Northside Ice Cream Shops

2020 NORTHSIDE ICE CREAM SHOPS

If you are looking for ice cream, frozen custard, Italian ice or gelato, the Northside offers plenty of local options to satisfy your sweet tooth. Here are some of our favorites!

864 Logan St. Noblesville, IN (317) 773-9177 alexandersicecream.com

An old-fashioned ice cream soda shop and restaurant, Alexander’s On The Square offers more than 30 hand dipped ice cream flavors, old fashioned sodas, malts and shakes made the way you want. Alexander’s also offers great food, from our signature Reuben to soups, salads and much more. ALEXANDER’S ON THE SQUARE

210 W. Main St. Carmel, IN (317) 706-2827 620 S Main St Zionsville, IN (317) 344-0927 bubsburgers.com

Perfectly hand-pattied, flame grilled and seasoned to perfection juicy cheeseburgers. BUB’S BURGERS & ICE CREAM

13170 Harrell Pkwy #1000 Noblesville, IN (317) 770-8220 coldstonecreamery.com

Ice cream chain offering design-your-own creations hand-mixed on a granite slab, plus shakes & more. COLD STONE CREAMERY

205 Park St. Westfield, IN (317) 399-7878 conecrumb.com

Handmade ice cream and desserts located on Park Street in downtown Westfield. CONE + CRUMB

11691 Fall Creek Rd. Indianapolis, IN (317) 288-7791 craveicecreamsocial.com

Super-premium, hand-dipped ice cream made locally from all the finest and freshest ingredients. CRAVE ICE CREAM SOCIAL

2740 E 146th St. Carmel, IN (317) 218-3304

9703 N Michigan Road Carmel, IN (317) 982-7512 freddysusa.com

Forget traditional hamburgers and ice cream. Freshly-churned frozen custard and cooked-to-order steakburgers make Freddy’s the Taste that Brings You Back! FREDDY’S FROZEN CUSTARD & STEAKBURGERS

Locations in Fishers, Carmel and Indianapolis graeters.com

Graeter’s ice cream produces craft ice cream and gelato lines using a small batch, artisanal method of production dating back over a century. Graeter’s has won the hearts of ice cream enthusiasts across the country as well as the respect of the nation’s most influential foodies. GRAETER’S ICE CREAM

2466 E. 146th St. Carmel, IN (317) 705-1855 8760 E 116th St Fishers, IN (317) 585-8065 handelsicecream.com/indy

On a hot summer day in July of 1945, Alice Handel began serving ice cream in Youngstown, Ohio. With the finest ingredients she made her ice cream one batch at a time using personal recipes and fresh fruit from her garden. Today, over 70 years later with locations coast to coast, Alice’s dedication to quality and service has remained the same. The Handel’s way is to serve with a smile and always use the best ingredients in abundance. HANDEL’S HOMEMADE ICE CREAM & YOGURT

834 W. Main St Carmel, IN (317) 740-0113 mammamiaindy.com

Authentic Italian gelato, pastries and coffee by Lucio Romani & Stefano Gangitano. We use only the finest and freshest ingredients imported from our homeland in Italy. Dairy free options available. Gelato cakes for any occasion. MAMMAMIA GELATO

916 E. Westfield Blvd Indianapolis, IN Fishers location soon to come at Fishers District A local Indianapolis business that specializes in making all-natural, gourmet frozen treats. NICEY TREAT

8910 E 96th St Fishers, IN (317) 598-5111 ritasice.com

Bob Tumolo and his mother opened the very first Rita’s in 1984. Whether you enjoy Rita’s famous Italian Ice, award-winning Frozen Custard, our #1 treat Gelati, or another signature treat, we’re committed to providing a dose of happiness with every visit. RITA’S ITALIAN ICE & FROZEN CUSTARD

111 W. Main St Ste. 130 Carmel, IN (317) 564-8158 subzeroicecream.com

Chain serving ice cream & yogurt, including vegan & soy options, made to order & flash-frozen. SUB ZERO NITROGEN ICE CREAM

9922 East 79th Street Indianapolis, IN (317) 570-0533 sundaeshomemade.com

Sundae’s Homemade opened in December 1995 and is located at the southern tip of the Geist Reservoir in Indianapolis. Over the last number of years, the store has perfected the homemade ice cream craft and mastered the art of coffee roasting. Discover some of Sundae’s staple flavors like Graham Central Station, Lemoreo, Key Lime Pie, or Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie. SUNDAE’S HOMEMADE ICE CREAM

800 S. Rangeline Rd., Ste. 220 Carmel, IN (317) 257-2253 thecakebakeshop.com

The Cake Bake Shop is a high-end bakery with outdoor seating offering cakes, pastries & high tea service in glam digs. When you walk through the French doors, the sparkling chandeliers, antiqued mirrors, French inspired furniture, beautiful seasonal decoration and the rich aroma of the French chocolate cakes baking in the oven immediately greets you. The shop also offers unique, homemade ice cream and sorbet options with daily specials! THE CAKE BAKE SHOP

9270 E. 141st St. Fishers, IN (317) 776-3800

Visit the Old Custard Stand, a small mother and daughter business. Custard is made daily. Vanilla, chocolate and butter pecan available daily with other specialty sundaes. A The Old Custard Stand, we are committed to bringing you the best oldfashioned style frozen custard. All of our items are made by our family from recipes we have enjoyed for years. We now invite you & yours to enjoy them, too. THE OLD CUSTARD STAND

“Working with Jamie and her Team was an amazing experience. Jamie took the time to come over and walk our home a few months prior to us listing and made an itemized list of what we needed to do to get ready for the market. She had a list of vendor partners that helped us prepare and it was totally stress free! We put our home on the market and sold it at Full Price the first day! She swiftly handled the inspection and appraisal processes like a boss! Her negotiation skills are nothing short of spectacular! She also negotiated our new home! We highly recommend Jamie Boer Homes!”

- Tina & Gregg M. -

MOVING TO THE FISHERS/GEIST AREA? CALL ME, YOUR LOCAL EXPERT TO HELP YOU FIND YOUR DREAM HOME!

I hope you and your loved ones are safe and healthy!

Pending

Coming Soon

10030 Cooper Saddle

Impressive 5 BR, 4.5 bath home w/finished bsmt in desirable Belmont Place!

Coming Soon

10629 Geist Ridge Court

Exquisite Valleys at Geist Estate home, nestled on 1 acre wooded cul de sac lot w/ deeded boat dock on Geist!

Coming Soon

8954 Glass Chimney Lane

Fantastic 3 bedroom ranch with super floor plan that is sure to please! Immaculate, new interior paint, neutral throughout in Fishers.

13841 Hawkstone Drive

Large 4BR + loft + fin bsmt w/open flr plan! 2 sty tiled foyer, 1st flr den/study, frml dining rm, 2 sty Great Rm & vaulted ceils throughout! HSE Schools!

13032 Bartlett Dr.

Amazing corner lot 5 bdrm in Tanglewood at Saxony. HSE Schools!

10583 Geist Ridge Court

Over an acre wooded cul-de-sac lot in coveted Valleys at Geist subdivision, state of the art kitchen, walk out basement, deeded boat dock on Geist. HSE Schools!

For more listings, visit: JamieBoerHomes.com

Certified Staging and Redesign Services Geist + Fishers Real Estate Experts #1 in Customer Service GET MORE WITH JAMIE BOER 317-289-9169