Skip to main content

Solution Manual for Business and Society Stakeholders, Ethics, Public Policy 17th Edition Lawrence

Page 1

Type:

Solution Manual

Business and Society Resource: Stakeholders, Ethics, Public Policy Edition:

17th Edition

Author(s):

Anne T. Lawrence James Weber


Page 1-1

CHAPTER 1 THE CORPORATION AND ITS STAKEHOLDERS INTRODUCTION Business corporations have complex relationships with many individuals and organizations in society. The term stakeholder refers to all those that affect, or are affected by, the actions of the firm. An important part of management’s role is to identify a firm’s relevant stakeholders and understand the nature of their interests, power, and alliances with one another. Building positive and mutually beneficial relationships across organizational boundaries can help enhance a company’s reputation and address critical social and ethical challenges. In a world of fast-paced globalization, shifting public expectations and government policies, growing ecological concerns, and new technologies, managers face the difficult challenge of achieving economic results while simultaneously creating value for all of their diverse stakeholders. PREVIEW CASE Amazon.com Teaching Tip: Preview Case Video The Amazon example that opens the chapter illustrates the challenges of managing successfully in a complex global network of stakeholders. It may also be used to illustrate how different stakeholders may perceive a corporation differently, depending on their vantage point. Instructors may wish to introduce a discussion of the opening example with a short video profile of the company: “How Big Is Amazon?” (WCDaily, March18, 2021, www.youtube.com/watch?v=SWjpbc-FJII&t=18 (4:06 minutes). This can be followed by prompts, such as: • Do you personally like or dislike Amazon? Why? • What groups have been helped by Amazon, and what groups have been hurt? The instructor can then build on student comments on groups that have been helped or hurt when introducing the concept of stakeholder later in the session.

CHAPTER OUTLINE I.

BUSINESS AND SOCIETY

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 1-2

A. A Systems Perspective II.

THE STAKEHOLDER THEORY OF THE FIRM A. The Stakeholder Concept B. Different Kinds of Stakeholders

III.

STAKEHOLDER ANALYSIS A. Stakeholder Interests B. Stakeholder Power C. Stakeholder Coalitions D. Stakeholder Mapping

IV.

THE CORPORATION’S BOUNDARY-SPANNING DEPARTMENTS

V.

THE DYNAMIC ENVIRONMENT OF BUSINESS

VI.

CREATING VALUE IN A DYNAMIC ENVIRONMENT

GETTING STARTED KEY LEARNING OBJECTIVES LO 1-1: Understanding the relationship between business and society and the ways in which business and society are part of an interactive system. (pp. 4-5) Business firms are organizations that are engaged in making a product or providing a service for a profit. Society, in its broadest sense, refers to human beings and to the social structures they collectively create. Business is part of society and engages in ongoing exchanges with its external environment. Together, business and society form an interactive social system in which the actions of each profoundly influence the other. LO 1-2: Considering the purpose of the modern corporation. (pp. 5-6) According to the stakeholder theory of the firm, the purpose of the modern corporation is to create value for all of its stakeholders. To survive, all companies must make a profit for their owners. However, they also create many other kinds of value as well for their employees, customers, suppliers, communities, and others. For both practical and ethical reasons, corporations must take all stakeholders’ interests into account. Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 1-3

LO 1-3: Knowing what a stakeholder is and who a corporation’s market and nonmarket and internal and external stakeholders are. (pp. 6-11) Every business firm has economic and social relationships with others in society. Some are intended, some unintended; some are positive, others negative. Stakeholders are all those who affect, or are affected by, the actions of the firm. Some have a market relationship with the company, and others have a nonmarket relationship with it; some stakeholders are internal, and others are external. LO 1-4: Conducting a stakeholder analysis and understanding the basis of stakeholder interests and power. (pp. 11-18) Stakeholders often have multiple interests and can exercise their economic, political, and other powers in ways that benefit or challenge the organization. Stakeholders may also act independently or create coalitions to influence the company. Stakeholder mapping is a technique for graphically representing stakeholders’ relationship to an issue facing a firm. LO 1-5: Recognizing the diverse ways in which modern corporations organize internally to interact with various stakeholders. (pp. 19-20) Modern corporations have developed a range of boundary-crossing departments and offices to manage interactions with market and nonmarket stakeholders. The organization of the corporation’s boundary-spanning functions is complex. Most companies have many departments specifically charged with interacting with stakeholders. LO 1-6: Analyzing the forces of change that continually reshape the business and society relationship. (pp. 20-22) A number of broad forces shape the relationship between business and society. These include changing societal and ethical expectations; a dynamic global economy; redefinition of the role of government; ecological and natural resource concerns; and the transformational role of technology and innovation. To deal effectively with these changes, corporate strategy must address the expectations of all of the company’s stakeholders.

KEY TERMS boundary-spanning departments business external stakeholder focal organization

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 1-4

general systems theory interactive social system internal stakeholder shareholder theory of the firm society stakeholder stakeholder analysis stakeholder coalitions stakeholder interests stakeholder (market) stakeholder (nonmarket) stakeholder map stakeholder power stakeholder salience stakeholder theory of the firm

INTERNET RESOURCES www.economist.com

The Economist

www.fortune.com

Fortune

www.nytimes.com

The New York Times

www.wsj.com

The Wall Street Journal

www.bloomberg.com

Bloomberg

www.ft.com

Financial Times (London)

www.cnnmoney.com

CNN Money

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 1-5

DISCUSSION CASE TIPPING POINT AT UNION SQUARE HOSPITALITY GROUP Discussion Questions 1. What is the focal organization in this case, and what decision did it make? The chapter defines a focal organization as the organization from whose perspective a stakeholder analysis is conducted. In this case, the focal organization is the Union Square Hospitality Group (USHG), an operator of upscale restaurants in New York City and Washington DC. The decision faced by its CEO, Danny Meyer, and his management team was whether to reintroduce tips for its servers when their restaurants reopened following the first wave of coronavirus closures in 2020. Five years earlier, USHG had eliminated tips, replacing them with a “hospitality included” policy. 2. List the four kinds of tipping mentioned in this case. If you worked in a restaurant, which kind of tipping would you support, and why? If you were a customer in a restaurant, which kind of tipping would you support, and why? Four kinds of tipping are mentioned in the case. These are: 1) Direct tipping. Customers tip their servers (waiters and waitresses) directly, and the servers keep their own tips. (This kind of tipping was historically widespread in fullservice restaurants in the United States.) 2) Tipping out: Servers voluntarily share their tips with bussers, hosts, cooks, and others who help them during their shifts. 3) Pooled tipping: The employer pools (collects) all tips and service charges at the end of a shift and then redistributes them to all employees, according to an equitable formula. (The National Restaurant Association supported this type of tipping.) 4) Hospitality included: Customers are not allowed to tip. Instead, menu prices are raised across the board to cover increased compensation for all employees. Teaching Tip: USHG When USHG first introduced a “hospitality included” policy in 2015, Danny Meyer appeared on several media outlets to explain the change. For example, he appeared on CBS Mornings in this 4:39 minute clip: www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3B2-_SLRBQ

Students might answer the second and third parts of the question in several ways. A sample response follows: If I worked in a restaurant, I would probably support whichever type of tipping produced the highest compensation. That would depend on my role. If I were a server, I would probably Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 1-6

support keeping my own tips, because tips can as much as double a server’s pay. If I were a back-of-the house worker, such as a cook or busser, I would probably support some type of shared tip policy, such as tipping out or pooled tipping, so I could receive a portion of customers’ tips. I might also support a hospitality included policy if it raised my compensation more than the other types. If I were a customer in a restaurant, I might have mixed feelings about tipping. On one hand, I would want to be free to reward my waiter or waitress for excellent service (or punish them for poor service by lowering or withholding my tip). On the other hand, I might also be concerned that direct tipping was not fair to others on the staff who had served me indirectly, such as the chefs, leading me to support a tipping out or pooled system. I might prefer a hospitality included policy, since it would take away the hassle of thinking about and calculating a tip after my meal. It might also make me feel good, because this approach would more fairly compensate the back-of-the house workers. But a hospitality included policy might cost more. 3. Identify the stakeholder groups that will be impacted by Meyer’s decision to reintroduce tips. For each, identify its interests and power, with respect to tipping policy. (Note: Some stakeholders may have different segments, with varying interests and power.) Teaching Tip: USHG This question can be addressed using board work, with a full class discussion, as shown. Alternatively, students groups may be assigned specific stakeholders and asked to identify their interests and power.

STAKEHOLDER Employees: frontof-the house

INTERESTS Highest possible compensation; freedom from harassment or discrimination by customers

Employees: backof-the-house

Highest possible compensation

POWER To quit and take a job somewhere else. To share or not share tips in a “tipping out” system. To provide variable levels of service to customers to attract higher tips. To provide excellent support to the servers, to encourage them to share their tips in a

NOTES Power is quite high, particularly in a tight job market.

Power is quite low for low-skilled Bof-H workers, e.g., dishwashers. May be higher for skilled

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 1-7

STAKEHOLDER

INTERESTS

Customers

Best possible service; good value

Community

Good paying jobs; tax revenue

Suppliers

Regular orders; to be compensated fairly

Investors

Profitability; high returns on investment

POWER tipping out system. To tip generously or not; to withhold tips. To patronize a restaurant or not.

NOTES workers, e.g., chefs. Power is high because customers can decide what restaurants to patronize and how much to tip (except under hospitality included policies). Issue may be of low salience to community members.

To influence government to enact legislation governing tipping policies. To refuse to supply, Suppliers are e.g., food or kitchen unlikely to be equipment. aware of tipping policies. To sell stock and Investors are invest in other unlikely to be companies aware of tipping policies.

4. If you were in Meyer’s position, what tipping policy would you support to best meet the needs of all the company’s stakeholders? What steps should the USHG management team take to implement this approach? USHG CEO Danny Meyer had a clearly articulated philosophy of “enlightened hospitality”—meeting the needs of all USHG’s stakeholders. He prioritized these stakeholders as follows: employees, guests (customers), community, suppliers, and investors. He strove to adopt policies that made “the math add up for all stakeholders,” in other words, to meet all their interests—although he acknowledged this “was never easy.” The fact that USHG had experimented with several types of tipping policy over the years suggested that Meyer and his team did not find it obvious which one would best meet all stakeholders’ needs. The management team’s challenge was made more complex by laws in New York state (where many USHG restaurants were located) that prohibited any sharing of tips with workers who did not spend at least 80 percent of their time interacting with customers (seeming to exclude pooled tipping policies that included back-of-the-house workers, e.g., cooks and dishwashers) or mandatory service charges (which could potentially conflict with a hospitality included policy). Students may respond to this question in several ways. Many students will argue that the best approach in 2020 would be to return to direct tipping by customers and to encourage servers to engage voluntarily in “tipping out” according to collectively determined rules. Direct tipping would meet most customers’ expectations, keep menu prices lower, and help Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 1-8

attract and retain wait staff during the coronavirus pandemic. This approach would avoid potential legal challenges to pooled tipping and service fees. At the same time, USHG could join others in the restaurant industry to lobby for changes in the law that would permit pooled tipping, to enable employers to redistribute tips to all employees according to a standardized and fair formula. Teaching Tip: Takeaways One takeaway from this discussion case is the difficulty of meeting all stakeholders’ interests simultaneously. By reinstating tipping in 2020, USHG may have met the interests of servers, some customers, and some investors, but may have disappointed back-of-the house workers and customers and investors concerned about equity in the workplace. Another takeaway is that managers often need to work with other external organizations to meet stakeholders’ interests. In this situation, management might need to work with other companies in the restaurant industry to press for legislative changes.

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 2-1

CHAPTER 2 MANAGING PUBLIC ISSUES AND STAKEHOLDER RELATIONSHIPS INTRODUCTION Businesses today operate in an ever-changing external environment, where effective management requires anticipating emerging public issues and engaging positively with a wide range of stakeholders. Whether the issue is growing concerns about employee safety, civil disorder, or privacy, managers must respond to the opportunities and risks it presents. To do so effectively often requires building relationships across organizational boundaries, learning from external stakeholders, and altering practices in response. Effective management of public issues and stakeholder relationships builds value for the firm.

PREVIEW CASE The Business Roundtable Teaching Tip: Preview Case If instructors want more background, they could read and/or assign the Business Roundtable Statement for students to read. The reference is: https://opportunity.businessroundtable.org/ourcommitment/. The members of the Business Roundtable explain the motivation for “The Statement of the Purpose of a Corporation”. Instructors may ask if the statement communicates commitment to a different way of doing business or provides cover and generates publicity to sway public opinion.

CHAPTER OUTLINE I.

PUBLIC ISSUES

II.

ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS Teaching Tip: Eight Strategic Radar Screens The “eight strategic radar screens” is a useful tool for nearly any case. The instructor may want to introduce a case from the end of the book,

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 2-2

before launching into a more elaborate analysis later in the semester using the same case, since the radar screens can provide an overview of the major forces engaged in the case. Or, a local situation from the community or campus might be a good focus for applying the radar screens.

A. Competitive Intelligence B. Stakeholder Materiality Teaching Tip: Stakeholder Materiality This emerging notion comes out of corporate practice. Students may be assigned to search for companies, other than Unilever, that use this tool. The instructor may want to apply this tool to a case used earlier in the semester, or an emerging issue/current event. This tool is implicitly used to organize and prioritize the many demands on us in our daily lives.

III.

THE ISSUE MANAGEMENT PROCESS A. Identify Issue B. Analyze Issue C. Generate Options D. Take Action E. Evaluate Results Teaching Tip: Issue Management Process This is another opportunity where a current issue on campus, in the local community, or on the national or international stage could be used for students to analyze how this issue is progressing or has progressed through the issue management process. The instructor may use this opportunity to highlight the connection between managing issues effectively and preserving a firm’s reputation.

IV.

ORGANIZING FOR EFFECTIVE ISSUE MANAGEMENT

V.

STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 2-3

A. Stages in the Business-Stakeholder Relationship Teaching Tip: Stages in the Business-Stakeholder Relationship The four stages provide an excellent comparison of business action toward a stakeholder. Comparing the impact of these different actions to any case could be a good illustration for the students of the many demands on us in our daily lives.

B. Drivers of Stakeholder Engagement •

Goals

•

Motivation

•

Organizational Capacity

C. The Role of Social Media in Stakeholder Engagement Teaching Tip: The Role of Social Media Students could investigate and locate examples of businesses turning to social media to engage with its stakeholders. Examples could be internal to the business or from the larger social environment.

VI.

STAKEHOLDER DIALOGUE A. Stakeholder Networks B. The Benefits of Engagement

GETTING STARTED KEY LEARNING OBJECTIVES LO 2-1: Identifying public issues and analyzing gaps between corporate performance and stakeholder expectations. (pp. 27-30) A public issue is an issue that is of mutual concern to an organization and one or more of the organization’s stakeholders. Stakeholders expect a level of performance by businesses, and if it is not met a gap between performance and expectation emerges. The larger the gap, the greater risk of stakeholder backlash or missed business opportunity.

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 2-4

LO 2-2: Applying available tools or techniques to scan an organization’s multiple environments and assessing stakeholder materiality. (pp. 30-35) The eight strategic radar screens (the customer, competitor, economic, technological, social, political, legal, and geophysical environments) enable public affairs managers to assess and acquire information regarding their business environments. Managers must also assess the importance or materiality of public issues to the firm and their stakeholders. LO 2-3: Describing the steps in the issue management process and determining how to make the process most effective. (pp. 35-38) The issue management process includes identification and analysis of issues, the generation of options, action, and evaluation of the results. LO 2-4: Identifying the managerial skills required to respond to emerging issues effectively. (pp. 38-39) In the modern corporation, the issue management process takes place in many boundaryspanning departments. Some firms have a department of external affairs or corporate relations to coordinate these activities and top management support is essential for effective issue management. LO 2-5: Understanding the various stages through which businesses can engage with stakeholders, what drives this engagement, and the role social media can play. (39-42) Stakeholder engagement involves building relationships between a business firm and its stakeholders around issues of common concern and is enhanced by understanding the goals, motivations, and organizational capacities relevant to the engagement. Social media is playing a more expansive role in stakeholder engagement. LO 2-6: Recognizing the value of creating stakeholder dialogue and networks. (pp. 42-44) Stakeholder dialogue is central to good stakeholder engagement, supported by network building or partnerships.

KEY TERMS competitive intelligence environmental analysis environmental intelligence issue management issue management process Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 2-5

performance–expectations gap public issue stakeholder dialogue stakeholder engagement stakeholder materiality stakeholder network

INTERNET RESOURCES www.wn.com/publicissues

World News, Public Issues

www.nifi.org

National Issues Forum

unfoundation.org/what-we-do/issues

United Nations Foundation, Global Issues

www.issuemanagement.org

Issue Management Council

www.scip.org

Society of Competitive Intelligence Professionals

www.globalissues.org

Global Issues

millennium-project.org

The Millennium Project

www.cfr.org

Council on Foreign Relations

pac.org/fpa

Foundation for Public Affairs, Public Affairs Council

DISCUSSION CASE ROBINHOOD: THE CHALLENGES OF KEEPING PACE WITH INNOVATION Discussion Questions 1. What was the public issue facing Robinhood in this case? Students are likely to identify poor customer service as the public issue facing Robinhood. Sophisticated students understand that poor customer service is a consequence of a larger issue: offering amateur investors access to complicated trades without providing the necessary support to ensure they have access to and understand relevant information for making informed trades. Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 2-6

