OPINION opinion
5 feature
9 centerspread 10-11 graphics
dhth: stand-up comedy
siri lawsuit
MISSION SAN JOSE HIGH SCHOOL
VOL. 60, NO. 5
41717 PALM AVENUE, FREMONT, CA 94539
“Cities like Fremont were not originally designed or equipped to handle homelessness, yet we are now doing more than ever to address this crisis. Counties were supposed to provide safety net services, and homelessness was intended to be funded through counties, state, and federal funds. However, the lack of adequate resources and funding at these levels has left cities like Fremont to step in and fill the gap. In the coming months, Fremont will focus on expanding shelter capacity and services to ensure that enforcement of public camping bans is humane and effective.” — Fremont Mayor Raj Salwan
In recent years, homelessness has become a pressing issue in Fremont, mirroring similar trends throughout the Bay Area. According to a press release by the Governor’s office, in 2023, approximately 181,000 Californians dealt with homelessness, with around 90,000 living without shelter, meaning they were found on the street, in vehicles, or abandoned buildings without access to an emergency shelter. CA Governor Gavin Newsom and CA legislators have taken steps to mitigate the crisis on a broader state-wide scale, employing a multi-departmental approach addressing encampments, houses, and services for those in need. In August of last year, Newsom signed two laws to address homelessness: AB 2835, which enhances stability for those in need by extending the use of hotels and motels for emergency shelters beyond 30 days, and AB 3057, which simplifies and streamlines the process of constructing junior accessory dwelling units, which are small, independent living spaces within an existing single-family dwelling. Since 2019, the state has invested over $40 billion to boost affordable housing, creating more than 7,500 housing units for CA families through the Housing Accountability Unit at the California Department of Housing and Community Development created in 2022. The state has also allocated $27 billion to support local governments in preventing homelessness and providing housing, including $3.3 billion for the Homekey program, $1 billion in Encampment Resolution Funding, and $4.85 billion in Homelessness Housing Assistance Program funds. Legal precedents also shape homelessness policies. On June 28, 2024, the Supreme Court ruled in Grants Pass v. Johnson that people experiencing homelessness can be arrested and fined for sleeping outside even when there are no safe alternatives. Additionally, the court ruled that local governments can enforce laws prohibiting public camping and sleeping without violating the Eighth Amendment, which prohibits the government from imposing cruel and unusual punishments. Homeless Population in the Bay Area Throughout the Years
Population
40k
35k
30k
25k
2019
Year
2022
2023
COMMUNITY PERSPECTIVES
2024 Data collected from siliconvalley.com
January 24, 2025
INVESTIGATIVE REPORT: CITY COUNCIL DECISIONS ON HOMELESSNESS By Dhaeshna Booma, Jennifer Li, Kaiwei Parks & Aarav Vashisht Staff Writers
The Bay Area’s housing crisis remains a significant challenge for local governments, with rising housing costs, increasing homelessness, and opposition to RV parking and encampments. On Dec. 17, 2024, Fremont’s City Council narrowly approved the Citywide Camping Ban on Public Property Ordinance, which will add to Chapter 8.90 of the Municipal Code. If enacted, this legislation will tighten restrictions on the homeless, sparking likely debates among residents, policymakers, and affected individuals.
BACKGROUND
2017
local craft shops
SMOKE SIGNAL
THE
2015
history of the smoke signal
20
RECENT POLICIES & DEVELOPMENTS
Average Length of Homelessness
On May 21, 2024, the City of Fremont adopted the Fremont Homelessness Response Plan, a comprehensive initiative designed to address the root causes 16% of homelessness, reallocate funding toward prevention and long-term solutions, and improve the effectiveness of support services. The plan aims to eliminate the 11% 11% 59% 23% annual growth rate of people experiencing homelessness and double the 14% proportion of people served by the homeless response system. A significant aspect of the plan involves reallocating funds for services and programs. At the time of the 24-35 months 0-6 months plan’s adoption, 79% of the City’s spending for addressing homelessness went to 36+ months 7-23 months crisis support services and mitigation activities, which manage homelessness rather Data collected from Alameda County Housing and Homeless Services than prevent or solve it. “[The Fremont Homelessness Response Plan’s] first step is to evaluate our current investments and see if there is anywhere to re-allocate or move our funding around to serve better and reinforce the most beneficial programs,” City of Fremont Homeless Services Manager Laurie Flores said. Meanwhile, recent legislation, such as the Citywide Camping Ban on Public Property Ordinance, though not yet signed into law, reflects a more restrictive approach to the homelessness crisis. However, city government officials emphasized that these measures will be implemented in the future with consideration for the homeless population. “In the coming months, Fremont will focus on expanding shelter capacity and services to ensure that enforcement of public camping bans is humane and effective,” Fremont Mayor Raj Salwan said.
Implications & Further Discussions
Fremont’s recent measures, including approving the camping ban, depart from the city’s previous approach to addressing homelessness. Historically, Fremont has allocated most of its homelessness-related funding toward shortterm solutions such as emergency shelters and street-level services. In contrast, the new policies reflect a shift toward prevention and long-term strategies, emphasizing the reallocation of resources to more sustainable programs. However, funding uncertainties remain a barrier to fully implementing these strategies. “We haven’t added any more beds or anything like that, because it really depends on investment and funding which had in the past couple months has not become available yet,” Flores said. If passed, the new ordinances aim to regulate RV parking and public encampments while shifting resources toward preventive services such as rental assistance and housing subsidies. These changes align with regional efforts, including Alameda County’s Home Together 2026 plan released in 2021. It builds on the Centering Racial Equity in Homeless System Design report, which supports housing with services and rental subsidies. Fremont’s participation in these initiatives, including outreach programs and housing applications, is designed to streamline access to services. Broader Bay Area challenges, such as reliance on temporary funding, impact these efforts. For example, 40% of Alameda County’s homelessness funding is nonrecurring, raising questions about long-term resource stability. Additionally, Fremont survey data from the 2024 Fremont Homelessness Response Plan reveals that 46% of unhoused individuals had not accessed services, highlighting the importance of improving outreach and trust-building efforts. Future directions include enhancing coordination with nonprofits and supporting profoundly affordable housing development, contingent on funding availability and developer participation. These measures would address immediate needs and systemic gaps in the city’s homelessness response.
Conversely, measures like the Citywide Camping Ban’s approval were criticized for being more punitive, making it difficult to reconcile the competing legal imperatives, community demands, and resources. MSJ students involved in community organizations like MSJ Poverty Patchup have expressed their voices on this issue. “We believe that they want to push this ban so the police have more power to clear the streets and put up a fight against people they want to persecute. It wouldn’t be fair if it was passed since they would never know if they are going to be persecuted or not,” MSJ Poverty Patchup President Sophomore Abirami Palaniappan said. Further, local activists speak out against the ordinance’s moral basis and potential ineffectiveness. “The camping ban ordinance, if passed, will likely not reduce homelessness … The city adopted certain principles of compassion in enacting public policy, and this camping ban … violates these principles of compassion,” Fremont For Everyone Leadership Team member David Bonaccorsi said. While Fremont’s new efforts align with broader regional goals, the effectiveness of these measures remains uncertain, especially given the limited long-term funding and concerns about their potential to displace rather than solve the crisis. Ultimately, whether these policies can balance enforcement with compassion will determine their success in alleviating homelessness in the Bay Area.
GRAPHICS BY NEWS EDITOR SHUHAN JIN
ONLINE
THIS MONTH
www.thesmokesignal.org
MEET THE ASB CANDIDATES As the ASB elections for the 2025-26 school year approaches, meet the final candidates running for the positions of President, Vice President, Secretary, Treasurer, and Activities Coordinator.`
MSJ HOSTS SPECIAL EDUCATION GYM DANCE During third period on Dec. 17th in the MSJ gym, Special Education students performed festive dances to celebrate the upcoming holiday season, inluding dances to “Feliz Navidad” and “Waka Waka (This Time for Africa).”
FOR MORE COVERAGE, VISIT www.THESMOKESIGNAL.ORG