Skip to main content

The Superyacht Report – Refit Focus issue 231

Page 1

The Superyacht Report

REFIT FOCUS

Who pays to close the hull? End-of-life costs analysis

The geography of refit – where yachts are heading for refit

What 2,300 brokerage listings say about refits and price

231

QUARTER 4/2026

What does €140 million actually buy?


FEWER LAYERS. GREATER EFFICIENCY. Awlgrip Gloss Finish Primer combines a show coat and finish primer so you can detect imperfections and prepare for your topcoat in one go – achieving more with less labor. It combines two steps in one, you’re not cutting any corners or compromising on the high quality you’ve come to expect from our Awlgrip system – you’re simply being more efficient.

www.awlgrip.com

@ Registered trademark of AkzoNobel in one or more countries. © 2026 AkzoNobel N.V


EDITOR’S LETTER

A BRAND NEW ERA The Editor-in-Chief spells out dynamic changes for the year ahead.

T

BY MARTIN H. REDMAYNE

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

his will be the last issue of The Superyacht Report for 2026 and the end of our magazine era, as we will transition from being a conventional magazine in the current format and style and move into some-thing completely new. The plan is really quite simple – from 2027 onwards, all our journalism and expert editorial content, including guest authors, opinion columns and features will move directly onto SuperyachtNews.com, which is currently undergoing a complete refit and rebuild, behind the scenes; more on that later this year. The “new” Superyacht Report will appear in early 2027, in a brand-new format, with highly intelligent content that will focus exclusively on key sectors of the industry, combining intelligence, research and analysis, similarly to the work our consultancy delivers to investors and business leaders. The market has a wide spectrum of media channels of varying shapes, sizes, quality and integrity, and the audiences seem to consume this myriad of channels in either bite-size chunks or flippant flips, never having the time to read the words or even find the content interesting enough to dig deeper. So we will shift our focus into a series of Quarterly Reports that are essentially Consultancy Documents that mirror a

large percentage of the reports we deliver to an individual client or investor, especially in the core segments of new build, refit, migration and OPEX financials. The objective is to provide a series of intelligence-led reports that any investor, owner, CEO or entrepreneur will find valuable, useful and highly relevant, without the need to spend several thousand euros on a bespoke or unique report. In addition, in the way that a McKinsey, UBS, Deloitte or Knight Frank will create a market-leading intelligence report, without advertising, we want to focus our attention on delivering something that adds serious value and that the core decision makers will recognise that it is worth buying. Therefore, in 2027 and beyond, The Superyacht Report will be exactly that, a serious market report that delivers unique analysis, intelligence and research every quarter, with all of our editorial and journalistic content being migrated onto a brand-new web platform, under the brand SuperyachtNews.com. It’s an exciting transition and one that will guarantee that The Superyacht Group is no longer seen as part of the traditional media landscape, but more recognised as the strategic information and intelligence consultancy that we have become. MHR

1


CONTENTS

Guest columns

Features

Adapt and react Terry Allen, Director at Maritime Engineering Consultancy Services, spells out the difference between a shipyard that simply carries out work and one that knows how to manage a maintenance period.

18

Future-proofing the refit A refit is usually planned around the next few seasons; however, the best ones are planned around the next owner. Lee Stevenson, Co-Founder of OCCAM, sets out what owners, captains and managers should be asking before the yard period starts, so the money spent today is still working in ten years’ time.

22

The future of yachting lies in refit Building on the past is the most sustainable choice. Mattia Massola Taliacarne of Italstyle Yacht Design explains why the industry must valorise existing vessels through refit and restyle.

40

What really makes a successful refit? And why is it not always what we think? By Rory Marshall, surveyor and marine coatings consultant, Newmar Overseas Consulting Ltd.

44

Every change was approved, but nobody priced the complexity A refit can account for the price of almost every change to a yacht. The more difficult calculation begins when all those individually sensible changes have to live together. By Vesna Djurdjevi, Economist | Organisation Development Consultant.

Why circadian lighting needs a more considered approach at sea As understanding of light’s non-visual effects develops, Michael Meeneghan, founder of MP Tech, argues that yacht lighting should be assessed by not only how an interior looks, but also how the light performs for the people living and working on board.

52

Superyacht refit and the long horizon Norina Edelman, CEO and founder of IMM, asks how we can ensure that we have not only the infrastructure to handle yacht refit well into the future, but also the skill and the appropriate incentives to keep vessels safe.

62

When shipyard risk changes Alex Emley, Senior Director at Willis Marine, offers five ways to protect your yacht and your investment ...

72

Beyond the meeting room Refit yards are full again and owners who plan late lose their choice. But booking the right yard is only the beginning, argues Bob Wagemakers of Virtue Yacht Projects.

80

A yacht is not a painted object Nicolas Nieswiodek, founder of OCEANSKIN Marine, on why the industry’s language around surface protection is too narrow and why substrate-first thinking should become part of modern refit strategy.

36

Mind the gap! Is technology being selected at contract signature or for the operational environment the yacht will face at delivery? Andy Brennan presents a measured approach to managing the four-year technology gap between concept and completion of the build.

46

ENX: asking a different question of superyacht electrification James Roy, Managing Director of Lateral Naval Architects, asks whether we have become so accustomed to designing for capability that we have overlooked the opportunity to design more deliberately for operation.

2

10

64


CONTENTS

Features

Why the best LED refits are the ones you never notice Instead of asking, “What should we replace?”, perhaps we should first ask, “What deserves to be preserved?” That single question can completely change the outcome of a refit ...

Reports

82

Who pays to close the hull? A yacht is costed to the last fender before it is built. However, almost nothing in this industry is costed for the day it stops being a yacht – and that bill is already accruing quietly across the fleet.

30

Reports

What does €140 million actually buy? 56 Comparing a representative two-vessel programme to a 120-metre yacht, SHADOWCAT’s Jennifer Smith explores how capital investment could be converted into operational capability.

A refit doesn’t add value, but it does remove a penalty Andrew Williams, marine surveyor and publisher of The Williams Superyacht Index, on what 2,300 brokerage listings say about refits and price.

6

The geography of refit The Med leads, while Northern Europe is on the rise. Jan Pieter Braam and Ilaria Bernardi of JPMarine report on where yachts are heading for refit.

20

From virtualisation to AI Rethinking the technology foundation of the modern yacht. By Ernesto Esposito of OmniAccess.

25

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

Painting within the lines Liselotte De Backer, Global Product and Sub-Segment Manager Yacht, AkzoNobel, explains how evolving regulatory restrictions on raw materials and sustainability targets are affecting yacht coatings and the refit process.

74

3


The Superyacht Report QUARTER 4/2026

Guest Authors Terry Allen Maritime Engineering Consultancy Services Liselotte De Backer AkzoNobel Ilaria Bernardi JPMarine Jan Pieter Braam JPMarine Andy Brennan Captain/chief engineer David Caddick Marine Light Corporation

For more than 30 years The Superyacht Report has prided itself on being the superyacht market’s most reliable source of data, information, analysis and expert commentary. Our team of analysts, journalists and external contributors remains unrivalled and we firmly believe that we are the only legitimate source of objective and honest reportage. As the industry continues to grow and evolve, we are forthright in our determination to continue being the market’s most profound business-critical source of information.

Vesna Djurdjevic Economist | Organisation Development Consultant Norina Edelman IMM Alex Emley Willis Marine Ernesto Esposito OmniAccess Rory Marshall Newmar Overseas Consulting Ltd Michael Meeneghan MP Tech

ISSN 2046-4983 The Superyacht Report is published by TRP Magazines Ltd (trading as The Superyacht Group) Copyright © TRP Magazines Ltd 2026 All Rights Reserved. The entire contents are protected by copyright Great Britain and by the Universal Copyright convention. Material may be reproduced with prior arrangement and with due acknowledgement to TRP Magazines Ltd. Great care has been taken throughout the magazine to be accurate, but the publisher cannot accept any responsibility for any errors or omissions which may occur. The Superyacht Report is available within The Superyacht Group Library, which is open to everyone in our audience so you can enjoy the highest quality journalism and analysis in the market – Reports Worth Reading. Download or read at your leisure on your desktop or your tablet: https://issuu.com/the-superyacht-group

Editor-In-Chief Martin H. Redmayne martin@thesuperyachtgroup.com

INTELLIGENCE Senior Research Analyst Amanda Rogers amanda@thesuperyachtgroup.com Data Analyst Miles Warden miles@thesuperyachtgroup.com

Nicolas Nieswiodek OCEANSKIN Marine Jaime Recasens RCA Engineering James Roy Lateral Naval Architect Jennifer Smith SHADOWCAT Lee Stevenson OCCAM

DESIGN & PRODUCTION

Mattia Massola Taliacarne Italstyle Yacht Design

Content Manager & Production Editor Felicity Salmon felicity@thesuperyachtgroup.com

Bob Wagemakers Virtue Yacht Projects Andrew Williams The Williams Superyacht Index

4


ADVERTISING

SuperyachtNews Spanning every sector of the superyacht sphere, our news portal is the industry’s only source of independent, thoroughly researched journalism. Our team of globally respected editors and analysts engage with key decision-makers in every sector to ensure our readers get the most reliable and accurate business-critical news and market analysis. Superyachtnews.com

1999 - 2024

The Superyacht Report The Superyacht Report is published four times a year, providing decision-makers and influencers with the most relevant, insightful and respected journalism and market analysis available in our industry today. Superyachtnews.com/reports/thesuperyachtreport The Superyacht Agency Drawing on the unparalleled depth of knowledge and experience within The Superyacht Group, The Superyacht Agency’s team of brilliant creatives, analysts, event planners, digital experts and marketing consultants combine four cornerstones – Intelligence, Strategy, Creative and Events – to deliver the most effective insights, campaigns and strategies for our clients. www.thesuperyachtagency.com

Follow The Superyacht Group channels on LinkedIn @thesuperyachtgroup Instagram @thesuperyachtgroup @superyachtobserver @superyachtagency

YOUR COATING CONSULTANTS With over 25 years of experience, we have overseen more than 150 successful new-build and refit projects in all major international yacht locations. Trust us for state-of-theart materials, cutting-edge technology and unparalleled expertise. Guarantee a flawless finish with WREDE Consulting.

Join The Superyacht Group Community By investing in and joining our inclusive community, we can work together to transform and improve our industry. Included in our Essential Membership is a subscription to The Superyacht Report, access to SuperyachtIntel and access to high-impact journalism on SuperyachtNews.

YO U R C OAT ING S O LU T IO N IN FO@W R E D E- C O N S U LT ING.C O M +49 4 0 8 81674 5 - 0 W W W.W R E D E- C O N S U LT ING.C O M HAMBURG • BREMEN • LA CIOTAT • BARCELONA • PALMA

Explore our membership options here: www.superyachtnews.com/shop/p/MH

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

VIAREGGIO • AMSTERDAM • SOUTHAMPTON • SOUTH FLORIDA

Wrede 221.indd 1

5 09:03 22/08/2024


The numbers behind refit valuations

A refit doesn’t add value, but it does remove a penalty

6


Andrew Williams, marine surveyor and publisher of The Williams Superyacht Index, on what 2,300 brokerage listings say about refits and price.

E

veryone in this industry says a refit adds value. Almost nobody says how much and nobody shows their working. I publish a quarterly price model for yachts over 24 metres, built from brokerage listings. This quarter’s sweep collected more than 2,300 listings – about 1,450 individual yachts, once the boats listed with several brokers are counted only once. The model’s own coefficients are estimated on a stricter core of that sweep – 286 motoryachts from five specialist houses, where every specification is verified – and then tested against the whole market. This piece uses the whole market. Each listing records whether the broker advertises a refit. So a fair test is possible: take yachts of the same length, age and builder, and compare the asking prices of those with a refit and those without. The result is not the one the industry usually claims. A refitted yacht does not ask more than my model says a yacht of its size and age is worth. It asks almost exactly that figure. The surprise is on the

other side. The boats with no refit to advertise ask well below it. At 15 to 19 years old, a refitted boat asks about 10 per cent more than an unrefitted boat of the same size. At 20 to 29 years, about 22 per cent more - the firmest number in this piece. Past 30 years, nearly 30 per cent more. The table below sets out the detail. In plain terms: a refit doesn’t add a premium, it removes the penalty of age. The timing surprised me. Between 10 and 14 years old, a refit makes no measurable difference to the asking price. Buyers seem to expect a boat of that age to be in good order and will not pay extra to be told that it is. The effect arrives later, and it grows. By 30 years, the advertised refit is the difference between being priced as a yacht and being priced as a project. If the aim is to protect value, the work starts to show in the price from about year 15 and shows most after year 20. One detail I will state rather than hide. Below 40 metres, the effect is strong.

Built

Boats compared

Refitted: ask vs the model’s figure

Unrefitted: ask vs the model’s figure

A refit is worth

10–14 yrs

18 refitted / 255 not

−5%

−7%

nothing measurable

15–19 yrs

19 refitted / 363 not

−5%

−15%

about +10%

20–29 yrs

23 refitted / 433 not

−1%

−21%

about +22%

30+ yrs

24 refitted / 230 not

+5%

−21%

nearly +30%

Median asking prices against the model’s benchmark for each yacht’s length, age and builder. Q3 2026 sweep; asking prices only. The final column is calculated from unrounded data as the gap between refitted and unrefitted asking prices, expressed as a share of the unrefitted price; it cannot be calculated by subtracting the rounded columns.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

7


Above 40 metres, in this quarter’s data, it almost disappears. There may be good reasons – buyers at that size order their own surveys and redo the interior to their own taste, so the seller’s refit buys less. But the sample above 40 metres is small, 42 refitted boats, so I treat the question as open. The model is re-built every quarter from a fresh sweep of the market and the answer will become clearer. The effect also lasts longer than I expected. I compared boats refitted within the last three years against boats refitted four or more years ago. The fresh refits are worth no more on the price tag than the older ones. Once a yacht’s record includes a proper refit, the market keeps giving credit for it, year after year. That changes the nature of the spend: at the asking level, a refit behaves like an investment, not like something that wears out by next season. A fair question follows: if refits matter this much, why is there no refit button on my calculator? By choice. The refit flag in the raw data is too crude to build into a model. It means whatever the broker chose to advertise, from new engines to new cushions, and only about one older listing in fifteen carries it. Build a number that vague into the model and every figure the model produces inherits the vagueness. So the model prices the specification – length, age, builder, type – and stays clean. The refit enters one boat at a time, as a stated adjustment with written reasons, when I value a named vessel. That is also why a well-refitted older yacht should sit in the upper part of the model’s range. The range is built to hold it. Now the caveats, because a number without them is worth little. These are asking prices. They measure what sellers and their brokers believe a refit is worth, not what buyers pay. Sale prices in this market are almost never published, which is a subject for another day. ‘Refit’ means whatever the listing says it means; the data cannot tell a rebuild from a repaint. The boats that advertise a refit are a chosen few, so part of the gap may reflect which boats get refitted in the first place, not the refit alone. And the

8

‘Refit’ in a listing is one word covering everything from a complete rebuild to new upholstery, and the market pays the word, not the work.

findings are the same whether I count every listing or each yacht once. Two practical conclusions survive all of that. First, for an owner weighing a refit against selling as-is: measure the work against the right line. The question is not ‘what will the refit add?’ but ‘what discount does the yacht carry without it’. For a 25-year-old yacht of 35 metres, that discount is around a fifth of its value, which is roughly what a serious refit costs. The sums more or less balance, and the refit buys one thing the discount never does: a boat that is sold as a yacht, not negotiated as a problem. Second, for anyone selling a refitted boat: say so, clearly and in detail. The one refit effect the market pays reliably is the advertised one. A refit done four years ago still holds the price up – but only if the listing says it happened. Work the buyer cannot see, filed in records the buyer never reads, goes unpaid. Which brings me to the question this report is asking: what is a refit? In my data, the confusion is visible in the price. ‘Refit’ in a listing is one word covering everything from a complete rebuild to new upholstery, and the market pays the word, not the work. The roughly 20 per cent credit goes to any older yacht whose listing can carry it – so the owner of a genuine rebuild earns the same advertised credit as the owner of a repaint, and the biggest projects are subsidising the smallest. Clear, agreed categories – maintenance, refit, rebuild – would let the market price each level of work for what it is and the sellers of properly rebuilt yachts would be the first winners. A yard quoting for a rebuild before a sale could put that arithmetic on the first page of the proposal. And the day listings carry those categories, my model will carry them too. The model, its method and its error margins are published at williamsyachtintelligence.com, and every figure in this piece can be re-calculated from them. The model is re-built every quarter from a fresh sweep of the market, so these numbers will be tested again in January. If your experience of refits adds something to the picture, I would be glad to hear from you. AW


If you could ask the market one question what would it be? S H A R E YO U R Q U E ST I O N

For the past 30 years, The Superyacht Agency, the consultancy division of The Superyacht Group has investigated, analysed, researched and explored what’s really happening in the market, asking very specific questions from owners, investors, CEOs, marketing teams and entrepreneurs who want to better understand the industry from their strategic perspective. We ask the right questions to the right people, generating unique insights, opinions, intelligence and opportunities to deliver strategic analysis and customised research that informs your business, so you can act and react accordingly. No matter what the question, we can find the answer.

Discover Our Consultancy


Yacht lighting performance

10


WHY CIRCADIAN LIGHTING NEEDS A MORE CONSIDERED APPROACH AT SEA

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

11


As understanding of light’s non-visual effects develops, Michael Meeneghan, founder of MP Tech, argues that yacht lighting should be assessed by not only how an interior looks, but also how the light performs for the people living and working on board.

L

ighting has traditionally been evaluated through a predominantly visual lens. Illuminance levels, colour temperature, colour rendering, architectural integration and atmosphere all remain essential components of a successful scheme, particularly within the highly considered interiors of modern superyachts. However, our understanding of the relationship between light and human biology has developed considerably and is continuing to improve. Light does more than enable vision. It is also one of the principal environmental signals used by the human circadian system, contributing to the regulation of sleep and wakefulness, alertness, hormone production and other physiological processes that follow an approximately 24-hour rhythm. For the marine industry, this creates a broader challenge for lighting designers, integrators, naval architects, interior designers, shipyards and specifiers: a yacht can be visually impressive and technically compliant while still providing a relatively poor biological lighting environment for the people on board. Beyond colour temperature Circadian lighting is sometimes reduced to a discussion about warm and cool colour temperatures, but the science is considerably more nuanced. The eye contains photoreceptors responsible for vision alongside light-sensitive cells involved in regulating the circadian system. The biological response to light is influenced by a combination of spectral composition, intensity, timing and duration, which means that two sources with the same nominal colour temperature can have very different physiological effects. This is one reason why conventional lux measurements must not be allowed to tell the whole story. We’ve discussed this before, but measures such as melanopic Equivalent Daylight Illuminance (mEDI)

12

Yacht-lighting performance should increasingly be considered in relation to when, where and how people occupy the vessel, rather than solely through the specification of individual luminaires. provide an additional way of understanding the biological strength of a lighting environment by considering its effect on the melanopic response. When used alongside more familiar measures of visual performance, they allow lighting to be evaluated in a more complete way, and that is why we are now using it as our fourth pillar of circadian lighting. The objective is not simply to maximise melanopic stimulation. Appropriate circadian lighting is fundamentally time-dependent: stronger biological signals are generally desirable during the active part of the day, while those signals should reduce as evening approaches. Natural daylight achieves this progression inherently, but most artificial lighting installations do not. On board a yacht, the relationship with daylight can also vary dramatically from one space to another. A guest on an exterior deck may experience very high levels of natural light, while a crew member working below deck may spend much of the same period with little or no daylight exposure. That makes the quality, timing and biological effectiveness of artificial lighting particularly important.


The same yacht, different biological requirements The limitations of static lighting become particularly clear when the way a yacht is used changes throughout the day. A breakfast area or crew mess at 07:30 may benefit from relatively strong, highquality light that supports both visual tasks and a clear daytime circadian signal. Twelve or fourteen hours later, the architectural environment is unchanged, but the physiological requirement of the person occupying it is very different. A conventional system may nevertheless continue to deliver almost identical light. The marine environment introduces additional complexity. Guests can move rapidly between intense natural daylight on external decks and comparatively low-light interiors, while crew may spend extended periods below deck without meaningful daylight exposure. Watchkeeping, overnight passages, irregular working patterns and frequent changes in time zone can further disrupt

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

the environmental cues used by the circadian system. The issue is therefore not limited to guest suites or wellness environments. The lighting requirements of the bridge, crew mess, galley, technical areas, guest staterooms, saloons, spa and exterior spaces may differ significantly because the people occupying them are carrying out very different tasks, at different times, under very different conditions. This suggests that yacht-lighting performance should increasingly be considered in relation to when, where and how people occupy the vessel, rather than solely through the specification of individual luminaires. Establishing a baseline before specifying a solution This thinking has assisted the development of MP Tech’s Circadian Light-Use Audit, designed to assess the performance of an existing lighting installation before determining whether an intervention is required. Rather than assuming that healthier light-

13


360 410 460 510 560 610 660 710 760

360 410 460 510 560 610 660 710 760

360 410 460 510 560 610 660 710 760

360 410 460 510 560 610 660 710 760

SUNRISE

NOON

EVENING

SUNSET

Crew members beginning an early watch may require light that supports alertness and provides a stronger daytime biological signal. A guest returning to a stateroom late in the evening requires almost the opposite.

14


A lighting assessment needs to combine technical performance with an understanding of how the yacht operates in practice, including guest routines, crew schedules, watch patterns and the relationship between internal spaces and available daylight. ing requires complete replacement, the audit establishes the condition of the existing system and considers its performance against four core areas. Spectral quality looks beyond nominal colour temperature to consider the distribution and balance of wavelengths produced by the LED source. Two sources can appear similar visually while having substantially different spectral characteristics. Colour rendering considers how accurately the light reproduces the colours of materials, finishes, artwork, food and skin tones. Within superyacht interiors, where material selection, artwork and visual detail are integral to the design, MP Tech Solutions always works towards a CRI of 97+ where appropriate. Flicker performance examines the stability of the light output. LED drivers and dimming technologies can create rapid fluctuations that may not always be consciously visible but remain an important consideration in the technical quality and visual comfort of an installation. Finally, circadian-effective light, using mEDI measurements, provides a way of assessing the biological signal delivered by the lighting at different times of day. The value lies in considering these elements together rather than treating any single metric as evidence of a healthy lighting environment. For existing yachts, this kind of assessment can be particularly valuable because it establishes what is already performing effectively before significant refit work is proposed. Lighting performance cannot be separated from use Specification data alone is not enough. A highquality light source can still be used at an inappropriate intensity or at the wrong time of day, while a technically capable installation may

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

be limited by its programming or control strategy. Equally, the requirements of individual spaces can differ significantly. A bridge or crew working environment serves a very different physiological purpose from a guest stateroom, cinema, spa or evening saloon. Crew members beginning an early watch may require light that supports alertness and provides a stronger daytime biological signal. A guest returning to a stateroom late in the evening requires almost the opposite. The same principle applies during overnight operation. Lighting required for safe movement and working must still perform its visual function, but excessive biological stimulation at inappropriate times may be counterproductive. A lighting assessment therefore needs to combine technical performance with an understanding of how the yacht operates in practice, including guest routines, crew schedules, watch patterns and the relationship between internal spaces and available daylight. This can reveal that an installation is fundamentally sound but would benefit from changes to particular light sources, drivers or control settings. In other cases, it may demonstrate that the underlying technology cannot deliver the spectral or circadian performance required. From targeted refit to human-centric lighting Once a technical baseline has been established, the appropriate level of intervention becomes clearer. For some existing yachts, a circadianfriendly lighting update may be sufficient. Selected LED sources, drivers, fittings or programming can be improved while retaining infrastructure that continues to perform effectively. This approach has particular relevance during refit periods, where improvements to wellbeing, comfort and lighting quality need to be balanced against the existing interior, on-board

15


For owners and guests, well-considered lighting can become another component of an increasingly sophisticated approach to on-board wellness ... For crew, the potential relevance is arguably even greater. infrastructure, available access and the practical implications of major replacement works. It also avoids the assumption that improving biological lighting performance automatically requires an entirely new installation. Where the opportunity is greater, the next step may be a complete Human-Centric Lighting (HCL) strategy. HCL moves beyond static scenes by allowing the lighting environment to evolve throughout the day. Through controlled changes in intensity and spectral characteristics, a system can deliver stronger, more biologically effective light during the morning and daytime before transitioning towards warmer, lower-stimulus conditions as evening approaches. On board, this can also allow different areas of the yacht to respond according to their function and occupancy. Crew working environments can be treated differently from guest accommodation, while interior spaces with limited daylight can compensate more intelligently for the absence of natural environmental cues.

16

When integrated correctly, these changes become part of the normal operation of the yacht rather than something guests or crew need to manage manually. It represents an important change in the role of lighting: from a collection of fixtures designed primarily to illuminate and create atmosphere, to an environmental system capable of supporting the way people live, work and rest at sea. A wider definition of good yacht lighting None of this diminishes the importance of aesthetics. Within the superyacht industry, the visual experience remains fundamental, and lighting plays an essential role in revealing materials, shaping architecture and creating atmosphere. The opportunity is to broaden the definition of a successful yacht lighting scheme so that interior design intent, visual performance and biological performance are considered together. There is also an important distinction between guest experience and crew wellbeing, although the principles apply to both. For owners and guests, well-considered lighting can become another component of an increasingly sophisticated approach to on-board wellness, helping the yacht respond more naturally as the day progresses and as the vessel moves between locations and time zones. For crew, who may live and work on board for extended periods and have considerably less control over their exposure to natural daylight, the potential relevance is arguably even greater. As circadian science becomes more widely understood, the question for the marine lighting industry may therefore be shifting from simply, “Does this yacht look well lit?” to a more demanding one: “Is the lighting appropriate for the people occupying this part of the yacht, at the time they are experiencing it?” For existing vessels, a structured audit provides a practical way of beginning that conversation: establishing what is performing well, identifying where limitations exist and determining whether the appropriate response is a targeted circadianfriendly refit or a more comprehensive HumanCentric Lighting solution. MM


LA CIOTAT / TOULON HARBOUR / BORDEAUX / CARIBBEAN / SXM


Guest Column by Terry Allen

Adapt and react Terry Allen, Director at Maritime Engineering Consultancy Services, spells out the difference between a shipyard that simply carries out work and one that knows how to manage a maintenance period. Refit or maintenance? To start with, let’s get the concept right: a refit changes or repurposes a vessel; maintenance keeps it in service. In yachting, annual maintenance and the five-year Class cycle are regular realities. Too often, however, a planned maintenance period grows into a refit without anyone acknowledging the change in scope.

facilities, and then other third parties in the industry add their elements. We now have a situation of ego and ideas that simply complicate matters and creates a maintenance period with a refit element thrown in, but no coordinated game plan and allows the shipyards to increase budgets. The old story of where there is mystery there is a margin.

Yachts arrive with incomplete work lists and limited technical information. The yard may understand the broad objective but not the true extent of the work. That is where its ability is tested – or, depending on the ability of the shipyard, where the opportunities begin . Adapt and react should be a working discipline, not a slogan. Not every shipyard understands the difference.

Nobody can predict everything that will be found when equipment is dismantled, tanks opened or insulation removed. Hidden corrosion, deteriorated pipework and questionable previous repairs are familiar discoveries. These are not examples of poor planning, they are the realities of working on an existing vessel.

The specification that doesn’t exist In an ideal world, a yacht would arrive with a detailed specification, accurate drawings, equipment histories, an agreed budget and a realistic completion date. In yachting, this is often wishful thinking. The captain has an operational work list, the chief engineer identifies machinery problems, the owner wants improvements to accommodation or

18

The mistake is not discovering additional work, it’s failing to establish who will assess it, authorise it and incorporate it into the programme. A shipyard must be more than a contractor A shipyard that simply waits for instructions, prepares quotations and carries out individual jobs is not necessarily equipped to manage a complicated maintenance period. It must take a broader technical and operational view of the vessel.

When a defect appears, the first questions are practical: is it critical to safety, Class or reliability? What is the repair method? Can it be done within the programme? Can other work be resequenced? What will it cost and who can authorise it? These questions require experienced people who understand ships, machinery and the consequences of their decisions. There is little value in a project manager who produces an impressive spreadsheet but cannot distinguish a genuine technical problem from an opportunity to increase the invoice. Equally, a technically competent workforce without effective coordination can waste enormous amounts of time and money. The successful shipyard needs both. Technical competence is essential, but so is the authority to make a decision while the work is still moving. Flexibility without losing control Flexibility is not the absence of a plan. The programme must identify the critical path, access constraints and long-lead materials, then be updated as actual conditions become clear. Consider the removal of an exhaust system. Significant corrosion is


There is no substitute for walking the vessel, inspecting the work and speaking directly to the trades. Problems are often identified faster on board than around a conference table. discovered in the supporting structure, although the specification contains no steel replacement. A poorly managed yard stops the work, waits for instructions and a quotation, then extends the programme. Other trades lose access and the delay spreads. A competent yard assesses the corrosion, agrees a repair method, identifies materials and works out how to integrate the steelwork with the ongoing jobs. The owner’s representative receives the findings, cost and programme impact promptly. Approval is obtained and work continues. The difference is not the defect, it’s the time lost between discovering it and making a workable decision. The commercial reality Unexpected work is a legitimate part of the business but unexpected expenditure without proper explanation or control is not. Owners must accept that additional defects will be discovered and that correcting them costs money. However, shipyards must also recognise that an incomplete initial specification is not an open invitation to issue uncontrolled variation orders. An incomplete specification is not an open cheque book. Variation orders must identify the defect, the proposed work, the cost basis and any effect on delivery before approval. Not every defect demands the

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

most expensive solution. A properly engineered repair may offer years of service, while a temporary fix may simply postpone a failure. The cheapest route is not necessarily the best one. The objective is a sound technical and commercial result for the owner. That requires transparency and the willingness to tell an owner something they may not want to hear. The shipyard must be equally honest about its own capabilities. Promising an unrealistic delivery date to win a contract and then blaming every delay on additional work is poor commercial practice. Communication One recurring weakness is not a shortage of meetings but a shortage of decisions. Minutes circulate while the people on board wait for an answer. A single work register should show findings, photographs, instructions, approvals, costs, responsibilities and completion status. More importantly, each open item needs a named decision-maker and a deadline. Digital systems help, but they cannot replace accountability. Nor is there a substitute for walking the vessel, inspecting the work and speaking directly to the trades. Problems are often identified faster on board than around a conference table.

The delivery date The delivery date is a commercial commitment, not a decorative line on a programme. A missed departure can disrupt an owner’s cruise, a signed charter, crew arrangements and downstream bookings. The real cost extends well beyond the shipyard invoice. Safety, workmanship and Class requirements are not negotiable, but non-essential improvements can sometimes be deferred rather than allowing them to put the entire vessel programme at risk. The real measure of a shipyard A shipyard is not judged by the appearance of its offices or the confidence of its sales presentation. It is judged by what happens on a difficult Tuesday afternoon when the plating is opened, the drawings are wrong and the next contractor is waiting for access . The yards worth returning to do not pretend there will be no surprises. They have the people, judgement and commercial discipline to deal with them without turning every discovery into a crisis. “Adapt and react” is not an excuse for poor preparation. It is the discipline of managing the unexpected without losing sight of the objective. That is what separates a yard capable of carrying out work from one capable of delivering the vessel. TA

19


THE GEOGRAPHY OF REFIT The Med leads, while Northern Europe is on the rise. Jan Pieter Braam and Ilaria Bernardi of JPMarine report on where yachts are heading for refit.

A

s owners’ reps and project managers, our jobs largely revolve around planning. A primary decision to make in planning a refit project, before narrowing down to the specific shipyard, is where the yacht should go into the sheds. In Europe, the Mediterranean is still by far the most common choice. From Gibraltar to Antalya, the coast accounted for over 60 per cent of all yard visits in 2025. Functioning as one of the most popular cruising grounds for yachts during summer and offering an extensive network of specialised shipyards and service partners, the Med stands strong as the most popular refit destination in the world. Southern Europe is followed by Florida with less than half the visits, close to 30 per cent of all traffic globally. However, a (in refit terms) smaller brother on the continent is catching up. While Northern Europe is of course known for its large new-build projects, at 2.3 per cent it still represents only a tiny proportion of the refit market. Yet another figure offers a different perspective. The average yacht visiting a Northern European shipyard measured 66.5 metres. In the Med, varying between West and East, that number was between

20

44.5 and 49 metres. These figures are worth considering together. They do not necessarily suggest that one region is performing better than the other, but that different regions attract different profiles of yachts and work. As JPMarine, with a presence in both The Netherlands and Italy, from our respective positions, we see how these regional differences influence the choices available to owners and their teams. Different regions, different strengths Northern Europe has developed a substantial concentration of technical expertise around the construction of large, complex yachts. The Netherlands and Germany, in particular, have established networks of shipyards, architects, engineering companies, equipment manufacturers and specialist subcontractors. Much of this expertise has developed through new-build projects, but it is equally relevant when an existing yacht requires extensive structural modifications, systems integration or technically demanding work. For an owner considering a significant conversion or a major engineering upgrade, access to this knowledge can be an important consideration.

The Mediterranean offers a different set of advantages. Its refit infrastructure has developed around one of the world's principal cruising regions, with an extensive network of shipyards, service facilities, contractors and suppliers supporting yachts throughout their operational lives. Yachts can access established facilities alongside specialist subcontractors covering everything from mechanical engineering and electrical systems to interiors, painting and deck equipment. The concentration of operational yachts also supports an extensive service infrastructure, with companies accustomed to responding to the practical requirements of vessels working to demanding seasonal schedules. There is, of course, considerable overlap. Northern European yards take on maintenance and smaller refits, just as Mediterranean facilities regularly execute complex technical projects and conversions. We would be cautious about associating particular types of work exclusively with one region. What influences the choice of a refit location? Beyond the regional differences, choosing the right refit destination involves a


DESTINATION

VISITS

AVG LOA

Mediterraenean

2,268 1,084 83 76 68 44

46.7M 41.6M 66.5M 44.1M 39.6M 39.3M

Florida Northern Europe East Coast America Pacific Rim West Coast America

SHARE OF VISITS

Particularly during extended refits, the availability Project scope. A yacht entering the yard of suitable for a routine check-up presents a very different proposition from one underaccommodation going a major upgrade, structural mod or complete interior overhaul. and local amenities While proximity to the yacht’s cruising programme may be decisive for smaller for crew can make works, more complex projects can justify travelling much further. a considerable Yard capacity and capability. Having difference. sufficient space to accommodate a yacht broader set of considerations. From an owner’s representative’s perspective, the decision should be based on the individual details of the project brief, rather than geography alone.

does not necessarily mean a yard is best equipped to undertake the work. Technical expertise, equipment, engineering capabilities and previous experience are equally important.

Specialist suppliers and subcontractors. The yard is only one part of a refit. Access to experienced subcontractors, OEMs, and service partners is critical, particularly when multiple disciplines need to work together within a limited timeframe. Existing relationships. Owners, captains and management teams often have established relationships with particular yards and suppliers. Previous experience, familiarity with the yacht and mutual trust are important pillars.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

62.6% 29.9% 2.3% 2.1% 1.9% 1.2%

Transit and logistics. Moving a yacht to a refit destination involves fuel, crew time, transport arrangements and operational costs. Availability and scheduling. An available berth does not mean that all of the required resources are available. Yard capacity, contractors schedules, equipment lead times and the yacht’s cruising programme must align for a realistic project timeline. Crew welfare and local environment. Particularly during extended refits, the availability of suitable accommodation and local amenities for crew can make a considerable difference. The captain and crew also bring valuable operational knowledge to the project, making their involvement and working conditions important considerations. Ultimately, these factors are interconnected and their importance changes from one project to another. Our role as owner’s representatives is to assess these considerations collectively, identifying the combination of location, facilities, people and commercial arrangements best suited to the owner’s objectives. Jan Pieter Braam and Ilaria Bernardi are Owner’s Representatives and Project Managers at JPMarine, working from the Netherlands and Italy respectively. Their work involves overseeing yacht projects and representing owners' interests across Northern Europe and the Mediterranean.

21


Guest Column by Lee Stevenson

Future-proofing the refit A refit is usually planned around the next few seasons; however, the best ones are planned around the next owner. Lee Stevenson, Co-Founder of OCCAM, sets out what owners, captains and managers should be asking before the yard period starts, so the money spent today is still working in ten years’ time.

Every refit is a rare moment of access. The ceilings are down, the tank tops are open and the yacht is out of service. It is the one time when the decisions that shape the next decade can be made at a sensible cost. Yet most refit specifications are written as a list of what is broken, worn or out of date. That is necessary, but it is not enough. A refit that only restores the yacht to how it was on delivery has, in effect, bought it a few more years of falling behind. Futureproofing is not about chasing every new technology. It is about knowing which decisions are expensive to make later and making room for them now. In our experience, that comes down to seven questions. 1.Whose future are we planning for? The first question is not a technical one, it’s about how long the owner expects to keep the yacht and how it will be used. An owner planning to sell within three years needs a refit that protects value and survives a buyer’s survey. An owner planning to keep their yacht for a decade needs a refit that anticipates how their family, guests and cruising will change. A yacht moving into charter needs to meet commercial requirements and a broker’s expectations.

22

These are three different specifications. We always ask an owner to think about the next owner too. Most yachts change hands at least once. The features that hold value at resale – sound regulatory standing, credible systems, clean documentation and a sensible layout – are rarely the ones that make the brochure, but they are what a good surveyor and a well-advised buyer look for first. The captain and crew must steer this conversation from day one. They know how the yacht is really used, where it falls short and what wears out first. Operational experience belongs in the design process and a refit is no exception. 2. What will the rules look like when the yacht next comes in? Regulation rarely arrives as a surprise. It is usually visible years ahead, and a refit is the time to plan for it rather than react to it. The question to ask is not ‘are we compliant today?’ but ‘what will we be asked for at the next yard period and will today’s work make that easier or harder?’ • Engines and emissions. Under MARPOL Annex VI, installing an additional engine, fitting a non-identical replacement or raising an engine’s rating by more than 10 per cent can count as a major conversion. That can bring the yacht into the NOx Tier

in force at the time, including Tier III where it operates in an Emission Control Area. Like-for-like swaps are treated differently. An owner who decides on a re-engine or new generators needs to know which side of that line they are on before the order is placed, not after. • Lithium-ion batteries. The MCA’s MGN 681, as amended at the end of 2025, says lithium-ion batteries for tenders, toys and small craft may only be charged in a certified container or space. On UK-registered yachts those containers must be certified by 1 January 2027. Every yacht carrying e-foils, electric tenders or seabobs should be planning the space, ventilation and fire protection for this now. • Cyber resilience. IACS Unified Requirements E26 and E27 apply to new ships contracted for construction on or after 1 July 2024. They are not retrospective, but they set the standard buyers, insurers and class will increasingly measure older yachts against. • Carbon. The IMO Net-Zero Framework, aimed at ships over 5,000gt, had its adoption adjourned in October 2025. The UK ETS was due to cover maritime emissions from 1 July 2026 for vessels over 5,000gt, and the EU’s maritime ETS and FuelEU rules are due for review in 2027. Most yachts sit outside these schemes


today. The direction of travel is towards smaller vessels and wider scope, and a yacht being refitted now will still be in service when that happens. • Flag and code changes. The 2024 REG Yacht Code continues to be amended, most recently on fire safety for yachts under 500gt. Any significant modification should be discussed with flag and class early, because the scope of work can change which standard applies. The practical step is simple: before the specification is frozen, run a regulatory horizon review with class, flag and the management company. List what is coming in the next five to ten years and decide what to do now, what to prepare for and what to leave. 3. How will the yacht be powered in ten years? Nobody can say with confidence which fuel will win. That is exactly why a refit should keep options open rather than bet on one answer. Start with the energy you do not use. Hotel load is usually the largest consumer on board, and lighting, HVAC and oversized generators running at low load are where most yachts waste fuel. An energy survey before the specification is written costs little and often pays for itself in the first season. It also gives the owner a baseline, which will matter if emissions reporting reaches yachts and on resale as evidence of the yachts fuel efficiency Then look at fuel flexibility. Drop-in renewable fuels such as HVO are the most practical route for the existing fleet, because they need little or no change to engines or tanks. Confirming engine and generator approval for HVO, and checking seals, filters and fuel system compatibility, is a sensible refit item. Methanol is further off for refit, not least because it needs roughly 2.4 times the volume of diesel for the same energy. But engine makers are moving: in August 2026 DNV issued a Methanol Readiness Certificate for the current MTU Series 4000. If a yacht is being re-engined, a ‘ready’ notation is worth asking about.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

Every yacht gains weight over its life. New toys, extra stone, heavier AV, additional tanks and years of small modifications all add up. Each refit that adds without measuring eats into the margin the next owner will need. Finally, think about electrical architecture. Better shore power, battery capacity for silent anchoring and switchboards with spare capacity and space all make later hybridisation far easier. The cheapest futureproofing is often a larger cable tray, a spare breaker and a few cubic metres of unallocated space in the right place. 4. How much margin is left? Every yacht gains weight over its life. New toys, extra stone, heavier AV, additional tanks and years of small modifications all add up. Each refit that adds without measuring eats into the margin the next owner will need. Before committing to a scope, we recommend an honest look at where the yacht sits today: • Weight and stability. When was the lightship last verified? How far is the yacht from its stability limits and what does the proposed work add? A refit that pushes it close to the line leaves no room for batteries, treatment systems or new tanks later. • Volume. Where is the unallocated space in the technical areas? Treatment systems, battery rooms, certified lithiumion lockers and larger fuel filtration all need somewhere to go. Protect that space rather than filling it with storage.

• Routes and access. Cable trays, pipe runs, hull and bulkhead penetrations, and removal routes for major equipment. If the ceilings are down anyway, adding spare capacity costs a fraction of what it will later . • Structure. Deck loads for heavier tenders and toys, and foundations for equipment that may be added in future. None of this is glamorous. It is, however, in our view, where the best value in a refit is usually found. 5. Will the systems still be supported? The hull will outlast almost everything bolted to it. IT, AV, navigation, alarm and monitoring, and control systems now have working lives measured in years rather than decades. The risk is not that they fail, it’s that the manufacturer stops supporting them and a single obsolete component forces a much bigger replacement. A good refit starts with an obsolescence review of every major system: what is installed, when support ends and what depends on what. That turns surprise failures into planned replacements, phased across future yard periods. When systems are replaced, we would push for: • Open, documented architecture rather

23


Guest Column by Lee Stevenson

Refit is rarely about the newest technology – it is more about asking the right questions as early as possible, protecting margin and space, keeping options open and leaving a clear record behind. than closed proprietary platforms, so future suppliers can integrate without starting again.

• A clear photographic record of what sits behind the linings, taken while the ceilings are down.

• Separated networks for guest, crew and operational systems, designed with cyber resilience in mind from the outset, even where the rules do not yet require it.

• Class and flag records closed out cleanly, with no open items carried forward without a plan.

• Infrastructure over equipment. Fibre backbones, spare cores, structured cabling and well-ventilated racks will outlive three generations of screens and access points. • Connectivity that can change. Satellite services have changed faster in the last five years than in the previous twenty. Mounts, cabling and power should allow antennas and providers to be swapped without structural work. 6. Will the next team know what was done? The most undervalued output of any refit is the paperwork. A yacht whose drawings, manuals and records match what is actually on board is cheaper to maintain, quicker to survey, easier to refit again and more valuable at sale. Too often, the as-built record is the last thing on the list and the first thing cut when time runs short. We would treat it as a deliverable with the same importance as the final invoice. In practice that means: • As-built drawings and GA plans updated for every modification, not just the major ones.

24

• Augmented reality videos of the inner workings of the yacht, equipment, fixtures, systems and fittings. The next refit team, and the next owner’s surveyor, will thank you for it. 7. Is the plan built for one yard period or several? Futureproofing is as much about process as it is about technology. The best refit plans we see look beyond the current yard period and treat the yacht’s life as a sequence of planned interventions. That starts early. Thorough pre-refit surveys, including the areas that are hard to reach, reduce the number of discoveries once work begins. A specification written around a clear owner brief, with every item tagged as ‘now’, ‘prepare for’ or ‘later’, keeps scope under control and makes the trade-offs visible. It also means being disciplined about what not to do. Value is won or lost in the specification. Adding scope mid-refit is the most reliable way to overrun on time and cost, and the future-proofing items are usually the first to be cut when that happens. Protecting them from the start is far easier. Three habits make the biggest difference:

• Equipment lists, certificates and manuals handed over in a structured, searchable form.

a. A long-term refit plan covering at least the next two yard periods, so today’s decisions are made with the next ones in view.

• The planned maintenance system updated before the yacht leaves the yard, so the crew start with an accurate picture.

b. A ring-fenced allowance for futureproofing items, separate from the contingency, so it is not quietly spent on surprises.

c. Independent representation. The yard’s priority is to deliver the contract. The owner needs someone whose only priority is the yacht and its future. Refit for the next owner OCCAM takes its name from Occam’s Razor: the simplest solution is often the most effective. Future-proofing a refit fits that idea well, and a conversation that ideally should start when the yacht is being constructed to make it ‘refit ready’. It is rarely about the newest technology – it is more about asking the right questions as early as possible, protecting margin and space, keeping options open and leaving a clear record behind. Before any refit specification is signed off, we would want every owner to have a clear answer to these questions: • How long will the owner keep their yacht and how will it be used? • Which regulations will apply at the next yard period and does this scope change which standard applies now? • Has an energy survey been done, and are engines and generators approved for renewable fuels? • How much weight, stability and space margin is left after this refit? • Which systems reach end of support in the next five years? • Will the as-built record match the yacht when it leaves the yard? • Is there a plan for the next two-yard periods and a protected budget for futureproofing? A refit is a chance to refine. Done well, it leaves the yacht better than it was and ready for whatever comes next. LS


Future technology infrastructure

FROM VIRTUALISATION TO

AI

BY ERNESTO ESPOSITO, OMNIACCESS

Rethinking the technology foundation of the modern yacht.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

25


O

nce upon a time, humans augmented their capabilities and solved problems by buying purpose-built appliances and installing them in their own environments, whether an office, a home or a vessel. Let’s take a vessel’s technical environment as an example, of course. The advent of broadband internet at sea, from VSAT to 5G and Starlink, pushed captains and ETOs to buy and install new antennas, modems and routers to make these indispensable services available to crew and guests. Then crew and guests realised that they could not access internet content from their home countries. So many started buying and installing VPN routers that allowed them to use their personal overseas accounts to access content such as TV shows and streaming services. Later, the need to control data usage became increasingly important, particularly with the capped data packages introduced by cellular and LEO operators such as Starlink and OneWeb. As a result, many legacy management systems needed a companion to control data usage, and here came the need for another server running a captive portal solution or similar application. Then we all realised that cyber incidents were becoming an increasingly frequent reality in maritime. A more powerful next-generation firewall became the bare minimum required to mitigate that risk – and here came yet another important system to install on board. Actually, two systems are always better than one when you want to reduce the risk of downtime if one fails. And all of this runs alongside the many other single-purpose appliances supporting the vessel’s network and IT infrastructure, including switches, Wi-Fi access points, servers, storage systems and more. Does this sound familiar if you are a captain, engineer or someone involved in building or refitting the technology stack of a vessel? Of course it does. Most vessels are still expanding their technology capabilities by stacking up ‘boxes’, adding cables and managing everything through different dashboards and vendors.

26

While all this fragmentation allows us to achieve specific goals, it also generates higher infrastructure costs, increased operating expenses, greater complexity and, perhaps most importantly, more time spent managing technology. For instance, studies suggest that during a typical working day, employees can spend close to an hour switching between and reorienting themselves across different tools and applications. Multiply that across an organisation and across an entire year, and consider how many hours are spent simply searching for information or triggering actions across different systems. Similarly, research suggests that fragmented data-centre architectures can result in significantly higher power consumption compared with consolidated environments. And there is another major challenge we face in technology today: the extraordinary pace of change. Especially with the mass adoption of AI, technology onshore is advancing at a pace humanity has never experienced before. At sea, however, the pace still feels completely different and considerably slower. So what is holding vessels back from evolving as quickly as the world around them? I like to think of it as a “convenient lack of vision”. Let me explain why. Convenient procurement Vessels are often designed around four years before their launch, and their technical specifications are frequently based on recycled bills of materials rather than on future users’ needs. The fault does not necessarily lie with any one person or organisation. Project teams understandably approach new projects by leveraging previous success stories and proven solutions, but this approach does not strategically consider what comes next. Even today, the technology infrastructure of some of the world’s most technologically advanced floating assets is designed not around a vision of the applications and services on-board users will need in the future, but around cost constraints and what buyers and project teams know today. This ultimately penalises the buyer,

A virtualised platform can provide the flexibility to integrate new applications as users’ requirements evolve, without requiring physical changes to the underlying infrastructure every time a new capability is introduced.

Ernesto Esposito, Head of Technical Sales and Account Management, OmniAccess.


who may already need to allocate additional budget by the time the vessel is delivered simply to modernise infrastructure that is becoming outdated . Convenient confidence Humans are naturally attracted to their comfort zones. In a technology context, this behaviour was described by sociologist Everett Rogers in his 1962 Diffusion of Innovations theory. Rogers showed how different groups adopt innovation at different speeds, with the majority tending to wait until they are influenced by evidence, experience or external pressure. On vessels, we see this pattern frequently, particularly among technical teams. Try convincing an engineer that it is time to replace a control system they have used successfully for years with something completely new. Their reaction is understandable: Why should I change something that works and that I know how to operate? Change requires time and motivation – and motivation is much easier to create when there is a clear vision of how that change can improve both our work and our lives. For this reason, the evolution of vessel technology is an industry-wide responsibility, starting with shipyards and builders and extending all the way to owners and end users.

Modern technology infrastructure needs to move away from siloed, single-purpose boxes. It needs to be scalable and capable of providing users with the services they need regardless of the year in which their vessel was built.

From boxes to technology domains Modern technology infrastructure needs to move away from siloed, single-purpose boxes. It needs to be scalable and capable of providing users with the services they need regardless of the year in which their vessel was built. This requires a paradigm shift: rather than considering a vessel’s technology infrastructure as one broad technical environment, we should design it around five distinct technology domains: • Network • Audio-video • IT • Applications • Cybersecurity Today, many vessels are still designed and built with essentially the same single-domain mindset used 20 years ago: the AV-IT domain. Audio-

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

27


A virtualised platform can provide the flexibility to integrate new applications as users’ requirements evolve.

Video is mixed with network systems and IT assets, while the applications and cybersecurity layers are often left for the final users to determine how to manage, without a clear design-and-build strategy from the outset. Consider AI as an example. Almost everyone on board is already using AI in some form. Many AI transactions need to travel to the cloud and back, often passing through public infrastructure. Yet, in many cases, there are limited cybersecurity guardrails in place to prevent incidents or data leakage. There may be no centralised administration defining which users are allowed to use which AI services and no data loss prevention mechanisms protecting sensitive information. All of this could be planned and designed from the beginning by treating cybersecurity as a dedicated technology domain requiring specialised expertise, architecture and services. Instead, cybersecurity is too often considered simply another feature of a ‘box’ included somewhere in an AV-IT bill of materials. Another example? Applications used by crew and guests are often treated as “their problem”. Project teams install the infrastructure and assume that users will achieve great performance. But how many projects actually look at exactly what users will be doing and what experience they will receive? An approach in which the applications layer is separated from the net-

28

work layer makes it possible to design and scope a scalable application environment, such as the OmniAccess Unity Possibilities Platform. These five domains should therefore be treated as distinct but interconnected layers, each requiring specialised expertise and dedicated design from the very beginning of any new-build or refit project. The application layer: from infrastructure to possibilities For the applications layer, technologies such as hyperconvergence and virtualisation can fundamentally change the approach. A virtualised platform can provide the flexibility to integrate new applications as users’ requirements evolve, without requiring physical changes to the underlying infrastructure every time a new capability is introduced. And that environment can extend from the edge (the vessel) to private and public cloud environments, depending on the functions being performed, the data being handled, and the performance and security requirements involved. Imagine a rack hosting a pair of identical servers running your vessel’s applications layer. Imagine a single pane of glass managing those applications. Imagine security and performance logs from multiple applications being collected, correlated and processed without requiring additional dedicated systems. Imagine AI helping you operate your technology environment, while

also helping to protect it. It is possible today, and it can be incorporated into the applications layer scope of a new-build or refit project from the very beginning, separated from the rest. Key takeaway: design for what comes next The question for shipyards, project teams, captains, ETOs and owners should become: “What technology foundation will allow this vessel to adapt to what comes next?” A yacht delivered today may remain in service for decades, while the technologies, applications, cybersecurity threats and AI capabilities surrounding it will evolve continuously. We cannot predict every application that will be needed five or ten years from now, but we can design an infrastructure capable of accommodating them. That is the paradigm shift: from buying technology for individual problems to building a platform for possibilities. For every new-build or refit project, the call to action is therefore simple: design for change from day one. Separate the technology domains, consolidate where it makes sense, virtualise what can be virtualised, connect edge and cloud intelligently, and make cybersecurity part of the architecture, not an afterthought. Because the ultimate objective should be to build a yacht that has the foundation to remain technologically advanced throughout its lifetime, and not just at its delivery. EE


You own We advise You charter We inform You cruise We plan You explore We guide You manage We research You buy We analyse You sell We connect You design We report You build We create You repair We strategise You service We market You are The Superyacht Market. We are The Superyacht Group.

superyachtnews.com


End-of-life costs analysis

Who pays to close the hull? A yacht is costed to the last fender before it is built. However, almost nothing in this industry is costed for the day it stops being a yacht – and that bill is already accruing quietly across the fleet.


BY JAIME RECASENS

P

icture a sailing yacht of 25 metres in the back corner of a yard on the Mediterranean coast, ashore for four years, invoiced for the first two and paid for none. It came in under its own power, went up on the hard for a survey that was never paid for and then the emails stopped being answered. The yacht is too intact to be called a wreck and too tired to be worth restoring. The boat is invented for this article and every yard manager reading it can supply the real one. Ask anyone in this business what that boat is worth and the answer comes within a minute, qualified by market, flag and refit history. Ask what it costs to close it and the room goes quiet. By ‘closing’ I mean lifting it, stripping out the systems and tanks, cutting the laminate to a size a licensed facility will take and moving every fraction to a plant entitled to receive it, with a paper trail that survives an inspection three years later. The figure exists and it’s substantial, but very few people in yachting have ever written it down. Part of the reason is that our instincts were formed around metal. A steel or aluminium vessel reaches the end of its life with a positive number attached to it, because the recycler is buying. A glassreinforced hull behaves in the opposite direction. The resin is a thermoset, crosslinked during cure and impossible to melt back into anything, so what comes off the saw is a mineral-rich solid with a combustible fraction locked into it. The outlet that operates at real volume in Europe today is co-processing in cement kilns, which takes the material as a solid recovered fuel within narrow limits of particle size, moisture, chlorine and calorific value. In France, where the figures are published, a little over half of the composite recovered from dismantled boats goes that way and the rest to controlled disposal.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

31


Better routes are coming, slowly. Pyrolysis and solvolysis plants are appearing, including mobile units now working on boat laminate. Gasification can convert the organic fraction into a fuel gas and take the mineral residue off as a slag, turning part of a disposal cost into an energy credit. What governs all of them is the laminate itself, because two thirds of a glass hull carries no energy and still has to be heated, so the resin content of the boat decides whether a thermal route pays. Capacity remains small against the volumes arriving and landfill is closing across member states. Whatever leaves the yard leaves as an expense and somebody standing nearby carries it. Priced line by line for Western Europe, the gross cost of closing that boat runs to some 40,000 euros. That covers the lift and the depollution, the weeks of strip-out and cutting, the containers and the haulage, a gate fee on every fraction that leaves the gate, the paperwork and the yard space it occupies for a month or more. Against it sit the credits, and here a sailing yacht has the advantage over a motor boat, because fifteen tonnes of lead are bolted to the bottom of it. Scrap lead, the winches, the engine and the electronics can bring the net figure down towards 25,000 euros, a shade under 1,000 euros per linear metre. That is the arithmetic for a complete boat. Boats waiting to be abandoned are stripped of their gear first and a keel is easy to sell on quietly, so by the time the yard inherits the problem the credits have gone and the gross is what remains. Add a long haul to the one plant that will take the laminate, and a bottom sample that comes back from the laboratory classified as hazardous, and the same boat passes 90,000 euros. Labour dominates the gross figure, which should surprise nobody. These structures are engineered to survive 50 years of slamming loads and resist being taken apart with the same tenacity. Bulkheads are bonded rather than bolted, stringers are laminated into the shell, and a well-built hull blunts a great deal of cutting media before it yields. The first time I priced this kind of work I was out by half on the cutting, because I had costed it as demolition when it behaves more like surgery. Around that sit the awkward fractions: cored panels that no route will take as a mixed sandwich, and

32

Table 1. What it costs to close a 25-metre composite sailing yacht (euros excl. VAT) Cost line

Favourable

Central

Adverse

Strip-out labour

3,840

8,000

17,600

Hull cutting and segmenting

2,880

6,400

14,300

Composite treatment

2,344

5,859

19,530

Haul-out, handling and cradle

2,500

4,500

8,000

Yard occupancy

1,500

4,250

12,000

Road transport to treatment

1,800

4,200

12,000

Hazardous fractions

1,575

2,835

4,410

Depollution

1,200

2,200

4,000

Cutting consumables and containment

800

1,600

3,000

Containers and on-site handling

900

1,600

2,800

Other waste streams

756

1,134

1,638

Documentation and deregistration

400

700

1,200

Gross closure cost

20,495

43,278

100,478

Lead ballast recovered

(18,000)

(13,500)

(9,000)

Equipment resold

(12,000)

(4,000)

(500)

Metals recovered

(1,210)

(832)

(567)

Net closure cost

(10,715)

24,946

90,411

Cost per linear metre

(429)

998

3,616

A negative net figure means the recovered lead and gear more than cover the work, which assumes the boat arrives complete. Indicative build-up, Western Europe. Source: RCA Engineering.


tanks that must be cleaned and certified before anyone will touch them. Distance matters too. Cut composite fills a trailer’s volume long before its weight limit, which is why the same hull costs materially different sums to close in Barcelona, in Southampton and in Split. Above 500 gross tonnes the regulatory answer is at least visible. The Hong Kong Convention came into force on 26 June 2025 and applies to ships of that size on international voyages. The European Ship Recycling Regulation has applied since 2018 to Europeanflagged ships above the same threshold and obliges larger vessels calling at European ports to carry an inventory of hazardous materials whatever flag they fly. Neither was written with yachts in mind. Both catch them. Below that line the picture changes. France has the only mature scheme in the sector, created by the energy transition law of 2015, run by APER and financed by an eco-contribution that builders and importers pay on every new boat sold. It works: 3,079 boats dismantled during 2025 and more than 16,000 since 2019, at no cost to the

owner. It also stops at 24 metres. Between that ceiling and the 500-tonne threshold lies an entire class of yacht for which no dedicated instrument exists, governed by ordinary waste law that hands the duty to whoever holds the material when the question is finally asked. The boat in that yard is 25 metres, which puts it one metre outside the only scheme in Europe that would have paid for it. The same blind spot runs through the insurance chain. When a hull is written off as a constructive total loss the underwriter takes title to what remains and the salvage line is habitually treated as zero or better. Once the keel and the gear have gone, that line is negative. An underwriter settling on a 40-year-old laminate hull has bought a disposal liability and booked it as an asset, and I have yet to see a hull book that reserves for it. So who pays today? Whoever cannot walk away. The yard absorbs it or the marina does, or a harbour authority carries the boat through the years that abandonment proceedings take until the public purse settles the invoice. None of them built it, sold it, insured it or enjoyed it.

Whoever writes the number gets to write the method, and a yard that can show a funded closure plan will find it becomes a quiet selling point in front of an owner who intends to sell again in eight years.

Table 2. Reference points Source

Figure

Relevance

France, APER scheme, 2025

3,079 boats dismantled in 2025; 16,183 since 2019; 37 approved centres

Dismantling is free to the owner, funded by an eco-contribution on new boat sales

France, scheme scope

Craft from 2.5 to 24 metres

Stops one metre below the yacht in this article

France, material split

Composite is 60-65% of boat weight; 56% to cement kilns as solid recovered fuel, 44% to controlled disposal

Basis for the composite mass share used here

United States, commercial dismantlers

US$140 to 170 per foot

Roughly 430-520 euros per metre, excluding haul-out and legal process

California, marina experience

US$20,000 to 40,000 per derelict boat

What the cost becomes once the owner has gone

Composite treatment, published ranges

Cement-kiln co-processing around 1 euro per kg; controlled disposal around 0.1 euro per kg

Brackets the gate fee range in Table 1

Hong Kong Convention

In force 26 June 2025, 500gt and above on international voyages

Above the threshold the regime applies whatever the vessel is used for

EU Ship Recycling Regulation

500gt and above, EU-flagged, plus inventory duties for port calls

No exemption for pleasure craft

Source: RCA Engineering.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

33


Where the money goes when a hull is closed (euros) Strip-out labour

8,000

Hull cutting and segmenting

6,400

Composite treatment

5,859

Haul-out, handling and cradle

4,500

Yard occupancy

4,250

Road transport to treatment

4,200

Hazardous fractions

2,835

Depollution

2,200

Cutting consumables

1,600

Containers and handling

1,600

Other waste streams

1,134

Documentation and deregistration

Lead ballast recovered

700

13,500

Equipment resold

4,000

Metals recovered

832

Once a boat has been stripped of its gear, the credits disappear and the yard faces the gross figure. Indicative build-up for a 25-metre composite sailing yacht, Western Europe. Central case. Source: RCA Engineering.

43,278

24,946

GROSS COST (EUROS)

NET COST (EUROS) OR

34

18,332

998

CREDITS (EUROS)

EUROS PER LINEAR METRE


What leaves the yard and where it goes End-of-life fractions from a 25-metre composite sailing yacht, 50 tonnes light displacement

25-metre hull 50t light displacement

Lead ballast 15.0t

Secondary lead market Value recovered

Metals 3.8t

Scrap metal market Value recovered

Composite laminate 19.5t

Cement kiln co-processing, controlled disposal and emerging pyrolysis, solvolysis and gasification Cost per tonne

Hazardous fractions 1.9t

Licensed hazardous treatment Cost per tonne

Other waste 6.3t

Mixed waste treatment Cost per tonne

Value flows back to the owner only from the keel, the metals and the gear. Every composite fraction leaves as an expense and the route available decides how large it is. Source: RCA Engineering.

Correcting this does not require new technology, which the industry tends to find disappointing. It requires a record of what the boat is made of, kept from the day it’s handed over, covering the laminate schedule and the resin system, the core and the metallic inserts, the ballast and the antifouling history. A polyester glass hull and a vinylester hull with a carbon package and a PVC core lead to different routes and different numbers, and nobody reconstructs either from a builder’s brochure 20 years later. That record then needs a figure attached to it, accrued per metre and quoted at handover rather than discovered in a yard a quarter of a century on. And the money has to sit somewhere, whether in an escrow tied to the registration, a levy at first sale on the French model

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

or a provision on the management company’s books. None of this is difficult – it is simply nobody’s job. There is a commercial reason to reach for this before it reaches for you. The wind industry has already had this argument, because blades pose the same problem with a higher public profile. Its manufacturers have committed to keeping them out of landfill by 2030 and several member states have banned the landfilling of composites outright. Voluntary positions harden into law and France legislated producer responsibility for boats a decade ago, which is the kind of precedent the rest of Europe borrows. Whoever writes the number gets to write the method, and a yard that can show a funded closure plan will find it becomes a quiet selling point in front

of an owner who intends to sell again in eight years. Every hull afloat already has a final invoice attached to it. It has been written. What it lacks is a name. The engineering to calculate the figure exists and the data to refine it sits in the fleet databases this industry already maintains, so the hard part was never the number. Somebody will settle this within a few years, either the industry or a legislator reading about abandoned boats in a marina. The first version tends to be the more comfortable one. JR Jaime Recasens is an industrial engineer and the founder of RCA Engineering, an independent advisory on composite end-of-life covering marine, wind and aerospace structures.

35


Extending the life of finishes

Why are we repairing the same damage again? Why surface protection film should become part of the yacht lifecycle before recurring damage becomes routine maintenance.

I

BY NICOLAS NIESWIODEK, OCEANSKIN MARINE

f the same fender marks, boarding scuffs or tender-bay abrasions return season after season, they are no longer isolated incidents, they are predictable results of repeated mechanical and environmental stress. The same applies to UV exposure, salt contamination, washdowns and polishing cycles. Each may seem minor, but over time they become part of the yacht’s maintenance burden. So if the exposure is predictable, why is protection still so often considered only after visible damage occurs? Superyachts represent significant craftsmanship, time and investment. Paint systems, carbon components, high-gloss interiors and exterior finishes should therefore be preserved as part of the yacht’s lifecycle from the outset. Damage starts before we can see it Mechanical damage is easy to recognise: a fender leaves a mark, a transom gets scratched or a boarding area begins to show wear. However, environmental deterioration is more gradual. Intense sunlight can influence colour stability, gloss and the visual consistency of exposed finishes, particularly in Mediterranean and similarly demand-

36

ing climates. Salt, minerals, water spotting and other contamination add to the maintenance burden. Keeping these surfaces presentable requires regular cleaning and, depending on their condition, may eventually involve stronger chemistry, corrective polishing or local refinishing. Surface deterioration is therefore often the result of hundreds of small exposures and maintenance interventions rather than one dramatic incident. This is where preventive protection becomes relevant. A suitable protective film creates a serviceable layer above the original surface and absorbs part of that exposure throughout the operating life of the yacht. Depending on the system, substrate and application, Surface protection film (SPF) can provide resistance against abrasion and contact while helping to protect suitable finishes from UV exposure, contamination and the everyday effects of operation. Premium systems can also offer hydrophobic properties that make water, salt and contamination easier to remove. The practical benefit extends beyond preventing an occasional scratch. Easier contamination release


can reduce the need for aggressive cleaning and repeated corrective work. Over time, that can mean fewer polishing cycles, fewer local refinishing interventions and less disturbance of the underlying finish. The real value then becomes literally visible over several seasons. The economics of preserving the original finish A yacht finish is valuable partly because of how it looks and partly because of what it takes to recreate it. A relatively small defect can lead to a much larger intervention. Access may need to be arranged, fittings removed and surrounding areas prepared and masked. Even a small area of damage can require a much larger repair area to ensure a consistent finish, while access, contractors and the yacht’s operating schedule all need to be coordinated. Surface protection should therefore be evaluated by its ability to reduce repeated maintenance, repair work and operational disruption over the yacht’s lifecycle. Repeated correction has consequences – polishing removes material, refinishing alters the existing surface and repainting involves significantly more time, labour and material. A sacrificial protection layer can introduce the possibility of renewing the protective surface while leaving the underlying finish substantially untouched, provided the substrate and application are technically suitable. For an owner or yacht manager, this changes the calculation. The relevant question becomes how long the original finish can be preserved before significant corrective work is required. That matters throughout ownership and becomes particularly relevant when a yacht is sold, refitted or refreshed. Protection has to work in real operation A yacht is an operating asset rather than a static showroom; any protection system, therefore, has to make sense for the people responsible for maintaining it. Captains and crew work in an environment where surfaces are continually exposed to salt, water, sunlight, equipment, fenders, tender operations and human contact. Protection becomes particularly useful when it helps reduce the amount of corrective work required to maintain presentation standards. On appropriately protected surfaces, hydrophobic properties can make contamination easier to manage, while resistance to abrasion and contact can help reduce recurring cosmetic damage in exposed areas. Less frequent corrective polishing and refinishing can save crew time and reduce the

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

A relatively small defect can lead to a much larger intervention. Access may need to be arranged, fittings removed and surrounding areas prepared and masked. Even a small area of damage can require a much larger repair area to ensure a consistent finish. 37


WHERE SURFACE DAMAGE HAPPENS Surface wear is rarely distributed evenly across a yacht. Operation, UV exposure and daily use concentrate damage in predictable areas. Indicative zone map. Not to scale.

10 PV AND TECHNICAL SURFACES U V / H E A T / S A L T / C L EA N I N G / M E CH A NIC A L L OA D I N G 9 GLAZING AND DECORATIVE SURFACES

8 EXTERIOR FURNITURE AND TOUCH POINTS HAN D S / EQUIP M E NT / CR E W S E R VICE / GUEST USE

U V / SA L T / MI N ER A L S / I N C OR R EC T C L EA N I N G / SC R A T C H I N G

10

1

8

3 9

6 5

7

4

2

7 TRANSOM AND SWIM PLATFORM H I GH TR A FFIC / WATE R / T O YS / TENDER IN TE RACTION

3 MOORING 5 GANGWAY INTERFACES R E P E A T E D M E CH A NICA L CO NT A CT / A LIG NM E NT CH A NG E S / M O VE M E NT A LO NG S IDE

6 TENDER OPERATIONS TE ND ER CONTACT / FU E L / CL E A NING ACTIVITY / EQUIPM E NT H A NDLING

2 FENDER ZONES R EPEA T ED C OMPR ESSI ON / MOV EMEN T / C ON T A MI N A T I ON / F EN D ER C OV ER F R I C T I ON

4 BOARDING AREAS FO O T T R A F F I C / L U G G A GE / E Q U IP MEN T / G U EST OPER A T I ON S

A yacht may leave the yard with freshly restored surfaces, only to return immediately to the same conditions that caused the damage in the first place. Where those risks are known, protection should be considered before the yacht returns to service. 38

L I NE S / HARD W ARE O P E RAT I O NS / RE P


BOW AND LEADING SURFACES S P R A Y / DEB R I S / CLEAN IN G / T E N DER /DOC K INTE RACTION

3 1

number of reactive maintenance interventions required during the season. The appropriate level of protection will vary from yacht to yacht. Some vessels may benefit most from protecting specific high-risk areas. On others, particularly where preserving a large newly painted or refinished exterior is the objective, a broader protection concept can make technical and economic sense. The decision should follow the surface, its exposure and the intended result. Manufacturers and refit yards have an opportunity to think one step further The condition of a yacht after several years also contributes to how owners experience the quality of the original product. A yacht that retains its finish well reinforces the standards associated with the builder. Visible wear, fading, repeated corrections or local repairs can influence that perception even when the original workmanship was not responsible for the deterioration. This creates an opportunity for manufacturers to consider surface protection earlier in the ownership lifecycle. Defined protection packages can potentially be integrated into new-build specifications or offered as part of the handover process, particularly for areas known to experience predictable exposure. The same principle applies after refit – a yacht

G STATIONS

E CO N T A C T / C R EW PEA TE D A B R A SI O N

may leave the yard with freshly restored surfaces, only to return immediately to the same conditions that caused the damage in the first place. Where those risks are known, protection should be considered before the yacht returns to service. For a refit yard, SPF helps preserve completed paint and refinishing work and can extend the time before further correction is required. Extending the life of what already exists The sustainability case is practical: protection can help existing high-value finishes last longer and reduce the need for repeated polishing, aggressive cleaning, local refinishing and repainting. That can mean less material, labour, chemical use and repeated intervention over time. In an industry where appearance standards are exceptionally high, extending the service life of an existing finish is a meaningful benefit. Film alone is not the solution Different yacht surfaces require different protection strategies : painted aluminium, gelcoat, carbon, glass and interior finishes all react differently to UV exposure, heat, cleaning chemistry, contact and wear. Effective protection therefore depends on more than choosing a premium film. The substrate, condition, environment and intended use all need to be considered. Depending on the yacht, this may involve protecting large exterior areas or focusing on specific zones with recurring exposure and damage. The objective remains the same: preserve the original finish for as long as technically and economically sensible. From installation to surface strategy For manufacturers and refit yards, assessing how yacht surfaces are exposed, how they deteriorate and where protection can be integrated into newbuild, refit and operational environments helps preserve finished surfaces. For captains and crew, it can reduce recurring maintenance, and for yacht managers and owners, it supports condition, lifecycle cost and long-term value. The real value of SPF lies in what happens to the surface underneath it: fewer polishing cycles, fewer repairs and more time with the original finish preserved. Extending the life of those finishes also means fewer materials, chemicals and repair processes are required over time. When exposure is predictable, protection should become part of the plan before the same damage has to be repaired again. NN

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

39


Guest Column by Mattia Massola Taliacarne

The future of yachting lies in refit Building on the past is the most sustainable choice. Mattia Massola Taliacarne of Italstyle Yacht Design explains why the industry must valorise existing vessels through refit and restyle. After years working in different shipyards on yachts of various types and materials, I’ve come to a conviction: the yachting industry stands at a crucial crossroads. On one hand, demand for new builds continues to grow; on the other, it becomes increasingly evident that this model is no longer sustainable, neither economically nor environmentally. I believe it is time to change perspective. The future lies not only in building ever more new boats, but also and above all in valorising existing vessels through refit and restyle. A necessary paradigm shift We cannot continue to think that the solution is only to keep producing. The global yacht fleet is growing incessantly, a trend that simply cannot continue unless we start to valorise existing constructions in parallel. In my view, refit and restyle are not simple maintenance operations, they represent a strategic, sustainable and economically efficient choice. Building a yacht from scratch involves long timelines, significant risks and considerable environmental impact. In contrast, an existing yacht is immediately available. It can be tested and experienced, allowing precise identification of necessary interventions. This is something I’ve seen time and again in my work. This transforms the project into a turnkey contract, with predictable costs and certain

40

timelines. While new builds typically require 18 to 36 months between design, construction and commissioning, a major refit closes in 3 to 9 months. That’s a difference that matters.

fixing things, you’re preserving a legacy. Architectural restyle becomes essential when the yacht appears dated and lacking character. The goal is to make it current, pleasant and less recognisable as ‘old’. Necessary interventions, such as updating stern areas to bring guests closer to the water, can be carried out in coherence with

The timeless appeal of classic yachts Classic yachts, those with a history, exert an unmistakable fascination. Vessels like the Cristina O remain navigational style icons, carefully maintained and constantly attended to. the original project, maintaining style There’s a reason for this. and harmonious forms. This is where the architect’s skill really shows. These boats have a market that holds steady over time, despite changing Refit versus restyle fashions and uses, because they The terms are often used represent a piece of history and style. interchangeably, but in my practice I’ve Every yacht has a story, a name, an found they describe distinct activities. identity. I’ve learned that there is an Refit is the work to address dated, emotional value that an owner develops damaged or obsolete parts. It divides over time for ‘their’ yacht, a narrative into ‘must do’ (interventions necessary built voyage after voyage. to maintain efficiency and operability) Refit preserves this history while and ‘nice to do’ (aesthetic interventions updating performance, allowing the that can be postponed). Restyle is the emotional connection with the vessel architectural work to make the yacht to be maintained without sacrificing more modern, graceful and pleasant, modernity and efficiency. This, to me, is both externally and internally. the heart of what we do. Let me be clear: exterior restyle, often Two paths forward undervalued, is fundamental. Simply In my experience, there are two main taking advantage of repainting to work approaches. Conservation refit applies on tape lines, glazing and chromatic when design and style are still valid. light-dark elaborations can transform Work is carried out with tact and the vessel. Recently, on a 50-metre delicacy to avoid altering the vessel’s project, the painting intervention alone character. I’ve found this requires a updated the yacht’s look to the point particular sensitivity – you’re not just of making it current. Can we call it a


facelift? Perhaps yes, because surfaces are rejuvenated while maintaining original forms. It’s remarkable what you can achieve. Interiors: re-editing with technology and craftsmanship Interior refit is equally interesting, and frankly, one of my favourite aspects of this work. Spaces can be re-edited and rethought not only in finishes and materials, but also in volumes. In Italy we have some of the world’s best craftsmen – this is not boasting, it’s fact – and, thanks to 3D scanning technologies, we can survey existing spaces to the millimetre, rebuild them on land, verify them and reassemble them on board with guaranteed excellent results. Costs are accessible, timelines contained. Remember that for years yachts have been built with facilitated assembly and disassembly systems, making refit and restyle operations very manageable. I’ve seen projects that would have been unthinkable just a decade ago. Work for everyone, including newbuild operators Here’s something important: there is work in refit for everyone, including the same new-build operators. The architectural side works alongside the technical, creating opportunities for diverse professionals. Consider modernising lighting systems, with energy efficiency interventions that reduce consumption and improve comfort. Or replacing engines and generators with more recent models, compliant with new antipollution regulations. These aren’t

optional extras, they’re necessities. These interventions not only update the yacht but also make it more sustainable and compliant with current standards. Refit generates significant spin-off, involving architects, engineers, specialised technicians, shipyards and component suppliers. It’s an ecosystem, and a thriving one. The yacht as a floating villa A yacht is, in all respects, a floating villa – an object with the characteristics of a static structure that operates in a dynamic environment. And here a question I often ask myself: why are villas regularly refitted, while refitted yachts are not yet the norm? Private homes are subject to continuous maintenance, modernisation and restyling interventions. No one thinks of demolishing and rebuilding a villa every twenty years. Why then should we assume that all owners necessarily want to express their desire by building new yachts every time? It doesn’t make sense to me. I am certain there are owners who love the challenge of updating, editing an existing yacht, finding in this process satisfaction equal to, if not greater than, building from scratch. There is a particular pleasure in giving new life to something that already has a history, in preserving its soul while updating performance and aesthetics. I’ve seen this satisfaction in my clients’ eyes. Resale value Let’s talk about money, because it matters. A well-refitted yacht should be seen as an investment rather than a cost. It can maintain or even

The future of yachting lies not only in new builds, but also in the ability to reinvent what already exists. The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

increase its market value, especially if interventions are documented and carried out by recognised professionals. A complete refit transforms an ‘old’ used vessel into a value opportunity, making the yacht competitive compared to more recent units. For an owner, this means protecting invested capital and, in some cases, achieving significant economic return at resale. Disassembly and end of life There is an often overlooked but crucial aspect, and, I’ll be honest, it keeps me thinking. Refit and restyle make the yacht easily disassemblable and editable, preparing the vessel for its future disposal. When a yacht reaches end of life – as late as possible, thanks to these interventions – its decommissioning becomes much simpler and more sustainable. The topic of yacht disposal is not yet widely addressed, but it deserves attention. Ships are often dismantled in so-called ‘Third World’ countries, with poorly controlled processes and significant environmental impacts. But yachts? Their moment of decommissioning will also come, and we should start thinking about how to manage this passage responsibly. We can’t ignore this forever. Investing in refit and restyle means not only extending a yacht’s useful life, but also ensuring that, when the time for retirement finally arrives, materials can be recovered and disposed of correctly. It is a responsibility the industry can no longer ignore, and I believe we all share it. Every yacht deserves a second life, a chance at restyle. Instead of looking only to the new, let us update the past in a modern key. Let us help the environment, valorise history and create sustainable economic opportunities. The future of yachting lies not only in new builds, but also in the ability to reinvent what already exists. This is what I believe and it’s what drives my work every day. MMT

41


PARTNER CONTENT

The refit is decided before the yacht arrives “Every refit runs on a list of work and on most yachts it is pulled together in the last weeks of the season,” argues Maks Obelšer, CPO of DeepBlue. “It should be built all season, in the same system that already holds the yacht’s planned maintenance.”

Most of what gets said about refit is about the yard itself. Much less is said about the list of work every refit is built on, even though the yard uses it to quote and plan the job. That list has two halves: the defects the crew have noted during the season and the planned maintenance tasks that fall due around the yard period. In my view the quality of that list decides a large part of how a refit goes, and it is fixed before the yacht arrives: whatever is left off the list, or described too loosely, comes back later as extra work and cost.

42

What the yard prices From the yard’s side the logic is simple. A clearly defined and documented scope gets a faster, more accurate quotation, while a vague scope gets priced with contingency, and the arguments over what was agreed happen later – in the dock. Owners’ teams know this well; the difficulty lies in how the list gets made. The end-of-season scramble On many yachts the list is put together in the final weeks of the season by whoever

is preparing the specification and negotiating with the yard. That person has to go back through months of notes, emails and conversations, so some items get missed and others are described too loosely to price, at the point when the crew has the least time to help. Some captains will say their crews already log defects as they go, and many do. It is hard to say how common this is across the fleet, but in our experience that log still tends to live in a spreadsheet or a separate tool, apart from the planned maintenance system. So before the specification goes out, someone has to merge the two and rewrite the items in a form a yard can quote from. The information is handled twice: once when it is found and again under pressure at the end of the season, which opens the door to mistakes and omissions.

“Whatever is left off the refit list, or described too loosely, comes back later as extra work and cost.”


fewer assumptions. The owner’s team could set the budget and track expenses and purchase orders against the same items, and after the yard period the work done would stay recorded against that equipment.

Writing it down when it is found Take a deckhand who notices a sticking door handle in July. It is a one-off job, and it belongs on the refit list just as much as the main engine overhaul the planned maintenance system has scheduled for that winter. The overhaul is already on record. The door handle is only on record if someone writes it down when it is noticed. Refit will always bring some surprises, because some things only show their condition once they are opened up. What a season-long list reduces is the part of the scope that was known all along but never written down.

“Engineers raise this with us all the time: defects should be recorded in the planned maintenance system, alongside the maintenance tasks.”

Before the next yard period This matters to both sides of the contract. Every hour the yard and the owner’s team spend clarifying a vague scope, or negotiating work that should have been on the list from the start, is time and money neither of them gets back. On board and in the office, preparing the list and negotiating with the yard is at the core of a manager’s or captain’s job. Good ones do it carefully, but often with incomplete information and when they have least time to spare. That is why building the refit list inside the planned maintenance system is what we are now working on at DeepBlue. Whatever the crew notice during the season will be able to go straight onto the list, so when the yard asks for it, it is already written. Maks Obelšer is chief product officer of DeepBlue, a Monaco-based company that has been developing yacht management software for over 15 years. Its platform is used on more than 500 yachts by over 50 management companies and family offices. Find out more at www.deepblue. app.

Keep the whole list in the planned maintenance system Engineers raise this with us all the time: defects should be recorded in the planned maintenance system, alongside the maintenance tasks. Most yachts already run one, so their equipment, its history and the work coming due are on record. If every new job were logged there too, tied to the equipment it concerns, and everyone on board, from deckhands to engineers, could add them as they spot them, the whole refit list could be drawn from one place. By the end of the season it would be complete and could go to the yard as it stands. Because it would be one system for the whole yacht, the list could also carry the financial side. The yard could quote from items that name the exact equipment and price the work with

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

43


Guest Column by Rory Marshall

What really makes a successful refit? And why is it not always what we think? By Rory Marshall, surveyor and marine coatings consultant, Newmar Overseas Consulting Ltd.

When a superyacht leaves the shipyard following a major refit, what leaves everyone involved with a genuine sense of success? Is it the quality of the finished yacht, the satisfaction of completing the project on time and within budget, or simply the feeling that the outcome has met, or perhaps exceeded, expectations? Interestingly, projects that achieve these objectives do not always leave everyone with the same sense of satisfaction. Equally, refits that encounter unexpected difficulties, additional costs or programme changes can still be remembered as highly successful. So what creates that feeling of success, and what can undermine it? Having spent many years involved in superyacht painting, where expectations of quality are particularly high and the results are there for everyone to see, I have often observed how differently those involved can view the same outcome. The owner, captain, shipyard and paint applicator may all have experienced the same project, yet each takes away a different impression of its success.

44

Perhaps one of the greatest challenges is how easily confidence can be unsettled. It’s remarkable how quickly a yacht that everyone was delighted with yesterday can become a yacht that everyone is questioning today. A passing comment about a finish, a repair method or a measurement can introduce doubt, even where the work has been properly carried out. This is why a successful refit must do more than deliver an impressive result. It must establish confidence in how that result was achieved. Different expectations, one project For an owner, success may be the satisfaction of seeing a yacht transformed and knowing the investment has been worthwhile. For the captain, it is the confidence to present that yacht to the owner, knowing the finished work will meet expectations and reflect the decisions made throughout the project. The shipyard is looking to maintain its budget and the programme for the project while working to achieve a finish that meets the expectations of

its client and is a good representation of the work it can carry out. The paint applicator wants to produce an exceptional finish that demonstrates their craftsmanship, strengthens their reputation and leads to future projects. All these expectations are reasonable, but they do not necessarily align. In painting, the expression “superyacht standard” is often used as though everyone understands precisely what it means. Yet visual appearance remains partly subjective. Differences in lighting, viewing conditions and individual interpretation can create disagreement over a finish that may otherwise satisfy the agreed technical requirements. Clear specifications and acceptance criteria are essential, but they are only the starting point. The real challenge is maintaining a shared understanding as the work progresses and circumstances change. The importance of how problems are managed Every experienced refit professional knows that unexpected discoveries


Ultimately, confidence is strengthened when everyone involved knows not only what has been done, but why it was done and how the result has been verified. are part of working with an existing yacht. Previous repairs, concealed deterioration or incompatible coating systems can introduce complications that were impossible to establish fully before work began. These discoveries do not necessarily indicate poor planning or workmanship. What matters is how they are addressed. Consider an area of existing fairing found to be unsound during preparation. The immediate temptation may be to protect the programme by limiting the repair. However, an experienced team will investigate the extent of the problem, consider the available solutions and assess the implications for quality, cost and delivery. The most appropriate decision may involve additional work or a revised programme. What creates confidence is knowing that the decision has been properly considered, technically justified and agreed by those responsible. The quickest solution is not always the one that produces the best outcome. This principle extends well beyond painting. Effective management means recognising problems early, making informed decisions and ensuring that

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

the consequences are understood rather than allowing them to emerge as unwelcome surprises. Protecting confidence in the result Confidence is built progressively throughout a refit, but it can be surprisingly fragile. Anyone who has spent time around a yacht during the final stages of a repaint will recognise how quickly a passing remark can influence opinion. “I'm not sure I would have done it that way”, or “That could become a problem later” may be enough to introduce uncertainty about work that was previously considered satisfactory. Equally, a well-informed explanation can have the opposite effect. “We've investigated that area, considered the alternatives and agreed the most appropriate repair” provides something far more reassuring than simply being told that everything is fine. Of course, questions and differing opinions are not necessarily unwelcome. Independent scrutiny is an essential part of quality assurance and genuine concerns must always be investigated. The important distinction is between raising a question and leaving an unsupported doubt in someone's mind. A well-managed project should

be able to respond with evidence. In painting, this means more than recording gloss readings, film thicknesses or visual imperfections. It means understanding their significance, establishing whether the agreed requirements have been met and being able to explain why the chosen methods were appropriate. Ultimately, confidence is strengthened when everyone involved knows not only what has been done, but why it was done and how the result has been verified. What ultimately creates success? A successful refit is not necessarily one without complications. It is one in which the expected result is achieved through competent workmanship, sound decisions and effective control of the programme and budget, including any changes agreed along the way. And perhaps the greatest achievement of a well-managed refit is that those involved leave with a shared sense of satisfaction, rather than lingering questions about what might have been done differently. Ultimately, confidence is not something that can be promised at the beginning of a project or manufactured through reassuring words at its conclusion. It is earned throughout the process and confirmed by the quality of the result. RM

45


Future-proofing the build

Mind the gap! BY ANDY ‘IVY’ BRENNAN

Is technology being selected at contract signature or for the operational environment the yacht will face at delivery? Our regular technical contributor presents a measured approach to managing the four-year technology gap between concept and completion of the build.

46


Introduction The rate at which human knowledge expands has fascinated researchers and futurists for decades. Claims that human knowledge now doubles within months are repeated, although no universally accepted measure substantiates them. What is undeniable, however, is that technological innovation advances rapidly while major capital projects remain bound by lengthy, inflexible design and construction programmes. For the owner of a gigayacht requiring four years or more to build, this creates an uncomfortable question: will the propulsion, automation and digital infrastructure specified in the build contract remain technologically relevant at delivery, or will the vessel emerge from the shipyard carrying systems selected for a world that has already moved on? Herein lies the paradox: the very design freezes intended to protect the owner’s vision may ultimately become the source of its vulnerability. From Vision to Vulnerability (V2V): the designfreeze paradox In the latest Owner’s edition, From Vision to Vulnerability (V2V) examined how immature specifications, design creep and late owner decisions can expose a superyacht project to cost, delay and operational compromise. Its argument was straightforward: front-end loading, a mature build specification and disciplined change control protect the owner’s vision and the integrity of the build. Yet there is a dynamic, opposing risk. A specification can be commercially sound, contractually coherent and appropriate when signed, but still lose technological currency during a four-year construction programme. Propulsion systems evolve, software platforms are updated, cyber threats change and regulatory requirements move on.

Design freezes are essential because they prevent uncontrolled change from destabilising costs, programme and production. Yet if they discourage reassessment of material technological developments, protection can become rigidity. The distinction is critical: uncontrolled design creep must be resisted, while justified technical adaptation must remain possible. When does the technology clock start ticking? The technology clock rarely starts at build contract signature. Long before steel is cut, concept development, feasibility work and specification buildout may already fix key assumptions around propulsion, automation, electrical architecture and on-board systems. By contract signature, some decisions may already be months, or even years, old. Equipment age and specification age are not the same thing. A newly installed component may still belong to a product generation selected earlier, with a finite manufacturer support life, software pathway and spares horizon. As the build progresses, change becomes more expensive. Procurement commitments are made, interfaces engineered, spaces allocated and systems physically integrated into the vessel. What might once have been a straightforward substitution can later require redesign, re-certification and programme disruption. Delays or suspended construction extend this exposure, widening the gap between specification and entry into service. The question is deceptively simple: is technology being selected at contract signature or for the operational environment the yacht will face at delivery? Simply, a design freeze must not become a technology freeze. Propulsion: engineering decisions cast in steel Few decisions are as difficult to revisit as propulsion. Conventional diesel remains proven and sup-

The challenge is not simply to select the newest technology at build contract signature, but to determine what will remain appropriate, reliable and supportable throughout the yacht’s operating life.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

47


A A display, processor or control unit may continue to function perfectly, yet depend upon proprietary software, manufacturerspecific interfaces or components that are no longer supported.

48

ported, while diesel-electric architectures, hybrid systems, battery storage, hydrogen, alternative fuels, advanced nuclear concepts and wind-assisted propulsion continue to develop. The challenge is not simply to select the newest technology at build contract signature, but to determine what will remain appropriate, reliable and supportable throughout the yacht’s operating life. Reliability is fundamental. Established machinery benefits from operating experience, mature maintenance regimes, proven spares networks and engineers able to maintain it at sea. Emerging technologies may offer greater efficiency, lower emissions or new capability, but can also bring complexity, limited operational history, fewer service locations and greater dependence on specialist manufacturers. Innovation, therefore, requires a balance between advancement and resilience in service. Propulsion choices extend beyond machinery. They influence hull structure, tankage, stability, electrical generating capacity, cooling, ventilation, exhaust arrangements and machinery-space geometry. Fuel availability adds another dimension. Disruption around the Strait of Hormuz has shown how geopolitical instability can affect energy flows and marine fuel markets, reinforcing the need to consider where and how a yacht will bunker throughout its cruising life. Once these relationships are engineered into the

vessel and major equipment procured, changing direction becomes disruptive and expensive. Different fuels may require different storage; greater battery capacity introduces weight, cooling and firesafety implications; wind assistance may impose structural and deck-layout demands. Future readiness means preserving sensible margins in space, electrical capacity, cooling, interfaces and fuel compatibility without prematurely committing to technology whose reliability, infrastructure or support network remains immature or unproven. The question is one of balance: how much technological flexibility can be engineered into propulsion without sacrificing the reliability upon which the owner will depend? Automation: when hardware outlives its software Automation is one of the least visible areas in which technological ageing can occur. Integrated bridge systems, machinery monitoring, power management, vessel automation and communications may remain physically serviceable for years, while the software running them reaches the end of its commercial life much sooner. A display, processor or control unit may continue to function perfectly, yet depend upon proprietary software, manufacturer-specific interfaces or components that are no longer supported. Updates may


cease, replacement hardware may become scarce, and compatibility with newer systems can become difficult to maintain. For a yacht delivered after a lengthy construction programme, this creates an inherent risk: a system may be new to the vessel but already approaching the end of its supported lifecycle. Operational consequences can extend beyond inconvenience, affecting diagnostics, integration, crew training, maintenance planning and future upgrades. Supportability should, therefore, be considered alongside specification and performance. Spare parts availability, software updates, technical assistance and migration pathways all deserve careful attention before the yacht is delivered. The key question is whether manufacturer support obligations should extend beyond warranty periods. Technological obsolescence does not necessarily mean equipment has failed; it may mean keeping it secure, compatible and economically supportable has become increasingly difficult. Cyber resilience: tomorrow’s threats, yesterday’s defences Cyber risk is unusual because the threat can evolve faster than the yacht systems being built to withstand it. Navigation, machinery control, power management, communications, guest entertainment and remote-support systems are increasingly connected, creating operational benefits while expanding the number of potential attack paths. A cybersecurity specification written at build contract signature may face a very different threat environment before launch, let alone commissioning. New vulnerabilities emerge; operating systems lose support, network architectures age and inadequate segregation between operational technology and information technology can expose systems that were never intended to interact. The regulatory framework is evolving too. IMO guidance promotes continuing cyber-risk management, whilst IACS (International Association of Classification Societies) Unified Requirements E26 and E27 address ship-level cyber resilience and onboard systems and equipment respectively. These are minimum requirements, not a ceiling on good practice. Cyber resilience should, therefore, remain active throughout construction and commissioning. A defined review procedure can track emerging threats, supplier vulnerabilities and software changes, then present the owner with proportionate recommendations while alterations can still be

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

incorporated efficiently. Supplier obligations should cover security updates, vulnerability notification, patching, remote access and recovery support. By commissioning, the yacht should not be playing catch-up. Networks should be hardened and mapped, interfaces verified, remote connections carefully controlled, backups tested and recovery procedures proven before handover. The central question is this: how can a cybersecurity specification written four years earlier adequately protect against threats that did not exist when the build contract was signed?

The central question is this: how can a cybersecurity specification written four years earlier adequately protect against threats that did not exist when the build contract was signed?

49


Regulatory compliance: designing for a moving horizon Regulation does not stand still while a yacht is under construction. Environmental and emissions standards, safety requirements, crew welfare provisions and digital regulation can all evolve during a lengthy build, while classification societies continue to revise technical rules. That creates a timing challenge. Applicability may depend on milestones such as build contract signature, keel laying, delivery or entry into service. The 2024 Red Ensign Group Yacht Code illustrates the point, with implementation provisions linked to contract and keel-laying dates, while IACS Unified Requirements use defined application dates. Grandfathering may preserve compliance, but it does not necessarily make a design the most resilient choice for the yacht’s future operating environment. The commercial question extends beyond minimum compliance. Incorporating anticipated requirements can add cost, engineering effort and approval risk during construction; yet ignoring foreseeable change may defer greater expense until after delivery. Regulatory exposure should therefore be reviewed throughout the build by the

50

classification society, flag administration, shipyard and owner’s representatives, with emerging requirements assessed while design choices remain available. The question is whether the yacht should be engineered to satisfy the rules applicable at delivery or with foresight to remain compliant and operationally credible in the regulatory environment it will enter. The 71-project warning: when the clock stops but technology doesn’t The 2026 Global Order Book identifies 71 superyacht projects as “on hold” – builds indefinitely but definitively paused, twice the previous year’s total. The reasons vary, and technological obsolescence should not be assumed to be among them. What matters is what occurs while construction stops. A suspended project widens the gap between specification and actual delivery. Equipment warranties may expire, suppliers may change or disappear, product lines can be discontinued and software support may move on. Components already purchased or installed can become dated – even obsolete – before the yacht enters service.


One practical response [to the technology gap] would be a formal Technology Currency Review (TCR), embedded within the existing construction and change-control framework rather than operating alongside it. This is where the earlier V2V argument reappears. Just as uncontrolled change can undermine the owner’s vision, prolonged inactivity can leave an unchanged specification drifting from technological relevance towards avoidable cost. Reactivation therefore deserves more than a restart. Before production resumes, the owner, yard and project team should review what remains current, what requires updating and what should remain unchanged. Bridging the gap: a new approach to technical governance Identifying the technology gap is only useful if the build process contains a disciplined way to manage it. One practical response would be a formal Technology Currency Review (TCR), embedded within the existing construction and change-control framework rather than operating alongside it. Reviews could be scheduled at agreed milestones such as design approval, major procurement, keel laying, system installation, launching and commissioning. Each should consider whether material technological developments have occurred and assess them against the owner’s vision, operational benefit, reliability, technical maturity, cost, programme impact and certification requirements. Responsibility should be shared. The owner, owner’s representative, project manager, shipyard and manufacturers would provide commercial, contractual and technical input, while the future captain, chief engineer and chief stewardess would test proposals against operational reality. Their role would not be to promote novelty, but to identify consequences for usability, maintenance, service delivery and long-term support. The build contract should also define how equipment substitutions, manufacturer support periods, software lifecycles and potential obsolescence are reviewed. Sensible future-proofing

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

measures may include modularity, spare electrical generation and distribution capacity, accessible installations, documented interfaces and realistic upgrade pathways. Before delivery, a final TCR should record outstanding risks, decisions taken, rejected alternatives and foreseeable future costs, giving the owner a current picture of the yacht’s technical position at handover. Crucially, the TCR must reinforce, not weaken, the V2V discipline. Technology reviews should pass through established change control so that justified adaptation does not become uncontrolled variation. The objective is not to install every new technology that appears during construction, but to ensure that material developments are identified, analysed, evaluated and addressed through informed, documented and proportionate project decisions by those leading the build. Conclusion The whole project team carries the responsibility of translating the owner’s vision into a yacht of enduring elegance, while ensuring that reliability, supportability, cyber resilience, regulatory com-pliance and adaptability remain integral to what lies beneath the aesthetic surface. That requires disciplined governance. A TCR can identify material developments, test them against operational need, maturity, cost and risk, and route justified change through V2V controls rather than around them. The objective is neither perpetual reinvention nor adoption of every emerging technology, it is to deliver a yacht capable of adapting intelligently to changing operational and regulatory demands, supported by a clear, traceable record of why key decisions were retained, rejected or changed. The warning is familiar and the responsibility is ours – mind the gap! AB

51


Guest Column by Vesna Djurdjevic

Every change was approved, but nobody priced the complexity A refit can account for the price of almost every change to a yacht. The more difficult calculation begins when all those individually sensible changes have to live together. Refit has an enviable relationship with numbers: something is removed, something is added, something is upgraded; sooner or later there is a specification, a quotation and a decision. Even surprises have a remarkable ability to become line items once somebody has opened the right panel.

technical decision can be living inside routines, handovers and decisions that were never part of its quotation. This is where the economics becomes interesting. Refit is very good at asking what a change will cost to make; the less visible question is what that change will cost the yacht to carry. Those two numbers are not necessarily the same.

who appeared in the refit as one supplier among many may become considerably more important once the yacht is several hundred miles from the yard. If expertise settles primarily with one engineer, the yacht may acquire better technology and greater dependence on one person’s knowledge at exactly the same time.

What interests me is what happens after all those individually sensible numbers have been added together. An owner may approve a modification for an excellent reason and engineering may support it. The yard may price it accurately and the supplier may execute it beautifully. Nothing in that sequence requires a mistake for the yacht to leave refit carrying something nobody consciously ordered: a more demanding organisation.

The price of the change is not the cost of carrying it Take a significant technology upgrade as an example. Perhaps the existing capability no longer meets the owner’s expectations, operational experience has exposed its limitations or a better solution has simply become available. The case for change may be entirely persuasive and the installation technically excellent, but the organisational life of that decision begins where the work package ends.

That does not make the upgrade a bad decision. It means the same decision can improve one form of capability while making another part of the framework more demanding.

Technical changes do not remain politely inside their work packages. A new capability enters somebody’s workload, a changed system alters what somebody needs to know, a specialist solution can create a new external dependency. Months later, a

52

Conventional project arithmetic becomes less helpful here. The installation has a price because somebody must quote it. The recurring requirement for knowledge, attention and coordination rarely arrives so conveniently packaged. It appears in minutes rather than millions: another Someone now has to understand the check, another conversation, another new architecture well enough to operate specialist call, another thing the next and troubleshoot it. Maintenance engineer needs to understand. Small requirements may change, costs have excellent camouflage, documentation grows, information particularly when competent people arrives differently and a specialist are absorbing them.


A yacht never operates one modification at a time There is another peculiarity in the way complexity accumulates. Refit decisions arrive separately; the yacht has to operate them together. A work package can be scoped, a supplier assessed and a modification approved on its own merits. The organisation, however, does not experience a series of beautifully separated project lines, it experiences their intersections. By the time two entirely rational modifications begin demanding the same knowledge, attention or coordination, nobody necessarily associates the resulting burden with either original decision – it has simply become how the yacht works. This is the part of refit economics that interests me most: individually rational decisions can create collectively expensive architecture without any individual decision being wrong. The yard may have priced its work correctly, the suppliers may have delivered exactly what was specified and the owner may have received every capability that was approved. The unpriced element sits elsewhere, in the cumulative structure required to make all those capabilities coexist. A yacht, after all, does not get to operate its improvements one at a time. Follow the change after everybody else has finished with it If I wanted to understand what a refit had really changed, I would

resist beginning with an inventory of modifications, I would choose the consequential ones and follow them. The first question remains technical: what changed? The next questions do not. What now has to happen because it changed? Who needs knowledge that was unnecessary before and where does that knowledge live? Has work migrated? Has a supplier moved from convenient to important? Has a decision quietly moved upwards because the new arrangement made authority less obvious? Then I would follow the change through time. What happens when the people who lived through the refit are no longer aboard? What will make perfect sense to the next engineer, and what only appears obvious because the current one remembers conversations that never made it into the documentation? Which workaround is currently indistinguishable from normal operation? Which dependency becomes visible only when the yacht changes programme, the season intensifies or something fails far from the people who installed it? What started as equipment may end as workload and what started as capability may end as dependency. The diagnostic value lies in following the change until its consequences stop moving. Only then can we see the distance between where complexity was created and where its cost is eventually paid.

When competence makes complexity look cheap Yachts possess a particularly effective mechanism for concealing that distance: capable people. Experienced crew learn the peculiarities of the yacht they inherit, engineers remember relationships between systems that no diagram completely captures, while captains connect departments, suppliers, management and owner requirements. Informal routines settle around formal ones until nobody remembers which came first. Somebody knows whom to call; somebody else knows which warning deserves attention; another person remembers why something was configured in a way that appears inexplicable three seasons later. This adaptability is enormously valuable. It can also distort our understanding of what the structure actually costs. When an excellent engineer carries critical knowledge in his or her head, the yacht receives the benefit every day without an invoice identifying ‘organisational dependency’. When a captain repeatedly joins dots between people because it is faster than redesigning how the dots connect, the additional coordination disappears into the captain’s job. When crew quietly create routines around systems that do not fit together particularly elegantly, human competence makes technical complexity look remarkably inexpensive. The better the people, in fact, the longer the architecture can escape scrutiny.

Yachts possess a particularly effective mechanism for concealing that distance: capable people ... This adaptability is enormously valuable. It can also distort our understanding of what the structure actually costs.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

53


Guest Column by Vesna Djurdjevic

The distinction worth making is between complexity that creates value and complexity whose organisational cost was never examined because it appeared somewhere other than the project that created it. Everything works until somebody leaves. The technical asset may be identical on Monday to what it was on Friday, yet part of its operating capability can disappear down the passerelle with a suitcase. What looked like an individual’s competence turns out to have been organisational infrastructure stored inside a person. That’s not merely a retention problem, it’s information about the design. When yesterday’s decision becomes today’s fact The refit may end, but its decisions do not. A specialist solution can deliver exactly what is wanted now while narrowing supplier choice later. Knowledge concentrated around a particular architecture can make the next crew transition more demanding. A new system becomes part of the environment into which the next upgrade must somehow fit. Documentation perfectly intelligible to those who lived through the refit may look rather more mysterious to somebody arriving three years later without the conversations that made it obvious. Then the next refit begins. By that point, yesterday’s decisions often no longer look like decisions. They have become facts about the yacht: constraints to work around, systems to integrate, relationships to retain, knowledge somebody is expected to possess. The next project begins by inheriting the structural consequences of the last one, frequently without remembering that they were once choices. This gives lifecycle cost a rather wider meaning. The yacht is not only carrying equipment across time; it is carrying the knowledge, relationships, routines and dependencies required to keep that equipment useful. The purchase

54

price belongs to the modification, but its organisational consequences can belong to several seasons.

is a peculiar outcome for an asset purchased, among other things, to create freedom.

The owner experiences the sum, not the spreadsheet None of this requires the owner to become a student of organisational design – quite the opposite. An owner approves a refit because something about the yacht should become better: its capability, reliability, comfort, performance, safety or suitability for the way it is actually used. The owner does not experience those ambitions afterwards as a collection of work packages, the owner experiences their sum.

What leaves the yard Eventually the work packages close. Contractors leave, invoices are settled and the yacht returns to what it was built for: being used rather than redesigned. Yet not everything created during the refit remains in the yard accounts. Some of it leaves in the knowledge people must carry, the suppliers the yacht continues to depend upon and the coordination required to make a technically improved yacht behave as one coherent whole. Some consequences will be obvious immediately; others may remain invisible precisely because good people are making them invisible.

That is why apparently small organisational consequences matter when we place them back inside the system. If additional capability also creates dependence on scarce knowledge, the consequence may eventually appear as reduced resilience. If modifications increase the coordination required to make ordinary operations work, the effect can surface as slower responsiveness or greater dependence on senior people. If specialist relationships become difficult to substitute, flexibility changes. If decisions repeatedly travel upwards because the framework around new capability was never reconsidered, complexity eventually begins consuming increasingly expensive attention. The owner need not see any of the architecture beneath a seamless experience. In luxury, invisibility is often evidence that the architecture is doing its job. But somebody has to see it, otherwise the owner can eventually become the most expensive integration mechanism in the system, which

None of this is an argument for timid refits, nor for simplicity elevated into a virtue regardless of purpose. Sophisticated yachts can legitimately require sophisticated capability. The distinction worth making is between complexity that creates value and complexity whose organisational cost was never examined because it appeared somewhere other than the project that created it. For a few months during refit, almost everything about a yacht becomes available for reconsideration. Systems are opened, assumptions revisited, modifications debated and extraordinary expertise applied to deciding what the yacht should become. Perhaps one more question deserves to sit beside the quotation before the next perfectly sensible change is approved: What organisation are we buying with it? VD


Essential reading for Owners, Captains and Senior Crew – wherever you are in the world

The Superyacht Group Library is open to our audience so you can enjoy the highest quality journalism and analysis in the market – Reports Worth Reading. Download or read at your leisure on your desktop or your tablet: https://issuu.com/the-superyacht-group/docs


Exploring investment strategies

What does €140 million actually buy? As yacht programmes become larger and more sophisticated, the relationship between size, capability and investment becomes increasingly nuanced. Comparing a representative two-vessel programme to a single 120-metre yacht, Jennifer Smith, SHADOWCAT Commercial Director, explores how capital investment could be converted into operational capability.

56


O

ver the past few weeks, thousands of owners, brokers and advisors will have toured the world’s largest yachts. It is easy to be captivated by scale – standing alongside a 120-metre yacht, the instinct is to assume that everything has become larger and therefore better. Beneath the surface, however, lies a more interesting question: How much of the owner’s investment is creating capability and how much is simply making the yacht larger? Here, we explore that question and attempt to illustrate what different investment strategies actually deliver. Defining the question For this exercise, we compared two representative programmes: Scenario A: A single 120-metre superyacht. Scenario B: An 80-metre superyacht supported by a 65-metre operational platform. Both programmes are intended to support sophisticated private cruising with aviation, large tenders, toys, expedition capability and extended operations. The objective was to understand how effectively each programme converts capital investment into operational capability, not to advocate one programme over another. Establishing the assumptions Like any effective comparative analysis, this study begins with a transparent set of planning assumptions. We did not intend to define a ‘typical’ 120-metre yacht or suggest that every owner's brief should allocate space in the same way. Instead, we developed representative planning models based on published general arrangement drawings, publicly available technical specifications, current market observations and common design practices observed across large custom yachts and support vessels.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

57


Some planning inputs, particularly the operational capability area, vary significantly depending on how an owner intends to use the vessel. A hospitalityfocused yacht, for example, will allocate substantially more space to guest amenities than one designed around aviation, expedition support or scientific operations. Rather than treating any single value as universally correct, we established representative planning ranges for those variables and selected midpoint values to create a consistent basis for comparison. Other assumptions, including representative build costs and annual operating expenses, were also selected as planning-level midpoints. These figures are not intended to predict the final cost of any individual project. Instead, they provide a transparent framework for evaluating how different programme architectures convert capital investment into operational capability. The goal is to ensure consistency within the model’s comparative relationship between the two programmes.

trying to achieve. This analysis takes The figures provide are that idea one step further by comparing programmes based upon mission infraa transparent structure. To do this, we are introducing the conframework for cepts of ‘operational capability area’ and ‘capability density’. Operational capability evaluating how area includes spaces that directly co-tribute to operating the owner’s programme. different programme These include: • Tender garages and deployment areas architectures convert • Helicopter landing and hangar facilities • Dive centres capital investment • Toy storage • Workshops • Logistics and provisioning areas into operational • Crew support for operational activities • Beach club support functions capability. • Mission decks and cargo handling areas Importantly, it also includes enclosed operational spaces rather than considering open deck area alone. We want to avoid unintentionally understating the capability available aboard larger yachts with substantial internal garages and support facilities. Conversely, guest hospitality spaces, including sun decks, lounges, pools and dining areas, were excluded because they contribute to owner comfort rather than operational capability. In addition to operational capability area, we have included capability

Measuring capability In “Are We Measuring What Matters?”, we suggested that traditional metrics such as length and gross tonnage don't always reflect the experiences owners

Table 1: Representative planning inputs Planning input

Representative planning range

Representative midpoint

120m gross tonnage

5,000–6,000gt

5,500gt

80m gross tonnage

2,000–2,500gt

2,250gt

65m operational platform gross tonnage

1,100–1,500gt

1,300gt

120m CapEx

€340–410m

€375m

80m CapEx

€145–175m

€160m

65m operational platform CapEx

€60–90m

€75m

120m operational capability area

1,200–2,100m²

1,650m²

80m + 65m operational capability area

1,850–2,050m²

1,950m²

Annual operating cost main yacht

planning-level estimate

12% of CapEx

Annual operating cost support vessel

planning-level estimate

8% of CapEx

Representative planning ranges used to establish the midpoint assumptions presented throughout this comparison. Ranges are informed by published technical information, representative vessel layouts and current market observations. Individual owner programmes may vary materially depending on specification, shipyard and operational brief.

58


Figure 1 : How the comparison was built A planning level analytical model

Planning-level comparison model showing the assumptions, calculation methodology and resulting performance metrics used throughout this analysis.

A single flagship naturally concentrates more capability, hospitality and guest experience within one platform. A distributed programme, by comparison, allows more of that investment to be directed towards dedicated operational infrastructure.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

59


Figure 2: Outcomes

Table 2: Sensitivity analysis

60

Assumed 120m operational capability area

120m cost per m² OCA

Two-vessel cost per m² OCA

120m premium vs two-vessel

1,200m²

€313k

€121k

+159%

1,400m²

€268k

€121k

+122%

1,650m² (representative midpoint)

€227k

€121k

+89%

1,800m²

€208k

€121k

+73%

1,950m²

€192k

€121k

+60%

2,100m²

€179k

€121k

+49%


The question is no longer simply “How large should Capability density = operational capability area ÷ total CapEx the yacht be?” While not every square metre has identical value, we believe this metric does but rather: “What provide a consistent way to compare how efficiently different programme are we trying to architectures convert capital into useachieve, and what able operational infrastructure. What the comparison suggests combination of Using the representative planning assumptions outlined in this analysis, a platforms is best few interesting observations emerge. Compared with the representative two- suited to deliver vessel programme, moving to a single 120-metre yacht required approximately: that experience?” • €140 million of additional capital density as another way to represent how many square metres of operational capability is achieved for every €1 million invested.

investment • Approximately €19 million of additional annual operating cost • Approximately 89 per cent higher capital cost per square metre of operational capability area Using the representative planning midpoint of 1,650m² for the 120-metre yacht, the two-platform programme also delivered approximately 300m² more modelled operational capability area. As the accompanying sensitivity analysis below will demonstrate, that figure will naturally move up or down depending on how an individual owner chooses to allocate space within the yacht. Some programmes will prioritise hospitality and guest experience, while others will devote more space to aviation, logistics or expedition capability. Perhaps the more interesting observation isn’t that one approach outperforms the other, but that different architectures spend the same investment in very different ways. A single flagship naturally concentrates more capability, hospitality and guest experience within one platform. A distributed programme, by comparison, allows more of that investment to be directed towards dedicated operational infrastructure. Neither approach is inherently right or wrong, they simply reflect different priorities. Testing the assumptions Because no planning model can represent every owner’s programme, we broadened our analysis across the full range of representative operational cap-

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

ability assumptions established in this study. Even when generous assumptions are made regarding the operational infrastructure aboard a 120-metre yacht, the comparative relationship changes only gradually. The amount of opera-tional capability varies, as expected, but the broader observations regarding investment allocation remain consistent. More importantly, the exercise demonstrates that there is no universally ‘correct’ amount of operational infrastructure for a yacht of this size. A hospitality-focused yacht, an expedition yacht and a science-focused platform may all occupy similar overall dimensions while allocating their internal volume in very different ways. The sensitivity analysis demonstrates that changing those assumptions influences the scale of the comparison, but not the value of the discussion. Rather than relying on a single planning figure, it shows how different programme architectures allocate investment toward different owner priorities across a realistic range of possible programmes. Designing the right programme This comparison was never intended to identify a universally ‘better’ programme based on operational capability. For some owners, the simplicity, prestige and seamless experience of a single flagship vessel will represent exactly the right solution. For others, flexibility, specialisation and the ability to evolve capability over time may lead to a different architecture. Both approaches are capable of delivering extraordinary experiences, they simply prioritise different outcomes. Perhaps that’s the real insight from this exercise. As yacht programmes become larger and more sophisticated, the relationship between size, capability and investment becomes increasingly nuanced. The question is no longer simply “How large should the yacht be?” but rather: “What are we trying to achieve, and what combination of platforms is best suited to deliver that experience?” For some owners, the answer may be a single, highly integrated flagship. For others, it may be an ecosystem of complementary platforms, each optimised for a specific role. Neither approach is inherently superior. The right solution is the one that best aligns with the owner’s ambitions, operating style and long-term objectives. JS

61


Guest Column by Norina Edelman

Superyacht refit and the long horizon Norina Edelman, CEO and founder of IMM, asks how we can ensure that we have not only the infrastructure to handle yacht refit well into the future, but also the skill and the appropriate incentives to keep vessels safe.

The refit sector is changing. Large groups and private equity funds have taken stakes, creating a new profile of ownership, built around asset portfolios and management platforms rather than a lineage of shipbuilding or naval repair. This consolidation brings a particular logic and imperative, one in which performance is measured in short-term profitability and shareholder or enterprise value over a defined holding period. It is worth considering what impact this change may have on yacht refit over the long term. The work that cannot be seen Although an essential part of refit is what we see, such as paint, interior and finishing work, the most critical items on the work list are those that keep the vessel safe at sea. A superyacht is, after all, oceangoing. Its hull, structure, machinery, steering, electrical systems and safety equipment must withstand

62

conditions that leave little margin for error. Refit yards are ultimately responsible for maintaining the vessel to ensure seaworthiness and, in turn, the safe passage of every person on board. Not only is this work itself largely invisible, so is the quality of that work. A properly prepared substrate, a correctly torqued fitting or a wellrebuilt engine can look the same as work done carelessly. Defects can emerge months or years later, perhaps in open water, and frequently long after the commercial result of the project has been booked. A business model skewed toward short-term profitability risks favouring lower costs now over quality in the long term. Diverging time horizons A yacht may remain in service for many decades, requiring every job to be done for longevity. That long life has suited an industry built on

relationships. Refit facilities have prioritised the relationship over any one job, and this was rewarded: vessels return, captains refer and crew return on their next yacht. There has been little room for chasing per-job profit because that may well, ultimately, result in long-term loss. An ownership model built around a five- to seven-year holding period operates on a different clock. Decisions that defer cost, compress schedules or limit scope can improve near-term results while transferring both risk and cost to a future that will be someone else’s concern. None of this is meant to imply bad intent. It is simply an economic reality when the time horizons of the business and its client diverge. The ecosystem behind every refit No yard delivers a refit alone. Specialist subcontractors, manufacturers and


Profit is necessary. Without it, no yard can invest in facilities, people or partners. The question is whether profit is the purpose. For the more traditional businesses in the sector, the drive has been quality, service, integrity and client relationships

suppliers form a network of expertise built over decades. When shorter-term profitability becomes the dominant objective, pressure is pushed down that chain. Rates are squeezed, often not for the benefit of the client, but for the bottom line of the primary contractor. The consequences of this pressure are predictable. Many capable specialists will leave the market or take their skills elsewhere. Those who remain must find ways to cut costs, often where the client cannot see them. Over time, the industry’s collective competence is diluted. No yard can sustain quality while eroding the partners on whom the work depends. Investment beyond infrastructure Refit craftsmanship takes years to develop. It passes from one person to another through apprenticeship and years of exposure to problems no instruction manual can teach. The

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

returns on that training are distant. The do? Test whether a yard is aligned with the vessel's time horizon. Ask investment rarely pays back within a for evidence, not assurances. Ensure single financial cycle. that subcontractors are not being squeezed – are the professional However, without investment in skill, discounts, rebates or commissions we will simply not be able to support the yard receives passed on to the superyacht fleet. An industry that ceases to invest in the next generation the client or retained? Does the facility apply a standard markup on of technicians, engineers and subcontractors, and will it share that supervisors is drawing down an asset figure? Who will manage the project, it cannot easily rebuild. and how many other vessels will Due diligence as future proofing that person be handling at the same Profit is necessary. Without it, no time? Who carries out quality control, yard can invest in facilities, people or independently of the project manager, partners. The question is whether profit and what inspection records will the is the purpose. For the more traditional client receive? businesses in the sector, the drive has been quality, service, integrity Asking these questions protects the vessel and it also protects the and client relationships. What we are market. As an industry, we need to seeing today is an effort to control ensure that we have not only the the sector through scale and market infrastructure to handle yacht refit share. well into the future, but also the skill and the appropriate incentives to The rigour refit demands keep vessels safe. NE So what can owners and captains

63


ENX: ASKING A DIFFERENT QUESTION OF SUPERYACHT ELECTRIFICATION 64


The potential of battery power

James Roy, Managing Director of Lateral Naval Architects, asks whether we have become so accustomed to designing for capability that we have overlooked the opportunity to design more deliberately for operation. Here he posits a deliberate technical investigation into what becomes possible when the conventional relationship between operational demand and specified capability is challenged.

T

here is something of a paradox in the way we design superyachts. We create extraordinarily capable machines, able to cross the world’s largest oceans, operate in remote locations and deliver exceptional levels of comfort and luxury. Yet, for much of their lives, they do remarkably little of what determines their engineering specification. A yacht designed to cross the Atlantic might spend the overwhelming majority of its time at anchor, alongside, or making relatively short passages between destinations. It might be capable of 17 knots or more, yet rarely approach that speed. And its machinery, energy systems and technical arrangements will have been substantially influenced by these exceptional operating conditions. There are perfectly good reasons for this. A yacht is fundamentally about freedom and optionality. An owner spending perhaps two or three hundred million euros understandably expects to be able to go where they want, when they want. The fact that a capability is rarely exercised does not necessarily diminish its value. But there is a question worth asking: have we become so accustomed to designing for capability that we have overlooked the opportunity to design more deliberately for operation? It is a distinction that has become increasingly important in Lateral’s work, particularly as we explore the possibilities for electrification. For some years, the maritime industry has been exploring alternative fuels and energy technologies in response to the need to decarbonise. Batteries, as a means of storing and delivering electrical energy, present different opportunities and challenges from primary energy carriers such as hydrogen, methanol or ammonia. For large yachts, however, the discussion has frequently been constrained by one particular requirement: range. A conventional superyacht of 70 metres might be specified for 4,000 to 5,000 nautical miles, providing genuine ocean-crossing

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

capability and the freedom to operate independently of the availability of bunkering infrastructure. If we approach electrification by asking how to store sufficient electrical energy in batteries to provide 4,500 nautical miles of range, the answer is fairly straightforward. With today’s technology, we cannot do so sensibly. The mass and volume of the required energy storage would be wholly impractical. It would be easy to conclude from this that battery-electric propulsion is simply not a viable proposition for large superyachts. But perhaps that is the wrong question. What happens if, rather than asking how much energy the yacht needs to satisfy its ultimate range capability, we ask how much energy it actually needs to operate? That was the starting point for ENX. Unlike a ferry operating to a timetable, a superyacht has no defined duty cycle. It might cross the Mediterranean, spend a week cruising between islands, remain at anchor for several days or make an ocean passage with little notice. Its operational requirements can also change considerably between owners. This uncertainty has historically encouraged the industry to retain substantial margins of performance and capability. However, we now have access to operational data that allows us to investigate how yachts are actually used, rather than relying exclusively upon assumptions about how they might be used. For ENX, we examined the movements of an active fleet of Mediterranean charter yachts, looking at where they travelled, their speeds, passage durations and the time spent at rest. We then translated representative itineraries into energy demand, considering both propulsion and hotel loads for an efficient 70-metre reference yacht of approximately 1,700gt. We deliberately looked at charter vessels because they are inherently active. They represent yachts being used for precisely the experience they

65


Five representative routes possible within an energy demand of 50MWh

66


were intended to deliver. Across five representative Mediterranean cruising itineraries, the combined propulsion and hotel energy requirement ranged from approximately 37 to 50MWh. These were not hypothetical voyages constructed to demonstrate battery capability, but itineraries developed from observed patterns of operation, including cruising in the Balearics, French and Italian Riviera, Corsica and Sardinia, Greek Islands and Turkey. Suddenly, the engineering problem looked quite different. Fifty megawatt-hours is a substantial amount of energy to store, but it is entirely within the territory of large marine battery installations already being developed and deployed in other sectors. Large electric ferries and emerging electric commercial vessels are now employing battery systems measured in tens of megawatt-hours. The scale of the storage technology is no longer particularly extraordinary. What is different is the application. Rather than trying to reproduce the entire capability of a conventionally powered yacht through batteries, we had identified a meaningful operating profile that could be satisfied by stored electrical energy. For a superyacht, the attraction of that proposition extends well beyond emissions. We spend enormous engineering effort pursuing low noise, minimal vibration, the elimination of exhaust nuisance and the delivery of an almost imperceptible technical environment for guests. Battery-electric operation inherently supports many of these ambitions. In that respect, electrification is not simply an environmental compromise. It potentially offers a better product. Of course, identifying an achievable batteryelectric operating profile does not remove the requirement for ocean-crossing capability. A 70-metre yacht still needs to be capable of travelling 4,500 nautical miles when required. For our reference vessel, that exceptional requirement represents approximately 110 tonnes of diesel or around 1.3GWh of chemical energy. That is an entirely different scale of energy requirement from the 37 to 50MWh associated with representative guest operation. Why, then, should we expect the battery to satisfy both? This distinction became central to ENX. Traditionally, diesel-electric yachts employ generators as their principal means of converting fuel into electrical energy. Batteries, where fitted, provide stored energy to support the generating plant through spinning reserve, peak shaving, load smoothing or limited periods of silent operation. Over time, Lateral’s work has explored increasingly significant roles for stored electrical energy, from hybrid architecture, through subsequent dieselelectric developments, to our e-Hybrid philosophy. With e-Hybrid, the battery becomes the primary

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

ENX is a 70-metre battery-led technical platform incorporating approximately 60MWh of energy storage. With a beam of 12 metres, a draught of 3.5 metres and a gross tonnage of approximately 1,700gt, the platform has been developed to demonstrate how large-scale battery storage can be integrated into a credible superyacht architecture. means of delivering electrical power to the vessel, while generation is increasingly decoupled from instantaneous demand. The generators can operate under more favourable conditions, replenishing the energy store rather than continually following variations in propulsion and hotel load. ENX takes that thinking a step further. Rather than incorporating batteries to support a conventional generating plant, the architecture is designed around stored electrical energy from the outset. Normal propulsion, hotel loads and guest operation are all supplied from the battery installation. The exceptional requirement for long-distance passagemaking is addressed separately through compact on-board energy extenders, using conventional generation to provide the additional energy needed for these journeys. Importantly, these generators are not intended to operate routinely during guest use, nor to become the normal means of replenishing the batteries. Their purpose is to preserve the freedom to undertake exceptional passages. The operational energy requirement and the exceptional capability requirement have therefore been separated, allowing each to be addressed through a more appropriate technical solution. The result is ENX, a 70-metre battery-led technical platform incorporating approximately 60MWh of energy storage. With a beam of 12 metres, a draught of 3.5 metres and a gross tonnage of approximately 1,700gt, the platform has been developed to demonstrate how large-scale battery storage can be

67


integrated into a credible superyacht architecture. Its principal performance characteristics include an electric range of approximately 625 nautical miles, an extended range of 4,500 nautical miles, a range speed of 11 knots and a maximum speed of 14 knots. The installed battery capacity has been established around representative operational demand, while accommodating reserve requirements and degradation over the battery’s life. There is a significant technical challenge in integrating approximately 300 tonnes of batteries into a yacht of this size, and it would be misleading to suggest otherwise. Energy storage must be considered from the outset, not accommodated within whatever technical spaces remain after the rest of the yacht has been designed. Battery location has implications for weight distribution, trim, stability, structure, fire safety, accessibility, maintenance and the wider vessel arrangement. The energy system itself is only part of the solution. An efficient hull form, deliberately moderated speed requirements, advanced HVAC and thermal management, and careful control of hotel loads all contribute to reducing the energy the

yacht needs in the first place. This matters because the most effective way to increase electric endurance is not necessarily to install more batteries. It may be to reduce the underlying energy demand. ENX is therefore not simply a conventional yacht with a very large battery installation. The technical platform has been developed around the energy architecture from the beginning. There is a further qualification in that the battery assumptions are based upon projected commercially applicable technology over approximately the next five years, incorporating an anticipated improvement in energy density of around 20 per cent compared with current marine products. This is a forward-looking technical platform, rather than a claim that every aspect of the solution is immediately available without further development. The ENX work also raises a broader question about how we establish yacht specifications. In a separate investigation undertaken by Lateral for a technical paper to be presented at the forthcoming 2026 HISWA International Symposium, we examined the relationship between specified maximum speed

1 AFT BATTERY ROOM 1 ENERGY EXTENDER 1 SWITCHBOARD 1 MIDSHIP BATTERY ROOM 1 FORWARD BATTERY ROOM

1

2

3

4

5

ENX is not simply a conventional yacht with a very large battery installation. This is a forward-looking technical platform, rather than a claim that every aspect of the solution is immediately available without further development.

68


Battery architecture Shore recharge Standard turnaround charging between Mediterranean charters. With predicted Mediterranean infrastructure, charging will typically require 10-48 hours (20%-100%).

Guest operation Typical operation throughout the charter. 100% silent running and zero-emission utilising battery power only to meet propulsion and hotel load demand.

and the speed at which large motor yachts actually operate. The study considered 20 yachts between approximately 60 and 150 metres, drawing on 94,182 hours of operational observations. Across the selected fleet, the vessels spent approximately 83 per cent of their observed time stationary. When underway, operation was concentrated within a relatively narrow speed range, generally around 70 to 80 per cent of specified maximum speed. The median proportion of underway time spent within the upper 10 per cent of the speed envelope was just 3 per cent. Within the upper 5 per cent, it was less than 1 per cent. Again, this does not mean that maximum-speed capability is unnecessary. There may be perfectly legitimate reasons to retain it, including schedule recovery, weather avoidance or an owner’s personal preference. But the engineering consequences of providing it are considerable. Our analysis indicated that moderating maximum-speed requirements by approximately 5 to 10 per cent could reduce effective propulsion power requirements by around 17 to 32 per cent, depending upon the hull form and operating characteristics. Those figures represent model-derived changes in required propulsion power, not equivalent reductions in fuel consumption or installed machinery. Nevertheless, their implications extend beyond the engines themselves. A different peak-power requirement may allow different machinery selections, smaller cooling and ventilation systems, revised exhaust arrangements, or potentially an entirely different engine-room configuration.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

Long-range transit The energy extender will enable extended passages between charters.

In some circumstances, crossing a machineryselection threshold can create opportunities that are disproportionate to the apparent reduction in power. Space previously committed to delivering exceptional performance might be redirected towards battery capacity, technical efficiency, improved accommodation arrangements or an entirely different operational capability. That, I think, is where this research becomes particularly interesting. The objective is not necessarily to design a yacht that can do less. It is to understand what we have committed to delivering, how frequently that capability is used, what it costs in engineering terms, and what else might become possible if we reconsidered it. ENX is one application of that philosophy. There is, of course, an obvious question. How do we recharge a 60MWh battery installation? The intended operating model for ENX involves replenishing stored energy from shore between guest itineraries. This is important because the environmental benefit depends fundamentally upon the source of that energy. Electricity generated on board using conventional diesel generators has a carbon intensity of approximately 660 to 700 grams of CO2 equivalent per kilowatt-hour. Shore electricity across much of Europe can have a substantially lower carbon intensity, with further improvements possible as electrical grids decarbonise. The distinction is therefore not simply between electricity and diesel, but between different sources of primary energy. By decoupling normal vessel operation from on-board combustion, the yacht can progressively benefit

69


Current commercial applicability of marine batteries

Installed power (MW)

Short range: battery

Range

from improvements in the carbon intensity of the electricity supply without requiring fundamental changes to its propulsion architecture. However, we should be realistic about the infrastructure challenge. Multi-megawatt shore power provision is developing rapidly in the commercial maritime sector, but high-capacity charging infrastructure suitable for superyachts remains limited, particularly when considering the diversity of locations in which yachts operate. Replenishing tens of megawatt-hours between charters requires significant electrical infrastructure, available connection capacity and sufficient turnaround time. The ENX study considers charging periods of approximately 10 to 48 hours under projected infrastructure scenarios. Achieving this consistently across the Mediterranean is not something we can assume today. It is important, therefore, to be clear about what ENX is intended to demonstrate. We are not suggesting that a 60MWh battery-led yacht represents a readily deployable solution within today’s superyacht operating practices and infrastructure environment. There are practical dependencies, particularly around charging availability, which would make its routine operation challenging today. Equally, ENX is not simply an abstract thought experiment unconstrained by engineering reality. The platform has been developed through a deliberate technical investigation into what becomes possible when we challenge the conventional relationship between operational demand and specified capability. It provides a credible engineering proposition against which the implications, opportunities and remaining

70

obstacles can be explored. Its value lies as much in what we learn from developing the architecture as in the architecture itself. There are also wider environmental questions associated with battery manufacture, raw materials, safety, degradation and eventual recycling. These do not disappear simply because emissions at the yacht are eliminated, and zero local emissions should not be confused with zero lifecycle emissions. None of these challenges invalidates the proposition. They are part of the engineering problem that needs to be addressed if electrification is to progress beyond individual demonstration projects. There is another dimension to this discussion that is perhaps less obvious. Historically, emissions regulation has largely determined how vessels must be designed and operated. Increasingly, it may also determine where they are permitted to operate. Norway’s World Heritage fjords provide an example of this emerging direction, with requirements for low- and zero-emission operation progressively influencing access to environmentally sensitive areas. For a vessel intended to operate globally, the ability to undertake meaningful periods of local zeroemission operation may become an increasingly valuable capability. Interestingly, when we examined a representative 48-hour visit to the Norwegian fjords, the energy requirement was approximately 10MWh. Once again, the requirement for the actual operation is considerably smaller than that associated with the yacht’s maximum range or endurance. This introduces an interesting shift in the meaning of capability itself. Historically, we have


ENX emerged because we stopped asking how to make a battery-powered yacht cross the Atlantic and started asking what energy a yacht actually needs to deliver the experience for which it was created. James Roy, Managing Director, Lateral Naval Architects

tended to define a capable yacht through measures such as maximum speed, range and endurance. In the future, might we also define capability through the ability to operate quietly, without local emissions, in places where conventional vessels face increasing restrictions? Could the capacity to spend extended periods in sensitive environments, without running generators, become more valuable to an owner than another knot of maximum speed? These are questions worth exploring. ENX is not intended to represent a finished answer to the decarbonisation of superyachts. It is one step in a much longer engineering journey. Lateral’s research and development work has progressively examined diesel-electric propulsion, hybrid systems, e-Hybrid architectures, advanced battery technologies and alternative fuels. We are also exploring longer-term possibilities, including nuclear energy. There is unlikely to be a single tech-

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

nology that resolves every aspect of the energy transition. Different vessel types, operating profiles and infrastructure environments will demand different solutions. Nor should we underestimate the importance of conventional engineering efficiency. Hull performance, propulsive efficiency, hotel energy demand and machinery selection remain fundamental irrespective of the fuel or energy carrier employed. But I do think there is a wider lesson emerging from this work. As engineers, we are generally very good at optimising solutions against a set of requirements. We can model, analyse, refine and progressively improve the efficiency with which those requirements are delivered. Perhaps we are less accustomed to challenging the requirements themselves. In the context of superyachts, where capability and optionality are fundamental to the product, that is not an entirely comfortable conversation. Nor should it be. The answer will not always be to reduce performance or surrender flexibility. But understanding the relationship between what a yacht can do and what it actually does gives us a better basis for making those decisions. ENX emerged because we stopped asking how to make a battery-powered yacht cross the Atlantic and started asking what energy a yacht actually needs to deliver the experience for which it was created. That change of question opened up a very different set of engineering possibilities. And perhaps that is the more important outcome of this work. Not simply a 70-metre yacht with 60MWh of batteries, but a demonstration of what can happen when we challenge the assumptions that define the problem. Sometimes meaningful innovation begins not with a better answer, but with a different question. JR

71


Guest Column by Alex Emley

When shipyard risk changes Alex Emley, Senior Director at Willis Marine, offers five ways to protect your yacht and your investment ...

A major yacht refit or new build can represent a significant investment, often concentrated within a single shipyard for an extended period. While owners naturally focus on a yard’s capability and reputation, its financial and operational resilience can be just as important. Financial pressure can lead to changes in key personnel, subcontractor availability, maintenance standards or site security, altering the risk environment at a time when the yacht may be particularly vulnerable. The following five points can help owners and their advisers protect the yacht and their wider investment throughout the project.

72

and parts of the vessel dismantled, potentially increasing exposure to fire, water ingress, theft or accidental damage.

look beyond whether the shipyard has insurance and ask instead: how would my yacht and my investment be protected if something went wrong?

The same principle applies to new builds. Significant value can accumulate long before delivery through completed hull sections, machinery, technology, equipment and materials.

Owner-Controlled Refit or Builders Risk insurance can provide an alternative approach. By arranging cover around the owner’s asset and project, rather than relying solely on the yard’s programme, owners can have greater control over policy terms, insured values and claims handling. However, Refit or Builders Risk insurance should not be assumed to cover every consequence of a shipyard being unable to complete the project. Cover for physical loss or damage and protection against the wider financial consequences of an interrupted project are separate considerations.

Practical takeaway: Look beyond the yard’s reputation and remain alert to changes in its financial and operational resilience throughout the project

1. Look beyond the shipyard’s reputation Selecting a reputable shipyard is important, but circumstances can change during a major project. Warning signs may include the departure of key personnel, payment delays, subcontractors becoming reluctant to continue working or declining operational standards.

2. Understand exactly whose insurance is protecting your yacht The existence of shipyard insurance does not necessarily mean the owner’s financial interests are fully protected. Shipyard insurance is generally arranged around the yard’s own property exposures and legal liabilities. Depending on the cover and contractual arrangements in place, an owner’s ability to recover following a loss may involve establishing liability and can be affected by exclusions, liability caps or disputes over responsibility.

These changes matter because yachts undergoing refit can be particularly vulnerable. Machinery may have been removed, critical systems disconnected

Those issues can become more complicated if the yard itself is experiencing financial or operational difficulties. Owners should therefore

Practical takeaway: Examine how the yard’s insurance, contractual protections and the owner’s own cover work together before work begins, and as the project evolves. 3. Protect everything going into the project, not just the yacht During a significant refit or new build, the owner’s financial exposure may extend well beyond the vessel itself. Owner-supplied equipment, tenders, technology, bespoke furnishings and


A shipyard’s circumstances can change during a major project. Owners should understand how their contracts and insurance arrangements protect the yacht, equipment and works – and where financial exposure remains.

other high-value items may arrive well before installation. Owners should understand how these items are insured while stored, handled and incorporated into the project. As work progresses, values can increase rapidly as machinery, systems and bespoke components are added. Practical takeaway: Treat insured values as dynamic. Reassess the value of the yacht, materials and owner-supplied equipment throughout the project, rather than relying solely on figures agreed at the outset. 4. Have a plan if the project must move Most owners begin a refit or new build expecting it to be completed at their chosen shipyard. But anticipating what would happen if that were no longer possible can be an important part of contingency planning. Moving a project can involve considerably more than relocating the vessel. Equipment and materials may need to be transferred, temporary storage arranged and unfinished work assessed before another yard can take over. Insurance continuity therefore deserves particular attention.

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

Subject to policy terms and insurer agreement, Owner-Controlled Refit or Builders Risk cover may be adapted to follow the project to another facility. This can provide greater continuity than relying solely on insurance attached to the original shipyard. Practical takeaway: Before work starts, understand what would happen to insurance protection if the project were delayed, suspended or transferred to another yard. 5. Keep monitoring the risk once work begins Insurance should not be a “set and forget” exercise. If concerns arise about a shipyard’s financial or operational resilience, scrutiny may need to increase. Areas to monitor include: • Fire protection and site security •S torage and protection of ownersupplied equipment and materials •C ontractor and subcontractor management • Insured values • Payment of insurance premiums •C onfirmation that relevant insurance remains in force. If a project is delayed, suspended or abandoned, owners should also assess the implications for lay-up arrangements,

preservation measures and security. A partially dismantled yacht or incomplete new build may remain exposed while decisions about the project’s future are being made. Practical takeaway: Monitor risk controls and insurance arrangements throughout the project and increase scrutiny if circumstances at the yard begin to change. Protecting the project when circumstances change In conclusion, a shipyard’s circumstances can change during a major project. Owners should understand how their contracts and insurance arrangements protect the yacht, equipment and works – and where financial exposure remains. Before work begins, and as the project evolves, three questions deserve particular attention: •W hat exactly is protected by the shipyard’s insurance, and what depends on establishing the yard’s liability? •W ould Owner-Controlled Refit or Builders Risk insurance give the owner greater control and continuity of protection? • I f the project stops or has to move, what is insured, what can move with the project, and what financial exposure remains with the owner? AE

73


Painting within the lines

74


Future-proofing coating performance

How evolving regulatory restrictions on raw materials and sustainability targets are affecting yacht coatings and the refit process – and how new technology can play a part in futureproofing yards and professional applicators.

BY LISELOTTE DE BACKER, GLOBAL PRODUCT AND SUB-SEGMENT MANAGER YACHT, AKZONOBEL

S

wirling in the midst of a perfect storm of increasingly stringent environmental compliance, rising customer expectations and compressed refit yard operations, paint and coatings are under pressure from all sides to evolve, adapt and improve. However, these challenges are not developing at a consistent speed, with rapidly changing regulations currently outpacing adjustments and innovations in the market. The role of a yacht coatings supplier has shifted from providing a paint system, once the most predictable line item on a refit budget, to delivering a complete service provision and solution that a yard can trust to perform and actually use within its own compliance framework, wherever it is located. As the superyacht fleet continues to grow, the predicted expansion disproportionately weighted towards larger vessels means greater surface areas, with more complex fairing and less tolerance for error when a paint job has to be redone. At the same time, the complex regulatory environment, sustainability targets and the ongoing reclassification of raw materials governing what can be used in coating formulations, and how paint can be applied, have never moved faster or in a more fragmented way, at a time when superyacht owners

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

are demanding ever higher standards in terms of appearance and cosmetic quality. For coatings suppliers, yards and applicators alike, the challenge is not simply keeping pace with the current rules, it is also ensuring future compliance too – making sure that the combined needs of the boat owner, professional refit team and the regulator are fulfilled, and that compliance and performance advance in parallel, rather than sacrificing one for the other. A moving regulatory target Sustainability and regulations are not just affecting paint and coatings technology. The effects are being felt much earlier in the build process, from the new designs of the yachts and the different materials that are being used, to how a yacht coatings supplier formulates, packages and documents its products and services. Simultaneously, the superyacht refit market is increasingly being managed in the same way as new-build projects, requiring suppliers to adapt to a new way of refit planning and scheduling. From a paint perspective, the clearest shift is towards reduced volatile organic compound (VOC) and less hazardous coatings, driven by a range of global regulations. Over recent years, for example, we have phased out chromates and

certain perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from its formulations, not necessarily because a particular material or product was banned outright, but because reformulation was the responsible course. This kind of proactive measure requires sustained investment in R&D, rather than a single reactive fix, with the continuously evolving landscape calling for development of new technologies. When it comes to below the waterline, effective fouling control remains crucial as part of responsible long-term biofouling management. High-performance antifouling not only helps reduce drag and improve fuel efficiency but also plays a critical role in protecting the marine environment by limiting invasivespecies transfer and helping to reduce carbon emissions. However, the regulatory picture for antifouling systems is fragmented. Biocides, which are traditionally used in antifouling products and are released gradually over time to prevent microscopic fouling organisms from attaching to the hull, are subject to tightening restrictions. But provisions governing biocidal coatings vary significantly depending upon where yachts are located, with antifouling systems regulated nationally, and sometimes regionally within a single country, through the EU’s Biocidal Products Regulation (BPR) and bodies such as the US Environmental Protection Agency. This represents a distinct challenge for owners’ representatives and yard technical teams for superyachts that travel between jurisdictions when it comes to selecting an appropriate, compliant coating to suit different needs and cruising plans. As the marine leisure industry moves towards more sustainable fouling control solutions, continued access to proven and approved biocides remains essential to managing the transition effectively while supporting the industry’s sustainability commitments. However, as

75


market signals point to a continued contraction in compliant biocidal antifouling products, boat owners, yards and professional applicators will increasingly need to engage with future-proofed fouling protection solutions. In a recent position paper, the International Council of Marine Industry Association (ICOMIA) highlighted the impact that ongoing restrictions on raw materials will have industry-wide. The report asserts that access to a broad range of approved biocides, supported by proven environmental risk assessments, is vital in maintaining effective fouling control within the market. The direction of travel is clear: sustainability aims and regulation are steadily narrowing the toolkit available to coatings suppliers. While this is a positive trend, pushing the whole industry towards safer working environments and reduced waste, it has implications for refit expectations and workflows. Changes on the ground The range of global regulations not only changes the type of technologies a coatings supplier can use, but it also affects the application of the products, which in turn changes drying and curing profiles, and sometimes changes mix ratios that applicators have relied on for years. A straightforward 1:1 mix that a painter has applied hundreds of times might become more complex, and that has direct implications for training, consistency and rework risk, particularly in a market already short of experienced painters and supervisors. Overall compliance requires more data tracking and documentation, which means investment in advanced digital tools, automated reporting and batch tracking will be an increasing focus for the future. On the coatings side, that means supplying more comprehensive Certificates of Conformity (CoC) and Certificates of Analysis (CoA) documents providing batch information and shelflife data.

76

[There] is a growing expectation of finish standards on refit projects to increasingly reflect a newbuild quality, at a time when refit schedules are compressed and skilled labour is more difficult to find.

With regulations on air quality, yards are required to track VOC emissions, as well as waste disposal. As a result, customers are asking for additional support with more data on VOC in paints or what packaging is used to allow correct reporting for their yards, through the use of Environmental Product Declarations (EPD), for example. Yards are also paying more attention to the hazardous substances or SVHC (Substances of Very High Concern) and asking questions on substances flagged on Safety Data Sheets (SDS). Underlying these issues is the growing expectation of finish standards on refit projects to increasingly reflect a new-build quality, at a time when refit schedules are compressed and skilled labour is more difficult to find. Meeting both a stricter environmental profile and a higher cosmetic bar, on the same budget and timeline as in previous years, is the central tension customers are looking to solve. Technology as the practical answer System simplification to help speed up the refit process, while maintaining the quality of finish expected within the industry, is key. Reducing the number of steps and products in a coating system is proving that new innovations can reduce material waste and the opportunities for applicator error, while also saving time. According to an early adopter of Awlgrip Gloss Finish Primer, Mike Voogd, founder of Excellence Yachtpainting, time savings are estimated at two to three weeks on small vessels, and five or six weeks for larger yachts. The feedback demonstrates how simplified painting processes can maximise efficiency and durability, while also supporting faster turnaround times, reduced material use and the need for more sustainable solutions, in addition to a premium finish. Improvements in how paints are applied can also be achieved with automated systems, such as a solvent-free


filler technology applied by pressurised airless spray rather than hand application. Enhancing transfer efficiency and reducing material waste, it also helps reduce rework and defects, which matters both financially and environmentally. High-solids, low-VOC and waterbased coatings do not need to trade performance for compliance, reducing emissions while still delivering the same durability and protection as older technologies. AkzoNobel focuses on the advancement of technologies which also make paints last longer, meaning longer repaint cycles in the vessel life cycle. Awlgrip HDT (High Definition Technology) is a good example of the benefits possible with the latest systems, delivering a sprayable topcoat that combines hardness and micro-scratch resistance with repairability, and with lower VOCs than traditional topcoats available in the market. Gold Coast-based superyacht finishing company Yachtsmiths selected it as the topcoat for a refinishing project on one of Australia’s largest charter superyachts, the 54-metre M/Y Mischief, making it the first superyacht to be coated with this system in Australia. The same applies underwater, where the fouling control products are made to last longer and have improved drag reduction, again helping with reduced maintenance, improved fuel efficiency and increased vessel longevity. As the pool of approved biocides contracts, new biocide-free antifouling systems and silicone-based fouling-release technology are now available, with more under development. These solutions meet new regulations to ensure yards and applicators are future-proofed, without compromising on performance, protection or project control. The continued development of low solar absorption (LSA) coatings, which reduce hull surface temperature and, by extension, help with fuel efficiency and on-board cooling loads, is increasingly

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

Application training at AkzoNobel’s Yacht Paint Application Centre (YPAC) in the Netherlands.

77


54-metre superyacht Mischief during a refinishing project in which Awlgrip HDT was applied by Yachtsmith in Australia.

78


Yacht paints and coatings have an important role to play in compliance and sustainability targets, with system simplification and new technology helping to meet regulations, while reducing the burden on the applicator and alleviating some of the cost and delay pressures building in the refit sector.

lead to project delays while the applicator waits for an expert opinion. In today’s climate, yards and professionals need access to the latest product education, hands-on training, and extra support to navigate evolving regulations so they can consistently deliver premium results in superyacht paint refit. Facilities such as the network of global AkzoNobel Yacht Paint Application Centers (YPAC) aim to answer this demand, including a new centre recently opened in Hamburg, Germany. These hubs enable applicators, distributors, designers and other professionals to receive specific advice and product training on technologies and sustainable practices.

relevant, particularly in warmer climates and as hotter temperatures become more widespread across the world. Contributing towards a yacht’s overall sustainability, LSA technology within topcoats helps minimise heat buildup from solar energy, particularly with darker colours, reducing the demand for additional cooling while helping exposed surfaces remain cooler to the touch. LSA coatings incorporate special pigments into the finish paint formulation with low reflectance in the visible spectrum, but high reflectance in the solar infrared; effectively reducing the heat the paint absorbs and providing a better working environment for the crew and sensitive electronic equipment. Finally, faster curing technology has an important part to play, with refit schedules under pressure and yachts needing to be back in the water as soon as possible. For specific markets, faster drying primers have been introduced along with a range of activators helping to tune drying speed.

The evolution of coatings solutions gathers pace Yacht paints and coatings have an important role to play in compliance and sustainability targets, with system simplification and new technology helping to meet regulations, while reducing the burden on the applicator and alleviating some of the cost and delay pressures building in the refit sector. Suppliers continue to develop products that have stronger health and safety profiles, but the role of a coatings partner must now go beyond the product. For instance, our technical team continually monitors all global regulatory requirements so customers can continue to access compliant products, regardless of where their refit is taking place, also providing information to support the creation of carbon footprint documentation to ensure the best system is being chosen for the vessel and yard. Coating performance still leads sustainability in most commercial conversations with owners and yards today. However, the two are converging rather than competing, because the compliant systems of tomorrow are, by necessity, also the more efficient, longer-lasting and lower-waste systems a cost-conscious refit market needs. Future-proofing a yard is less about betting on a single new technology than about building the flexibility, training and documentation capability to accommodate the combination of solutions each project, jurisdiction and hull requires, both today and for decades to come. LDB All images courtesy of AkzoNobel.

Training tools bring added value Training itself is becoming part of the technology story. Virtual Reality enables advanced training without paint waste, while additional application training and initiatives like paint bootcamps allow applicators to enhance their skills by practising unfamiliar mix ratios and application techniques, reducing errors, rework and material waste on-site. Remote diagnostic support allows a specialist to review a coating issue on-site in real time from anywhere in the world, cutting the delay and travel that would otherwise

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

79


Guest Column by Bob Wagemakers

Beyond the meeting room Refit yards are full again and owners who plan late lose their choice. But booking the right yard is only the beginning, argues Bob Wagemakers of Virtue Yacht Projects.

Once again this autumn, the highend refit yards we have visited are full. Owners who called around at the end of the season found their preferred yard booked well into next year and are now settling for whichever yard has a slot. With the global fleet passing 6,000 superyachts, and dock space and skilled labour struggling to keep up, this is no passing squeeze. Last year in these pages we made the case for early preparation and the message continues to be equally important. A refit planned twelve to eighteen months ahead, with a defined scope, a condition survey and a realistic budget, secures the yard and contractors of choice and a stronger negotiating position and will allow the refit yard to perform better. It also creates time to ask a bigger question: what else should this refit achieve? Increasingly, the answer includes the yacht’s environmental footprint. The existing fleet far outnumbers each year’s new deliveries, so much of our industry’s progress must be made in refit, when systems and spaces are opened and surveys take place.

80

To improve it, you need to measure it. We intend to use YETI, the Yacht Environmental Transparency Index developed by Water Revolution Foundation, whose method now underpins ISO/TS 23099, published in March 2026 as the first internationally recognised framework for assessing the environmental performance of large yachts. An assessment before the scope is fixed shows where upgrades will have

most effect, with a quantifiable valuation of the impact from changes made during the refit. The results often point away from the obvious. Water Revolution Foundation’s work shows the hotel load makes up more than half of a yacht’s annual energy demand, so some of the biggest gains lie in the HVAC system. Typical refit upgrades include variable-speed

A yacht leaving the yard today will sail for decades, facing tighter emissions rules, new fuels and charter guests who ask about its credentials. Future proofing means making room for what cannot be done yet ...


Delivering a project on time, within budget and to an uncompromised standard of quality requires a blend of engineering foresight and relentless process inspection. chillers and pumps, generator heat recovery for hot water, LED lighting and modern power management. Correctly sized and integrated shore power converters keep generators off in port, and a battery bank can cover silent anchoring and peak loads. Below the waterline, the simplest measures remain among the most effective: a clean bottom and clean propellers cut resistance and fuel burn, and a low-friction, biocide-free coating or propeller redesign takes this further. Just as important is thinking beyond this refit. A yacht leaving the yard today will sail for decades, facing tighter emissions rules, new fuels and charter guests who ask about its credentials. Future proofing means making room for what cannot be done yet: space and weight for a future battery room, cable routes and switchboard capacity for later upgrades, and engines approved for renewable fuels such as HVO. These provisions cost less while the yacht is opened up, protect resale value and make the next refit simpler and cheaper. The same applies to new builds. A yacht specified as future fuel or methanol ready, with space, tank arrangements and structural provisions

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

in place, is far easier to convert later. Regulations for alternative fuels still need to catch up, but in commercial shipping such retrofits are already happening at scale. So, who should lead a refit of this kind? A major refit touches structure, stability, propulsion, systems, interiors and Class compliance at once, and every change affects the others: a hull extension, for instance, alters both weight and stability. In our view, a naval architect is particularly well placed, trained to see the yacht as one integrated platform, rather than a collection of trades. This, supported by a team of specialists as the project requires, such as, for example, electrical and marine engineers. With several decades of experience in superyacht refit and technical project management, that lets us assess proposals across disciplines, spot conflicts early and speak with authority to shipyards, Class, Flag and suppliers, answering or challenging technical questions on engineering grounds rather than simply passing them on. Equally important is what refit management involves day to day. A project can be on time and on budget and still disappoint. Quality is decided in steps the owner never sees: surface

preparation before fairing and paint, the bedding of deck fittings, the routing of cables and pipework, insulation before a ceiling is closed. Problems then surface months later as blistering paint, leaks or corrosion, becoming warranty discussions long after the yacht has left the yard. That is why refit management, for us, does not just happen behind a desk or in a meeting room. You need to spend time on board, following the work at each stage. Knowing how things are built means knowing what to look for at every step and catching issues while they are easier to fix. Agreed inspection points, shared records, testing and clear reporting keep owner, captain and yard aligned. Ultimately, modern refit success cannot be bought with a reactive approach or superficial oversight. Delivering a project on time, within budget and to an uncompromised standard of quality requires a blend of engineering foresight and relentless process inspection. By placing technical leadership at the helm and using scientific tools like YETI, we can navigate the complexities of modern refit management, ensuring our fleet remains compliant and exceptional and becomes more sustainable for years to come. BW

81


82


The lighting evolution

Why the best LED refits are the ones you never notice Instead of asking, “What should we replace?”, perhaps we should first ask, “What deserves to be preserved?” That single question can completely change the outcome of a refit ...

BY DAVID CADDICK, FOUNDER, MARINE LIGHT CORPORATION

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

83


A

s you walk around the interior of almost any superyacht that’s been in service for twenty years or more it wouldn’t surprise you to hear a familiar statement: “The lighting needs updating”. In many cases, that’s absolutely true. Halogen lamps have become increasingly difficult to source, power consumption is high by today’s standards, maintenance is continual, and the quality of light often deteriorates over time as lamps, reflectors and optics age. We know modern LED technology has transformed what’s possible: power energy consumption, significantly longer service life, reduced heat output and improved reliability all make a compelling case for upgrading older systems. But after more than three decades working in marine lighting in the superyacht industry, I’ve become convinced that our industry often starts with the wrong question. Instead of asking, “What should we replace?”, perhaps we should first ask, “What deserves to be preserved?” That single question can completely change the outcome of a refit. Too often, an LED upgrade is approached as a replacement exercise – existing luminaires are removed, new products installed and the project moves on, and while, on paper, that sounds straightforward, in reality, it rarely is. This is superyachts, after all. Every fitting removed has the potential to affect joinery, decorative finishes, ceiling cut-outs, cabling, dimming systems and, perhaps most

84

importantly, the original vision of the designer. Many of the fittings found aboard older yachts are beautifully engineered: precision-machined bronze, solid stainless steel and handcrafted decorative luminaires built to standards that would be difficult (and often prohibitively expensive) to reproduce today. Why discard that craftsmanship if the housing itself still has decades of life left in it? For me, a successful refit isn’t about replacing as much as possible, it’s about preserving everything that’s worth keeping while discreetly introducing modern technology where it genuinely adds value. One of the biggest misconceptions surrounding LED conversions is that they’re simply about replacing a light source. They aren’t; they’re about understanding light itself. The LED is only one part of the equation. The thermal management, optics, colour consistency, beam control and the interaction between all those elements ultimately determine how a space feels. I’ve dismantled enough fittings over the years to know that the housing is rarely the problem! Sometimes the limitation lies in outdated driver technology. Sometimes it’s an optic originally designed around a tungsten filament, sometimes it’s simply the way heat is managed within the fitting. Modern engineering often allows those issues to be solved without changing the appearance of the luminaire at all and, to anyone walking through the yacht, nothing appears different.

Marine lighting isn’t simply architectural lighting installed outside, the sea has an extraordinary ability to expose poor engineering, and it always wins eventually.


The lighting simply feels better and that’s exactly how a successful refit should feel. One of the most rewarding aspects of my work is looking at products others have already written off. It’s not uncommon to hear that an older fitting is obsolete or that complete replacement is the only practical option, and I’ve learned to treat those conclusions with a healthy dose of scepticism. The first step is always to understand how the fitting was originally engineered; only then can you decide whether modern technology allows it to perform better than it did when it first left the factory. The same philosophy applies to the exterior. Marine lighting is subjected to one of the harshest operating environments imaginable: sand, salt, ultraviolet exposure, moisture, vibration and thermal cycling relentlessly expose weaknesses in design and manufacture. Marine lighting isn’t simply architectural lighting installed outside, the sea has an extraordinary ability to

The Superyacht Report Refit Focus ISSUE 231

expose poor engineering, and it always wins eventually. That is why material selection, drainage, corrosion resistance, serviceability and thermal management are every bit as important as the light source itself. Owners understandably focus on energy savings, but some of the biggest benefits of LED refits are less obvious. Traditional halogen fittings generate significant heat. Every watt of heat produced by a luminaire eventually becomes another watt that the yacht’s air-conditioning system has to remove. Reducing lighting load also reduces cooling load, so it’s one upgrade delivering two efficiencies. And longer service life, fewer failures and reduced maintenance quietly deliver value year after year. Lighting itself has evolved dramatically over the past decade and we’re no longer simply illuminating spaces. We’re now actively shaping how people experience them. Today’s lighting design discussions increasingly involve

circadian lighting, colour rendering, visual comfort and creating environments that support wellbeing rather than simply meeting illumination levels. Guests rarely admire the specification of a luminaire, what they will remember is how a space made them feel. The best lighting allows architecture, artwork, materials and craftsmanship to speak for themselves. Technology will continue to evolve. LEDs will become more efficient, controls will become more intelligent, and solutions more sustainable. Tomorrow’s lighting systems will undoubtedly out|perform today’s, but I suspect one principle will remain unchanged: good engineering starts by understanding what already exists before deciding what should replace it. Preserve everything that’s worth keeping, improve everything that isn’t and respect the original vision. Leave the yacht looking exactly as she always has, but performing better than ever, because the very best LED refits are the ones you never notice. DC

85


STERN WORDS

365 DAYS AND COUNTING A five-year strategy based on filtering out the fluff and focusing on what really counts.

A

BY MARTIN H. REDMAYNE

s we get closer to the end of the year and the various holiday seasons we all relish, I often look back and wonder where all those months, weeks and days disappeared to, and how the year has ended so quickly. Like many of my industry colleagues, time is very precious, not just personally, but professionally too, and if you look at the effectiveness of the 52 weeks, the 24 hours and the 60 minutes and seconds that make up our year, we all have to start to take stock and focus on what really makes sense. Now I’m not going to rant about events and how many days a year you could transit an airport to visit a country you travel to regularly, to spend four days at a show or exhibition that guarantees that you’ll meet people you already know and some you don’t. We’re all grown-ups now and we have a choice, where do we spend our time and to what end. However, if I break down my future and think about the next five years in business – the approximate lifecycle of a major new-build project, from concept to delivery – in those 60 months we have to carve out time to meet clients, visit shipyards, talk to industry leaders and spend time in the office thinking, planning, researching and analysing what’s actually happening. Like many industry leaders, it’s not five days a week

The Superyacht Report (ISSN 2046-4983) is published four times a year by TRP Magazines Ltd.

86

or even eight hours a day, it’s a constant flow of managing and planning; even in the shower the mind hardly switches off. So for the next 60 months, my mantra is going to focus on efficiency and effectiveness, less distraction and more action, less haste and no waste and a clear mission to operate a business that the market needs every day, for information, advice, intelligence or introductions. There is a better way of using each working hour so maybe Artificial Intelligence will be my friend for the future, but I also want to use our Authentic Intelligence too and block out the noise, reduce the fluff, clear the BS and stop the constant flow of irrelevant information that gushes across the market and just clogs up the eyeballs. I’m even considering exiting Instagram and maybe even Linked IN, as it requires more time than it deserves, to find something useful or valuable or even credible. I’m looking forwa rd to trying this new “year” strategy and teaching myself to focus on what matters and ignoring the rest, I’m even going to turn off certain apps that suddenly push my screen time count into the few hours a day of scrolling, watching what others are doing and glimpsing into how wonderful their artificial world is. MHR


THE ART OF A CUSTOM FIT

AMICO MARINE BRINGS TOGETHER THE AMICO & CO, AMICO LOANO, AND GATTI SHIPYARDS AND ALL OUR SERVICE COMPANIES UNDER A UNIFIED BRAND. WE ARE OFFERING MORE THAN 30 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE IN SUPERYACHT REFITTING, TOGETHER WITH THE AMICO FAMILY’S MARITIME LEGACY DATING BACK TO 1799. ONE TRUSTED SYSTEM: DESIGNED FOR YACHTING, DEFINED BY QUALITY. AMICOMARINE.IT


A�UBY 10

I 230

AB EKING & RASMUSSEN


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
The Superyacht Report – Refit Focus issue 231 by The Superyacht Group - Issuu