U of W prof ’s talk on trans health care sparks protest Some wanted talk cancelled, last-minute move to Zoom caused confusion

Colton McKillop, staff Aaron Moore, chair of the political science department, declined to speak to the Manitoban Boucher did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

AUniversity of Winnipeg professor’s talk on the economic interests involved in gender affirming health care caused controversy last week, leading to protests and calls to cancel the event.

U of W political science professor Joanne Boucher’s lecture, titled “The Commodification of the Human Body: The Case of Transgender Identities,” was advertised as part of the U of W department of political science’s 2022-23 speaker series.

A poster for the event said that the talk would “focus on the economic interests involved in transgenderism” and would examine the role of governments, corporate lobby groups and the medical and biotechnology industries.

The talk caused controversy among U of W students and non-students alike, and received coverage from a number of outlets in the lead-up to the event. Boucher declined requests for comment from press.

University of Winnipeg Students’ Association 2SLGBTQ* students’ director Brie Villeneuve said that they were concerned when they saw the event description, particularly its use of terms such as “the commodification of the human body.”

“ That’s kind of saying that we’re some capitalistic or pharmaceutical ploy or something, which is just a really gross way of [thinking],” they said.

They also pointed out that the term “transgenderism,” which was used in the event description, is a term not typically used by the trans community and is often utilized by anti-trans groups or individuals to delegitimize trans identity by depicting it as merely an ideological perspective.

While Villeneuve said that dialogue and academic freedom are important, they argued that hate speech should not be protected.

A Change.org petition to cancel the event gathered over 1,700 signatures.

The university released a statement saying they would not be “intervening” in the talk.

U of W assistant English professor Alyson Brickey noted that the university making clear that it would not intervene is strange, since the administration allowed the talk to go forward in the first place.

“ They’ve already performed an action that is supportive of this event, whether implicitly or explicitly,” she said. “I think in some ways, it’s something that they could have stopped earlier, or at least raised some concern about a lot earlier.”

“ They failed to do so, and now they are refusing to intervene in what essentially was within their control to change.”

Brickey said that she supports academic freedom, but that it should not be used as a cover to promote intolerance. She pointed out that hate speech is not legally protected in Canada.

However, she said that she doesn’t “think the law has anything to do with this.”

“ We have members of our community that are telling us that they are feeling unsafe and that they are feeling unwelcomed by an institution that claims to welcome them, and we ought to listen to those voices,” she explained.

Brickey and two English professors from the U of M organized a “ Trans Love Cupcake Hour,” an open roundtable event scheduled at the same time as Boucher’s lecture intended “to hold a space of community connection and really celebrate our wonderful 2SLGBTQIA community at the University of Winnipeg and in the broader city as well.”

Confusion following lecture’s last-minute switch to Zoom

Those seeking to attend the talk were left scrambling when they arrived at the scheduled location and found a sign on the door notifying attendees that the lecture had been moved online to Zoom.

A representative from the university led a group of people waiting outside the lecture hall to the university library to view the online lecture.

The sign on the lecture hall door contained a URL for the Zoom meeting, but when the group arrived at the library, they learned that the meeting required a password to enter, which had not been provided.

The group was then led back to the lecture hall so that the Zoom meeting could be shown on the projector. By this time, the group had missed about 20 minutes of the lecture.

Boucher’s talk discussed the profit-seeking interests involved in trans health care and argued that these interested groups see increases in people seeking treatments as an expansion of potential markets.

She explored how economic and legal barriers to trans health care vary depending on what medical and legal systems one may live under. Boucher said that the costs of some treatments and surgeries may be prohibitive for some. She continued that it was not her intent to make recommendations on legal policy concerning gender affirming health care.

Boucher also said that investors in gender-affirming health care see legal and political environments that accept and affirm trans and gender non-conforming people as “crucial to market expansion.”

She discussed the potential negative side-effects associated with some treatments and argued that pharmaceutical companies may not be inclined to closely study the effects of already profitable drugs used in gender affirming health care.

Protestors hold rally on front lawn

As Boucher spoke, a crowd gathered on the U of W campus front lawn to protest the event.

A number of people gave speeches denouncing the talk, including Manitoba NDP MLA Uzoma Asagwara.

Asagwara told the crowd that as a non-binary person themself, “these moments are tough.”

They said that trans and non-binary people “are not obligated to educate people” or to “respond to the demands of people to justify our existence.”

“We do that work and we do it really, really well, but do that heavy lifting on your own,” they said.

“Get on Google, go to the library, go on social media and follow and support trans and non-binary people who have the capacity to do that work.”

Brook Allarie, a first-year psychology student at the U of W, said that they are angry the university allowed the talk to go forward.

Regarding the outcome of the protest, Allarie said that they “want the university to see that things like this are not okay.”

“In our modern world, we have trans students, gender diverse students — I’m one of them,” they said.

Allarie said that they feel discussions of trans issues should include trans voices.

“Why are you, as a cisgender person, trying to spread this rhetoric about transgender people without consulting transgender people, without having them be involved in the message that you’re spreading?” they said.

EDITOR-IN-CHIEF ? editor@themanitoban.com

Gillian Brown

BUSINESS MANAGER ? accounts@themanitoban.com

Dhruv Patel

ADVERTISING CO-ORDINATOR ? ads@themanitoban.com

Richard Plant

MANAGING EDITOR ? me@themanitoban.com

Grace Anne Paizen

COPY DESK ? copy@themanitoban.com

Ezra Taves (ed.)

Morgan Heck

NEWS DESK ? news@themanitoban.com vacant (ed.)

Colton McKillop (ed.)

Kasey Pashe

Ashley Puchniak

Alicia Rose

RESEARCH & TECHNOLOGY DESK ? research@themanitoban.com

Elah Ajene (ed.)

Robert Moshe Thompson

COMMENT DESK ? comment@themanitoban.com

Sarah Cohen (ed.)

Braden Bristow

Dina Hamid

ARTS & CULTURE DESK ? arts@themanitoban.com

Alex Braun (ed.)

Damien Davis

Jessie Krahn

SPORTS DESK ? sports@themanitoban.com

Joshua Brandt (ed.)

Quinn Mayhew

PHOTO DESK ? photo@themanitoban.com

Ebunoluwa Akinbo (ed.)

Faith Peters

DESIGN DESK ? design@themanitoban.com

Matthew Doering (ed.)

Taeran An

GRAPHICS DESK ? graphics@themanitoban.com

Dallin Chicoine (ed.)

Jenna Solomon

AUDIO DESK ? audio@themanitoban.com

Harmatpreet Brar (ed.)

SOCIAL MEDIA DESK ? social@themanitoban.com

Jory Thomas (ed.)

Violet Baker email me@themanitoban.com today!

VOLUNTEERS THIS ISSUE ?

VOLUNTEER STAFF ?

Lucas Gomes, Matthew Merkel interested in volunteering?

THEMANITOBAN.COM

109 HELEN GLASS BUILDING

UNIVERSITY OF MANITOBA

WINNIPEG, MB

204. 474. 6535

The Manitoban is the official student newspaper of the University of Manitoba. It is published monthly during the summer and each week of regular classes during the academic year by the Manitoban Newspaper Publications Corporation.

The Manitoban is an independent and democratic student organization, open to participation from all students. It exists to serve its readers as students and citizens.

The Manitoban is a member of the Canadian University Press, and our journalistic standards can be found on the Manitoban’s website.

The newspaper’s primary mandate is to report fairly and objectively on issues and events of importance and interest to the students of the University of Manitoba, to provide an open forum for the free expression and exchange of opinions and ideas and to stimulate meaningful debate on issues that affect or would otherwise be of interest to the student body and/ or society in general. The Manitoban serves as a training ground for students interested in any aspect of journalism.

Students and other interested parties are invited to contribute to any section of the newspaper. Please contact the appropriate editor for submission guidelines.

The Manitoban reserves the right to edit all submissions and will not publish any material deemed by its Editorial Board to be discriminatory, racist, sexist, homophobic or transphobic, ableist or libellous.

Opinions expressed in letters and articles are solely those of the authors. Editorials in the Manitoban are signed and represent the opinions of the writer(s), not necessarily those of the Manitoban staff, Editorial Board or the publisher.

A “volunteer staff” member is defined as a person who has had three volunteer articles, photographs or pieces of art of reasonable length and/ or substance published in the current publishing year of the Manitoban.

Any individual who qualifies as a volunteer staff member must be voted in by a majority vote at a Manitoban editorial board meeting. Elected representatives and non-students may be excluded from holding votes as volunteer staff members in accordance with the Manitoban Constitution.

All contents are ©2023 and may not be reprinted without the express written permission of the Editor-in-Chief.

News pages 3 to 4

Research & Technology pages 5 to 6

Editorial page 7

Comment pages 8 to 12

Diversions pages 13 to 14

Arts & Culture pages 15 to 17

Sports pages 18 to 20