Quaquebeke et al., 2022). The study also recorded few responses from the Americas (n = 5) and as a consequence, the results should not be considered generalizable to this region. The recommendation for future research is therefore longitudinal studies, qualitative research to understand the causes of the variation, and wider use of the SILS in more schools and contexts. It is also recommended to intentionally recruit from underrepresented regions to establish more global representation.

References Aarons, G. A., Ehrhart, M. G., & Farahnak, L. R. (2014). The implementation leadership scale (ILS): development of a brief measure of unit level implementation leadership. Implementation Science, 9(1), 45. Benedict, J., Moreland, K., Olson-Wyman, S., Cofino, K., & Killion, J. (2025). The landscape of instructional coaching in international schools. In Issues and trends in international school leadership (pp. 1–36). IGI Global Scientific Publishing. Blase, K. A., Fixsen, D. L., Sims, B. J., & Ward, C. S. (2015). Implementation science: Changing hearts, minds, behavior, and systems to improve educational outcomes. National Implementation Research Network; Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. British Educational Research Association [BERA]. (2024). Ethical Guidelines for Educational Research (5th ed.). Century, J., & Cassata, A. (2016). Implementation research: Finding common ground on what, how, why, where, and who. Review of Research in Education, 40(1), 169–215. Cook, C. R., Lyon, A. R., Locke, J., Waltz, T., & Powell, B. J. (2019). Adapting a compilation of implementation strategies to advance school-based implementation research and practice. Prevention Science, 20(6), 914–935. Creswell, J. W., & Creswell, J. D. (2023). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches (6th ed.). SAGE Publications. de Mejia, A. M. (2002). Power, prestige, and bilingualism: International perspectives on elite bilingual education. Multilingual Matters. Dolby, N., & Rahman, A. (2008). Research in international education. Review of Educational Research, 78(3), 676–726. Duda, M. A., & Wilson, B. A. (2015). Using implementation science to close the policy to practice gap. Literacy Information and Computer Education Journal, 6(3), 1297–1305. Fitz, J. (1994). Implementation research and education policy: Practice and prospects. British Journal of Educational Studies, 42(1), 53–69. Fixsen, D. L., Naoom, S. F., Blase, K. A., Friedman, R. M., & Wallace, F. (2005). Implementation research: A synthesis of the literature (FMHI Publication No. 231). University of South Florida, Louis de la Parte Florida Mental Health Institute, The National Implementation Research Network. Fixsen, D. L., Blase, K. A., Horner, R. H., & Sugai, G. (2009). Scaling up evidence-based practices in education. State Implementation and Scaling-up of Evidence-based Practices Center (SISEP). 68


George, D., & Mallery, P. (2003). SPSS for Windows Step by Step: A Simple Guide and Reference. 11.0 Update (4th ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon. Hayden, M., & Thompson, J. (2008). International schools: Growth and influence. UNESCO International Institute for Educational Planning. ISC Research. (2020). Data. ISC Research. https://www.iscresearch.com/ ISC Research. (2021). The international school student profile the 2021 report. ISC Research. Klein, K. J., & Knight, A. P. (2005). Innovation implementation: Overcoming the challenge. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 14(5), 243–246. Klimoski, R. J., & Amos, B. (2012). Practicing evidence-based education in leadership development. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 11(4), 685–702. Lee, M., Hallinger, P., & Walker, A. (2011). Leadership challenges in international schools in the Asia Pacific region: Evidence from program implementation of the International Baccalaureate. International Journal of Leadership in Education, 15(3), 289–310. Leithwood, K., Seashore Louis, K., Anderson, S., & Wahlstrom, K. (2005). How leadership influences student learning. The Wallace Foundation. Leithwood, K., Harris, A., & Hopkins, D. (2020). Seven strong claims about successful school leadership revisited. School Leadership & Management, 40, 5–22. Locke, J., Lawson, G. M., Beidas, R. S., Aarons, G. A., Bunger, A. C., & Lyon, A. R. (2025). “Not getting better, but not getting worse”: A cluster randomized controlled pilot trial of a leadership implementation strategy in elementary schools. Implementation Science, 18, Article 6. Lyon, A. R., Cook, C. R., Brown, E. C., Locke, J., Davis, C., Ehrhart, M., & Aarons, G. A. (2018). Assessing organizational implementation context in the education sector: Confirmatory factor analysis of measures of implementation leadership, climate, and citizenship. Implementation Science, 13, Article 5. Lyon, A. R., Cook, C. R., Locke, J., Davis, C., Williams, N., & Ehrhart, M. G. (2019). Importance and feasibility of an adapted set of implementation strategies in schools. Journal of School Psychology, 76, 66–77. Lyon, A. R., Le, T., Leickly, E., Dorsey, S., Pullmann, M. D., Alvord, M. K., & Aarons, G. A. (2022). Leading the charge in the education sector: Development and validation of the School Implementation Leadership Scale (SILS). Implementation Science, 17, Article 78. Malin, J. R., Brown, C., Ion, G., van Ackeren, I., Bremm, N., Luzmore, R., Flood, J., & Rind, G. M. (2020). World-wide barriers and enablers to achieving evidence-informed practice in education: What can be learnt from Spain, England, the United States, and Germany?. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 7(1). Macur, D., & Macur, N. (2025). Designing effective leadership structures in international schools: Roles, strategies, and implementation. In L. L. Hammer, J. L. Hansen, & M. R. Barker (Eds.), Handbook of research on critical issues and global trends in international education (pp. 59–80). IGI Global. Moore, S. A., Sridhar, A., Taormina, I., Rajadhyaksha, M., & Azad, G. (2024). The perspective of school leaders on the implementation of evidence-based practices: A mixed methods study. Implementation Research and Practice, 5. Olson-Wyman, S. L. (2023). Embracing linguistic diversity or perpetuating prejudice? A study of international school teachers’ language ideologies [Doctoral dissertation, Wilkes University]. ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. Opdenakker, M.-C., & Van Damme, J. (2007). Do school context, student composition and school leadership affect school practice and outcomes in secondary education? British 69


Educational Research Journal, 33(2), 179–206. Prairie, A. (2020). Leadership for the implementation of standards-based grading in Asian expatriate high schools (Publication No. 27956424) [Doctoral dissertation, University of San Diego]. ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. Reinke, W. M., Stormont, M., Herman, K. C., Puri, R., & Goel, N. (2014). Using coaching to support teacher implementation of classroom-based interventions. Journal of Behavioral Education, 23(1), 150–167. Schmidt, R. J. (2025). Leadership readiness in K-12 international schools. In L. L. Hammer, J. L. Hansen, & M. R. Barker (Eds.), Handbook of research on critical issues and global trends in international education (pp. 213–252). IGI Global. Schultes, M.-T., Aijaz, M., Klug, J., & Fixsen, D. L. (2021). Competences for implementation science: What trainees need to learn and where they learn it. Advances in Health Sciences Education, 26(1), 19–35. Shapiro, V. B., Ziemer, K. L., Accomazzo, S., & Kim, B. K. E. (2019). Teachers’ assessment of “implementation leadership” during a new social emotional learning initiative. Contemporary School Psychology, 24(2), 174–180. Van Quaquebeke, N., Salem, M., van Dijke, M., & Wenzel, R. (2022). Conducting organizational survey and experimental research online: From convenient to ambitious in study designs, recruiting, and data quality. Organizational Psychology Review, 12(3), 268–305. Xia, Y., & Yang, Y. (2019). RMSEA, CFI, and TLI in structural equation modeling with ordered categorical data: The story they tell depends on the estimation methods. Behavior Research Methods, 51(1), 409–428.

70


71


Journal of Educational Research and Theory Vol. 3 Spring/Summer 2026 Published by The Bridge

Education Consultant to The Bridge Dr Karen L Taylor

The Bridge Wellington College Dukes Ride Crowthorne RG45 7PU Email: thebridge@wellingtoncollege.org.uk Web: thebridge.wellingtoncollege.org.uk Follow us on: LinkedIn Phone: +44 (0) 1344 444 238


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook