Skip to main content

TUESDAY 10TH NOVEMBER 2026

Page 1

FG: Foreign Firms Mobilise $21bn to Invest in Nigeria’s Oil, Gas Sector Lokpobiri says two non-binding MoUs sealed with foreign investor groups Calls for more exploration campaigns to discover more barrels Peter Uzoho The federal government has secured

commitments from foreign investor groups to mobilise $21 billion in fresh capital for Nigeria’s oil and

gas sector, the Minister of State for Petroleum Resources (Oil), Heineken Lokpobiri, has disclosed.

The Minister said the commitments followed his recent engagements in Abu Dhabi, at the

just-concluded ADIPEC conference, where global investors showed renewed interest in Nigeria as a

diversification destination amid Continued on page 8

Oil Traders Seek Release of US-sanctioned Tankers Amid Vessels’ Scarcity, Soaring Freight Costs... Page 5 Tuesday 10 November, 2026 Vol 31. No 11538. Price: N400

www.thisdaylive.com TR

UT H

& REASO

N

$4.5tn Nvidia Faces Major Storm After CEO Admits to Inappropriate Relationship with Alleged Spy... Page 7

Amupitan: Nigeria’s Stability in Hands of Poll Judges, 375 Officers Sworn in for 2027 CJN, Fagbemi task lawyers on efficiency HURIWA warns against turning courts into victory markets for politicians INEC removes 1.6m invalid registrations from voters register Chuks Okocha, Alex Enumah and Adedayo Akinwale in Abuja

Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Professor Joash Amupitan,

has warned that the political stability of Nigeria would be determined by the verdicts of the Election

Petition Tribunal (EPT) set up to handle grievances arising from the conduct of the 2027 general elections.

Addressing this some 70 days to next year’s presidential election, Amupitan, SAN, said, while INEC

was saddled with the responsibility Continued on page 8

Tinubu Expands Campaign to More Cities, States to Match Atiku, Obi, Makinde’s Campaigns Considers campaigning across all 36 states in new strategy as train moves to Dutse, Ibadan Ex-Vice President’s Sokoto, Kebbi rallies put presidency on alert

INSURANCE DIRECTORS’ CONFERENCE...

Story on page 8

L-R: Special Adviser on Public Finance to the Honourable Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister of the Economy, Dr. Greg Ezeilo; Registrar/CEO, Nigerian Institute of Management (NIM), Mrs. Ganiyat Taiwo Olusesi; former President of African Development Bank (AfDB), Dr. Akinwunmi Adesina; Commissioner for Insurance and Chief Executive Officer, NAICOM, Mr. Olusegun Ayo Omosehin; President/Council Chairman, Chartered Insurance Institute of Nigeria (CIIN), Mr. Akinjide Orimolade; Deputy President, CIIN/Board Chairman, College of Insurance and Financial Management (CIFM), Mrs. Adetutu Arusiuka; Special Adviser to the President on Economic Affairs, Office of the Vice President, Dr. Tope Fasua; Rector, CIFM, Dr. Chizoba Ehiogu, and Actuary Partner, Ernest & Young, Mr. Miller Kingsley, during the 2026 Insurance Directors’ Conference held in Lagos...recently


2

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, T H I S D AY


3

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, T H I S D AY

"SF ZPV JOWPMWFE PS JOUFSFTUFE JO

/0/ 0*- &91035 #64*/&44

$POOFDU XJUI PVS OPO PJM FYQPSU UFBN WJB FNBJM BU $POOFDU XJUI PVS OPO PJM FYQPSU UFBN WJB FNBJM BU FYQPSUEFTLEFQBSUNFOU![FOJUICBOL DPN 03 FYQPSUEFTLEFQBSUNFOU![FOJUICBOL DPN 03 7JTJU BOZ ;FOJUI #BOL CSBODI OBUJPOXJEF BOE MFU VT TVQQPSU ZPV UP HSPX ZPVS CVTJOFTT


4

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, T H I S D AY


5

THISDAY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

Group News Editor: Goddy Egene Email: Goddy.egene@thisdaylive.com, 0803 350 6821, 0807 401 0580

NEWS

ONE DAY ROTARY GOVERNOR...

L-R: Rotary International District 9111 Governor, Rotarian Bukola Bakare; Winner of Interact Essay competition and One Day Governor, Diana Sodade from Ronik Secondary School Ejigbo, Lagos; Chairman District 9111 Interact Committee, Otunba Emeka Wilson Metus; and Principal Ronik Secondary School, Ejigbo, Mrs. Victoria Duru, during a press conference on Interact Week held at Rotary Centre, Ikeja GRA, Lagos, yesterday PHOTO: SUNDAY ADIGUN

Oil Traders Seek Release of US-sanctioned Tankers Amid Vessels’ Scarcity, Soaring Freight Costs Cost of chartering supertankers rises 10 times compared to before Iran conflict US sanction covers 1,568 ships, including 462 crude tankers Emmanuel Addeh in Abuja Some of the world’s biggest oil traders are seeking permission from the US government to return sanctioned tankers to service, as a global vessel shortage pushes oil transportation costs to unprecedented levels. Trafigura, Vitol, Mercuria and Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (ADNOC) are negotiating with US officials for licences to purchase or lease blacklisted oil tankers, Bloomberg reported. The talks involve about 50 vessels currently under US sanctions. Treasury officials are said to be considering approvals on a case-by-case basis, although no decisions have been finalised. The proposal comes after months of shipping disruptions stemming from the Iran war, which has forced tankers onto longer routes, increased insurance costs and tied up vessels in inefficient transfers around the Strait of Hormuz. The cost of chartering a supertanker from the US Gulf Coast to China, according to the report, reached nearly $80 million in October, roughly 10 times

the average rate before the conflict. Valero estimated last month that shipping US crude to Asia had reached $30 to $35 per barrel, compared with about $5 a year earlier. The soaring costs have already affected trade flows. Asian orders for US crude for November delivery

fell roughly 50 per cent in October, potentially pushing shipments to their lowest level in seven years. According to the report, adding sanctioned vessels could relieve some of that pressure. US Energy Secretary, Chris Wright, said last month that Washington was

exploring arrangements allowing investors to acquire and refurbish blacklisted tankers for transporting legitimate oil cargoes. As of November 4, US sanctions covered 1,568 ships, including 462 crude tankers, according to Treasury data compiled by Bloomberg.

The federal government, states and local governments are to spend about N70 billion over the next five years to implement the National Oral Health Strategic Plan (2026 to 2030). Minister of State for Health and Social Welfare, Dr. Iziaq Salako, unveiled the plan in Abuja at the commemoration of the 2026 National Noma Day and National Oral Health Week. Salako said the plan, developed through extensive consultation with the Nigerian Dental Association, other dental professional bodies, academic institutions, development partners and state governments, was part of the roadmap towards achieving universal health coverage for oral health. He said about 49 per cent of the

Many blacklisted tankers are also ageing vessels requiring repairs, inspections and insurance before entering conventional commercial service. The report however stated that US authorisation would not automatically remove restrictions imposed by the European Union (EU) or Britain.

NLNG Opens Entries for 2027 Creative Arts Prize, Appoints Advisory Board Peter Uzoho Nigerian filmmakers have been challenged to tell stories that reveal aspects of the country rarely seen on screen, as Nigeria LNG Limited (NLNG) opens entries for the 2027 edition of The Nigeria Prize for Creative Arts. The edition, themed, “Nigeria Unseen,” invites documentaries that bring lesser-known stories of Nigerian life to wider attention and examine

familiar subjects through perspectives that have been overlooked, including everyday experiences that rarely feature on screen. NLNG announced the opening yesterday in a statement signed by its Manager, Corporate Communications & Public Affairs, Anne-Marie Palmer-Ikuku. The company stated, “Following its inaugural edition in 2026, the competition returns with a prize of US$20,000 and is open to Nigerian

filmmakers aged 18 to 35, irrespective of their country of residence. “A three-member Advisory Board has also been appointed to guide the Prize’s development and uphold its standards of excellence. Award-winning filmmaker and producer Femi Odugbemi will chair the Board, with journalist and broadcaster Kadaria Ahmed and documentary filmmaker Joel Kachi Benson will serve as members as well.”

FG, States to Spend N70bn on Oral Health, Unveil 5-Year Action Plan

Onyebuchi Ezigbo in Abuja

But the potential benefit depends heavily on which vessels receive approval. Restoring previously idled tankers would add actual shipping capacity, while simply legalising vessels already transporting sanctioned oil would do considerably less to ease the shortage.

funding was expected from states and local governments, about 30 per cent from the federal government, and the remainder from development partners. “The costing of N70 billion is a minimum required to implement the strategic plan. It does not mean that if we have more, we cannot utilise it efficiently and judiciously,” he said. He stressed that Noma, a rapidly progressing gangrenous disease of the mouth and face that destroys tissues of affected children, should have no place in Nigeria in the 21st century. Salako stated, “What often begins as a simple gum infection in a malnourished and immunocompromised child can, within days, result in devastating facial destruction, disability and even death if left untreated.” The minister said Nigeria carried one of the highest burdens of Noma

disease in the world, particularly in the North-west and North-east, while survivors faced stigma, social isolation, and exclusion. Salako recalled that World Health Organisation (WHO) recognised Noma as a neglected tropical disease in 2023, a process Nigeria played a major role in ensuring, describing it as a landmark victory for affected children. He said Noma was preventable through good nutrition, exclusive breastfeeding, routine immunisation, proper oral hygiene, and prompt treatment of childhood illnesses, such as measles and malaria. The federal government, he said, had integrated Noma surveillance into the Integrated Disease Surveillance and Response System and was working to ensure primary healthcare facilities could identify and refer cases at stage

zero and stage one, when intervention was most effective. “No child should die or suffer permanent disfigurement from Noma in Nigeria again,” he said. He disclosed that the ministry had trained frontline health workers, traditional healers, and traditional birth attendants on early identification of Noma and other oral diseases in 19 states, leading to detection of cases even in the South-west and South-south. Salako also lamented the poor state of oral health generally, stating that over 80 per cent of Nigerians have never visited a dentist, two out of every three children live with untreated dental caries, while the dentist-to-population ratio is about 1:30,000, compared to WHO’s recommendation of 1:7,500.

According to the statement, the board would provide strategic direction, oversee the administration of the prize, and safeguard the integrity of its adjudication process. It said the board’s mandate will emphasise originality, artistic quality and compelling storytelling, while supporting a transparent and independent competition that remains responsive to Nigeria’s evolving creative sector. Speaking on the call for entries, NLNG’s General Manager, External Relations and Sustainable Development, Sophia Horsfall, said the new edition would build on the company’s support for Nigerian creative talent. Horsfall stated that the prize sought to recognise the quality of Nigerian filmmaking and encourage work that broadened public understanding of the country and its people. She stated, “Our support for The Nigeria Prize for Creative Arts reflects our confidence in Nigerian talent and our recognition of the work that goes into making good, structured content. Documentary filmmaking demands time, research and the patience to understand a subject before presenting it to an audience. “With ‘Nigeria Unseen’, we are encouraging filmmakers to pursue stories that deserve closer attention and tell them with care. We want the Prize to give outstanding work the recognition it deserves and introduce audiences to aspects of Nigeria they may not otherwise encounter.” Chairperson of the Prize’s

Advisory Board, Femi Odugbemi, said the theme offered considerable freedom in the choice of subject. Odugbemi encouraged entrants to consider not only what their films would reveal, but also how their treatment of a subject could deepen an audience’s understanding of it. “Nigeria Unseen’ does not necessarily mean travelling to a remote place or finding a subject that has never been filmed. It may mean looking again at something we pass every day and asking questions we have never thought to ask. “An unfamiliar subject is a starting point, but the filmmaker still has to find the story and establish why it matters. That requires research, access and the trust of the people whose lives are being documented. “We encourage filmmakers to test their assumptions and give the people in their films room to speak for themselves. The choices made during filming and editing should do justice to the complexity of their experiences. “A film should leave viewers with more than the knowledge that a place or a way of life exists; it should help them understand the people whose lives it portrays.” The company said the board brought together experience in filmmaking, journalism, creative education and media leadership. Odugbemi is Founder and Chief Executive Officer of Zuri24 Media, a member of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, and a cofounder of the iREP International Documentary Film Festival.


6

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 • THISDAY

NEWS

LEKKI PORT ART EXHIBITION...

L-R: Head of Department, Fine and Applied Arts, University of Lagos (UNILAG), Professor John Adenle; Managing Director, Lekki Port, Wang Qiang; Winner, Painting Art Exhibition Contest, Eunice Kolawole; Deputy Comptroller, Lagos Free Trade Zone Command, Nigeria Customs Service (NCS), Olufemi Kukoyi; and Port Manager, Nigerian Ports Authority(NPA), Emmanuel Anda, during the Lekki Port art exhibition held in Lagos, yesterday

Dangote: Our Refinery, Fertiliser Expansion to Employ Over 90,000 in Lagos Says 20 fertiliser blending plants to drive Africa’s agricultural revolution Peter Uzoho Africa’s richest man and President/ Chief Executive of Dangote Industries Limited, Aliko Dangote, has said over 90,000 people are expected to be working at the group’s petroleum refinery & petrochemicals and fertiliser operations in Lagos next year, as the group accelerates investments to create jobs, strengthen industrial production, and transform agriculture across Africa. Dangote disclosed this in an interview, where he also unveiled plans to establish 20 fertiliser blending plants in strategic locations across the continent to improve farmers’ access to essential inputs and support year-round supply. The projects form part of an invest-

ment programme that could reach $65 billion over four years, spanning refining, fertiliser, petrochemicals, power, pipelines, and other businesses. “The refinery expansion is huge. By next year, we expect to have almost 90,000 people working on the refinery and fertiliser projects in Lagos,” he said, in a statement issued yesterday. Dangote said creating opportunities for Africa’s youthful population was a central motivation for the group’s expansion, stressing that the continent needs more factories and greater domestic production to meet its growing needs. He stated, “My biggest concern is job creation in Africa. We have a very youthful population, and we are not creating enough jobs. We must push

harder to create opportunities and keep our young people productively engaged.” The refinery expansion will add another 700,000 barrels per day of processing capacity, taking the planned total to about 1.4 million barrels per day, alongside additional petrochemical facilities and infrastructure. Beyond energy, Dangote outlined a fertiliser expansion programme designed to help turn Africa’s agricultural potential into greater production, more reliable food supplies and economic opportunities. He said, “We also plan to establish 20 blending plants in strategic locations across Africa. We intend to begin mining potash and phosphate in Congo-Brazzaville very soon.”

He disclosed that the group was working towards nine million tonnes of urea capacity, with plans for 1.2 million tonnes of diammonium phosphate, DAP, and one million tonnes of NPK blending capacity in Lagos. Dangote said the objective was to ensure that farmers in countries hosting the group’s operations, as well as neighbouring markets, could obtain fertiliser when needed, without the uncertainty associated with lengthy import and delivery processes. He stated, “What we want is for the countries where we operate, and their neighbours, to have fertiliser available 365 days a year. Farmers should be able to buy it when they need it, without worrying about supply.”

Air Peace, Ethiopian Airlines Sign Interline Agreement to Enhance Connectivity Across Africa Chinedu Eze Ethiopian Airlines, Africa’s leading aviation group, and Nigeria’s leading carrier, Air Peace, have signed interline agreement to enhance connectivity across Africa and beyond. After signing the agreement in Lagos yesterday, the two airlines said the partnership marked a significant step towards strengthening air transport connectivity across Africa, other destinations, and expanding travel opportunities for passengers. Under the agreement, Ethiopian Airlines and Air Peace will collaborate through a bilateral interline arrangement covering both passenger travel and checked baggage services. The partnership enables each airline to issue tickets for eligible itineraries that include flights operated by both carriers, providing customers with a more convenient and integrated travel experience. Through the collaboration, passengers will be able to book qualifying journeys on a single ticket and enjoy through-checked baggage to their destination, where applicable. The airlines explained that the streamlined process eliminated the need for separate bookings and baggage re-checks, creating a smoother

and more efficient travel experience. The agreement links Air Peace’s domestic and regional network with Ethiopian Airlines’ vast international network spanning Africa, Europe, Asia, the Middle East, and the Americas. As a result, travellers departing from major Nigerian and West African cities will gain seamless access to Ethiopian Airlines’ global destinations through Addis Ababa, while international passengers arriving on Ethiopian Airlines flights will benefit from expanded onward travel options across Nigeria and West Africa through Air Peace’s domestic network. Commenting on the partnership, Ethiopian Airlines Chief Executive Officer, Mr. Mesfin Tasew, said, “We are delighted to partner with Air Peace, a leading carrier in Nigeria, through this strategic interline agreement. “This collaboration reflects our shared commitment to enhancing connectivity, improving customer convenience, and supporting the growth of air travel across the African continent. By combining our strengths, we are creating more travel opportunities and bringing Africa closer to the world.” Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Air Peace, Dr. Allen Onyema, said, “This partnership

with Ethiopian Airlines represents another significant milestone in our commitment to strengthening Africa’s aviation connectivity and bringing the continent closer together. “By combining Air Peace’s extensive domestic, regional network, and our growing international network with Ethiopian Airlines’ global reach, we are creating greater opportunities for seamless travel in and out of the African continent. “Beyond expanding travel options, this collaboration reflects our shared vision of fostering stronger economic, commercial and cultural ties across Africa and beyond.” Onyema said, “At Air Peace, we remain committed to building strategic partnerships that enhance passenger convenience, broaden connectivity and position African aviation as a formidable force in global air transport.” Both African carriers stated that the partnership was expected to contribute significantly to regional integration and economic development by facilitating the movement of people, businesses, and investments across Africa and the rest of the world. As African economies continue to pursue closer integration under the African Continental Free Trade Area

(AfCFTA), improved air connectivity remains a critical enabler of economic cooperation and sustainable growth. The airlines added, “The Ethiopian Airlines-Air Peace interline agreement will help bridge markets, connect communities, and create new opportunities for businesses and travellers alike.

Citing Ethiopia, he explained that fertiliser imports had to pass through Djibouti before being transported inland, creating logistical challenges that could leave supplies arriving after the planting season. “With local production, the fertiliser will be available there. We will also have one million tonnes of NPK capacity attached to the project,” he said. Dangote linked the programme to his determination that Africa should build the capacity to meet its own agricultural input requirements, rather than remain vulnerable to disruptions in international markets. “At the beginning of the Russia–Ukraine crisis, the African Union went to Russia to plead for fertiliser. I said then that, within four years, Africa should never again have to go anywhere to beg for fertiliser,” he said. He expressed confidence that sufficient access to gas would enable a much larger expansion in fertiliser production. “If Africa needs 30 million tonnes and we can secure enough gas, we can produce and supply it,” he said. He added, “Africa has an enormous agricultural advantage. We must lead the effort to turn that opportunity into a major agricultural transformation.” The group’s wider investment programme includes an initial ambi-

tion to develop 10,000 megawatts of power with some African countries and increase cement capacity to 100 million tonnes. Dangote said reliable electricity was essential to industrial growth, enabling African countries to process their raw materials, retain more value within their economies and create opportunities for their people. He disclosed that approximately $50 billion of the planned investment would go into existing businesses, while another $15 billion would be directed towards new ventures, including projects yet to be announced. The programme would be financed through a combination of free cash flow, internally generated equity and debt, he said. Dangote urged African investors to take the lead in developing the continent, stating that substantial domestic investment would encourage international capital to follow. He stated, “I am tired of hearing about ‘potential’. We have been talking about Africa’s potential for decades. But Africans themselves must invest in their continent. “What gives other investors comfort and confidence is seeing us put our own money on the table. That is what we are trying to do. We are demonstrating that we are serious.”

Awosika: Public Sector Reforms Must Be Driven by Trust, Consultation Former Federal Permanent Secretary, Dr Dere Awosika, has called on government to prioritise consultation and trust-building in public sector reforms, warning that top-down approaches could undermine implementation and sustainability. Awosika said successful reforms required engaging public servants responsible for implementation and citizens affected by policy changes, rather than imposing decisions without adequate consultation. She made the call during an episode of the Aig-Imoukhuede Foundation podcast, ‘Reform Is Not a Guessing Game’. Awosika said reformers must first identify institutional weak-

nesses and understand why existing objectives were not being achieved before introducing new policies or interventions. “Reforms are not supposed to be a pass-down of instructions. It’s supposed to be a discussion on the weaknesses, identify them, and see that the goals that you set to meet are not being met,” she said. The chief executive officer of Josephine Consulting Ltd. stressed that public servants and affected communities must be involved in designing implementation strategies to ensure that reforms reflect their interests and local realities. Drawing from her experience leading polio eradication efforts in Nigeria,

Awosika said engaging traditional and religious leaders helped address community concerns and secure public acceptance of vaccination. “We need to build trust with citizenry. They cannot believe us unless we trust them,” she said. Also speaking, an economist and policy strategist, Dr Akin Olusoji-Akinyele, said consultation should remain an integral part of the reform process, with feedback from beneficiaries used to determine the effectiveness of interventions. He said the success of reforms should not be measured solely by their implementation but by their impact on the people they were designed to serve.


7

THISDAY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

NEWS

WIMBIZ 25TH ANNUAL CONFERENCE...

L-R: Executive Director, Women in Management, Business and Public Service (WIMBIZ), Omowunmi Akingbohungbe; Keynote speaker/Chairman of Heirs Holdings, Tony Elumelu; and Chairman, Board of Trustees, WIMBIZ, Mrs. Ebisan Akisanya, at WIMBIZ 25th Annual Conference, held in Lagos, weekend

$4.5tn Nvidia Faces Major Storm After CEO Admits to Inappropriate Relationship with Alleged Spy Company’s shares slide, trim $220bn as board begins probe China denies spying claim, calls it smear campaign Emmanuel Addeh in Abuja Nvidia, the world’s most valuable listed company, came under pressure on Monday after its board opened an independent investigation into Chief Executive, Jensen Huang, over his relationship with a business executive US officials have linked to alleged Chinese intelligence. The stock, which trades as NVDA, fell more than 4 per cent in early trading to about $178, trimming about $220 billion from its market value. The company, which was valued at about $4.50 trillion on Friday, is now worth about $4.28 trillion, still ahead of any other public company. The probe followed a New York Times investigation published at the weekend. The paper reported that Huang had an intimate relationship with Alice Huang, also known as Huang Le, an executive at Megaspeed, a Singapore based data centre operator. The two are not related. Megaspeed had emerged in the past two years as one of Nvidia’s largest customers in Southeast Asia, with purchases estimated at more than $4.8 billion. US authorities are already looking into whether chips sold to the company were diverted to China in breach of export controls that bar the sale of Nvidia’s most advanced AI processors to Chinese entities. Nvidia’s board said that a committee of independent directors, supported by outside counsel, will examine whether Huang was targeted as part of a foreign intelligence effort.

“The board prioritises US national and economic security, which is paramount to the interests of Nvidia and its shareholders. While the board has no reason to believe that either national security or Nvidia secrets were compromised, the board’s inquiry will examine all available information,” the board said. Huang, 63, who co founded Nvidia in 1993 and has led its rise as the core supplier for the AI boom, told staff in an email on Sunday that he had been unfaithful to his wife. “I was unfaithful to my wife. My

actions hurt her and our children. There is no excuse for what I did. I am deeply sorry. I take full responsibility for what I did and the hurt I caused,” he stressed. “Regarding the national security concerns raised in news reports, Nvidia’s Board of Directors has initiated an independent investigation. I support the investigation and will cooperate fully,” he added. The case lands at a sensitive moment for Nvidia and the broader AI trade. The company sits at the centre of US efforts to maintain a lead in artificial

intelligence while restricting China’s access to cutting edge computing. Washington has tightened rules since 2022 to block sales of Nvidia’s most powerful chips to China, and Singapore has become a focal point for enforcement. Investors are also watching Nvidia’s balance sheet shift. The company has moved beyond being just a chip seller to financing parts of its customer ecosystem, with financial commitments under its neocloud partner programme rising to $165 billion in the last quarter. In Beijing, foreign ministry spokes-

Aggrieved houseboat workers yesterday, protested at the Federal High Court in Port Harcourt, Rivers State, over 34 months unpaid salaries arising from the alleged failure of the Nigerian Army to pay boat owners and contractors. The protest coincided with the hearing of a suit instituted by three indigenous houseboat contractors in the Niger Delta over the allegedly unpaid rental services. The suit was instituted by Peaches Integrated Services Limited, Etucom

When the AI boom took off in 2022, demand for its processors exploded. Its H100, Blackwell and now Rubin chips became the workhorse of AI data centres, turning Nvidia from a niche gaming supplier into the world’s most valuable listed company, worth more than $4.5 trillion at its peak with annual revenue above $130 billion. Because its technology is considered strategic, the US government since 2022 has barred it from selling its most advanced chips to China, a restriction that has put its sales routes through Southeast Asia under close scrutiny.

Lagos Business School Alumni Seek Leadership, Capital, AI-Driven Innovation to Boost Nigeria’s Economic Growth Funmi Ogundare The Lagos Business School Alumni Association (LBSAA), yesterday, called for stronger leadership, increased capital mobilisation, and adoption of Artificial Intelligence (AI)-driven innovation to accelerate Nigeria’s economic growth. The president of the Owner Manager Programme of the association (OMP 40), and Chief Executive Officer of Microwave Solutions Limited, Michael Ekeagbara, made the call while briefing journalists on the association’s forthcoming homecoming activities. The event will feature an Alumni Day Conference, themed, “Driving Nigeria’s Economic Transformation

through Leadership, Capital and AIdriven Innovation,” and a President’s Dinner, themed, “Leadership and Resilience in the New Frontier,” scheduled to hold on November 12 and 13 at Harbour Point, Victoria Island, Lagos. Ekeagbara said the meeting was designed to move conversations about Nigeria’s ambition of building a $1 trillion economy beyond rhetoric by bringing stakeholders together to develop actionable policy recommendations that could influence national economic planning. He explained that leadership, capital and AI were deliberately selected as the three pillars of the conference because of their importance to sustainable economic

development. According to him, “Leadership provides the vision and direction required to drive economic policies and ensure effective execution, while capital remains essential for financing initiatives capable of transforming the economy.” On Artificial Intelligence, Ekeagbara said no economy aspiring to remain competitive could afford to ignore the technology, stressing that rather than making people lazy, AI would change how work is done and promote smarter productivity. The meeting, the president stated, would feature keynote presentations, fireside chats, and panel discussions involving experts across leadership, finance, and technology, with a view

Aggrieved Houseboat Workers Protest Over Unpaid 34 Months Salaries Blessing Ibunge in Port Harcourt

man Guo Jiakun on Monday dismissed any Chinese role. “The so called Chinese spy allegation is groundless. It is nothing but a smear against China,” he said at a regular briefing. Nvidia is due to report third quarter results next week, on November 17. The American chip company powers most of the world’s artificial intelligence. Founded in 1993 in California by Huang and two engineers, it started making graphics chips for video games but later discovered those same chips were ideal for training AI models.

Integrated Services Limited, and Godsam Industrial Services Limited, seeking to compel the Attorney General of the Federation, the Chief of Defence Staff, and the Commander of the Joint Task Force (JTF), Operation Delta Safe, to settle outstanding debts. When the matter came up in court on Monday, counsel for the plaintiffs, Mr. Reuben Wanogho, informed the court that the matter was for preliminary objection. As at the time the matter was mentioned in court only counsel for

the first defendant was present when the matter was mentioned. The trial Judge, Justice Stephen Daylop Pam thereafter adjourned the case till November 18, this year for hearing of the preliminary objection on the matter. Meanwhile, the protesters, carrying placards, called on President Bola Tinubu and the National Assembly to intervene and compel the military authorities to pay what they described as their legitimate entitlements. Some of the inscriptions on their placards read: “National Assembly

intervene now! Houseboat contractors are not slaves”, “Mr. President hear our cry, pay our contractors”, “Our families are hungry, our children are suffering. Pay us our monies”, and “We believed in the Renewed Hope Agenda of Mr. President. Save our soul - 34 months unpaid”. Others read: “DHQ injustice to Niger Delta contractors”, “Pay us for our 34 months houseboat supply services”, “Our sweat, our labour, our right”, and “Enough is enough. Army is on our boat, but refused to pay for the services”.

to developing practical recommendations for policymakers. He stated that the association, with more than 10,000 members drawn from the public and private sectors, including industry leaders and policymakers, was strategically positioned to contribute to national development. He said the gathering was also an opportunity for alumni to leverage the knowledge, experience, and resources acquired through their association with the institution to give back to the country. “This is not just an event for LBS alumni to come and discuss. It is an event with the objective of giving back inputs that will help shape Nigeria’s policy towards economic growth,” he said. President of the Alumni Association and Chief Executive Officer of Neimeth Pharmaceuticals PLC, Valentine Okelu, said the gathering would provide a platform for members and other influential stakeholders to exchange ideas and develop principles that could shape governance and economic policies in the country. Okelu explained that the conference would bring together members of the association, alongside non-members occupying strategic positions in the political, economic, social, entertainment and academic sectors, to discuss issues affecting national development. According to him, “The objective is to harness the diverse experience and expertise of participants to generate

ideas that could influence how the country is governed and its economy managed.” He described the conference as the intellectual and academic component of the homecoming, stating that participation would extend beyond alumni members to other stakeholders interested in the issues under discussion. Okelu said the president’s dinner will provide an opportunity for alumni members and invited guests to network and strengthen professional relationships, adding that it would also feature the inauguration of the association’s new executive committee, which he leads as president. Equally speaking, the vice president of the association, Wole Abu, said the conference was designed to provide a platform for stakeholders across different sectors to examine critical national issues, exchange ideas, and identify opportunities for businesses to thrive. Abu stated that national development should not be left to government policies alone, stressing the need to create an enabling environment for enterprises to grow, generate employment and contribute to economic prosperity. He stressed, “Developing a country is not just about government policy; it is also about making sure that enterprises can thrive and grow, employ and contribute to the economy. And that’s what the alumni day does.”


8

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 • THISDAY

EIGHT

Stanbic IBTC Bank Rolls Out Naira-RMB Direct Payment Platform CBN hails rollout as landmark development

Dike Onwuamaeze

Stanbic IBTC Bank has rolled out its Cross-border Interbank Payment System (CIPS) that allows Nigerian businesses to initiate transactions in Naira and settle directly in Renminbi (RMB). The CIPS will drastically cut transaction processing times from several days down to a matter of hours, minimise exchange-rate exposure risks for local businesses, and inject predictability into the bilateral trade corridor between Nigeria and China. CIPS was launched yesterday in Lagos by Chief Executive Officer of Stanbic IBTC Bank, Mr. Wole Adeniyi, in an event, titled, “CIPS

Go-Live Ceremony.” Adeniyi said, “What really made it possible for us to do this is because our group, Standard Bank Group, is a direct participant in the China cross-border interbank payment system. “As a direct participant, we are able to connect and bring this service seamlessly to our clients in Nigeria.” He said the platform would drive business between Nigeria and China as part of the Stanbic IBTC and Standard Bank Group’s goal of strengthening transactions and connection between Nigeria and China. In his presentation, Head, Transaction Banking, Stanbic IBTC Bank, Mr. Jesuseun Fatoyinbo, said CIPS

would support faster, efficient, and reliable cross-border RMB clearing and settlement. According to Fatoyinbo, CIPS is a purpose built clearing and settlement rail for international RMB payment. He said, “It is really about connecting you directly into that destination. It is like a direct flight out of Lagos for your payment into China. “And why this is important is not just about the payment itself, but about the commercial opportunity behind the payment. “CIPS creates a faster, a costefficient and efficient alternative. So while we continue to have multi-city flights or connecting flights into multi-city, CIPS comes as the

direct flight into China.” He explained that at the heart of CIPS was a market infrastructure that China has introduced on a global scale to help the clearing and settlement of cross-border payments. He said that CIPS did both the clearing and settlement and creates efficiency, cost reduction, eliminates complexity, and introduces simplicity, which improves the overall value or benefit for client. Fatoyinbo said what took the traditional rail between 48 and 72 hours to accomplish, CIPS could get done in 24 hours. “Overall, it is that we are delivering real value that delivers speed, that makes the process and

the experience simpler, but more importantly, delivers tangible value in terms of financial benefits to clients,” he said. Director, Trade and Exchange Department of Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), Ms. Aderinola Shonekan, in her goodwill message described the rollout of CIPS as a landmark development. Shonekan, who was represented by an Assistant Director, Trade and Exchange, Lagos, CBN, Mrs. Nnenna Ann Ezekannagha, said Nigerian importers and entrepreneurs had faced systemic hurdles, primarily driven by transaction delays, multiple currency conversions, and high settlement volatility associated with over-reliance on third-party

Mr. Wole Adeniyi intermediary currencies, despite the fact China is one of Nigeria’s largest trading partners, but for years She said the integration of Stanbic IBTC into China’s CIPS would provide a definitive, cuttingedge solution to these historical bottlenecks.

TINUBU EXPANDS CAMPAIGN TO MORE CITIES, STATES TO MATCH ATIKU, OBI, MAKINDE’S CAMPAIGNS Olawale Olaleye Some events of the last few days might have compelled President Bola Tinubu to substantially revise his initial plan to personally campaign in only 12 states, as political developments across northern Nigeria, particularly the growing visibility of former Vice President Atiku Abubakar threatens to complicate the re-election calculations of the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC). With nearly 63 per cent of Tinubu’s 2023 presidential votes coming from the 19 northern states, the battle to retain that support has become central to his second term ambition. The changing political atmosphere in northern Nigeria, has forced Tinubu to reconsider the scope of his personal campaign appearances ahead of the January 16, 2027 presidential election, with the possibility of extending his

tour to all 36 states of the federation instead of the initial 12 states announced in the released. Apart from the challenge posed by Atiku, Mr. Peter Obi of the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC) and Seyi Makinde of the Allied People’s Movement (APM), the adjustment to the ruling party’s strategy may also be forced by the growing displeasure over economic hardship and insecurity in sections of the north. The possibility of an expanded presidential tour acquired greater significance following the impressive public reception accorded Atiku, the African Democratic Congress (ADC) presidential candidate, during the formal commencement of his campaign in Sokoto on November 4. However, Tinubu’s visit to Jigawa State today for an APC presidential campaign rally and the inauguration of four development projects as well as

Ibadan in the coming days buttresses the new thinking in his camp. The ADC had publicly interpreted the large gathering as evidence of growing discontent with the Tinubu administration and increasing acceptance of Atiku’s promise to make life more affordable. While the size of political rallies cannot be treated as conclusive evidence of electoral strength, the development has reinforced the need for APC to reassess the political temperature in a region that played a decisive role in Tinubu’s emergence as president in 2023. It has also raised questions of whether the president can afford to delegate much of his northern campaign to governors, ministers, and other party leaders, when his principal opponent is personally engaging communities where economic hardship and insecurity have become

sensitive political issues. The president’s recent campaign activity has already demonstrated that the original schedule is not immutable. On November 6, he attended a political rally in Akwa Ibom State, which was outside the 12 states earmarked for his personal appearances, before proceeding to Rivers on November 7. Although there has been no formal announcement expanding his North-west itinerary, the Akwa Ibom rally attendance suggests that additional presidential appearances remain a practical possibility. The greater consideration, however, is not merely the number of states Tinubu visits, but what he intends to achieve in those states.

The 62 Per Cent That Made Tinubu President The clearest explanation, perhaps,

AMUPITAN: NIGERIA’S STABILITY IN HANDS OF POLL JUDGES, 375 OFFICERS SWORN IN FOR 2027 of managing the ballot, deploying technology, and safeguarding the voter franchise, the EPT on the other hand stood as the ultimate guardians of democratic legitimacy. The INEC boss, spoke at the swearing-in ceremony of 375 judges nominated to serve on the Election Petition Tribunals for the 2027 general election. He pointed out that when political contestations overflow from polling units into the courtroom, the judiciary provides the constitutional sanctuary where grievances are transformed into peace, unlawful shortcuts are corrected, and the sovereign choice of the electorate is vindicated under the Rule of Law. “Let me emphasise, my Lords, that the stability of our electoral process, and as a matter of fact of Nigeria, is very, very important for the continent of Africa. Because Nigeria is the largest democracy in Africa, and so, so many countries look up to Nigeria for guidance. “I recall at a meeting of EMBs of Africa in Egypt, most people were wishing me well. And I remember all the EMBs’ heads from other African countries, two of them, for that matter, the EMB head of Kenya, said, ‘we want you to succeed. Because whatever happens in Nigeria will happen in Kenya. “And also, the EMB chair of Ghana echoed the same thing. ‘Whatever happens in Nigeria is just a matter of time. It will happen in Ghana and other African countries.’ “So that is why it is so important that we see our role as a tool of political stability, not just in Nigeria, but on the continent of Africa,” Amupitan said. According to him, the Election Petition Tribunal is not a mere postelection administrative panel; but

one that serves as a constitutional valve that releases political pressure and prevents electoral friction from devolving into civil disruption. He stressed that when the tribunal functions with procedural speed, evidentiary rigor, and absolute impartiality, it achieves three vital democratic outcomes: de-escalation of conflict: institutional accountability: and preservation of the social contract. “Conversely, where judicial adjudication is perceived as unpredictable, excessively technical, or delayed, political stability is threatened. “The election tribunal is therefore not merely an arbiter of private disputes between candidates; it is an active engine of national stability and constitutional order,” he said. While observing that electoral litigation has become increasingly complex with the introduction of technology, the chairman urged that technology must be assessed within the framework of the Constitution, the Electoral Act and applicable regulations, adding that it should neither be treated as infallible nor discounted simply because the evidence is electronic. “A clear distinction must be maintained between the generation of technological information, the statutory purpose it serves and the legal standard required to prove a case before a tribunal. “My Lords, the threat matrix confronting our democratic process has expanded beyond traditional physical challenges like ballot snatching. “We have entered an era of digital information manipulation, powered by Artificial Intelligence, high-fidelity audio cloning, deepfake video generation, and Foreign Information Manipulation and

Interference (FIMI),” he added. According to Amupitan, during election periods, malicious actors will attempt to disrupt the electoral process through three primary digital threat vectors: He listed such to include, Synthetic Operational Directives: AI-generated audio or text messages impersonating election officials, claiming that polling units in specific strongholds are relocated or canceled to suppress voter turnout. Eve-of-Poll/Blackout Window Attacks: Deepfake audio or video drops released during statutory broadcast blackouts—hours before polls open—impersonating candidates or electoral officials confessing to fraudulent deals, exploiting the timeframe when official rebuttals struggle to gain traction.

Fake Declaration Videos: Cloned videos of Returning Officers falsely declaring premature election results in battleground constituencies to trigger civil unrest before official collation concludes. He advised that to safeguard political stability, tribunals must apply rigorous evidentiary standards under Section 84 of the Evidence Act regarding electronic evidence, adding that demonstrating digital provenance, forensic chain of custody, and reliance on certified data directly from INEC would be vital to prevent synthetic digital fabrications from misleading the courts. Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Justice Kudirat Kekere-Ekun and the Attorney General of the Federation Continued on page 26

for the emerging campaign dilemma lies in the electoral arithmetic of 2023. According to the presidential election results declared by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Tinubu secured 8,794,726 votes nationwide, defeating Atiku, who received 6,984,520 votes, and Peter Obi, who obtained 6,101,533 votes. Rabiu Kwankwaso, who contested on the platform of New Nigeria Peoples Party (NNPP), received 1,496,687 votes. A closer examination of the results reveals that Tinubu obtained approximately 5,507,784 votes from the 19 northern states alone. That represents 62.6 per cent of his entire national tally, meaning that nearly two out of every three votes credited to Tinubu came from the north. This is fundamental. It establishes that Tinubu’s victory was significantly dependent on northern voters, notwithstanding his status as South-west political leader and the strong support he enjoyed in his traditional regional base. Indeed, the 2023 figures show that his advantage over Atiku across the 19 northern states was approximately 348,505 votes, a comparatively narrow margin given the size of the region. The North-west contributed approximately 2.65 million votes to Tinubu’s total, while the North-central delivered about 1.67 million, and the North-east did approximately 1.19 million. The implication is unmistakable: the north was not simply an additional source of support, it constituted the foundation upon which Tinubu’s national electoral coalition rested. Losing a substantial proportion of that support in 2027 could place considerable pressure on his re-election

chances, even if he improves his performance elsewhere. That is particularly important because the 2027 contest is unfolding under circumstances markedly different from those of 2023. Tinubu is no longer an oppositionstyle candidate promising a departure from an existing government. He is the incumbent president defending his own economic policies, security record, and administrative decisions. The electoral calculation this time is less about what he promises to do and more about how Nigerians judge what his administration has already done.

Why the North-west Has Become Critical Battlefield Of the three northern geopolitical zones, the North-west presents, perhaps, the most consequential political challenge. With seven states — Kano, Kaduna, Katsina, Jigawa, Kebbi, Sokoto and Zamfara — it contains some of the country’s largest voting populations and has historically played a major role in determining presidential outcomes. In 2023, Tinubu obtained 2,652,235 votes from the region, compared with Atiku’s 2,329,540. This gave Tinubu a zonal advantage of just 322,695 votes. The result, however, concealed a much more complicated electoral pattern. Atiku actually won four of the seven states: Kaduna, Katsina, Kebbi and Sokoto. Tinubu won Jigawa and Zamfara, while Kwankwaso defeated both men in Kano. Consequently, although Tinubu secured the highest aggregate number of votes in the North-west, he did not dominate the region in terms of the number of states won. Continued on page 27

FG: FOREIGN FIRMS MOBILISE $21BN TO INVEST IN NIGERIA’S OIL, GAS SECTOR

geopolitical risks in the Gulf region. Lokpobiri stated this yesterday in Lagos, at the opening of the 44th annual international conference of the Nigerian Association of Petroleum Explorationists (NAPE), with the theme, “Unlocking More Barrels, Driving Reserve Growth through Exploration, Local Capabilities and Adaptive Technologies.” Lokpobiri said the government was linking the foreign groups to Nigerian companies to discuss commercial details, as part of efforts to mobilise capital for development at a time Western lenders are restricting funding to Africa. He said: “I can assure you that we had one or two non-binding MOUs with groups. One group is willing to mobilise $15 billion to invest in Nigeria. And their argument is that we know that in terms of spare

capacity, it is more in the Gulf region. But with what has happened in the Strait of Hormuz, it is important for companies that have money to diversify their investments in terms of locations. “Some of them are willing to come to Nigeria and invest. So, if there is any disruption in one location, the investment in Nigeria will continue to sustain your cash flow. There’s another group that is committing $6 billion. And so, what I’m doing is linking those companies, those groups to companies in Nigeria.” The Minister said he was deepening collaboration between the foreign groups and local operators, noting that some chief executives at the conference were already in discussion with him. He said he was not interested in

the commercials, but in bringing the parties together to negotiate details. Lokpobiri said the push for new capital was necessary because the West has weaponised access to capital against the Global South, particularly Africa. That, he said, led to the creation of the African Energy Bank. He recalled that on October 31, 2026, the President of Afreximbank and the President of the African Petroleum Producers’ Organisation (APPO) came to Nigeria for the formal launch of the bank. According to him, the bank’s annual general meeting had been held, conditions precedent met, and a president and board appointed, adding that it set to formally take off on January 4, 2027 in Abuja. The Minister said discussions with the incoming investor groups also

include how to position the African Energy Bank to raise funding for the industry. Lokpobiri reviewed the progress made since his appointment in August 2023, when he said the industry was in coma state and oil production was about one million barrels per day, inclusive of condensates. “When I was appointed minister in August 2023, the industry was in comatose. Our production was about a million barrels, inclusive of condensates. And now NUPRC is here, I think the records as of today show that we are doing over 1.8 million barrels per day,” he said. He said the mandate given by President Bola Tinubu was to build a bigger pie that the federation can Continued on page 25


9

THISDAY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

NEWS

NIGERIAN ALLIANCE FOR CLEAN COOKSTOVES INDUSTRY STAKEHOLDERS CONFERENCE...

L–R: Managing Director, Century 1, Mr. Chidera Ezigbo; Management Executive, Shree Sai Engineering Limited, Mr. Olalekan Alawoya; National Coordinator, Fire and Allied Chemicals Association of Nigeria (FACAN), Abulrazaq Baba; Head of Sales, BetterGas Energy Limited, Mr. Benjamin Olusegun; Head, Mechanical Engineering Unit, Standards Organisation of Nigeria (SON), Engr. Ega Ijachi; Managing Director, Megatron Investment Services Limited, Mr. Chris Igbine; and Chief Operating Officer, FuelTree Limited, Mr. Godwin Okoduwa, after a panel session during Nigerian Alliance for Clean Cookstoves (NACC) Industry Stakeholders conference held in Abuja... recently

Dele Oye: Nigerians Should Judge Tinubu’s N68.3tn 2026 Budget by Impact, Not Size Proposes 40% debt-to-revenue guardrail by 2028 Wants confusion over oil benchmark addressed Says election spending can put further pressure on current deficit Emmanuel Addeh in Abuja A former President of the Nigerian Association of Chambers of Commerce, Industry, Mines and Agriculture (NACCIMA), Dele Oye, has said Nigerians should judge President Bola Tinubu’s N68.3 trillion 2026 budget by what it delivers and not by its size. Oye, who is Chairman of the Alliance for Economic Research & Ethics (AERE), in a statement argued that a nation’s budget is a promise that must be funded, executed and

accounted for and not just another document. He recalled that the approved budget in 2026 provides for N68.32331 trillion expenditure, N36.86668 trillion revenue and N31.45663 trillion deficit, pointing out that higher revenue is valuable only when the public can see what it funds. “For a family, the meaningful test is whether the clinic has essential supplies and the school can keep its doors open. For a business, it is whether power, transport and predictable public services reduce

operating costs,” he said. He maintained if a budget grows substantially after presentation, government should publish a clear reconciliation of the additional amount by project, legacy obligation, ministry and financing source. Besides, Oye flagged what he called a material discrepancy in the oil price assumption for the year. While some analyses of the approved budget identify $64.85 per barrel, others say the benchmark was raised from $65 dollars to $75 by federal lawmakers. He insisted that

the confusion should be addressed by the government. “Government should publish the authoritative fiscal assumptions and clarify which figure governs,” he said, adding that a credible budget should be honest about uncertainty and should set a base case, a downside case and a trigger for corrective action. On capital execution, Oye said the Budget Office’s N4.17734 trillion first half capital spending total and the World Bank’s approximately N0.7 trillion fiscal comparison figure have

Sterling Bank Takes Nigeria’s Climate Financing Drive to COP31 Nume Ekeghe Sterling Bank is stepping up efforts to mobilise climate finance for Nigeria through strategic engagements with the Lagos and Ondo State Governments at the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31), holding from November 9 to 20, 2026, in Antalya, Türkiye. The Bank’s participation is aimed at unlocking investment opportunities, expanding access to sustainable financing and connecting state-led development projects with international investors and development finance institutions. The engagements underscore the growing role of subnational governments in Nigeria’s climate response, particularly as states grapple with the need to build climate-resilient infrastructure, safeguard livelihoods and address mounting environmental threats. For Lagos and Ondo, the stakes are particularly significant, given their exposure to coastal erosion, flooding and other climate-related risks. These challenges have heightened the need for sustained investment in adaptation infrastructure and solutions that can protect vulnerable communities while supporting long-term economic development. The bank in a statement noted that they will participate in the Lagos State

Government’s COP31 programme, which seeks to advance an estimated $25–50 billion climate investment opportunity spanning more than 300 potential projects. Led by the Office of Climate Change and Circular Economy (OCCE), the initiative will bring together global investors, financial institutions and strategic partners to explore opportunities across renewable energy, sustainable transportation, waste management, climate-resilient infrastructure, agriculture and green enterprise. A major highlight of the state’s participation will be Lagos Climate Investment Day, scheduled for 13 November 2026. The event will provide a platform to present the state’s investment pipeline, engage prospective financing partners and explore structures capable of moving priority projects towards implementation. Sterling Bank will contribute its financing expertise to discussions on project bankability, sustainable investment and opportunities for private-sector participation in Lagos’s climate development agenda. On Ondo, Sterling Bank is supporting the Ondo State Oil Producing Areas Development Commission (OSOPADEC) in drawing international attention to the growing environmental

crisis affecting Aiyetoro and other coastal communities in Ilaje Local Government Area. The COP31 sideline engagement organised under the theme ‘Saving the Vanishing Coast,’ will highlight the impact of rising sea levels, coastal erosion and environmental degradation while seeking partnerships to support long-term coastal protection, infrastructure development and economic recovery. The urgency of the intervention is underscored by research into shoreline changes along the Ilaje coast, which found that approximately 86% of the coastline studied had experienced erosion. Aiyetoro, once a thriving fishing community, has suffered extensive land loss, damage to residential and public infrastructure, and disruption to traditional livelihoods. The situation illustrates the increasing economic and social costs of climate inaction, particularly for communities with limited resources to withstand repeated environmental shocks. Through its programme at the Nigeria Pavilion, OSOPADEC will present a coastal-resilience roadmap covering shoreline protection and land reclamation, climate-resilient infrastructure, clean water and energy access, restoration of fisheries and blue-economy livelihoods, and

early-warning systems. Sterling Bank’s involvement will support engagements aimed at identifying potential financing structures and development partnerships for these priorities, including proposed discussions with institutions such as the Green Climate Fund and the World Bank, particularly its West Africa Coastal Areas programme.

different coverage and are not directly comparable. He said the Budget Office also reported that implementation of the 2026 ministries, departments and agencies capital budget remained at zero as at June 30, while agencies used funds from the extended 2025 programme. “An appropriation is authority to spend, it is not proof that citizens have received a working asset,” he said. “The public should be able to trace each major project from its budget year and funding source to verified completion and use,” he emphasised. Oye called for one public project record showing allocations, releases, payments, independently checked progress and completion, a transparent close out of carried over projects, and readiness and funding tests before new projects are added. Oye listed risks that could derail the 2026 targets. He said election period spending could put pressure on the deficit. In the same vein, Oye stated that the 2025 capital extension runs to December 31 2026 which creates a risk that agencies will be managing old obligations while trying to start new work. According to him, security shocks can affect oil production, agriculture and project

execution. He said for the remaining weeks of 2026, government should close the 2025 capital programme on the statutory date and publish a realistic first quarter cash plan for 2027 based on confirmed resources. On debt, Oye proposed a path to reduce the consolidated debt service to revenue ratio to 40 per cent by 2028, from the World Bank’s comparable 49.5 per cent 2025 baseline, which would mean a reduction of 9.5 percentage points over three years. According to him, the 40 per cent was chosen as an intermediate fiscal guardrail not because it is a universal statutory threshold or a magic number, but that the target should use the same published definition each year. He also called for disciplined borrowing through enforcement of the Fiscal Responsibility Act’s borrowing purpose rules and publication of borrowing authorised, borrowing raised, debt service and use of proceeds in one quarterly statement. “Revenue reporting should therefore show, by period, what was forecast, collected, borrowed and spent and how those figures reconcile to the approved budget.

Tinubu’s Ibom Deep Seaport Approval: N’Delta Youth Demand Revival of Regional Ports Blessing Ibunge in Port Harcourt The Niger Delta Ethnic Nationalities Youth Leaders Forum (NDENYLF) has commended President Bola Ahmed Tinubu for approving the Ibom Deep Seaport project in Akwa Ibom State. The group also emphatically urged the federal government to extend similar attention to other ports across the Niger Delta. The forum in a statement yesterday, described the approval as a significant step towards unlocking the region’s maritime potential, attracting investments, creating employment and strengthening Nigeria’s position in international

trade. In the statement jointly signed by its Chairman, Dr. Doubra Okotete, and Spokesman, Legborsi Yamaabana, the forum said the presidential approval followed its recent press briefing in Port Harcourt, where it called for the actualisation of the deep seaport and comprehensive rehabilitation of maritime infrastructure across the region. NDENYLF also acknowledged the contributions of the Akwa Ibom State Government, the Senate President and other stakeholders in advancing the project. In the statement made available to journalists in Port Harcourt, the

youth leaders stressed the approval should mark the beginning of a broader maritime development agenda rather than an isolated achievement. “Our position is clear: the approval of the Ibom Deep Seaport is a welcome development, but the ultimate objective must be the total revival of the Niger Delta’s maritime economy,” the statement said. The forum specifically called for the dredging, rehabilitation and modernisation of Rivers Port, Onne Port, Warri Port and Calabar Port, including improvements in cargo-handling facilities, navigational safety, access roads and rail connectivity.


10

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, T H I S D AY


11

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, T H I S D AY

+".&4 )01& $0--&(& ˬ̛̌Ν˵ʍɾʳʍࢫࢫ-˂Ʉ͍Ʉɲͩʍ͍ࢫė͍ͷͩ˂

kĤėĤþHࢫ§H 8HþĊࢫ8Ìࢫ½Ìėࢫ ĤĊėࢫz ööH½ࢶࢶࢶėzHŖࢫ þHࢫkÌþ·H8 ėࢫ ·HĊࢫzÌöHࢫ-̧§HnHࢷࢫ§H ࢷࢫ§ nÌĊ ½ÌŅH·%Hþࢫ࠵࠳࠵࠸ࢫ- ·%þ 8nH

· Ŗࣃ Ĥ½Hࢫ࠵࠳࠵࠹ࢫŋ H-

n-ĊHࢫHœ · ½ ė ̽ࢫþHĊĤ§ė

Hœ · ½ ė ̽ࢫþHĊĤ§ė

ࣁ

࠴ ࠶ ࢫ࣒ࢫ% nþ 8HĊࢸࢫ࠼࠷य़

nþ 8HĊࢸࢫ࠹࠺य़

࠴

ࣁ ࢫ࣒ࢫ nþ 8HĊࢸࢫ࠼࠹य़

࠹

ࢫ࣒ࢫ-ࢫࢫnþ 8HĊࢸࢫ࠴࠳࠳य़

ࣁ ࢫ࣒ࢫ% nþ 8HĊࢸࢫ࠼࠼य़ ࣁ ࢫ࣒ࢫ-ࢫࢫ nþ 8HĊࢸࢫ࠴࠳࠳य़ ĊͩɄͩʍࢫ̛ʱࢫͩ˂ʍࢫɄ͍ͩࢫɲ˵Ʉ͛​̛͍͛​̛̆͛ࢷࢫ˵Ʉɩ̛͍Ʉ̛͍ͩˏʍ͛ࢷࢫɩ̛Ʉ͍ɾˏ̌ʳࢫɄ̌ɾࢫ̛͍͛ͩͅˏ̌ʳࢫʱɄɲˏ˵ˏͩˏʍ͛ࢶ HΦɲʍͩͅˏ̛̌Ʉ˵ࢫʍɾͷɲɄ̛͍ͩ͛ࢫΝ˂̛ࢫɲ˂Ʉ˵˵ʍ̌ʳʍࢫ̆ˏ̌ɾ͛ࢷࢫ̌ͷ͍ͩͷ͍ʍࢫɄ̌ɾࢫɩ͍ˏ̌ʳࢫ ̛ͷͩࢫͩ˂ʍࢫɩʍ͛ͩࢫˏ̌ࢫʍΘʍ͍Ωࢫ˵ʍɄ͍̌ʍ͍ࢶ ơ͍̈ͷɾࢫΝˏ̌​̌ʍ͍͛ࢫ̛ʱࢫ͍ͅʍ͛ͩˏʳˏ̛ͷ͛ࢫˏ̌ͩʍ͍̌Ʉͩˏ̛̌Ʉ˵ࢫɄ̌ɾࢫ̌Ʉͩˏ̛̌Ʉ˵ࢫɄΝɄ͍ɾ͛ࢶ %ʍɄͷͩˏʱͷ˵ࢷࢫ͛ʍ͍ʍ̌ʍࢫɄ̌ɾࢫ͛ʍɲͷ͍ʍࢫΝ̛͍˵ɾ࣒ɲ˵Ʉ͛​͛ࢫɲɄ̆ͅͷ͛ࢫΝ˂ʍ͍ʍࢫ˵ʍɄ͍̌ˏ̌ʳࢫͩ˂͍ˏΘʍ͛ࢶ H½ėþ ½-HࢫHœ · ½ ė ̽ࢫkÌþࢫŖH þࢫ࠺ࢫࣜ ĊĊ࠴ࣝࢫ8 Ŗࢫ ½8ࢫ%Ì þ8 ½nࢫĊėĤ8H½ėĊࢫkÌþ ėzHࢫ࠵࠳࠵࠺ࣃ࠵࠳࠵࠻ࢫ - 8H· -ࢫĊHĊĊ ̽ࢫ ĊࢫĊ-zH8Ĥ§H8ࢫėÌࢫė Hࢫö§ -Hࢫ Ċࢫķ§ÌŋĊࢸ

§ nÌĊ 8Ʉͩʍ͛ࢸࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫĊɄͩͷ͍ɾɄΩࢷࢫ࠶࠳ͩ˂ࢫ Ʉ̌ͷɄ͍ΩࢫɄ̌ɾࢫ࠹ͩ˂ࢫkʍɩ͍ͷɄ͍Ωࢷࢫ࠵࠳࠵࠺ §̛ɲɄͩˏ̛̌ࢸࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫ Ʉ̆ʍ͛ࢫz̛ͅʍࢫ-̛˵˵ʍʳʍࢷࢫėΝˏ̌ࢫ§Ʉˬʍ͛ࢫH͛ͩɄͩʍࢷࢫ§ʍˬˬˏࢷࢫ§Ʉʳ̛͛ࢶ ėˏ̆ʍࢸࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫ࠴࠳ ·

%Ĥ ࢫऑࢫöÌþėࢫz þ-ÌĤþė 8ɄͩʍࢸࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫĊɄͩͷ͍ɾɄΩࢷࢫ࠹ͩ˂ࢫkʍɩ͍ͷɄ͍Ωࢷࢫ࠵࠳࠵࠺ §̛ɲɄͩˏ̛̌͛ࢸࢫࢫࢫ࠺࠴ࢫĤ͛ͷ̆ɄࢫĊ͍ͩʍʍͩࢷࢫÌͅ​ͅࢶࢫė͍Ʉ̌͛ɲ̛͍ͅࢫzˏ˵̛ͩ̌ࢷࢫ·ɄˏͩɄ̆Ʉࢷࢫ ɩͷ˥Ʉࢶ ࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫ࠴࠸ࢫ½̌Ʉ̆ɾˏࢫ ηˏˬˏΝʍࢫþ̛Ʉɾࢷࢫơ͍̈ͩࢫzɄ͍ɲ̛ͷ͍ͩࢷࢫþˏΘʍ͍͛ࢫĊͩɄͩʍࢶ ėˏ̆ʍࢸࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫ࠴࠳ ·

öö§ - ė ̽ࢫ-§ÌĊHĊࢸࢫkþ 8 Ŗࢷࢫ࠵࠵½8ࢫ ½Ĥ þŖࢫ࠵࠳࠵࠺ ͅ​ͅ˵ˏɲɄͩˏ̛̌ࢫʱ̛͍̆͛ࢫɲɄ̌ࢫɩʍࢫɾ̛Ν̌˵̛Ʉɾʍɾࢫʱ̛͍̆ࢫΝΝΝࢶ˥Ʉ̆ʍ͛˂̛ͅʍɲ̛˵˵ʍʳʍࢶʍɾͷࢶ̌ʳࢫͷ̌ɾʍ͍ࢫͩ˂ʍࢫ ࣪Ʉɾ̆ˏ͛​͛ˏ̛̌࣫ࢫͩɄɩࢫ̛͍ࢫɲɄ̌ࢫɩʍࢫɲ̛˵˵ʍɲͩʍɾࢫʱ̛͍̆ࢫ Ʉ̆ʍ͛ࢫz̛ͅʍࢫ-̛˵˵ʍʳʍࢷࢫėΝˏ̌ࢫ§Ʉˬʍ͛ࢫH͛ͩɄͩʍࢷࢫ§ʍˬˬˏࢷࢫ§Ʉʳ̛͛ࢶ

23(1 '$<6 8 ėHࢸࢫĊ ėĤþ8 Ŗࢫ࠴࠷ėzࢫ½ÌŅH·%Hþࢷࢫ࠵࠳࠵࠹ࢫऑࢫĊ ėĤþ8 Ŗࢫ࠼ėzࢫ ½Ĥ þŖࢷࢫ࠵࠳࠵࠺ ė ·Hࢸࢫ࠼ ·ࢫėÌࢫ࠴࠵ࢸ࠶࠳ö·

k̛˵˵̛Νࢫͷ͛ࢫ̛̌ࢫɄ˵˵ࢫ̛ͷ͍ࢫ̛͛ɲˏɄ˵ࢫ̆ʍɾˏɄࢫ˂Ʉ̌ɾ˵ʍ͛ࢸ ऐ˥Ʉ̆ʍ͛˂̛ͅʍɲ̛˵˵ʍʳʍ ऐ

Ʉ̆ʍ͛ࢫz̛ͅʍ

ėʍ˵ࢸࢫॆ࠵࠶࠷࠺࠳࠻࠶࠹࠹࠵࠵࠵࠼ࢷࢫॆ࠵࠶࠷࠺࠳࠴࠻࠵࠻࠵࠳࠹࠸ࢷ ऐ z-§ʍˬˬˏ

ࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫࢫॆ࠵࠶࠷࠺࠳࠻࠸࠶࠹࠼࠶࠺࠹ࢷࢫॆ࠵࠶࠷࠺࠳࠴࠸࠶࠷࠼࠵࠸࠺ H̆Ʉˏ˵ࢸࢫɄɾ̆ˏ͛​͛ˏ̛̌ऐ˥Ʉ̆ʍ͛˂̛ͅʍࢶʍɾͷࢶ̌ʳ ŋʍɩࢸࢫΝΝΝࢶ˥Ʉ̆ʍ͛˂̛ͅʍɲ̛˵˵ʍʳʍࢶʍɾͷࢶ̌ʳ


12

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, T H I S D AY

3(752/(80 7(&+12/2*< '(9(/230(17 )81' 37') 37') 7RZHU 2SSRVLWH 6KHKX 0XVD <DU $GXD &HQWUH 1HDU 6LOYHUELUG *DOOHULD &HQWUDO %XVLQHVV 'LVWULFW $EXMD :HEVLWH ZZZ SWGI JRY QJ

37') $118$/ 2,/ *$6 5(6($5&+ *5$17 &203(7,7,21 &<&/( &$// )25 5(6($5&+ 352326$/6 ,1752'8&7,21 7KH 3HWUROHXP 7HFKQRORJ\ 'HYHORSPHQW )XQG 37') LQ OLQH ZLWK LWV PDQGDWH WR EXLOG LQGLJHQRXV FDSDFLW\ IRU 1LJHULD V RLO DQG JDV LQGXVWU\ LQYLWHV TXDOL¿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လ (25 ÀRZ DVVXUDQFH FRUURVLRQ VFDOH FRQWURO SLSHOLQH DQG VXEVHD LQWHJULW\ URERWLFV DQG PHFKDWURQLFV *DV &RPPHUFLDOLVDWLRQ 8WLOLVDWLRQ )ODUH 5HGXFWLRQ *DV WR SRZHU *7/ PLQL /1* &1* / 3 * S H W U R F K H P L F D O S U R F H V V L Q J À D U H PRQHWLVDWLRQ PRGXODU JDV V\VWHPV &&86 LQ JDV YDOXH FKDLQV JDV WR FKHPLFDOV VWUDQGHG JDV PRQHWLVDWLRQ ,QWHJUDWHG 7HFKQRORJLHV 5HQHZDEOHV /RZ &DUERQ 6ROXWLRQV /RFDO PDWHULDO VRODU 39 K\EULG JDV UHQHZDEOH V\VWHPV R໤VKRUH ZLQG EDWWHU\ VWRUDJH PLFURJULGV K\GURJHQ EOXH JUHHQ JHRWKHUPDO ZDVWH WR HQHUJ\ &&86 IRU QDWXUDO JDV SURFHVVLQJ (QYLURQPHQWDO 6XVWDLQDELOLW\ &LUFXODU (FRQRP\ (6* %LRUHPHGLDWLRQ QDQRWHFKQRORJ\ FOHDQXS SURGXFHG ZDWHU WUHDWPHQW PHWKDQH UHGXFWLRQ FDUERQ DFFRXQWLQJ 059 GLJLWDO (6* V\VWHPV FLUFXODU HFRQRP\ ZDVWH YDORULVDWLRQ ELRGLYHUVLW\ VSLOO GHWHFWLRQ DQG UHPHGLDWLRQ KRVW FRPPXQLW\ GHYHORSPHQW HPSRZHUPHQW 'LJLWDO 2LO¿HOG $XWRPDWLRQ (PHUJLQJ 7HFKQRORJLHV $, 0/ RSWLPLVDWLRQ LQGXVWULDO ,R7 URERWLFV IRU LQVSHFWLRQ GULOOLQJ F\EHUVHFXULW\ FORXG HGJH V\VWHPV DXWRQRPRXV RSHUDWLRQV GLJLWDO WZLQV EORFNFKDLQ JHQHUDWLYH $, //0V GLJLWDO JRYHUQDQFH )DFLOLWLHV (QJLQHHULQJ ,QIUDVWUXFWXUH /RFDO &RQWHQW ,QGXVWULDO 6\VWHPV ,QWHJUDWHG IDFLOLW\ PDQDJHPHQW UHOLDELOLW\ HQJLQHHULQJ EURZQ¿HOG UHWUR¿WV HQHUJ\ H໥FLHQW RSHUDWLRQV VPDUW

I D F L O L W L H V O R F D O I D E U L F D W L R Q D G G L W L Y H PDQXIDFWXULQJ LPSRUW VXEVWLWXWLRQ VXSSO\ FKDLQ DQG ORJLVWLFV V\VWHPV (QHUJ\ (FRQRPLFV )LQDQFH )LVFDO 6\VWHPV 3ROLF\ $QDO\WLFV +XPDQ &DSLWDO 'HYHORSPHQW 0DFURHFRQRPLF SROLF\ HYDOXDWLRQ RLO SULFH YRODWLOLW\ ¿VFDO V\VWHPV 3,$ PRGHOOLQJ LQYHVWPHQW RSWLPLVDWLRQ JDV ¿VFDO IUDPHZRUNV H Q H U J \ P D U N H W I R U H F D V W L Q J F D U E R Q SULFLQJ PDUNHWV JUHHQ ¿QDQFH VWUDQGHG DVVHW ULVN FRPSHWHQF\ IUDPHZRUNV ZRUNIRUFH 352326$/ )250$7 *8,'(/,1(6 &RYHU 3DJH 5HVHDUFK 0LVVLRQ WKHPH 3URMHFW 7LWOH ([HFXWLYH 6XPPDU\ SDJH , Q G X V W U \ S U R E O H P S U R S R V H G V R O X W L R Q FRPPHUFLDOLVDWLRQ SDWKZD\ H[SHFWHG LPSDFW WHFKQLFDO HFRQRPLF HQYLURQPHQWDO SROLF\ %DFNJURXQG 3UREOHP 'H¿QLWLRQ ,QGXVWU\ FKDOOHQJH HYLGHQFH RI UHOHYDQFH GDWD RSHUDWRU QHHGV UHJXODWRU\ JDSV QDWLRQDO SULRULW\ DOLJQPHQW /LWHUDWXUH 5HYLHZ *DS $QDO\VLV &XUUHQW NQRZOHGJH H[LVWLQJ WHFKQRORJLHV LGHQWL¿HG JDSV QRYHOW\ 1LJHULDQ VLWXDWLRQDO FRQWH[W 2EMHFWLYHV 0DLQ REMHFWLYH VSHFL¿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¿FDWLRQ 3HUVRQQHO HTXLSPHQW ZLWK DYDLODELOLW\ FRQ¿UPDWLRQ FRQVXPDEOHV GDWD DFTXLVLWLRQ W U D Y H O L Q V W L W X W L R Q D O F K D U J H V G L J L W D O LQIUDVWUXFWXUH VRIWZDUH OLFHQVLQJ YDOXH IRU PRQH\ MXVWL¿FDWLRQ $OO FRVWV VKRXOG DOLJQ ZLWK WKH QRPLQDO FDSSLQJ RI FRVW FDWHJRULHV QDPHO\ (TXLSPHQW 3HUVRQQHO 7UDYHO &ROODERUDWLRQ DQG 'LVVHPLQDWLRQ LQVWLWXWLRQDO FKDUJHV 7KHVH OLPLWV DUH WR DLG LQ VHOI DVVHVVPHQW EHIRUH VXEPLWWLQJ WKH SURSRVDO

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¿HUV LQFOXGLQJ QDPHV ORJRV HWF DUH DOORZHG LQ DOO VXEPLVVLRQV )ROORZ DOO RWKHU SRUWDO GLUHFWLRQV WR VXEPLW 27+(5 *8,'(/,1(6 $ WHDP RI DFDGHPLF DQG LQGXVWU\ UHVRXUFH SHUVRQV ZLOO VKRUWOLVW SURSRVDOV IRU RUDO SUHVHQWDWLRQ 6XEPLVVLRQV ZLOO EH DVVHVVHG DJDLQVW WKH IROORZLQJ FULWHULD LQGXVWU\ UHOHYDQFH SUREOHP GH¿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

68%0,66,21 3URSRVDOV PXVW EH VXEPLWWHG HOHFWURQLFDOO\ WKURXJK WKH 3257$/ KWWSV RLODQGJDVUHVHDUFK SWGI JRY QJ 'HDGOLQH 7KUHH FDOHQGDU PRQWKV IURP WKH ¿UVW GDWH RI SXEOLFDWLRQ 6LJQHG 37') 0DQDJHPHQW


TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, T H I S D AY

13


TUESDAY NOVEMBER 10, 2026 ˾ T H I S D AY

14

NEWS

CASER Condemns Rising Electoral Violence across Nigeria Alex EnumahinAbuja A social rights group, the Citizens’ Advocacy for Social and Economic Rights (CASER), has condemned the rising wave of electoral violence and political intimidation across the country ahead of the 2027 general election.

The group noted that within days, incidents in Ado-Ekiti, Calabar and Asaba have raised urgent questions about the safety of candidates, campaign workers and ordinary citizens. CASER in a statement issued by its Executive Director, Mr. Frank Tietie, said that Nigerians must be able to attend a

rally, support a candidate or campaign for a political party without risking their lives. “So far, one Nigerian has been killed in Asaba, while others have been severely injured in the above three locations,”

CASER said while extending its condolences to the bereaved family and its solidarity to the injured. The group, accordingly, warned that it is documenting these incidents and at the same

time putting Nigeria’s political class on notice. “We will use appropriate national, regional and international mechanisms to pursue accountability for those who carry out, order, finance,

organise or knowingly facilitate electoral violence. We will press for prosecution wherever the evidence warrants it and seek compensation and other lawful remedies for victims and bereaved families.

WIM Leaders Seek Increased Access to Capital, Global Opportunities for African Women Civil Society Decries Jonathan opportunities, global edition of the WIM Global celebrating women’s Eze Osun NLC Strike

Yinka Kolawole in Osogbo The Executive Director World Institute for Peace, Lamina Omotoyosi, yesterday warned the Osun State Government and the various labour unions on the three-day warning strike embarked upon by the Osun State chapter of the Nigeria Labour Congress (NLC) over the lingering local government crisis in the state. The executive director noted that as an organisation committed

to promoting peace, stability, development and social justice, “he considered this warning strike needless, barbaric, deceptive and a deliberate attempt to ground the state’s economy and potentially trigger civil unrest.” According to him, “We have no reservation in concluding that the strike is being embarked upon in bad faith and is politically motivated, with the intention of blackmailing the judiciary and creating a possible atmosphere of anarchy in the polity. “

The Founder and Chairperson of Women in Management (WIM), Dr. Sulochana Segera, and Chairperson of Women in Management Africa (WIMAFRICA), Dr. Ngozi Oyewole, have called for greater economic

recognition and increased participation of Nigerian and African women in trade, investment, entrepreneurship and leadership. The duo made the call at a press conference in Lagos yesterday ahead of the maiden African

Economic Forum with the theme: ‘The Power Shift: Women Driving Africa’s Global Economic Influence’, scheduled for November 10 to 11, 2026, at the Federal Palace Hotel, Lagos. They said the gathering would move beyond

achievements to creating practical opportunities for them to influence economic decisions, access capital, expand businesses, participate in international trade and establish strategic partnerships across continents.

Yewande Olagbende Joins Solad Power Group Board of Directors Yusuf Ebiti

Nigerian operations. Olagbende joined Solad Solad Power Group, a in 2018 and has since leading decentralised played a central role in energy solutions provider building its Nigerian operations, in Nigeria, has announced that Yewande Olagbende establishing Solad as a will join the Group’s recognised participant Board of Directors after in Nigeria’s rapidly successfully leading its developing distributed

clean energy sector and positioning it strongly within the country’s Just Energy Transition. Her appointment to the Group leadership team is a natural progression of this work. Under her leadership, the Nigerian business

expanded its business in mini-grids, stand-alone solar systems, commercial and industrial solar, solar home systems and decentralised energy infrastructure. It also developed the operational capability to deliver and maintain energy solutions across multiple States.


15

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, T H I S D AY

N155BN ISSUED MORTGAGES. 2,000+ HOMES DELIVERED

Sokoto Kano

Lagos

Funds managed by ARM Investment Managers

Borno

Enugu


1

16 I S D AY TUESDAY NOVEMBER 10, 2026 TR

UT H

& RE A S O

Tuesday November 10, 2026 Vol 27. No 11529

N

opinion@thisdaylive.com

www.thisdaylive.com

BATTLE FOR AHMADU BELLO HOUSE Salihu Yakubu Danladi has what it takes to govern Kwara, argues MUSTAPHA BALOGUN

See page 17

ON SALIM IBRAHIM'S NOVEMBER 4 RULING

The judgement nullifying the APC senatorial primary for Kogi West is unfortunate, contends TUNDE OLUSUNLE

See page 17

EDITORIAL

APPLAUSE FOR THE FLAMINGOS

See page 17

GODWIN SOGOLO argues that Nigeria’s electoral process is too deeply compromised by corruption to make any meaningful change

AMERICA'S MIDTERM ELECTIONS: LESSONS FOR NIGERIA 2027 Nigeria is not the United States of America. Consequently, our electoral processes cannot be expected to mirror those of the United States, nor should Nigerians be expected to behave exactly like Americans in the exercise of their democratic rights. These are fundamental distinctions worth establishing at the outset – if only to pre-empt those who might question the appropriateness of drawing comparisons between the recently concluded US midterm elections and Nigeria’s forthcoming general elections in January 2027. There are, however, other fundamental facts that cannot be ignored. First, the presidential system of government practised in Nigeria is borrowed – almost wholesale – from the United States of America. Second, Western democracy is founded on certain principles and values against which its success or failure is measured. Perhaps even more fundamentally – whether American or Nigerian – we are all human beings, endowed with the common faculties of rationality, free will and the capacity to make independent choices. For the purpose of this comparison, it is worth emphasising that the circumstances that led to the outcome of the American midterm elections were – in many respects – remarkably similar to those confronting us here in Nigeria: the rising cost of living, declining D൵RUGDELOLW\ H[WUHPH KDUGVKLS LQ WKH case of Nigeria) corruption and the consequences of bad governance. Prior to the American midterm elections of November 3, 2026, much of the world had been grappling with HFRQRPLF GL൶FXOWLHV FRPSRXQGHG by President Donald Trump's arbitrary LPSRVLWLRQ RI WDUL൵V RQ VHYHUDO FRXQWULHV and, in particular, his war against the Islamic Republic of Iran. Today, protests are erupting in various parts of the world – particularly across Europe – in response to the resulting economic and political disruptions. The United States itself has not been insulated from these challenges, and American voters made their discontent unmistakably clear at the ballot box. The outcome – widely described as a “blue tsunami” – saw the Democrats make VLJQL¿FDQW JDLQV LQ WKH 86 &RQJUHVV One of the newly elected senators, James Talarico of Texas, delivered a memorable victory speech in which he emphasised the triumph of ordinary

collapse of the nation's security system, farming has become an increasingly unviable occupation for many farmers. The educational system is in serious decline, with parents increasingly unable WR D൵RUG VFKRRO IHHV 0RUH JHQHUDOO\ PLOOLRQV RI 1LJHULDQV FDQ EDUHO\ D൵RUG the basic necessities of life, including food, healthcare and transportation. Thus, the indicators of a system in deep crisis are glaring everywhere. Much of this has been due to the disastrous failure of the political leadership. Now, back to the question: can the people over money and political power. Nigerian electorate – like the Americans He referred to the huge amount of half have successfully done – rescue a billion dollars reportedly deployed by the nation? The answer is doubtful the world's richest man, Elon Musk, in – perhaps even improbable, if not an attempt to prevent his victory. He seemingly impossible. The electoral likened his electoral success to “the process itself is too deeply compromised underdog defeating the powerful” – by corruption to make such an outcome invoking the biblical story of David and likely! Furthermore, unlike their Goliath. American counterparts, Nigerians are Talarico also accused powerful interests widely perceived as being less capable of exploiting divisions along political, of exercising their electoral mandate to racial, gender, religious and cultural bring about corrective change through lines to distract and manipulate ordinary the ballot box. The explanation often citizens – a strategy also commonly used advanced is that, whereas a substantial by Nigerian political leaders in their proportion of the American electorate treatment of disadvantaged populations. retain the moral independence and His central message was that political integrity necessary to hold their leaders GL൵HUHQFHV VKRXOG QRW SUHYHQW FLWL]HQV accountable, the Nigerian situation from recognising their common SUHVHQWV D VWULNLQJO\ GL൵HUHQW SLFWXUH interests and using their votes to demand As the renowned paediatrician, accountability from those who govern Professor Emeritus Ajovi B. Scottthem. The critical question is: Can Emuakpor of Michigan State University, Nigerian voters demonstrate a similar aptly observes: “In an impoverished capacity to use their electoral mandate to society, where millions struggle for the demand accountability and bring about basic necessities of life, even a relatively meaningful political change? small gift can become an instrument of Before attempting to answer this political persuasion. Poverty makes question, it is important to correct political allegiance vulnerable to a possible misconception. Nigeria's transactional inducements.” challenges cannot be attributed entirely The Professor is absolutely to external forces or impositions. Long right. Most Nigerians have been so EHIRUH WKH LQWURGXFWLRQ RI WDUL൵V DQG thoroughly subjugated, humiliated Trump's war on Iran, Nigerians were and psychologically broken by their already grappling with severe economic circumstances that they have come hardship; these external developments to see their salvation in the very have merely compounded an already dire individuals and forces responsible for situation. For decades, bad governance, their predicament. Yet, we must never greed, corruption and poorly conceived lose hope. After all, as a former First policies of successive administrations Lady famously reminded us: “There is have been at the root of many of the God o!” country's persistent problems. Political leaders have reduced the Sogolo quality of life of Nigerians to a level is an Emeritus Professor who has barely above subsistence, with the taught and conducted research in consequences felt across virtually every 3KLORVRSK\ IRU RYHU ¿YH GHFDGHV ± facet of life – economically, socially and DW WKH 8QLYHUVLW\ RI ,EDGDQ &DUGLৼ educationally. The Nigerian middle class University of Wales and currently at the has almost been wiped out. With the National Open University of Nigeria.


T H I S D AY

317

TUESDAY NOVEMBER 10, 2026

Salihu Yakubu Danladi has what it takes to govern Kwara, argues MUSTAPHA BALOGUN

BATTLE FOR AHMADU BELLO HOUSE On 27 July 2026, a Banquet Hall in Ilorin echoed with a chant. Governor AbdulRahman AbdulRazaq stood before young APC supporters at the party’s Youth Engagement programme, themed “One Kwara Project, One Voice; Youths Driving APC Victory 2027.” He led them in the chant: “SYD! SYD!! SYD!!!” A sitting governor does not lead a chant for just anybody. To understand why he did, you have to go back to where the story began. Salihu Yakubu Danladi, born in 1985 into the royal lineage of Gwanara, Baruten Local Government Area of Kwara North, did not start in politics. He started with circuits and systems. But Engineering was never the whole story. But it teaches how systems hold together. In 2019, Danladi became Speaker of the Kwara State House of Assembly, one of the most demanding offices in any state. A Speaker must manage competing interests, keep the House disciplined and hold the executive to account without undermining the working relationship that governance requires. The numbers tell part of the story. Under his leadership, the Ninth and Tenth Assemblies passed 63 bills and considered more than 100 motions of public importance, while maintaining regular oversight of ministries, departments and agencies. The laws include the Kwara State Public Procurement Law, the Social Investment Programme Law and the Sports Commission Law (both 2019), the Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) (Amendment) Law, 2019, and the Electric Power Sector Law, 2025. Annual appropriation acts were passed on time, giving Governor AbdulRazaq’s reforms a steady legislative backbone. His influence soon extended beyond Ilorin as he chaired the APC Conference of Speakers in Nigeria from 2024 to 2026, and in 2026 served on the Election Appeal Committee of the APC National Convention. But leadership is not measured by titles alone. It’s true test is what changes in the lives of the people, particularly in the communities farthest from power. In Baruten, his interventions in water supply have helped improve access to clean and safe water, easing the burden on households and communities. He also contributed to the realisation of key road projects, including the Ilesha-Gwanara Road, while supporting the grading and opening of feeder roads. These interventions have improved connectivity, eased transportation, opened up rural communities and strengthened access to markets, farms and essential services. On security, the upgrading of the NSCDC outpost in Gwanara to a Divisional Office has strengthened the security presence in the area. He also facilitated the training and equipping of community hunters and vigilantes, im-

proving their capacity to support local security efforts. Many of those trained have since been seconded to the National Forest Security Service. Access to basic infrastructure has also improved, with solar-powered systems and streetlights providing illumination in selected villages, while some communities have gained access to grid electricity. Renovated and furnished primary healthcare centres have improved access to medical services, while telecommunications facilities have connected previously underserved communities. In education, the establishment of the Federal Science and Technical College in Gwanara and the completion of the KWASU Ilesha-Baruba campus have expanded access to higher and technical education within the region. Investments in school infrastructure, scholarships and examination sponsorship have further supported students. Farmers have benefited from agricultural inputs and equipment, while artisans, cultural troupes and women's groups have received support to strengthen their livelihoods. The provision of motorcycles, vehicles, employment opportunities and political appointments has also extended his interventions to different segments of the community. Which brings us back to that chant in Ilorin. Kwara has existed for more than 50 years, and no youthful Speaker has ever gone on to succeed a sitting governor. SYD’s candidacy would also give Kwara North, a region central to the state’s agricultural economy, geographical spread, and electoral landscape, an opportunity to produce the next governor. For many in the State of Harmony, that speaks to equity, fairness, and justice. Voters will decide, as they should. Campaigns run from 9 September 2026 to 4 February 2027. But look again at the man at the door of Ahmadu Bello House: engineer, administrator, legislator, national party figure and grassroots politician. At 41, SYD brings years of public service, political experience and a clear understanding of the aspirations of a new generation. His story is not just about age; it is about experience, capacity and the opportunity to shape Kwara’s next chapter. Balogun writes from Ilorin

The judgement nullifying the APC senatorial primary for Kogi West is unfortunate, contends TUNDE OLUSUNLE

ON SALIM IBRAHIM'S NOVEMBER 4 RULING

There are moments when a court judgement does not merely decide a case, but exposes the moral rot at the centre of our public life. The judgement of the Federal High Court, Abuja, on Wednesday, November 4, 2026, in Suit No. FHC/LKJ/ CS/63/2026, nullifying the APC senatorial primary for Kogi West duly won by Senator Sunday Steve Karimi and awarding the ticket to Samuel Bamidele Aro, is one such moment. It is not law. It is not justice. It is a farce dressed in the robe of law. How do you nullify a primary duly conducted and won, and hand its fruit to a man who, on record, exited the race in writing before it was held? As Pastor Stanley Ajileye wrote from Lokoja, one is tempted to announce, with sadness and irony, that the Rule of Law has lost its rule. Let us be clear about the facts. Aro was a Member of the House of Representatives between 2007 and 2011. Earlier this year he sought the APC ticket for Kogi West. But just before the primary on Monday, May 18, 2026, Aro, like former three-term Senator Smart Afolabi Adeyemi, threw in the towel in writing. He said he did so in the interest of the APC and in deference to President Bola Ahmed Tinubu's desire for the return of a sizeable percentage of federal parliamentarians because of their experience and institutional memory. On May 17, 2026, in Kabba, stakeholders from every federal constituency in Kogi West met separately to endorse Karimi as consensus candidate. On that strength, Aro willingly submitted his withdrawal letter. The proceedings were captured on video, and videos do not lie. Karimi therefore contested almost unopposed and garnered 51,665 votes. Yet on November 4, Justice Salim Ibrahim held the opposite. He held that the May 18 primary which produced Aro was the valid, INEC-monitored exercise. He held that the primary which produced Karimi was not monitored by INEC as required by the Electoral Act and was consequently invalid. He held that Aro has not withdrawn, directly contradicting the withdrawal letter. He ordered APC to forward Aro's name to INEC, directed INEC to accept and publish him, and restrained Karimi from parading as candidate. He rejected the 51,665-vote result, saying INEC had no record of it. Here lies Pastor Ajileye's million-naira question: can a person who allegedly did not participate be declared winner? If Aro participated and won, he deserves protection. But if he did not, where does the law derive authority to transform a non-participant into a winner? Has Nigeria discovered participation by judicial recognition? There is also jurisdiction, which the court treated with levity that should alarm every lawyer. The defence, led by eminent Senior Advocates, raised a fundamental objection: the action was statute-barred, having been instituted outside the 14 days prescribed by Section 285(9) of the Constitution. This was not about punctuation

or the colour of a result sheet. It touched the very jurisdiction of the court. Jurisdiction is not decorative. It is the foundation of judicial authority. Without it, even the most eloquent judgement cannot acquire legitimacy. Yet the court proceeded to grant reliefs. One would expect such an objection to receive an unmistakable determination before substance was considered. If the 14-day period applies, no sympathy can extend it. If the court found the cause of action arose on a different date, Nigerians deserve the precise reasoning. Then there is the INEC monitoring controversy. During the primary, all Local Government returning officers, not anonymous foot soldiers but high-ranking appointees, stood before cameras. The Commissioners for Finance, Environment and Information, alongside the Special Adviser and Senior Special Assistant to the Governor, each stepped forward. One by one, they submitted results, watching as figures were counted, recorded and announced. Unanimously, they acknowledged one reality: Karimi had won. Then came the recantation. The same appointees, the same Kogi West APC Chairman Ayo Emmanuel and LGA chairmen, later denied on camera what they had affirmed on camera, after what observers described as being bought. The very men who visited Karimi at his home, ate, drank and sang his praises, are the same men now disparaging him. The videos do not lie. The results from Kabba do not lie. Who benefits? The fingerprints are familiar. Yahaya Bello, immediate past governor who styles himself de facto leader of APC in Kogi State, has slid into political irrelevance nationally. He was in office for eight uneventful years between January 2016 and January 2024 when he handed over to his lackey, Ahmed Ododo. He left a legacy of humongous malfeasance. Between him and his proxies, including his son or nephew, Ali Bello, recycled into the Ododo government as Chief of Staff, there are several corruption cases grossing well over N200 billion to which Bello is answering. Olusunle, PhD, is a Fellow of the Association of Nigerian Authors (FANA), and the Nigerian Guild of Editors (FNGE) respectively


18 4

T H I S D AY TUESDAY NOVEMBER 10, 2026

EDITORIAL

Editor, Editorial Page PETER ISHAKA Email peter.ishaka@thisdaylive.com

APPLAUSE FOR THE FLAMINGOS

N

The Flamingos deserves a hero’s welcome for making their presence felt

LJHULD UHFRUGHG DQRWKHU ¿UVW ODVW Saturday evening, becoming the ¿UVW $IULFDQ QDWLRQ WR ZLQ WKH ),)$ 8 :RPHQ¶V :RUOG &XS 7KH YLFWRU\ FDPH DIWHU WKH )ODPLQJRV GHIHDWHG WKHLU -DSDQHVH FRXQWHUSDUWV E\ WZR JRDOV WR RQH LQ WKH ¿QDO RI WKH FDGHW :RUOG &XS LQ 5DEDW 0RURFFR $JDLQVW WKH IDVW SDFHG $VLDQV D VHQVDWLRQDO JRDO E\ $ZDZX %DVKLUX LQ WKH ¿UVW KDOI DQG D FOLQLFDO ¿QLVK E\ 2OXHEXEH 8PHMLDNX LQ WKH VHFRQG UHQGHUHG )XNL ,WR¶V WK PLQXWH VWULNH IRU -DSDQ D PHUH FRQVRODWLRQ DV WKH KLVWRU\ PDNHUV KDG DOUHDG\ MRLQHG WKH KDOO RI IDPH RI WKH 8 :RPHQ¶V :RUOG &XS DV ¿UVW $IULFDQV WR ZHDU WKH FURZQ ,W LV UHPDUNDEOH WKDW WKH )ODPLQJRV EHFDPH ZRUOG FKDPSLRQV WKURXJK DQ LQGLJHQRXV &RDFK $NHHP %XVDUL -XVW OLNH DOO WKH RWKHU ¿YH WLPHV WKH PDOH WHDP *ROGHQ (DJOHWV KDG ZRQ WKH ),)$ 8 :RUOG &XS %XVDUL KDV QRZ HPXODWHG 6HEDVWLDQ %URGHULFNV ,PDVXHQ )DQQ\ $PXQ <HPL 7HOOD 0DQX *DUED DQG (PPDQXHO $PXQHNH ,QWHUHVWLQJO\ WKH VWRU\ RI 1LJHULD¶V YLFWRU\ LQ 5DEDW UHDG OLNH D EHDXWLIXOO\ FUDIWHG 1ROO\ZRRG PRYLH VFULSW 7KLV ZDV D WHDP WKDW QRERG\ JDYH DQ\ FKDQFH RI PDNLQJ LW RXW RI WKH JURXS VWDJH IRU REYLRXV UHDVRQV 1LJHULD¶V VHQLRU DQG MXQLRU WHDPV LQ WKH PDOH DQG IHPDOH FDWHJRULHV KDYH IDLOHG DE\VPDOO\ LQ FRQWLQHQWDO DQG JOREDO FRPSHWLWLRQV LQ UHFHQW \HDUV 7KH 6XSHU (DJOHV IDLOHG WR TXDOLI\ IRU EDFN WR EDFN :RUOG &XSV LQ DQG 7KH VHQLRU PHQ¶V WHDP KDYH KDG WZR QHDU DWWHPSWV DW WKH DQG $IULFD &XS RI 1DWLRQV FODLPLQJ VLOYHU DQG EURQ]H UHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KH 6XSHU )DOFRQV DOVR IDLOHG WR PDNH WKH FXW IRU QH[W \HDU¶V ),)$ :RPHQ¶V :RUOG &XS WR EH KRVWHG E\ %UD]LO IRU WKH ¿UVW WLPH VLQFH WKH LQDXJXUDO HGLWLRQ \HDUV DJR LQ &KLQD 7KHUH ZHUH FRXQWOHVV RWKHU IDLOXUHV DFURVV DOO WKH QDWLRQDO IRRWEDOO WHDPV UHVXOWLQJ LQ WKH PDVV UHVLJQDWLRQ RI WKH ,EUDKLP *XVDX OHG

1LJHULD )RRWEDOO )HGHUDWLRQ ERDUG IURP R൶FH ,W ZDV DJDLQVW WKLV EDFNGURS WKDW OLWWOH DWWHQWLRQ ZDV SDLG WR &RDFK %XVDUL DQG KLV ZDUGV 7KH JLUOV DOVR EHJDQ WKHLU MRXUQH\ WR WKH XOWLPDWH SUL]H RQ D VKDN\ JURXQG ORVLQJ WKHLU ¿UVW PDWFK WR 3RODQG %XW WKH 1LJHULDQ VSLULW RI QRW JLYLQJ XS HYHQ LQ WKH IDFH RI DGYHUVLW\ EHFDPH WKH JXLGLQJ SULQFLSOH IRU WKH )ODPLQJRV 7KH\ URVH VWRXWO\ IURP WKDW VHWEDFN WR ZLQ WKHLU QH[W VL[ PDWFKHV WKDW IROORZHG WR OLIW WKLV SUHVWLJLRXV WURSK\ 7KH\ EHDW 3XHUWR 5LFR VKRFNHG GHIHQGLQJ FKDPSLRQV 1RUWK .RUHD LQ WKH JURXS VWDJH NQRFNHG RXW 0H[LFR LQ WKH 5RXQG RI EHIRUH VHQGLQJ KRPH 9HQH]XHOD ZLWK VFRUHOLQH LQ WKH TXDUWHU¿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¶7LJUHVVHV ZKR ZHUH UHZDUGHG ZLWK GROODUV HDFK SOXV KRXVHV DQG QDWLRQDO KRQRXUV 7KLV WURSK\ PXVW EH SURSHUO\ FHOHEUDWHG DQG UHZDUGHG &RQJUDWXODWLRQV WR RXU ZRUWK\ DPEDVVDGRUV DV RXU DSSUHFLDWLYH QDWLRQ DZDLWV WKHLU DUULYDO IURP 0RURFFR ZLWK WKH ),)$ 8 :RUOG &XS WURSK\

A careful plan must be made for these young women and their handlers that made this feat possible T H I S D AY EDITOR SHAKA MOMODU DEPUTY EDITOR WALE OLALEYE MANAGING DIRECTOR ENIOLA BELLO DEPUTY MANAGING DIRECTOR ISRAEL IWEGBU CHAIRMAN EDITORIAL BOARD OLUSEGUN ADENIYI EDITOR NATION’S CAPITAL IYOBOSA UWUGIAREN THE OMBUDSMAN KAYODE KOMOLAFE

T H I S D AY N E W S PA P E R S L I M I T E D EDITOR-IN-CHIEF/CHAIRMAN NDUKA OBAIGBENA GROUP EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS ENIOLA BELLO, KAYODE KOMOLAFE, ISRAEL IWEGBU DIVISIONAL DIRECTORS SHAKA MOMODU, PETER IWEGBU, ANTHONY OGEDENGBE DEPUTY DIVISIONAL DIRECTOR OJOGUN VICTOR DANBOYI SNR. ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR ERIC OJEH ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR PATRICK EIMIUHI CONTROLLERS ABIMBOLA TAIWO, UCHENNA DIBIAGWU, NDUKA MOSERI DIRECTOR, PRINTING PRODUCTION CHUKS ONWUDINJO TO SEND EMAIL: first name.surname@thisdaylive.com

Letters to the Editor Letters in response to specific publications in THISDAY should be brief (150-300 words) and straight to the point. Interested readers may send such letters along with their contact details to opinion@thisdaylive.com. We also welcome comments and opinions on topical local, national and international issues provided they are well-written and should also not be longer than (750- 1000 words). They should be sent to opinion@thisdaylive.com along with photograph, email address and phone numbers of the writer.

LETTERS

THE FLAMINGOS’ GOLDEN DAWN

7KHUH LV D GLVWLQFW PHDVXUDEOH VKLIW LQ WKH QDWLRQDO FRQVFLRXVQHVV ZKHQHYHU 1LJHULD UHFRUGV DQ HSRFKDO FKDPSLRQVKLS WULXPSK RQ WKH LQWHUQDWLRQDO IRRWEDOO VWDJH )RU D PRPHQW WKH GHHS VHDWHG SROLWLFDO HWKQLF DQG HFRQRPLF DQ[LHWLHV WKDW GH¿QH FRQWHPSRUDU\ GDLO\ OLIH \LHOG WR D VKDUHG VHQVH RI FROOHFWLYH SXUSRVH DQG XQEXUGHQHG SDWULRWLVP 2Q 6DWXUGD\ 1RYHPEHU DW WKH 0RKDPPHG 9, )RRWEDOO &RPSOH[ LQ 5DEDW 0RURFFR RXU XQGHU ZRPHQ¶V QDWLRQDO IRRWEDOO WHDP WKH )ODPLQJRV IRUPDOLVHG WKLV SKHQRPHQRQ %\ GHIHDWLQJ D KLJKO\ WHFKQLFDO -DSDQHVH VLGH ± WKH\ GLG ZKDW QR RWKHU $IULFDQ WHDP LQ KLVWRU\ KDV HYHU DFFRPSOLVKHG WKH\ ZRQ WKH WRXUQDPHQW DQG KRLVWHG WKH ),)$ 8 :RPHQ¶V :RUOG &XS WURSK\ LQWR WKH 1RUWK $IULFDQ VN\ /HW WKH PDJQLWXGH RI WKLV WULXPSK VLQN LQ 7KLV LV QRW PHUHO\ DQRWKHU IRRWEDOO WURSK\ LW LV D SURIRXQG VRFLRORJLFDO EUHDNWKURXJK )RU GHFDGHV 1LJHULD FOXQJ WR WKH KLVWRULFDO SUHVWLJH RI \RXWK IRRWEDOO GRPLQDQFH EXW

WKDW FURZQ ZDV WUDGLWLRQDOO\ DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK RXU ER\V WKH *ROGHQ (DJOHWV²D OHJDF\ WKDW KDV LWVHOI ÀRXQGHUHG VLJQL¿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

$OO 3URJUHVVLYHV &RQJUHVV $3& JRYHUQPHQW $PRQJ SDVVLRQDWH IRRWEDOO IDQV DQG SROLWLFDO F\QLFV DOLNH DQ XUEDQ OHJHQG WRRN ¿UP URRW WKH LGHD WKDW WKH SDUW\ FDUULHG D KLVWRULFDO EDG OXFN RU D VWUXFWXUDO FXUVH ZKHQ LW FDPH WR JOREDO IRRWEDOO JORU\ &\QLFV RSHQO\ ZLVKHG IRU ORVVHV MXVW WR HQVXUH $3& SROLWLFLDQV KDG QRWKLQJ WR ERDVW DERXW (YHU\ PLVVHG TXDOL¿FDWLRQ DQG HYHU\ KHDUWEUHDNLQJ H[LW IURP D ),)$ WRXUQDPHQW VLQFH ZDV WDOOLHG XS OLNH D SROLWLFDO EDODQFH VKHHW %XW IRRWEDOO LQ LWV LQ¿QLWH ZLVGRP FDUHV YHU\ OLWWOH IRU SROLWLFDO YRRGRR RU DUWL¿FLDO KH[HV %\ KRLVWLQJ WKLV R൶FLDO ),)$ WURSK\ WKHVH PDJQL¿FHQW \RXQJ JLUOV KDYH VLQJOH KDQGHGO\ VKDWWHUHG WKDW SHUVLVWHQW QDUUDWLYH SURYLQJ WKDW WUXH WDOHQW ULJRURXV SUHSDUDWLRQ DQG VKHHU ZLOOSRZHU FDQ HYHQWXDOO\ RYHUULGH PRUH WKDQ D GHFDGH RI LQVWLWXWLRQDO IDLOXUH Dr Cosmas Odoemena is a consultant family physician, Lagos


LAWYER TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

A

TR

UT H

& RE A SO

N

WEEKLY PULLOUT

TR

UT H

& RE A S O

N

Ch

Adulterated Drugs and Consumable Products: Should Culprits Face Death Penalty?


II

T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

IN THIS EDITION

R E Y W LA A

TU ES DAY, NO

VE MB ER 10,

LLOUT WEEKLY PU

TRU

T H & RE A

TRU

T H & RE A

SO

N

N SO

20 26

Whether Defence of Accident Avails Acts done Unlawfully, Wilfully and Recklessly Page IV

Ch

d n a s g u r D d e t a r e t l Adu d l u o h S : s t c u d o r Consumable P h Penalty? t a e D e c a F s t i r p l u C

T

Osinbajo, South East Govs, Galadima, Utomi, Others, to Attend NBASPIDEL Annual Conference Today Page V

Oramah: Africa’s $500bn Reserves Trapped Abroad Despite Funding Crisis

am in support of decentralisation of policing QUOTABLE ‘Ipowers….But, my prescription would have

Page V

been to decentralise it to the Zonal levels first…then to State, the Local Governments….’ -Senator Seriake Dickson, CON, Lawyer; NDC Senator representing Bayelsa West Senatorial District, 10th National Assembly, Federal Republic of Nigeria

COLUMNIST STEPHEN KOLA-BALOGUN Stephen Kola Balogun, is a vastly experienced Legal Practioner who obtained his LL.B from University of Ife and LL.M from School of Oriental & African Studies, University of London. He has Post-Graduate Diplomas in Intellectual Property Law, Construction Law, Management and Arbitration. He has served in various capacities since his Call to the Nigerian Bar in 1982, including practicing at Akinjide & Co., and lecturing part-time at Oxbridge Tutorial College. He was the Honourable Commissioner for Youths, Sports and Special Needs, State of Osun, August, 2011 to November, 2014. He is currently the Principal Partner at Kola Balogun & Partners. SKB, as he is fondly called, is accredited with several publications to his name, both International and Domestic.

LAWYER

Nigerian Legal Awards to Honour Mutfwang, Tinubu, Ajumogobia, Others Page V

Pinheiro Unveils Six Landmark Books on Law, Arbitration Page V

ONIKEPO BRAITHWAITE: EDITOR, JUDE IGBANOI: DEPUTY EDITOR, PETER TAIWO, STEVE AYA: REPORTERS


III THE ADVOCATE

T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

Justice Lifu, the NJC and Judicial Integrity

F

irstly, I would like to state categorically that my primary constituency is the legal profession (the Bar and the Bench), and it should be a cause for concern for all members when activities by some erring members of the profession, drag its reputation into the mud.

Re: Lifu and NJC’s Inaction What did the National Judicial Council (NJC) do to Justice Peter Lifu of the Federal High Court in June 2026, when according to the Court of Appeal, he abused court process by committing ‘judicial rascality’ because he failed to recognise or adhere to judicial hierarchy, and ordered the deregistration of ADC and four other political parties, despite an order of the Court of Appeal, staying proceedings in the case pending the determination of an interlocutory appeal in the matter, which was scheduled for October 2026? The Court of Appeal set aside his judgement, describing his conduct as the highest form of “judicial impertinence, judicial rascality, judicial indiscipline and gross insubordination”. See the case of Owoniyi v Aiyewunmi 2025 16 N.W.L.R. Part 2011 Page 237 per Habeeb Adewale Olumuyiwa Abiru, JSC which was cited by the Court of Appeal in their reprimand of Lifu, on defiance of superior court orders. To the best of the public’s knowledge, the NJC has done nothing to Lifu J. so far. Because, had Lifu J. been punished for his judicial rascality, he may still be on suspension now, and wouldn’t be available to cause more confusion. I have always maintained that, the NJC cannot always wait to receive a petition, before it takes disciplinary action, at least for abuses which are done openly for all to see. In Unity Bank PLC v Tambuwal Construction & Trading Co. Ltd & Anor (2025) LPELR-80562 (SC) per Mohammed Baba Idris, JSC, the Supreme Court held thus: “Judicial notice is the cognisance taken by the Court itself of certain matters which are so notorious, or clearly established, that evidence of their existence is deemed unnecessary”. This principle of taking notice of things done publicly, could also be extended to the NJC. With all due respect, all that may have been required in the case of Lifu J. flouting the Court of Appeal’s order, was for the NJC to examine the judgements of the Court of Appeal and that of Lifu J. and if a prima facie case was established against him, issue him a query. In some instances, such as this, disciplinary proceedings require swift action, particularly when they concern serious matters like the ADC case, which touch on the upcoming general elections taking place in less than 90 days, especially as a means of deterring other judicial officers who may be working hand in glove with politicians, and have the penchant for causing confusion in the polity. Conflicting Court Order from a Sister Court Last Thursday, in Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1819/2025 Nafiu Bala Gombe v ADC & Ors per Lifu J., despite an earlier judgement of a court of coordinate jurisdiction, that is, Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1637/2025 Hon Abejide v ADC & Ors per Justice Musa Liman delivered on 2/7/2026, affirming the legitimacy of the Senator David Mark-led Committee, Lifu J. delivered his own later judgement, declaring the same Mark/Aregbesola Committee that had been previously affirmed, as illegal. I have not had the benefit of reading either judgement, but, some of the highlights of both cases are in the public space. One side of the argument that I have heard is that, Liman J’s d ecision isn’t binding on Lifu J., but persuasive, especially if both cases weren’t on all fours with each other. But, the other side of this argument is that, the essence of justice is to bring clarity and resolution to issues, not to cause confusion. Clarity is a precondition of fairness and equal application. The goals of civil justice, centre on dispute resolution and legal certainty. Confusion is what justice is meant to dispel. Even if the parties in both matters or their subjectmatters aren’t exactly the same, there are some common denominators - 1) Though the Plaintiffs are different - Abejide in the first case and Gombe, in the second; the Defendants appear to be the same in both suits - ADC, INEC, Mark, Aregbesola, Nwosu; and 2) Abejide and Gombe both objected to the Mark/ Aregbesola Committee, and wanted it nullified. Their reasons for seeking the nullification may have been different, but the outcome of their prayers was either of these two options - the affirmation or denial of the Mark/Aregbesola Committee. Additionally, though Liman J. ruled that Abejide didn’t have locus standi to institute the proceedings, he did more than decline jurisdiction, he affirmed the validity of Mark’s Committee. Could a second argument be that, once Liman J. determined that Abejide didn’t have locus and declined jurisdiction, he didn’t have the power to make any pronouncement validating the Mark/Aregbesola Committee? See Madukolu & Ors v Nkemdilim (1962) LPELR-24023(SC) on the consequences on the lack of jurisdiction. Or, once Liman J. affirmed the Mark/Aregbesola Committee, could Gombe then have sought the leave of court to apply to be joined as an interested party in that case and appeal, since the affirmation of the Mark/Aregbesola Committee directly impacted on his own prayer? The answer is, Yes, he could have. After all, it is trite law that an order of a court remains valid, until it is set aside. See Adegbanke v Ojelabi & Ors (2021) LPELR-54992(SC) per Kudirat

for his previous action of judicial rascality. No doubt, Senator David Mark and his co-Defendants must have lodged their appeal against Lifu J’s judgement by now, and applied for a stay of execution of the judgement, pending the outcome of the appeal.

ONIKEPO BRAITHWAITE BRAITHWAITE ONIKEPO

onikepo.braithwaite@thisdaylive. com onikepob@yahoo.com

The

Advocate What did the NJC do to Justice Peter Lifu of the Federal High Court in June 2026, when, according to the Court of Appeal, he abused court process by committing 'judicial rascality'…. To the best of the public’s knowledge, the NJC has done nothing to Lifu J. so far…. Lifu J’s actions have reflected badly on the Judiciary…. Seeing as the Court of Appeal had already openly rebuked Lifu J. for judicial rascality in the deregistration case involving ADC, the CJ shouldn’t have assigned any ADC-related matter like Gombe’s case to Lifu J. This is where allegations of connivance, bias, and wanting to cause confusion may gain ground…. what we are left with today, is one decision saying the Mark/Aregbesola Committee should stay, and another, saying it should go! If at all, the matter should have been assigned to a neutral third party Motonmori Olatokunbo Kekere-Ekun, JSC (now CJN) where the Supreme Court held that “The law is settled that the judgement of any competent court, once perfected, and not appealed against, is valid and subsisting until it is set aside by competent court or authority”. In this situation, the competent court is the Court of Appeal, to where appeals from the Federal High Court lie - see Section 243(1) of the 1999 Constitution. That way, a situation in which sister courts appear to have given conflicting decisions would have been avoided, because what we are left with today, is one decision saying the Mark/ Aregbesola Committee should stay, and another, saying it should go! In FAAN v Bi-Courtney Ltd & Anor (2024) LPELR-79934(SC) per Helen Moronkeji Ogunwumiju, JSC, the Supreme Court held that “The law is settled that only parties affected by a decision of the court may appeal against it as of right, any other interested party requires leave to appeal as such…A non-party having an interest in the matter…must first and foremost, seek leave to join and be made a party in the matter as his name did not feature in the record of proceedings”. In Re: Nigeria Customs Service Board (2022) LPELR-56659(SC) per Tijjani Abubakar, JSC, the Supreme Court held thus: “An Applicant seeking for leave of court to appeal as an interested party, must make a detailed deposition in his affidavit in support of the application to show; (a) his interest in the matter; (b) why he was not a party in the trial court; (c) good reasons for the delay in filing the application”.

Justice Peter Lifu

Was this a deliberate, orchestrated attempt to cause confusion, using the Gombe case? It certainly looks like it, particularly with the matter being reassigned to Lifu J. who had shown his bias by desperately ordering the deregistration of ADC and others, during the pendency of a stay of proceedings. Furthermore, whether or not Abejide and Gombe’s cases can be distinguished, Lifu J’s pronouncement declaring the Mark/Aregbesola Committee illegal, resulted in reversing the order of a sister court, more or less appearing as if Lifu J. had sat as an appeal court over the judgement of Liman J. of the same court! In Edo State House of Assembly & Ors v Agbebaku (2018) LPELR-45056(CA) per Helen Moronkeji Ogunwumiju, JCA (as she then was), the Court of Appeal held inter alia that: “The general position of the law is that, a court cannot set aside its decision, or the decision of a court of coordinate jurisdiction made on the merits”. Lifu J. then went on to make orders restraining Mark and Rauf Aregbesola from parading themselves as National Chairman and National Secretary of the ADC respectively, when Liman J. had directed INEC to recognise them. Lifu also nullified their actions, including the party’s primary that produced Alhaji Atiku Abubakar, GCON, as the ADC Presidential Candidate. Lifu J’s actions have reflected badly on the Judiciary; if anything, they seem to have dented its reputation, as he literally threw caution to the wind, descended into the arena and was emboldened, since he suffered no consequences

Judicial Bias and Forum Shopping The truth is that Lifu J. appears to be biased, against those whom he has been ruling against. In Rafiu Womiloju & Ors v Fatai Ogisanyin-Anibire & Ors (2010) LPELR-3503 (SC) per Ibrahim Tanko Muhammad, JSC (later CJN) the Supreme Court held that “When a Judge appears to give more favour or consideration to one of the parties before him, either in his utterances, attention or actions, which is capable of perverting the cause of justice, or where fair hearing cannot be said to take place, all in favour of the party he supports covertly or overtly, then an allegation of bias against him can be grounded. That of course is a Judicial bias”. In the case of Lifu J, he appears to have defied the doctrine of judicial hierarchy, precedent, and the rule against setting aside the decision of a court coordinate jurisdiction, to decide against the Mark/Aregbesola Committee and their ADC, come hell or high water! From the information available, there is also an allegation of forum shopping against Gombe, which is also an abuse of court process. See the case of Mailantarki v Tongo & Ors (2017) LPELR42467(SC) per Ejembi Eko, JSC, where the Supreme Court held that “forum shopping is a specie of abuse of judicial process: Forum shopping denotes a rather reprehensible practice of choosing the most favourable territorial jurisdiction or court, in which a matter or cause may be entertained and adjudicated upon”. Gombe’s suit was originally before Justice Emeka Nwite. After the Supreme Court in related proceedings, set aside the Court of Appeal’s status-quo order and directed an accelerated hearing, Gombe petitioned the FHC Chief Judge (CJ) for reassignment of the case, citing loss of confidence in Nwite J. It was reassigned to Lifu J - see Mailantarki v Tongo & Ors (Supra). That, in itself, wasn’t just wrong, but showed some deliberate collusion on the part of the FHC CJ and Lifu J. Seeing as the Court of Appeal had already openly rebuked Lifu J. for judicial rascality in the deregistration case involving ADC, the CJ shouldn’t have assigned any ADC-related matter like Gombe’s case, to Lifu J. This is where allegations of connivance, bias, and wanting to cause confusion may gain ground. If at all, the matter should have been assigned to a neutral third party. The Defendants had also applied for recusal of Lifu J. on grounds of bias; Lifu J. dismissed the application, even ordering costs against them. This points to a denial of the Defendants’ right to fair hearing, contrary to Section 36(1) of the Constitution, and smacks of partiality in favour of Gombe. If Gombe’s application for reassignment was granted, it is only fair that that of the Defendants, be also granted. After all, what is good for the goose, is good for the gander! Effects of Bad Behaviour Can we simply sit back, and let judicial officers and legal practitioners who may be in cahoots with politicians who practice ‘by any means necessary’ or ‘the end justifies the means’, ruin the reputation of the Judiciary and the legal profession, and destroy these institutions? The core effects of tolerating this kind of abusive practice is that, it erodes the rule of law; undermines democracy; encourages corruption and impunity; has dire economic consequences, as it chases away both local and foreign investors, and diminishes public trust in the Judiciary, which ordinarily, should be the last hope of the common man. Conclusion The repeated pattern of disregard for superior orders, coordinate-jurisdiction principles, and the doctrine of judicial hierarchy, cannot be dismissed as isolated error. When a Judge who has already been publicly reprimanded by the Court of Appeal for judicial rascality, is permitted to deliver a second judgement in a related matter that effectively nullifies the decision of a sister court, the damage extends far beyond the parties before him. It signals that there may be no real consequences, for judicial indiscipline. The NJC has a constitutional responsibility, to protect the integrity of the Judiciary. Publicly available facts - the Court of Appeal’s findings in the deregistration matter, the existence of two conflicting FHC judgements on the Mark-led ADC leadership, the reassignment controversy, and the proximity of the 2027 elections - furnish a sufficient basis for the NJC to examine the conduct of Lifu J., without waiting for a fresh petition that may itself be delayed or discontinued. Failure to act in a matter this visible and this consequential, does not merely leave one Judge unaccountable; it erodes the very hierarchy and discipline upon which the entire judicial system rests. A Judiciary that appears to tolerate such conduct, is perceived to be one that isn’t a reliable guardian of the rule of law. In an election season, that failure carries a direct cost to democratic stability. The institutions charged with judicial discipline must either assert themselves now, or accept that the public will increasingly view conflicting court orders not as aberrations, but as features of a system that no longer polices its own. Already, with the issues in its appeal process, the LPDC which is responsible for the discipline of Lawyers, resembles a dog that barks, but has no bite. Haba!


IV LAW REPORT

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 ˾ T H I S D AY

Whether Defence of Accident Avails Acts done Unlawfully, Wilfully and Recklessly Facts

The Appellant was engaged in an argument with one Aniefon Patrick Umoh (the deceased) in front of the deceased’s residence, about whose house is bigger. Following the argument, the Appellant returned to his residence, armed himself with a machete and proceeded to the deceased’s residence, where he attacked the deceased as he emerged from the bathroom, inflicting a fatal injury to his neck. The deceased consequently, died from the injury sustained. Following the incident, the Appellant was arrested and arraigned before the High Court of Akwa Ibom State, Ikot Ekpene, on a one-count charge of murder contrary to Section 326(1) of the Criminal Code, Cap. 38, Vol. 11, Laws of Akwa Ibom State, 2000. At the trial, the Appellant pleaded not guilty to the charge. In proof of its case, the prosecution called five witnesses and tendered documentary exhibits, including the Appellant’s extra-judicial statements, the deceased’s post-mortem report and photographs of the deceased’s corpse. The Appellant testified in his defence, as the sole defence witness. In its judgement, the trial court held that, the prosecution had proved the charge of murder beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the court convicted the Appellant and sentenced him to death by hanging. Dissatisfied with the judgement, the Appellant appealed to the Court of Appeal, Calabar Division, which affirmed the conviction and sentence imposed by the trial court. Still dissatisfied, the Appellant appealed to the Supreme Court. Issues for Determination The Supreme Court considered the following three issues for determination of the appeal: i. Whether the learned Justices of the Court of Appeal erred in law, when they held that medical evidence was irrelevant to establish the guilt of the Appellant in the circumstances of this case? ii. Whether the lower court was wrong to rely on the evidence led by the Respondent’s witnesses? iii. Whether PW1 was a tainted witness, and his evidence ought not to be relied upon. Arguments On issue one, the Appellant contended that medical evidence was necessary to establish beyond reasonable doubt, that the injury inflicted on the deceased caused his death. He submitted further that the Court of Appeal erred in treating the challenge to the competence of PW5 to give medical evidence as a fresh issue requiring leave of court, when he had raised the issue in his final written address before the trial court, on the ground that PW5 was not a pathologist. The Appellant argued that the competence of PW5 to give medical evidence under Section 55(1) of the Evidence Act was a substantial question of law, which could be raised without leave of court. Responding to the submissions, the Respondent argued that medical evidence was not necessary to establish the cause of the death of the deceased, as the testimonies of PW1 and PW2, together with the Appellant’s confessional statements, sufficiently established that the deceased died immediately after being attacked by the Appellant with a machete. The Respondent argued further that, the challenge to the competence of PW5 to give medical evidence ought to have been raised before the trial court. Having failed to do so, the Appellant could not raise the issue for the first time before the Court of Appeal, without obtaining leave. In his reply, the Appellant maintained that only a government pathologist was competent, to tender a post-mortem report in a criminal trial. The Appellant relied on STATE v AJIE (2000) FWLR (PT. 16) 2031 and reiterated that, the competence of PW5 was a substantial question of law requiring no further evidence or leave of court. Regarding issue two, the Appellant submitted that the requisite intention to commit murder was not established, as the Appellant neither intended to kill the deceased nor cause him grievous bodily harm. He argued that PW1 was not an eyewitness to the incident, having neither witnessed the attack nor seen the Appellant inflict the fatal injury on the deceased. He posited that merely hearing the deceased’s cry and subsequently seeing the Appellant holding a machete, wasn’t sufficient to establish the Appellant’s culpability; submitting further that the Appellant acted in the heat of passion following the injury inflicted on him by the deceased, without sufficient time for his temper to cool, and was therefore, entitled to the defence of provocation. The Appellant argued that the contradictions in the testimonies of PW1 and PW4 regarding the time of the incident undermined their credibility, and rendered their evidence unreliable. Reacting to the submissions, the Respondent argued that a person is presumed to intend the natural consequences of his actions, particularly having regard to the nature of the weapon used, the part of the deceased’s body struck, and the severity of the injury inflicted. The Respondent submitted that the defence of provocation was unavailable to the Appellant, as sufficient time had elapsed between the alleged provocative act and the Appellant’s retaliation. Further, that any discrepancy in the witnesses’ accounts regarding the time of the incident was immaterial, and did not affect the substance of the prosecution’s case. On issue three, the Appellant argued that PW1, being a blood relative of the deceased, was a tainted witness whose testimony ought to have been treated with caution. He contended that the trial court failed to exercise the requisite caution or seek corroborative evidence, before relying on the testimony of PW1. He submitted that reliance on the testimony of PW1 by the lower courts was perverse, and occasioned a miscarriage of justice. The Respondent posited contra-wise, arguing that the Appellant failed to establish any basis for treating PW1 as a tainted witness, as no evidence was adduced to demonstrate

Honourable Abubakar Sadiq Umar, JSC In the Supreme Court of Nigeria Holden at Abuja On Friday, the 27th day of March, 2026 Before their Lordships Helen Moronkeji Ogunwumiju Adamu Jauro Moore Aseimo Adumein Habeeb Adewale Olumuyiwa Abiru Abubakar Sadiq Umar Justices, Supreme Court SC/1411c/2019 Between Imo Denis Akpan Obot

Appellant And

The State

Respondent

(Lead Judge delivered by Honourable Abubakar Sadiq Umar, JSC)

that PW1 had any personal interest or ulterior motive in testifying against the Appellant. It maintained that the mere fact that PW1 was the deceased's brother did not, without more, render him a tainted witness. Court’s Judgement and Rationale In resolving issue one, the Supreme Court reiterated the settled principle of law that, in criminal proceedings, the prosecution bears the burden of proving beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased died as a result of the act or omission of the Defendant. Although medical report or autopsy is the standard scientific method for establishing the link, such reports are not always indispensable. The court held that the most prominent exception to the requirement of medical evidence is based on the principle of obvious cause of death, such that even a layperson can reasonably infer it, without scientific expertise. The principle is often applied, in cases where the deceased was healthy before and died after sustaining the injury from

a lethal weapon – SANSANI v STATE (2023) 3 NWLR (PT. 1871) 259. The Supreme Court held that the court, in dispensing with medical report, can rely on cogent and credible confessional, direct or circumstantial evidence, to infer the cause of death. The court will also look at the nature of injury, if the injuries are so severe for which death is the logical outcome. Further, Pursuant to Section 40(1) of the Evidence Act as amended, a statement made by a person as to the cause of their death is admissible. If a victim in danger of death, identifies their attacker or describes the events leading to their fatal injury, this “dying declaration” can be used to prove the cause of death without the absolute necessity of a corroborating medical report, provided the statement is credible. Therefore, the testimony of PW1 about the dying declaration of the deceased that “Imo Denis has killed me” is cogent and admissible. Deciding issue two, the Supreme Court held that

The defence of accident does not avail an act done unlawfully, wilfully, recklessly as in the instant case, whereby the Appellant claimed he intended to stab the hands of the deceased

for the defence of accident to avail a Defendant, he must show the following (a) that the act was done by accident; (b) that there was no criminal intention or knowledge; and (c) that the act was done in the course of doing a lawful means and with proper care and caution. The defence of accident does not avail an act done unlawfully, wilfully, recklessly as in the instant case, whereby the Appellant claimed he intended to stab the hands of the deceased. The Supreme Court held further held that dying declaration is an exception to hearsay evidence. Under Section 39 of the Evidence Act as amended, statements made by persons who cannot be called as witnesses (including those who are dead) are admissible under specific conditions. The justification for this exception, is rooted in the solemnity of the occasion. For a statement to be admitted as a dying declaration under the Nigerian Law, certain conditions must be met, these include: (a) The declarant must have died, before the statement is offered in evidence; (b) the statement must relate to the cause of the declarant’s death, or the circumstances leading to it; (c) the cause of the declarant’s death, must be the subject of the inquiry; (d) the declarant, at the time of making the statement, must have believed himself to be in danger of approaching death – IDAHOSA v IDAHOSA (2020) LPELR – 52018 (SC). The Supreme Court, relying on its earlier decision in IGENTI v STATE (2025) LPELR-80111 (SC) held that, the defence of provocation does not exonerate or exculpate the accused person. Instead, it acknowledges that the accused acted under a temporary loss of self-control triggered by the deceased’s action. Where the defence succeeds, it has the effect of mitigating the offence to manslaughter. For the defence of provocation to avail an accused person, specific conjunctive elements must be proven: (a) grave and sudden provocation; (b) heat of passion and loss of self-control; (c) absence of cooling time. From the statement of the Appellant, the defence of provocation can no longer avail him, because he did not retaliate on the spur of the moment; he had to run to his house to find machete, before heading to the deceased’s house. Within that period, there is enough time for the boiling passion to have cooled. It follows that the lower courts were right, in holding that the defence of provocation could not avail the Appellant in the circumstances. With regard to the submission on contradiction of evidence, the court held that for a contradiction to invalidate the evidence of a witness or be fatal to the prosecution’s case, it must be material and touch upon the essential ingredients of the offence charged. In OLANREWAJU v STATE (2022) LPELR-57788 (SC), it was emphasised that a human being is not a supernatural being, and the human faculty may miss minor details due to the lapse of time and errors in narration. If every trial contradiction or put differently, minor discrepancies were to vitiate a trial, nearly all prosecutions would fail. Consequently, the defences of accident and provocation and the discrepancy in time the crime was committed raised by the Appellant, are not substantial to create a reasonable doubt in the mind of the court. Deciding issue three, the Supreme Court held that the law does not disqualify a witness, simply because they share a familial or biological bond with a victim or Defendant. Instead, the focus of the court remains on competence, relevance, and credibility of the testimony provided – Section 175(1) of the Evidence Act. Their Lordships held further that there is no law prohibiting a blood relation from testifying for the prosecution, provided the evidence is cogent enough to rule out the possibility of deliberate falsehood or bias. Blood relations of a victim are competent witnesses, and their evidence does not require corroboration. It would be unjust to classify them as automatic “tainted witnesses”, who have their own purposes to serve. Relying on its earlier decision in ILIYASU V STATE (2024) LPELR-62971 (SC), the court held that evidence of a blood relation is admissible and can be relied upon for conviction, but the court must be “wary and cautious”. Once the court warns itself of the relationship and is satisfied that the witness is speaking the truth, it can safely convict based on that testimony. It is not enough that PW1 is a blood relative, the Appellant ought to show that PW1 is indeed, a tainted witness with facts and material evidence, before the evidence of PW1 can be discountenanced. In conclusion, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal for lack of merit, and affirmed the concurrent judgements of the trial court and the Court of Appeal, convicting the Appellant for murder and sentencing him to death by hanging. Appeal Dismissed. Representation Chief Paul C. Obi, SAN and Luke Okpalike for the Appellant. Godwin Udom, Assistant Director (Legal) M.O.J. Akwa-Ibom State for the Respondent. Reported by Optimum Publishers Limited, Publishers of the Nigerian Monthly Law Reports (NMLR) (An affiliate of Babalakin & Co.)


V

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 ˾ T H I S D AY

NEWS

Former Vice President, Prof Yemi Osinbajo, L-R: Prof L. Fubara Anga, SAN; Mrs Oramah; Keynote Speaker, Prof Benedict Okey Oramah; Lecture Chair, Mrs Bola Adesola; Femi D. Ojumu; and Theophilus Emuwa GCON, SAN

Dr Kemi Pinheiro, SAN

Osinbajo, South East Govs, Galadima, Utomi, Others, to Attend NBA-SPIDEL Annual Conference Today Gbenga Sodeinde in Ado-Ekiti Former Vice President, Prof. Yemi Osinbajo, GCON, SAN will today deliver the Keynote Address at the 2026 Nigerian Bar Association Section on Public Interest and Development Law (NBASPIDEL) Annual Conference. The address is the highlight of the Keynote Session, holding today at the International Conference Centre (ICC), Umuahia, Abia State. The Conference theme is “In Public Interest: Advancing Justice, Democracy &

Development”. The Keynote Session will be chaired by former Supreme Court jurist, Justice Suleiman Galadima, CFR, with responses by Prof. Pat Utomi, Founder/ CEO, Centre for Values & Leadership; Lisa Henry, Secretary General of the International Rehabilitation Council for Torture Victims (IRCT); and Assoc. Professor Sam Amadi, Director of Abuja School of Social & Political Thought. The NBA-SPIDEL Annual Conference Speech will be delivered by the AttorneyGeneral of the Federation

and Minister of Justice, Prince Lateef Fagbemi, SAN. The Opening Ceremony will feature welcome remarks by the Chairman of the 2026 Conference Planning Committee, Sir Ejike Ezenwa, SAN, a welcome address by NBA-SPIDEL Chair, Prof. Uju Agomoh, and the NBA President’s Address by Mrs Oyinkansola Badejo-Okunsaya, SAN. Goodwill messages will be delivered by past NBA Presidents, Dr Olisa Agbakoba, SAN, Mr Augustine Alegeh, CON, SAN, Mr Paul Usoro, SAN, Mr Olumide Akpata and

Mazi Afam Osigwe, SAN. Also expected are Dr Kingsley Udeh, SAN, Minister of Innovation, Science and Technology; Imo State Governor, Senator Hope Uzodinma; Enugu State

Dr ‘Kemi Pinheiro, SAN, is set to unveil six landmark legal publications covering different aspects of legal practice, jurisprudence, arbitration and the relationship between law and faith. The public presentation

of the books, scheduled for November 20, 2026, is expected to celebrate Pinheiro’s four decades of legal practice and contribution to the development of legal scholarship. The six publications include Defining Moments (Chronicles of a Silk), Volume

Appeal Court Clears Way for Fresh Offa Robbery Trial Stories by Steve Aya The Court of Appeal has rejected applications by former Senate President, Dr Bukola Saraki and former Kwara State Governor, Abdulfatah Ahmed, seeking to stop proceedings in the fresh Offa robbery case before the Kwara State High Court. The appellate court, sitting in Ilorin, held that the pending appeals did not provide sufficient grounds to suspend the criminal proceedings. The applications followed a fresh 20-count charge filed by the Kwara State Government against Saraki, Ahmed and two other Defendants over the deadly robbery in Offa on April 5, 2018. The Defendants are facing allegations, bordering on criminal conspiracy and culpable homicide. They had approached the

appellate court, seeking an order restraining the trial court from proceeding with the case, until their appeals were determined. However, the prosecution opposed the applications, arguing that the appeals should not be used to frustrate the criminal proceedings. In its decision, the Court of Appeal refused the requests for a stay of proceedings, but granted the Appellants four days to file their reply briefs. The decision allows the Kwara State High Court to continue hearing the case, while the appeals are being considered. The 2018 robbery resulted in the deaths of several people, including Police officers. Five principal suspects were convicted in 2024, with their convictions subsequently, upheld by the Court of Appeal.

One; Arbitration Law and Practice in Nigeria; Insolvency Law in Nigeria: Practice and Procedure; Strategies Criminal Trials: A Practitioner’s Guide; The Compendium; and Trending Issues of Law and Faith in Honour of ‘Kemi Pinheiro. The publications explore critical areas of legal practice, drawing from the author's professional experience, courtroom engagements and extensive involvement in legal discourse. According to the announcement, the books

East Council of Traditional Rulers, His Royal Majesty, Dr Lawrence Agubuzu, CFR. Abia State Governor, Dr Alex Otti will deliver his address, and formally declare the Conference open.

Oramah: Africa’s $500bn Reserves Trapped Abroad Despite Funding Crisis Former President of the African Export-Import Bank (Afreximbank), Prof. Benedict Oramah, has urged African leaders to reclaim control of the continent’s financial

Pinheiro Unveils Six Landmark Books on Law, Arbitration

Stories by Steve Aya

Governor, Dr Peter Mbah; Ebonyi State Governor, Rt. Hon. Francis Nwifuru; Deputy Speaker, House of Representatives, Rt. Hon. Benjamin Okezie Kalu; and former Chairman, South-

have received commendations from distinguished members of the legal profession for their depth, practical relevance and accessible presentation. The collection is expected to serve as a valuable resource for legal practitioners, Judges, academics, students and policymakers. The six-book project is described as an intellectual contribution, aimed at strengthening legal knowledge and advancing discussions on law and justice.

resources, warning that up to $500 billion in reserves remain outside Africa, despite severe local funding shortages. Oramah said Africa’s foreign reserves were estimated at between $350 billion and $500 billion, with most held in non-African banks. He noted that African countries could be denied credit by the same institutions holding their funds, citing compliance and country-risk concerns. He spoke last Wednesday at the 20th AELEX Annual Lecture at the Nigerian Institute of International Affairs, Lagos, where he called for home-grown economic solutions, and less dependence on foreign financing and imported economic models. Citing Asia’s response to the 1997–1998 financial crisis, Oramah pointed to the Chiang Mai Initiative,

a regional financial safety net established by ASEAN countries, China, Japan and South Korea, with about $240 billion in financing capacity. He urged African countries to strengthen indigenous financial institutions, expand local-currency financing, and retain more capital within the continent. Oramah also advocated wider use of the Pan-African Payment and Settlement System (PAPSS) to facilitate trade in African currencies, reduce transaction costs and deepen regional integration. He disclosed that Afreximbank mobilised more than $40 billion through its central bank deposit programme, during his tenure. He also called for investment in energy, data centres and local processing of critical minerals.

Lawyer Seeks New Appeal Framework for LPDC Decisions A legal practitioner, Emmanuel Umohinyang, has called on the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA), the Attorney-General of the Federation and the Body of Benchers, to establish a constitutionally valid appeal mechanism for challenging decisions of the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC). Umohinyang made the appeal in separate letters to the three institutions, warning that the absence of a clearly defined appellate process could undermine the rights of Lawyers facing disciplinary proceedings. He said the situation also raised concerns about transparency

and public confidence, in the regulation of the legal profession. His intervention followed a Supreme Court decision which declared unconstitutional the

provision of Section 12(7) of the Legal Practitioners Act, conferring jurisdiction on the Apex Court to entertain direct appeals against LPDC decisions.

The judgement has raised questions about the appropriate judicial channel, through which Lawyers dissatisfied with disciplinary sanctions can seek redress.

Nigerian Legal Awards to Honour Mutfwang, Tinubu, Ajumogobia, Others The 13th edition of the Nigerian Legal Awards will recognise outstanding Lawyers, business leaders and institutions whose contributions have shaped Nigeria’s corporate, financial and economic landscape. The awards, organised by ESQ Trainings Limited, publishers of ESQ Legal Practice Magazine, will hold on Sunday, November 15, 2026, at the Landmark Event

Centre, Victoria Island, Lagos. Among prominent personalities billed for recognition are Plateau State Governor, Caleb Mutfwang; former Minister of State for Petroleum Resources and Foreign Affairs, Odein Ajumogobia, SAN; Group Chief Executive of Oando Plc, Adewale Tinubu; and Senator Adeniyi Adegbonmire, SAN. Institutions expected to receive recognition include,

the Nigerian Communications Commission and the Securities and Exchange Commission. According to the organisers, this year's edition will place particular emphasis on major financial and commercial transactions undertaken between August 2024 and September 2026, highlighting the legal expertise behind investments, acquisitions, financing arrangements and corporate restructuring.


VI

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 ˾ T H I S D AY

COVER

Senator President, Godswill Akpabio, GCON

Coordinating Minister of Health and Social Welfare, Prof Muhammad Ali Pate

Adulterated Drugs and Consumable Products: Should Culprits Face Death Penalty? For years, Nigeria has been plagued by the activities of greedy and unscrupulous persons who manufacture and distribute fake, adulterated and substandard drugs, drinks and food items. The consequences are stark: dialysis centres in hospitals across the country are overstretched, and preventable deaths continue to mount in large numbers. In response, the National Assembly has taken a significant step, by considering legislation that would impose the death penalty on those found culpable. Will the Bill scale through? Is capital punishment justified under the circumstances? Jonathan Gunu Taidi, SAN; Norrison Quakers, SAN; George Oguntade, SAN and Ayoade Oluwasanmi examine these questions against the background of the law Proposed Death Penalty for Counterfeit Drugs and Unsafe Food Products: A Constitutional and Legislative Appraisal Jonathan Gunu Taidi, SAN Introduction he principal legislation currently governing this subject, is the Counterfeit and Fake Drugs and Unwholesome Processed Foods (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act. The Act prohibits various activities involving counterfeit, adulterated, banned, fake, substandard and expired drugs, as well as unwholesome processed foods. Section 3 prescribes imprisonment for a term of not less than five years and not more than 15 years, a fine not exceeding 500,000 or both, for offences under the Act. This legislation operates alongside the NAFDAC Act, the Food, Drugs and Related Products (Registration, etc.) Act and other applicable provisions of the Penal Code and Criminal Code. The proliferation and persistence of these criminal activities have prompted calls for more stringent punishment, including the death penalty. The dangers posed by fake and substandard medicines, cannot be overstated. They can result in failed treatment, organ damage, infant mortality and increased resistance to antibiotics. Members of the Senate have also linked the circulation of counterfeit medicines, to kidney failure and other serious health complications. The victims are often

T

among the most vulnerable members of society, with little or no capacity to distinguish genuine products from dangerous imitations. The harm is frequently insidious, affecting numerous unsuspecting consumers, while those responsible knowingly exploit the market for profit. NAFDAC has maintained that existing sanctions have proved inadequate, to deter a trade that poses grave risks to public health and human life. Proponents of capital punishment also invoke the principles of retribution and incapacitation, alongside the understandable public demand for a decisive response. The urgency of the problem, is beyond dispute. The real question, however, is not whether a stronger response is necessary, but whether the death penalty is the appropriate and proportionate response.

According to the DAWN Commission report quoted by the Sicuro Group article, 40% of general consumer goods in major markets are counterfeit or substandard….The dangers posed by fake and substandard medicines, cannot be overstated. They can result in failed treatment, organ damage, infant mortality and increased resistance to antibiotics. Members of the Senate have also linked the circulation of counterfeit medicines, to kidney failure and other serious health complications

Constitutionality of the Proposed Death Penalty The starting point is Section 33(1) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended), which guarantees the right to life, but expressly recognises an exception in respect of the execution of a death sentence imposed by a court for a criminal offence of which the person has been found guilty. The Supreme Court has recognised the constitutional validity of the death penalty, within this framework. Accordingly, a properly enacted law prescribing capital punishment for a clearly defined criminal offence would not be unconstitutional, merely because the prescribed punishment is death. The legislative competence of the National Assembly must, however, be considered in relation to the subject-matter of the proposed legislation. Drugs and poisons fall within the Exclusive Legislative List, thereby giving the National Assembly the requisite legislative competence to regulate and legislate on the subject. Food, drinks and cosmetics present a more nuanced constitutional question. Federal legislative authority in these areas derives principally from its powers relating to regulation, importation and interState commerce, as well as the statutory mandate of NAFDAC. A constitutional argument could nevertheless, arise in respect of activities involving the production and sale of food products confined entirely within a State. To minimise the risk of such a challenge, the legislation should be carefully framed around products subject to Federal regulatory oversight, including those regulated by NAFDAC, and products involved in inter-State or international trade. Point for Legislative Consideration Precision in the definition of offences, is particularly important. Section 36(12) of the Constitution requires that an offence and its prescribed punishment, must be defined in a written law. Terms such as ‘fake’, ‘counterfeit’ and ‘adulterated’ must therefore, be clearly and objectively defined, especially where a conviction could result in the loss of life. It may also be argued that, the death penalty is inconsistent with the prohibition of torture and inhuman or degrading treatment under Section 34(1)(a) of the Constitution and the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, particularly its protections of life and human dignity. In my view, such arguments face considerable constitutional difficulty. Although the African Charter is domestically enforceable, it does not enjoy supremacy

over the Constitution and cannot override the express qualification contained in Section 33(1). Nevertheless, its provisions remain relevant in interpreting the human rights safeguards, and procedural protections that must accompany any legislation of this nature. Proportionality: A Critical Consideration The death penalty is the most severe punishment the State can impose, and should therefore, be reserved, if at all, for the gravest forms of criminal culpability. Consider three situations: a trader who dilutes a beverage to increase profit margins; an importer who brings in improperly labelled cosmetics; and a manufacturer who knowingly introduces a toxic substance into children’s medicine. Although each situation may involve a regulatory or criminal violation, the degree of culpability and the potential consequences, are materially different. A broadly framed provision, such as the one reportedly contemplated in the Enugu draft legislation, covering the manufacture, importation, exportation and distribution of counterfeit products, could potentially subject persons with substantially different levels of culpability to the same punishment. The existing criminal law already provides a framework, for dealing with the most egregious cases. A person who knowingly supplies poison disguised as medicine, resulting in the death of a consumer, may, depending on the available evidence and the applicable law, be prosecuted for murder or culpable homicide, offences which attract the death penalty upon conviction. The more difficult issue is establishing the requisite knowledge, intention and causal connection, particularly where the harmful effects are distributed across numerous victims. If the National Assembly considers it necessary to create a distinct aggravated offence, its application should be tied to a proven death and evidence that the accused knew, or was reckless as to, the likelihood of that fatal outcome. It should not be triggered merely by the commercial act of manufacturing, importing or distributing the offending product. Whether the Death Penalty is the Appropriate Solution The available body of research does not establish that, the death penalty is a more effective deterrent than long-term imprisonment. Research on deterrence consistently suggests that the likelihood of detection, arrest and conviction has a greater influence on criminal behaviour, than the severity of the punishment alone. The counterfeit products trade thrives in an environment characterised by weak detection mechanisms, porous borders, inadequate laboratory capacity, poorly regulated


VII

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 ˾ T H I S D AY

COVER

Adulterated Drugs and Consumable Products: Should Culprits Face Death Penalty? cont'd from page VI

informal markets and corruption. Increasing the severity of punishment does not, in itself, address these underlying weaknesses. Indeed, the proposed Senate legislation also contemplates measures such as tracking technology and expanded enforcement powers, suggesting that effective regulation and detection are equally important components of the response. There is also the possibility that excessively severe punishment, could undermine effective prosecution. Prosecutors, Judges and witnesses may exercise greater caution where conviction carries the ultimate penalty, while suspects facing execution may have stronger incentives to destroy evidence or obstruct investigations. A punishment that is rarely imposed or implemented, may ultimately have limited deterrent value. Furthermore, enforcement efforts often expose small-scale traders and retailers more readily, than the financiers and organised networks behind the counterfeit products trade. Capital prosecutions would also depend heavily on laboratory analysis, expert testimony and the integrity of the chain of custody of exhibits, all of which require considerable institutional and technical capacity. The consequences of a wrongful conviction in such circumstances, would be irreversible. The Enugu draft reportedly combines the proposed death penalty with specialised courts, a 90-day trial period and asset forfeiture. While expeditious trials are desirable, particularly in cases involving serious threats to public health, they must not compromise the constitutional right to a fair hearing. Section 36(1) of the Constitution, guarantees a fair hearing within a reasonable time. However, imposing a rigid 90-day deadline on proceedings in which the accused person’s life is at stake could prejudice the defence, particularly where sufficient time is required to examine forensic evidence, challenge expert testimony and establish the reliability of scientific findings. Any specialised court established for this purpose, must also operate within the existing constitutional framework governing the administration of justice. Similarly, a blanket prohibition of bail raises serious concerns, under the constitutional guarantees of personal liberty and the presumption of innocence. The preferable approach would be to retain judicial discretion, guided by clearly defined statutory considerations. Asset forfeiture provisions, must equally be carefully framed. Forfeiture should be tied to a conviction or an appropriate court-supervised process, and limited to the proceeds and instrumentalities of the offence. A provision permitting indiscriminate or total forfeiture could raise legitimate constitutional concerns under Section 44 of the Constitution, which protects the right to acquire and own property. Any prosecutorial powers conferred on NAFDAC, must also be reconciled with the constitutional powers of the Attorney-General under Section 174. The Deputy President of the Senate has similarly drawn attention to the need for a clear legislative relationship between the proposed framework and the existing NAFDAC Act, in order to avoid duplication and institutional conflicts. My Overall View A consideration of the foregoing issues leads me to the conclusion that the Constitution does not, in principle, preclude the National Assembly from prescribing the death penalty for a properly defined offence involving counterfeit drugs or dangerous food products. The public health emergency underlying the proposal is also real, and demands a decisive legislative response. My reservations, however, are substantial. First, the proposed punishment raises difficult questions of compatibility with evolving international and regional human rights standards. Second, a broadly framed capital offence risks imposing a punishment grossly disproportionate to the culpability of persons, who may have engaged in unlawful commercial activities without intending or knowingly causing death. Third, the available evidence doesn’t establish that the death penalty would deliver a significantly greater deterrent effect than a robust system of detection, prosecution and enforcement. Finally, the procedural measures associated with some versions of the proposal raise legitimate concerns about fair hearing, judicial discretion and the protection of constitutional rights. Reasonable legislators may arrive at different conclusions on the appropriate penal response. Ultimately, the choice of punishment is a matter of legislative policy, subject to constitutional limitations. Whatever position the National Assembly adopts, however, the resulting legislation must contain precise definitions of offences, proportionate penalties and procedures that fully respect the guarantees of Section 36 of the Constitution. Recommendations to the National Assembly In considering the proposed legislation, I respectfully recommend the following: Clearly define and distinguish the offences The legislation should distinguish between counterfeit, fake, adulterated and substandard products, with penalties proportionate to the nature of the offence, the degree of culpability and the actual or potential harm. Restrict any capital offence to the gravest cases If the death penalty is retained, its application should be confined to cases in which death has resulted and the accused is proved to have known, or to have been reckless as to, the likelihood of the fatal consequence. The sentence should remain discretionary, with life imprisonment available as a severe alternative. Protect innocent retailers and consumers The legislation should recognise an appropriate due diligence defence, for persons who can demonstrate that they exercised reasonable care in sourcing and handling products. Strict liability or reverse burdens of proof, should not apply to offences carrying the death penalty. Provide for corporate liability and carefully circumscribed forfeiture The legislation should adequately address the liability of corporate entities, and their responsible officers. Asset forfeiture should be restricted to the proceeds and instrumentalities

Director-General, National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC), Prof Moji Adeyeye of the offence, and made subject to conviction or an appropriate judicial order. Safeguard the constitutional right to a fair hearing Specialised judicial divisions and effective casemanagement mechanisms, may be introduced to facilitate expeditious trials. However, rigid trial deadlines that could compromise the accused person’s right to adequately prepare a defence, should be avoided. Decisions on bail, should remain within the discretion of the courts. Ensure institutional and statutory coherence The proposed legislation should be properly aligned with the NAFDAC Act and the mandate of the NDLEA, while ensuring that any prosecutorial powers conferred on regulatory agencies are consistent with Section 174 of the Constitution. Undertake comprehensive stakeholder consultations and provide for periodic review The National Assembly should conduct a public hearing to obtain the views of relevant stakeholders, including regulatory agencies, pharmaceutical manufacturers, medical practitioners, legal experts, consumer protection organisations and civil society groups. The legislation should also incorporate a review mechanism requiring periodic assessment of its effectiveness through data on investigations, prosecutions, convictions and its overall impact on the market. Conclusion A statutory provision prescribing the death penalty for counterfeiting and adulteration offences would arguably withstand constitutional scrutiny in Nigeria, provided it is properly framed and enacted. However, its compatibility with international and regional human rights standards remains open to serious debate, while the available evidence provides limited support for the proposition that capital punishment would achieve greater deterrence.

The more sustainable legislative response is a carefully calibrated system of penalties that reflects the seriousness of the offence and the culpability of the offender. If capital punishment is retained at all, its application should be restricted to cases involving the knowing or reckless commission of an offence that results in death. Above all, the fight against counterfeit drugs and unsafe food products requires more than severe punishment. It demands stronger regulatory institutions, effective border controls, reliable forensic capacity, consistent enforcement and a criminal justice system capable of identifying and prosecuting those who finance and organise these dangerous activities. The ultimate objective of the proposed legislation should not simply be to punish offenders more severely, but to protect lives, restore public confidence and dismantle the structures that sustain this dangerous trade. Jonathan Gunu Taidi, SAN, former General Secretary, NBA Proposed Death Penalty for Production and Distribution of Fake, Adulterated and Counterfeit Drugs, Drinks and Food Items in Nigeria: A Critical Analysis Norrison Quakers, SAN Introduction The safety of food, drugs and beverages consumed by citizens is fundamental to the survival, health and development of any nation. A society in which citizens cannot confidently purchase medicines, food or drinks without the fear of poisoning, organ damage or death is a society confronted with a serious public health and national security challenge. The proliferation of counterfeit drugs, adulterated alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages, substandard food products and other dangerous consumer goods in Nigeria has

If the death penalty is retained, its application should be confined to cases in which death has resulted and the accused is proved to have known, or to have been reckless as to, the likelihood of the fatal consequence. Ultimately, what Nigeria needs is….a system that ensures that counterfeiters are detected, arrested, prosecuted, convicted and deprived of the financial benefits of their criminal activities. The greatest deterrent to crime, is not necessarily the severity of punishment….

become a matter of considerable public concern, particularly considering the rising and alarming cases of kidney-related health challenges including cancer cases. The activities of unscrupulous manufacturers, importers, distributors and retailers have exposed millions of Nigerians to avoidable illnesses, permanent disabilities and, in some cases, death. Against this background, calls have emerged for the National Assembly to introduce the death penalty as the ultimate punishment for persons who deliberately manufacture, distribute or sell fake and adulterated drugs, drinks and food products. The proposal raises an important question of public policy and criminal justice: Is the death penalty an appropriate, necessary and effective response to the menace of counterfeit and adulterated consumer products, or would it constitute an excessive and potentially counterproductive punishment? This question deserves serious examination, beyond public anger and political expediency. It must be considered from the perspectives of public health, constitutional law, criminal justice, deterrence, human rights and the practical realities of law enforcement in Nigeria. The Merits of Imposing the Death Penalty There are compelling arguments in support of a severe punishment, for persons who deliberately manufacture and distribute dangerous counterfeit products. Protection of human life and public health The strongest argument in favour of the proposal, is the need to protect human life. A person who deliberately manufactures counterfeit medicines, adulterates alcoholic beverages or introduces poisonous substances into food products, is potentially exposing hundreds or thousands of unsuspecting consumers to serious injury or death. Unlike many conventional crimes, the consequences of these activities may extend far beyond the immediate victim. A single production facility can distribute dangerous products across several States, affecting entire communities. Fake medicines may result in treatment failure, organ damage, antimicrobial resistance and death. Adulterated drinks and contaminated food may cause acute poisoning, and other serious health complications. It is therefore, arguable that individuals who knowingly engage in these activities for financial gain, despite being aware of their potentially fatal consequences, should face the severest possible criminal sanctions. The argument is that, the law must demonstrate that commercial profit cannot be placed above human life. Deterrence of prospective offenders The second argument is that, the possibility of capital punishment may discourage individuals and organised criminal networks from engaging in the production and distribution of counterfeit products. Where the existing penalties are perceived as insufficient, offenders may regard the business as a profitable venture, in which the financial benefits outweigh the risks of prosecution. The introduction of a severe penalty, may increase the perceived consequences of engaging in such criminal activities. It may also send a strong message that the Nigerian Government will not tolerate the deliberate endangerment of citizens, through the production and distribution of dangerous consumer products. The protection of innocent and vulnerable consumers Consumers generally have no practical means of determining whether a medicine, bottle of drink or packaged food is genuine, merely by examining its appearance. Counterfeiters frequently imitate established brands, reproduce labels and packaging, manipulate expiry dates, and use sophisticated distribution networks to deceive unsuspecting members of the public. Children, elderly persons, pregnant women and individuals suffering from serious illnesses, are particularly vulnerable. The law must therefore, recognise that the deliberate production of dangerous consumer products constitutes a serious violation of the rights and welfare of the public. Protection of legitimate businesses and the Nigerian economy Counterfeiting does not only injure consumers; it also undermines legitimate businesses. Manufacturers who invest in research, quality control, regulatory compliance, product development and proper distribution, are placed at a competitive disadvantage when counterfeiters flood the market with cheaper and inferior products. This practice damages established brands, discourages investment, reduces consumer confidence and threatens the survival of genuine manufacturing enterprises. Severe penalties may therefore, serve as part of a broader strategy to protect legitimate businesses, encourage investment and strengthen confidence in Nigerian-made products. Demonstration of governmental commitment The introduction of stringent punishment would demonstrate the determination of the National Assembly and the Federal Government to confront a problem that has persisted, despite the existence of regulatory institutions and criminal laws. It would also communicate that the production and distribution of dangerous counterfeit products, should no longer be treated as ordinary commercial or regulatory misconduct. Where offenders knowingly and systematically expose the public to potentially fatal products, the State has a legitimate responsibility to intervene decisively. The demerits and dangers of imposing the death penalty Notwithstanding the foregoing arguments, the introduction of capital punishment raises serious legal, constitutional, moral and practical concerns. The death penalty is irreversible Perhaps, the most compelling objection is the irreversible nature of capital punishment. The Nigerian criminal justice system is not immune from investigative errors, unreliable witnesses, inadequate forensic cont'd on page VIII


VIII COVER

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 ˾ T H I S D AY

Adulterated Drugs and Consumable Products: Should Culprits Face Death Penalty?

Fake and adulterated medicines cont'd from page VIII

facilities, corruption, mistaken identification and wrongful convictions. In cases involving counterfeit drugs, food and beverages, scientific evidence will frequently be central to establishing whether a product is adulterated, contaminated, poisonous or otherwise unsafe. Questions may arise, concerning the source of the product, the person responsible for its manufacture, the knowledge of the accused, the chain of custody of samples and the scientific reliability of laboratory findings. There may also be situations in which a distributor or retailer, unknowingly sells a counterfeit product supplied by another person. If such a person is wrongfully convicted and executed, no subsequent discovery of the truth can restore the person's life. A prison sentence, however severe, can at least be reviewed, commuted or reversed, where fresh evidence establishes a miscarriage of justice. Execution cannot. The principle of proportionality of punishment Criminal punishment must bear a reasonable relationship to the seriousness of the offence, the culpability of the offender, and the circumstances in which the offence was committed. There is a fundamental distinction between: A person who deliberately manufactures poisonous drinks, with the intention of causing harm. A manufacturer who knowingly adulterates food products, for financial gain. A distributor who knowingly supplies counterfeit medicines. A retailer who unknowingly, purchases and sells counterfeit products. A manufacturer who commits a regulatory breach, without an intention to deceive or endanger consumers. These persons cannot reasonably be treated, as having the same degree of criminal responsibility. The imposition of a mandatory death sentence across these different categories of conduct, would offend the principle of proportionality. The law should distinguish between deliberate and reckless conduct, negligence, regulatory violations and innocent involvement. A punishment that fails to distinguish between the levels of culpability of offenders, risks becoming an instrument of injustice, rather than an instrument of justice. The constitutional implications Section 33(1) of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, guarantees the right to life but recognises an exception where life is taken pursuant to the sentence of a court in respect of a criminal offence for which the person has been found guilty. Accordingly, the death penalty is not automatically unconstitutional in Nigeria. The Supreme Court recognised the constitutional validity of capital punishment in Onuoha Kalu v. State (1998) 13 NWLR (Pt. 583) 531. Nevertheless, the constitutional permissibility of capital punishment does not mean that every offence should attract it. Any proposed legislation must also comply with section 36 of the Constitution, particularly the rights to fair hearing,

presumption of innocence, adequate facilities for defence and the principle that no person may be convicted of an offence unless the offence and its punishment are prescribed by written law. The introduction of capital punishment would therefore require particularly rigorous safeguards to prevent arbitrary convictions and executions. The death penalty may not necessarily deter crime One of the assumptions underlying the proposal is that the threat of execution will automatically discourage counterfeiting. However, the relationship between the severity of punishment and the prevention of crime is not that straightforward. A criminal enterprise driven by enormous financial returns, organised criminal networks, weak enforcement and corruption may not be sufficiently discouraged by the existence of the death penalty. An offender who believes that the possibility of arrest is remote may continue the illegal business irrespective of the punishment prescribed by law. The National Human Rights Commission has previously expressed the view that the death penalty, as a retributive measure, may not necessarily serve as a deterrent to crime. It has also highlighted the need for caution in its application, considering the challenges within the Nigerian criminal justice system. The problem of ineffective enforcement Nigeria already has laws prohibiting counterfeit drugs, and unwholesome processed food. The Counterfeit and Fake Drugs and Unwholesome Processed Foods (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, Cap. C34, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria, 2004, and the National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC). The persistence of counterfeit products raises a more fundamental question: Is the problem primarily the inadequacy of the punishment prescribed by law, or the failure to effectively enforce existing legislation? If offenders can operate illegal factories, procure counterfeit packaging materials, manipulate product registration numbers and distribute dangerous products through established commercial channels without being detected, increasing the punishment alone may not solve the problem. A death penalty that is rarely enforced may have less practical impact, than a properly enforced law prescribing substantial imprisonment, financial penalties and asset forfeiture. Potential abuse of the criminal justice system Capital punishment carries a heightened risk where investigative and prosecutorial institutions are vulnerable to corruption, political interference or improper influence. There is a danger that innocent distributors, employees, transporters or business competitors may be implicated in criminal proceedings arising from commercial disputes

There is a fundamental distinction between: A person who deliberately manufactures poisonous drinks, with the intention of causing harm. A manufacturer who knowingly adulterates food products, for financial gain. A distributor who knowingly supplies counterfeit medicines. A retailer who unknowingly, purchases and sells counterfeit products. A manufacturer who commits a regulatory breach, without an intention to deceive or endanger consumers. These persons cannot reasonably be treated, as having the same degree of criminal responsibility

or regulatory disagreements. The severity of the proposed punishment may also create opportunities for intimidation, extortion and manipulation of investigations. This is not an argument for leniency, towards genuine offenders. Rather, it is an argument for ensuring that the criminal justice system is sufficiently reliable before the State is empowered to take a person's life. The possibility of driving the illegal trade underground An excessively punitive approach, particularly where it is not accompanied by effective regulation and enforcement, may drive illegal activities further underground. This could make investigations more difficult, and encourage offenders to operate through more sophisticated and concealed distribution networks. The better approach is to dismantle the entire criminal supply chain, identify the financiers and beneficial owners, trace the proceeds of crime, and prosecute those who control the operations. The critical issue: Should the death penalty apply only where the offence results in death? This is perhaps, the most important consideration that the National Assembly must address. There is a significant difference between the deliberate manufacture of a dangerous product, and the manufacture of a product that actually causes death. The law should not automatically equate the two. For instance, where an individual knowingly manufactures and distributes poisonous alcoholic beverages which cause the death of several consumers, the gravity of the conduct is substantially different from a situation where counterfeit products are discovered before they are consumed. Similarly, where a manufacturer deliberately introduces poisonous substances into food products, knowing that the products may cause serious injury or death, the offender's conduct may justify a substantially more severe punishment than an ordinary regulatory violation. I would therefore, suggest a graduated system of punishment based on the following considerations: 1. Ordinary regulatory violations: Substantial fines, suspension or withdrawal of licences and appropriate custodial sentences. 2. Deliberate counterfeiting without proven injury: Lengthy imprisonment, substantial fines, confiscation of proceeds and forfeiture of equipment and premises used for the illegal business. 3. Reckless or intentional adulteration causing serious bodily injury: Significantly enhanced imprisonment, compensation and asset forfeiture. 4. Deliberate adulteration or counterfeiting resulting in death: The severest available criminal punishment, with capital punishment considered only where the prosecution establishes the necessary elements of an existing or properly defined capital offence, or where a constitutionally valid new offence is created with appropriate safeguards. This approach would ensure that the punishment reflects the seriousness of the conduct, and the actual degree of criminal responsibility. What should the National Assembly prioritise instead? In my view, the National Assembly should focus on a comprehensive legislative and enforcement framework, rather than making the death penalty the central feature of the proposed reform. The following measures deserve serious consideration: Strengthening NAFDAC's enforcement capacity NAFDAC should be adequately funded and equipped with modern laboratory facilities, product-tracking technology, forensic investigation equipment and trained enforcement personnel. The Agency should have the capacity to detect counterfeit products at the point of manufacture, importation, distribution and sale. Criminal prosecution of the entire supply chain

The law should not concentrate exclusively, on the person found manufacturing the counterfeit product. It should also target the financiers, importers, warehouse operators, distributors, suppliers of counterfeit packaging materials, and other persons knowingly facilitating the illegal business. The objective should be to dismantle the criminal enterprise, rather than merely arresting its operatives. Mandatory asset forfeiture Where a person is convicted of deliberately manufacturing or distributing counterfeit products, the court should have the power to confiscate the proceeds of the criminal enterprise and property used in furtherance of the offence, subject to appropriate legal safeguards. This is particularly important, because many of these criminal activities are financially motivated. The confiscation of illegally acquired wealth may be a more effective economic deterrent, than punishment directed solely at the individual offender. Victim compensation The proposed legislation should provide effective mechanisms for compensating victims and the families of persons who die or suffer permanent disabilities, as a result of counterfeit or adulterated products. It is not sufficient for the State to prosecute an offender, while leaving victims and their families to bear the financial and emotional consequences. Compensation should be considered, alongside criminal punishment. Protection of whistleblowers Employees and insiders who expose illegal manufacturing facilities, distribution networks and regulatory violations, should be protected. A confidential reporting system, supported by appropriate witness protection measures, would assist regulatory agencies in uncovering criminal operations. Strengthening border and market surveillance The Nigeria Customs Service, NAFDAC, the Standards Organisation of Nigeria, the Nigeria Police Force and the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, should develop a coordinated enforcement strategy. The illegal importation and distribution of counterfeit medicines, drinks and food products, must be addressed through intelligence-led surveillance and effective border controls. Expedited trials and effective prosecution One of the major weaknesses of criminal justice administration, is the delay between arrest, prosecution and conviction. The proposed legislation should establish effective mechanisms for speedy trials, without compromising the constitutional rights of accused persons. A criminal law that prescribes severe punishment, but cannot secure timely and successful prosecution, will have limited deterrent value. The international human rights perspective The death penalty remains legally permissible in Nigeria under Section 33(1) of the Constitution, subject to the conditions prescribed by law. However, international human rights standards, increasingly encourage the restriction and eventual abolition of capital punishment. Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights recognises the right to life, and places restrictions on the circumstances in which countries retaining capital punishment may impose it. The United Nations Human Rights Committee has interpreted the concept of the most serious crimes restrictively, generally limiting it to crimes of extreme gravity involving intentional killing. This raises an important question, about whether every form of counterfeit drug production, food adulteration or beverage counterfeiting, could properly be classified as an offence warranting capital punishment. It would be difficult to justify treating every such offence as deserving of execution, particularly where there is no proven death or intention to kill. The National Assembly must therefore, consider Nigeria's international obligations, and the constitutional implications of any proposed amendment. My Position: Tougher Punishment, but not necessarily the Death Penalty I strongly support the introduction of substantially tougher penalties for individuals and organisations deliberately engaged in the production and distribution of fake drugs, adulterated drinks and dangerous food products. Indeed, the deliberate poisoning of consumers for financial gain, is an exceptionally grave form of criminal conduct. However, I do not consider the automatic imposition of the death penalty on everyone convicted of counterfeiting or adulteration, to be the most appropriate legislative response. My position is informed by three fundamental considerations. First, the sanctity of human life must be protected, not only against private individuals who engage in criminal activities, but also against the possibility of wrongful or unjustified State execution. Second, criminal punishment must be proportionate to the nature of the offence, the intention of the offender, the consequences of the conduct, and the degree of participation. Third, the effectiveness of criminal legislation should be measured by its ability to prevent crime, identify offenders, secure convictions and protect society, rather than merely by the severity of the punishment it prescribes. There is little value in prescribing the death penalty, where the institutions responsible for detecting and prosecuting offenders are incapable of effectively enforcing the law. The National Assembly should therefore, concentrate on creating a legal framework that makes it virtually impossible for counterfeiters to operate profitably and with impunity. Conclusion The law must protect life, not merely threaten death The fight against counterfeit drugs, adulterated beverages and unsafe food products is a fight for the survival, health and dignity of Nigerians. No individual or business enterprise, should be permitted to turn the lives of innocent citizens into instruments of commercial exploitation. Those who deliberately manufacture poisonous products, falsify medicines and distribute dangerous consumables for financial gain must face severe consequences. Nevertheless, the wisdom of legislation is not determined by the harshness of its punishment, but by its fairness, cont'd on page IX


IX

T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

COVER

Adulterated Drugs and Consumable Products: Should Culprits Face Death Penalty? cont'd from page VIII

effectiveness and capacity to achieve its intended objectives. The death penalty may appeal to public sentiment, in the face of disturbing revelations about counterfeit products. But, public anger, however justified, should not become the sole foundation of criminal legislation. The objective of criminal justice should be to prevent the loss of innocent lives, not merely to create additional opportunities for the State to take lives. The National Assembly must therefore, strike a balance between the protection of public health, the deterrence of criminal conduct, the rights of accused persons and the administration of justice. A properly designed law prescribing lengthy imprisonment, substantial fines, forfeiture of criminal proceeds, compensation for victims and effective prosecution may offer a more sustainable response, than an indiscriminate death penalty. Ultimately, what Nigeria needs is not simply a law that threatens counterfeiters with death, but a system that ensures that counterfeiters are detected, arrested, prosecuted, convicted and deprived of the financial benefits of their criminal activities. The greatest deterrent to crime is not necessarily the severity of punishment; it is the certainty that the law will catch up with the offender. Recommendations to the National Assembly 1. The National Assembly should resist an indiscriminate death penalty provision, covering all forms of counterfeiting and adulteration. 2. The proposed legislation should distinguish between intentional adulteration, reckless conduct, negligence and innocent commercial involvement. 3. The law should prescribe particularly severe penalties for deliberate adulteration that causes death or serious bodily injury, while respecting the legal requirements for establishing a capital offence. 4. There should be mandatory forfeiture of proceeds and instruments of criminal activity upon conviction, subject to due process. 5. Corporate directors and beneficial owners who knowingly authorise or facilitate these activities, should be held personally accountable. 6. NAFDAC and other regulatory agencies should receive adequate funding, technological support and prosecutorial cooperation. 7. There should be a comprehensive product-tracking and consumer-reporting system. 8. The legislation should provide for compensation to victims and their families. 9. Specialised and expedited procedures should be introduced, for prosecuting serious counterfeit-product offences without compromising fair hearing. 10. The National Assembly should establish an effective monitoring mechanism, to assess the implementation and impact of the legislation. Norrison Quakers, SAN, Constitutional Lawyer, Lagos NASS Should Consider Life Imprisonment Instead of Death Penalty George Oguntade, SAN This proposed Bill by the National Assembly raises a profound question about the relationship between morality, criminal responsibility, the sanctity of human life and the limits of State punishment. A legal system is not necessarily more effective, because it prescribes death for more offences. Its effectiveness lies in its ability to detect crime, secure reliable evidence, prosecute offenders, obtain convictions and impose appropriate punishment. The function of the law is to be uncompromising in punishing those who knowingly trade in human lives, but the State must not sacrifice the principles of proportionality, fairness and the sanctity of human life, in its determination to punish them. Ultimately, morality should inform the law, but it should not become an excuse for abandoning the rule of law. The National Assembly should instead of the proposed Death Penalty Bill, consider a graduated punishment regime: - Life imprisonment for exceptionally grave cases involving deliberate manufacture and distribution of poisonous products, subject to constitutional and international law. - Long-term imprisonment for knowing and deliberate counterfeiting. - Enhanced punishment where the offence results in death or serious bodily injury, with prosecution for homicide where the elements of that offence are established. - Mandatory forfeiture, following conviction and due process, of proceeds and assets acquired through the criminal enterprise. - Personal criminal liability for directors, promoters and financiers who knowingly participate in the criminal enterprise. - Victim compensation, including compensation to families of persons who die as a consequence of the offences. - Specialised prosecution and expedited trials, with adequate forensic facilities and protection against interference. George Oguntade, SAN, Lagos Curbing Nigeria’s Counterfeiting N1.5 Trillion Industry: Is the Death Penalty the Solution? Ayoade Oluwasanmi According to quick Google search, Nigeria’s counterfeit product industry is worth N15 trillion per year, factoring in lost tax revenues, destruction of legitimate industry, and

A kidney disease patient undergoing dialysis healthcare costs. According to an article by the Sicuro Group. The figures came from a report published by the DAWN Commission, a technocratic institution set up by Governments of the Southwest States, for the sustainable development of the region. According to the article, one of the conclusions is that, “Southwest Nigeria is the epicentre of Africa’s largest counterfeit consumer goods economy”. The article also mentioned that based on the level of counterfeiting going on, Nigeria could legitimately meet all the pharmaceutical needs of West Africa. The size of the counterfeit industry is estimated to be 57.4% of Nigeria’s GDP. According to the DAWN Commission report quoted by the Sicuro Group article, 40% of general consumer goods in major markets are counterfeit or substandard. These are huge numbers by any metric. N15 trillion cost to the economy. 57.4% of Nigeria’s GDP. 40% of consumer goods are counterfeit or substandard. Those are very scary numbers. Its almost as if there are no legitimate products being made in the country, and that counterfeiting is what powers the Nigerian economy. There are urgent solutions that the Nigerian government and other stakeholders need to come up with, to help sanitise the manufacturing industry. However, if reports are to be believed, the National Assembly is considering passing a law to impose the death penalty on product counterfeiters. According to a report in Sahara Reporters, sometime in October 2026, the Forum of Former Members of the Enugu State House of Assembly sent a legislative memorandum and draft bill — Counterfeit Products (Special Penal Provisions and Fast-Track Judiciary) Act, 2026 — to the President, and senior members of the National Assembly and security agencies. The Bill allegedly proposes capital punishment, non-bailable status, total asset forfeiture, and 90-day fast-track trials for manufacturing or distributing counterfeit drugs, falsified consumables, and hard drugs. Also in July of this year, according to an article in The Cable, the Senate passed for second reading, the Counterfeit Medical Products, Fake Drugs and Unwholesome Processed Foods (Prohibition and Control) Bill, 2026, which currently proposes a 15-year prison term, asset forfeiture, and victim compensation, rather than the death penalty. To put this in perspective, there are laws in certain States that impose the capital punishment for kidnapping, terrorism and other offences, but these heinous acts are still being carried out. Why? The people involved consider the monetary rewards from carrying out these heinous acts, greater than the risk involved. Even when they fully understand the risk, they convince themselves they can either beat the system by being smarter and one step ahead, or finding a way to corrupt the system. Without mincing words, while I do believe that those who counterfeit or adulterate consumable goods or pharmaceuticals are despicable human beings who deserve lengthy prison sentences, I am not sure the death penalty is the cure-all they want to make it out to be. I am not a manufacturer and I do not claim to have all the answers, but I do have a few thoughts as to how Nigerian can tackle the issue of counterfeit products. Tackling Counterfeit Products The first thing is that, the Federal Government needs to fix the economy and the education system as a matter of urgency. While it is not my intention to try and humanise or condone illegal actions, it would be foolish to ignore the fact that people are making choices about whether to engage in illegal acts or not, based on their access to education and the opportunities open to them in the economy based on their education or lack of it. I understand that some will make the argument that there are those who have no education and have limited economic choices as a result of that, and do not make the choice of a life of crime, that taking to a life of crime is a choice these counterfeiters make. However, no one can deny that education opens up

It is not sufficient for the State to prosecute an offender, while leaving victims and their families to bear the financial and emotional consequences. Compensation should be considered, alongside criminal punishment people’s horizons, and allows them to see opportunities or create opportunities. The Government also, as a matter of urgency, needs to create policies that will help grow the economy, so everyone can find their niche to grow. When I consider the work of most if not all of the regulatory agencies in Nigeria, they are simply nothing more than revenue generating institutions who, as a by-product of generating revenue, do some regulatory stuff. Which is why these agencies charge exorbitant fees, for their regulatory duties. NAFDAC is the agency charged with the registration of drugs and products that are manufactured in Nigeria, or imported into the country. I have friends and family who are either pharmacists or into the pharmaceutical business, and I listen to their stories of frustration about how difficult it is to deal with NAFDAC and the time it takes to register a product or get samples tested in their laboratory. No one is asking if NAFDAC and its processes are still fit for purpose, and if the processes can be sped up without endangering lives as a result, or if there is equipment NAFDAC needs to ensure their work can be done faster or more smoothly. For instance, can most of the processes be digitalised and computerised, such that one can be sure when they’ll get a result on a test or response from NAFDAC? For instance, under the Buhari Administration, a regulation came into force that each agency was to set a time limit for certain administrative acts. The regulation further stated that if there was an administrative task that was supposed to have been completed within a certain time with a member of the public receiving a response, if after a certain period had passed and there was no response from the Government agency involved, then it would be deemed that the process had been completed and the response was favourable. This could be applied, where possible, to NAFDAC. Ensuring the registering of safe products and pharmaceuticals that are safe for Nigerians to take, is a matter of national importance. Also, no one is asking if there are NAFDAC officials colluding with unscrupulous manufacturers and importers because of financial inducements, to allow unsafe products be sold in our markets. I am not advocating for paranoia, but working on active intelligence. Which of course leads to my next point. While people are clamouring for special courts to prosecute sex crimes, financial crimes and election related matters, if the product counterfeit problem is as huge as they say it is, it is an issue of national security. Any issue that affects our national security, needs to be taken seriously and urgently tackled. I am therefore suggesting that the Nigeria Police at the national and State level, need to be restructured to take an active role in dealing with the menace of counterfeiting. For instance, in the

United States, the United States Secret Service (“USSS”) is charged with the investigation into the counterfeiting of the United States Dollars. The Federal Bureau of Investigation (“FBI”) gets involved when the counterfeiting cases intersect with other major Federal crimes, such as organised crime, large-scale fraud, or multi-jurisdictional cyber operations. The Police should be working hand in hand with NAFDAC, gathering and sharing evidence. Nigeria should have a database of known counterfeiters, their bases of operation, and whether they have been prosecuted and are in prison or not. There should be databases about the products that suffer from counterfeiting the most, and where these counterfeits are found. Are they found within a localised area indicating that maybe the counterfeit operations are near where the products end up being sold, or can they be found all over the country indicating that the counterfeiters have a large-scale operation? Based on my limited knowledge, a lot of these counterfeit products are found in our local markets like Oloosha Market and Ojuwoye Market in Mushin, and Apongbon Market and Idumota Market on Lagos Island. There is the likelihood that the counterfeit products are most likely, made somewhere in and around these markets. Incentives should be given to whistleblowers to say something if they see or know something suspicious, so the Police and NAFDAC can come and investigate. Also, some people know they are selling counterfeit products. If they are caught, they should be given plea deals, so the kingpins of these operations can be caught. Also, if the numbers about the amounts of money being lost is true, manufacturers and importers of these products have a legitimate and growing problem. It means that the money they could have made from Nigerians buying their legitimate products, is going to counterfeiters instead. Therefore, manufacturers and importers of these products have an incentive to partner with the Government and NAFDAC, on ideas on how to curb the activities of counterfeiters and sensitise Nigerians on how to identify counterfeit products. Recently, a list allegedly created by NAFDAC of counterfeit products in Nigeria, was circulating on social media. I saw the list on WhatsApp. However. However, in a press release posted on their official Facebook page (https:// web.facebook.com/NafdacNigeria/posts/nafdac-hasclarified-that-the-viral-list-of-products-circulating-on-socialmedia/1470127418634087/?_rdc=1&_rdr#), NAFDAC has since come out to say the list did not emanate from them as NAFDAC doesn’t issue sweeping, brand-wide bans without formal laboratory sampling and official public alerts. There needs to be a better way for Government and NAFDAC, to issue alerts about counterfeit products. I am not sure as many people saw the disclaimer, as the fake list. This summer in Europe was one of the hottest on record. The Government, manufacturers, importers and other stakeholders, should come up with a robust system to alert consumers on counterfeit products - safety tips. So, while setting up the death penalty as the punishment for those caught engaging in the act of counterfeiting products is a first step (not necessarily a great one), there needs to be greater collaboration between Government at all levels, NAFDAC, the Police, manufacturers, importers, other stakeholders and the general public, in actively combating the evil of counterfeiting. The passage of an act to enact the death penalty for counterfeiters, cannot be end. Ayoade Oluwasanmi, Lawyer; Author; Partner, Litigation Department of Gbenga Biobaku & Co.


X

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 ˾ T H I S D AY

My Brief by SKB STEPHEN KOLA-BALOGUN Why allegations, investigations and forfeiture proceedings, should not be confused with criminal conviction. Introduction wo Federal High Court judges have given opposite judgements, on the leadership of the African Democratic Congress (ADC.) The conflict cannot be resolved by asking who was first. It will be resolved by three doctrines — stare decisis, per incuriam and obiter dicta. This is because, although on 5th November, 2026, Nigeria's opposition was completely thrown into confusion by a single judgement, the confusion itself was not really political, but doctrinal.

T

Facts Two Judges of the same court, gave two opposite answers on the same party leadership. To understand which judgement stands, you do not need to choose a faction, but rather, the above stated principles of law. Judgement 1 — Justice Musa Liman On 2nd, July 2026, in a suit instituted by Hon. Abejide, Liman J. struck out a challenge to the David Mark led leadership of the ADC. He held that the dispute was an internal party affair, that the internal party remedies hadn’t been exhausted, and that Abejide lacked locus standi to institute the action. He however, positively declared the emergence of the Mark led leadership and directed INEC to recognise the Mark led National Working Committee. Judgement 2 — Justice Peter Lifu On 5th November, 2026, in a fresh suit instituted by Nafiu Bala Gombe, Lifu J. held that the Mark-led caretaker committee was illegally constituted, because it violated the ADC constitution, the Electoral Act and the 1999 Constitution. He nullified all its actions since 27th July, 2026, including the primary that produced former Vice President, Alhaji Atiku Abubakar, GCON, as presidential candidate, and ordered INEC not to recognise them. The ADC immediately argued that a court of coordinate jurisdiction, cannot nullify the judgement of another court of equal jurisdiction. That argument sounds powerful, but, it is also incomplete. 1. Stare Decisis The principle: Stand by what has been decided. A lower court must follow a higher court. A court of equal rank, need not follow another court of equal rank. Stare decisis is vertical, not horizontal. Lifu J. was therefore, not bound by Liman J. Liman's decision was persuasive only. Lifu was entitled, as a matter of law, to disagree with it, if he believed it was wrong. What comity required was respect, not obedience. Lifu should have considered Liman's reasoning carefully, and explain why he was departing from it. He did so by distinguishing the cases: Liman struck out for want of jurisdiction; Lifu decided the substantive merits. Application: Stare decisis does not save the ADC. The first judgement does not win because it was first. Only the Court of Appeal which is a higher court, can resolve the conflict between the two coordinate judgements. 2. Per Incuriam The principle: A decision given in ignorance of binding law, has no binding force. Per incuriam means "through lack of care". It applies when a Judge decides a case, without considering a statute or a decision of a higher court that was directly on point.

stephenkolabalogun@yahoo.com

Two Judges, One Party: Why the ADC Crisis Will be Decided by Precedent, Not Politics Forum of Former Legislators, orders were sought asking that INEC deregister ADC, Accord, Action Alliance, Action Peoples Party, and Zenith Labour Party as political parties. On 22 May, 2026, the Court of Appeal made an order staying further proceedings in that suit, pending an interlocutory appeal. Despite that, Justice Lifu went ahead and delivered judgement ordering INEC to deregister the five parties. A three-member panel of the Court of Appeal led by Justice A.B. Mohammed held that Lifu proceeded even though his attention had been drawn to the stay order, and called it “a form of judicial impertinence” and “a brazen violation” of judicial hierarchy. The panel quoted the Supreme Court precedent that a Judge who acts in that manner “is unfit for the Bench, as it amounts to judicial rascality”. The Court of Appeal then stayed execution of Lifu's deregistration judgement.

Mere error is not enough. The court must have overlooked the binding authority altogether. This is the real battleground. How it applies - The ADC will not win by saying Lifu ignored Liman. The decision by Liman was not binding. It must show Lifu ignored a higher court for example, a binding authority on fair hearing, which requires that a person whose rights will be affected, like Atiku, must be heard before an order is made against him. Conversely, Bala's camp will argue Liman was per incuriam, for treating a clear breach of a party constitution as a mere internal affair. Per incuriam therefore, asks a different question from stare decisis: not "who was first?" but "who ignored the Supreme Court or an existing statute/ Constitution?

persuasive. Every judgement contains a ratio decidendi (the binding reason) and obiter dicta (passing comments). Application: This distinction cuts both ways. If Liman's ratio was "I have no jurisdiction, suit struck out," then his further order that INEC should recognise Mark, may be obiter. A court with no jurisdiction, cannot make a positive order. If Lifu's ratio was "the Mark committee was illegally constituted", then his further order nullifying Atiku who was not a party when the suit was filed in September 2025 and whose candidacy did not then exist may be obiter, or at least, a consequential overreach. The Court of Appeal may therefore, uphold Lifu's core ratio on the leadership, while setting aside his consequential orders on the candidates as obiter and a breach of fair hearing.

3. Obiter Dicta The principle: Only the reason necessary The De-registration case to decide a case binds. Everything else In suit number FHC/ABJ/ is obiter, said by the way, and is merely CS/2637/2026, filed by the National

Until the Court of Appeal decides on these two conflicting cases, or on the allegations of an ignored stay of proceedings (if indeed confirmed), Nigeria will still have two valid, conflicting judgements of equal rank. Neither side can treat its preferred judgement as final, but a recourse to first principles will give us a fairer idea as to how the two cases will ultimately be resolved….

Lifu's Own Explanation Lifu did not deny the sequence, but gave a different reason. He held that no subsisting order of stay from the Court of Appeal had been served on his court before parties adopted their final written addresses and before the matter was fixed for judgement, and that the law does not recognise arrest of judgement. The Court of Appeal rejected that reasoning. Its position was that, once notified, he had to stop, including stopping judgement delivery. On 6-7th November, 2026, Prof Chidi Odinkalu repeated the allegation in relation to the second set of ADC cases the David Mark leadership/Atiku candidacy judgements which are under discussion in this article, alleging Lifu again “disregarded an order of the Court of Appeal directing a stay of proceedings” in one of the matters. That second allegation has not yet been the subject of a fresh Court of Appeal ruling in the reports available, unlike the first one, in the deregistration case. In the deregistration case, the Court of Appeal has formally found that Lifu ignored its stay order. In the newer ADC leadership cases, the same charge has been made publicly, but it is still an allegation and as such, it is impossible to comment further. Conclusion Married together, the three principles give a clear framework: Stare decisis tells us Lifu was not bound by Liman. Per incuriam tells us the appeal will turn on, whether either Judge ignored binding higher authority. Obiter dicta tells us that, not every sentence in either judgement is law. The leadership question is the ratio. The nullification of Atiku may be obiter. Until the Court of Appeal decides on these two conflicting cases, or on the allegations of an ignored stay of proceedings (if indeed confirmed), Nigeria will still have two valid, conflicting judgements of equal rank. Neither side can treat its preferred judgement as final, but a recourse to first principles will give us a fairer idea as to how the two cases will ultimately be resolved, other than through a farcical recourse to the National Judicial Council as is now being suggested by the Presidency.


XI

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, T H I S D AY

6$/( 2) $66(76 2) &/26(' 0,&52 ),1$1&( %$1.6 %< 38%/,& $8&7,21 $1' 38%/,& &203(7,7,9( %,' 7KH 1LJHULD 'HSRVLW ,QVXUDQFH &RUSRUDWLRQ 1',& LQ H[HUFLVH RI LWV ULJKW DV /LTXLGDWRU RI IDLOHG 0LFUR ¿QDQFH EDQNV 0)%V KHUHE\ LQYLWHV LQWHUHVWHG PHPEHUV RI WKH JHQHUDO SXEOLF WR EX\ WKH DVVHWV IXUQLWXUH ¿[WXUH ¿WWLQJV HTXLSPHQW JHQHUDWRUV PRWRU YHKLFOHV HWF RI WKH XQGHU OLVWHG GHIXQFW 0)%V E\ 38%/,& &203(7,7,9( 6($/ %,' $8&7,21

$8&7,21 352&(66 7KH 3XEOLF $XFWLRQ IRU WKH IXUQLWXUH ¿[WXUHV ¿WWLQJV HTXLSPHQW ZLOO WDNH SODFH IURP WK WR WK 1RYHPEHU &21',7,216 )25 %,'',1* )25 7+( *(1(5$7256 $1' 02725 9(+,&/(6 %LGV VKRXOG EH VXEPLWWHG LQ D VHDOHG HQYHORSH WRJHWKHU ZLWK D GHSRVLW RI RI WKH ELG SULFH LQ &HUWL¿HG %DQN 'UDIW LQ IDYRXU RI WKH UHVSHFWLYH PLFUR¿QDQFH EDQNV ,Q /LTXLGDWLRQ DQG ZLWK DQ LQVFULSWLRQ ³%,' )25 *(1 6(7 02725 9(+,&/( ´ RQ WKH WRS OHIW KDQG FRUQHU RI WKH HQYHORSH 7KH ELG VKRXOG FRQWDLQ WKH QDPH DGGUHVV DQG WHOHSKRQH QXPEHUV RI WKH ELGGHU 7KH VXFFHVVIXO ELGGHU ZLOO EH UHTXLUHG WR SD\ WKH EDODQFH RI WKH ELG SULFH ZLWKLQ KRXUV RI ZLQQLQJ WKH ELG 7KH GUDIW IRU WKH XQVXFFHVVIXO ELGGHUV ZRXOG EH UHWXUQHG LPPHGLDWHO\ %LGV VKRXOG EH VXEPLWWHG WR WKH $XFWLRQHHUV RU 1',& &RQWDFW SHUVRQV ZLWKLQ WKH VWDWHG SHULRG 6XEPLWWHG ELGV VKDOO EH RSHQHG EHIRUH WKH ELGGHUV DW WKH YDULRXV ORFDWLRQV $OO $VVHWV DUH VROG DV ³DV LV´ DQG ³QHW RI DOO WD[HV´ $OO SXUFKDVHG LWHPV PXVW EH HYDFXDWHG ZLWKLQ KRXUV RI SXUFKDVH )RU IXUWKHU HQTXLULHV SOHDVH FRQWDFW 'LUHFWRU $VVHW 0DQDJHPHQW 'HSDUWPHQW 1LJHULD 'HSRVLW ,QVXUDQFH &RUSRUDWLRQ /DJRV 2I¿FH 0DPPDQ .RWDQJRUD +RXVH WK )ORRU $ /CTKPC /DJRV 7HO 1R /DJRV 2IÀFH

#1',&1LJHULD


XII

T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

BUSINESS/MONEYGUIDE

Alpha10 Unveils N28bn Investment Portfolio in Port Harcourt Blessing Ibunge ÓØ ÙÜÞ ËÜÍÙßÜÞ

The Rivers State Government has intensified efforts to protect investors from Ponzi schemes and restore confidence in the South-South financial market, demanding greater transparency and accountability from investment management companies operating in the region. The renewed push came at the unveiling of Alpha10 Fund Management Limited’s Port Harcourt office, where the government challenged fund managers to demonstrate their ownership structures, investment track records, assets under management, risk exposure and corporate governance standards. Speaking on behalf of the state government, Jerry Ugo said repeated losses to fraudulent investment schemes had weakened public

confidence and discouraged genuine investment activities across the Niger Delta. He said the government was interested in distinguishing credible investment operators from fraudulent promoters, adding that prospective fund managers must provide verifiable information about their operations. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) also cautioned investors against unrealistic returns, urging them to patronise regulated investment platforms. SEC’s Port Harcourt Zonal Director, Bernard Ebe, described the region’s investment environment as unique, noting that the oil-driven economy had cultivated expectations of quick and substantial financial gains at the expense of patient, long-term investments. “Ponzi thrives on gullibility. Investors should conduct checks.

Come and invest in the capital market, not in roadside fund Ponzi schemes,” he said. Providing a snapshot of its business operations, Abigail Utomi, Managing Director of Alpha10, disclosed that the group had N28 billion in assets under management, including N6.9 billion in public funds. She said the company also managed three public funds and seven private investment products approved by From left: Chairman, AW Network and STARC, Adebola Williams; Former Managing Director, Daily Times Nigeria (DTN), Dr Yemi Ogunbiyi and Group Managing Director Sahara Power, Dr Kola Adesina, the SEC. According to her, during the DTN @ 100 Times Heroes Awards, held in Lagos...recently Alpha10 commenced operations in 2024 and began full operations in January 2025, expanding its physical presence to Abuja, Lagos, Port MONEY AND CREDIT STATISTICS (MILLION NAIRA) Harcourt and Kano. October 2025 Chairman of Alpha10, Month Chibuzor Ekwekwuo, Money Supply (M3) 119,037,577.07 said the group had -CBN Bills Held by Money Holding Sectors 9,291.49 recorded N6.29 billion in added value within nine Money Supply (M2) 119,028,285.58 months, describing the Quasi Money 79,681,419.97 company as one of the fastest-growing financial -- Narrow Money (M1) 39,346,865.60 groups.

MARKET INDICATORS

---- Currency Outside Banks

4,646,794.28

Adebola Williams Receives Daily Times of Nigeria TrailBlazer Award

---- Demand Deposits

34,700,071.33

Net Foreign Assets (NFA)

34,804,442.84

Co-founder of RED | For Africa and chairman of AW Network and STARC, Adebola Williams has been named the winner of the Trailblazer Award at the DTN @ 100 Times Heroes Awards, recently held in Victoria Island, Lagos, as part of the centenary celebrations of Daily Times Nigeria (DTN). The centenary programme, themed “Honouring the Past, Shaping the Future,” brought together three components: the Shaping the Future Town Hall, the Honouring the Past Exhibition and the DTN @ 100 Times Heroes Awards. Together, they marked 100 years since the newspaper was founded in 1926.

Net Domestic Assets(NDA)

84,233,134.23

-- Net Domestic Credit (NDC)

99,199,655.08

---- Credit to Government (Net)

24,787,980.96

Williams received the Trailblazer Award for his role in shaping modern African political communications and nation branding for a trifecta of African presidents, including President Muhammadu Buhari, President Nana Akuffo-Addo and President Macky Sall. The platforms he founded and owns including YNaija, Rubbin’ Minds on Channels TV, The Future Awards Africa, and StateCraft Inc. continue to dominate social impact storytelling and youth engagement across the continent. He was honoured alongside Elohor Aiboni, Shell’s Executive Vice President and Country Chair for Nigeria;

Dr Kola Adesina, Group Managing Director of Sahara Group; General Christopher Gwabin Musa, Nigeria’s Honourable Minister of Defence; Iyinoluwa Aboyeji, CEO and General Partner of Future Africa; and Uche Pedro, Founder of Bella Naija. In his keynote address, former Governor of Ogun State and former Managing Director of Daily Times, Chief Aremo Olusegun Osoba, said that attaining 100 years gives Daily Times the chance to go beyond celebrating itself and to recognise the individuals and institutions whose vision, leadership and achievements have shaped Nigeria, while preserving their stories for future generations.

NOG Energy Week Opens Call for Technical Papers NOG Energy Week has opened submissions for its 2027 Technical Seminar, inviting researchers, engineers, academics and other energy professionals to present technical solutions and innovations capable of addressing challenges across Nigeria’s oil and gas industry. The call for papers, which covers 14 technical categories across the energy value chain, is aimed at promoting the exchange of research, field experience and practical knowledge to support investment, operational efficiency and technological development in the sector. The organisers said submissions would

cover upstream activities, including geoscience, field development, drilling and asset management, as well as midstream operations involving infrastructure, facilities, supply and pipeline transportation, shipping and marine services. Asset Operations Support at TotalEnergies EP Nigeria, Razaq Shuaib, who reviewed submissions for last year’s programme, said the contributions reflected the range of expertise available across the industry, including working engineers and students. He stressed the importance of developing technical knowledge and human capacity to sustain progress in Nigeria’s energy sector, noting that

human capital remained a major driver of industry growth. Also, Portfolio and Country Director, dmg Nigeria, Wemimo Oyelana, said the programme was designed to give professionals working on practical industry challenges an opportunity to share their experience and findings with a wider audience. “We built this programme to reach the people actually solving problems in the field and providing them with a platform to share what they are learning within the wider industry. If you have worked through something the industry needs to hear about, this is the platform for it,” Oyelana said.

---- Memo: Credit to Govt. (Net) less FMA

0.00

---- Memo: Fed. and Mirror Accounts (FMA)

0.00

---- Credit to Private Sector (CPS)

74,411,674.12

--Other Assets Net

2,603,854.03

Reserve Money (Base Money)

36,641,142.21

--Currency in Circulation

5,057,881.01

--Banks Reserves

31,583,261.21

--Special Intervention Reserves

284,361.95

˾ ÙßÜÍÏ ̋

Money Market Indicators (in Percentage) Month

October 2025

Inter-Bank Call Rate

October 2025

Minimum Rediscount Rate (MRR) Monetary Policy Rate (MPR)

27.00

Treasury Bill Rate

15.07

Savings Deposit Rate

7.43

1 Month Deposit Rate

11.37

3 Months Deposit Rate

11.32

6 Months Deposit Rate

11.12

12 Months Deposit Rate

11.78

Prime Lending rate

18.89

Maximum Lending Rate

29.56

NSE MARKET INDEX CAP

0.75%(52%YoY)

Index

0.9% (29%Y/D) ˾ ÙØÏÞËÜã ÙÖÓÍã ËÞÏ ̋ Ͱ͵ϱ

OPEC DAILY BASKET PRICE AS AT 24TH NOVEMBER , 2025

The price of OPEC basket of twelve crudes stood at $63.14 a barrel on Monday, according to OPEC Secretariat calculations. The OPEC Reference Basket of Crudes (ORB) is made up of the following: Saharan Blend (Algeria), Djeno (Congo), Zafiro (Equatorial Guinea), Rabi Light (Gabon), Iran Heavy (Islamic Republic of Iran), Basrah Medium (Iraq), Kuwait Export (Kuwait), Es Sider (Libya), Bonny Light (Nigeria), Arab Light (Saudi Arabia), Murban (UAE) and Merey (Venezuela).


XIII

T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

MARKET NEWS

Stock Market Gains N2.32tn on Investors’ Demand for Dangote Cement Kaode Tokede

The Nigerian equities market opened the week on a positive note, as investors’ Investment rose by N2.32 trillion amid soar in the price of Dangote Cement Plc. As Dangote Cement gained 9.61per cent, the Nigerian Exchange Limited

All-Share Index (NGX ASI) gained 3,579.52 basis points or 1.44 per cent to close at 252,456.74 basis points. The positive performance reflects renewed buying interest and improved investor confidence, with the benchmark index reclaiming the 250,000-basis point level. Consequently, equity market capitalisation increased by approximately N2.32 trillion to close at

P R I C E S MAIN BOARD

F O R DEALS

N163.92 trillion. Analysts noted that the session was characterized by bullish sentiment and improved trading activity, as the market recorded a strong rebound, recovering above the 250,000-point threshold. As measured by market breadth, market sentiment was negative, as 20 stocks gained relative to 28 losers. AXA Mansard Insurance led the gainers with a 9.75 per

S E C U R I T I E S MARKET PRICE

QUANTITY TRADED

cent rise, closing at N12.95, per share. Sovereign Trust Insurance followed with a 9.74 per cent gain to close at N2.14, while Dangote Cement surged 9.61 per cent to close at N1,469.90, per share. Oando rose 8.46 per cent to close at N35.90, and Fidelity Bank advanced 6.85 per cent to close at N24.95, per share. On the downside, Thomas Wyatt Nigeria led the losers, falling 9.62 per cent to close

T R A D E D

VALUE TRADED ( N )

MAIN BOARD

A S

O F

at N2.35, per share. University Press followed with a decline of 8.70 per cent to close at N4.20, while Fortis Global Insurance dropped 7.38 per cent to close at N1.38, per share. The Initial Plc (TIP) fell 6.88 per cent to close at N25.05, while Zichis shed 5.59 per cent to close at N16.05, per share. The total volume traded declined by 20.0 per cent

N OV E M B E R DEALS

MARKET PRICE

to 453.31 million units, valued at N30.55 billion, and exchanged in 42,891 deals. Looking ahead, Cowry Assets Management Limited said sustained demand for large-cap stocks could support further market gains, although negative market breadth and lingering profit-taking pressures may limit broader upside momentum.

9 / 2 6 QUANTITY TRADED

VALUE TRADED ( N)


T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY NOVEMBER 10, 2026

XIV

FEATURES Amaka Nwokeji: Making Waves in Male-dominated Industries

Group Features Editor: Chiemelie Ezeobi Email chiemelie.ezeobi@thisdaylive.com,

Royce Okolie

I

n industries traditionally dominated by men, where leadership and strategic decision-making have long rested largely in male hands, women who enter these spaces often face the added challenge of proving their competence while navigating demanding professional environments. Yet through determination and technical expertise, a growing number of women continue to break barriers and establish themselves as influential figures. One such woman is Mrs. Amaka N. Nwokeji, Managing Director of Zotmann International Limited, whose professional journey reflects the rising influence of women across Nigeria’s oil and gas, manufacturing, mining and industrial sectors. L-R: Former Special Adviser to UK Prime Minister, Dr. Nero Ughwujabo; Co founder FLAIR Global Summit, CBE Deputy Lieutenant of Greater A petroleum engineer by training, London and Co-Founder FLAIR , Dr Yvonne Thompson; Managing Director Zotmann International Limited, Mrs Nneamaka Nwokeji and Dr. Nwokeji brings years of diverse Tonye Rex Idaminabo FRSA during the presentation of the Excellence in Industrial Development & Economic Transformation to Zotmann experience in the oil and gas International Limited in London… recently industry, with expertise spanning years in the oil and gas industry, strategic planning, development has given her a strong foundation planning, operations support, for navigating the complexities of production optimisation, reservoir industrial business operations. engineering and project management Her academic background further for oil and gas field operations. underscores these qualifications. Her career began in 2012 at She holds a Bachelor ’s degree in Neconde Energy Limited, one of Petroleum Engineering from the Nigeria’s largest independent oil Federal University of Technology, and gas companies, where she Owerri, and a Master ’s degree in joined as a pioneer staff member. Project Management (Oil and Gas), Over the years, she held several with Distinction, from the University positions there, including Production of Liverpool. Engineer, Reservoir Engineer and Beyond her credentials and Planning Executive. professional milestones, Nwokeji’s These roles gave her valuable journey reflects the expanding role of technical and managerial experience, women in industries where technical exposing her to the operational expertise, strategic thinking and complexities of the petroleum leadership are critical to success. industry and strengthening her Her story challenges conventional capabilities in engineering, corporate perceptions of women’s place in planning and business development. traditionally male-dominated In 2017, she moved to Salvic sectors, and shows that competence, Petroleum Resources, where she preparation, vision and determination continued to build her credentials remain the essential ingredients of in various capacities, including as professional advancement. Reservoir and Operations Engineer. As Nigeria pursues industrialisation, Her progression later saw her economic diversification and appointed Strategy and Planning greater participation in the global Executive in the Office of the energy and mining industries, the Chief Executive Officer, a role that contributions of women like Mrs deepened her exposure to corporate Amaka N. Nwokeji highlight the strategy, executive decision-making importance of inclusive leadership and organisational development. Mrs. Nwokeji with the Flair Award and equal opportunity. Nwokeji’s ambition, however, Zotmann International Limited Zotmann’s growth. She has played Her journey from petroleum extended beyond a successful at a defining moment in its a pivotal role in shaping the engineering to executive leadership corporate career. In 2019, she took history, as its leadership sought company’s strategic direction, and entrepreneurship is a testament a bold entrepreneurial step by to expand into new areas of strengthening its operations and to what becomes possible founding Lhambi Company Limited business. Brought in to lead advancing its ambitions in the when professional excellence and serving as its pioneer Managing that transformation, she has mining and industrial sectors, meets ambition, courage and Director. The move opened a new spearheaded a comprehensive bringing strategic thinking, determination. She represents a chapter in her journey, marking her restructuring of the organisation, administrative discipline and a growing generation of women who transition from corporate engineering steering its evolution from a clear understanding of business are not merely seeking space in and strategic management into single-entity enterprise into a development to the organisation. male-dominated industries, but entrepreneurship and industrial diversified group of companies. Her grounding in engineering, actively shaping their direction, development. Today, as Managing Director, project management and driving corporate growth and In October 2020, she joined Nwokeji is a key force behind corporate strategy, built over building lasting business legacies.


THISDAY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

XV

TRIBUTE Frank Aigbogun at 70: The TEXEM Alumnus Turning Vision into Institutions, Journalism into Impact By Dr Alim Abubakre

A

nation’s future is shaped by the quality of its institutions and the courage of those who build them. Some leaders create successful enterprises. Others develop institutions that influence how societies think, make decisions and pursue progress. The latter leave something particularly valuable: opportunities for people they may never meet. Following Frank Aigbogun’s 70th birthday celebration on November 1, 2026, which I could not attend, I take immense pride in honouring a distinguished TEXEM alumnus, an exceptional media entrepreneur, an accomplished journalist, and a remarkable Nigerian whose contributions to national development extend far beyond the newsroom. Frank’s life offers an inspiring lesson in purposeful leadership. His journey demonstrates that intellectual curiosity, enterprise, perseverance and a commitment to the public good can combine to create enduring national value. Beginning his journalism career at The Guardian in 1982, Frank subsequently worked with the Associated Press and Vanguard, where he rose to significant editorial positions. These experiences prepared him for an undertaking that would reshape Nigerian business journalism. In 2001, he co-founded BusinessDay, recognising the need for a publication dedicated to serious economic reporting, corporate governance, financial markets and public policy. What followed was an extraordinary exercise in institution building. BusinessDay developed into one of Nigeria’s foremost platforms for business intelligence and economic debate, helping executives, investors, policymakers and citizens engage with issues central to national prosperity. Peter Drucker, the influential management thinker, observed, “The purpose of information is not knowledge. It is being able to take the right action.” Few observations better capture the importance of Frank’s contribution. Reliable economic journalism informs investment decisions, improves public understanding and creates opportunities to scrutinise government policies. Where credible information flourishes, accountability is stronger. Frank’s commitment to nation-building is equally evident in his involvement with the Nigerian Economic Summit Group. His 19 years of membership, including 10 years of board service, contributed to the sustained engagement between the private sector and government that Nigeria needs for meaningful economic reform. His recognition by the NESG in October 2026 was especially fitting, acknowledging years of dedication to policy dialogue and institutional development. His leadership as chairman of the board of trustees of the Impact Investors Foundation further demonstrates his interest in linking investment, enterprise and positive social outcomes. Yet, perhaps, one of Frank’s most significant contributions is the professional talent he has helped develop. Through BusinessDay, journalists, analysts and editors have gained opportunities to sharpen their abilities and contribute to public discourse. Albert Einstein famously observed, “The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existence.” That spirit of inquiry is indispensable to responsible journalism. It encourages

Frank Aigbogun

professionals to challenge assumptions, examine evidence and pursue understanding. Frank’s professional journey illustrates how curiosity, supported by discipline and sound judgement, can become a foundation for lasting institutional achievement. His accomplishments also offer an important lesson about good governance. Independent journalism strengthens democracy when it encourages transparency, examines public decisions and gives citizens reliable information with which to hold institutions accountable. Nelson Mandela expressed this responsibility powerfully: “A critical, independent and investigative press is the lifeblood of any democracy.” As Nigeria confronts complex economic choices, this principle’s relevance cannot be overstated. Strong institutions require scrutiny. Responsible policymaking requires evidence. Sustainable prosperity requires citizens and leaders who understand the consequences of their decisions.

As founder of TEXEM, UK, I find Frank’s remarkable achievements particularly gratifying because he is a valued member of our distinguished alum community. His journey embodies the commitment to strategic leadership, good governance, intellectual development, societal responsibility and nation-building that TEXEM seeks to encourage. The TEXEM alum community is enriched by accomplished leaders such as Frank, whose professional contributions show what can emerge when expertise is matched with dedication to the wider public interest. At 70, Frank’s achievements deserve admiration, but his example also invites reflection. How many institutions are we strengthening? Whose opportunities are we expanding? What knowledge are we passing to those who will lead after us? These questions matter because enduring leadership is measured through the value that continues to benefit society long after individual achievements have been celebrated.

Dear Frank, on this magnificent milestone, I celebrate your courage, your intellectual contributions, your entrepreneurial accomplishments and your dedication to building institutions that matter. May the years ahead bring abundant good health, happiness, renewed energy and deeper fulfilment. May you continue to inspire younger generations, shape important national conversations and enjoy the immense satisfaction of seeing the people and institutions you have supported flourish. On behalf of TEXEM, UK, and our global alum community, I congratulate you wholeheartedly on your 70th birthday. May your next chapter be your most fulfilling yet, and may the institutions you have strengthened continue to enlarge the possibilities of our nation. Happy 70th birthday, Frank. Keep flourishing, keep inspiring and keep making a difference. •Dr Alim Abubakre is the founder of TEXEM, UK


XVI

T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY NOVEMBER 3, 2026

PROPERTY & ENVIRONMENT Lagos Coastal Corridor: The Rise of a New Waterfront Real Estate Frontier Bennett Oghifo A new real estate frontier is steadily taking shape along the Lagos coastal corridor, transforming what was once regarded largely as a commercial and leisure district into an emerging premium destination for luxury residences, offices and mixed-use developments. From Ahmadu Bello Way

through Eko Atlantic City, Oniru and the emerging Bluewater Okunde axis, a wave of infrastructure investment, land reclamation and private-sector development is redefining the character and value of the Lagos waterfront. The transformation is so pronounced that the corridor is increasingly being described by property investors and

industry watchers as the next Grade A address in Lagos—an emerging waterfront district with the potential to rival the established prestige of Victoria Island. The development, however, does not diminish Victoria Island’s traditional identity. Rather, it represents an outward expansion of the high-value real estate market, extending

the island’s residential, commercial and lifestyle ecosystem towards the Atlantic waterfront. At the heart of the transformation is infrastructure. The reclamation and development of Eko Atlantic City, combined with the LagosCalabar Coastal Highway, has altered the investment equation along the coast, improving accessibility while opening up

previously underdeveloped areas to large-scale residential and mixed-use projects. The first phase of the LagosCalabar Coastal Highway, measuring 47.47 kilometres, was formally opened to traffic earlier this year. The dual carriageway, with a central rail track, begins around Ahmadu Bello Way in Victoria Island and runs through Eko Atlantic

towards the Lekki axis. Beyond its immediate transportation benefits, the road is changing the way investors perceive waterfront land. Travel times along parts of the corridor have been reduced, while improved access has strengthened the attractiveness of locations that were previously constrained by connectivity challenges.

IIM Global Network Charts New Course for AI, Data Ethics at Australia Conference Bennett Oghifo The Institute of Information Management (IIM) Global Network has ended its Australia Annual Conference, Induction and Investiture Ceremony with the theme “AI-Driven Transformation: Strengthening Public Trust, Ethics, and Data Resilience in a Digital Australia” in Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. The one-day conference that held on Saturday, April 11, 2026 was attended by global thought leaders, senior data governance professionals, technology policymakers, academics, enterprise executives and industry stakeholders who engaged in impactful discussions on the transformative and complex forces reshaping the digital world. Drawing on his extensive international experience in technology, policy and institutional leadership, Ambassador (Dr)

Oyedokun Ayodeji Oyewole, the International President/ Chairman, IIM Africa who delivered the keynote address said, “Artificial Intelligence is only as powerful as the trust that underpins it. As we accelerate digital transformation globally, we must ensure that our systems are transparent, accountable and ethically grounded. Data resilience and governance are no longer optional - they are strategic imperatives for sustainable development.” Oyewole enlightened the gathering on the critical intersection of AI innovation, regulatory compliance and institutional trust and challenged leaders across sectors to move beyond performative commitments towards genuinely-embedded ethical cultures in their organisations. He disclosed that in an era of unprecedented data proliferation, the quality of

governance frameworks will ultimately determine whether digital transformation delivers equitable, sustainable and trustworthy outcomes for citizens and societies. In her own presentation, Dr Ayodhya Wathuge, a distinguished Scholar and Educator in Information Systems at Southern Cross University on the Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia addressed the challenge of the persistent and often widening gap between high-level AI ethics and their meaningful operational implementation. Wathuge who spoke on the sub-theme of “From Principles to Practice: Building Trustworthy AI through Governance, Risk and Ethical Accountability” said the proliferation of AI ethics frameworks, even though a welcome development, has not yet translated into consistent accountable governance practices across

industries and governments. She added that principles such as fairness, transparency, explainability and accountability remain aspirational for many

organisations rather than embedded features of their AI development and deployment processes. Wathuge disclosed that bridging this gap requires a

fundamental shift from treating AI governance as a compliance checkbox to treating it as an active, continuous and organisation-wide discipline.

L-R: Pastor Opeyemi, FIIM, LFC Brisbane; Dr Olabode Akinola Agbasale, FIIM, Mountview Doctors, Redbank Plains, Queensland; Dr Ayodhya Wathuge, Scholar and Educator in Information Systems, Southern Cross University, Gold Coast, Queensland; Amb. (Dr) Oyedokun A. Oyewole, FIIM, International President, IIM Africa; Scott Spence, ICT PMO Lead, Queensland; Oladapo Owolabi, FIIM, Founder and President, SEEIA Connect and Dr Oladapo Olukomaiya, FIIM, Data Governance SME, Queensland, at the IIM Global Network Conference in Australia… recently

Iwemi, NBTE Move to Turn Polytechnic Research into Jobs, Innovation Bennett Oghifo The National Board for Technical Education (NBTE) and Iwemi, a Nigerian digital research and publishing company, are exploring a partnership to transform research in polytechnics and technical colleges into marketable innovations, employable skills and new sources of income. The proposed collaboration,

discussed during a visit by Iwemi’s delegation to the NBTE headquarters in Abuja, seeks to bridge the gap between academic research and practical applications by providing digital infrastructure for preserving, publishing and commercialising research outputs from Nigeria’s technical institutions. The initiative comes amid growing calls for technical and vocational education institutions

to strengthen industry linkages, improve skills development and produce innovations capable of creating jobs and generating wealth. Leading the delegation, Iwemi’s Founder and Chief Executive Officer, Mr. Ejimofor Akah, presented the Iwemi Academic Publishing and Research Platform as a digital ecosystem designed to preserve students’ projects, theses and

institutional research while expanding access to academic resources and creating opportunities for lecturers to earn royalties from published learning materials. Akah disclosed that the platform was already operational in five tertiary institutions, including Edo State Polytechnic, Usen, and hosted more than 500,000 titles. He said the platform

could provide polytechnics with institution-branded digital repositories for National Diploma (ND) and Higher National Diploma (HND) projects, ensuring that research work was preserved, accessible and available for future academic and industrial applications. Under the proposed arrangement, lecturers would also be able to publish digital textbooks for technical and vocational

education and training (TVET), with digital rights management protection and royalties paid within 48 hours. The platform is also designed to improve the global visibility of institutional research through indexing that makes academic outputs searchable internationally, potentially strengthening the online presence and research profiles of participating institutions.

IFMA Nigeria Inaugurates Abuja Branch, Calls for Technology-Driven Facility Management Practice Bennett Oghifo The International Facility Management Association (IFMA) Nigeria Chapter has inaugurated its Abuja Branch as part of efforts to expand the association’s national presence, strengthen professional engagement, and

advance facility management practice in Nigeria. The inauguration, held at the platinum LEED-certified AFREXIM African Trade Center, alongside the 2026 IFMA Advocacy Day, featured discussions on the theme, “Beyond Maintenance: Leveraging Technology for Sustainable

Facility Management Practice in Nigeria,” highlighting the need for facility management professionals to embrace innovation, digital solutions, and sustainable practices to improve the performance and long-term value of buildings and infrastructure. Speaking on the inaugura-

tion, President of the IFMA Nigeria Chapter, Engr. Sheriff Daramola, FMP, explained that the branch would serve as a platform for professional training and certification, industry collaboration, student mentorship and stronger networking among built-environment professionals in Abuja and

the wider northern region. Daramola added that Abuja hosts critical national assets including government ministries, hospitals, institutions, airports, and major infrastructure that require strategic facility management. That sustainable facility management must incor-

porate energy efficiency, water conservation, waste management, asset longevity and safe, healthy indoor environments, while ensuring that solutions respond to Nigeria’s operating conditions, including energy reliability, infrastructure constraints and operating costs.

Lagos Supports Older Persons with Disabilities, Elderly Caregivers Fadekemi Ajakaiye The Lagos State Government has reaffirmed its commitment to the welfare of older persons with disabilities and elderly caregivers, providing financial assistance and free healthcare services to improve their quality of life. The Honourable Commissioner for Youth and Social Development, Mr Mobolaji

Ogunlende, stated this at the 2026 Older Persons with Disabilities and Elderly Caregivers Support Programme organised by the Lagos State Office for Disability Affairs (LASODA) held at the Lagos Chamber of Commerce and Industry on 2nd November 2026. In his words, “As a responsive government that leaves no one behind, in line with the THEMES Plus Agenda of

Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu’s administration, we must bring succour to our elderly citizens with disabilities and ensure they continue to enjoy dignity, care and inclusion in society.” He noted that supporting older persons with disabilities was an important aspect of building an inclusive society where everyone, regardless of age or disability, could live with dignity.

The General Manager of LASODA, Mrs Adenike Oyetunde-Lawal, said the programme was designed to give dedicated attention to older persons with disabilities and elderly parents who continue to shoulder the responsibility of caring for children with disabilities, even in their later years. She explained that the theme, Ageing with Dignity,

highlighted the need to recognise a group whose needs and contributions must never be overlooked. The programme featured financial support for beneficiaries and free healthcare services, including dental screening and consultations, scaling and polishing, blood pressure checks, medical consultations and the provision of basic medications.

Participants also benefited from health education sessions, with Dr Olufunmi Adeniyi delivering a presentation on Older Persons with Disabilities and Elderly Caregivers Support, while Dr Busuyi Oladunjoye spoke on Hypertension in Older Adults: Causes and Management for Effective Wellbeing, highlighting the importance of proper health management among older persons.


T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

19

BUSINESSWORLD R A T E S MONEY MARKET OPR OVERNIGHT

A S

A T

REPO 25.34% 25.18%

Group Business Editor Eromosele Abiodun Email oriarehu.eromosele@thisdaylive.com

08056356325

N O V E M B E R

S & P INDEX

9 ,

S & P INDEX

CALL 1-MONTH

23.25% 21.37%

INDEX LEVEL 1-DAY

595.26 0.10%

3-MONTH

22.41%

MONTH-TO-DATE

0.24%

2 0 2 6 EXCHANGE RATE

1/4 TO DATE YEAR TO DATE

0.24% -10.99%

N1,364/ 1 US DOLLAR* *AS AT MONDAY, NOV. 9, 2026

NESG: Export Sub-index Contracts to 95.1, Lowest in 13 Months

Dike Onwuamaeze The export sub-index of the Nigeria Economic Summit Group (NESG) Business Confidence Monitor (BCM), fell into contraction territory in October 2026, while the financial results index moved into expansion territory. According to the NESG BCM report, readings above 100 is expansion while readings lower that 100 signifies contraction. However, cost of doing business and

prices (producer prices) have an inverse interpretation, meaning that an index rising towards or above 100 indicates easing pressure, while a decline towards or below 100 signals rising pressure. The export sub-index fell from 103 in September to 95.1 in October 2026, which is its least performance since October 2025 when the subindex stood at 105.5. But the financial result’s index rose from contraction at 99.1 in September to 132.1

in October 2026. The BCM also reported that the cost of doing business and prices sub-indices reported elevated costs and producer prices at readings below the neutral 100-point threshold at 45.2 and 65.5 points, respectively. The report stated that both readings rose relative to the previous month’s levels, implying that cost and price pressures eased but remained elevated in October 2026. It said that despite sustained

business growth, most firms grappled with key constraints, especially irregular electricity supply, credit squeeze, insecurity, high rental costs, and inadequate infrastructure. These challenges may have partly contributed to elevated cost pressures during the month. However, the BCM’s current business performance index “CBPI) showed that Nigeria’s business activity sustained its expansion in October 2026. The CBPI moderated to

115.4 points from 117.8 points in September 2026, but rose from 111.3 points in October 2025. Although all sectors remained in expansion territory in October 2026, only trade and services performed better than in the previous month. The report also said that future business expectations index stood at 130.8 points, up from 128.9 in September 2026, which reflected improved optimism about short-term

business conditions. It said: “Trade registered the strongest optimism level at 194.0 points, followed by manufacturing (145.1 points) and non-manufacturing (135.0 points). Conversely, services and agriculture recorded relatively weaker optimism. The overall positive outlook reflects strong consumer demand during the yearend festivities and ongoing campaign activities.” The story continues online on www.thisdaylive.com

Fish-sufficiency: FG Unveils $200m World Bank-backed Fish Production Drive Eromosele Abiodun The federal government has intensified efforts to reposition Nigeria as a fish-sufficient nation, securing a $200 million commitment from the World Bank Group to support national drive to expand fisheries and aquaculture production across the country. The funding, which will be made available to state governments as concessional loans, is expected to strengthen their capacity to develop and expand fisheries and aquaculture activities, unlock investment

opportunities, boost domestic fish production and ultimately bridge Nigeria’s widening fish supply deficit. The federal government’s renewed push also places greater emphasis on collaboration between federal and state governments, investors and development partners to reduce the country’s dependence on imported fish and strengthen national food security. The Minister of Marine and Blue Economy, Dr Adegboyega Oyetola disclosed this at a high-level Executive Training on Aquaculture

Investment Guide organised by the Federal Ministry of Marine and Blue Economy in collaboration with the World Bank Group. The training, held in Abuja, brought together key policymakers and technical officials, including commissioners from Rivers, Bayelsa, Delta and Cross River States, permanent secretaries and directors of fisheries and aquaculture from across the federation. It was designed to equip state-level decision-makers with the expertise to translate investment opportunities

FOOD NAME OF COMMODITY

SIZE

STATE

RICE

50KG

ABUJA

50KG

LAGOS

50KG

PLATEAU

50KG

OYO

50KG

RIVERS

50KG

SOKOTO

PRICE

₦53,000 – ₦60,000 ₦55,000 – ₦65,000

₦55,000– ₦68,000 ₦55,000– ₦65,000 ₦70,000– ₦82,000 ₦55,000– ₦70,000

into bankable aquaculture projects, with emphasis on viable business models, risk management, environmental and social safeguards, and public-private partnerships. Represented by the Senior Special Assistant to the President on Marine and Blue Economy, Professor Busayo Fakinlede, Oyetola said Nigeria’s ambition to achieve fish sufficiency could only become a reality through deliberate sub-national participation, stressing that states must assume greater responsibility for expanding domestic production.

COMMODITIES NAME OF COMMODITY

SORGHUM

SIZE

PRICE

STATE

100KG JIGAWA 100KG

BENUE

100KG

KADUNA

50KG

ENUGU

50KG

LAGOS

100KG

DELTA

100KG

ABIA

“Fish is a pillar of food security, household nutrition and rural livelihoods. No nation can call itself food secure while it imports most of the fish it eats. Our ambition is to produce more, import less and, in time, become a net exporter. That ambition can be achieved only when every state plays its part,” he said. Nigeria requires approximately 3.6 million tonnes of fish annually but currently produces about 1.4 million tonnes, leaving a deficit exceeding 2.2 million tonnes. The shortfall is

largely bridged through imports, which cost the country close to US$1 billion annually in foreign exchange. To reverse the trend, the ministry is pursuing a state-driven aquaculture development framework under which each state will identify priority value chains, assess investment readiness, develop bankable project pipelines and commit to measurable contributions towards national fish production. The story continues online on www.thisdaylive.com

T O D AY

PRICE

₦65,000– ₦85,000 ₦70,000– ₦90,000 ₦65,000– ₦85,000 ₦40,000– ₦50,000 ₦42,000– ₦55,000 ₦75,000– ₦95,000 ₦75,000– ₦95,000

NAME OF COMMODITY

SIZE

STATE

PRICE

BEANS

50KG BAG

IBADAN, OYO

50KG

LAGOS

₦65,000– ₦80,000 ₦65,000– ₦80,000

50KG

ABUJA

50KG

ENUGU

₦60,000– ₦75,000 ₦65,000– ₦85,000

50KG

DELTA

₦70,000– ₦85,000


20

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 ˾ T H I S D AY

BUSINESSWORLD

NEWS FOOD

NAME OF COMMODITY

PALM OIL

SIZE

STATE

PRICE

₦42,000 – 25CL LAGOS ₦50,000

NAME OF COMMODITY

GROUNDNUT

COMMODITIES SIZE

STATE

PRICE

100KG KANO N75,000–₦95,000

25CL

PH

₦40,000 – ₦50,000

100KG BENUE ₦80,000–₦105,000

25CL

OYO

₦45,000 – ₦55,000

100KG LAGOS ₦100,000–₦125,000

25CL

IMO

₦40,000 – ₦50,000

100KG DELTA ₦105,000–₦130,000

25CL

EDO

₦40,000 – ₦50,000

100KG

25CL ABUJA

₦48,000 – ₦60,000

100KG ENUGU ₦90,000–₦115,000

ABIA

₦95,000–₦120,000

PRICE

T O D AY

NAME OF COMMODITY

SIZE

ONIONS

₦75,000– 100KG IBADAN ₦100,000 100KG KANO ₦55,000– ₦80,000 ₦80,000– 100KG BENUE ₦110,000 ₦80,000– 100KG PLATEAU ₦110,000 100KG DELTA ₦95,000– ₦125,000 ₦90,000– 100KG LAGOS ₦120,000 ₦90,000– 100KG ENUGU ₦120,000

STATE

PRICE

NAME OF COMMODITY

SIZE

LOCATION

PRICE

MAIZE

50KG

OYO

₦80,000– ₦105,000

50KG ENUGU

₦90,000 – ₦115,000

50KG

ABIA

₦90,000– ₦115,000

50KG LAGOS

₦95,000 – ₦115,000

50KG

KANO

₦70,000– ₦95,000

100KG BENUE

₦65,000– ₦90,000

FCTA Seeks $1.5bn Green Investment to Transform Abuja Energy, Transport Sectors Olawale Ajimotokan in Abuja The Federal Capital Territory Administration (FCTA) is seeking to attract approximately $1.5 billion in green investment to transform Abuja’s energy and transportation sectors as part of efforts to address infrastructure deficits, improve public mobility and promote sustainable urban development. The investment drive gained momentum Thursday, November 5, 2026, when the FCTA disclosed that it had received two major privatesector proposals targeting sustainable e-mobility and waste management in the Territory. The proposals were unveiled at the FCT Post-COP30 Investment Roundtable in

Abuja, themed “Mobilizing Investment for Green Infrastructure and Sustainable E-Mobility in the FCT.” Speaking on behalf of the FCT Minister, Nyesom Wike, the Acting Head of Service, Mrs. Nancy Sabanti Nathan, said the administration was exploring innovative financing and private-sector partnerships to address the growing infrastructure demands arising from Abuja’s rapid urban expansion. She disclosed that the largest proposal, valued at approximately $1.5 billion, was submitted by Magnifique Integrated Concept Limited and its consortium partners to develop an integrated e-mobility and supporting energy infrastructure system across the FCT.

Eleganza Announces Plans to Reopen Alaba Suru Factory Eleganza Industrial City Limited is making plans to reopen its Alaba-Suru factory in Lagos, bringing its household products closer to customers and strengthening access to its locally manufactured products. The Alaba-Suru facility, which previously served as a major production centre for Eleganza products, was

Group Business Editor Eromosele Abiodun Deputy Business Editor Chinedu Eze Comms/e-Business Editor Emma Okonji Asst. Editor, Energy Emmanuel Addeh Asst. Editor, Money Market Nume Ekeghe Correspondents KayodeTokede(CapitalMarkets) James Emejo (Finance) Ebere Nwoji (Insurance) Reporter Peter Uzoho (Energy)

known for manufacturing quality household items, including coolers, chairs and other essential products. The planned re-opening is part of the company’s commitment to improving product accessibility, expanding its production capacity and positioning its operations closer to the heart of Lagos’ vibrant commercial community. As a company focused on household products, Eleganza Industries Limited recognises the importance of being accessible to the people it serves and reopening the Alaba factory will help bring production and product distribution closer to customers, making it easier for them to access the quality products they have come to trust. Founded by foremost industrialist, Chief Rasaki Akanni Okoya, CON, the move will bring the company closer to its distributors, customers and other stakeholders. Preparations for the re-opening are currently underway, with the company hopeful that operations will resume soon.

The proposed investment is expected to cover electric mass transit fleets, cleaner vehicle technologies, charging infrastructure, supporting energy systems and digital transport services. She noted that the increasing population of the nation’s capital had placed significant pressure on existing infrastructure, making investments in cleaner energy, efficient transportation and climate-resilient infrastructure increasingly necessary.

She also disclosed that a second investment proposal had been received from Hallmark Technologies and General Services Limited, focusing on converting municipal waste into economic assets through comprehensive waste-to-wealth systems. According to her, the proposed waste management initiative would promote resource recovery and produce biocompost to support agricultural productivity in farming communities within

and around the FCT. Earlier, the Chairman of the FCT Green Bond Committee and Permanent Secretary, Treasury and Budget Department, Adamu Ibrahim Wanki, said the investment roundtable was convened to build on the momentum generated by the FCT’s participation at COP30 in Belém, Brazil. He explained that the committee was working to translate expressions of interest secured at the climate summit

into concrete, investmentready projects capable of attracting financing. In a goodwill message delivered on behalf of the Director-General of the National Council on Climate Change (NCCC), the Head of Climate Finance, Ms. Benny Ejiofor, said Nigeria’s third Nationally Determined Contributions (NDC 3.0) had established a national climate financing target of $337 billion between 2026 and 2035.

AbdulRazaq Harps on Tax Education to Boost Revenue Generation Hammed Shittu in Ilorin Kwara state governor, Alhaji Abdulrahman Abdulrazaq has said that, payment of taxes by the residents of the state remains a major collective commitment towards the infrastructural and sustainable development of the state. Towards this end, the governor called for tax education among residents and schools in bid to strengthen revenue generation, promote fairness, and improve compliance. AbdulRazaq stated this in

Ilorin during the 2026 grand finale of the state Internal Revenue Service (KWIRS) tax club quiz competition in Ilorin. The governor who was represented at the event by the state commissioner for Education and Human Capital Development, Dr. Lawal Olohungbebe, the governor said that introduction of students to fundamentals of taxation at an early stage by the KWIRS is a commendable investment in the future of our state. He also said that the

move would help to nurture a generation that appreciates the relationship between tax revenue, public expenditure, accountability, and development. The governor said that his administration remains committed to building a Kwara State where opportunities for learning, innovation, and personal development are accessible to young people. “We recognise that education and human capital development are critical pillars of sustainable

growth, and we will continue to support initiatives that equip our students with the knowledge, skills, and values necessary to succeed in an increasingly competitive world”. Meanwhile, Government Secondary School, Lafiagi, has again emerged the overall winner for the KWIRS annual tax quiz competition with N2.5million grand prize. This is the second time the school will be emerging as the overall winner as it did in the year 2025 tax quiz competition.

Olam Agri Breaks Ground on $70m New Integrated Feed Mill in Delta State Dike Onwuamaeze Olam Agri has commenced the development of its new $70 million Integrated Feed Mill facility in OgwashiUku, Delta State. The new investment on 99.99 hectares of land will have capacity to deliver 1,500-tonne-per-day poultry feed mill, a 300-tonne-perday aqua feed mill and

125,000-tonne silo bag storage upon completion in 2027. It will further strengthen and expand its animal feed operations in West Africa and mark another significant milestone in the company’s expanding investment in Nigeria’s agricultural sector. Senior Vice President & Business Head of Integrated Feeds & Proteins, Olam Agri in Nigeria, Mr. Amit

Agarwal, said: “At Olam Agri, we believe building a resilient food system requires a sustained investment in local production, infrastructure and the partnership that connects farmers’ businesses and consumers. “The ground breaking of our new Integrated Feed Mill reflects our confidence in Nigeria’s agricultural potential and our commitment to

strengthening our capabilities across food and feed. “By establishing production capacity closer to customers in the South-South and South-East, we aim to improve access to quality animal feed, support the productivity of livestock farmers and contribute to the development of a more efficient and competitive livestock sector.”

Union Bank and Partners Recognise Outstanding Educators Union Bank of Nigeria has again demonstrated its longstanding commitment to improving educational outcomes for students, teachers, and young people in the communities it serves through its sponsorship of the 2026 Maltina Teacher of the Year Award Grand Finale, held in Lagos. Now in its third consecutive year as a partner

of the Maltina Teacher of the Year Competition (MTOTY), which is in its 12th edition, the Bank joined the organisers, Nigerian Breweries Plc and the Felix Ohiwerei Education Trust Fund, and sector stakeholders to celebrate teaching excellence as the overall winner was announced. Ms Busayo Victoria

Adeyemo of Lanre Awolokun High School, Gbagada, Lagos, was named Maltina Teacher of the Year 2026 from ten finalists selected out of more than 2,000 entries nationwide. Her prizes include N10 million, a new Honda SUV, an international capacity development programme, and a N30 million infrastructure project for her school.

Speaking on behalf of Union Bank at the Grand Finale, the Chief Brand and Marketing Officer, Mrs Olufunmilola Aluko, congratulated the finalists and state champions and described the competition as one of the most consistent private sector commitments to the teaching profession in Nigeria, with more than 300 teachers recognised to date.


T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

21

BUSINESSWORLD

INTERVIEW

Adelola: How Nigerians Can Survive, Flourish in Uncertain Times

Dr Rotimi Adelola is an organisational psychologist, leadership development consultant, educator, public administrator, author, filmmaker, and transformational thinker whose professional journey spans academia, banking, oil and gas, public service, organisational development, and human capacity building. His career reflects a lifelong commitment to understanding a fundamental question: Why do some individuals, organisations, and societies flourish while others struggle? The search for answers has shaped his work as a scholar, practitioner, executive, teacher, and author. Dr Adelola began his professional career in academia before moving into the corporate sector, where he played a key role in one of the most significant organisational transformation initiatives in Nigerian banking history—the turnaround of Owena Bank and its emergence as Omegabank. In this interview, he extensively discusses what people need to do to flourish and blossom in challenging and uncertain times, as we all do around the world. Using his new book, Psychology of Success: A Practical Guide to Flourishing in Uncertain Times, Dr Adelola offers valuable insights for career professionals and entrepreneurs, young graduates, government officials, and students. Excerpts Congratulations on your new book. Who or what inspired you to write Psychology of Success? hank you very much. The book grew out of two concerns: the uncertainty around us and the human possibilities within us. In Nigeria, economic difficulties, unemployment and insecurity have left many people anxious about their future. Similar anxieties are evident elsewhere in the world. People are asking: How do I plan when circumstances keep changing? How do I remain hopeful without deceiving myself? How do I build a worthwhile life under pressure? The second source was a question I encountered repeatedly in my work as an organisational psychologist: Why do people with apparently comparable talents respond so differently to difficulty? Some learn, adapt, and keep making progress; others become disillusioned or feel unable to act. Of course, their circumstances are never completely identical. Access to resources, support and opportunities matters. Nevertheless, how people interpret events, regulate their emotions, and organise their actions can also influence what happens next. I wrote this book to make relevant psychological knowledge accessible and useful. I wanted readers to understand that even when they cannot determine every circumstance, they can develop greater capacity to respond to it. Uncertainty makes preparation more necessary. That conviction drives the book.

reflect honestly, choose one action, schedule it, and review the result. For example: ‘ When it is 7 pm on Tuesday, I will spend thirty minutes revising my CV and then send it to a trusted colleague for feedback. A scheduled behaviour is easier to act on than a vague intention. Return to the exercise after a week or a month. Look for evidence of changed behaviour. Completing a workbook is a beginning; repeated practice is what gives it value.

T

Awesome. What did you set out to achieve with the book? My primary objective is to help people move from merely wishing for success to understanding and practising the behaviours that make meaningful achievement more likely. I also wanted to broaden the conversation about success. Money matters. Financial security can protect dignity and expand opportunity. But wealth, power, and public recognition do not, by themselves, tell us whether a person is living well. In this book, authentic success includes psychological well-being, meaningful relationships, personal growth, ethical conduct, and positive contributions to society. These dimensions give achievement its direction and its human value. Practically, I want readers to become better at understanding themselves, setting worthwhile goals, taking disciplined actions, and learning from experience. Someone who finishes reading the book should be able to identify a behaviour to change and explain how to begin changing it. Is this another motivational book full of theoretical concepts? That is a fair question. Inspiration has value, but people also need a practical explanation of how change happens and what it requires. My approach combines psychological knowledge, professional experience, illustrative case stories and exercises. The intention is to connect an idea with something the readers can actually

Ad e lol a do. Take self-efficacy, associated with Albert Bandura. It concerns people’s beliefs about their ability to carry out particular actions. For a graduate facing job interviews, useful confidence can grow through preparation, practice, feedback, and the experience of improvement. Simply telling that graduate to believe more strongly is insufficient. Similarly, goal-setting research by Edwin Locke and Gary Latham helps explain why clear, challenging goals can improve performance when people have the necessary commitment, capability, and feedback. A student who wants better results needs a study plan, an appropriate level of challenge and a way to check understanding. The book also discusses Nigerians and international figures. These stories invite readers to examine choices, persistence, learning, and adaptation. They should be read thoughtfully: a successful person’s experience can offer lessons, but it cannot establish a universal formula or tell us everything about the conditions behind that success. Each Chapter ends with a workbook. That allows the reader to examine an idea, apply it and review the result. The book’s practical test is what readers do with it after the initial excitement of reading has passed.

Why did you incorporate a workbook into every chapter? Because understanding a principle and practising it are different achievements. A reader may agree that discipline matters and still postpone the same important task tomorrow morning. The workbooks bridge reading and daily behaviour. They encourage readers to pause, examine their own experience and make a practical commitment. Several psychological ideas inform this approach. Active learning requires the reader to work an idea rather than merely recognise it. Self-awareness helps people notice habits, assumptions and emotional reactions they might otherwise overlook. Self-regulation involves planning an action, monitoring progress and adjusting the approach. Small, completed tasks can also provide experiences of mastery that strengthen confidence in a particular activity. Consider someone who says, I never get opportunities. An exercise might prompt more precise questions: Which opportunities have I pursued? What feedback have I received? What skills would improve my chances? Where do I need help or a different route? Those questions prompt readers to identify an actionable response. To get the most out of the workbooks, I suggest a simple routine for readers:

Who did you have in mind while writing this book? Who will benefit most? I wrote it for people who want to take a more deliberate role in shaping their future, whatever their starting point. That includes graduates entering the labour market, professionals seeking advancement, entrepreneurs facing difficult business conditions, leaders managing uncertainty and people rebuilding after a setback. I am particularly concerned about young Nigerians. Many are intelligent, ambitious and resourceful, but opportunities are unevenly distributed. They need relevant skills, supportive institutions, and psychological tools to manage frustration, sustain effort, and make sound decisions. The book is also relevant later in life. A person approaching retirement may need to redefine purpose. An experienced executive may need to improve relationships. An entrepreneur may need to reconsider a business model that once worked well. Teachers, parents, counsellors, and human resource professionals can use the exercises to support constructive conversations and development activities. The readers most likely to benefit are those willing to examine their assumptions and practise what they learn. Personal Development remains possible at different ages, but it requires participation. What is the central theme of the book? The central theme is that meaningful success develops through the intersection of who we become, what we do and the value we contribute. I explored this through three connected dimensions. The first is mastery of self: understanding our beliefs, emotions, strengths, limitations, and behaviour patterns. The second is purposeful actions: translating aspirations into goals, plans and sustained effort. The third is meaningful contribution: building relationships, exercising judgement and creating values beyond ourselves. By mastery, I mean growing competence in managing these areas, not perfect control over life. Someone may achieve professional distinction while damaging important relationships or neglecting personal health. That achievement may be real, but it leaves important questions unanswered about the quality and sustainability of the person’s life. Success is not merely about what you acquire. It is about who you become and the value you create. The story continues online on www.thisdaylive.com


T H I S D AY ˾ TUESDAY NOVEMBER 10, 2026

22

Acting Group Politics Editor DEJI ELUMOYE

POLITICS

Email: deji.elumoye@thisdaylive.com 08033025611 SMS ONLY

As NLC Squares Up with TUC Over N70,000 Transport Allowance...

For decades, the Nigeria Labour Congress and the Trade Union Congress have presented themselves as two pillars of one house - Organised Labour. Most times when they speak they do so with one voice and governments are compelled to listen. But when they disagree, it’s government that gains to the disadvantage of workers, writes Onyebuchi Ezigbo.

Ajaero

R

ecently the two labour centres - the Nigeria Labour Congress (NLC) and Trade Union Congress (TUC) disagreed over a seemingly simple issue which is should workers take N70,000 as a transport allowance for six months, or should they insist that the money be built permanently into their salaries? What began as a difference in negotiating tactics has grown into a public rift, with statements, counter-statements and affiliate unions taking sides. Now, veteran labour leaders have stepped in, warning that the quarrel, if left unchecked, could undermine the unity, solidarity and strength that took decades to build. Observers of the unfolding crisis of confidence within organised Labour family of the opinion that it will augur well for the workers whose interest are better protected when both labour centres join hands to confront the government and other employers of labour. The bone of contention in this current misunderstanding was an agreement reached between the Federal Ministry of Labour and Employment and NLC on October 27, 2026 with major focus on commencement date for negotiation of a new minimum wage, issues on public service welfare and adjustment of tax relief for workers. The agreement also addressed the Joint Health Sector Unions (JOHESU) issues on CONHESS Palliative to cushion the effect of challenges faced by the workers, demands by Joint National Public Service Negotiation Council (JNPSNC) and reduction in petroleum pump price. Other issues include, demand for payment of hazard allowance for Agricultural workers. According to JNPSNC, the agreement was the product of more than six hours of tough negotiation presided over by the Minister of Labour and Employment, Alhaji Mohamed Maigari Dingyadi. The labour team was led by NLC President, Comrade Joe Ajaero, with participation from JNPSNC and the Joint Health Sector Union (JOHESU). A major highlight of the deal was the N70,000 transport allowance to be paid for

Osifo

the next six months to public servants starting November 2026, to subsidize unbearable transport costs. It also cemented implementation of the long-overdue 40 per cent peculiar allowance reflecting the N70,000 minimum wage, which ought to have started since July 2024. The allowance will be domesticated at sub-national levels from November 2026, while arrears from May 1, 2026 will be paid in three tranches. Other gains listed in the JNPSNC circular signed by National Secretary, Comrade Gbenga Olowoyo, include: a tripartite negotiation committee comprising government, labour and NECA to commence immediately; resolution of the 13-year-old CONHESS adjustment demand, with the National Salaries, Incomes and Wages Commission (NSIWC) given three weeks to conclude work; payment of 19-month arrears of health workers’ allowances in three installments from December 2026; issuance of a circular for hazard allowance to agricultural professional officers within three weeks; and a one-month window to reconvene to evaluate implementation. On its part, the Federal Government has said it is “fully committed to ensuring that the ongoing collective bargaining agreement negotiation is concluded as soon as possible and that its implementation can bring the

Waba

expected relief and improved condition of service to your members.” It gave the undertaking through the Minister of Labour Alhaji Muhammad Maigari Dingyadi at the opening of the National Executive Council meeting of the Medical and Health Workers Union in Abuja. For NLC, the N70,000 is not the end of the struggle. NLC President, Joe Ajaero said it is a starting point, a foothold that cannot be taken away. “Whatever we got for you, nobody can take away from us. The N70,000 you are hearing is just an intervention. Like I said somewhere, when you give glucose to someone and it is inside his mouth, if you want to bring it out and you put your hand there. You know what will happen. So now that we have N70,000 on top of N70,000 you know where we are going to start from,” he told the 52nd National Executive Council meeting of the Medical and Health Workers Union of Nigeria (MHWUN) in Abuja. He said the agreement was negotiated with the mandate from affiliate unions, including handling of JOHESU and JNPSNC issues, and represents a landmark achievement. Already, the move has the backing of the leadership of JNPSNC which dismissed the notion that NLC is a union of junior workers, saying all its affiliates have members across Ministries, Departments and Agencies up to Directorate level. JNPSNC scribe argued that TUC, which was not part of the negotiation, has no basis to reject what it did not negotiate, though he added it would be commendable if TUC could secure a higher amount.

Both arguments have merit. Both carry risk. Accepting a temporary allowance could become a substitute for real salary review. However rejecting it outright could leave workers with nothing while negotiations drag.

“Rejection of any item by any trade union is inconsequential to implementation because wider spectrum of workers has applauded decision as right step in right direction,” the circular said. On the other hand, TUC sees the same N70,000 through a different lens - basing it’s argument on previous lessons where government failed to religiously implement the wage award. In its communique after an emergency National Administrative Council (NAC) meeting on Wednesday, November 4, 2026, signed by Secretary General, Dr. Nuhu Toro, TUC reaffirmed its demand for a sustainable salary increase, not another wage award. Its argument is rooted in experience: the wage award palliative agreed on October 2, 2023 was to run until the new minimum wage was signed into law on July 29, 2024. Workers, TUC said, received an average of only three months out of the ten months agreed upon. “A sustainable salary increase offers a more meaningful intervention to improve workers’ purchasing power and living standards,” the communique said, stressing that the minimum wage is a statutory floor and not a ceiling on workers’ earnings. Secretary General of TUC, Dr. Nuhu Toro who spoke at the recent MHWUN NEC meeting, put it more plainly: “The NLC is saying pay N70,000 transport allowance. The TUC was not there when that was negotiated, and the TUC said, we think you should negotiate for the N70,000 to be component of the salary. For instance, if N70,000 is added to your housing allowance, it becomes part of your salary and will not be taken off after six months. So the TUC said no, let’s make it holistic so that they won’t take it off after six months. So that is the argument. It’s not any issue.” TUC also acknowledged the positions of its public-sector affiliates — SSAUTHRIA, NUAHP and SSASCGOC — noting they are consistent with its earlier position. NOTE: Interested readers should continue in the online edition on www.thisdaylive.com


THISDAY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

23

PERSPECTIVE

Ken Saro-Wiwa: 31 Years of Begging the Question Nigeria has continued to evade, rather than confront, the issues at the heart of the Niger Delta agitation. Vincent Obia writes

N

igeria marks a bitter anniversary today. On November 10, 1995, the Nigerian state, under the military rule of General Sani Abacha, silenced one of the most powerful voices of justice in environmental rights history. Ken Saro-Wiwa, a celebrated writer, environmental rights campaigner, and leader of the Movement for the Survival of the Ogoni People (MOSOP), was hanged alongside eight other Ogoni activists after a trial that was widely condemned as designed to act out a script rather than deliver justice. Saro-Wiwa, Barinem Kiobel, John Kpuinen, Baribor Bera, Felix Nuate, Paul Levula, Saturday Dobee, Nordu Eawo, and Daniel Gbook were accused of murder by the state, which also applied every known treachery to frustrate the efforts of the accused to prove their innocence. But it was clear from the kangaroo trial that the crime of the Ogoni 9 was daring to challenge the environmental devastation and economic injustice visited on their homeland by decades of oil exploration and exploitation. Many believe the murder of four Ogoni chiefs – Chief Albert Badey, Chief Edward Kobani, Chief Theophilus Orage, and Chief Samuel Orage (Ogoni 4) – in 1994, for which Saro-Wiwa and the others were tried, was conducted by the establishment to create an excuse to silence the Ogoni 9. Abacha conducted the executions in Port Harcourt on a day the Super Eagles played against Uzbekistan in the second leg of the Afro-Asian Cup of Nations, at the National Stadium, Lagos, and the attention of the whole country was diverted. The celebratory mood that would have followed Nigeria’s 1-0 victory in the edgy game turned to national bitterness as news of the executions broke. The indignation flowed quickly across the world. Nigeria was isolated by the international community, until it commenced visible efforts to return to civil rule in 1999. Thirty-one years after, the questions Saro-Wiwa raised remain unresolved. And like the state under Abacha, successive administrations have seemed more zealous to apply cosmetics and divert attention from the real issues than address them. This begs the question of whether Nigeria is committed to justice and sustainable development in the Niger Delta. The federal government launched the Hydrocarbon Pollution Remediation Project (HYPREP) in June 2016 following the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) report findings on Ogoniland. HYPREP was set up to clean up soil and groundwater contamination and restore shorelines and mangroves damaged by over 50 years of oil activities in the Niger Delta. Under the scheme, some infrastructural projects have been established, including hospitals, potable water, environmental research centres, as well as educational and skills acquisition schemes. In September, HYPREP commenced the development of a new five-year Strategic Plan, 2026-2031, focussing on completing outstanding projects, sustaining restored ecosystems, and safeguarding the gains of the Ogoni Cleanup Programme. Minister of Environment and Chairman of HYPREP Governing Council, Balarabe Lawal, said at the 10th anniversary of the Ogoni Cleanup Programme that the plan will also focus on “preventing repollution and strengthening community ownership of completed projects”. Lawal unveiled the remodelled Ogoni Cleaup Plaque and monument at the historic Patrick Waterside in Bodo City, Gokana Local Government Area, saying it is a permanent reminder of the Nigerian government’s commitment to the people of Ogoni. But Executive Director, Health of Mother Earth Foundation(HOMEF), Nnimmo Bassey says the clean-up exercise in Ogoni does not address the continuing “environmental genocide” in the Niger Delta. Bassey states, “There has been some throwing of money at the region through the NDDC, but

Late Ken Saro-Wiwa

that does not address the existential challenges of massive, persistent, and possibly irreversible damage done to the environment of the region.” Nigeria has historically established interventionist agencies to try to tackle environmental degradation, poverty, and infrastructural deficit in the Niger Delta. They include Niger Delta Development Board (NDDB), established in 1961 following the Willink Commission report; Oil Mineral Producing Areas Development Commission (OMPADEC) set up in 1992 by the military government; Niger Delta Development Commission (NDDC) created by the President Olusegun Obasanjo government in 2000; and Ministry of Niger Delta Affairs created in 2008 by the President Umaru Yar’Adua government to coordinate development policies and supervise federal development agencies in the region. There is also the Presidential Amnesty Programme initiated by the Yar’Adua government. The derivation principle is also a major policy intervention in the Niger Delta. But the regions under the Independence Constitution of 1960 and Republican Constitution of 1963 controlled their natural resources, and retained 50 per cent of revenue derived from such resources, while the rest went to the common pool and the central government. From 1970, the states were stripped of control over their natural resources by the military, which also created an onshore/ offshore dichotomy that limited derivation to onshore production. The derivation principle was reduced to as low as 1.5 per cent, before it went up slightly to three per cent, and to the current 13 per cent under the 1999 Constitution. Successive governments have initiated intervention agencies and programmes for the Niger delta, but the fundamental questions of environmental justice and resource control remain largely unresolved. Yet, the Niger Delta remains the economic lifeblood of a country whose fortunes have depended heavily on crude oil exports. But for many in the region, the

wealth produced on their land has brought neither economic prosperity nor a healthy environment, as pollution from oil spills, gas flaring, blowouts, and other oil-related disasters continue to degrade the environment and destroy livelihoods. The recent divestment of Shell’s onshore Nigerian subsidiary underlines a seeming alliance between the state and foreign capital in the continuing economic exploitation of the Niger Delta. It raises the question of whether international oil companies (IOCs) can walk away from decades of devastating operations without fully accounting for their environmental liabilities. Bassey believes the divestment by IOCs should be revoked. He says, “The IOCs must clean up their mess. They own their toxic legacy and cannot leave without addressing the gross harms.” The issues that inspired Saro-Wiwa’s agitation appear to have become even more entrenched, with politicians hardly seeing the Niger Delta question as a serious topic. The HOMEF director says, “Any presidential candidate who cannot enunciate his plans for addressing the Niger Delta genocide should not be voted for. “The same goes for the Niger Delta candidates for the state Houses of Assembly, House of Representatives, and Senate.” The persistence of the ugly circumstances in the region has raised fears of a possible return to agitation by the people. Bassey says, “The issue is whether the people can survive and reasonably expect a future for coming generations. “The region has been essentially sacrificed and the reign of life threatening health issues continue to be compounded by reckless and irresponsible exploitation and pollution of the area.” Last year, President Bola Tinubu granted a posthumous pardon to the Ogoni 9 and Ogoni 4, ironically, recognising them as heroes, but refusing

to exonerate Saro-Wiwa and his eight compatriots of the bogus charges for which they were executed. Amnesty International Nigeria and many in Nigeria’s civil society community rejected the pardon as deficient, insisting that the government must grant the Ogoni 9 a full legal exoneration rather than a pardon that implies retention of guilt. Bassey insists, “You don’t pardon persons who were not found guilty of any offense through a fair justice system. “Saro-Wiwa and the other eight leaders were denied the right to appeal the sentence handed down to them by the kangaroo tribunal. They should be exonerated. Nothing short of that would come close to an admission of grave error.” Paradoxically, amid the unfinished clean-up work in Ogoni, the federal government is pushing for the return of oil production in the area. And outside Ogoniland, the environmental devastation has continued, with burning oil wells, abandoned oil wells, and gas flaring. Bassey says, “The federal government should declare an environmental state of emergency across the Niger Delta and urgently commence environmental auditing, remediation, and restoration.” He says the push to resume oil production in Ogoni “shows a lack of understanding of the interwoven nature of the Niger Delta environment and would be the final nail sealing of the hopes of ever getting the Niger Delta environment cleaned up and restored”. According to him, “Not one new oil wells should be drilled in the region. And Ogoni oil should be left in the ground. To drill that oil is literally to bleed the blood of the people and the land.” Thirty-one years after Saro-Wiwa and his compatriots were executed, Nigeria still confronts the issues for which they died. The Niger Delta question remains alive and unresolved, and operators of the Nigerian state appear content to beg the question, with no indication of when – or if – they will ever provide a real answer.


24

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 • THISDAY

NEWS

HACKAHOLICS 7.0 GRAND FINALE...

L–R: Executive Director, Retail, Digital and Finance, Wema Bank, Tunde Mabawonku; Representatives of Niteon and First-place Ideathon Winners, in the Hackaholics 7.0, Daniel Chukwuemeli and Tony Nwose; Managing Director/Chief Executive Officer, Wema Bank, Moruf Oseni; and Executive Director, Corporate and Global Markets, Wema Bank, Olukayode Bakare, at the Hackaholics 7.0 Grand Finale in Lagos... recently

FG Plans $2bn Spending on East-West Super Grid, Set to End Unreliable Power Supply in 3 Years Tegbe: Issues with Egbin plant resolved, electricity restored to Lagos, others Emmanuel Addeh in Abuja The federal government has said that it is planning to invest $2 billion in an East-West super grid to strengthen Nigeria’s electricity transmission network and increase its capacity to 19,000 megawatts, with a three to five year horizon to achieve stable supply. The Minister of Power, Joseph Tegbe, disclosed this on Monday during a TVC television programme monitored by TheCable, where he also said recent electricity supply challenges in some states have been resolved. “Number one, we have sorted out this little challenge we had in the last few days. It was painful for most of you. But look, we fixed it. And we will ensure that that stability remains. My focus is to ensure grid stability,” he said. On the Lagos corridor, the minister said power had been restored to several areas as of Sunday night. “I am sure in Lagos, I confirm as at last night because I made personal calls, Ajah, Leki, Ikoyi, Magodo, Ikeja, lights are back,” he said. “And people have attested to it, people have sent me messages. Nigerians, again, I appeal to you, just bear with us, we will get there,” he stressed. Tegbe said Nigerians will enjoy stable power within three to five years,

noting that infrastructure build out is not done overnight. “Honestly speaking, you already see some visible improvement despite the challenge we have had. By the time we fix the grid, I will look at the horizon of about three to five years from now,” he said. “Infrastructure build out is not done overnight. Even when we fix some of the challenges we have today, we need to build the capacity. Everybody is building capacity for AI, for data. Most young people work from home, and because of that, there is a need for bandwidth and for electricity supply,” he emphasised. He said the proposed east west super grid will complement existing infrastructure rather than replace it and will improve resilience and stability of the national grid. According to him, the grid will cut across the country, linking Funtua, Gwagwalada, Ikot Ekpene, Benin, Epe and Ilorin. Tegbe said government has commenced the procurement process for the project, which could be completed within two years, and that it will help increase grid capacity from about 4,000 megawatts to 19,000 megawatts. He said government also expects private sector participation in electricity transmission within the next two to three years.

“So give me a time horizon of three to five years. Nigeria will enjoy stable life. And as demand improves, it will get better,” he said. Meanwhile, Tegbe in an update on the power situation yesterday said power has been restored to many areas earlier affected by disruptions, largely in Lagos, Ogun, Oyo, Kwara and the FCT.

The Federal University Lokoja, FUL, is set to graduate a total of 5,638 students of the Class of 2026 during the 10th Convocation Ceremony on Saturday . The Vice Chancellor, Professor Gbenga Ibileye disclosed this while speaking during the pre-10th Convocation Ceremony press conference in Lokoja yesterday. Professor Ibileye explained that at the Tenth Convocation, the university will graduate a total of 5,638 students of the Class of 2026. Of this number, 4,828 will receive first degrees, 182 diplomas, and 628 postgraduate qualifications. Out of the 4,828 first-degree recipients, 4,786 are honours degree

graduands, classified as follows: First Class Honours – 24; Second Class Honours (Upper Division) – 881; Second Class Honours (Lower Division) - 2,928; and Third Class Honours - 953. “By faculty, the largest graduating class is from the Faculty of Life Sciences, with 1,024 graduands, followed by the Faculty of Education with 806 and the Faculty of Arts with 773. “At the postgraduate level, the university will award 46 Postgraduate Diplomas, 162 Professional Master’s degrees, 238 Academic Master’s degrees and 182 Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) degrees. “This year, we also have the privilege of conferring honorary degrees on three distinguished Nigerians in

repaired and deployed to transmit power, which helped bring total supply to the Lagos Complex to over 1,000 megawatts. “This restoration helped to bring the total power supply to the Lagos Complex to over 1,000 megawatts, effectively normalising to the condition before the disruption,” he said. Tegbe said the ministry was

working with key power sector stakeholders, including the Generation Companies (Gencos), System Operator, Transmission Company and the Distribution Companies (Discos) to ensure sustained and improved availability of power. “Our priority continues to be the provision of reliable electricity to Nigerians,” he said.

Barau Awards MSc Scholarships to 85 Indigent Students, Donates Laptops Deputy Senate President expands postgraduate scheme to five varsities Sunday Aborisade in Abuja The Deputy President of the Senate, Senator Jibrin Barau, has awarded postgraduate scholarships to 85 indigent students to pursue Master of Science (MSc) programmes in emerging and technology-driven disciplines at Bayero University, Kano (BUK). Barau, who presented admission letters to the beneficiaries of Batch A of his Domestic Postgraduate Scholarship Programme in Kano on Monday, also announced the donation of laptops to all the beneficiaries to

FUL Graduates 5,638 Students, Tackling Financial Challenges to Survive Ibrahim Oyewale in Lokoja

“I would like to report that power has since been restored to many of the areas earlier affected by power disruptions, largely in Lagos, Ogun, Oyo, Kwara and the FCT. Our teams continue to work to restore full supply to the remaining affected locations,” he said. He said the vandalised Benin Egbin 330kV power line has been swiftly

recognition of their outstanding contributions to commerce, industry, journalism, and humanity. “These degrees will be conferred during the convocation on Saturday, 14 November 2026. “The Vice Chancellor pointed out that despite successes and other achievements, the management has continued to strive hard to address daunting challenges confronting the university. “The university has advanced discussions on a N3 billion Public-Private Partnership project for the development of a model hostel. We have made substantial progress towards securing the necessary regulatory approvals and are optimistic that implementation will commence soon.

facilitate their academic work. The scholarship programme, implemented through the Barau I. Jibrin Foundation (BIJF), covers several specialised fields, including Cybersecurity, Solar Energy Technology, Software Engineering, Climate Change, Information Technology and Natural Resources Management. A statement by his Media Aide Ismail Mudashir on Monday said Barau, speaking at the presentation ceremony held at Amani Event Centre, Kano, the described human capital development as fundamental to national progress, stressing that investment in education and advanced knowledge remained critical to building a productive workforce. He said Nigeria needed a skilled

and knowledgeable population capable of responding to contemporary challenges, promoting innovation and driving sustainable development. He said, “Investing in education, skills acquisition and advanced knowledge is essential to building a skilled workforce capable of addressing contemporary challenges and driving sustainable development. “I will continue to strive to ensure that our youths, particularly those from Kano North, are empowered through education to become productive and useful members of society. “The number one driver of economic development is human capital development. If you build the youth, you build the nation,” he said. Barau also disclosed that five

additional universities had been selected for the second batch of the domestic postgraduate scholarship programme. The institutions are Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria; University of Ibadan; University of Lagos; Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife; and University of Nigeria, Nsukka. He explained that extending the scholarship scheme beyond Kano was intended to expose beneficiaries to different academic environments, cultures and social experiences, which he said would enrich their intellectual development. According to him, studying outside their immediate environment would enable the students to acquire broader perspectives and experiences beyond their chosen academic disciplines.

Ogoni Cleanup: MOSOP Reaffirms Total Support for HYPREP Blessing Ibunge in Port Harcourt Leaders of the Movement for the Survival of Ogoni People (MOSOP) have resolved to partner with the Hydrocarbon Pollution Remediation Project (HYPREP) to ensure the successful implementation of the Ogoni cleanup exercise recommended by the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP). The resolution followed an inspection tour of HYPREP’s signature projects across Ogoni communities in Rivers State. The projects inspected included the Rope Access Training Centre at Elimgbu, Bodo Water Scheme,

Bomu Mangrove Restoration Site, Specialist Hospital at Kpite and land remediation project at Ogale, among others. Speaking with journalists after inspecting the Specialist Hospital at Kpite, one of the MOSOP leaders, Olu Anda Wai-Ogosu, expressed satisfaction with the progress recorded by HYPREP, particularly its efforts to restore the devastated Ogoni ecosystem. “We’ve seen some signature projects in the midst of all the projects that HYPREP has carried out. Most importantly, the efforts so far that we have seen is that HYPREP is trying to bring back

some lost ecosystems,” he said. Ogosu noted that evidence of ecological recovery was already emerging, particularly along previously devastated coastlines where mangrove restoration activities were underway. Another MOSOP chieftain, Prince Biira, described the cleanup exercise as a physical manifestation of the decades-long Ogoni struggle for environmental justice. “Today is very historic, the 5th of November, 2026, because a few months ago in August, we just celebrated the 10th anniversary of the establishment of HYPREP,” he said.


25

THISDAY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

NEWS

2026 ALMOND INSURANCE INDUSTRY AWARDS...

L-R: Chief Executive Officer, Heritage Capital Markets Limited, Mr. Chidi Ajaegbu; Senator, representing Abia South Senatorial District, Senator Enyinnaya Abaribe; Awardee/ Managing Director/CEO, Rex Insurance Limited, Mrs. Ebelexhukwu Nwachukwu; and Nigerian Insurance Veteran/ Chairman of the Occasion, Mr. Ogala Osoka, during the 2026 Almond Insurance Industry Awards and presentation of CEO of the year award to Nwachukwu held in Lagos... recently

Noma: MSF Alarmed Over Preventable Disease Devastating Nigerian Children, Demands Urgent Government Action Reveals 1,759 reconstructive surgeries performed on victims as poverty, malnutrition, late diagnosis fuel deadly infection Michael Olugbode in Abuja Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF), otherwise known as Doctors Without Borders, has warned that Nigeria risks losing more children to noma, a largely neglected but preventable disease that can destroy the face within days, unless the government urgently strengthens early detection, community surveillance and access to treatment. The international humanitarian organisation said the disease, which primarily affects malnourished children living in conditions of extreme poverty, remains a serious public health concern despite growing national and international efforts to combat it. MSF Country Representative in Nigeria, Ahmed Aldikhari, who raised the concern at the 2026 National Noma Day commemoration in Abuja, said the country must move beyond policy commitments and translate existing interventions into effective action at the grassroots, where vulnerable children are most likely to be missed by the healthcare system. He stressed the difference between survival without permanent disability and a lifetime of severe facial disfigurement could depend on how quickly the disease is recognised and treated. Aldikhari called on the federal government to strengthen communitybased surveillance, equip frontline health workers to recognise the early warning signs of noma and ensure that suspected cases are promptly referred to specialised treatment facilities.

He said the inclusion of noma in Nigeria’s Surveillance Outbreak Response Management and Analysis System (SORMAS), alongside efforts to integrate the disease into primary healthcare guidelines, represented important progress but would achieve little without effective implementation across states and local government areas. The MSF representative also welcomed the launch of the National Strategic Plan on Oral Health 2026–2031 by the Federal Ministry of Health, describing it as an opportunity to institutionalise noma prevention, early diagnosis and treatment within the country’s broader healthcare delivery system. He however insisted the responsibility for combating the disease must not rest solely with the federal government or specialised hospitals, arguing that effective intervention requires coordinated action involving state governments, local authorities, community health workers, traditional and religious leaders, teachers and caregivers. According to him, community-based identification is particularly important because noma often develops among children in disadvantaged communities where access to healthcare is limited and awareness of the disease remains low. Noma, also known as cancrum oris or gangrenous stomatitis, is among the most devastating diseases affecting vulnerable children, yet it remains relatively unknown outside communi-

ties and medical circles where cases are frequently encountered. The disease begins as an infection of the gums, often presenting with painful, swollen or bleeding gums and foul-smelling breath. Without prompt intervention, it can progress rapidly, destroying the soft tissues and bones of the mouth and face, sometimes within a matter of days. It primarily affects children between the ages of two and six, particularly those experiencing severe malnutrition, poor oral hygiene, weakened immunity and recurrent infections. The World Health Organisation (WHO) has identified noma as a neglected tropical disease and described it as a disease closely associated with extreme poverty, social exclusion and inadequate access to essential healthcare. In December 2023, the WHO formally included noma on its list of neglected tropical diseases following an initiative spearheaded by Nigeria and supported by 32 member states. The recognition was significant for Nigeria, which has long been one of the countries at the centre of efforts to address the disease. According to WHO estimates, noma was associated with approximately 140,000 new cases annually worldwide, based on estimates dating back to 1998. The organisation also estimated a case fatality rate of about 90 per cent, although it acknowledged that early treatment can substantially reduce the risk of death.

FG: FOREIGN FIRMS MOBILISE $21BN TO INVEST IN NIGERIA’S OIL, GAS SECTOR benefit from. He said oil production has grown by over 80 percent since the government came in, though Nigeria is not yet where it wants to be. Active rigs, he said, have risen from about 10 to over 60, with continuous drilling campaigns by different operators. The Minister dismissed the value of reserves on paper, citing Venezuela which has over 300 billion barrels of reserves but remains one of the poorest countries in the world. He described Nigeria’s 37 billion barrels oil reserves and 215 trillion cubic feet of gas deposit as academic unless they were unlocked and taken to market. He said the modest efforts of the government have strengthened the economy, citing the Central Bank

of Nigeria (CBN) records showing foreign reserves of about $56 billion, 85 percent of which came from oil and gas. Lokpobiri warned that Nigeria faces a potential manpower crisis if it fails to rebuild training pipelines for geoscientists and petroleum engineers. He recalled an incubation centre in Warri, Delta State, where young graduates gained real industry skills, which has since been shut down. He backed NAPE’s plan to establish an academy, urging the industry to support it and to extend support to universities, where many lecturers lack practical experience. “So, NAPE came to my office a few weeks ago and said they are nursing an idea of a NAPE academy. The details could be

worked out. My own is that the industry needs to support NAPE. That idea needs to be supported,” Lokpobiri said. He called for more frontier exploration in the Anambra Basin, Benue Trough, Dahomey Basin and other basins beyond the Niger Delta, noting that the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) provides a fund for frontier exploration. He said if Nigeria explores aggressively, reserves could more than double, with an additional 18 billion barrels potentially in deepwater yet to be certified. The Minister said the global energy landscape was being redesigned and Nigeria had been strategically positioned in the new map, adding that the government awaits recommendations from experts at the conference.

The actual burden remains difficult to establish because many affected children are never diagnosed or reported. Some die in their communities without reaching a hospital, while survivors frequently endure severe facial deformities, difficulties eating and speaking, psychological trauma and social discrimination. Importantly, noma is not contagious. Its occurrence is strongly associated with preventable conditions, including malnutrition, poor oral health, inadequate sanitation and untreated infections. The disease is particularly tragic because early intervention with antibiotics, improved nutrition and appropriate oral hygiene can halt its progression before permanent facial damage occurs. However, when children arrive at hospitals after the infection has advanced, treatment becomes considerably more complicated, often requiring multiple reconstructive operations and prolonged rehabilitation. Against this background, MSF said it had sustained its partnership with the Federal Ministry of Health and the Sokoto State Ministry of Health in providing comprehensive care for people affected by noma at the Noma Children’s Hospital in Sokoto State since 2014. Aldikhari disclosed the collaboration had facilitated more than 1,759 major reconstructive surgeries for 1,174 patients through 35 surgical missions over the past decade. In 2026 alone, he said, MSF conducted 114 surgeries for 96 patients,

underscoring the continuing demand for specialised treatment. The interventions extend beyond surgery to include inpatient management of acute noma cases, oral physiotherapy, nutritional support, community engagement, health education and mental health and psychosocial services. The organisation has also invested in developing local medical capacity, with 28 Nigerian surgeons and 14 anaesthetists trained by international specialists to improve the country’s ability to manage complex noma cases. The training is particularly important given the specialised nature of reconstructive procedures required by survivors, many of whom suffer extensive tissue damage that affects their ability to eat, speak and perform everyday activities. For MSF, however, the ultimate objective should not simply be to expand the number of reconstructive surgeries performed but to prevent children from reaching the stage where such procedures become necessary. This, Aldikhari suggested, requires a fundamental shift towards prevention, early diagnosis and timely referral. The MSF representative said Nigeria’s primary healthcare system must become the frontline of the country’s response, given that primary healthcare facilities are often the first point of contact for families seeking medical attention for sick children. He called for the integration of routine noma screening into primary healthcare services and the training of frontline health workers to recognise its

earliest symptoms, provide appropriate initial care and refer suspected cases without delay. He also advocated stronger community surveillance involving traditional rulers, religious leaders, teachers, caregivers and community health workers, noting that these groups could help identify children showing early symptoms before their conditions deteriorate. He welcomed the inclusion of noma in SORMAS but cautioned the effectiveness of the surveillance system would depend on consistent reporting, adequate training, reliable data management, supportive supervision and the timely use of information to guide interventions. He further urged the government and development partners to provide sustained funding for the implementation of the National Strategic Plan on Oral Health, expansion of treatment facilities and strengthening of referral networks. Beyond the health sector, the disease also highlights the consequences of persistent poverty, food insecurity, inadequate sanitation and unequal access to basic healthcare. Efforts to eliminate noma, therefore, cannot be separated from broader interventions to improve child nutrition, access to clean water, sanitation, immunisation and essential primary healthcare. Nigeria’s leadership in securing WHO recognition for noma as a neglected tropical disease has provided an important platform for mobilising international attention and resources.

Alleged Cyberbulling: DSS Lawyer Can’t Be Your Witness Court Tells Sowore Alex Enumah in Abuja Justice Mohammed Umar of a Federal High Court, Abuja, has dismissed the motion by presidential candidate of the African Action Congress (AAC), Omoyele Sowore, asking the court to order the Department of State Services (DSS) counsel, Mr Akinlolu Kehinde, SAN, to testify in his ongoing alleged cyberbullying trial. Justice Umar who turned down the activist request on Monday in a ruling, also set aside the subpoena earlier issued against

Kehinde, holding that lawyers owe their clients a strict duty of confidentiality and cannot ordinarily be compelled to disclose communications relating to legal representation. The judge further explained that a legal practitioner could only be compelled to testify under limited circumstances, particularly where the evidence sought relates to an uncontested matter or an issue that would not prejudice the interests of the client. Following the ruling, defence counsel, Ruben Adakole, informed

the court of the defence’s intention to subpoena a chieftain of the All Progressives Congress (APC), Joe Igbokwe, and the Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Professor Joash Amupitan, as witnesses. In response, Justice Umar granted the request and directed that subpoenas be issued to the proposed witnesses to appear before the court. The court subsequently adjourned the matter until November 11, 2026, for the appearance of the subpoenaed defence witnesses.


26

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 • THISDAY

NEWS

DANGOTE DEPLOYS FOOTBALL TO UNITE IBESE, OKPELLA HOST COMMUNITIES...

The Olu of Imasayi, His Royal Majesty, Oba (Dr.) Lukman Olalekan Kuoye (centre), during the opening ceremony of the maiden Host Communities’ Unity Football Tournament in Ibese... recently

Tinubu Graduated from Chicago State University in 1979, Reno Omokri Insists Sunday Ehigiator Nigeria’s Ambassador to Mexico, Reno Omokri, has insisted that President Bola Tinubu graduated from Chicago State University (CSU), United States, in 1979, citing what he described as documentary evidence, the testimony of the institution’s registrar, and a Supreme Court judgement. Omokri, in a statement yesterday, said he personally visited Chicago State University on September 19, 2022, where he confirmed that Tinubu was admitted to, attended, and graduated from the institution. He said the university provided him with a document confirming the president’s academic records, which he attached to his statement. He also recalled that on October 3, 2023, the university’s Registrar, Caleb Westberg, testified under oath before a court that Tinubu attended and graduated from the institution in 1979. According to Omokri, the BBC Global Disinformation Team subsequently corroborated the findings of his visit and the registrar’s testimony in a report published on October 11, 2023. He said the BBC investigation found allegations that Tinubu forged a diploma from the institution to be false. Omokri further referenced the Supreme Court judgement of October

26, 2023, stating that the apex court has dismissed allegations questioning Tinubu’s graduation from the university as lacking merit. He described renewed questions about the president’s academic qualifications as politically motivated, alleging that some political interests are attempting to revive allegations he considered already disproved.

He said, “This is campaign season. So, of course, you can expect that a TV station linked in ownership to a vice-presidential candidate of an opposition party would resurrect this malicious, fallacious and disproven propaganda.” Although he did not identify the television station, Omokri maintained that the controversy had been suf-

AGF, Lateef Fagbemi, SAN, have however canvassed proper conduct and professionalism from lawyers that would represent various litigants at the 2027 election petition tribunals across the federation. Kekere-Ekun specifically warned lawyers against filing multiple suits on the same subject matter, seeking conflicting orders from courts of coordinate jurisdiction and using ex- parte applications to secure tactical advantages in election disputes ahead of the 2027 general elections. According to the CJN, such practices could undermine the administration of justice and turn the courts into instruments of political contest, urging legal practitioners to uphold professional ethics and respect judicial processes. She said the Judiciary must be prepared adequately to handle

election disputes fairly, competently and within the strict timelines prescribed by the Constitution and the Electoral Act. Fagbemi, on his part, called on the Nigerian Bar Association to develop ethical guidelines or a code of conduct for lawyers that would be involved in election-related litigations to ensure seamless resolution of disputes. The minister stated that the code of conduct and guidelines should promote professionalism, restraint and respect for judicial processes while discouraging conduct capable of undermining public confidence in electoral justice. President of the Court of Appeal, Justice Monica Dongbam- Mensem, has also disclosed that a total of 375 judges have been penned down to handle petitions that may likely

Says federal ownership will boost North-East exports, create jobs, attract investors The Kulen Allah Cattle Rearers Association of Nigeria (KACRAN) has described the federal government’s takeover of the Yobe International Cargo Airport as a strategic economic intervention capable of transforming the North-East into a major agricultural, livestock and commercial export hub. The association also urged Yobe State governor, Mai Mala Buni, to channel part of the billions of naira expected as reimbursement for the airport project into agriculture, commerce, water supply, rural infrastructure and other critical sectors. KACRAN National President, Hon. Khalil Bello, in a statement on Monday, commended President Bola

whelming evidence above, there are still journalists or even politicians who still, regrettably, doubt the mountain of evidence proving the President’s bona fides, then they should do what I did and physically go to Chicago State University or electronically contact them via the contact details in the attached document to hear directly from the horse’s mouth.”

Omokri also cautioned against relying on claims by political opponents, stating that such positions could be influenced by partisan interests. He maintained that the university’s records, the registrar’s testimony, the BBC investigation and the Supreme Court judgement collectively established that Tinubu attended and graduated from Chicago State University in 1979.

AMUPITAN: NIGERIA’S STABILITY IN HANDS OF POLL JUDGES, 375 OFFICERS SWORN IN FOR 2027

Group Applauds Tinubu over Yobe Cargo Airport Takeover, Urges Buni to Invest Refund in Agriculture Michael Olugbode in Abuja

ficiently addressed by the evidence already presented by the university and other independent sources. He challenged journalists, politicians, and other Nigerians still questioning Tinubu’s academic credentials to independently contact Chicago State University or visit the institution to verify the records. Omokri saod, “If, after the over-

Tinubu for approving the takeover and reimbursement of the investment made by the Yobe State Government, describing the decision as a masterstroke for national economic development. He also applauded members of the National Assembly for approving the promissory note for the reimbursement, expressing optimism that federal government ownership would accelerate the airport’s full operationalisation as an international cargo hub. Bello said the facility, when fully operational, would serve not only Yobe but the entire North-East, neighbouring countries and the wider business community by providing an efficient channel for transporting agricultural produce, livestock products

and manufactured goods to domestic and international markets. He credited former Yobe Governor and Minister of Police Affairs, Senator Ibrahim Gaidam, with initiating the airport project, while commending Buni for sustaining its construction despite the enormous financial demands. The KACRAN president described Buni’s decision to hand over the airport to the federal government as an act of patriotism and statesmanship, saying it reflected his commitment to regional and national economic development. According to him, the airport’s economic significance extends beyond aviation, as it could stimulate investment in agriculture, livestock processing, fisheries, mining and other commercial activities across the region.

arise from the conduct of the 2027 general elections. Dongban-Memsen noted that 138 of the judges were returning members with previous Tribunal experience, while the remaining 237 were newly nominated judges. Meanwhile, the Appeal Court president observed that the occasion highlighted the collective commitment to constitutional democracy, the rule of law and the integrity of Nigeria’s electoral process. According to her, the inauguration of the tribunal members is an important institutional preparation for one of the most consequential responsibilities entrusted to the judiciary. “The credibility of democracy depends not only on the conduct of elections but also on the existence of impartial, effective and timely mechanisms for resolving electoral disputes. “Through the fair determination of such disputes, the Judiciary safeguards the people’s mandate, upholds constitutional supremacy and sustains public confidence in democratic governance. “The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended), particularly Section 285(1) and (2), vests in the President of the Court of Appeal the responsibility of constituting Election Petition Tribunals for the adjudication of disputes arising from National and State Houses of Assembly and Governorship elections. “Similarly, Section 134(3)(a) and (b) of the Electoral Act, 2026, prescribes the timelines for constituting the Tribunals and opening their registries. “These provisions impose a clear obligation on the Court to ensure adequate institutional and administrative preparedness. “Your Lordships must appreciate the magnitude of the responsibility entrusted to you. Your nomination followed consultations with Heads of Courts and the Nigerian Bar Association, informed by considerations

of professional competence, integrity, judicial temperament and experience. “This confidence must be regarded as a solemn obligation. Your appointment is a call to service, not privilege; a commitment to uphold the law, not an opportunity for personal or political accommodation,” she said. She, therefore, urged the judges to remain steadfast in judicial independence, impartiality and fidelity to the Constitution. According to her, the judges must resist every attempt at improper influence, whether through political pressure, inducement, intimidation, personal relationships or other considerations extraneous to the administration of justice. “Your judicial oath must remain your guiding compass, and your decisions must be determined exclusively by the evidence, applicable law and judicial conscience. No individual, however highly placed, should be permitted to compromise the independence of your courts”, she added. In a related development, the Human Rights Writers Association of Nigeria (HURIWA), has warned INEC and the 375 judges, insisting that Nigerians would not accept a democracy in which politicians lose elections at the ballot box but purchase victories through questionable court judgments. HURIWA said the 2027 elections must produce winners determined by the votes of citizens, not by the financial war chests of desperate politicians, judicial manipulation or alleged backroom arrangements between litigants and compromised judicial officers. The association, in a statement, by its National coordinator, Emmanuel Onwubiko, declared that Nigeria could not continue to operate an electoral system in which the courts were perceived as the final destination for politicians seeking to overturn the choices of voters. It warned that the 2027

post-election season would be a defining moment for the Nigerian judiciary, adding that judges, who compromise their oath of office for financial inducements should expect unprecedented public scrutiny and accountability. Specifically reacting to the inauguration of 375 judges for election petition tribunals, HURIWA said the judicial officers must understand that they are being entrusted with the future of Nigeria’s democracy and not the political survival of powerful individuals. The association warned that any judge, who converted the courtroom into a marketplace for electoral victories would be betraying the Constitution and undermining the sovereignty of the Nigerian people. It said it had received disturbing concerns about alleged attempts by some politicians to influence election-related judicial proceedings through financial inducements. HURIWA, therefore, warned that the days when judicial corruption could be concealed behind complicated legal arguments and controversial judgments must come to an end.

INEC Removes 1.6m Invalid Registrations From Voters Register, Says Amupitan In another development, INEC, has removed 1,609,553 invalid registrations from the preliminary register of voters ahead of the publication of the final register on 15th December, 2026. Amupitan, SAN, announced this at a press conference yesterday in Abuja. He explained that following complaints, claims and objections raised by the public during the display of the register at ward level between 9th and 15th October, 2026 and its subsequent online publication, the invalid registrations were removed by the commission. Continued on page 29


27

THISDAY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

NEWS

COURTESY VISIT...

Nigerian Film Actress and Script Writer, Eniola Badmus (left) with Lagos State Commissioner for Tourism, Arts and Culture, Mrs. Toke Benson-Awoyinka, during a courtesy visit to the commissioner’s office, Alausa Secretariat... recently

ADC Demands Release of Lifu’s Judgement Chuks Okocha in Abuja The African Democratic Congress (ADC), has demanded the immediate release of Justice Peter Lifu’s judgment. The ADC said Justice Lifu had declared in open court that copies of the judgement were ready, but lamented that, ‘’Our counsel applied for the certified copy and paid the required fee, yet the judgment remains

out of reach.’’ In a statement, yesterday, the ADC Presidential Campaign Director of Strategic Communication, Phrank Shaibu, said the inability to make the certified true copies of the judgement available to party’s lawyers is indefensible. ‘’This is an indefensible denial of access to a ruling that directly affects the party and its members.

If the judgment was ready, there is no excuse for keeping it from the parties. Release it now. ‘’Our counsel for the first defendant filed a formal application for the certified true copy on 6 November 2026 and paid the assessed fee. Counsel for the third defendant applied the day before, on the very day the judgment was delivered. ‘’Both applications carry the

Federal High Court’s ‘PAID’ stamp. Every requirement was met. Yet the applicants are still being denied the judgment. ‘’This is not a routine administrative delay. It is a denial of access to a court decision that directly affects the rights of the parties. Justice Lifu declared the judgment is ready; the applicants paid for its certified copy; the court has acknowledged payment.

‘’Why, then, are they still being kept in the dark? A judge cannot announce that a judgment is ready and leave litigants to chase the document they need to understand and challenge it. ‘’Withholding its certified copy prevents the affected parties from knowing the exact orders made and responding fully through the courts. If the ruling is sound, there is no justification for keeping it out

of reach. ‘’The Federal High Court must release the judgment immediately and explain why paid applications have gone unanswered. Public confidence cannot survive a process in which consequential judgments are announced, but their official records are denied to the parties,’’ the ADC Director of Strategic Communication stated.

TINUBU EXPANDS CAMPAIGN TO MORE CITIES, STATES TO MATCH ATIKU, OBI, MAKINDE’S CAMPAIGNS That distinction is particularly important as the 2027 campaign gathers momentum. In Kaduna, Atiku defeated Tinubu by 554,360 votes to 399,293. In Katsina, the former vice president secured 489,045 votes against Tinubu’s 482,283, winning by only 6,762 votes. In Kebbi, Atiku polled 285,175 votes against Tinubu’s 248,088, while Sokoto produced one of the closest contests, with Atiku receiving 288,679 votes against Tinubu’s 285,444. The outcome in Sokoto was decided by only 3,235 votes. Tinubu’s victories were recorded in Jigawa, where he obtained 421,390 votes against Atiku’s 386,587, and Zamfara, where he polled 298,396 against Atiku’s 193,978. In Kano, Kwankwaso emerged as the dominant political force with 997,279 votes, while Tinubu secured 517,341 and Atiku finished with 131,716. These figures demonstrate just how vulnerable the North-west could become to relatively modest changes in voter preferences. A swing of fewer than 7,000 votes could have altered the outcome in Katsina in 2023, while approximately 3,300 additional votes for Tinubu could have changed the result in Sokoto. For Atiku, such narrow margins offer opportunity for consolidating existing support. But for Tinubu, they represent both the possibility of recovering lost territory and the danger of conceding further ground.

Atiku’s Growing Visibility and the Sokoto Signal Atiku’s decision to open his campaign in Sokoto was politically significant. Apart from being one of the states he won in 2023, Sokoto occupies an important position in the North-west’s religious, traditional and political hierarchy. His November 4 campaign attracted a large gathering of supporters, prompting ADC Presidential Campaign Council to describe the reception as an expression of dissatisfaction with the Tinubu administration. According to the opposition party,

Atiku’s motorcade spent several hours moving through the city as residents lined major roads to welcome him. The party subsequently framed the event around its affordability message, presenting Atiku as an alternative to the economic difficulties experienced under the current administration. The significance of this development lies less in the crowd itself than in the political message accompanying it. Atiku is attempting to shift the contest away from party affiliations and elite endorsements towards the everyday experiences of ordinary voters. For many northern households, the central questions concern the prices of food, transportation, agricultural inputs, electricity and other essential goods. The opposition is also seeking to exploit public frustration over insecurity, particularly in communities affected by banditry, kidnapping and disruptions to farming activities. These concerns are not imaginary. Food and Agriculture Organisation reported in September that conflict was severely disrupting agricultural activities in several Nigerian states, including Kaduna, Katsina, Sokoto and Zamfara. Its assessment also highlighted the continuing effect of high food prices and insecurity on livelihoods. This creates a potentially receptive environment for opposition candidates promising a different economic and security approach. Nevertheless, Atiku’s apparent momentum should not be overstated. A large rally does not necessarily translate into an electoral majority, and no independently verified, comprehensive opinion poll establishes that he currently enjoys overwhelming support across the North-west. What can be established is that Atiku retains a substantial electoral base in the north, he is actively seeking to expand it, and he has found a campaign message that connects with widespread concerns about living costs. For Tinubu, that is sufficient reason to take the challenge seriously.

Seven APC Governors, But Where Are the Voters? The greatest political advantage available to Tinubu in the North-west is that all seven governors are now members of APC. This represents a major departure from the political configuration of 2023. The ruling party controls the governments of Kano, Kaduna, Katsina, Jigawa, Kebbi, Sokoto and Zamfara, giving it access to an extensive network of party structures and influential political officeholders. In January, Kano State Governor Abba Kabir Yusuf, defected from NNPP to APC, altering the political configuration of a state where Kwankwaso had exercised considerable influence. Zamfara Governor, Dauda Lawal, also moved into APC, strengthening the party’s formal control of the zone. At the presidential campaign flag-off in Kaduna on October 24, the APC leadership presented party flags to the seven North-west governors, underscoring the importance it attaches to consolidating its dominance in the region. On paper Tinubu possesses an electoral advantage that Atiku cannot easily replicate. The governors can provide organisational coordination, mobilise party structures, and engage political stakeholders across their respective states. But there is a difference between controlling a government and commanding the preferences of its electorate. The 2023 results demonstrated that voters do not always follow the political preferences of incumbent governors. That reality has acquired greater importance in an election, where public dissatisfaction may prove more influential than conventional political loyalty. The question is whether the seven governors can persuade voters, who are dissatisfied with national economic conditions, to support the continuation of the federal administration.

Tinubu’s possible decision to eventually visit every North-west state personally may reflect a recognition that the political structures of governors, however extensive, cannot entirely substitute for direct presidential engagement.

Kano: The Most Complicated Equation Kano remains the North-west’s most intriguing electoral battlefield. In 2023, Kwankwaso’s 997,279 votes made the state his principal political stronghold and demonstrated the strength of his personal political organisation. Tinubu finished second with 517,341 votes, while Atiku secured 131,716. The situation has since changed considerably. Yusuf’s defection to APC in January has given the ruling party control of the state government, but Kwankwaso remains an important opposition figure. Now running as Obi’s vice presidential candidate on the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC) ticket, Kwankwaso could complicate the contest between Tinubu and Atiku. If he retains a substantial proportion of his 2023 support, APC may find it difficult to achieve a decisive victory even with the governor’s backing. On the other hand, if Yusuf succeeds in transferring a significant part of NNPP’s former political structure to APC, Tinubu could improve considerably on his previous performance. Atiku faces his own challenge. Although he maintains longstanding political relationships in Kano, his 2023 tally was far below those of Kwankwaso and Tinubu. His task is not merely to benefit from dissatisfaction with the federal government, but to persuade voters, who previously supported other candidates, to consider him. Kano could consequently become a three-way contest in which the ultimate result depends on grassroots mobilisation, the durability of Kwankwaso’s political network, and the ability of APC to exploit its control of the state government.

Katsina, Sokoto and Kebbi: The Margins That Matter If Kano presents the largest numerical challenge, Katsina, Sokoto and Kebbi represent the states where relatively small shifts could have substantial political consequences. Katsina is particularly sensitive because of its association with former President Muhammadu Buhari and the historic influence of APC in the state. Despite that political heritage, Atiku defeated Tinubu there in 2023, although by a narrow margin. The president consequently has a reasonable opportunity to reverse the result if his campaign succeeds in consolidating the APC political organisation. Yet, continuing insecurity, rural poverty, and economic hardship mean that the ruling party cannot rely exclusively on traditional loyalties. Sokoto presents a similar dilemma. Atiku’s recent campaign reception, coming in a state he won by just 3,235 votes in 2023, has given ADC an opportunity to project growing momentum. Tinubu’s original campaign itinerary already includes Sokoto, but the emerging political competition could make further engagement necessary. Kebbi, where Atiku won by 37,087 votes, is another state in which APC could realistically seek to reverse its 2023 defeat. The combined picture suggests that those three states may become crucial to the North-qest contest, not necessarily because of enormous voting margins, but precisely because their margins were relatively small. A carefully organised campaign could change the outcome in any of them.

Zamfara, Kaduna and Jigawa: Different Challenges, Same Stakes Zamfara presents Tinubu with the challenge of retaining a substantial victory while addressing the insecurity that has continued to affect parts of the state. His 2023 advantage over Atiku was 104,418 votes, giving APC

a relatively strong position. However, the political environment has changed, and the presence of Governor Dauda Lawal within APC introduces a new dimension to the party’s internal relationships. The ruling party will need to reconcile its various political interests while demonstrating progress against the violence that has disrupted rural communities. In Kaduna, Tinubu confronts a more substantial electoral deficit. Atiku’s advantage of 155,067 votes in 2023 was reinforced by the significant support Obi received, particularly among sections of the electorate concerned about religious representation and security. Tinubu’s campaign began in Kaduna on October 24, demonstrating that the state is already considered a priority. Governor Uba Sani’s political network and reconciliation initiatives may strengthen APC’s position, but the president will still need to persuade voters that conditions have improved sufficiently to justify another mandate. Jigawa, meanwhile, offers a different calculation. Tinubu defeated Atiku there by 34,803 votes in 2023, giving APC a comparatively narrow advantage. Governor Umar Namadi’s political organisation could help consolidate that support, but the state cannot be regarded as beyond the reach of the opposition. Taken together, the three states illustrate why a uniform North-west campaign strategy may be inadequate. Each has distinct political interests, security challenges and electoral loyalties. North-east and Danger of Wider Northern Rejection Although the North-west has emerged as a particular concern, Tinubu’s challenge extends to the North-east, where Atiku enjoyed a considerable advantage in 2023. Across the six North-east states, Atiku secured 1,741,846 votes, compared with Tinubu’s 1,185,458. The former vice-president defeated Continued on page 28


28

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 • THISDAY

NEWS

STAKEHOLDERS MEETING...

L-R: All Progressives Congress (APC) Deputy Governorship Candidate for Ogun State, Mrs. Kudirat Abiodun Adegunwa-Balogun; the wife of All Progressives Congress (APC) Governorship Candidate for Ogun State, Chief Mrs. Temitope Adeola; All Progressives Congress (APC) Governorship Candidate for Ogun State, Senator Solomon Olamilekan Adeola (YAYI); the Deputy Governor of Ogun State, Engr. Mrs. Noimot Salako-Oyedele; and the Onimeko of Imeko, Oba Benjamin Oyeditan Alabi Olanite (Egi-Ogboye, Akanku IV), during the stakeholders meeting at Imeko-Afon Local Government Area, Ogun State, last Friday

FG Suspends Broadcast Licence Fee Reviews Indefinitely Olawale Ajimotokan in Abuja The federal government has suspended all reviews of broadcast licence fees until further notice, following concerns by operators over rising costs and the challenging business environment in Nigeria’s broadcasting industry. Minister of Information and National Orientation, Mohammed Idris, announced the suspension yesterday in Abuja when he received a delegation of the Broadcasting

Organisations of Nigeria (BON), led by its Chairman, Tony Akiotu. Idris directed the National Broadcasting Commission (NBC) to ensure strict compliance with the directive, stressing that no increase in broadcast licence fees would be allowed pending a review of the situation. “Any increase in licence fees is hereby put on hold. All reviews relating to licences are suspended until further notice. I am directing the NBC to ensure strict compliance while

we review the situation,” he said. The minister also directed the DirectorGeneral of the NBC to expedite the review of the National Broadcasting Code to ensure that the regulatory framework reflects emerging developments and realities in the broadcasting industry. On the Digital Switch-Over (DSO), Idris promised to convene a stakeholders’ meeting to address outstanding issues, while assuring BON that the federal government would engage

relevant stakeholders on concerns relating to affordable financing and spectrum allocation. He also disclosed that he had directed the Advertising Regulatory Council of Nigeria (ARCON) to ensure the full implementation of the 45-day payment period for advertising services, a policy BON had urged the government to enforce. The minister reaffirmed the government’s commitment to creating an enabling environment for the broadcasting industry, noting that

the sector plays a critical role in strengthening democracy, promoting national cohesion and ensuring access to credible information. With the 2027 general election approaching, Idris urged broadcasters to uphold professionalism, fairness and ethical standards in their coverage, stressing that freedom of expression must be exercised responsibly. “Freedom of expression must go with responsibility. You cannot simply say anything and claim to be practising journalism. Journal-

ism has standards, procedures and ethics. I urge broadcasters to ensure that what they report is factual, responsible and promotes national unity and peaceful coexistence,” he said. Earlier, Akiotu commended the minister for his intervention during the June 2026 DSO launch, saying the stakeholders’ meeting convened by Idris helped address concerns about ensuring a level playing field for operators.

TINUBU EXPANDS CAMPAIGN TO MORE CITIES, STATES TO MATCH ATIKU, OBI, MAKINDE’S CAMPAIGNS Tinubu by approximately 556,388 votes in the zone. Atiku won Adamawa, Bauchi, Gombe, Taraba and Yobe, while Tinubu prevailed only in Borno, Shettima’s political base. For APC, the political realignments that have brought additional governors into its fold offer an opportunity to reduce that deficit. But the fundamental electoral challenge remains. Atiku is from Adamawa and retains longstanding political relationships across the zone. His candidacy consequently poses a threat that cannot be neutralised merely by controlling additional state governments. Tinubu’s original campaign schedule recognises this reality by including Adamawa, Bauchi and Borno among his planned personal appearances. Nevertheless, a deterioration in the APC position in the North-west, combined with continued Atiku strength in the North-east, could create a difficult national electoral equation for the ruling party.

Can Tinubu Afford to Lose Northern Votes? The numbers offer a useful illustration. Tinubu defeated Atiku nationwide by 1,810,206 votes in 2023. In the North-west alone, Tinubu received 2,652,235 votes. If just 10 per cent of those North-west votes were to switch directly from Tinubu to Atiku in 2027, with every other voting pattern unchanged, the two candidates’ national margin would change by approximately 530,447 votes. Such a shift would be sufficient to overturn Tinubu’s 2023 aggregate advantage over Atiku in the NorthWest. This is only an arithmetical illustration, not an election forecast. Actual voting in 2027 will involve other candidates, changes in turnout and potentially different alignments. Nevertheless, the exercise demonstrates why APC cannot dismiss even relatively modest changes in northern voter preferences. The president does

not necessarily need to repeat his exact 2023 performance in every state to win re-election. But he must retain enough of the coalition that brought him to power while compensating for any losses with additional support elsewhere. That could prove difficult if dissatisfaction spreads simultaneously across several northern states. The problem is compounded by the fact that APC’s opponents are not competing for precisely the same electorate. Atiku’s ADC is seeking to consolidate a largely northern political base while expanding into other regions. Obi’s NDC ticket with Kwankwaso could retain significant support in the Middle Belt and Kano, alongside its southern constituencies. Other candidates may also affect the distribution of votes in particular states. The president must therefore manage several electoral threats at once rather than concentrate exclusively on Atiku.

Economic Reforms Versus Everyday Realities A central difficulty facing Tinubu is the gap between improvements in some macroeconomic indicators and the living conditions experienced by ordinary Nigerians. The administration has defended its removal of fuel subsidies, foreign exchange reforms, and other policy changes as necessary measures to stabilise the economy and restore long-term growth. The International Monetary Fund acknowledged in its June 2026 assessment that the reforms had improved economic resilience and supported stronger macroeconomic outcomes. However, IMF also warned that living conditions remained difficult, estimating that poverty has reached 63 per cent under the national poverty line. The World Bank similarly reported improvements in economic stability while emphasising the persistence of

widespread poverty and the need for growth that translates into better employment and living standards. For many voters in northern Nigeria, the political relevance of these assessments is immediate. A farmer, who cannot cultivate his land because of insecurity may be less persuaded by improved foreign reserves than by the prospect of returning safely to his farm. A trader facing higher transport costs may judge economic policy by the impact on business rather than by improvements in fiscal balances. A household struggling with food prices may be unwilling to accept that macroeconomic progress automatically represents improved welfare. The APC campaign must find a way to explain the benefits of its reforms without dismissing the difficulties experienced by the electorate. Atiku, conversely, must demonstrate that his alternative economic programme offers a credible route to improving living conditions rather than simply expressing dissatisfaction with existing policies. This contest between economic arguments and lived experience may be more influential than the number of governors or political endorsements available to either candidate.

Why Tinubu’s Original 12-State Strategy May No Longer Be Sufficient APC’s original campaign timetable provided for Tinubu to personally attend rallies in Kaduna, Rivers, Plateau, Oyo, Borno, Enugu, Bauchi, Sokoto, Delta, Kano, Adamawa and Lagos. The selection was clearly strategic. It included several states where Tinubu lost in 2023, alongside others considered important to maintaining existing support. The broader party programme covered all 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory, with governors and campaign officials assigned responsibility for rallies the president would not attend personally.

The arrangement appeared designed to allow Tinubu to concentrate on presidential responsibilities while participating directly in selected high-priority political engagements. However, the changing campaign environment presents a different challenge. A presidential election is not determined solely by the visibility of political structures. The personal presence of a candidate can influence campaign enthusiasm, attract undecided supporters and demonstrate the importance attached to particular communities. The argument for expanding Tinubu’s North-west campaign rests on the political value of direct engagement. Rather than restricting himself to Kaduna, Sokoto and Kano, the president could consider additional appearances in Katsina, Kebbi, Jigawa and Zamfara. Such a decision would give him the opportunity to address security concerns, engage local political leaders, defend his economic policies, and appeal directly to voters in all seven states. The possibility of extending the campaign to all 36 states would represent a more ambitious undertaking. Yet with only a limited period remaining before the election, such a plan would require significant scheduling adjustments and greater delegation of official responsibilities. For now, the original itinerary remains the publicly established programme. The possibility of further expansion should be understood as an emerging political calculation rather than an officially announced revision.

longstanding relationships in the region, his familiarity with northern political structures, and his ability to campaign on the cost of living provide identifiable advantages. Yet, he faces considerable obstacles. APC controls all seven North-west governorships and has attracted several prominent politicians from opposition parties. Atiku must also contend with Kwankwaso’s influence in Kano and the wider challenge posed by the Obi-Kwankwaso ticket. A divided opposition could enable Tinubu to secure victories with pluralities substantially below an outright majority of votes cast. There is also the question of whether Atiku can improve his performance outside the north. In 2023, Tinubu benefited from a broad coalition that combined northern support with substantial votes in the South-west and other parts of the country. Atiku cannot assume that a stronger northern showing alone would be sufficient to overturn the national result. He would need to prevent further losses in the south while expanding his electoral reach in the North-central and other competitive areas. For Tinubu, the equivalent challenge is to preserve enough of his northern coalition while improving his performance in states he lost. The real contest is not simply between a northern candidate and a southern incumbent, but between competing national coalitions with different strengths and vulnerabilities.

The Opposition’s Opportunity, and Its Own Difficulties

The greatest danger for APC would be to assume that the political conditions that produced Tinubu’s 2023 victory remain substantially unchanged. They do not. The president now has the advantage of incumbency, wider political alliances, and the support of governors who were previously

Atiku’s growing visibility in northern Nigeria has given ADC an opportunity to present itself as the principal alternative to the incumbent administration. The former vice president’s

2027: Different Election, Different Reality

outside the ruling party. But he also carries the political consequences of three years of economic reforms, persistent insecurity, and public expectations that have not always been met. Atiku has the advantage of campaigning against the government’s record, but must overcome the organisational superiority of APC and the fragmentation of the opposition vote. The North-west sits at the intersection of these competing realities. Its voters helped deliver the presidency to Tinubu in 2023, but the same region provided Atiku with victories in four states. Its governors now belong to APC, but their political affiliations cannot determine how citizens will vote. Its communities have experienced the pressures of economic hardship and insecurity, yet their political responses will not necessarily be uniform. The emerging lesson, for Tinubu, is that retaining the north may require more than the endorsements of influential politicians and the mobilisation of state governors. It may require sustained personal engagement, convincing explanations of policy choices, and credible evidence that the government understands the difficulties facing ordinary citizens. Whether that leads to visits to all seven North-west states or a much broader tour of the federation remains to be seen. What is increasingly evident is that the original 12-state calculation cannot be treated as politically untouchable. Tinubu’s 2023 electoral coalition was built substantially on northern votes. The central challenge of 2027 is whether he can persuade enough of those voters to renew their confidence in his leadership. To that extent, if the political atmosphere in the region becomes sufficiently competitive, the president may discover that the journey back to Aso Rock requires considerably more stops than he originally planned.


29

THISDAY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

NEWS

PRESENTATION OF PARTICIPATION CERTIFICATE...

L-R: Deputy Director, Administration and Human Resources, Project Implementation and Monitoring Unit, Lagos State Office of Chief of Staff, Mrs. Olasumbo Akano; Permanent Secretary, Lagos State Ministry of Tourism, Arts & Culture; Mrs. Bopo Oyekan- Ismaila; Executive Assistant to Lagos State Governor on Project Implementation and Monitoring, Mr. Olusegun Sanwo-Olu; Technical Assistant to the Head, Project Implementation and Monitoring, Lagos State Office of Chief of Staff, Mrs. Oluwabusolami Ayodeji, during the presentation of participation certificate to the Permanent Secretary in her office... recently

Shettima: Tinubu’s Security, Infrastructure Boom Igniting South-East Economy Canvasses renewed mandate for president We won’t vote for sentiment, say Uzodimma, Umahi, Nwifuru Deji Elumoye, Adedayo Akinwale in Abuja and Onuminya Innocent in Sokoto Vice-President Kashim Shettima has declared that the President Bola Tinubu-led government was engineering a seismic economic and security shift in the SouthEast through aggressive capital injections into transport, green energy, agriculture, housing and human capital development. According to him, the intervention of the government at the centre in Ebonyi State and the wider South-East were designed to improve regional connectivity, strengthen food security, expand economic opportunities and address longstanding development challenges that have constrained the region’s economic potential. Speaking during the All Progressives Congress (APC) presidential campaign rally in Abakaliki, Ebonyi State capital, Shettima said the Tinubu administration had demonstrated its commitment to the state through major infrastructure projects, federal appointments and policies aimed at improving the welfare of citizens. “This campaign has been a season

of triumph. We have triumphed over the falsehoods of our opponents. We have triumphed over those who mistook the limits of their imagination for the limits of our reach. “We have never turned our backs on you. We have answered your support with projects and President Bola Tinubu has honoured Ebonyi through distinguished appointments and projects across the state,” he said. He maintained that the administration’s development programmes reflected its determination to honour the confidence reposed in it by Nigerians, stressing that public office imposed an obligation to deliver measurable improvements in people’s lives. “If any state can speak with confidence about the dividends of democracy, it is Ebonyi. You have stood by us. You have assured us that a mandate is a debt of honour, repayable only through service. “Yet democracy demands the humility of asking again. We have returned to seek the renewal of your mandate, to serve you, to defend you, and to stand by you,” he said. Highlighting ongoing infrastructure investments, Shettima

identified the Calabar–Ebonyi– Benue–Kogi–Nasarawa–Abuja Superhighway, which formed part of the administration’s Trans-Saharan highway vision, as a major project intended to strengthen trade and economic integration between the South-East, North-Central and other parts of the country. He also listed the Ndibe Bridge, designed to improve connectivity between Ebonyi and Cross River states, as well as ongoing work on the Enugu–Abakaliki–Ogoja Expressway and the Okposi–Ohaozara–Ukawu–Cross River road. “Where shall we begin the account of our work? Shall we begin with the Calabar–Ebonyi– Benue–Kogi–Nasarawa–Abuja Superhighway, part of our TransSaharan highway vision? “Or with the Ndibe Bridge, which will link Ebonyi with Cross River? We are advancing work on the Enugu–Abakaliki–Ogoja Expressway and the Okposi–Ohaozara–Ukawu– Cross River road. Again, I ask: where shall we begin?” he stated. He explained that the road projects would improve the movement of agricultural produce, manufactured goods and other commodities while reducing the

logistical barriers facing businesses and communities across the region. On agriculture, Shettima described Ebonyi as an important contributor to Nigeria’s food security, particularly through rice and cassava production, noting that the administration is supporting farmers with fertiliser distribution, interest-free FarmerMoni assistance and other agricultural development programmes. He said investments in rural roads were equally important to agricultural productivity, as improved access to markets would help farmers reduce losses, increase earnings and expand production. The vice-president further disclosed that thousands of beneficiaries in Ebonyi State had received grants under the Presidential Conditional Grant Scheme, while federal employment and digital skills initiatives were creating opportunities for young people to acquire relevant skills and establish sustainable livelihoods. On security, Shettima said President Tinubu’s government had intensified efforts to restore stability across the South-East, stressing that lasting economic development depended on the

safety of communities, businesses and critical infrastructure. He identified the establishment and commencement of operations at the Nigerian Army Recruits Training Depot at Amasiri–Edda in Ebonyi State as one of the Federal Government’s security interventions in the region. “The security of the South-East has changed since President Bola Ahmed Tinubu became Commander-in-Chief over three years ago. We have worked to restore order, and we will keep working,” Shettima assured. Shettima also noted the establishment of the South East Development Commission, the launch of the South-East Vision 2050 and the approval of the South East Investment Company as major institutional initiatives intended to accelerate regional development, attract investment and create sustainable economic opportunities. According to him, these interventions recognise the relationship between security, economic inclusion and long-term stability, adding that the Federal Government remains committed to addressing the structural challenges affecting the South-East.

Shettima said the administration had returned to Ebonyi to give an account of its work and to seek the renewal of its mandate to serve, defend and stand by the people. Shettima also announced that funding had been set aside for renewable energy projects in eight locations across Ebonyi State to power homes and businesses. Shettima stated: “We have returned to seek the renewal of your mandate: to serve you, to defend you and to stand by you. “We have set aside funding for renewable energy projects in eight locations across the state. These investments are intended to power homes and businesses. “Construction has begun on the renovation of housing estates to give more families decent places to live. “We know what education means to you. Through NELFUND and TETFund, we are supporting students and educational institutions.” The vice-president further noted that thousands of people in the state had benefited from grants under the Presidential Conditional Grants Scheme, while employment and digital skills programmes were helping young people acquire skills and build livelihoods.

AMUPITAN: NIGERIA’S STABILITY IN HANDS OF POLL JUDGES, 375 OFFICERS SWORN IN FOR 2027 He revealed that 1,608,660 confirmed invalid registrations removed were from the 2025/2026 Continuous Voter Registration (CVR), while 873 verified deceased voters were removed as a separate category. Amupitan explained that INEC harvested 11,088,238 records from the three phases of the 2025/2026 CVR, while the Automated Biometric Identification System (ABIS) initially flagged 1,545,052 for examination. He stressed that before the preliminary register was published, 1,277,052 had already been confirmed invalid and excluded. Amupitan noted that after display, a further 268,000 cases went through adjudication — 217,722 were confirmed invalid and removed,

while 50,278 were cleared as valid and retained. He disclosed that additional screening later identified 113,886 more invalid registrations, which were also removed. The chairman added: “The cumulative total of confirmed invalid registrations removed after the objections, claims and complaints is 331,608, in addition to the 873 separately verified deceased voters’ records. This brings the total clean-up to 1,608,660. “The Commission confirms that the current register-cleaning exercise for the 2025/2026 Continuous Voters Registration (CVR) has been concluded. “All 1,608,660 confirmed invalid registrations have been removed. In addition, 873 records belonging

to verified deceased persons have also been removed as a separate category. “The combined total of records removed under these two categories is 1,609,553. Final reconciliation, quality assurance and publication checks remain to ensure that approved changes are accurately reflected in the final register, scheduled for publication on 15 December 2026.” Giving an insight on how the irregularities happened, the Commission said its technical assessment found instances where some registration personnel deliberately circumvented procedures and misused provisions meant for exceptional cases, including for persons with disabilities. Amupitan pointed out that 54 persons across 10 states have been

identified as complicit during the CVR exercise, saying disciplinary action would be taken against them, including possible prosecution. The Chairman admitted that cleaning only the 2025/2026 CVR would not solve the problem, saying most of the duplications, strange pictures and unusual names circulated on social media came from the 2011-2023 historical register. He said the Commission has also decided to remove already flagged duplications and obvious cases in the old register after proper verification. The chairman further clarified that most complaints about omitted names came from voters who registered between 2011-2023, moved to a new location and re-registered instead of transferring.

He said their second registration was voided by ABIS, but their names remained in their previous location, advising those that fell into that category to check their previous locations. Amupitan recalled that in February 2026, INEC had announced a nationwide voter revalidation exercise to update biometrics and resolve inconsistencies. The exercise, he added, was deferred till after the 2027 general election following stakeholder concerns about its proximity to the elections, saying the deferment did not suspend biometric screening, adjudication and other verification procedures. The chairman revealed that distribution of Phases 1 and 2 PVCs and transferred PVCs are ongoing

at LGAs, while PVCs for Phase 3 are being delivered and would be dispatched to states by next week. He said from 1st December, 2026, distribution would return to Registration Areas nationwide. The commission, however, appealed for patience from Phase 3 registrants, saying production was done outside the country. The Chairman assured Nigerians that BVAS would prevent multiple voting, adding that every voter must be physically present at their designated Polling Unit and undergo biometric authentication using fingerprint or facial recognition. He said the Commission remained committed both to removing confirmed invalid entries and to protecting eligible Nigerians from wrongful exclusion,” Amupitan said.


30

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 • THISDAY

TUESDAYSPORTS

Group Sports Editor: Duro Ikhazuagbe Email: duro.ikhazuagbe@thisdaylive.com

0811 181 3083 SMS ONLY

Ag. General Secretary of the Nigeria Football Federation (NFF), Dr Emmanuel Ikpeme and the Federation’s Management members with the team at their hotel on Monday afternoon....in Abuja

NFF, Musawa, Oborevwori, Others Hail World Champions Flamingos As heroines return to Abuja early hours of Monday with U17 World Cup trophy Monimichele Hails Flamingos,

Olawale Ajimotokan in Abuja and Sylvester Idowu in Warri

Nigeria’s cadet women’s team, Flamingos, returned to Abuja early hours of Monday from Rabat, Morocco where they won this year’s FIFA U17 Women’s World Cup after a pulsating final with Japan. Speaking at the team’s hotel in Abuja yesterday, Nigeria Football Federation’s Acting General Secretary, Dr Emmanuel Ikpeme, MON, described the feat of the Flamingos as magnificent, as a joyous nation continues to celebrate the triumph of the young ladies in the Kingdom of Morocco. Dr Ikpeme restated the appreciation of the NFF and the entire Nigeria football family for the hard work, discipline and dedication of the young players in ensuring that they triumph in the tournament. He fed the team with words of encouragement and motivation, assuring them of the Federal Government and the good people of Nigeria’s appreciation for how they had improved the country’s position on the world football map. The Ag. General Secretary reiterated that not only is Nigeria the first African country to win the FIFA U17 Women’s World Cup, Nigeria is also the first African country to win male and female titles of the FIFA U17 World Cup.

“There is no way the history of the FIFA U17 Women’s World Cup will be written without your names. The Federal Government is happy and the generality of Nigerians are happy about this accomplishment. Our prayer is that as a collective and as individuals, you will continue to improve your game to get even better and take your game to the next level.” Ikpeme disclosed how FIFA President Gianni Infantino and the President of CAF, Dr Patrice Motsepe commended the Flamingos and spoke so highly of the team. Present during the visit were the NFF’s Acting Deputy General Secretary, Dr Ademola Olajire; Director of Legal Services, Okey Obi, Esq; Director of Competitions, Ms Ruth David; Director of Finance and Administration, Mr Rajan Zaka; Director of Planning, Research and Statistics, Mr. Dayo Enebi Achor and; Head of Women’s Football, Hajiya Amina Daura. Also yesterday, the Minister of Art, Culture, Tourism and the Creative Economy, Hannatu Musa Musawa, congratulated the Flamingos following their historic victory at the 2026 FIFA U-17 Women’s World Cup in Morocco. In a congratulatory statement issued by her Special Adviser on Media and Publicity, Nneka Ikem Anibeze, the minister described the triumph as a defining moment for Nigerian

sports and a significant milestone for African women’s football. Musawa said the victory demonstrated the resilience, talent and determination of young Nigerian women, noting that the team had inspired the country and the continent with their remarkable journey to the title. “This is more than a trophy. It is a story of young Nigerian girls who refused to give up, who rose after defeat, and who carried the hopes of a continent to the top of the world,” she said. Musawa particularly commended Oluebube Umejiaku who emerged winner of the tournament’s Golden Ball award as the best player, as well as Awawu Bashiru for their crucial contributions in the final. She also praised the entire squad for their teamwork, discipline and collective determination, which she said were instrumental to the country’s historic achievement. The minister reaffirmed the commitment of her ministry to celebrating, protecting and promoting the stories of young Nigerians whose achievements inspire national pride and project the country’s positive image globally. “Our girls have shown the world what Nigeria is made of. We celebrate you today, and we will continue to stand with you,” she said. In his reaction, Delta State Governor, Rt. Hon. Sheriff Oborevwori, also

congratulated the Flamingos on their historic victory at the 2026 FIFA U-17 Women’s World Cup in Morocco, describing the feat as a moment of immense national pride. In a congratulatory statement issued yesterday by his Chief Press Secretary, Sir Festus Ahon, Governor Oborevwori described the triumph as a remarkable achievement that had brought honour to Nigeria and the African continent. He praised the players for their determination, discipline, resilience and fighting spirit, noting that their performance demonstrated the growing strength of women’s football and the abundance of sporting talents in Nigeria. The Governor particularly celebrated Onyinyechi Opara of Delta Queens FC, who was part of the victorious squad, describing her contribution as another source of pride for Delta State. He noted that Opara had reinforced Delta’s reputation as a leading contributor to sports development in Nigeria, following in the footsteps of other outstanding athletes who had represented the state and country with distinction. Oborevwori said her achievement demonstrated the capacity of young Deltans to excel on the international stage when provided with the necessary opportunities, encouragement and support.

Praise Ugoh WinsYouth Olympic 400m Gold for Nigeria Nigeria’s remarkable run of success at the Dakar 2026 Youth Olympic Games continued on Monday as Praise Ugoh became the first Nigerian to win a 400m title at the competition, adding another gold medal to the country’s historic sprint double secured by Rosemary Chigozie Nwankwo and Gift Bright earlier on Sunday. Ugoh produced a superb performance in the women’s 400m final, clocking a personal best of 52.76 seconds to claim gold in a closely contested race. She finished ahead of Venezuela’s Osmary Pacheco, who took silver in 52.85 seconds, while Aisha Muhammed of the United Arab Emirates settled for bronze in 53.06 seconds. The victory marks a major milestone for Nigerian athletics with Ugoh becoming the first Nigerian to win the 400m title at the Youth

Olympic Games. Her personal best performance also underlines the progress of the young athlete, who delivered when it mattered most to secure her place in the competition’s history. Her triumph follows Nigeria’s outstanding achievement in the 100m events on Sunday, when Rosemary Nwankwo and Gift Bright swept both sprint gold medals to complete a historic Nigerian double. Nwankwo stormed to victory in the women’s 100m in 11.16 seconds while Bright made history in the men’s event, becoming the first Nigerian to win the Youth Olympic Games 100m title. Nigeria’s sweep of the men’s and women’s 100m titles marked the first time the country had won both sprint crowns at the same edition of the Youth Olympic Games.

Praise Tejiri Ugoh ..won Team Nigeria’s third gold medal at the ongoing 2026 Youth Olympic Games in Dakar, Senegal...on Monday

Attributes Victory to Good Preparations on Quality Turf

Nigeria’s Flamingos victory at the just concluded FIFA Under-17 Women’s World Cup in Rabat, Morocco, has been attributed to proper preparations under very conducive atmosphere and facilities. The Flamingos defeated Japan 2-1 in Saturday’s final at the Mohammed VI Football Complex in Rabat to emerge champions, becoming the first African nation to win the women’s U-17 global tournament. Nigeria took the lead through Awawu Bashiru in the 39th minute, while Oluebube Umejiaku doubled the advantage two minutes into the second half. Japan’s Fuki Ito reduced the deficit in the 80th minute, but the Nigerian side held on to secure a landmark victory first time victory for Africa. Speaking yesterday on Flamingos victory, Nigeria’s stadium facility expert, Ebi Egbe, attributed the team’s success to the result of training on quality turf under a good manager. Egbe who is the Chief Executive Officer of Monimichelle Sports Facility

Limited, the company that constructed the Remo Stadium turf in Ikenne where Flamingos honed their skills before leaving for the tournament in Morocco, Insisted that the facility played a major role in the success of the team. “The Flamingos’ example illustrates the importance of proper preparation ahead of major competitions. “The team spent several months training at the Remo Stars Stadium facility in Ikenne before travelling to Morocco for the youth championship. “The point is that consistent training on a quality, well-maintained playing surface helps young players adapt, improve their technical abilities, build confidence and prepare better for competitive football,” observed Egbe one of the country’s best known groundsman. The Monimichelle Boss restated his long held opinion that Nigeria teams will become better in continental and global competitions if they training longer on quality playing surfaces like the Flamingos have done.

Bendel Insurance Petitions NPFL over Matchday 9 Clash with Rangers Felix Omoh-Asun in Benin City Bendel Insurance Football Club of Benin has petitioned the Nigeria Football Federation (NFF), demanding the cancellation of its 1-0 defeat to Rangers International FC in their rescheduled Nigeria Premier Football League (NPFL) Matchday 9 midweek encounter played at the Awka City Stadium on November 4, 2026. The club accused league managers of double standards, insisting displaced goalframe invalidated Rangers’ winning goal. The petition, signed by the club’s Chairman, Comrade Jarrett Tenebe, followed an earlier protest to the NPFL over a controversial goal scored by Rangers after the goalframe defended by Bendel Insurance was visibly displaced during an attacking move. Tenebe is also threatening to withdraw Bendel Insurance from the league, going by the repeated unfair officiating of matches involving the team over some time and especially

if the false goal awarded to Rangers is allowed to stand In a significant development, the NPFL has acknowledged the grievance raised by Bendel Insurance, admitting that its review of the match footage brought it to terms with the club’s complaint. However, the league declined to overturn the result, citing its inability under existing regulations to annul the outcome of a concluded match. In its November 6, 2026 letter addressed to the Chairman of Bendel Insurance, the NPFL Chief Operating Officer, Dr Ayo Abdulrahaman, said the league had reviewed the video evidence submitted by the club and decided to refer the referee to the NFF Referees Appointment Committee for further examination of the decision. The NPFL explained that its position was informed by the existing rules governing concluded matches and what it described as football’s longstanding tradition of not overturning decisions made by referees on the field of play.


T H I S D AY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

31

BACK PAGE CONTINUATION 2027 AND THE LEADERSHIP QUESTION put-downs in the political arena today. In the lead up to the 2023 election, he had advised former Vice President Yemi Osinbajo to consider selling popcorn and ice cream because “nice men do not make good leaders.” He has overreached his own accomplishments in political rhetoric this time around and his main target is Peter Obi, the NDC Presidential candidate. Obi may be modest and less contrarian but he is backed by an army of irreverent, abusive foot-soldiers on social media and in the streets who make it impossible for even those who respect him to overlook his shortcomings. He receives much collateral damage as a result. At the inauguration of the APC Presidential campaign Council in Abuja in October, VP Shettima dismissed Peter Obi, “my very good friend” as “a master of bogus statistics and incoherent economic prescriptions”. He further said: “He seems convinced that a size 36 shirt tailored for Bangladesh will somehow fit Nigeria’s size 52 frame.” And that for claiming he won the 2023 Presidential election without evidence, “this is called delusion of grandeur.” Three days ago, at the APC Rally in Akwa Ibom, VP Shettima accused Peter Obi of squandering away his “political goodwill” with falsehoods and statistics.” In Port Harcourt

Vice President Kashim Shettima on Saturday, November 7, Shettima dismissed Obi again as “having philosophised himself into political irrelevance”, with Obi’s reputation as Governor of

Anambra State or Chairman of a Bank for being “at best mediocre.” The Vice President also didn’t leave out the flagbearer of the ADC, Atiku Abubakar whom he previously referred to as a “sanitary inspector”,, “Dubagari”, also a Kachalla and now, he says Atiku is “intellectually malnourished,”, receiving poor economic advice from “voodoo economists.” He had previously called Atiku a serial presidential election loser, comparing him to Kenyan politician, the late Raila Odinga. Shettima has also reminded Atiku Abubakar that the Presidency of Nigeria is not “a retirement benefit!” The curious thing is that President Tinubu himself seems to have joined this strategy of insults to overwhelm the opposition. In his campaign rallies in Uyo and Port Harcourt, the President descended into the arena as he dismissed both Atiku Abubakar and Peter Obi in very uncomplimentary terms. He more or less called Atiku a thief. He dismissed Obi as incompetent. And he concluded by saying both men do not have enough ability to lead Nigeria. “They lack the leadership, character and traits.” He quipped, referring to Obi: “He ran away from erosion in Anambra, and he now wants to be President? President of where?” Nigerians tend

to remember the tirades of the season trying to figure out which is more entertaining or more memorable. But this campaign should not be all about rhetoric. In the face of the expletives and strong personal exchanges, the key issues about the future of Nigeria and how best to move the country forward are swept under the carpet. An election campaign should not be a circus. It should be an opportunity for reasoned engagement which empower the people to make an informed choice in a credible and fair process. Nigerian politicians should learn from the recent American midterm elections. President Trump was very good at abusing his party’s opponents or those he disliked -in Ohio, Michigan, Minnesota, California, Georgia. When it came to the vote, Americans voted on the issues and gave control of Congress to the Democrats, including Rep Ilhan Omar who won in Minnesota’s 5th Congressional District and Abdul el-Sayed, the Senator-elect from Michigan. Nigeria’s 2027 election process raises many questions of leadership, the quality and non-quality. Nigerians should not get carried away with the drama of politics, because when the drama is over, what remains will be the realities of our lives.

NDIC Decries Over-valuation of Failed Banks’ Assets Moves to tighten recovery, disposal procedures, eliminate delay in depositors’ repayment Seeks transparency, stronger collaboration with valuers, auctioneers, estate surveyors

James Emejo in Abuja The Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation (NDIC), yesterday identified inflated valuations of assets belonging to failed banks, alongside unethical disposal practices and possible collusion among service providers, as major obstacles to the recovery of funds for uninsured depositors. The corporation said unrealistic valuations were making it difficult to attract buyers and convert properties and other assets into cash, thereby prolonging the liquidation process and delaying the settlement of outstanding claims. Director, Asset Management Department, NDIC, Mr. Ogungbemi Theophilus, disclosed this at a stakeholders’ seminar and public relations workshop organised by the department. Theophilus said NDIC was seeking stronger collaboration with estate surveyors, valuers, auctioneers and sales agents to address operational weaknesses undermining the recovery of assets from failed financial institutions. According to him, one of the major challenges confronting the NDIC is the tendency by some professionals to place valuations on failed banks’ properties above their actual market worth, making such assets difficult to dispose of when exposed to market realities. He said the corporation was also concerned about undervaluation and possible collusion in the disposal process, where some stakeholders might seek to manipulate transactions for personal benefit. He said, “The environment is dynamic. We need to be on the same page as to what we intend to achieve with asset realisation. A major challenge that we have is overvaluation of failed bank assets.” Theophilus explained that when valuations were excessively high, prospective buyers were discouraged, making asset recovery more difficult. He added that although undervaluation might be less prevalent, the possibility of collusion among those engaged to facilitate asset sales remained a concern. The NDIC director said the engagement was designed to improve coordination with professionals responsible for identifying, valuing, marketing, and disposing

assets belonging to closed banks. He stressed that the ultimate objective was to accelerate recoveries and ensure that depositors whose balances exceeded the insured limits could receive their outstanding funds. The corporation, he explained, paid insured deposits without waiting for the recovery of assets from failed banks. However, balances above the applicable insurance limits can only be settled through liquidation dividends generated from loan recoveries and the sale of assets. Under the current deposit insurance framework, depositors of deposit money banks, non-interest banks,

and mobile money operators enjoy coverage of up to N5 million per depositor per bank, while those of microfinance banks, primary mortgage banks and payment service banks are covered up to N2 million. Theophilus said about 99 per cent of depositors were fully covered under the existing limits, but the remaining uninsured balances depended substantially on the corporation’s ability to recover assets and outstanding loans. He described the Asset Management Department as responsible for managing the asset side of failed banks’ balance sheets, while the Deposit Insurance and Claims Department handled verification

and payment of depositors. The department oversees three broad categories of assets: risk assets comprising loans and advances granted by failed institutions; physical assets, including land, buildings, vehicles, machinery and office equipment; and investments such as stocks, treasury bills, fixed deposits, joint ventures and subsidiaries. He stated that recovering loans previously granted by failed banks remained particularly difficult, as obligations that were not honoured when the institutions were operational did not automatically become easier to recover after their closure. Theophilus said the corporation

could not effectively manage and realise assets across the country without the support of professionals with knowledge of local markets and the capacity to provide services in different locations. He urged stakeholders to prioritise credible market valuations, timely reporting, and transparent disposal procedures, warning that NDIC would not tolerate insider dealings, collusion with prospective buyers, diversion of proceeds, or other practices capable of short-changing depositors. He said, “The money we realise is not NDIC’s money. It is depositors’ money. It is somebody’s school fees, somebody’s retirement, somebody’s

business capital. We must handle it as such.”

Policy, Accountability To strengthen the process, the director disclosed that the corporation was developing a comprehensive Asset Management Policy to guide asset identification and documentation, valuation procedures, disposal strategies, and accountability in recoveries. He said the policy would provide a more structured framework for managing the assets of failed institutions and improve transparency in the conversion of such assets into funds for settling depositors’ claims.

Stakeholders: Nigeria Risks Export Market Losses, Billions in Green Finance Over Agriculture, Climate Inaction Abubakar Kyari canvasses private investment in mechanisation, local manufacturing, cold-chain infrastructure Afreximbank urges financing of entire agricultural value chain, cautions against production without market access Atai Akpan says sustainability compliance can shut Nigerian farmers out of European markets and green financing Autodex targets 4,000 tractors, 8,000 hand tillers annually through local assembly James Emejo in Abuja Stakeholders in the agricultural sector, yesterday warned that the country risks forfeiting billions of dollars in export earnings and emerging green-financing opportunities unless it urgently shifts from raw commodity production to technology-driven, industrial-scale agriculture anchored on value addition and environmental sustainability. They also challenged the government, financial institutions, manufacturers and farmers to translate years of agricultural reform commitments into measurable investments, internationally competitive products and export-ready value chains. Their admonition came at the opening of the 3rd edition of the Farm, Food and Allied Technologies Expo (FARMFATECH 2026) with the themed, “Driving Agricultural Industrialisation: Local Manufacturing, Technology Transfer and Export for Africa’s Prosperity” in Abuja. In his keynote adddress, Head of Sustainability and SDG Alignment, World Agriculture Forum Nigeria Council, Mr. Atai Akpan, was particularly critical of the country’s slow progress, insisting that Nigeria could no longer afford to substitute speeches and policy pronouncements

for concrete action. He stressed that Nigerian agricultural producers could increasingly find themselves excluded from international markets and financing opportunities as sustainability, traceability and environmental compliance become critical conditions for trade. Akpan said Nigeria was still lagging behind in meeting emerging global requirements, despite the enormous economic opportunities available in sustainable agriculture and carbon markets. “We need to move beyond speeches,” he stressed, adding that little progress had been made in value addition and the country’s preparedness for international sustainability obligations. He explained that the European Union’s Deforestation Regulation, which takes effect from December 30, 2026, for large and medium-sized operators and June 2027 for smaller operators, would impose additional requirements on exporters of commodities including cocoa, oil palm, rubber, soya and wood. Under the regulation, exporters must be able to establish the geographical origin of their products and demonstrate that the land on which they were produced had not been deforested or

degraded after 2020. Akpan said farmers and cooperatives unable to provide the required information could jeopardise their exporters’ access to European markets, potentially leaving them dependent on less demanding domestic outlets. He said sustainability compliance was also becoming a condition for accessing finance, with banks increasingly required to account for climate-related risks associated with their lending portfolios. Under Nigeria’s roadmap for adopting International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) sustainability standards, banks and other public interest entities are expected to commence reporting climate-related information from January 2028. Consequently, agribusinesses without credible operational, energy, emissions and supply-chain records could face difficulties securing financing as lenders strengthen their risk assessments. Akpan also drew attention to the country’s limited participation in the global carbon-credit market, which he estimated at over $300 billion, lamenting that the country had attracted less than two per cent of the available opportunities. He said Nigeria was missing out on a significant source of investment and

revenue because of inadequate preparation, weak sustainability infrastructure and failure to translate environmental commitments into verifiable projects. The economic implications, he maintained, extend beyond environmental considerations to export earnings, industrial competitiveness, employment and access to international capital. He urged agricultural businesses to begin mapping their supply chains, measuring fuel and electricity consumption, documenting emissions and establishing credible sustainability records.

Afreximbank demands value-chain financing Similarly, the Manager, Clients Relations, Anglophone West Africa, African Export-Import Bank (Afreximbank), Mr. Otitodilichukwu Onuegbu, emphaised that Africa’s continued dependence on exporting unprocessed agricultural commodities was undermining its capacity to create wealth, industrialise and compete effectively in international markets. He noted that the continent’s agricultural challenge was not simply inadequate production or access to credit, but its inability to transform abundant raw materials into processed,

packaged and branded products capable of commanding higher prices. Onuegbu said Africa must move away from its traditional position at the lower end of global value chains and prioritise domestic processing, industrial manufacturing and value addition. He noted that producing more agricultural commodities without building the capacity to process, aggregate, transport and market them would perpetuate the continent’s economic disadvantages. According to him, the critical financing gap is the failure to fund the entire agricultural ecosystem rather than concentrating lending on individual farmers. He explained that financing production without aggregation creates bottlenecks, just as funding processing facilities without adequate working capital could leave factories underutilised. Similarly, financing exporters without reliable supplies, established markets and payment arrangements exposes the entire value chain to commercial risks. Onuegbu said Afreximbank was promoting an integrated financing model covering production, aggregation, processing, logistics and market access.


THISDAY • TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026

Price: N400

BACK PAGE LEAD PHOTOGRAPH

NATIONAL MSME CONFERENCE 2026...

R-L: Governor of Lagos State, Mr. Babajide Sanwo-Olu; Group Chief Executive, Oando PLC, Mr. Adewale Tinubu; Cluster Coordinator, Sustainable Economic Development Cluster, GIZ Nigeria and ECOWAS, Dr. Didier Djoumessi; and German Deputy Consul General in Nigeria, Ms. Katharina Ziegler, during the National MSME Conference 2026 – Nigeria First Fair, organised by the Small and Medium Enterprises Development Agency of Nigeria (SMEDAN), themed “The Next Frontier for Innovation, Policy and Market Access,” at the Ecobank Pan African Centre, Victoria Island, Lagos, yesterday

TUESDAY WITH REUBENABATI abati1990@gmail.com

2027 And The Leadership Question

“I

appeal to each one of you to remember that political participation places obligations on those who organize others. Keep your engagements peaceful, and your message issue-based... reject violence, threats, intimidation, misinformation, and every form of electoral conduct”. These were the wise, fitting and relevant words by Vice President Kashim Shettima in the month of September 2026 while formally inaugurating the National Working Committee of Transporters for Tinubu/ Shettima 2027. He could well have been talking to all supporters of the Tinubu/Shettima ticket and everyone else involved in the struggle for political office in the 2027 elections under whatever party platform. His admonition was also on all fours with the objectives of the National Peace Committee, which on August 18, 2026 got political parties, their chairpersons and presidential candidates to sign an accord to act after the fashion of gentlemen and respect the same principles outlined and reiterated by Vice President Shettima in September. In recent instalments in this column, (Oct. 27, Nov. 3, 2026), we have given a sketch of the resort to violence, threats, and intimidation by Nigeria’s combative political elite, noting the danger that this poses to the integrity and credibility of the 2027 general elections with corresponding impact on voter turn-out and post-election legitimacy questions that may arise. The additional note is the pervasive reign of abuse, competitive rhetoric, character defamation, absolute lack of respect for the other or political ethos which would appear to have overtaken the Nigerian landscape, 59 days to the first election, the Presidential and National Assembly elections having been scheduled for January 16, 2027. The closer we get to the elections, the more febrile the rhetoric. Political rhetoric is part of the condiments of electioneering or political campaigns, edifying when it is constructive, but lamentable when it collapses to the level of a street-fight with all decorum thrown to the winds. It then becomes difficult to know exactly what the politician is selling to the public, noise or reason, propaganda or issues, as in that mix, every participant tries to outdo the other. It is most unfortunate that this is where we are at the moment in Nigeria and even Vice President Kashim Shettima who has asked for an issue-based campaign, has found himself also descending into the arena of vitriol, a variant of “bolekaja politics” which was more or less elevated to the status of statecraft during the Obasanjo years. The Presidential candidate of the African Democratic Congress (ADC), Waziri Adamawa, Atiku Abubakar is a denizen of those old-time battlefields, and it should not be surprising that he was the first to set the stage for the current rise of combative politics. In August 2026, he fired up the space by dismissing Tinubu’s decision to remove fuel subsidy as a wrong-headed policy which has impoverished Nigerians, and were he to win the Presidency,

President Bola Tinubu

NDC presidential candidate, Peter Obi

fuel subsidy would be restored. He pooh-poohed Tinubunomics as a system of “fiscal sedation and rascality.” The Tinubu Presidency did not waste time in firing back, dismissing Atiku’s statements as “a demonstration of serious ignorance on governance and economy.” Atiku’s hitman, Phrank Shaibu, also fired back with his acidic pen. What could have been a robust debate of Tinubunomics, for the benefit of the public, and a necessary review of the administration’s reforms soon became a shouting match. In subsequent interventions, Waziri Atiku Abubakar began to refer to the President at every turn not as Tinubu or President Tinubu, but simply Bola. He affected a tone of familiarity, that was entirely dismissive, to convey the impression that he does not recognize Tinubu as President. When the commentariat observed that this was disrespectful to the office of the President, Atiku’s aides smeared pepper on an open wound by insisting that “the President’s name is Bola”, and those who found that offensive were guilty of illiteracy. Even in the United States, those who try to get familiar with President Trump, either call him Mr. President or The Donald, as he was known in “The Apprentice”, a 2004 television series on NBC. The attack on President Tinubu by the Atiku camp and the ADC was sustained. In African communities, respect matters a lot to the people, and certain positions attract specific levels of reverence which must be openly demonstrated. Besides, African leaders are monarchs of some sort, they relate with others as the overall boss, the ruler, not as equals. Each time Atiku refers to the President as “Bola”, he breaks the code. The Bolanization of President Tinubu has since placed the Tinubu team on a war-path with the Atiku camp. In October, Rotimi Amaechi, Vice Presidential candidate of the ADC following in his Principal’s footsteps, declared in Edo State that “only a mad man will vote Tinubu in 2027”

He added: “If Edo people vote for Tinubu, that means Edo people are mad. If you are not mad, Tinubu should not win here.” In this war of words, there has been quite a competition, as to who can outsmart the other. Senator Adams Oshiomhole, one of the key campaigners of APC extraction has been very vocal. He has described Peter Obi, the NDC Presidential candidate as “a trader” whose business is “to export jobs, and import unemployment to the country”, a shop-owner who wants to run Nigeria, and yet he could not fix Anambra state for eight years when he was Governor. He calls Rotimi Amaechi a “serial loser,” “failure”, “shallow and unreliable”. As he puts it: “Amaechi has been a serial loser, very, very stubborn. He was a Governor who came into office without winning an election…Amaechi is a failure. He cannot benefit from other people’s abuse and pass it off as his own achievement…. hungry, ruthless individuals, shallow, unreliable”. Amaechi has since asked Senator Oshiomhole to make his educational certificates available for public scrutiny, and that he, Amaechi led the team that kicked away Oshiomhole when he was Chairman of the APC and he was still a member of the ruling party. Oshiomhole could not have spared Atiku Abubakar, the ADC Presidential candidate who has become a thorn in the flesh of the APC and President Tinubu, and who despite a Justice Peter Lifu judgement nullifying his emergence as the ADC flagbearer, has continued to insist that he remains a candidate, and that no one can stop him from that happening. Oshiomhole says “Atiku is a serial loser. He has been felled four times and he is completely broken with internal pollical bleeding.” Chieftains of the two leading political parties have been the most vociferous in the combat of verbal assault in the 2027 electoral process, but other presidential candidates and their agents have been no less

aggressive. Omoyele Sowore, leader of the African Action Congress (AAC), insists he is determined to take back Nigeria from the ruling class. When he and his supporters were attacked recently in Ado Ekiti, on October 30, Sowore protested that “It was not just a random attack. Tinubu’s aide and inlaw were involved in my attack in Ekiti.” He has also refused to back down on his various characterizations of the President “as a criminal” , a matter that is in court and only just yesterday, his lawyers got Justice Mohammed Garba Umar, presiding judge in Sowore’s defamation case, to subpoena Tinubu’s election documents in 1999 and 2023, and for INEC to make same available to the Federal High Court in Abuja. The matter has been adjourned to November 11, 2026 for further proceedings. Adewole Adebayo, Presidential candidate of the Social Democratic Party (SDP) has dismissed President Tinubu in these words: “Tinubu is not a mistake, he is a punishment.” He adds: “Tinubu is not just breaking the pot. He wants to break the pot, cart the pieces away and set the entire kitchen on fire.” He also says: “Tinubu should wear a mask of shame”. Seyi Makinde, Governor of Oyo State, Presidential candidate of the Allied People’s Movement (APM), a former Tinubu supporter turned adversary, has joined the anti-Tinubu group by dismissing the APC campaign team as a “Necbuchadnezzar Coalition of discredited and failed politicians.” He says what he calls “Tigunomics” is nothing else but voodoo. He tells Tinubu “win fair and square if you can.”. There are other players also in this game of competitive rhetoric: There is former Governor, Senator, and Minister of Works, Dave Umahi who has rechristened himself “Lion of the South East, a fanatical Tinubu supporter, who tells us that “Peter Obi can never be South East’s best”. However, Mr. Peter Obi, candidate of the NDC has said publicly that he will never abuse President Tinubu or any other political office holder, but he has been consistent in tearing into the Tinubu’s administration’s policies. His slogan is that a New Nigeria is POssible. According to him: “I cannot abuse any governor. I cannot abuse anybody in government. I don’t need to abuse people in the Federal Government. I’ve never abused anybody. Who has seen me calling Tinubu’s name? Never! I will never do that. He’s the President of the country, he has all my respect… But I can argue on other issues, whether you’re doing well, or you’re not doing the right thing. That is allowed.” Peter Obi is probably an exception to what has become the norm in Nigeria’s political discourse: the on-going competition to be the man with the most memorable attacks on the opponent. The prize for that at the moment should go to the Vice President, Senator Kashim Shettima, who is standing out as the man with the bon mot, and the most entertaining Continued on page 31

Printed and Published in Lagos by THISDAY Newspapers Limited. Lagos: 35 Creek Road, Apapa, Lagos. Abuja: Plot 1, Sector Centre B, Jabi Business District, Solomon Lar Way, Jabi North East, Abuja . All Correspondence to POBox 54749, Ikoyi, Lagos. EMAIL: editor@thisdaylive.com, info@thisdaylive.com. TELEPHONE Lagos: 0802 2924721-2, 08022924485. Abuja: Tel: 08155555292, 08155555929 24/7 ADVERTISING HOT LINES: 0811 181 3085, 0811 181 3086, 0811 181 3087, 0811 181 3088, 0811 181 3089, 0811 181 3090. ENQUIRIES & BOOKING: adsbooking@thisdaylive.com (ISSN 1117-871X)


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
TUESDAY 10TH NOVEMBER 2026 by THISDAY Newspapers Ltd - Issuu