Skip to main content

TMM: Identifying Mortgage Fraud

Page 1

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026 | www.tmmonline.nz

IDENTIFYING MORTGAGE FRAUD 18

MY BIZ: FINDING TIME TO ADVISE

30

USING AI TO TURN ENQUIRIES INTO CLIENTS

32

QUESTIONS AROUND TWO YEAR INSURANCE PAYMENT TERMS.


   

   

   

  02

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026


www.tmmonline.nz

03


Contents. FEATURES

22

UP FRONT 05

EDITORIAL Rising fraud a serious issue for advisers.

06

NEWS Advisers write $40 billion in a year for three of the big banks; Two new non-bank lenders come to town.

09

PEOPLE Mortgage Supply gets group business manager and Astute gets operations manager. Loan Market makes two senior regional appointments, FMT keeps growing, Heartland execs dominate merged bank’s top roles, King steps down and MPM gets new network manager.

14

REGULATION FMA outlines its latest expectations for advisers

16

PROPERTY NEWS Sally Lindsay rounds up the latest property news.

LEAD

MORTGAGE FRAUD IS BECOMING A BIG ISSUE TMM investigates what’s happening and provides red flags to watch out for.

18

COLUMNS 30

SALES AND MARKETING They’re interested, they’re just not ready yet.

21

HOUSING COMMENTARY What’s happening in the housing market.

32

INSURANCE Steve Wright asks; Are two-year payment terms suitable options for income cover or mortgage repayment cover?

34

THE TMM ONLINE TOP 10 Here are the most read stories online recently.

MY BIZ

HANDS IN OTHER PIES KEEPS MORTGAGE ADVISER FRESH

04

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026


UP FRONT

EDITORIAL

RISING FRAUD A SERIOUS ISSUE FOR ADVISERS

M

ortgage fraud has always been a thing, but what many in the industry did not realise is how big an issue it is currently when one of the aggregator groups spelt the scale of the problem out to members at a recent Professional Development Day. Fraud levels are at record highs and only likely to increase with the emergence of AI. In this issue we canvas some of the dealer groups on the issue and also provide some tips and tools to help advisers identify potential cases of fraud. A key take out is advisers can no longer take anything clients says, or documents they provide, at face value. Now more than ever advisers need to be scrupulously vigilant. Similarly, dealer groups must ensure their compliance systems are fit for purpose and detect potential fraud. The worst thing that could happen for the mortgage advice sector is to have a large scale fraud event happen

Head office & Advertising

1448A Hinemoa Street, Rotorua PO Box 2011, Rotorua P: 0274 377 527 E: philip@tmmonline.nz

Publisher

Philip Macalister

through the advice channel. It’s not just New Zealand either. Anyone who keeps an eye on mortgage developments around the world will see it is a global problem. Banks are clearly freaking out over potential fraud and starting ask far more questions around deals and using AI to assist them. A safe prediction is that we will hear much more about mortgage fraud and it is going to make the job of giving advice much harder.

Vale Josh It would be remiss of me not to acknowledge the passing of Josh Bronkorst in this editorial. Josh, who rescued Mortgage Link, and transformed it to Link Financial Group and brought in NZ Home Loans as a major shareholder passed away from cancer recently. Josh was the all-round good guy who unreservedly put his members front and centre of what he did. Between this issue being finished

Design

Michelle Veysey

Subscriptions

P: 0274 377 527 E: subscriptions@tarawera.co.nz ISSN 1176-2063 (Print) ISSN 2537-799X (Online)

Staff writer Sally Lindsay

Contributors

Paul Watkins, Steve Wright, Kip Hanna

and distributed there will be a Memorial Service to Josh in Auckland. Undoubtedly it will be one of the big events of the industry this year as he was held in such high regard from lenders to competitors to advisers. You can find my Obituary online (tmmonline.nz) to Josh. He is a guy I had a huge amount of respect for and he was a great supporter of TMM over the years. A good man taken far too early. RIP mate.

TMM is published by Tarawera Publishing Ltd (TPL). TPL also publishes online money management magazine Good Returns www. goodreturns.co.nz and ASSET magazine.

Philip Macalister Publisher

All contents of TMM are copyright Tarawera Publishing Ltd. Any reproduction without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.

TMM welcomes opinions from all readers on its editorial. If you would like to comment on articles, columns, or regularly appearing pieces in TMM, or on other issues, please send your comments to: editor@tmmonline.nz

How to update your mailing address Make sure you don't miss an issue by changing your address. Go to: www.tmmonline.nz 05 tarawera.co.nz/coa


UP FRONT

NEWS

Advisers wrote an estimated $40 billion of home loans at three of the big four banks

CATHERINE MCGRATH

Westpac: 70% of flows, despite removing trails Westpac chief executive Catherine McGrath said advisers wrote 70% of all mortgages in the 12 months period. That is some of the bank’s biggestever adviser flows, even though trail

06

TMM JUNE | 2026

commissions were removed earlier this year. Advisers’ share of Westpac’s total home loan book rose from 59.5% to 62.3%. Sarah Curtis, a Kerikeri-based mortgage adviser, said the result confirms something the adviser community already knows. In a LinkedIn post, she said the majority of advisers always put their clients’ interests first. “If Westpac is the best bank for them when we have done our analysis, that’s where they go,” she said, “regardless of commission”. Curtis said the issue for advisers was that agreements were in place that business owners had no transparency over, so they didn’t know it was a risk to plan for. “Now we do,” she said. Advisers know to ask more questions and to remember that it is a business, and to plan for a future where “there is a bit we can’t control”, she said, and to focus on what they can. Westpac’s home loan book grew 4% to $74.5 billion, below market growth of 5.4%. The bank said turnaround times have fallen from more than eight days to one day, and McGrath said it had “invested well in the broker origination channel” and used AI tools to make sure submissions are in great shape. One adviser has suggested turnaround times have improved because volumes are down, and that they will blow out again when the market picks up because banks haven’t re-resourced their broker units. McGrath had no comment on that suggestion.

Advisers wrote 61% of ANZ’s home loans over the past year, unchanged from a year earlier. Their share of ANZ’s overall book edged up from 53% to 54%. ANZ’s book grew from $116 billion to $121 billion, but its market share slipped from 30% to 29.7%. Chief executive Ben Kelleher said it is difficult to predict whether advisers’ share has plateaued. “I think it’s really customers’ choice,” he said. He said switching activity has roughly doubled over the past five years, and acknowledged that sudden increases in demand can put pressure on banks. “When things do pick up, sometimes it can take a time to adjust to that,” he said. Unlike Westpac, he did not disclose turnaround times.

BEN KELLEHER

TMM’s figures are based on bank disclosures for the year to September 30. In total advisers wrote about $39.7 billion of new home loans across the three banks, from a combined $66.3 billion of new home loan lending. At New Zealand’s largest bank, ANZ, advisers wrote $17.7 billion of its $29 billion in new home lending, a 61% share. Westpac says advisers wrote 70% of its new mortgages, but it doesn’t disclose gross new lending, so TMM estimates its adviser flow at about $12.9 billion. BNZ declined to disclose flows, so its adviser flow is estimated at about $9.1 billion of its $18.9 billion in new drawdowns, or 48%. ASB, the fourth of the big four banks, is not included as it has a different balance date and it has refused to disclose adviser flow numbers to TMM for years.

ANZ: flows steady at 61%

SARAH CURTIS

Analysis by TMM shows mortgage advisers wrote an estimated $39.7 billion of new home loans in the past year at Westpac, ANZ and BNZ, about 60% of the three banks’ combined new lending.

BNZ: book share up, flows not disclosed Advisers’ share of BNZ’s $68.8 billion home loan book rose from 39.3% to 40.8%. BNZ’s book grew 7.7%, or $4.9 billion, which parent company NAB said was 1.4 times system growth. BNZ refused to disclose flow numbers, although it has done so previously, and ASB and Westpac are upfront with the data. Its results presentation specifically calls out the performance of its in-house channel, which accounts for nearly six in every 10 dollars of its mortgage book.


Confidence matters more than certainty in today's market BY KIP HANNA, NZHL CEO

KIP HANNA

O

ne of the interesting things about the current market is that many people are waiting for certainty, but certainty may be the one thing the market can't provide. The latest NZHL Property Report by Tony Alexander shows buyers remain cautious. Concerns about interest rates continue, but buyers are also worried about what might happen to property prices after they purchase. At the same time, many buyers don't feel they need to rush. They have options, choice and the ability to take a little more time before deciding. One of the things I'm hearing from advisers across the country is that clients aren't necessarily saying no. They're taking longer to say yes. They're reading more, asking more questions and weighing up more options before making a move.” You can understand why. Whether it's buying a home, refinancing a mortgage or investing in property, people want confidence they're making the right decision. The challenge is that no one knows exactly where interest rates or property prices will be six months from now. That's where advisers have an important role to play. Not because we can provide all the answers. None of us can. Our value comes from helping clients cut through the noise, understand their options and make decisions that align with their goals and circumstances. It's also important to acknowledge that price matters. Interest rates matter. Cashback offers matter. Product features matter. Every adviser has seen clients attracted by a sharper offer or a larger cashback. That's part of a competitive market and always will be. But when we look at NZHL's latest customer research, it's clear those aren't

the only things clients value. One of the strongest findings from the survey, which included feedback from approximately 4,000 customers, was the connection between adviser engagement and customer confidence. Customers who had regular contact with their adviser reported higher levels of satisfaction and greater confidence in their financial position than those who had gone longer without meaningful engagement. In fact, customers who were contacted by their adviser at least annually reported an overall satisfaction score of 88%, significantly higher than customers who experienced less frequent engagement. What's interesting about that finding is what it tells us about adviser value in the current market. In stronger markets, value is often measured by speed, access to lending and getting deals done. In markets like this, most clients already have plenty of information. They've read the headlines, heard the forecasts and understand that rates and property prices may move. The challenge isn't finding information. It's deciding what to do with it.

The question many are really asking is simple: What should I do next? Helping clients answer that question is where advisers can create real value. The advisers who stand out in environments like this aren't necessarily the ones making the boldest market predictions. They're the ones helping clients focus on the things they can control, whether that's their lending structure, cashflow, debt reduction strategy or longerterm financial goals. The latest NZHL Property Report suggests many New Zealanders are taking a cautious approach while they assess their options and navigate ongoing uncertainty. However, our customer research provides an encouraging reminder. Despite the backdrop of fluctuating interest rates, cost-of-living pressures and ongoing market uncertainty, 80% of clients told us they feel in control of their financial situation. For me, that's the most interesting finding from the survey. It suggests that while people may be waiting for more certainty, they're not standing still. They're continuing to make decisions, adjust plans and work towards their financial goals. That's where advisers play an important role. When people feel informed, supported and clear on their next steps, they're far more likely to move forward, regardless of what the market does next. In a market where there's no shortage of uncertainty, it's a reminder that people don't need all the answers before they can make progress. They just need the confidence to take the next step. :

ABOUT NZHL GROUP

NZHL Group is a Kiwi-owned, respected, and trusted brand – a purpose-driven (financial freedom, faster) home loan and insurance network that offers a solution to support advisers and help put Kiwi in a better financial position. Part of Kiwi Group Capital Ltd (KGC) which is 100% Government owned, NZHL Group operates with an Independent Board and local business owners nationwide. www.tmmonline.nz

07


UP FRONT

NEWS

Two newest non-banks come to market New Zealand already has numerous non-bank lenders, and two more have entered the market in recent months. MB Private has launched as a new player in New Zealand's rapidly growing private credit market, backed by an initial $150 million funding commitment from Westpac New Zealand. The other new player is Madox Finance which has a funding line from BNZ. MB Private is headed up by Marcus Morrison who is known to the mortgage advice sector through peerto-peer lender Zagga, which recently rebranded to Vestee. Madox is headed by Greg Munt. Munt set up One50Group and sold that business to Lifetime (which has recently been acquired by Booster). He was also worked in specialist lending with the likes of Reesby and Co. Westpac funds other non-bank lenders including the likes of Avanti and Basecorp. TMM asked Westpac chief executive Catherine McGrath how much exposure the bank had to the nonbank sector. She refused to provide a number and noted Westpac had been an “agency bank” for a long time. Madox's funding is linked to future securitisation plans. Munt says Madox is the first non-bank start up to secure 08

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026

a bank funding line. MB Private's Westpac funding is complemented by a further $20 million in first-loss capital provided by MB Private shareholders, creating alignment between the business, its funding partners and investors. The firm appointed Mike Kinley as its business development manager, He is well-known to advisers after roles at Bluestone and Loan Market. Meanwhile, Madox has appointed Vincent van der Kraaij as its head of credit. He is highly regarded in this role and was formerly with Marac and Resimac. MB Private will manage private credit funds providing property-backed lending to residential borrowers, with loans secured by first mortgages over New Zealand property. The business combines institutional-grade credit disciplines with technology, streamlined decision-making and a strong focus on speed and ease of process for borrowers. Founder Marcus Morrison says securing Westpac's support at launch provided a strong foundation from which to build the new lending platform. "The partnership with Westpac New Zealand gives MB Private a solid base from which to scale and respond to growing demand for alternative lending solutions. It is also an important endorsement of the

team we have built and the quality of the credit and operational disciplines underpinning our business." Morrison says the opportunity for MB Private is not merely to participate in a growing market, but to establish a strong point of difference within it. The company expects to build on its initial $150 million funding pool, targeting a further $500 million in lending capacity following deployment of its first tranche. Munt says Madox has started off writing non-CCCFA loans and will move into regulated loans further down the track. His goal is to build a $1 billion book in the space of five years. With a background as a broker he understands what advisers want and says the firm can turn around deals in 24 hours and get to settlement in 48 hours with all the right paperwork. "It's an exciting time to launch a new business," he says. There are plenty of deals to be written and AI has really helped with systems and processes. KPMG's recent Specialist Lenders Insights Report (March 2026) identified approximately $22 billion in loan obligations across the sector, with more than 80% of lenders reporting growth in lending volumes and 75% of respondents reporting increased net profit after tax compared with the previous year.


UP FRONT

PEOPLE

People on the move

Got a new appointment you would like to tell advisers about? Email details and a pic to editor@tarawera.co.nz

Mortgage Supply tops up The Mortgage Supply Co, part of the Astute group, has grown from a small mortgage broking business into a team of 78 people across three brands. Steve Starke has joined the team as group business manager, with a brief to help those businesses work together as one integrated financial services group. “I'm not new to the Supply Co world, having worked with director David Windler since 2009, and extensively with Jack Windler and long-standing hands like Colin Hill. “I have also been a customer: Dave and Jack have both handled my own family and business lending. I knows what the service feels like from the other side of the desk.” That relationship began in property

education and coaching. Over 16 years Starke has coached in the classroom and in the field across multiple property types. He was general manager and tutor at PropertyTutors, director at GRA Property Education Ltd, a director of his own firm, Property Mentor, and head coach for Steve Goodey Property Coaching. “Along the way I have helped hundreds of aspiring and established investors build wealth through property for themselves and their families. As an AFA I wrote many financial plans for people to age 100 for both partners, canvassing KiwiSaver, direct property investment and other fund management, through the clients projected life cycles and risk appetites.” Starke’s career also spans real estate and financial planning. He has held a real estate licence since 2014 and has been project marketing manager, sales

WE’LL TAKE A DIFFICULT DEAL AND

MAKE IT SIMPLE, FAST

manager and business growth ganager, often at the same time. “I was part of the Don Ha team at RE/MAX that achieved #1 Global Top Team in Closed Transactions (Owner Team) at the 2020 RE/MAX Global Awards. I have previously achieved Platinum Sales Status, owned and ran my own RE/MAX franchise, and have been a Certified Guild Member of the Institute for Luxury Home Marketing. I hold a Postgraduate Diploma in Business Administration and National Certificates in both Financial Advice and Real Estate.” “That mix is why I am here, in a company driven to deliver excellence in outcomes for their clients aspirations, and with many awards to prove it.”:

STRAIGHTFORWARD NON-BANK MORTGAGE LENDING At Basecorp, our brokers know us for our dependability with straightforward and We offer: • Competitive, fair rates • Most approvals within two days of loan application • Strong industry knowledge, experience and relationships developed from over 25 years in the business

Get in touch now for simple, smart residential mortgage solutions.

07 839 2999 | info@basecorp.co.nz www.basecorp.co.nz

www.tmmonline.nz

09


UP FRONT

PEOPLE

Operations Manager switches groups Kelly Brough has been appointed to the new role of operations manager at Astute Financial. She has 16 year’s experience in the aggregation space with Link Financial Group. Brough brings in depth experience in CRM, compliance and distribution across both the lending and risk advice environments. During her 16 years with LFG she worked in several roles, including as an adviser, business development manager and national manager, before moving across to head up the group’s CRM system (Advice Link). “During my time at LFG, I worked alongside a developer to create and develop the system, so I have a real appreciation for the importance of having technology that works for advisers and supports the way they do business,” she says. “A key focus for me over the coming months is building on the strong foundations already in place across our systems and processes, refining areas where we can create efficiencies, strengthen and simplify our compliance documentation, and assist our GEM support and compliance teams to continue tailoring our systems to further support the needs of our New Zealand members.”

010

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026

Loan Market NZ invests in adviser growth with two senior regional appointments Loan Market NZ has strengthened its regional support team with two experienced regional manager appointments, reinforcing its commitment to helping advisers build stronger, more successful businesses. Amelia Gini joins the Wellington office, supporting advisers across the lower North Island and South Island. With more than 25 years of experience across banking, mortgages and insurance in New Zealand and the United Kingdom, Gini brings extensive expertise in business growth, strategic leadership and relationship management. Most recently a regional manager at Gallagher Insurance, she has a strong track record of leading high-performing teams and driving business improvement. Michelle Kinilau joins the Auckland office, supporting advisers across the northern regions. With more than 14 years of experience spanning banking, mortgage advice and non-bank lending, Kinilau understands first-hand the opportunities and challenges advisers face. Having worked as both a successful mortgage adviser

and, most recently, national sales manager at Liberty Financial NZ, she is passionate about building strong relationships, delivering practical coaching and helping advisers grow their businesses. Loan Market NZ national director Nicole Ferguson says the appointments reflect the group's continued investment in delivering meaningful, hands-on support to its adviser network. "We're thrilled to welcome Amelia and Michelle to the Loan Market family. Both bring exceptional industry knowledge, fresh perspectives and a genuine passion for helping advisers succeed.” "They understand what it takes to run a successful advice business and the importance of having the right support, tools and strategies in place to achieve sustainable growth.” "From unlocking the potential of MyCRM's new MyIntelligence tools to supporting our business growth and Kaizen programmes, Amelia and Michelle will play an important role in helping advisers work smarter, strengthen their businesses and seize new opportunities.


