Taylor's Bakery 2024 Catalog

Memories.

Some of life’s most pivotal moments include a piece of cake.

Our vision at Taylor’s Bakery is to be the heart of Indianapolis’ community celebrations, where every milestone, big or small, is marked with a Taylor’s cake.

Our mission is to bake happiness into every bite. We are dedicated to handcrafting delicious, one-of-a-kind cakes and desserts that are as unique as the people we serve. With a consistent commitment to quality, reliability, and tradition, we strive to create and deliver authentic, made-in-house creations that are “taylored” to each individual’s preferences.

Our goal is to make every occasion a little sweeter, a lot more special, and truly unforgettable.

©2024, Taylor’s Bakery

JOIN THE FAMILY

Follow us on Facebook or Instagram for seasonal features, sales, gift ideas and more.

Danish, Donuts, & Pastries

Danish Donuts - Cake, Yeast Coffee Cake

Candy, Chocolate & Ice Cream

Candy Chocolate Ice Cream

Individual Desserts Breads & Pies Cakes

Cupcakes Cookies

Squares & Bars Dog Treats

Seasonal

Classic Dessert Cakes

Angel Food

Petit Fours Bread, Rolls, & Stuffing Pies - Sweet & Savory Quiche

Popular Cake Designs Flavors, Fillings, & Servings

Allergens.

Please note that our products are made with common allergens, including dairy, eggs, wheat, soybeans, tree nuts, and wheat. We are a peanut-free facility.

Denotes products that contain tree nuts.

BEARCLAW

Sweet almond paste spread over danish dough, finished with white icing.

BUTTERHORN APPLE

Danish dough swirled with cinnamon, complemented by cinnamon apple filling and white icing.

BUTTERHORN CHERRY

Danish dough swirled with cinnamon, topped with cherry filling and white icing.

CINNAMON ROLL BUTTER DANISH

Classic cinnamon roll from our swirled cinnamon danish dough, topped with a soft butter icing.

FRIED DANISH

Chewy deep-fried danish dough dipped in a donut glaze.

MINIATURE ALLIGATOR

Braided and swirled cinnamon danish dough, garnished with pecans and white icing.

THREE WAY CHEESE DANISHPECAN CRISPY

Danish dough swirled with cinnamon, filled with cream cheese, and topped with white icing.

Danish dough coated in a mixture of cinnamon, sugar, and pecans, flattened and baked to perfection for a delightful crunch.

STICKY PECAN ROLL

Our renowned sticky swirled cinnamon danish, generously crowned with pecans.

CARMEL ICED

Classic cake donut topped with caramel icing.

SPRINKLES

Classic cake donut topped with white icing and rainbow sprinkles.

CHOCOLATE ICED

Classic cake donut topped with rich chocolate icing.

WHITE ICED

Classic cake donut topped with white icing.

GLAZED PLAIN

Classic cake donut dipped in a sugar glaze.

GLAZED DONUT HOLES

Classic cake donut holes dipped in a sugar glaze.

Classic cake donut with no frills.

ASSORTED DONUTS & DANISH BY THE DOZEN

THE HOMER

FLAVORS

IN THE OVEN

CINNAMON TWIST

Hand twisted yeast dough dipped in a sugar glaze and covered with cinnamon sugar.

PERSIAN GLAZED

Cinnamon swirled yeast donut topped with a sugar glaze.

BAVARIAN CREME

RASPBERRY FILLED

PERSIAN CARAMEL

Yeast donut filled with bavarian creme and topped with chocolate icing.

GLAZED

Yeast donut dipped in a sugar glaze.

Yeast donut filled with raspberry jelly and topped with white icing.

SPRINKLES

Yeast donut topped with white icing and rainbow sprinkles.

Cinnamon swirled yeast donut topped with caramel icing.

CHOCOLATE ICED

Yeast donut topped with rich chocolate icing.

CARMEL ICED WITH PECANS

Swirled cinnamon danish dough topped with chopped pecans and covered in caramel icing.

WHITE ICED WITH PECANS

Swirled cinnamon danish dough topped with chopped pecans and covered in white icing.

CHERRY SOUR CREAM - WHOLE

Swirled cinnamon danish dough topped with cherry filling, streusel, and white icing.

CINNAMON

Swirled cinnamon danish dough topped with streusel, and white icing.

CREAM CHEESE

Swirled cinnamon danish dough topped with cream cheese filling, streusel, and white icing.

A full yellow cake bundt swirled with cinnamon, pecans, and sour cream, resulting in an extra moist texture. Finally, it is finished with powdered sugar for a delectable finishing touch.

SOUR CREAM - HALF

A half yellow cake bundt swirled with cinnamon, pecans, and sour cream, resulting in an extra moist texture. Finally, it is finished with powdered sugar for a delectable finishing touch.

RUM BUNDT

Find me in the fall. This is a yellow cake bundt filled with pecans and dunked in a sticky rum sauce. Also includes an extra cup of rum sauce on the side! Serves 16.

Tuesday

- Saturday. Greater Indianapolis Region.

WHITE CHOCOLATE CHEX MIX® BARK

Get ready to treat yourself with our White Chocolate Chex Mix® Bark. Imagine munching on crunchy Chex Mix® and mini M&M®’s, all covered in creamy white chocolate. It’s that awesome sweet and salty combo you love. 13 oz.

WHITE CHOCOLATE AND M&M® DIPPED PRETZELS

Salted pretzel rods dipped in white chocolate and mini M&M®’s. 2 pretzel rods per package.

WHITE CHOCOLATE AND SPRINKLE DIPPED PRETZELS

Salted pretzel rods dipped in white chocolate and rainbow sprinkles. 2 pretzel rods per package.

GUMMY BEARS

Colorful rainbow gummy bears in 12 different flavors from Albanese® Candy Factory. 12 oz.

WRAPPED CARAMEL CANDY

Signature caramel candy is hand cut and wrapped into individual delights. 12 oz.

We churn our ice cream in small batches and pack it by hand to ensure the quality you deserve. This process creates a custom ice cream that we’re proud to offer you and your family! Sold by the quart.

Available in 12 oz. bags or by the pound.

All the chocolates in our bakery are crafted by hand, in small batches, to bring out the best flavors. Our offerings include melt-in-your-mouth chocolate turtles, sweet and salty combinations with pretzels and trail mix, and more. Be sure to check-in as we continue to add more chocolate and candy to the menu!

TRIPLE DIPPED MALT BALLS

Take a dip with our triple dipped malt balls. 21 oz.

CHOCOLATE COVERED M&M® PRETZELS

Salted pretzels dipped in milk chocolate and smothered mini M&M®’s. 12 oz.

Buttery, melt-in-your-mouth caramels set over chopped pecans and covered in milk chocolate. 6 per package.

Buttery, melt-in-your-mouth caramels set over chopped pecans and covered in milk chocolate. Papered and wrapped individually. 1 per package.

CHOCOLATE COVERED OREOS ™

Everyone's favorite OREOS™, coated in milk chocolate and string drizzled with white chocolate. 16oz.

White chocolate bark mixed with fresh crushed peppermint and broken into bitesized bark pieces. Available in the winter.

TURTLES - BOXED

TURTLES - INDIVIDUALLY WRAPPED

PEPPERMINT BARK

Seasonal

A simple cooked white icing is poured over our famous white cake and served in 2-inch squares. Each petit four comes wrapped individually in it’s own paper. You’ll find rosebuds and seasonal decorations available in-store and ready to go. You can also pre-order with custom designs.

SMALL BUTTER COOKIES

Our small bite-sized butter cookies topped with a dollop of icing. Colors vary by season. 12 oz.

Seasonal

LARGE BUTTER COOKIES

A 4” round fluted butter cookie that’s glazed, then decorated with cream icing. Decorations vary by season.

If you’re gearing up for corporate events, weddings, or any large-scale gathering, we’ve got a tasty solution for you. Our 4” fluted butter cookies are perfect, and if you preorder, they can be a game-changer.

With it’s buttery and flaky texture, our butter cookies are not only scrumptious, but they’re also super versatile for decorating to match your theme. You can request custom colors, decorations, and even take it up a notch by adding edible images or individual wrapping to make them truly unique.

INVIDIDUAL WRAPPING ROYAL ICING

EDIBLE IMAGES

BULK & RE-OCCURING ORDERS

Our famous white cake with white icing.

Chocolate cake with chocolate icing.

Rich red velvet cake with cream cheese icing.

Snickerdoodle Sugar

Our soft and chewy sugar cookie covered in cinnamon and sugar. 2.25 oz.

Our soft and chewy sugar cookie with a slight almond flavor. 2.25 oz.

Oatmeal

A chewy cookie loaded with oats and spices. 2.25 oz.

Monster Cookie Sandwich

Two chocolate chip cookies sandwiched together with white icing.

Chocolate Chip

Our traditional chocolate chip cookie. Yummy! 2.25 oz.

BROWNIE (NO NUTS)

A rich brownie topped with fudge icing.

LEMON SQUARE

MINIATURE ECLAIR

The miniature version of our large eclair. A light, airy pastry filled with non-dairy custard and topped with fudge icing.

A light, airy pastry filled with non-dairy custard and topped with fudge icing.

RASPBERRY SQUARE

A pastry base topped with raspberry and streusel. 2”x2” square.

Lemon filling on top of a pastry base, then covered with our in-house streusel. 2”x2” square.

TURTLE SQUARE

A rich brownie is topped with pecans, streusel, and swirled caramel and sits on a pastry base. 2”x2” square.

PASTRY TRAY COOKIE TRAY

There’s something for everyone on this tray! An assortment of bite sized treats from our pastry case.

Raspberry Squares, Lemon Squares, Turtle Squares, Miniature Eclairs, and Brownies. 38 servings.

Our cookie tray includes 18 homemade Chocolate Chip cookies and 18 Snickerdoodle cookies. Simple yet sweet, this tray is perfect for luncheons, parties, and events. Advance order recommended during holidays. 3 dozen.

LARGE ECLAIR

Round of A-Paws! / 1 \ 1\ \ \1/

BUTTERFLAKE ROLLS BREAD STUFFING

Our most popular Thanksgiving item is no other than our famous Butter Flake Rolls. Soft, flaky pastry dough is folded into a cupcake pan and baked until it unfolds into delicious layers of golden brown. Be sure to enjoy them warm next to any meal.

Absolutely perfect for gatherings! 1 doz.

Available in the fall, our classic cream bread cubed and dried for you to make your favorite stuffing. Each bag contains 1 ½ loaves.

9” SPINACH ONION & PARMESAN QUICHE

An egg-cellent addition to any breakfast or lunch is our light and fluffy spinach, onion, and parmesan cheese quiche! 8 servings.

9” HAM & SWISS QUICHE CHICKEN POT PIE

An egg-cellent addition to any breakfast or lunch is our light and fluffy ham and swiss quiche! Filled with eggs, ham, swiss cheese and seasonings. 8 servings.

Bring dinner home for the family! We’ve done the work for you. Simply put in the oven for 30 minutes and dinner is ready! 12 servings.

All of our savory pies are par-baked approximately 80% of the way for you. We’ve done this to ensure a safe, internal temperature of 165 degrees. Then, they’re quickly flash frozen.

Instructions are provided on how to bake-off your savory dish in the oven, either frozen or thawed!

Seasonal

There was a time when local bakeries were a dime a dozen. But now it’s kinda hard to find those charming, family-owned gems.

So, we just wanted to say ank You For Supporting

Zocal

Ðough

Multi Grain

A hearty loaf of wheat bread brimming with cracked wheat, oat flakes, sunflower seeds, millet and flaxseed.

French Baguette

A long thin shaped loaf with a soft white interior and a crispy crust.

Vienna

Soft white bread with a crispy crust.

9” APPLE PIE

A cinnamon sugar-dusted flaky crust filled with Idared apples. 8 servings.

9” KEY LIME PIE

Key lime filling, made with real key lime juice, in a graham cracker pie shell, topped with whipped cream. 8 servings.

9” DUTCH APPLE PIE

Flaky crust mounded with our crumbly streusel and filled with Idared apples. 8 servings.

9” CHERRY PIE

A flaky crust filled with juicy tart cherries from Michigan. 8 servings.

9” DUTCH CHERRY PIE

Flaky crust mounded with our crumbly streusel and filled with juicy, Michigan tart cherries. 8 servings.

Seasonal Seasonal Seasonal

9” PUMPKIN PIE

Sweet and tart filling in a graham cracker pie shell and garnished with whipped cream. Made with real key lime juice. 8 servings.

BLUEBERRY BREAD

A moist sweet bread made with Michigan blueberries and topped with streusel. 8 servings.

9” SALTED CARAMEL APPLE PIE

A flaky crust filled with spiced Idared apples, homemade caramel, and a crumbly streusel, all topped with more caramel. 8 servings.

9” PECAN PIE

A flaky crust loaded with a sweet, buttery pecan filling. 8 servings.

PUMPKIN BREAD

Spiced pumpkin bread. One of our fall specials! 8 servings.

Seasonal

WE’LL SEE YOU THERE!

Get ready to be dazzled by the magic at Hilbert Circle Theatre during the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra's AES Indiana Yuletide Celebration! Get your Taylor's Bakery Yuletide-themed cookie in the lobby and experience an unforgettable night with Conductor Jack Everly and the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra. Experience performances by annual special guests and enjoy holiday favorites like Toy Shop and Dollies. Don't miss out on the fun - get your tickets now!

Explore our vast selection of flavors, delightful decorating options, along with a range of cakes available daily in our storefront.

At the heart of every cake is our time-tested recipe and baking process, resulting in light and moist confections perfect for any occasion.

SEASONAL CAKE

CLASSIC DESSERT CAKE

ANGEL FOOD CAKE

FLAVORS, FILLINGS, & SERVINGS

POPULAR DESIGNS

COLOR CHART

TO GO

We know that things can get hectic when you’re planning a special occasion, but don’t worry, we’ve got you covered! Taylor’s has Ready to Go cakes that can be customized with a personal message within an hour. So, even if you’re running a bit behind, you can still grab a delicious and unique cake for your celebration.

8” SINGLE LAYER ROUND SERVES 6

8” 2-LAYER ROUND SERVES 12

8” SINGLE LAYER ROUND SERVES 6

8” 2-LAYER ROUND SERVES 12

¼

MINIATURE BIRTHDAY CAKE SERVES 1-2

SHEET CAKE SERVES 24

White Cake with White Icing | Chocolate Cake with White Icing Flower decorations vary by season.

White Cake with White Icing

Visit us in-store or on online for the flavor of the month!

Don’t’ miss some of our popular rotations including, Raspberry Mist (shown), Lemon Mist, Boston Cream, Shadow Cake, and more.

TRIPLE CHOCOLATE GANACHE

Three layers of chocolate cake iced in chocolate icing, then poured over with a rich chocolate ganache shell. Serves 10

7” 3-LAYER CARROT

Three layers of spiced carrot cake filled with pecans, cream cheese icing, crushed graham cracker coating, and then scored for your friends and family to enjoy! Serves 8

7” 2-LAYER WHITE

*Advance order required.* 2 layers of our famous white cake with that signature almond rum flavor, covered in our white cream icing. Serves 10

Little delights are sprinkled throughout the year including peppermint, chocolate chip, lemon, and english toffee angel food.

RASPBERRY ANGEL FOOD

A light raspberry flavored angel food cake with fluffy raspberry icing.

WHITE ANGEL FOOD

A light white angel food cake with fluffy white icing.

AVAILABLE PLAIN OR ICED

ORANGE ANGEL FOOD

A light orange flavored angel food cake with fluffy orange icing.

Looking for something unique? With just one day’s notice, you can order a customized cake that reflects your unique style and taste preferences. Whether you’re treating the office, celebrating a birthday, wedding, or any other special occasion, we’re here to help make your special day even sweeter.

*Tiered cakes require an appointment.

*Fresh flowers would be done by a florist and are not offered through Taylor’s Bakery.

PICK YOUR DATE

• 24 Hour Notice is required on all orders.

• Tiered cakes and weddings require an appointment.

CHOOSE YOUR SIZE

Every event is unique, from the size of the party, to the logistics of the best way to serve your guests. Our Layer Cake Sizes Guide pairs cake with serving sizes and dimensions, making it easier for you to find what best fits your needs.

When individual or handheld desserts are more appropriate, we also offer customization on our butter cookies, 12” cake cookies, cupcakes, pull-apart cupcakes, sheeted brownies, and petit fours.

SELECT YOUR FLAVOR, ICING, AND FILLING

All of our Taylor cakes and icings are made in-house. With five flavors of cake, five types of icing, and a multitude of fillings, the options are endless.

DESIGN YOUR CAKE

Now it’s time to design your cake! Customize your colors, inscription, and decorations such as spring flowers, roses, confetti, balloons, and more.

Additional charges apply for hand-drawn designs, edible images, etc.

*Taylor's does not offer fresh flowers or floral.

* Consent is required and must be granted in advance for the printing/recreation of any copyright material.

50/50

½ WHITE / ½ YELLOW

½ WHITE / ½ CHOCOLATE

½ CHOCOLATE / ½ YELLOW

More FLAVORS

RED VELVET

CARROT

YELLOW WITH LEMON

TINTED GENDER REVEAL

CARAMEL

RASPBERRY

LEMON

CHERRY

STRAWBERRY

COCONUT

BAVARIAN CREME

FUDGE

GENDER REVEAL

CREAM CHEESE

WHIPPED CREAM

FLAVORED TINTED RED

SPRINKLES

We Put Č icing on / cake RED PINK ORANGE YELLOW GREEN BLUE PURPLE GOLD CLEAR BLACK SILVER MULTICOLOR

CARNIVAL WHITE ORANGE

CARNIVAL NONPAREILS BLACK GREEN BLUE LAVENDER YELLOW AUTUMN

Pastel PinkMedium PinkNeon PinkFuchsiaBurgundyLavender

Medium PurpleNeon PurplePastel BlueMedium BlueNeon BlueRoyal Blue

Navy Blue Teal Pastel GreenMedium GreenNeon GreenGrass Green

Forest Green Sage Pastel YellowMedium YellowNeon YellowGolden Yellow

Summer GoldPastel OrangeMedium OrangeNeon Orange Red Light Brown

Brown Ivory White Light Gray Gray Black

• Blank

• Rosebuds

• Drop Flowers

• Graduation Diplomas

• Current Year

• Anniversary Year

• Monogram

*The trademarks “Indiana University,” “IU,” and all associated marks, logos, and designs are the sole property of Indiana University. Taylor’s Bakery holds a valid license that grants authorization for the reproduction of the Indiana University logo as an edible image.

Taylor’s Bakery

*The trademarks “Colts,” “Indianapolis Colts,” and the Colts’ horseshoe logos are the property of Indianapolis Colts, Inc. Taylor’s Bakery has obtained permission and is authorized for the creation of cakes featuring the horseshoe and helmet shapes resembling the Colts’ logos. *Consent is required and must be granted in advance for Colts logo to be used in written form or printed as an edible image.