2. Describe the “performance–expectations gap” found in the case. What were the stakeholders’ (consumers, employees, legislators) expectations, and how did they differ from Robinhood’s performance? Consumers expected a platform that would function properly along with prompt and responsive customer assistance. Employees expected a leadership team that would be responsive when informed of technical problems with the platform as dedicate resources and support to address issues with customer service. Instead, it appeared as if the CEOs continued to conduct business despite promising to address these issues. Legislators expected that Robinhood would address the customer support issue promptly, especially after unresponsive customer service was attributed as a contributing factor to a customer’s suicide. Instead, at the hearing where Robinhood CEO Vladimir Tenev was testifying, a congressman called the helpline and got a recorded message. 3. If you applied the strategic radar screens model to this case, which of the eight environments would be most significant, and why? Customer Environment: Robinhood was targeted to young people who would be most comfortable with the technology. The app was “gamified” with transactions replicating the reward experiences often associated with video games. Unfortunately, this demographic is also vulnerable because they are likely to have little experience to inform complicated transactions such as options. Poor and unresponsive customer support exacerbated problems caused by inexperience with complex trades. Robinhood did have the staff necessary to field all of the requests for support. Technological Environment: Robinhood’s app provided a novel platform for amateur investors to execute trades. Some trades were those that had been previously available to professional traders. This app was one of the first of its kind and as a result experienced technical problems (executing trades incorrectly, site crashing and/or freezing) Social Environment: Sentiment toward the app changed rapidly. Initially, Robinhood was perceived as tool that expanded access to non-professional traders. It was seen as democratizing trading so that the average joe could make bigger and more complex transacations that would yield bigger returns without the need to include a professional trader as an intermediary. Over time, Robinhood was seen as uncaring company that benefited from the inexperience of its customers. Political Environment: Incidents like Nick’s suicide and complaints from constituents who experienced slow customer service and technological problems with the platform that resulted in loss of money motivate increased scrutiny from legislators. Congress convened hearings to investigate issues with Robinhood. All of these events could result in increased regulation. Legal Environment: Robinhood could be the target of law suits initiated by customers who lost money due to the problems with the app as well as families, like Nick’s, who sue for the company’s part in contributing to their self-harm or suicide.

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 2-7

4. Apply the issue management life cycle process model to this case. Which stages of the process can you identify? Identify issue: leadership at Robinhood failed to anticipate the problems generated by its investment app. Employees brought concerns about capacity to provide customer service. Customers complained about the delay in responding to their requests for assistance. Analyze the issue: leadership at Robinhood seemed unaware of the gravity of the concerns brought forward by employees and customers. Employees describe leadership as unresponsive. Generate options: CEOs of the company proposed improvements to the app that would provide more guidance for customers, updates on how the app would display busying power, and live customer support for customers with open options positions. Take action: CEOs failed to take action. When congressman called their customer service line, he was directed immediately to a recorded message. Evaluate results: Information from the case does not address whether or not leadership did anything differently after the congressional hearing. 5. In your opinion, did Robinhood respond appropriately to this issue? Why or why not? Students answers will vary. Good answers will express an opinion and refer to facts from the case to support their point of view. 6. If you were a member of Robinhood’s leadership team, what would you have decided to do (or not to do) in the face of emerging concerns about online investing apps? Student answers will vary. Good answers will be informed by stakeholder model, considering the interests of affected stakeholders and developing a course of action that would address the needs of as many stakeholders as possible.

