Skip to main content

American Social Welfare Policy A Pluralist Approach, 9th Edition Howard Karger Solution Manual

Page 1

Type:

Solution Manual

Resource:

American Social Welfare Policy A Pluralist Approach

Edition:

9th Edition

Author(s):

Howard Karger David Stoesz


Instructor’s Resource Manual Shaunna C. Millar, LMSW Wichita State University

American Social Welfare Policy A Pluralist Approach Ninth Edition Howard Karger Kailua, Hawai’i

David Stoesz Up$tart


Table of Contents Chapter 1

Social Policy and the American Welfare State Error! Bookmark not defined.

Chapter 2

The Origins of American Social Welfare

7

Chapter 3

Social Welfare Policy Research

11

Chapter 4

Discrimination and Stigma in American Society

15

Chapter 5

Poverty in America

20

Chapter 6

The Voluntary Sector Today

25

Chapter 7

Privatization and Human Services Corporations

29

Chapter 8

The Making of Governmental Policy

34

Chapter 9

Tax Policy and Income Distribution

39

Chapter 10

Social Insurance Programs

43

Chapter 11

Public Assistance Programs

48

Chapter 12

The American Health Care System

53

Chapter 13

Mental Health and Substance Abuse Policy

58

Chapter 14

Criminal Justice

63

Chapter 15

Child Welfare Policy

68

Chapter 16

Housing Policies

73

Chapter 17

The Politics of Food Policy and Rural Life

78

Chapter 18

Social Policy and Education Error! Bookmark not defined.

Chapter 19

The American Welfare State in International Perspective

iii .

87


Chapter 1: Social Policy and the American Welfare State

Chapter 1: Social Policy and the American Welfare State CHAPTER SUMMARY Social welfare policy is arguably best viewed through the lens of political economy (i.e., the interaction of economic, political, and ideological forces). This chapter provides an overview of the American welfare state through that lens. In particular, it examines various definitions of social welfare policy, the relationship between social policy and social problems, and the values and ideologies that drive social welfare in the United States. In addition, the chapter examines the effects of ideology on the U.S. welfare state, including the import-ant roles played by conservatism and liberalism (and their variations) in shaping welfare policy. An understanding of social welfare policy requires the ability to grasp the economic justifications and consequences that underlie policy decisions. As such, this chapter contains a brief introduction to Keynesianism, free market economics, socialism, and communitarianism, among others.

STUDENT LEARNING OBJECTIVES • • • • • •

Students will define social welfare policy, and identify how it drives social work practice. Students will understand how the redistributive role of social welfare policy may contribute to the maintenance and survival of our society. Students will understand the distinctive values and economic perspectives associated with Keynesianism, free market economics, and democratic socialism. Students will understand the political continuum from liberalism to libertarianism with an emphasis on the distinctive values and economic assertions of each. Students will understand some of the major systemic and personal implications for the current conservatism resurgence in America. Students will examine the growth of fringe groups in the United States.

TEACHING TIPS •

• • • •

It is important to create a comfortable, safe space for students to be able to discuss political perspectives. The instructor should lead the class in a discussion of how to participate in civil discourse in the classroom, and encourage students to develop a set of class expectations for mutual regard and respect. Begin by exploring the term “policy.” Ask student about the policies they follow in their personal lives, at work, or in any agencies they encounter in their daily lives. Challenge students to provide support for their opinions shared in class, and to develop skills in providing convincing and compelling arguments that are substantiated. Identify the swinging pendulum of how the United States has moved from liberal to conservative approaches historically in addressing social issues. Bring up a number of controversial topics such as immigration, reproductive health care services, voting access, and other similar challenges. Ask your students to explore how a libertarian, a liberal, or a conservative may solve each one.

LECTURE GUIDE AND ASSET CORRELATION The below lecture guide and asset correlation indicates where discussion prompts, assignments, activities or online activities connect to a given topic. The full descriptions of these prompts and assignments follow the below guide.

Discussion Prompts Throughout this chapter, various discussion prompts have been provided for in-class use. These prompts are developed to assist you in starting open conversation with students about key topics of the chapter.

1 .


Chapter 1: Social Policy and the American Welfare State

Assignments and Activities These assignments and activities can be used in place of or in supplement of the online activities available for students.

Key Terms Each chapter provides a list of key terms or concepts that students should know.

Chapter Outline I.

Definitions of Social Welfare Policy (Discussion Prompt 1)

II.

Social Problems and Social Welfare Policy (Discussion Prompt 2 and Out-of-Class Assignment 1)

III.

Social Work and Social Policy (In-Class Activity 4)

IV.

Values, Ideology, and Social Welfare Policy (Discussion Prompt 3)

V.

The Political Economy of American Social Welfare (Out-of-Class Assignment 4)

VI.

The U.S. Economic Continuum (Discussion Prompt 4)

VII.

Keynesian Economics (In-Class Activity 3)

VIII.

Conservative or Free Market economics

IX.

Democratic Socialism

X.

The U.S. Political Continuum (In-Class Activities 1 and 2)

XI.

Liberalism and Left-of-Center Movements (Out-of-Class Assignment 2) a. Liberalism b. Neoliberalism c.

XII.

Self-Reliance School

Classical Conservatives and the Far Right (Out-of-Class Assignment 3) a. Classic conservatism b. Neoconservatism c.

Cultural and Social Conservatism

d. Libertarianism XIII.

The Growth of Fringe Groups (Discussion Prompt 5)

XIV.

The Welfare Philosophers and Neoconservative Think Tanks

XV.

Conclusion

KEY TERMS 1. Capitalism 2. Case management 3. Democratic capitalism 4. Democratic socialism 5. Governmental sector 6. Gross domestic product (G DP) 7. Human capital 8. Ideology 9. In-kind benefits 10. Keynesian economics 2 .


Chapter 1: Social Policy and the American Welfare State

11. Mixed welfare economy 12. Neoliberalism 13. Political economy 14. Public choice school 15. Self-reliance school 16. Social services 17. Social justice 18. Social policy 19. Social welfare policy 20. Socialism 21. Supply-side economics 22. Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (T A NF) 23. Think tanks 24. Welfare state

DISCUSSION PROMPTS 1. Since social welfare is a mechanism for redistributing resources from those in a society who have assets to those who do not, under what conditions do you think that social welfare is justifiable. Identify categories of people that you believe society should assist and categories of people that society should not assist. How do these groups of people differ? How are they alike? 2. What are the strengths and the weaknesses of the mixed welfare economy of the United States? Government agencies, for-profit corporations, and not-for-profit corporations all provide some social services. Identify the strengths and weaknesses of each with attention to the primary sources of revenue, potential for innovation, and capacity to respond to changing social problems. 3. What is the political ideology of one of your favorite family members? Describe how that person feels about a free market economy. Does your family member tend to believe that government is the solution or the problem? What does your family member think causes poverty? Would they prefer that people who are economically disadvantaged solve their own problems, or that our society give people a little more help? Where do you think your family member sit on the U. S. political continuum? 4. What are the advantages to a free market economy in comparison to an economy in which the government is more active? Unrestrained capitalism tends to increase economic disparities between rich and poor, but may offer more opportunity for some to succeed. Which is more important, opportunity or equality? Why? 5. As your text identifies, the United States has seen an increase in the presence of fringe groups both in social media and real, day-to-day experiences for people. Why do you think this has happened? Do you see these groups having an impact on your life and world? Why or why not?

IN-CLASS ACTIVITIES 1. The Politics of the President. Divide students into teams of 3–4 students and have them recreate the U. S. Political Continuum (pp. 12–18) with seven columns from Liberalism to Libertarianism. Teams should brainstorm at least 10 different policy proposals advanced during the current President’s administration and locate them within the appropriate column to identify the political orientation of the President. Share answers in class after teams are finished. 2. Examining the Political Spectrum. Chapter 1 introduces social welfare policy, and examines both economic and political continuums. Educations are able to create a group quiz by scrolling down the page at the Pew Research Center “Political Typology Quiz.” Once created, students can compare their own place on the continuum with their peers in the class. Ask students to examine their results, and be prepared to participate in a class discussion about those results, and the sources of their political ideologies. Link: https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/quiz/politicaltypology/ 3 .


Chapter 1: Social Policy and the American Welfare State

3. Liberal vs. Conservative Economic Views of Social Welfare. Watch the YouTube video for an entertaining contrast of Keynes’ and Hayek’s viewpoints titled “Fear the Boom and Bust: Keynes vs. Hayek Rap Battle.” Use the video to illustrate and discuss these different perspectives. Link: https://youtu.be/d0nERTFo-Sk 4. Social Work and Policy. Take a look at the website of the National Association of Social Workers, and read through some of the advocacy and legislative issues links. Where would you place the NA S W along the U.S. political continuum? How do your own values and beliefs about policy issues put you in line with social work as a profession, and where do they deviate? Link: https://www.socialworkers.org/Advocacy

OUT-OF-CLASS ASSIGNMENTS 1. Self-Reflection Exercise. Students write a one-page paper in class with the following prompt, “I believe that social welfare programs in the United States should be expanded (or restricted) because . . . .” On the back of the page, students should identify at least five groups of people that will benefit from the implementation of this proposal and at least five groups who will be penalized from the implementation of this proposal. 2. The Politics of the Republican or Democratic Party. Students should access the website for the Republican Party or the Democratic Party. Have them review the materials available at the website. Compare the assigned party’s positions on contemporary issues to the Liberal to Libertarian political continuum discussed in the text and write a 2–3-page paper identifying the political ideology or ideologies of the assigned party. 3. Media and Political Ideology. Watch at least one hour on one of the cable news channels that you do not regularly watch (e.g., Fox News Channel, M S N BC, CN B C, Headline News, or C NN). Write a 2–3-page paper reflecting on the economic and/or political perspective of the commentators. Did they appear slanted toward any specific political or economic perspective? Was an effort made to present both sides of ideological issues? Compare this news source to the news source that you customarily prefer. Were there any significant differences? 4. Richard Wilkinson: How Economic Inequality Harms Societies. Watch the T ED video titled “How Economic Inequality Harms Societies.” Write a 2–3-page paper reflecting on the economic system in the United States. How might the U. S. economy support economic inequality? If you wanted to decrease the economic inequality in the United States, what changes might you suggest?

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES Books Barber, B. R. (2007). Consumed: How markets corrupt children, infantilize adults, and swallow citizens whole. New York: W. W. Norton & Company. Harvey, D. (2007) A brief history of neoliberalism. New York: Oxford University Press. Haynes, K. S. and Mickelson, S. (2006). Affecting change: Social workers in the political arena. New York: Longman. Krugman, P. (2009). The return of depression economics and the crisis of 2008. New York: W. W. Norton & Company. Lane, S. & Pritzker, S. (2018). Consider yourself asked: Introduction to political social work. Political Social Work: Using Power to Create Social Change. (pp. 3–21) Lane, S.R., Ostrander, J., Rhodes Smith, T. (2017). ‘Politics is social work with power’: Training social workers for elected office. Social Work Education, 37, 1–16. McClelland, P. D., & Tobin, P. H. (2010). American dream dying: The changing economic lot of the least advantaged. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. Mizrahi, T., & Davis, L. E. (2008). Encyclopedia of social work (20th ed.). Washington, D C; Oxford, UK; New York, NY: NASW Press and Oxford University Press. Popple, P. R., & Leighninger, L. (2019). The policy-based profession: An introduction to social welfare policy analysis for social workers (7th ed.). Pearson Education. 4 .


Chapter 1: Social Policy and the American Welfare State

Rome, S. H., & Hoechstetter, S. (2010). Social work and civic engagement: the political participation of professional social workers. Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare, 37(3), 107–129. Stern, M. J., & Axinn, J. (2018). Social welfare: A history of the American response to need (9th ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson Education.

Journals, Articles, Videos, and Podcasts Andrew Marantz, “The Anti-Coup,” The New Yorker, Nov. 23, 2020. Esposito, L., & Perez, F. (2014). Neoliberalism and the commodification of mental health. Humanity and Society, 38(4), 414–442. Gray, M., Dean, M., Agllias, K., Howard, A., & Schubert, L. (2015). Perspectives on Neoliberalism for Human Service Professionals. Social Service Review, 89(2), 368–392. Hacker, J. (2005). Bringing the welfare state back in: The promise (and perils) of the new social welfare history. The Journal of Policy History, 17(1), 125–151. Hanauer, A. (2015, May 15). The Influence of Policy. Retrieved from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iBRxl3Klhj0 Helleiner, E. (2011). Understanding the 2007–2008 global financial crisis: Lessons for scholars of international political economy. Annual Review of Political Science, 14(1), 67–87. Rosenwald, M., Weiner, D. R., Smith-Osborne, A., & Smith, C. M. (2012). The place of political diversity within the social work classroom. Journal of Social Work Education, 48(1), 139–158. Sabeel Rahman, K. (2011). Conceptualizing the economic role of the state: Laissez-faire, technocracy, and the democratic alternative. Polity, 43(2), 264–286. Strier, R. (2013). Responding to the global economic crisis: Inclusive social work practice. Social Work, 58(4), 344–353.

Websites American Solidarity Party—https://www.solidarity-party.org/ •

A newer political party, established in 2011.

Congressional Research Institute for Social Work and Social Policy—https://crispinc.org/ •

An independent, nonpartisan group that works to expand the participation of social workers in federal legislative and policy processes.

Constitution Party—https://constitutionparty.com/ •

One of the three largest third party organizations in the United States, this website provides information and background on the party since its creation in 1992.

Democratic Party—https://democrats.org/ •

This is the primary website for the national Democratic Party with links to policy statements, key people on the national and state level, and additional information about party organization and constituents.

Economic Policy Institute—https://www.epi.org/ •

This is the website for the Economic Policy Institute, a non-profit and nonpartisan think tank that conducts research and proposes policies that focus on the needs of low- and middleincome people.

Green Party—https://www.gp.org/ •

This is the primary website for the Green Party in the United States, and provides information on the party’s current and historical activities, since its founding in 1984.

Libertarian Party—https://www.lp.org/ •

This is the official website to the Libertarian Party, and provides information on the party’s platform and leadership. 5 .


Chapter 1: Social Policy and the American Welfare State

Republican National Committee—https://www.gop.com/ •

This is the primary website for the national Republican Party with links to state parties, news events, and social issues of interest to the G O P.

White House—https://www.whitehouse.gov/ •

This is the primary website for the President of the United States where videos of recent speeches and briefings can be located along with specific information of political issues.

6 .


Chapter 2: The Origins of American Social Welfare

Chapter 2: The Origins of American Social Welfare Chapter Summary This chapter examines the historical antecedents of the American social welfare state, examining the early institutions that addressed human needs. The influence of Judeo Christian charity customs is examined, as well as the English Poor Laws which served as an early model for much of American social welfare. These influential eras of social welfare development—colonial America, the Civil War, Progressivism, the Great Depression, Post-World War II, the Great Society—are linked to modern welfare state. The roles of industrialization and the voluntary sector are also examined. Early social welfare leaders who emerged throughout the 19th and 20th centuries created structures that would advance social justice in America, create models for social welfare responses, and champion causes to improve conditions for people.

STUDENT LEARNING OBJECTIVES •

Students will understand how the English Poor Laws are reflected in modern social welfare.

•

Students will describe the legacy of social welfare policies from historically significant eras.

•

Students will examine religion’s important role in developing the social work profession.

•

Students will be able to identify the differences and similarities between Charity Organization Societies and the Settlement House movement.

•

Students will name key leaders in social work, and identify their accomplishments.

TEACHING TIPS •

Students benefit from seeing the “big picture” of how the elements of social welfare history combine together to form the puzzle of understanding present day values and policies. Emphasize the connection of these pieces as part of the whole.

•

It is useful for students to connect how historical events played an important role in the development in their own values, as well as those within social welfare.

•

When students feel disconnected from the “real life” application of events decades and centuries ago. Help students consider personal experiences and real world examples of where the values of the past are connected into their present day lives.

LECTURE GUIDE AND ASSET CORRELATION The below lecture guide and asset correlation indicates where discussion prompts, assignments, activities or online activities connect to a given topic. The full descriptions of these prompts and assignments follow the below guide.

Discussion Prompts Throughout this chapter, various discussion prompts have been provided for in-class use. These prompts are developed to assist you in starting open conversation with students about key topics of the chapter.

Assignments and Activities These assignments and activities can be used in place of or in supplement of the online activities available for students.

Key Terms Each chapter provides a list of key terms or concepts that students should know.

7 .


Chapter 2: The Origins of American Social Welfare

Chapter Outline I.

Early Antecedents of Welfare Statism (Discussion Prompt 1) a. Judeo-Christian Doctrine and Social Welfare (In-Class Activity 1)

II.

The English Poor Laws (Discussion Prompt 2)

III.

The Poor in Colonial America (Out-of-Class Assignment 1)

IV.

Social Welfare in the Civil War Era (Out-of-Class Assignment 2)

V.

Industrialization and the Voluntary Sector a. Social Darwinism (Discussion Prompt 3) b. Religion and Social Welfare (Out-of-Class Assignment 4) c.

Charity Organization Societies

d. Settlement Houses e. Black American Associations f.

The Social Casework Agency

g. The Progressive Movement VI.

The Great Depression and the Modern Welfare State (Out-of-Class Assignment 3)

VII.

The Post-World War II Welfare State

VIII.

The Languishing Social Welfare State (Discussion Prompt 4)

IX.

Conclusion: Social Work's Leadership in Social Welfare (In-Class Activity 2)

KEY TERMS 1. Elizabethan Poor Laws 2. Great Society 3. New Deal 4. Office of Economic Opportunity 5. Settlement houses 6. Social Darwinism 7. Social welfare functions

DISCUSSION PROMPTS 1. What was the historical role of the social work profession in social welfare policy development? 2. Is contemporary society inconsistent with the Protestant work ethic? Answers should include discussion of the theological, moral, and contextual factors that made the colonial period such a good setting for this work ethic. 3. How has the impact of Social Darwinism continued to impact social welfare in America? Answers could reflect on “blame the victim” orientation toward those experience poverty and focus on personal morality, rather than economic justice, by the religious right. 4. How have the values and ethics of the social work profession evolved since its inception?

IN-CLASS ACTIVITIES 1. Timeline Development. Create groups in class to create a timeline of significant religious events that have influenced social welfare policy. If possible, distribute poster paper so that timelines can be large enough to be posted on the classroom walls. Have each group discuss their timeline including why these specific events were considered most important to them. This could also be done digitally through Flipgrid, with peer replies.

8 .


Chapter 2: The Origins of American Social Welfare

2. Major Social Welfare Issues of Today. As a group, reflect on one or more major social welfare issues facing our society today. Where do these issues come from? What are their historical roots?

OUT-OF-CLASS ASSIGNMENTS 1. Create a Digital Timeline. If students do not create a timeline in class, have them go to an online timeline website, such as the one at “Read Write Think” (http://interactives.readwritethink.org/timeline). This one is easy to use and free, and you simply insert your information and it creates the timeline for you from the info. Have students create a timeline with a particular historical era described in the chapter, providing a brief overview of the key elements of that era and how it was important to social work & social welfare, or present these orally to the class. 2. Visit The Social Welfare History Project. Visit the Social Welfare History Project at V CU Libraries to research different periods in American social welfare history. Students can click on the different eras and find a plethora of articles about the historical periods of their choosing. Have students research a particular era or social problem history, and report back to the class on their findings. Link: https://socialwelfare.library.vcu.edu/ 3. Fireside Chats. Choose one of the Fireside Chats listed at the American Presidency Project website. Draw parallels between the Great Depression Era and today. Contrast the response of government during the Great Depression and the current administration. Link: https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/presidential-documents-archive-guidebook/firesidechats-f-roosevelt 4. Self-Reflection: Religious Motivations for Social Work. The Encyclical Letter of Pope Benedict XVI called “Deus Caritas Est” may be considered an example of a traditional Christian argument for social welfare. How is the religious concept charity related to your personal interest in helping others? Is the promotion of social justice, as described in this document, too restrictive? What is the role for people in the support and promotion of social justice? Write a two-page paper with your answers.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES Books Addams, J. (1938). Twenty years at Hull House: With autobiographical notes. New York: Macmillan. Axinn, J. J., & Stern, M. J. (2007). Social welfare: A history of the American response to need. Boston: Allyn & Bacon. Blau, J., & Abramovitz, M. (2014). Chapter 6: Social movements and social change. In The dynamics of social welfare policy. New York: Oxford University Press. Day, P. J. (2009). A New History of Social Welfare 6th Edition, Boston, Allyn & Bacon. Dionne, Jr., E. J. (2010). Souled out: Reclaiming faith and politics after the religious right. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Gushee, D. P. (2008). The future of faith in American politics: The public witness of the evangelical center. Waco, TX: University of Baylor Press. Katz, M. B. (1996). In the shadow of the poorhouse: A social history of welfare in America. New York: Basic Books. Reisch, M., & Andrews, J. (2002). The road not taken: A history of radical social work in the United States. New York: Routledge. Russell, J. W. (2006). Double standard: Social policy in Europe and the United States (pp. 43–52). Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield. Stern, H., & Axinn, J. (2012). Social Welfare: A History of the American Response to Need. (8th Edition). Pearson. Trattner, Walter (1999). From Poor Law to Welfare State, Sixth Edition. New York: Free Press. 9 .


Chapter 2: The Origins of American Social Welfare

Journals, Articles, Videos, and Podcasts Belcher, J. R., & Tice, C. J. (2011). Protestant church charity: History, trends, and implications. Journal of Religion & Spirituality in Social Work, 30, 164–177. Cannon, L. (2017, July 11). Ronald Reagan: Impact and legacy. Miller Center, University of Virginia. https://millercenter.org/president/reagan/impact-and-legacy Council on Social Work Education. (2021, Feb 19). Dr. Iris Carlton-LaNey Presents on the Contributions of Black Icons [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/yZa-UXhAai4 Faherty, V. E. (2006). Social welfare before the Elizabethan Poor Laws: The early Christian tradition, AD 33-313. Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare, 33, 107–122. Lowe, T. B. (2006). Nineteenth Century Review of Mental Health Care for African Americans: A Legacy of Service and Policy Barriers, Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare, 33(4), 29–50. Reagan Foundation. (2011, August 3). President Reagan's Address to the Nation on the Campaign Against Drug Abuse [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/Gj8gAQ_cQ7Q Schottland, Charles (1987). Wilbur Joseph Cohen: Some Recollections. Social Work, 32(5), 371–372. Shields, J. A. (2011). Framing the Christian right: How progressives and post-war liberals constructed the religious right. Journal of Church and State, 53, 635–655.

Websites Hull House Museum—https://www.hullhousemuseum.org/ •

Explore this site for more information about Hull House and early work within the Chicago community.

Jane Addams Digital Edition—https://digital.janeaddams.ramapo.edu/ •

Collections of Jane Addams’s papers, digitalized.

NASW National Association of Social Workers—https://www.socialworkers.org/ •

Provides further descriptions of pioneers in the social work profession and their contributions.

National Women’s History Museum—https://www.womenshistory.org/ •

An extensive web collection on "Reforming Their World: Women in the Progressive Era".

Portrait of America: Survey Graphics in the Thirties— https://xroads.virginia.edu/~MA01/Davis/survey/home.html •

With its emphasis on the New Deal, this site features selected Survey Graphic articles from the 1930s and a bibliography of related books and journal articles for further reading.

Social Welfare History Project, V CU Libraries—https://socialwelfare.library.vcu.edu/ •

The website to help the public understand and appreciate the history of social reform and social welfare services that have strengthened the fabric of American society.

10 .


Chapter 3: Social Welfare Policy Research

Chapter 3: Social Welfare Policy Research CHAPTER SUMMARY Policy analysts engage in the systematic investigation of a social policy or a set of policies. They are employed in a variety of settings, including federal, state, and local governments; think tanks; universities; social justice or public interest groups or community organizations; and larger social agencies. The goals of policy analysis can range from pure research to providing information to legislators (i.e., congressional researchers) and to advocacy research. This chapter examines one of the major tools used by the policy researcher, a systematic and structured framework for policy analysis. The authors also propose a model for policy analysis.

STUDENT LEARNING OBJECTIVES • • • • •

Students will understand the usefulness of a framework for policy analysis. Students will analyze the factors contributing to the viability of a policy proposal. Students will explore how to determine the feasibility of a policy proposal. Students will gain exposure to a variety of resources critical to policy analysis. Students will learn to identify and utilize the elements in a policy analysis framework.

TEACHING TIPS •

Emphasize the importance of following the model provided and of including all elements.

•

It is useful for students to be exposed to policy briefs from the various U.S. governmental agencies, from the UN, World Bank, or other organizations that produce two-page policy briefs. This helps students visualize policy analysis.

•

Have students identify the policy analysis elements in the policy briefs they identify.

•

Students benefit from analyzing very simple policy, such as their personal policy for health and safety. This contextualizes the process of policy analysis itself.

•

Talk about policy analysis as a narrative that tells the story of policy. It is the evidence that is presented within this story that leads to critical thinking with analysis and recommendations.

LECTURE GUIDE AND ASSET CORRELATION The below lecture guide and asset correlation indicates where discussion prompts, assignments, activities or online activities connect to a given topic. The full descriptions of these prompts and assignments follow the below guide.

Discussion Prompts Throughout this chapter, various discussion prompts have been provided for in-class use. These prompts are developed to assist you in starting open conversation with students about key topics of the chapter.

Assignments and Activities These assignments and activities can be used in place of or in supplement of the online activities available for students.

Key Terms Each chapter provides a list of key terms or concepts that students should know.

Chapter Outline I.

Introduction (Out-of-Class Assignment 1)

II.

A Proposed Model for Policy Analysis (Discussion Prompt 1)

III.

Historical Background of the Policy (Discussion Prompt 2) 11 .


Chapter 3: Social Welfare Policy Research

IV.

Problems That Necessitate the Policy (In-Class Activity 1)

V.

Policy Description

VI.

Policy Analysis (Out-of-Class Assignment 2, In-Class Activity 2) a. Policy Goals b. Political Feasibility c.

Economic Feasibility

d. Administrative Feasibility VII.

Researching and Analyzing a Social Policy Assignment (In-Class Activity 3, Discussion Prompts 3 and 4)

VIII.

Social Policy Research and the Internet (Out-of-Class Assignment 3, Discussion Prompt 5)

IX.

Conclusion

KEY TERMS 1. Effectiveness 2. Efficiency 3. Pay-go financing 4. Policy framework 5. Social Science Index

DISCUSSION PROMPTS 1. Why is a framework for policy analysis important? Answers should include discussion of the mission and goals of the welfare state, the key values of social welfare, and historical precedents associated with the policy. 2. What are the key elements of policy frameworks? The eight key elements are noted on pages 53 of the text. Additional critical thinking might be developed in identifying the ways in which these elements are highly rational and systematic and therefore somewhat incompatible with the political process through which policies are actually adopted. Utilize Spotlight 3.1 in your textbook to help you discuss this in class. 3. What might be some of the unintended consequences of legalizing marijuana in the United States? Discussion of this question should be used to highlight the difficulties involved in identifying all of the consequences that might be associated with adopting a policy change. 4. What are the three ways in which a systematic analysis of a social policy should be tested for feasibility? Class discussion should focus on the challenges associated with identifying all of the political, economic, and administrative factors influencing feasibility. 5. What are the strengths and weakness of the primary sources of information for policy analysis? The sources of information identified on page 56–58 should be identified and critiqued through class discussion.

IN-CLASS ACTIVITIES 1) Welfare State Mission and Goals. The authors propose that the policy framework is useful to policy analysts in assessing the consistency between a social policy and its mission/goals. Divide the class into groups of 4–5 students to discuss these questions: How would you define the mission and goals of the American welfare state? Is there any difference in the understanding of the mission and goals of the American welfare state between conservatives and progressives? What are the strengths and weaknesses of each position? Which position seems most persuasive to you? Have each group present their findings in class for discussion. 2) Policy-Making as a Political Process. The eight key elements included in well-designed policy frameworks assume that policy analysis is a rational and systematic process, but in practice, policies are most frequently developed through a political process. Create groups in the class to brainstorm the potential differences between rational policy-making and policy-making as a 12 .


Chapter 3: Social Welfare Policy Research

political process. Have teams share their ideas and write them on the board. The instructor may usefully identify aspects of the political processes that will be discussed in Chapter 8. 3) Self-Reflection Writing Prompt. Have the students imagine that they are new employees at a nonprofit agency providing social services. After working a couple of weeks, they notice that some potential clients seem to be denied services for reasons that appear a bit questionable. In a onepage paper, describe the information would you might need to be able to assess the political feasibility, the economic feasibility, and the administrative feasibility of proposing a change to client intake?

OUT-OF-CLASS ASSIGNMENTS 1) Podcast Analysis. Podcasts have become enormously popular, and now you can find links to podcasts for even most major newspapers, such as the New York Times, Washington Post, and LA Times. For this assignment, use your Internet search engine to locate a conservative podcast (the Dan Bongino Show, Heritage Explains) and a liberal podcast (e.g., FiveThirtyEight, Pod Save America). Why do you think these have become so popular? What role do they appear to be playing in policy analysis? How does the policy analysis role of podcasters differ from that of think tanks? Write a two-page paper with your answers to these questions. 2) Ideologies and Policy Analysis. The Brookings Institution and the Cato Institute are two influential policy research think tanks that often take different views on specific social problems. Access these websites and compare the materials provided by each think tank on the research topic of your choice. How would you describe the different frameworks through which the problem is approached? Does one appear to support a particular ideological perspective more than the other? Which seems to consider the policy analysis with more sensitivity to prior history on the issue? Which would you access first when looking for new information? Why? Write a two-page paper with your answers. 3) Self-reflection: Framework for Policy Analysis. Look carefully at Figure 3.1 on page 52 that diagrams the authors’ framework for policy analysis. From your perspective, which portion of this framework is the most relevant to social work policy practice? Which portion seems least relevant to you? Is there anything that you think is missing? Write your answers in a two-page paper.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES Books Boardman, A., Greenberg, D., Vining, A., & Weimer, D. (2011). Cost-benefit analysis. New York: Pearson Longman Publishing. Lewis, M., & Widerquist, K. (2002). Economics for social workers. New York: Columbia University Press. Meenaghan, R. M., Kilty, K. M., & McNutt, J. G. (2004). Social policy analysis and practice. Chicago: Lyceum Books, Inc. Popple, P. R., & Leighnenger, L. L. (2011). The policy-based profession: An introduction to social welfare policy analysis for social workers. Boston: Pearson Education, Inc. Stoesz, D. (2005). Quixote’s ghost: The Right, the Liberati, and the future of social policy. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Weimer, D., & Vining, A. R. (2011). Policy analysis: Concepts and practice. New York: Pearson Longman Publishing.

Journals, Articles, and Podcasts Daguerre, A. (2011). U S social policy in the 21st century: The difficulties of comprehensive social reform. Social Policy & Administration, 45, 389–407. Edes, A., & Bowman, E. (2018, February 19). 'Automating Inequality': Algorithms In Public Services Often Fail The Most Vulnerable. https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2018/02/19/586387119/automating-inequalityalgorithms-in-public-services-often-fail-the-most-vulnerab 13 .


Chapter 3: Social Welfare Policy Research

James, T.E., & Jorgensen, P.D. (2009). Policy knowledge, policy formation, and change: Revisiting a foundational question. Policy Studies Journal, 37, 141–162. Lee, S., & Aos. S. (2011). Using cost-benefit analysis to understand the value of social interventions. Research on Social Work Practice, 21, 682–688. McNutt, J. (2011). Is social work advocacy worth the cost? Issues and barriers to an economic analysis of social work political practice. Research on Social Work Practice, 21, 397–403. O’Connor, M. K., & Netting, F. E. (2008). Teaching policy analysis as research: Consideration and extension of options. Journal of Social Work Education, 44, 159–172.

Websites Association for Public Policy Analysis & Management—https://www.appam.org/ •

The website for A P P A M, a professional organization focused on improving public policy analysis and management.

Council on Social Work Education—https://www.cswe.org/ •

The website of C S W E contains information of public policy initiatives of the largest professional organization of social work educators in the United States.

Evidence-Based Policymaking Resource Center—https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-andanalysis/articles/2018/12/18/evidence-based-policymaking-resource-center •

The Pew Charitable Trusts’ collection of evidence-based policy-making resources.

GCS W Policy Briefs—https://csd.wustl.edu/grand-challenges-for-social-work-policy-briefs/ •

Policy briefs were developed by members of the Grand Challenges networks for the 2016 Social Innovation for America’s Renewal. Policy briefs continue to be written and are available by searching for “policy recommendations” in Publications.

National Institute for Research Advancement—https://english.nira.or.jp/ •

The website for the N IR A contains a searchable database of think tanks worldwide.

National Association of Social Workers—https://www.socialworkers.org/ •

The website for the N A S W contains links to policy research pages for the largest professional organization of social workers in the United States.

14 .


Chapter 4: Discrimination and Stigma in American Society

Chapter 4: Discrimination and Stigma in American Society CHAPTER SUMMARY Discrimination occurs in virtually all countries, and spans the spectrum from moderate to severe. Forms of discrimination include (1) religious, (2) gender, (3) sexual orientation, (4) national origin, culture or tribal, (5) racial (including “colorism” based on the skin tones), (6) class and caste, (7) political, and (8) personal characteristics such as disability, age, and appearance. Discrimination and poverty are inextricably linked to the fabric of American social welfare. Economic, social, and political discrimination often leads to poverty, which in turn, results in the need for income maintenance and other social programs. Realizing that discrimination leads to poverty, some policymakers have tried to address this cycle by attacking discrimination. These policymakers hope that if discriminatory practices and attitudes are curtailed, the result will be equal opportunities for achievement and success. This chapter probes discrimination based on race, gender, sexual orientation, disability, and age.

STUDENT LEARNING OBJECTIVES •

Students will understand the consequences of various forms of discrimination on the welfare of the victims.

•

Students will apply the various theories of discrimination in relation to the contemporary welfare and poverty status of various underrepresented groups in the United States.

•

Students will critique the effectiveness of legal attempts to rectify the consequences of discrimination.

TEACHING TIPS •

Students may not be aware that discrimination takes many forms. It is important to be as inclusive as possible. Students themselves are excellent sources of information, and can be their own best experts on subject material.

•

Ask students about their own experiences with discrimination. Make sure students understand this is completely voluntary. Students may also be sources of great insight in addressing discrimination.

•

It is important to ensure that the content of the chapter is connected to social work values and ethics. Nondiscrimination, as well as anti-racism, is a hallmark value of the profession, and this fact cannot be overstated to students.

•

Whenever possible, encourage your students to expose themselves to different communities and people. Encourage them to go outside their comfort zones and visit different temples, cultural events from a variety of communities, L GB TQI A events, nursing homes and senior centers, centers for people who are disabled, and in general, communities and events that are different from their own experience. Encourage your students to reflect upon these experiences and to share them with their classmates. Students may often have a wealth of knowledge of what is happening within the campus and surrounding community, and can share social media links, pages, resources, and more.

LECTURE GUIDE AND ASSET CORRELATION The below lecture guide and asset correlation indicates where discussion prompts, assignments, activities or online activities connect to a given topic. The full descriptions of these prompts and assignments follow the below guide.

Discussion Prompts Throughout this chapter, various discussion prompts have been provided for in-class use. These prompts are developed to assist you in starting open conversation with students about key topics of the chapter. 15 .


Chapter 4: Discrimination and Stigma in American Society

Assignments and Activities These assignments and activities can be used in place of or in supplement of the online activities available for students.

Key Terms Each chapter provides a list of key terms or concepts that students should know.

Chapter Outline I.

Discrimination (In-Class Activity 1)

II.

Racism (Discussion Prompt 1)

III.

Race and the Middle Class

IV.

Black Americans (Discussion Prompt 2) a. The Demography of Black Americans b. Black Americans in Poverty c.

The “Diswelfare” of Black Americans (Out-of-Class Assignment 1) i. Poverty ii. Family structure iii. Labor force participation and income iv. Crime v. Housing vi. Health vii. Education

V.

Hispanic or Latino Americans a. Hispanic Poverty and Income

VI.

American Indians and Native Alaskans

VII.

Asian Americans (Discussion Prompt 3)

VIII.

Immigrants and Immigration (In-Class Activity 2)

IX.

Immigration-Based Discrimination in Europe

X.

Women and Society a. Violence and Sexual Harassment b. The Feminization of Poverty c.

Myths around Women and Work

d. Income and Job Disparities between Men and Women e. Day Care and Material Leaves: Barriers to Female Employment f.

Other Obstacles Faced by Working Women (Discussion Prompt 4)

g. Women’s Reproductive Health h. Gender Discrimination and Violence in an International Context XI.

LGB TQI A+ Populations at Risk a. LGB TQI A + Rights b. Gays and Lesbians in the Military c.

LGB TQI A + Family Life

d. Homophobia XII.

Ageism (Discussion Prompt 5) 16 .


Chapter 4: Discrimination and Stigma in American Society

a. Elderly Poverty and Social Programs b. Health Care and the Elderly c.

COVID-19

XIII.

People with Disabilities

XIV.

