Skip to main content

Print Edition for The Observer for Friday, November 20, 2026

Page 1

INSIDER

2 | THE OBSERVER

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

FOOTBALL

Collins: Defense rekindles swagger By Ellie Collins Associate Sports Editor

The forecast is calling for an unseasonably warm Saturday in South Bend, but it is the Irish defense and whatever quarterback it faces that are truly heating up. In mid-October, Notre Dame put on one of its most passive defensive performances in years as it battled Bear Bachmeier and thenNo. 8 BYU in Provo, Utah. The Cougars’ offense overwhelmed the vaunted Irish unit from kickoff, converting eight of 12 third-down attempts and scoring touchdowns on all four of its red-zone trips. Despite months of preparation, defensive coordinator Chris Ash and his group had no answer for BYU’s schemes; with not quite enough help from the offense, Notre Dame fell 28-24, continuing a trend under Ash in which the Irish gave up a game-winning drive against marquee opponents in Miami, Texas A&M and BYU. After a bye week, Ash arrived in Foxborough, Massachusetts, with few to no mulligans left against Navy’s sophisticated triple-option offense. Yet in the first half, his squad gave up 13 points and 189 yards, allowing the Midshipmen to possess the ball for over 23 minutes. After the break, however, the Irish rallied to hold Navy scoreless and to 56 yards to seal a comfortable 35-13 win. Whatever happened at halftime in the Bay State will likely never be known. But whatever it was, it relit a snuffed match. Head coach Marcus Freeman, visibly frustrated and more actively involved with players on the sideline, certainly made it clear what he felt needed to change. “[We’ve] gotta play physical,” he said at the break. “We’ve gotta play on their line of scrimmage, but can’t be out of control.”

On Nov. 7 in South Bend against top-ranked Miami and its potent offensive attack, Notre Dame returned to form when it mattered most. The defense finally attacked with violence, generating 34 pressures, including 6 total hits on and sacks of normally unflappable quarterback Darian Mensah. The Irish also forced a field goal on first-and-goal from the 1-yard line in the second quarter. My analysis of what ignited the fire: The Irish attacked on every down and distance, led by the hyper energy of junior linebacker Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa from the opening snap. Due to senior captain Drayk Bowen’s lower-leg injury suffered against Navy that will sideline him for at least the rest of the regular season, Viliamu-Asa got his first start of the season, and his infectious desire to wreak havoc makes it borderline coaching malpractice not to unleash the blitz. “He’s as physical in practice as anyone I’ve ever coached,” Freeman said of Viliamu-Asa and his 7 tackles in Notre Dame’s 41-7 victory against Boston College on Nov. 14. “The other thing I like about Kyng is that he can [be physical with] somebody on offense, and the guy on offense tries to get mad and start a fight, and he’ll run back to his huddle and start laughing and smiling. It’s a little bit sick, man.” The Irish blitzed on 59% of Miami’s pass plays — more than double the 28% rate before the contest. The aggression continued against the Eagles and hopefully will the rest of the way, as the defense’s DNA is built for it. It doesn’t require squinting to envision improvement on the recent performances. Junior

Keys to victory: Irish need to stay sharp in home finale By Jack Muething Sports Reporter

Head coach Marcus Freeman’s Notre Dame enters its Saturday matchup against SMU with a 9-1 record and likely needs to win out to secure a spot in the College Football Playoff. The Mustangs are the tougher of the two opponents remaining on its schedule, but the Irish still enter the contest as 20.5-point favorites. Here’s what they need to do to take care of business against the Mustangs. Limit the passing game SMU quarterback Kevin Jennings has been one of the best signal-callers in the nation, as he is seventh in the country in passing yards and fifth in touchdowns. He also completed 72.6% of his passes this year — the second-best completion percentage among quarterbacks with over

200 completions. He’s also taking care of the ball much better than he did last year, as he’s only thrown 7 interceptions compared to the 13 last season. Jennings will be the second-best quarterback Notre Dame faces this season, after Miami’s Darian Mensah. When teams have found success against the Mustangs, it has been because they have limited his offense. Jennings brings both talent and experience, as he’s been the SMU starter for three years now, and this Irish secondary will need to be ready for one of their toughest tests of the year. Find a rhythm on the ground In their last contest, the Mustangs were blown to bits by the Wake Forest Demon Deacons, who are ranked No. 11 in the country in the most recent CFP rankings. The key for Wake Forest in that 49-7 win was running the ball, as the

Demon Deacons had 286 rushing yards and 535 total offensive yards. Sophomore Nolan James Jr. and freshman Jonaz Walton have taken turns as the top rusher for Notre Dame, with each leading in three of the past six games. In four of those, the top running back eclipsed 100 yards. The running game has become increasingly effective in the past six matchups, and the Irish will want to use that to their advantage as they get ready to play one of the weaker rushing defenses they have seen this year. Keep CJ Carr protected Junior quarterback CJ Carr joins Jennings as one of the best at his position this season, and a key part of that has been the superb play of his offensive line. Keeping the quarterback protected is always a key aspect of a game, but it will be see “Keys” on page 15

TEAGAN BARRY | The Observer

see “Defense” on page 17

Junior quarterback CJ Carr readies for a snap during Notre Dame’s 41-7 win over Boston College on Nov. 14. The Saline, Michigan, native threw for 217 yards and 2 scores to advance his Heisman Trophy candidacy. FOOTBALL

A Midwest and Southern rivalry: ND vs. SMU By Tess Corvera Sports Reporter

This Saturday, the Notre Dame football team will compete against its southern rival, Southern Methodist University. This matchup is different from other rivalries, as the schools don’t meet every year or play for a specific trophy, but it still holds historic weight. The teams first met on Oct. 4, 1930, and Notre Dame came out victorious, defeating SMU 20-14. The Irish were led by the legendary coach Knute Rockne, who is widely considered one of the greatest college football coaches of all time. Notre Dame’s win against SMU was part of its road to a perfect 10-0

record and national championship that year. This season marked Rockne’s third overall national championship title and the end of his coaching career at Notre Dame. The 1930 contest was the first football game played in Notre Dame Stadium, which replaced the old Cartier Field. A week following that matchup, Notre Dame Stadium was officially dedicated on Oct. 11, 1930, as 40,593 fans watched the Irish defeat Navy 262. The stadium became known as “The House That Rockne Built” because of Rockne’s role in planning and constructing it. The nickname became permanent following his sudden death in 1931. Notre Dame and SMU next met

in 1939, and the two teams continued to meet sporadically in the following two decades, meeting eight times from 1949 to 1958. Notre Dame’s longest winning streak in that stretch series was three games, a mark it reached twice: from 1930 to 1949 and from 1953 to 1955. After 1958, Notre Dame and SMU did not meet again until the 1984 Aloha Bowl in Honolulu, where the Mustangs picked up a 27-20 win. This victory was SMU’s final bowl game appearance before the infamous NCAA “death penalty,” imposed on the Mustangs in 1987. This punishment is known as the harshest sanction ever handed down in college athletics. SMU was caught giving forbidden cash

payments to players after already being placed on probation for prior recruiting violations against NCAA guidelines. The illicit payments were exposed, and the NCAA canceled SMU’s entire 1987 season and all 1988 home games in response. The program suffered, as it was also placed on a multiyear ban for television appearances, bowl games and scrimmages as well as given severe scholarship restrictions. SMU football returned to the field for the 1989 season, but the break weakened the program’s competitive spirit and ability. SMU and Notre Dame last met during this 1989 season when Notre Dame came out victorious in a 59-6 win. Between the years 1989 and 2008,

SMU had just one season with a winning record, a 6-5 season in 1997. The Irish currently hold a 10-3 series lead against the Mustangs. Notre Dame is currently ranked No. 3 in the AP Poll with a 9-1 record after its 41-7 win against Boston College on Saturday. SMU lost to No. 10 Wake Forest on Saturday by a score of 49-7. Notre Dame will host SMU Saturday, Nov. 21, at 7:30 p.m. for its final home game of the 2026 regular season. The game will be streamed live on NBC and Peacock. Contact Tess Corvera at tcorvera@nd.edu


THE INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPER SERVING NOTRE DAME, SAINT MARY’S AND HOLY CROSS FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026 | VOL. LXI, NO. 23

ESTABLISHED 1966

NDSMCOBSERVER.COM

Feds deny South Shore Line SMC holds $56 million grant international week By Gracie Shea

By Sophie Lewandowski

The Federal Railroad Administration recently denied a $56 million grant to fund the South Shore Line’s Airport Realignment Project. This project would cut approximately 15 minutes in travel by going more directly to the South Bend Airport from the west side, rather than making a loop around the east side. “We are clearly disappointed we didn’t get the grant because we believe this is an excellent project,” Nicole Barker, spokesperson for the South Shore Line Railroad, said in an interview with The Observer. According to Barker, they plan to reapply for a new grant during the next cycle. In a general email to South Shore Line passengers,

Saint Mary’s International Students Week offers an opportunity to celebrate international students and discuss their experiences. Throughout the week, f lags from countries around the world were hung from the second-f loor balcony in the atrium of the Student Center, a movie night featuring the film “Big Fish & Begonia” with an assortment of Asian treats was hosted Thursday night and the Student Diversity Board hosted a panel discussion with international students in Haggar College Center. The panel, which occurred Tuesday, featured seniors Maria Aredes Brasil

Reporter

Senior Staff Reporter

MARA HALL | The Observer

The South Shore Line’s Airport Realignment Project would cut roughly 15 minutes of commute time between South Bend and Chicago.

Northern Indiana Commuter Transportation District president and general manager Dave

Dech wrote, “While disappointing, we remain committed to this see “Grant” on page 7

ND professor Alex Chávez nominated for Grammy By Observer News Staff Notre Dame anthropology professor Alex Chávez received a Grammy nomination in Best Global Music Performance for his song “Una Flor En Cada Estrella.” Chávez is co-nominated with contemporary folk band KerreKe and artist Mireya Ramos. Other artists up for

the award include big names such as Shakira, Burna Boy, ROSALÍA, Quavo and Pharrell Williams. According to a Nov. 19 press release, the song explores the immigrant experience. Its title translates to “a f lower on every star.” “The song is a tribute to the immigrant story — to those who’ve arrived with dreams,

open hearts, and who contribute to the richness of this country,” Chávez said in the press release. He added, “Its message is particularly salient, given the anti-immigrant politics of our times targeting some of the most vulnerable communities in the United States.” see “Grammy” on page 7

HCC hosts major reliquary of St. André Bessette By Jack Beshoar

By Mara Hall Associate News Editor

Students and some faculty were invited to fill out a survey on artificial intelligence usage in an email sent by provost John McGreevy and executive vice president Shannon Cullinan at 2:06 p.m. on Thursday. The email stated, “AI tools are now part of the world in which you learn, and their place in your academic life may differ greatly from one course, discipline, or student to the next. The University wishes to understand that experience as fully as possible.” University spokesperson Erin Blasko wrote to The Observer, “The AI Cross Campus Survey is part of an ongoing effort to evaluate and explore AI, its use and its impact across all areas of the University.” “The survey asks whether and how you use AI, how clear the University’s guidance and your instructors’ expectations have been, what concerns you

Holy Cross College honored St. André Bessette on Nov. 18 with a Mass celebrated by the vicar provincial of the Canadian Province of the Congregation of Holy Cross, Fr. Jomon Kalladanthiyil, and veneration of the major reliquary of Bessette at the College’s St. Joseph Chapel.

of its weeklong pilgrimage through the greater South Bend area, providing students and local residents an opportunity to see a relic of Bessette, a Holy Cross brother and the Congregation of Holy Cross’s only canonized saint. According to materials provided by Kalladanthiyil, the reliquary travels to spread

NEWS | PAGE 5

OPINION | PAGE 9

SCENE | PAGE 12

SPORTS | PAGE 15

Mathematics professor Ranjan Rohatgi wins county council seat for District B.

Columnist Grayson Beckham asks: Is ND College Republicans rage baiting us?

Notre Dame FTT department hosts a play that documents the lives of four working women.

Sports editor Ben Hicks blames the conference for the issues in college athletics.

SMC professor wins

Republican rage bait

see “Reliquary” on page 7

‘These Shining Lives’

see “International” on page 6

Notre Dame conducts AI survey

The reliquary contains fragments of Bessette’s heart as well as a medallion and stone from St. Joseph’s Oratory in Montreal, Canada. The Oratory was founded by Bessette. Participants were also able to receive an anointing with the oil of St. Joseph, a devotion popularized by Bessette. The reliquary was hosted by Holy Cross College as part

Reporter

de Mendonca and Daniela Rivera alongside freshmen Isabella Montalvo and Marian Zetina. The panel, composed entirely of international students, was moderated by junior Monica Marquez. She invited the students to share their experiences navigating college. Mendonca explained the choice to apply to schools abroad was easy. It was something that she had always wanted to do. Mendonca, from Brazil, worried she would not be able to qualify for her local schools under the Brazilian standardized test requirements. “If you go through the traditional route, you have to take a standardized test

Conferences fail

hold, and what support would serve you best,” the email read. Encouraging students to respond, the email assured students that “responses will be reported only in aggregate,” and will not be shared with instructors or “used in any academic integrity matter.” The survey, which the email says will take around 10 minutes, features questions that ask which AI tools students have used, the use of generative AI across different activities, the account type used, the understanding of University policies — including what University data can and cannot be provided to AI — the areas where further clarity on expectations is needed, the confidence in evaluating AI usage, the limitations on AI usage, the University AI resources and the additional University resources that would be helpful. There is also a space for written feedback. However, the Qualtrics survey operates see “Survey” on page 7

SPORTS | PAGE 17

Hidalgo stands alone The senior became the first player to record 2,500 career points and 500 career steals.


DAILY

4 | THE OBSERVER

QUESTION OF THE DAY:

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

What is the most beautiful place you’ve ever been?

Have a question you want answered? Email photo@ndsmcobserver.com

Maya Garcia

Sean Huvane

Damien Micor

“Royal Chapel of Granada.”

“Co. Clare, Ireland.”

“The Basilica.”

sophomore Flaherty Hall

graduate student off campus

junior Dillon Hall

Josie Sigfried

Audrey Turley

“St. Mary’s Church in Aspen, Colorado.”

“Smoky Mountains.”

senior Pasquerilla West Hall

freshman Farley Hall

SOCIAL MEDIA POLL

PHOTO OF THE DAY | BERHAN HAGEZOM

Have an idea for a poll? Email social@ndsmcobserver.com

How did class registration go for you? Went great Went fine

9.3%

Went poorly Went terribly

14.4% 41.2%

35.1%

THE NEXT FIVE DAYS

CROSSWORD | WILL SHORTZ

Want your event included here? Email news@ndsmcobserver.com

Friday Notre Dame women’s soccer vs. Milwaukee Irish take on the Panthers in the NCAA First Round. 6 p.m. Alumni Stadium

Saturday Saturdays with the Saints lecture Talk on two saints ahead of the SMU game. 10:30 - 11:30 a.m. Andrew’s Auditorium

Sunday “The Debut” film A woman transforms from a shy into a vivid method actor. 7 - 8:45 p.m. Browning Cinema

Monday Mantelpieces and the Mundane Photographic exhibit of Irish history and culture. All day Hesburgh Library

Tuesday “Billy Preston: That’s the Way God Planned It” film Biography of musician Billy Preston’s life. 7:30 p.m. Browning Cinema

ndsmcobserver.com “TO UNCOVER THE TRUTH AND REPORT IT ACCURATELY” 900 Hesburgh Library, Notre Dame, IN 46556 Editor-in-Chief Gray Nocjar Managing Editor Grace Tadajweski

Asst. Managing Editor: Abby Hernan

Graphics Editor: Liam Flynn

Asst. Managing Editor: Zack Pohlman

Social Media Editor: Lilly Martin

Asst. Managing Editor: Henry Jagodzinski

Ad Design Manager: Isabelle Rutland

Asst. Managing Editor: Noah Cahill

Advertising Manager: Cassandra Sisk

Notre Dame News Editor: Megan Cornell

Policies The Observer is the independent, daily newspaper published in print and online by the students of the University of Notre Dame du Lac, Saint Mary’s College and Holy Cross College. Editorial content, including advertisements, is not governed by policies of the administration of any institution. The Observer reserves the right to refuse advertisements based on content.

SMC News Editor: Berhan Hagezom Holy Cross News Editor: Nick Kowal Opinion Editor: Duncan Stangel Sports Editor: Ben Hicks Scene Editor: Peter Mikulski Photo Editor: Mariella Taddonio

The news is reported as accurately and objectively as possible. Unsigned editorials represent the opinion of the majority of the Editor-in-Chief, Managing Editor, Assistant Managing Editors and department editors. Commentaries, letters and columns present the views of the authors and not necessarily those of The Observer. Opinion space is available to all readers. The free expression of all opinions through letters is encouraged. Letters to the Editor must be signed and must include contact information.

Questions regarding Observer policies should be directed to Editor-in-Chief Gray Nocjar.

Today’s Staff News

Nick Kowal Mara Hall Eileen Doyle

Graphics Liam Flynn

Photo

Keira Jones

Opinion

Duncan Stangel

Sports

Ben Hicks Ellie Collins

Scene

Nolan Scozzaro

Editors Noah Cahill Grace Tadajweski Henry Jagodzinski


NEWS

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

THE OBSERVER | 5

Ranjan Rohatgi wins county council seat By Berhan Hagezom Saint Mary’s News Editor

Ranjan Rohatgi, professor in the Department of Mathematics and Computer Science at Saint Mary’s College, recently won the St. Joseph County Council District B seat as a Democrat. His opponent, Republican incumbent Amy Drake, lost by a 14.8-percentage-point margin, 1,190 votes. Endorsed by organizations such as the A14 Action Fund, Run for Something and Indian American Impact, he built his campaign from the ground up with the help of volunteers over the course of a year. Prior to his campaign, Ranjan Rohatgi joined the College as a professor in 2016, where he became a part of a nationwide trend of mathematicians looking at the act of redistricting and gerrymandering following the 2010 census. Following the 2010 census, advances in computing technology allowed political parties to analyze voter data and draw increasingly precise district boundaries, raising concerns about partisan gerrymandering. In his early time as a professor, he created a class focused on this topic, “Mathematics of Voting,” with professor emeritus of political science Patrick Pierce, who later became his campaign manager. Through their partnership, the two combined perspectives from mathematics and political science to examine voting systems and the effects of redistricting. Another class he teaches, “Big Problems in Mathematics,” brings together mathematics and computer science students to analyze issues alongside community partners and businesses before presenting their

findings. Former community partners have included the St. Joseph County Department of Health and St. Joseph County Public Library. “They use their math skills, their computer science skills, their statistics skills to try to address these problems,” he said. They “meet with the liaison from the partner organization, give them updates, ask them questions” every two weeks. Through the course, Rohatgi said he realized these issues need “young people working on those problems to help guide the future of the county.” Following the 2020 census, Pierce encouraged Ranjan Rohatgi to be a part of the Indiana Citizens Redistricting Commission, a nonpartisan advocacy initiative that sought to give voters a greater role in the redistricting process. By working with both Democrats and Republicans on the issue, the group was able to address the issue more effectively. “Now, of course, we had our disagreements about what the best map should be, but we all knew what the problem was and we worked together to come up with a solution,” Ranjan Rohatgi said. “And I thought that’s really how local government, county government should function.” However, what ultimately pushed him to run for office was his dissatisfaction with the actions of County Council members who took office in 2023. He said it had become increasingly difficult over the past decade to watch federal, state and local changes that he believes have negatively affected the country. On his campaign website, Ranjan Rohatgi highlighted several key issues that he believed are crucial to address within St. Joseph County:

data centers, redistricting, public health, paving and plowing, affordability, libraries and parks. In terms of public health, he noted that Department of Health employees faced allegations of harassment involving County Council members, contributing to staff resignations. Yet from Ranjan Rohatgi’s perspective, the department was actually making strides. Representatives from other states were visiting Indiana’s department to observe its successes, including the development of one of the first testing areas in northern Indiana during COVID-19. “Department of Health really was a body that functioned as best it could, got grants, had decent support from the state and from the county to do its work and to let the experts do their thing,” he said. “That really changed after the election in 2022. And so over the past four years, the work that they’ve been able to do has just been curtailed and gutted from multiple directions.” A similar pattern emerged when the County Council withdrew funding for the New Day Intake Center, a low-barrier housing shelter, and delayed the naloxone distribution program for a month. Portage Manor, an assisted living facility for adults with health issues in South Bend, was also closed in 2023 by the County Council and Board of Commissioners, which led to negative effects on former residents as they began the selling process. Ranjan Rohatgi has also joined with other Democrats in a ban on new data centers. There is already an Amazon Web Services center in New Carlisle, and the development of a Microsoft facility is in progress in Granger. Ranjan Rohatgi explained that, due to St. Joseph County’s

size, it cannot “go up against these massive, multi-billion-dollar multinational corporations.” He believes that federal or state-level policies should be implemented regarding environmental impact, energy and water use, transparency and overall data collection. According to Ranjan Rohatgi, the lack of support for these measures stems from pro-data center positions held by the state legislature, which has supported sales tax exemptions for data centers. Amid the country’s affordability crisis, Rohatgi noted that residents have seen the “prices of groceries, prices of housing, price of daycare or senior care” rising with gas prices being “mainly due to the war.” One solution he proposed is “targeting relief” through incentives for developers to build entry-level housing while avoiding increases in property taxes. Over the course of the campaign, he stated that he kept the election and his professional work at the College separate. He said that though he is elected, it will not “affect my ability to reach students and teach them math and stats in any way.” He started his campaign in May 2025, the same month his second daughter was born. Both he and his wife, professor of nursing Kylee Rohatgi, work full time at the College while hosting campaign events in the evenings and on weekends. Department chair of chemistry Jennifer Fishovitz assisted with the social media and digital facets of the campaign, including the campaign launch event occurring in February. On election day, he shared that he was nervous. He went to his 8 a.m. class and was not able to focus on

class prep or grading. He then went for a two-hour run with a friend. That evening, he attended a watch party hosted by the St. Joseph County Democratic Party, where he was told at one point in time that 80% of the votes had been cast and he was down by hundreds. Following the release of the early vote totals, Rohatgi and the other Democrats at the watch party celebrated significant victories. “I hadn’t experienced a day like that ever in my life,” Ranjan Rohatgi said. As he begins his term next year, he hopes to increase transparency and “ease of participation in local government” through County Council meetings that people know about and have the opportunity to speak at. For those unable to attend, he hopes to establish alternative ways for residents to make their voices heard, including through email and phone calls. Ranjan Rohatgi mentioned that there would be various challenges along the way, but the most significant one would be funding cuts passed by the state Legislature to the county and others. During his term, he plans to focus on providing services without increasing the budget that is already limited. He also hopes to encourage students to run for office and make an impact in their communities through local government. “I never thought I was going to run for office. And I want students to know that if I can do it, so can they,” he said. “I really want every student to get involved in their local community wherever that may be.” Contact Berhan Hagezom at bhagezom01@saintmarys.edu

SIBC students delayed by FAA ground stop By Teresa Doran Reporter

Notre Dame students traveling for Student International Business Council projects were stranded in wake of the Federal Aviation Administration ground stop for all domestic flights on Nov. 13. SIBC members in New York and Boston were left scrambling to access travel plans and find lodging for the night. The ground stop, issued at 3:30 p.m. EST, was due to issues with equipment during an upgrade to telecommunication lines. The Observer spoke with Luke Williams, a junior and one of the project leaders for the Citi finance team. Following the initial disappointment of travel issues on Friday afternoon, Williams said he and his team’s perspective quickly shifted to the opportunity at hand. “I’m so happy we did get stuck because we got to explore the city,” Williams said. Williams, along with some of his team members, rode Citi Bikes around Central Park, walked down Madison Avenue and got pizza in the East Village. They also walked

to West Village, Greenwich Village and the Flatiron District. “It was absolutely beautiful,” Williams said. After the Flatiron, the group got tickets to go to the top of the Empire State Building. They also enjoyed pizza and gelato during their time in the city. Williams informed The Observer that the Notre Dame Institute of Global Investing was allegedly willing to pay for any expenses the team amassed in New York. Before the reimbursement, Williams said he spent $372.36 on expenses separate from Uber and Lyft. He also has a $250 Uber reimbursement that he is expecting to receive from SIBC. Other members of the Citi team traveled to the airport in hopes their flight would leave, while some got to see nearby relatives. Williams said there were three SIBC travel teams in New York, which is about 30 people total delayed in the city. Williams added that he heard of one group renting a car and driving back overnight to South Bend from New York City in order to make it back for the football game

against Boston College on Saturday afternoon. “I think it was pretty difficult to complain about the situation just because, hey, we’re a bunch of college students that got stuck in New York City and we basically had free rein to explore, go see really cool things, visit awesome places, eat great food. Thank you to SIBC and thanks to NDIGI for hopefully funding that amazing trip,” Williams said. The Observer also spoke with Grant Sonnenberg, a sophomore team member of the Citi project. Sonnenberg said he and two other team members spent the day with Williams. “It was confusing because we kept trying to figure out what was happening. We were emailing with the SIBC leaders and calling the other half of our team at the airport, kind of trying just to figure out like, what’s happening?” Sonnenberg said. Sonnenberg said the group took the train to one of the members’ houses in Greenwich, Connecticut. The four of them slept for a few hours and flew out the next morning. The team got back in time for

the Boston College game, which Sonnenberg said he and the team were happy about. Elliot Seng, another sophomore member of the Citi project, reported that other team members spent the night in a hotel. “People had to sleep in their suits, four people in a room,” Seng wrote in a statement to The Observer. Zachary Wirth, a sophomore co-lead of the Putnam consulting team, was also stuck in New York City. Wirth and his team stayed at his project co-lead’s house about an hour away from LaGuardia Airport. They stopped at a Target along the way to get clothes and change out of their suits. The team slept for three hours and then returned to the airport, Wirth said. Before reimbursements, Wirth and his team had to pay around $400 extra in Ubers to and from the airport. “I mean, we didn’t have a ton of information, especially from Notre Dame, about anything. They kind of left us to figure it out ourselves, at least for the beginning of the night,” Wirth said. Wirth said that a lot of the teams

had to rebook flights and look for hotels themselves. “It was just a lot of burden on the project leads,” Wirth said. The Observer also spoke with Sophia Lenceski, a member of the Lumanity consulting project that traveled to Boston on Friday. “Everyone was really confused at first because this was the second time that this has happened since 9/11. There was another one that happened in 2023, but everyone was kind of scared at first,” Lenceski said. The previous ground stop came Jan. 11, 2023, when a real-time alert system went down, and lasted for 90 minutes. The first ground stop occurred Sept. 11, 2001. American Airlines Flight 11 and United Airlines Flight 175, the hijacked planes that were flown into the World Trade Center, both departed from Boston Logan International Airport. Lenceski added that her project leader booked a hotel around 10 minutes from the airport for the Lumanity team to stay the night. Contact Teresa Doran at tdoran2@nd.edu


NEWS

6 | THE OBSERVER

International Continued from page 3

that is very time consuming and very long, and I am really not great with tests, so I did always know that I didn’t want to go through that route. So I always knew that I wanted to apply to go to either the United States or Europe,” she said. This did not eliminate challenges for Mendonca, though, who shared difficulties navigating scholarships and IRS forms. However, she said Saint Mary’s helped her navigate the process. Rivera said that financial forms were confusing for both her and her parents. She worked with her high school counselor to navigate them. Facing so many unfamiliar processes, Rivera learned to work with a variety of people to help her. In addition to her high school counselor, Rivera continues to work with Saint Mary’s staff, including Adriana Petty and International Student Services at the College. “Saint Mary’s helps support international students, especially as you’re navigating more of the legal side of things, because that’s a bigger process. I feel, as I mentioned, a lot of it is finding a way to be your best advocate but also, if you don’t know something, always asking,” Rivera explained. Beyond the legal processes, the panelists have found support in accessing school materials, winter clothing and other items they might need while at Saint Mary’s. Montalvo shared that, through the Office of Student Empowerment, she was able to receive a laptop, winter clothing and free football tickets. “So they do have a lot of those things and I feel like a lot of people don’t talk about it. But it’s definitely been very great. It’s been very nice. My parents, obviously, they love it,” Montalvo said. Through Saint Mary’s, Mendonca shared that she has been able to gain access to other health and wellness services. “They make sure that you also have emotional support, and we also have the option to obtain health insurance through Saint Mary’s, which is also nice because you don’t have to look for an outside resource to come through health insurance,” Mendonca said. Contact Sophie Lewandowski at slewandowski01@saintmarys.

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

USCCB reelects Bishop Rhoades By Observer News Staff Bishop Kevin C. Rhoades has been re-elected to a three-year term as secretary of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. Rhoades is bishop of the Diocese of Fort Wayne-South Bend, in which the tri-campus community is located. According to the National Catholic Register, Rhoades received 157 votes, as compared with the 59 received by Bishop Earl K. Fernandes of Columbus, Ohio. The vote took place at the organization’s fall plenary assembly in Baltimore. Rhoades will serve the remainder of his current term

until Nov. 2027, with his new term extending him through Nov. 2030. In addition to Rhoades, a selection of bishops from around the country was chosen to serve in leadership for six of the conference’s committees. Before being elected to this position, Rhoades chaired the Committee on Religious Liberty. Rhoades was first elected the conference’s secretary in Nov. 2025 to fill the vacancy left by Archbishop Paul Coakley of Oklahoma City, who had been selected to serve as president of the USCCB. At the time of his first election as secretary, EW TN

News wrote that Rhoades “has criticized government policies that impose mandates for abortion and contraception,” in his role on the Religious Liberty Committee, citing a statement by Rhoades titled “No Employer Should be Forced to Participate in Abortion.” While serving as secretary, Rhoades criticized U.S. immigration policy, particularly that which is related to detention centers. “We’re talking about human lives in the United States and really important principles of our country — including just human dignity [and] religious liberty,” Rhoades said at the November 2025

assembly, regarding the message of the Church being to cross the aisle as a nonpartisan organization grounded in pastoral spiritual care. On Tuesday, the press office of the Diocese of Fort WayneSouth Bend released a statement regarding Rhoades’ election. “I am honored to have been elected by my brother bishops to continue serving as Secretary of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. I am grateful for their trust and look forward to continuing this service to the Church in the U.S,” Rhoades wrote in a statement included in the press release.

PAID ADVERTISEMENT

Get a glimpse of Notre Dame classes in action.

Nov. 20

(vs. SMU)

with Meredith

y g lo o p o r h t n A , n Chesso

For more information, visit al.nd.edu/crashcourse

2:30 p.m.

141 DeBartolo Hall


NEWS

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

THE OBSERVER | 7

Catena carries leprechaun dream By Isabelle Baier Reporter

Leprechaun Riley Catena has had a lifelong dream of being the face of Notre Dame sports. “I’d always wanted to be the leprechaun,” Catena said. Originally from Rochester, New York, Catena is a senior majoring in applied and computational mathematics and statistics with minors in business and music. He also serves as a resident assistant in Knott Hall. The leprechaun mascot is a longstanding tradition at Notre Dame, with tryouts held each spring. From tryouts, four leprechauns are selected and named gold, blue or green leprechauns. Sports are divided among the four leprechauns. Catena, this year’s gold leprechaun, covers football, women’s basketball and men’s lacrosse. He was the blue leprechaun the past two years. This year his fellow leprechauns are Louis DelFra, Owen Augustine and Michael Babincak. The leprechauns are required to try out again each spring. “So you always got to be on your toes, always be at the top of your game,” Catena said. “They pick the four best people out there.”

Reliquary

Continued from page 3 awareness of Brother André’s life and devotion while encouraging prayer and veneration. Maria Gorecki, assistant director of campus ministry at Holy Cross, helped organize the event’s logistics and served as a lector during the Mass. She has previously assisted in leading Holy Cross students on pilgrimages to St. Joseph’s Oratory.

Survey

Continued from page 3 question by question and, at times, changes a subsequent question based on a previous response. Most questions include an option for not using AI, and for all questions a response is not required in order to move forward in the survey. You complete the survey with a submission button, and a back button is also available throughout. Blasko wrote, “Our Catholic mission and the data collected will inform decisions on the guidance, policies, and resources that the University

JONATHAN KARR | The Observer

The Notre Dame gold leprechaun Riley Catena celebrates during the Irish’s defeat of Michigan State on Sept. 19. The senior represents the University at football, women’s basketball and men’s lacrosse games.

Once accepted, the four chosen students begin training the following August. During this preseason training, the leprechauns learn how to represent Notre Dame as a brand and develop their skills in order to portray the role. Along with physical training, the leprechauns are also media trained. The leprechauns are part of the cheerleading team and practice four times a week, in addition to two days of exercise. On football game days there are always three leprechauns

suited up visiting various tailgates spreading school spirit. They make sure never to cross paths in order to keep the illusion of being one singular mascot. Catena said being on the football field during the game is an incredible experience. “It’s obviously a dream come true for me,” Catena said, referring to the Notre Dame Stadium crowd as “77,000 of my best friends.” Outside of game days, the leprechauns also make appearances for student organizations, nearby schools and the local community.

The leprechauns spend a lot of time with each other and the rest of the cheerleading team. Catena described the cheer team as a “second family that I’ll have here at Notre Dame for the rest of my life.” Catena’s favorite memory as a leprechaun has been traveling to Rome with the men’s and women’s basketball teams this fall, where he spent time with both programs, visited the Vatican and even got a picture with Pope Leo XIV.

“It was unique for part of the oratory to come to Holy Cross College rather than vice versa. It was a very special opportunity for our students that have not been able to go on the week-long pilgrimage before,” Gorecki wrote to The Observer. Holy Cross sophomore and altar server at the Mass Wendall Bauman also had the opportunity to venerate the relic. “I thought it was interesting, and really an honor, to see and be near a relic from

someone who had such an impact on so many people,” Bauman said. “It was also a pleasure to serve at the Mass and venerate the relic.” Before becoming known for sanctity, Bessette served as a doorkeeper at Collège Notre-Dame in Montreal for almost 40 years. Originally named Alfred Bessette and born in 1845, he entered the Congregation of Holy Cross in 1870. Bessette died Jan. 6, 1937, at the age of 91. He was canonized by Pope Benedict XVI

on Oct. 17, 2010. Gorecki hopes the experience helps the Holy Cross community recognize how Bessette’s faith continues to live on and inspire others. “I hope that the veneration of St. Brother André helped our community recognize how God’s grace worked through his life and is calling us to serve as faithful disciples, too,” Gorecki wrote.

provides.” While the email students received was directly addressed, “Dear Students,” the email went on to note that the survey is being conducted by Institutional Research, Innovation & Strategy and collecting responses from students, faculty and staff. The Observer did not obtain a copy of the email to faculty or staff. The email to students read, “This link is unique to you; we ask that you not forward it.” John Behrens, professor and director of the Technology & Digital Studies Program, explained in a statement to The Observer

that he was not a part of making the survey but “received a request to complete one today.” American Studies professor Katherine Walden wrote, “I was not aware of the survey, nor have I seen it. So I am not able to comment.” The email directed students to reach out to IRIS if they had any questions. Neither IRIS, McGreev y nor Cullinan immediately responded to requests for comment regarding how the data will be used, if it will be made available to the larger Notre Dame community, if this survey has been administered before and if there are

plans for the survey to be administered again. Hannah Heinzekehr copied Blasko and spoke on behalf of Meghan Sullivan, director of the Institute for Ethics and the Common Good, a group that created the DELTA framework for AI. She wrote that Sullivan was unavailable to comment on whether she, ECG or those working on DELTA had been involved in the creation of this survey or if ECG would use the findings of this survey. The survey will close Wednesday, Dec. 2.

Contact Isabelle Baier at ibaier@nd.edu

Contact Jack Beshoar at jbeshoar@hcc-nd.edu

Contact Mara Hall at mhall27@nd.edu

Grant

Continued from page 3 important safety and service improvement. The project would eliminate numerous grade crossings and provide a shorter, more direct route to South Bend International Airport. We will continue working with our local, state, and federal partners to identify other funding opportunities.” The South Shore Line offers a popular way for students to get to Chicago — an option some utilize in order to reach the city’s airports. Jenna Saidman, a junior from Ryan Hall, cited efficiency, affordability and schedule flexibility as factors influencing her choice to take the train. She explained that she took rideshare buses during her freshman year but eventually switched to the South Shore Line because it had more options for times she could arrive at the airport. Coming home from fall break, Saidman said she experienced delays totaling nearly an hour in Chicago due to construction. However, she reported that the train operators were clear and efficient in communication throughout the process. Dech acknowledged that throughout the fall, “service has not been as reliable as it should be,” attributing the issue to residue from falling leaves and environmental moisture. “Improving reliability remains one of my highest priorities. In January, we will introduce a revised train schedule designed to improve on-time performance and provide more dependable service. Our team has been reviewing train performance, identifying recurring delays, and working to make adjustments that will help us operate more consistently. The new schedule is an important step, but our work will not stop there,” he stated in the email. Impacts related to the possible Airport Realignment Project are yet to be determined. Barker noted that the operational plans for construction would come after a contractor evaluated the site. Contact Gracie Shea at gshea@nd.edu

Grammy

Continued from page 3 Throughout the track, Chávez plays two Mexican folk instruments. He also contributes vocals to the final stanza. Chávez released his debut solo album, titled “Sonorous Present,” in 2024, which includes themes of race, migration and mourning, according to his personal website. The Grammy Awards will take place on Feb. 7, 2027, live on ABC from Crypto. com Arena in Los Angeles.


OPINION

8 | THE OBSERVER

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

In defense of student government By Michael Doyle Columnist, “Our Thread”

Around campus, there is a list of well-known crowd pleasers you can toss into any conversation for a guaranteed laugh. Such topics include South Bend’s dreadful weather, the treacherous pathway of the engineering degree and, of course, the exceedingly useless branches of student government. While many continue to decry the perceived egregious inefficiencies and bureaucratic meanderings found within all manner of executive offices and student bodies here at Notre Dame, there’s often more to these proceedings than meets the eye. Take, for example, the Campus Life Council. Composed of rectors, on and off-campus undergraduate students, graduate students, administrators and somehow, yours truly as a hall senator, this legislative body aims to address all the laments and woes of students’ life on campus. In many ways, it functions similarly to the Student Senate and other student-influenced “governing” bodies, wherein through debate and research, members formulate resolutions — which are for all intents and purposes, just letters

to various divisions of the university — to effect change, ideally for the better, in students’ life on campus. Ultimately, however, the CLC is unique in that, in comparison to the black hole that is Senate resolutions, where an inquisitive letter sent to Campus Dining or Residential Life garners hardly more than a “sorry not our problem,” CLC resolutions are sent directly to the desk of Fr. Gerry Olinger, the vice president for Student Affairs, where he has an obligation to respond in good faith. While it’s easy to bemoan the dour offerings at North Dining Hall (when are we getting our quesadillas back?), grovel about the lack of snow clearing in certain areas of campus or express outrage at how three of your professors managed to perfectly schedule all of their most important midterms in a 24hour period, there is in fact something you can do about it, via the CLC. Yet despite the apparent ease of access to the administration and valuable feedback, the CLC has often been relegated to the depths of the student executive. For a span of three years, until under the past administration of Jerry Vielhauer, the council didn’t pass a single

resolution. Think about that. The average student is merely two degrees of separation from the main man in charge of their daily lived experience on campus, and yet we can’t seem to make the most of it. Certainly much of the blame is structural: With fewer than 10 undergraduates on the CLC, you’re left with just about two individuals to represent the 2000-odd students per class year. Couple that with the aforementioned disinterest and forgettability of this council, and it’s hardly surprising it’s as ineffective as it is. As it stands, the best channel any student has to examine and impact their own and others lives runs through a handful of already busy full-time students. Truth be told, it’s not always easy as an individual student representative to recognize the myriad problems on campus. That’s why it’s valuable to mention as much to your hall senator. While they may not be affiliated with the CLC, it’s a straightforward enough process to raise it within the senate, and from there, work to pass something along to the council via the two elected senators. Do you wonder why medical excuse policies are so exceedingly vague and vary wildly from PAID ADVERTISEMENT

professor to professor? Are you also confused by why professors can get away with assigning both a final exam and a final project, with no scheduling constraints placed on the latter? These, among others, are questions for which the CLC is actively pursuing an answer from the Office of Student Affairs. And so, the next time you catch yourself or your friends complaining about the lack of lakeside seating or the exorbitant prices of textbooks, make the effort to tell your senator as well. While the dense bureaucracies of student government will certainly remain a

MARIA GORECKI | The Observer

point of contention for most of the student body, I believe that those who feel more strongly about campus issues will be emboldened to realize the change that they want to see. In truth, there’s something real underneath all of the meanderings of the executive, but the burden of using it effectively falls on us. The views expressed in this column are those of the author and not necessarily those of The Observer. Write to Michael Doyle at mdoyle25@nd.edu


OPINION

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

THE OBSERVER | 9

LETTER TO THE EDITOR

Notre Dame can be a model for disagreeing better We disagree. And we have done so publicly. As many on the Notre Dame campus will be aware, one of the authors of this op-ed believes, consistent with the teachings of the Catholic Church, that life begins at conception and that abortion is morally wrong and should be prohibited. The other is not sure when life begins and would like to minimize abortion rates, but also believes that abortion is sometimes necessary and that banning it is not the most effective way to reduce the practice. End of story, right? It would have been easy to let that be the case, to do nothing, to sit behind our computers on different floors of the building where both of us have our offices, convinced that such a fundamental disagreement was unbridgeable. Instead, we had lunch at Legends. We spent time getting to know each other, talking about our families and lives, discovering that we live in the same neighborhood, enjoy the same neighborhood bars and have quite a few common interests, not least in India and the subcontinent. We talked about our experiences in the field studying and being involved in places that have seen deep conflict, one in Kashmir, the other in Nepal. These are places where fundamental disagreements spiraled into society-wide violence, with everyday life becoming a series of complex strategic calculations. These are places where friendship across divisions can become dangerous. Knowing

LIAM FLYNN | The Observer

this, we could have done what so many do in current or former conflict zones: limit our conversation to safe topics. “Talk about the weather.” That’s not what we did. While sharing lunch at Legends and in subsequent conversations at our favorite neighborhood bars, we did not avoid the issue we disagreed about and discovered that we have some common ground. For instance, we both agree that sex-selective abortion is wrong on many levels, as is any type of government program coercing people to use contraception or undergo abortion or sterilization. Perhaps most importantly of all, we agree that we both value friendship in disagreement

and believe that disagreement can be good, especially when it pushes us to refine our own arguments and to be better, more empathetic humans. With humility, we propose some insights about good disagreement to the Notre Dame community and beyond. First, we did not sing kumbaya together, nor do we suggest that others do. We both reject approaches to disagreement that spuriously submerge or paper over deep differences, or, perhaps worse, proclaim resolution, reconciliation or agreement in a way that masks the dominance of one side. This kicks the can down the road and can produce deep misunderstandings. A better

approach to disagreement, we argue, is one that involves a true exchange of views in all of their depth and honesty, yet does so in friendship and trust and with a desire to understand, not to undermine. This is not easy, and it takes practice, as both of us have learned in tough settings of conflict overseas. It involves active listening, sometimes to ideas that one doesn’t want to hear (and even wants to reject). It involves an effort to understand the perspective of the other in its full depth, putting the best interpretation on meaning and motives, finding genuine common ground and agreeing to be friends and colleagues despite the differences.

In our view, this effort is worthwhile. Actively engaging across differences and sitting peacefully with them are, at worst, good mental and emotional exercise. At best, they offers possible paths forward that were previously unimaginable, like these two authors writing this very op-ed. In Fr. Bob Dowd’s address to Notre Dame’s faculty earlier this month, he talked about continuity and change. He acknowledged the polarization and turbulence that the country is experiencing and that sometimes erupts at Notre Dame. To be sure, we live in challenging times, but challenge is another word for possibility. In authoring this op-ed, we are not just telling you that; we are showing you. Notre Dame is not the only university that reports problems with disagreement. With people afraid to express their views, they are unwilling to engage in discussion with the so-called other side. If our friendship is any guide, we think that Notre Dame could be a model for “good disagreement” and that our Catholic mission offers clues as to what that looks like. Susan Ostermann Associate Professor of Global Affairs Daniel Philpott Professor of Political Science Nov. 17 The views expressed in this column are those of the author and not necessarily those of The Observer.

Notre Dame’s Republican rage bait epidemic By Grayson Beckham Columnist, “Citizen Gray”

In 2025, Oxford named “rage bait” its word of the year, defining it as “online content deliberately designed to elicit anger or outrage by being frustrating, provocative or offensive” with the goal of increasing internet engagement. It’s an apt choice for the English language’s most influential word. Though rage bait has existed since Homo sapiens gained the ability to interpersonally communicate, its prevalence has reached epidemic status. Patient zero? The University of Notre Dame. Last week, College Republicans Vice President Sam Marchand wrote a postmortem of his party’s resounding defeat in the 2026 midterms. His analysis is partially correct, as he acknowledges that the primary cause of the blue tsunami was the Iran War and its effects on the cost of living. He voraciously denied the premise that Trump’s insistence on mass deportations, tariffs and the culture war turned off voters. I have no problem with Mr.

Marchand having those beliefs. He’s within his rights to endorse the America First agenda, as are all Republicans. I just want to ask: Do you really believe what you’re saying? Do we really believe in imminent “drag shows in Congress” or that Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed is associated with the Muslim Brotherhood — a Sunni Islamist organization based in Egypt? No serious person holds these beliefs, and I don’t think he does either. A clear attempt at rage baiting an “abortionist, multigender, ‘God is nonbinary,’ alhamdulillah Democrat” like myself has succeeded. As ridiculous as letters like these may seem, they belong to a broader pattern of behavior from our campus’s College Republicans chapter. In a since-deleted tweet, the group criticized former Assistant Attorney General (and Trump appointee) Harmeet Dhillon’s “demon worship,” citing her invocation at the 2024 Republican National Convention. Dhillon, a Sikh, responded to the racist post, saying to “stay classy, kids.” To the Notre Dame College Republican

who anonymously posted on that account — are you happy? Did you get what you wanted? Jake Tapper, a leading CNN anchor, shared the exchange with his 3.2 million followers, saying that “it is alarming how much bigotry is brazenly shared on campuses these days.” When one of the country’s most famous journalists calls out your campus for bigotry, it shocks the conscience. We all learned in grade school how social media posts live on forever. You can’t take back what’s put online, which is why it should continue to concern Notre Dame students that such behavior continues. At 2026’s BridgeND debate, our Republican colleagues claimed that they use their Twitter accounts in provocative manners to “start conversations.” Are these the kinds of conversations that are worth having? Fundamentally, the question comes down to how serious a group wants to be. I’ll give our friends at the College Republicans the benefit of the doubt and say that I don’t really think that they believe that Sikh Americans are

demon worshippers. If they do, they should answer to the members of the Notre Dame community who belong to that faith tradition. I don’t think they do. What’s really going on here is an account hungry for clicks. So they turn to rage bait. On the other hand, I was delighted earlier this week to see two professors — both having taken diametrically opposed positions on abortion — co-write a letter to the editor regarding their newly found constructive friendship. This paper’s editorial board also published an editorial, exhorting the campus community to have more dialogue. Both articles are worth your time because they shed light on a recurring issue at this campus — we’re too afraid to exercise free speech. However, endorsing free speech should not encourage rage bait. Perhaps free speech is chilled on our campus because of the recurring rage bait posted by particular groups. A freshman coming to this campus might be unwilling to share their opinion on a controversial matter because they don’t want the stink of unseriousness to follow

them. That’s a valid concern! And to return to my earlier point — the rage bait is working. Not only have I been rage baited, but in writing this article I am driving more engagement and attention to ridiculous, bigoted behavior. Maybe I’m part of the problem. Here’s an invitation from me: disagree! Write a column! Send me an email if you feel differently! America became a great country not only because of our political institutions but also because of our democratic culture. Notre Dame is healthier when we encourage, rather than shy away from, such traditions. At the same time, we must prudently exercise our free expression. While elections, congresses and administrations come and go, ink is indelible — and history is always watching. The views expressed in this column are those of the author and not necessarily those of The Observer. Write to Grayson Beckham at gbeckham@nd.edu


PAID ADVERTISEMENT


FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

PHOTO

THE OBSERVER | 11

Hockey vs. Michigan State Notre Dame hockey swept Michigan State in a pair of games inside Compton Ice Arena on November 11-12, 2026. Photography by Patrick McDonald and Abby Hernan


SCENE

12 | THE OBSERVER

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

Time flies in unforgettable ‘These Shining Lives’ By Matias Aguilar Scene Writer

This week, the Notre Dame Film, Television, and Theatre department is putting on Melanie Marnich’s “These Shining Lives,” directed by senior FTT and psychology major Logan Schlitt. I had the pleasure of sitting in on a final dress rehearsal the evening before opening night. It was marvelous. “These Shining Lives” is a twohour historical drama that documents the lives of four women who are considered disposable in their work at the Radium Dial Company. The play, similar to and based on the same injustice told in the book “Radium Girls,” centers around the enduring life of Catherine Donohue, played by freshman Clare Younger, as she navigates the joys of newfound independence, motherhood and marriage alongside a devastating, work-induced illness. I have to say, from the moment I walked into the Philbin Studio Theatre, I was in awe of the dynamic set that encompasses the 1920s in all its troubling glory. I actually had the unique experience of watching multiple productions of “These Shining Lives” before, as it’s one of the most done shows for the UIL Texas theater competition high school circuit. Still, I was immediately able to tell I was in for something I had never seen before. From the clock towering over the rest of the set to the repeated motifs of time, the show makes the relentless passage of time impossible to

MARIA GORECKI | The Observer

ignore. The light and sound production necessitates a huge shout-out. Throughout the show, and especially in its devastating final moments, subtle shifts in lighting pull the audience deeper into the women’s deteriorating reality. Paired with a haunting soundscape of rhythmic ticking, the technical elements act as a constant, ominous pulse beneath the dialogue. But no matter how fast time goes by, the play moves through it seamlessly. Two hours later, after the production was over and the cast made their final bow, I somehow felt like I had just arrived at the theater two minutes ago while at the same time knowing these

characters for a lifetime. It’s a story about friendship through adversity, arguably, above all else. The ensemble, and specifically the female core quartet, has such dynamic rapport with one another that by the end of the production, I felt like I was their friend. The ensemble throughout the entire production truly works magic. And each actress in the ensemble takes their silhouette and not only embodies but transforms their character. There are so many standout performances throughout the play, and while this ensemble really is shining when they are together, they shine just as well individually. Actresses like sophomore Caroline

Morrissey as Pearl and freshman Flannery Hipp as Frances create such a positive dynamic that captures the unbeatable charm of friendship, girlhood and, above all, love. Right off the bat, senior Maia Tolud as Charlotte Purcell has such a breathtaking gravitas. Her essence as Charlotte from the minute she walked on stage was nothing short of a breathtaking performance. There was one given moment of the play when, for just a beat, Tolud was able to let a single tear slip down her cheek. It was the kind of gut-wrenching moment of vulnerability that you could feel through the entire studio. Tolud was a true, honest, captivating

performer. Younger, as Catherine Donohue, also delivers an impressive performance as a freshman. Her grounded portrayal of a woman fighting an impossible legal and physical battle forces the audience to confront the grim human cost behind industrial progress. Strikingly, her performance in traversing motherhood is jarring yet incredible. I would also venture to guess that the Notre Dame theater community is just seeing the beginning of a decorated career for Younger. I also could not speak positively about the play’s performances without mentioning Nicholas Anderson, in the roles of Mr. Reed and Leonard Grossman (among others). Anderson brings a chilling detachment to his roles. His understated menace creates a key juxtaposition to the warmth of the four women and ultimately makes their corporate exploitation feel all the more devastating. If stories on the power of women or stories of history’s tragedies interest you, “These Shining Lives” is a must-watch. If neither interests you, go watch it anyway. The performances, design and ultimate production Schlitt cultivated are remarkable and unforgettable. Schlitt’s “These Shining Lives” is a play about time that makes you lose track of it. The play, as simplistic as it is empowering, has an attention-grabbing production that is nothing short of shining. Contact Matias Aguilar at jaguila7@nd.edu

‘VisionQuest’ is the end of an era for Marvel By Harry Penne Scene Copy Editor

Editor’s note: There are spoilers ahead for the entire “WandaVision” trilogy. And so, an era ends. After five years, the story initiated by “WandaVision” concludes in “VisionQuest.” This latest chapter in the Marvel Cinematic Universe was a strong entry to the canon. Nevertheless, I have thoughts. Even though Paul Bettany’s Vision is the show’s focus, James Spader steals “VisionQuest.” Yes, Ultron is a villain, but it’s hard to hate him. He’s a narcissistic monster … yet it works. He is hysterical and brings so much dark humor to the show with his sarcastic commentary and witty remarks. He’s also surprisingly philosophical, making classical references. The AIs added so much life to the show, and I enjoyed getting to know them. EDITH and her bubbly personality were definitely my favorite; she was pure fun. A nice nod was the Spider-Man callback when Tom Holland’s Spidey musical motif scored EDITH reminiscing about her previous teenage boss. Iconic British comedian and

actor Diane Morgan (Handler) was underutilized. I was thrilled to see her in the show, but she got limited screen time and left before the finale. I predicted the twist of her being an artificial intelligence fairly early and wasn’t surprised by the reveal. She could’ve been such a wonderful addition to the main cast, and it was sad to see her go. Nevertheless, Handler had one of the best jokes in the show: She dreams of writing term papers for university students. “VisionQuest” has too many competing villains. We begin the show thinking that Paladin is the villain. Then, we meet the AI Jocasta, an interesting and morally gray character painted to be the season’s antagonist. Ultron inserts himself as another villain eventually, and, if this isn’t complicated enough, in the finale we’re introduced to the mysterious “Client” teased throughout the show, Virgil Horton, also played by Spader. It was hard to keep focus on who the proper threat was, especially as they kept changing their motivations. I was disappointed that Kathryn Hahn didn’t return as Agatha Harkness, although her presence was implied. However, I was thrilled when Joe Locke

appeared as Billy Maximoff in the finale, reuniting with Tommy. Before the show, I suspected Locke’s return, and I’m glad he came back. I’m curious to see how the twins’ story will manifest in the future. The most shocking return was Wanda Maximoff in a very brief postcredit sequence that insinuates she might team up with Doctor Doom in “Avengers: Doomsday.” “VisionQuest” is strangely paced. It begins high-energy, hits a midseason lull and returns to proper action at the end. “VisionQuest” is not your typical Marvel action series. Yes, it has its epic CGI battle moments, but it’s far more introspective and, dare I say it, philosophical. Episode five felt especially talky; it’s a show where you need to listen and pay attention. It’s not a victim of the double-screen rule that plagues so many contemporary shows (“Stranger Things 5” comes to mind). The finale felt rushed; there wasn’t enough buildup. Jocasta’s redemption arc was particularly expedited and not fully earned, happening so she could be removed from the villains list. Also, Horton had so little screen time he didn’t feel like a proper threat. He entered, info-dumped

his scheme, busted a few dance moves, then died. Suddenly, the finale has a new threat initiated by Ultron that doesn’t feel continuous with the episode’s first half. Aesthetically, this was one of the MCU’s strongest shows. The design of Vision’s Mindspace — which was made to look AIgenerated — was particularly noteworthy, having a retro-future 1960s design in both its wardrobe and architecture. This is contrasted by a gritty and dark reality. This separation of the Mindspace and Earth was striking and well executed. Typically, Marvel productions take an “allude, don’t show” approach toward graphic violence. “VisionQuest” didn’t; it’s not afraid to show blood and guts. The most shocking and disturbing death was Horton’s in the finale. Ultron squeezes him so hard that his eyes burst from his skull with copious blood. Episode two was also particularly gruesome, with bloody wounds galore. I’m glad this WandaVision installment escaped Westview, which, while now an iconic MCU location, has little to add to this story; “Agatha” tied up its final threads. The United Kingdom, especially London, was a perfect backdrop for “VisionQuest.” It

physically separated Vision from his previous life yet still allowed his story to unfold. Kristen Anderson-Lopez and Robert Lopez, the songwriting duo behind the “WandaVision” themes and “The Ballad of the Witches’ Road,” bring “Don’t Kill the World,” a new sitcom theme. In a last ditch effort to convince Ultron to spare humanity, EDITH and Vision force him into a ‘90s sitcom called “UltraVision.” Unfortunately, it backfires. While fun in “VisionQuest,” had the new theme been in “WandaVision,” I don’t think it would’ve ranked as highly against the other Lopez songs. It isn’t as memorable as the earworms “A Newlywed Couple” or “Agatha All Along”; it’s more like “Let’s Keep It Going” and “Making It Up As We Go Along” — it gets the job done, is memorable, but probably won’t be stuck in your head. Overall, “VisionQuest” is a strong MCU program but still has flaws. I highly recommend watching it if you enjoyed the other installments in the WandaVision franchise, as it appears important for “Doomsday” next month. Contact Harry Penne at hpenne@nd.edu


HUMOR

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

THE OBSERVER | 13

What to do if dorm maintenance ignores you By Danica Szabo Scene Writer

It’s that time of year again: The holidays are quickly approaching, classes are wrapping up and everything in your stupid, old dorm keeps breaking. We all have experienced at least one of these things: You go to turn off your heat, nothing happens; you press start on the microwave, nothing happens or you ask your roommate for $23, and they report you to the RA. The one-percenters on campus — i.e., Coyle and Grojean residents — don’t have to worry about such issues, but those of us who live in the slums don’t get that luxury. We have to suffer greatly in our massively endowed buildings, which is arguably against Catholic Social Teaching. I have sent in 109 different complaints to dorm maintenance, my rector and my little, yet to no avail. Like always, since everyone else is incompetent, I have decided to take matters into my own hands. Dorm maintenance has been a core value of mine since four days ago when my heater stopped working. 1. Learn a trade A lot of dorm issues are related

DIONE QUIAMBAO PAHILAN | The Observer

to HVAC, plumbing and electricity. And what do all of these have in common, besides being something I am really scared of? Exactly, they’re all trades! We all know that people who do trades are not smart at all, especially with all their practical skills and years of training, so how hard could it be? I have recently picked up learning electrical skills because Pikachu is an electric-type Pokemon, and I don’t know what HVAC and plumbing mean. I found the best way to practice is to go into any of my hallmates’ rooms when they are not there

and start taking apart the lights above their sinks. It’s really a winwin for everyone: I get to play with their light, and they don’t have to worry about it breaking because I already broke it. 2. Start breaking everything Speaking of breaking things, if dorm maintenance is ignoring you about your heating issue, you shouldn’t take the injustice lying down. As Karl Marx once said, “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs.” That means in a situation like this, the only thing to do is to break all PAID ADVERTISEMENT

of your hallmates’ heaters. It’s the right thing to do — nobody should be getting preferential treatment. I hear you whining, “Wait, how is that the right thing to do?” To that I say, have Karl Marx’s ideas ever been applied incorrectly and misinterpreted? Exactly, checkmate. 3. Kindly suggest to a friend they should let you move in with them After you broke everything in the dorm, you’re going to want to get out of there ASAP. But where is there to go? That’s where your friend comes in. Now, I am only

friends with people that serve a purpose, so I have over seven people in my contacts who are viable roommate candidates. Dorm maintenance may ignore me, but my friends never will. Workshop a friendly message to suggest the idea of cohabitation, such as: “are you still fat? just kidding, i know you are.” A little playful banter goes a long way. Then, pop the question, “anyways, can i sleep in your bed for an indefinite amount of time? i just figured since you have a couch, you can sleep there. thanks xoxo.” They’ll be sure to say yes! Okay, so as of now, it looks like I have been kicked out of my dorm, and they somehow cut off my phone’s service because none of my friends are responding to me — which means, problem solved! I don’t have to worry about the quality of the dorm anymore, so now I am giving those evil dorm people a taste of their own medicine: I am ignoring them. As Karl Marx once said, “I am moving back in with my parents,” and therefore, I am moving back in with my parents. Thanks, dorm maintenance! Contact Danica Szabo at dszabo2@nd.edu


SCENE

14 | THE OBSERVER

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

A look at Oscars category fraud in 2026 By Jack Schreiber Scene Writer

Editor’s note: This article contains spoilers for “You Can See Everything.” Sunday was the 2026 Governors Awards. This event typically marks the commencement of the awards season for movies. Directors, producers, actors and distributors are getting ready to hit the campaign trail to lobby for their 2026 films. Awards seasons are often rife with controversy. Last year, Timothée Chalamet’s comments on ballet and opera as dying art forms were suspected to have hurt his chances of winning the Academy Award for best actor. A year prior, the resurfacing of Karla Sofía Gascón’s old tweets, which were racist and Islamophobic in nature, strongly derailed both her and “Emilia Pérez’s” chances at the Academy Awards. But one controversy that has always surrounded the Oscars has been category fraud, which sees contenders nominated in categories that they don’t necessarily fit into. Typically, when we talk about category fraud, we are discussing the nomination of an actor in a best supporting Oscar category, when in actuality they are a lead performer. There are countless examples of such swaps. Julianne Moore was nominated for a best supporting actress award in “The

Hours,” despite being a lead actress for a majority of the film. The same rings true for Casey Affleck in “The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford,” Ethan Hawke in “Training Day” and William H. Macy in “Fargo.” The 2025 Academy Awards (honoring movies released in 2024) were marked by two separate instances of this, with Kieran Culkin in “A Real Pain” and Zoe Saldaña in the aforementioned “Emilia Pérez.” Many instances of a lead actor being placed in supporting award contention come from child actors. Mary Badham in “To Kill a Mockingbird,” Haley Joel Osment in “The Sixth Sense” and Tatum O’Neal in “Paper Moon” all come to mind as examples of child stars being relegated to supporting categories. However, examples of the opposite can still occur. The most prominent example of a supporting actor being placed into a lead category is Anthony Hopkins in “The Silence of the Lambs,” but Daniel Day-Lewis in “Gangs of New York” and Anne Bancroft in “The Graduate” are also cases of such a category change. Typically, the relegation or promotion of a performer comes as a strategic choice from a film’s distributor or studio based on the landscape of a particular awards season. Most Oscar aspirants will run in a less competitive category, which historically has been in

supporting awards. The composition of the Academy Awards allows for this, as there are no formal restrictions in order to regulate such fluidity in acting consideration. This looseness allows campaigners to push whatever narrative is more likely to lead to success. But this year, we are looking at a different kind of category fraud. This year’s potential category fraud is largely surrounding the landmark documentary “You Can See Everything,” a box office smash that earned around $94 million worldwide despite its $7 million budget. Furthermore, the second weekend saw a 20.1% increase in earnings, a rare feat that typically underscores extremely positive word of mouth. The project, co-directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, is also an incredible success critically. Soon after its release, it had an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars on Letterboxd, making it the highest-rated film of all time on the platform at that point. It also maintains an impressive 97% on Rotten Tomatoes and 96 on Metacritic, making it the secondhighest-rated film of the year on the latter platform. For weeks, the documentary became the center of pop culture and conversation. Such monumental critical and financial success would normally make any narrative film a shoo-in for at least a best picture nod. But “You Can See Everything” complicates the awards climate, given

that it’s a documentary. Should it earn a nomination for best picture, it would be the first documentary in history to do so. However, due to the semantics of the best picture category, many question whether it will even be eligible. The Directors Guild of America Awards has announced that “You Can See Everything” will not be eligible for their best picture equivalent award for outstanding directorial achievement. This is notable because the DGA nominations have always been seen as a major precursor to the Academy Awards. Whether the project joins the race for best documentary feature is also being questioned, given its lengthy recreation sequences. “You Can See Everything” marks a major shift in category fraud at the Oscars because, for the first time, the fraudulence is not being pushed by the film’s constituents. It emerges from the friction between the film’s hybrid form and the Academy’s rigid categories. The Golden Globes and Emmys have been dealing with this issue for years because they categorize their top prizes. At the 2026 Golden Globes, which honored films from 2025, “Sinners,” described as a horror musical, was nominated for best picture in the drama category instead of best picture in the musical or comedy category. Meanwhile, “The Bear” has been ripping the Emmys to shreds since it first hit the air, consistently being

nominated for outstanding comedy series despite often being perceived as a drama. “You Can See Everything” is experiencing a similar level of category misalignment. Could it be eligible for below-the-line categories, such as production design, cinematography or even costume design? If you view “You Can See Everything” as purely a documentary, then you might be inclined to say no, but the film’s recreation sequences incorporate incredibly impressive belowthe-line technique that deserves acclaim. Most notably, could “You Can See Everything’s” Amanda Seyfried earn a nomination for best actress? The surprise reprise of her role as Elizabeth Holmes marks one of the film’s greatest surprises and successes, but an acting nomination for a documentary would be unprecedented and could lead to a major reconsideration of what constitutes a documentary. The Academy has shifted before. From expanding to 10 best picture nominees following the snub of “The Dark Knight” to the overhaul of Academy membership following the #OscarsSoWhite campaign in 2016, the Oscars have seen landmark metamorphoses before. “You Can See Everything,” and other boundary-shifting films like it, underscore that it may be time for the Oscars to change again. Contact Jack Schreiber at jschrei3@nd.edu

Doctor Doom will make or break Marvel’s future By Joseph Schimmoller Scene Writer

Editor’s note: This article contains spoilers for several MCU projects, recent and old. For nearly two decades, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has expanded into a franchise so monumental its bounds are past the borders of our universe and into other parallel universes. Starting with the first Iron Man film in 2008, the franchise saw a significant upward trajectory for several years, at least until 2019. “Avengers: Endgame” seemed, to many, to be a high point in the franchise, one that may never be reached again, but that perspective is being challenged with the impending release of “Avengers: Doomsday” as excitement is reemerging among Marvel fans. With that hype, why is the state of the MCU even being questioned in the first place? First, it lost a lot of footing by placing its faith in television series during the pandemic. After the great success of shows like “WandaVision” and “Loki,” the MCU seemed to subtly replace quality with quantity. Take the release of shows like “She-Hulk: Attorney at Law,” “Echo”

and “Secret Invasion” as examples. This, compounded with subpar reception of films like “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness,” “Thor: Love and Thunder” and “Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania” immediately following the pandemic, conveyed to audiences that Marvel was lost. It was confused with its overarching narrative and did not have an effective plan for a grand team-up movie. This rejection was so harmful that it hindered the success of future projects, which were without these shortcomings: “Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3,” “Deadpool & Wolverine” and “Fantastic Four: First Steps.” It must not be forgotten that Marvel was forced to pivot from their original development of Kang the Conqueror. Jonathan Majors, who played Kang, was fired following a domestic assault conviction. The main multiversal villain needed to have a quick and immediate transition out, one that would make sense too. It is the position of this article, with less than one month before his arrival, that Marvel has succeeded in creating a fulcrum between

Kang the Conqueror and Victor von Doom, and all fans of superhero movies ought to f lood the theater for the next Avengers movie. As displayed with the incredible success of “SpiderMan: Brand New Day,” Marvel fans are still quite willing to watch good, quality works with coherent and intentional narratives. In other words, good storytelling makes money. Using Kang the Conqueror’s variant, Victor Timely’s death in “Loki” season two, as well as the multiversal destruction that appears to be going on in “Avengers: Doomsday,” it is not unreasonable to develop a new villain to take advantage of the chaos. Timely’s death, and the restructuring of the Time Variance Authority, means Kang is safely out of the picture, and a household name, Doctor Doom, can easily step in to make his debut in the MCU. Within this multiversal catastrophe, a seemingly endless number of cameos of characters from previous superhero movies, such as Tobey Maguire’s “SpiderMan” as well as nearly the entire Fox X-men franchise, are set to make an appearance in an epic showcase of

films dating all the way back to 2002. At minimum, the cameos should engage the curiosity of the slightest superhero fans and fill them with excitement. With the recent release of “VisionQuest,” an excellent show by the way, Doctor Doom has had the same number of appearances prior to his debut that Thanos had at the release of “Avengers: Infinity War.” Thanos, as far as villains go, did not require any help establishing himself as the main threat as he was eagerly awaited by countless audiences globally. I pray you, the

reader, count yourself among them. Doctor Doom’s casting, motivation and actions are uncertain and will be uncovered upon release of the film. For now, however, based on the collection of characters including Bruce Banner, Scarlet Witch and, potentially, Doctor Strange, this showdown will be brutal and one worth watching. But, who knows? Dec. 18 could very well be doomsday for the MCU if the project fails to succeed. Contact Joseph Schimmoller at jschimmo@nd.edu

PAID ADVERTISEMENT


SPORTS

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

THE OBSERVER | 15

FOOTBALL

Keys

Continued from page 2 especially important if sophomore offensive lineman Will Black is out after sustaining an injury against Boston College. The Irish will likely either move junior Anthonie Knapp back to left tackle and put junior Styles Prescod at guard, or put Prescod at tackle and keep Knapp at guard. Either way, it will be a different-looking offensive line if Black is out as the Irish face a very experienced SMU defensive line. Mustangs edge Marques White leads the team with 8.5 sacks, while Aakil Washington has 3. The Irish line has only allowed 3 sacks through 10 regular-season games, but it will have an uphill battle against this defensive line that has put up good numbers throughout the regular season. Eliminate key penalties Notre Dame played a pretty much flawless game against Boston College, but if there was one flaw, it was its nine penalties. The Irish had three false starts called against them in the first half and, in the second, committed four penalties of 10 yards or more. Against Miami, Notre Dame committed five holding penalties and had a defensive pass interference in the fourth quarter. These selfinflicted wounds will certainly prove fatal for the Irish if they want to make a deep postseason run, and a clean game against SMU would go a long way to help the Irish secure a win on their senior night. Notre Dame takes on SMU on Saturday at 7:30 p.m. The game will be played at Notre Dame Stadium and will be broadcast live on NBC and Peacock. Contact Jack Muething at jmuethin@nd.edu

Hicks: Conferences have ruined sports By Ben Hicks Sports Editor

The commodification of college athletics is attributable to a combination of complex causes. If you want to blame the student-athletes, fine. You’d also be right to blame the universities, the television companies, the courts or the system as a whole. Regardless, the proverbial genie is out of the bottle, and you’d be naive to assess our current landscape as anything other than professional sports. With that said, a handful of events from the past week have made me realize that much of the responsibility rests with a few powerful actors in Chicago, Dallas, Charlotte and Birmingham, Alabama. Those four cities house the headquarters of the “Autonomous Four” conferences — the Big Ten, Big 12, ACC and SEC. The fact of the matter is that the unbridled greed and crony capitalism that currently define college sports began long before NIL. The chaos we experience began not with player compensation but with the geopolitical expansionism and TV arms race harnessed by these conferences. Conferences weren’t intended to operate like this. In fact, the Big Ten was founded in 1896 with the original objectives of limiting athletics participation to students in good standing and regulating and aligning athletics at universities with like-minded institutional values. Now, conferences are the most egregious offenders of attempted regulation, and it’s hard to imagine how aligned Rutgers University and the University of Oregon truly are. Also, the suggestion that college athletes remain fulltime students in good standing is

PAID ADVERTISEMENT

MARIELLA TADDONIO | The Observer

BYU students hold a sign to express their displeasure with the expanded field of the College Football Playoff. The 24-team format, which will debut in 2027, was supported by the commissioners of the Big Ten and SEC.

just comical. They hardly even attend class. But if we’re being honest, college athletics as a whole wasn’t designed to function like this. The United States, the bastion of free-market capitalism, is the only country in the world where institutions of higher education simultaneously operate billiondollar sports teams. In reality, colleges support athletics to serve their financial needs, and conference affiliation is the avenue to the lucrative payday. The traditional logic in building a conference is that big brands in big media markets are attractive. Hence, Oregon State and Washington State were abandoned during the last round of realignment. You have to wonder, though, how Corvallis, Oregon, or Pullman, Washington, is any different from, say, Starkville, Mississippi. Starkville sits in the 134th-largest media market nationwide, reaching just 190,000 television households, far fewer than Corvallis and Pullman. Mississippi State has also accounted for only one team national championship in school history, not exactly an SEC “brand.” This disparity highlights a broader issue in college athletics, in which the A4 sets rules for thee, but not for me. They decide who gets to play, under what circumstances the games are played and how the game is scored. It’s a fixed game. It has become impossible for mid-majors to succeed. In 2004, 12 teams from outside the power conferences earned at-large bids to March Madness. This past year, that number dwindled to four, and Miami (OH) had to go a perfect 31-0 in the regular season just to earn the final spot. Early projections for next year’s tournament forecast only one at-large bid for the non-power leagues, despite there being 10

more at-large spots than existed in 2004. This is because the criterion for being selected for the big dance has changed. Winning no longer matters. Instead, you have to rank high in predictive metrics, which are quite literally programmed from the start of each season to favor teams from the power leagues. Quality wins have also increased in importance, but midmajors can’t collect quality wins if quality wins only come from beating power conference teams. It’s this same logic that props up an overrated Alabama football team due to its collection of ranked wins, even though 6-4 No. 21 South Carolina (who just lost to six-loss Arkansas by 28 points) is not a better football team than unranked 8-2 New Mexico. If you thought this was an issue just limited to football or men’s basketball, think again. There has been plenty said about the partiality of the College Football Playoff committee, but the prejudice toward the power leagues was arguably more present in the college soccer postseason brackets unveiled Monday. Starting on the women’s side, SEC members Tennessee and Arkansas earned the right to host first-round tilts despite RPIs in the 40s and single-digit win totals. In fact, Tennessee won just two games after Sept. 6, failed to qualify for its conference tournament and fired its coach two weeks ago. This favoritism for the Hogs and Vols is despite the fact that the SEC last won a national championship in soccer 28 years ago. It also unjustly conscripts both Villanova and UNC Wilmington, two teams that combined to lose one game all season, to openinground road games. On the men’s side, 10-win Xavier and Utah Valley met similar fates, this time

to the benefit of the ACC. Men’s college soccer is notorious for handing out bids straight down the RPI rankings. With two spots left in the field, the committee conveniently skipped over No. 32 Xavier to select both 6-55 California and 8-8-3 Syracuse, joining 7-6-6 NC State in the field from the almighty ACC. It’s not like Xavier plays in an uncompetitive conference; the Big East ranked third nationally and boasted two No. 1 seeds in Georgetown and Akron. Both the Musketeers and the Wolverines of Utah Valley also equaled Cal and ‘Cuse in top-50 wins, despite having far fewer opportunities. And then we get to Tuesday’s CFP rankings, which can only be characterized as an infuriating embarrassment. The affection for the SEC is to be expected, but that doesn’t make it any less unserious. I can’t describe it better than Joel Klatt, lead college football analyst for FOX, when he compared the committee’s stubborn incompetence to an inescapable feedback loop. “Why is Alabama No. 3? Well, because the SEC is really difficult this year and very strong. Okay, well, why is the SEC really strong? Well, because Alabama is No. 3. Okay, got it. I heard that, but why is Alabama No. 3? Well, because the SEC is so difficult and very strong,” Klatt joked on his podcast. Ultimately, we’ve reached a point where a team’s logo patch on its jersey signaling conference affiliation means more than the actual product put forth on the field of play. I guess the SEC’s braggadocious shibboleth, “It just means more,” is true — being in the SEC, or any of the A4 conferences, does mean more than actually being good. Contact Ben Hicks at bhicks2@nd.edu


SPORTS

16 | THE OBSERVER

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

ND WOMEN’S SOCCER

Irish to host Milwaukee in NCAA tournament By Emma Colitz Sports Reporter

Notre Dame women’s soccer will begin its campaign for a national championship on Friday night, hosting the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee at Alumni Stadium. The Irish, ranked No. 4 nationally, earned the No. 2 seed in the NCAA tournament after a successful regular season. Friday marks Notre Dame’s 32nd NCAA appearance in the last 34 years and its sixth consecutive tournament as a seeded team. The Irish are looking to rebound from Thursday’s 1-0 loss to Virginia in the ACC Tournament semifinals. Before that loss, the team was riding a six-game winning streak, highlighted by road wins over Cal and Stanford and a 1-0 shutout of Miami to earn the ACC regularseason title. Head coach Nate Norman, who was named the 2026 ACC Coach of the Year, stated that the team’s ability to respond to adversity will come in handy as it prepares for another postseason run. “Every time we do run into some adversity, or we lose, or we don’t play that well, we’ve

been able to really grow and improve,” Norman said. “Sometimes it’s hard to kind of grow in postseason play, but teams that can do that … have a lot of success.” Leading the Irish on offense this season have been junior forwards Izzy Engle and Lily Joseph, who have combined to score 16 of Notre Dame’s 37 goals this season with 9 and 7 goals, respectively. Both earned first-team All-ACC honors, with Joseph also being recognized as ACC Midfielder of the Year. Milwaukee enters Friday’s contest on a 13-game winning streak, having secured its ninth consecutive Horizon League conference championship with a 5-2 victory over IU Indianapolis on Saturday. Senior forward Emily Petring recorded a hat trick and an assist in the title game, earning tournament MVP honors. Ashlyn SkinnerBarrett and Natalie Zodrow were also impact players for the Panthers, contributing 2 goals and 2 assists apiece in Milwaukee’s two tourney games. The Irish defense will be tested Friday as Milwaukee enters the matchup coming off a 5-goal performance in its conference

championship game. The Panthers recorded 28 shots against the Jaguars; however, the Irish have recorded seven shutouts this season and have been undefeated at Alumni Stadium. A strong defensive performance will be key to limiting the Panthers’ scoring opportunities and disrupting their offensive momentum. Friday’s contest will mark the fourth meeting in the NCAA tournament between Notre Dame and Milwaukee, with the Irish having won all three previous games. The teams most recently met in the first round of the 2024 tournament, when Notre Dame defeated the Panthers 5-1. Plus, home-field advantage has historically proved significant for the Irish, who hold an impressive 53-5-1 record at home in the NCAA tournament. “Being at home is, I think, such a great advantage,” Norman said. “Our players have a lot of great memories playing on this field.” Under Norman, the Irish have reached the Elite Eight twice — in 2022 and 2024 — but their tournament run was cut short in the second round last year. They are now

seeking their first national championship since 2010. While a national title remains the ultimate goal, Norman stressed the importance of maintaining composure and staying true to the team’s identity throughout the tournament. “Stay calm, have fun, enjoy this process,” Norman said. “Don’t put too much pressure, but … come out and really be yourself.” The Irish will have the

opportunity Friday to put their ACC tournament loss behind them and take a step toward their fourth national championship. The winner of Friday’s game will advance to face either Mississippi State or Samford in the second round. Kickoff is scheduled for 6 p.m. Friday at Alumni Stadium. Contact Emma Colitz at ecolitz@nd.edu

ELLIE COLLINS | The Observer

The Irish huddle prior to a 4-1 defeat at No. 1 North Carolina on Oct. 2. Notre Dame recovered to win its first outright ACC regular-season title.

PAID ADVERTISEMENT

2026 Dean’s Speaker Series:

Patrick Cady

Chief Executive Officer, Global P&G PRO 12:30 – 1:30 p.m. Friday, November 20 Jordan Auditorium Mendoza College of Business Lecture is free and open to the public. The Dean’s Speaker Series is sponsored by the Eugene Clark Distinguished Lecture Series endowment.


SPORTS

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

THE OBSERVER | 17

FOOTBALL

Defense

Continued from page 2

TEAGAN BARRY | The Observer

Junior linebacker Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa celebrates following a defensive stop during Notre Dame’s 41-7 rout of Boston College on Nov. 14. Viliamu-Asa led defensive coordinator Chris Ash’s unit with 7 tackles.

preseason All-American candidate Brauntae Johnson is due back at safety for the first time since hurting his foot in the opener against Wisconsin, and he rejoins a position group that features senior big-play machine Luke Talich, who arguably has been the defense’s most valuable player as Johnson’s replacement. Defensive tackles Francis Brewu and Jason Onye should also be back as soon as Saturday to further fortify the stout front seven. If

the Irish can make a playoff run, the future return of Bowen and senior cornerback DJ McKinney wouldn’t hurt either. After suffering through some turmoil, injuries and angst, the defense, to put it plainly, is finally looking “hangry.” Players are arriving at the ball carrier with bad intentions; they get visibly pumped up following big hits. In order for Notre Dame to go on the run of its dreams, the defense needs to maintain its rekindled dominance. Contact Ellie Collins at ecollin9@nd.edu

ND WOMEN’S BASKETBALL

Hidalgo stands alone in college basketball history By Emma Colitz Sports Reporter

During her four years playing basketball for Notre Dame, senior guard Hannah Hidalgo has made a habit of rewriting the record books. From her 31-point collegiate debut against South Carolina to her NCAA-record 16-steal game against Akron last season, Hidalgo has proved herself as one of the greatest all-around players in NCAA basketball history. On Saturday, she added another accolade to her historic career and accomplished something that no player before her has. During Notre Dame’s 108-84 victory over DePaul in the SoFi Shamrock Classic, Hidalgo became the first men’s or women’s player in Division I basketball history to record 2,500 career points, 500 rebounds, 500 assists and 500 steals. Hidalgo finished Saturday’s game with 31 points, seven rebounds, seven assists, four steals and two blocks, a stat line representative of the resourcefulness that has defined her throughout her career. Her offensive statistics alone warrant national recognition, but it is Hidalgo’s ability to match that production on defense that truly places her in a category of her own. Not many players have

established a defensive presence as early in their collegiate career as Hidalgo did. In just her second collegiate game against NJIT in 2023, the then-freshman recorded 12 steals, offering Irish fans a preview of the defensive tenacity that would define her career. She went on to earn both ACC Rookie of the Year and ACC Defensive Player of the Year honors as a freshman, averaging 22.6 points and 4.6 steals per game in her debut season. By her junior year, Hidalgo had surpassed Irish legend Skylar Diggins as the program’s all-time steals leader, doing so with more than a full season of eligibility remaining. Her 44-point, 16-steal performance against Akron in November 2025 simultaneously set records for the program (points scored in a single game) and NCAA basketball (steals in a single game). Despite the remarkable nature of her accomplishments, Hidalgo attributes much of her success to consistency rather than any fundamental changes to her game. “This is the same defense I’ve been playing for the past four years,” Hidalgo said to NBC Sports following Saturday’s victory. “I just try and be as consistent as possible.” For Hidalgo, however, her defensive presence extends far beyond

what is included in the stat sheet. Her unrelenting full-court pressure disrupts opposing offenses before they can establish a rhythm, lifting some of the defensive burden that is placed on her teammates. “I try and make the game as easy as possible for my teammates, and that’s me picking up full court and trying to turn over the offensive player so they don’t even get into their sets,” Hidalgo said. While Hidalgo’s defensive strategy has remained the same throughout her four seasons, her offensive responsibilities have changed significantly with the roster surrounding her. During her sophomore campaign, Hidalgo shared the backcourt with Olivia Miles and Sonia Citron, two of the most talented guards in the country. After their departures from the roster following the conclusion of that season, the then-junior assumed greater offensive responsibilities as she guided a largely reconstructed Irish team to a third straight appearance in the Sweet 16. Now a senior, Hidalgo is once again the lone returning starter, meaning she is once again tasked with leading and establishing chemistry with a new group of players. This season, however, the offensive abilities of her teammates

have afforded Hidalgo greater flexibility in how she approaches the game. “It’s really helpful being able to be off ball and being able to get my break, especially when I want to pick up full court,” Hidalgo said. “And so now offensively, I’m able to take more rests, and I can rely on my team.” Saturday’s victory over DePaul, although highlighted by Hidalgo’s performance, demonstrated the potential of the team. Sophomore forward Leah Macy contributed 24 points and nine rebounds while freshman forward Jacy Abii added 18 points and nine rebounds. Fifthyear guard Madison St. Rose came in clutch in the final quarter, scoring 13 points to help the Irish close out the win. For the first time in program history Notre Dame has scored 100 points in three straight games. Against DePaul, five players scored in double digits, and the offensive balance this season is particularly encouraging for a team whose success last season often relied on extraordinary individual performances from Hidalgo. As the Irish move into conference play, the ability to distribute offensive responsibilities among several players could be the key to maximizing Hidalgo’s impact on

defense. For a player whose defensive style demands considerable energy, the opportunity to operate off the ball without sacrificing offensive efficiency is invaluable. Perhaps more consistent than Hidalgo’s defensive excellence is the passion with which she approaches each game. Whether forcing turnovers or racing down the court in transition, Hidalgo brings an intensity that sets the tone for the Irish. “I don’t ever take a game for granted,” Hidalgo said. “Me showing my passion is just my way of showing how blessed I am to play the game of basketball.” Now in the beginning of her final season in South Bend, Hidalgo is without a doubt among the greatest to have worn an Irish uniform; the question remains how much greater she can be. For a player who has spent nearly four years making the unprecedented look easy, there is little reason to believe she is finished rewriting history. With the same defensive intensity that has always defined her and a star-studded team around her, Hidalgo has the opportunity to make her final season her best one yet. Contact Emma Colitz at ecolitz@nd.edu

FOOTBALL

Laslo: CFP, you have done it again By Ethan Laslo Sports Reporter

The latest edition of the College Football Playoff rankings has officially been released. These were probably the least anticipated rankings so far in terms of the actual 12-team field, but there was plenty of movement in the bottom half. In fact, these somehow may be the most mind-boggling rankings yet. Before we get into the big stories, however, a couple of quick hitters: 1. No. 5 Texas jumps No. 6 Notre Dame: No surprise here. The Longhorns have what is almost certainly the nation’s best resume, and despite their two losses, the

committee has shown that their priority is how many good wins a team has. 2. No. 11 Wake Forest, last team in: The Demon Deacons have been the definition of eye test and finally find themselves in the 12team field. They haven’t played the strongest competition but have outscored their opponents 145-0 in the first half over their last four games. My goodness. 3. Still one Group of 6 team: Spoilers, I know. Somehow, the committee again left out every non-Power 4 team except the Boise State Broncos. The AP Poll had 9-1 Liberty at No. 22 and 8-2 Memphis at No. 24. Seven other Group of 6

teams received votes. What more must they do to gain respect? Now, the big storylines. 21-25: Seriously? In the AP poll this week, two four-loss SEC teams found their way into the rankings: AP No. 23 Florida and AP No. 25 Ole Miss. The committee had other plans. Of the bottom five teams in the CFP rankings, four of them are four-loss SEC teams: No. 21 South Carolina, No. 22 Oklahoma, No. 24 Florida and No. 25 Ole Miss. What? To start, South Carolina had potentially the worst loss by a ranked team all season: a 34-6

drubbing on the road against a then-3-6 Arkansas team that has looked poor all season, to say the least. Oklahoma at least got a win at home Sunday over Ole Miss, but that should not justify a ranking considering that they were 5-4 just over 48 hours earlier. The same can be said for Florida, although the Gators at least earned a solid road win over then-No. 11 Kentucky. Ole Miss may have been ranked last week, seemingly justifying Oklahoma’s leap, but that doesn’t make things any better. The Rebels’ ranking is identical in both the AP and CFP, though, so I suppose they’re the least susceptible to judgment.

Keep in mind, these rankings would mean that, in next year’s 24-team format, at least three of these four-loss teams would be in. A bit inexplicable on the committee’s part in the bottom five. Quick shout-out to No. 23 Louisville: the Cardinals escaped a literal brawl in Chapel Hill to beat North Carolina and improve to 7-3. Winners of the Week: Boise State and Arizona After a shootout win following College GameDay in Boise, the Broncos shot up from No. 24 in last week’s rankings to No. 17 in see “CFP” on page 18


INSIDER

18| THE OBSERVER

Shuler reflects ahead of finale By Payton Dymek Senior Sports Reporter

The final home game of the regular season is supposed to be a day to celebrate everything the seniors have accomplished. But for senior captain Adon Shuler, this weekend’s matchup with SMU will represent something more. Just one week before Notre Dame’s season opener against Wisconsin at Lambeau Field, Shuler’s father died. Instead of missing the game, Shuler played some of his toughest ball, totaling seven tackles in the Irish’s 41-13 victory. Since the beginning of the season, the Irish have had to focus on the next game in front of them, not the inevitable peak of the season against Miami. Now, the game staring them in the face may be the hardest of all for different reasons. With senior night looming as the final confirmed home game of the season, the emotional weight Saturday’s game carries is hard to ignore. As the fans honor Shuler, four words will be running through the captain’s mind on the field: gratitude, faith, brotherhood and pride. Senior night is about gratitude In Tuesday’s post-practice press conference, Shuler started by answering what’s on everyone’s minds: what will Saturday look like given everything he’s been through this season? Despite wanting to treat it like any other game, he knows “it’s a little different being the last guaranteed home game.” However, he noted that he is focused on “taking it in, having gratitude to do it with the brotherhood and just embracing the journey.” Shuler recognizes the opportunity ahead of him, especially playing for one of the most storied programs in all of college football, and even calls that “the cherry on top” of getting to play. For Shuler, the senior game isn’t just about him but also all the work, experiences and relationships that carried him to this moment. The emotions and appreciation of the night will extend beyond him. For example, sophomore cornerback Jayden Sanders spoke about how the senior class has become his “older brothers,” and said they’ve done a great job of instilling gratitude within each of the younger athletes. Faith is first and foremost From the very beginning, Shuler was instilled with a strong sense of faith, and he pointed to the influence that his grandmother and family had on his beliefs. “Faith is number one,” Shuler

explained, saying, “I feel like God guided me here and my family, and every decision I make is to better myself and to be a light through God.” This answer, although not directly connected to football, offers a glimpse into how he approaches playing football at Notre Dame. In a season that has brought heavy emotions in all aspects, Shuler continually emphasizes the importance of family and the specific values instilled in him. Being “the man” from the start Shuler’s growth at Notre Dame has been remarkable, and after starting with six total tackles in 2023, his tackle total climbed to 59 and 53 in the following years. In 2026, with the season still in progress, he has 42. One of the moments that stand out to him in his career was in 2024 when he learned he would be the starting safety against Texas A&M. “It was just a testament to all the work that I put in, knowing that the coaches and my teammates believed in me to go out there and do my job,” Shuler said. That opportunity showed the staff what Shuler could bring to the team and how he could be a part of something bigger than himself. Since that start, he has established himself as a dependable member of the Irish secondary. Editor’s Note: Read the unabridged version of this story at ndsmcobserver.com. Contact Payton Dymek at pdymek@nd.edu

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

FOOTBALL

CFP

Continued from page 17 this week’s. That’s a massive win for them, as they now essentially control their own destiny as the Group of 6 conference champion in the playoff. As of now, they’d travel to Austin to take on now-No. 5 Texas. It’s great that the Broncos are finally getting their respect: at 9-1, they’ve clearly been the team to beat outside of the Power 4 this year. One team that had many wondering where they would land this week is Arizona. The Wildcats dropped a heartbreaker late Saturday night — or Sunday morning, depending on time zone — to No. 2 Utah at home. Fortunately, the 40-39 loss did them more good than bad. Arizona, which was No. 23 last week, made the largest jump in CFP rankings history for a team coming off a loss, climbing four spots to No. 19. Completely warranted for a team that was two minutes away from upending No. 2. The Big Ten Bubble The Big Ten’s bubble teams are certainly an interesting group. No. 8 Indiana and No. 4 UCLA essentially control their own destinies as of now, with the two likely on a collision course to Indianapolis

for the Big Ten Championship assuming neither is upset in the final few weeks. Beyond the top 10, three more teams are lurking for potential at-large bids: No. 13 Oregon, No. 14 Ohio State and No. 15 Iowa. The Hawkeyes seem to have received the short end of the stick here, although their ranking is somewhat justifiable. They remained stagnant this week, with Ohio State jumping them as a result of their head-tohead matchup. The most intriguing ranking is No. 13 Oregon, which appeared dead in the water after a shocking road loss to Illinois. Since then, though, the Ducks have kept quacking along. Wins over Northwestern and Ohio State have shot the Ducks right back into playoff contention as the committee’s highest-ranked three-loss team. They don’t completely control their own destiny, but if they win out and the right dominoes fall, the Ducks could very well sneak their way into the final at-large bid. Alabama: the committee’s darling The main question entering this week’s rankings was what the committee would do with Alabama. The Crimson Tide escaped Nashville with an ugly 21-6 win over a struggling Vanderbilt team, while the rest of their resume took a significant hit. In fact, every single conference opponent the

Tide has beaten lost last week. A similar situation unfolded last week against Indiana, the only difference being that the Hoosiers were on bye. The committee subsequently dropped them from No. 4 to No. 9. So, naturally, many expected Alabama to experience a similar drop in the rankings this week. They’re a two-loss team in the top three, which is already shocking enough. Now, their best win is No. 16 Kentucky. In fact, many have drawn comparisons between the Tide and last season’s Notre Dame squad that was ultimately left out. So, what did the committee do? Keep them at No. 3, of course! I can’t offer a reasonable explanation as to why. Check out committee chair Hunter Yurachek’s explanation to Rece Davis on the rankings reveal show if you want to hear the committee’s reasoning. Otherwise, I have no words. The Tide were ranked No. 7 in both the AP and USA Today Coaches Polls. These rankings were expected to be the most straightforward of the year outside of the 18-25 range. Somehow, the committee has again outdone itself and made potentially its most controversial edition yet, which is quite impressive after the previous two weeks. Contact Ethan Laslo at elaslo@nd.edu

GRAY NOCJAR | The Observer

Athletic director Pete Bevacqua speaks to the media at the Joyce Center on Dec. 9, 2025, following Notre Dame’s snub from the College Football Playoff. The Irish fell behind Alabama and Miami in the last week.

PAID ADVERTISEMENT


INSIDER

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026

THE OBSERVER | 19

FOOTBALL

Football beat picks: Notre Dame vs. SMU By Observer Sports Staff Football Beat

Noah Cahill Notre Dame is so close, it can taste a College Football Playoff berth. And not that they should need it, but the Irish have some reasons for some extra juice on Saturday — namely a surprising drop to No. 6 in the College Football Playoff rankings, and an aspiration to honor their 23 seniors with a win. In the final home game of the regular season, Notre Dame takes on an SMU team that just had its doors blown off by No. 11 Wake Forest. It’s hard to explain a 49-7 home loss, especially for a team with an experienced quarterback leading a high-powered offense. While I don’t expect SMU to lay down like that again Saturday night, this Notre Dame defense won’t make it easy to bounce back, especially if some of the “questionables” on the depth chart become “actives” (Jason Onye, Francis Brewu and Brauntae Johnson). The bigger issue for SMU is that, even if its offense reaches the high level it has shown capable of reaching, its defense matches up terribly against an Irish rushing attack hitting its stride. Notre Dame takes one step closer to the CFP, and does so in convincing fashion. Prediction: Notre Dame 41, SMU 14 Ellie Collins SMU arrives in South Bend bruised and battered after a 49-7 drubbing by Playoff contender Wake Forest. There is no rest for the weary as it faces another stiff test against a Notre Dame team that seems to be peaking at the right time. The Mustangs’ hope lies in their offense, led by dual-threat quarterback Kevin Jennings. He can be mercurial, but when on his game, he has the ability to give any defense problems, as proven last year in an overtime upset of Miami when he threw for 365 yards. That signature performance, however, was at home, and Jennings and the Mustangs tend to struggle on the road. I suspect that will continue this weekend. Sophomore Nolan James Jr. and freshman Jonaz Walton should find holes aplenty behind a stout offensive line; I see both backs hitting the century mark on the ground. Junior quarterback CJ Carr should also have his way against a suspect pass defense. All said, for SMU to have any sort of chance, it will need to get off to a fast start. I do not see that happening. Prediction: Notre Dame 45, SMU 17 Chris Dailey I have a revelation: Notre Dame is going to win this one. The Irish will then reign victorious over Syracuse a week later and remain the six seed headed into playoffs. Wake Forest will remain the 11 seed, and we will have the Bachelor Bowl on ABC in primetime. Sam Hartman will make an appearance at halftime to promote his new show. He’ll walk on to the field with a Wake Forest jersey,

LINA LIU | The Observer

Freshman running back Jonaz Walton gallops down the sideline in Notre Dame’s 41-7 romp over Boston College on Nov. 14. The youngster took 15 carries for an impressive 141 yards and 1 touchdown in the victory.

only to rip it off in front of a booing home crowd to reveal a Notre Dame jersey. Every single Golden Domer in the student section will go crazy. Tim Duncan, sitting comfortably in a luxury box, will not. Now that my big-picture prediction is out of the way, let’s talk ball. SMU is beaten, bruised and barely limping after being thrashed a week ago. Expect the Irish to come out with intensity and punish a Mustang team that has lost its horsepower as of late. While I hope to see Carr sling the rock at will, it’s more likely that Notre Dame’s Walton and James will combine for over 200 rushing yards for the second consecutive week, and all will be right in the world. Irish by a million. Okay, you got me. Irish by 28. Prediction: Notre Dame 42, SMU 14 Payton Dymek Right now, Notre Dame is riding a high from a 41-7 win over Boston College, inching closer to a home playoff game. However, on the SMU side, the Mustangs took a rough 49-7 loss to Wake Forest last weekend and have been eliminated from chances of competing for the ACC Championship as a result of a 7-3 record. With the Irish being ranked the No. 1 defense in all of college football, SMU may struggle to find its footing. The Mustangs are slow in the rushing game, sitting 65th in FBS, so if senior wide receiver Yamir Knight can’t connect the way he has been, then it’s sure to be a low-scoring output. In terms of the Irish offense, I’m obviously keeping my eye on junior quarterback Carr, especially after his Heisman probability dropped last weekend when he only threw for 217 yards against an abysmal defense. On a more positive note, I will have my eyes on all the seniors as it’s Senior Night, and I expect an aggressive tone to be set early as they play with a different level of emotion for their last confirmed game in the “Cathedral of College Football.” Prediction: Notre Dame 42, SMU 17 Ben Hicks Last week may have been the worst thing to happen to SMU football since the “death penalty.” The

Ponies had their tails sufficiently kicked by Wake Forest, on their home field nonetheless. But if you think SMU is just gonna lay down with a top-10 team in Notre Dame upcoming, you’re dead wrong. Mustangs signal caller Jennings is one of the most experienced quarterbacks in America. In fact, he’s been in Dallas so long he already has a building on campus named after him. The senior Texan has 93 career touchdowns and has won road games at Louisville and Clemson as a starter, so he is no stranger to the bright lights. Factor in the Irish cycling in many of their returning injured defenders, and I expect SMU to hang around Saturday night. With that said, Notre Dame still possesses a substantial talent advantage at most spots on the field. Marcus Freeman’s crew also has much more at stake than the visiting Mustangs, with the opportunity to lock up a playoff spot on the line. SMU earns some respect following last week’s whipping, but the Irish continue the postseason push. Prediction: Notre Dame 38, SMU 20 Ethan Laslo Hicks may have already said it, but wow, last week was rough for the Pony Express. SMU looked like it hardly belonged on the same field as Wake Forest. As good as the Demon Deacons have looked this season, it was a shocking result for an SMU squad that hadn’t lost at home since 2025. However, there’s one stat that caught my eye this week regarding head coach Rhett Lashlee’s team. In the games following their six losses over the previous few seasons, SMU is 6-0 the next week. That includes two ranked wins. Could that trend continue this week on Senior Night in Notre Dame Stadium? I doubt it although I have a feeling this could be closer than expected. The Mustangs will be hungry while the Irish will be trying to stay the course and cruise to a College Football Playoff berth. I expect SMU quarterback Jennings’ experience to be a key factor in how this game goes for the Mustangs. He’s played more meaningful football than most quarterbacks in college football, but I’m not

sure he’s seen a defense like this Irish unit. Assuming Notre Dame handles business on defense, especially up front, I see a comfortable victory. If they cover, it’ll be a slow burn much like it was with Boston College last week. Prediction: Notre Dame 45, SMU 14 Henry Lytle I think everyone is overreacting to the stomping SMU endured last week. Yes, the Mustangs were thoroughly thwacked by Wake Forest at home, but most people on ESPN that told you that didn’t bother to watch the game. SMU’s first half was riddled with careless mistakes that snowballed together: turnovers, blown coverages on defense, poor pass protection and subpar decision making by Jennings. SMU is not the caliber of a team trailing 42-0 at halftime against Wake Forest, and I believe the Mustangs will make this game significantly more competitive after emerging as a topic of conversation for all the wrong reasons over the last week. Notre Dame is trending toward the return of Johnson and DJ McKinney, who should anchor the Irish secondary through the Playoff. I would expect the training staff to push for their expected reentry into the lineup until the postseason because they are simply not needed in this one. SMU’s defense is allowing over 27 points per game, which jumps up to 45 points against the two ranked opponents in Louisville and Wake Forest, who both beat SMU by double digits. Frankly, Jennings has not been a threat with his legs this season, which is the only way I could see SMU keeping scoring pace with the Irish in a BYU-style offensive formula. The Irish defense will create havoc getting after Jennings, and Notre Dame will roll to Syracuse. Prediction: Notre Dame 52, SMU 21 Jack Muething SMU’s offense is legit. Jennings is 11th in the country in terms of passing yards per game, and the Mustangs have eclipsed 50 points in three of their 10 games this season. Running back Kendrick Raphael has some talent as well, and the SMU offense is very well rounded.

The same is not true for the defense though. Wake Forest ran for 286 yards against the SMU defense, and Notre Dame’s running back duo of James and Walton has really been heating up down the stretch. Especially with them having to focus on Carr’s passing ability, the Notre Dame run game should be able to have its way with the Mustang defense. Additionally, while the SMU offense is talented, Notre Dame will be the best defense it has faced all season. I don’t expect this game to go as bad for the Mustangs as the one against the Demon Deacons did, but Notre Dame is going to win this game, and it won’t be super close. Prediction: Notre Dame 41, SMU 17 Nikki Stachurski The Irish have no intention of letting their foot off the gas anytime soon. The Mustangs’ loss to Wake Forest last weekend was a reality check, especially regarding SMU’s frequent mistakes that cause far too many turnovers. Notre Dame has gotten over its tendency to have slow starts and low-scoring first halves, and if the Irish come out of the tunnel with a profound sense of urgency, they can run the scoreboard up early. But it is crucial for Irish fans to remember SMU has been a decent team. Its 7-3 record includes wins over Florida State and Virginia Tech. Last week’s 49-7 whooping was uncharacteristic, and the Mustangs are likely to take the field with every attempt at upsetting the Irish on Senior Night. But when comparing the offense, Notre Dame’s leadership and football IQ allows for gritty, creative plays that SMU just cannot beat. The Mustangs have a high-intensity passing offense, but the Irish defense is well-equipped to break it up. Dropping one spot in the CFP Rankings despite a win has proven the SEC bias runs deep, and the Irish are prepared to leave no doubt they deserve to play in December. Prediction: Notre Dame 48, SMU 17 Claire Watson Notre Dame has been firing on all cylinders since it lost to BYU in mid-October. But the Irish shouldn’t let their foot off the gas now nor should they take any game for granted. Despite the fact that the CFP seems to be in its future, Notre Dame needs to finish strong to secure the opportunity to earn a bye or a first-round home game. Over the last few weeks, Carr has been impressive in his game management and ability to find his receiving weapons. Additionally, the Notre Dame run game has been equally as successful recently. That being said, the offense needs to keep up that killer mentality. Additionally, Saturday is the last home game for the Irish, which means it could be the seniors’ final opportunity inside Notre Dame Stadium, making it even more important for the Irish to come out on top. Prediction: Notre Dame 56, SMU 14


PAID ADVERTISEMENT


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Print Edition for The Observer for Friday, November 20, 2026 by The Observer - Issuu