IT Governance Business Case Cemetery Management Software
THE IMPORTANCE OF CEMETERIES TO THE CITY OF DURHAM Our cemeteries are a vital community asset. Maplewood and Beechwood Cemeteries, established in 1872 and 1924, are the resting places of many local citizens, including prominent historical figures who were instrumental in Durham’s growth. Both cemeteries have a deep historical importance to the community in that they bring today’s residents closer to an understanding of the past. Cemeteries today can reveal information about historic events, religions, lifestyles, genealogy, and potentially our future…
Project: Cemetery Management Software 3 Major Objectives: • Ensure business continuity and record integrity by replacing dated management software • Streamline our existing cemetery operations with the help of a more robust software-based management tool • Increase visibility to public and provide web services in-line with other municipal cemeteries
Desired Business Value: • Increased software stability and data integrity • Reduced reliance on paper-based records by further moving towards digital records and documents • Added value for customers by way of new robust, public-facing features
Stakeholders: • General Services • Technology Solutions • City Residents
Current State •
The Cemeteries division of General Services uses a software product called NEXUS to track historical burial and lot ownership information for the City’s two cemeteries, Beechwood and Maplewood
•
NEXUS was implemented back in 2001 to replace the division's dependence on a nearly century-old card filing system
•
NEXUS was supported for five years up until 2006 via a required maintenance contract. However, that maintenance agreement has long since expired and no additional updates/upgrades to the software platform have been made. Our version of NEXUS is an end-of-life software product.
Current Pain Points •
The current system is no longer supported, meaning no software and security updates.
•
Because the current platform is severely aged, it lacks user friendliness and customization. Data entry and retrieval are cumbersome and repetitive.
•
Limited reporting and data analytics capabilities. Management cannot get what it needs to make informed decisions based on data.
•
The current system has no digital Mapping Component that the Cemeteries Division or the City’s Residents can utilize. This increases the level of difficulty for location of burials for both staff and visitors.
•
No data visualization or dashboards to provide quick overviews of things like task status, metrics, alerts, etc.
•
Cemeteries continues to rely on old paper maps to find existing available plots.
NO DIGITAL MAPPING To the right represents a current paper map that is being used at Durham’s Maplewood Cemetery. This map is used to identify available plots and is updated by hand. Because the map is not tied directly to a database, a separate verification of the plot’s status in NEXUS must be made as well.
Future State
Our future state is a cloud-based Cemetery Management Software Platform. An intuitive and easy to use record management software will streamline the staff’s day to day burial operations, provide the public with online access to digital cemetery data, and incorporate a true GIS-based mapping system.
Future State Benefits •
An interactive digital mapping component that can be utilized by both staff and City residents. An interactive map would allow residents and families to locate burial sites on their own at anytime, from any location, via a front-facing app and/or website.
•
Data reporting and visualization capability.
•
Efficiently plotting and display of grave information.
•
The ability to visually connect burial, grave, owner, and marker information.
•
Increased ease in location and identification of burial sites that lack a physical marker.
•
Increased data security and preservation via cloud based hosting.
•
Repetitive data entry and excessive paper forms would be replaced with single screen data entry and digital signature ability for burial and lot sale forms.
Solution Options & Analysis
10
1. Acquire and implement a new Cemetery Management Software Platform
2. Develop an in-house Cemetery Records Management and Mapping solution
11
Acquire and implement a new Cemetery Management Software Platform
Description
Pros
Cons
• •
Ensure business continuity and preservation of historical records Updated features will provide benefits to both internal and external stakeholders
•
Implementation will potentially be lengthy and cause at least some interruption to operations due to re-training for staff
12
COST ESTIMATES
FUNDING
Total One Year Costs (Hours)
Description
Run Costs (Hours)/ KTLO
Departmental Funding Amount:
$0
Labor $ (Hours) Total Internal TS:
97 hours
72 hours
0 hours
0 hours
TS Services
97 hours
72 hours
TS Project Management:
96 hours
0 hours
Project Run Cost (External)
$5,876.00
184 hours
24 hours
*Total Project Funding Requested
$72,130.00
Business Analysis
General Services Department: External: Business Analysis Professional Services
$0 (0 hours)
$0 (0 hours)
$0 (0 hours)
$0 (0 hours)
$62,100
$0 (0 hours)
$0
$0
$10,030
$5,876
$0
$0
Funding Requested (Y/N):
Project One Time Costs
*Recurring Cost
Y
$72,130.00
$5,876
Non-Labor $ Hardware: Software: Other:
*Total Project Funding Requested (External), includes External Year 1 Run Costs and Non-Labor
13
Description
Pros
Cons
2. Develop an in-house Cemetery Records Management and Mapping solution
• Ensure business continuity and preservation of historical records • Updated features will provide benefits to both internal and external stakeholders • Complexity and data migration may be difficult. Will not have as many features as off-the-shelf package • Development of an in-house solution may take more time to complete
14
COST ESTIMATES
FUNDING
Total One Year Costs (Hours)
Description
Run Costs (Hours)/ KTLO
Departmental Funding Amount:
$0
Labor $ (Hours) Internal TS: Business Analysis TS Services (Including GIS inhouse development) TS Project Management: General Services Department: External:
277 hours
72 hours
0 hours
0 hours
277 hours
72 hours
96 hours
0 hours
184 hours
24 hours
$0 (0 hours)
$0 (0 hours)
Business Analysis
$0 (0 hours)
$0 (0 hours)
Professional Services
$0 (0 hours)
$0 (0 hours)
Hardware:
$0
$0
Software:
$0
$0
Other:
$0
$0
Funding Requested (Y/N):
N
Project One Time Costs
$0
Project Run Cost (External)
$0
*Total Project Funding Requested
$0
*Recurring Cost (In budget operational cost of the GIS program)
$0
Non-Labor $
*Total Project Funding Requested (External), includes External Year 1 Run Costs and Non-Labor
15
SECURITY OBJECTIVE CATEGORY
Confidentiality
POTENTIAL IMPACT LOW
Unauthorized disclosure of information = limited adverse effect on organizational operations, organizational assets, or individuals.
National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Special Publication 800-60, Volume 2, Rev. 1
Integrity
Unauthorized modification or destruction of information = limited adverse effect on organizational operations, organizational assets, or individuals.
Availability
Disruption of access to or use of information or an information system = limited adverse effect on organizational operations, organizational assets, or individuals.
The information type identified for the Cemetery Management Software is Public Resources, Facility and Infrastructure Management, with the following security categorization recommendation: Final Security Categorization = Confidentiality: Low; Integrity: Low; Availability: Low 16
Risk: Are there proper resources to support on-going administration and operation of a new cemetery management system? Risk Management Plan: 1) General Services Department has a dedicated Cemeteries division that would be responsible for the administration of the software. 2)Technology Solutions has a dedicated GIS division which provides GIS mapping Support and potential development. 1)
2)
Utilizing experience and qualified employees from General Services •
Cedar Glasgow
•
Dennis Farmer
Utilizing experience and support from the entire GIS Division within Technology
Solutions. GIS will support the mapping component of the Cemetery Management System and also possibly build the entire platform, if certain requirements are met.
17
Summary & Recommendation
18
Options
Cemetery Management Software – Desired Business Value Analysis Criteria Cloud-based/ Shorter Increased Added value for Data Migration software stability customers through Vendor Hosted Implementation capability and data integrity enhanced features solution Time
Cost
1. New CMS
$$$
2. In-House CMS
$
19
Recommendation Option 1: Proceed with procurement of a new Cemetery Management Software Package
20
Our Ask
We are asking for approval of this Business Case and to recommend the funding of a New Cemetery Management Software package for the City of Durham’s Cemetery Operations
Project Planning
Risk & Risk Mitigation
Project Timeline
23
• March 2019: Gain Approval from Steering Committee • May 2019: Begin Bidding Process for Cemetery Management System • August 2019: Select winning bid and procure Cemetery Management Software • September 2019: Begin implementation of software, beginning with extensive data migration • March 2020: Launch new Cemetery Management Software
xxx 2018
24