Let’s go broader

Let’s go further

Let’s go larger

Let’s go beyond

Bare land now accepted up to 60% LVR

More regional opportunities across Cat 1

Loans up to $2.5m and $5m exposure

Up to 90% LVR for Alt Doc option

Talk to us

0800 945 658

scenariocentre@pepper.co.nz

Really helpful loan options

Applications are subject to Pepper New Zealand Limited completing responsible lending checks and considering the borrower’s individual circumstances, credit assessment, eligibility criteria and lending limits. Terms, conditions, fees and charges apply. Information provided is factual information only and is not intended to imply any recommendation about any financial product(s) or constitute tax advice. We recommend clients obtain independent financial or tax advice. © Pepper New Zealand Limited NZBN 9429031065153 NZ Company Number 3416551.

www.tmmonline.nz

011


UP FRONT

PEOPLE

King to step down

FMT expands Auckland team Small business lender Prospa adds two new Business Development Managers. FMT has expanded its Auckland lending team with the appointment of Barend Nienaber as business development manager, and the promotion of Adam Richardson to associate business development manager. The expanded team gives advisers access to additional support, credit expertise and practical help to engage early and keep deals moving. The appointments reflect FMT’s commitment to being an accessible lending partner with a personal approach that advisers can rely on. Advisers deal directly with experienced, local people who take the time to understand each scenario and what their clients want to achieve. Nienaber brings a strong background in sales, customer relationships and

commercial lending, with a focus on practical conversations about clients’ funding needs. Richardson’s promotion reflects FMT’s commitment to developing talent from within. His experience as a loans analyst gives him a strong understanding of credit analysis, deal assessment and structuring. Sue Griffiths, National Strategic Partnership Manager at FMT, says the appointments give advisers greater access to the right expertise and support early in the process. FMT have five BDMs in Auckland and 11 nationally. Larger and/or more complex deals are managed by Cam McLachlan and Anneka Herdson, who specialise in development funding. Nienaber and Richardson will work alongside Jono Singh, who is well known across the lending industry in the Auckland.

Heartland execs take majority of roles in combined bank Heartland Group executives are tagged to lead the combined TSB Heartland group once the deal is confirmed.

•

The endorsed leadership team (designate), intended to report to TSB Heartland Bank chief executive designate Leanne Lazarus, are: • Kerry Conway, chief financial officer: Currently chief financial officer, Heartland Bank. • Andy Wood, chief risk officer: Currently chief risk officer, Heartland Bank. • Larissa Vaughan, chief legal officer: Currently general manager regulatory affairs and general counsel, TSB.

•

012

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026

•

•

•

•

Rebecca Thomas, chief technology, digital and data officer: Currently chief digital and transformation officer, Heartland Bank. Lana West, chief people and culture officer: Currently chief people and culture officer, Heartland Bank. Penny Burgess, chief customer officer – retail: Currently general manager customer delivery, TSB. Peter Griffin, chief customer officer – specialist: Currently chief commercial officer, Heartland Bank. Nick Herbert, chief product and proposition officer: Currently general manager product and marketing, TSB. Molly Auva’a-O’Brien, chief operating officer: Currently general manager operational excellence, TSB.

Non-bank lender managing director Brent King intends to leave the role in June next year. General Finance’s parent, General Capital is listed on the NZX. Currently, the board is working to identify a successor. Chairman Rewi Bugo said: "Brent has led General Capital through a sustained period of growth, with total assets growing from $12 million eight years ago to more than $300 million. He has done an exceptional job growing the group over the last eight years and leaves the group well established as a licensed deposit-taker with a strong credit profile of BB+.” General Finance's objective is to become a bank in December 2028. “Along with the strong asset growth he has grown profits and cashflow of the group enabling dividends to be paid to shareholders.”

MPM gets new network boss Mike Pero has appointed Christchurch-based Network Manager John Sherrat to the team to reinforce its strong regional presence. “Given the economic success of the South Island and continued strong performance of our southern franchises, it’s a logical and positive step to have boots back on the ground on the mainland,” Mike Pero general manager Lenska Papich says. “In his role he will support National Franchise Manager Charlotte Ireland in growing our presence further.” Sherrat is an experienced ex SBS branch manager and also a professional rugby coach. He moves into the role after Colleen Dennehy left the business. :


MEET FINN AND GRANT. The partnership behind better lending.

Supporting Mortgage Advisers since 1996. Got a deal? Let’s take a look. “TALK

TO FMT

”

0800 321 113 fmt.co.nz www.tmmonline.nz

013

Terms, conditions & fees apply. Lending is from the First Mortgage Trust Group Investment Fund. FMML, the issuer, is not a registered bank under the Banking (Prudential Supervision) Act 1989.


UP FRONT

REGULATION

MICHAEL HEWES UPDATES ADVISERS ON FMA EXPECTATIONS

FMA outlines its latest expectations for advisers PHILIP MACALISTER

T

he Financial Markets Authority is raising the bar on financial advice firms, warning that having policies, templates and controls in place is no longer enough. FMA director of deposit taking, insurance and advice Michael Hewes told advisers at the NZ Financial Advisers Association (NZFAA) conference in Christchurch that the financial advice regime is now well embedded and the regulator expects firms to demonstrate their systems are working and producing good client outcomes. “The next step for the sector is moving beyond having controls to showing what and how they actually work,” Hewes says. “We have an adage when we go through and engage with entities, and when we supervise: don’t just tell us,

014

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026

you need to now show us.” For advisers, the message is not to create more paperwork. It is to make sure a client file clearly shows why advice was given, how conflicts were managed and whether the client understood the recommendation. Hewes says advisers should be able to demonstrate the thinking behind their advice rather than rely on completed forms and disclosure documents as evidence they have met their obligations. That will become increasingly important as the FMA focuses on four areas: conflicts, product design, complaints and fraud prevention. Hewes says the FMA recognises the significant work advice firms have done since the new financial advice regime was introduced, including rebuilding processes, policies and professional

standards. However, supervision is now moving into a more mature phase.

Files need to tell the story Hewes says good advice starts with the client rather than the product and describes the advice process as a chain in which each link depends on the one before it. The first requirement is genuinely understanding the client's circumstances, objectives and priorities. “It’s not a data capture exercise. It is, in fact, an understanding.” Advisers then need to clearly define the scope of their advice. Hewes stresses there is nothing wrong with narrow advice, provided clients understand what is and is not being considered and the implications of those limitations. When assessing suitability, the FMA wants to see more than the final recommendation. “When we read the file, when we come into your offices, all we’re looking for is the reasoning. The trade-off, the alternatives considered, the clientspecific facts that actually drove the recommendation.” His message to advisers is simple: “Make the reasoning explicit.”


"...don’t just tell us, you need to now show us.” Records do not need to become lengthy essays, but they must contain enough information for the regulator to understand how the adviser reached the recommendation. “If the thinking was good, but the file doesn’t show it, you’ve done the hard work, but keep none of the benefit.”

Disclosure won't fix a conflict Hewes says conflicts will remain an “absolute priority” for the FMA, with a large-scale thematic review starting this year. He stresses that identifying conflicts is not a judgement on an adviser's integrity. Conflicts can arise structurally through remuneration arrangements, product relationships, targets, campaigns and non-financial benefits. “A campaign creates a time-bound incentive. Non-financial benefits can be just as influential as money.” But Hewes says simply telling clients about a conflict is insufficient. “Disclosure is important, but disclosure by itself does not neutralise a conflict.” The practical implication for advisers is that a disclosure statement alone will not demonstrate a conflict has been adequately managed. The FMA wants firms to show what controls reduce the potential influence of conflicts and to monitor advice for patterns of product concentration, replacement, switching and recommendations made around campaigns. “We expect you to be able to explain why the client's interests came first, not assert it, but actually explain it, with reference to what you did.”

Silence isn't necessarily good news Complaints will also receive greater regulatory attention. Hewes says good firms treat complaints and other signs of client dissatisfaction as valuable information rather than threats. “The best firms I see treat friction,

dissatisfaction and vulnerability signals as intelligence – free intelligence from the people best placed to actually give it.” Firms should capture expressions of dissatisfaction rather than limiting their complaints register to formal written complaints. He also warns advisers against assuming a low number of complaints proves they are providing a good service. “Low volumes of complaints can reflect barriers to complaining, or inconsistent capture.” “Silence is certainly no proof of success.” For advice businesses, that means looking beyond the number of complaints received and asking whether clients have easy ways to raise concerns and whether recurring problems are being identified.

AI doesn't shift responsibility The FMA is also undertaking work on the adoption of artificial intelligence in financial services. Hewes says the regulator is seeing AI used for onboarding, fact-finding, analysis, content generation, adviser decision support, monitoring and post-advice engagement. The FMA is examining both the opportunities and risks and considering how it should supervise its use. But its starting position is clear. “Technology may change the tool, but it does not remove the responsibility for the outcome.” If AI produces a recommendation, summary or client communication, the FAP remains responsible for understanding and overseeing how it is used. Hewes says meaningful human oversight is particularly important where judgement or suitability is involved. “Rubber stamp is not oversight.” Firms should also protect client information, maintain records of how AI contributed to decisions and test systems for bias, errors, drift and unintended behaviour. The adviser takeaway is that AI can

make an advice business more efficient, but it cannot become a black box. Firms need to understand what their systems are producing and be able to explain how those outputs contributed to client advice. The regulator is encountering AI from the other direction too. Hewes says some complaints received by the FMA are now clearly AI-generated, running to pages and sometimes citing legislation that does not exist.

FMA wants to make advice easier Hewes says the regulator's agenda is not solely about finding problems. Its recent work on access to financial advice reflects the FMA's view that more New Zealanders could benefit from advice. “We believe in advice, and we know that all New Zealanders would benefit from the advice you actually provide.” The FMA is looking at whether additional guidance or regulatory guardrails could make advice easier to deliver, including through digital technology and AI. However, Hewes says innovation has to improve access without compromising advice quality. The FMA also does not expect every FAP to operate identical compliance systems. “You know your business best. Size it right.” That leaves advisers with a relatively straightforward test: rather than asking whether every form has been completed, they should ask whether their records demonstrate the client was understood, the recommendation was suitable, conflicts were managed and the client could make an informed decision. Hewes says the regulator wants systems proportionate to the business, rather than compliance paperwork for its own sake. “The form question is one that generates a lot of paperwork. The outcomes question is the one that generates actual value.” : www.tmmonline.nz

015


UP FRONT

PROPERTY NEWS

Bursting the housing bubble The unwinding of the housing bubble after the Covid-era is nearly at an end, ANZ economists say. Enormous progress has been made in restoring house prices to a more sensible level and while it has undeniably been painful, it has been achieved without any financial stability wobbles, chief economist Sharon Zöllner says. “We should celebrate that progress; our economy is much more robust for it. But are we there yet?” Considering four long-term fundamentals - the house-price-toincome ratio; the Reserve Bank’s estimate of sustainable house prices; home ownership running costs; and, the house-price-to-build-cost ratio, ANZ’s economists judge house prices to still be a little above where the fundamentals indicate. The main reason for this is that prices appear to have not yet fully adjusted to the large increase in long-term interest rates that has occurred since 2021. However, the house-price-to-income ratio, which increased from a level

Poor policy needs to be axed ACT is on the path to encouraging the next government to remove rental loss ring fencing. Rental loss ring fencing was brought in to slow down the property market, at a time when demand outstripped supply. The New Zealand Property Investors Federation (NZPIF) says it was poor policy, distorting the tax system to try to lower demand instead of fixing the actual problem – lack of supply. 016

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026

where prices were about four times household income before 2002 to a peak of nearly nine in 2021, has since corrected back to six as house prices declined and incomes rose with inflation. The big question: where might the house-price-to-income ratio gravitate back to in the long term, is hard to know, the bank says. “Prior to the 2000s, a ratio of about three to four was typical and regarded as ‘affordable’. While a return to such levels would be great for first home buyer housing affordability, we are doubtful the ratio will get all the way back to there.” The ratio hasn’t been below five since 2004, and several structural changes mean the equilibrium ratio is likely to be higher than it was before the 2000s. On the other fundamentals, the difference between house prices and the cost to build is now historically low, but overall house-building activity is subdued as a share of GDP. That suggests there’s limited scope for further large falls in house prices

before construction of new housing drops away further. “There is a limit on how much further prices can fall from here in the long run,” Zollner says. “It’s also worth emphasising that some drivers of fundamentals can be hard to predict, such as where interest rates will trend in the long term. “We’re expecting interest rates to stay higher than they were through the 2010s. However, if interest rates start trending lower than we and financial markets expect, current house prices may prove to be more sustainable. “On the other hand, if long-term interest rates start trending higher than we and financial markets expect, house prices could come under further downward pressure.” Unwinding a housing bubble of the size we had is no mean feat, she says. “New Zealand is far better off with house prices now at more sensible levels. “Housing affordability for the next generation of first home buyers is much improved.”

NZPIF Advocacy Manager Matt Ball says if ACT can get the policy kicked to the kerb it will be a positive change. “It will encourage more people to invest in providing rental property, giving renters more choice and access to newer, better properties. It will help rental owners invest in their property, improving quality and features. It will benefit the construction sector, boosting jobs and local economies.” “When private investors fund building projects, the benefits go well beyond the worksite. Builders hire tradies, tradies buy materials, suppliers get more orders, apprentices get hours and local businesses benefit from workers spending in their communities.” “This is a win, win, win policy.” The federation says the way to fix a

housing crisis is with good housing policy, not bad tax policy. In recent years lawmakers have changed tack, introducing multiple policy changes to make it easier, cheaper and faster to build houses. Supply is up, rents and prices are stable, so it’s time to get rid of bad taxes, Ball says. This tax change will remove an upward cost pressure on rents; make it easier for new rental providers to enter the sector, to replace those who are leaving; make it easier for rental owners to upgrade and improve their properties; and encourage investment in new build rentals, supporting the construction sector. The removal of ring-fencing was the NZPIF’s number one policy goal during the election campaign.


Gap between buying and renting starting to widen again The costs of buying a house versus renting are just starting to widen again, with higher mortgage rates the key driver. The gap between new ownership and renting costs had narrowed in recent years, coinciding with a lift in the housing market by first home buyers. And over the past two and a half years home ownership costs declined as a share of income as flat-to-falling house prices and lower mortgage rates have offset higher costs from rates, insurance, and maintenance. The BNZ has now updated its estimates on the relative (cash) of owning versus renting, deliberately side-stepping the role that expected capital gains (or losses) can play in the equation. It focused only on cash costs, mainly to keep the comparison like-for-like. It puts the annual cash ownership costs for a new house purchase at about 35% of median household incomes. That compares to a peak of 50% in 2023. Rent costs, by comparison, have held close to 25% of household incomes, or a little lower once deposit earnings are allowed for. By region, the largest difference between renting and ownership costs is in Auckland. This reflects Auckland’s higher house prices and the additional debt servicing required. Wellingtonians might be bemused to see their new ownership costs being estimated as (just) below those in Canterbury, Mike Jones, BNZ chief economist says. “Contributing to this is the fact Wellington house prices have fallen by more than elsewhere but it is, in fact, the capital’s relatively higher incomes doing the work here – on a pure cash basis, ownership costs for Wellington are the second highest in the country.” However, the bank’s forecasts don’t imply anything like the sharp run-up in home ownership costs of 2021-23. What happens to house prices often ends up being the key swing factor. A favourable house price revaluation can easily offset, on paper, the higher day-to-day operating costs of owning a house. “For large chunks of history strong

house price appreciation has done just that. It’s impossible to know whether those days will return but our suspicion (and indeed our forecasts) imply it will be much more of a close-run thing than in the past,” Jones says. For example, a 2.3% increase in the median house price would, again on paper, offset the relatively higher cash costs of purchasing and running a house relative to renting. The bank has plotted this concept of the “breakeven” rate of house price inflation over time. The 2.3% estimate for the third quarter is higher than recent history but is still just below the long-run average. Jones says the concept may be a more important consideration for those with an investment mindset. “None of what we’ve outlined makes any allowance for the non-financial benefits of owning a home. That’s things like security of tenure and being able to hang your pictures up. “For many households, these factors will matter more than the numbers dropping out of our spreadsheet.”

Assumptions Ownership proxy •

A median house ($765,000 as at September) is financed with a 20% deposit and the

•

remaining 80% as (interest only) debt. Principal repayments are excluded as they are equity/ savings. Interest costs are split equally across six-month and two-year fixed mortgage rates. To these financing costs, the bank added estimates of typical maintenance, rates, and insurance costs. For the September quarter, these come in just under 2% of the median home price (about $14,500 on the $765,000 median). This estimate has increased from 1.5% four years ago.

Renting proxy •

•

A new tenancy is entered into at the current average rent of $570/ week, scaled up by 10% to reflect the median rental home value being below that of the median home. To make it a fair comparison, the bank subtracted from the rental cost the after-tax returns from leaving the 20% deposit – used to finance the house purchase above – in the bank earning interest (assume a six-month term deposit). Assuming the deposit is instead invested in the share market, earning potentially higher returns, doesn’t change the thrust of the results. : www.tmmonline.nz

017


UP FRONT

MY BUSINESS

Hands in other pies keeps mortgage adviser fresh Andrew Kay fits a lot into a working week – mortgage adviser, local board member, power board trustee and JP and he wouldn’t have it any other way. BY SALLY LINDSAY

B

eing a mortgage adviser though Simply Finance takes up about half of his 50-hour working week and having his “hands in other pies” serving the Counties Manukau community during the rest of his time gives him immense satisfaction. Pukekohe-based Kay was an ANZ business manager when he was invited to join Simply Finance as an owner shareholder. The FAP was originally created by a group of ANZ ex-bankers. Contracting to Simply Finance, each shareholder runs their own business under the brand, which is essentially a marketing company using Prosper as its aggregator. Although the company does all types of loans, Kay’s set of skills is more geared towards self-employed business clients, but he doesn’t limit himself. His expertise has extended to helping community housing providers raise sizeable bank loans to build new homes even though their income is mainly based on donations. He talks to TMM about combining his “main job” with his other community interests.

Was it difficult leaving a comfortable job to becoming self-employed? It was, yes, because you're going from the security of fortnightly pay

018

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026

down to a test of who you are as a person. My pay was cut by about 95%. I lived off the smell of an oily rag for about six months. I had conversations with my mentor about whether I was cut out for being self-employed. I had one settlement in two months and all I was seeing was cost, cost, cost. He told me to stick at it, follow the path and remember behaviours. At the end of the first year I looked back and thought there was something in it. By the end of the second year I had earned the same amount as my bank salary for half the hours. Then Covid struck. That wasn’t great but I learned one thing – build a trail income, so you can rely on it to sustain you in tough times.

What would you say to an adviser just starting out now? Would they need six months income behind them? At the least. We had some new advisers join during the Covid boom and I explained to them not to expect much in the first three to six months. New advisers need a growth


mindset and a hunter’s instinct, otherwise they are going to find it hard. We had an adviser completely new to the industry, with great analytical and people skills, but didn’t have the hunter mindset. They struggled, I understood and they were mentored, but realised after 18 months it wasn’t for them. That was disappointing but I learned a lot. On the upside, we have also had a couple of advisers move on to their own businesses and we have mentored them on that.

How did you build up your client base? Simply Finance was largely built on a gentlemen's agreement. We have a 'no dickheads' policy, as we call it. As time goes on, you just build up your book and your relationships with clients. And I believe in the 1+1 theory. You get one and

they refer you one, and then they refer you one. From one client and using my spreadsheet I can track down who has come from which client, and that allows me to thank them at the end of the year saying, you referred X, Y, and Z to me. I always like to give back and say thanks because without them I'd have no business.

Is Simply Finance across all lenders? All the banks except TSB. We had a direct connection with TSB for a number of years, but then it decided to go down the aggregator path rather than have individual agreements. There is no bank I haven’t been able to foster good relationships with and that works well for clients.

Now that the trail income is disappearing, do advisers need to add other things to their bow? Yes, and that's something that advisers need to pivot towards. No longer can advisers just rely on one form of advice – mortgages, insurance, or KiwiSaver. They have to build up a business. If they are looking to sell, they've got to have something to sell. For instance, having KiwiSaver is complementary to mortgage advice. Insurance is probably another good bow. I know an adviser friend, who has worked with us, who has put together a good business giving advice on mortgages, insurance and KiwiSaver using connections with registered agents and a lawyer.

Are you doing the same? I'm just focusing on mortgages, purely because of where my time is as an Auckland Council Franklin Local Board member, Counties Energy Trust trustee and Justice of the Peace (JP).

Subscriptions, streaming services and Afterpay are seen as the bogey banks’ use to refuse mortgage loans. How do you handle those conversations? I give clients pathways. Thankfully, most are not in that situation but if they are I just show

Andrew Kay From Auckland, lived in Epsom moved to Pukekohe 2013

Family Wife and two fur babies.

Outside Work Watching rugby, league, cricket, walking, regular brunch.

TV show NCIS, YellowStone.

Favourite book So many to choose from, but I like anything political / autobiographical.

Favourite music 60-80's rock, EDM.

Motto ABC, Always Be Closing .

them what it looks like behind door A, B, or C. If the serviceability is tight, and they are borderline, there will be a discussion on how they can give themselves the best possible chance of getting a mortgage. I have not met one client who will refuse that advice. Once they see what it will achieve they are committed. Then it is my job to impress upon the bank that if a client has a choice between buying KFC or making their loan repayment they are going to ensure their mortgage obligations come first rather than discretionary spending.

www.tmmonline.nz

019


UP FRONT

MY BUSINESS

‘Customer service is paramount – the stickiness, always touching base with them. It only takes five minutes to give them a call every couple of months.’

How much time would you spend on your mortgage business? There's no set time frame. I look at my week ahead and what I have on? And then I allocate time. So for the local board, it's about 16 hours a week, but can go up to 30 depending what's going on. For mortgages, if, for example, I've got three applications on the go, I'd probably allocate 20 hours. I spend about 50 hours a week spread across everything I do and seem to be more productive at night. I'll work right up to midnight or 1am to the annoyance of my wife, sometimes. However, I'm always swapping and changing.

Is it helpful for your mortgage business to be involved in these other aspects? It's more complementary. I wouldn't say it's helpful. I can't say I've received any business from my connections being on the local board or as a trustee or a JP. On the other hand, my council knowledge is helpful for clients as I know the ins and outs of the local areas. If they ask about specific areas to buy in I can point out if there is growth about to happen or not. I can explain to new homebuyers how rates work and what they pay for and as a trustee for the power board ensure the lines are resilient so the power doesn’t go off and help consumers with problems they might have. As a JP I sign a lot of KiwiSaver withdrawals for first home buyers. It is nice to have a second eye on whether the buyer is using an adviser or not, to point out what advisers can do and whether dealing with a bank directly is the best for their mortgage options.

Obviously you get paid for your local board and trust 020

TMM JUNE | 2026

work. How much of your income does that make up or do you rely on mortgage advice work for most of it?

approached by other mortgage advisers he tells them: “Andrew's my guy”.

Probably 50 to 60% of my income is from writing mortgages. As my local board and trust work are parttime gigs, the money from them goes directly into a savings account. That is what my father taught me as he was on the board as well. He was also a partner in a law firm and used that income for day-to-day living and the money he earned from the local board work was put towards his retirement fund. I am doing the same. I tend not to look at that account but it’s nice to know I have a little nest egg.

I don't charge extra, which is probably, in a business sense, not a smart idea. But I've always been community-minded, and I firmly believe that if you help someone, it will come back to you. It shouldn’t be an issue for any adviser, If you do a good job for that client they could refer you to other clients who may want big loans.

What do you think is the biggest mistake most mortgage advisors make? Expecting too much too soon and turning down potential deals, even $50,000 top-ups. Annoying as those small deals are because they take the same amount of time as a $500,000 mortgage, you never know where they end up. That client may come into a large inheritance, move on to bigger properties or have a change in circumstances. I've got one client who's recently settled, but when I met him six years ago, he was an immigrant, didn't have citizenship or permanent residency and his income was low. I kept in touch with him and he's now on quite significant income. He saved a 10% deposit and bought a flash lifestyle property after I gave him an honest opinion on several properties he looked at. He now has a good property with a reasonably big mortgage, which he can afford. By maintaining that relationship and being straight up with him, he says he will stick with me if he buys other property. Although he's been

Should mortgage advisers charge for extra advice?

What does it take to be a great mortgage adviser? Customer service is paramount – the stickiness, always touching base with them. It only takes five minutes to give them a call every couple of months. When the mortgage rate comes up for a review that is a chance for an indepth conversation to lay out goals and investment scenarios for the next few years. Always ask in the conversation if you can help their friends? I love connecting people and solving little small day-to-day problems.

If you were starting out now as a mortgage broker, what advice would you give to yourself? Join a bigger firm. Don't go it alone because you need the support of other advisers and admin staff. You need someone to back you on that because it's hard becoming a one-man band in this industry now, unfortunately. Join a firm that your values align with, you have a good relationship with, and the banter is fun. Once you get yourself sorted and settled, you can either choose to stay because you love working with the team that you're with, or go out on your own and create your own business. :


UP FRONT

HOUSING COMMENTARY

Property sellers face toughest market in 14 years Summary

The Pain and Gain Report is an analysis of homes which were resold over the previous quarter (excluding leasehold). It compares the most recent sale price to the home’s previous sale price, determining whether the property resold at a gross profit (‘gain’) or gross loss (‘pain’). It provides a proxy for the performance of the housing market and highlights the magnitude of profit or loss the typical seller of a home makes in each area.

Key findings from this report (for resales between 1 July 2026 and 30 September 2026) include:

Nearly one in six New Zealand properties is now selling at a loss, with Auckland and Wellington homeowners facing the toughest conditions. Cotality's latest Pain and Gain Report, released in November, shows 15.8% of properties resold during the September quarter made a gross loss, up from 13.2% in the previous quarter. It is the highest proportion of lossmaking sales since September 2012. However, 84.2% of sellers still made a profit, although that is well below the peak of more than 99% in late 2021. The median gross profit was $270,000, down from $440,000 at the market peak, while the median loss was $60,000. Cotality says the figures reflect the prolonged housing downturn rather than a fresh collapse in property values. National property values remain about 18% below their peak, with plentiful listings giving buyers greater negotiating power. Auckland remains the weakest major market, with 25.5% of properties selling at a loss. Wellington follows at 20.4%, Hamilton at 19.1% and Tauranga at 15.3%. Christchurch and Dunedin are performing considerably better, with lossmaking sales accounting for 7.5% and 6.9% respectively. Apartments remain particularly vulnerable, with 48% selling at a loss, compared with 22.5% of townhouses and 13.4% of standalone houses. Investors are also slightly more likely to lose money than owner-occupiers, with 16.4% of investor resales recording losses compared with 15% for owner-occupiers. How long a property has been owned remains critical. Properties selling for a profit had been held for a median 10.4 years, compared with 4.5 years for those selling at a loss. Cotality says sellers increasingly have to meet the market, although there is little evidence of widespread forced selling. For mortgage advisers, the figures highlight the risks facing recent buyers who need to sell or refinance before property values recover.