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 3-1

CHAPTER 3 CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND CITIZENSHIP INTRODUCTION The idea that businesses bear broad responsibilities to society as they pursue economic goals has been debated for decades. Both market and nonmarket stakeholders expect businesses to act responsibly, and many companies have responded by making social goals a part of their overall business operations and adopting the goal of being a good corporate citizen. Businesses embracing these responsibilities often build positive relationships with stakeholders, discover business opportunities in serving society, and transform a concern for financial performance into a vision of integrated financial, social, and environmental performance. Business ventures of all sizes-entrepreneurial, small to medium business enterprises, and corporate endeavors-hold responsibilities to those stakeholders they impact. Establishing effective structures and processes to meet a company’s social and corporate citizenship responsibilities, assessing the results of these efforts, and reporting on the firm’s performance to the public are important challenges facing today’s managers and business owners. PREVIEW CASES Nike Carnegie Mellon University’s CREATE Lab Are the efforts described above examples of social responsibility practiced by a corporation and social entrepreneurs? Do good global corporate citizens have an obligation to support social causes? How far should an organization or entrepreneur go to help those in society in need of their support? Teaching Tip: Socially Responsible Companies The preview cases should provide students will ample opportunities to debate the questions raised above – social responsibility or inappropriate use of company assets – and how far “should” a company go? Students may want to locate examples of social responsibility from their local communities or off the Internet.

CHAPTER OUTLINE I.

CORPORATE POWER AND RESPONSIBILITY Teaching Tip: Iron Law of Responsibility

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 3-2

Students could look through local or national business periodicals or the Internet for examples of businesses who have abused their power and encountered the wrath of social interest groups or the government. Alternatively, are there examples of businesses that have survived over the long term because they have used their power for social good? To inspire debate in class, ask students whether the Iron Law of Responsibility exists in the modern business climate.

II.

CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND CITIZENSHIP Teaching Tip: Corporate Social Responsibility and Citizenship The CEO at UBS sees it “as a duty to understand the scope and scale of societal challenges.” Do other executives share this vision or are they opposed to this view? Besides the examples included in the text book, students could explore differences in corporate citizenship, possibly from around the world, based on their own experiences, observations, or from information acquired by surfing the Internet. Students could search for CEO letters to shareholders to uncover CSR messages and visions.

A. The Origins of Corporate Social Responsibility B. Balancing Social, Economic, and Legal Responsibilities

III.

THE CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY QUESTION Teaching Tip: The CSR Question Students could be divided into teams and assigned one side of the CSR question, or be in support of or have concerns about each issue in the question for in-class presentations. Students could support their position by acquiring quotes from local executives via interviews or from corporate documents, such as annual reports or press releases. Figure 3.3 The Pros and Cons of Corporate Social Responsibility might help students form the discussion. A. Support for Corporate Social Responsibility

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 3-3 

Balances Corporate Power with Responsibility

Discourages Government Regulation

Promotes Long-term Profits for Business

Improves Stakeholder Relationships

Enhances Business Reputation

B. Concerns About Corporate Social Responsibility

IV.

Lowers Economic Efficiency and Profits

Imposes Unequal Costs Among Competitors

Imposes Hidden Costs Passed on to Stakeholders

Requires Skills Business May Lack

Places Responsibility on Business Rather Than Individuals

SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURS AND B CORPORATIONS Teaching Tip: Introducing the B Corporation The B Corporation is intended to be somewhat controversial given the newness of this phenomenon and the few organizations that have received this certification. It is an effort to provide some sort of license or objective seal of approval on firms seeking to be socially responsible. Is this a good development? Do firms really care about being known as a socially responsible company? Students may want to explore which other firms, besides those mentioned in the chapter, have been awarded this designation. There are numerous videos available online focusing on and describing the actions of B Corporations – just search for “B Corporations videos” and many can be found on YouTube. Also, see www.bcorporation.net for more information about these organizations and the certification procedures.

V.

MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS FOR CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND CITIZENSHIP

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 3-4 Teaching Tip: Corporate Social Responsibility and Citizenship Professional Associations Groups of students could be assigned each of the associations listed in Exhibit 3.A and compare how each association serves the interests of its members differently. Are there regional differences around the world when it comes to the practice of corporate social responsibility and citizenship?

VI.

STAGES OF CORPORATE CITIZENSHIP Teaching Tip: Corporate and Individual Philanthropy The Boston College Center’s stage model, Figure 3.5, provides an array of possible assignments for students to explore a firm’s corporate citizenship activities. It might be interesting for students to identify firms operating at different stages of corporate citizenship. Are there firms within an industry that are at different stages? Or, students might explore corporate citizenship practices by a single firm over time to see if the firm has progressed from one stage of corporate citizenship to another. Another interesting question for exploration is whether firms change in their stage of corporate citizenship after experiencing a corporate crisis, embarrassment in the press, or change in senior leadership at the firm.

A. Elementary Stage B. Engaged Stage C. Innovative Stage D. Integrated Stage E. Transforming Stage VII.

ASSESSING AND REPORTING SOCIAL PERFORMANCE A. Social Audit Standards Teaching Tip: Corporate Social Audits Locate, using the Internet, examples of firms that conduct social audits. Assess their audit evaluations. Do they consider the “major elements” of corporate citizenship? Are their conclusions and commitment for

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 3-5 future actions likely to promote the social and economic objectives espoused by the firm? Are they pursuing an effective corporate citizenship strategy to meet social goals?

B. Social Reporting Teaching Tip: Global Reporting Initiatives Students may also want to explore the Global Reporting Initiatives at www.globalreporting.org. What services or new opportunities does the GRI provide to firms?

Teaching Tip: Social and Environmental Reporting Social and environmental reports are easily available in most global corporation’s websites. Students could compare and contrast reports, determine the level of transparency found in the reports, and identify which firms have integrated reports.

GETTING STARTED KEY LEARNING OBJECTIVES LO 3-1: Understanding the role of big business and the responsible use of corporate power in a democratic society. The world’s largest corporations are capable of wielding tremendous influence, at times even more than national governments, due to their economic power. Because of this potential influence, the organizations’ stakeholders expect businesses to enhance society when exercising their power. LO 3-2: Knowing history and evolution of the corporate social responsibility concept and investigating how a company’s purpose or mission can integrate social objectives with economic and legal objectives. The idea of corporate social responsibility was adopted by business leaders in the United States in the early 20th century. It has evolved from a notion of stewardship and strategic responsiveness to an ethics-based understanding found in culture and the practice of corporate citizenship. Socially responsible businesses attempt to balance economic, legal, and social obligations. Following an enlightened self-interest approach, a firm may be economically rewarded while society benefits from the firm’s actions. Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 3-6

LO 3-3: Examining the key arguments in support of and concerns about corporate social responsibility. Corporate social responsibility is a controversial notion. Some argue that its benefits include discouraging government regulation, promoting long-term profitability for the firm, and enhancing the company’s stakeholder relationships and business reputation. Others believe that it lowers efficiency, imposes undue costs, and shifts unnecessary obligations to business. Most executives believed that they should use their corporate power and influence to balance their response to multiple stakeholders rather than maximize stockholders’ return alone. LO 3-4: Examining the role of business with an explicitly social mission, such as social entrepreneurial ventures and B corporations. Social entrepreneurs incorporate social and environmental benefit into their core business mission. B Corporations, similarly, are businesses that seek and achieve certification, through rigorous assessments by the nonprofit B Lab organization, gained via specific social and environmental standards. LO 3-5: Defining global corporate citizenship and recognizing the rapidly evolving management practices to support global citizenship. Global corporate citizenship refers to putting a commitment to serving various stakeholders into practice by building stakeholder partnerships, discovering business opportunities in serving society, and transforming a concern for financial performance into a vision of integrated financial and social performance worldwide. Global corporate citizenship programs can be considered a strategic investment by the firm. LO 3-6: Distinguishing among the sequential stages of global corporate citizenship. Companies progress through five distinct stages as they develop as global corporate citizens; these are termed the elementary, engaged, innovative, integrated, and transforming stages. A specific company may be at more than one stage at once, as it may be progressing more quickly on some dimensions than on others. LO 3-7: Understanding how businesses assess and report their social performance. Many companies have created systemic audits of their social, ethical, and environmental performance, measured against industry-wide performance expectations as well as auditing standards developed by global standard-setting organizations. An emerging trend is the practice of communicating social, environmental, and financial results to stakeholders through an integrated corporate report. KEY TERMS B Corporation Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Page 3-7 corporate citizenship corporate power corporate social reporting corporate social responsibility (CSR) creating shared value enlightened self-interest global corporate citizenship integrated reporting iron law of responsibility reputation social audit social entrepreneurs social entrepreneurship social venture transparency

INTERNET RESOURCES www.bsr.org

BSR: The business of a better world

www.businessinsociety.eu

The Business in Society Gateway

www.bcorporation.net

Certified B Corporation

www.csrwire.com

The Corporate Social Responsibility Newswire

consciouscompanymedia.com

Conscious Company Media

www.3blassociation.com

3BL Association

www.unicef.org/csr

UNICEF and Corporate Social Responsibility

Copyright © MCGRAW HILL LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF MCGRAW HILL LLC.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook