30 September 2020 | Volume 79 | Edition 11
Semenya: World Athletics are on “the wrong side of history” Olympic 800-metre champion, Caster Semenya, will be unable to defend her title in Tokyo next year unless she takes hormone suppressants.
Caitlin MacDonald
O
Source: The Telegraph
n Thursday, September 8, Switzerland’s came sixth in a WA semifinal which Semen- risks of bone health deterioration and cardiFederal Supreme Court upheld ya won, said “These kinds of people should ovascular complications. In a 2019 press rethe Court of Arbitration for Sports’ not run with us. For me, she is not a woman. lease, Semenya described the medication as (CAS) defense of World Athletics’ (WA) She is a man.” Since then, WA has instituted making her “feel constantly sick and unable hormone-regulated eligibility criteria, various regulations which limit the amount to focus for many years.” In responding to denying an appeal made by two-time of testosterone permitted in a competing the Supreme Court’s ruling, Semenya firmly Olympic gold medalist, Caster Semenya. female athlete’s body. rejected the prospect of altering her body, saying “I [...] refuse to let World Athletics WA’s criteria bars female athletes with above “These kinds of people should not run with drug me or stop me from being who I am.” average testosterone levels from competing us. For me, she is not a woman. She is a in specific events. For athletes with differenman.” “Semenya described the medication as ces in sexual development (DSD) this ruling making her ‘feel constantly sick and unable means that they are required to alter their WA has asserted that their regulations are to focus for many years.’ ” bodies or face exclusion from major spornecessary for the protection of “the rights ting events. Following the court’s ruling, of all female athletes to participate on fair Semenya accused the athletics governing and equal terms,” rejecting claims that the While Semenya may challenge the Swiss body of being on ”the wrong side of history.” requirement for medical intervention or ex- Federal Supreme Court’s ruling in the Euroclusion of athletes with DSD is an infringe- pean Court for Human Rights, this would “Semenya has been at the nucleus of debates ment upon their rights to dignity and bodily be costly and time-consuming. For the time being, rights groups such as the South Afrisurrounding hormone regulation in sport.” integrity. can Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) and the Commission for Gender Equality Semenya has been at the nucleus of debates “[E]xclusion of athletes with DSD is an (CGE) have declared that they will petition surrounding hormone regulation in sport. infringement upon their rights to dignity and the United Nations and African Union for bodily integrity.” Her highly successful arrival on the world intervention. They maintain that the WA’s stage in 2009 at the age of 18 was marked rules constitute “gross human rights violatiwith controversy, with various athletes and Sports Scientist, Dr Ross Tucker, refutes this ons.” Semenya has announced her intention commentators questioning her woman- claim, telling Cape Talk that the hormone to run the 200 meters in the 2021 Olympic hood and WA administering a sex verifica- suppressants DSD athletes are compelled Games in Tokyo, a division that is not covetion test. Italian runner, Elisa Cusma, who to take “are not innocuous drugs,” citing the red by hormone regulations.