Legal Attempts to Remedy Discrimination (Out-of-Class Assignment 3) a. Desegregation and the Civil Rights Movement b. Affirmative Action (In-Class Activity 3)

XV.

Conclusion

KEY TERMS 1. Affirmative action 2. Comparable worth 3. DA CA 4. De facto segregation 5. Dual labor market 6. Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 7. Institutional racism 8. Mortality rate 9. Occupational segregation 10. Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (P R W OR A) 11. Public transfer programs 12. White privilege

DISCUSSION PROMPTS 1. Why do you think may be causes of racism? Have attempts to address racism worked? Why or why not? 2. What is the meaning of the phrase “diswelfare” in relation to Black Americans? Answers should address the variety of statistical disparities reported in the chapter. 3. How is treating someone like a “model minority” person an act of discrimination? Answers should focus on the resulting disparity in expectations between “model minorities” and the rest of American society. Utilize Spotlight 4.1 on page 65 to assist you with class discussion. 4. In what ways have highly educated White women become the primary beneficiaries of the civil rights movement? Answers should focus on expansion of career options and legislation related to comparable worth, educational opportunities, and access to credit. 5. How does ageism compare and contrast with other forms of discrimination? Answers should focus on the inevitability of aging for everyone and the physical and mental limitations that accompany aging.

IN-CLASS ACTIVITIES 1. Causes of Discrimination. Create small teams of 4–5 students. Ask them to come to class with a current news article, personal experience, YouTube video, meme, social media post, etc. that appears to exemplify at least one of the seven forms of discrimination listed in Chapter 4. They will share this with your team in as much detail as possible, and provide a link to it, if online. Ask them to choose one or two to examine with the theories that have been proposed to explain discrimination (pp. 62–63). Have each group attempt to explain what they believe the cause of 17 .


Chapter 4: Discrimination and Stigma in American Society

discrimination may be, in light of that specific theory and if there is time, ask them to report their findings to the larger class group. 2. Immigration Debate. Divide the class into an even number of groups and have them look at the immigration information provided in the textbook (pp. 72–77). Assign pairs of teams to prepare for an in-class debate on one of the following statements (Flip a coin to assign pro/con sides for each pair and allow three-minute debates): a. Immigration to the United States should be encouraged by federal policies. b. Immigration to the United States should be discouraged by federal policies. c. Immigrants should have the same civil and employment rights as anyone else in America. d. Undocumented immigrants should have the same civil and employment rights as anyone else in America. 3. Affirmative Action Debate. Divide the class into an even number of groups and have them look at the affirmative action information provided in the textbook. Assign pairs of teams to prepare for an in-class debate on one of the following statements. Flip a coin to assign pro/con sides for each pair and allow three-minute debates): a. Affirmative action is a good means of correcting historical patterns of injustice. b. Affirmative action is harmful to the disadvantaged groups it seeks to assist. c. Affirmative action is a form of discrimination against society’s majority groups. d. Affirmative action should only be voluntary, not mandatory.

OUT-OF-CLASS ASSIGNMENTS 1. Black Lives Matter. In 2020, in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, uprisings and large protests broke out across the United States and around the world in response to police killing of George Floyd. The organization Black Lives Matter demanded and started a petition calling for the defunding of police across the United States. You can read it here at this link: https://blacklivesmatter.com/defundthepolice. Research and write a response explaining the motivation behind BLM’s call to defund the police, what defunding the police entails, and what it might mean for the Black community. 2. LGBTQI A+ Equity. How does equity for the L G BTQ+ community vary around the United States? Guide students to the site: http://www.lgbtmap.org/equality-maps. Ask them to prepare a brief single-page summary on an LG BTQ + equity issue of their choice based on the options available on the site. Instruct students that they should narrow their focus to be able to accommodate the parameters of the assignment and that they will give a brief presentation of their findings to the class. 3. Debate Online. Move your debates from in-class to online, by asking students to record their debate through a video conferencing platform like Zoom or Teams, and posting it on YouTube for the class to watch.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES Books Alexander, M. (2010). The new Jim Crow: Mass incarceration in the age of colorblindness. New York: The New Press. Garcia, R. (2012). Marginal workers: How legal fault lines divide workers and leave them without protection. New York: N YU Press. Gilreath, S. (2011). The end of straight supremacy: Realizing gay liberation. New York: Columbia University Press. Sullivan, L. et al. (2015). The racial wealth gap: Why policy matters. New York: Demos. Vos, K., & Bloemraad, I. (eds.). (2011). Rallying for immigrant rights: The fight for inclusion in 21st century America. Berkeley, C A: University of California Press. 18 .


Chapter 4: Discrimination and Stigma in American Society

Journals, Articles, Video, and Podcasts Aday, T. (2015). The effectiveness of the Violence against Women Act (V A W A) in creating systemlevel change. S PN H A Review, 11(1), 3. Benassi, D, & Morlicchio, E. (2019). “New Urban Poverty.” The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of Urban and Regional Studies. Edited by Anthony Orum, 2019. Carten, A. (2016, August 21). How racism has shaped welfare policy in America since 1935. https://theconversation.com/how-racism-has-shaped-welfare-policy-in-america-since-1935-63574 Engelbrecht, C. (2018, June 3). Fewer immigrants are reporting domestic abuse. Police blame fear of deportation. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/03/us/immigrants-houston-domestic-violence.html Jim Crow Stories: Personal Narratives. (n.d.) The Rise and Fall of Jim Crow: Jim Crow Stories. Retrieved December 15, 2021, from https://www.thirteen.org/wnet/jimcrow/stories_narratives.html Lee, E. (2017). The Clery Act on Campus: Status update and gender implications. New Directions for Community Colleges, 2017(179), 59–66. McKernan, S., Ratcliffe, C., Steuerle, C.E., Quakenbush, C, and Kalish, E. (2015, February). Nine Charts about Wealth Inequality in America (Updated). Urban Institute. https://apps.urban.org/features/wealth-inequality-charts/ NBC News Learn. (2020, May 1). Freedmen's Bureau [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/5B4cpiTYhWk Noyori-Corbett, C., & Moxley, D. (2017). A transnational feminist policy analysis of the Trafficking Victims Protection Act. International Journal of Social Welfare, 26(2), 107–115. Whittier, N. (2016). Carceral and intersectional feminism in congress: The Violence Against Women Act, discourse, and policy. Gender & Society, 30(5), 791–818. Wooten, S. C. (2017). Revealing a hidden curriculum of Black women’s erasure in sexual violence prevention policy. Gender & Education, 29(3), 405–417. https://doiorg.proxy.libraries.rutgers.edu/10.1080/09540253.2016.122501

Websites American Civil Liberties Union—https://www.aclu.org/ •

The website for the A C LU founded in 1920 is an association of attorneys who defend American civil liberties.

Human Rights Campaign—https://www.hrc.org •

The website for the H RC founded in 1980 and advocating for the civil rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgendered people.

National Association for the Advancement of Colored People—https://naacp.org •

The website for the N A AC P, founded in 1909, the N A AC P is the oldest civil right organization in America.

National Association of Black Social Workers—https://www.nabsw.org/ National Urban League—https://nul.org/ •

The website of the N U L founded Sullivan, L. et al. (2015). The racial wealth gap: Why policy matters. New York: Demos in 1910 to advocate for civil rights through economic empowerment.

UnidosUS (formerly the National Council of La Raza)—https://www.unidosus.org/ •

The website for this organization, founded in the 1960s to support the civil rights of Hispanic Americans.

19 .


Chapter 5: Poverty in America

Chapter 5: Poverty in America CHAPTER SUMMARY This chapter examines the characteristics of poverty in the United States, focusing particular attention on demographic aspects and ways of measuring poverty; family constitution and poverty; child poverty and elderly poverty; the urban and rural poor; and the connections between poverty and workrelated issues such as the minimum wage, structural unemployment, dual labor markets, job training programs, and the alternative financial sector or the fringe economy. Last, key strategies developed to combat poverty will be surveyed.

STUDENT LEARNING OBJECTIVES •

Students will understand the various explanations and theories of poverty in the United States.

•

Students will critically understand how and why poverty affects different demographics in the United States.

•

Students will critique the historical approaches to combat poverty.

•

Students will understand how the quasi-financial and financial institutions in the United States are increasing the financial burden of low-income and working poor.

TEACHING TIPS •

Experiential learning such as the apartment search exercise work well with students who have not experienced poverty in their own lives. Alternatively, students may try to budget for other needed goods and services, such as food (a healthy diet) or transportation on welfare or the minimum wage. Many students may have done a similar exercise in high school, but ask them to look through the lens of their current lives—college students, maybe with partners or families, living in a pandemic, etc.

•

Acknowledge that you understand that students may have experienced poverty in their lives—and may indeed still be experiencing poverty. The pandemic may be accentuating this reality even further, so be sensitive to this, as well. Consider bringing in campus resources for food assistance, housing, health services, and more, that students could benefit from knowing about.

•

Help your students explore websites such as the Census Bureau in class. Many sites aren’t user friendly, and students will feel more comfortable using them if they have been exposed to the sites in class.

•

It is important to keep in mind the racial and gendered aspects of poverty, and to integrate discrimination and oppression material into this chapter.

•

The social work profession is dedicated to promoting social and economic justice. Help your students connect the material in this chapter with this goal of our profession by explicitly bringing this to the students’ attention.

•

Students can be challenged at first to differentiate between poverty threshold and poverty guidelines, where they come from, and how they are determined. This chart can be helpful in understanding them further: https://aspe.hhs.gov/topics/poverty-economic-mobility/povertyguidelines/frequently-asked-questions-related-poverty-guidelines-poverty

LECTURE GUIDE AND ASSET CORRELATION The below lecture guide and asset correlation indicates where discussion prompts, assignments, activities or online activities connect to a given topic. The full descriptions of these prompts and assignments follow the below guide.

20 .


Chapter 5: Poverty in America

Discussion Prompts Throughout this chapter, various discussion prompts have been provided for in-class use. These prompts are developed to assist you in starting open conversation with students about key topics of the chapter.

Assignments and Activities These assignments and activities can be used in place of or in supplement of the online activities available for students.

Key Terms Each chapter provides a list of key terms or concepts that students should know.

Chapter Outline I.

Theories on Poverty (In-Class Activity 1) a. Culture of Poverty b. Eugenics and Poverty c.

The Progressive Understanding of Poverty (Out-of-Class Assignment 1)

II.

Who Makes Up the Poor? (Out-of-Class Assignment 2)

III.

Measuring Poverty (Out-of-Class Assignment 3)

IV.

Measuring the Depth of Poverty

V.

Families and Poverty

VI.

Child Support Enforcement (Discussion Prompt 1)

VII.

Children in Poverty

VIII.

Poverty and Older Adults

IX.

The Rural Poor (In-Class Activity 2)

X.

Poverty and the Economy a. The Changing Economy

XI.

Work and Poverty (Discussion Prompt 2) a. The Working Poor b. Why Are There Working Poor? c.

Underemployment and Unemployment

d. The Minimum Wage e. Strategies Developed to Combat Poverty f.

ID As

a. Three Approaches to Combat Poverty (Discussion Prompt 3) XII.

America’s Fringe Economy (Discussion Prompt 4)

XIII.

World Poverty

XIV.

Conclusion (Discussion Prompt 5)

KEY TERMS 1. Absolute poverty 2. Alleviative approach to poverty 21 .


Chapter 5: Poverty in America

3. Annual percentage rate (A PR) 4. Area poverty 5. Case poverty 6. Chronic unemployment 7. Culture of Poverty (C o P) 8. Curative approach to poverty 9. Cyclical unemployment 10. Discouraged workers 11. Flexicurity 12. Frictional unemployment 13. Fringe economy 14. Gig economy 15. Nongovernmental organizations (N G Os) 16. Poverty line 17. Preventive approach to poverty 18. Primary labor market 19. Relative poverty 20. Secondary labor market 21. Social wage 22. Structural unemployment 23. Underemployed 24. “Working poor”

DISCUSSION PROMPTS 1. How does child support enforcement resolve and exacerbate the problems of family poverty? Answers should move beyond the textbook to think of the impact of child support on the family that receives the payments as well as on the family that remits the payments. 2. Why are wages lower than a living wage permitted by law in the United States? Answers should focus on discussion of the beneficiaries of a low minimum wage, employment at will, and the existence of dual labor markets. 3. What are the strengths and weaknesses of the three approaches to combatting poverty— curative, alleviative, and preventative? Discussion should go beyond the textbook to discuss policy ideas that might really be curative, alleviative, and preventative. 4. What is predatory lending? Who could be particularly vulnerable because of the practices within this industry? Utilize Spotlight 5.4 on page 135 to extend your class discussion with the case scenario presented. 5. COVID-19 has had an impact on how people are able to support themselves in their day-to-day lives. Listen to this story together as a class, “COVID-19 Teaches Us a lot about differences in the disability community,” and ask students to reflect on the implications of the information presented. This can also lend itself to a strong asynchronous online discussion together with students on a class discussion board.

IN-CLASS ACTIVITIES 1. Theories of Poverty. Create groups in class to discuss the theories that are discussed in the textbook. Have each group select the theory that they think is most persuasive and to compile a list of reasons to support their choice. Have each group report to the class as a whole. 22 .


Chapter 5: Poverty in America

2. Rural Poverty. Create groups in class to discuss the differences between rural poverty and urban poverty. Have each group brainstorm ideas for solving poverty in each of these settings. Would all potential solutions work in both? What about in suburban areas? Have groups discuss together, and then share their ideas to the class as a whole. 3. Labor Markets and Poverty. Create groups to discuss the structural aspects of the U.S. labor market that work to sustain poverty. After discussion, have each student write a 1–2-page paper in class with this prompt, “It is unlikely that poverty can be eliminated in the U.S. until the labor markets are changed to . . . .”

OUT-OF-CLASS ASSIGNMENTS 1. Apartment Search. Using your local newspaper or Internet search engines, try to find an available apartment for single occupancy that would be affordable for someone in your place of residence working for minimum wage. Could you find somewhere to live? If you worked 40 hours a week and were willing to spend no more than 30 percent of your income on an apartment, how much would you have to make per hour to afford the lowest priced apartment that you could find? Bring the advertisement for the cheapest residence you could find to class along with your calculations. 2. Fringe Economic Services. Utilizing the U.S. Census Bureau website, identify two geographical areas near your school or residence that differ significantly based on income, rental costs, or ethnicity. With a partner, conduct a windshield tour of both neighborhoods counting the number of pawn shops, rent-to-own stores, check cashing services, and banks. Are alternative financial services more readily available in the lower- or higher-income neighborhood? How do you explain the difference, if there is any? Use your mobile phone to document the differences pictorially. 3. Supplemental Poverty Measure. Using an Internet search engine, access current information available on the Supplemental Poverty Measure (S P M) on the U.S. Census Bureau website. In what groups of Americans does the S P M seem to indicate a higher level of poverty than the poverty line? Is there any indication that some groups have a lower poverty rate using the SPM? Document your findings in a two-page paper. 4. Families and Poverty*. Direct students to play the poverty simulation game “Spent” from the Urban Ministries of Durham. Link: https://playspent.org/ Ask students to complete a couple of simulations, making different choices as they go.... what happens? Ask students to reflect on this experience with a 1–2-page paper, choosing at least three of these to consider in their writing: a. Did you make it through the month without running out of money? If you made it through the month without running out of money, how much longer do you think you could have made it under the conditions of the exercise? b. What surprised you about this exercise? What didn't? c.

How do your class text readings this week inform your understanding here?

d. What does a game like this get right about poverty, and/or what does it miss? e. Did you make any decisions that seemed wise at the time but which you later regretted? f.

Why might a simulation like this be important for social workers to experience?

*This activity can also be modified easily into an online discussion board, as well.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES Books Allard, S.W (2017). Places in need: The changing geography of poverty. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation. Edin, K.J., & Shaefer, H.L. (2015) $2.00 a Day: Living on Almost Nothing in America. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin, Harcourt. Rivlin, G. (2010). Broke, U SA: From pawnshops to Poverty, Inc. – How the working poor became big business. New York: Harper Business. 23 .


Chapter 5: Poverty in America

O’Connor, A. (2002). Poverty knowledge: Social science, social policy and the poor in twentiethcentury U.S. history. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Sherman, J. (2009). Those who work, those who don’t: Poverty, morality, and family in rural America. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Shipler, D. K. (2005). The working poor: Invisible in America. New York: Vintage Press. Journals, Articles, Videos, and Podcasts Huto, N., Waldfogel, J., Kaushal, N., & Garfinkel, I. (2011). Improving the measurement of poverty. Social Service Review, 85, 39–74. Karger, H. J. (2007). The “poverty tax” and America’s low income households. Families in Society, 88, 413–417. Rural Sociology, 72, 331–358. Kharas, H., & Dooley, M. (2021, June 2). Long-run impacts of COVID-19 on extreme poverty. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/future-development/2021/06/02/long-run-impacts-of-covid-19-onextreme-poverty/ Lichter, D. T., & Johnson, K. M. (2007). The changing spatial concentration of America’s rural poor population. McMasters School of Social Work Leadership Archive. (2020, September 3). British Poor Law Social Policy History and its Effects on Contemporary Policy Contexts. YouTube. British Poor Law Social Policy History and its Effect on Contemporary Policy Contexts - YouTube Sheffield, R. (n.d.). Air Conditioning, Cable T V, and an Xbox: What is Poverty in the United States Today? The Heritage Foundation. Retrieved November 30. 2021, from https://www.heritage.org/poverty-and-inequality/report/air-conditioning-cable-tv-and-xbox-whatpoverty-the-united-states Tortajada, C. (2016). Nongovernmental Organizations and Influence on Global Public Policy. Asia & the Pacific Policy Studies, 3(2).

Websites Center for Poverty Research—https://poverty.ucdavis.edu/ •

The website for the federally funded poverty research institute at University of California, Davis.

Institute for Research on Policy—https://www.ipr.northwestern.edu/ •

The website for the federally funded poverty research institute at the University of Wisconsin.

National Poverty Center—http://www.npc.umich.edu/ •

The website for the federally funded poverty research institute at the University of Michigan.

Talk Poverty—https://talkpoverty.org •

Talk Poverty is a website of the Center for American Progress, a progressive public policy research and advocacy organization. There you can find data on poverty state by state.

U.S. Census Bureau. Poverty—https://www.census.gov/topics/income-poverty/poverty.html •

This page of the U.S. Census Bureau website contains information on the latest national statistics on poverty.

West Coast Poverty Center—http://depts.washington.edu/wcpc/ •

The website for the federally funded poverty research institute at the University of Washington.

24 .


Chapter 6: The Voluntary Sector Today

Chapter 6: The Voluntary Sector Today CHAPTER SUMMARY This chapter locates the voluntary sector with respect to the other institutions involved in social welfare in the United States. Supporting the voluntary sector are philanthropic contributions that have been a mainstay for social service initiatives. Prominent human service agencies are embedded in communities nationwide, providing essential social services. Historically, voluntary organizations have been the platform for social justice movements. While voluntary sector organizations have been dependent on philanthropy from large foundations, individual contributors provide most of the donations to this sector of American social welfare. In recent decades, government purchase-ofservice contracts have been an important source of revenue for nonprofit organizations. Finally, the responses to September 11, 2001, Hurricane Katrina in 2005, and the Great Recession of 2008 demonstrate the importance of the voluntary sector in responding to Americans in need.

STUDENT LEARNING OBJECTIVES •

Students will understand the interaction between the nonprofit sector and other institutions in U.S. welfare service provision.

•

Students will appreciate the roles of nonprofit agencies and marginal interest groups in representing marginalized populations in the U.S. class and interest conflicts.

•

Students will understand the role of a diversified social services system and how this is consistent with social work values and ethics.

TEACHING TIPS •

Engage students by referring to the agencies in which they are placed, or agencies they have encountered in their lives.

•

Students have some trouble identifying the voluntary sector. It is helpful to provide a large number of very specific examples of the voluntary sector.

•

It is also very helpful to provide examples of social entrepreneurship, clinical entrepreneurs, social services executives, etc. It helps the student distinguish among all these groups if they are encouraged to come up with the examples themselves.

•

Students benefit from having clear definitions of each of the types in the voluntary sector. It is worthwhile to spend time coming up with definitions the students can understand and can find relatable. It is important to clarify the goals and characteristics of each type you introduce.

LECTURE GUIDE AND ASSET CORRELATION The below lecture guide and asset correlation indicates where discussion prompts, assignments, activities or online activities connect to a given topic. The full descriptions of these prompts and assignments follow the below guide.

Discussion Prompts Throughout this chapter, various discussion prompts have been provided for in-class use. These prompts are developed to assist you in starting open conversation with students about key topics of the chapter.

Assignments and Activities These assignments and activities can be used in place of or in supplement of the online activities available for students. 25 .


Chapter 6: The Voluntary Sector Today

Key Terms Each chapter provides a list of key terms or concepts that students should know.

Chapter Outline I.

The Voluntary Sector Today (in-Class Activity 1)

II.

Community-Based Agencies (Discussion Prompt 1) a. The Independent Sector (Out-of-Class Assignment 3) b. Advancing Social Justice c.

The United Way (Out-of-Class Assignment 1)

d. Elite Philanthropy (Discussion Prompt 2) III.

The Future of the Voluntary Sector

IV.

Commercialization

V.

Faith-Based Social Services

VI.

Social Entrepreneurship (Discussion Prompt 3)

VII.

Issues Facing the Voluntary Sector a. Frivolity b. Dark Money c.

Property Tax Exemptions

d. Religious Precepts e. Celebrity Philanthropy f. VIII.

Salaries

Conclusion (Discussion Prompt 1)

KEY TERMS 1. Charity Organization Society 2. Commercialization 3. Standardize 4. Voluntary sector

DISCUSSION PROMPTS 1. How have you seen philanthropy at work in the fight against COVID-19? Consider different community and human needs that humanitarian and charitable organizations have mobilized to address. 2. How might the voluntary sector’s capacity to advance social justice be determined by funding sources? Answers should include an awareness of the competitive marketplace for funding, governmental restrictions on social service budgets, and the tendency for public confidence in charitable organizations to wax and wane from time to time. 3. In response to diminishing resources, creativity has become an important skill for raising money. How do you see organizations and social service agencies getting creative in our community? What entrepreneurial strategies would you think would be important for success within nonprofit agencies in your community?

26 .


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
American Social Welfare Policy A Pluralist Approach, 9th Edition Howard Karger Solution Manual by TBtutors - Issuu