Key findings from this report (for resales between 1 July 2026 and 30 September 2026) include:

The proportion of properties being resold for more than the original purchase price ( i.e. a gross profit, or ‘gain’) in Q3 2026 was 84.2% – still a fairly high result, but continuing the slow drift downwards of recent years. Indeed, the latest figure was well down from the peak of more than 99% in Q4 2021 and also the lowest since Q3 2012. That’s fully consistent with the weakness for property values in recent years. Clearly, this remains a challenging market for resellers and the frequency of profits continues to fall – vendors are having to ‘meet the market’ more than they might have done in the past. But some context is also important. After all, this still means that more than four in every five property resellers are making a profit. Meanwhile, even though resellers make a gain less frequently than before, the size of those gross profits (when they occur) remains significant. The median resale profit in Q3 2026 was $270,000, well down from the peak of $440,000 in Q4 2021, but still higher than anything seen prior to Q4 2020. The latest median resale loss figure was $60,000, still hovering within a consistent range of $50 - $60,000 since late 2022. Hold periods remain a significant distinguishing factor. Properties resold for a gross profit in Q3 2026 had been owned for a median of 10.4 years, unchanged from Q2’s figure. By contrast, the median hold period for resale losses in Q3 was much shorter, at 4.5 years. Standalone houses tended to be owned for less than the overall average on both profits and losses, with townhouses and apartments higher. As always tends to be the case, standalone houses have a lower frequency of resale losses than other property types, but even so there was still a deterioration in Q3 – with the figure for a loss rising from 11.4% in Q2 to 13.4% in Q3. Smaller property types have tended to be sold for a loss more often, which isn’t particularly surprising given they are on less land and don’t tend to deliver as much capital gain over time – meaning they’re always more vulnerable to a loss (even in a market upswing). The splits by region and owner type are telling a fairly consistent message to previous reports, with Auckland and Wellington the weakest of the main centres . Meanwhile, there’s not a huge difference between resale performance of investors versus owner occupiers.

-

Overall, the latest weakening in the pain & gain figures is not a sign that the property market is collapsing even further. Instead, it’s a reflection of the large falls in values already seen, with more sellers just progressively having to make a deal in those softer conditions as each quarter passes.

4

© 2026 CoreLogic NZ Limited t/as Cotality. Proprietary.

Proportion of total resales at a loss - national

Q3 2026

15.8%

Q2 2026

13.2%

Source: Cotality Pain and Gain Report November 2026

www.tmmonline.nz

021


UP FRONT

FRAUD

Mortgage fraud: think it's genuine? Think again Mortgage advisers have long relied on payslips, bank statements and valuation reports to help tell a client's story. Increasingly, however, that story may not be true. BY SALLY LINDSAY

022

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026


www.tmmonline.nz

023


UP FRONT

FRAUD

M

ortgage fraud remains a persistent risk within New Zealand's financial system and appears to be on the rise, with complaints to the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) climbing from just one in 2023 to 21 last year. As artificial intelligence becomes more sophisticated, the ability to alter documents is making it easier for fraudsters to deceive banks, aggregators and advisers who are not alert to the warning signs. For advisers, the message from industry leaders is simple: trust, but verify. “There is no excuse for ignorance in the industry. Advisers need to be alert to the fact that this is happening,” says Bruce Patten, chief executive and managing director of New Zealand Financial Services Group (NZFSG). “It's as much about questioning and critically analysing paperwork and not automatically trusting everything that you see. If something smells wrong, do some more investigation. “You can't take everything just on face value anymore like you used to do.” Mortgage fraud occurs when information is deliberately misrepresented or concealed to obtain lending that would otherwise be declined or approved on different terms. This can include false information relating to income, employment, assets, liabilities, deposits or property values. Its organised nature, reliance on convincing documentation and involvement of multiple parties can make detection difficult. In some cases, mortgage fraud has also been linked to organised

criminal activity, with residential property used to generate, store or legitimise illicit funds.

Millions at stake While fraudulent applications account for less than 1% of mortgage lending, the financial consequences can be substantial. Across the Tasman, the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), which owns ASB, was caught up in what has been described as a A$1 billion mortgage fraud scandal. The bank self-reported concerns to authorities and has been working with regulators to assess loans allegedly supported by fraudulent documentation, suspect deposits and shell companies. Mortgage fraud can quickly escalate beyond hundreds of thousands of dollars, says Tim Larkin, the recently appointed general manager at Link Financial Group (LFG). “The problem is detection is difficult and it doesn't take many mortgage loan transactions before the numbers reach into millions of dollars of exposure for the banks, so I can understand the concern. Fraudsters these days are smart people, or they have smart people working for them. If a scheme does well enough and people are making money out of it over there, eventually someone will try it on here.” Mortgage fraud in New Zealand might be on a smaller scale but is still significant. In the biggest mortgage fraud case to date, a former lawyer, property developer and former bank employee were convicted for illegally obtaining $54 million in

home loans across 110 separate property transactions in Auckland and Hamilton. The scheme was designed to obtain cheaper lending for a commercial property development.

When AI enters the equation While mortgage fraud itself is nothing new, advisers are increasingly facing a more sophisticated challenge. AI and digital editing tools can make altered payslips, bank statements and employment records increasingly difficult to identify based on appearance alone. “That's why verification matters,” says Patten. “A document looking genuine isn't the same as the information being genuine.” If advisers suspect documents may not be authentic, they should verify key information using independently sourced details wherever possible, rather than relying solely on information supplied by the client, he says. “Keep a clear record of the discrepancy, what you asked and the response you received. If a concern remains unresolved, pause and escalate it through your compliance process before progressing the application. Never alter or omit information to make an application work.” Good advice sometimes means questioning a document that appears legitimate, challenging an explanation that does not quite fit or slowing an application down when there is pressure to move quickly, says Patten. Advisers still have plenty of opportunities to spot manipulated documents, says Warwick Slow, chief executive of the Kiwi Adviser Network

‘There is no excuse for ignorance in the industry. Advisers need to be alert to the fact that this is happening.’ Bruce Patten

024

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026


(KAN). “Most of what we come across is standard fraud tied to issues that were around well before AI existed. That won't be true forever, and advisers should assume the quality improves each year, but the defence doesn't change: verify at the source and ask enough questions that the story has to hold together.” To help address the issue, NZFSG's next version of its My Documents tool will include AI-enabled screening designed to identify whether documents have been altered. But the strongest long-term defence against document fraud will be open banking, says Slow, because information can be sourced directly from banks rather than through customer-supplied files.

the regulator's executive director of response and enforcement, including cases where borrowers themselves are victims and may not realise they are involved in a fraudulent transaction. “Some of those facets of mortgage fraud are more detectable than others. But from the work that we've done over recent years, we've identified several red flags that can show there may potentially be mortgage fraud happening.” Among the more common warning signs are incorrect information in mortgage applications, identity fraud, misuse of gifting certificates and the misuse of KiwiSaver deposits, she says.

The sharp end

Patten says suspicious activity often involves fictitious gifted deposits and properties being resold before settlement. Gifted deposits can involve inflated property valuations that create the appearance of equity or a deposit that does not actually exist. Where a deposit is described as a gift, advisers need to understand exactly where the funds originated and whether the supporting evidence aligns with the explanation being provided, he says Another area requiring scrutiny is

The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) sits at the centre of New Zealand's response to mortgage fraud and has several investigations under way at any one time. After assessing information and speaking with those who provided it, cases may be referred to the Serious Fraud Office (SFO), Police or investigated by the FMA itself. There are many different forms of mortgage fraud, says Louise Unger,

Red flags

contemporaneous settlements, where a property is sold before the original transaction has settled, often at a significantly higher price. A sharp increase in value is not necessarily evidence of fraud, Patten says, but it should prompt further investigation. “Does the purchase price align with the valuation and transaction history? Is there a reasonable explanation for the increase?” Slow says most fraudulent documents still carry “tells” and an adviser can pick them up if they know what to look for. One habit worth building is opening the document properties and looking at who last edited the file and when, he says. “A payslip modified by the applicant the night before it was sent is worth a conversation. That's not proof on its own, plenty of genuine documents get resaved, but it tells you where to ask the next question.” He also recommends reviewing email trails and enlarging documents to look for visual discrepancies. What KAN encounters most frequently is manipulation around affordability and the source of funds. Altered bank statements, falsified payslips, false gifting certificates, debts left off, balances adjusted - the common

www.tmmonline.nz

025


UP FRONT

FRAUD

thread is making an application serviceable when it isn't, says Slow. “Gifting certificates are part of that because the true source of funds is one of the easiest things to misrepresent and one of the hardest for an adviser to verify on paper.” Beyond that, it’s whether the story holds together, says Slow, adding that most of the time detection happens in conversation rather than in the documents.

Who gets caught? According to the FMA, some alleged mortgage fraud schemes have disproportionately affected specific ethnic communities. Patten says newer migrants can be particularly vulnerable, while struggling property developers may become tempted to use increasingly creative approaches to move unsold stock. The fraud itself can involve participants from throughout the property and lending chain, including valuers, lawyers, real estate agents and developers, says the FMA. What concerns Slow most, however, is the emergence of so-called property coaches operating around the edges of the industry. “There are individuals marketing themselves as property coaches, charging large fees to get people into homes. The coach pays off the client's short-term debt. So the mortgage application looks stronger than it is, then loads the customer with

more debt after settlement.” The clearest pattern in mortgage fraud is debt paid off quickly with no matching savings or proof of a sale of an asset,

‘Some of those facets of mortgage fraud are more detectable than others. But from the work that we've done over recent years, we've identified several red flags that can show there may potentially be mortgage fraud happening.’ Louise Unger, FMA

he says. “That’s usually the coaching arrangement showing up in the file. More broadly, the pattern is information that doesn’t reconcile - a deposit the banking history doesn’t support, an income jump that can’t be evidenced, repaying a debt with no history of the funds used or savings, a gift that isn’t really a gift. Any one of those can have an innocent explanation. Several together rarely do.”

Protecting yourself The FMA’s recent strong messaging has been about the need for banks, mortgage aggregators and advisers to be aware of red flags and to have appropriate systems and controls in place to identify, prevent and respond to mortgage fraud risks. Unger says mortgage advisers should work in tandem with banks to ensure their processes and controls work effectively across the lending system. “Ultimately this is about trying to mitigate and reduce people who are borrowing money from being the victims of mortgage fraud.” The country’s biggest home loan lender, ANZ, says it is continuing to invest in application fraud prevention to protect customers and the bank. While rare, mortgage fraud is a complex area, advisers play an important role in helping ensure home loan applications accurately reflect a customer's circumstances, says an ANZ spokesman. This includes advisers having a thorough understanding of a customer’s circumstances, the property transaction and how it has come together; carefully reviewing supporting documentation, checking that information is consistent and complete; and questioning or clarifying anything that does not look right. “People who are under financial pressure can be particularly vulnerable to scammers offering quick fixes, guaranteed loan approvals, or

Red Flags • • • • • •

Common third-party deposit sources, guarantors, business entities, or professional intermediaries appearing across multiple otherwise unrelated customers or applications. Income or employment patterns inconsistent with genuine servicing capacity, including income commencing shortly before application and ceasing or materially reducing shortly after approval or settlement. Deposit funds introduced shortly before application or settlement that are inconsistent with the customer’s historical savings behaviour or cannot be reasonably explained. Indicators of simultaneous lending across multiple financial institutions, resulting in understated liabilities or affordability assessments appearing more favourable than the customer’s true position. Property or settlement irregularities, including the vendor not being the registered owner, very recent ownership changes, or contemporaneous settlement arrangements without a clear and reasonable explanation. Post-settlement behaviour inconsistent with the stated purpose or financial position, including early refinancing, top-ups, restructuring, or transfers of funds to undisclosed third parties.

Source: NZ Police

026

TMM JUNE | 2026


assistance with house deposits,” says ANZ. “Customers should be cautious of anyone requesting upfront fees, asking them to share personal or banking information, or encouraging them to provide information on a loan application that is inaccurate or misleading.” Patten warns banks are taking a far more serious approach to mortgage fraud than in the past. As concerns about mortgage fraud escalate, an adviser will need to prove their innocence more so than in the past, he says. “What banks are going to do is critically analyse an adviser's work and the adviser will need to be above reproach if a question is asked. They can’t just look back and go: ‘Geez, I should have seen the signs there’.” The biggest risk is for advisers operating alone, he says, because larger organisations review thousands of files and are more likely to spot unusual patterns. “In a slow market, a single adviser under their own licence might be more prepared to make something happen.”

Spotting the bigger picture Larkin says banks remain in the strongest position to identify emerging fraud patterns because they see activity across large numbers of applications. “The banks are the only organisations with the scale and the ability to look into applications and identify where some of the fraud patterns may be forming.”

For example, fraud syndicates may form around developers, real estate agents or valuers, but individual advisers often only see one transaction and have limited visibility of broader trends, he says. “It is extremely difficult for an adviser to be able to identify that a particular development has had a high level of transactions and property turnovers if they have only been involved in one transaction. Banks can start to see the patterns forming a lot quicker.” Slow says the best way for advisers to protect themselves is to keep asking questions. “The more you ask, the more suspicious documentation starts to unravel. Any time something doesn’t quite stack up and you move on, you’ve given someone the opportunity to get away with it.” Advisers do not need to prove fraud before raising concerns, he says, while accepting obvious inconsistencies without asking further questions carries conduct, lender and regulatory risk on its own. “Stop, ask, get further evidence, document what you’ve done and escalate if it can’t be resolved. And don’t be lured in by a strong referral source if that referrer is trying it on with you.” The FMA can only be as effective as the information reaching it, says Slow, so it’s important the industry works together. “Advisers, aggregators, lenders and the FMA all see a different part of the picture. When we share what we’re seeing, the whole industry improves.” :

‘More broadly, the pattern is information that doesn’t reconcile - a deposit the banking history doesn’t support, an income jump that can’t be evidenced, a gift that isn’t really a gift. Any one of those can have an innocent explanation. Several together rarely do.’

Creating good habits The most important habit is simple: don't assess documents in isolation. Take another look when: • Income doesn't reconcile with bank credits, payslips or tax information; • Employment or business activity is difficult to independently verify; • The source of a deposit or gifted funds isn't clear; • Property information, purchase price, transaction history and valuation don't align; • Information changes during the application without a reasonable explanation; • Supporting documents conflict with information elsewhere in the file; • Independently sourced contact details don't match those provided; • There is unusual urgency or pressure to get an application submitted. An inconsistency doesn't mean fraud has occurred. It means there's another question to ask. Source NZFSG

Good questions Four questions to ask on every file when checking documentation for any sign of fraud: 1. If a client has suddenly repaid significant debt, where did the money come from? 2. If income has materially increased, can it be explained and evidenced? 3. If savings form part of the deposit, does the banking history reasonably support that? 4. And if a gift is involved, is it genuinely a gift, and can you establish the source? Keep copies of the original information, document the questions you asked and record the client’s explanation. Source KAN

Warwick Slow, KAN

www.tmmonline.nz

027


Visit the new look Good Returns website today. Good Returns has been the go-to news source for New Zealand financial advisers for 30 years. We’ve given it a full makeover from tip to toe to make it even better.

Amongst the new features:

More of our content is highlighted on the home page to make it easier to find Save articles to read later Read articles and log them against your CPD log Access our new Research Centre with White Papers and Research Watch, read and listen to our Good Returns TV interviews Give a thumbs up or thumbs down to comments Advertise for new staff

028

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026


www.goodreturns.co.nz www.tmmonline.nz

029


COLUMNS

SALES & MARKETING

THEY’RE INTERESTED. THEY’RE JUST NOT READY YET Paul Watkins explains how AI can help turn a quiet enquiry into a future client.

I

n the previous edition, I suggested that the biggest opportunity with AI was using it as your research department. Understanding what prospective clients worry about. Identifying gaps in your marketing. Discovering which questions you should be answering. Once you have those insights, what do you actually do with them? Here’s one practical application: use AI to help build an email follow-up sequence for people who are interested in your services but aren’t ready to make an appointment. You know these people. They download something from your website, ask a question, or say they’ll come back when they’re closer to buying. Insurance prospects say they need to discuss it with their partner. Then everything goes quiet. Some will have gone elsewhere. Others simply need more time, more understanding or a little reassurance.

030

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026

A useful follow-up sequence gives them reasons to keep listening. Choose one audience and one problem Start small. “Everyone who might need a mortgage or insurance” is too broad. For a mortgage adviser, your audience could be first-home buyers who want to purchase within the next year but don’t know whether they’re ready. For an insurance adviser, it could be self-employed people who are unsure what would happen financially if illness stopped them working. Choose one for your first sequence. The more clearly you define the situation, the easier it becomes to write something relevant. Let’s use first-home buyers as our example. Their immediate problem may not be finding the lowest rate. It may be embarrassment about their spending,

uncertainty about their deposit, or fear that talking to a broker means committing to something. Those concerns give your emails their purpose. Give AI the raw material. Before asking AI to write anything, gather ten or fifteen questions you regularly hear from this audience. Write them yourself from experience. There’s no need to upload client files. Include the awkward questions as well as the obvious ones. “Will you think we’re hopeless with money?” may be more useful than another question about interest rates. Then add your answers, including your process, your fees (if applicable), and what an initial conversation involves. This is where your expertise matters. AI can organise and simplify your material, but it shouldn’t invent your services, lender requirements or promises. You could use this prompt: “Help me plan five short educational


emails for New Zealand first-home buyers who have opted in to hear from my business. Their main concerns and my approved answers are below. Give each email one question to answer and one simple next step. Use plain, reassuring language. Do not invent facts, recommend products or imply approval is guaranteed. Flag anything requiring verification.” Ask for the outline first. Build a sequence that earns the next email. Here’s how that sequence might work: Email one: One welcomes the reader and answers: “Is it too early to speak to an adviser?” Explain what an initial conversation covers, what they might prepare and whether there’s any obligation. Remove uncertainty about contacting you. Email two tackles: “What does being ready actually look like?” Explain the areas you’ll discuss, such as their deposit, income, commitments and spending. Avoid turning

it into a universal lending checklist. Email three addresses: “What costs are we overlooking?” Help readers think beyond the deposit. Explain that legal fees, moving expenses, rates, insurance and maintenance deserve consideration, with costs depending on their circumstances. Email four answers: “What if our situation isn’t straightforward?” Discuss how you approach questions about self-employment, existing debt or a change in circumstances. Explain the process without suggesting every problem has an easy solution. Email five invites action: “Would a conversation help you work out your next step?” By now, you’ve demonstrated how you think and what working with you might feel like. The invitation has some substance behind it. Every email should be useful even if the reader never books an appointment with you. Make it sound like you. Once you approve the structure of the emails, ask AI to draft one email at a time. Give it a short sample of your own writing and ask for perhaps 150 to 200 words for each email. One question, one helpful answer, one invitation. Then read it aloud. Would you say this across the desk? Would your clients understand it? Has AI added a claim you need to tone down? Remove stock phrases like, “Embarking on your homeownership journey”; that probably isn’t how you speak. Something like this is more natural: “You don’t need to have everything sorted before we talk. An initial conversation can help you understand what to work on next.” Only use that wording if it accurately describes your service. AI gets you to a draft. Your judgement makes it yours. Put the follow-up on a sensible timetable. Your email platform or CRM handles the scheduling and sending. AI helps you prepare the content. As a starting point, you might spread five emails over three weeks. Treat that as a trial, not a magic formula. Explain at sign-up what people will receive. Obtain appropriate consent, identify your business clearly and include a functioning unsubscribe option. Don’t assume an old enquiry gives you permission for an ongoing marketing sequence. Set the system to remove people from the prospect sequence when they book or become clients. If someone replies, respond personally. Nothing spoils a promising conversation quite like receiving an automated “Ready to talk?” email after you’ve already talked. The same method works for insurance. An insurance adviser can use exactly the same approach with different questions. Keep it educational. This is the key. It must be genuinely valuable to the reader, not a sales pitch. Don’t let AI diagnose a protection gap

‘Every email should be useful even if the reader never books an appointment with you. ’ or recommend a particular cover option. Avoid fear-based subject lines. You’re helping someone consider a financial risk, not trying to frighten them into an appointment. Measure conversations, then improve them. Start by tracking how many people join, reply, book and unsubscribe. Look at how many appointments become suitable advice opportunities. Here is the next step that AI is great at. After a month or two, give AI the aggregate results and ask what you could test next. One question may generate replies while another produces little interest. Change one element at a time so you can learn something. Keep identifiable client information out of the exercise. Check every financial claim before publication and review the sequence whenever your service or relevant information changes. The aim is straightforward: answer the questions that keep interested people from taking the next step. Your previous research tells you what those questions are. AI helps you turn your answers into a repeatable follow-up. Next time I can explain how to use AI as a powerful business mentor. NOTE: There are now hundreds of AI tools, but I recommend the paid versions of either ChatGPT or Claude. Choose one, as they both work equally well for this kind of work. Each costs about $40 a month. :

Paul Watkins is a marketing adviser to the financial services industry. www.tmmonline.nz

031


COLUMNS

INSURANCE

Are two-year payment terms suitable options for income cover or mortgage repayment cover? Opinion: Two-year payment terms on income cover and mortgage repayment cover are common, but are they suitable for most clients? BY STEVE WRIGHT

032

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026


S

ome might believe that a two-year payment term will be sufficient because most periods of disability don’t last that long. But here is the problem: some clients will be disabled for a long term, even forever. A two-year payment term leaves a very big financial risk uninsured. Some might believe that adding lump-sum TPD to a short payment term will take care of the long-term disability risk, but there are weaknesses in this strategy too. • While some who are disabled longer than two years may be totally and permanently disabled, some will not. Some will be able to return to work eventually and some may be permanently but only partially disabled, neither of which results in a TPD payment. This again leaves a very big financial risk uninsured. • In any case, adding a couple of hundred thousand dollars of TPD Cover will not cut it for anyone with more than a few years to retirement. A 35-year-old, disabled on an income of $100,000pa would have earned $3 million to age 65 (assuming continuous employment) and that’s without any income increases. The additional lump-sum TPD Cover needed to compensate for a payment term of only two years (and assuming only 75% of income is insured) would likely be closer to $1.4 million (at 3% and again without income growth). You may find that $1.4 million own occupation TPD costs more than the same

income cover with a to-age-65 payment term! Can you imagine explaining to a client with a young family, who is disabled and with uncertain prospects of return to work, that their income cover claim payments will be stopping after 24 payments? I can’t: and for this reason, the go-to payment term recommendation for me in the first instance (for anyone with more than 5 years to go to retirement) is to-age-65 as least. So why a two-year payment term? In a word, it’s likely to be ‘budget’. Budget is almost always an issue, but is reducing the payment term the best tactic to reduce premium? For me, reducing the payment term should be the last resort for the following reasons: • A 2- or 5-year payment term leaves the client exposed to very large potential income loss, something they may not be able to recover from financially; • Increasing the waiting period can be very efficient at reducing premium and even at waiting periods of 13 or 26 weeks, leaves the client only exposed to a few months of lost income; something they are more likely to be able to recover from financially; • There may be other ways to trim premium. Dropping some inefficient options (expensive for what they provide) may be better strategically. A good example is the ‘Booster Benefit’ option,

which pays an additional amount, typically for the first three months of disability. In my opinion this can be inefficient, being relatively expensive considering the benefit paid. •

Splitting income or mortgage repayment cover into multiple payment terms and differing waiting periods may achieve a better compromise than simply reducing the payment term for the entire sum insured.

•

If your client is self-employed, suitable advice on ACC Cover Plus Extra may help, recognising that reducing cover under Cover Plus Extra is not always the right advice.

If a reduced payment term is recommended and agreed with the client, the Code requires that all the potential consequences of any underinsurance be explained to the client, so that they can make informed decisions about taking that risk. The underinsurance should also be flagged for review as soon as the client is able to afford to pay the increased premium that comes with a longer payment term, remembering the increasing a payment term in the future will probably require underwriting – so there is that risk too. : Steve Wright has spent 20 years in sales, product, and professional development roles with insurers. He is now independent and helping advisers improve business through training and advice coaching.

‘A two-year payment term leaves a very big financial risk uninsured’ Steve Wright

www.tmmonline.nz

033


The Top 10 stories on tmmonline.nz A lot has happened in the market since the last edition of the magazine. Here are the most-read industry stories from tmmonline.nz

01 VALE JOSH BRONKHORST [Obituary] Josh Bronkhorst. Josh passed away recently after a short battle with cancer. TMM Publisher Philip Macalister reflects back on Josh's time in financial services. NZ CEO Antonia Watson to retire; Ben Kelleher to take over.

02 NZFSG CALLS OUT BANKS FOR CHASING ADVISERS' CLIENTS

NZFSG is calling out banks for undercutting mortgage rates quoted by advisers, setting up a channel conflicts register as lenders fight harder for borrowers in a slowing market.

03 ADVISERS EMBRACE WESTPAC AFTER TRAIL COMMISSIONS REMOVED

Westpac is seeing some of its biggest ever flows from mortgage advisers despite the bank removing trail commissions earlier this year.

04 IN A SURPRISE MOVE OCR HELD AT 2.75%

It was a close call, but the Reserve Bank decided to leave the OCR unchanged today just days out from the election.

05 UNTRAINED BUSINESS MORTGAGE

ADVISERS COST BORROWERS TIME AND MONEY There has been a call for the entry level of business mortgage advisers to be lifted.

06 MORTGAGE SECTOR SLOWDOWN HIGHLIGHTED BY FAST BANK TURNAROUND TIMES

A recent significant drop in adviser-led mortgage business has been highlighted by bank turnaround times.

07 TELLA ROLLS OUT SIGNIFICANT CHANGES TO MYDASH AND NEWPARK

Tella upgrades MyDash from a CRM to a full advice platform. Plus, it changes at Newpark.

08 NEWEST NON-BANK LENDER OFFICIALLY LAUNCHED

MB Private has launched as a new non-bank lender, and it has the backing of Westpac New Zealand.

09 AVANTI FINANCE APPOINTS CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER

Avanti Finance has appointed Tracy Pennell as Chief Operating Officer, as the specialist lender strengthens its executive structure to create better alignment and clearer ownership across operations, risk and its business areas.

10 MEET PROSPA BDM RYAN DENNEHY-BEALS

Prospa business development manager Ryan Dennehy-Beals talks to TMM Publisher Philip Macalister about his new role at small business lender Prospa.

To keep up with all the news make sure you check www.tmmonline.nz regularly. Or you can get the news and rates update sent to you each day. 034

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026

Sign up to the TMM email newsletter. tmmonline.nz/newsletter-signup


www.tmmonline.nz

035


036

TMM NOVEMBER | 2026


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
TMM: Identifying Mortgage Fraud by TMM - The NZ Mortgage Mag - Issuu