Skip to main content

Public Sector October 2026

Page 1

OCTOBER 2026

www.businessmediamags.co.za

CAPABILITY

Building institutions that deliver

ACCOUNTABILITY

Restoring the line between oversight and administration

WATER

Tackling the failures behind the crisis

TALENT

CAN THE STATE DELIVER?

Keeping the expertise government depends on

MUNICIPALITIES

From financial reform to better services

INTEGRATION

Why government must work beyond departmental silos

Systems, skills and leadership needed for real outcomes

PS COVER_3 final.indd 1

2026/10/19 09:55


Untitled-1 2

2026/09/23 09:15


Untitled-1 3

2026/09/23 09:15


Innovative solutions for economic opportunity and empowerment TransUnion (NYSE: TRU) is a global information and insights company with over 13 000 associates operating in more than 30 countries and territories, including South Africa. We make trust possible by ensuring each person is reliably represented in the marketplace. We do this by providing an actionable view of consumers, stewarded with care. TransUnion manages multiple complex databases containing insurance, cellular, consumer, commercial and auto data assets. Through our acquisitions and technology investments, we have developed innovative solutions that extend beyond our strong foundation in core credit into areas such as marketing, fraud, risk and advanced analytics. As a result, consumers and businesses can transact with confidence and achieve great things. We call this Information for Good® – and it leads to economic opportunity, great experiences and personal empowerment for millions of people around the world.

For more information, visit: www.transunion.co.za

ToCheck_fcp hv.indd 2

2026/10/19 09:11


FROM THE EDITOR

PUBLISHED BY

MAKING THE STATE WORK

S

outh Africa has no shortage of plans, policies or ambition. What we continue to struggle with is turning those ambitions into outcomes. So, what does it actually take to make the state work? Can government deliver reliable services with ageing infrastructure, constrained budgets and critical skills shortages? Can it attract and retain the engineers, managers and technical specialists needed to build institutional capability – and then give them the stability to do their jobs? Are we investing wisely, or are we too focused on building new while failing to maintain what we already have? Can every rand of public money work harder, delivering greater value without compromising the services citizens depend on? And, can government overcome the silos,

A proud division of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd Hill on Empire, 16 Empire Road (cnr Hillside Road), Parktown, Johannesburg, 2193 PO Box 12500, Mill Street, Cape Town, 8010 www.businessmediamags.co.za EDITORIAL Content Manager: Raina Julies rainaj@picasso.co.za Contributors: Trevor Crighton, Ryland Fisher, Itumeleng Mogaki, Busani Moyo, Monei Seleho, Geoff Tooley Copy Editor: Brenda Bryden Content Co-ordinator: Natasha Maneveldt DESIGN Head of Design: Jayne Macé-Ferguson Senior Design: Mfundo Archie Ndzo Cover Images: Liubomyr Vorona/istockphoto.com, Fearless on Four Wheels/istockphoto.com, Nico van Blerk/istockphoto.com, Andrey Grigoriev/istockphoto.com, SALES Project Manager: Frank Simons Franks@picasso.co.za | +27 82 366 3125

IMAGES: XXXXXXXX

IMAGES: XXXXXXXX

MANAGEMENT Management Accountant: Deidre Musha Business Manager: Lodewyk van der Walt General Manager, Magazines: Jocelyne Bayer

Copyright: No portion of this magazine may be reproduced in any form without written consent of the publisher. The publisher is not responsible for unsolicited material. Public Sector is published by Picasso Headline. The opinions expressed are not necessarily those of Picasso Headline. All advertisements/ advertorials have been paid for and therefore do not carry any endorsement by the publisher.

Raina Julies

CONTENTS 11 04

DIGITAL Online Editor: Stacey Visser vissers@businessmediamags.co.za PRODUCTION Production Editor: Shamiela Brenner Advertising Co-ordinator: Shamiela Brenner Subscriptions and Distribution: Fatima Dramat fatimad@picasso.co.za Printer: CTP Printers, Cape Town

political-administrative tensions and fragmented accountability that make complex problems even harder to solve? These are not simply questions of efficiency. They are questions of state capability, public trust and the social contract between government and citizens. The challenge is not necessarily to reinvent government. It may be to make the institutions we already have work better – with the right people, clearer accountability, stronger professional expertise and a relentless focus on outcomes. The question this issue asks is a simple but uncomfortable one: does South Africa have the capability to make the state work – and, if not, what needs to change?

6

8

10

CAPABILITY South Africa’s delivery crisis cannot be solved by recruiting skilled people alone. Skilled public servants are essential, but their expertise becomes public value only when institutions give them the systems, stability and authority to act – and hold them accountable.

16

POWER AND ACCOUNTABILITY The line between political oversight and professional administration is becoming increasingly blurred, with consequences for accountability, expertise and effective government.

17

SERVICE DELIVERY With municipal elections approaching, questions around service delivery are once again under the spotlight. Experts weigh in on what is holding government back – and what needs to change.

PUBLIC INVESTMENT South Africa has invested billions in infrastructure, but ageing assets and inadequate maintenance are eroding that investment.

20

WATER SECURITY The National Water Action Plan promises to tackle the systemic failures behind South Africa’s water crisis. However, experts warn that infrastructure investment must be matched by skills, maintenance, accountability and faster action.

INTEGRATED GOVERNMENT Water, electricity, housing, transport, health and economic development rarely fit neatly into departmental boundaries – so how did government end up working in silos?

PUBLIC SECTOR TALENT Local government needs a stronger pipeline of engineering expertise and institutional knowledge, but attracting and retaining skilled professionals requires continuity, effective leadership and functioning municipalities.

FINANCIAL REFORM Unpacking how stronger financial management, revenue collection and accountable leadership can help municipalities restore sustainable service delivery.

20

PU BL IC SECTOR

EDSCONTENTS_subbed.indd 3

3

2026/10/19 10:22


South Africa’s delivery crisis cannot be solved by recruiting skilled people alone, writes BUSANI MOYO

S

outh Africa has no shortage of policies promising reliable services, sound infrastructure and better lives. Yet the distance between what government commits to and what citizens experience remains stubbornly wide. The country’s real deficit may therefore lie less in knowing what to do than in building institutions capable of doing it consistently. This is the central concern raised by Dr Busani Ngcaweni, director of the Centre for Public Policy and African Studies at The University of Johannesburg’s Johannesburg Business School; Wayne Duvenage, chief executive officer of the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (OUTA); and Janine Erasmus, editor at Corruption Watch. Although they approach the problem from different vantage points, all three locate it in the interaction between people, institutions, political power and accountability – not in qualifications alone. Their diagnosis is reinforced by the Auditor-General of South Africa’s (AGSA)

4

2024–25 Consolidated General Report on Local Government Audit Outcomes. Only 39 municipalities, or 15 per cent, achieved clean audits. Although financial-statement submissions improved and disclaimers declined, 215 municipalities had material findings on compliance with key legislation. The findings show that capability failures are not abstract administrative shortcomings; they weaken finances, delay projects and leave communities living with unreliable services and deteriorating infrastructure.

MORE THAN A SKILLS SHORTAGE Dr Ngcaweni argues that implementation is too often treated as something that should follow automatically once policy is adopted and money allocated. In reality, it depends on a complete institutional system. “Implementation is itself a complex institutional capability, requiring competent people, stable leadership, functioning systems, clear delegations, reliable data, effective

A CYCLE OF INSTITUTIONAL DECLINE Vacancies, acting appointments, leadership changes and blurred lines of authority do not

PU BL IC SECTOR

CAPABILITY CRISIS_subbed.indd 4

2026/10/19 09:16

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

MORE THAN A SKILLS CRISIS

procurement and financial management, co-ordination across institutions, and managers who have both the authority and judgement to respond when implementation inevitably departs from the original plan,” he says. He compares the state to aviation. A qualified pilot is indispensable, but cannot fly safely without engineers, air traffic controllers, reliable information, maintenance regimes and operating procedures. Similarly, an excellent engineer, economist or manager cannot indefinitely compensate for a dysfunctional institution. Duvenage places accountability at the centre of that dysfunction. “When leaders or oversight authorities are either unwilling or unable to hold underperforming officials accountable, poor performance becomes entrenched and service delivery deteriorates,” he says. “South Africa does not lack policies; it lacks accountable leadership capable of ensuring those policies are implemented effectively.” Erasmus identifies the same implementation gap. “We have some highly effective, on paper, frameworks, such as the in-progress public service professionalisation framework, but the best ideas break down when implementation is weak,” she says. There are nevertheless genuine shortages. Dr Ngcaweni lists engineering, planning, economics, project and programme management, digital technology and data science among capabilities that are distributed unevenly across government, particularly in municipalities and provincial institutions. Erasmus points to technical shortages and high vacancy levels. Both caution against mistaking qualifications for institutional capability. The AGSA’s municipal findings illustrate the distinction. In 2024–25, 225 municipalities spent R1.61-billion on financial-reporting consultants. Consultants were appointed due to skills shortages, vacancies, or both, yet 61 per cent of the municipalities that used them still submitted statements containing material misstatements in the areas for which consultants had been hired. Buying expertise cannot substitute for building durable internal systems. The report also identified material findings in 73 per cent of the performance reports initially submitted for audit, weakening the information councils and communities need to assess whether promised services were actually delivered.


STATE CAPABILITY

operate independently. Each intensifies the others. A long-standing vacancy produces an acting appointment; temporary authority discourages difficult decisions; changing leaders shift priorities; and confused responsibilities make it harder to identify who should be held accountable for failure. “The cumulative result is an institution that spends an increasing amount of its energy managing uncertainty within itself rather than fulfilling its mandate to the people of the republic,” Dr Ngcaweni says. Duvenage describes a cycle in which leadership instability weakens decision-making and institutional memory, political influence delays appointments and capable officials become demoralised or leave when poor performance is tolerated. Erasmus adds that when politicians interfere in operational matters, accountability becomes blurred. Politicians and administrators point at each other, nobody is sanctioned and further interference is encouraged. For Dr Ngcaweni, however, depoliticising administration does not mean pretending that politics and administration can be entirely separated. Elected governments must set priorities, while professional administrators translate those choices into lawful action. Using his aviation analogy, political leaders determine the destination – the difficulty begins when they enter the cockpit and attempt to operate instruments entrusted to professionals. Conversely, officials cannot use technical expertise to disregard a democratic mandate. This distinction matters because accountability without authority is as ineffective as authority without consequences. Officials cannot reasonably be held responsible for outcomes if they lack the freedom to make lawful decisions. However, security of tenure and administrative independence must not become a shield against scrutiny or consequences.

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

REBUILDING THE MACHINERY The contributors converge around three priorities: • Merit-based appointments. • Stronger accountability. • Institutions that enable professionals to perform. Duvenage wants recruitment, promotion and discipline insulated from political influence, with competence, integrity and experience driving appointments. He also calls for consequences for senior executives, boards and accounting officers responsible for persistent

“SOUTH AFRICA DOES NOT LACK POLICIES; IT LACKS ACCOUNTABLE LEADERSHIP CAPABLE OF ENSURING THOSE POLICIES ARE IMPLEMENTED EFFECTIVELY.” – WAYNE DUVENAGE

underperformance, financial mismanagement and governance failures. High performers, he says, should be recognised and retained. Erasmus proposes independent expert panels to reduce political discretion in senior appointments, centralised and properly enforced consequence management and a depoliticised process for appointing directors-general and other senior officials. “Where performance, decision-making and disciplinary outcomes are linked to political agendas, even a skilled and capable official will not be able to give their best,” she says. Dr Ngcaweni adds a longer-term institutional dimension. Professionalisation should begin with meritocratic recruitment and continue through induction, learning, leadership development, performance management, career progression and the reinforcement of ethical standards. Like pilots returning to simulators, public servants require recurrent opportunities to test judgement, confront realistic problems and prepare for new responsibilities. This is not remedial training, but an acknowledgement that professional competence must continually be renewed. Institutions must learn too. Replacing leaders, launching another plan or establishing a new structure after every failure can erase experience rather than turning it into improved practice. Capable institutions retain memory, recognise failure early, co-ordinate across boundaries and adapt without losing sight of their mandates.

Follow: Dr Busani Ngcaweni www.linkedin.com/in/busani-ngcaweni-b94501237 Wayne Duvenage www.linkedin.com/in/wayneduvenage Janine Erasmus www.linkedin.com/in/janine-erasmus-58a6395

Progress should therefore be visible in outcomes, not the volume of reform activity. It would mean shorter vacancies, fewer prolonged acting appointments, stable and credible leadership, faster disciplinary processes, stronger procurement, bettermaintained infrastructure and more reliable delivery. It would also mean audit improvements: not merely better paperwork, but credible performance information and fewer recurring breaches of the law. The picture is not uniformly bleak. Dr Ngcaweni cautions against declaring the entire state incapable, pointing instead to islands of capability, sometimes within the same sphere or department, as profound dysfunction. Those successes should be studied to understand how effective institutions recruit and retain people, organise authority, preserve knowledge and solve problems. The lesson is that South Africa cannot train or recruit its way out of the crisis while leaving the surrounding machinery untouched. Skilled public servants are essential, but their expertise becomes public value only when institutions give them the systems, stability and authority to act – and hold them accountable for doing so. A capable state is not created by another promise of reform. It is continuously built, tested and maintained through the quality of delivery citizens can see.

READ THE LATEST AUDITOR-GENERAL’S REPORT

PU BL IC SECTOR

CAPABILITY CRISIS_subbed.indd 5

5

2026/10/19 09:16


POWER AND ACCOUNTABILITY

WHERE POLITICS MEETS ADMINISTRATION The line between political oversight and professional administration is becoming increasingly blurred, with consequences for accountability, expertise and effective government, writes ITUMELENG MOGAKI

W

RESTORING ACCOUNTABILITY

Professor Linda Meyer

WHERE THE SYSTEM BREAKS DOWN For Professor Meyer, the consequences are particularly visible when political authority influences appointments and procurement. “Too many political leaders want authority without accepting responsibility. When a programme succeeds, politicians claim the credit. When it fails, officials are blamed, suspended or replaced,” she says. She also highlights the pressure placed on officials who challenge improper or politically motivated decisions. “Competent officials who resist political pressure may be suspended or marginalised, while politically protected officials can remain in office despite repeated evidence of misconduct or failure,” Professor Meyer continues.

“COALITION GOVERNMENT INTRODUCES ANOTHER DIFFICULTY WHERE PUBLIC SERVANTS MAY RECEIVE CONTRADICTORY DIRECTIVES FROM DIFFERENT POLITICAL PARTIES.” – DR THABO KEITH BOB

6

Neither expert argues for officials operating without political scrutiny. The issue is how that scrutiny is exercised. “Political leaders must ensure that policies are affordable, practical and supported by credible implementation plans,” says Professor Meyer. “They should not function as procurement officers or administrative managers.” Dr Bob believes political leaders must also protect capable officials from interference while holding them accountable. “They should engage with their departments through structured performance reviews, asking tough questions about progress, budget expenditure and audit findings,” he says. “A critical role is to act as a shield for the administration and ensure professional officials have the resources and stability to do their jobs.” Both see stronger accountability as essential: Professor Meyer calls for transparent, competitive appointments and meaningful consequences for poor performance, while Dr Bob wants the Public Service Commission restored to a stronger oversight role, alongside more rigorous governance training for political office-bearers. For Professor Meyer and Dr Bob, effective government ultimately depends on getting this balance right: political leaders provide direction and oversight, while officials apply their expertise and remain accountable for implementation.

Follow: Professor Linda Meyer www.linkedin.com/in/linda-meyer-2b236866 Dr Thabo Keith Bob www.linkedin.com/in/dr-thabo-keith-bob-1073474b

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

ho really runs the state? The answer is less straightforward than it appears. Ministers, members of executive committees, mayors and councillors provide political leadership and oversight, while public officials are responsible for translating government decisions into workable programmes and services. The relationship between the two is essential to effective government. However, when political oversight crosses into day-to-day administration, or officials fail to account for their performance, the distinction blurs – and institutions suffer. Professor Linda Meyer, MD at Rosebank International and visiting professor at Nelson Mandela University, says the problem is not a lack of rules, but a failure to respect them. “Political oversight becomes political interference when office-bearers involve themselves in appointments, tenders and routine administrative decisions. Public officials serve the government of the day, not a political party. Their first obligation is to the constitution, the law and the public,” says Professor Meyer. Dr Thabo Keith Bob, an independent political expert and Regenesys Business School academic tutor, agrees. “Effective government occurs when political leaders articulate a clear destination and the professional administration provides the most effective route to get there,” says Dr Bob.

Dr Bob places the problem within the wider institutional environment, arguing that the coalition government can add another layer of complexity. “That threatens the neutrality and professionalism of the civil service,” adds Dr Bob. “When appointments favour political loyalty over professional merit, the independence and competence of the administration are compromised from the outset,” he says. “High turnover among senior officials also creates instability and discourages skilled professionals from entering and remaining in the public sector.”

PU BL IC SECTOR

power and accountability_subbed.indd 6

2026/10/19 10:15


ToCheck_fcp.indd 2

2026/10/06 15:14


THE CAPACITY QUESTION Can government deliver? With municipal elections approaching, questions around service delivery are once again under the spotlight. By RYLAND FISHER

A

A CAPACITY CRISIS?

George Asamani

THE CAPACITY TO DELIVER Business leader and academic Professor Bonang Mohale believes South Africa has the capacity to deliver services to its citizens. “South Africa is poor by choice, especially when one considers the country’s abundant resources. Government has more than 730 state-owned enterprises and companies(SOE/ Cs). SARS has collected about R2.01-trillion in the 2025 financial year. The Public Investment Corporation (PIC) manages over R3.7-trillion in assets under management. Gauteng Province’s nominal gross domestic product is $165-billion – larger than the economies of many African countries. “There are 800 000 stokvels in South Africa in 2025, with 11 million members saving R50billion annually. SASSA benefits 19.2 million people with R250-billion annually. NSFAS benefits 1.1 million of 1.3 million students with R50-billion annually, while the National Skills Fund (NSF) has R13-billion in reserves, even as 4.7 million young people are unemployed. “Two hundred and fifty thousand taxi operators handle about R90-billion annually, while 172 000 spaza shops and general dealers handle about R1-trillion annually. Big retailers are a R1-trillion-per-year business. The country has 29 000 ATMs handling R900-billion in cash withdrawals per annum.”

8

Professor Mohale says the root cause of nondelivery of services is greed. “This can be rectified by being intentional in electing a leader who is committed to rooting out and defeating state capture; completing the unfinished task of transformation; ethical leadership; good governance; service delivery; and law and order, safety and security.” He says people who can afford it are increasingly looking to the private sector for alternatives, but the majority of South Africans cannot. “Service delivery must remain the primary function of government, considering that only about 9.8 million people – about 14 to 15.5 per cent of the total population – have private medical aid cover, and only 13.3 to 14.5 per cent of people have a dedicated fixed home internet connection inside their dwelling. “For general financial, life and asset insurance, estimates indicate that up to eighty per cent of individuals hold no formal coverage outside of basic funeral plans, while about six to eight million people lack access to basic employment benefits such as pensions, paid sick leave or medical aid.” Professor Mohale says government should consider what is being done in countries such as Scandinavia, Singapore and South Korea.

However, while good governance may provide the foundation for effective service delivery, the question remains whether government has the capacity to put these principles into practice. Dr Iraj Abedian, chief economist and founder of Pan-African Investment and Research Services, believes it does not. “This is in part due to the historic legacy of apartheid. For example, local government infrastructure was not designed to provide services to all, while the majority of residents did not expect to pay for services in protest against the illegitimacy of the political system. “Four decades later, these two factors have evolved into a real sociopolitical challenge for the country. Meanwhile, the corruption that has beset the ANC and others has contaminated the field, compounding these historic factors.” Dr Abedian believes the main reason for nondelivery of services is the over-politicisation of local government. “Running a municipality is a business – a very specialised one – involving short-, medium- and long-term logistics and infrastructure provision. “Municipalities should be populated and run by technocrats who understand political sensitivities, rather than by politicians who have no grasp of complex urban planning and maintenance. “In South Africa, it is all politics, purging competence and populating offices with incompetence so that politicians can plunder. A case in point is Johannesburg. Over the past forty years, Johannesburg has not had a single mayor who has shown the ability to assemble a competent team or build the city’s technocratic capabilities. Instead, over time, incompetence, theft and corruption have become the hallmark of the city.”

PU BL IC SECTOR

SERVICE DELIVERY_subbed2.indd 8

2026/10/19 09:31

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

s South Africa heads towards municipal elections in November, service delivery is once again at the centre of the national conversation. From unreliable infrastructure and water challenges to uneven access to basic services, many municipalities continue to struggle to meet citizens’ expectations. However, the challenge goes beyond whether municipalities are delivering or not. It raises a bigger question: is the current model of service delivery working, and what needs to change to make government more effective, accountable and responsive to citizens? We asked experts where they believe the problems lie – and what can be done differently.

“Good governance matters because it ensures public or private institutions operate with transparency, accountability and fairness. It builds public trust, prevents corruption, manages risks effectively and drives sustainable economic and social growth by responding fairly to the needs of all people.”


SERVICE DELIVERY

NO NEED TO REINVENT THE WHEEL Dr Abedian says there is no need to look for alternatives to the way services are currently delivered. “Running cities and municipalities dates back seven hundred years. There is no need to reinvent the wheel or even refine it. “This is the oldest sphere of governance, dating back to Athens and Rome, for which we have historic records. There is no alternative to sound urban service delivery: competence and expertise are needed. “South Africa has gone way too far in admiring incompetence and trying to prop up incompetence at a huge cost to the poor and the working class. All alternatives, at the end of the day, lead to additional costs. “This does not mean that there is not a role for public-private partnerships or outsourcing in projects, but the institutional structure of city governance should be founded on the tried-and-tested pillars of competent and committed staff, supported by transparency and technology.” Dr Abedian says there are many examples worldwide that government can learn from. “There may be minor variations, but by and large they follow the tried-and-tested model. Even in South Africa, there are some successful models. However, the incompetent do not want to look in the mirror and are always looking for explanations.”

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

FROM CAPACITY TO EXECUTION While Dr Abedian places the problem squarely at the door of political interference and a lack of technical competence, George Asamani, MD for sub-Saharan Africa at the Project Management Institute (PMI), offers a more nuanced assessment: the capacity to deliver exists, but it is unevenly distributed across government. “Some institutions demonstrate that effective delivery is possible within the country’s existing governance framework. The challenge is how we replicate that capability, strengthen weaker institutions and build a more consistent culture of execution across government. “South Africa has no shortage of policies or development ambitions. Increasingly, the challenge is translating those ambitions into tangible outcomes for citizens. Every improvement in public services ultimately must be delivered through projects. Whether it is water infrastructure, roads, housing, healthcare or digital services, successful delivery requires strong project leadership,

effective governance, capable institutions and accountability for outcomes.” Asamani says this is one of the reasons the Public Sector Project Management Community of Practice (PSPMCoP) is important. “By bringing together the Presidency, public institutions, academia and the project management profession, the CoP creates a platform for institutions to share knowledge, exchange practical experience, learn from successful delivery models and strengthen execution capability across the public sector. Rather than every institution trying to solve similar challenges independently, the opportunity is to identify what works and create mechanisms to replicate and scale those successes.” The CoP can also complement the District Development Model (DDM) by strengthening the execution capability needed to translate integrated planning into measurable outcomes. “The DDM provides a framework for breaking down silos and enabling the three spheres of government to plan, budget and implement around a shared ‘One Plan’ at district level. The CoP can reinforce this by helping practitioners strengthen common approaches to project governance, implementation, monitoring, risk management and accountability. “The intention is to support what already exists by connecting expertise, sharing proven practices and helping successful approaches travel across institutions and districts. Integrated planning ultimately has to be matched by integrated execution. “Where municipalities or public institutions do not have sufficient capacity to deliver alone, alternative delivery models should be considered. This could include collaboration

across government, partnerships with academia and professional bodies, private-sector participation, outsourcing or appropriately structured public-private partnerships.”

WHAT NEEDS TO CHANGE? Pan-African Investment and Research Services’ Dr Iraj Abedian’s suggested corrections to improve local government service delivery: • Depoliticise the running of the city; make a minimum of 10 years’ business experience a basic requirement for anyone who wants to serve the city as a councillor, municipal manager or in another executive role. • Appoint qualified professionals with the required experience to head each division. • Make the appointment and interview processes public and put the focus on merit. • Anyone found to be involved in corruption or malfeasance should be barred from nomination for any public service role. • Background checks and psychometric profiling should be mandatory for any executive or general manager role. • Commitment to public service should be a key requirement.

Follow: George Asamani www.linkedin.com/in/gasamani PMI www.linkedin.com/company/pmiafrica

“THE ROOT CAUSE OF NONDELIVERY OF SERVICES IS GREED.” – PROFESSOR BONANG MOHALE

PU BL IC SECTOR

SERVICE DELIVERY_subbed2.indd 9

9

2026/10/19 09:31


PUBLIC INVESTMENT

INVESTING IN AGEING ASSETS South Africa has invested billions in infrastructure, but ageing assets and inadequate maintenance are eroding that investment, writes GEOFF TOOLEY, president of the Institute of Municipal Engineering of Southern Africa

S

ince South Africa’s 1994 move into the democratic era, the focus has been on investment in infrastructure and rectifying the imbalances in spatial development. From roads and rail to water systems, schools and hospitals, billions have been poured into building new assets. Despite this scale of investment, the challenge is not only the need to build new infrastructure, but also to protect and sustain the value of what has already been built. The concept of the “maintenance dividend” highlights why prioritising preventative care of existing assets may yield greater returns than continually building new ones.

