June 2022 Tulsa Lawyer Magazine

Community, Diversity & More

A Message from the President

Kara Vincent 2021-2022 TCBA President

Pg. 2

TULSA LAWYER

In this Issue

June 2022

2

Let’s All Stop Talking About It And Do Something Kara Vincent

6

Tourney Review

9

VP's Corner - Happy Juneteenth!

Mike Esmond

10

Tulsa County Students Awarded Member Event - Take me out to the ballpark!

Friday, July 1st

ELECTION RESULTS Pg. 8 2022 Judicial Survey – June Primary Races

By Michael P. Taubman

Pg. 21

11

YLD Meeting Notice - Tuesday, June 8th

12

TCBA Community Spirit

14

TCBA Lawyers Fighting Hunger Hugh Robert

16

Ask-a-Lawyer....WOW!

17

Member Event - Main Event Saturday, June 11th

18

Law Day Lunch Review

19

Summer To-Do List

20

Member Event - Member Appreciation Day Wednesday, June 22nd

30

Diversity, Equity and Inclusion - 2021 Survey Results Brown Bag CLE - Wed. June 15th

32

Member Benefit - Pilates Yoga Fusion is Back!

33

Street Law’s Final Meeting

34

Grapevine

35

Classified Ads

36

Committees, Sections, Contact Us

In North America, the first day of summer is Tuesday, June 21st.

The longest day of the year!

A Message from the President

Kara Vincent Let’s All Stop Talking About It And Do Something

Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey (1992) regarding the rights of individuals to have access to abortion. This month I’m taking some time to discuss a topic that affects our whole society. I know it may be polarizing and my while my goal is not to turn the TCBA in to a political tool, as attorneys we see people in society who are directly affected by our laws and we cannot ignore their effect. We may not be able to agree on abortion, but we can all agree that people in our community need help.

In the first version of this article, I considered a curter approach, with the title of “Shut Up And Do Something About It.” It encapsulated my thoughts in the moment and my frustrations, but, as one colleague who was reviewing the article said, “They won’t be able to hear the message you’re trying to convey.”

She was right. It was aggressive, and I think it lacked the objectivity necessary when we counsel parties to consider solutions. Even with the revisions I’ve made, you may still not be able to hear the message. This topic tends to drive each of us into our own subjective viewpoint, which is one of the problems in finding a common solution. I know that it is for me.

This article completely consists of my story and opinions, and I am well aware that this topic is inflammatory. Even though this article contains my story and opinions, the TCBA and TCBF are focused on helping their members and the larger community. So, to the extent that you feel called to take some kind of action for your community, the TCBA and TCBF stand ready to help you. Also, for those of you who actually read these articles, I’d ask you to bear with me on this This topic hits close to home because it’s deeply one. I believe the issue is important. personal, and each story or situation is different. Therein lies the rub. How do we as a nation, or even as a State, As I’ve said in previous articles, the drafting legislate something for which there is no standard set of of this TCBA President’s address occurs a full month facts and circumstances? I do not claim to have THE before you see the finished product. I wrote this article answer, and I frankly don’t know that anyone does. In in May around the time of Mother’s Day, around the the end, barring nefarious intent, we’re all doing the best same time that a draft Supreme Court opinion in that we can.

Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, about pre-viability prohibitions on elective abortions, has To provide some context to my article, I’ll tell been leaked indicating that the Court will overturn its you that I’m a mother of seven, and, for those of you previous decisions in Roe v. Wade (1973) and Planned who know me well, you’re probably wondering where 2 Tulsa Lawyer

I acquired the extra children. I have two biological children, two step-children, one child who chose to marry into my family (my son totally over-married), and two children who were lost to miscarriage. These are all my children regardless of origin or outcome. I sometimes say that my favorites are the ones that came to me after they were fully grown. Their parents did a great job, there was no potty-training or teenager angst to get through, and I just get to enjoy them. They all bring me joy, so Mother’s Day is a great experience for me.

However, my appreciation is heightened by the knowledge that it’s not a great day for everyone. It’s especially good for me because I get to see my oldest son while he parents my three grandchildren, presently six, four and two. As he told me one day when the middle child was one and strolled through the living room with a cheerio in her mouth that had mysteriously appeared from nowhere, “Mom, it’s a zoo around here!”

I laughed and then I shut up because who am I to judge the ring master in a circus, right? There’s such joy in seeing him parent because I am struck by what might not have been.

I became pregnant with my oldest son (or as they used to say – I “turned up” pregnant – as if one morning, with no provocation or outside influence, poof!, I was with child), in 1991. I was a freshman in college at OU, had fallen madly in love with a senior at OSU (talk about bedlam) and well, the heart wants what the heart wants. I later went on to marry that OSU grad, but not until my oldest son was 4. This was the early 90’s, and, although I knew of girls that had become pregnant before marriage, they were handled through whispers and alternative schools, and all other kinds of avenues for dealing with those things people find uncomfortable to recognize or deal with. My parents didn’t take that approach.

I grew up in a full-on Southern Baptist family.

We were in church every Sunday morning, Sunday night and Wednesday night. There was Children’s Choir, Vacation Bible School, Sunday School lessons and many Bible verses memorized. Generally…lots of Jesus. So when the “always does well in school, captain of the drill team, never wore short skirts, always followed the rules” daughter of my Sunday School teacher mother and Deacon father fell in love with a (gasp) Catholic boy and got pregnant, they had some difficult choices to make in how they reacted. I will tell you right now that if you think abortion wasn’t discussed as an option,

you’d be wrong. It was. My “Bible believing, Jesus is the son of God, love one another” parents actually uttered the words. It was quite surreal to have this kind of discussion with them, but when you are up against something that seems so steep and insurmountable, you discuss every option available. I’ll also tell you that if you’ve not been there and felt the weight of this, no one who has been will ever be interested in hearing your opinion on what action should have been taken (for some people, that comes as a shocking revelation).

That night, my mother tucked me into bed like she had when I was five. She told me that I was ok and that everything would be ok. I was convinced she was right because she was my mother and as far as I could tell, she knew everything. Now that I’m a mom, I know she was attempting to be reassuring and prophetic because I am certain she was unsure about everything in that moment.

The next day, we had a conversation. She and my father had talked more, and she told me, “I don’t know what we’re supposed to do, but I know what we’re not supposed to do.” The idea that abortion was off the table actually gave me great relief. The knowledge that my parents were helping to make the decision and would support me gave me strength. We didn’t yet have the answers, but together, we found a path forward. However, this point is where my story varies significantly from that of other young women in their experiences.

Not all girls have that same amount of family support and care when faced with having to make this decision. Some are left without any guidance, feeling abandoned and alone in facing this endeavor.

Abandonment is devastating at any age. I was fortunate to have the resources I needed with parents who stood by me, helped me to search for and find my answer instead of threatening me with damnation and being outcast. I had a place to go and people to turn to for support, but it’s not the same for everyone when faced with this circumstance. That can make the world seem more alone, cold, and lacking in choices when faced with a major life decision.

As I and my parents know now, I was, truly, ok. Everything did turn out ok, but that’s not to say there weren’t times of struggle, pain, and uncertainty following my decision. It changed my life to be sure, but I was able to finish my two undergrad degrees, provide for my son and his younger brother when he came along almost nine years later, and graduate from

law school. I see my oldest son now and am touched by the wonderful person he has become, and what a blessing he has been in each phase of his life. He’s now fully grown, is married with children, and a doctor of pharmacy. I believe I made the right choice for me and for him.

I wasn’t financially prepared. If we’re discussing the right time to have a baby, nineteen years old in college, without a partner, and without a job is probably not at the top of the list. So, for the sake of the analysis, let’s just assume that the same holds true for the vast majority of girls and women who seek an abortion. I still ask – who cares? Whether you’re conservative or liberal, pro-life or pro-choice, what’s your solution to the problem of young mother’s not having what they need to either raise or carry a baby? What’s the answer for young women who lack the necessary support to make this monumental decision? And, if you have a solution that will work, how do you implement it?

That’s my story. As I said above, not all girls have that experience. Many are lacking the necessary resources and support to be able to think about the long-term effects of their decisions, even lacking basic necessities such as reliable food and shelter, not to mention the routine prenatal care during a pregnancy.

Some are struggling with addiction, mental illness, or I have friends on both sides of the issue. other infirmities, and we routinely see these outcomes in our juvenile deprived court system with the State Whether they are pro-life or pro-choice, I have yet to intervening to protect the children born of these hear anyone I know say that the goal is to end more pregnancies. They both talk about the issues, but neither circumstances. has found a solution. How do we create an environment During law school I took a class about children that gives girls and women the education, assistance and the law and we covered all issues affecting children, and empowerment so that the number one reason for including abortions. I will always remember that the an abortion isn’t a lack of financial stability and the top reasons cited for abortion were related to financial number two reason isn’t that it’s just not a good time stability and it not being a good time to have a child. I to have a baby? I believe there has got to be a better don’t have all the statistics, but a quick review of two answer. research articles appears to confirm that is still the case.

But really, why does that matter? I can tell you that

Obviously, I have strong feelings about this topic, and I reach my limit for listening to people who have never been faced with this issue talk about what the right answer is. Rarely does any action accompany the talk of answers to this problem. Opinions are easy to come by. My apologies to all the men who are reading this, but your words matter the least in this discussion. It’s not that you aren’t important to the issue or that you aren’t vital to making sure that children in this world are adequately cared for. It’s just that historically speaking, if we’re pinpointing where the most words and least amount of action come from when it comes to pregnancies, well, I’ll just say it’s not women. The same goes for women who are only using their words. They meet for lunches and dinners and they argue about Biden and Trump and senators who say inane things about this topic. They heavily debate the merits of both sides and they truly believe that a woman should have control of her own body, and then they go on about their lives and do nothing to make a difference in the life of a woman facing an unplanned pregnancy.

Let’s be about the business of providing education, assistance, and empowerment to those who need it in our communities. Let’s both recognize and deal with the underlying issues that create the end result.

Let’s provide support, encouragement and guidance to girls and women who don’t have any. Invest your time, energy and resources into helping people be the kind of parents they need to be. Stop talking at people regarding this issue and start doing something that will really make a difference. And, if you aren’t talking about it at all, wake up. Step outside of your box and gain some perspective and encourage others to do the same. Get involved in an organization that is already working to help make a difference in the lives of people who are most directly affected. If you want to really make a difference and you don’t know where to get plugged in, reach out to the TCBA and we can direct you to an organization that will be more than happy to have your assistance. I am committed to the TCBA, the TCBF and to making a difference. I hope you are too.

The end result is that you can make a difference, but it won’t happen by just talking. It will only happen I haven’t seen the draft of the Supreme Court if each of us takes a step to help someone in our circle decision in Dobbs, but I understand from others that of influence. So, let’s all stop talking about it and do the gist is that it moves the control for rules governing something. this issue back to the states. I can’t control the Supreme Court. I can make my voice heard to my state legislators Sincerely, and congressmen, but I can’t force them do anything. Kara Vincent You can’t either. Our circles of influence are most TCBA President, 2021-2022 often not at the capitol building in Oklahoma City and not in Washington DC. However, we can all find a person who is affected by this issue and help her. As the saying goes, do what you can, when you can, where you can, in whatever way you can.

I understand those who struggle internally with this issue. Because of my faith, I am certain that life begins at conception and that each abortion ends a life.

However, as a woman, I am equally certain that no one else should control what I do with my body. I believe I’m not alone in this internal conflict. So, what’s the answer? How do I change the world? How do we change the world? The only conclusion I have come to is that we do it one step at a time; one action at a time; one gesture at time. I humbly suggest that we all just quit talking and take some action. I’ll also add that I believe if you’re not doing anything to help, you are part of the problem.

Bar Center Summer Hours Fridays closing at 2pm beginning June 3rd

2022 TCBF Charity Golf Tournament Thank you to all who participated!

6 Tulsa Lawyer

The TCBF Golf Committee would like to 1st thank everyone who supported the 2022 TCBF Annual Charity Golf Tournament through sponsorships, playing in the tournament, our online auction and volunteering.

Longest Drive in the Fairway TJ Dupree

The tournament took place on Monday, May, 2, 2022, at the Meadowbrook Country Club. The weather was gray, the rain looked like it would never stop, and the wind was feisty. Despite all that Mother Nature threw at us, we did end up with 103 of 120 confirmed players for the day – and that’s fantastic!! After all expenses, we raised over $23,000!!

Longest Putt Shannon Thompson

Brian and I would like to thank the following: Judge Keele & son, Judge Nightingale, all of the volunteers from Veteran’s Treatment Court, the TCBA staff and their volunteers, and the TCBF Golf Committee.

Closest to the Pin Ryan Yates

If I failed to acknowledge anyone specifically, please know that your participation and assistance was greatly appreciated!!

We look forward to another GREAT tournament in 2023 & hope to have all of your support again!!

Kimberly K. Moore, Chair

We would also like to recognize and extend our thanks to our Eagle and Birdie Sponsors: Eagle - $2500 Regional Hyundai Richards & Conner PLLP Mazzio’s Corporation Birdie - $1500 Bama Companies Graves McClain Third Generation Electric McAfee Taft

Moyers & Martin Litgistix Barrow & Grimm

Although the ultimate winners of the tournament are our 4 beneficiaries: Veterans Treatment Court – BC Franklin Legal Clinic – Tulsa Lawyer’s for Children – Legal Aid Services of Oklahoma, Inc.- I wanted to share with each of you the tournament & challenge winners.

1st Place: Barrow & Grimm Jim Gotwals, Will Farrior, Brad Heckenkemper, Allen Barrow 2nd Place: Tulsa Drug Screening Tyler Funderburk, Jared Poulter, Carl Funderburk, Michael Walker 1st Place / Playing Super Putter: Guarantee / FirsTitle Jeff Lower, Melissa Herron, Neil Dailey, Jaren Anderson Shortest Drive in the Fairway Bruce Williams

Brian Keester, Co-Chair

2022-2023 ELECTION RESULTS

President Philip D. Hixon

President Elect Michael Esmond

Past President Kara Vincent

Vice President Stephanie R. Jackson

Library Trustee: Julie A. Evans Director at Large, Large Firm: Natalie Sears Director at Large, Med Firm: Kara Pratt Director at Large, Sm Firm: Mark A. Smith Incumbents (serving 2nd year of term)

Library Trustee: Kimberly Vojvoda Director at Large, Public Sector: Hon, Ann Keele Director at Large, Large Firm: C. Austin Birnie Director at Large, Med. Firm: Jennifer Struble Director at Large, Sm. Firm: LInda Morrissey OBA Delegates (2 year term)

Kara Vincent Julie Evans Natalie Sears Molly Aspan Kara Pratt Philip Hixon Melissa Webb Bruce McKenna

Georgenia A. Van Tuyl James C. Milton Mike McDonald Kate Forest David Tracy Mike McDonald Colton Richardson Andrew King

OBA Alternate Delegates Joel Daniel Auringer Paul McTighe, Jr Eric Yoder Sofia Maranda 8 Tulsa Lawyer

Roger Curlik Madison D. Cataudella Michael Thelan

Secretary Lizzie Riter

ABA Delegate: Molly Aspan

Treasurer Michael P. Taubman

VP'S CORNER Mike Esmond

TCBA Vice President 2021-2022

Happy Juneteenth!

As we turn our calendars to June, it’s time to start looking forward to summer.

For many of us it’s the time for vacations and a welcome break from school for our kids. This month is also the time to celebrate the Juneteenth holiday which commemorates the ending of slavery in the United States. The official federal holiday title is “Juneteenth National Independence Day,” but it’s known by other names, such as Emancipation Day, Black Independence Day, and simply Juneteenth. It marks the day June 19, 1865 – two and a half years after President Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation and two months after General Lee’s surrender at Appomattox – when Union soldiers landed at Galveston, Texas, with news that the war had ended and that the enslaved were free.

While Juneteenth has been observed and celebrated since 1865, it wasn’t designated a federal holiday until 2021, when President Biden signed into law the Juneteenth National Independence Day Act. This recognition as a national holiday is significant for many reasons. It acknowledges our national history of slavery and, as expressed in the President’s Proclamation on Juneteenth Day of Observance, 2021, it celebrates “the centuries of struggle, courage, and hope that have brought us to this time of progress and possibility.” But, as many have noted, the pursuit of equality, justice, and freedom from oppression Juneteenth celebrates is not the work of a single day. It requires constant effort by all people to ensure that the equality promised in our Constitution and in the legislative enactments since our founding will be fulfilled. The TCBA strives to make positive contributions to that effort.

Under the leadership of Deborah Reed, the TCBA Diversity Committee works to develop and participate

in community outreach programs focused on developing diversity within the practice of law and the Association.

Ms. Reed’s article in this issue highlights some of the Committee’s recent and upcoming initiatives, including the upcoming open house at the Bar Center on August 30, for affinity bars in the Tulsa metro area.

TCBA also partnered with Street Law this year to teach “practical law” to young people who are vulnerable to racism and injustice. The program is designed to ensure that participants know their rights and build key life skills to help them advocate for themselves and their communities. It also exposes participants to potential careers in the legal field. Several TCBA members and staff dedicated their time and other resources to make this project possible, including Rachel Baker, Carol Beatty, Katie Dilks, Whitney Dockrey, Jeril Haug, Timothy Michaels-Johnson, Pansy Moore-Shrier, Deborah Reed, Pierre Robertson, Kara Vincent, and Tami Williams.

The contributions of these members and staff are great examples of the positive impact our Association can make in the pursuit of equality, justice, and freedom in the Tulsa community. And they are just a few examples of programs currently underway. Our ability to do more is limited only by the initiative of our members and their willingness to pitch in. If you want to get involved or have ideas for improving programs or adding new ones, please let us know. In the meantime, I hope you all have a great kickoff to summer and take the opportunity to observe and celebrate our newest national holiday.

JUNETE ENTH JUNE 19, 2022

The Bar Center will be closed Monday, June 20th

Law Day Student Reception Held May 6thTulsa County Students Awarded Students from across Tulsa County reaped cash prizes and recognitions in this year’s Law Day Student Art and Writing Contests. The 2022 contest theme captured the Nation’s unceasing legal dynamic “Toward a More Perfect Union . . . the Constitution in Times of Change”.

The impact of the contests brought home to students the enormous contribution our Constitution, the Judicial branch and legal professionals bring to the Nation’s blessing of peaceful and reasonable means

10 Tulsa Lawyer

for resolution of conflict. Much credit goes to teachers and parents for their encouragement and leadership in motivating the students to reach for expression.

The contests, sponsored by the Tulsa County Bar Foundation in Tulsa County and the Oklahoma Bar Association across the State, were open to all public, private and home school students from Pre-K to 12th grade.

Hundreds of students submitted their art and writings with winners selected on quality and theme adherence. Each student entering competed for their grades’ prizes, many students submitting entries in both the art and writing contents. Teachers and parents can find contest details each Fall on the OBA and TCBF websites.

Thirty-four Tulsa County contest winners and honorees, accompanied by their proud parents and siblings, were awarded their prizes on May 6, 2022 at the Tulsa Bar Center.

Attorneys Lizzie Riter and Rodney Buck, and TCBF’s Tami Williams, helped with honoring the student winners.

Young Lawyers Division Committee meeting Tuesday, June 28th 5:30 PM at the Bar Center

STEIDLEY & NEAL, PLLC,

is searching for an associate attorney with 2-4 years’ experience in Insurance Defense for its Tulsa office.

Competitive salary and other benefits commensurate with level of experience. Looking for a motivated candidate interested in providing assistance to a partner.

Applications will be kept in strict confidence.

Send resume to Steidley & Neal, located in CityPlex Towers, 53rd Floor, 2448 E. 81st St., Tulsa, OK, 74137, attention Dwain Witt, Legal Administrator.

Tulsa Lawyer 11

TCBA COMMUNITY SPIRIT

Kayla and Kevin Finnegan with baby Liam

The puppacinos were a hit!

Doug Inhofe and Lynn Moore with Countess

Above: Katy Inhofe, Moura Robertson and Melissa Sublett Left: Tim and Sarah Gilpin

April 30th Pause 4 Paws Event held in the Downtown Arts District.

TCBA was a proud sponsor of this event.

TCBA & Food Bank of Eastern Oklahoma The TCBA food bank volunteer event, held on Saturday, May 7th was a great day! Volunteers packed 1,110 pounds of food which will provide 925 meals to members of our community.

12 Tulsa Lawyer

The Eddie Sutton Challenge - Shoot for the Center

April 30th - Funds were raised to support The Center for Individuals with Physical Challenges.

Above: Kevin Keller, Jason Lollman, Judge Tanya Wilson Left: Judge David Guten, Judge Ann Keele and Judge Tanya Wilson Right: Chris Jones & David Potts

Lawyers Fighting Hunger and TCBA Outreach Committee Iron Gate Volunteer Events - April 16th at Iron Gate downtown Tulsa.

TCBA Lawyers Fighting Hunger On Saturday April 16th local lawyers and judges all came together to provide Easter meals to families in need here in Tulsa. Lawyers Fighting Hunger paired up with Iron Gate of Tulsa to ensure local families were given everything they needed to make this Easter special. This year marks the 13th annual Easter event for Lawyers Fighting Hunger, which also provides turkey and sides for Thanksgiving each year.

Thanks to law firms such Graves McLain, Sherwood McCormick & Robert, and Gorospe Law Group, who were all platinum sponsors. They not only helped raise money for the event, but also donated their time organizing the food and getting it to the families.

While Iron Gate provides hot meals to anyone in need 365 days a year, there is a lack of food pantries in the Tulsa area that can provide the needed resources to make a special holiday meal. Iron Gate Executive Director Carrie Vesely Henderson explained, “Iron Gate serves a meal every day, Thanksgiving, Christmas, we are open. If you’re hungry, we will feed you.” Henderson continues, “The partnership with Lawyers Fighting Hunger, and the distribution through agencies, assists in relieving our agency partners of food distribution and allows them to focus on their core missions and expand the impact of their vital work.”

Lawyers Fighting Hunger helped to fill in this gap by providing local families the ingredients they need to make a holiday meal. This differs from other food banks, which may only have the resources to provide 14 Tulsa Lawyer

canned and boxed food or kitchens which only have the resources to provide an individual hot meal. Lawyers Fighting Hunger helps families who have access to a kitchen to cook a nice holiday meal, but do not have the finances to purchase the deluxe items needed. “We are happy to provide a complete Easter ham meal to those in need,” Lawyers Fighting Hunger Founder Hugh Robert said. “We know the need is great and we are glad to provide the funds and volunteers to make it a reality.”

These meal kits are assembled by local lawyers and judges, then given to various agencies for distribution.

While years past have seen all of the volunteers outside organizing the bags of food, this years rain prevented that from happening. Despite that, all the volunteers came ready to work and assemble bags. The bags of food included hams, corn, fresh potatoes, cake mixes, and tons of other sides to create the perfect Easter dinner.

Local judges were seen aiding in the event, as Judge Cantrell helped pass out corn and Judge Moody aided in walking the bags through the lines to help fill them up.

Once the bags are filled, volunteers ensure they make it to various agencies in the Tulsa area for distribution

to local families. These agencies include: Women in Recovery, Women’s Justice Team, Domestic Violence Intervention Services, Dayspring Community Services, Parkview Terrace, Life Senior Services, Youth Services of Tulsa, Arubah Community Clinic, Emergency Infant Services, Parkside Hospital & Clinic, Veteran’s Administration, CURA, EduRec, and the Tulsa Health Department.

Ultimately, Lawyers Fighting Hunger was able to provide 1,000 hams and bags of groceries to over 20 local agencies, and they hosted a drive thru pantry at Iron Gate for families in need. Feeding America project 1 in 5 Oklahomans do not have enough to eat. “Through the generosity of our sponsors and volunteers, and the hard work of Iron Gate and affiliated agencies we are making a huge impact on hunger in Tulsa,” said Lawyer Fighting Hunger Board Member Rachel Gusman.

Thanks to the work done by Lawyers Fighting Hunger and Iron Gate, fewer families will be facing that hunger during the holidays.

ASK-A-LAWYER 2022 (A New Beginning Recap) The one word above describes how successful our new beginning was for the ASK-A-LAWYER program, held for the first time (and forevermore) at our own Tulsa County Bar Center. Allow me to elaborate: Many of you know that before this year, the OBA had ‘partnered’ with the OETA for over 30 years to help host and produce this program. For a variety of reasons, the OBA decided it was time to advance into the 21st Century with new ideas and technology.

Our new ideas included a series of informative short 60 second videos that appeared on several social media platforms to help saturate our exposure to the public. These videos will become a permanent addition the various OBA social platforms and will be available all year round, not just on one day!

For technology upgrades, we switched to a VOIP protoco, routing calls through iPads, and headphones with microphones for all eight stations we had set up. The OBA and TCBA own this equipment now, so we are no longer ‘borrowing’ space and equipment from anybody.

16 Tulsa Lawyer

The audio quality was the best in all of my 32 consecutive years being a part of the program. Our volunteer Attorneys all agreed on this aspect; it was as if the callers were in the room with us. Tulsa had eight phones in use, while OKC had only 4 in use. I venture to say we may have finally eclipsed OKC in the number of calls that came through the program. (A goal I have pursued for many years) Some special programming and software placed all the incoming calls into the ‘cloud’ where they were distributed on a pre-set basis with Tulsa always getting

the first call, (even if the caller dialed the OKC number.)

While the OBA is still data mining and analyzing statistics, I suspect we will learn a bit later just exactly how well the program went.

From my own personal observations there, I would say the Tulsa phones have not been that busy and engaged in over 10 years! To be frank, we had more calls coming in than Attorneys to answer them.

For the first 3 hours, every Tulsa phone was lit up constantly with no break between calls for all 8 stations.

(We even had an emergency 9th station set up which became busy as well throughout the day.)

I believe we could have used 12-15 phones and all that is needed for next year (2023) is enough Attorneys to operate the phones. Again, when I say phones, I mean portable iPads that you could carry in one hand with a donut in the other hand and actually walk around the Bar Center while taking calls!

Speaking of the Bar Center, I want to acknowledge and thank our Executive Director Tami for the hospitality shown to us. A fully stocked refrigerator with water, tea, soft drinks and juice was complimented with donuts & sausage rolls as well as excellent gourmet sandwiches from Capriotti’s in Broken Arrow. I forgot to mention the pizza and hot wings we had for supper!

I want to thank the OBA and the TCBF for their generosity in purchasing the equipment and software,

which can be used year-round for other projects as well.

While we all owe a huge debt of gratitude to the OETA for DECADES of service to us, it was time to create and walk our own path in our own way with our own equipment now and forevermore.

I say again: WOW! Dan Crawford

Tulsa Lawyer 17

Law Day

April 29, 2022

20 Tulsa Lawyer

2022 Judicial Survey – June Primary Races

By Michael P. Taubman

EDITOR’S NOTE – For the Judicial Survey, the respondents were contacted via e-mail and asked to respond to the following set of questions. The results published below are only the responses of those candidates for judicial office who have one or more challengers for the specific Office. Ditrict 14, Office 12 will have a primary on June 28, 2022. Responses are grouped by the Office race and published in the order received from the candidates.

DISTRICT JUDGE – DISTRICT 14, OFFICE 12 (3 candidates) Hon. Tanya Wilson Special Judge, Tulsa County District Court Q1:

Current Occupation &/or Position Held?

I am a Tulsa County Special Judge

Q2:

Law degree(s) from which institution(s)?

I graduated in 2002 from the University of Tulsa College of Law

Q3:

Years in the practice of law?

20 years in September

Q7: Good management skills are important in order to be productive administrators of the court.

What strengths will you rely upon to manage the court's docket and proceedings in the courtroom if elected?

The strengths I currently rely on as a special judge are: decision making, knowledge of the case and the law applicable to the case and fairness.

Q8: When considering your future serving in our judicial system, what changes would you advocate to see and why?

Q4: If you are currently a Judge, for which docket(s) do you have/have you had responsibility? If you are not a Judge, what area(s) do you focus on in your practice?

As a current judge, I notice the lack of mentorship and/or training of new attorneys. I would like to see attorneys, who are knowledgeable in a particular field, mentor young attorneys who are new to the practice.

I am currently assigned to the criminal division in preliminary hearings

Q9: Please describe the key attributes you bring to the bench that you believe are important in the role of judge. Give an example of when you employed these attributes to successfully resolve conflict(s)?

Q5: Civic involvement and community service activities you regularly participate with in serving others?

For many years, I was a trustee at my church, Mount Zion Baptist Church. I have been involved and served on various juvenile boards specifically devoted to juvenile justice and crimes against children. I am Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, Inc. which is devoted to serving the members of our community.

Q6: Briefly describe the topic areas in which you regularly teach in a classroom or CLE setting, lecture, or publish in regard to the practice of law or another subject area.

I am an adjunct professor of Trial Practice at the University of Tulsa College of Law. I have previously served as the Mock Trial coach for the BLSA Mock Trial Team.

The key attributes I believe I bring to the bench are: decision making, communication, time management and knowledge of the law. At the preliminary hearing level, cases should not linger for long periods of time. Special Judges have to ensure cases are not passed unnecessarily and make rulings on cases in a timely manner.

I use these skills daily at the preliminary hearing level.

However, decision making and communication are the skills I employ the most. Often times during preliminary hearings, the State and the Defense have a breakdown in communication. This lack of communication can often result in an impasse in the case. As a result, cases linger for months and prevent a defendant from resolving his/ her case. I have, on occasion, asked each side to tell me their offer and helped the parties reach a resolution that Tulsa Lawyer 21

provides justice for the victim and also fairness for the defendant.

Q10: Numerically describe below your work in terms of the percentage that is devoted to or total number of cases conducted, as asked to respond:

Kevin Gray Tulsa County Assistant District AttorneyDirector of the Homicide Unit Q1:

Current Occupation &/or Position Held?

Tulsa County Assistant District Attorney- Director of the Homicide Unit

Q2:

Law degree(s) from which institution(s)?

University of Tulsa College of Law

Number of cases tried to verdict? #20+

Q3:

Years in the practice of law?

12+

Number of cases tried to a jury? #20+

Q4: If you are currently a Judge, for which docket(s) do you have/have you had responsibility? If you are not a Judge, what area(s) do you focus on in your practice?

Civil Litigation?

10% Criminal litigation?

90%

If you are currently a judge, number of bench trials conducted? #0 If you are currently a judge, number of jury trials conducted? ..#1 Q11: What combination of qualifications or qualities do you believe make you the best candidate for this judicial seat?

I know I am the best candidate for this judicial seat because I am currently a judge. I know what factors a judge has to consider when deciding a case and make a fair ruling. I know how to effectively manage my docket to not allow cases to stall at the preliminary hearing level.

I am also responsible for presiding over the bond docket.

When considering bond, I know how to balance public safety versus the right of an individual to a fair bond.

Q12: Access to civil justice for low-income and disadvantaged people involves identifying civil legal needs, developing strategies to meet them, and evaluating progress. If elected, how do expect to ensure and/or improve access to justice for the Tulsa community?

The Tulsa Community is fortunate to now have agencies and partners dedicated to providing access to justice for all Tulsa citizens. There are numerous expungement fairs, probate and FED workshops which are conducted throughout the year to provide services for members of our community who are unable to otherwise afford these resources.

As an Assistant District Attorney prosecuting almost exclusively homicides, 100% of my practice is in criminal law.

Q5: Civic involvement and community service activities you regularly participate with in serving others?

I have been actively involved in the Tulsa Air and Space Museum for over twenty years, serving on the Board of Directors and most recently transitioning to the Emeritus Board. I am also an active participant in the activities of our children’s schools, on the PTSA and in volunteer and fundraising capacities. I have also been a member of First Christian Church-Tulsa since childhood, and served for a number of years as a deacon, elder, and as the church archivist. In addition, I led a twenty year-long research project into the “Tulsamerican,” the last B-24 bomber built during WWII in Tulsa. That project resulted in locating the airplane underwater off the coast of Croatia and having the wreck site digitally mapped. Ultimately, the project’s research enabled the United States military to recover the remains of the pilot, who was buried with full military honors in Arlington National Cemetery.

Q6: Briefly describe the topic areas in which you regularly teach in a classroom or CLE setting, lecture, or publish in regard to the practice of law or another subject area.

I have been a guest speaker/lecturer to a number of area civic groups, church groups, veteran’s groups and other organizations on the topic of the “Tulsamerican,” the last B-24 bomber built in Tulsa during WWII. Those

lectures included being one of the first invited speakers for the Centennial Series of lectures at the Tulsa Air and Space Museum, which celebrated Oklahoma’s centennial.

Q7: Good management skills are important in order to be productive administrators of the court. What strengths will you rely upon to manage the court's docket and proceedings in the courtroom if elected?

As a new felony attorney in 2011, I was responsible for two preliminary hearing dockets each week totaling an average of 50-60 cases. The life of a new felony attorney in the District Attorney’s office is simple triage. Quick but fair decisions have to be made about the disposition of dozens of cases. When managing a District Court Arraignment docket, I regularly handled over 100 cases on a single day. As the Director of our Homicide Unit, I am primarily responsible for making filing decisions on almost all of the homicides that happen in Tulsa County. I assign myself about 1/3 of those cases for prosecution. That results in an individual caseload for me of 25-30 active homicide cases, with 8-10 of those tried to a jury each year. As a consequence, I regularly make important, impactful decisions that impact not only the life of the offender, but the lives of the victims that the offender leaves behind. I will be able to draw on the lessons learned during over a decade of managing thousands of felony criminal cases if I am elected to the bench. I have an excellent handle on courtroom dynamics, the flow of a docket, and how to efficiently move cases from an early stage to a final disposition.

Q8: When considering your future serving in our judicial system, what changes would you advocate to see and why?

One of the biggest challenges the judiciary faces is its anonymity. While local judges are well-known in the legal community, the broader community has almost no familiarity with the bench. Judges are some of the most powerful elected officials in Tulsa County, but a lack of recognition enables a minimum amount of accountability.

While most residents know their mayor, at least by name, almost none know the judges who make daily decisions about child custody, major civil disputes, and sentences for those convicted of crimes. I think it is critical for the judiciary to have a presence outside the courthouse, and for the individual judges to build strong bonds with the citizens they serve. The judiciary, for the average citizen, is a complete mystery. The courthouse, to most, is a foreboding place. The camera system installed thanks to recent federal grants enables most courtrooms to take advantage of live streaming technology that can open our courtrooms to a broader range of citizens who are unable or who lack the time to visit court in person. Recent trials

have been live-streamed to the media and others, enabling a far greater number of citizens to remotely participate in their legal system. I believe prudent expansion of the use of this system would increase transparency, and improve accountability not just for the judiciary but for the entire legal system.

Q9: Please describe the key attributes you bring to the bench that you believe are important in the role of judge. Give an example of when you employed these attributes to successfully resolve conflict(s)?

Successful judges command respect – respect that is earned as a consequence of their reputation and their work ethic.

Successful judges are smart, willing to listen and open to new ideas. Those judges are also good communicators, and are able to clearly interact with the parties that appear in front of them. Conflict is a daily reality in my work.

Criminal trial work is, at its heart, an adversarial process.

The process impacts citizens in very personal ways, as both defendants and victims come to court seeking justice. One of my most important tasks is listening to the families of homicide victims as they share with me the loss that they have experienced, the impact that loss has had on their lives, and their hopes about the judicial process moving forward. One of the biggest challenges I face is managing their expectations. Some families come expecting to see a defendant receive a maximum sentence when such a sentence isn’t possible. Some come hoping to find a sense of closure, when the reality is that even a guilty verdict often doesn’t heal the pain a family feels. This dynamic often puts prosecutors in conflict with the families they work with, as the prosecutor seeks to balance the family’s desires with a duty to secure a just outcome for the case.

With every family I meet, I explain the court process and then sit back and listen. I learn far more by listening then by talking. I try to communicate effectively with each family, trying to help them manage their own expectations as we work through the process together. Ultimately, I make every effort to give them a voice in the process. Often (but not always) this results in a family well served, and justice secured for all parties.

Q10: Numerically describe below your work in terms of the percentage that is devoted to or total number of cases conducted, as asked to respond: Civil litigation? % Criminal litigation?

100%

Continued on next page...

Tulsa Lawyer 23

Arbitration / Mediation? % Number of cases tried to verdict? # 93 Number of cases tried to a jury? # 93 If you are currently a judge, number of bench trials conducted? # If you are currently a judge, number of jury trials conducted? # Q11: What combination of qualifications or qualities do you believe make you the best candidate for this judicial seat?

A district judge, in most cases, is a trial judge. Over the last decade I have tried over 90 felony jury trials, with over 50 of them being homicides. I’ve tried some of the highest profile cases in Tulsa County, and have done so with efficiency and integrity. I have a deep understanding of the jury trial process and how to best manage a trial from beginning to end. I believe that experience is unparalleled in Tulsa County in the last decade, and would allow me to take the bench ready to try cases on day 1.

I also care deeply about the Tulsa community. I was born at St. John Medical Center, and lived in east Tulsa. I was enrolled in Tulsa Public Schools from kindergarten through high school. My family moved to south Tulsa, but I attended Carver Middle School and Booker T. Washington High School in north Tulsa. My family attended church downtown. I earned two degrees from the University of Tulsa. As an adult, my family lives in midtown. My children also attend Tulsa Public Schools. I have lived, gone to school, worshipped and worked in almost every part of our community. My wife and I chose to raise our family here in our hometown because we believe in our community and want to make it better. My deep Tulsa roots make me invested in its success.

Q12: Access to civil justice for low-income and disadvantaged people involves identifying civil legal needs, developing strategies to meet them, and evaluating progress. If elected, how do expect to ensure and/or improve access to justice for the Tulsa community?

One of the biggest barriers for low-income and disadvantaged people regarding the legal system is simple understanding of the legal process. I have personally observed judges demonstrate compassion with citizens who have a need for help from the legal system, but who simply don’t know where to start. The willingness of judges to pair citizens with attorneys who are ready and able to assist is critical. I think that far too often, both judges and attorneys I am also terribly patient and easy to get along with. Jury are unwilling to take simple steps that would facilitate trials are, by nature, a contentious process. I have tried access. Whether it’s directing citizens to events hosted by cases against over 50 different attorneys, and handled cases the local Bar that answer basic legal questions, or calling with scores more. I have a reputation for being upfront on an attorney to offer some simple assistance, judges are and honest, and have been able to maintain strong, cordial in a position to facilitate resolution to simple challenges. relationships with the attorneys I work with in court. A Explaining the legal process in language a lay person can judge’s authority depends primarily on the trust that understand also facilitates access. As an Assistant District attorneys and the public have in that particular judge. The Attorney, I regularly encounter citizens who have no strong relationships I have with a wide variety of attorneys understanding of the steps a simple criminal case requires.

The most effective strategy with those citizens is explaining would greatly help my service as a judge. the process in a basic way.

I also have a reputation for being fair. My job requires me to make filing decisions on homicides that happen in Tulsa County, and to determine what degree of homicide to file. Once filed, I have to make decisions on what plea SOLO ATTORNEY offers to extend to defendants. I have a reputation among SET OF OFFICE FURNITURE the defense bar as someone who is fair but firm. I believe in assessing the strengths and weaknesses of each case on its Computer & desk, HP printer, large wood own merits, and then arriving at a plea offer that takes into desk, file cabinet, three open cabinets, account a variety of factors, including the culpability, age, hat stand, TV, phone, two leather client and background of the defendant. A judge has to do the chairs, shredder, deskchair & pad, music same thing, whether serving on a juvenile, civil, or criminal and sound system, wall pics, and two docket. My reputation for being firm but fair is precisely lamps. $1500.00 Call 918-605-0039 the quality a judge needs on the bench.

24 24 Tulsa Tulsa Lawyer Lawyer

Todd Tucker, Partner Welsh & McGough, PLLC Q1:

Current Occupation &/or Position Held?

I am currently a partner at with my primary areas of practice including criminal defense, civil defense, and plaintiff’s personal injury work.

Q2:

Law degree(s) from which institution(s)?

Oklahoma City University

Q3:

Years in the practice of law?

I have practiced law for 28 years.

Q4: If you are currently a Judge, for which docket(s) do you have/have you had responsibility? If you are not a Judge, what area(s) do you focus on in your practice? n/a Q5: Civic involvement and community service activities you regularly participate with in serving others?

I am involved with the Little Light House and enjoy volunteering with developmentally disabled children.

Q6: Briefly describe the topic areas in which you regularly teach in a classroom or CLE setting, lecture, or publish in regard to the practice of law or another subject area.

each other. Ideally, a juvenile justice center housing all case dealing with kids would be a dream. Since McGirt, the number of criminal cases being filed are down. Some dockets need to be shifted.

Q9: Please describe the key attributes you bring to the bench that you believe are important in the role of judge. Give an example of when you employed these attributes to successfully resolve conflict(s)?

I have real-world business experience. I understand case values from years of litigating cases. I can manage and run a business, and I recognize the value of the billable hour. I am the only candidate in my judicial race who is not a government employee and has to make sure employees receive a paycheck through sound business decisions.

As a criminal defense attorney, I recognize the need to get violent offenders off the streets. I also see jail and prison over-crowding and the need for diversion programs, Frankly, I have the common sense from years of business experience to understand how to manage dockets and keep cases moving forward. No private-practice attorney wants to spend hours waiting on a Judge to start a docket or constantly continue status conferences. Time is money.

Q10: Numerically describe below your work in terms of the percentage that is devoted to or total number of cases conducted, as asked to respond:

I have spoken to groups about civil litigation discovery and evidentiary issues.

Civil litigation?

50%

Q7: Good management skills are important in order to be productive administrators of the court. What strengths will you rely upon to manage the court's docket and proceedings in the courtroom if elected?

Criminal litigation?

20%

I believe that judicial economy is best served by dockets that are moving. I will rely on court staff to make sure cases are moving forward and that trial dates are readily available. Some of my greatest frustration as a practitioner has been delays in getting cases heard. I will make sure to minimize wait-times by practitioners in my court.

Q8: When considering your future serving in our judicial system, what changes would you advocate to see and why?

I will encourage young lawyers to sit in on dockets and hearings to gain confidence and experience. I think there needs to be a streamlining of several dockets. Children’s guardianships, juvenile cases, and family/domestic cases need to have judges in closer proximity speaking with

Arbitration / Mediation? % Number of cases tried to verdict?

More than 50 Number of cases tried to a jury?

More than 50 If you are currently a judge, number of bench trials conducted? # If you are currently a judge, number of jury trials conducted? #

Continued on next page...

Tulsa Lawyer 25

Q11: What combination of qualifications or qualities do you believe make you the best candidate for this judicial seat?

I have a combination of private-practice experience, business knowledge and common sense to make me the best candidate for a judicial seat. Frankly, while I appreciate the role of the district attorney’s office for many reasons, a judiciary packed with prosecutors is not enhancing fairness or justice. While there is no doubt violent convicted offenders need to be in prisons, we also must remember the United States Constitution and the protections it affords. Every citizen is entitled to the protections under the law.

We need judges with practical experience who can preserve defendant’s rights, understand evidence and can set trials day one on the bench. I have the real-world experience to make sure justice is impartially administered.

Q12: Access to civil justice for low-income and disadvantaged people involves identifying civil legal needs, developing strategies to meet them, and evaluating progress. If elected, how do expect to ensure and/or improve access to justice for the Tulsa community?

There are many great programs in place, and many more needed. Fortunately, on the civil side, there is no shortage of talented attorneys willing to help or volunteer. But that is not enough. More needs to be done to improve access to justice. The internet is a tremendous resource, and using the resources available through the Tulsa County Bar Association, Oklahoma Bar Association, etc., programming needs to continue to be expanded and available through websites. Great programs have already been started with forms available through websites, even through Legal Aid. We need to continue moving programming forward to ensure no one is unable to access the court system for a legitimate reason.

Did You Know?

It took Thomas Jefferson 17

days to write the Declaration of Independence.

26 Tulsa Lawyer

DISTRICT JUDGE – DISTRICT 14, OFFICE 13 (2 candidates) Hon. R. Kyle Alderson Associate Municipal Judge, City of Tulsa Q1:

Current Occupation &/or Position Held?

Attorney—Titus Hillis Reynolds Love

Q2:

Law degree(s) from which institution(s)?

Tulsa University

Q3:

Years in the practice of law?

10+ years.

Q4: If you are currently a Judge, for which docket(s) do you have/have you had responsibility?

If you are not a Judge, what area(s) do you focus on in your practice?

I currently serve as the sole Municipal Judge for the cities of Pawnee and Cleveland. I also serve as an Associate Municipal Judge for the City of Tulsa. As part of these municipal judgeships, I have called a criminal and juvenile delinquent docket for the past 3.5 years.

I am currently an attorney at Titus Hillis Reynolds Love, where I practice in the fields of civil litigation and criminal defense. I accept appointments as conflict counsel for the Oklahoma Indigent Defense System and serve as a public defender for the Muscogee (Creek) Nation.

Q5: Civic involvement and community service activities you regularly participate with in serving others?

I am an active parishioner at Christ the King Catholic Church and volunteer as a coach for Marquette Catholic Schools soccer, flag football, baseball, and basketball teams and serve on the Marquette Athletic Association. I also coach a Tulsa Alliance Lacrosse 2nd/3rd Grade team. I am a member of the Knights of Columbus. I have previously served on the Tulsa CityCounty Library Commission from 2008-2011.

Q6: Briefly describe the topic areas in which you regularly teach in a classroom or CLE setting,

lecture, or publish in regard to the practice of law or another subject area.

I lecture on topics related to criminal law and banking law.

Q7: Good management skills are important in order to be productive administrators of the court.

What strengths will you rely upon to manage the court's docket and proceedings in the courtroom if elected?

Public service has been a driving force in my life from a young age. I earned my Eagle Scout Award at age 13. At 14, I founded a non-profit organization, R.E.A.D.: Reading Encourage All Dreams, to combat childhood illiteracy.

During high school and college, I volunteered and worked on political campaigns. In law school, I interned for the Governor Brad Henry. I served as an Assistant District Attorney for over seven years, including serving as First Assistant District Attorney, where I prosecuted violent crimes and crimes against children. For nearly the last four years, I have served as a Municipal Judge hearing misdemeanor and juvenile cases.

This experience has taught me the value of a strong and independent court system. As a District Judge, I will firmly and independently apply the law as written to any factual scenario presented to me by the parties. I will consistently look for and listen to any method to maximize efficiency in the court’s dockets and in achieving a fair and just resolution.

Q8: When considering your future serving in our judicial system, what changes would you advocate to see and why?

As a District Judge, I will advocate for practices that increase access to the courthouse for all citizens and maximize the resources available to the court and all parties. I will strive to work with non-profits and law firms to increase the pro bono representation for under served communities while ensuring a quick and just resolution for all parties. in any dispute before the Court.

Q9: Please describe the key attributes you bring to the bench that you believe are important in the role of judge. Give an example of when you employed these attributes to successfully resolve conflict(s)?

As a Municipal Judge, I have increased the efficiency of the court system by reducing the number of regular dockets by half while creating juvenile diversionary programs to combat the youth vaping epidemic.

Q10: Numerically describe below your work in terms of the percentage that is devoted to or total number of cases conducted, as asked to respond: Civil litigation?

50% Criminal litigation?

50% Arbitration / Mediation?

10% Number of cases tried to verdict?

100+# Number of cases tried to a jury?

27# If you are currently a judge, number of bench trials conducted?

0# If you are currently a judge, number of jury trials conducted?

0# Q11: What combination of qualifications or qualities do you believe make you the best candidate for this judicial seat?

I have the experience to being a well-seasoned prosecutor, public defender and criminal defense attorney, civil litigator, and judge. Regardless of the assigned docket, I am ready on day one to hear and decide any case. I have previously worked in the executive, the legislative, and the judicial branches of government and I appreciate the necessary separation of powers and the checks and balances that the judiciary can provide.

Q12: Access to civil justice for low-income and disadvantaged people involves identifying civil legal needs, developing strategies to meet them, and evaluating progress. If elected, how do expect to ensure and/or improve access to justice for the Tulsa community?

Ensuring equal access to the courthouse should be a paramount goal of any jurist. I will constantly listen and modify my dockets to maximize efficiency for all litigants. Further, I will rely on my non-profit experience to coordinate with local organizations to increase access to pro bono representation for our under served communities.

Tulsa Lawyer 27

Hon. David A. Guten Special Judge, Tulsa County District Court Q1:

Current Occupation &/or Position Held?

Special District Judge, Tulsa County, assigned to the Criminal Division Q2:

Law degree(s) from which institution(s)?

University of Tulsa, College of Law

Q3:

Years in the practice of law?

18+

Q4: If you are currently a Judge, for which docket(s) do you have/have you had responsibility? If you are not a Judge, what area(s) do you focus on in your practice?

Upon taking the bench in 2019 I was assigned to the Criminal Division and was assigned to Traffic and Misdemeanors where I handled the Arraignment Docket, the Bond Docket, the Court Cost Docket, the DPS Appeals Docket and assisted with the Misdemeanor Dockets.

In mid 2020 I was assigned to the Preliminary Hearing Dockets where I have remained.

Q5: Civic involvement and community service activities you regularly participate with in serving others?

I’ve been involved with the TCBA Military & Veteran’s Committee as well as the OBA’s Military Law Committee for a number of years and do a tremendous amount of volunteering with various veteran organizations around Tulsa. I’m currently serving on the board of directors for one of our local private schools and have been involved in a number of volunteer events for Bishop Kelley High School. Over the years I have been involved with Metro Tulsa Soccer Club as a youth soccer coach and previously worked with a number of nonprofit organizations, such as Tulsa Advocates for the Protection of Children where I served as a board member, Tulsa Court Appointed Special Advocates (CASA) and the Child Abuse Network (CAN).

I am also a reservist in the Air Force with the Oklahoma Air National Guard and have been serving for nearly 18 years.

Q6: Briefly describe the topic areas in which you regularly teach in a classroom or CLE setting, lecture, or publish in regard to the practice of law or another subject area.

While I was still practicing I was a frequent lecturer on military law matters that overlapped in various areas of law such as family law, employment law, criminal law and estate planning. I have also presented CLE’s on small firm/solo practice issues, and recently was a guest lecturer for the Access to Justice Summit. Over the years I have written several articles for the Tulsa Lawyer on various military-law related legal issues.

Q7: Good management skills are important in order to be productive administrators of the court. What strengths will you rely upon to manage the court's docket and proceedings in the courtroom if elected?

My strength comes from already having successfully managed large dockets for the last three (3) years.

During this time, I’ve been able to develop and refine my practices to ensure the dockets run efficiently and that matters are heard timely. Preparation, communication and understanding of the law is crucial to good docket management.

Q8: When considering your future serving in our judicial system, what changes would you advocate to see and why?

The judicial system serves a vital role for the public. As judges, we should ensure that cases are heard timely with a just result to promote confidence in our system and strengthen the public’s trust. The Court should always be working to increase its efficiency and effectiveness in disposing of cases and develop ways to increase access for the public to the justice system itself.

Q9: Please describe the key attributes you bring to the bench that you believe are important in the role of judge. Give an example of when you employed these attributes to successfully resolve conflict(s)?

Integrity, experience, temperament and the ability to actively listen and understand potential outcomes are all vital attributes to being a good judge.

Member renewal begins in July.

Be sure your account information is up to date.

Contact Julie Rivers for assistance.

28 Tulsa Lawyer

Q10: Numerically describe below your work in terms of the percentage that is devoted to or total number of cases conducted, as asked to respond: Civil litigation?

10% Criminal litigation?

90% Arbitration / Mediation? % Number of cases tried to verdict? # Number of cases tried to a jury? # If you are currently a judge, number of bench trials conducted?

23 If you are currently a judge, number of jury trials conducted?

1 Q11: What combination of qualifications or qualities do you believe make you the best candidate for this judicial seat?

Based on my number of years as a practicing attorney and now as a Judge, I believe that I have the qualification with both the legal and the judicial experience to be Tulsa’s next District Judge. I have a commitment to civility and impartiality, carrying out the law in a fair and unbiased manner, and the temperament required of someone who sits on the bench.

Q12: Access to civil justice for low-income and disadvantaged people involves identifying civil legal needs, developing strategies to meet them, and evaluating progress. If elected, how do expect to ensure and/or improve access to justice for the Tulsa community?

There are already a number of organizations in Tulsa County that are working to assist low-income and disadvantaged individuals in addressing their legal needs.

These organizations contribute greatly to ensuring that all citizens have access to the judicial system and that the needs of the public are being addressed. There can never be enough resources to assist those in need and our court system should always be working to enhance its ability to be more accessible. During the COVID-19 pandemic I was heavily involved in the establishment of a virtual court for multiple dockets and worked with many of our judges to allow for cases to continue being heard despite courthouse closings or limitations in the courtrooms for social distancing. I would continue to assist in improving that process as well as any other process that increases access to our justice system.

Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Deborah A. Reed

The Oklahoma Bar Association recently requested input from its members about several things, including diversity, equity, and inclusion. This time last year, the Tulsa County Bar Association sent out a request for a similar survey focused almost entirely on diversity, equity, and inclusion.

The TCBA survey shows we need to continue our efforts to diversify the membership. 198 people responded to the 2021 TCBA survey. This represented ____% of the membership. 82.32% of the respondents identified as White for race or ethnicity. For the same time period, the United States Census Bureau says the population of Oklahoma was 74% White.

with the University of Tulsa School of Law, we held the Annual Diversity Panel and Networking Reception in early March 2022. This was TU Law’s first live event since the pre-covid era.

A new initiative the TCBA is implementing through its Diversity Committee is the Affinity Bar Reception.

There are several Bar Associations operating in Tulsa County whose memberships are comprised almost entirely of lawyers with diverse backgrounds. In a program based on the Affinity Bar Partners program of the Boston Bar Association, the TCBA will invite members of diverse Bar Associations to a reception at the newly renovated Bar Center. TCBA members will have the opportunity to welcome area lawyers. Some will be old friends, but some may be entering the doors for the first time.

As a result of the survey results, the TCBA Diversity Committee submitted an increased budget request for the current year. We increased our sponsorship level for the Annual Tulsa MLK Parade where TCBA members The remaining results of the 2021 TCBA survey are and staff marched to honor one of the greatest civil rights below. Thank you to all who participated. activists our country has ever known. In cooperation

30 Tulsa Lawyer

Q1 What is your race/ethnicity as described by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission? Mark all that apply.

Answered: 198 Skipped: 0

Q2 What is your gender identity?

Answered: 198 Skipped: 0

Q3 Which pronouns do you use to identify yourself?

Answered: 198 Skipped: 0

Q4 Do you identify as LGBTQ+?

Answered: 198 Skipped: 0

Tulsa Lawyer 31

Q5 Do you identify as transgender?

Answered: 198 Skipped: 0

Q6 Are you a military Veteran?

Answered: 198 Skipped: 0

Q7 Do you have a disability?

Answered: 198 Skipped: 0

Pilates Yoga Fusion

Pilates Fusion incorporates exercise from different workout styles – including barre, yoga, strength training and cardio to give a modern twist to mat Pilates. Similar to mat Pilates, this style has a deep focus on the core and emphasizing moves that will tone, stretch, and elongate muscles. What better way to end your work week!

Starting in July

Free & Live Streaming from TCBA

Fridays 12-12:45p

32 Tulsa Lawyer

Street Law’s Final Meeting

Zone Student participants pictured with TU Law Students who assisted.

Left to right / TU Students: Cheyenne Barnard, 2L, Matthew Blewitt, 2.5L and Trevion Martin 3L.

The Street Law program held a semester wrap up party at the Bar Center and featured guest speaker Lucky Lamons and snacks provided by the TCBF Outreach Committee.

The students spent time learning about Lucky’s long career as a police officer, legislator and advocate as well as toured the bar center. If you are interested in participating in the Street Law Program through TCBA please contact Tami Williams at tamiw@tulsabar.com.

Grapevine News The Tulsa law firm of Atkinson, Brittingham, Gladd, Fiasco & Edmonds announces that Thomas “Tommy” H. Gayle has become a partner in the firm.

Mr. Gayle graduated from Loyola University Chicago School of Law in 2007 after earning a B.S. in business management from Louisiana State University.

He began his career in Chicago representing employees, and later employers, in workers’ compensation bench trials, civil appeals, and before the Illinois Appellate Court.

In early 2018, Mr. Gayle joined the law firm of Atkinson, Brittingham, Gladd, Fiasco & Edmonds where his practice is focused in the area of civil litigation defending against claims of medical negligence, general liability, and claims arising from motor vehicle accidents. He is a member of the Oklahoma Bar Association.

GableGotwals is pleased to announce it has established a $25,000 scholarship at The University of Tulsa College of Law in loving memory of former shareholder, mentor, and friend, Judge Joseph W. Morris.

As part of his long and distinguished legal career, Joe Morris served as Dean of The University of Tulsa College of Law from 1972-1974, before becoming chief judge of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Oklahoma. Joe’s vast legal experience also included being the VP & General Counsel of Shell Oil Company and the General Counsel of Amerada Petroleum Corporation. In later years, he taught oil and gas law and arbitration law at the TU College of Law for many years. Judge Morris received his law degree from Washburn University School of Law and an advanced degree from the University of Michigan Law School. He also served as an officer in the U.S. Navy during World War II, assigned to the Admiral O. C. Badger in Honolulu, Hawaii.

34 Tulsa Lawyer

In 1984, while attending Ellis Gable’s 50th wedding anniversary, Joe was asked what he would do following his retirement from Shell. Joe replied that he would likely move back to Tulsa. With that, Ellis told Joe to come see him when he was ready. Shortly thereafter, Joe was invited to join GableGotwals, where he was shareholder for more than 35 years.

We are deeply saddened by the passing of Judge Morris. Establishing this scholarship in his name on what would have been his 100th birthday is our way of honoring his great legacy. It will provide opportunities for students who have a demonstrated track record of academic success that might not otherwise have had the financial means to pursue a legal degree,” said John Dale, Shareholder and CEO of GableGotwals.

GableGotwals began as a two-person enterprise between Ellis Gable and Charles Gotwals in 1944 and has since grown into a distinguished full-service law firm that employs 100 attorneys and more than 60 professionals with offices in Oklahoma City and Tulsa. Though Oklahoma-based, the Firm’s and reach are global, representing a diversified client base that includes Fortune 500 companies, private and public entities, entrepreneurs, foundations, and individuals.

Clients trust us every day with the stewardship and strategic management of their legal challenges due to the exceptional services provided by our litigators and transactional attorneys.

Tulsa Lawyer Advertising We are Targeted, Local and Convenient Check out our rates at www.tulsabar.com!

Limited time specials available, contact tulsabarnews@yahoo.com

Classified Ads Helton Law Firm is searching for an attorney with 5+ years litigation experience or an attorney with 8+ years transactional experience. Please forward resumes to scott@heltonlawfirm.com.

Jon Starr Mediator and Arbitrator Contact DRC for scheduling 918-382-0300

Send your classifieds to tulsabrnews@yahoo.com

June Birthday Celebrations?

HAPPY BIRTHDAY! We are striving to take care of our members as well as taking care of the community. If there’s anything we can do to help you, please let us know. We are here to support your business and we want you to be successful.

By being a member of the TCBA, you are also a member of the Tulsa County Bar Foundation. As a general rule, the funds that come into the Foundation are the result of a fundraising event for our community and the monies raised are immediately distributed back out into the community through non-profit organizations.

In an effort to assist the Foundation, we have implemented a monthly “Fund the Foundation” program.

To participate we are asking each member who has a birthday this month to consider making a donation to the Foundation. You can do so with the QR Code to the below.

If you are not currently a Fellow, please consider joining that program. As a thank you (and let’s be honest, an encouragement to other members), if you donate before the 10th of the month we will include a shout out to you in the next issue of Tulsa Lawyer Magazine.

If you wish to donate or join the Fellows program, please contact Tami Williams or Julie Rivers and they can assist you.

We value your membership & Happy Birthday!

Sincerely, Kara Vincent, TCBA President Tulsa Lawyer 35

2021-2022 TCBA CONTACTS, COMMITTEE & SECTION CHAIRS

www.tulsabar.com

PHONE: 918-584-5243 FAX: 918-592-0208 1446 South Boston, Tulsa, OK 74119-3612 Executive Director Tami Williams tamiw@tulsabar.com Ext. 1002 Membership Director CLE, Sections & Committees Julie Rivers julier@tulsabar.com Ext. 1001

Front Desk Coordinator General Inquiries

frontdesk@tulsabar.com Ext. 1000 Accounting accounting@tulsabar.com

Lawyer Referral & Community Resource Navigator Jeril Haug jerilh@tulsabar.com Ext. 1003

Tulsa Lawyer Editor - Michael Taubman michael@tulsafirm.com Associate Editor - Milly Dunlap Tulsa Lawyer Submissions - tulsabarnews@yahoo.com

TCBA OFFICERS

President................................................................ Kara Vincent Past President.........................................................Kimberly Moore President-Elect.........................................................Philip D. Hixon Vice President.......................................................... Mike Esmond Secretary..............................................................Stephanie Jackson Treasurer................................................................. Lesa Creveling Budget/Internal Operations..................................Michael Taubman Foundation President ............................................Hon. Ann Keele Director at Large (1) Large Firm.................................Austin Birnie Director at Large (2) Large Firm..........................

Philip Hixon Director at Large (1) Medium Firm........................Jennifer Struble Director at Large (2) Medium Firm..................

Kara Pratt Director at Large (1) Small Firm...........................Linda Morrissey Director at Large (2) Small Firm...........................Tamera Childers Director at Large (2) Public Sector.........................Hon. Ann Keele ABA Delegate............................................................. Molly Aspan OBA Delegate................................................................Rick White Library Trustee (1)......................................................Kim Vojvoda Library Trustee (2)........................................................ Julie Evans Presiding Judge .......................................... Hon. Doug Drummond U.S. District Court ..................................

Hon. John Heil Tulsa Municipal Court............................. Hon. Gerald Hofmeister TU Law School Student Representative...............Trevion Freeman

FOUNDATION APPOINTMENTS

Law Day ......................................................................Lizzie Riter Community Outreach................................................ Ashley Webb Golf Chair.......................................................... ...Kimberly Moore Scholarship Chair........................................................Randy Lewin

Submission, Grapevine & Advertising- Visit www.tulsabar.com Subscriptions to Tulsa Lawyer are available for $40.00 a year to those who are not Tulsa County Bar Association members or others who do not currently receive the publication.

Contact tamiw@tulsabar.com

FOUNDATION

President.............................................................. ...Hon. Ann Keele Foundation Vice President............................................Justin Munn Treasurer..................................................................... Philip Hixon Trustee....................................................................... Lizzie Riter Trustee........................................................................Chad McLain Trustee......................................................................... Jim Gotwals Trustee................................................................Catherine Hoopert Trustee...........................................................................Rick White Trustee..................................................................Michael Taubman TCBA President..........................................................Kara Vincent TCBA Pres. Elect....................................................Philip D. Hixon

COMMITTEE CHAIRPERSONS

Access to Justice..........................................Pansy Moore-Shrier Animal Law..................................................... ..........Katy Inhofe Bench & Bar.................................................... Kevinn Matthews Children & the Law......................................... ........Lizzie Riter Children & the Law Vice Chair..........Timothy Michaels-Johnson CLE ................................................................. ...Michon Hughes Diversity Development...........................................Deborah Reed Fee Arbitration................................................. ...........Gary Crews Law Related Education.................................................................

Lawyer Referral............................................... .......Karen Wilkins Membership Services....................................................Kara Pratt Mentoring......................................................... ..................................

Military/Veterans ............................................ ...Mitchell Garrett Military/Veterans Co-Chair.............................. Hon. David Guten Nominations & Awards.................................... ..Kimberly Moore Pro Bono............................................................... Mac Finlayson Professionalism................................................ ...........Rick White Public Relations....................................................Steve Layman Social Media.........................................................Collaborative Special Events.................................................. .......Natalie Sears Tulsa Lawyer.................................................... Michael Taubman Young Lawyers Division..............................Colton Richardson Young Lawyers Division............................... ........Billy Duncan

SECTION CHAIRPERSONS

ADR/Mediation..........................................................Melissa Fell Bankruptcy....................................................... ........Paul Thomas Business/Corporate.......................................... ..............................

Criminal Law................................................... ........Daniel Levy Employment Law..............................................Kassidy Quinten Energy & Mineral Law.................................... .......Ryan Pittman Family Law...................................................... ..Jordan Dalgleish Health Law . .................................................... ............................

Health Law Vice Chair..................................................................

Juvenile Law.................................................... ..........Lizzie Riter Juvenile Law Co-Chair.......................Timothy Michaels-Johnson Litigation...............................................................Mark A. Smith Municipal Law.......................................................................TBD Paralegals/Legal Assistant.......................................Karlyn Apon Paralegal /Legal Assistants Vice Chair............ Kathyrn Keener Probate/Estate/Elder......................................... .........................

Tax ......................................................... .....Ashlee Crouch Technology ...................................................Pansy Moore-Shrier Workers Comp................................................. ............................ * Section Chairs will be updated as positions are filled.

Tulsa Lawyer is a monthly publication of the TCBA. The TCBA does not necessarily share or endorse the opinions expressed in the materials published. The views are those of thoughtful contributors. Similarly, advertising does not imply endorsement by the TCBA of products or services or any statements concerning them.

Tulsa County Bar Association 1446 S. Boston Ave. Tulsa, OK 74119

PRSRTD STD US POSTAGE PAID Pontiac, Illinois PERMIT# 592