Choose Stillwater

Why Choose Stillwater

Rock-solid financial strength, stability and reputation.

Financial Strength

A- Excellent.

Our A- (Excellent) rating by A.M. Best gives customers peace of mind knowing that we have the financial stability necessary to be there when our customers need us most and to pay their claim. Not many companies our size can offer such big protection.

A+ Rated Business.

Stillwater’s A+ accreditation with the Better Business Bureau is proof positive that our customers come first and that we’ll always deliver on our promises with transparency, integrity and responsiveness. It’s what sets us apart from other companies who don’t necessarily walk the walk when it comes to caring for customers’ needs. Our focus is – and always will be – to take care of our customers when they need us most.

9 out of 10 customers recommend us.

Our highly-trained claims adjusters deliver fast, fair and empathetic service. We’ll help you get back on your feet quickly if you report a claim.

About Stillwater

Stillwater Insurance Group is a national insurance provider offering a full suite of insurance products and services. We strive to be the most respected insurance provider in the United States by setting and achieving the highest standards in quality products, service, customer experience and claims satisfaction.

Stillwater is:

Smart—We meet your evolving needs for homeowners, auto and business insurance Fast—We exceed your expectations for customer and claims service Strong—We’re ready when you need us, and help you get back on your feet

We have an A+ accreditation from the Better Business Bureau. This recognizes our commitment to transparency, responsiveness, integrity and delivering on the promises we make. And we have an “A-” (Excellent) rating from A.M. Best, the leading insurance rating organization.