2020
Year in Review RAILROAD COMMISSION OF TEXAS
ADAPTABLE, COLLABORATIVE, PROTECTIVE, EFFICIENT.
The Railroad Commission of Texas’
natural gas utilities and the number
COVID-19 pandemic, and we here at
duties and responsibilities are the
of abandoned well sites cleaned up
the Railroad Commission are no dif-
most diverse and widespread they’ve
with the use of state managed funds.
ferent. The RRC is 800 people strong,
been in the agency’s 130-year history.
The agency continued its efforts to
and their talents are being used on
Even so, the Commission, which
modernize IT systems, transforming
the right projects, at the right time
regulates the energy industry in
outdated processes into cutting-
regardless of where they work in the
the state, has remained unified and
edge platforms that allow business
Commission.
focused in our mission to protect the
operations to continue as usual
public, environment and economy of
despite the impact of the COVID-19
Texas. The COVID-19 pandemic made
pandemic.
the Railroad Commission continues
These accomplishments make us
and successfully meet our mission to
all safer and couldn’t have happened
protect the safety of communities and
without the close teamwork reflected
the environment throughout Texas. We
in our One Agency, One Team culture.
are proud we have kept our operations
Life as we knew it was put on pause
running as normal with essential staff
as people across the world have dealt
coming into offices around the state
with drastic changes in the face of the
and other employees teleworking.
2020 one of the most challenging years ever for the entire country, including the Commission. Yet even with the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Railroad Commission went above and beyond targets set by the Texas Legislature in protecting public safety and the environment.
to meet and exceed legislative goals
Our inspectors, engineers,
Thanks to staff’s unity and
geologists, accountants, attorneys,
commitment, the agency exceeded
computer scientists, programmers
target numbers for inspections of oil
and other trained professionals are
and gas wells, pipeline infrastructure,
deeply committed to serving our
alternative fuels facilities and coal
fellow Texans.
surface mining sites. RRC surpassed goals in the number of field audits of
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
As the 2020 Year in Review shows,
We are One Agency, One Team.
2
COMMISSIONER VIDEOS: Chairman Craddick ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������4 Commissioner Sitton ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������4 Commissioner Christian �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������4
ADAPTABLE RRC’s Information Technology Services Division Rises to Challenge ����������������������������������������������������������� 7 RRC Recommends Temporary Halt of Gas Disconnections �������������������������������������������������������������������������� 8 RRC Alternative Fuels Safety Training Moves Online ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 9 Industry Training ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������10 Pipeline Damage Prevention – Know What’s Below ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������10 Pipeline Safety ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������10 Alternative Fuels ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������10 Hearings Division ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������11 RRC Staff Training/Professional Development ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������11 Oil and Gas Division �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������12 RRC Communications ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������13
COLLABORATIVE RRC Sends Good News to City of Gorman �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������14 Brownfields Outreach ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������16 RRC Conducts Extensive Inspections of Major New Pipeline Project ��������������������������������������������������� 17 EPA Report Recognizes Railroad Commission’s Underground Injection Control Program ��������������������17 Railroad Commission Restores Somerset Abandoned Mine Site ���������������������������������������������������������������18 Fluid Injection Well Files Dating Back to 1960s Now Fully Digitized �����������������������������������������������������������20
PROTECTIVE Railroad Commission Balances Protections While Facilitating Development of Energy Resources ���22 RRC Orphan Well Program Beats Legislative Goal for Fourth Straight Year ���������������������������������������������23 RRC Oil and Gas Inspections Exceed Expectations for Fiscal Year 2020 ��������������������������������������������������24 Railroad Commission Adopts New Pipeline Safety Rules �����������������������������������������������������������������������������25
EFFICIENT Oil and Gas Monitoring and Enforcement Plan Finalized ������������������������������������������������������������������������������26 RRC Increases Transparency in Hearings Process ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������27 Railroad Commission Launches Drone Program to Enhance Emergency Response ����������������������������28 Office of General Counsel ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������30 O&G Administrative Compliance ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������30 O&G Technical Permitting ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������30 RRC Increases Transparency with Interactive Data Online ���������������������������������������������������������������������������31 Railroad Commission Further Enhances Its Efficiency ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������32
3
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
COMMISSIONER VIDEOS: CHAIRMAN CRADDICK
“
We’ve done more inspections, kept up with well plugging and our staff has done an amazing job, so that has kept us on track.
“
COMMISSIONER SITTON single person that I've dealt with “hereEvery is so committed to doing the job right and doing it well. “
COMMISSIONER CHRISTIAN
“
The Department of Energy is working with us very closely to make it a national pilot program in energy training.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
“
4
5
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
ADAPTABLE Our daily lives were put on hold in 2020 as the world dealt
to all staff and enabled Zoom, Microsoft Teams and Skype
with the COVID-19 pandemic. The Railroad Commission
for Business tools for Commission conferences, hearings,
was no different. However, we kept operations running by
and virtual meetings. The agency’s Operations Division
adapting to evolving conditions while remaining service
contracted with professional services for sanitizing and
oriented. Every aspect of how the Commission conducts
disinfecting Commission offices. Employees were able to
business was adapted quickly and efficiently to allow it
carry out their work safely—both at home and in RRC offic-
not only to meet but exceed goals and expectations.
es—without interruption.
Amidst the challenges of COVID-19, RRC was well prepared and rapidly ramped up technology and personal protective equipment for a smooth transition to telework. Information Technology Services deployed laptops or desktop remote access
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
6
RRC’S INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY SERVICES DIVISION RISES TO CHALLENGE The agency continued its efforts to modernize IT systems during FY 2020, transforming paper processes and
• Increased the number of employees with laptops
outdated systems to cutting-edge platforms with online
from
public access. New online portals and online forms
462 employees to 732;
• Increased GOTOMY PC licenses from
enabled the regulated communities and the general public
120 to
219 for employees with home computers;
to continue their business with the Commission as usual
• Provided guides and training for online resources,
despite the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.
including Skype for Business, Microsoft Teams and Zoom; and
During FY 2020, RRC upgraded internet speed for every district office. Availability for all
• In less than 2 months, researched, selected, and
Commission systems and networks have
prepared agency staff to use Zoom Enterprise
consistently been above 99 percent throughout
Videoconferencing for public meetings.
the year. RRC also achieved 100 percent compliance with the new cybersecurity statute (HB 3834, 86th Legislature) before the required
On April 14, 2020, the Commission held a virtual meet-
deadline. Our success in this area is a clear
ing to discuss proration. The meeting lasted more than
demonstration of the agency’s commitment
10 hours and included more than 50 speakers providing
and ability to continue its mission in trying
comment. The meeting was watched online by almost
times.
30,000 viewers, including people in 49 states and 86 countries.
In March when Gov. Greg Abbott issued his disaster declaration and executive
Virtual Commission Conference meetings followed
order in reaction to COVID-19, non-
according to schedule beginning April 21 and the Hear-
essential Railroad Commission staff
ings Division was transitioned to virtual hearings. This
began teleworking. RRC’s Information
could not have been accomplished without the swift
Technology Services Division was
and thorough work of RRC’s ITS Division.
challenged with ensuring all employees had capabilities to work remotely, and quickly implemented these solutions:
7
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
RRC RECOMMENDS TEMPORARY HALT OF GAS DISCONNECTIONS Shortly after the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, the
Recently, three of the large gas utilities in the state have
Railroad Commission recommended that gas utilities tem-
reinstated the disconnection process with Texas Gas
porarily suspend disconnecting residents facing financial
Service and CenterPoint reaching out to customers
constraints during the COVID-19 state of disaster.
with large past due amounts in September and Atmos in November.
Gas utilities began voluntarily suspending disconnections, and in a Notice to Operators, the RRC authorized utilities to
The notice that had been sent earlier to gas utilities can
create accounting mechanisms to track COVID-19-related
be found online here.
expenses, such as uncollected debt, employee personal protective equipment, occupational health costs, and cleaning supplies. RRC committed to working with utilities to help provide relief to residents facing hardships across Texas. If those utilities come to the RRC for rate change hearings in the future, the agency will thoroughly review the accounting of expenses accrued due to COVID-19 and determine whether they can recover those costs when rates are set.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
8
RRC ALTERNATIVE FUELS SAFETY TRAINING MOVES ONLINE Because of the impact of COVID-19, the Commission
The Commission launched an initiative to provide webinars
embarked on several online training sessions and explored
to ensure LPG dispenser operators would receive continu-
ways to provide more online training as part of the agency’s
ing education safety training.
future outreach to the oil and gas industry. Alternative Fuels
The online training provided an easy way for RRC to reach
Safety provides training and testing for propane (LPG) and
a large audience across the state at one time while saving
testing for compressed natural gas (CNG) and liquefied
individuals the time and money they would have spent trav-
natural gas (LNG).
eling to Austin for the training.
One example is the safety training required for individuals
The Alternative Fuels training center began virtual training
in the Liquified Petroleum Gas (LPG) industry. These indi-
on March 12. To date, almost 75 online webinars have
viduals perform services for a variety of activities including
been conducted with almost 900 students in attendance.
filling propane cylinders used for barbecue pits and deep
In October, AFS began offering certification examinations
fryers, as well as cylinders used for forklifts and industrial
online and the online classes were expanded to include
equipment. They also fill propane tanks used in vehicles as
initial courses of training.
an alternative to gasoline, and in recreational vehicles that use it to supply their appliances.
Beginning in June, the Railroad Commission resumed training classes and exams at the Alternative Fuels Training Center by appointment only. Some time-saving changes were implemented to LPG Form 16, and safety precautions were strictly followed, including limiting the number of individuals allowed in the training facility to 25 percent of normal capacity.
9
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
INDUSTRY TRAINING
PIPELINE SAFETY
While the annual regulatory conference was postponed due
Between March 15 and Aug. 31, the Pipeline Safety
to COVID-19, the Commission hosted the first online Oil and
Department conducted 3,032 evaluations, the majority
Gas Regulatory Webinar series (July 2020) covering a vari-
of which were done virtually. This compares to 2,523
ety of topics in 18 sessions with 1,080 total attendees and
during the same time frame in 2019. The remote hiring of
3,720 total views through Aug. 31. Archived webinar videos
six Pipeline Safety Inspectors after the COVID pandemic
and handout materials can be found online here.
began in March, resulted in an all-time high of 70 inspectors. Senior Pipeline Safety Inspectors continued to receive virtual training allowing them to grow and ensure
PIPELINE DAMAGE PREVENTION – KNOW WHAT’S BELOW
consistency of inspections statewide.
Since teleworking began, Pipeline Damage Prevention
ALTERNATIVE FUELS
Program (PDPP) staff attended 20 educational outreach
The Alternative Fuels department continued to conduct
events, all held virtually. PDPP also hosted the Big 4
inspections and nine of the 14 Alternative Fuels Inspec-
distribution operator meeting for the first time, also done
tors significantly exceeded their individual inspection goal
virtually. This quarterly meeting of the four largest gas
of 1,400.
service companies in Texas, Atmos Energy, CenterPoint Energy, Texas Gas Service and CPS Energy, features roundtable discussions related to their damage prevention programs and initiatives. Additionally, PDPP staff reduced
Additionally:
the damage prevention incident review time from 55 days to 8 days.
• Pipeline mileage fees collected increased from $3.1 million in FY2019 to $4.1 million in FY2020;
RRC’s Pipeline Safety T-4 Permitting group reduced the inoffice average number of days to review a T-4 permit by 38 percent, from 11.1 days down to 6.9 days. This group also
• PDPP conducted 55 outreach events including 28 virtual events, compared to a high of 40 events in previous years;
processed 5,929 permit actions, an increase of 15 percent from the previous fiscal year, and improved the processing time from 8.3 days to 7.6 days. The group also updated the RRC website to include A Guide to Shapefile Submissions.
• Outreach efforts resulted in a 70 percent decrease in mileage fee non-compliance rates and an all-time low for damage per thousand locates of 2.5 per thousand; and • Participated in five educational webinars that drew an audience of over 1,000 from all parts of the state and resulted in collection of fees totaling $5.9 million, including T-4 renewal and mileage fee, an increase from the $4.48 million collected during the previous fiscal year.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
10
HEARINGS DIVISION
2,091 1,594 150
RRC’s Hearings Division processed 2,091 total new cases in FY 20, an increase over the previous three years. The total number of dockets closed was 1,594. Of those closed, 1,531 were Oil and Gas dockets which equates to just over 150 per examiner. Working with ITS, Hearings established a virtual Zoom hearing process for all hearing types, including complex protested dockets for Oil and Gas, Surface Mining and Gas Utility dockets.
Total New Cases Total Dockets Closed Dockets Per Examiner
RRC STAFF TRAINING/PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT The Commission had one of the lowest turn-over and vacancy rates in recent history. During fiscal year 2020, the Commission filled 221 job vacancies, hired 139 new employees, and maintained the headcount of 850 at the end of the fiscal year. Additionally, the Biennial Employee Survey showed significant increase in employee morale, satisfaction and engagement.
From March through August 2020:
71.8%
• More than 600 of the Commission’s 850+ employees (71.8 percent) participated in remote or online training, maintaining the pre-Covid-19 training attendance rate of approximately 73 percent;
• Deployed the Texas CAPPS Enterprise Learning Management System (LMS) module over the summer to maintain and manage training schedules and records, while streamlining training coordination efforts; and
• By the end of calendar year 2020, seven RRC employees in the GROW program received Executive Leadership Certifications from the Texas Executive Education program at the University of Texas McCombs School of Business.
11
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
OIL AND GAS DIVISION Prior to COVID-19, the Oil and Gas Division hosted a
RRC’s chief geologist represented the Commission on
variety of in-person educational training opportunities.
the Texas Radiation Advisory Board and the Coastal Ad-
In March, the focus shifted to virtual learning. The need
visory Board; reviewed and prepared comments on U.S.
for educational offerings was not diminished and only
EPA proposed regulations, and participating in numer-
the format changed. Over the course of the year, the Oil
ous national oil and gas endeavors including the EPA’s
and Gas Division:
National Policy for Oversight of Permitting effort and the National Petroleum Council’s Carbon Capture, Utilization,
• Conducted eight One Agency, One Team workshops;
and Storage study report.
• Hosted four regional conferences for industry in Corpus Christi, Houston, and Fort Worth with a virtual webinar taking place for the Midland conference; • Conducted six Boots on the Ground sessions providing staff training to 82 participating oil and gas inspectors.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
12
RRC COMMUNICATIONS The Communications Division took charge of ensuring
Communications staff participated in 18 public
all RRC stakeholders – including industry, legislators, the
conferences and stakeholder events and coordinated
general public, and RRC employees – were kept apprised
another 28 public appearances by Commission staff, prior
of important information in a clear and timely manner.
to the pandemic shutdown. When operations went virtual,
A COVID-19 website page was created, collating all RRC
Communications staff provided support for Oil and Gas
actions to assist operators in response to the pandemic.
and Pipeline Safety educational webinars for industry
Internally, a COVID-19 resource page was targeted to
operators. Throughout the year, Communications staff
RRC staff providing them with resources for effective
published monthly newsletters sharing agency news,
teleworking and well-being.
initiatives, and events.
Communications also conducted extensive design, development, and data migration for an enhanced RRC website to be launched in FY 2021. Numerous instructional videos were created, and Communications staff responded to more than 2,000 stakeholder inquiries averaging approximately eight inquiries every workday.
13
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
COLLABORATIVE One of the Railroad Commission’s core values is collaboration. By working across divisions and departments within the agency, the Commission improves efficiency and not only meets but exceeds expectations. Collaborative efforts extend beyond the walls of the agency as we work with other governmental agencies, industry, community groups and more to protect the public and our natural resources.
RRC SENDS GOOD NEWS TO CITY OF GORMAN The Railroad Commission worked with city leaders
risks associated with consumption of fish at the lake is
in Gorman to revitalize the once popular Bass Lake.
within protective concentration thresholds.
Located in Frank Gray Memorial Park in Eastland County,
The project in Gorman is another example of how RRC
the lake was the site of a crude oil spill in 1990. Cleanup
strives to help communities across Texas safeguard the
occurred immediately following the incident. In 2018,
environment, and today, the lake can be enjoyed by all
the city entered the Railroad Commission’s Brownfields
Texans for recreational purposes.
Response Program to assess the lake for any potential lingering hazards related to the oil spill.
The RRC receives grant funding from the EPA for the Brownfields program, which allows the Commission to
RRC staff worked with an environmental engineering firm
conduct free environmental assessments and cleanups,
to conduct a site assessment and analyze samples of
if necessary, at abandoned oil and gas sites. Local gov-
surface water and sediments from the lake, soils along
ernments and non-profits can apply for the program. More
the bank and groundwater from an onsite water well.
information on the BRP and other environmental cleanup
Test results for compounds related to the oil spill were
programs can be found in the Environmental Cleanup
all within protective concentration levels, and RRC issued
category of the Oil & Gas section on our website.
a Certificate of Completion to the city, noting that any
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
14
15
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
BROWNFIELDS OUTREACH Oil and Gas Brownfield Program and Pipeline Damage Prevention Department participated in approximately 40 public outreach events. As a result, more candidate sites are identified for remediation using Brownfield grant funds.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
16
RRC CONDUCTS EXTENSIVE INSPECTIONS OF MAJOR NEW PIPELINE PROJECT
COMMISSION’S UNDERGROUND INJECTION CONTROL PROGRAM
RRC inspectors conducted critical inspections of the
The Railroad Commission continues to make positive
Permian Highway Pipeline (PHP), one of the largest
strides with its Underground Injection Control program,
pipeline projects under construction in Texas in 2020.
ensuring the protection of underground sources of drinking
Stretching more than 400 miles from the Permian Basin to
water and the control of seismic activity, according to a
the Houston area, the pipeline will bring West Texas’ natural
recent report from the EPA.
gas to the world market. Given the sheer scale of the PHP and its route through the
The report titled,
sensitive Texas Hill Country, RRC engaged in a comprehen-
2019 EPA Region 6
sive response to ensure that the pipeline is constructed in
End-Of-Year Evaluation
a manner protective of public health and the environment.
Railroad Commission of
Oil and Gas and Pipeline Safety inspectors conducted over
Texas Underground In-
150 inspections, investigated 16 formal complaints and
jection Control Program,
witnessed activities related to construction of the pipeline
can be found on RRC’s
in calendar year 2020.
website
RRC staff in Government Relations, Office of General Coun-
RRC’s UIC program pro-
sel, and Communications worked closely with area resident
tects the state’s drinking
groups and the pipeline company, as well as city, county
water and controls seismic
and state officials to provide information throughout the
activity through enforce-
construction process. Other entities, including the Texas
ment of EPA-approved rules
Commission on Environmental Quality and Army Corps of
on permitting, construction, and testing of underground
Engineers, also played a role in oversight of the pipeline’s
injection wells. Injection wells are used to process waste
construction.
fluid from oil and gas operations, especially water with high levels of brine; for brine mining; for enhanced recovery,
New pipelines are important to efficiently and safely
which prolongs the life of oil and gas fields; and hydrocar-
transport large amounts of natural gas and oil. Pipelines
bon storage. Wells are located in underground formations
also help reduce flaring by alleviating potential backing
geologically separate from aquifers that are sources of
up of supply at the point of production. RRC inspectors
drinking water.
at construction sites ensure the operator is compliant with agency rules to prevent the pollution of surface and
The EPA’s report acknowledges the efforts of Railroad
groundwater resources.
Commission staff to responsibly manage injection wells to protect our natural resources and mitigate any seismic
EPA REPORT RECOGNIZES RAILROAD
activity because of them. RRC will continue to work with our federal counterparts to build on and improve our work to help protect Texans.
17
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
RAILROAD COMMISSION RESTORES SOMERSET ABANDONED MINE SITE Shallow coal mines are often associated with the English
AML’s latest project in the Somerset area was completed
countryside in the 18th to early 20th centuries. But Texas,
in August 2020 at a cost of almost $300,000. It involved
too, has its fair share of those types of mines, such as ones
a four-acre area where the historic Kirkwood and Kinney
around the Somerset community south of San Antonio. Ini-
lignite mines had been in operation.
tially dug in the latter half of the 19th century, these mines
Contractors collapsed tunnels, filled the holes, graded
have been causing problems more than a century after they closed.
the property, and then hydromulched the site with native
Thanks to the Railroad Commission’s federally funded
surface and others sinking. The perimeters of such sink-
Abandoned Mine Land Program (AML), hazards such as
holes are unstable, and the mined-out rooms are prone to
these are being methodically addressed.
collapse, especially during periods of high rainfall. It took
species. Some of the shallow tunnels were exposed to the
about two months to complete the project.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
18
The Somerset project involved a stormwater permit from the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality to ensure no runoff from the site. An environmental survey was done on the property, including a bird survey, to ensure no endangered species were threatened. A biologist was on site during the work in case any species needed to be relocated. RRC’s AML program deals with mines that were abandoned before laws that regulated such structures began appearing in the 1970s. The AML program receives federal funds
More information on RRC’s AML program can be found in
thanks to the Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act,
the Surface Mining section of RRC’s website.
which was passed by Congress in 1977.
19
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
FLUID INJECTION WELL FILES DATING BACK TO 1960S NOW FULLY DIGITIZED When a governmental body is as old as the Railroad
Paper takes up a lot of space, and because of its physical
Commission, a lot of paperwork can accumulate –
needs, it is not the most accessible of filing systems. But
especially with technical documents.
as technology became more powerful and affordable, it began to make a lot of sense to digitize such massive records, which the Railroad Commission has been doing.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
20
In August 2020, the Commission completed digitization of Underground Injection Control well files, which date as far back as the 1960s. The estimated 8,500 files, which include permitted fluid injection files, oil and gas records, and docket files, can now be accessed through the Injection/ Disposal Permit Query. Digitizing the UIC records helps the Railroad Commission to be more effective at protecting public safety and the environment. The information is plotted on a map showing the location of all injection wells, allowing RRC inspectors to have a more complete picture of potential sources of pollution that may need to be examined closely. There are other benefits as well. Applicants for new injection well permits are required to identify other wells within a certain radius, and the digital record makes the process easier to complete. It helps RRC permitting staff with their technical reviews of applications and ensures all needed information is accessible to them. It also allows RRC to be more responsive to open records requests by putting UIC information at a person’s fingertips with an internet connection, saving time for them and staff. It took about eight years to complete and was a collaboration between the agency’s RRC’s UIC section, Central Records, and Information Technology Services, and was funded in part by the EPA.
21
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
PROTECTIVE Protection of public safety and the environment is the Railroad Commission’s highest priority. Field inspections, well plugging activities, enforcement actions and more resulted it the Commission not only meeting but exceeding goals set by the Texas Legislature. The Commission remains committed to ensuring Texas’ energy resources are used in a way that is beneficial and safe for all Texans.
RAILROAD COMMISSION BALANCES PROTECTIONS WHILE FACILITATING DEVELOPMENT OF ENERGY RESOURCES The Texas economy is dependent on its oil and gas
and an integrated online system connecting the work
industry, but so are we in our everyday lives.
of technical specialists and agency field staff.
It is the Railroad Commission’s job to ensure we safely
As the Railroad Commission takes these important
benefit from these valuable resources. In its role regulating
steps, there have been some recent positive trends.
the state’s energy production and ensuring its natural
While the amount of natural gas produced from oil
resources are extracted responsibly, the agency has
and gas wells dropped by 13 percent from June 2019
been taking advantage of operational and technological
to May 2020, the rate of produced gas that was flared
efficiencies to achieve its goals.
went down by an even greater 79 percent over the 12-month period. More importantly, the flaring rate
In 2020, RRC commissioners took actions to further
of casinghead gas, which is the gas produced from
address flaring with revisions to the Application
oil wells, decreased by 85 percent, and the ratio of
for Exception to Statewide Rule 32. The agency’s
casinghead gas flared to the amount of crude oil pro-
commissioners approved a revamped Form R-32,
duced decreased by 82 percent.
Application for Exception to Statewide Rule 32, which had previously been titled Statewide Rule 32 Exception Data
The sharp decline in the flaring rate suggests that
Sheet and will be used by oil and gas operators to apply for
decreased flare volume was caused by more than
an exception to flare gas during oil and gas operations. The
simply a decrease in production. RRC will continue
form provides specific guidance on when an exception to
analyze the monthly data. That information, along with
flare would be permissible, under which circumstances, and
the modifications to the Statewide Rule 32 application
for how long. The Commission has created better reporting
will help us continue a comprehensive approach to
requirements to record for how much each flare releases
regulating flaring.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
22
Commission Plugs Abandoned Oil and Gas Wells Using Industry Fees In Fiscal Year 2017, the goal was to plug 875 wells, and the agency plugged 917 wells. In Fiscal Years 2018 and 2019 the performance goal was to plug 979 abandoned wells each year, and the agency plugged 1,364 and 1,710 respectively. The agency plugged 1,477 orphan wells in Fiscal Year 2020, which exceeded the target of 1,400 set by the Legislature.
RRC ORPHAN WELL PROGRAM BEATS LEGISLATIVE GOAL FOR FOURTH STRAIGHT YEAR The Railroad Commission’s abandoned oil and gas well
The work done in the most recent fiscal year continues a
plugging program has exceeded its performance goal for
positive trend in the RRC’s work in exceeding performance
the fourth year running.
targets.
With the fiscal year ending on Aug. 31, the agency plugged
To improve the State Managed Plugging Program, RRC
1,477 orphan wells in Fiscal Year 2020, which exceeded the
streamlined internal processes, which, along with improved
target of 1,400 set by the Legislature.
employee retention, has contributed to the success of the program despite limitations brought on by the COVID-19
The State Managed Plugging Program is an important
pandemic.
part of RRC’s critical mission to protect public safety and the environment. Given the energy industry downturn, the
See what the State Managed Program is doing in your neck
program also helps to employ oilfield service company
of the woods with RRC’s interactive data visualization map.
workers throughout Texas. These employees are contracted and supervised to plug abandoned orphan wells
More information about the State Managed Plugging Pro-
by the Railroad Commission.
gram can be found via this link.
The State Managed Plugging Program is paid through industry fees rather than by taxpayers. This program addresses wells that are no longer productive and are considered orphaned in accordance with state laws and regulations. Railroad Commission staff prioritizes which orphan wells to plug based on potential risks to public safety and the environment.
23
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
RRC OIL AND GAS INSPECTIONS EXCEED EXPECTATIONS FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020 In April, Oil and gas inspectors at the Railroad Commission
347,000 inspections
of Texas surpassed annual inspection targets, even with more than four months remaining in the fiscal year.
2,107 avg. per Inspector
The Texas Legislature sets performance measures tied to agency budgeting for each state fiscal year. For Fiscal Year
Inspected 33% of well population
2020 the target for oil and gas well and facility inspections was 189,367. Ultimately, 347,617 inspections were conducted, an amount equal to 33.4 percent of the total well
1% of wells not inspected
1,540 Oil & Gas violations
population. Inspections include responding to incidents and com-
258 abandoned wells
plaints; conducting routine well inspections; and witnessing critical well operations, including setting surface casing to
602 severance/seal orders
protect groundwater, mechanical integrity tests and well pluggings.
Plugged 1,477 orphan wells
More than 317,000 oil and gas well and facility inspections (more than 91 percent of the total inspections performed) found no violations. Each RRC inspector averaged 2,107 inspections during fiscal year 2020.
The Field Operations section of the Oil and Gas Division:
Only one percent of wells across the state have not been inspected in the last five years, exceeding the five percent legislative performance measure.
• performed more than 347,000 inspections exceeding the performance measure goal of 189,367;
The Commission has an online tool, RRC OIL, that allows
• averaged 2,107 inspections per inspector, 895 more than that goal of 1,199;
the public and oil and gas operators to lookup inspection
• reduced the percent of wells not inspected in last five years down to 1 percent, exceeding the goal of 5 percent;
and violation data recorded during inspections of oil and gas leases, wells, facilities and other sites.
• inspected 33.4 percent of the total well population, surpassing the goal of 22.5 percent; • referred 1,540 oil and gas rule violations for legal enforcement, exceeding the goal of 1,300; • investigated, assessed or cleaned up 258 abandoned sites, exceeding the goal of 230 by 12 percent, and averaging 104 days to complete cleanup; • initiated 602 severance/seal orders, surpassing the goal of 425; and
LAUNCH RRC OIL
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
• plugged 1,477 orphan wells, exceeding the target of 1,400 set by the Legislature. Wells were plugged in an average of 46.75 days with an aggregate depth of 3,216,698 feet.
24
RAILROAD COMMISSION ADOPTS NEW PIPELINE SAFETY RULES In February 2020, pipeline safety rules were adopted by the Railroad Commission prohibiting natural gas distribution pipeline operators from installing underground cast iron, wrought iron or bare steel pipelines. Other new pipeline safety requirements require operators to report and remediate accidents on gathering lines.
Local distribution gas pipeline operators transport natural gas to households and businesses through thousands of miles of small-diameter distribution pipes. RRC’s new pipeline rules also require these natural gas distribution pipeline operators to replace any known existing cast iron pipelines by Dec. 31, 2021.
The Commission adopted these amendments weeks before a statutory deadline for House Bills 864 and 866 passed by the 86th Legislature in 2019.
RRC’s Chapter 8 Pipeline Safety rules can be found here.
RRC’s Pipeline Safety Department exceeded all inspection goals set by the Texas Legislature: • 3,561 standard inspections completed (target 3,013)
3,561 standard inspections
• 2,014 accident and specialized inspections completed (target 1,100)
2,014 accident and specialized inspections
Additionally, Pipeline Safety: • Ended the fiscal year with 70 inspectors, a new record high;
70 Inspectors
• Also ended the year with 63 inspectors qualified to perform standard comprehensive inspections, the highest level ever compared to approximately 50 in previous years; and
63 standard comprehensive Inspectors
• Completed business and testing phases of the RRC PIPES system.
completed business and testing phases
Surface Mining & Reclamation Division: • completed 417 inspections exceeding the legislative performance goal for the first time in five years;
417 inspections
• received 188 permit actions and completed 254 between March 1 and Aug. 31; and
254 permit actions Mar-Aug 31
• despite the COVID-19 pandemic processed mail, financial instruments, and public and staff records requests, ensuring productivity, and efficiency within the division.
25
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
EFFICIENT Over the past year, the Railroad Commission improved efficiencies, increased transparency, streamlined processes and reduced the administrative burden on industry. Automated datasets made information used frequently by the public easily accessible, and interactive data is now available online in an easy to understand format. All this was accomplished while remaining fully committed to RRC’s mission and responsibility to Texas.
OIL AND GAS MONITORING AND ENFORCEMENT PLAN FINALIZED In June, the Railroad Commission released its latest strategic priorities in regulating the state’s oil and gas industry. The RRC’s FY 2021 priorities are outlined in the Oil and Gas Monitoring and Enforcement Plan. Texas’ oil and gas industry is vital to the state’s budget and economy and contributes toward the country’s security by helping it be energy independent. By ensuring the industry operates in a manner that protects public health and the environment, the Railroad Commission helps protect this critical resource that all Americans rely upon. The annual planning document outlines how the agency will continue to build upon its current success to ensure all wells in the state are inspected at least once every five years and documents ongoing enhancements to agency operations.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
26
RRC INCREASES TRANSPARENCY IN HEARINGS PROCESS New Online Portal Benefits the Public and Energy Industry
RRC CASES has also helped the agency’s Hearings
In 2020, the Railroad Commission of Texas launched the Case
Division adapt to the current COVID-19 pandemic
Administration Service Electronic System (RRC CASES) public
because it allows administrative law judges and
portal. Since that time, improvements have been made with
technical examiners to access dockets in CASES
more data accessible online.
without having to retrieve a hard copy file.
The CASES portal processes all Railroad Commission
CASES not only make RRC’s hearings documents
hearings and enforcement case types. The system now
available for anyone to view, but it also makes it easier
includes dockets from the agency’s Oil and Gas Division,
for operators to submit case files electronically. As
Oversight and Safety Division, and the Surface Mining and
public servants, RRC strives to serve the public better,
Reclamation Division. When the first phase of the RRC CASES
and CASES is a digital tool that helps the agency
portal launched in March, it processed a smaller number of
accomplish that goal.
case types originating from the Oil and Gas Division.
Parties to a case or their representatives can save time
With more documents now readily accessible to the public
and money by filing electronically through CASES. Legal
than ever before, the Railroad Commission has been able
Enforcement dockets can also be viewed by the public
to further expand the transparency of its functions, decrease
and authenticated users can also upload or download
reliance on paper records, and streamline agency processes
files to the docket. Also, the updated CASES system
such as open records requests. Once documents are
now allows entities to pay administrative penalties
approved for digital filing, they are available for the public
via the portal.
to view.
For more information, visit the RRC CASES page.
27
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
RAILROAD COMMISSION LAUNCHES DRONE PROGRAM TO ENHANCE EMERGENCY RESPONSE
Taking advantage of 21st century technology, the Railroad
gression of mining in active operations which can change
Commission launched a statewide drone inspection team.
drastically from month to month. Aerial images will also
Drones help inspectors to quickly respond and inspect
help in the oversight of reclamation activities in previously
sites that are unsafe or inaccessible during emergencies
mined areas.
such as fires, flooding and other natural disasters. Drones
With drones, RRC inspectors can now immediately monitor
can also assist in situations, such as the current COVID-19
well blowouts, oil spills, and other emergency incidents, and
pandemic, where they provide an alternative to in-person
quickly cover large areas of ground in responding to those
inspections.
situations where time is of the essence.
Nineteen inspectors in the agency’s Oil and Gas Division
RRC’s drone team flew 32 missions in FY 2020. These mis-
and Surface Mining and Reclamation Division received
sions enhanced the agency’s operation efficiency in emer-
remote pilot certification from the Federal Aviation Administration.
gency response and routine inspections.
The RRC’s first drone emergency response was April 28
RRC’s drone program operates in compliance with federal regulations and state laws established to ensure safety and
following reports of an incident in Reeves County west of
the protection of individual and property owners’ privacy.
Midland. The affected area could not be physically inspected because the road to the site was under water. A licensed
RRC is also a member of the State Emergency Operations
RRC pilot launched a drone and determined a possible
Center. The agency’s drone fleet can be a critical resource
source of release using aerial and thermal images. The
in helping state emergency response by providing aerial
operator was contacted to immediately remediate
views of inaccessible areas.
the site.
A list of frequently asked questions (FAQ) and answers is
During the summer, SMRD used drones for emergency
also on the RRC’s Drone Program page
responses and inspections. Drones can document the pro-
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
28
29
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
LEGISLATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
OFFICE OF GENERAL COUNSEL
The 86th Legislature (2019) passed several bills affecting
RRC’s Office of General Counsel (OCG) also stayed busy
agency operations. Immediately following the legislative
with a wide variety of legal issues and responsibilities. OGC
session, and after the bills were signed by Governor Greg
initiated the Warrant Hold program resulting in more than
Abbott, the agency used a project management approach
$800,000 in additional penalty payments with another $2
to ensure timely compliance with the new laws. Some of
million committed to payment plans. OGC transitioned 100
the key efforts by the agency include:
percent of all new dockets to RRC CASES and developed reports to track metrics. The Damage Prevention backlog was reduced by more than 1,000 dockets, and a new investigator position was established to coordinate with industry
• Implemented programming and procedural changes for processing applications for severance tax exemptions for two-year inactive wells and notified operators of the eligibility to apply for a severance tax exemption (SB 533);
and law enforcement. OGC also procured game cameras for each district office to monitor sites and prevent theft of assets belonging to the Commission. They processed 1,564 open records requests in fiscal year 2020, an increase over the previous two fiscal
• Approved rules implementing new pipeline safety requirements relating to the replacement of certain pipe types and operator notification to the Commission regarding certain pipeline incidents (HB 864 and HB 866);
years. Another important aspect of their work is the regularly scheduled Commissioner Conference meetings both before and after the pandemic began. OCG provided support for
• Updated Memorandum of Understanding between RRC and the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality relating to the permitting of discharges of produced water, hydrostatic test water, and gas plant effluent (HB 2771);
Commissioner Conferences and supported the transition to
• Adopted rules streamlining the processes for liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) licensure (HB 2714); and
The Commission’s Well Compliance department completed
the Zoom online format.
O&G ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLIANCE a pilot project to scan P-5 Organization Report Forms to Neubus. The P-5 forms for the 2019 renewal year are now available online. Completion packets, specifically
• Achieved full compliance with requirement that agency staff complete cybersecurity training (HB 3834).
Form G-1 and W-2, saw a reduction in review time from over 40 days at the beginning of the fiscal year to a review time of five days by the year’s end. Drilling permits successfully transitioned to a remote work environment while maintaining legislatively mandated processing times. System enhancements to the Online Drilling Permit reduced the number of manual reviews by nearly 80 percent. GIS Mapping launched a project to scan and enhance historic well location maps for research purposes and to preserve historic maps.
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
30
O&G TECHNICAL PERMITTING Technical Permitting transferred a high-cost gas program
In March, the Commission added more data to its Public
to the Groundwater Advisory Unit. This included a backlog
Geographic Information System (GIS) Map Viewer allowing
of more than 2,100 ST-1 applications, many of which were
the public to view information on Voluntary Cleanup Pro-
more than a year old at time of transfer. The results speak
gram (VCP) and Brownfield Response Program (BRP) sites
for themselves.
around Texas. The two programs are designed to incentivize the remediation and redevelopment of abandoned oil
GAU staff reduced the backlog entirely, and today, GAU
and gas sites.
staff typically process complete ST-1 applications within The VCP and BRP data on the interactive map includes
2–3 weeks.
information such as project size, project status, and CertifThe Engineering Unit reduced completions backlog from
icate of Completion for closed sites. Communities, engi-
more than 4,000 in February to less than 600 by the end of
neers and banks can find the information very useful if they
August. The average age of completion packets decreased
are planning any redevelopment initiatives near these sites.
from 61 days to 32 days. More layers were also added to the existing EnvironmenEnvironmental Permits eliminated the backlog of legacy
tal Permits information on the GIS Viewer. The new in-
permit applications. Today, 94 percent of environmental
formation shows Commercial Waste Disposal Sites and
permit applications are processed within established time
Discharge Permits, allowing anyone to view information
frames, exceeding the goal of 90 percent.
including the operator name, permit numbers and the types of wastes received and processed at the facility. Oil and gas operators and waste haulers can use the information
RRC INCREASES TRANSPARENCY WITH INTERACTIVE DATA ONLINE
to locate the most convenient authorized disposal facilities. Data from RRC’s Site Remediation and Abandoned Mine
In 2020, the Railroad Commission made great strides in
Land (AML) programs were added to the website in July.
laying out large amounts of data in an easy-to-understand
Each data visualization project includes bar graphs, an
format. A series of interactive data projects launched
interactive Texas map, a list of counties, and other options
throughout the year help the public and energy industry
to fine tune a search. The AML program works to reclaim
operators easily see key aspects of the important work we
and restore land and water resources as the result of aban-
do in protecting the safety of Texans and the environment.
doned mines.
Interactive data maps showing oil and gas drilling permit
Visit the Data Visualization page
approvals and the number of wells spudded (when operators begin drilling a well) were among the first to be released in January. Information is displayed by counts, operators, county locations and on a statewide level. As one of the first steps of the well completion process, the number of wells spudded in a month may provide a snapshot of drilling in a particular area. RRC’s Well Compliance Department uses this data to monitor and regulate well completion activity on a monthly basis.
31
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
RAILROAD COMMISSION FURTHER ENHANCES ITS EFFICIENCY 2020 saw the continuation of the Railroad Commission’s
ground water quality in Texas. On average more than a
Oilfield Relief Initiative The initiative is intended to improve
thousand of these forms are mailed to the agency each
efficiencies for the agency and reduce the regulatory
month. The new online filing option for Form H-15 saves
administrative burden on industry, while ensuring the RRC
time for staff and industry.
continues to protect the public and environment.
Operators are required to conduct tests on wells older than
Oil and gas operators may now file Form W-3, Plugging
25 years in each year that a well is inactive. The test results
Record, online. Operators are required to file the Form W-3,
are submitted in H-15 forms to ensure an inactive well does
Plugging Record, with the RRC 30 days after plugging a
not pose a pollution threat to ground water.
well. When filing the Form W-3 online, an operator can also
Operators have been asking for an easier filing option
submit attachments, including cementing reports (Form W-15) and electric log status reports (Form L-1).
for these important forms and the Railroad Commission
When the Form W-3 is submitted online using the RRC
long-term goal to make the agency’s operations efficient
Online System, the system will generate a print-friendly
and reduce administrative burdens for both the agency
PDF. All reports will be available to view in the RRC Online
and the operators. Online filing is also beneficial in unique
System after being reviewed by the RRC.
situations such as the current COVID-19 pandemic in which
delivered. These online filings represent another step in our
we try to minimize in-person contact to maintain the safety
Online filing of Form W-3 began in April 2020. Two months
of staff and the public.
later, the Railroad Commission made yet another form available for online filing. Oil and gas operators can now
For more information on filing the Form W-3 online,
go online to easily file Form H-15, Test on an Inactive Well
operators can view an instructional video on
More than 25 Years Old. This test is vital to protecting
the RRC’s YouTube channel
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
32
RRC’S FREE DATASETS DRAWS MORE THAN 33 MILLION DOWNLOADS IN FY 2020 Last year, RRC automated the creation of various datasets
Before automation, it could take days after the agency
of information frequently requested by the public that
received an open records request to create the customized
involve programmers from Information Technology Ser-
set of data and deliver it via a CD-ROM or through a File
vices having to write computer code to pull and customize
Transfer Protocol or FTP site. Instead of processing these
electronically stored data.
sorts of requests, the ITS technician dedicated to this task now spends time providing customer service.
The datasets—more than 50, in fact—are now automatically made available through a webpage aptly titled, Data Sets
Visit the Data Sets Available for Download page.
Available for Download. The page is broken down in the following categories: Boundary Ventures, Notices of Hearing, Digital Map Data, Drilling Permit Data, Oil and Gas
The Executive Office began a project in FY 2020 to provide the public with data visualization experience on RRC’s website. Eight interactive maps were released in 2020. Since release, the interactive maps garnered nearly 8,000 unique page views for oil and gas production data and nearly 1,400 unique page views for the abandoned well plugging data.
Field Data, Production Data, Oil and Gas Regulatory Data, Oil and Gas Well Data, Severance Tax Incentive Data, and Underground Injection Control Data. Making the data available for download triggered a wider use of our data. The information, which is available around the clock at no charge, has been so popular with the public that in Fiscal Year 2020 the agency recorded about 33.37 million downloads of the datasets. In August, the agency averaged nearly 152,000 daily downloads totaling a collective 304 gigabytes of data per day.
RRC’s Central Records Department completed preparing 1.7 million documents, identifying nearly 1.2 million documents to be imaged— some that are nearly 100 years old, detailing the East Texas oilfield records since 1924. Since the Commission began digitizing agency records, close to 25.5 million documents were imaged from paper. Between original and digitized records, more than 51 million images totaling approximately 62 terabytes of data were uploaded for online access.
Before the website with the datasets, the agency usually received fewer than 7,000 such requests annually, mostly from businesses that would reimburse RRC for staff time and programming costs. Now the information is being used by groups that would normally not have the means to pay for its creation, such as college students, especially geographical information systems students looking for shapefiles. The datasets also benefit journalists, who use the information to either provide more detailed analytical business reporting or to hold the agency and its regulated industry more accountable, which serves the public interest.
33
2020 RAILROAD COMMISSION YEAR IN REVIEW
www.rrc.texas.gov © 2020 Railroad Commission of Texas