Comparative Study and Pilot Testing of Business Models for Battery Collection in Kenya
Supported by
siemens-stiftung.org
Imprint
Published by Siemens Stiftung Kaiserstraße 16 80801 München Tel.: +49 (0) 89 / 54 04 87-0 info@siemens-stiftung.org www.siemens-stiftung.org Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH Mahiga Mairu Avenue Nairobi, Kenya www.giz.de
Responsible for Content Dr. Nina Smidt and Robert Balthasar Editorial team Enviroserve: Justin Larby, Shaun Mumford Siemens Stiftung: Sebastian Gruss, Winnie Njogo
Layout Niko Creative 90 JGO James Gichuru Road, Nairobi, Kenya www.nikocreative.co.ke Photo Credits ©Siemens Stiftung
About Us
The non-profit, internationally operative Siemens Stiftung is committed to sustainable social development. Together with individuals and communities, it creates opportunities to actively shape social and ecological transformation. It focuses on three key areas of action: Essential Services, Digitality, and Climate. By collectively addressing challenges in these fields, the foundation harnesses them as opportunities for innovation and positive change. Through projects in Education, Social Entrepreneurship, and Culture, it facilitates access and participation, strengthens futureoriented competencies, and enables interdisciplinary and collaborative learning. Siemens Stiftung connects local actions with global perspectives to support resilience, social cohesion, and regenerative practices. www.siemens-stiftung.org
Enviroserve Kenya Limited is a commercial social enterprise founded in 2017 to deliver environmentally friendly and sustainable ways of managing electronic waste, keeping toxic material out of landfill and dumps and contributing to a circular economy that simultaneously provides opportunity for new business initiatives and entrepreneurship.
The Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) is a service provider in the field of international cooperation for sustainable development and international education work. We are dedicated to shaping a future worth living around the world. We have over 50 years of experience in a wide variety of areas, including economic development and employment promotion, energy and the environment, and peace and security. We work with businesses, civil society actors and research institutions, fostering successful interaction between development policy and other policy fields and areas of activity. Our main commissioning party is the German Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ).
Table of Contents Executive Summary 1. Summary of Original Six Pillars 1.1 Initial Pilot Implementation & Project Pivot 1.2 Implementation of Redesigned Pillars 2. Enviroserve-led Collection Initiative 2.1 Lessons Learned 2.2 Recommendations 3. Map the Informal Supply Chain 3.1 Throughput Volumes 3.2 Pricing Along the Supply Chain 3.3 Battery Chemistries, Sorting, & Handling 3.4 Degree of Formalization Within the Supply Chain 3.5 Lessons Learned from Mapping the Informal Supply Chain 3.6 Recommendations from Mapping the Informal Supply Chain 4. Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs 4.1 Lessons Learned from Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs 4.2 Recommendations from Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs 5. Informal Battery Purchasing Program 5.1 Informal Sector Battery Purchases 5.2 Lessons Learned from the Battery Purchase Program 5.3 Recommendations from the Battery Purchase 6. Formal Institution Collaboration 6.1 Lessons Learned 6.2 Recommendations 7. Business as Usual Enhancement Pilot 7.1 Lessons Learned 7.2 Recommendations 8. Future Challenges 9. Conclusion
Executive Summary
Executive Summary
This report presents the findings of the Comparative Study and Pilot Testing of Business Models for Battery Collection in Kenya, funded by Siemens Stiftung. The study was originally designed around six collection pillars intended to increase the collection of end-of-life lithiumion batteries (LIBs) through community engagement, repair shop partnerships, faithbased organisations, formal institutions, and enhancements to existing collection operations. However, early implementation revealed that many of the assumptions underpinning the original pilot design did not fully reflect market realities. The study found that a preexisting informal waste LIB market already operates in Kenya. Waste battery collectors, aggregators, repurposers, exporters, and other actors actively trade waste batteries, and end-users generally recognise that end-of-life batteries have economic value.
This reduced the effectiveness of collection models based primarily on environmental awareness, community stewardship, or voluntary participation. As a result, the study shifted its focus towards understanding and engaging the existing informal market rather than attempting to establish a new collection ecosystem. To support this revised approach, three analytical pillars were introduced: Mapping the Informal Supply Chain, Modelling Transportation and Processing Costs, and the Informal Battery Purchasing Programme. Together, these pillars were designed to answer four critical questions: Who participates in the informal market and how is it organized?
How much does it cost to sort, transport, and test batteries?
1
2
Which suppliers can costeffectively provide waste LIBs?
What is the market price of waste LIBs?
3
4
Implementation of the Redesigned Pillars The redesigned pillars enabled the study to generate stronger evidence on the structure and economics of Kenya's emerging waste LIB collection ecosystem. By adapting the original pilot approach in response to observed market conditions, the study examined existing supply chain actors, transportation and processing costs, procurement practices, and opportunities for developing commercially viable battery collection and recycling systems. These findings form the basis of the recommendations presented in this report.
Executive Summary
6
Enviroserve-led Collection Initiative Enviroserve acquired an electric 3-wheeled cargo vehicle (3-wheeler) converting it to operate using a
9.6 kWh Second-life LFP
battery pack remanufactured from end-of-life batteries
The Enviroserve-led Collection Initiative focused on developing a low-cost, low-emission collection vehicle capable of transporting the majority of Enviroserve’s waste LIB shipments. Enviroserve acquired a Piaggio Apé E-xtra electric 3-wheeled cargo vehicle (3-wheeler) and began converting it to operate using a 9.6 kWh second-life LFP battery pack remanufactured from end-of-life batteries collected through its recycling activities. However, technical challenges associated with removing proprietary battery controls installed by the previous owner delayed deployment and prevented operational testing during the project period. Despite these delays, Enviroserve successfully assembled and tested the second-life battery pack and developed a transportation cost model that estimates vehicle operating costs, including depreciation, energy consumption, maintenance, insurance, labour, and regulatory compliance. Following delivery of the 3-wheeler in May 2026, Enviroserve identified the motor controller as the primary barrier to integrating the remanufactured battery system and is evaluating replacement options. Once operational, the 3-wheeler will be used to validate the transportation cost model and assess the viability of second-life battery-powered collection vehicles for waste LIB logistics in Kenya.
Mapping the Informal Supply Chain The study identified a five-tier supply chain consisting of collectors, aggregators, super aggregators, repurposers, and recyclers and exporters. Sixteen stakeholders were interviewed across the supply chain. The findings indicate that dedicated LIB collection remains limited, with most actors handling batteries as part of broader e-waste activities. The study estimates that individual aggregators may handle approximately 0.7–1.9 tons of LIBs annually, while super aggregators may handle approximately 3.5–14.5 tons per year. Repurposers generate relatively small volumes of recycling feedstock but provide the advantage of pre-sorted batteries. Based on estimated waste LIB throughput of 75 tons/year, Enviroserve would need to work with approximately 10 super aggregators, or roughly 60 aggregators, to secure enough LIB feedstock.
Executive Summary
The mapping exercise also revealed that battery chemistries are frequently co-mingled throughout the lower tiers of the supply chain. Lead-acid, Nickel-cadmium (NiCad) and lithium-ion batteries are often traded together, creating a need for acceptance testing and chemistry separation after collection.
7
Modelling Transportation and Processing Costs A transportation and processing cost model was developed to evaluate the impact of shipment volume, vehicle selection, and transportation fuel on collection economics. The analysis demonstrated that shipment size is one of the most important drivers of collection cost. Larger shipments from super aggregators significantly reduce transportation and processing costs compared to smaller shipments from aggregators. Average transportation and processing costs for super-aggregator deliveries were estimated at KES 17–27 per kilogram, compared to KES 37–79 per kilogram for aggregator-sized deliveries. The analysis also showed that electric 3-wheelers represent the most cost-effective collection vehicle for routine collections, while larger trucks should be reserved for bulk deliveries exceeding the payload capacity or range of the 3-wheeler fleet.
Informal Battery Purchasing Program Enviroserve purchased over a tonne of waste LIBs from informal suppliers during the pilot period. The average purchase price was KES 224 per kilogram, although prices varied significantly between transactions. A battery disassembly experiment established that waste LIBs contain approximately 8.3 percent copper by weight, corresponding to an estimated copper value of approximately KES 80 per kilogram of waste batteries. This copper value provides a useful reference point when evaluating sustainable procurement prices. The purchasing program demonstrated that suppliers are willing to sell batteries at a wide range of prices
Executive Summary
and that procurement staff can successfully negotiate lower prices when supported by market intelligence. However, the study also showed that many suppliers continue to apply margins significantly above the intrinsic material value of the batteries. The project also identified an important environmental and occupational health concern within Kenya’s informal waste battery sector. Informal waste collectors are increasingly extracting copper foil from waste lithium-ion batteries using simple manual disassembly techniques that release electrolyte-containing solvents and lithium salts into the environment. These practices expose workers to flammable volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and hydrofluoric acid (HF), while also contaminating wastewater and discarding valuable materials such as aluminium, steel, plastics, and black mass that could otherwise be recovered through formal recycling processes.
8
Formal Institution Collaboration Interviews with formal-sector stakeholders revealed that many organisations do not yet have effective takeback programs for end-of-life batteries and frequently misunderstand their responsibilities under Kenya’s Extended Producer Responsibility legislation. A formal-sector battery collection model developed during the project estimates that more than 600 tons of LIBs in Kenya will reach their end-of-life in 2026 across the e-mobility, off-grid solar, on-grid solar, energy storage, aeronautics, cell manufacturing, and camping sectors. The off-grid solar sector is expected to remain the largest source of waste LIBs for the foreseeable future. The study also found that many batteries generated by formal institutions eventually enter the informal supply chain due to the absence of established collection and takeback mechanisms.
Business-as-Usual Enhancement The pilot demonstrated that waiving disposal fees can increase collection volumes from existing customers. However, it also showed that Enviroserve cannot rely solely on fee waivers to drive waste LIB volumes because batteries increasingly have positive market value. In at least one case, batteries that Enviroserve intended to collect were sold into the informal market before collection could occur. This suggests that formal institutions will increasingly require financial incentives and operational policy support if Enviroserve wishes to secure batteries before they enter the informal sector.
Executive Summary
9
Overall Findings
The project demonstrates that Kenya already possesses the foundations of a waste LIB collection ecosystem, but that the system is fragmented, largely informal, and heavily influenced by waste battery value. Future collection strategies should focus on engaging super aggregators, implementing robust sorting and acceptance procedures, supporting takeback programs within the formal sector, and establishing sustainable battery purchasing guidelines. As Kenya’s Extended Producer Responsibilities (EPR) framework matures and battery volumes continue to increase, there is a significant opportunity for Enviroserve to position itself as a leading processor and recycler of end-of-life lithium-ion batteries in East Africa.
Executive Summary
10
1.
Summary of Original Six Pillars
1. Summary of Original Six Pillars
Enviroserve originally proposed six different Battery Collection Business Model Pilots as part of Siemens Stiftung Comparative Study and Pilot Testing of Business Models for Battery Collection in Kenya. 1. Enviroserve-led Collection Initiative This pillar focused on building out Enviroserve’s ability to collect directly from lithium-ion battery (LIB) end-users. A key component of this pillar was converting a 3-wheeler to run on electricity for lowcost transportation of waste LIBs.
1. Summary of Original Six Pillars
2. Repair Shop Collection Points Mobile phone and laptop repair shops collect a large quantity of waste LIBs through the course of their normal work. Storing and disposing of LIBs are a liability so Enviroserve planned to partner with various repair shops and give containers, signage, and training to their staff to safely store and handle waste LIBs.
12
3. Community-based Organization Partnership Enviroserve would identify and train members in youth and women’s groups to identify, collect, and turn in caches of end-of-life LIBs in their respective communities to Enviroserve. Enviroserve would provide gear, incentives, and coordination support to each community-based organization (CBO). The primary goal was to increase a sense of environmental protection, community ownership of proper waste disposal, and reduce hazardous waste in households with communities served by these CBOs. 5. Formal Institution Collaboration The personal electronics and solar off-grid industries were early adopters of LIBs, but several new industries are converting to LIBs. These include mobility (2-wheeled and 4-wheeled), on-grid solar, commercial and residential energy backup, aeronautics, and camping. This pillar focused on finding ways to offer training, signage, on-site containers, and regular collections with the electric 3-wheeler to key players in these industries.
1. Summary of Original Six Pillars
4. Faith-based Groups Engagement Enviroserve would identify faith-based organisations (FBOs) that it can train to collect waste LIBs from affiliated churches. Like the CBO collaboration pillar, this pillar looked to increase community ownership of waste disposal through exploring trust-based awareness and localized engagement. 6. Business as Usual Enhancement Pilot The Business-as-Usual Enhancement Pilot was designed to test whether reducing or eliminating Enviroserve’s waste LIB processing fees could increase collection volumes from formal-sector clients that increasingly view end-of-life batteries as having positive economic value. The pilot also sought to determine whether a revised pricing approach could help Enviroserve secure waste LIBs before they are diverted into the informal market.
13
1.1 Initial Pilot Implementation & Project Pivot
The original project design was based on the assumption that environmental stewardship and community engagement would encourage voluntary participation in end-of-life LIB collection, thereby reducing collection costs. It also assumed that assigning a direct monetary value to waste LIBs could encourage unsafe informal collection practices. However, initial implementation of the CBO Partnership, Repair Shop Collection Points, and Formal Institution Collaboration pillars demonstrated that an informal market for waste LIBs was already well established and that battery owners generally expected financial compensation for end-of-life batteries. As Enviroserve started to engage CBOs, it was clear that members were not incentivized by Enviroserve’s message of environmental responsibility and proper battery disposal. Most CBOs were primarily interested in working with Enviroserve to increase employment within the surrounding communities. Enviroserve’s negotiations with CBOs revealed that most members were planning to collect waste LIBs from waste collectors in Ngara and Dandora rather than from battery end-users within their respective communities. Enviroserve could not get any CBO to agree to a model where it compensated informal actors for time and effort rather than the batteries themselves; every organization demanded to be paid for the batteries themselves. Engagement with laptop and mobile phone repair shops indicated that businesses preferred to dispose of waste batteries as quickly as possible rather than store them on-site. Interviewees explained that repair shops are subject to regulatory oversight because they may also handle devices associated with theft investigations, making prolonged storage of waste batteries undesirable. Participants further indicated that concerns about regulatory inspections and compliance requirements discouraged
1. Summary of Original Six Pillars
14
on-site storage of waste LIBs. Consequently, none of the repair shops interviewed acknowledged storing waste LIBs, and discussions suggested that batteries were typically transferred to local e-waste collectors shortly after becoming available. Engagement with formal institutions indicated that corporate social responsibility and regulatory compliance alone were insufficient incentives for formal-sector battery disposal. When disposing of LIBs imposes a KES 200/kg cost to the company, there is very little incentive to check if the waste batteries placed in storage 12 months ago are still there. This situation may increase the risk of batteries being diverted into the informal market without being detected. Formal companies need to have processes in place to regularly audit waste batteries in storage to prevent the batteries from disappearing into the informal market and that will only happen if the company can earn money from selling the waste batteries. The absence of an informal waste LIB recycling supply chain in Kenya was one of the principal tenants of half of Enviroserve’s six project pillars. However, the lessons from the initial implementation of the CBO Partnership, Repair Shop Collection Points, and Formal Institution Collaboration pillars showed that an informal market for waste LIBs already existed, end-users understood that waste LIBs have value, and that Enviroserve was going to have difficulty using the message
1. Summary of Original Six Pillars
of environmental responsibility to incentivize end-users to consistently give batteries to Enviroserve. Enviroserve felt it needed to pivot the implementation of the project to learn how it should best engage this pre-existing informal supply chain. To know how to best engage the pre-existing informal supply chain, Enviroserve needed to answer four new questions:
Who participates in the informal market and how is it organized?
How much does it cost to sort, transport, and test batteries?
1
2
Which suppliers can costeffectively provide waste LIBs?
What is the market price of waste LIBs?
3
4
Enviroserve replaced old three pillars that were aimed at cultivating a nascent informal market with three new pillars aimed at answering these four questions (Table 1). Table 1: Replaced Project Pillars Old Project Pillars Repair Shop Collections Community-based Organization Partnerships Faith-based Groups Engagement
New Project Pillars Map the Informal Market Model Transportation & Processing Costs Informal Battery Purchase Program
15
The descriptions of the new pillars are: 1. Map the Informal Supply Chain Enviroserve needs to understand who participates in the informal market, how many batteries do they collect per annum, what is the waste LIBs price, and how many pay VAT on the goods they sell. This pillar maps the different levels within the informal market — from collector up to exporter and recycler — to help Enviroserve understand who it could purchase batteries from.
3. Informal Battery Purchase Program The informal market mapping pillar will collect battery sales prices in interviews with stakeholders, but battery prices need to be verified through actual purchase data. Enviroserve will need to set an initial waste LIB price and then see how low it can push battery purchase prices.
2. Model Transportation & Processing Costs Whether Enviroserve is purchasing batteries from formal institutions or the informal market, Enviroserve will incur costs above and beyond the cost of the batteries themselves. The most important costs to understand are the costs associated with sending technicians to conduct acceptance testing of battery shipments before they are loaded onto trucks, transporting battery shipments to Enviroserve’s warehouse, and separating different lithium chemistries apart. Understanding how these costs grow with battery shipment size will help Enviroserve decide if it should focus on collecting from many small suppliers or a small number of large suppliers.
1. Summary of Original Six Pillars
16
1.2 Implementation of Redesigned Pillars Enviroserve is confident that it has improved its collection pilot business model outcomes by pivoting its project in the face of initially disappointing engagement from CBOs, repair shops, and formal institutions.
1. Summary of Original Six Pillars
17
2.
Enviroserve-led Collection Initiative
2. Enviroserve-led Collection Initiative Enviroserve collected, dismantled, and tested end-of-life batteries itself to remanufacture a 51.2V, 9.6-kWh battery from LFP 2nd life cells. the 3-wheeler to date. Delays associated with bypassing the proprietary battery management system postponed vehicle deployment by more than six months. Following these delays, responsibility for the remaining modifications was transferred to Enviroserve, and the Piaggio Apé E-xtra was delivered later in the implementation period.
The Enviroserve-led Collection Initiative aimed to develop a low-cost collection vehicle capable of transporting the majority of waste LIB shipments. A second-hand electric-powered Piaggio Apé E-xtra 3-wheeler with a 500 kg payload capacity was selected and modified to incorporate an onboard solar charging system and a remanufactured 9.6 kWh battery pack assembled from end-of-life LFP batteries. The selected vehicle had previously been configured to operate with a proprietary battery management system, requiring integration with a third-party battery pack before deployment. The conversion from the previous owner’s proprietary battery pack to Enviroserve’s battery pack has been fraught with difficulties that delayed the delivery of the 3-wheeler and prevented operation of
2. Enviroserve-led Collection Initiative
While waiting for the 3-wheeler delivery, Enviroserve collected, dismantled, and tested end-of-life batteries itself to remanufacture a 51.2V, 9.6-kWh battery from LFP 2nd life cells. Enviroserve also developed a model that estimates transportation cost using vehicle depreciation, fuel, maintenance, insurance, driver salary, and NEMA registration costs. TThe transportation cost model provides a framework for comparing predicted operating costs with observed vehicle performance once operational testing is completed. Following delivery of the vehicle, the motor controller was identified as the primary barrier to integrating the remanufactured battery system, and replacement options are currently being evaluated. Once the motor controller is replaced, Enviroserve plans to deploy the 3-wheeler, test its capabilities to transport waste LIBs, and compare its cost of ownership to the predicted values calculated by Enviroserve’s model.
19
2.1 Lessons Learned This pillar highlights the risks associated with purchasing and modifying vehicles that rely on proprietary battery management and motor control systems. Enviroserve underestimated the technical challenges involved in integrating a third-party battery into a vehicle that had already been modified by a previous owner. Reliance on the previous owner to resolve these issues resulted in significant delays and ultimately prevented field testing of the 3-wheeler during the project period. The project further demonstrated the value of developing analytical tools in parallel with hardware implementation. Although the 3-wheeler has not yet entered service, the transportation cost model developed during the project provides Enviroserve with a framework to evaluate vehicle operating costs and compare actual performance against modelled expectations once the vehicle is operational. This model will also allow Enviroserve to compare the economics of electric collection vehicles against conventional fuelpowered alternatives in a pillar discussed later in this report.
2.2 Recommendations Enviroserve should complete the replacement of the motor controller and proceed with operational testing of the Piaggio Apé E-xtra as soon as practical. Priority should be placed on validating vehicle range, payload capacity, reliability, and operating costs under real-world collection conditions. Once operational, Enviroserve should use the 3-wheeler to collect detailed performance data and compare actual transportation costs against those predicted by its transportation cost model. Particular attention should be given to battery performance, energy consumption, maintenance requirements, and vehicle utilization rates. This data will help determine whether electric 3-wheelers can serve as the primary collection vehicle within Enviroserve’s future battery collection network. Future vehicle acquisitions should prioritize platforms with open architectures or manufacturer-supported battery integration pathways. Enviroserve should avoid purchasing vehicles that depend on proprietary battery communication protocols unless the supplier can demonstrate compatibility with third-party battery systems.
2. Enviroserve-led Collection Initiative
20
3.
Map the Informal Supply Chain
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain The waste Li-ion battery supply chain in Nairobi includes six types of organisations — collectors, aggregators, superAggregators, repurposers, recyclers, and exporters — operating across five identifiable tiers in Figure 1. There are also two types of organisations that operate outside of the supply chain that Enviroserve also interviewed: producer responsibility organisations, and industrial associations. After a user throws away a waste LIB, it moves through the five tiers of the supply chain before being exported to another country or ground up for recycling1. Sixteen stakeholders were interviewed as part of this informal sector mapping, covering the entire waste LIB supply chain (Table 2).
COLLECTORS 3 organizations spoken to
2 Ngara Collectors
VAWOCO (Phone Repair Shop)
AGGREGATORS 4 organizations spoken to
Ngara Aggregators
Metal Scrap Dealer 1
Metal Scrap Dealer 1
Metal Scrap Dealer 1
SUPER AGGREGATORS 4 organizations spoken to
E-Waste Initiativ e Kenya (EWIK)
Nairobi Circular Economy Network
Rock E-Waste Solutions (Prospective)
WEEE Centre
REPURPOSERS 3 organizations spoken to
Lithogen East Africa
After Life Innovations
AceleAfrica
RECYCLERS | EXPORTERS 0 organizations spoken to
ORGANIZATIONS OUTSIDE THE SUPPLY CHAIN TIERS
EPROK Responsibility Org
Kenya Association of Waste Recyclers (KAWR) Industrial Association
Figure 1: Informal Supply Chain Diagram
1. The Repurposer tier is unique in that a fraction of cells/ batteries that reach this tier will be removed from the waste LIB supply chain placed back with new battery users.
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
22
2.1 Lessons Learned This pillar highlights the risks associated with purchasing and modifying vehicles that rely on proprietary battery management and motor control systems. Enviroserve underestimated the technical challenges involved in integrating a third-party battery into a vehicle that had already been modified by a previous owner. Reliance on the previous owner to resolve these issues resulted in significant delays and ultimately prevented field testing of the 3-wheeler during the project period. The project further demonstrated the value of developing analytical tools in parallel with hardware implementation. Although the 3-wheeler has not yet entered service, the transportation cost model developed during the project provides Enviroserve with a framework to evaluate vehicle operating costs and compare actual performance against modelled expectations once the vehicle is operational. This model will also allow Enviroserve to compare the economics of electric collection vehicles against conventional fuelpowered alternatives in a pillar discussed later in this report.
2.2 Recommendations Enviroserve should complete the replacement of the motor controller and proceed with operational testing of the Piaggio Apé E-xtra as soon as practical. Priority should be placed on validating vehicle range, payload capacity, reliability, and operating costs under real-world collection conditions. Once operational, Enviroserve should use the 3-wheeler to collect detailed performance data and compare actual transportation costs against those predicted by its transportation cost model. Particular attention should be given to battery performance, energy consumption, maintenance requirements, and vehicle utilization rates. This data will help determine whether electric 3-wheelers can serve as the primary collection vehicle within Enviroserve’s future battery collection network. Future vehicle acquisitions should prioritize platforms with open architectures or manufacturer-supported battery integration pathways. Enviroserve should avoid purchasing vehicles that depend on proprietary battery communication protocols unless the supplier can demonstrate compatibility with third-party battery systems.
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
23
Table 2: Number of Interviewees
Tier
Role
Actors Interviewed
Collector
Gather batteries from households, repair shops, schools, solar companies, and corporates Consolidate batteries from multiple collectors
1 phone repair shop,
High-volume consolidation, sensitization, and connection to formal recyclers
E-Waste Initiative Kenya (EWIK)
Aggregator
Super-Aggregator
Repurposer
Resells batteries or cells or manufactures new batteries from used LIBs
Recycler
2 Ngara Collectors
1 Ngara Aggregator 3 Metal scrap dealers3
Rock E-Waste Solutions Nairobi Circular Economy Association WEEE Centre Lithogen East Africa After Life Innovations AceleAfrica
Extracts scrap materials E-Waste Initiative Kenya and minerals batteries for (EWIK) black mass recovery Rock E-Waste Solutions Nairobi Circular Economy Association Exports waste LIBs for recycling abroad
Exporter
4
WEEE Centre Indirectly alluded to in an interview
Producer Responsibility Connects waste Organization producers and aggregators to battery refurbishes and recyclers
Electronic Waste Producer Responsibility Organization of Kenya (EPROK)
Industrial Association
Kenyan Association of Waste Recyclers
2. Unknown deliveries per month.
Advocates for and informs the waste recycling industry on policy, legislation, and stakeholder engagement
3.Interviewed by proxy
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
Estimated Scale of Activity Low — may handle 1-10 kg of co-mingled scrap batteries per delivery2 Moderate — may handle 400-800 kg of co-mingled scrap battery per month High — may handle 2-6 tons of co-mingled scrap batteries per month
Low — may produce 0.9 tons of waste LIBs per year.
High — may handle 2-6 tons of co-mingled scrap batteries per month
Unknown
None — EPROK has the potential to link Enviroserve to more super aggregators beyond those this mapping has identified None
4.Usually illegally
24
Based on Enviroserve’s mapping, Kenya lacks formal waste LIB recycling organisations. These organisations are the natural endpoints for a waste supply chain, and they serve as “buyers of last resort” for actors within the informal waste LIB supply chain. Their absence slows the organic growth of informal supply chain because waste LIB collection currently depends on repurposer demand, which is irregular and only buys the highest quality waste LIBs. Waste LIBs are classified as hazardous waste, and Kenya lacks a certified hazardous waste landfill for waste LIBs rejected by repurposers. Thus, the lack of recyclers increases improper disposal of LIBs when supply chain participants cannot find buyers for batteries they have collected. The absence of a LIB recycler within Kenya both negative economic impacts for stakeholders in the informal waste LIB supply chain and negative environmental impacts on the communities where waste LIBs are thrown away. Direct interviews with waste battery exporters were not conducted during the study. However, one collector reported having been approached by an exporter, providing additional evidence that waste LIBs are being exported from Kenya. This finding is consistent with information gathered from collectors interviewed as part of the Informal Battery Purchase Program. Most other interviewees were unwilling to disclose the buyers of their waste batteries.
The interviews also indicated that few collectors, aggregators, or super aggregators specialise in supplying LIBs through the informal value chain to repurposers, recyclers, or exporters. Instead, most repurposers and recyclers primarily source e-waste and LIBs directly from formal-sector organisations. The findings nevertheless suggest an opportunity to expand the informal LIB supply chain by encouraging existing waste collectors, aggregators, and super aggregators to participate through appropriate battery pricing, training in battery identification and handling, and guidance on separating LIBs from mixed waste streams.
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
25
3.1 Throughput Volumes Quantifying the volume of waste LIBs flowing through the informal supply chain is difficult because most interviewees are unable to differentiate LIBs from other batteries thrown away. There are also relatively few end consumers of waste LIBs compared to other waste streams, so the average aggregator and super aggregator only occasionally collects waste LIBs. The following waste battery throughput estimates were documented: Table 3: Annual Battery Throughput
Actor
Yearly Volume (Est.)
Notes
Ngara Collector
Unknown
Ngara Aggregator
0.7 – 1.9 tons
EWIK (Super Aggregator)
3.5 – 14.5 tons
Acele Africa (Repurposer)
0.9 tons
Individual collectors store up to 3 kg of co-mingled batteries before selling them to an aggregator. Unknown frequency of sales. 600 kg/month of co-mingled batteries; 17.5% of co-mingled batteries are lithium-ion. 4 tons of co-mingled batteries per month; 17.5% of co-mingled batteries are LIBs. All batteries from AceleAfrica have lead acid batteries separated out.
It was assumed that the waste LIB fraction in the co-mingled battery waste mimics the importation ratio of lithiumion to lead acid batteries into Kenya in 2024/2025: 15-20%.
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
When interviewees gave monthly throughput numbers, they gave a range of co-mingled waste battery that they handled. It was assumed that the waste LIB fraction in the co-mingled battery waste mimics the importation ratio of lithium-ion to lead acid batteries into Kenya in 2024/2025: 15-20%. While the quantity of LIBs recovered from battery repurposers is low — on the order of 1 ton per year — the batteries are already sorted potentially reducing the associated collection and acceptance cost.
26
3.2 Pricing Along the Supply Chain Waste battery prices appear to vary more across the same level of the supply chain than from level to level. High prices in the market are primarily driven by low volume repurposers buying higher quality batteries directly from collectors and aggregators to make low-cost batteries for energy storage or cell phone battery replacement. Low prices in the market may be driven by waste LIB exporters collecting batteries for foreign battery recycling companies. Table 4: Waste Battery Pricing
Actor / Tier
Buy Price (KES)
Sell Price (KES)
Unit
Notes
Ngara Collector
—
20 - 250
Per kg
Quality-dependent. Sells to aggregators or directly to superaggregators.
Phone Repair Shop (Collector)
—
>75 - 850
Per kg
Ngara Aggregator
—
20 – 250
Per kg
Scrap Metal Dealers (Aggregators) EWIK (Super Aggregator)
—
100
20 – 250
100 – 300
Per kg (comingled) Per kg
One-time sale to a repurposer. Rejected a Chinese buyer at KES 75/kg. Quality-dependent. Consolidates from collectors and sells on. Batteries co-mingled with other scrap and sold by total weight. Quality-dependent.
WEEE Centre (Super Aggregator)
150 – 600
—
Per kg
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
Also operates a tip-fee (paidto-collect) model. Downstream selling prices withheld.
27
LIB price at the collector-level is difficult to deduce from the above table because collector interviewees gave such a wide range in prices. However, Enviroserve has heard that the value of copper scrap within waste LIBs (KES 80/kg) is a rough floor to what collectors will accept for waste LIBs; provided they know how to access the copper foil inside. The aggregator-level price is not deducible from the above table. The Ngara aggregator has given the same price range as the collectors and the scrap metal dealers have given a price of KES 100/ kg of co-mingled battery scrap which is higher than both the price of lead acid batteries (KES 40-70/kg) and scrap copper in LIBs (KES 80/kg). Pricing data collected from organisations operating at the superaggregator level provided the most complete picture of market pricing within the informal supply chain. The data suggest that super aggregators typically apply a margin of approximately KES 50–80/kg to waste LIBs, with minimum selling prices ranging from 25–50% above the estimated copper scrap value. These findings indicate a trade-off between higher procurement costs and the operational efficiencies associated with sourcing larger battery volumes. Procuring directly from aggregators may reduce acquisition costs but would require engagement with LIB price at the collector-level is difficult to deduce from the above table because collector interviewees gave such a wide range in prices. However, Enviroserve has heard that the value of copper scrap within waste LIBs (KES 80/kg) is a rough floor to what collectors will accept for waste LIBs; provided they know how to access the copper foil inside.
All the prices found in Table 4 can probably be reduced somewhat when negotiating with waste LIB suppliers because no permanent market for LIBs currently exists. If Enviroserve sets up a LIB mechanical pre-processing plant, it will create a price floor which will trickle down through the e-waste sector. Due to supply and demand, Enviroserve will pay a little more than it wants to for waste LIBs until it is able to identify 10 super aggregators, at which point it can start to push waste LIB prices down. However, as stated in the Initial Pilot and Implementation & Project Pivot section, it is increasingly difficult to charge formal institutions a fee to collect waste LIBs.
The aggregator-level price is not deducible from the above table. The Ngara aggregator has given the same price range as the collectors and the scrap metal dealers have given a price of KES 100/ kg of co-mingled battery scrap which is higher than both the price of lead acid batteries (KES 40-70/kg) and scrap copper in LIBs (KES 80/kg). Pricing data collected from organisations operating at the superaggregator level provided the most complete picture of market pricing within the informal supply chain. The data suggest that super aggregators typically apply a margin of approximately KES 50–80/kg to waste LIBs, with minimum selling prices ranging from 25–50% above the estimated copper scrap value. These findings indicate a trade-off between higher procurement costs and the operational efficiencies associated with sourcing larger battery volumes. Procuring directly from aggregators may reduce acquisition costs but would require engagement with approximately 60 aggregators to secure the same annual feedstock volume that could be obtained from around 10 super aggregators.
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
28
3.3 Battery Chemistries, Sorting, & Handling
LIBs appear to co-mingle with lead acid batteries until the repurposer level. Sorting and quality assessment practices vary significantly by tier: Informal collectors: Physical inspection only. One respondent described shaking batteries to detect loose internal components. No electrical testing is performed. Scrap metal dealers: No sorting or testing. Batteries are sold as-is and comingled with other metals by weight. EWIK: Sells battery packs intact where conditions allow. EWIK was observed to separate batteries by cell chemistry. Lithogen East Africa: Rigorous preassembly electrical testing; cells are grouped by matched state-of-charge (SOC) and state-of-health (SOH) before assembly into repurposed domestic storage packs. Sub-standard cells are disposed of, not sold on. After Life Innovations: Testing and verification in progress as part of R&D for second-life battery applications. A critical observation across the
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
chain is that lumping of different battery types together is common, particularly at the lower tiers. Batteries are rarely separated by chemistry among collectors, aggregators, and scrap dealers; EWIK is the notable exception. This has direct implications on Enviroserve’s acceptance testing and sorting costs. Enviroserve should be prepared to account for the cost of sorting and should consider three broad options: Buy lumped batteries wholesale — acquiring all chemistries together and conducting sorting at Enviroserve’s own warehouse. Sort on-site at the seller’s location — deploying sorting capacity to the point of collection before taking custody. Selectively source only from tiers where sorting has already been done — limiting procurement to actors such as EWIK who handle chemistry separation upstream. When Enviroserve sets the price it is willing to pay for waste LIBs, it should consider the cost of sorting or acceptance testing co-mingled batteries at the supplier. It should not accept unsorted, co-mingled battery waste as this could result in super aggregators dumping lead acid batteries onto Enviroserve’s hands while selling LIBs to others. This could result in Enviroserve overpaying for lead acid batteries and starving its waste LIB collection business.
29
3.4 Degree of Formalization Within the Supply Chain The level of supplier formalisation has a direct impact on the financial implications of procuring batteries from the informal supply chain. Purchases from suppliers without KRA PINs cannot be claimed as business expenses or VAT inputs, increasing the apparent taxable income associated with these transactions. Consequently, sourcing batteries from informal suppliers carries additional tax implications as materials move from the informal to the formal economy.
66% 75% of interviewed repurposers and recyclers are formally registered and have KRA PINs
66% of interviewed super aggregators are formally registered and have KRA PINs
Unknown number of aggregators had KRA PINs
No collectors had KRA PINs
3.5 Lessons Learned from Mapping the Informal Supply Chain The mapping exercise found that Kenya's informal waste LIB supply chain currently ends at the repurposer level, with limited evidence of established domestic recycling or export pathways. While repurposers extend the useful life of batteries through second-life applications, interview findings suggest that end-of-life batteries that can no longer be repurposed have limited formal recycling options within the country. This represents a gap in the waste LIB value chain and highlights an opportunity for investment in downstream recycling and recovery infrastructure. Based on interview responses, annual throughput estimates were developed for aggregators, super aggregators, and repurposers (Table 5). Although annual throughput could not be estimated for collectors because of irregular collection and sales patterns, the findings indicate that super aggregators handle substantially larger battery volumes than aggregators, making them a more efficient point of engagement for large-scale battery collection initiatives 5. Enviroserve was not able to deduce annual throughput data for informal Collectors due to their unpredictable delivery schedule
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
30
Table 5: Estimated Informal Sector Players' Annual Throughput Low Throughput [tons/ year]
Mid Throughput [tons/ year]
High Throughput [tons/year]
0.7
1.3
1.9
Super-Aggregator 3.6
8.4
14.4
Repurposer
0.9
0.9
Aggregator
0.9
The mapping exercise also showed that co-mingling of battery chemistries is common throughout the lower tiers of the informal supply chain. Lead-acid, NiCad and lithium-ion batteries are frequently collected, transported and traded together, while LIB recycling processes require batteries to be separated by chemistry. As a result, battery sorting and acceptance testing remain essential requirements before batteries can enter formal recycling or repurposing pathways. The study further found that dedicated waste LIB collection remains limited. Most collectors, aggregators and super aggregators handle LIBs as part of broader e-waste activities rather than as a specialised business. Interviews suggest that this is largely due to the absence of a consistent domestic purchaser of end-of-life LIBs. As battery volumes increase and recycling capacity develops, there is potential for greater specialisation within the informal supply chain. The mapping exercise also highlighted differences in the level of formalisation across the supply chain. While many super aggregators and repurposers were formally registered and held KRA PINs, transactions at the collector and aggregator levels frequently occurred outside the formal tax system. This presents administrative and tax challenges for formal organisations procuring batteries from informal suppliers, including limitations on recognising procurement costs and recovering input VAT. These findings highlight an important structural consideration for integrating informal collection activities into formal recycling systems
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
31
3.6 Recommendations from Mapping the Informal Supply Chain Recommendation 1: Improve battery sorting at the point of collection The study found that lithium-ion batteries are frequently comingled with lead-acid and NiCad batteries throughout the lower tiers of the informal supply chain. Improving battery sorting before collection would reduce downstream handling costs, minimise contamination of recycling feedstock, and improve the consistency of battery quality. Training suppliers in basic battery identification and sorting procedures, supported by simple acceptance criteria at the point of purchase, would strengthen the quality of material entering formal collection and recycling systems. Recommendation 2: Develop procurement mechanisms that support engagement with the informal sector The study identified tax and administrative challenges associated with purchasing batteries from informal suppliers that are not registered with KRA. Organisations sourcing waste LIBs from the informal sector should develop procurement mechanisms that maintain regulatory compliance while recognising the realities of informal market participation. Addressing these barriers will be important for integrating informal collection networks into formal battery recycling value chains. Recommendation 3: Prioritise engagement with high-volume suppliers The mapping exercise indicates that super aggregators provide substantially larger battery volumes than individual aggregators, reducing supplier management requirements and improving transportation efficiency. Based on the estimated annual throughput presented in Table 5, approximately 10 super aggregators could supply a similar volume of waste LIBs as around 60 aggregators. Organisations establishing battery collection systems should therefore consider supplier throughput alongside battery purchase price when evaluating procurement strategies, recognising the trade-off between supplier margins and operational efficiency.
3. Map the Informal Supply Chain
32
4.
Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs
4. Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs Following the mapping of the informal supply chain, a transportation and processing cost model was developed to evaluate the trade-offs associated with sourcing waste lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) from different supplier tiers. While larger suppliers typically command higher battery prices, they may also reduce transportation, sorting and processing costs through larger shipment volumes. The modelling exercise was undertaken to quantify these trade-offs and identify procurement strategies that minimise the overall cost of battery collection.
The cost model estimates the transportation and processing costs associated with collecting, testing and sorting waste LIBs under different operating scenarios. Transportation costs were modelled for three vehicle types commonly used for battery collection, while processing costs included shipment sampling, battery sorting and acceptance testing. Average monthly shipment sizes were estimated using the throughput analysis presented in Table 5. Aggregators were assumed to supply approximately 108 kg per month, while super aggregators were assumed to supply approximately 700 kg per month. These shipment sizes formed the basis of the transportation cost analysis.
4. Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs
The analysis compared transportation and processing costs for different vehicle types across both supplier categories. The results indicate that electric 3-wheelers consistently provide the lowest transportation costs under the modelled assumptions. They also show that collecting larger shipments from super aggregators reduces transportation and processing costs relative to sourcing equivalent battery volumes from aggregators. Depending on vehicle type and utilisation, the model estimates savings of approximately KES 20–52/kg when sourcing from super aggregators rather than aggregators. When considered alongside the battery purchase prices presented in Table 4, these savings represent a meaningful component of total procurement costs.
34
Transportation and Processing Costs for Difference Scenarios KES 90.00 KES 80.00 KES 70.00 KES 60.00 KES 50.00 KES 40.00 KES 30.00 KES 20.00 KES 10.00 KES 3-Wheeler 108 kg Loads
1-ton Pickup
3-ton Truck
700 kg Loads
Figure 2: Cost of Transportation and Processing Costs
4. Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs
35
4.1 Lessons Learned from Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs
The Transportation and Processing Costs modelled by Enviroserve The transportation and processing cost estimates presented in Table 6 demonstrate that vehicle utilisation and shipment size are significant drivers of the overall cost of waste LIB collection. Across all modelled vehicle types, larger shipments from super aggregators consistently incur lower transportation and processing costs than the smaller shipments typically sourced from aggregators. The model estimates savings of between KES 20/kg and KES 52/kg, depending on vehicle type and utilisation. When these cost savings are considered alongside the waste LIB selling prices presented in Table 4, they represent a meaningful component of the overall procurement cost and should therefore be evaluated together when assessing sourcing strategies. The analysis also highlights the importance of supplier scale. Although super aggregators generally command higher battery prices, their larger shipment volumes reduce transportation and processing costs while requiring fewer supplier relationships to achieve equivalent annual throughput. Procurement decisions should therefore consider total acquisition cost rather than battery purchase price alone.
The findings further indicate that electric 3-wheelers are the most cost-effective transport option under the operating assumptions used in the model, particularly for routine collection activities. Larger vehicles become economically attractive primarily when collecting substantial battery volumes or when higher payload capacity is required. Finally, the modelling illustrates the value of integrating transportation, processing and procurement costs into a single decision-making framework. Evaluating these costs together provides a more realistic assessment of collection economics than considering battery purchase prices in isolation.
Table 6: Minimum Transportation Costs per Vehicle Electric 3-Wheeler KES 3,300 per ton
1-ton Pickup KES 12,300 per ton
4. Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs
3-ton Truck KES 6,800 per ton
36
4.2 Recommendations from Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs 1. Prioritise collection strategies that maximise transportation efficiency The modelling demonstrates that transportation costs are minimised when vehicles operate close to their payload capacity. Collection programmes should therefore prioritise regular collection routes using smaller vehicles for routine battery pickups, while larger vehicles should be reserved for occasional highvolume collections where their greater carrying capacity can be fully utilised. Maintaining high vehicle utilisation is essential for minimising transportation costs. 2. Prioritise high-volume suppliers where commercially viable The modelling indicates that sourcing batteries from super aggregators offers significant operational advantages. Although super aggregators may command higher battery purchase prices, their larger shipment volumes reduce transportation and processing costs and require substantially fewer supplier relationships than sourcing equivalent volumes from aggregators. Based on the estimated annual throughputs presented in Table 5, approximately 10 super aggregators could supply a similar annual volume of waste LIBs as around 60 aggregators. Procurement strategies should therefore evaluate total acquisition costs— including transportation, processing and supplier management costs—rather than battery purchase price alone. Aggregators remain a viable source of supply where commercial terms or logistical arrangements offset the additional transportation costs associated with smaller shipment sizes. 3. Incorporate repurposers into collection networks where appropriate Repurposers represent a valuable supplementary source of waste LIBs because batteries have generally already been sorted by chemistry and separated from lead-acid and NiCad batteries before collection. This reduces downstream sorting and acceptance costs compared with batteries sourced from lower tiers of the informal supply chain. However, the relatively low annual throughput of repurposers means they are unlikely to provide sufficient volumes to support large-scale collection programmes on their own and are best considered as part of a diversified supplier network.
4. Modelling Transportation & Processing Costs
37
5.
Informal Battery Purchasing Program
5. Informal Battery Purchasing Program
The Cost & Revenue Model developed for this study provides an estimate of the maximum price at which waste LIBs can be purchased while maintaining a financially sustainable battery collection system. However, the model also requires a realistic lower price bound to estimate the minimum market price that collectors are likely to accept for waste LIBs. Interviews conducted during the informal supply chain mapping identified a wide range of waste LIB prices, from KES 20/kg to KES 850/kg, making it difficult to establish a representative market floor. An alternative approach was therefore required to estimate the minimum value of waste LIBs within the informal market. The study found that artisanal disassembly of waste LIBs enables informal collectors to recover copper foil, which can then be sold to scrap metal dealers. Where collectors possess the knowledge and tools required to recover the copper, the recoverable copper value provides an effective lower bound for the market price of waste LIBs, as batteries are unlikely to be sold below the value of the materials that can be directly recovered. The artisanal copper extraction process is relatively simple and does not require specialised equipment, making it readily accessible to informal collectors. The process begins by cutting open a waste LIB, releasing the electrolyte contained within the cell. The internal electrode foils are then unrolled, rinsed with water, and separated to recover the copper foil for sale as scrap metal. The remaining
5. Informal Battery Purchasing Program
39
battery materials, together with the wastewater generated during the process, are typically discarded.
and lower price bounds provide a more realistic framework for evaluating battery procurement strategies than relying solely on interview-based market prices.
While this process enables the recovery of copper, it also results in the loss of other valuable materials contained within the battery, including aluminium, steel, plastics and black mass, all of which could otherwise be recovered through formal recycling processes. In addition, the dismantling process is generally undertaken without appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE) or environmental safeguards. The uncontrolled release of battery electrolyte and disposal of wastewater present potential environmental and occupational health risks, while manually opening battery cells also increases the likelihood of thermal events and fires during dismantling.
To establish a market-based reference price, a controlled battery disassembly experiment was conducted using appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE) to quantify the recoverable copper content of different lithium-ion battery chemistries. A combination of cylindrical- and pouch-format LiFePO₄ and LiCoO₂ cells was disassembled. As summarised in Table 7, the batteries contained an average copper content of 8.3% by weight.
By estimating the recoverable copper value within waste LIBs, the study establishes a practical market benchmark that complements the upper price estimates generated by the Cost & Revenue Model. Together, these upper
The measured copper value of KES 78.9/kg therefore provides an evidence-based reference point for estimating the lower bound of waste LIB prices within the informal market. When considered alongside the upper price estimates generated by the Cost & Revenue Model, this benchmark provides a practical basis for evaluating sustainable battery procurement prices.
Based on an average scrap copper price of approximately KES 950/kg in Kenya, the recoverable copper represents an estimated value of KES 78.9/kg of waste LIBs. The experiment also quantified the average quantities of aluminium, steel, plastic and black mass contained within the batteries, demonstrating that informal dismantling practices recover only a fraction of the total material value. The analysis estimates that battery disassemblers discard approximately 60% of the potential value of a waste LIB when only the copper foil is recovered.
Table 7: Copper Content Results
Battery Chemistry
Total Weight Disassembled grams
Copper Recovered grams
Copper Content %
LiFePo4
515
57
11
LiCoO2
1,787
135
7.6
Total
2,302
192
8.3
5. Informal Battery Purchasing Program
40
5.1 Informal Sector Battery Purchases During those six months, Enviroserve purchased 1,128 kg of cylindrical and pouch cells from waste LIB aggregators.
6 Months
1,128 Kg
The Informal Battery Purchasing Programme was implemented between October 2025 and April 2026 to establish representative market prices for waste lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) through direct procurement from informal-sector suppliers. During the sixmonth pilot, 1,128 kg of cylindrical- and pouch-format LIBs were purchased from informal-sector aggregators. At the start of the programme, limited information was available on prevailing market prices for waste LIBs. Procurement staff therefore relied on discussions with multiple suppliers to estimate purchase prices. The existing informal supply chain primarily serves battery repurposers, who require relatively small quantities of higherquality batteries. As a result, suppliers typically trade batteries on a per-battery rather than per-kilogram basis. Because solar lantern, mobile phone, laptop and electric vehicle batteries vary considerably in weight, per-battery pricing obscures the effective price per kilogram and makes direct price comparisons difficult. The absence of reliable market intelligence also limited the ability to negotiate procurement prices during the early stages of the programme. Purchase prices ranged from KES 0/kg to KES 625/kg, with most transactions concentrated between KES 125/kg and KES 250/kg, as shown in Figure 3. The average purchase price across the programme was KES 224/ kg. Following completion of the Waste Battery Copper Content Experiment in March 2026, the average purchase price declined to KES 118/kg, indicating that improved understanding of the material value of waste LIBs and prevailing market conditions strengthened procurement
5. Informal Battery Purchasing Program
41
negotiations. Despite this reduction, the average purchase price remained above the estimated KES 78.9/kg intrinsic copper value contained within the batteries. The programme also provided insights into supplier behaviour. The largest individual transaction yielded 147 kg of waste LIBs, while the average transaction size was 59.4 kg. Several suppliers returned between two and four times with additional batteries to sell, and the largest supplier delivered a cumulative 326 kg over the six-month period. These repeat transactions suggest that supplier relationships can contribute meaningfully to sustained procurement volumes. Most suppliers delivered batteries directly to the collection facility, reducing transportation and processing costs by an estimated KES 27.8/kg. Although these operational savings improved the overall economics of battery collection, they were insufficient to offset the margins charged by suppliers above the estimated material value of the batteries. This indicates that procurement price remains the primary driver of overall battery acquisition costs..
Informal Battery Purchase Histogram
Number of Transactions per Bin
12 10 8 6 4 2 0
Price per kg
[ KES -, KES 125 ]
[ KES 125 , KES 250 ] [ KES 250 , KES 375 ] [ KES 375 , KES 500 ] [ KES 500 , KES 625 ]
Figure 3: Informal Sector Battery Purchase Histogram 5. Informal Battery Purchasing Program
42
The largest quantities that Enviroserve collected ranged between KES 125 and 250/kg, and Enviroserve did not collect a substantially larger quantity of waste batteries when it offered higher prices per kilogram. The largest purchase yielded 147 kg of waste batteries, but the average weight of each transaction was 59.4 kg. A few Battery Purchase Program participants returned to Enviroserve between 2 to 4 times with additional waste LIBs to sell. The largest supplier provided 326 kg over 6 months.
The largest purchase yielded 147 kg of waste batteries, but the average weight of each transaction was 59.4 kg.
Most of these LIB shipments were dropped off at the Enviroserve warehouse, offsetting the high battery purchase price with lower transportation and processing costs. By having these shipments dropped off at the warehouse, Enviroserve saved KES 27.8/kg in transportation and processing costs. While Enviroserve was able to reduce the transportation costs by having Battery Purchase Program participants drop off batteries at the Enviroserve warehouse, the transportation and processing cost savings do not offset the margin its suppliers were charging above the value of copper in the batteries.
5.2 Lessons Learned from the Battery Purchase Program The battery purchasing programme highlighted the significant environmental and occupational health risks associated with the artisanal extraction of copper from waste lithium-ion batteries (LIBs). Manual battery disassembly exposes workers to hydrofluoric acid (HF) generated from electrolyte degradation and increases the risk of fires resulting from damaged battery cells. In addition to the risks faced by individual battery disassemblers, the uncontrolled release of HF and flammable volatile organic compounds (VOCs), together with the improper disposal of battery waste, presents broader environmental and public health concerns. Although these impacts were observed during individual battery disassembly, the cumulative effects are likely to increase as
5. Informal Battery Purchasing Program
larger volumes of waste LIBs enter the informal sector. The findings also highlight the current absence of adequate recycling and hazardous waste management infrastructure to safely manage these materials in Kenya. The Waste Battery Copper Content Experiment established that waste LIBs contain approximately KES 80/kg of recoverable copper value. When considered alongside the Cost & Revenue Model, this analysis indicates that purchasing waste LIBs at approximately KES 80/kg represents a commercially sustainable acquisition cost for collection programmes that intend to repurpose batteries or mechanically pre-process them prior to recycling. Battery purchasing data collected during the pilot indicate that most transactions occurred at approximately KES 250/ kg, while a small number of
43
purchases approached KES 625/kg, as illustrated in Figure 3. These findings suggest that suppliers were generally pricing batteries well above their intrinsic material value. However, following completion of the Informal Supply Chain Mapping and the Waste Battery Copper Content Experiment, procurement prices declined, indicating that improved market intelligence strengthened price negotiations and enabled procurement staff to secure batteries at lower prices. Comparison of the quantities purchased through the Battery Purchasing Programme with the annual throughput estimates presented in Table 3 indicates that the pilot primarily sourced batteries from collectors and aggregators rather than super aggregators. Consequently, the programme did not validate the pricing information obtained from super aggregators during the informal supply chain mapping. This represents an important evidence gap and suggests that additional procurement data from super aggregators would improve confidence in the pricing ranges presented in Table 4.
5.3 Recommendations from the Battery Purchase The battery purchasing programme indicates that procurement strategies should prioritise purchases from super aggregators at prices that are as close as practical to the estimated intrinsic material value of waste LIBs. While the Waste Battery Copper Content Experiment estimated a copper value of approximately KES 80/kg, interviews with super aggregators suggest that commercially viable purchase prices are likely to fall within the range of KES 100–150/kg, reflecting the margin required to compensate suppliers for collection and consolidation activities. Procurement prices significantly above this range are likely to reduce the commercial viability of battery collection operations. Furthermore, the Cost & Revenue Model indicates that collection programmes purchasing waste LIBs at approximately KES 100/kg would need to process more than 200 tonnes per year to achieve financial sustainability.
by the Cost & Revenue Model, the intrinsic material value of waste LIBs, and prevailing market conditions. Establishing clear purchasing guidelines can improve procurement consistency, reduce exposure to price volatility, and support more efficient allocation of procurement budgets. The programme also demonstrated the importance of continuous market intelligence and procurement oversight. As the battery purchasing programme progressed, improved understanding of supplier pricing and market dynamics contributed to lower negotiated purchase prices. Collection programmes should therefore regularly monitor market conditions, review procurement data, and refine purchasing strategies to ensure battery acquisition costs remain aligned with evolving market realities while supporting long-term operational sustainability.
The high-price outliers observed during the battery purchasing programme, including purchases approaching KES 650/kg, highlight the importance of establishing clear procurement policies that define maximum purchase prices and minimum order quantities. These procurement thresholds should be informed
5. Informal Battery Purchasing Program
44
6.
Formal Institution Collaboration
6. Formal Institution Collaboration
Kenya's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) legislation, enacted in 2024, places responsibility on producers and importers for the collection and environmentally sound management of products containing lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) at the end of their useful lives. While many organisations are still developing mechanisms to comply with these requirements, the study explored opportunities to collaborate with formal-sector institutions to improve the collection and responsible disposal of waste LIBs. The assessment focused on organisations operating within the e-mobility, off-grid solar, on-grid solar, commercial and residential energy backup, aeronautics, lithium cell manufacturing, and camping sectors.
Interview responses consistently reflected several common themes:
A semi-structured questionnaire was developed to assess the quantities of waste LIBs currently held by formal organisations, estimate the volumes expected to reach end-of-life annually, and evaluate existing battery takeback and disposal practices. A total of 93 organisations across the seven target industries were identified for inclusion in the assessment, of which 37 organisations were interviewed. Although the assessment covered approximately 40% of the target sample, responses became highly consistent across sectors, indicating that the principal themes were repeatedly observed throughout the interview process.
•
6. Formal Institution Collaboration
•
•
•
Organisations had not been selling lithium-ion battery products long enough for significant quantities to reach end-of-life. Batteries that failed during warranty periods were collected, but end-of-life batteries were generally considered the responsibility of the end user. Many organisations intended to repurpose batteries internally rather than dispose of them. Several respondents expressed concern that waste batteries stored on their premises could easily be diverted into the informal market because of their growing economic value.
These findings highlight two broader challenges. First, many organisations demonstrated a limited understanding
46
of their obligations under Kenya's EPR framework, particularly the responsibility placed on producers and importers for end-of-life battery management. Second, while battery repurposing can extend the operational life of lithium-ion batteries, it does not provide a complete end-of-life management solution and therefore cannot replace responsible recycling or disposal pathways. The original objective of the questionnaire was to quantify both the volume of waste LIBs currently stored by formal-sector organisations and the quantities expected to arise annually. However, interview data alone proved insufficient to estimate national waste battery volumes with confidence. Consequently, the information gathered through stakeholder interviews was combined with additional market data to develop a Formal Sector Battery Collection Model that estimates when batteries
sold across the seven target industries will reach end-of-life and become available for collection. The model estimates end-of-life battery volumes across the e-mobility, off-grid solar, on-grid solar, commercial and residential energy backup, aeronautics, lithium cell manufacturing, and camping sectors. Interview responses informed assumptions regarding battery service life, the proportion of batteries suitable for second-life applications, and the distribution of lithium-ion battery chemistries. Historical sales data and vehicle registration records were validated against stakeholder responses on cumulative sales, while projected sales beyond 2025 were extrapolated using observed industry growth trends. The resulting estimates, presented in Figure 4, indicate that more than 600 tonnes of lithium-ion batteries are expected to reach end-of-life in Kenya during 2026. In contrast to many developed markets, where electric mobility represents the dominant future source of waste batteries, the analysis indicates that Kenya's off-grid solar sector is expected to generate more than 20 times the volume of waste LIBs produced by the other six sectors combined. The model further projects continued growth in end-of-life battery volumes over the coming years, accompanied by a gradual transition in battery chemistry from nickel manganese cobalt (NMC) to lithium iron phosphate (LFP).
Availability of End-of-Life Lithium-Ion Batteries 2000.0 1800.0
Tons of Batteries per Year
1600.0 1400.0 1200.0 1000.0 800.0 600.0 400.0 200.0 0 2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
Figure 4: LIB Availability for Collection
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
LFP Batteries
2029
2030
NMC Batteries
6. LiCo and NMC chemistries versus LFP chemistries
6. Formal Institution Collaboration
47
6.1 Lessons Learned The Formal Sector Battery Collection Model estimates that more than 600 tonnes of lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) generated across the e-mobility, off-grid solar, ongrid solar, commercial and residential energy backup, aeronautics, lithium cell manufacturing, and camping sectors will reach end-of-life in 2026. Analysis of the Formal Sector Battery Collection Model together with the Cost & Revenue Model suggests that a commercially viable collection programme would need to recover approximately 12.5–25% of the waste LIBs generated by the formal sector from 2026 onwards. The modelling further indicates that while approximately half of the batteries reaching end-of-life in 2026 are expected to be lithium iron phosphate (LFP) batteries, this proportion is projected to increase to 75–80% between 2027 and 2031. This shift in battery chemistry has important implications for the economics of battery recycling, as LFP batteries generally contain lower-value materials than nickel manganese cobalt (NMC) batteries and therefore generate lower revenues in international recycling markets. The formal-sector assessment also found that most organisations across the seven target industries have not yet established end-of-life battery takeback programmes. In the absence of these programmes, companies have limited incentives to retain waste LIBs within formal collection systems, resulting in many batteries entering the informal supply chain. This increases procurement costs for formal collectors while reducing opportunities for environmentally sound end-of-life management.
6. Formal Institution Collaboration
While roughly half of the LIBs reaching the end of their life in 2026 are LFP batteries, about 75 – 80 percent of the batteries reaching the end of their lives between 2027 and 2031 will be LFP.
75% - 80%
2027
2031
Kenya's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) framework assigns Producer Responsibility Organisations (PROs) a central role in supporting producers and importers to establish takeback programmes and connect them with licensed waste management providers. However, the assessment found that implementation remains at an early stage. Although the Electronic Waste Producer Responsibility Organisation of Kenya (EPROK) has begun supporting organisations with takeback programme development, battery-specific collection and disposal mechanisms remain limited. Consequently, some companies are developing their own takeback initiatives, while others have yet to establish practical pathways for complying with EPR requirements for end-of-life lithiumion batteries
48
6.2 Recommendations
The formal-sector assessment indicates that financial incentives alone are unlikely to encourage organisations to participate in formal end-of-life battery collection programmes. Many organisations have not established operational procedures for collecting batteries from customers, and consequently have limited incentives to develop formal takeback systems. Effective collection programmes should therefore provide an integrated service offering that includes:
Economic incentives through competitive waste LIB purchase pricing;
The assessment further indicates that existing Producer Responsibility Organisations (PROs), including the Electronic Waste Producer Responsibility Organisation of Kenya (EPROK), are currently focused primarily on supporting the
6. Formal Institution Collaboration
Support for the development of battery takeback programmes; and
Environmentally compliant collection and disposal services that enable organisations to meet their obligations under Kenya's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) framework.
development of takeback programmes. Expanding access to integrated services that combine takeback programme support, compliant battery collection, and responsible end-of-life management would strengthen formal-sector participation and increase the proportion of waste lithium-ion batteries captured before they enter the informal supply chain.
49
7.
Business as Usual Enhancement Pilot
7. Business as Usual Enhancement Pilot Enviroserve currently charges KES 200/kg to collect e-waste, including lithium-ion batteries (LIBs), to recover disposal costs. However, the study found that many formal-sector organisations have begun withholding end-of-life LIBs from their e-waste shipments because the batteries are increasingly perceived to have positive economic value. This pilot was designed to evaluate whether reducing or eliminating disposal fees could increase the volume of waste LIBs collected from existing formal-sector clients. Many organisations do not allocate budgets for waste LIB disposal, resulting in batteries being stored in warehouses until a low-cost disposal option becomes available or storage costs outweigh disposal fees. Between October 2025 and April 2026, disposal fees were waived for 12 formalsector clients as part of the pilot. During this period, 5.95 tonnes of waste LIBs were collected. The largest single shipment comprised 4 tonnes of waste batteries from Roam Electric, demonstrating that removing disposal fees can encourage organisations to release long-stored battery inventories. The pilot also highlighted an emerging market challenge. Although large battery shipments could initially be secured without purchasing the batteries themselves, the growing informal market increasingly competes for these materials by offering direct financial incentives. As the market value of waste LIBs continues to rise, formal collectors may find it increasingly difficult to secure batteries through disposal-fee waivers alone. As part of the pilot, an attempt was made in April 2026 to purchase approximately 1 tonne of waste LIBs from a formal-sector organisation at KES 20/ kg, a price substantially below the estimated intrinsic copper value of the batteries. Although the offer was initially accepted, the batteries were subsequently sold into the informal market before collection could occur. This experience illustrates
7. Business as Usual Enhancement Pilot
51
the commercial challenge of acquiring waste LIBs below prevailing market prices. The pilot further demonstrated that internal inventory management practices can influence battery recovery rates. Many organisations do not routinely monitor or audit stored waste batteries, creating opportunities for batteries to leave formal storage channels without authorisation. Such losses prevent organisations from recovering value from waste batteries while also undermining compliance with Kenya's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) requirements. The findings suggest that effective inventory controls, combined with commercially competitive procurement strategies, will become increasingly important for retaining batteries within formal collection systems.
7.1 Lessons Learned The Business-as-Usual Enhancement Pilot demonstrated that waiving disposal fees can increase the quantity of waste lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) collected from existing formal-sector clients. However, the pilot also showed that this approach alone is unlikely to remain effective as waste LIBs acquire increasing economic value. In at least one transaction, a shipment of waste LIBs that had been earmarked for collection was sold into the informal market before collection could take place, demonstrating the growing competitive pressure exerted by informal buyers. The findings suggest that such competition is likely to intensify as repurposers, informal recyclers, and other market participants increasingly recognise and recover the value of materials contained within end-of-life batteries, particularly copper. Consequently, formal collection programmes are likely to require commercially competitive procurement strategies, alongside operational and compliance services, if they are to consistently secure waste LIBs before they enter the informal supply chain.
7. Business as Usual Enhancement Pilot
52
7.2 Recommendations Formal-sector battery collection programmes should work with participating organisations to develop standard operating procedures (SOPs) for the secure storage, tracking, and management of waste lithium-ion batteries (LIBs). Robust inventory management practices can help reduce unauthorised diversion of batteries into the informal market, enable organisations to recover value from end-of-life batteries, and support compliance with Kenya's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) framework. Improved inventory controls can also reduce collection and processing costs by ensuring that batteries remain available for formal collection.
Finally, improving the commercial viability of formal battery collection will require increasing the value recovered from endof-life batteries. The absence of domestic lithium-ion battery recycling capacity presents an opportunity to expand local value addition through mechanical pre-processing, including the safe recovery of copper, aluminium, iron, plastic, and black mass for sale to downstream recycling companies. Increasing revenue from recovered materials would improve the financial sustainability of formal collection programmes and strengthen their ability to compete for waste LIBs in an increasingly competitive market.
The findings further suggest that formal collection programmes should offer commercially competitive procurement prices that reflect prevailing market conditions. Aligning purchase prices more closely with those offered by informal buyers would reduce opportunities for price arbitrage and increase the likelihood that waste LIBs remain within formal collection channels. Interviews conducted during the Informal Supply Chain Mapping indicate that exporters are paying approximately KES 75/ kg for waste LIBs. While competitive battery purchase prices are likely to be necessary, they may be complemented by charging formal organisations for regulatory compliance and environmentally sound disposal services, including the provision of disposal certificates where appropriate.
7. Business as Usual Enhancement Pilot
53
8.
Future Challenges
8. Future Challenges Kenya's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) framework is expected to increase the financial resources available for the collection and environmentally sound disposal of waste lithium-ion batteries (LIBs). As the market for battery collection expands, the relatively low barriers to entry are likely to attract new participants into the e-waste collection sector. Increased competition may place downward pressure on collection margins, particularly if some market participants do not fully comply with NEMA requirements for the safe handling, transportation, and storage of hazardous waste. At the same time, the study identified a significant gap in Kenya's battery value chain: there is currently no
8. Future Challenges
domestic lithium-ion battery disposal solution that fully complies with NEMA's hazardous waste management requirements. This presents an opportunity to develop local battery preprocessing capacity as an intermediate step before recycling. Mechanical pre-processing enables the safe separation of waste LIBs into copper, aluminium, steel, plastic, and black mass, creating materials that can be supplied to downstream recycling companies. The findings further suggest that expanding into battery preprocessing could provide greater commercial resilience than focusing solely on battery collection. While collection activities may become increasingly competitive as new market entrants emerge, battery pre-processing requires specialised technical expertise and investment, creating higher barriers to entry. A mature collection market could therefore complement domestic pre-processing by increasing the availability of feedstock while simultaneously reducing battery procurement costs for processing facilities.
55
9.
Conclusion
9. Conclusion The transportation and processing cost analysis demonstrated that logistics efficiency is fundamental to collection economics. Collection strategies based on larger shipment sizes and higher vehicle utilisation can substantially reduce operating costs and improve commercial viability. Similarly, the Battery Purchasing Programme demonstrated that disciplined procurement practices, supported by market intelligence, are essential for securing sufficient battery volumes at sustainable prices. The Comparative Study and Pilot Testing of Business Models for Battery Collection in Kenya achieved its primary objective of identifying practical, scalable pathways for increasing the collection of end-of-life lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) in Kenya. While several of the original pilot concepts generated lower levels of engagement than anticipated, the project successfully adapted to market realities and produced valuable insights into how waste batteries currently move through Kenya's economy. The study's most significant finding is that a functioning informal waste LIB market already exists. Waste batteries are widely recognised as valuable materials, and collection behaviour is driven primarily by economic incentives rather than environmental awareness alone. These findings indicate that successful collection strategies should work with the existing informal ecosystem rather than attempt to replace it. The study further identified super aggregators as the most effective point of engagement within the informal supply chain. Compared with collectors and aggregators, they offer larger shipment volumes, lower transportation and processing costs, and a more manageable supplier base. At the same time, the study highlights the importance of robust sorting, testing, and acceptance procedures to prevent contamination from lead-acid and NiCad batteries within the lithium-ion battery collection stream.
9. Conclusion
The formal-sector assessment identified a second major opportunity. Kenya's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) framework is increasing pressure on importers and manufacturers to establish battery takeback and disposal solutions. However, many organisations currently lack the systems, incentives, and disposal pathways needed to comply effectively. This creates opportunities for integrated service providers to offer collection services alongside takeback programme support, compliance assistance, and environmentally sound end-of-life battery management. The study also highlighted the growing environmental and public health risks associated with informal waste LIB processing. As the value of copper within waste batteries becomes more widely recognised, informal battery dismantling is likely to increase unless formal collection and recycling pathways are established. These practices expose workers to hazardous substances, including flammable volatile organic compounds (VOCs)
57
and hydrofluoric acid (HF), while recovering only a small proportion of the batteries' material value. Developing a formal battery collection and pre-processing industry would improve resource recovery while reducing the environmental and occupational health risks associated with informal dismantling activities. The findings reinforce the longterm importance of battery recycling infrastructure in Kenya. Although battery repurposing extends battery life and delays disposal, it does not eliminate the need for recycling. As battery volumes continue to increase and the proportion of lowervalue lithium iron phosphate (LFP) batteries grows, dedicated pre-processing and recycling capacity will be required to safely recover valuable materials from end-of-life batteries. The absence of this infrastructure remains one of the most significant gaps in Kenya's battery value chain. Looking ahead, one of the greatest opportunities identified by the study is the development of domestic battery pre-processing capacity. Producing black mass and recovered material streams for downstream recycling companies would enable greater value recovery, establish a compliant disposal pathway for waste LIBs, and create higher barriers to entry than battery collection alone. The continued growth of Kenya's battery market, together with the implementation of EPR regulations, provides a strong foundation for this transition. The study therefore concludes that a commercially viable battery collection and recycling ecosystem can be developed in Kenya, provided that collection strategies align with existing market incentives, procurement practices remain disciplined, and investment is made in the processing infrastructure needed to responsibly manage the growing volume of end-of-life lithium-ion batteries entering the market.
9. Conclusion
58
Siemens Stiftung Kaiserstrasse 16 80801 Munich Germany siemens-stiftung.org
59