MAINTENANCE DIVIDEND The maintenance dividend is not just about saving money. It is about safeguarding service delivery and economic competitiveness: • Reliability of services: communities depend on consistent water, electricity and transport. Maintenance ensures continuity. • Equity: poorly maintained infrastructure disproportionately affects vulnerable communities, widening inequality. • Economic productivity: businesses rely on functioning logistics, energy and communications. Maintenance supports growth. • Climate resilience: well-maintained stormwater systems, dams and coastal defences reduce disaster risks, a growing concern in South Africa.

Preventative maintenance is not glamorous. Its benefits are often less visible in the short term, making it harder to compete with projects that offer an immediate, tangible demonstration of progress. Short five-year political and administrative tenures can therefore incentivise visible new capital projects over less glamorous maintenance. However, economically, it is far more efficient than reactive repairs or wholesale replacement. International studies suggest that every rand spent on preventative maintenance can save between three and five rand in future rehabilitation costs. For example: • Roads: regular resurfacing extends the life of a road by decades. Neglect leads to potholes, requiring costly reconstruction. • Water and sewer systems: routine inspection of pipelines prevents leaks and contamination, avoiding expensive emergency repairs and water losses. • Electricity grids: scheduled maintenance reduces outages and prolongs asset life, this lowers the need for new generation capacity. Stormwater maintenance can have an even greater impact: when systems fail, roads, water, electricity, sewerage and telecommunications infrastructure can also be lost, as recent floods have demonstrated. Despite the clear economics, maintenance has historically been underfunded. This is driven by several factors, including a budgeting bias, where capital expenditure on new projects is

10

politically attractive, while maintenance is often seen as deferrable; fragmented accountability, with municipalities, provinces and national departments sharing responsibilities, but often lacking co-ordination; skills shortages, with engineering and technical staff often overstretched, limiting proactive asset management; and data gaps, where outdated asset registers and incomplete GIS datasets make it difficult to plan maintenance strategically. The result is a vicious cycle: infrastructure deteriorates, service delivery falters, public trust erodes, and government responds with costly new builds rather than protecting existing investments. To unlock the maintenance dividend, government may need to fundamentally change how it budgets, manages and protects public infrastructure: 1. Shift in budgeting philosophy • Ring-fence a percentage of infrastructure budgets for maintenance. Municipalities often spend less than one per cent of asset value on upkeep, below the recommended two to five per cent. • Adopt life-cycle costing, ensuring new projects include long-term maintenance provisions.

2. Professionalisation of asset management • Strengthen municipal engineering capacity and ensure senior administrative leadership are professionally registered. • Require competency standards for infrastructure managers, aligned with the broader professionalisation framework for public service. 3. Data-driven planning • Modernise asset registers using GIS and digital tools. • Benchmark maintenance performance across municipalities to identify best practices. 4. Public accountability • Publish annual “state of infrastructure” reports. • Engage communities in monitoring, creating transparency around maintenance backlogs. 5. Incentivising preventative care • Treasury could reward municipalities that demonstrate effective maintenance with additional allocations. • Performance-based grants could shift incentives away from new builds toward sustainable asset management. South Africa’s infrastructure story cannot be written only in terms of new projects. Preventative maintenance saves money, protects services and strengthens resilience.

Follow: Geoff Tooley www.linkedin.com/in/geoff-tooley-7111177a/

IMAGES: NICO VAN BLERK/ISTOCK.COM

PREVENTATIVE MAINTENANCE IS CRITICAL

PU BL IC SECTOR

public investment_subbed2.indd 10

2026/10/19 10:15


WATER SECURITY

FROM WATER CRISIS TO LASTING SOLUTIONS

The National Water Action Plan tackles South Africa’s water crisis, but experts warn investment must be matched by skills, maintenance and accountability, writes ITUMELENG MOGAKI

IMAGES: FEARLESS ON FOUR WHEELS

F

or many South Africans, water outages have become a recurring feature of daily life, exposing failures that go beyond ageing infrastructure. Municipal capacity, maintenance, skills, revenue management and accountability are all part of the problem. The National Water Action Plan (NWAP), released by President Cyril Ramaphosa in July 2026, aims to tackle those underlying weaknesses through infrastructure investment, institutional and regulatory reform, improved municipal performance and action against corruption. The Presidency says the plan is intended to address the root causes of water supply failures, rather than simply provide short-term relief. Chris Campbell, CEO of Consulting Engineers South Africa (CESA), says: “The lack of accountability over many years is the reason why we are now seeing the need for critical interventions such as the National Water Action Plan,” he says. Campbell believes the plan will only work if municipalities have the people and technical capability to execute it. “No amount of ring-fencing or institutional reform will hold water if there are not enough competent people to run treatment plants, maintain assets and make sound engineering decisions on the ground,” says Campbell.

“Engineers, technicians, technologists and process controllers who left or retired from the public sector were not always replaced, while existing personnel were not necessarily adequately trained,” adds Campbell. He also questions why another major intervention is needed when the National Water and Sanitation Master Plan was introduced in 2019 to guide investment and service delivery through 2030 and beyond.

He also sees a role for local stakeholders in protecting scarce water resources, supported by skills development and succession planning. The difficulty is that long-term reform cannot immediately repair already failing systems. Dawid Bredenkamp, co-founder of Damsak, a manufacturer and supplier of liquid storage solutions, argues that government needs a parallel response. “Government plans are necessary. They are also slow. The municipalities failing today will still be failing while the NWAP is being implemented because infrastructure at that scale takes years to turn around,” Bredenkamp says. Bredenkamp proposes formally recognising decentralised water storage as part of national water security, allowing businesses, farms and communities to build resilience while larger systems are repaired. “Businesses, farms and communities that invest in their own water independence are not giving up on the system. They are buying the system time to fix itself,” says Bredenkamp. The NWAP has therefore set the direction. Its real test will be whether government can turn plans into functioning institutions, maintained infrastructure and accountable delivery, so that fixing the next outage becomes less important than preventing it.

FROM REFORM TO RESULTS Kate Stubbs, business development director at waste management company EnviroServ, believes the NWAP correctly identifies the breadth of the challenge, but the “critical question now is whether we can translate this plan into functioning treatment works, maintained pipelines, reduced water losses and, ultimately, reliable water coming out of people’s taps”. Dr Lester Goldman, CEO of the Water Institute of Southern Africa (WISA), emphasises the need to ensure infrastructure investment is supported by the skills required to manage it. “Infrastructure investment is important, but it must be matched by skilled professionals who can ensure that investment translates into effective and sustainable water management,” Dr Goldman says.

DOWNLOAD

THE NATIONAL WATER ACTION PLAN

READ

THE NATIONAL WATER AND SANITATION MASTER PLAN

Follow: Chris Campbell www.linkedin.com/in/christopher-campbell-a97b5255 Kate Stubbs www.linkedin.com/in/kate-stubbs-526ba23 Dr Lester Goldman www.linkedin.com/in/dr-lester-goldman-8887136 Dawid Bredenkamp www.facebook.com/dawid.bredenkamp CESA www.cesa.co.za Enviroserv www.enviroserv.co.za WISA www.wisa.org.za Damask www.damsak.co.za/about-us

PU BL IC SECTOR

WATER SECURITY_subbed2.indd 11

11

2026/10/19 09:32


WHY TRUSTED DIGITAL IDENTITY IS THE FOUNDATION OF MODERN GOVERNMENT To manage risk effectively, public sector institutions need assurance that the person, business or organisation behind any transaction is legitimate – this is where a digital identity system plays a vital role, writes AMRITHA REDDY, Senior Director of Fraud Product Management, TransUnion Africa

E

very year, government manages billions of rand in public funds and delivers essential services to millions of citizens. Yet public institutions are under growing pressure to improve service delivery, reduce fraud and ensure support reaches the right beneficiaries without creating barriers for legitimate citizens. These priorities are particularly important as South Africa accelerates its digital transformation. Initiatives such as Digital ID, MyMzansi and MzansiXchange point towards a more connected, citizen-centric state, where people can access services more easily, and government institutions can work more efficiently across systems. However, South Africa’s next phase is not simply about digitising more services. It is about building trusted digital government: a model in which citizens can access services securely and efficiently, public resources are protected, and institutions can make confident, responsible decisions. Digital identity is a foundational enabler of this shift. A digital identity system and verified digital credential wallet could enable South Africans to securely store and share verified personal information, from identity documents to educational certificates in digital form. Done well, this could reduce reliance on physical documentation, simplify access to services and improve citizen experiences. However, the real value lies beyond the technology itself. The question for government is not simply how to verify someone’s identity, but how trusted information can help deliver better outcomes.

12

IDENTITY IS THE STARTING POINT, NOT THE DESTINATION Every digital interaction begins with confidence in who is accessing a service. Whether a citizen is applying for social support, accessing an account, updating personal information or engaging with a public institution, government needs to be confident that the person behind the transaction is legitimate. The same applies to businesses and organisations engaging with the public sector.

FRAUD PREVENTION IS MOST EFFECTIVE WHEN IT ENABLES INSTITUTIONS TO DISTINGUISH LEGITIMATE USERS FROM HIGHER-RISK ACTIVITY, APPLYING ADDITIONAL VERIFICATION ONLY WHERE APPROPRIATE.

For government, this matters because the consequences extend beyond individual transactions. Weak controls can expose public programmes to fraud and leakage, while overly rigid controls create unnecessary friction for legitimate citizens. The scale of the challenge is evident in TransUnion’s H1 2026 Update: Top Fraud Trends Report, which found that government recorded South Africa’s highest suspected digital fraud rate among the sectors analysed in 2025, at 12.5 per cent, while suspected fraud attempts also increased by 46 per cent year-on-year. The report also found that South Africa was one of the few markets where the highest suspected fraud risk occurred during account login rather than account creation. These findings highlight an important reality for public sector leaders: risk does not stop once someone has been verified. As services become increasingly digital, institutions need the intelligence to identify changing risks throughout the citizen journey and respond before losses occur.

Risk evolves throughout the digital journey. Legitimate accounts can be compromised, behaviours can change, and previously unseen connections between devices, identities and organisations can emerge over time. What appears trustworthy at onboarding may present a very different risk profile months later. This changing threat landscape requires public-sector organisations to move beyond static verification and adopt a more continuous approach to trust and risk management. Amritha Reddy

PUBLIC SECTOR

Transunion_dps TL.indd 12

2026/10/19 09:05


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH

A CONNECTED STATE REQUIRES CONNECTED INTELLIGENCE Government’s digital transformation strategy places growing emphasis on interoperability and responsible information sharing between institutions. A transaction may appear legitimate in isolation, yet information held elsewhere may reveal anomalies, relationships or behavioural patterns that warrant closer scrutiny. Connected intelligence can help institutions see signals earlier and make better informed decisions. For government, managing large-scale programmes, coupled with constrained resources, the ability to identify higher-risk activity and focus attention where it is most needed can be particularly valuable. Better data matters when it enables fairer, more explainable, and measurable decisions. Its value is ultimately measured by the outcomes; it enables more efficient verification, stronger accountability, reduced friction and better public-sector decision-making. As government increasingly adopts advanced analytics, biometrics and artificial intelligence, governance becomes even more critical. Privacy, transparency and accountability are not compliance exercises; they are essential trust requirements that underpin effective digital government.

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

PROGRAMME INTEGRITY AND CITIZEN INCLUSION MUST WORK TOGETHER Effective government requires balancing two equally important responsibilities: protecting public resources and ensuring that legitimate beneficiaries can access services and support. Getting this balance right is important. South Africa’s 2026 Budget notes that the social wage supports approximately 26.5 million grant beneficiaries and accounts for around 60 per cent of non-interest government expenditure. On this scale, even small improvements in verification, decision-making and programme oversight can have significant impact. Fraud prevention is most effective when it enables institutions to distinguish legitimate users from higher-risk activity, applying additional verification only where appropriate. At the same time, digital identity should expand secure access rather than create new barriers to essential services. Verification processes should be transparent,

TRANSUNION AFRICA

A DIGITAL IDENTITY SYSTEM AND VERIFIED DIGITAL CREDENTIAL WALLET COULD ENABLE SOUTH AFRICANS TO SECURELY STORE AND SHARE VERIFIED PERSONAL INFORMATION, FROM IDENTITY DOCUMENTS TO EDUCATIONAL CERTIFICATES IN DIGITAL FORM.

proportionate and supported by appropriate review mechanisms to ensure legitimate citizens are not disadvantaged. Programme integrity and citizen inclusion are therefore complementary obligations. Stronger controls should help ensure public resources reach those who qualify for them while maintaining trust and accessibility.

PUBLIC-PRIVATE COLLABORATION STRENGTHENS TRUST As digital ecosystems become more interconnected, effective risk management increasingly depends on collaboration between government and trusted private-sector partners. This collaboration works best when capability is matched by accountability. Government retains responsibility for policy, citizen data and public outcomes, while the private sector can contribute trusted information, analytics, technology and expertise. Together, these capabilities can help strengthen identity verification, improve decision-making and support more resilient digital services.

South Africa’s opportunity is to build trust into digital services from the outset, creating a more secure, resilient and inclusive digital ecosystem that improves citizen outcomes, protects public resources and strengthens confidence in government. It is not simply about building a more digital state, but about creating a state that citizens can trust in a digital world. TransUnion brings extensive experience in identity verification, fraud prevention and data-driven risk management to support organisations on their digital transformation journeys. For government institutions looking to strengthen digital trust, improve service delivery and balance fraud prevention with citizen inclusion, contact TransUnion Africa at AskTUAfrica@transunion.com to explore how we can help build more secure, resilient and inclusive digital services.

THE NEXT PHASE OF DIGITAL GOVERNMENT South Africa has already established a clear direction for digital transformation. The opportunity now is to ensure trust keeps pace. The next phase is not digitisation for its own sake. It is trusted digital government, where technology, data and identity work together to deliver better outcomes for citizens and stronger protection of public resources. Digital identity is an important first step, but it is not the final destination. Its real value comes from enabling government to establish trust, understand risk, improve decision-making and deliver services more effectively. Success will depend on bringing together trusted identity, responsible data use, strong governance and effective collaboration, while keeping citizen inclusion at the centre of the digital journey.

VISIT WEBSITE

SCAN THIS QR CODE TO GO TO THE TRANSUNION AFRICA WEBSITE

For more information: www.transunion.co.za

Follow: TransUnion www.linkedin.com/company/transunion/home

PU BL IC SECTOR

Transunion_dps TL.indd 13

13

2026/10/19 09:00


ToCheck_DPS.indd 2

2026/10/06 12:59


ToCheck_DPS.indd 3

2026/10/06 13:00


INTEGRATED GOVERNMENT

FROM SILOS TO SYSTEMS Why government needs to work as one Water, electricity, housing, transport, health and economic development rarely fit neatly into departmental boundaries, so how did government end up working in silos? By TREVOR CRIGHTON

– DR XOLANI THUSI

“Section 41(1)(b) indicates that all spheres of government and all organs of state within each sphere must provide effective, transparent, accountable and coherent government for the republic as a whole. This clearly indicates that government institutions must work together across all levels in a clear, organised and unified way to achieve shared goals without working against each other,” he says.

PERSISTENT SYSTEMIC WEAKNESS France Kgobe, a researcher in public administration, says one persistent weakness in our system of governance is the absence of policies, institutions or development plans. “A municipality may plan a housing development before the required bulk water infrastructure is in place. For citizens, however, these are not separate government responsibilities. “They experience the result as one system – whether water flows, roads function, electricity is available, and communities can access jobs, schools, healthcare and safe human settlements.”

HARMONISATION OVER ALIGNMENT Dr Thusi believes that leveraging the President’s Co-ordinating Council, the Premier’s Intergovernmental Forum, interprovincial forums and municipal intergovernmental forums to promote co-operation within government institutions

France Kgobe

16

and to support sustainable service delivery and economic development is one way of tackling the “silo” challenge. “These forums comprise individuals in strategic political positions across all spheres of government. They are aware of the challenges facing their respective government institutions and can leverage support and streamline operations with other government institutions to ensure their institutions meet their objectives,” he says. “In a country with a thirty-two per cent unemployment rate, dependence on government becomes massive, and co-operation within government institutions has never been this urgent. The machinery of government will achieve its objectives if government promotes collaboration and co-operation within its institutions.” Kgobe says his ongoing research into development planning has increasingly reinforced the importance of harmonisation rather than simple alignment. “Alignment can mean putting different plans next to each other and identifying common priorities. Harmonisation goes further: institutions jointly determine priorities, sequence investments, co-ordinate budgets, share information and accept collective responsibilities, budgets, timelines and accountability mechanisms,” he says.

Follow: Dr Xolani Thusi www.linkedin.com/in/xolani-t-74649b13a France Kgobe www.linkedin.com/in/france-kgobe-m-a-a19252184

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

S

outh Africa has an extensive planning architecture, but the deeper problem is that government does not always function as an integrated system. Water, electricity, housing, roads, transport, health and economic development are interconnected in the lives of citizens, yet institutionally they are often planned, funded and implemented through different departments, entities and spheres of government. This fragmentation has real consequences. “South Africa is a country where most citizens depend on the government for the provision of basic services. On this basis, intergovernmental relations become imperative to ensure government is responsive to the needs of citizens as stipulated in the Constitution,” says Dr Xolani Thusi, senior lecturer in the School of Public Management, Governance and Public Policy at the University of Johannesburg.

“THE MACHINERY OF GOVERNMENT WILL ACHIEVE ITS OBJECTIVES IF GOVERNMENT PROMOTES COLLABORATION AND CO-OPERATION WITHIN ITS INSTITUTIONS.”

PU BL IC SECTOR

INTEGRATED GOVERNMENT_subbed.indd 16

2026/10/19 09:22


PUBLIC SECTOR TALENT

RETAINING THE SKILLS THAT KEEP CITIES RUNNING

B

uilding a strong institution with integrity and a delivery focus, in which there’s a continuity of skills, is a great challenge at local government level. That continuity challenge has contributed in part to the struggle to attract and retain skilled experts at local government level. “In politics and public service, there’s always a continuity problem. Although political leadership is temporary, institutions require long-term commitments to building skills. The culture of leadership makes a huge difference in terms of recognition of skills and building institutional integrity over time,” says Andrew Donaldson, former deputy director-general at the National Treasury and now senior research associate in the Southern African Labour and Development Research Unit at the University of Cape Town. “The way in which transformation is implemented has sometimes had self-defeating outcomes, which has the consequence of weakening continuity of skills and the retention of expertise.”

WE NEED MORE ENGINEERS

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

Takudzwa Mutize, development economist in the Department of Economics and Finance at the University of the Free State, and Donaldson are of the same view: South African local government suffers from a lack of engineering expertise.

“WITHOUT ENGINEERING CAPACITY IN PLACE, LOCAL GOVERNMENT CAN’T DELIVER THE SERVICES FOR WHICH IT IS RESPONSIBLE.” – ANDREW DONALDSON

“South Africa is caught in a training bottleneck. We produce engineering and tech graduates, but because municipalities have lost their senior experts, there is no one left inside to mentor newcomers. The state ends up surrounded by unemployed graduates on one side and vacant senior Takudzwa Mutize engineering posts on the other, simply because the bridge to get fully qualified is broken,” says Mutize. Donaldson says the engineering expertise shortfall has been under the spotlight for a long time: “Allyson Lawless wrote a report for the South African Institution of Civil Engineering twenty years ago in which she pointed out that out of two hundred and thirty-one local municipalities, less than fifty employed a qualified civil engineer. “Since then, it has got worse. Municipalities now rely almost entirely on technologists and technicians. However, the availability of qualified engineers is the single most-important determinant of the capacity of a municipality to ensure electricity networks are functioning, roads are maintained and water and sanitation are operational – without engineering capacity in place, local government can’t deliver the services for which it is responsible.”

ATTRACTION AND RETENTION Donaldson believes the country is not producing anywhere near enough engineers to start with – and then people graduate with engineering degrees, but head into finance, change careers or emigrate because there isn’t enough opportunity for them. It is both a supply and a demand problem. Asked about whether a lack of will is influencing that lack of opportunity at local government level, he says: “Leadership is about focusing

Local government needs a stronger pipeline of engineering expertise and institutional knowledge, writes TREVOR CRIGHTON

on the really important things. Our municipalities have countless targets and reporting objectives, but the main thing is to maintain infrastructure and invest in meeting future needs. When the performance management systems are too congested with key performance indicators and not actually focused on delivery, it’s impossible to make progress in service delivery and improve living standards over time.”

CREATING A CONDUCIVE ENVIRONMENT Mutize says talented people don’t just choose a job; they choose a place to live. “Good schools, safe neighbourhoods and reliable local services play a huge role in where experts decide to bring their families, which is why functional cities pull talent away from struggling towns.” Inspiring engineers to look to the local government sector as a prospective employer requires getting infrastructure projects underway, according to Donaldson. “We shoot ourselves in the foot so often when it takes two or three years to do planning and design, then start sorting out finances and getting approvals. Then some or other blunder in the process is identified, and we start again. That acceleration of projects and investment is the mechanism through which you attract more engineers, who can then learn on the job and build infrastructure in the process,” he says.

Follow: Andrew Donaldson www.saldru.uct.ac.za/contacts/andrew-donaldson Takudzwa Mutize www.linkedin.com/in/takudzwamutize

PU BL IC SECTOR

skills_subbed.indd 17

17

2026/10/19 10:14


ToCheck_dps.indd 2

2026/10/12 15:07


ToCheck_dps.indd 3

2026/10/12 15:08


FINANCIAL REFORM

FIXING MUNICIPAL FINANCES TO RESTORE TRUST MONEI SELEHO, head of public sector: Nedbank Business and Commercial Banking, examines how stronger financial management, revenue collection and accountable leadership can help municipalities restore sustainable service delivery

THREE RECURRING CHALLENGES From Nedbank’s engagements across the sector, three recurring challenges emerge: 1. Inefficient, fragmented and outdated revenue management systems. 2. Weak enforcement of credit control and consequence management. 3. Persistent revenue leakages alongside a breakdown in payment culture, particularly where service reliability and public trust have deteriorated. What begins as a revenue management challenge can quickly escalate into broader

20

financial distress, reflected in growing debtor books, cash flow pressures, deteriorating balance sheets and compromised service delivery. Strengthening municipal financial sustainability requires effective revenue management, implementation discipline and collective action. Financial institutions can partner with municipalities by providing not only capital, but also revenue collection solutions, including digital payment platforms that improve collection rates and cash flow. Communities, too, must contribute by restoring a culture of payment for services rendered.

BUILDING STRONGER MUNICIPALITIES Financial stability also depends on human capital, sound financial practices and transparent, accountable governance. Operational capability, leadership stability and technical and financial expertise are equally important. When these elements align, municipalities are better positioned to maintain and expand infrastructure, improve service delivery, strengthen financial resilience and restore trust with communities.

LESSONS FROM LOCAL SUCCESS There are already examples of municipalities demonstrating what is possible when leadership, governance and accountability align. The City of uMhlathuze and Midvaal Local Municipality have shown how focused interventions can strengthen financial sustainability and service delivery. At a recent Nedbank Public Sector Roundtable on strengthening municipal financial performance, these municipalities shared how they improved revenue collection, tightened credit control, reduced revenue leakages and implemented systems that deliver measurable results. They are also instilling a culture of payment through mechanisms such as tight credit control,

Monei Seleho

STRENGTHENING MUNICIPAL FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY REQUIRES EFFECTIVE REVENUE MANAGEMENT, IMPLEMENTATION DISCIPLINE AND COLLECTIVE ACTION. implementing disconnections and imposing penalties for overdue accounts. The outcomes include clean audits – an impressive performance worth emulating by other municipalities. Importantly, they have also rebuilt trust with households and businesses, resulting in an improved culture of payment within their communities. As South Africa advances its industrialisation ambitions, effective local governance cannot be overstated. Municipalities must recalibrate priorities, strengthen financial management and break the cycle of financial distress and governance failures that continue to undermine development.

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

T

he recent launch of the Metro Trading Services Reform by National Treasury marks an important step towards restoring municipal functionality, governance and service delivery. The reforms aim to improve operational performance and ensure communities have access to essential services, including water, sanitation, electricity and waste management. This is particularly important given the financial and operational challenges facing many municipalities. Weak revenue collection, a deteriorating culture of payment, rising consumer debt and ageing infrastructure are undermining sustainable service delivery. Municipalities sit at the centre of South Africa’s development agenda. Access to reliable basic services and functioning infrastructure directly affects residents’ quality of life, economic inclusion and the prospects of local communities. South Africa has a comprehensive legislative and policy framework supporting municipal finance, including the Municipal Finance Management Act 56 of 2003 (MFMA), the Municipal Systems Act 32 of 2000, the Municipal Property Rates Act 6 of 2004, revenue regulations, credit control policies and governance standards. Yet implementation remains uneven and requires significant improvement.

PU BL IC SECTOR

FINANCIAL REFORM EVERY RAND_subbed.indd 20

2026/10/19 09:22


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CLIFFE DEKKER HOFMEYR

CONTENTS 30 32 FRUITLESS AND WASTEFUL EXPENDITURE

22 22 WHEN THE STATE FAILS WOMEN Institutional culture, accountability and South Africa’s gender-based violence crisis. By BRIGITTA MANGALE, director – Pro Bono & Human Rights, and SIBONOKUHLE BAART, candidate attorney – Pro Bono & Human Rights, at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr

34 WHEN GOVERNMENT SERVICES DRIVE UP COSTS

Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr’s LEBOHANG MABIDIKANE, director – Competition Law, and CHRISTOPHER KODE, associate – Competition Law, delve into the recently released Competition Commission’s Cost of Living Report

25 NOT NECESSARILY A FIDUCIARY BREACH Senior officials who make irregular decisions aren’t automatically guilty of breaching their fiduciary duty, write YVONNE MKEFA, director – Employment Law, and NOMPUMELELO NDWANDWE, candidate attorney – Employment Law, at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr

28 ARBITRATING WITH THE STATE: Images: Supplied

PROCEED WITH CAUTION

Contracting with the state is rarely straightforward and may give rise to significant legal and commercial consequences. By VINCENT MANKO, director – Dispute Resolution at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr

Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr’s KAMOHELO MOLAPO, associate – Tax & Exchange Control, and HOWMERA PARAK, director – Tax & Exchange Control, unpack why expenditure made in vain and which is avoidable if reasonable care is exercised is more than a PFMA concern

28 30 THE COST OF BEING UNDOCUMENTED - When paperwork shapes women’s choices ELGENE LUTSHITI, director – Pro Bono & Human Rights at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr, writes that identity documentation should be understood as a women’s rights issue

25 PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH_Contents.indd 21

21

2026/10/16 16:36


WHEN THE STATE FAILS WOMEN

Institutional culture, accountability and South Africa’s gender-based violence crisis. By BRIGITTA MANGALE, director – Pro Bono & Human Rights, and SIBONOKUHLE BAART, candidate attorney – Pro Bono & Human Rights, at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr

S

outh Africa has no shortage of laws, policies and constitutional commitments directed at protecting women from gender-based violence (GBV). Yet, studies show nearly 40 per cent of women have experienced physical and/or sexual violence in their lifetime. The challenge is not simply whether the rules exist. It is whether the institutions responsible for giving effect to those rules have the capacity, culture and accountability necessary to make them meaningful in the lives of the women who need them. For many women, the state is encountered not through a

Brigitta Mangale

22

constitutional judgment or a policy document, but through an ordinary interaction with a public official. It may be the police officer who receives a report of rape or domestic violence, the prosecutor who decides how a matter should proceed, the health worker who attends to a survivor, or the official responsible for facilitating access to protection and support. In those moments, constitutional rights move from principle to practice.

INSTITUTIONAL CULTURE This is why South Africa’s GBV crisis must also be understood as a crisis of state institutions. Where officials

repeatedly fail to apply the law, where poor performance is tolerated and where citizens encounter indifference rather than service, the problem cannot be explained only as the misconduct of individual employees. Repeated individual failures can reveal something deeper: an institutional culture that has normalised conduct inconsistent with the standards imposed by law. The distinction matters. A state can have an extensive legal framework and still have weak state capacity. Effective institutions are not simply those that possess good laws; they are institutions capable of implementing those laws consistently through competent, professional and accountable systems. In the context of GBV, this distinction can have devastating consequences. For a survivor approaching SAPS, the police station is often the doorway through which the protections of the Constitution, the Domestic Violence Act and related policies are either accessed or denied. The duties imposed on police officials are not vague aspirations. They include obligations to assist complainants, explain available remedies, properly record complaints, open dockets where charges are registered, arrange assistance where necessary and provide appropriate referrals and protection. Yet the existence of these obligations does not by itself ensure that they are performed properly. The quality of that first interaction matters. A woman who is dismissed, discouraged from opening a case, told to resolve the matter herself, or treated without dignity is not merely receiving poor customer service.

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 3 pages Public Sector Leaders - B Mangale_subbed.indd 22

2026/10/16 16:00


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CLIFFE DEKKER HOFMEYR

She is encountering the state at a moment of particular vulnerability and discovering whether the legal protections promised to her are practically available. Research on procedural justice has repeatedly linked fair treatment, victim support, confidence in police and perceptions of police effectiveness with willingness to engage with law enforcement. When people stop believing that an institution will assist them, they may stop approaching it altogether. It is against this backdrop that we must consider institutional culture. Every institution has formal rules: legislation, regulations, policies, directives and codes of conduct. However, institutions also have informal rules. These are the behaviours that employees learn are actually expected, tolerated or rewarded. A policy may require an official to treat a complainant with dignity, but the informal rule may be that difficult cases should be discouraged. A directive may require a thorough investigation, while the practical message from colleagues or managers may be that closing a docket quickly is what matters. A disciplinary framework may exist, while the institutional experience tells employees that failure to comply will rarely have consequences. Over time, the informal rules can become more influential than formal ones. New employees learn not only from training manuals, but also from watching what happens around them. They observe who is praised, who is promoted, who is disciplined and who is left alone. They learn what managers actually monitor and what they ignore. In this way, organisational culture is produced through everyday institutional practice.

THE CONSEQUENCES OF CULTURE FAILURE The consequences are particularly serious in the GBV context. When poor performance becomes normalised, a dangerous cycle

can develop. Good employees may become demoralised when diligence attracts no greater recognition than negligence. Managers lose credibility when standards are unenforced. Poor practice becomes routine rather than exceptional. Most importantly, members of the public begin to experience the law as something that exists on paper, but cannot reliably protect them in practice. Accountability therefore matters far more than punishment. It is a mechanism through which an institution communicates what it values. If an institution recruits carefully, but does not train adequately, it sends one message. If it trains well, but never evaluates performance, it sends another. If performance is measured, but poor performance carries no meaningful consequence, the institution communicates that the standard is not really a standard at all. Conversely, when competence is recognised, professional conduct is expected, performance is measured and persistent failure has consequences, employees receive a clear message about what the institution stands for. This is where the broader question of meritocracy becomes relevant. Merit-based recruitment and promotion are important components of professional public administration because public servants should be selected and advanced on the basis of competence, suitability and performance rather than irrelevant considerations. However, meritocracy alone is not enough. It must form part of an institutional ecosystem that includes rigorous training, clear expectations, effective supervision, objective performance management and credible consequence management. The constitutional significance of this cannot be understated. South Africa’s Constitution establishes values and principles for public administration that include a high standard of professional ethics, efficient and effective

MERITOCRACY ALONE IS NOT ENOUGH. IT MUST FORM PART OF AN INSTITUTIONAL ECOSYSTEM THAT INCLUDES RIGOROUS TRAINING, CLEAR EXPECTATIONS, EFFECTIVE SUPERVISION, OBJECTIVE PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT AND CREDIBLE CONSEQUENCE MANAGEMENT.

Sibonokuhle Baart

use of resources, development-oriented administration, impartial and equitable service delivery, accountability, and sound human-resource management and career development. These are not merely managerial preferences. They are constitutional standards for how public power should be exercised. For women confronting violence, failures in institutional culture can therefore implicate fundamental constitutional rights. The right to equality is engaged when institutional practices reproduce patterns of disadvantage or fail to respond appropriately to gendered violence. The right to dignity is compromised when a survivor is belittled, dismissed or treated as an inconvenience. The rights to freedom and security of the person and, potentially, to life, take on particular urgency

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 3 pages Public Sector Leaders - B Mangale_subbed.indd 23

23

2026/10/16 16:00


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CLIFFE DEKKER HOFMEYR

where state failures leave women exposed to continuing violence. It is important not to suggest that every administrative failure automatically amounts to a constitutional violation. The point is more fundamental: the state cannot meaningfully fulfil its constitutional responsibilities if its institutions systematically fail to perform the functions through which those responsibilities are realised. Rights require institutions capable of giving them practical effect. This is also why institutional failure should not be reduced to a question of individual morality. There will always be officials who act improperly and officials who go beyond what is required. However, an institution should not depend on individual heroism to protect constitutional rights. It should create conditions in which lawful, professional and humane conduct is the expected norm, and in which persistent departures from that norm are identified and addressed.

GOOD LEADERSHIP, VALUES AND ETHICS ARE ESSENTIAL Proper leadership is therefore central. Public-service leaders shape institutional culture not only through speeches and strategic plans, but also through the standards they enforce every day. What is measured becomes important. What is rewarded becomes desirable. What is ignored becomes permissible. What is consistently sanctioned becomes unacceptable. For institutions responding to GBV, this should mean asking harder questions about what constitutes successful performance. It is not enough to count how many complaints were received, how many dockets were opened or how many cases were

24

administratively finalised. Quality matters. Was the survivor treated with dignity? Was the complaint accurately recorded? Were the relevant legal remedies explained? Was the investigation properly conducted? Were referrals and protections provided where required? Did the institution do what the law required, and did it do so in a manner that respected the person seeking its assistance? These questions require institutional commitment rather than another layer of policy. South Africa already has substantial legal and policy architecture addressing GBV. The more difficult task is ensuring that the people and systems charged with implementing it are competent, properly supported, appropriately supervised and meaningfully accountable. The National Framework Towards the Professionalisation of the Public Sector recognises the importance of a professional, meritocratic and ethical public administration, improved leadership, governance and accountability, functional government and

SOUTH AFRICA’S RESPONSE TO GBV THEREFORE REQUIRES MORE THAN NEW COMMITMENTS. IT REQUIRES INSTITUTIONS THAT ARE CAPABLE OF DELIVERING ON THE COMMITMENTS ALREADY MADE.

meaningful engagement with stakeholders. These principles are directly relevant to the GBV crisis. A professional state is not simply one that employs qualified people. It is one that has created an institutional environment in which quality service is expected, monitored and sustained. Ultimately, the question we should be asking is not only whether South Africa has the right laws to combat GBV. We should also ask: what does the state allow its officials to get away with?

PROTECTING WOMEN’S RIGHTS REQUIRES THE FULL COMMITMENT OF STATE INSTITUTIONS The perpetrator may commit the original act of violence, but the quality of the state’s response can determine whether a survivor encounters protection or further vulnerability, justice or abandonment, dignity or humiliation. The constitutional promise cannot end with legislation. It must be carried through the institutions that give that promise practical meaning. South Africa’s response to GBV therefore requires more than new commitments. It requires institutions that are capable of delivering on the commitments already made. Building those institutions means taking culture seriously: recruiting and promoting for competence, training for excellence, measuring meaningful performance, supporting effective leadership and ensuring that persistent failure has consequences. A constitutional democracy cannot ask women to place their trust in laws that its institutions are not equipped, or not required, to implement. If we are serious about confronting GBV, we must be equally serious about building a state in which protecting women’s rights is not an aspiration, but an ordinary and consistently enforced part of public service.

Follow: Brigitta Mangale www.linkedin.com/in/brigitta-mangale-4358b1a2 Sibonokuhle Baart www.linkedin.com/in/sibonokuhlebaart www.cliffedekkerhofmeyr.com

IMAGES: SIMPSON33/ISTOCK.COM, SUPPLIED

A WOMAN WHO IS DISMISSED, DISCOURAGED FROM OPENING A CASE, TOLD TO RESOLVE THE MATTER HERSELF, OR TREATED WITHOUT DIGNITY IS NOT MERELY RECEIVING POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE. SHE IS ENCOUNTERING THE STATE AT A MOMENT OF PARTICULAR VULNERABILITY AND DISCOVERING WHETHER THE LEGAL PROTECTIONS PROMISED TO HER ARE PRACTICALLY AVAILABLE.

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 3 pages Public Sector Leaders - B Mangale_subbed.indd 24

2026/10/16 16:00


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CLIFFE DEKKER HOFMEYR

NOT NECESSARILY A FIDUCIARY BREACH

Senior officials who make irregular decisions aren’t automatically guilty of breaching their fiduciary duty, write YVONNE MKEFA, director – Employment Law, and NOMPUMELELO NDWANDWE, candidate attorney – Employment Law, at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr

T

he public sector has long been confronted with concerns surrounding corruption and maladministration. At the centre of this discourse is the extent to which senior employees, who are entrusted with significant responsibilities, are required to exercise those responsibilities in the interests of their employer and in accordance with applicable legislation, policies and directives. Where an irregular decision is subsequently

identified, it may be tempting to attribute responsibility to the senior employee overseeing the relevant function. However, the mere fact that an employee occupies a senior position, or that an employee participated in a process that ultimately proved to be irregular, does not necessarily establish a breach of fiduciary duty. This distinction was recently considered by the Labour Appeal Court (LAC) in Department of Sports, Arts, Culture and

POOR OUTCOMES, IRREGULAR DECISIONS AND FIDUCIARY BREACHES ARE NOT INTERCHANGEABLE CONCEPTS.

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 3 pages - FIDUCIARY DUTY_subbed.indd 25

25

2026/10/16 16:13


THE COURT MADE IT CLEAR THAT A FIDUCIARY-DUTY CHARGE IS NOT ESTABLISHED MERELY BECAUSE AN EMPLOYEE WAS INVOLVED IN A PROCESS THAT ULTIMATELY PROVED FLAWED.

Recreation, Gauteng v General Public Service Sector Bargaining Council and Others (case no JA14/25), delivered on 1 September 2026. The judgment illustrates that where an employer relies on an alleged breach of fiduciary duty as the basis for disciplinary action, the focus must ultimately be on the employee’s own conduct, knowledge and culpability.

The facts and proceedings Mr Kolanisi was employed as chief director: human capacity management in the Gauteng Department of Sports, Arts, Culture and Recreation. The department charged him with, among other things, breaching his fiduciary duties by allegedly recommending the appointment of a candidate who did not meet the minimum requirements prescribed by a Department of Public Service and Administration (DPSA) directive. The department contended that, given his senior position and responsibility for ensuring legislative compliance, he ought to have prevented the appointment from proceeding. Following a disciplinary hearing, Mr Kolanisi was found guilty and dismissed. He subsequently challenged the fairness of his dismissal at arbitration. The commissioner found that the recruitment process was flawed from the outset and concluded that the department had failed to establish that Mr Kolanisi had acted in bad faith or otherwise breached his fiduciary duties.

26

The LAC’s approach to fiduciary duties The central issue before the LAC was whether the commissioner’s conclusion that Mr Kolanisi had not breached his fiduciary duties was one that a reasonable decision-maker could reach on the evidence. In answering that question, the court focused not on the existence of an irregular appointment, but on whether the department had proven Mr Kolanisi’s personal culpability in relation to that appointment. The court accepted that senior employees can owe fiduciary duties to their employers. However, it cautioned against conflating an irregular outcome with a breach of fiduciary duty. In rejecting the Department’s reliance on RSF Administrators (Pty) Ltd v Samons and Others, the court stated: “The case seems to confirm that senior employees owe fiduciary duties, however, it does not establish a principle that if a poor decision is made, a breach is proved.” This statement lies at the heart of the judgment. The court made it clear that a fiduciary-duty charge is not established merely because an employee was involved in a process that ultimately proved flawed. Nor can an employer rely solely on the employee’s seniority or general responsibility for compliance. Rather, the employer bears the onus of proving that the employee personally acted in bad faith or in a manner

incompatible with the duties of loyalty, honesty and good faith arising from the employment relationship. The LAC accordingly emphasised that an employer must establish a sufficient connection between irregularity and the employee’s own conduct. This requires evidence demonstrating the employee’s involvement in the impugned decision, the authority exercised by the employee, the employee’s knowledge of the relevant circumstances, and conduct that is culpable or inconsistent with the employee’s obligations to the employer. Without such evidence, a fiduciary breach cannot simply be inferred from an irregular result. On the facts, the court found that the evidence did not establish the necessary connection between the irregular appointment and Mr Kolanisi’s conduct. The advertisement containing the allegedly defective requirements had been approved on 2 August 2016, approximately one month before Mr Kolanisi assumed his position on 1 September 2016. He therefore had no involvement in drafting or approving the advertisement that formed the foundation of the recruitment process. As the court observed, the person responsible for approving the advertisement, rather than Mr Kolanisi, was the individual responsible for that particular irregularity. The court further accepted that Mr Kolanisi was not a member of the selection panel and had no authority to recommend an appointment. His role was limited to supporting the recommendation generated through the recruitment process. Importantly, the department’s own recruitment policy provided that selection criteria could not be changed after interviews had commenced. This meant that Mr Kolanisi could not simply alter the criteria or restart the process without potentially acting contrary

IMAGES: JACOB WACKERHAUSEN/ISTOCK.COM, SUPPLIED

Yvonne Mkefa

The commissioner accordingly found the dismissal substantively unfair and ordered his reinstatement. The department launched review proceedings in the Labour Court, arguing that the commissioner had failed properly to assess Mr Kolanisi’s obligations as a senior employee and had incorrectly concluded that no fiduciary breach had occurred. The Labour Court dismissed the review application, finding the commissioner’s conclusions reasonable. The department then appealed to the LAC.

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 3 pages - FIDUCIARY DUTY_subbed.indd 26

2026/10/16 16:14


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CLIFFE DEKKER HOFMEYR

WHILE SENIOR EMPLOYEES MAY OWE FIDUCIARY DUTIES TO THEIR EMPLOYERS, THE EXISTENCE OF SUCH DUTIES DOES NOT RENDER THEM STRICTLY LIABLE FOR EVERY IRREGULARITY OCCURRING WITHIN THEIR SPHERE OF RESPONSIBILITY.

IMAGES: JACOB WACKERHAUSEN/ISTOCK.COM, SUPPLIED

Nompumelelo Ndwandwe

to the applicable policy framework. These circumstances undermined the department’s argument that he should be held responsible for the appointment. The court also attached significance to the absence of evidence establishing that Mr Kolanisi knew about the NEHAWU observation report, which raised concerns regarding the recommended candidate. The report had been addressed to the acting head of department, who was its custodian. Mr Kolanisi testified that he never received the report and had made enquiries regarding its whereabouts. Significantly, the acting head of department did not testify to contradict this evidence. In those circumstances, the commissioner was entitled to accept Mr Kolanisi’s version and conclude that the department had failed to establish the necessary knowledge on his part. The court also considered evidence originating from the department itself. The department’s head of department had previously assisted the MEC in responding

to the Public Service Commission and stated that the acting head of department was satisfied that the recruitment and selection process had been followed correctly and that the recommended candidate met the requirements set out in the advertisement. The LAC regarded this as significant because it demonstrated that Mr Kolanisi was not alone in his understanding of the process and supported the conclusion that he had not acted dishonestly or in bad faith. Having considered the totality of the evidence, the court concluded that the department had failed to discharge the onus resting upon it. As the court explained: “The appellant bore the onus of proving that Mr Kolanisi acted in bad faith or in a manner incompatible with his duties. The commissioner found that the appellant failed to discharge that onus, and that finding, based on the evidence on record, is reasonable.” The court further held: “The commissioner correctly identified the issue as whether the appellant had proved that Mr Kolanisi had recommended the appointment and acted in bad faith. She considered the totality of the evidence and concluded that the appellant had failed to discharge its onus.”

culpability, not merely accountability The judgment provides an important reminder that a fiduciary-duty charge is ultimately concerned with culpability and not merely accountability. While senior employees may owe fiduciary duties to their employers, the existence of such duties does not render them strictly liable for every irregularity occurring within their sphere of responsibility. Importantly, case no JA14/25 clarifies that an employer seeking to prove a breach of fiduciary duty must establish more than an irregular outcome. The employer must

demonstrate the employee’s personal involvement in the impugned conduct, the authority exercised by the employee, the employee’s knowledge of the relevant facts, and conduct demonstrating bad faith, disloyalty or behaviour otherwise inconsistent with the obligations arising from the fiduciary relationship. Seniority and responsibility may be relevant factors in that enquiry, but they cannot substitute for proof of culpable conduct. For employers, the practical lesson is clear. Investigations should focus not only on identifying whether a process was irregular, but also on determining who was responsible for the irregularity, what authority the employee exercised, what the employee knew, and whether the employee’s conduct was inconsistent with the duties of loyalty, honesty and good faith owed to the employer. In the absence of such evidence, disciplinary action based on an alleged fiduciary breach may be difficult to sustain. This case therefore reinforces a fundamental principle of workplace discipline: poor outcomes, irregular decisions and fiduciary breaches are not interchangeable concepts. A finding of breach requires proof of the employee’s own culpable conduct, and cannot be inferred merely from an employee’s position or from the fact that an irregular decision was ultimately taken.

Follow: Yvonne Mkefa www.linkedin.com/in/yvonne-mkefa-aa95a58a Nompumelelo Ndwandwe www.linkedin.com/in/nompumelelo-ndwandwe-79205629b www.cliffedekkerhofmeyr.com

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 3 pages - FIDUCIARY DUTY_subbed.indd 27

27

2026/10/16 16:15


ARBITRATING WITH THE STATE: PROCEED WITH CAUTION

P

arties, including organs of state, frequently agree to resolve commercial disputes through arbitration because arbitration may offer a more flexible and efficient alternative to ordinary court proceedings. As organs of state more meaningfully participate in commercial activity to support economic growth, manage public resources and deliver critical infrastructure, the current trend is that they are becoming increasingly inclined to include arbitration clauses in contracts concluded with private parties

28

pursuant to a public tender process. The involvement of an organ of state introduces constitutional and public-law considerations that may affect both the conduct of the arbitration and the kinds of disputes that may validly be determined by an arbitral tribunal.

PRIVACY AND CONFIDENTIALITY In general, and across jurisdictions, whether one talks about private or international arbitration, the privacy and confidentiality of arbitration is considered one of its core qualities, especially in comparison to litigation. Arbitration is consensual in

nature. The parties ordinarily determine the appointment of the arbitrator or tribunal, the procedure to be followed and, within the applicable legal framework, the substantive law governing the dispute. That autonomy is not unlimited. The limited state supervision over arbitrations may potentially raise questions about the accountability and legitimacy of the arbitration process, particularly where an organ of state is involved as a disputing party. In the context of international arbitrations, the International Arbitration Act, 2017 contains a strong indication that international commercial arbitration proceedings are in principle private (and confidential). It creates a specific transparency regime for organs of state by recording that arbitration proceedings to which a public body is a party are held in public unless, for compelling reasons, the arbitral tribunal directs otherwise. The provision also caters for the confidentiality of arbitral proceedings where such proceedings are held in private. Where an organ of state is a party to arbitration proceedings, such proceedings must be held in public due to public interest in the matter. So even though privacy and confidentiality have always been the hallmark of arbitral proceedings and should rightfully not be ignored, one can readily imagine a trend towards publicity, more so in arbitral proceedings involving organs of state.

IMAGES: BUSINESS/ISTOCK.COM, SUPPLIED

Contracting with the state is rarely straightforward and may give rise to significant legal and commercial consequences. By VINCENT MANKO, director – Dispute Resolution at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr

ARBITRATION CLAUSES IN CONTRACTS INVOLVING ORGANS OF STATE SHOULD BE DRAFTED WITH PARTICULAR CARE.

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 2 page Commercial arbitrations involving organs of state_V Manko_subbed.indd 28

2026/10/16 16:16


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CLIFFE DEKKER HOFMEYR

Parties should therefore not assume that an arbitration involving an organ of state will enjoy the same degree of privacy and confidentiality ordinarily associated with purely private commercial arbitrations.

IMAGES: BUSINESS/ISTOCK.COM, SUPPLIED

CONSTITUTIONAL COMPLIANCE AND PROCUREMENT LEGALITY A further difficulty that arises concerns the nature of disputes that may properly be referred to arbitration. This issue is particularly important where the underlying agreement, including the arbitration agreement, was concluded through a public-procurement process. Organs of state conduct procurement under exacting laws for reasons of transparency, fairness, competitiveness, accountability and public service delivery. The procurement laws, binding upon organs of state, flow from section 217(1) of the Constitution. Public procurement is therefore subject to laws that concern the exercise of public powers. When an organ of state contracts for goods and services, it is not merely exercising a private law competence, but its public powers as an organ of state. The question has thus been whether the lawful exercise of public powers and the remedies for their unlawful exercise are matters that can be decided by referral to arbitration. The general answer is no because it is courts that supervise the exercise of public power and provide remedies under the Constitution and the scheme of review provided for under the rubric of legality and the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act, 2000. While the source of an arbitrator’s powers is the arbitration agreement concluded between the parties, only courts are the arbiters of legality in constitutional matters. This is because conformity with procurement requirements by an organ of state constitutes a public authority in terms of procurement prescripts. These prescripts require an evaluation of fairness, equity, transparency, competitiveness and the legality of public procurement. The determination of these issues must be undertaken before the courts, rather than commercial arbitration proceedings.

WHERE AN ORGAN OF STATE IS A PARTY TO ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS, SUCH PROCEEDINGS MUST BE HELD IN PUBLIC DUE TO PUBLIC INTEREST IN THE MATTER.

A distinction must consequently be drawn between ordinary contractual disputes and disputes concerning the legality of administrative action or the exercise of public power. Contractual issues, such as

interpretation, performance, payment and damages, may, depending on the terms of the arbitration agreement and the nature of the dispute, be capable of determination by arbitration. Private parties should therefore, when concluding arbitration agreements with organs of state, carefully consider the nature of the dispute of any potential disputes that may be referred to arbitration. They should also keep in mind that arbitration proceedings involving organs of state may not necessarily always be held in private. Arbitration clauses in contracts involving organs of state should be drafted with particular care. The benefits of arbitration remain significant, but the parties’ autonomy is necessarily constrained by constitutional legality and public accountability.

Follow: Vincent Manko www.linkedin.com/in/vincent-manko-4216a617 www.cliffedekkerhofmeyr.com

Vincent Manko

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 2 page Commercial arbitrations involving organs of state_V Manko_subbed.indd 29

29

2026/10/16 16:16


THE COST OF BEING UNDOCUMENTED When paperwork shapes women’s choices

ELGENE LUTSHITI, director – Pro Bono & Human Rights at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr, writes that identity documentation should be understood as a women’s rights issue

30

CHANGING THE TRAJECTORY OF A WOMAN’S LIFE Consider a young woman who finishes school, but cannot obtain an identity document. She may have the marks and ability to pursue further education, but may find herself unable to register. When she looks for work, formal employment may be difficult to access. Without the necessary documentation, opening a bank account and participating in ordinary financial life may also become complicated.

AN IDENTITY DOCUMENT DOES NOT GUARANTEE EQUALITY, SAFETY OR ECONOMIC INDEPENDENCE. HOWEVER, ITS ABSENCE CAN CLOSE DOORS TO ALL THREE.

These are not simply administrative inconveniences. Over time, they can fundamentally change the trajectory of a woman’s life. The real cost of being undocumented is found in those lost opportunities, the qualification not pursued, the job that cannot be accepted, the income not earned and the financial independence that becomes harder to achieve. That loss of independence matters. The ability to earn an income and support oneself does not guarantee that a woman will have complete control over her life, but it can materially affect the choices available to her. This becomes particularly important when documentation barriers intersect with gender-based violence. We sometimes speak about a woman “leaving” an abusive relationship as though leaving is a single act or decision. In reality, leaving requires options. Where will she live? How will she support herself and her children? Can she obtain employment? Can she access social assistance if she qualifies for it? Does she have the documentation needed to navigate the systems and

IMAGES: JACOB WACKERHAUSEN/ISTOCK.COM, SUPPLIED

F

or most people, an identity document is something we seldom think about until we need it. We produce it at a bank, when applying for a job or when dealing with a government department. Its significance is easy to overlook precisely because we have one. However, for a woman who is undocumented, the absence of that document can shape almost every aspect of her life. It can affect whether she can study, obtain formal employment, open a bank account, access social assistance, regularise her immigration status or secure documentation for her children. Where she is already economically vulnerable or experiencing violence, it can significantly limit the choices available to her. This is why documentation should also be understood as a women’s rights issue. We often speak about women’s economic empowerment in terms of access to education and employment. Both, however, assume something more basic: that a woman can prove who she is.

PUBLIC SECTOR

3. Elgene Lutshiti_subbed.indd 30

2026/10/16 16:17


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CLIFFE DEKKER HOFMEYR

THE REAL COST OF BEING UNDOCUMENTED IS FOUND IN THOSE LOST OPPORTUNITIES, THE QUALIFICATION NOT PURSUED, THE JOB THAT CANNOT BE ACCEPTED, THE INCOME NOT EARNED AND THE FINANCIAL INDEPENDENCE THAT BECOMES HARDER TO ACHIEVE.

IMAGES: JACOB WACKERHAUSEN/ISTOCK.COM, SUPPLIED

institutions from which she may need help? For an undocumented woman, each question may present another obstacle. Her documentation status may also affect whether she feels able to approach state institutions in the first place. Migrant, refugee and stateless women may be particularly reluctant to approach authorities where they fear that seeking protection will result in questions about their own immigration or documentation status. That vulnerability can itself become a means of control where an abusive partner uses a woman’s lack of documentation or her uncertain status to discourage her from seeking help. A lack of documentation does not cause gender-based violence. However, it can reduce the options available to a woman attempting to escape it.

Elgene Lutshiti

FURTHER IMPLICATIONS FOR WOMEN The consequences of being undocumented may also extend beyond the woman herself. A woman who struggles to establish her own identity or nationality may encounter further difficulties when she has a child. Where her own documentation is uncertain, registering the child’s birth or establishing the child’s nationality can become considerably more complicated. The consequences can therefore become intergenerational. For a mother who has spent years trying to resolve her own status, this can mean having to navigate another complex administrative process to ensure her child does not begin life with the same uncertainty. Difficulties with birth registration can require repeated visits to government offices, supporting documents that may be difficult or impossible to obtain and evidence relating to circumstances that occurred years earlier. There is also a practical cost to this bureaucracy that is easily overlooked. For a woman living on a limited income, every trip to a government office may mean transport costs, a day away from work and

arrangements for childcare. Being told to return with another document is not a minor inconvenience when every visit requires money she can barely afford. And, where the requested document simply does not exist, the process can become almost impossible to navigate without assistance. In this way, administrative barriers do not operate in isolation from the circumstances of a person’s life. They can compound existing disadvantages. Documentation barriers do not affect only women, and not every administrative difficulty experienced by a woman amounts to gender discrimination. However, that does not mean their gendered impact should be ignored. A documentation system may appear entirely neutral on paper while operating against a social reality in which women continue to carry significant caregiving responsibilities, experience economic inequality and are disproportionately affected by gender-based violence. Single mothers, survivors of violence, migrants, refugees and stateless women may encounter documentation systems while already navigating these vulnerabilities. The question is therefore not simply whether the same administrative requirements apply to everyone. We should ask what those requirements mean in practice for the people expected to comply with them, and what happens when they cannot. An identity document does not guarantee equality, safety or economic independence. However, its absence can close doors to all three. If we are serious about women’s ability to participate equally in society and to make meaningful choices about their own lives, then we must also pay attention to the administrative systems that can either enable those choices or quietly place them further out of reach. Sometimes inequality is obvious. Sometimes it looks like paperwork.

Follow: Elgene Lutshiti www.linkedin.com/in/elgene-lutshiti-29999710a www.cliffedekkerhofmeyr.com

PUBLIC SECTOR

3. Elgene Lutshiti_subbed.indd 31

31

2026/10/16 16:17


FRUITLESS AND WASTEFUL EXPENDITURE Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr’s KAMOHELO MOLAPO, associate – Tax & Exchange Control, and HOWMERA PARAK, director – Tax & Exchange Control, unpack why expenditure made in vain and which is avoidable if reasonable care is exercised is more than a PFMA concern

F

or a taxable public entity, fruitless and wasteful expenditure can carry a double cost; the entity may lose the value of the expenditure and may also lose the corresponding income tax deduction. SARS’s updated Interpretation Note 54 (Issue 3), which was published on 1 September 2026, provides timely guidance on section 23(o) of the Income Tax Act 58 of 1962 (Income Tax Act). The provision prohibits deductions for certain expenditure connected with corrupt activities, fines and penalties and fruitless and wasteful expenditure. The guidance is an important reminder that a determination made under the Public Finance Management Act 1 of 1999 (PFMA) may have consequences beyond governance, disclosure and recovery. It may also affect an entity’s taxable income.

THE PFMA DEFINES FRUITLESS AND WASTEFUL EXPENDITURE AS EXPENDITURE “WHICH WAS MADE IN VAIN AND WOULD HAVE BEEN AVOIDED HAD REASONABLE CARE BEEN EXERCISED”.

32

FOR A TAXABLE PUBLIC ENTITY, FRUITLESS AND WASTEFUL EXPENDITURE CAN CARRY A DOUBLE COST; THE ENTITY MAY LOSE THE VALUE OF THE EXPENDITURE AND MAY ALSO LOSE THE CORRESPONDING INCOME TAX DEDUCTION.

Howmera Parak

differently situated. State ownership or the performance of a public function does not, by itself, confer exemption from normal tax. Some institutions, boards and bodies established by or under law may not qualify for exemption under section 10(1)(cA), subject to the requirements of that provision. Others remain fully or partly taxable. The entity’s legal form, enabling legislation, activities and tax status must therefore be established before the effect of section 23(o) can be determined. For taxable public entities, the classification of expenditure under the PFMA can have a direct and potentially material effect on their income tax liability.

WHICH PUBLIC ENTITIES ARE AFFECTED?

HOW DOES SECTION 23(O) OPERATE?

The starting point is whether the institution is subject to normal tax. Section 10(1)(a) of the Income Tax Act exempts the receipts and accruals of the national, provincial and local spheres of government. The denial of a deduction under section 23(o) will therefore generally have no practical income tax effect for a government department. Public entities and state-owned companies with separate legal personality may be

Expenditure must first qualify for deduction under section 11(a), read with section 23(g), or another applicable deduction provision. Broadly, it must have been incurred in the production of income and for purposes of the taxpayer’s trade and must not be capital in nature. Section 23(o) then operates as a specific prohibition. Even if expenditure would ordinarily qualify for deduction, no deduction is permitted for (1) expenditure

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 2 page_Fruitless and wasteful expenditure_1.indd 32

2026/10/16 16:18


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CLIFFE DEKKER HOFMEYR

where the payment, agreement or offer to make the payment constitutes a corrupt activity contemplated in Chapter 2 of the Prevention and Combating of Corrupt Activities Act 12 of 2004 (PCCA), (2) a fine or penalty imposed as a result of an unlawful activity in South Africa or conduct abroad that would have been unlawful if carried out in South Africa, or (3) expenditure that constitutes fruitless and wasteful expenditure as defined in the PFMA and is determined in accordance with that Act. The third category is particularly significant for taxable entities falling within the PFMA framework.

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

WHEN IS EXPENDITURE FRUITLESS AND WASTEFUL? The PFMA defines fruitless and wasteful expenditure as expenditure “which was made in vain and would have been avoided had reasonable care been exercised”. Both requirements must be satisfied. The expenditure must have produced no intended value or result and must have been avoidable through the exercise of reasonable care. Examples may include paying for goods or services that were never received, avoidable interest arising from late payment or expenditure incurred for no useful purpose. Whether the definition is met will, however, always depend on the facts. Importantly, an unsuccessful outcome does not automatically make expenditure fruitless and wasteful. A project may fail, or an investment may underperform, despite a reasonable decision-making process and the exercise of appropriate care. The definition should not be applied with the benefit of hindsight simply because the anticipated result was not achieved. Section 23(o)(iii) also requires the expenditure to be determined as fruitless and wasteful in accordance with the PFMA. A preliminary allegation or ongoing investigation will not necessarily amount to such a determination. SARS indicates that amounts disclosed as fruitless and wasteful expenditure in audited annual financial statements will generally be accepted as such. Expenditure that meets the PFMA requirements may, however, still be nondeductible even if it was not correctly disclosed in those statements.

A PFMA DETERMINATION CAN BECOME A TAX COST. HOWEVER, NOT EVERY IRREGULAR EXPENSE, FAILED PROJECT OR POOR COMMERCIAL OUTCOME IS AUTOMATICALLY NONDEDUCTIBLE.

The accounting, governance and tax consequences of the classification must therefore be considered together.

IRREGULAR EXPENDITURE IS DIFFERENT A critical distinction must be drawn between fruitless and wasteful expenditure and irregular expenditure. Irregular expenditure generally concerns noncompliance with prescribed legislative requirements, including applicable procurement requirements. The underlying goods or services may nevertheless have been received, may have served a legitimate purpose and may have represented fair value. Expenditure can therefore be irregular without having been made in vain. Conversely, expenditure may be fruitless and wasteful without necessarily being irregular. Section 23(o)(iii) refers specifically to fruitless and wasteful expenditure. It does not create a blanket prohibition against the deduction of all irregular expenditure. Where expenditure is irregular but not fruitless and wasteful, its deductibility must be determined under the ordinary provisions of the Income Tax Act and any other specific prohibition that may apply. A PFMA classification should consequently not be carried into the income tax calculation without first identifying the precise category and underlying facts.

WHAT IF THE EXPENDITURE IS RECOVERED? The PFMA framework requires potentially recoverable fruitless and wasteful expenditure to be investigated and appropriate recovery steps to be considered. Where an amount previously prohibited as a deduction under section 23(o)(iii) is recovered in a subsequent

year of assessment, section 10(1)(zL) exempts the recovery from normal tax. The provisions are intended to produce a neutral result: the entity receives no deduction when the expenditure is incurred, but is not taxed when that same expenditure is later recovered. The exemption is, however, limited to an amount that was previously denied as a deduction under section 23(o)(iii). It is not a general exemption for every recovery arising from misconduct, contractual default or noncompliance with the PFMA.

FROM GOVERNANCE CLASSIFICATION TO TAX TREATMENT For taxable public entities, fruitless and wasteful expenditure is not solely an accounting or governance issue. Finance, legal, internal audit and tax teams should co-ordinate to determine (1) whether the entity is subject to normal tax, (2) whether the expenditure has been properly and finally determined to be fruitless and wasteful under the PFMA, (3) whether it was claimed as a deduction in the current or an earlier income tax return, and (4) whether a subsequent recovery qualifies for exemption under section 10(1)(zL). This is particularly important where expenditure is identified or finally determined only after the year in which it was originally incurred. The key point is simple: a PFMA determination can become a tax cost. However, not every irregular expense, failed project or poor commercial outcome is automatically nondeductible. The entity’s tax status, the precise PFMA classification and the underlying facts must all be considered before the tax treatment is determined.

Follow: Kamohelo Molapo www.linkedin.com/in/kamohelo-molapo-b998721b0 Howmera Parak www.linkedin.com/in/howmera-parak-159723158 www.cliffedekkerhofmeyr.com

PUBLIC SECTOR

CDH 2 page_Fruitless and wasteful expenditure_1.indd 33

33

2026/10/19 10:11


WHEN GOVERNMENT SERVICES DRIVE UP COSTS Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr’s LEBOHANG MABIDIKANE, director – Competition Law, and CHRISTOPHER KODE, associate – Competition Law, delve into the recently released Competition Commission’s Cost of Living Report

T

he Competition Commission (Commission) recently published its third Cost of Living Report, dated August 2026 but published on 4 September 2026, building on the findings of its inaugural report released in September 2025 and its second report released in April 2026. The third report continues to track changes in the prices of essential goods and services affecting South African households and, critically, includes a deep dive into water price formation. Across all three reports, a consistent and concerning theme has emerged: the primary drivers of cost-of-living pressures in South Africa are not external market shocks or private sector pricing alone, but rather the prices of services administered, regulated or provided by government and state entities.

ADMINISTERED PRICES: THE PERSISTENT FLASHPOINT From the first report onwards, the Commission has highlighted that electricity and water tariffs consistently outpace general inflation. The third report confirms this trend has intensified. Between January 2020 and July 2026, cumulative electricity inflation reached approximately 100.5 per cent, while water supply inflation reached approximately 85 per cent, compared to headline consumer inflation of approximately 36 per cent over the same period. In the short term, between July 2025 and July 2026 alone, electricity inflation increased by 8.1 per cent and water inflation by 10.1 per cent, both substantially above the headline consumer price index of 4.3 per cent. The second report had already raised concerns about an expected 18 per cent electricity price increase over the following two years, attributable to a

34

Lebohang Mabidikane

NERSA undercalculation of Eskom’s costs by approximately R54-billion. The third report notes that government is now in the process of introducing reforms, including a revised electricity pricing policy approved by Cabinet in July 2026 that seeks to categorise customers by income level and usage, and increase the free basic electricity allocation from 50kWh to between 200 and 300kWh. While welcome, these reforms remain under consultation, and the underlying cost-plus pricing methodology that the Commission has repeatedly flagged as problematic persists.

WATER: A NEW DEEP DIVE INTO GOVERNMENT’S ROLE The third report’s deep dive into water price formation reveals a layered and largely

A CONSISTENT AND CONCERNING THEME HAS EMERGED: THE PRIMARY DRIVERS OF COST-OF-LIVING PRESSURES IN SOUTH AFRICA ARE NOT EXTERNAL MARKET SHOCKS OR PRIVATE SECTOR PRICING ALONE, BUT RATHER THE PRICES OF SERVICES ADMINISTERED, REGULATED OR PROVIDED BY GOVERNMENT AND STATE ENTITIES.

self-regulated value chain in which the Department of Water and Sanitation, water boards and municipalities each set tariffs based on their own cost structures, without oversight from an independent economic regulator. The Commission found that each municipality determines its own retail tariff increase, with no standard methodology applied and rarely on the basis of an analysis of the actual change in the cost of providing water services. The result is significant variation: municipal retail tariff increases for 2026/27 ranged from 4.5 per cent in Cape Town to 83.88 per cent in Chris Hani District Municipality. The Commission further found that even municipalities served by the same water board may have vastly different retail tariffs. For instance, the City of Johannesburg proposed a 65.6 per cent increase to its fixed water charge, separate from its 12.5 per cent block tariff increase, meaning consumers experience a significantly larger overall increase than the headline figure suggests.

PUBLIC SECTOR

5. Third Cost of Living Report_subbed.indd 34

2026/10/16 16:19


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CLIFFE DEKKER HOFMEYR

These findings raise serious questions about the transparency and accountability of municipal tariff-setting processes. The Commission has noted that the National Water Action Plan released by the Presidency in July 2026 contemplates the establishment of an independent economic regulator for the water sector, which would strengthen tariff oversight and promote greater consistency in pricing across municipalities. Importantly, the Commission has cautioned that the costplus pricing methodology prevalent across the water value chain raises concerns, as it guarantees cost recovery plus a return, thereby limiting incentives for cost containment and keeping tariffs higher than they might otherwise be.

BEYOND UTILITIES: EDUCATION, HEALTHCARE AND TRANSPORT The government’s role in cost-of-living pressures extends beyond utilities. Basic education costs continue to outpace general inflation, with public school fees increasing by approximately 10 per cent for 2026, largely because operational costs are not sufficiently covered by government funding. Primary healthcare costs, as measured by GP consultation fees, reached approximately 38 per cent cumulatively by July 2026, exceeding headline inflation, in a context where constraints within the public health system drive employed but uninsured individuals to seek private care. Transport costs were a significant contributor in the first half of 2026, driven by the sharp increase in fuel prices following the US-Iran conflict, notwithstanding a temporary reduction in the General Fuel Levy.

IMAGES: PITINAN/123RF.COM, SUPPLIED

ADDRESSING THE COST OF LIVING The trajectory across all three reports is clear: the cost-of-living crisis facing South African households is, to a significant degree, a crisis of government-administered and government-provided services. As we discussed in our recent webinar on the topic, the question of where the line falls

THE COMMISSION HAS CAUTIONED THAT THE COST-PLUS PRICING METHODOLOGY PREVALENT ACROSS THE WATER VALUE CHAIN RAISES CONCERNS, AS IT GUARANTEES COST RECOVERY PLUS A RETURN, THEREBY LIMITING INCENTIVES FOR COST CONTAINMENT AND KEEPING TARIFFS HIGHER THAN THEY MIGHT OTHERWISE BE. between the mandates of sector regulators such as NERSA and the Competition Commission’s own oversight function remains a live and important one. The Commission has itself concluded that “addressing the cost of living requires greater scrutiny of administered price-setting mechanisms, enhanced transparency and accountability in tariff

determinations and targeted protection for vulnerable households.” The establishment of an independent water regulator, the reform of electricity pricing, and greater scrutiny of municipal tariff-setting processes are positive developments. However, until these reforms are fully implemented, households, particularly lower-income households, will continue to bear the burden of pricing structures that are opaque, inconsistent and insufficiently accountable. Businesses operating in affected sectors should monitor the Commission’s ongoing work closely, as the evolution from monitoring to enforcement action remains a real possibility.

Follow: Lebohang Mabidikane www.linkedin.com/in/lebohang-mabidikane-ba286488 Christopher Kode www.linkedin.com/in/christopher-kode-904b10194 www.cliffedekkerhofmeyr.com

Christopher Kode

PUBLIC SECTOR

5. Third Cost of Living Report_subbed.indd 35

35

2026/10/19 10:10


K

nowledge has long been regarded as the foundation of management education. Increasingly, however, organisations recognise that knowledge alone is not the source of sustained organisational performance. Value is created when knowledge is translated into leadership capability, enabling leaders to exercise sound judgement, adapt to changing circumstances and mobilise organisations towards shared goals. As organisations contend with increasingly fragile operating environments, rapidly shifting competitive dynamics, accelerating technological change and strategic challenges that often defy straightforward solutions, leadership capability has become a defining driver of organisational success. The challenge facing organisations is therefore no longer simply how to educate leaders, but how to develop leadership capability. Capability goes beyond competence and reflects the ability to integrate knowledge, experience, judgement, relationships and continuous learning into effective action. Leaders who

36

consistently learn, adapt and renew their thinking are better equipped to anticipate change, make sound decisions under pressure, mobilise people around a common purpose and create organisations capable of sustained performance. While many leading MBA programmes have long incorporated coaching, experiential learning and organisational engagement, the common thread is growing recognition that leadership capability is developed not only through what participants know, but also through how effectively they apply, refine and adapt that knowledge in practice. This philosophy rests on the principle that capability is developed through intentional and reflective experience. Leaders grow when they engage with authentic organisational challenges that require them to analyse complex problems, test new approaches, engage diverse stakeholders and evaluate the consequences of their decisions. Experience without reflection risks becoming repetition, while reflection without application seldom produces

LEADERSHIP CAPABILITY IS DEVELOPED NOT ONLY THROUGH WHAT PARTICIPANTS KNOW, BUT ALSO THROUGH HOW EFFECTIVELY THEY APPLY, REFINE AND ADAPT THAT KNOWLEDGE IN PRACTICE.

meaningful organisational change. Real organisational projects therefore become powerful learning environments where knowledge is transformed into judgement and capability. These principles increasingly shape leading MBA programmes globally. While their structures and delivery models differ, they share a common commitment to developing leaders who can apply knowledge in complex organisational settings. At the NWU Business School, this philosophy is embedded throughout the MBA programme. Academic learning is integrated with leadership coaching,

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

Organisations need leaders who can apply and adapt their knowledge in complex organisational settings. This learning is deeply embedded in the MBA programme at the NWU BUSINESS SCHOOL

PUBLIC SECTOR

NWU Bus School_DPS_5.indd 36

2026/10/16 09:04


IN PARTNERSHIP WITH

AN MBA SHOULD REPRESENT FAR MORE THAN AN ACADEMIC QUALIFICATION. IT SHOULD BE A TRANSFORMATIONAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY THAT DEVELOPS THE CAPABILITY TO THINK STRATEGICALLY, LEAD ADAPTIVELY AND CREATE MEANINGFUL ORGANISATIONAL AND SOCIETAL IMPACT. As organisations continue to navigate fragile operating environments, accelerating technological change, unpredictable market dynamics and increasingly complex strategic decisions, adaptive leadership capability will drive competitive advantage. Organisations will increasingly require leaders who can build organisational capability, develop resilient teams, foster innovation, create learning cultures and continuously renew their capabilities as conditions evolve. For professionals seeking to prepare for this future, an MBA should represent far more than an academic qualification. It should be a transformational leadership journey that develops the capability to think strategically, lead adaptively and create meaningful organisational and societal impact.

READY TO BUILD YOUR LEADERSHIP CAPABILITY? Applications for the 2027 MBA at the NWU Business School are now open. Designed for ambitious professionals, the programme

combines rigorous academic learning with leadership coaching, business simulations, a company-based consulting project and a blended learning model that enables participants to apply new knowledge directly within their organisations. Participants engage in intensive week-long study schools before returning to their workplaces to apply new insights, evaluate outcomes and strengthen their leadership capability through practice.

VISIT WEBSITE

SCAN THIS QR CODE TO GO TO THE NWU BUSINESS SCHOOL WEBSITE

To learn more about the MBA programme, visit: https://nwubusinessschool.co.za/mba

IMAGES: SUPPLIED

business simulations and a company-based consulting project that requires participants to address real strategic challenges within organisations. Rather than separating theory from practice, participants continually apply new knowledge, test ideas, evaluate outcomes and refine their leadership capability in contexts where results matter. The programme is delivered through a blended learning model specifically designed for working professionals. Intensive week-long study schools provide immersive engagement with academics, industry leaders and experienced executives, creating an environment where ideas are challenged, assumptions tested and new perspectives developed. Through interactive learning experiences, leadership coaching, business simulations and collaborative problem-solving, participants develop the judgement, strategic thinking and adaptability required of senior leaders. Learning does not end when the study school concludes. Participants continue their learning journey online, engaging with course content, discussions and assessments while applying new insights within their own organisations. They return to subsequent study schools with new experiences, reflections and perspectives that enrich the next stage of learning. This continuous integration of face-to-face engagement, online learning and workplace application transforms knowledge into lasting leadership capability.

NWU BUSINESS SCHOOL

PU BL IC SECTOR

NWU Bus School_DPS_5.indd 37

37

2026/10/16 11:08


ToCheck_fcp.indd 2

2025/08/26 16:01


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook