Skip to main content

Property Lawyer Volume 22 Issue 1

Page 1

The

Property Lawyer August 2021 · Volume 22 Issue 1


VO L U M E 22 I S S U E 1

ISSN 1175-4419

Contents 3 From the Chair: Off to a good start By Mark Sherry 4 Contract: Survival guide to “off the plans” purchases and KiwiSaver withdrawals for deposits By Kristine King 7 From the Editor: Interesting cases By John Greenwood 9 The Section Manager: Musings on motivation By Kim Bull 10 Registrar-General of Land: Is the proposed landowner capable of taking title? By Robbie Muir

The Property Lawyer is the quarterly magazine of the Te Kāhui Ture o Aotearoa | New Zealand Law Society Property Law Section (PLS), and is distributed to all section members and subscribers. You can join the PLS for an annual subscription of $207, or $172.50 for subsequent members. Member benefits include a subscription to The Property Lawyer, email bulletins, access to the PLS Accredited Specialist scheme for qualifying members, access to the members’ section of the website including guidelines and other resources, and the ability to tap into the expertise of section members throughout the country. Members also receive preferential pricing for CPD and collegial events. Subscriptions are available to non-members at $115 per annum. To join the section, or to subscribe to The Property Lawyer, please email property@lawsociety.org.nz or visit our website www.lawsociety.org.nz/pls.

Property Law Section Kim Bull Property Law Section Manager   DX SP20202 or PO Box 5041, Lambton Quay Wellington 6145   0275 511 559   kim.bull@lawsociety.org.nz

Advertising Maria Pirela

Communications Co-ordinator   04 463 2905   advertising@lawsociety.org.nz The views expressed in The Property Lawyer are not necessarily those of, or endorsed by the Property Law Section or the New Zealand Law Society. No responsibility whatsoever is accepted by the Property Law Section or the New Zealand Law Society for any opinion, information, or advertisement contained in this publication. Unless otherwise stated, all articles in The Property Lawyer are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 New Zealand license, the full terms of which are available at creativecommons. org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/nz/. This allows you to copy any item for your own use or for educational purposes or to republish articles for non-commercial purposes. Attribution should include The Property Lawyer, the volume and issue number, and the Author's name if listed. The Property Lawyer is printed on an environmentally responsible paper, produced using elemental chlorine free (ECF), FSC certified mixed source pulp sourced from well managed & legally harvested forests.

11 E-dealing Consultant: Retirement and appointment of trustees and delegation of powers By Duncan Terris 12 Sustainability: Climate change clauses in contracts By Debra Dorrington 15 Commercial Leases: Refusing to renew a commercial lease – do it once, do it right By Michelle Hill and Georgia Beverley 17 Resource Management: The NBEB Exposure Draft and Significant Natural Areas By Helen Andrews 19 A Property Lawyer’s Brief: Leaky building nightmare By Sarah Wroe 22 Māori Land: Changes to succession under the Te Ture Whenua Māori Act 1993 By Claire Tyler 23 Estate Administration: IRD, estates and MyTrove By Sharon Cornwell 24 Construction: Construction Contracts (Retention Money) Amendment Bill By Hamish Bolland 26 AML/CFT: Amendment Regulations relating to the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Act 2009 By Scott Abel and Lara Wood 28 Profile: Ken Lord talks about being a Notary Public 29

Land Titles: New Landonline services

31 Book Review: Land Registration and Title Security in the Digital Age By John Greenwood 32

Thomson Reuters: Westlaw AU Case Notes

37

Library: New Zealand Law Society Library Service Case Notes


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

FROM THE CHAIR

Off to a good start BY M A R K S H E R RY

As I write this column the country is shivering due to a massive cold front, with snow in many parts of the South Island and lower North Island. Hopefully as you read this things are a bit warmer as we claw our way towards spring and then daylight savings! We’re well into the first quarter of the 2020-21 membership year, and the rate of our PLS membership renewals is better than ever before. To give you some background, we usually expect some degree of attrition as we cross over into a new membership year as we can be hit by retirements, changes in specialist practice areas, members going on parental leave and so forth. Then, as the year progresses, we claw back those numbers. But this year has been different. We already have 1,527 members, which the highest we have had at this time of year. The Executive is always challenging itself to be relevant in the services we provide and our membership numbers are a good way to gauge just how we are doing. Thank you for your support – we do not take it for granted. The recent update to the PLS Guidelines has been well received and the process that has been instituted for settlements between lawyers and conveyancers seems to be working well. PLS has fielded a few enquiries but the response has been positive and we believe the approach that has been instituted is proving to The recent be effective. update to the Our Land Titles Subcommittee has PLS Guidelines been in discussions with Toitū Te has been well Whenua Land Information New Zealand received and on some formatting updates to the Authority and Instruction forms, which the process will see a more modern layout. The A & that has been I forms are derived from the guidelines, instituted for although generated by Landonline. The settlements refresh would not likely require any between immediate changes to the guidelines, lawyers and but a fuller review of the forms will take conveyancers place over the coming months and will then be incorporated in the next iterseems to be ation of the guidelines. We’ll keep you working well posted on these developments, but in

the meantime, we hope you enjoy the modernised forms when they become available through Landonline. More generally, we are continuously reviewing the guidelines to ensure they reflect current best practice. We always welcome members’ feedback on matters they would like to see considered as part of this process. Feel free to email any comments to property@lawsociety.org.nz. In June the PLS Executive hosted Thinking Property with local property lawyers in Dunedin. There was a great turnout of members and an upbeat atmosphere despite the rain outside. Although there is always a strong focus on CPD-qualifying learning at these events, this meeting in particular seemed to be a much-needed opportunity for colleagues to come together. This was a real highlight on the day. We are planning to help facilitate a less formal follow-up gathering in Dunedin for property lawyers with help from a couple of experienced PLS members and we encourage local property lawyers to support that in due course. Our next Executive meeting and Thinking Property will be held in Tauranga later this month. We’re looking forward to co-presenting with the Registrar-General of Land and LINZ team, plus tax lawyer, Arti Chand (Law Society Vice President, Wellington). Finally, campaigning by candidates for the New Zealand Law Society Presidency is underway. The Property Law Section will have a vote in this election, which takes place at the next Council meeting in October. The section has nominated its past Chair, Duncan Terris, for the role. There are currently three other nominees: Frazer Barton, Jacque Lethbridge and Arti Chand. We wish them all the very best in their bid for the Presidency, as they travel around the country to present to Law Society Branch Councils and other Law Society Council constituents. ▪

3


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

CONTRACT

Survival guide to “off the plans” purchases and KiwiSaver withdrawals for deposits BY K R I S T I N E K I N G

Buying “off the plans” is becoming increasingly common around New Zealand as purchasers gravitate towards properties that are still under construction or are at concept stage. First home buyers (or a Kainga Ora qualified previous property owner) withdrawing their KiwiSaver investment for the deposit payable for these off the plans purchases is also becoming more common. As a quick recap, the ability to use KiwiSaver towards the deposit payable rather than at settlement was introduced over six years ago in 2015 with the Taxation (KiwiSaver HomeStart and Remedial Matters) Act 2015. It was intended that the KiwiSaver funds would be protected by undertakings and returned to the KiwiSaver provider for reinvestment if the transaction did not proceed to settlement. Unfortunately, the KiwiSaver Act 2006 (the Act) and the provisions relating to the withdrawals set out in Schedule 1 do not provide much guidance about how this might work in practice. Off the plans purchases warrant additional care to ensure the KiwiSaver deposit funds are protected. Construction may not have started, and issue of title and the code compliance certificate (CCC) as the usual triggers for settlement for the off the plans purchases, could be months or years away. Add to this the possibility that the development will never be completed, or liquidation or receivership of the developer, and you have a potent

4

blend of risk factors. This article hopes to provide some useful tips and warnings for dealing with our clients wanting to withdraw their KiwiSaver for payment of the deposit.

Option 1: NOT using KiwiSaver

Off the plans purchases warrant additional care to ensure the KiwiSaver deposit funds are protected

This is the preferred option, and not to simply limit hassle and liability for lawyers. If at all possible, the purchasers should be encouraged to explore other options to satisfy the deposit requirement. If achieved this will have a number of benefits for our first home buyers. Off the plans purchases can be at various stages of progress – from a concept where the developer is not yet the owner of the land to a construction project that is almost complete. For many clients this will mean that there are months or even years between the date of contract and the settlement date. If a withdrawal is undertaken, for example, a year prior to settlement the purchaser will lose the ability to withdraw all their and their employer’s contributions for that year, plus also not receiving any gains derived by the fund on the amounts withdrawn. Instead the funds will be on investment via a solicitor’s trust account likely earning a negligible rate of interest, which may not even be for the benefit of the client. Many purchasers also seem unaware that they are not able to withdraw towards a purchase in tranches – assuming they can take a partial withdrawal for payment of the deposit and then make a subsequent withdrawal at the time of settlement. Due to misinformation regarding the process, we are aware of some purchasers with large KiwiSaver balances electing to withdraw only enough to pay the initial deposit required under the contract to find that they were unable to withdraw again at settlement, despite having significant residue funds in their KiwiSaver accounts. Don’t assume that the purchaser has no other option but KiwiSaver available to satisfy their deposit requirements. Some purchasers actually have the funds in their bank account but are considering using their KiwiSaver funds instead to preserve these savings or they because they read online that it was the thing to do.


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

Purchasers should be encouraged to take financial advice regarding the amount of savings they need “just in case” against the likely contributions and possible gains. Another avenue to explore, if more than one person is buying the property, is using a mixture of savings and only withdrawing from one KiwiSaver account rather than both or all. Family lending, with appropriate documentation of course, may also be a good short to medium term solution rather than withdrawing from KiwiSaver for the deposit. Lastly, don’t overlook that many developer vendors are very understanding of the circumstances facing the first home buyers and the consequences of an early KiwiSaver withdrawal and may be willing to negotiate a smaller deposit, say 5% rather than the usual 10%, an agreed amount that equates to funds available in savings or in some cases nil deposit, having sighted evidence of the KiwiSaver balance and loan pre-approval. It is likely that a lawyer will be asking for amendments to the off the plans contract as part of the due diligence process, so a request for a deposit variation could be included in that correspondence.

Option 2: “KiwiSaver deposit clause” In some circumstances however, a purchaser has no other option to satisfy their deposit requirement but to apply to withdraw from their KiwiSaver account. If this is the case we would like to see a clause in the agreement that maps out four aspects: 1. An acknowledgment that the deposit will be paid with funds withdrawn from a KiwiSaver account; 2. Timeframes within which the purchaser is obliged to apply for the withdrawal, subject to receipt of the vendor’s solicitors’ undertakings to hold the funds; 3. Extended date for payment of the

deposit linked to receipt of the KiwiSaver funds into the purchaser’s solicitor’s trust account; and 4. A requirement for the vendor’s solicitor to undertake to hold the funds as stakeholder in accordance with the undertakings required by the KiwiSaver provider. Real estate agents are generally quite amenable to including these clauses, so a lawyer may be in a position when undertaking an initial review to request this. The key is knowing that our clients actually require KiwiSaver for the deposit and also educating them that we would like to review the contract before they sign. For some reason, many first home buyers assume that their lawyer will “just know” that they will be using KiwiSaver funds for their deposit or think the process can be completed quickly and easily at any time, including after the contract is unconditional. This is incredibly frustrating for lawyers and the best way is to try to get disclosure from your client of their requirements as part of your engagement process and provide them with a copy of your preferred clause to take to the agent when looking for properties. Another great benefit of having the clause in the agreement is the certainty of knowing that the vendor accepts the purchaser’s KiwiSaver situation and that the vendor’s lawyer will be obliged to provide their undertaking to hold the funds. This will save the lawyer time in not having to request KiwiSaver undertakings and deferral of the deposit payment date from the vendor’s solicitor.

Option 3: Ask the vendor’s solicitor for “KiwiSaver undertakings” Contracts will frequently arrive in a lawyer’s inbox pre-signed and there is no early opportunity to request the inclusion of a KiwiSaver Deposit clause. For conditional

contracts where a KiwiSaver deposit withdrawal can be undertaken, it is good practice to immediately contact the vendor’s solicitor and alert them to the need for a KiwiSaver withdrawal for the deposit payment. The lawyer should also request a variation to the deposit payment dates to ensure there is sufficient time to complete the KiwiSaver withdrawal for the deposit. The lawyer should be mindful of the client’s particular situation if agreeing to a set date for payment of the deposit– an ordinary KiwiSaver withdrawal application is usually processed in 10 – 15 working days however if your client has been overseas during their KiwiSaver membership, the application will also need to be assessed by the Inland Revenue Department (IRD) to determine if any government contributions need to be clawed back. The IRD process can take up to 20 working days. For this reason we recommend linking the payment process to when the funds are received by the purchaser’s solicitor into their trust account, for example two working days after receipt into the trust account, subject to evidence of withdrawal having been applied for. Whilst the dates are important, the purchaser solicitor’s priority should be seeking appropriate undertakings from the vendor’s solicitors to hold the KiwiSaver funds received in accordance with the undertakings required by the provider (KiwiSaver undertakings). Whilst each provider will have their own wording the undertakings to be given by the purchaser’s lawyer will generally follow the following format derived from clause 8(7) of Schedule 1 of the Act: We confirm that we act for the member, who is to purchase the property under the agreement, and we undertake to you that: 1. As at the date of this letter, any funds received by us pursuant to this application (the funds) will be paid to a stakeholder or vendor who is obliged to hold the funds while the agreement is conditional, and 2. If settlement under the agreement is not completed by the due date in the agreement or any extended date: (a) except where the non-completion is due to the default of the purchaser(s), the stakeholder is obliged to repay the funds to us, and (b) we will, as soon as possible, repay to you the funds received from the stakeholder on account of the member with no deductions or disbursements. As the undertaking to the provider requires the stakeholder to be “obliged to repay the funds” to that lawyer in the event of non-completion, the purchaser lawyer must ensure before giving that undertaking that the stakeholder is actually obliged to repay the funds. The best way to achieve this is to have the vendor’s lawyer provide their own undertaking to hold the funds undisbursed until settlement or (where appropriate) refund the deposit if settlement is not completed. The purchaser’s lawyer can then safely rely on this undertaking when

5


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

giving their undertaking to the provider. This sounds very straightforward especially as most agreements provide for the deposits to be held until settlement or close to that time. However, a number of lawyers acting for developers, including those marketing “KiwiBuild” properties targeted at first home buyers routinely refuse to provide KiwiSaver undertakings and instead direct the purchaser’s lawyer to consider the deposit clauses in the agreement for sale and purchase.

Option 4: Deposit provisions in Agreement? In most off the plan agreements, the deposit is held until settlement or close to it. Careful review of deposit clauses is required for every agreement, as no agreement is the same. Bespoke agreements are drafted for each development and there are a variety of deposit release provisions in circulation. The most common are: • Deposit released on settlement, with settlement being a number of working days from issue of title, CCC and in some cases also Practical Completion (PC); • Deposit released on the later of issue of title, CCC or PC; • Deposit released on earlier of issue of title, CCC or PC; • Deposit released on issue of the Pre-Settlement Disclosure (PSD) under s 147 of the Unit Titles Act 2010, if the title is a unit title; and • Deposit held until settlement unless permitted to be released earlier by other clauses in the agreement. Where the deposit is able to be released prior to settlement, for example on the later of issue of title, CCC or PC, the purchaser’s lawyer is exposed to risk for the period between release and settlement if they have given undertakings to a KiwiSaver provider. If the developer is placed into liquidation or

6

receivership during this period it may be difficult or impossible to recover the KiwiSaver funds released to them. The purchaser’s lawyer has given an undertaking that the vendor’s lawyer as stakeholder is obliged to repay the funds if settlement doesn’t occur and clearly, in the case of “early release” in an agreement prior to settlement, the purchaser’s lawyer has not ensured that the undertaking given to the provider is correct. This leads to a general discussion as to whether it is appropriate to rely on provisions in the agreement when giving undertakings to a KiwiSaver provider instead of requiring a KiwiSaver undertaking from the vendor’s solicitor. Each off the plan agreement is a contract between vendor and purchaser and the respective lawyers are not parties to the contract. A lawyer stakeholder will be bound to hold the deposit under the terms of the contract but the terms of the contract can be varied by the agreement of the parties. Whilst unlikely, it is not impossible to imagine a scenario where a developer vendor

approaches a purchaser and offers a discount in exchange to a release of the deposit prior to the settlement date. The purchaser may agree to this and not inform their lawyer until after the variation is signed. The purchaser’s lawyer will still be bound by the undertaking given to the KiwiSaver provider despite not being in a position to fully ensure the undertaking is carried out. It is acknowledged that there is no obligation on the vendor’s solicitor to provide the KiwiSaver undertakings if not is not a requirement of the contract. Very sadly for the first home buyer clients, if a request for KiwiSaver undertakings is refused, good practice suggests that the purchaser’s lawyer should not complete the KiwiSaver withdrawal process and provide the undertaking. This will mean that there are buyers who miss out on the opportunity to acquire their first home. ▪ Kristine King is a Director at DK Law in Auckland. She is also the Property Law Section’s Deputy Chair and a member of the PLS Property Law Reform Panel.


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

FROM THE EDITOR

Interesting cases BY J O H N G R E E N W O O D

The cases in this editorial demonstrate the need for wise counsel before going down a litigious route as resulted in the Easton decision (always difficult to upset privileged advice) and in the Dromgool decision (ignoring an important Supreme Court decision). The Wanaka case, involving the Queenstown Lakes District Council, is a lesson in Council adopting an overly aggressive commercial approach given the consultation regime that exists under the Local Government Act.

Wanaka Stakeholders Group Incorporated v Queenstown Lakes District Council [2021] NZHC 852 This High Court decision involved a stakeholders group taking the Council to task over the grant to the Queenstown Airways Corporation over a perpetually renewable lease of the Wanaka Airport. For the first 100 years the rent was paid as a lump sum up front of $11.3 million, representing the freehold market value of the land discounted by 5%. The lease also included the sale of all airport buildings, the runway and associated infrastructure, as well as the grant of rights to the Queenstown Airways Corporation to the future development of the Wanaka Wasterwater Plant, known as Project Pure. The stakeholders’ claim alleged that the Council failed to comply with ss 97(1)(b) and 97(2) of the Local Government Act 2002 (LGA), given that there was a transfer effectively of ownership or control of the Wanaka Airport. The stakeholders also claimed the grant of such a lease to develop a jet capable airport was tantamount to altering significantly the level of service provision for a significant activity without complying with sections 97(1)(a) and 97(2) of the LGA and this should have been explicitly provided for in the Council’s long-term plan. Further, the lease was a significant decision within the meaning of section 76(3)(b) of the LGA and the requirements for disclosure and consultation required under section 76, 77, 78 and 82 was not adhered to. Thus, the

The words “ownership or control” used in s 97(1) of the LGA are to be interpreted disjunctively; the Judge accepted that the concepts of “ownership” and “control” need to be considered separately, but also in relation to each other

lease entered into was done so on an unlawful basis. It was agreed that the words “ownership or control” used in s 97(1) of the LGA are to be interpreted disjunctively; the Judge accepted that the concepts of “ownership” and “control” need to be considered separately, but also in relation to each other. Section 97(1) applies whether there is a transfer of ownership or control. The Judge held that the term “ownership” refers to legal ownership which he determined did not occur. However, he found that the Council transferred effectively the control of the Airport sufficient to trigger the requirement of s 97 of the LGA. As a result, the lease entered into in favour of Queenstown Airport Company was declared unlawful and set aside with no legal effect. An interesting issue is whether the Court adopted a too narrow approach given the nature of the lease and payment effectively for the freehold of that land that to all intents and purposes a disposal or transfer of the ownership had resulted.

Easton v New Zealand Guardian Trust Company Ltd [2021] NZHC 519 This is one of the first cases to consider the rights of beneficiaries to obtain trustee information under ss 52 and 53 of the Trusts Act 2019. The proceedings involved a dispute between three beneficiaries of a trust which holds assets from their parents’ estate. The beneficiaries were the son of the late parents, and his two sisters were the other

7


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

beneficiaries. The primary asset of the trust was farmland used for cropping, which was leased to the son. In the parents’ Memorandum of Wishes they stated that the assets of the trust should not be distributed prior to ten years following the death of the survivor of them giving the son sufficient time to organise his affairs to hopefully put him in the position where he was able to purchase the farm property from the trust. This did not occur. Disputes emerged in relation to whether the plaintiff should be obliged to pay full market price. As a consequence, the trustees made a decision to sell to a third party. The son as plaintiff requested in discovery a list of documents which his counsel argued were not privileged for production. His counsel argued that legal professional privilege could not be claimed because the plaintiff was not dealing with the trust in a separate capacity, but rather in his position as a lessee and potential purchaser was as a beneficiary. As the Court noted, the dispute turns on a contest between two important rights. The first being the right to seek and receive legal advice on a confidential basis, and the second, the right of beneficiaries to have access to trust information. Legal professional privilege is described by some as a “fundamental human right”, and it is affirmed as a basic right that should be respected. The Judge noted the Trusts Act 2019 did not categorise a beneficiary’s right to information as an absolute right. It is a presumption that information should be provided under s 52 unless a trustee reasonably considers the information should not be provided having regard to the number of considerations in s 53. Among considerations listed are the effects on the trustee, other beneficiaries and third parties. The Judge held the primary duty of a trustee is to act in the interests of the trust (beneficiaries as a whole). However, once an adversarial relationship exists it becomes contrary to the beneficiary who is suing the trust to see all the legal advice the trustee is receiving about the matters

8

subject to the claim against the trust. The Judge held that would be grossly unfair to the sisters and would be inconsistent with the best interests of the trust as perceived by the trustees if disclosure was permitted.

Minster for Land Information v Dromgool [2021] NZCA 44 This Court of Appeal case involved Top Energy Limited as a requiring authority under s 186(1) of the Resource Management Act (RMA), seeking easements to enable the construction of an electricity transmission line between Kaikohe and Kaitaia. The land may be taken or acquired “if the Minister ... agrees”. The Minister gave her agreement to the taking and objectors, being affected landowners, appealed to the Environment Court. The Court considered that the Minister’s response was fully discretionary as guided by the decision of the Supreme Court in Seaton v Minister for Land Information [2013] NZSC 42. The appeal to the High Court was successful on the finding that the Minister alone has the obligation to consider any relevant factors. The Court of Appeal noted that there was no such thing as the Minister having unfettered discretion but found that the Judge in the High Court gave an incorrect analysis that it was the Minister alone who has the obligation to consider any relevant factors. The Court of Appeal held that the Minister is only required to be satisfied that the proposal will definitely meet the requirements of s 24(7) of the Public Works Act 1981 plus if the Minister is satisfied it is capable of doing so. As the Courted noted: “The Minister is the Minister for Land Information, and could not be expected to have access to institutional knowledge and expertise equivalent to that of the network utility operator, so far as assessment of the technical and economic feasibility of different alternatives is concerned. Nor is there any indication in the statutory scheme that the Minister has the role of deciding that the proposal is one that should be approved on the merits. That is an issue deliberately left to the Environment Court where there The Trusts is an objection.” The basis of the Court of Appeal decision Act 2019 is that it is the utility operator who holds did not the cards under a s 186 application as was categorise a noted in Seaton where Justice William beneficiary’s Young noted the references to “Minister” right to in ss 186(1)(a) and (b) must be read as a information reference to network operator (because as an absothe proposed taking will be to give effect to its objectives, rather than those of the lute right Minister). ▪


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

SECTION MANAGER

Musings on motivation BY K I M B U L L

It’s quite well known that positive emotions motivate us as employees – it’s how we feel that drives our motivation. A factor playing into this is purposeful work. So if we feel that our work has a purpose, we are likely to be more productive. When employees have access to customers they can see firsthand the human impact of their work, which serves as a great motivator. The PLS lives by this philosophy through its regular contact with members – speaking to and connecting with members regularly helps to keep us motivated to do better, stay relevant, and always to keep you up to date with the latest developments in property law and practice. The regularity with which we review and update the PLS Guidelines to ensure they reflect the various changes in property practice is a tangible example of the PLS as thought leader in articulating conveyancing best practice. Our guidelines are often referred to in court judgments and provide a valuable point of reference for best practice in New Zealand.

Advocacy We were so pleased with the ANZ’s recent announcement that it will no longer seek advice on whether a particular restriction affecting the title will adversely affect the property’s value or resale. Instead, ANZ will ask whether a particular restriction might materially prejudice its interests. This change was made in response feedback from the PLS and is just one example of the advocacy we undertake on behalf of members.

popular, and it has been great to reach so many more of you in locations we would not otherwise be able to visit in person every year. We have quite a busy events calendar for the remainder of the year – avoiding December of course which is always a manic month for property lawyers!

Thinking Property There are three more opportunities to attend the ever-popular Thinking Property sessions in 2021. See below for details.

Law reform – Law of Succession The PLS – via our Property Law Reform Panel – contributed comments to the New Zealand Law Society | Te Kāhui Ture o Aotearoa’s submission on the Law Commission’s Review of Succession Law Issues Paper 46. We submitted that property practitioners support the Administration Act being included in the consolidated statute dealing with succession law. Matters of estate administration should be considered at the time of estate planning, and having them in the same statute will ensure a wholistic approach to succession law. The Administration Act covers the appointment of executors and trustees and/or their removal, and it is integral to family protection. We compared this to the Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017, which consolidated similar disparate legislation into the one statute thereby improving this area of law.

PLS events As a national organisation, we are mindful of ensuring that our PLS events and CPD opportunities provide coverage throughout the country. Our webinars have been

Toitū Te Whenua | LINZ Overseas Investment Office – webinar The first of two PLS/OIO webinars to educate lawyers on significant changes that have been made to the Overseas Investment Act and regulations will be held on 2 September. The changes: • simplify the requirements for investors, • reduce screening of low-risk transactions, and • help focus attention on investments that pose a higher risk.

Toitū Te Whenua | LINZ/PLS/Legal Executives New Zealand – lunchtime seminar A LINZ-PLS-LENZ joint lunchtime seminar will be held in New Plymouth on 19 October – please note the date change from that advertised in the last issue of The Property Lawyer. Toitū Te Whenua’s Registrar-General of Land team, and Titles and Processes experts and technical specialists will provide an update on relevant, practical information for those who use Landonline regularly.

PLS events calendar Event

Venue

Date

Thinking Property

Tauranga

19 August

Online

2 September

New Plymouth

8 September

Thinking Property

South Auckland

23 September

Thinking Property

Napier

25 November

LINZ OIO/PLS webinar LINZ/PLS/LENZ lunchtime seminar

Source: Marcel Shwantes, Leadership from the Core, Inc.com.

9


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

REGISTRAR-GENERAL OF LAND

Is the proposed landowner capable of taking title? BY R O B B I E M U I R

Landowner must be a natural person or legal entity It is one of the fundamental requirements for registration of title under the Land Transfer Act 2017 that the landowner must be a natural person or a legal entity capable of owning real property. Accordingly, when preparing a conveyancing transaction, if the party purporting to take title (whether as transferee, lessee, mortgagee or otherwise) is not a natural person, the practitioner responsible for certifying on behalf of that party must ensure it is a legal entity capable of acquiring title. An obvious example of such a legal entity is a company incorporated under the Companies Act 1993. Other legal entities able to acquire land include corporates sole, such as the Māori Trustee (see section 3 Māori Trustee Act 1953), charitable trusts incorporated under the Charitable Trusts Act 1957 (see section 13), incorporated societies under the Incorporated Societies Act 1908 (see section 10) and local authorities under the Local Government Act 2002 (see section 12). If the nature and status of the party named in the transaction is unclear, the practitioner certifying on behalf of that party should take further steps to determine whether or not it has the necessary legal capacity. In particular, in the absence of any specific authorising legislation, it is not possible to have land registered in the name of an unincorporated association, charity, society, partnership or trust. It is also important to state correctly, and in full, the name under which the entity is legally incorporated. Additional information, such as related trading names (ie “trading as…..”) should not, however, be included. LINZ monitors these matters and will query non-complying transactions or require the responsible practitioner to take corrective action. This can be particularly problematic in the case of non-legal entities as rectification may require cancellation of title and registration of fresh documentation (supported by appropriate A & I forms) to re-convey the property into the correct form of ownership.

Non-disclosure of trusts When registering land in connection with a family trust, the individuals (or corporate trustees) who are to hold legal title as

10

trustees must be named as the landowners. As noted above, property cannot be registered in the name of a family trust. In this context, it is also important to note that the Land Transfer Act 2017 specifically prohibits disclosure of trusts on the register (see section 153). For this reason, the fact that landowners hold the land in their capacity as trustees cannot be stated in the transfer or recorded in the register. LINZ is vigilant about keeping trusts off the register. Instruments which purport to describe parties as trustees or otherwise disclose the existence of a trust are generally refused registration.

Alternative ownership arrangements There are a few notable cases where specific provision has been made for registration of alternative forms of ownership. Under section 220A of Te Ture Whenua Māori Act 1993, for example, trustees appointed by the Māori Land Court may opt to have Māori freehold land registered in the name of a trust or a tipuna (ancestor). Alternative land ownership arrangements have also been legislated for in the Treaty settlement context. Under section 104 of the Ngāti Whare Claims Settlement Act 2012, for example, certain lands may be registered in the name of Wharepakau, the eponymous ancestor of Ngāti Whare.

Overseas governments The government of any overseas country is deemed to be capable of being registered as a landowner in New Zealand. These matters are provided for under section 49 of the Land Transfer Act 2017. In such cases, it is the government of the overseas country, rather than any particular office holder, which should be named as the landowner. ▪


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

E - D E A L I N G C O N S U LTA N T

Retirement and appointment of trustees and delegation of powers Does the new Trusts Act change anything? BY D U N C A N T E R R I S

We are quite familiar with the historical requirements when changing trustees of a trust. The Deed of Retirement and Appointment of New Trustee(s) is the typical starting point. The requisite changes to the title(s) come next. Most trusts will have a mortgage that will need to be redocumented in the new trustee(s)’ name, together with the transfer. All of this necessitates the appropriate Client Authority and Instructions forms (A & Is) being signed. That may include a corporate trustee in combination with private individuals with the respective A&Is required.

Recent legislation The process to remove incapacitated trustees has now been simplified from having to obtain a court order in the past with the new Trusts Act 2019, which came into effect on 30 January 2021. Some practitioners have asked whether various provisions in the new Trusts Act circumvent some of the historical requirements for needing A & Is from all trustees. This article will canvass some of the issues and provide clarification on the impact of the recent legislation.

Delegation of powers – scenario A trustee appoints a person (for example, to ‘help’ with the sale of the trust’s property). That appointed person wishes to sign the A & I and related transfer documentation pursuant to s 67(1) of the Trusts Act 2019. Is that possible in any of the following circumstances: (a) a letter signed by the trustee appointing the person with that appointed person accepting such appointment; or

While the Trusts Act 2019 may give some flexibility from a trust perspective, that does not override the requirements of the Land Transfer Act and Regulations

(b) a deed signed by all the trustees and the appointed person defining the parameters of what the appointed person can do. While the Trusts Act 2019 may give some flexibility from a trust perspective, that does not override the requirements of the Land Transfer Act and Regulations. Toitū Te Whenua Land Information New Zealand’s position has always been very clear about ALL TRUSTEES needing to sign an A & I for any instrument. An appropriate properly executed Power of Attorney may be used in some circumstances, but there is strong opinion that calls into question whether a PoA can be used to exercise the donor’s powers as trustee. A trustee may delegate, by power of attorney, all or any of the trustee’s powers or functions under s 70 of the Trusts Act 2019 only when they are: • outside of NZ; or • temporarily unable to be contacted; or • temporarily incapacitated, either physically or mentally. By contrast, an attorney appointed under an enduring power of attorney (EPoA) in relation to property represents the donor in their personal capacity only and does not have powers to act in a trustee capacity. An enduring power of attorney can only be used to remove a trustee in limited circumstances. Those are dealt with later in this article. In all cases: • the power of attorney must be clear in terms of the powers conferred on the attorney and the attorney’s authority to act in relation to the specific transaction; and • a certificate of non-revocation of power of attorney (dated the same date or later than the power of attorney) must be held

11


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

CONTINUED FROM PAGE 11 with the A & I form and provided to LINZ upon a Compliance Review. If an A & I form is signed by an attorney under a PoA (whether for a private individual or a private corporate body), the identity of the attorney must be verified.

Delegated power to remove and appoint Regarding appointment and replacement of trustees, s 92 of the Trusts Act permits the following parties to do so: • the person nominated in the terms of the trust as having the power to remove trustees; or • if there is no person authorised by the trust, or the person is unable or unwilling to act, the remaining trustees; or • if there is no person authorised as noted above, or the person is unable or unwilling to act, any of the following persons acting in relation to the trustee being removed such as: • a property manager appointed under the Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988 to act as manager of the trustee’s property; or • a person holding an enduring power of attorney over the property of a trustee who is mentally incapable. (If they still have capacity the EPoA cannot be used, even if it is noted as coming into effect immediately upon signing.)

Conclusion It is an easy ‘trap’ to fall into to simply assume that the Trusts Act 2019 is a panacea for resolving all issues. A careful examination of both the Trust Deed and the details of any PoA are essential to prevent falling foul of the legislative requirements. ▪ Duncan Terris is a Director at Terris Legal in Christchurch, convenor of the PLS Land Titles Subcommittee and a member of the Property Law Section’s Executive.

12

S U S TA I N A B I L I T Y

Climate change clauses in contracts BY D E B R A D O R R I N G T O N

Climate change provisions are finding their way into legal documents, and it is not only activists who are causing the trend. Climate risk is a relevant, modern day issue that demands our attention even without an overriding intention of changing behaviour. Even in the ordinary course of events, legal advice for property clients will encounter the need for such clauses.

Force majeure A typical force majeure clause will identify events considered beyond the control of the parties and, where the contractual terms cannot be met because of those events, it will typically enable cancellation of the contract. Often such a clause will refer to “acts of God”, and “unforeseeable events” or “matters beyond the reasonable control of the parties”. Changing times mean this language might be understood differently now to how it was even five years ago. In this Anthropocene era, where humanity now impacts weather and ecosystems, what can be truly described as an “act of God” or an “unforeseeable event”? Historically acts of God have been understood to be one off events that happen independent of humanity. In 2002 the House of Lords, in deciding a tortious matter, considered the meaning of “act of God”. Lord Hobhouse reflected on the long-held view that “act of God” describes something that: • involves no human agency • is not realistically possible to guard against

• is due directly and exclusively to natural causes; and • could not have been prevented by any amount of reasonably expected foresight, plans or care. Arguably, not one of these indicators applies to sea level rise or to storm surges or flooding caused through global warming. In July this year we saw horrendous flooding in Germany. “It is the intensity and the length of these events [that] science tells us, is a clear indication of climate change” says Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Commission. In the same month, the US was fighting fires and drought “Climate change is driving a dangerous confluence of extreme heat and prolonged drought. We’re seeing wildfires of greater intensity that move with more speed,” said President Biden. Where humans contribute to the conditions that cause the harm, has there been an act of God? What if a party to the contract contributed to the likelihood of such harm themselves, if they built their property in an area that was expected to be subject to sea level


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

rise or flooding for example? The day I wrote this paper I listened to the Mayor of the Buller District being interviewed on RNZ about the flooding that that had occurred there only days previously. What, asked the interviewer ought any purchaser of a property in the flooded area to have known of the likelihood of floods? Given the frequency of these types of events, is it appropriate that public funds be used to rebuild homes in these areas that are known to flood? A same question can be asked of contracting parties facing the responsibility for rectifying damage. It is worth carefully considering the wording of the force majeure clause to make certain it addresses what you really expect it to, including the impact of supply disruption through drought, hurricanes, fires, disruption of transport, unsafe working conditions, or changes in climate legislation throughout the world. Once the wording is clear and specifically addresses the circumstances the parties expect, address who should bear the risk of these climate change outcomes. Is it fair that one party should shoulder the risk, or is it more appropriately shared? The Chancery Lane Project brings together lawyers and others from throughout the world. They collaborate and freely provide model clauses and contracts that address climate risk. The vision of the project is “a world where every contract and law enables solutions to climate change”. The project’s website is a rich resource. You may find the clauses do not perfectly fit the way you draft your clauses, or the language we use in New Zealand, but the collaboration of more than 700 legal

brains provides access to issues that are relevant, and to ideas about how matters can be addressed. From there, you can make the clauses fit your own needs. Lawyers within the project have drafted a clause that draws a distinction between climate change events and force majeure events. It recognises that “neither party should bear the entire risk of a climate change event [or pandemic] occurring”. The clause then sets out a system for sharing the problem, including addressing wasting embedded carbon emissions. This provision might address more than you or your builder client, or your joint venture client or your lessor want to address. Nonetheless it offers a useful starting point for considering the issues.

Terms of engagement What does your firm’s letter of engagement say about the part that climate risk plays in the advice given? Is there anything in the standard instructions from the banks that expects enquiry into climate risk? An obligation to report

on matters affecting value perhaps. It is likely the topic is not specifically addressed in either document but consider this. Both asset value and insurability face threat from climate change activity, whether that is because of severe weather or changes in societal behaviour. Legal risk associated with climate change arises not only through the direct impact of weather change. Litigation risk is real. So too is unexpected regulatory change that can render assets and plans obsolete overnight. Does your client expect you to address each of these? Consider the answer to that question when it is being asked of you in five or 10-years’ time. Our actions and the advice that we provide in 2021 will be judged through a different lens in the not-too-distant future. To be certain that you and your clients are on the same wavelength when it comes to the extent climate change risk will be ignored, include a specific reference to it in your engagement letter. Here’s an example: “Our advice will not, unless

13


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

specifically requested in writing, examine any aspect of climate change risk associated with your (purchase of the property, purchase of the business, negotiation of the construction contract, completion of this joint venture, finalisation of this lease or these loan documents, the drafting of your power of attorney, the creation of this company constitution….).” Frankly, you would be best to add: “This exemption does not in any manner, suggest the absence of such risk. Our view is that the matter ought to be addressed.”

Boilerplate provisions If a client does encourage you to consider climate change issues in the drafting of an agreement, consider how that might impact boilerplate provisions, i.e. those clauses at the end of the document that deal with assignment, waivers, notice, disputes and the like. There is room for these provisions to address climate action too. If minimising carbon emissions is important (and remember MBIE’s Building for Climate Change Programme and the Government’s sustainable procurement objective), these boilerplate clauses should be imbued with that recognition. They should support the sustainability targets of the parties. If not, outcomes that will be acceptable contractually, will fly in the face of those expectations. Consider the likely results from a dispute resolution process that does not account for climate action, or assignment provisions that allow assignment to others who do not support climate action.

Private clients It is easy to think that climate action has little impact on those who practise in trust and estate work. Here are a few ideas about how it might. Both a memorandum of wishes and a will can provide direction about the use of funds and the criteria for decision-making. Consider including in each of these documents a request to trustees that climate issues and net zero targets are incorporated into decision-making, that climate risk is analysed prior to the investment of funds, that funds are only used to support enterprises with net zero targets, that homes or vehicles purchased by the fund are analysed in terms of their carbon footprint. People making the decision about

14

As trusted advisers, [lawyers] can legitimately raise new and important, but often controversial, issues for proper debate. Discussing them in the confidential context of legal and business requirements can take the heat out of the debate

whether to account for climate action in their private lives will not be hamstrung by the business decisions of their employers, shareholders, or stakeholders. That may make it easier for them to make such decisions. Would you, as a trustee company, be willing to embed provisions in the constitution that direct decisions to be made in a way that reduces harm to the environment and to society? Imagine if every lawyer required that as a pre-requisite to becoming a trustee.

Why is it up to lawyers? Lawyers are in a position of significant influence when it comes to implementing climate action. As trusted advisers, they can legitimately raise new and important, but often controversial, issues for proper debate. Discussing them in the confidential context of legal and business requirements can take the heat out of the debate. It can enable an informed decision. Nor are lawyers thought of as radical either, but often seen as significantly more conservative than their clients. If conservative lawyers understand that the issues warrant consideration, clients will in general take that view seriously. Contractual terms have lasting impact. First the debate about whether to use them is something useful of itself. It addresses risk. It highlights issues. It clarifies thinking. Once used, contractual terms create cogent, binding, black and white standards that survive the years. They dictate decisions to be made years later, sometimes far into the future. Conversely, without addressing climate change, fundamental considerations will be omitted from decision making for years to come.

Sources The Chancery Lane Project: https://chancerylaneproject.org/ Eddy, M., & Ewing, J. (2021, July 17). Flooding in Western Europe. Retrieved from New York Times: https://www. nytimes.com/2021/07/16/world/europe/climate-changegermany-flooding.html Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment. (2020). Building for Climate Change:Transforming the Building and Construction Sector to reduce emissions and improve climate resilience. Nugent v Smith, 1 CPD 423 (1876). The Sustainability Consortium; HSBC. (2020). Improving Supply Chain Resilience to Manage Climate Change Risks. Transco plc v Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council [2003], UKHL 61 (House of Lords). ▪ Debra Dorrington practised as a property lawyer for many years. She now consults, helping lawyers understand the importance of sustainability in keeping their legal advice relevant. Earlier this year she completed Te Araroa – a 3000km walk that traverses the length of the country. “It’s good for perspective,” she says. You can see more of what she is doing at www. debradorrington.co.nz.


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

COMMERCIAL LEASES

Refusing to renew a commercial lease – do it once, do it right BY M I C H E L L E H I L L A N D G E O R G I A B E V E R L E Y

It may be tempting for a landlord, who wants to refuse the renewal of a commercial lease with a difficult tenant, to reiterate the point. However, the recent High Court decision of SGAH Investments Ltd v Mei Enterprises Ltd1 serves as a warning to landlords to just do it once, but do it right. In SGAH Investments Ltd v Mei Enterprises Ltd, an application for possession following the expiry of a lease, two matters were explored before the Court. SGAH Investments Ltd (SGAH, as landlord of the commercial premises in Clendon, Auckland) sought possession of the premises on the basis the lease to Mei Enterprises Ltd (Mei) had expired, under s 244 of the Property Law Act 2007 (the Act). The second matter saw Mei seek relief against the refusal of SGAH to extend or renew the lease or grant a new lease to Mei, brought under ss 261, 262 and 264 of the Act. Under s 261 of the Act, a tenant may apply for relief against a landlord’s refusal to enter into a renewal of the lease. Under s 262 an application under s 261 must be made within three months from the date the landlord gives notice to the tenant of its refusal to renew the lease. Section 263 outlines the requirements of such a notice from the landlord.

Two notices – which one counts? Landlords need to be aware that issuing several s 263 notices may expand the time within which a tenant can bring a claim for

Michelle Hill

Georgia Beverley

relief against that. In this case the landlord sent two such notices to the tenant – one in August and one in September. The August notice fulfilled the requirements of s 263 and informed Mei that it should be treated as a s 263 notice. However the September notice expressly referred to the statutory requirements of s 263, including the right to apply for relief lapsing if the application is not made “within 3 months of the date of service of this notice” and giving the date of the notice as “23 September 2020”. Even though there was no evidence Mei thought the September notice substituted the August notice and that time ran from September not August, the Court turned to the statutory purpose of s 262 and 263 in determining the September notice as the relevant s 263 notice. The purpose is to ensure that a tenant is properly informed of its rights and the statutory requirements it must satisfy to seek relief under s 261. Accordingly, allowing s 262 notices to be issued in a way that causes confusions is contrary to this purpose. A tenant needs to be clearly informed when time for seeking relief will expire. Therefore where there are two notices that both comply with s 263, the issue of each further notice extinguishes the earlier notice. Therefore Mei brought the claim on time, by filing the application for relief on 1 December 2020, within three months of the September notice.

Next step – should relief be granted? Typically, if a landlord’s refusal to renew a commercial lease is due to rent arrears, the Court will grant relief against a refusal to renew once the rent arrears are paid2. This is based on the principle that the landlord was prepared to contemplate the possibility of renewal at the outset. There are exceptions to this approach, which were unsuccessfully argued in this case. We will go through these now to demonstrate the high standard the Court requires before they will refuse to grant relief against a refusal to renew.

Tenant’s conduct SGAH argued Mei’s breach of the lease twice, in failing to perform maintenance and subleasing the premises without SGAH’s permission, warranted a refusal by the Court to grant Mei relief. The Court held that these concerns

15


are not serious or material enough to the performance of the lease to warrant refusing relief but rather are matters that can be addressed by the parties.

Prejudice to tenant if relief not granted Mei argued it would suffer prejudice if not granted relief. The business, that had operated at the site for 20 years, had complied with all lease obligations and had 2 successful renewals already. Mei argued that the business cannot be relocated elsewhere and that it would not have paid the $840,000 for the business had it not been assured of a long-term lease. The lotto licence it has for its lotto shop was also tied to the premises. Mei said it would have lost the business if it couldn’t operate the business from the premises. The Court held that Mei would suffer prejudice through loss of its business if the lease is not renewed. In terms of the rent arrears, Mei argued that it stopped paying rent because it had lodged a claim that it was entitled to an extension of the lease, and believed that during this time it was entitled to set-off the rent against its claim. Mei, accepting that was wrong, since paid all rent arrears.

Prejudice to landlord if relief granted When considering the prejudice to the landlord, the Court acknowledged Mei’s refusal to pay rent prejudiced SGAH and was inexcusable at the time. The Court also

16

noted SGAH’s scepticism of Mei’s promise to pay rent and the now damaged relationship between the parties. However since Mei had paid all rent arrears, it couldn’t see what prejudice SGAH would suffer if relief was granted to Mei. The Court held the payment of the rent arrears had rectified any prejudice to the landlord.

Landlord’s motivation for the refusal to renew the lease A landlord’s motivation for refusal is another factor that the Court will consider. Here the Court found that, since the rent arrears has been paid, one of the motives SGAH had to refuse to renew the lease was its scepticism that Mei will continue to pay the rent. It was held that since the rent had been paid there was no reasonable basis for refusing to renew the lease. This goes to show that, even if a tenant refused to pay rent for months on end, and as a result the landlord lacks faith in the tenant paying rent on time in the future, if they eventually pay it back, the court will not give much weight to the landlord’s skepticism.

Mei’s bad behaviour The final factor the Court considered was the risk that Mei would continue to behave badly as tenant. The landlord asserted that Mei displayed several occasions of bad behaviour including withholding rent and engaging in a series of “combative actions”3 to pressure SGAH into extending the lease

until 2044. This involved taking SGAH to Court on the basis the Landlord had promised Mei that the lease could be extended, letters of demand for payment from SGAH, a court proceeding in relation to a liquor store business operating within the same block of shops, issuing trespassing notices on SGAH’s shareholders, threatening liquidation proceedings against SGAH without any legal basis and a private prosecution by the director of Mei for perjury against one of SGAH’s shareholders. SGAH argued the conduct of Mei had left the relationship beyond repair. SGAH had also incurred costs greater than $27,500 in these matters. The judge acknowledged that no landlord is likely to grant a 20-year extension to a lease with a Tenant who behaves as Mei did. However the absence of disputes since lease commencement, Mei’s discontinuance of the liquidation proceeding and its payment of rent arrears, showed Mei had rectified its errors and could behave sensibly. The judge therefore concluded that the tenant was entitled to relief under s 261 of the Property Law act 2007. The landlord was accordingly ordered to enter into a new lease with the tenant (in renewal) and the landlord’s application for recovery of the property was dismissed.

Commentary In other cases, neither disharmony and hostility between parties4 nor high degrees of animosity5 were enough to deprive a tenant of a right to renewal of a lease. This case further demonstrates the high standard the Court requires before it will refuse a tenant relief against a landlord’s refusal to renew the lease and the importance of landlords ensuring they get the procedure right if wanting to insist upon their refusal to renew the lease. ▪ Michelle Hill is a Partner at Dentons Kensington Swan in Auckland. This article was written with the assistance of Georgia Beverley, a Solicitor at the firm.

1.

[2021] NZHC 1588

2. SGAH Investments Ltd v Mei Enterprises Ltd [2021] NZHC 1588 at [33] 3. SGAH Investments Ltd v Mei Enterprises Ltd, above n 1, at [60] 4. Saisatnam Ltd v Brandons Trustee Co Ltd [2017] NZHC 538, (2017) 18 NZCPR 215 5. Arthur Devine v Highgate on Broadway Ltd (2011) 13 NZCPR 276


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

The NBEB Exposure Draft and Significant Natural Areas BY H E L E N A N D R E W S There is once again much activity occurring in the resource management space. In this column, we: • Provide an update on the exposure draft of the Natural and Built Environments Bill (NBEB) which was released on 29 June 2021; and • Comment on the issues relating to the identification of significant natural areas (SNA), which have recently received media attention.

Exposure draft of the NBEB In our February 2021 column, we summarised Minister Parker’s recent announcements regarding next steps in the resource management reform process. To recap, the Minister confirmed that as part of this process: • The Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA) is to be repealed and replaced by the Natural and Built Environments Act (or as it will be known prior to enactment, the NBEB); and • Two new statutes will be enacted, neither of which has a current equivalent. These are the Strategic Planning Act (SPB) and Managed Retreat and Climate Change Adaptation Act (CAB). As expected, in this regard the Government has largely adopted the key recommendations from the Resource Management Review Panel (Panel) that it commissioned, to report on what our future resource management system should look like. As part of that announcement, Minister Parker also indicated that an “exposure draft” of the NBEB would be released in late May 2021, once it had been agreed by Cabinet. This draft would contain the broad structure of the NBEB and proposed drafting of its key provisions. In a somewhat unusual step, this draft would be the subject of a Select Committee inquiry, in advance of the full NBEB being the subject of a Select Committee report (as would normally be the case) in due course. For simplicity, we will refer to the exposure draft as the “Bill”, and the full version of the new legislation (which is still to be released) as the NBEB.

So, what does the Bill contain? The Bill contains only 25 clauses, which cover the following: • Preliminary provisions (including interpretation, Part 1); • Purpose and related provisions (Part 2); • National Planning Framework (NPF) (Part 3); and • Natural and Built Environment Plans (Part 4). Further, within those 25 clauses, there are a number of “placeholders”. We also do not yet have a draft of either the SPB or CAB, both of which are intended to be introduced (and operate) in

conjunction with the NBEB. The potential effectiveness of many of the provisions included in the Bill will depend on their relationship with both the remaining provisions of the NBEB and, in some cases, those in the SPB and/or CAB. As such, one of the most important points to note is that it is difficult to fully understand or comment on the potential implications of the Bill when that has been provided in a vacuum, without having the full drafting for all three pieces of proposed legislation.

And does the Bill align with the Panel’s recommendations? Again, as foreshadowed, the Bill largely follows the Panel’s recommendations with respect to the matters that it covers. As such, it does not contain any significant surprises. That said, there are a few notable differences between the Bill and what the Panel recommended. The Panel recommended that the purpose of the NBEA should be to enhance the quality of the natural and built environments, to support the wellbeing of present and future generations, and to recognise the concept of Te Mana o te Taiao. By contrast, the Bill provides that the purpose of the NBEA is to enable Te Oranga o te Taiao to be upheld, and people and communities to use the environment in a way that supports the well-being of present generations, without compromising the well-being of future generations. The list of “outcomes” that must be provided for in order to achieve the purpose of the NBAB has been reduced under the Bill, from those recommended by the Panel. Further, the Bill’s list of outcomes arguably retains a greater focus on the natural environment, than that proposed by the Panel (which was trying to ensure an equal balance on built and natural environment objectives). Notably, the list of outcomes in

17


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

the Bill does not refer to or use the phrase “built environment”. The relevant clause in the Bill is also titled “Environmental Outcomes”, as opposed to just “Outcomes” as recommended by the Panel. The Panel recommended that all existing and new national direction should be brought together into a coherent combined set and any conflicts between them resolved. The Bill takes this one step further, requiring national direction to be collated as the NPF. However, rather than requiring the NPF to resolve conflicts between national direction instruments, the Bill simply requires the NPF to include provisions which “help” to resolve such conflicts. The Bill adopts the Panel’s recommendation that those exercising powers and functions under the NBEB must give effect to the principles of Te Tiriti o Waitangi. This is a much stronger obligation than the current requirement under the RMA to “take into account” those principles. But having done so, the Bill does not require the NPF include mandatory direction as to how decision makers under the NBEA must comply with that obligation. By contrast, the Panel was clear that a national policy statement should be required on how the principles of Te Tiriti are given effect to. Such direction would clarify, for example, the extent to which this provision is intended to provide a “veto” right on development. The Panel recommended that the terms “built environment” and “natural environment” both be defined. By contrast, the Bill only contains a definition of “environment”, which is significantly different from that included in the RMA. In particular, the definition of “environment” in the

conveyit. maestro cloud based conveyancing

Bill refers to both the natural and built environments, and is to be determined “as the context requires”.

What is next for the Bill? Submissions on the Bill closed on 4 August 2021. Those submissions will now be heard by the Environment Select Committee, which is required to provide a report on the Bill by 18 October 2021. Following the Select Committee’s report, a full draft of both the NBEB and SPB (as well as potentially the CAB) are due to be introduced to the House for their first reading in early 2022. There will then be a further opportunity for parties to make submissions on those bills, which we recommend all with an interest in the resource management area take advantage of. We will provide a further update on the reform proposals once the Select Committee’s report on the Bill is released.

Identification of SNAs There has been recent media attention regarding the issue of identifying SNAs, largely due to the exercise being undertaken by the Far North District Council (FNDC) in the process of reviewing its District Plan. This has resulted in concerns from the property sector that large swathes of land could be identified as SNAs, affecting the potential use of the land and accordingly, property values. In that regard, we note that Councils have always had the ability to identify SNAs and include overlays within their planning instruments to protect them, since the RMA was introduced in 1991. So this is not a novel matter. Some of the media reporting inferred that FNDC was required to identify and

map SNAs, in anticipation (or as a result) of a national policy statement for indigenous biodiversity (NPS:IB). That is incorrect. While an NPS:IB is being prepared, that has not yet been promulgated, so does not have any effect. As noted, FNDC was actually undertaking the exercise as part of its District Plan review (which the RMA requires be undertaken every 10 years) and in accordance with the provisions of the Northland Regional Policy Statement (which the District Plan is required to give effect to). The identification of an SNA/imposition of an SNA overlay does not have any particular effect per se, in accordance with the RMA. That is, there are no provisions in the RMA that automatically prohibit certain activities (or impose any particular additional rules), if a property is identified as being subject to an SNA. Rather, the introduction of an SNA must be accompanied by amendments to the text of the relevant planning instrument, which set out the rules relating to activities within an SNA. It is those rules that determine the potential effects of an SNA categorisation. The introduction of an SNA overlay and associated rules must be done by way of a plan review or specific plan change (as is occurring in FNDC). All affected parties would be notified of, and be able to submit on, those new planning provisions, before they come into effect. Hopefully those brief comments provide some clarity on this issue. We will provide further updates on development of the NPS:IB as those come to hand. At present, that is intended to be gazetted by the end of 2021. ▪ Helen Andrews is a Partner at Berry Simons Environmental Law in Auckland.

It’s the cloud based conveyancing software that’s got everyone talking conveyit Maestro is an automated cloud based conveyancing system designed by New Zealand Lawyers for New Zealand Lawyers, Professionals and Conveyancers www.conveyit.co.nz

18

0508 33 22 88


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

A P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R ’ S B R I E F

Leaky building nightmare BY S A R A H W R O E This is Sarah Wroe’s second column, following the great success of the “practical, reallife scenarios” panel session at the 2021 NZLS CLE Property Law Conference. It takes the format of an informal exchange of correspondence between a property lawyer and barrister. Dear Sarah, I would appreciate your views on a terrible situation that my clients are facing. I have just assisted Mr and Mrs Weasley in the purchase of a property from Mr and Mrs Malfoy. The day after they moved in there was a heavy rainstorm. Water started pouring into the lounge at the point where the upper balcony meets the ceiling of the lounge. In the course of 24 hours they collected a couple of buckets of water. The next day as things were drying out, they removed some of the gib on the lounge wall and ceiling. The timber framing behind it is black and rotten. The lounge has been painted and the gib looks new. As you can imagine the Weasleys are devastated. They got a pre-purchase inspection report and that did not pick up any issues. It is a plaster house. They believe that the house must have been leaking for a long time and are very angry that the Malfoys did not tell them about leaks at the property. What should they do? Kind regards Sirius Black Solicitor, Hogwarts

Dear Sirius, How terrible for the Weasleys. An all too common story I am afraid. To advise your clients you will need a lot more information. What follows are some preliminary thoughts and a bit of a download about the things that you should have in mind. As a starting point I suggest that you write to the Malfoys’ solicitors notifying them of the leaks and asking them to confirm if their clients have experienced leaks with the property in the past and whether they have carried out any repair work in relation to leaks during their ownership. You will need to take a full history from the Weasleys. While it is still relatively fresh in their minds get them to write down everything they can remember about conversations with any real estate agent or the vendors themselves. Ask them to try and remember precise words used. Keep copies of all marketing material and if there are marketing videos on YouTube download copies. They should keep a diary of active leaks and take photos and video evidence. If they find evidence of repairs or decoration that has covered up evidence of leaks or damage they should take photographs of that as well. Look out for swollen skirting boards and rusted carpet fixings. They should talk to the neighbours to find out if they know anything about repairs or leaks at the property. The next thing to do is to understand the full extent of the issues. With plaster homes where there is a leak and evidence of rot in one area it is likely that the same will be true in other parts of the house. I suspect that the pre-purchase inspection report will have been carried out by a builder rather than a building surveyor. A building surveyor is qualified to investigate defects and damage. It is too early to say if the pre-purchase inspector has missed defects or damage that should have been identified, but a building surveyor who is registered with the New Zealand Institute of Building Surveyors will be able to advise the Wealseys whether this is an isolated problem or a systemic issue with the house. Building surveyors’ reports are much more expensive than the kind of report that is completed for a pre-purchase inspection as they are much more thorough. A surveyor should be able to identify areas of current defects and damage and any areas where there is a risk of future damage. You will need a copy of the property file which the territorial authority will have for the property. You can either order that yourself or your expert can get hold of it.

19


T H E P R O P E R T Y L A W Y E R

I am sure that the Weasleys will want to limit the damage to their house. They should also be aware that if your clients are thinking about bringing a claim to recover their losses, then they will be under a duty to mitigate their loss. This means that they should take advice on how to mitigate the effect of leaks. They may need to put a tarpaulin up over the balcony. In terms of any potential claim, I presume that the Malfoys were not the builders or developers? Is the property less than 10 years old? If it received a code compliance certificate from the territorial authority within the last 10 years and there are aspects of the construction which do not comply with the building code, then there may be a claim against the territorial authority and the builders and developers of the property. Identifying the date of the code compliance certificate from the property file should be a priority just in case this house has been built in the last ten years. Most plaster homes were built more than ten years ago, but leaky buildings are still being built and certified so do not presume its age. I can understand why the Weasleys must be very angry with the Malfoys. Unless there has been a representation (by words or conduct) which you can show to be false, it may be hard to bring a claim against them. Homeowners often think that if a house leaks they will be told about it. There is no duty in New Zealand for people selling a property to tell purchasers about leaks or defects. The principle of caveat emptor (buyer beware) still applies. Someone selling a house can put it on the market knowing that it leaks and without disclosing it to the potential purchasers – effectively selling it on an “as is where is” basis leaving it to the purchaser to do their own due diligence. This may be unethical, and unwise, but it is not illegal. What

20

vendors cannot do is misrepresent the condition of a property or tell half truths about it. That is why it is always wise for purchasers to ask about leaks or repairs that have been done in the past – “ask me no questions and I’ll tell you no lies”. The situation can be a little different where a real estate agent is acting. If a vendor instructs a real estate agent to represent them in selling the property the real estate agent’s code of conduct imposes duties in relation to the sale of properties that are of a style that is known to be prone to leaking. When selling a plaster home like this one, the real estate agent ought to have either obtained from the vendors a report confirming that the house did

not leak, or have told any potential purchaser that the house is of a style that is known to be prone to leaking. Usually a real estate agent will ask vendors to fill out a questionnaire which includes specific questions about leaks. If a vendor lies to the real estate agent and that carries through to representations or halftruths to buyers, then there may be a claim against the vendor, and possibly the real estate agent under the Fair Trading Act 1986 (although depending on the circumstances the real estate agent may have a “mere conduit” defence). A claim against the Malfoys will depend on what they were told and how the property was presented to them. You will need to understand


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

whether there were any actionable misrepresentations. An expression of opinion or description of the owner’s experience in the house as opposed to a representation about the quality of the house, will usually not be actionable. In some circumstances it may be possible to argue that conduct which conceals defects amounts to a misrepresentation. This is a form of misrepresentation by silence so is not straightforward. If there has been new paint and replaced gib in the lounge, the Weasleys should try and find out the full extent of the repairs prior to sale to see if it can be said to amount to concealment. For example, if the Malfoys have also replaced carpet that has been damaged by leaks or gib elsewhere in the house, the neighbours may have noticed and may be able to tell them more about what was done. The other thing to find out is whether the Malfoys lived in the house or had tenants. If they owned it as an investment property, they may have been in trade when they sold it to the Weasleys. This will open up the possibility of a claim under the Fair Trading Act for misleading and deceptive conduct.

An expression of opinion or description of the owner’s experience in the house as opposed to a representation about the quality of the house, will usually not be actionable. In some circumstances it may be possible to argue that conduct which conceals defects amounts to a misrepresentation

If there are indeed systemic defects in the property, then it may be that the pre-purchase inspector did not do his job. A building surveyor can also comment on what a pre-purchase inspector should have picked up issues and whether they have followed the New Zealand Standard for reporting. There may well be a claim in negligence, contract and under the Fair Trading Act 1986 against the inspector. Check the terms of the contract for any disclaimers or limitation of liability. A lot of pre-purchase inspectors operate as sole traders through a company and there is often not insurance in place that would cover damages or much in the way of assets to meet any claim so it will be important to identify any other possible defendants. These cases are very fact specific. Here are some examples of cases of misrepresentation and leaks – as you’ll see, the results for the unsuspecting purchasers are mixed: White v Zadeh [2020] NZHC 3221; Mitchell v Murphy [2019] NZHC 3262; Ridgway Empire Ltd v Grant [2019] NZCA 134 (leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was refused); Shen v Ossyanin [2019] NZHC 2430; Magee v Mason [2017] NZCA 502. (PS – how is that lovely godson of yours getting on? Staying out of trouble I hope?) Kind regards Sarah Wroe Barrister Sarah Wroe is a barrister practising from Eldon Chambers in central Auckland. The editor welcomes ideas for future scenarios that readers would like to see covered in this column. Please email them to property@ lawsociety.org.nz, with The Property Lawyer in the subject line.

21


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

MĀORI LAND

Changes to succession under the Te Ture Whenua Māori Act 1993 BY C L A I R E T Y L E R

A Māori landowner died and was survived by her second husband and five children from her first marriage. As she did not leave a will, the second husband was able to obtain a life interest to her Māori land interests under the intestacy provisions of Te Ture Whenua Māori Act 1993 (the Act), notwithstanding that he did not whakapapa to the land. This meant that the children were unable to make any decisions about the land they had whakapapa to, while the husband had voting rights and was entitled to receive any income from the Māori land interests. This would continue until the second husband died, entered a new relationship, or surrendered his interest. Changes to this part of the Act came into effect on Waitangi Day this year, with one significant change being to succession and the rights of descendants. Before the changes came into effect, a deceased landowners’ interests in land could pass to their surviving partner or spouse even if

22

that person did not whakapapa to the land. As outlined above, descendants who did whakapapa to the land would often not be entitled to succeed to their land interest or shares until the partner or spouse died, entered a new relationship, or surrendered their interest. Under the new amendment, when a landowner dies leaving a spouse, descendants can apply immediately to succeed to the Māori land interest. The surviving partner or spouse of the landowner does not receive the land interest but can receive income from the land and occupy the family home,

if the family home is on Māori land. The benefit for descendants is that they are now able to be involved as owners of the land and exercise their voting rights sooner, which means they are now able to connect with and make decisions about their land. This can be compared with what happens when a person with interests in Māori land dies and leaves a will. Under the Act, a person can only leave these interests to select classes of people. These are: • their children or further direct descendants; • people who are blood relations of the testator and are also members of the hapu associated with the land; • other owners of the land who are also members of the hapu associated with the land; • people who would be entitled to succeed to the interest if the testator did not leave a will (as discussed above); and • trustees of any of the above. This will still be subject to the right of a surviving spouse or partner to live in the family home and earn income from the land. If the will-maker leaves their interest to anyone who does not fall into one of the classes above, that clause in the Will will be of no effect, and the interest will then be passed on as if the deceased did not leave a will, as discussed above. Any practitioners advising on succession to Maori land need to be aware of these changes to ensure they are giving correct advice. ▪ Claire Tyler is a Partner at Rainey Collins in Wellington.


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

E S TAT E A D M I N I S T R AT I O N

IRD, estates and MyTrove BY S H A R O N C O R N W E L L

Hidden amid the flurry of tax announcements recently, comes some good news in the form of an Operational Statement from the Commissioner of the Inland Revenue (CIR) setting out a change in the approach to applying the income tax filing exemption in s 43B of the Tax Administration Act 1994 to estates. Operational statements are used to set out the CIR’s view of the law and deal with practical issues arising from the administration of the Inland Revenue Acts. Section 43 allows trustees of non-active trusts to be excused from the obligation to file income tax returns if the trust meets certain requirements. Historically, the CIR’s general approach is that s 43B only applies to non-active trusts. On the basis that an “estate” is different from a “trust”, this approach did not apply to estates that derive no income. The CIR has now modified this position to accept there may be occasions during the administration of an estate where the estate property is held on trust and the s 43B exemption can apply. The CIR has recognised that sometimes during the administration of an estate a trust can arise, and that trust may qualify under section 43B. For estates a trust will arise when all debts have been paid and the remaining property is ready for distribution. At that point it could be said the remaining property is being held on trust by the executors or administrators effectively changing their capacity to trustees. If at this point the property being held by the trustees is not generating any income, then section 43B may apply. What has not changed is the CIR’s position in relation to the requirements regarding income tax filing and applying for a separate IRD number for the estate: • For income derived by a deceased person until the date of death, executors and administrators must meet whatever filing and income tax obligations the deceased would have had if they had lived; • The executors and administrators must also obtain a separate IRD number for the estate and make returns for income derived in the years following death. Many executors and administrators are unaware that they need to obtain a separate IRD number for the estate, often discovering this aspect in the lead up to settlement of a transmission or transfer of land. Aside from being necessary for land transfer, an application for an IRD number for the estate also ensures the Inland Revenue Department (IRD) knows

of the death and can then review the final tax position pre-death of the deceased. Notifying the IRD will ensure the following: • any final income return to the date of death and arrange for a refund or advice of any tax to pay to the date of death; • avoid penalties on tax owing; • any child support owed is paid, or any child support due is paid to their estate; • any changes to a Working for Families situation; • student loans • transfer of KiwiSaver funds that IRD hold to the estate. These compulsory steps of notifying of death and applying for an IRD number are not difficult tasks in these times. Notifying the IRD and other organisations of a death has been made easier by the free web service MyTrove (www.mytrove. co.nz) and an IRD number for the estate can be easily applied for on-line via the IRD website. The following maps out the usual steps when utilising these resources: Once you have entered the details in MyTrove, selected the entities you wish to advise of the death and uploaded any requested documents

(such as the death certificate) those entities will be notified and they will each contact you in due course. A response from the IRD after notifying them via MyTrove (relating to the individual up to date of death): “Thank you for your notification through MYTROVE to advise of the passing of [name of deceased]. We have now finalised and closed Inland Revenue record for [name of deceased]. There are no outstanding returns, debits, credits or any further obligations to Inland Revenue.” Applying for an IRD number for the estate can be done by completing the online form via the IRD website and providing a copy of the death certificate and/or probate. The IRD will notify you directly with the estate IRD number. Some executors overlook or fail to understand their obligations to apply for an IRD number, believing that if income is taxed at source there are no obligations to the IRD or that estates do not need IRD numbers at all. Are executors and administrators sure that no income is being generated – have all investments pre death and after death been taxed at the right rate? Has a property of the estate been rented and still being rented? Has the deceased invested in peer-to-peer lending and receiving small amounts of interest? When an estate has a house to sell then an IRD number will be required and also should funds be held on interest bearing deposit the estate will also need to have an IRD number -failing to provide an IRD number to the bank holding funds

23


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

CONSTRUCTION CONTINUED FROM PAGE 23 on deposit in an estate results in a higher tax rate deduction. It is compulsory to have an IRD number, but this does not mean you are required to file an income return if there is no income received. To close off the estate IRD number contact accountclosure@ird.govt.nz and advise them that the estate has been distributed and no further income will be received and request the account be closed. Currently you can select the following entities to be notified via MyTrove: • IRD • DIA • Westpac • TSB • Asteron • Fidelity Life • Partners Life • Resolution Life MyTrove has advised that they are also working with other entities such as MSD, other insurance companies and banks and also working with IRD to enable users to apply for the estate IRD number via MyTrove. Obtaining the IRD number for the estate at the beginning of the administration process will ensure any liability to the IRD has been dealt with prior to the final distribution. There are then the flow on benefits that that when the estate is fully distributed and the IRD confirms the account is closed, an executor and administrator can be assured that no further steps are required. This process is far more efficient than having the IRD contacting the executor and administrator at a much later date saying a return is required and they then have to spend time collating information well after the administration file has been closed. ▪ Sharon Cornwell is a Registered Legal Executive at DK Law in Auckland.

24

Construction Contracts (Retention Money) Amendment Bill BY H A M I S H B O L L A N D

The Construction Contracts (Retention Money) Amendment Bill to repair the defects in the Construction Contracts Act retentions regime, particularly in relation to the protections available to payees, had its first reading on 8 June and is currently before the Transport and Infrastructure Select Committee. The Government laid out the key changes last June and we have been waiting for the Bill’s introduction to get a better grip on the detail. There is a lot to absorb. We run through the main elements.

Commentary The Bill deals with many of the problems which have bedevilled the existing regime, but may give rise to issues of its own if passed in its current form. We identify the key takeaways below. A statutory trust arises as soon as retention money is retained, regardless of whether actual cash is set aside. This prevents subcontractors missing out if a non-compliant retention holder becomes insolvent – as happened with Ebert Construction Ltd. But if no cash is set aside, where are the trust assets? The Courts will likely answer that question by

reference to decisions related to a similar statutory trust in section 167(1) of the Tax Administration Act 1994. If a payer fails to pay an amount due under a construction contract, the payer must set aside the retention portion of that amount on trust for the payee. Given the new penalties discussed below, directors of struggling construction companies may find themselves personally liable to pay a fine if there is no money to set aside. Reporting requirements will now be written into the statute. These were meant to have been prescribed by regulation, but that never happened. There is, however, a lack of clarity which we hope will be dealt with at the select committee stage. • On the one hand, reporting must be provided with every payment schedule, which could mean monthly if the contract provides for monthly payment claims (amendment to section 21), but • on the other hand, reporting is to be provided at least once every three months, whether or not a payment schedule is required (new section 18FD). It is unclear whether this must be provided in addition to the reporting contained in the payment schedule.


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

We think that in practice most contracts will end up with monthly reporting and we wonder whether this was the intention of the drafters. Directors will be personally liable for fines up to $50,000, and firms will be liable up to $200,000. Receivers and liquidators will automatically become trustees of retention money. This makes sense for liquidators who are tasked with winding up the affairs of the company, but may be controversial for receivers who are tasked with realising value for the appointing secured creditor. The legislation is also unclear about who will be responsible for administering the retention trust when multiple insolvency practitioners are appointed to a company (i.e. more than one receiver or a receiver and a liquidator).

Key changes Provisions in the Construction Contracts (Retention Money) Amendment Bill include: • amending the definition of ‘Retention Money’ to include any amount withheld, and the retainable portion of an amount the payee is liable to pay but does not pay • all the rules of the common law and equity relating to trusts apply to retention trusts. This means that: • party A must keep the retention money separate from other money and assets • in dealing with the retention money, party A must act in the best interests of party B • party A cannot use the retention money except: • to remedy any defects in the performance of party B’s obligations under the contract, and • to pay party B when required by the contract, and • if party A goes into receivership or liquidation, the retention money cannot be taken by the receiver or liquidator to meet party A’s other debts • retention money must be held in a trust account in a registered bank in New Zealand or in the form of a complying instrument (such as an insurance policy or guarantee) that requires an insurance company, a bank, or another prescribed issuer to pay to party B an amount equal to the retention money if party A does not pay the retention money to party B when required by the construction contract • party A must keep all of party B’s retention money under a particular contract in the same account. There can be other retention money in the same account. The bank account cannot be used for any other purpose. If a single account is used for multiple party’s retention money, party A must keep proper accounting records showing to which party and which contract each payment into or out of the account was made • retention holders must issue regular ‘transparency reports’ (as soon as practicable after money is first retained and then every three months) so that payees can be satisfied that the responsibilities imposed in the Act are being met and that their rights are protected. Currently the documentation is only available

on request • if party A withholds retention money, or already holds retention money on behalf of the payee, any payment schedule must include the details required in such ‘transparency reports’ • if party A is the Crown, the retention money must be held in accordance with the provisions in the Public Finance Act 1989 instead of the provisions of this Act • failing to comply with retention obligations is an offence which will attract maximum penalties of $200,000 for firms and $50,000 for company directors. There is a defence to liability if the defendant proves: • that party A took all reasonable steps to ensure that it complied with its obligations, or • if the defendant is a director, that they took all reasonable steps to ensure that party A complied with its obligations. • failing to keep proper accounting and other records of all retention money and failing to issue regular ‘transparency reports’ are both offences with a maximum penalty of $50,000 • if party A becomes insolvent, the receiver or liquidator becomes trustee of the retention money for the purposes of collecting and distributing it (and is entitled to be paid reasonable fees and costs from the trust). The retention money is subject to the trust and cannot be used to meet party A’s other debts, thereby protecting the Contractor from party A’s creditors, and • the amendments will only apply to construction contracts entered into after this Bill commences or entered into before that date but amended afterwards. However, the new sections 18J to 18L (which relate to receivership and liquidation) apply in all cases if party A goes into receivership or liquidation after this Bill commences.

Next steps The Bill is due to be reported back from the select committee on 11 November 2021. ▪ Hamish Bolland is a Partner at Chapman Tripp in Auckland.

25


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

AML/CFT

Amendment Regulations relating to the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Act 2009 BY S C O T T A B E L A N D L A R A W O O D

In June 2021, a suite of four amendment regulations relating to the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) regime were published. These amendments will come into force on 9 July 2021. In particular, the suite of amendment regulations expands and amends reporting entities’ customer due diligence (CDD) duties and obligations where they have customers that are companies or limited partnerships (LPs). In such instances, reporting entities will need to establish whether their customer has any nominee directors, nominee shareholders or nominee general partners, verify information about such persons in the prescribed manner and, where such nominees exist, to undertake enhanced CDD. Reporting entities should consider how the changes might affect their AML/CFT obligations and processes.

Background The Anti-Mo ney Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Act 2009 (the AML/CFT Act) is currently supported by a suite of six regulations1 (Regulations) that prescribe additional requirements in a number of areas. Two of the existing Regulations were set to expire in 20212. These Regulations had expiry dates as they were new and untested when the Regulations were issued, and the expiry dates were designed to ensure a review took place within five years3. In October 2019, prompted by these expiry dates, the Ministry of Justice began a process of consultation with various stakeholders. 19 submissions were received from a variety of industry stakeholders and most were generally supportive of the proposals. The consultation aimed to identify whether changes or updates were needed to the current AML/CFT regime to ensure that the Regulations remained fit for purpose in the current money laundering and terrorism financing risk environment. In March 2020, the Cabinet Economic Development Committee

26

published a Cabinet Paper and Cabinet Minute, taking the review as an opportunity to update the suite of Regulations as well as remove the expiry dates for the expiring Regulations. We outline the key changes made in in this article.

Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Requirements and Compliance) Amendment Regulations 2021 The Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism ( R e q u i r e m e n t s a n d C o m p l i a n c e) Amendment Regulations 2021 amends the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Requirements and Compliance) Regulations 2011. Some of the key changes are as follows: • Introduces definitions of key terms, including ‘nominee director’, ‘nominee general partner’ and ‘nominee shareholder’4; • Introduces a requirement for a reporting entity to obtain information about whether a customer which is a company or LP (on whom it is conducting customer due diligence (CDD)) has nominee directors, nominee general partners and/or nominee shareholders. This is in response to the Financial Action Task Force’s recommendations that all jurisdictions should put measures in place to ensure that nominee directors are not misused5 • Introduces a requirement for a reporting entity to conduct enhanced CDD for a customer that is a company with nominee director(s) or a customer that is a nominee general partner of a limited


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

partnership/overseas limited partnership • Replaces the requirement to audit a reporting entity’s risk assessment and compliance programme every 2 years under section 59(2) of the AML/CFT Act with a default requirement to do this every 3 years. This change is intended to assist medium and low-risk reporting entities by lowering their compliance burden.6 Once the regulations are in force, all AML/CFT audits will be required every three years, subject to the AML/CFT supervisors’ assessment of a reporting entity’s money laundering and terrorism financing risk. The AML/CFT supervisors will notify the reporting entity if it is required to have an audit more or less frequently than every three years.

Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Exemptions) Amendment Regulations 2021 The Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Exemptions) Amendment Regulations 2021 amends the AntiMoney Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Exemptions) Regulations 2011 (Exemptions Regulations). Some of the key changes are as follows: • Expands the exemption provided to related entities to also capture entities that are not body corporates. This exemption allows for a person to be exempt from the AML/CFT Act if their only customers are related entities. As a result, regulation 16 of the Exemptions Regulations is amended to contain the full definition of a ‘related’ entity, rather than refer to section 12(2) of the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013 • Clarifies that regulation 11 of the Exemptions Regulations applies to life insurers only, more specifically life insurers that provide relevant insurance policies that are closed to new customers and

new premiums are exempt from the AML/CFT Act • Prevents the use of structuring (in relation to the stored value instrument exemption in regulation 15 of the Exemption Regulations) to avoid obligations under the AML/CFT Act, by providing that the maximum possible value thresholds in regulation 15(1) (a) and (b) of the Exemptions Regulations apply to the combined total maximum value of all stored value instruments issued that are of the same kind • Consolidates the exemptions applying to relevant services provided under premium funding agreements by insurance companies and non-insurance companies (previously regulations 17 and 18) into one regulation (new regulation 17) • Inserts new exemptions for relevant services provided: • by court-appointed liquidators • in respect of certain third party payments made by a designated non-financial business or profession • to a person that is the subject of a Commissioner of Police’s order or a production order • by a reporting entity acting as executor or administrator of an estate • to an executor or administrator of an estate.

Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Definitions) Amendment Regulations 2021 The Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Definitions) Amendment Regulations 2021 amends the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Definitions) Regulations 2011 (Definitions Regulations). Some of the key changes are as follows: • Clarifies that a company in liquidation is a ‘customer’ of a court-appointed liquidator under the AML/CFT Act

• Prescribes that related limited partnerships may be members of a designated business group under the AML/CFT Act • Clarifies that services as an executor, administrator or trustee are excluded from being a financial activity under the AML/CFT Act • Clarifies that a person carrying out any property management activity is not managing client funds, accounts, securities or other assets for the purposes of the application of designated non-financial business or profession under the AML/CFT Act • Amends CDD timeframes for real estate agents carrying out agency work in relation to commercial leases – the real estate agent must conduct CDD before the real estate agent presents an offer of lease to the landlord of the commercial property.

Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Cross-border Transportation of Cash) Amendment Regulations 2021 The Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Cross-border Transportation of Cash) Amendment Regulations 2021 amends the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (Cross-border Transportation of Cash) Regulations 2010 (CBTC Regulations). It replaces the prescribed form for a border cash report in the Schedule of the CBTC Regulations with an updated list of information that this cash report must contain. This information remains substantially the same as the previous schedule. The change allows for the regulations to prescribe the information instead of the actual form that must be used, modernising the regime by allowing modern approaches to declaring cash movements, such as through using an electronic form. ▪ Scott Abel is a Partner and Lara Wood is Special Counsel at Buddle Findlay in Auckland.

1.

AML/CFT (Cross-border Transportation of Cash) Regulations 2010; AML/ CFT (Definitions) Regulations 2011; AML/CFT (Exemptions) Regulations 2011; AML/CFT (Ministerial Exemption Form) Regulations 2011; AML/ CFT (Prescribed Transaction Reporting) Regulations 2016; AML/CFT (Requirements and Compliance) Regulations 2011.

2. AML/CFT (Exemptions) Regulations 2011 which expire on 30 June 2021 and AML/CFT (Definitions) Regulations 2011 which partially expire on 27 July 2021. 3. Office of the Minister of Justice Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Act 2009 – Expiring Regulations and New Regulatory Proposals (Cabinet paper, 18 March 2020) at [2]. 4. “nominee director” – an individual who is a director and who is required to carry out or accustomed to carrying out that role in accordance with the directions or instructions of someone who is not a director; “nominee general partner” – a person who is a general partner of a limited partnership and who is required to carry out or accustomed to carrying out that role in accordance with the directions or instructions of someone who is not a general partner; and “nominee shareholder” – a person who is a shareholder and who is required to carry out or accustomed to carrying out that role in accordance with the directions or instructions of someone who is not a shareholder (with certain limited exceptions). 5. Office of the Minister of Justice Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Act 2009 – Expiring Regulations and New Regulatory Proposals (Cabinet paper, 18 March 2020) at [35]. 6. Office of the Minister of Justice Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Act 2009 – Expiring Regulations and New Regulatory Proposals (Cabinet paper, 18 March 2020) at [45].

27


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

PROFILE

Ken Lord talks about being a Notary Public Ken Lord tells us about himself and his experience being a Notary Public to help raise awareness of the shortage of notaries in New Zealand, particularly in rural areas. To encourage others to become Notaries Public, Ken shares some insights.

My background I joined Parry Field Lawyers in 1980 and became a partner that same year. My focus was on Property and Personal law including trusts and asset planning with strong interests in issues relating to the charitable sector, assisting the elderly and charitable trusts. As one of the authors of the LexisNexis Law of Trusts, I have written, and continue to review, the chapter devoted to charity law, as well as chapters in the LexisNexis publication The Law and Practice of Charities in New Zealand. G r a d u a t i n g L L B f ro m t h e University of Canterbury in 1977, I completed a BA in English and Russian literature in 2004, a BA Hons in 2020, and am now preparing for my master’s degree in English literature. I have taken an active part in the New Zealand Law Society, having spoken at Law Society Conferences, been a member of property law committees, seminar/conference organisation and committees. I served as Convenor for the Trusts and Wills Committee, was a member of the Canterbury Westland NZLS Standards Committee, and a Mediator. Retiring from the partnership in

28

2019, I remain a Consultant and Notary Public.

What does a Notary Public do? The role of a notary includes witnessing signatures on contracts, birth registrations, powers of attorney and a multitude of other documents for use in many overseas countries, particularly in recent times, given current travel restrictions. Notaries also certify copies of original documents, like passports, driver licences, and degrees and diplomas.

Becoming a notary In 2013, I became a notary because a friend of mine was one for many years and suggested I do so. I am pleased I did, as I have found the

work to be varied and interesting. What appears to be simple can swiftly become complicated. In the words of Kathryn Burns, author of the research paper Notaries, Truth, and Consequences in The American Historical Review, notaries are “truth’s alchemists… [and provide] protection and gateways to the legal system”. For example, I was involved with two contrasting tasks, the sale of a trading ship and retrieval of an old but much-loved vehicle from NZ customs. For the sale of the trading ship, a notary was required by both the overseas vendors and purchasers to witness directors’ signatures on a contract for a ship sale worth millions of dollars. The notarial act was the final seal, following which the crews waiting at the local port could change hands, an example of the work of notaries as “crucial cogs” in commerce. Just as satisfying was the ability to assist the occasional distraught car owner, one recently returned from Australia, whose car could not be released from customs until a notarial certificate evidenced enquiries by the notary with Australian authorities as to ownership, the owner having lost papers in the move, enabling release to the happy owner within a few hours. In the same way as the notary Roderigo de Escobedo stood alongside Columbus as he ‘discovered’ America, documenting for the King and Queen of Spain, the evidence for Columbus’ incessant demands for more ships and resources, so the notary today must be the person on the spot to ensure, as far as possible, that what seems to be the case, whether it be an allegation of ownership, a degree, a passport, or a signature, is the truth.

Benefits of being a notary The benefits are many and varied, including providing an important public service to a wide cross-section of the community. Notarial fees are always less than the usual legal charge-out rates because notaries are providing a service to members of the public. However, notaries in New Zealand are appointed for life which means that notaries may continue to provide notary services well after retirement from or ceasing legal practice. Skills gleaned from the practice of the law are fully utilised as we draft our notarial certificates. National and international collegiality is another benefit, including making friends with notaries from Australia, England, Singapore, Canada, USA and Europe at international conferences. A conference is planned for the Hague, Covid permitting.

Is it time to consider becoming a notary? In New Zealand, there is a shortage of notaries, especially


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

LAND TITLES in rural areas. The current cohort of notaries is ideally in need of younger notaries, to ensure succession in the notary profession, and the Society of Notaries can continue to provide a comprehensive public service across New Zealand.

How to become a notary public The process of becoming a notary, while not difficult, does take time, and money. To become a notary, you apply to the New Zealand Society of Notaries to be admitted as a Notary to the Faculty Office of the Archbishop of Canterbury in London. You need to have 10 years’ experience as a lawyer and must have been a law firm partner or sole practitioner for at least 5 years. A Certificate of Good Standing must be obtained from the New Zealand Law Society. If the application satisfies the Council of the New Zealand Society of Notaries’ criteria, all members are then asked to comment. If Council approves the application, the applicant must undertake a study course and undertake to remain a society member once they are a member. An application is then made to the Archbishop of Canterbury in London, through the Faculty Office, accompanied by the written support of a substantial number of business, banking and professional people, who are not lawyers. Once the faculty is granted, the Notary is sworn in by a High Court judge, joins the New Zealand Society, pays the fees, obtains their seals and press, and has their signature and seal sent to both the Society and the Department of Internal Affairs. They may then act as a notary. ▪ Visit the New Zealand Society of Notaries website for full details on how to apply to become a notary: www.notarypublic.org.nz. Source: www.lawsociety.org.nz

New Landonline services A taste of the future Toitū Te Whenua Land Information New Zealand is modernising Landonline, the NZ Title and Survey register which holds the official record of more than 2.6 million parcels of land. Landonline is world-class but, at 20 years old needs to be modernised to ensure it integrates with modern software, is future proofed, and can deliver better services to its customers.

Consulting Solicitor for the Modernising Landonline programme Andrea Watson says the work is being delivered in phases. “This means we’re able to make new services available regularly, rather than all at the end of the programme. It also means we’re able to add new features and tweaks based on customer feedback,” she says. There have been three new features released recently- Web Search, Notice of Change and Notice to Mortgagee.

Web Search – find it faster Searching land records has been made easier. The new tool, Web Search, is a taste of future Landonline. It’s easier to use, more intuitive and reduces some hassles of the older system such as session timeouts. Searching land records has also been made faster. Web Search can be accessed from a web browser on any computer or device with a Landonline username and password. Land records can be searched and ordered using key information such as address, title reference or registered owner. The system is intuitive and suggests search results as you type. There’s also an

interactive visual map view, using aerial imagery, that assists in finding the right location. Andrea says LINZ is regularly releasing more functionality into Web Search. “We have recently added the ability to order multiple titles from the search results screen, and to view statutory actions on parcels,” she says. Fees for Web Search are the same as for searches in Legacy Landonline and are integrated into the same invoice.

Streamlining conveyancing Conveyancing professionals have an obligation to advise the relevant Territorial Authorities when ownership on a title changes. The Modernising Landonline programme has created an option to complete

29


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

▸S olicitor and surveyor customers testing prototypes as part of regular co-design workshops

this process within an e-dealing, improving data accuracy, reducing manual effort, improving timeliness of notification and streamlining the end-to-end process. The new Notice of Change (NoC) can be used when completing a transfer (T), transmission (TSM), change/correction of name (CN), TPS, CO or A90 instrument for titles in participating Territorial Authorities including Tauranga City, Wellington City, Marlborough District, Western Bay of Plenty District, Central Otago District, Napier City, and Taupo District with more coming soon. In the prepare instrument screen, a Notice of Change button (“Add NoC”) will appear at the bottom of the window, which will launch the NoC form. The form will auto-populate most of the required information from the e-dealing and from the Territorial Authorities’ records. All finalised NoCs will automatically send as soon as the instrument is registered. The new Notice to Mortgagee feature automatically sends subscribed lenders copies of mortgage instruments and updated Records of Title upon registration. All that is needed is to insert the ‘bank client ref ’ specified in the lender’s letter of instruction on the post registration search screen. This new field is enabled for any mortgages to subscribed lenders. This replaces the need for the post registration searches to be manually forwarded to lenders by the acting solicitor. “Rather than just looking at our piece of the puzzle, we’ve looked at the whole process and how we can help make things easier for our customers,” explains Andrea. Notice of Change of ownership is being rolled out geographically and Notice to Mortgagee is steadily adding participating banks and lending institutions. As each Territorial Authority or lender comes on board, the option to use the new service

30

will show up for eligible transactions. Find out more about how to use the NoC and which Territorial Authorities are participating on the LINZ website help pages https://help. notices.landonline.govt.nz/general.

Working with customers Customers are at the centre of the Landonline modernisation. There are working groups and pilots and the team is constantly reaching out for customer feedback on what’s being worked on. Right now, there’s a small technical pilot for creating dealings in the modernised Landonline. This will expand throughout the year and is planned to be released to all e-dealing customers next year. Once rolled out, customers will be able to transact some of the most common instruments in the

modernised Landonline. Andrea says our customers like what we’re doing. “We are hearing a lot about Web Search right now. Words like easier, better, and faster pop up a lot, and we’re often told that from the first time customers use it, there’s no looking back.” “What we really want our customers to consider is: don’t wait. Start using the new services now and enjoy the additional features and improvements along the way. It also gives you a taste of what’s to come, and how the new Landonline will look and feel.” ▪ Fo r m o r e i n f o r m a t i o n o n Modernising Landonline or to provide feedback, head to www.linz. govt.nz/land/landonline or contact LINZ via modernisinglandonline@ linz.govt.nz.


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

BOOK REVIEW

Land Registration and Title Security in the Digital Age New horizons for Torrens BY J O H N G R E E N W O O D

The text put together by Professor David Grinlinton of the University of Auckland, Faculty of Law and Associate Professor Rod Thomas of AUT Law School, comprises a collection of essays following the conference in 2018 styled as “New Horizons for Torrens”. The focus of the text is a very worthwhile collection of experiences in dealing with the new world of automation. It includes essays from authors with experience in Australia, England and Wales, Ireland, Scotland, the Netherlands and from Canada, with a presentation from the Director of Titles for the Province of Ontario. One of the themes throughout the text is the concern of controls being gradually eroded by centralised government agencies, legal practitioners, contractors and IT specialists with the focus centred on title security, competencies of registry performance under automation principles, and emerging challenges. The text is divided into three Parts. The first Part covers an examination of recent developments and current issues. This includes an examination of the scope of indefeasibility as currently applied in various Torrens jurisdictions and in particular examines the scope of fraud being the exception to indefeasibility as presented by William

Gummow, a former Justice of the High Court in Australia. Included is Fiona Burns’ chapter on the historical influences and recent jurisprudence of “in personam claims”. There is also a very useful chapter by Associate Professor Rod Thomas and Neil Campbell, analysing the new definition of fraud in the Land Transfer Act 2017. The final chapter in Part 1 of the text is by Thomas Gibbons discussing concerns raised over the operation of covenants and encumbrances in the New Zealand environment. Part 2 traverses the current state of automation of land registries from a number of different overseas jurisdictions. Part 3 of the text contains a potpourri of current issues and emerging challenges, including the privatisation of land registries and considers the question of who actually “owns” the information. A few extracts from some of the authors highlight the challenges ahead: • Sir Peter Blanchard commented: “Once again, the expression ‘indefeasibility’ or ‘indefeasible title’ is not used in the draft Bill, nor does it appear in the Act. But the concept has been retained. As now appears in section 51(1) of the 2017 Act, on registration of a person as owner of an estate or interest in land, that person obtains title to the estate or

interest that cannot be set aside.” • A counter to the Torrens rule of indefeasibility, Professor Reid from the University of Edinburgh made this observation: “Torrens title is an elusive ideal; his title is subject to defeasibility through error inherited in a human system. To whatever that extent Torrens can acquire an interest from a predecessor through error, is vulnerable to losing that interest to the same error repeated after his registration”. He also makes the observation that the Torrens tradition in New Zealand is instinctively pro-purchaser, while in Scotland there is no legal equivalence between the owner and the purchaser. It seems title is able to be challenged in the Scotland jurisdiction for reasons other than fraud. • Associate Professor Rod Thomas notes a number of improvements that could be made to the automation system such as introducing a pre-approval regime of dealings; providing training for practitioners who obtain a licence to lodge and improving the verification of ownership and ability to transact. • Professor Elizabeth Toomey’s paper provided a thought-provoking discussion on her disquiet at the concept of manifest injustice with the possible result that an innocent bona fide purchaser can be deprived of obtaining their

31


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

CONTINUED FROM PAGE 31 interest in a property purchased, while the innocent vendor can have their title reinstated. • Finally, there is an excellent analysis by Dr Ben France-Hudson of the University of Otago in the Supreme Court decision in Green Growth No2 Limited v Queen Elizabeth II National Trust [2018] NZSC 75, where the majority of the Court considered that registered documents “should be construed without regard to extrinsic evidence which is particular to the original parties and is not apparent on the face of the register”. Ben also noted in his paper “The decision presented: a hard-edged, and hard-nosed rule reinforces and upholds Torrens principles and would facilitate the continued certainty, economy, simplicity and facility of the transfer and ownership of land”. Overall, the text presents an opportunity for practitioners to understand the backdrop to indefeasibility and acknowledges the strengths and weaknesses of automation with there being some authors holding a somewhat sceptical view of privatisation, while a number of authors voiced the need to better prepare for the verification of identity of owners, such as through biometrics, and to see better outcomes given the reduced expertise of technical staff within LINZ. The book is highly recommended for those practitioners involved in the conveyancing world, giving an insight into the rationale behind indefeasibility and why it might need to be revisited in some cases. ▪ Land Registration and Title Security in the Digital Age is available from www.routledge.com. ISBN 9780367211776. Published April 30, 2020 by Informa Law from Routledge. 438 Pages

32

Westlaw AU case notes 0 6 M AY 2 0 2 1 T O 2 0 J U LY 2 0 2 1 Full copies of judgments summarised in this service are available through Thomson Reuters judgment service. You can order judgments by emailing service@thomsonreuters.co.nz. Include your name, phone number and how you want the judgment delivered (post, fax, DX). Please provide as much detail about the judgment as you can! (Name, Judge, Court etc).

BUILDING CONSENT BNZ Branch Properties Ltd v Wellington City Council 12/5/2021, Clark J, High Court, Wellington, [2021] NZHC 1058 Building– Consent– Erection Building– Regulation– Construction– Compliance certificate Building– Regulation– Construction– Defects Building– Regulation– Construction– Inspection Civil procedure– Pleadings– Striking out Tort– Negligence– Breach of duty of care

Unsuccessful application by Beca Carter Hollings & Ferner Ltd (‘BCHFL’) for orders striking out WCC’s claim against it, or alternatively summary judgment against WCC on all causes of action against it; original proceedings were brought by BBPL, which managed properties of its parent company BNZ Ltd (‘BNZL’) following Kaikoura earthquake in 2016; in 2006 CentrePort Ltd, which owned land at Waterloo Quay, Wellington, agreed to build a building on the land to meet specific requirements of BNZL, which would then lease it; BNZL leased premises from February 2011; building suffered irreparable damage in Kaikoura earthquake and had to be demolished; BNZL and BBPL sought damages from WCC for alleged negligence in granting building consent application for building superstructure; WCC filed proceedings against

BCHFL and Professor Mander, who BCHFL engaged to peer review design details; BCHFL claimed WCC was out of time under 10 year limitation provision in s 393(2) of the Building Act 2004 (‘BA’) as acts/omissions relied on ended by March 2008 and WCC filed its claim in September 2019; BCHFL argued Courts had rejected existence of continuing duty of care as means to extend time limit; WCC focused on primacy of right of a tortfeasor to recover from another tortfeasor. Held, before proceedings could be struck out, the causes of action must be shown to be so clearly untenable they could not succeed; for summary judgment against WCC BCHFL must show on balance of probabilities that proceedings were statute-barred; it was unclear from decisions on which BCHFL relied whether Courts were invited, as Court was in this proceeding, to engage with legislative history of provisions solidifying right to claim contribution; s 34 of the Limitation Act 2010 (‘LA2010’) contained competing limitation period to that in s 393(2) of the BA; previous Limitation Act 1950 (‘LA1950’) enactment consolidated and amended legislation relating to limitation of actions and arbitrations; s 14 of the LA1950, which amended s 17(1)(c) of the Law Reform Act 1936 (‘LRA’), was intended to protect a person’s right to claim contribution while delaying time at which cause of action arose to the point when the person’s liability was established; in


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

reviewing LA1950, Law Commission concluded solidary rule (by which each wrongdoer is liable for a plaintiff ’s entire loss) should remain unchanged; LA2010 followed enactment of BA and was mindful of s 393 of the BA in particular, which it amended; under s 393 of the BA LA2010 applied to civil proceedings against any person arising from building work as in s 393(1)(a) of the BA, or performance of functions described in s 393(1)(b) of the BA; s 17(1)(c) of the LRA, with LA21010, created a code for bringing contribution claims which was untouched by terms of s 393(2) of the BA; this interpretation was consistent with policy and other objectives leading to enactment of 10-year limitation period in BA; WCC’s claim was not so clearly statute-barred it should be struck out; period in which WCC claimed BCHFL became aware of defects fell well within limitation period; BCHFL had not shown, on balance of probabilities, that that WCC could not succeed; application declined.

CAVEATS Angurala v Fernandes 4/6/2021, Hinton J, High Court, Auckland, [2021] NZHC 1309 Property– Real– Encumbrances– Caveats– Removal– By order Property– Real– Sale and purchase agreement

Successful application by A for an order removing a caveat lodged by F against a property owned by A in Mt Roskill, Auckland; on 9 March 2021 A agreed to sell their property to Singh (S) for $1.6m with conditions; sale was subject to S’ satisfaction with due diligence and also obtaining finance by 12 March 2021; at 5.07pm on the 12th S’ lawyer emailed A twice asking for an extension of time to fulfil conditions; A did not respond; that evening real estate agents received an offer from F for $1.535m; F knew there had been an earlier offer but understood it was not going ahead; real estate agent visited A later that evening and told them the first agreement was at an end because conditions had not been met; agent then produced the second unconditional offer by F; A asked to consult their lawyer but agent was insistent they sign the agreement; parties signed and F paid two tranches of $100,000 by way of deposit; the

following afternoon S’ solicitor sent email advising A that S had satisfied the conditions and his agreement had gone unconditional; on 17 March real estate agent told F that they had had trouble cancelling the first agreement; F lodged a caveat the following day, claiming an interest as purchaser in the land under the second agreement; A sought to remove the caveat in order to comply with settlement notice from S; A submitted that they accepted (rightly or wrongly) that S’ agreement was still on foot at the time it was declared unconditional; no application or evidence from S; A accepted that F had a reasonably arguable case to support her caveat; A argued S’ claim to title was first in time and his interest should prevail; A submitted F was put on notice of the existence of the first agreement and should have made further inquires; F should not have relied on real estate agents advice; F submitted A had the onus of proving why the caveat should be removed; F argued they were a bona fide purchaser and could seek specific performance. Held, on the face of it S appeared to have clear priority; F had little chance of success in an application for specific performance; A had expressly taken no steps to avoid their agreement with S; available documents were consistent with that submission; no evidence of any disentitling conduct on S’ part that might cause him to lose his priority; on the face of the agreements and in the circumstances it was likely F may have lost approximately $65,000; it was appropriate to round this figure up to $80,000, to be held pending final resolution of the dispute between parties; caveat removed; application granted.

prior leave of the Court; two previous judgments of the HC refused C’s application that the caveat not lapse; C had argued that the caveat should not lapse until her substantive proceeding heard; C alleged misrepresentation and repudiation with respect to the loan agreement; HC held that C had not established a reasonably arguable case that she remained purchaser under a sale and purchase agreement; C failed to show why the agreement had not ended following WIL’s cancellation; C lodged a second caveat on the day of that decision; C did so on the basis she was a beneficiary under a constructive trust; HC found this interest to be entirely speculative; the second caveat was ordered to be removed; C argued her partner had not complied with s10 of the Companies Act 1993 and he had never been to New Zealand; C alleged her partner’s lawyers provided misleading information to the Court as to his residency status; C argued the HC ignored these concerns. Held, C’s application for stay was misconstrued so was declined; HC properly considered s10 of the CA; however that decision was under appeal so that was proper place to consider that issue; there was no evidence to support C registering further caveats; application for leave to lodge caveat refused; C directed to apply for an interim injunction pending her appeal in order to protect her position; given C’s history of lodging caveats and lack of evidence to support any new caveatable interest it was appropriate to grant WIL’s application; application granted.

Studio New Zealand Ltd v Wallace 3/5/2021, Andrew Associate Judge, High Court, Auckland, [2021] NZHC 959

Chen v Auckland Weihao Investment Ltd 31/5/2021, Gordon J, High Court, Auckland, [2021] NZHC 1240 Civil procedure– Proceedings– Stay Property– Real– Encumbrances– Caveats Property– Real– Sale and purchase agreements

Unsuccessful applications by C for orders staying an earlier judgment of the High Court (HC) and for leave to lodge an additional caveat against the title to the property; successful application by AWIL for orders restraining C and a company of which C was a director from lodging any further caveats against the property without

Contract – Formalities – Acceptance – Intention Property – Real – Encumbrances – Caveats – Removal Property – Real – Sale and purchase agreements Trusts – Trustees – Rights and powers

Successful application by SNZL to sustain caveat over a property at Porchester Road, Takanini; BW and others (trustees) were proprietors of the property; SNZL identified property as attractive site for developing a screen production complex and approached trustees to purchase or lease it; parties entered into an initial conditional agreement, never formally terminated, for sale

33


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

and purchase of property subject to due diligence; at trustees’ suggestion, parties entered into a joint venture arrangement instead and sought resource consent and government funding for project; SNZL claimed two of the trustees, BW and Robert Wallace (‘RW’) purported to terminate the joint venture and made them another conditional offer to purchase the property; SNZL claimed that, following an email exchange and a letter, there was a binding agreement for sale and purchase of property that entitled them to a beneficial interest in the property; parties had not signed formal agreement, but continued without prejudice discussions; trustees claimed there was no legally binding agreement for sale and purchase and formal agreement executed by all trustees and other parties would have been objectively contemplated before any such agreement could come into effect; trustees claimed that the authors of the emails had no authority under s 24 of the Property Law Act 2007 (‘PLA’) to bind all the trustees to an agreement. Held, key issue was whether SNZL had established reasonably arguable case for a legally binding agreement for sale and purchase of the property; required to determine whether (a) email correspondence gave rise to a binding agreement for sale and purchase of the property, including intention to be immediately bound and (b) BW and RW had actual or ostensible authority to bind all trustees under s 24 of the PLA; starting point in addressing critical issue of objective interpretation was language of the correspondence, especially the words if you avail yourselves of the opportunity as presented, then the property and the project will be yours; even if this was invitation to submit a proposal rather than offer capable of acceptance, formal offer was arguably on the table; while there was no agreement on a deposit and settlement date, parties had reached agreement on all legally essential terms as purchase price was clearly stated as $53.5m plus GST and agreement was conditional on SNZL completing due diligence by specified date; while absence of formality was important in context of complex commercial deal involving $53.5m sale, language used, given parties’ lengthy relationship, objectively established an arguable basis to sustain caveat; because SNZL had not met due diligence condition by required date, it must establish that agreement

34

remained on foot and was not cancelled; there was an arguable case, reinforced by trustees’ actions, that all trustees as registered proprietors were prepared and willing to sell property; trustees’ concerns about SNZL’s financial security were best addressed when establishing security for costs in substantive proceedings between parties; application granted.

ESTATE ADMINISTRATION AP v Lucas 7/5/2021, Fitzgerald J, High Court, Auckland, [2021] NZHC 1017 Property– Real– Interests in land Wills, probate and administration– Family protection– Further provision– Claim by child Wills, probate and administration– Family protection– Breach of moral duty

Unsuccessful appeal by P against Family Court (‘FC’) Judge’s determination under s 4 Family Protection Act 1955 (FPA) that residue of P’s father’s estate should be divided equally between herself and her two daughters, J and M; P and her three sisters, children of father’s first wife, A, lived in the Netherlands; father and A divorced acrimoniously, father had a strong personality and relationships with all three children were difficult; father moved to NZ and remarried; relationship with P rekindled following birth of P’s children; P visited father in NZ and formed a close, caring relationship with father’s second wife, G, who died of cancer, leaving P a legacy of $300,000; father met Ms L during one of many admissions to Auckland Hospital two years before his death; Ms L moved in with father, providing care and support and they bought a Newmarket apartment together; father’s will left P items of sentimental value with estimated value of $10,000 and G’s Rolex watch also passed to her; all father’s remaining personal and household effects and Newmarket apartment, passed to Ms L; residue of estate was left equally to J and M; father’s previous will left residue to P; P’s sisters received nothing and took no steps; FC Judge found responsibility for volatile relationship between P and her father was mainly a result of father’s difficult behaviour and deliberate

decision to leave his family in Netherlands and resettle in NZ; decision to change will occurred when father became aware P and L had discussed divorce with A and P’s position in it; all parties agreed father breached moral duty to provide for P; FC Judge concluded P should receive further provision in manner interfering as little as possible with father’s intent to assist L and help J and M establish themselves in early adulthood; FC Judge left bequest in father’s will unchanged and divided residue of estate into thirds, with P, J and M each receiving one third, increasing P’s share to around $700,000; on appeal P claimed (a) FC Judge erred in effectively equating her provision with that for J and M and (b) her provision was insufficient compared with that for L, who only knew father during the last two years of his life. Held, appeal was basically against FC Judge’s exercise of discretion and limited accordingly; as long as award sufficed to remedy father’s breach of moral duty to P, award should not be disturbed; award fell within range available to FC Judge on the evidence before him and represented a significant and somewhat generous increase in amount; award did not reflect P’s parenting skills or compare importance of P and L to father, but was intended as least ‘interference’ with father’s wishes that sufficed to remedy breach of moral duty to P; approach to J and M’s awards was appropriate as beneficiaries should not be obliged to justify gifts made in their favour; father’s estate was sufficiently large to accommodate moral claims to it; while relationship between P and her father had rekindled more recently, there was no suggestion she had provided significant support; father’s bequests to J and M indirectly benefited P by relieving her to an extent from need to support them; updating evidence concerning value of Newmarket apartment was not significant; FC Judge did not err in not making award that would enable P to purchase a home in Netherlands debt free; FC Judge was not obliged to consider rewriting father’s will to convert bequest to L to life interest only; while relationship between father and L was relatively short, it was intense and entailed L caring for him on 24/7 basis; FC Judge’s decision acknowledged L’s care and support as well as father’s gratitude and expressed desire that she should have Newmarket apartment; appeal dismissed.


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

LAND TITLES Sharma v Wati 18/6/2021, Gordon J, High Court, Auckland, [2021] NZHC 1444 Civil procedure– Documents– Signature Civil procedure– Jurisdiction– Inherent Property– Real– Title– Transfer

Successful application by W for an order appointing a person to sign documents in place of S to enable sale of property to proceed; previously High Court (HC) made orders for the sale of a property in order to give effect to the judgment of Allan J of 27 February 2009; S did not object to the sale of the property but did object to parts of the methodology proposed by W; W submitted S had refused to sign the listing form from Barfoot & Thompson; S declined to give reasons for his refusal to sign; in May 2021 a hearing proceeded in S’s absence; orders were made that the Court should treat W’s without notice application as an on notice application; despite S having received affidavits and documents via email, the date of service was deemed to run from the date of those orders; timetable orders were made and a further hearing was scheduled for 11 June 2021; on 4 June 2021 S filed memorandum opposing W’s application; S submitted he had not deliberately failed to answer his telephone at the relevant times; S said he did not outright refuse to sign any listing form; he explained he was busy preparing for another Court of Appeal hearing; S said he was prepared to sign the necessary documents but not “at the click of [W’s lawyers] fingers”; despite apparent willingness to sign S made other submissions in opposition; S submitted the property should be sold by auction. Held, evidence established that S refused, or at least failed to sign the Barfoot &

Thompson listing form; he failed to provide any reasonable grounds for doing so; if an auction was held and S failed to show up at auction to sign the agreement that could complicate the matter and prevent sale finalising; sale by negotiation was preferable; S given two working days to sign the listing form; in the likely event he did not sign, the Registrar was most appropriate person to be appointed to sign on his behalf; if within 24 hours of being presented with any sale and purchase agreement S failed or refused to sign the agreement the Registrar was appointed to sign on his behalf; the Registrar would also sign on S’s behalf any A & I form required to convey title in the event of a sale; application granted.

Siddiqui v Siddiqui 28/5/2021, Davison J, High Court, Auckland, [2021] NZHC 1234 Equity – Interests Property – Real – Ejectment Property – Real – Interests in land – Beneficial interests Property – Real – Title Trusts – Classification – Constructive trusts – Institutional constructive trusts

Successful claim by AAS and Usha Siddiqui (Ss) for constructive trust in their favour over residential property purchased by their son and daughter-in-law AS and Yashika Siddiqui (YS), the registered owners; unsuccessful claim by Ss that AS and YS fraudulently obtained title to property by falsely representing that they would assist Ss to purchase it, while concealing fact that AS and YS would be registered owners; Ss claimed registration in AS and YS’s names in 2006 was arranged by AS to facilitate obtaining bank finance and between May 2006 and April 2015 they made payments to AS and YS in respect of ANZ bank mortgage AS arranged

to effect their purchase; Ss also claimed that they paid insurance, rates and maintenance on the property; payments only stopped in April 2015 when Ss discovered that they were not registered owners of the property and AS and YS refused to transfer it into their names; Ss sought order vesting title of the property in their names and alternatively, order directing AS and YS to transfer the property to them, as well as recovery of moneys they claimed to have paid to AS and YS to meet mortgage on the property, but which AS and YS retained; AS and YS denied allegations and counterclaimed for possession of property and repayment of mortgage; AS and YS claimed they made oral agreement with AAS allowing him and US and AS’s sister Supriya to continue living at the property, for a fortnightly payment of $800. Held, Ss proved, on basis of probabilities, that parties expressly agreed that AS and YS would purchase the property on behalf of and on trust for them; Ss had justifiable and reasonable expectation of an interest in the property as its beneficial owners; although AS and YS acted largely independently, they made it clear they were assisting Ss to purchase their own home and had encouraged them to do so; AAS arranged mortgage repayments into AS’ personal bank account and arranged and paid rates and insurance bills; after purchase AS and YS continued to deal with Ss on the basis that Ss owned the property, although they used it as security for their own borrowings; AS raising issue of transferring title to Ss if they could obtain a mortgage for amount then outstanding on bank loan was confirmation of his acceptance that he and YS held property on Ss’ behalf; Ss stopping mortgage payments was not concession re validity of their interest in property; payments made by Ss exceeded amounts required for mortgage payments; refusal to recognise Ss’ beneficial

Legal Counselling Service It’s okay to ask for help. Anyone in a legal workplace can access free counselling sessions through the Vitae Legal Counselling Service. 0508 664 981 · Complete an online form on vitae.co.nz · Download the Vitae New Zealand app

35


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

interest was unconscionable; circumstances would have also warranted Court imposing remedial constructive trust; AS and YS did not become registered owners of property through a trick or fraudulently misleading Ss; Ss had no prior interest in the property, AS and YS did not obtain title by fraud or dishonesty and any fraudulent conduct by them did not occur at time of transfer; AS and YS’s actions were not undertaken as a dishonest trick to produce non-registration of Ss’ interest in property, but as a well-intentioned means to circumvent bank’s lending criteria to enable them to purchase a home; however, soon afterwards AS and YS used the property as security and borrowed further funds from bank to finance purchase of their own investment properties; changing nature of relationship between parties and increasing disharmony that arose led AS and YS to reframe arrangements to suit themselves and advance explanation that Ss were renting the house from them; claim under s 63(1)(c) of the Land Transfer Act 1952 unsuccessful; orders made directing AS and YS, when called on by Ss, to transfer legal title to the property to them and to pay mortgage payments owing on the property; AS and YS entitled to adjustment for bathroom renovations; claim of fraudulent misconduct rejected; claim for constructive trust accepted.

OVERSEAS INVESTMENT Chief Executive of Land Information New Zealand v Zhang 1/6/2021, Van Bohemen J, High Court, Auckland, [2021] NZHC 1266 Commercial law– Investment– Overseas investment– Overseas Investment Act 2005 Property– Real– Interests in land– Beneficial interests– Acquisition

Judgment of Van Bohemen J as to quantum of penalty following breach of the Overseas Investment Act 2005 (OIA); CEOLINZ alleged Z acquired a legal interest in “sensitive land” without obtaining consent as required under OIA; land comprised two properties in Mellons Bay, Auckland; Z admitted breaching the OIA; both parties sought orders that Z pay civil pecuniary penalty of $110,000 and $15,000 towards the Regulator of OIA’s costs; parties submitted agreed statement of

36

facts; Z a Chinese citizen and businessperson; Z was approved for a residence class visa on 14 July 2015; visa not issued until 17 March 2017; Z entered New Zealand under that visa on 17 March 2018; prior to 17 March 2018 Z was an “overseas person” under s7(2)(a) of the OIA; Z entered into sale and purchase agreement for property on 13 September 2015; Z obtained legal title of the properties on 18 September 2015; both steps taken without obtaining consent under OIA; Z agreed to pay the civil penalty in respect of the breach; parties agreed breach was moderately serious given size of the properties, the heritage value, monetary value, and proximity to adjoining foreshore; Regulator of OIA conceded the breach was inadvertent; Z submitted she had made no quantifiable gain; Z argued she had cooperated fully with the Regulator. Held, although moderately serious breach it was a single breach, that ceased in 2018 when Z became a resident; the breach was inadvertent; Z was not attempting to circumvent the system for personal gain; presence of heritage site and position adjacent to foreshore were important factors to consider; Z purchased the properties for use as a home for her and her children; Z’s children were New Zealand citizens; no aggravating factors; discount of 20 percent appropriate given breach was unintentional; however it could have been avoided with proper due diligence; $110,000 civil pecuniary penalty appropriate; Z ordered to also pay $15,000 towards Regulator of OIA’s costs; orders accordingly.

RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES Harding v Schellevis 1/6/2021, Walker J, High Court, Auckland, [2021] NZHC 1265 Civil procedure– Appeals– Question of law Tenancy law– Residential Tenancies Act 1986– Exclusions– Landlord’s residence Tenancy law– Tenancy agreements– Premises Tenancy law– Tenancy tribunal– Jurisdiction

Unsuccessful appeal by H of District Court (DC) decision dismissing an appeal from the Tenancy Tribunal; it concerned the interpretation of s5(1)(n) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1986 (RTA); s5(1)(n) excluded

the operation of the RTA where the rented premises was principally used as the landlord/owner’s residence or a member of their family’s residence; if the RTA was excluded it meant the Tenancy Tribunal had no jurisdiction to adjudicate such disputes; H ran two level house with six bedrooms in Auckland; her family generally occupied the upper level; S and others at various times occupied the ground floor ‘granny flat’; H had previously rented the granny flat as a separate dwelling however council had advised them that there was no firewall between the premises so it could not be tenanted as a separate dwelling; H started signing occupancy agreements thereafter because it remained legal to have flatmates; agreements acknowledged the property was a family home and therefore exempt from the RTA; degree of separation and independence of the levels was contested; Tenancy Tribunal declared the granny flat was a residential tenancy over which it had jurisdiction; DC agreed; S submitted that whilst water and power were shared, the cost of both was included in the rent as a fixed amount; internet was separate and arranged by the occupants; S emphasised the separate entrance, parking, exclusive use of an outside area, no mingling with H and family; H was only entitled to enter the granny flat for inspections, repairs and viewing for new tenants; S submitted they had no right of entry to H’s family’s area. Held, the narrow question of law on appeal; whether ground floor ‘granny flat’ was a “residential premises” for the purposes of RTA or whether the entire property (the family home and granny flat) was the “residential premises”; s5(1)(n) did not apply to present situation; the premises was a granny flat occupied by S, not an entire dwelling; natural and ordinary meaning of “premises” contemplates there may be more than one premises within a larger premises; statutory definition of residential premises included any part of any premises; purpose and policy of the RTA supported a generous approach to the jurisdiction of the Tenancy Tribunal; there was no shared or common areas which characterised a flat share scenario; H had no entitlement without notice to enter the granny flat; that was determinative; the relevant premises was the functionally independent granny flat; s5(1)(n) did not apply; appeal dismissed. ▪


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

New Zealand Law Society Library Service CAVEATS

COVENANTS

Melco Property Holdings (NZ) 2021 Limited (Melco) v Hall (H)

Chand (Cs) v Auckland Council

[2021] NZCA 184 – Collins, Brewer and Dunningham JJ – 14 May 2021

Unsuccessful appeal against refusal to sustain caveat – Melco was purchaser and H vendor under agreement for sale of commercial property subject to due diligence clause – Melco made initial due diligence inspections and arranged further inspection on last day before clause expired which H cancelled – H cancelled ASAP when Melco failed to give notice of fulfilment or waiver – Melco claimed H breached agreement by failing to provide access for further inspection and lodged caveat – Melco also purported belatedly to waive condition and sought settlement which was refused – Applied for order that caveat not lapse which was declined – Appeal issue whether in summary context of application to sustain caveat it was open to Associate Judge to find H was entitled to avoid agreement on basis clause had not been fulfilled – Onus on Melco to show reasonably arguable case that H had breached obligations, made some concession or given binding assurance such that purported avoidance was ineffective – CA held Associate Judge was correct to find there was no reasonably arguable case that failure to fulfil condition was due to H’s default – Onus on Melco to show reasonably arguable case it would have fulfilled condition had H given access not discharged.

[2021] NZCA 282 – Miller, Venning and Peters JJ – 30 June 2021

Unsuccessful appeal from decision declining to modify covenant under s317(1)(d) PLA – Parties owned properties at Manukau which were part of 8-lot subdivision completed by former owners (Ss) – Each property subject to restrictive covenant precluding further subdivision and dwellings – Cs were owners of the Ss’ property – Sought to extinguish covenant affecting their property to permit subdivision to fullest extent permitted under Auckland Unitary Plan – Owners of 3 properties opposed – Valuation evidence that development would diminish market value of each affected property by $100,000 with further $100,000 in injury due to extinguishment of covenant – CA agreed with HC that evidence established enduring injury in form of loss of view and privacy, intrusion of traffic and noise and likely loss of property values; considered provisions of s317, lost property rights as injury under s317(1)(d), Synlait Milk (SC) and compensation for loss of property rights at common law – Approach to treat loss as injury under s317 and assess compensation on willing buyer, willing seller basis – Judge not wrong to find substantial injury would result and refuse modification.

EASEMENTS Cornes (C) v Village Residential Limited (VRL) [2021] NZCA 216 – Clifford, Brewer and Dunningham JJ – 31 May 2021

Unsuccessful appeal from decision that VRL could carry out proposed upgrade of driveway – Cs owned large rear property and driveway in Havelock North – Driveway ran alongside VRL property which enjoyed easement access over driveway and had received consent for subdivision – Easement included vehicular access “for whatever purpose [driveway] may be lawfully used” –Resource consent provided for driveway upgrade including permanent resurfacing and installation of stormwater pump – Cs were opposed to subdivision and driveway upgrade – CA considered terms of easement, conditions in Schedule 5 PLA and common law – Development not limited to land’s original condition at time of grant (Newcomen v Coulson and Dand v Kingscote) – Rights conferred could respond to evolving circumstances to enable lawful use at any given time – Subdivision lawful based on grant of resource consent – Permitting drainage works did not constitute grant of drainage easement – HC decision authorising completion of works upheld.

GUARANTEES Dumasia (D) v Ikon Building Co-operation Limited (Ikon) [2021] NZCA 292 – Cooper, Mallon and Wylie JJ -2 July 2021

Successful appeal from summary judgment – Appellants were guarantors of loan to SKKY Ltd to undertake residential development in Stanmore Bay – Building contract abandoned by main contractor due to defects in concreting work – Appellants claimed lender agreed to vary loan to enable project completion and then assigned rights to B Ltd as bare trustee

37


T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R   —   V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1

for Ikon – B Ltd said to have declined to release funds and begun charging penalty interest – B Ltd gave notice of default relying on delays and cancellation of contract by main contractor – Served PLA notices and exercised power of sale – Ikon issued proceedings for loan balance – Appellants argued Ikon was estopped from relying on strict terms of loan agreement (Agreement) and notice of default was invalid as SKKY was not in default when notice issued – HC found original contract was never varied and defence based on estoppel failed; default notice not issued for purposes of s119 PLA and B Ltd did not rely on notice for subsequent actions; summary judgment entered for $1.5M – Appeal focussed on default notice issued “out of the blue” 2 days after B Ltd purchased loan – Appellants argued SKKY not in breach of Agreement at date notice issued; main contractor’s cancellation of contract was default event; discovery required to determine lender’s “reasonable opinion” under Agreement; issuing default notices repudiated Agreement and was catalyst for development stalling and SKKY default; majority of units subject to agreements to sell – if B Ltd had continued promised funding, all units would have been sold with substantial profit enabling loan to be repaid – CA found appellants had arguable defence – Not prepared to exclude possibility of estoppel if notice wrongfully issued causing funding and progress on development to cease or that the no set-off clause would be ineffective to shield Ikon from consequences of breach – Matters to be determined at trial – Summary judgment set aside.

NUISANCE Nottingham Forest Trustee Limited (NFT) v Unison Networks Limited (Unison) [2021] NZCA 227 – Cooper, Clifford and Collins JJ – 3 June 2021

NFT owned and operated commercial forest – Found liable in nuisance and under Rylands v Fletcher (R v F) for losses caused by trees falling on Unison’s power lines – Corridor for power lines left when forest

38

planted but by 2010 closest trees were taller than distance from line – Between 2010 and 2018 falling trees caused outages and other damage in adverse weather – NFT unable to identify at-risk trees by inspections – HC found Unison had sufficient interest in land to enable claim in nuisance or R v F: (i) (R v F) interest had been substantially interfered with – principle of strict liability applied – individual falls were “one-off ” escapes of dangerous things and “accumulation” of trees took activity outside “natural” use of land; (ii) (nuisance) physical damage caused by “recurrently falling trees” constituted ongoing substantial and unreasonable interference with enjoyment of interest in land – alternatively growing trees within falling distance of line constituted unreasonable use – Appeal challenged finding of strict liability – NFT argued growing trees and forestry was natural use of land; liability for tree falls required fault in tree management; NFT complied with regulatory regime, conducted regular inspections and was not at fault – CA discussed law relating to nuisance and R v F: (i) aspect of “continuous or recurring emanation” distinguished cases where owners were not liable for falling trees – liability in nuisance upheld – NFT created state of affairs that caused unreasonable and continuing interference with line and was strictly liable even if reasonable precautions taken; (ii) liability under R v F not established – activity of maintaining forest was natural and ordinary use of land – trees not dangerous on planting and status of use did not change when they grew above certain height – Appeal dismissed.

SALE OF LAND Robertson v Robertson NZCA 295 – Kos P, Brewer and Davison JJ – 5 July 2021

Unsuccessful appeal from decision under s339 PLA directing sale of jointly owned land at public auction and division of proceeds – Rs were brothers and boatbuilders who had fallen out – Partnership dissolved 25 years ago – C had continued

business from the 8.3ha property beside Mahurangi River and wished to purchase brother’s share – M wished to redevelop land for housing – Process of negotiation unsuccessful – On appeal C sought order (rejected by HC) that he be allowed to purchase M’s share at fair and reasonable price under s339(1)(c) – Alleged HC failed to give sufficient weight to “extreme hardship” he would suffer if sale occurred as directed – CA upheld HC decision: decision involved exercise of discretion and higher appellate standard applied; C did not advance present proposition in HC which opened entirely new page in “kaleidoscopic catalogue of changing proposals”; claim that business could not be moved contrary to C’s evidence; proposed sale at 2020 valuations represented price advantage to C and unconscionable.

TRUSTS Arnerich (A) v DHC Assets Limited (DHC) [2021] NZCA 225 – Goddard, Duffy and Nation JJ – 3 June 2021

Unsuccessful appeal against order that A pay compensation under s301 Companies Act; successful appeal from decision declining to determine claim for further amounts owed – A, property developer was sole director of company (Vaco) which engaged DHC to design and build commercial building – Vaco was sole trustee of Vaco trust and carried out development project in capacity as trustee – Trust beneficiaries were A and his family – Vaco in voluntary liquidation since Jul 2014 – DHC claimed $1M as unpaid debt under construction contract – DHC was awarded $367,768 in CCA adjudication and pursued further claims – A had distributed the trust funds to the beneficiaries and Vaco unable to pay sums awarded or claimed – HC ordered A to pay sum awarded but declined to determine claim for further sums on the basis the contract required claims be determined by other mechanisms and claims had been referred to arbitration – On appeal A argued he acted in good faith in best interests of Vaco, did not breach duties as director


V O L U M E 2 2 I S S U E 1   —   T H E P R O P E R T Y L AW Y E R

under s131 and made provision for further claims before trust distribution – DHL sought orders that HC determine total amount owing and A be required to pay that directly to DHL under s301 – CA upheld order to pay award sum but modified interest award; found A breached s131 by causing Vaco to distribute remaining funds without retaining sufficient to meet contingent claims; HC should also have determined total amount owed and awarded A compensation for full debt which Vaco could have paid but for A’s breaches – Proceeding remitted to HC to determine quantum and further orders.

WEATHERTIGHTNESS Roberts (R) v Jules Consultancy Ltd (in liq) (JCL) and Leloir (L) [2021] NZCA 303 – Gilbert, Mallon and Edwards JJ – 9 July 2021

Unsuccessful appeal against award of damages for false and misleading representations on sale of leaky apartment; partly successful cross-appeal relating to reduction for contributory negligence – R purchased apartment in “Sirocco” Wellington in Mar 2014 – L provided secretarial and management services to body corporate through JCL – HC found R relied on false and misleading representations by L to effect that building had experienced watertightness issues only in relation to walkways which had been rectified – Awarded damages for breach of Fair Trading Act (purchase price less market value at time of sale) – 15% reduction for contributory negligence (R failed to obtain building report and body corporate minutes before confirming purchase) – CA considered: whether damages correctly assessed; whether loss should be assessed at hearing date; reduction for contributory negligence – CA had sympathy for both parties – L was conscientious body corporate secretary who lacked expertise to identify weathertightness risks – R’s failure to obtain specialist inspection and minutes significant and direct cause of loss – Damages to be assessed at time of purchase – R’s contribution increased to 40% – Costs to lie where they fell. ▪

At your fingertips All the latest in-depth information on all areas of New Zealand law lawsociety.org.nz/law-library

39


CPD Calendar PROGRAMME

PRESENTERS

CONTENT

WHERE

WHEN

Amanda Donovan Ben Jefferson

It is becoming ever increasingly difficult to save for a deposit on a house, and luckily for some, generous parents are able to help out so that their children can get their first step on the property ladder. These arrangements begin with the best of intentions, however, things can go wrong down the track when the parties have a different understanding of what was agreed to with a key dispute being whether the money was a gift or a loan. This webinar will help enable you to work effectively with your clients in ensuring clarity about what is being agreed to and in providing robust advice if issues do emerge.

Webinar

9 Sep

Katherine Ewer

Trust issues can often prove to be extremely challenging and the new Trusts Act 2019 has added further layers of complexity that you need to take into account in this rapidly changing landscape. This webinar will address some of the key issues you are likely to face including; common drafting issues and how to avoid them; reviewing trust deeds in light of the Trusts Act 2019; appointment and removal/retirement of trustees; resettlements and associated tax issues.

Webinar

15 Sep

This one-day workshop is specifically tailored for lawyers and is designed to enhance your ability to connect with Māori who you may be working with as clients, stakeholders, partners, or in another capacity. Experienced facilitators will guide you through an interactive day as you consider the who, why and the how to successfully engage with Māori in the law.

Christchurch

13 Sep

Auckland

14 Sep

Wellington

15 Sep

Melanie Ashall or Philip Strang

One of the important duties of a solicitor practising on their own account is to maintain clear and reliable trust account records, which must be up to date and in compliance with professional duties and trust accounting regulations. Frequently, the day-to-day duties of trust account recording fall to a staff member on whose skills and diligence the firm depends. This course equips attendees with the technical knowledge and self-confidence to administer a trust account effectively and efficiently. This practical course has two elements: pre-course work and a half-day workshop.

Auckland

14 Sep

Hamilton

15 Sep

Online (Full)

21 Sep

Melanie Ashall or Philip Strang

The Financial Assurance Scheme requires all practices operating a trust account to appoint a qualified Trust Account Supervisor. The Trust Account Supervisor may be a partner or director in a law firm, or a sole practitioner. To become a Trust Account Supervisor you must pass the NZLS Trust Account Supervisor assessments. The assessments are limited to lawyers and are required under Regulation 19, Lawyers and Conveyancers Act (Trust Account Regulations) 2008.

Wellington

22 Sep

Auckland

19 Oct

Christchurch

9 Nov

Director: Warwick Deuchrass

All lawyers wishing to practise on their own account, whether alone or in partnership or in an incorporated practice, and some in-house counsel, will be required to complete the course.

Wellington

23-25 Sep

Auckland

25-27 Nov

Chair: Greg Kelly

Described as “New Zealand’s Premier Trust Conference” and the “Most useful update on current issues & developments in Trust Law” the biennial NZLS CLE Trusts Conference, now in its 12th year, will once again offer an excellent programme providing practical advice by a stellar line up of presenters.

Wellington

18-19 Oct

Live Web Stream

18-19 Oct

PROPERTY & TRUSTS GIFT OR LOAN?

1 CPD hours

TRUSTS – NAVIGATING THE MAZE

1.5 CPD hours

PRACTICE & PROFESSIONAL SKILLS KUA AO TE RĀ: INTRODUCTION TO TE REO MĀORI FOR THE LEGAL PROFESSION

Alana Thomas Apimaera Thomas

6 CPD hours TRUST ACCOUNT ADMINISTRATORS

4 CPD hours

TRUST ACCOUNT SUPERVISOR TRAINING PROGRAMME

7.5 CPD hours

STEPPING UP – FOUNDATION FOR PRACTISING ON OWN ACCOUNT

19 CPD hours TRUSTS CONFERENCE – 2021 A TRUSTS ODYSSEY

13 CPD hours

For our FULL CPD calendar with programme details see www.lawyerseducation.co.nz


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Property Lawyer Volume 22 Issue 1 by The Property Lawyer - Issuu