Ironwood | Magazine of Santa Barbara Botanic Garden | Issue 33

MAGAZINE OF SANTA BARBARA BOTANIC GARDEN

I SS U E

Ironwood

33

Ironwood

Volume 33 | Spring/Summer | 2023 Editor-in-Chief: Jaime Eschette Editor: Brie Spicer Designer: Kathleen Kennedy Staff Contributors: Hannah Barton; Michelle Cyr; Jaime Eschette; Kylie Etter; Joan Evans; José Flores; Denise Knapp, Ph.D.; Keith Nevison; Scot Pipkin; Zach Phillips, Ph.D.; Rikke Reese Næsborg, Ph.D.; Jordan Sanderson; Dylan Schuyler; Christina Varnava; Laiken Warner; Steve Windhager, Ph.D. Guest Contributors: Melinda Palacio, David Starkey Ironwood is published biannually by Santa Barbara Botanic Garden.

As the first botanic garden in the nation to focus exclusively on native plants, Santa Barbara Botanic Garden has dedicated nearly a century of work to better understand the relationship between plants and people. Growing from 13 acres in 1926 to today’s 78 acres, the grounds now include more than 5 miles of walking trails, an herbarium, a seed bank, research labs, a library, and a public native plant nursery. Amid the serene beauty of the Garden, teams of scientists, educators, and horticulturists remain committed to the original spirit of the organization’s founders — to conserve native plants and habitats to ensure they continue to support life on the planet and can be enjoyed for generations to come. Visit SBBotanicGarden.org.

The Garden is a member of the American Public Gardens Association, the American Alliance of Museums, the California Association of Museums, and the American Horticultural Society. ©2023 Santa Barbara Botanic Garden. All Rights Reserved.

Santa Barbara Botanic Garden 1212 Mission Canyon Road Santa Barbara, CA 93105

1 Director’s Message 3 Using Pollinator Networks To Recover Whole Ecosystems 8 A Closer Look at Island Mallow (Malva assurgentiflora) 13 The Unseen Ecology of Dirt: The Story of Mycorrhizae 18 The Ecology Process: The Unusual Techniques Scientists Use To Study Ecosystems 22 The Bug Report: A Plant Is Worth a Thousand Bugs 39 Why Our Living Collection Matters

Garden Hours Daily: 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.

Members’ Hour: 9-10 a.m.

42 The Garden’s Impact

Phone: 805.682.4726 Development: ext. 103 Education and Engagement: ext. 161 Membership: ext. 110 Nursery: ext. 112 Registrar: ext. 102 Volunteers: ext. 119 Board of Trustees Jeremy Bassan Sarah Berkus Gower Sharon Bradford Frank W. Davis, Ph.D. Mark Funk, Board Chair John Gabbert George Leis, Vice Chair

Contents

Bibi Moezzi, Treasurer William Murdoch, Ph.D. Helene Schneider Warren Schultheis Kathy Scroggs, Secretary Ann Steinmetz Nancy G. Weiss

Leadership Team Denise Knapp, Ph.D., Director of Conservation and Research Jaime Eschette, Director of Marketing and Communications Jill Freeland, Director of Human Resources Keith Nevison, Director of Horticulture and Operations Melissa G. Patrino, Director of Development Scot Pipkin, Director of Education and Engagement Steve Windhager, Ph.D., Executive Director

44 From the Archives: The Art of Research 46 Volunteer Story: From Behind the Lens 49 Field Notes: Poetry Inspired by Nature 50 The Book Nook 51 Budding Botanist: At-home Ecology

Join Our Garden Community Online Sign up for our monthly Garden Gazette e-newsletter at SBBotanicGarden.org and follow us on social media for the latest announcements and news. @SBBotanicGarden Santa Barbara Botanic Garden Santa Barbara Botanic Garden

On the cover: Little bear beetle (Paracotalpa ursina) on California buckwheat (Eriogonum fasciculatum) in Carrizo Plain National Monument (Photo: Kylie Etter)

Director’s Message

W

ith each new issue of Ironwood, I have had the pleasure of opening this dialogue with you, our growing community of native plant advocates and friends. Historically, I’ve used this space to look back and celebrate the progress we’ve made together toward our mission of conserving native plants and habitats. Santa Barbara Botanic Garden membership recently passed 6,000 households, which is an all-time high, and our attendance continues to top out at our county-imposed 110,000 annual guest capacity limit. We have seen significant growth in our staff, which has come with continued improvements to the Garden itself, including the introduction of the Backcountry a year ago this month! Alone, all of these achievements are incredible, but together they are setting the stage for the Garden’s future. Thank you so much for your support on this journey.

Without you, we never could have accomplished so much — and we certainly wouldn’t be ready to set into motion one of the biggest initiatives in the Garden’s history!

If we’re to continue to make progress in achieving our mission, we must refine our focus and look at new ways to extend our impact beyond the boundaries of the Garden’s 78 acres (31 hectares).

And I’m excited to say that our road map is ready and we’re already underway.

Recent research tells us that with enough of the right plants in our landscapes, our urban, suburban, and rural zones can provide critical habitat to ensure that the widest number of species are able to survive, despite stressors of a highly variable climate and continued development pressure. Based on this research, the Garden has set a goal — and is developing strategic programs — to achieve 30% coverage of native plants in residential, commercial, and public landscapes across the central coast, which will support local ecosystems and healthy biodiversity.

To maximize our impact, we’ll be launching a multilayered Plant With Purpose initiative, which will enable us to broaden our outreach by offering programs that bring the Garden’s expertise directly to you in several different ways.

1. Training landscape professionals and the general public in the selection and care of native plants 2. Working with volunteer groups and regional parks departments to establish native plant habitats in city and county parks throughout Santa Barbara County 3. Improving the Garden’s online resources and outreach efforts 4. Expanding our efforts to promote native plant use through local and regional policy initiatives Together, the components of our Plant With Purpose initiative will help us overcome many of the barriers to native plant adoption and lead to greater utilization of native plants in all types of landscapes in our region. Ultimately it will create a community where the health and well-being of people and the planet thrive.

In this issue of Ironwood, we’re exploring the idea of plants with a purpose by looking closer at ecology and some of the nuanced connections that support the web of life, from our research on pollinator networks, a spotlight on the island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora), and the unseen ecology in the “dirt” to some of the processes we use to study all of this and why our Living Collection matters. We hope this issue inspires you to join us as we work together to Plant With Purpose — ultimately, healing and protecting the planet so we can leave it better than we found it for future generations.

Are you ready to grow?

Steve Windhager, Ph.D. Executive Director Ironwood 1

2 Ironwood

Using Pollinator Networks To Recover Whole Ecosystems By: Denise Knapp, Ph.D., Director of Conservation and Research

A

bout 87% of the world’s flowering plants need insects and other animals to pollinate them in order to reproduce. That is why the growing evidence for pollinator decline in many places of the globe, including California and the rest of the American West, is of real concern. Now, what if the plant needing pollination is rare? Could be double trouble. At Santa Barbara Botanic Garden, one of the many ways that we work to conserve and recover our region’s rare plants is by investigating and understanding their pollinator networks. Networks are also a useful tool to assess environmental health.

It’s “the interactions between organisms that breathe life into ecosystems,” explains one of my favorite scientific papers, “Conservation and restoration of plant-animal mutualisms on oceanic islands” by Christopher N. Kaiser-Bunbury, et al.

(Malva assurgentiflora ssp. glabra), and the little lilac-colored island rockcress (Sibara filifolia).

This work took us to different habitat types and populations scattered around the island, including within the actively bombed Shore Bombardment Area, otherwise known as SHOBA. (We of course had to wait for a day when they weren’t bombing.)

Over six visits in spring 2019 and at each of seven sites, Dr. Hazlehurst and Stephanie Calloway, our conservation technician, (with help from me and Casey Richart, Ph.D., the Garden’s first invertebrate ecologist) surveyed 10 plots, each 6.5-by-13 feet (2-by-4 meters) containing these rare plants for 30 minutes each.

Pollinator networks reveal not only the animals visiting our rare flowery friends but also the animals using the rare plants’ neighboring plants. This helps us to understand the connections between all of these different organisms. For the rare plant, it reveals 1) whether it has enough different kinds of visitors to be resilient to change, 2) what the priority pollinators are that can be supported to boost its pollination services, and 3) which more common plants attract those priority pollinators. Networks also point to pollinator species that visit a lot of different plants in the area and thus may be important for supporting pollination services in general. In fact, these generalist species have been called the linchpins of networks, since they help keep the system robust to environmental changes — that’s especially important these days.

1a: Southern island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora ssp. glabra) (Photo: Stephanie Calloway)

The Garden’s Invertebrate Ecology Team or “bug team” as they are affectionately called internally, together with collaborator Jenny Hazlehurst, Ph.D., from California State University, East Bay, recently investigated the pollinator networks of five different rare plants on San Clemente Island, located west of San Diego and owned by the U.S. Navy. Those rare plants are the angelic white San Clemente Island larkspur (Delphinium variegatum ssp. kinkiense), the delicate San Clemente Island woodland star (Lithophragma maximum), the creamy San Clemente Island bush mallow (Malacothamnus clementinus), the marvelously magenta southern island mallow

The plant that was the big winner for flower visitors was the southern island mallow (figure 1a), which attracted 18 different unique species — from bees and wasps to flies and beetles (figure 1b). This is great news for a plant that is only found in a few locations on Earth. Two bees that visited this mallow more than most (as noted by the thicker segments connecting the pollinator to the plant in figure 1b) were the bindweed turret bee (Diadasia bituberculata) and the metallic green sweat bee (Agapostemon texanus). You can see how well the turret bee fits into the flower (figure 2), undoubtedly getting covered in pollen to ferry to the next plant. Both bee species also

Opposite: A cactus chimney bee (Diadasia australis complex) gathers pollen from a coast cholla (Cylindropuntia prolifera) (Photo: Casey Richart, Ph.D.)

Ironwood 3

On the other end of the spectrum was the sweet little island rockcress (figure 4), which did not receive any flower visitors, despite hours of searching. Luckily, the rockcress can self-pollinate — although any plant benefits from mixing genes from time to time (inbreeding isn’t good for plants any more than it is for humans). Since our survey, another group who maps and monitors rockcress populations regularly on San Clemente Island observed three small insects visiting it: large-tailed aphideaters (Eupeodes volucris), which is a type of flower fly, soft-winged flower beetles (Family Melyridae), and a type of predatory thrips (tiny, slender insects with fringed wings) in the Genus Aelothrips. The hairy little flower beetles appear to be a good fit for the rockcress, and typically this family is fairly abundant; hopefully they are doing the job for the endangered island rockcress.

1b: Chart showing which pollinators visited which plants during spring 2019 research on San Clemente Island

2: A bindweed turret bee (Diadasia bituberculata) visits a southern island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora ssp. glabra).

(Photo: Casey Richart, Ph.D.)

3: The bindweed turret bee (Diadasia bituberculata) visits island false bindweed (Calystegia macrostegia).

(Photo: Casey Richart, Ph.D.)

visit the much more common island false bindweed (Calystegia macrostegia) (figure 3). Since this is an easy plant to grow, the Navy planted more of it to support the bindweed turret bee on San Clemente Island.

4 Ironwood

We were really hoping to find Greya politella moths on the San Clemente Island woodland star, since we know that they have evolved together and have a specialized relationship. This relationship benefits both the moths, which will only lay eggs in woodland star flowers, and the flowers, which get pollinated (and only lose a few seeds in the process). We weren’t allowed to go at night into the bombed canyons full of cactus (go figure), but that is when many moths are active — so we purchased the most advanced remotely triggered camera system we could find.

Despite steep slopes and technical difficulties, Calloway got images of two different woodland star visitors: the southern-Channel-Islands-endemic urbane digger bee (Anthophora urbana clementina) and the widespread generalist alfalfa looper (Autographa californica) moth, which you can see in figure 5. Alas, there were no Greya moths, which have never been recorded on the island.

That alfalfa looper moth also came into play with another of our rare plants, the San Clemente Island larkspur. In this case, not only did the adult moth visit the rare flower to drink nectar but its larval stage (known as a caterpillar for moths and butterflies) also visited the larkspur to eat the plant itself (figure 6a, 6b). Dr. Richart raised a caterpillar to adulthood in our lab to confirm its identity. Is the alfalfa looper having a net positive or negative effect? We’d need to study more to find out. Photos seem to indicate, though, that the moth is able to drink nectar with its long proboscis (mouthparts) without getting any pollen on it. Chances are, it’s not one of the larkspur’s better helpers.

The endemic urbane digger bee, which has such a lovely and unusual rusty color (figure 7), may be

4: Island rockcress (Sibara filifolia) (Photo: Denise Knapp, Ph.D.)

important as a pollinator of several rare island plants.

Not only was it documented visiting the woodland star but also the larkspur, bush mallow, and southern island mallow. This would be a good pollinator for the Navy to keep an eye on, both for its endemism and its likely importance as a pollinator. They should not only make sure that it has enough nectar sources but also that it has enough bare soil to nest in. The digger bee, like about 70% of our other native bees, is a ground nester.

Bees range from generalists that will use many types of plants, like our urbane digger bee and the European honeybee (Apis mellifera), to specialists that will only use a small group of plants, like mallows, cacti (Family Cactaceae), or sunflowers (Genus Helianthus). But it’s been shown that on islands, generalists are typical. It makes sense, since it’s hard enough to disperse to a remote island, let alone find your favorite plant. In one way, this is good news for the islands’ resilience to ecological change. But in another, the loss of a few super-generalists could spell doom for the plants that

5: An alfalfa looper (Autographa californica) moth visits the San Clemente Island woodland star (Lithophragma maxima).

(Photo: Stephanie Calloway)

Ironwood 5

6a: The alfalfa looper (Autographa californica) larva munches the San Clemente Island larkspur (Delphinium variegatum ssp. kinkiense). (Photo: Casey Richart, Ph.D.)

6b: The alfalfa looper (Autographa californica) adult moth sips nectar from the San Clemente Island larkspur (Delphinium variegatum ssp. kinkiense). (Photo: Casey Richart, Ph.D.)

depend on them. This is a good reason to keep an eye on the urbane digger bee.

Another important generalist flower visitor on the island may surprise you: it’s a fly. Or rather, several kinds of flies, known as flower flies in the Family Syrphidae. One species, Copestylum avidum, was found at every site, while another, Copestylum marginatum, was found at all but one site. Flower flies visit four out of five of our rare plants: the larkspur, bush mallow (figure 8), island rockcress, and southern island mallow. Furthermore, two different kinds of flies called bee flies (Genus Bombylius) visited both the larkspur and the bush mallow. Flies (Order Diptera) are the second most important order among flower-visiting insects worldwide. In some circumstances, they may equal or rival bees as effective pollinators. Furthermore, they can be much more abundant, and many visits may add up to the same amount of service. More research is needed to determine whether the flower flies and bee flies on the island are good pollinators compared to the local bees, but it seems that this is another important group for conservation.

6 Ironwood

7: The urbane digger bee (Anthophora urbana ssp. clementina) visits a liveforever (Dudleya ssp). (Photo: Casey Richart, Ph.D.)

Of course, not all floral visitors are effective pollinators, and even among pollinators, different degrees of pollination services are provided. Photographs can be a great way to get a first sense of how well an insect can do the job, as we’ve shown here. We take as many photographs of these interactions as we can, which helps to generate hypotheses about which visitors are the most important pollinators. These hypotheses help us to design and pursue further studies where we investigate the amounts, and types, of pollen an insect carries to determine how effective they are as pollinators. In 2024, we’ll be following up with both the San Clemente Island woodland star and the island rockcress to survey and collect flower visitors. We’ll also then investigate pollen loads using a combination of microscopy and DNA barcoding. There is always more to explore and understand and so, the conservation journey continues. O

8: A flower fly (Family Syrphidae, Genus Copestylum) visits the federally endangered and endemic San Clemente Island bush mallow (Malacothamnus clementinus).

(Photo: Cedric Lee)

Santa Barbara Botanic Garden

The Garden Nursery Located in our courtyard, Santa Barbara Botanic Garden Nursery is open to our members and the public seven days a week, featuring the largest selection of California's native plants on the central coast. With hundreds of varieties available, there is something for everyone.

Garden members receive 10% off every purchase!

Nursery Hours DAILY

10 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.

Scan to shop.

MEMBERS’ HOUR

9 - 10 a.m.

Ironwood 7

A Closer Look at Island Mallow (Malva assurgentiflora) By: Keith Nevison, Director of Horticulture and Operations

F

lanking the Pritzlaff Conservation Center on Santa Barbara Botanic Garden’s eastside are strikingly beautiful, tropical-ish plants with a unique connection to our Conservation Team going back decades. Although semi-common in the nursery trade today, island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora), aka malva rosa, royal mallow, or mission mallow, is endemically native only to several California Channel Islands, including the northern islands of San Miguel and Anacapa, and the southern islands of Catalina and San Clemente. Island mallow plants form into two distinct subspecies: assurgentiflora and glabra, with the northern island populations grouped in the former and the southern island plants representing the latter. The subspecies assurgentiflora is a taller, tree-like plant that can reach 12 feet (over 3 meters) tall with maturity, while the southern subspecies glabra is shorter in stature with larger, glossier, and smoother (glabrous) leaves.

Island mallow is currently listed as seriously threatened in California (1B.1) on the California Rare Plant Rank scale due to once widespread grazing by feral and domesticated livestock, which were deliberately introduced to the islands more than a century ago. Thankfully, many of these animals were removed from the islands over the past decade, giving plants the chance to recover and for researchers to step up their restoration efforts to recover the species. In 1992, Steve Junak, then the Garden’s Clifton Smith Herbarium curator, and Sarah Chaney, an experienced Channel Islands National Park ecologist, collected seeds of island mallow from

middle Anacapa Island from the last remaining island mallow plants there. Those plants subsequently declined, and Anacapa’s natural populations of island mallow were declared as extirpated or extinct.

Restoration work since that time, however, has reestablished appropriate ecotypes of island mallow back on east Anacapa Island, and this work would not have been possible without the collaborative efforts of the National Park Service and the Garden’s joint collection, propagation, and dissemination efforts.

Historically, collections of island mallow that trace genetically from Anacapa Island were planted through many parts of coastal California, from the Bay Area down to Baja California, Mexico, as a garden ornamental and a windbreaking hedge. We find that it performs excellently in our conservation beds surrounding our Island View Section, where it blooms profusely, through many months of the year. Island mallow is a fast-growing plant, best adapted for full sun and low water, and it is listed as a probable host plant for 15 different species of butterflies, moths, and skippers, according to the California Native Plant Society’s Calscape database. Oddly enough, given its rarity and the narrowness of its native home range, island mallow is documented as an escapee in other coastal parts of the world, including Guatemala, western South America, and Oceania. Fun fact: Island mallow is listed as the only Malva that is native to the United States, while seven other nonnative species are listed as being naturalized in Santa Barbara County.

From left: Flower of Coronado Island tree mallow (Malva occidentalis) taken on Guadalupe Island (Photo: Matt Guilliams, Ph.D.); northern island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora ssp. assurgentiflora) growing at Santa Barbara Botanic Garden (Photo: Matt Guilliams, Ph.D.); flower of Purisima island mallow (Malva ‘Purisima’), which is a hybrid between northern island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora ssp. Assurgentiflora) and San Benito Island mallow (M. Pacifica) (Photo: Matt Guilliams, Ph.D.) Opposite: Flower of northern island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora ssp. assurgentiflora) from the Point Bennett area of San Miguel Island, where a small population of a few hundred, naturally occurring plants is slowly recovering from historical land uses during the ranching era (Photo: Matt Guilliams, Ph.D.)

8 Ironwood

Ironwood 9

A few garden cultivars exist for island mallow, including some borne from hybrid crosses with Malva pacifica, a species native to the islands off Baja California, and from M. occidentalis, a species exclusively endemic to the Coronado Islands off the coast of the U.S./Mexico border, and to Guadalupe Island, an island located over 160 miles (257 kilometers) approximately west of the provincial boundary between Baja California and Baja California Sur. Some selected cultivars like ‘Blackheart’ and ‘Pastel Stripes’ are said to even have their origin at the Garden and are understood to be plant crosses emanating from a cutting of M. occidentalis that was gifted by the Garden to plantsman Ed Mercurio, which he subsequently planted, allowing for crosspollination by bees, resulting in deep, rich, and interesting flower colors.

Island mallow makes a wonderful, quick-growing, wind-breaking evergreen hedge, very well-suited for coastal gardens. We are happy to share several handsome specimens in our collection and encourage you to come to the Garden, where you can find it located in the Island View Section, as well as for purchase in our Garden Nursery. O Gardener tip: If you are interested in growing island mallow in your garden, please note that mallows are very popular with deer and other ungulates, as well as rodents. Having adequate fencing protection is therefore advised.

Currin, K., Merritt, A., & Spriggs, P. (2023). The California Lavateras and Their Hybrids.

Pacific Horticulture. https://pacifichorticulture.org/articles/the-california-lavateras/ Hinsley, R. S. (2023). The Lavatera Pages: Californian Lavateras. Malvaceae Info. http://www.malvaceae.info/Genera/Lavatera/californian.html#assurgentiflora

northern island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora ssp. assurgentiflora) southern island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora ssp. glabra) This map shows how ssp. assurgentiflora occurs on the four northern islands and San Nicolas Islands, while ssp. glabra only occurs on Santa Catalina Island and San Clemente Island. Each green dot represents locations of northern island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora ssp. assurgentiflora) and each yellow dot represents southern island mallow (Malva assurgentiflora ssp. glabra), recorded by either Santa Barbara Botanic Garden staff or specimen data from the Consortium of California Herbaria Portal 2 (CCH2). CCH2 is where digitized herbarium data from 48 institutions is stored, including data from the Garden.

10 Ironwood

Grow With Us

Welcome, Seniors We invite those 60 and better to enjoy a day in the Garden — for free — thanks to our generous sponsor.

Join us on one of our upcoming dates.

Reservation are required.

August 16 | October 18 | December 13 Sponsored By

Ironwood 11

12 Ironwood

The Unseen Ecology of Dirt: The Story of Mycorrhizae By: Scot Pipkin, Director of Education and Engagement

“There’s a world going on underground.” —Tom Waits

Establishing the Roots

I

Standing under the shade of an oak tree in California, say, a coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia), blue oak (Quercus douglasii), valley oak (Quercus lobata), or canyon live oak (Quercus chrysolepis), one might feel the urge to dig down — beneath the layer of decaying leaves, twigs, and bark and into the earth. Across the threshold of duff and piercing the truly subterranean world, it might not take too long to encounter mighty roots mirroring a mighty canopy. Careful inspection of these woody threads would reveal that, like the metaphorical strands in the web of life, these structures are more than what they seem. In fact, these roots will begin to look a lot like the strands of the web of life previously described: intertwined lengths of living tissue exchanging energy and building resiliency. It’s one of the great and ancient symbiotic relationships in nature. It is an amazing partnership between plant and fungus.

f you spend time at Santa Barbara Botanic Garden, you will hear many people talk about the “web of life.”

It’s an elegant and instructive metaphor illustrating the strong but sometimes invisible connections between organisms. Disturb one strand and others will be affected. Lose many strands and the structure ceases to function.

As I write this article, the Garden is celebrating Bird Month, as a perfect example of the web of life. Not only do birds rely on plants for nesting, roosting, and direct food sources (fruits and seeds), they also rely heavily on the insects that are associated with plants.

If we take the example of the Order Lepidopteran (butterflies and moths), we find that they represent up to 70% of a songbird’s diet (Piel, Tallamy, Narango, 2021). Most butterflies and moths rely on a limited set of larval host plants to survive. We can just look at the example of monarch butterflies (Danaus plexippus) and milkweed (Asclepias spp.) to get a sense of how the relationships function in the web of life. If we zoom more closely into this metaphorical web, we might notice something fascinating about the strands themselves. Like yarn or rope, these strands, which look like single, solid entities at our scale, actually consist of smaller fibers woven together, intertwined to create strength.

On any scale, the web of life metaphor reminds me to be aware of my connection to others, including those of the non-human (i.e., plant, animal, mineral) world.

I have a friend who works as a hydrologist. They are quick to clarify that their interest and specialty are surface water, not groundwater hydrology. “Once it goes underground,” they say, “I pretend it doesn’t exist anymore. What happens down there is too complicated.” In many ways, I have felt a similar sense about ecology. The things that happen above ground, on terra firma, are within my realm of comprehension.

Once we start asking questions about what’s happening beneath our feet, all bets are off. Don’t even get me started on marine or aquatic ecology. As I’ve gotten older and my curiosity more refined, the dark, often dusty (around here, anyway) world of soil ecology has remained mysterious; however, it has become less intimidating. Any sense of fear I’ve had has been replaced with allure.

Opposite: The author holding fruiting bodies of chanterelle fungus (Cantharellus sp.), an edible mycorrhizal fungus that associates with oaks (Quercus spp.) throughout California (Photo: Jessie Altstatt)

Oaks (Quercus spp.) are not the only plants that benefit from this relationship with fungus. In fact, it is estimated that up to 90% of plants globally are involved in these relationships, where fungus in Class Mycorrhizae (etymologically speaking, “myco” refers to fungus and “rhizome” refers to root) works with plant roots. The ubiquitousness of mycorrhizal relationships with plants hints at their significance.

In fact, research demonstrates that the presence of fungus in a plant’s roots greatly increases the plant’s ability to uptake water; absorb essential nutrients such as carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus (Simard, 2018); fight off pathogens (Duchesne, 1994; Linderman, 1994); and even reduce a plant’s susceptibility to herbivory (Koziol et al., 2018).

A closer study of mycorrhizal symbiosis is revealing fascinating insights into soil ecology. Researcher Suzanne Simard has spent decades studying such relationships in the temperate rainforests of western Canada, and what she has learned is awesome in the most literal sense. Based on Simard’s experiments, it is becoming clear that the mycorrhizal relationship with plants isn’t as simplistic as sharing resources.

Mycorrhizal networks enable nutrient sharing between trees of multiple species and even facilitate communication within the forest. It appears that through the mycorrhizal network, trees can democratically allocate resources to each other and promote the growth of seedlings. Within the network, Ironwood 13

hubs of activity center around particular trees, often within a certain age class. These “Mother Trees” help dictate the distribution of resources within the network (Simard, 2018). Through these partnerships between Mother Trees and fungus, there is an ability to recognize both kin and individual neighbors (ibid).

The health of the forest as we experience it is mediated in large part by what is happening below ground. A special shoutout goes to old growth habitats. Those are the realms of Mother Trees.

Such community-level implications aren’t limited to the ancient cedar and hemlock forests (Family Pinaceae) of the Pacific Northwest where Simard conducts her research. Here in California, researchers observed the transfer of nitrogen from gray pine (Pinus sabiniana) to nearby blue oaks (Southworth, 2013), suggesting that similar dynamics may be at play in the oak woodlands of California as they are in the forests of Canada. In fact, these mycorrhizal networks benefit a number of species in the plant community, including buckbrush (Ceanothus cuneatus), and other annual plants (He et al., 2006).

Additional studies in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada reveal that dozens of mycorrhizal fungi can be associated with blue oaks and those communities can differ in significant ways from nearby interior live oak (Quercus wislizeni) associations (Morris et al., 2008). This study was only examining the diversity of ectomycorrhizae, or mycorrhizae whose hyphae (fungal equivalent to roots) do not penetrate the cell walls of the host roots. This class of mycorrhizae is particularly noteworthy because it includes chanterelles (Cantharellus spp.); agarics (Amanita spp.), including Amanita muscaria, one of the infamous “magic mushrooms”; and other common mushrooms of forests and woodlands. Mycorrhizae, therefore, are responsible for the health of our plant communities and a significant food source for humans the world over.

Biodiversity Loss and Recovery Given the importance of mycorrhizae to plant communities, it stands to reason that we should be prioritizing the conservation of soil integrity in addition to saving the plants we care about. Conversely, we can also know that by saving native plants, even individuals in some cases, we are protecting the networks that support a healthy landscape on a broader scale.

There is evidence that suggests soil disturbance ranging from tilling to grazing to development can significantly impact mycorrhizal fungi. In one study in coastal sage scrub communities in California, it appears that conversion to nonnative grasses has tilted the soil microbial balance to favor mycorrhizae that provide more benefit to the introduced plants.

14 Ironwood

This represents a possible competitive advantage for the invasive plants as they might be able to utilize their mycorrhizal advantage to outcompete native species (Brooks, et al., 2022).

The interconnected web of life is only one aspect of why biodiversity is so critical to ecological function on our planet. Living systems influence abiotic (nonliving) components of our world profoundly. In the steep terrain of Southern California, mycorrhizae work with plant roots to stem the pull of gravity and stabilize soils. Mycorrhizae help create soil aggregates through biochemical and biological processes (Rillig and Mummey, 2006). When living strands are broken through disturbance, soil is more easily eroded, leading to slumping, incised channels, and sometimes catastrophic slope failures. More than wildfire and flooding, human activities are a primary source of soil disturbance on our planet. The scale at which we convert native habitats for mining, forestry, agriculture, development, and transit is unparalleled.

As a result, mycorrhizal communities are being negatively impacted by human activities across the globe (Xavier and Germida, 1999).

Your Home Garden Can Help By now, it should be evident that mycorrhizal fungi are essential for supporting healthy habitats. In the face of massive disturbance and destructive practices, it might feel intimidating to think about what we as individuals can do to promote soil biodiversity and plant health. Fortunately, we have the potential to make real impacts in our local communities.

For those who have access to land, whether it be a yard or community site, what could be more beautiful than facilitating healthy soil interactions that could beget even more biodiversity? If you are a homeowner or caretaker of a property with land, consider this: for supporting mycorrhizal communities, any plant is better than bare soil or impervious concrete, a California-native plant is even better, and a locally adapted native plant is best. There is limited but potentially significant evidence that local genes might play a role in colonization by local mycorrhizal fungi (Van Geel, et al. 2021). Though rare, some local nurseries sell plants whose genetics they can confidently say come from nearby populations. But it all starts with native plants.

While it is possible to purchase mycorrhizal inoculants for installation in your own yard, it might not be as simple as acquiring a product and inoculating the earth. Fungi might be a little bit fickle, or at least adapted to more specific conditions. Some inoculants may be effective with some plants or soil conditions

Which habitat has more mycorrhizae? Is it the oak (Quercus spp.) woodlands in the foreground or the agricultural fields in the distance? (Photo: Scot Pipkin)

but not colonize as vigorously in others. Manzanitas (Arctostaphylos spp.), for instance, have relationships with an entire group of mycorrhizal fungi (known as ericoid mycorrhizae), and some plants — like manzanita — benefit most from multiple mycorrhizal associations at once. Mycorrhizal communities may also change over time as a landscape or habitat matures. Inoculation can work for some species and might not be a bad idea in a landscape that has seen significant recent disturbance, but it may not be a necessary step toward healthy soil. Spores have been spreading for a billion years and fungi have found a way to colonize the various corners of this planet.

There is hope that your small patch of soil could be the landing spot for a microscopic hitchhiker looking for a plant root to share energy with. Try to make that home welcoming.

In an age when climate change and threats to the web of life loom large over our environmental psyche, it’s easy to fall into a paralyzed sense of despair. This is a normal response. The problems are so big and we

as individuals have seemingly so little recourse, it’s easy to disassociate from the topic altogether. But I say, despair not! We have to fight for the things we love and what could be more beautiful than helping the next generation of Mother Trees get established?

Tips for Getting Started Before prepping any ground or buying a tree from a nursery, it’s important to reconnect with nature.

Fall back in love with the earth that sustains us and remind yourself that YOU are a strand in the web of life — reliant on other connections and capable of supporting a great load. Go outside and spark your curiosity. Walk around barefoot and connect with the earth. Carefully flip a decaying log and see what life lies just underneath the surface. Mycorrhizal fungi are an incredible, miraculous component of the world we inhabit, but theirs is just one story unfolding around us at all times. By cultivating your curiosity and establishing a connection to the natural world, you will be positioning yourself to be a better advocate for and steward of the web of life.

Ironwood 15

Once you have reconnected with the natural world, there are actionable steps you can take to improve soil health and local ecology. Using natural mulch and home composting are great ways to contribute to soil biology and help create a good environment for organisms like mycorrhizal fungi to colonize.

Bottomline, soils are home to an array of microbes, herbivores, hunters, decomposers, and other organisms that contribute to our local biodiversity.

Planting native plants helps ensure that mycorrhizal networks can get established and local ecology has the opportunity to recolonize our lives.

Even if you don’t have access to a patch of earth to tend, there are significant steps you can take to advocate for native biodiversity and our local webs of life. I am consistently inspired by a friend who is a dedicated advocate for nature in our communities.

They attend public meetings, provide public comment on development plans, serve on one of the local public tree advisory commissions, among other things. In turn, I’ve become activated to attend meetings, write comment letters, and use my voice to advocate for nature in our communities. What I’ve realized in the process is these are real policies with longstanding implications and precious few people are speaking up. Your voice can change the direction of local policy for decades and that should feel empowering. In fact, the Garden can be another “friend” encouraging you to get involved by signing petitions, writing letters,

and taking more action to support native plants and habitats.

So, go outside, commune with the earth, contribute to her well-being, plant native plants, and use your voice to let others know that we are all connected in this vast web. Like the spores of a chanterelle, your actions will multiply and intertwine with others to create something astonishing. O Duchesne, L. C. (1994). Role of ectomycorrhizal fungi in biocontrol. Mycorrhizae and plant health (pp. 27-46). The American Phytopathological Society.

Piel, G., Tallamy, D. W., & Narango, D. L. (2021). Lepidoptera Host Records Accurately Predict Tree Use by Foraging Birds. Northeastern Naturalist, 28(4), 527-540. https://doi.org/10.1656/045.028.0410 Linderman, R. G. (1994). Role of VAM fungi in biocontrol. Mycorrhizae and plant health (pp. 1-26). The American Phytopathological Society.

Morris, M. H., Smith, M. E., Rizzo, D. M., Rejmánek, M., & Bledsoe, C. S. (2008). Contrasting ectomycorrhizal fungal communities on the roots of co-occurring oaks (Quercus spp.) in a California woodland. The New Phytologist, 178(1), 167-176. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.

1469-8137.2007.02348.x Pickett, B., Irvine, I. C., Arogyaswamy, K., Maltz, M. R., Shulman, H., & Aronson, E. L. (2022).

Identifying and Remediating Soil Microbial Legacy Effects of Invasive Grasses for Restoring California Coastal Sage Scrub Ecosystems. Diversity, 14(12), 1095. https://doi.org/10.3390/d14121095 Rillig, M. C., & Mummey, D. L. (2006). Mycorrhizas and soil structure. The New Phytologist, 171(1), 41-53. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-8137.2006.01750.x Simard, S. W. (2018). Mycorrhizal Networks Facilitate Tree Communication, Learning, and Memory. In F. Baluska, M. Gagliano & G. Witzany (eds.), Memory and Learning in Plants (pp. 191-213). https://boomwachtersgroningen.nl/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/ Simard2018_Chapter_MycorrhizalNetworksFacilitateT-1.pdf Southworth, D. (2013). Oaks and mycorrhizal fungi. Oak: Ecology, types and management (pp. 207-218). https://tinyurl.com/bdfybv28 Van Geel, M., Aavik, T., Ceulemans, T., Träger, S., Mergeay, J., Peeters, G., van Acker, K., Zobel, M., Koorem, K., & Honnay, O. (2021). The role of genetic diversity and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungal diversity in population recovery of the semi-natural grassland plant species Succisa pratensis. BMC ecology and evolution, 21(1), 200. https://doi.org/10.1186/ s12862-021-01928-0

Next time you see a mushroom, ask yourself, “What role does it play in the ecosystem?” (Photo: Scot Pipkin)

16 Ironwood

SPONSORS

Thank You

to Our Beer Garden Sponsors

All Heart Rentals

Jump On The School Bus

Arroyo Seco Construction Landscape and Design

Katalyst Public Relations

Balance Financial

Mission Wealth

Bibi Moezzi

Pondel Law

Bite Me SB

Randy Solakian Estates Group

BRIGHT Event Rentals BrightView

Santa Barbara Adventure Company

Buddha Properties

Santa Barbara Life and Style

Dan Crawford, Realtor DiBenedetto Family

Santa Ynez Band of Chumash Indians

Edible Santa Barbara

Sarah & Hayden Gower

Flowers & Associates, INC.

Scale Microgrids

Forward Lateral

Schipper Construction

Helene Schneider

Sol Wave Water

Hutton Parker Foundation

The Spracher Family

Jeffrey & Rebecca Berkus

Urgent Veterinary Care of Santa Barbara

Knight Real Estate Group

VENDORS FEATURED SPONSOR

FEATURED VENDORS

Augie’s

Little Dom’s Seafood

brewLAB Convivo

Night Lizard Brewing Company

Draughtsman Aleworks

Oat Bakery

Eating with Jo

Sama Sama

Figueroa Mountain Brewing Co.

T.W. Hollister

Firestone Walker Brewing Company

Third Window Brewing

Island Brewing Company

Tyger Tyger

La Paloma Cafe

Validation Ale

Tarantula Hill Topa Topa Brewing Co.

SBBotanicGarden.org Ironwood 17

The Ecology Process: The Unusual Techniques Scientists Use To Study Ecosystems By: Denise Knapp, Ph.D., Director of Conservation and Research

Y

ou’ve likely seen it in cartoons or on TV, if not in person: the geeky scientist collecting insects with a butterfly net, frantically swiping through the air for their prize then marveling at the tiny creature they have then trapped inside a jar. You may have chuckled at those strange people — you wouldn’t be alone — who are so fascinated by bugs that they want to collect one of everything. Trust me, it gets so much stranger.

Insects, together with other arthropods like spiders and centipedes, are the most species-rich animal group on the planet. They also do a wide variety of jobs, from the more picturesque act of pollinating flowers to the less fun feat of breaking down waste. So, it makes

sense that they are found in all kinds of places, with all kinds of behaviors — and that it takes all kinds of strange techniques to collect them when you want to understand our biological diversity and how to rebuild food webs from the bottom (native plants) up, like we scientists at Santa Barbara Botanic Garden do.

It starts with meeting them where they are at. Are they mostly flying around or hunkered down on (or in) a plant? Are they buried deep in the soil or in the plant litter? Are they active during the day or are they more of a nighttime kind of creature? Come with me as I lead you on a tour of just a few of the odd ways that entomologists (or ecologists, like those of us at the Garden) collect these critters.

Above: Winkler extractors hang below a string of old-school Christmas lights on Santa Rosa Island. (Photo: Denise Knapp, Ph.D.) Opposite: Casey Richart, Ph.D., uses the beat sheeting method on San Clemente Island within a woodland of island ironwood (Lyonothamnus floribundus) and island oak (Quercus tomentella). (Photo: Denise Knapp, Ph.D.)

18 Ironwood

Ironwood 19

Shake Them Loose

Flying Insects Love Color and Light

For those insects that feed on plants, you have to go to them. About half of all insects are herbivores, and about 70% of those are specialists that can only feed on a narrow range of related plants. Our favorite technique for getting those that like the green stuff is what’s called a beat-sheeting method, together with an aspirator (also called a pooter). We are literally beating the bugs off the plants and then sucking them up into a vial! First you place a white sheet stretched onto a frame beneath the plant of interest, and then you gently but vigorously shake the plant until the bugs fall off onto the sheet. Quickly you spring into action with the aspirator, with one tube that goes from the bug to the vial and another tube that goes from the vial into your mouth. When you suck on the tube, it draws the bug into the vial. Luckily, a layer of muslin or mesh keeps us from ingesting the hapless insect.

For flying insects, we typically trick the bugs into coming to us and then trap them there. Many dayflying insects are attracted to the color yellow, so we put out a yellow bowl with soapy water and after a while, voilà — bowl ’o’ bugs. The soap in the water breaks the surface tension so these tiny nimble creatures can’t crawl out. It’s sad, I know, but not harmful. An insect’s fine features help us identify them — the small patches of hairs or bristles, vein patterns on the wings, or the number of antennal segments — and we can’t see those details if they are moving.

Black lights draw many night-flying insects. (Photo: Denise Knapp, Ph.D.)

20 Ironwood

After dark, black lights are great for night-flying insects like moths since most flying bugs are drawn to light. Black lights emit a type of UV light, which insects see but humans don’t. The UV lights also give off some heat, which helps to lure the insects. Then we diabolical scientists can pick off the bugs we most want with an aspirator.

The San Clemente Island invertebrate surveys team: Jenny Hazlehurst Ph.D., Casey Richart, Ph.D., and Stephanie Calloway (Photo: Denise Knapp, Ph.D.)

Creepy Crawlers Watch Out We use a similar method to capture insects that crawl around on the ground. This version is called a pitfall trap, because — as the name implies — the insects fall into a pit. We have to be careful to bury the trap so that it doesn’t stick up above the soil; for tiny bugs this would act like a fence.

Collecting bugs from soil and plant litter is tricky.

Sure, movement is a dead giveaway, but bugs are often quite tiny, which makes them difficult and time-consuming to separate from the small bits of soil and duff. Luckily, there is a smarter way! If you put soil and plant litter into a Winkler extractor device, with its internal mesh layers, and create heat using lights (see opposite photo), the bugs will separate themselves for you. They do this because they like to move downward and away from heat. Finally, jars of soapy water or ethanol at the bottom collect them for our research.

Preserving for Research Once you’ve collected the insects, you need to preserve them for long-term scientific examination.

For the bugs that we have collected dry and dispatched in the field, they must be pinned pronto, before they get brittle. But the bugs collected by way of soapy water still need to be preserved in ethanol so that they don’t decay. Once we bring these bonanzas

of bugs back to the lab, common household items help us finish the job. Bit by bit, we pour our bug stew into a plastic coffee filter and then use paintbrushes and forceps to transfer the bugs into vials of ethanol for later sorting, identification, and imaging.

For hairier insects like bees, the preservation is even more detailed than this. If you pin bees straight out of ethanol, they will end up looking permanently like wet dogs! Among other things, this makes the important identifying patterns on their bodies difficult to see.

So, the bees need the diva treatment, via tea strainer and blow-dryer. First, you put a small clump of bees in the tea strainer — which acts like a little washing machine — and put them through a few wash-rinse cycles. Then it’s time for a blowout, which fluffs them up in a flash!

I may be in the minority in finding bugs always fascinating, often beautiful, and, many times, quite cute, but I hope that we can all appreciate that if we didn’t have them to pollinate our food, break down our waste, feed the food web, and maintain order in the ecosystem, we’d be in a world of trouble. You can help support them, and the many animals that depend on them, by building habitats with native plants. The diversity of life that you support will make our world more functional — and, if you’re asking me, even more fascinating. O Ironwood 21

The Bug Report: A Plant Is Worth a Thousand Bugs By: The Invertebrate Ecology Conservation Team

A Survey of San Clemente Island’s Plant-associated Invertebrates

eyes of arachnids, and Denise Knapp, Ph.D., swarmed the flies.

I

In the gallery that follows, we each share some of our favorite bugs from the survey and describe one of the tools we used to identify, curate, or photograph

n 2019, Santa Barbara Botanic Garden conducted a survey of insects, spiders, and their invertebrate kin (collectively, “bugs”) on San Clemente Island.

Of California’s eight Channel Islands, San Clemente is one of the most remote and least accessible, possessing a rich flora of rare and endemic plants. We collected bugs associated with these plants using an oldie-but-goodie entomological method called beatsheeting. Here’s a more than thorough description of the method: You place a sheet underneath a plant, hit the plant with a stick, and collect the bugs that fall onto the sheet.

The island’s plants support bugs that feed, breed, and live on them, and the island’s bugs support plants through pollination and other services. To better understand these relationships, beat-sheeting was repeated at sites across San Clemente, and bugs were collected from a variety of plants in different habitats. The bug-plant co-occurrence data gleaned from this approach (i.e., what bugs were found on what plants) can ultimately help us better protect the Channel Islands’ distinct flora and fauna. For example, we collected specimens of a bark beetle new to science, Carphobius caterinoi, (Cognato & Smith) exclusively on island oaks (Quercus tomentella), suggesting the survival and reproduction of these beetles is dependent on the endemic oaks.

Divide and Curate We found a lot of bugs, looked closely at a lot of bugs, and photographed a lot of bugs, many recorded on San Clemente Island for the first time (Phillips et al., 2023). Such intensive bug work can transform anyone into a connoisseur of fine insects (e.g., bees and butterflies), or even an enthusiast of Two-Buck Chuck creepy-crawlies (e.g., ants and cockroaches).

Without exception, the Garden staff and volunteers who helped on the project became bug ambassadors, each developing an affinity for certain groups of invertebrates. Kylie Etter became a wasp whisperer, José Flores earned his bad beetle-boy badge, Jordan Sanderson took a long trip on the thrips train (last stop: more thrips), Laiken Warner and I gazed into the

22 Ironwood

Team using the beat-sheeting method in the field (Photo: Denise Knapp, Ph.D.)

Taxa Codependency

said bugs. The photos represent just a few of the approximately 55,000 individuals we collected, belonging to 695 morphospecies (morphospecies are hypothesized species based on morphological characteristics), 201 families, and 33 orders. You can view more photos on the survey’s iNaturalist page,

a publicly accessible digital collection of specimens (“2019 SBBG Terrestrial Inverts of San Clemente Island” project at iNaturalist.org). If you’d like to get involved with similar projects at the Garden, contact me about bug volunteer opportunities (zphillips@ SBBotanicGarden.org).

Ironwood 23

Take a look at some of the 48 plant taxa on which we collected bugs during the survey, including rare and endemic Channel Island species and subspecies.

All plant photos provided by Casey Richart, Ph.D.

San Miguel Island milkvetch (Astragalus miguelensis)

Island false bindweed (Calystegia macrostegia)

Island mallow (Deinandra clementina)

San Clemente Island paintbrush (Castilleja grisea)

San Clemente Island evening-primrose (Camissoniopsis guadalupensis ssp. clementina)

24 Ironwood

Coastal pricklypear (Opuntia littoralis)

San Clemente Island buckwheat (Eriogonum giganteum var. formosum)

Golden-spined cereus (Bergerocactus emoryi)

California golden violet (Viola pedunculata)

San Clemente Island larkspur (Delphinium variegatum ssp. kinkiense)

San Clemente Island brodiaea (Brodiaea kinkiensis)

San Clemente Island bird’s-foot trefoil (Acmispon argophyllus var. adsurgens)

Ironwood 25

Kylie Etter Conservation Technician

Metaphycus wasp (Order Hymenoptera) specimen collected from coyote bush (Baccharis pilularis) Most of the world’s wasp diversity is made up of tiny parasitoid wasps, like this one (Metaphycus sp.). Parasitoid wasps grow on or inside their hosts as juveniles and they must kill their hosts to complete their lifecycle. (This is what distinguishes parasitoids from parasites, which don’t have to kill their hosts).

Due to the hyper-diversity and tiny size of parasitoid wasps, they can be difficult to identify. I was only able to identify this specimen to family (Encyrtidae), but after posting these photos on BugGuide.net, a wasp expert was able to identify it to genus. He also noted that this might be an undescribed species, which means it has not been formally described and named.

Phygadeuontini wasp (Order Hymenoptera) specimen collected from island buckwheat (Eriogonum grande var. grande) Can you spot the wasp among the acrobat ants (Crematogaster sp.) in this picture? I don’t know why she is pretending to be an ant, but I am sure it’s to her benefit!

The wasp is a parasitoid wasp in the Family Ichneumonidae. Compared to the ants, it has long antenna with numerous segments, a smaller head, bigger eyes, and a long ovipositor (a long, specialized organ used to deposit eggs) extending out from the end of its abdomen.

Urbane Digger bee (Order Hymenoptera) specimen collected in chaparral woodland The Urbane Digger bee (Anthophora urbana) can be found on the mainland, but this subspecies, Anthophora urbana ssp. clementina, is an island endemic.

The island subspecies has rusty red colored hair, while the mainland one has more blond hair. Anthophora urbana ssp. clementina visits some of the island’s rare plants such as San Miguel Island milkvetch (Astragalus miguelensis), leafy desert dandelion (Malacothrix foliosa ssp. foliosa), and San Clemente Island bush mallow (Malacothamnus clementinus).

Mason bee (Order Hymenoptera) specimen collected on the ground We collected 15 specimens of Osmia aglaia from the island, a species previously not recorded as being on San Clemente. It’s important to do insect surveys consistently to track population numbers, understand community structure, and record new species either recently introduced to the island or that have been missed in past efforts.

Paintbrush The paintbrush is my favorite all-around go-to tool while doing insect sorting, identification, and photographing. It can gently separate insects from one side to the other in a petri dish of ethanol, pick up insects and move them from vial to vial, and brush off any dirt or dust clinging onto pinned specimens interfering with getting the perfect picture.

Clockwise from upper left: Kylie Etter in the field on Santa Cruz Island, Metaphycus wasp (Photo:

Alex

Jimenez),

Kylie's

favorite tool (Hand model: Zach Phillips, Ph.D. Photo: Kylie Etter), two photos of the Phygadeuontini wasp

(Photo:

Kylie

Etter/Alex

Jimenez), Mason bee (Photo: Kylie Etter), and Urbane Digger bee (Photo: Kylie Etter)

26 Ironwood

Ironwood 27

José Flores Conservation Technician

California ladybeetle (Order Coleoptera) photographed on San Clemente Island buckwheat (Eriogonum giganteum var. formosum) The California ladybeetle (Coccinella californica) is a species of ladybeetle that exists along the coast from Baja California, Mexico, to southern Alaska. They’re easy to identify from their spotless forewings (called “elytra”), and a dark band running vertically across their elytra. Overall, ladybeetles are a nice guest to have around your home garden. They may not look like voracious predators to us, but they eat a lot of aphids, including the pesty aphids that can infest garden plants.

Johnson’s ladybeetle (Order Coleoptera) photographed on golden yarrow (Eriophyllum confertiflorum) Johnson’s ladybeetle (Coccinella californica form johnsoni) is a form of ladybeetle that exists on islands along the western United States and Canada, including the Channel Islands. It has five large spots on each forewing and one spot being shared between the forewings, giving it a total of 11 spots. Sometimes the two spots in the back appear to be coalescing into one giant spot.

Kidney-spotted fairy ladybeetle (Order Coleoptera) specimen collected from coyote bush (Baccharis pilularis) Lady beetles (Family Coccinellidae) are diverse. This kidney-spotted fairy ladybeetle (Psyllobora renifer) has the same general shape as the other ladybeetles collected on San Clemente Island, but it exhibits a distinct color pattern on its hardened forewings.

Ladybeetle larva (Order Coleoptera) specimen collected from island morning glory (Calystegia macrostegia ssp. amplissima) Before a ladybeetle (Family Coccinellidae) matures into an adult and develops its wings, it looks like this. Like adult ladybeetles, the larvae feed voraciously on aphids that feed on plants. Insect larvae are generally more difficult to identify than adults, and the vast majority of insect identification keys and guides are based on adult features, not larval ones. This is one of the reasons we generally didn’t include larvae in our survey.

BugGuide.net We post images of some of our specimens on iNaturalist.org, a well-known nature website and app used to share images and information about all kinds of animals and plants, and on BugGuide.net, a website used in a similar fashion but exclusively for “insects, spiders, and their kin.” BugGuide has been around since 2003, and it is where a lot of experts have congregated to help identify these invertebrates. The website also serves as a great learning tool as each unique species, genus, etc., has its own page that is curated by frequent users where they can add information such as identification tips, species ranges, and a list of print and internet references, to name a few. For our San Clemente Island invertebrate project, we posted on BugGuide only if iNaturalist did not assign an ID to a specimen’s taxonomic family within a week. Like iNaturalist, identification on BugGuide is all based on volunteer time, so we do not expect an immediate response, but we always get excited when our tougher-to-identify specimens are identified.

28 Ironwood

Clockwise from upper left: José Flores in the field capturing his latest specimen, the California ladybeetle (Photo: Casey Richart, Ph.D.), the Kidney-spotted fairy ladybeetle (Photos: José Flores), ladybeetle larva (Photos: Helen Noroian), José's favorite tool, and the Johnson's ladybeetle (Photo: Casey Richart, Ph.D.)

Ironwood 29

Jordan Sanderson Volunteer

Thrips (Order Thysanoptera) specimen collected on island buckwheat (Eriogonum grande var. grande) Over half of the insects that were collected on San Clemente Island are thrips (Order Thysanoptera), which have close associations with plants. They’re hard to see with the naked eye, especially their feathered wings and the hairs all over their body.

Thrips (Order Thysanoptera) specimen collected from bush sunflower (Encelia californica) Thrips (Order Thysanoptera) specimen collected on blue dicks (Dipterostemon capitatus) Springtail (Order Collembola) specimen collected on California sagebrush (Artemisia californica) Like thrips, springtails (Order Collembola) are a ubiquitous but often overlooked group of tiny animals. Springtails are closely related to insects, but they don’t have jointed appendages like insects do.

Springtail (Order Collembola) specimen collected on common fiddleneck (Amsinckia menziesii var. intermedia) Springtail (Order Collembola) specimen collected on California sagebrush (Artemisia californica) Dissecting scope Sorting through all the insects in this project would have been impossible without the help of a dissecting microscope. This scope allows 3D views of teeny tiny objects and allows invisible details to be seen as clear as day. It also allowed us to orient bugs properly before placing them under the microscope camera and photographing them.

Clockwise from top left: Jordan

Sanderson

Garden,

thrips

in

collected

the on

island buckwheat (Photo: Helen Noroian),

springtail

collected

from California sagebrush (Photo: Alex Jimenez), springtail collected from

fiddleneck

(Photo:

José

Flores), José working with Jordan's favorite tool (Photo: Kylie Etter), another springtail collected from California sagebrush (Photo: José Flores), thrips collected on blue dicks (Photo: Helen Noroian), and thrips collected from bush sunflower (Photo: Helen Noroian)

30 Ironwood

Ironwood 31

Laiken Warner Volunteer

Leafhopper (Order Hemiptera), with a parasitoid wasp attached (Order Hymenoptera) — specimen collected on island tarplant (Deinandra clementina) This leafhopper (Family Cicadellidae) should choose its friends more carefully.

The dark blob attached to its side is a parasitoid wasp larva. At this stage, both the leafhopper and wasp are juveniles. Eventually, the wasp will emerge as an adult, mate, and if she’s female, find more leafhoppers to deposit her eggs in.

Phidippus jumping spider (Order Araneae) specimen collected from coastal prickly pear (Opuntia littoralis) Have you ever seen a spider sparkle? This is the distinctive face of a jumping spider (Family Salticidae), and the sparkle is coming from its chelicerae, or jaws. Jumping spiders don’t capture prey in webs. Instead, they actively track them down, and their two large, forward-facing central eyes help them hunt.

Mecaphesa crab spider (Order Araneae) specimen collected from San Clemente Island paintbrush (Castilleja grisea) Here’s a peek into the arachnid cardiovascular system. Spiders have hearts too, you know! This crab spider (Family Thomisidae) was collected from the endemic plant San Clemente Island paintbrush (Castilleja grisea), where it may have been waiting to pounce on visiting pollinators.

Hand sanitizer Hand sanitizer is the unsung hero of the invertebrate imaging world. The humble sanitizer holds bugs in position while taking a photo with the microscope. And when you need to move the bug to get another angle, it’s easy to do. For the project, we typically took at least three photos of each specimen: one from above (dorsal), one from below (ventral), and one from the left side (lateral) of the bug.

Clockwise from top left: Laiken Warner along the coast of Santa Barbara, California, two images of parasitoid wasp larva attached to a leafhopper (Photos: Zach

Phillips,

Ph.D.),

Laiken's

favorite tool (Photo: Kylie Etter), two images of the Mecaphesa crab spider (Photo: Laiken Warner), and the face of the Phidippus jumping spider (Photo: Laiken Warner)

32 Ironwood

Ironwood 33

Zach Phillips, Ph.D. Terrestrial Invertebrate Conservation Ecologist

Metepeira orbweaver spider (Order Araneae) specimen collected on San Clemente Island hazardia (Hazardia cana) Spiders are astute botanists, and they use their ancient knowledge of plants to hide and hunt more effectively. They camouflage themselves against flowers, anchor webs to stems and branches, and hop around vegetation seeking prey.

This fuzzy Metepeira spider is in the orbweaver family (Araneidae), a group that decorates San Clemente’s plants with silken traps.

Jumping spider (Order Araneae) specimen collected on coyote bush (Baccharis pilularis) Jumping spiders (Family Salticidae) get a lot of media attention because they’re adorable — and they know it. As if this spider’s head wasn’t big enough already, you can see an enlarged copy of this photo on a wall in the Pritzlaff Conservation Center Gallery at the Garden.

Ghost spider (Order Araneae) specimen collected from Blair’s wirelettuce (Munzothamnus blairii) Some of the spiders we collected on San Clemente feed directly on plants.

In addition to eating bugs, ghost spiders (Family Anyphaenidae) drink nectar from flowers to help fuel their active lifestyle.

Stilt bug (Order Hemiptera) specimen collected from island tarplant (Deinandra clementina) What a bug. Its long legs are characteristic of the family it belongs to, the stilt bugs (Berytidae). It was collected from island tarplant, where it was likely using its straw-like mouthparts to suck some of the plant's juices, or scavenging other insects stuck to the plant's surface. The stilt bug’s spines and long legs help it avoid a similar fate, enabling freer movement through a plant’s sticky and clingy hairs.

Leafhopper (Order Hemiptera) specimen collected from San Clemente Island buckwheat (Eriogonum giganteum var. formosum) This leafhopper (Family Cicadellidae) likely represents a new species to science.

If she seems bland, it’s not her fault. Blame us. Her natural colors have been washed away by the ethanol in which she was stored. She uses the long, bladelike ovipositor at the end of her abdomen to lay eggs inside of plants. We don't know which plants, but our survey results suggest a few candidates, including San Clemente Island buckwheat.

Coffee We need to talk. Yes, it’s serious. I don’t ever want to see your ugly mug again.

Sure, I remember the good times. We’ll always have the jitterbug, you and I — we danced like it was nobody’s business! I held the bugs, and you made them jitter. But that doesn’t change a thing. The project is over, and I need to sleep. You’re out; chamomile is in. I’m telling you SCRAM, bub! You may not be single origin, but you’re single now, got it? I don’t care where you go, just lose my number and stop sending me latte art. Wait, don’t leave … maybe just one more sip.

Clockwise from top left: Zach

Phillips,

Ph.D.

University

of California,

Barbara

campus,

the Santa

Metepeira

orbweaver spider (Photo: Laiken Warner), jumping spider (Photo: Laiken Warner), leafhopper (Photo: Zach Phillips, Ph.D.), ghost spider (Photo: Alex Jimenez), two images of the stilt bug (Photos: Zach Phillips, Ph.D.), and a brokenhearted mug of coffee (Photo: Zach Phillips, Ph.D.)

34 Ironwood

on

Ironwood 35

Denise Knapp, Ph.D. Director of Conservation and Research

Bee Fly (Order Diptera) specimen collected from California golden violet (Viola pedunculata) Bee flies (Family Bombyliidae) are the reason I went back to graduate school.

While working as a plant ecologist on Catalina Island, I would watch them and wonder what they were. There I was, trying to protect an array of very rare plants, and I didn’t know who their pollinators were. Bee flies are not only adorable and effective at pollinating while they stick their long mouthparts into a deep-throated flower, but they also have a cool edginess: their larvae are parasitoids of other insects, especially bees. This one (Bombylius major) was collected from California golden violet (Viola pedunculata).

Robber fly (Order Diptera) specimen collected on a rock Everything about this robber fly (Family Asilidae) says “predator.” The piercing mouthparts, huge eyes, and copious strong bristles are most obvious. It takes more observation, though, to see these venomous, athletic flies catching and sedating their prey, and then sucking out the contents of their bodies, all while on the wing. They have a long mustache called a mystax that protects them from their flailing victims.

Cactus fly (Order Diptera) specimen collected on island false bindweed (Calystegia macrostegia) One reason I love flies is that they do so many jobs that benefit ecosystems and people. They pollinate flowers, help control pest populations, and, among other things, act as saprophages that break down dead and decaying matter.

The cactus fly pictured here (Odontoloxozus longicornis) is a saprophage, and commonly feeds and breeds in rotting cactus. Although there is only a single species of cactus fly recorded from the United States, regional populations exhibit distinct genetic variation, including those on the Channel Islands.

Fly books The most important tool for me when identifying flies is a good dichotomous key, with descriptions and illustrations that help me decide if I got it right or not. “Flies: The Natural History and Diversity of Diptera” by Stephen A. Marshall has a wonderful, user-friendly key with drawings of important features, along with excellent natural history information and photographs. “The Manual of Nearctic Diptera” volumes, authored by numerous experts, have many illustrations of the different groups and important features like wing venation, bristle patterns, and facial features.

O

Clockwise from top left: Denise Knapp, Ph.D., enjoying her home native garden, two images of the bee fly (Photo: Alex Jimenez), two images of the cactus fly (Photo: Alex Jimenez), two images

Cognato, A. I., & Smith, S. M. Taxonomic review of Carphobius Blackman, 1943 (Curculionidae: Scolytinae) and a new species from San Clemente Island, California, U.S.A. The Coleopterists Bulletin. (In review) Phillips, Z. I., Flores, J. M., Etter, K. J., Lee, C., Calloway, S. M., Searcy, A. J., Sanderson, J., Warner, L., Zhang, D., Trujillo, S. H., Makler, L. C., Zendejas, S., Noroian, H. M., Martín, A. J., Cusser, S. J., & Knapp, D. A. (2023). San Clemente Island Terrestrial Invertebrate Survey: Guiding Biodiversity Inventory, Rare Plant Conservation, and Habitat Restoration. Report prepared for U.S. Navy by Santa Barbara Botanic Garden.

36 Ironwood

of the robber fly (Photo: Alex Jimenez), and Denise’s favorite tool (Photo: Denise Knapp, Ph.D.)

Ironwood 37

38 Ironwood

Why Our Living Collection Matters By: Christina Varnava, Living Collection Curator

T

he towering bigcone Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga macrocarpa) in the Manzanita Section. The colorful irises (Iris spp.) surrounding the Meadow Section. The elusive California peony (Paeonia californica) on the Porter Trail. The appearance of these plants is very different, but they are all part of the Living Collection at Santa Barbara Botanic Garden. The Living Collection is one of the Garden’s three American Alliance of Museums accredited collections, along with the Blaksley Library and the Clifton Smith Herbarium. But what exactly is a living collection?

have used the plants in our Living Collection for projects on pollination biology, documenting hidden patterns of UV colors on flowers (figure 2), understanding gall ecology, measuring live fuel moisture to learn more about how fires spread, and more. Living collections are excellent tools for research, since they can house a broad array of species in a relatively small space. Plants in a collection also respond to stimuli from their environment in ways similar to how they would in the wild.

A Record of Every Plant Living collections are distinguished from ordinary gardens by the practice of keeping and maintaining detailed records on their specimens. These accession records include information about where and when a plant was collected, which is also known as its provenance. Provenance data is critical, since without it, there is no way to trace the origins of a plant.

A great example of the value of provenance is the accession record for our great yellow pond-lily (Nuphar polysepala), which is located in the Arroyo Section. The great yellow pond-lily is not a rare species; it is found in wetlands throughout western North America and is quite common in Northern California. However, it no longer grows in Southern California. When our specimen in the Arroyo bloomed last year for the first time in years, I looked at the accession record for additional information that we could share with our visitors. What I found surprised me. Our specimen was collected in 1956 from Santa Barbara County from a place that was once a wetland but is now a golf course. Now that its habitat is gone, this plant is no longer found in the wild there — or in other places it historically existed in Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo counties. Our specimen, therefore, represents a part of the genetic diversity of this species that would have otherwise been lost. It may have a part to play in helping with restoration efforts someday in the future, but in the meantime, it will be cared for here at the Garden to ensure its continued existence (figure 1).

In addition to harboring genetic diversity, living collections are used in a variety of ways. Researchers

2: Visible and UV light captures of the same giant coreopsis (Leptosyne gigantea) flower from Santa Barbara Botanic Garden’s Living Collection (Photo: Justen Whittall)

Conserving California’s Biodiversity We have been keeping accession records of our wild collected plants for nearly 100 years. The Garden was founded by people who understood the value of California’s native plants and habitats.

Living collections with accurate provenance data such as ours are vital tools in the fight to counter the biodiversity crisis. According to Kew’s Plant Assessment Unit of global plant diversity, two in five plants globally are threatened with extinction in their native habitats. Critically, the areas with the most threatened plants are also areas with the highest biodiversity (places like California) since there are simply more unique species to lose. To help address this dramatic potential loss, the Global Strategy for Plant Conservation recommends that threatened plant species should be preserved in “ex situ” collections or collections outside of their native habitats. These ex situ collections are generally seed banks and living collections like the ones we have here at the Garden.

One rare species in our Living Collection that illustrates this is Franciscan manzanita (Arctostaphylos franciscana), a manzanita that is now extinct in the wild. This species once grew

Opposite, 1: Great yellow pond-lily (Nuphar polysepala) blooming in 2022 from our specimen collected in 1956 (Photo: Stephanie Ranes)

Ironwood 39

3: Island barberry (Berberis pinnata ssp. insularis) flowers encased in a bag to prevent insect pollination as part of a study researching the seed viability of this species (Photo: Kylie Etter)

on a few outcrops of serpentine rock around San Francisco, including the Laurel Hill Cemetery where the species was first described. As the city expanded, these rugged spaces were bulldozed, taking the Franciscan manzanita with them. Fortunately, some cuttings were rescued before the species was totally eliminated, and these were sent away to botanic gardens for safekeeping. One of our accessions of this plant dates to 1938 where it was collected from Laurel Hill Cemetery by Lester Rowntree. Rowntree was a pioneering California field botanist and horticulturalist who spent months-long stretches camping and living among native plants throughout the state. Our specimen represents a piece of genetic diversity that would have been completely lost without the living collections of botanic gardens.

Over the years, we have propagated cuttings from this plant for safekeeping, and it now grows in many locations throughout the Garden.

The Islands of the Californias Our proximity to the biodiverse and beautiful California Channel Islands has inspired researchers and horticulturists here at the Garden for decades.

Our Living Collection now contains 57 species found only on the Channel Islands. Many of these endemic species were once highly threatened by the introduction of grazing animals like cattle, elk, and sheep, putting them at risk of extinction. In fact, some of our specimens were collected from 40 Ironwood

species with only a handful of plants left in the wild, such as the island barberry (Berberis pinnata ssp. insularis). Island barberry historically grew on a few of the Channel Islands, but the population has been reduced to a handful of individuals on Santa Cruz Island. This plant grows in shady riparian habitats, which were severely degraded by erosion caused by feral pigs and other grazing animals. By the time the last of these animals were removed in 1984 only a handful of island barberry plants remained. Even worse, these plants were separated from each other and growing on different parts of the island. This isolation appears to have made it difficult for them to reproduce since opportunities for cross-pollination are limited, and they produce little viable seed.

Cuttings from a large island barberry plant on Santa Cruz were brought into cultivation at the Garden in 1958. Plants grown from this specimen have been thriving here since. Recently, scientists at the Garden have begun researching pollination in this species using our specimen from 1958, hoping to help explain the low seed viability of this species in the wild (figure 3).

Our Collection Is Always Growing This year, we added new specimens of the federally endangered Santa Cruz Island bush mallow (Malacothamnus fasciculatus var. nesioticus) to the Garden’s Living Collection. Bush mallows thrive in open spaces with lots of room to spread, but on

Santa Cruz Island their habitat was destroyed by introduced herbivores, which had also helped the spread of invasive plants such as fennel (Foeniculum vulgare). This left only a small handful of plants in the wild. Heather Schneider, Ph.D., the Garden’s rare plant biologist, along with other staff from our Rare Plant Conservation Team collected cuttings from two previously uncollected populations on Santa Cruz Island. The goals of the project were to install these plants into our Living Collection to safeguard them from further decline and to produce material for future restoration on Santa Cruz Island. This fall our conservation and horticulture staff worked together to plant this species into areas of the Garden where they can thrive. We also paid close attention to where we added these plants since they tend to spread very far and wide — we needed to be sure that they would not grow near the other closely related bush mallow species (Malacothamnus spp.) in our Collection.

Our goal is to preserve the genetic integrity of Santa Cruz Island bush mallow. Once these plants are large enough to take cuttings, we will share plants with other botanic gardens so that this species can be preserved in more ex situ conservation collections (figure 4).

Preserving Native Traditions Our Living Collection also offers the original stewards of local lands access to native plants important to their traditions. Members of the Barbareño Band of Chumash Indians have utilized plants in the collection that they may not be able to attain freely from wild places, such as Baltic rush (Juncus balticus), white sage (Salvia apiana), Santa Cruz Island ironwood (Lyonothamnus floribundus ssp. apleniifolius), and dogbane (Apocynum cannabinum).

Building Connection With Visitors Finally, these plants have incredible value as ambassadors of their species. When people see plants at the Garden they have an opportunity to learn more and to make a connection with a plant that they may never see in the wild. Seeing a photo of coast redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) and standing among them are two utterly different experiences.

The Living Collection has been fostering these kinds of connections with California’s native plants for nearly a century now, along with providing a platform for research and conservation. As the curator of this wonderful Living Collection, I look forward to seeing the impact our Garden will have over the next century. O Right, 4: Santa Cruz Island bush mallow (Malacothamnus fasciculatus var. nesioticus) flowering at the Garden (Photo: Christina Varnava)

Ironwood 41

T H E G A R D E N ’ S I M PACT

1861

Through your generous support, Santa Barbara Botanic Garden inspires and empowers everyone to cultivate biodiversity — both locally and beyond — so we can restore the health of the planet, one seed at a time.

The oldest specimen, cowbag clover (Trifolium depauperatum var. truncatum), was added to our Clifton Smith Herbarium

by W. Brewer 161 years ago.

2.9M Seeds

22,443 This number of native plants sold at the Garden Nursery continues to provide vital habitat across California.

Our Conservation Seed Bank safeguards nearly 3,000,000 seeds, protecting 305 rare species from extinction.

Visitors from around the world experienced the wonder and beauty of California’s native plants at the Garden, selling out our county-issued attendance cap for the year.

8,600 Hours

Nearly 300 volunteers support our education, conservation, and horticulture teams throughout the year, driving our mission forward.

974 Taxa Our Living Collection has 974 unique native species, subspecies, and cultivars.

1934 The year the oldest specimen in our Living Collection records, a bigcone Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga macrocarpa), was planted.

42 Ironwood

110,000

211K

The number of unique specimens of California’s plants, lichen, and fungus currently in our Clifton Smith Herbarium continues to grow. The Garden is home to the second largest collection of lichens in the U.S.

March 16,

1926

Thanks to Anna Dorinda Blaksley Bliss’ generous donation, the Garden was able to preserve this space and open its doors to the public, inspiring generations through the power of native plants.

11,405

Samples

The Garden’s Tissue Bank contains more than 11,000 DNA samples representing 120 plant families and 465 genera. Helping us better identify and protect rare plants.

59%

This is the percentage of species endemic to the Channel Islands now included in our Living Collection. This makes the Garden one of the only places, besides the islands, you can see them.

162.7 Feet (49.6 Meters) Our tallest tree is a coast redwood (Sequoia sempervirens).

55+ Contracts

With 23 scientists on staff, a seed bank, a genetics lab, and more than 55 active contracts with local and national partners, we’re a conservation powerhouse creating a better future by harnessing the power of native plants.

Ironwood 43

From the Archives: The Art of Research By: Hannah Barton, Garden Archivist

W

hile it may not seem like art and botany have much in common, in fact, botanical art was used as an early tool to aid in the scientific identification of differing plant species and plant parts. Before the advent of photography, artistic documentation of specific plants acted as the visual definition of each plant, and often were able to leave a more lasting impression on the botanist than a descriptive text might. Artists who engage with their subject matter in a strictly representational form have carried on a lasting tradition aimed at studying, capturing, and preserving these plants over time, without disturbing any physical part of the plant.

Henry R. Mockel (1905–1981) was a German American artist and amateur botanist who spent the second half of his life living near Joshua Tree National Park and studying the plants of the Mojave Desert. In this time, he produced a large body of artwork (mainly prints), many of which we are fortunate enough to house in the Garden’s Archives.

Of this collection, I am particularly drawn to a series of six serigraphs that follow the Mojave yucca (Yucca schidigera) through its progressive stages of flowering, from bud to flower to fruit, and even illustrates the dried panicle after the fruit has been scavenged by desert dwellers. The Mojave yucca is a unique plant that is well adapted to life in the harsh desert environment. It has long, spiky leaves which emerge from a central rosette and a tall, central stalk that can grow up to 20 feet (6 meters) tall. The Mojave yucca grows very slowly, sometimes only up to 1 inch (2.5 centimeters) per year, and does not die after blooming, like many of its monocot relatives.

Henry R. Mockel, “Mojave Yucca Inflorescence,” serigraph, ca. 1960s

44 Ironwood

Henry R. Mockel, “Mojave Yucca Panicle,” serigraph, ca. 1960s

Mojave yucca (Yucca schidigera) in the Santa Barbara Botanic Garden Desert Section, 1998. (Photo: Steve Junak)

Mockel’s Mojave yucca serigraphs capture the beauty and intricacy of this important desert plant in stunning detail. Through his careful and consistent observation, Mockel created a useful tool for those wanting to study and identify these yuccas, but he also retained an artist’s signature style and voice.

These prints, in particular, are striking not only in their muted palette and artistic beauty but also in their ability to educate those who might not observe these plants in the wild over the span of time that it would take to witness the bud bloom into the flower, the flower form into the fruit, and what remains after the fruit has been harvested. These prints act almost as an artist-rendered time-lapse in six frames, and display the patience that Mockel demonstrated in capturing this process. He wrote: “We [artists] claim that it is our prerogative to retain a high regard for the different aspects of nature that we witnessed, sometimes by happenstance, sometimes by patiently waiting.” (Mockel, Mockel’s Desert Flower Notebook, 1971: 9) With his series of prints, Mockel also emphasizes the importance of forging a relationship with plants beyond their peak blooming stage — and taking the time to appreciate and study the full flowering cycle, from start to finish. I hope that in seeing these prints, you might develop a broader awareness for how plants in your environment evolve throughout the year, as these observations over time have the potential to teach us so much about the cyclical nature of plants and their ecosystems. O

Henry R. Mockel, “Mojave Yucca In Bloom,” serigraph, ca. 1960s

Ironwood 45

Volunteer Story: From Behind the Lens By: Jaime Eschette, Director of Marketing and Communications

Greg Trainor with a selection of his images from around Santa Barbara Botanic Garden

W

hen it rains in Santa Barbara, a stroll around Santa Barbara Botanic Garden is probably not high on your priority list. But for Greg Trainor, Garden volunteer and Channel Island Professional Photographers Association’s Nature Photographer of the Year (2022), it’s an invitation he simply can’t resist.

That’s because, as Greg put it, “When you catch it just right, the rain amplifies the natural beauty of the Garden in a way you can only witness from behind the lens.” He claims some of his favorite pictures were captured in these brief moments between the perfect and even more perfect weather we experience here on the central coast.

remembers a time when he explored with his family dog and snapped photos with one of his very first cameras. Once he had a family of his own, he dabbled in “photo safaris” with his children when they were younger and shared an affinity for photography with his wife, Janice. Through these experiences, and Greg’s analytical and inquisitive nature, the seeds were planted for a future in photography. However, it would be many years before this creative hobby would blossom.

Whatever the forecast, Greg loves nature and being in the Garden. You can often catch him roaming the trails with his camera at the ready. So, when we (literally) crossed paths over two and a half years ago, we were thrilled he accepted our invitation to become one of our Garden volunteers. Since then, he has helped us share the power and beauty of native plants through his art of photography. Today, his photos can be found across our website, social channels, and even throughout this magazine.

In 1993, Greg’s career in information technology and project management brought him and his young family to Tucson, Arizona, where they would spend much of their time exploring nature — hiking on the local trails, biking, and even scuba diving. Yes, scuba diving! Being so close to Mexico, Greg would often take trips south, where he finished his training and is now a certified dive master. In Arizona, a passion for nature emerged and it was there that Greg first fell in love with native plants. His experiences across land and sea during those years also sparked a desire to tell others how important and precious our wild spaces are to our overall health and well-being.

Photography and nature weren’t always central in Greg’s story. Growing up in a military family mostly in the suburbs of Illinois and Michigan, Greg was accustomed to moving around during his early childhood. As he traveled from place to place, he

When it was time to look at retirement, Greg and Janice, his wife of 35 years now and still going strong, knew exactly where they wanted to be. Greg was familiar with California, having moved here — and met Janice here — in the late 1980s. So, it was an

46 Ironwood

easy decision to relocate to Janice’s hometown of Santa Barbara, a place that Greg notes, “rival(s) the beauty of the Tucson deserts.” Janice remembered the Garden, though she hadn’t visited in more than 30 years, and knew it would align with Greg’s passion for exploration, nature, and photography.

Greg still remembers the first time he visited the Garden in 2016. He was astounded by the beauty of it all with “this breathtaking meadow and pristine mountain backdrop and the biggest array of native plants” he’d ever seen in one place. He knew during that early visit that he wanted to return, and this would be where he would hone his photography skills and make good on his dream of sharing the beauty of the natural world in the hope of protecting it. In 2021, he was approached by Guest Services and Volunteer Programs Manager Kathy Castaneda to become a volunteer photographer for the Garden. Greg humbly agreed and launched into his first assignment taking

pictures of various Garden oaks (Quercus spp.). He’s been going strong since and shares that he truly loves being surprised by what he finds in the Garden.

Through his drive, passion, and technique, Greg has been able to capture the beauty and essence of California’s native plants through photography.

And through his dedication as a Garden volunteer, Greg has helped impart our mission to conserve native plants and habitats for the health and wellbeing of people and our planet. Our entire volunteer community has a magnified impact in this way. We are forever grateful for your time and talent in helping to conserve native plants and habitats here in Santa Barbara and beyond — for generations to come. O Enjoy the Garden and nature through Greg’s eyes by following him on Instagram @sbshutterbug or checking out his website at sbshutterbug.myportfolio.com.

Ironwood 47

SBBotanicGarden.org

Become a Volunteer

Make Friends and Help Us Grow. Get Started Today.

We will match your interests, abilities, and availability with the Garden’s current volunteer needs. By becoming a volunteer, you will be making a substantial contribution to the preservation of California’s native plants and habitats.

48 Ironwood

Become a volunteer today by contacting us at volunteer@SBBotanicGarden.org

Field Notes: Poetry Inspired by Nature By: David Starkey, Founding Director of Santa Barbara City College's Creative Writing Program

A Visit to the Botanic Garden Wander without map, plan, or name tag, unlike the bees who hive by a white sign: Bees Working • Abejas Trabajando.

Out of an oval opening in a coastal oak,

an ecstasy of bees exits. Their zigzags draw me closer and I wonder:

How brave would I have to be to put my hand in Melinda Palacio (Photo: Greg Trainor)

M

elinda Palacio is the Poet Laureate of Santa Barbara. She is the author of the novel “Ocotillo Dreams” and the poetry collections “Folsom Lockdown”; “How Fire Is a Story, Waiting”; and “Bird Forgiveness.” Look for her new column, “Poetry Connection,” on Independent.com.

Reflecting on her poem, Palacio notes, “A visit to Santa Barbara Botanic Garden means renewal and opportunities for self-care. On my last visit, I noticed the sign and was impressed by how fierce the bees were buzzing and working. From educators to insects, so much work goes into maintaining the Garden. I decided to write about the balance of work and play by taking time out to enjoy the grounds and songbirds.” O

the tree’s crevice, extract hard-earned sweetness?

I mind my manners.

Last year’s sting lingers as most wounds do.

I leave the honeybees to their work.

Enter the raised courtyard.

A young mother feeds her baby, pale breast in hand, she smiles

as her older daughter frolics free.

I circle back towards the grove of redwoods.

Renewed in the stillness of a forest bath, a towhee’s song sets the world straight.

Soon other voices join joyous:

goldfinches, orioles, sparrows.

As if to say, all’s well in the world today.

Working hive in the Manzanita Section (Photo: Greg Trainor)

— Melinda Palacio Ironwood 49

The Book Nook By: The Garden Staff

“The Next Great Migration: The Beauty and Terror of Life on the Move” | Sonia Shah

“Finding the Mother Tree: Discovering the Wisdom of the Forest” | Suzanne Simard

Focusing on human migration, this book beautifully illustrates the connections and similarities between human, animal, and plant migration in the face of climate change. The book opens with a story about a California local, the Edith’s checkerspot (Euphydryas editha) butterfly. Author Sonia Shah sites a study documenting how the butterfly’s geographical distribution has shifted and changed the perspective on the capacity for organisms to shift their range in response to climate change. Movement is a natural part of how every species, including Homo sapiens, survives. Shah uses these stories of movement, migration, and change to explore the history of modern ecology and how ideas within the field have been implicitly designed or applied by cultural biases.

The ecological language we use, and theories applied to plants or animals, are harmful when people try to apply them to human beings as a tool to restrict or discriminate. This book offers more context and grounding for ecological theories and ideas that scientists have been taught for years. Overall, it is an essential read for anyone who is interested in ecology.

Recommended by Kylie Etter, Conservation Technician O

“Finding the Mother Tree: Discovering the Wisdom of the Forest” is a rewriting of our understanding of nature. Suzanne Simard is a pioneer researcher studying plant communication and intelligence. She tells a vivid story about how trees, with the help of fungi, have evolved to perceive one another, to learn and adapt their behavior, to recognize their neighbors, to remember the past, to send out warnings and mount defenses against threats, and to compete and cooperate with each other. Vital parts of forests are the Mother Trees that connect and sustain the trees around them. Interwoven in this tale is the journey of Simard’s own life. She portrays how her experiences have led to groundbreaking discoveries and how these discoveries were initially met with resistance from the scientific establishment. This book is an inspiring story about the amazing, intersecting webs in nature.

Recommended by Rikke Reese Næsborg, Ph.D., Tucker Lichenologist and Curator of the Lichenarium O

“A Gardener’s Guide to Botany: The Biology Behind the Plants You Love, How They Grow, and What They Need” | Scott Zona, Ph.D. Making no assumptions about the reader’s previous knowledge, this guide is not just another book on how to grow plants. Instead, author Scott Zona, Ph.D., explains the how and why of plant science in a way that everyone can understand. Through his beautiful illustrative guide and simple explanations, he starts by detailing what it means to be a plant. He then explains the parts of a plant, the three components necessary for a plant to thrive, plant defense, and plant reproduction. Whether you are new to the world of plants or an old hand, this book will take you on an adventure into the amazing kingdom of plants. You’ll get to know your plant families like you never have before. A must read for every native plant gardener!

Recommended by Joan Evans, Accounts Payable and Treasury Manager O 50 Ironwood

“Upstream: Selected Essays” Mary Oliver In her book “Upstream: Selected Essays,” poet and nature writer Mary Oliver presents a selection of 19 essays (16 from previous collections) that are deeply touching, like this sentiment: “Occasionally I lean forward and gaze into the water. The water of a pond is a mirror of roughness and honesty — it gives back not only my gaze, but the nimbus of the world trailing into the picture on all sides.” Through her rhythmic prose, she beautifully records unique things about nature that many people never take the time to notice. Her essays come together to both inform and inspire the artists and naturalists within each of us. It’s as though she is asking readers to slow down so they can find more meaning in the nature that surrounds them by carefully observing and considering what they see. Grab a cup of coffee/tea — this is a book you’ll want to read again and again.

Recommended by Dylan Schuyler, Backcountry Ranger O

The Budding Botanist: At-home Ecology By: Michelle Cyr, Youth and Family Programs Manager

What life does my backyard support?

S

anta Barbara Botanic Garden studies the interactions between plants and animals. This relationship between organisms, known as ecology, helps us better understand and protect the natural world. You don’t need a lab or fancy equipment to observe ecology in your backyard or neighborhood. To explore the insects in your area, try out this method that is utilized by scientists and researchers all over the world.

DIY Insect Survey Insects, like plants, are the main food source for many creatures, and understanding which plants best support them is an important step to creating a healthy habitat. The beat-sheeting method of collecting insects uses very few materials, making it a very handy technique to use in the field.

Materials • 1 light-colored sheet (e.g.: a piece of an old bed sheet, a towel, a large piece of paper, an open notebook) • Long stick (optional) • 1 notebook to log your findings (optional) • 1 hand lens to view insects (optional)

Directions • Locate a plant that you would like to examine.

• Lay out your sheet flat on the ground so it is directly under the plant. If you are surveying a tree, you may need to have one or two helpers lift the sheet, so it is more directly underneath the foliage.

• Grab hold of a branch that is above your sheet and shake it vigorously (while being careful not to damage your plant), so that any insects on the branch will be knocked off. You may also use a stick to carefully rustle or “beat” the branch.

• Check out what’s fallen onto your sheet. If you don’t know the specific species, you can categorize them by groups such as beetles, flies, ants, etc. Record your observations in your notebook.

• Repeat this method on other plants to get an idea of what other insects the landscape is supporting.

Want to learn more about the insects you’ve observed? Take a photo and upload it to the iNaturalist app or website for identification and to contribute to one of the largest community science projects in the country. O Ironwood 51

Make Protecting Your Habitat a Habit Become a member today to support the Garden’s mission to conserve native plants and habitats throughout California.

Membership

Membership Benefits

Family: $125

– Digital membership card to expedite check-in at the Garden and for reserved parking.

Individual: $75 Includes year-round admission for one individual.

Dual: $100 Includes year-round admission for two adults.

Includes year-round admission for two adults and up to five named dependent children or grandchildren under 18.

– Two one-time-use guest passes.

– Reciprocal benefits to over 345 gardens and arboreta nationwide.

ADD-ONS FOR MEMBERSHIPS

Add Plus One: $25

– Advance registration and reduced fees on classes, field trips, lectures, and special events.

Includes admission for one individual (not named) on each visit in addition to named members.

– 10% discount at the Garden Nursery and Shop, as well as at other participating local nurseries.

Add Dog Friendly: $30

– Mailed subscription to the Garden’s biannual Ironwood magazine and monthly Garden Gazette e-newsletter.

Additional donation to support a dog-friendly Garden and includes a branded doggie bandana.

BECOME A GARDEN ADVOCATE For $35 a year you can help support the Garden and stay up-to-date on events and research. Includes mailed biannual Ironwood magazine and monthly Garden Gazette e-newsletter.

Does not include admission to the Garden or other benefits listed above 52 Ironwood

Scan to become a member.

Philanthropic Tiers GUILD

Wildflower: $200 Includes all of the benefits of a membership, plus admission for one guest each visit. Also get six one-time-use guest passes, branded Garden tote bag, and free 1-gallon native plant from our Nursery.

OTHER WAYS TO SUPPORT

Give Today Whether you are a home gardener, hiker, teacher, or busy professional, the Garden’s programs help deepen connections to nature, ultimately ensuring its protection for the future.

Will you join us in championing a better future for us all?

Ironwood: $500

Leave a Legacy

Includes the benefits listed under Wildflower, plus eight one-time-use guest passes and one free education class for two.

Connect with us to learn how to include the Garden in your will and explore more resources to help you and your family plan for the future.

CIRCLE

Make a Tribute or Memorial Gift

Manzanita: $1,000 Includes all benefits listed above, plus 10 one-time-use guest passes, two free guests per visit, physical cards sent in the mail, and invitations to Circle exclusive events.

Honor a loved one with a plant tribute or memorial bench.

Sycamore: $2,500

Whatever your motivation, we welcome your talent and enthusiasm.

Includes all benefits listed above, plus 15 one-time-use guest passes.

Redwood: $5,000 Includes all benefits listed above, plus 20 one-time-use guest passes.

CORPORATE

Volunteer

Contact Us Volunteer Team 805.682.4726, ext. 119 volunteer@SBBotanicGarden.org Membership Team 805.682.4726, ext. 110 membership@SBBotanicGarden.org

Spending time in nature improves productivity and promotes improved mental health — even a few minutes a day can make a big difference.

Development Team 805.682.4726, ext. 103

Give your employees access to the Garden while supporting the conservation of native plants and habitats. We have several tiers of corporate membership available starting at $2,500. For more information, please email our membership office at membership@SBBotanicGarden.org.

SBBotanicGarden.org/support

SBBotanicGarden.org Ironwood 53

ADDRESS SERVICE REQUESTED

NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION U.S. POSTAGE PAID SANTA BARBARA, CA PERMIT NO. 451

1212 Mission Canyon Road Santa Barbara, CA 93105 805.682.4726 SBBotanicGarden.org

Are you ready to Plant With Purpose?

Donate online at SBBotanicGarden.org/support/give or scan this QR code: