LOCAL NEWS
AND CULTURE MARCH 17-23, 2021
SFREPORTER.COM FREE EVERY WEEK
2
DECEMB ER 16-22, 2020
•
SFREPORTER.COM
MARCH 17-23, 2021 | Volume 48, Issue 11
NEWS
I AM
OPINION 5 THE FIGHT FOR LIGHT 9 It’s Sunshine Week, and it’s still not clear what that means to Santa Fe leaders
Lynn Baldwin Director of Wealth Management
NEWS 7 DAYS, CLAYTOONZ AND THIS MODERN WORLD 6 WORST-CASE SCENARIO 11 Bills to fund and renew Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Relatives Task Force stall in session COVER STORY 12 THE FOILIES Since 2015, The Foilies have served as an annual opportunity to name and shame government agencies and officials who have stood in the way of public access. We publish stories from around the country from journalists, activists and everyday folk who have filed public records requests and experienced retaliation, over-redactions and other transparency malpractice.
facebook: facebook.com/sfreporter
AN ADVISOR .
WE’RE HERE FOR YOU The journalists at the Santa Fe Reporter are in overdrive to help our community stay connected. We plan to continue publishing a print edition and daily web updates. Can you help support our journalism mission? Learn more at sfreporter.com/friends
My clients desire sound advice from a local, qualified investment and trust professional. With our expertise, my team and I can help your reach your financial and estate goals. I AM Century Bank. *Investment products purchased through Century Trust and Asset Management are not FDIC Insured, are not deposits of Century Bank, have no bank guarantee, and may lose value.
Cover illustration by Caitlyn Crites
MyCenturyBank.com 505.995.1226
EDITOR AND PUBLISHER JULIE ANN GRIMM ASSOCIATE PUBLISHER AND AD DIRECTOR ANNA MAGGIORE
CULTURE
ART DIRECTOR ANSON STEVENS-BOLLEN
SFR PICKS 17 The borderlands and journalism, hot, hot foods and low-pressure folk art A&C 18
CONTRIBUTING EDITOR JEFF PROCTOR SENIOR CORRESPONDENT JULIA GOLDBERG
SOUND OF MUSIC EDUCATION While basic Zoom limitations abound, remote learning lets teachers hear their students better FOOD 19 SMOKIN’ UP RUFINA STREET Uncle DT’s Smokehouse scores points for an unpretentious vibe in Midtown, plus a damn fine piece of chicken MOVIES 20 THE VIGIL REVIEW Director Keith Thomas brings Jewish ghost lore to the mainstream horror milieu THE CALENDAR Things are happening, people are talking, spring is springing and folks are getting vaxx’d left and right—get in on our online culture and events calendar by visiting sfreporter.com/cal
www.SFReporter.com
CULTURE EDITOR ALEX DE VORE
Phone: (505) 988-5541 Mail: PO BOX 4910 SANTA FE, NM 87502
STAFF WRITERS LEAH CANTOR KATHERINE LEWIN COPY EDITOR CHARLOTTE JUSINSKI CONTRIBUTING WRITER RILEY GARDNER EDITORIAL INTERN WILLIAM MELHADO DIGITAL SERVICES MANAGER BRIANNA KIRKLAND PRINT PRODUCTION MANAGER AND GRAPHIC DESIGNER SUZANNE S KLAPMEIER DISPLAY/CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING EXECUTIVE ROBYN DESJARDINS CIRCULATION MANAGER ANDY BRAMBLE OWNERSHIP CITY OF ROSES NEWSPAPER CO. PRINTER THE NEW MEXICAN
EDITORIAL DEPT: editor@sfreporter.com CULTURE EVENTS: calendar@sfreporter.com DISPLAY ADVERTISING: advertising@sfreporter.com CLASSIFIEDS: classy@sfreporter.com
THOUGH THE SANTA FE REPORTER IS FREE, PLEASE TAKE JUST ONE COPY. ANYONE REMOVING PAPERS IN BULK FROM OUR DISTRIBUTION POINTS WILL BE PROSECUTED TO THE FULL EXTENT OF THE LAW. SANTA FE REPORTER, ISSN #0744-477X, IS PUBLISHED EVERY WEDNESDAY, 52 WEEKS EACH YEAR. DIGITAL EDITIONS ARE FREE AT SFREPORTER.COM. CONTENTS © 2021 SANTA FE REPORTER ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MATERIAL MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION.
association of alternative newsmedia
SFREPORTER.COM
•
MARCH 17-23, 2021
3
Thanks to our current and future Friends! B U S I N E S S F R I E N D S O F T H E R E P O R T E R ($500 minimum donation per year)
A Biz by Bre AllStays.com Cerrillos Station Del Norte Credit Union Egolf + Ferlic + Harwood + Martinez
Milagro Dental Monroe Gallery of Photography Monsoon Design Mouth + Gism Rothstein Donatelli, LLP
Santa Fe Community College Santa Fe Institute Melinda Silver Fine Art Spirited Goods
Suzanne Timble Ultra Health Violet Crown Cinema WoodMetalConcrete Architecture
B F F ’ S (Recurring gifts of $19.74 per month)
James Auerbach Gini Barrett Kent Buckingham Cactus Salon David Cantor
John and Bekki Cook Pedro B Coronel James Y Coulter Katherine J Davis Design Enginuity
Gaucho Blue Contemporary Art Gallery, Peñasco Richard Meeker Thomas J. Mescal, II, Esq Charlene Muellenberg
Modern Aphrodite & Dr. Anne Ridley Juliet Myers Nan Newton Patricia Ortiz
Lise Poulsen Cathryn Schmidt Silver Saddle Motel Bill Thornton Thom Wilson
SUPPORT INDEPENDENT LOCAL JOURNALISM WITH A DONATION SMALL OR LARGE, OR SIGN UP FOR RECURRING GIFTS! Elaine and Michael Clayman Mary Coffman Nadja Schreiber Compo Barbara Conroy Tom Costello Mary Costello Ann Crouse Mary Ann Crowe Sloan Cunningham Roxanne Darling Lou Ann Darras Julie Davies Katherine Davis Stephen Day Adrienne DeGuere Kenny DeLapp Diane Denish Margaret A De Vore Merilee De Vore Dee Dee Downs Dona A Durham MR Dykton Earthfire Gems Gallery Brian Eckert Chad and Judy Eckhart Kay Enfield John Erickson Joseph Esposito Areena Estul and Shell Goldman Mary Fahr Miles Fairris Melanie Lamb Faithful James Faris John Alan Farmer Seth Feder Jill & Terry Fernandez Kristina G Fisher and Phil Carter Barbara Fix Gail B Flanagan Jen Fong Albo P Fossa and Jill Foster Katherine Fox Ehlert Ella Frank Michael Freed Candace Frostenson Lisa Fulton Maria and Edward Gale Q Gallaher Bernice García-Baca Linda S Gardner Lynn Gary Dr. Jan Gaynor
Fran Adams & Dave Patterson Jan and Jim Allen JoAnne Allen Keith Anderson and Barbara Lenssen Jarratt Applewhite Dena Aquilina A thankful minion A twinkling galaxy Irene P Ayala Sylvia V Baca Mikey Baker Cris and Marilyn Barnes Lisa Barsumian Rachelle Batt Rebecca S Batt Ben Baur Gayla Bechtol Terry Becker Judith Benkendorf Bill and Nancy Bergner Jason Berry Fritz & Nancy Biederman Joyce Blalock JB Blair Ruth Blaser Gay Block The Blogs Jamie Blosser Sky Bluestar The Bobs Joyce Bogosian Boodlebody.com Curtis Borg Brian Botkiller Lisa Botos Sally Brandt Gino Brazil Liz Bremner Beth Brown Markeeta Brown The Buckinghams Sue Burnham The Thomas Cannon Fund Kristin Carlsen Rowley Nathan Chael Susan and Appy Chandler Julie and Matthew Chase-Daniel Betty Chern-Hughes Tom Claffey Barbara A. Clark Paul Clarkson
4
FEBRUARY 3-9, 2021
•
SFREPORTER.COM
Phil Geller Lina S Germann Dan and Connie Gerth Marvin J Godner Shelley Goldman Cynthia Goldstone John Gonzales Charles Goodmacher MacDonnell Gordon Cheryl Fossum Graham Constance Grason Ellie Gray Lynn Gray Peter Grendle Daniel and Judith Gresham Annette Groenfeldt Katy Gross Daniel Guevara John Guffey David Gunter Jacquelyn S Hall Cynthia Hartling Heath Haussamen Wendy Havlir Cherry Annette V Hayden Haydenfold Karen Heldmeyer Shyana Helin Jay Heneghan Victoria Hennelly Arnold Hershman Henry Okie: The Sage of Tijeras Betty L Hileman Jeff & Audrey Hill Anne Hillerman and Don Strel Tom & Rose Himrod Irene Hofman Samuel Hokin Vicki Holmsten and Don Allen Deborah Holloway Bernhard Holzapfel Lynn Hopkins W. Houston and Kimberly P. Dougharty Lee and Jane Hruska Ken Hughes Deeda Hull JoAnna T Hurley
In Honor of David Bowie In Honor of Tina Girouard IPRA Leon Jamele Elisabeth A Jennings Perry Johnson Beverly Johnston William I Johnstone and Elizabeth Crysler Julie Joyce Dr. Mary Ann Kaczmarski Hal Kahn Megan Kamerick Heather Karlson Diane Karp Rev. Cannon Ted Karpf Joseph Karnes Spider Kedelsky Chris Kemper KevinBoxStudio Karen King Nicholas King Photography Catherine and Charles Kinney Bobbi Kline Dan Klein and Robbyne Jones Lynn Komer Patricia Kontgis Michael Kovnat Ruth and Paul Kovnat Sherry Kraemer Corrine Kratz Betty Kuhn Ellen Kurnit Philip Kyle Laurel Ladwig and Trina Altman David LaPlantz Ann Lawrence Agnus Lawson Lee and Marcus Leslie Lakind Lamy Catherine and Britt Leach Allen Lewis Edwina Lieb Signe Lindell Brenda Lindlief-Hall Lucy Lippard M Jean Little Patrick Lohmann
Douglas Lonngren Kathryn Lowerre James Lutz Tara Maestas Eileen Mandel Paul and Jane Mandel Dave Maass Maddawg Laurie P Maitre Michael Marcotte Linda Marianiello Carrie Marsh Linda Marshall K Martinez Arnold Mayberg Alice McAlpine In memory of Richard McCord Mike & Mary McGuire Lynn McKelvey and Glenn Dickter Sara McKenzie Jean McCray Jodi McGinnis Porter Jean McIntosh Dan McKay Maureen Joyce McKenna Sara McKenzie Bram Meehan Jon Mertz Amy and Ben Migliori Paula Miller Tiffany Montavon Amanda Montgomery and Rick Von Kaenel Marilyn Morgan James McGrath Morris Patrick Murphy and Gene Covington Margo Murray Heidi Munzinger Jane Napier Kate Noble MJ Norton Obscura Gallery Dylan O’Reilly William Osborne Gary Oakley Laura Paskus Jim Patrick
Give today: sfreporter.com/friends
Victoria Pavel Catherine Peck Lucas Peerman, Las Cruces Sun-News Kristen Pelz Peoples Progressive Media Janet Perelson Diane Petrin Sandra Place Mary and Robert Platt PopUp-Santa Fe.com Annalise Porter Johnnie Prather Larry W Prescott Lauren E Prescott Brenda Priddy Spencer Ralston Tom and Dori Ramsay Barbara Rauch Judith Redstone Matthew Reichbach M. Reifman Coletta Reid and Pat Hastings M. Reifman In Loving Memory of Richard Ricci Elissa Ritt John Robertson Shelley Robinson Dominic and Susan Baker Roybal Monica Roman Gagnier Iliana Limón Romero Andy Ross Patsie E. Ross Lisa Rossbacher Karen Rowell Patricia Ann Rudy-Baese Selby and Eddie Sonya and Myron Salamon William Salopek Helene Schoch Fernanda Santos Carol Schrader Richard Schrader, River Source Inc. Don and Jane Schreiber Nan Schwanfelder Gayle Scott Vickie Sewing and Janis Rutschman Mary Ann Shaening Alysha Shaw Peter Shotwell
Joan Sickler and Mike Rosow Linda Siegle and Liz Stefanics Jason Silverman Janet Simon Caitlin Smith Jason and Joann Smith Sunny Sonnenschein and Stuart Feen Suzanne Somers Anne Souders Meredith Speers Bryan Sperry Philip Stelnicki Sub Rosa Mercantile Tiago Stock Katie and Andrew Stone Dennis Storz Elaine Sullivan Debbie Swanson Gregory W. Swift Trudy Swint The Tappans Denise Tessier Lisa Thompson Rachel W Thompson John Kelly Tonsmeire Desiree & Steve Turner Tamara van der Does Pamela Villars Paul Vogel Tresa Vorenberg Goldsmiths Kaela Waldstein Victoria Wall PatriciaWallaceandDanielPeck Richard Wallen and Mary Eloisa David Wannigman Jeff Waters Lisa Weeast Tracy Cook Wein and Doug Wein Jenny Weinbloom Ben and Carolyn Whitehill Kay Whitman Robert Wieneke and Shari Schumsky Judith K Williams Robert L Williams Kathy Wimmer Leslie Wippen Nancy Witter Spencer Wright Faith Yoman Ellen Zieselman
SFR FILE PHOTO
S F R EPORT ER.COM / NEWS / LETTERSTOTHEEDI TO R
LETTERS
Have you had a negative dental experience? Michael Davis,
DDS
New Patients Welcome
Would you like to experience caring, smiling, fun, gentle people who truly enjoy working with you?
SMILES OF SANTA FE Michael W. Davis, DDS 1751 Old Pecos Trail, Suite B (505) 988-4448 www.SmilesofSantaFe.com
P R OV I D E R F O R D E LTA A N D U N I T E D C O N C O R D I A D E N TA L P L A N S • M O S T I N S U R A N C E S A C C E P T E D
Mail letters to PO Box 4910, Santa Fe, NM 87502; or email them to editor@sfreporter. com. Letters (no more than 200 words) should refer to specific articles in the Reporter. Letters will be edited for space and clarity.
ONLINE, MARCH 12:
task force’s first meeting. (An SFR article from Oct. 14, 2020, A Crack in the Shield, notes “… Rivera’s recent push for some task force meetings to be closed to the public.”) So much for transparency. RomeroWirth, the vote against the resolution including closing meetings, should be thanked for her principled stand.
BERL BRECHNER SANTA FE
“TASK FORCE GETS ‘SAFE SPACE’”
BOO FOR SECRECY
“HOW BIG A SPLASH”
WEEK OF MARCH 15-19, 2021
Wednesday, March 17, 2021 4:00 PM Buckman Direct Diversion Board Special Meeting – Virtual Meeting: https://santafenmgov.zoom.us/j/91023070113?pwd=QTJrQjl3M2c3TFpCRjVaRkJYZU53UT09 5:00 PM
Quality of Life Committee – Virtual Meeting: https://www.youtube.com/user/cityofsantafe
Thursday, March 18, 2021 3:30 PM Archaeological Review Committee – Virtual Meeting: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuW5Fb7iWuKpTdsWYNDurgA 5:00 PM
Mayor’s Youth Advisory Board – Virtual Meeting: https://santafenmgov.zoom.us/j/91023070113?pwd=QTJrQjl3M2c3TFpCRjVaRkJYZU53UT09
5:00 PM
Solid Waste Management Agency Joint Powers Board – Virtual Meeting: https://santafesolidwastemanagementagency.my.webex.com/santafesolidwastemanage mentagency.my/e.php?MTID=mc4c493d05172afc82acacef021116717
6:00 PM
Planning Commission – Virtual Meeting: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuW5Fb7iWuKpTdsWYNDurgA
Friday, March 19, 2021 No Meetings Scheduled
SUBJECT TO CHANGE Please visit https://santafe.primegov.com/public/portal to view agendas, participation information and corresponding materials. For additional information, contact the City Clerk’s Office at 505-955-6521
THERE’S HOPE I am amazingly optimistic about cannabis. But definitely not holding my breath.
BOB THOMPSON VIA FACEBOOK
CORRECTION
O AIRP
NOW OFFERING
D.
.
3909 ACADEMY RD.
LOS RD
APR PERFORMANCE PRODUCTS
RT R
CERRIL
Last week’s news story “How Big a Splash” gave the wrong bill number for Sen. Cliff Pirtle’s cannabis proposal. It’s Senate Bill 288.
SPECIALIZING IN:
OWS EAD S. M RD.
Note that the city resolution that orders city committees and task forces to comply with the state Open Meetings Act goes back to 1984 (Resolution 1984-56). So the exception in this task force’s resolution allowing for secret meetings goes against 37-yearold procedures for public openness and transparency. In addition to Councilor Carol RomeroWirth’s proposed amendment to create ways for the task force, focusing on policing issues, to receive information or accounts from individuals who wish anonymity or privacy, other suggestions for this were made at the latest council meeting and prior committee meetings. But the council ultimately voted 8-1 to allow for closed meetings. It’s strange that Councilors Renee Villarreal and Chris Rivera pushed so hard for secret meetings, despite other options being available. Rivera had apparently been seeking secrecy for months, even before the
NEWS, MARCH 10:
MEETING LIST
SFR will correct factual errors online and in print. Please let us know if we make a mistake: editor@sfreporter.com or 988-7530.
3909 Academy Rd., Santa Fe, NM 87507 | 473-3001
SANTA FE EAVESDROPPER “It makes me feel so good to be the first one to touch things at the supermarket.” —Overheard in South Capital
Send your Overheard in Santa Fe tidbits to: eavesdropper@sfreporter.com
We pay the most for your gold coins, heirloom jewelry and diamonds! On the Plaza 60 East San Francisco Street, Suite 218 Santa Fe, NM 87501 • 505.983.4562 • SantaFeGoldworks.com SFREPORTER.COM
•
MARCH 17-23, 2021
5
S FREP ORTER.COM / FUN
HAPPY ST. PADDY’S DAY, EVERYONE! Now go do a bunch of non-Irish stuff and pretend like it’s not just a big fat excuse to get trashed. Oh, and wear green.
SANTA FE OPERA HIRES COVID SAFETY MANAGER If we’ve learned anything from opera, though, the real threat is a duplicitous uncle/duke/scorned lover who has designed some sick-ass murder/punishment/banishment for you.
DEB HAALAND CONFIRMED AS SECRETARY OF INTERIOR, BECOMING THE FIRSTEVER NATIVE PERSON IN A CABINET POSITION USA! USA! USA!
DAYLIGHT SAVING BILL A NO-GO AGAIN THIS YEAR Great news for people who like feeling sad all winter!
MEXICO LEGALIZES CANNABIS Not us in New Mexico, though. It’s too hard to grow weed when it gets dark at 3 pm for half the year.
AID-IN-DYING BILL DOES MAKE IT TO GOV’S DESK, THOUGH Finally—you’ll have the same rights as your dog.
THE WEEKND, OTHER MUSICIANS SLAM THE GRAMMYS You know, because the whole institution is a bunch of garbage.
6
MARCH 17-23, 2021
•
SFREPORTER.COM
READ IT ON SFREPORTER.COM THE GREAT OUTDOORS With the weather getting nicer, might local classrooms pop outside for a little al fresco learning?
W E A R E WAY M O R E TH A N W E D N E S DAY H E R E A R E A CO UP LE O F O N LI N E E XC LUS I V E S :
THE RESIDENTS A pair of Indigenous artists join forces with the IAIA Museum of Contemporary Native Arts for an evolving digital residency program.
YOU' VE WORKED HARD TO MAKE IT A
Make sure your mortgage is still working for you, talk to our experts about a Mortgage Wellness Check-up Get star ted today at dncu.com
Build upon your foundation! mortgage@dncu.org
505-455-5228
Women’s History Progr a ms
Governance Lessons for Today’s Leaders from QE 1 Renaissance woman Kristin Bundesen has some suggestions for future success from one of the past’s greatest leaders. Her reign is called “The Elizabethan Age” for very good reasons. (3/25)
Christ on a Cracker! Tech exec by day, Laura Lanford is a Nerd Nite maven after dark. She’ll explain why we see religious icons on food and hear secret messages in songs played backwards. (3/23 & 30)
Renesa n.org SFREPORTER.COM
•
MARCH 17-23, 2021
7
Have you been putting off your Estate Planning because you don’t know where to start?
Albuquerque/Santa Fe Attorneys for
WILLS, PROBATE, TRUSTS, ESTATE PLANS
We are your lawyers for life! Since 2003, the locally owned and operated firm
has provided fast
and affordable Estate Planning. We are thrilled to bring our services to Santa Fe! C A L L T O D AY F O R A N A P P O I N T M E N T
431 St. Michaels Drive, Suite A, Santa Fe, NM 87505 (505) 903-7000 | Email: info@walkinwills.com | https://walkinwills.com 8
MARCH 17-23, 2021
•
SFREPORTER.COM
OP-ED
S FR E P O RTE R .CO M
It’s Sunshine Week, and it’s still not clear what that means to Santa Fe leaders BY J E F F P RO CTO R j e f f p r o c t o r @ s f r e p o r t e r. c o m
A
speck of light appeared last fall as I worked with SFR’s Katherine Lewin on a cover story documenting the city’s latest public-facing efforts to build trust in the police: the oddly named Community Health and Safety Task Force. Its creation came amid a spike in complaints against Santa Fe Police Department officers for a host of alleged infractions, from sexual assault and excessive force to rude behavior and delayed response times. And more broadly, officials built the task force at the end of a long, hot summer of protest and renewed calls for police accountability nationwide. Two Santa Fe city councilors and nine other residents would tackle the big issues as part of the task force’s work, then make recommendations for change, city leaders promised. It was all on the table: citizen oversight, a deep dive into policy, non-police responses to situations better suited for a softer touch— even increased transparency at the cop shop. But last week, while editing an online dispatch from Lewin’s SFR colleague, Leah Cantor, the wee ray of light I’d seen last year was snuffed out, enveloped in the darkness of a near-unanimous City Council vote that cordoned off the work of the task force from the public it’s meant to serve. Only Councilor Carol RomeroWirth thought Santa Feans should get to watch the business of a group ostensibly working to improve Santa Fe. “And just in time for Sunshine Week,” I hissed while reading Cantor’s story. The reference is to the seven-day stretch each year when journalists celebrate victories for transparency, grouse about setbacks and launch efforts to intensify the spotlight in shrouded corners. Sunshine Week exists because, at nearly all levels of government around the US, opacity is the rule, not the exception. Santa Fe and its cloaked police department are,
alas, in the mainstream—regardless of which political party is running things. This national problem is once again hilariously and devastatingly chronicled on the cover of this week’s SFR, which features an annual syndicated piece shepherded by one of our infamous alums, Dave Maass, director of investigations for the Electronic Frontier Foundation. (My favorites among the 2021 Foilies are “The Eric Cartman Respect My Authoritah Award” and “The Thin Crust, Wood-Fired Redactions Award.” Please read the EFF’s amazing piece.) Had it taken its ill-advised vote but a bit sooner, the Santa Fe City Council could have added a Foilie to its impressive record of anti-transparency measures. This time around, neither I nor SFR is asleep to the rationale for secrecy given by Councilors Renee Villarreal and Chris Rivera, who co-chair the task force. Calling out the police for misconduct and worse is a sensitive, dangerous undertaking. Members’ reluctance to do so in front of
Our hope is for some fortification of New Mexicans’ right to know about the inner workings of their police departments. After all, Santa Fe isn’t the only city that considers facts to be opinions. hot cameras is understandable, as is their desire for a “safe space” to share traumas. In a brave, lonely stand for sunshine, Romero-Wirth tried to salve those concerns by suggesting that less formal, information-gathering sessions could be conducted in private, while meetings of the task force itself should remain public. After all, although the group is not subject to the state Open Meetings Act, which mandates policymaking meetings be accessible to the public, a 2009 city ordinance says all meetings, including those of boards, commissions and task forces should be open.
ANSON STEVENS-BOLLEN
The Fight For Light
The idea: more transparency and, in turn, more trust. But with the March 11 vote, the council has opened the city to more criticism and less trust from both ends. If the task force’s recommendations appear too soft to reformers, they’ll wonder how such decisions were made; same for supporters of the status quo if the suggestions push for real change. There’s another irony, as well. Among the task force’s self-described duties is the examination of SFPD’s transparency policies. They are awful. For a couple of years, SFR has been embroiled in litigation with the city over a basic question: When SFPD metes out discipline for a policy violation, should the public have the right to know what the punishment was for an employee whose salary we pay? Like those of his predecessors, Mayor Alan Webber’s position is that the fact of officer discipline is a “matter of opinion” and therefore exempt from disclosure under the New Mexico Inspection of Public Records Act (IPRA). SFR believes that facts are facts, not opinions, and we continue the fight. After a mixed bag of rulings from state District Court Judge Bryan Biedscheid, our dedicated legal team of Daniel Yohalem and Katherine Murray are now preparing to argue in front of the New Mexico Court of Appeals. Our hope is for some fortification of New Mexicans’ right to know about the inner workings of their police departments. After all, Santa Fe isn’t the only
city that considers facts to be opinions, and we deserve an untangling of the case law. By the way, if it seems like you’ve read a rant similar to this one under my byline before, it’s because you probably have. And if it seems like SFR is constantly in court, slugging it out with political leaders of both parties over access to government happenings, it’s because we kind of are. A yearslong legal battle against the administration of former Republican Gov. Susana Martinez came to a (partial) close in December 2017, when then state District Court Judge Sarah Singleton ruled that Martinez and Co., had not violated the state constitution in freezing our newspaper out of the information flow, but had broken IPRA three times in refusing to give us records. (The state, by the way, kept fighting under Martinez’s successor, Democrat Michelle Lujan Grisham, to prevent our attorneys from being paid until finally relenting in mid-2019 and ultimately coughing up well-deserved fees and costs.) I don’t especially enjoy being a listed party in a lawsuit. Neither do my colleagues. We just want to inform our readers about the functions of their governments, whether that be by coverage of public meetings, analysis of public records or some other means that ought to be accomplished with the lights on. In a city with a police transparency problem, we hope leaders will reconsider their decision for darkness with the Community Health and Safety Task Force. We are all part of this community, and our collective health depends on it.
SFREPORTER.COM
•
MARCH 17-23, 2021
9
southwestcare.org
From ref is to home buys,
Homewise is still here to help
Although our physical offices remain closed to keep us all safe, we continue to help New Mexicans prepare for and achieve homeownership. • Work with a coach by phone or teleconference
to set goals.
• Find free online resources with financial tips
and advice on when and how to buy a home.
• Take virtual home tours or visit homes while
maintaining social distance.
Find out more! Call, visit our website, or engage with us on YouTube, Facebook, and Twitter.
505.983.9473 www.homewise.org 10
MARCH 17-23, 2021
•
SFREPORTER.COM
S FR E P O RTE R .CO M / N E WS
Bills to fund and renew Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Relatives Task Force stall in session
B Y K AT H E R I N E L E W I N k a t h e r i n e @ s f r e p o r t e r. c o m
T
hrough countless generations in the Southwest, Indigenous women and girls have gone missing or been murdered at much higher rates than other races. It’s a crisis that a state-mandated task force composed of government and tribal appointees set out to tackle with a plan to spend a year compiling a comprehensive report of data. But, unfortunately, that year was 2020. The Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Relatives Task Force faced significant hurdles: first, unresponsive law enforcement agencies unwilling or unable to share data combined with a small budget and then, suddenly, the COVID-19 pandemic sent all of the task force’s meetings online, when they happened at all. Despite the difficult undertaking, the group released a 64-page report at the
ANSON STEVENS-BOLLEN
WorstCase Scenario
end of 2020, a little over a month late, and cutting it very close to the start of the 2021 legislative session. The report found gaps in available data, and the task force did not recommend strong policy changes. But the three original sponsors of the first measure that set up the task force promised to pursue renewed legislation in 2021 to continue the work. House Bill 208, which would extend the existence of the task force until the end of FY 2022, expand and diversify the members of the group, bring in the New Mexico Department of Public Safety as a consultant and stakeholder, mandate the creation of policy recommendations, and give the Indian Affairs Department $50,000, was tabled in the House Appropriations and Finance Committee back in February and shows few signs of return in the final days of the session. Supporters and lawmakers are preparing for the worst-case scenario: a year where the task force is not sanctioned by the Legislature. Even if the task force’s enabling legislation is not renewed, one senator from Indian Country has found a way to try to funnel cash for the cause. Sen. Benny Shendo, D-Jemez Springs, has offered to give the department $50,000 from his part of a supplemental, or “junior” spending bill, which allots money to each lawmaker for pet projects. But that legislation is still awaiting Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham’s signature. Her office did not reply to a request for comment by presstime. “Ultimately, we were placed in an awkward position in hoping that our legislation would make it all the way through, but once we were promised some continued funding, that seemed to be the safest route to go at that time to ensure that we at least have the funds to continue this work,” Stephanie Salazar, general counsel for Indian Affairs, tells
NEWS
SFR. “I think some of the structural changes that we wanted to make, we felt would be stronger had it been implemented through legislation.” Those structural changes would include adding more state representatives and Indigenous community members to the task force, as well as continuing work with Harvard’s Nation Building course, which is helping the group with policy recommendations. Some of the small amount of funding would go toward compensating members for their time and travel as well as administrative costs stemming from the task force and community meetings. The meetings include multiple presenters from all over the state in areas where the MMIWR crisis is particularly prevalent. Without the backing of HB 208, Salazar says the task force will be left without formality that is helpful when asking law enforcement agencies for their data on MMIWR cases. And more of the work will have to be done on a volunteer basis. There is also the possibility that a task force could be created by an executive order. But much of the potential state support is still bookended by question marks. There is no question, according to lawmakers and state representatives, however, that the MMIWR work will continue. Rep. Andrea Romero, D-Santa Fe, one of the original sponsors of the legislation, says it is “critical” the task force continues, with or without funding or law. “We just want to see the work continue and that’s what this will provide for,” Romero says of the pending funding. “It takes the constraint off of the department to figure out how to do it otherwise, because it is a priority for them regardless. But this really ensures that they can get it done.”
Collections Spotlight Native artists bring us together to discuss and interpret the Coe’s collection. Every third Tuesday each month @ 3pm MST. To register, visit coecenter.org
—if you missed it...watch past events on the Coe Center Youtube channel. In partnership with First American Art Magazine
Coe Center
Coe Center 1590 B Pacheco Street, Santa Fe, NM 87505 www.coeartscenter.org • 505.983.6372
SFREPORTER.COM
•
MARCH 17-23, 2021
11
The Foilies 2021 12
MARCH 17-23, 2021
•
Recognizing the Year’s Worst in Government Transparency COMPILED BY THE ELECTRONIC F R O N T I E R F O U N D AT I O N A N D MUCKROCK NEWS I L L U S T R AT I O N S B Y C A I T LY N C R I T E S
SFREPORTER.COM
T
he day after the 2021 inauguration, Sen. Chris Murphy of Connecticut took to Twitter to declare: “Biden is making transparency cool again.” This was a head-scratcher for many journalists and transparency advocates. Freedom of Information—the concept that government documents belong to and must be accessible to the people—has never not been cool. Using federal and local public records laws, a single individual can uncover everything from war crimes to health code violations at the local taqueria. How awesome is that? If you need more proof: there was an Australian comic book series called The Southern Squadron: The Freedom of Information Act; the classic anime Evangelion has a Freedom of Information Act cameo; and the Leeds-based post-punk band Mush received 7.4 stars from Pitchfork for its latest album Lines Redacted. OK, now that we’ve put that down in writing, we realize that the line between “cool” and “nerdy” might be a little blurry. But you know what definitely is not cool? Denying the public’s right to know. In fact, it suuucks. Since 2015, The Foilies have served as an annual opportunity to name and shame the uncoolest government agencies and officials who have stood in the way of public access. We collect the most outrageous and ridiculous stories from around the country from journalists, activists, academics and everyday folk who have filed public records requests and experienced retaliation, over-redactions, exorbitant fees and other transparency malpractice. We publish this rogues gallery as a faux awards program during Sunshine Week (March 14-20, 2021), the annual celebration of open government organized by the News Leaders Association.
This year, the Electronic Frontier Foundation is publishing The Foilies in partnership with MuckRock News, a nonprofit dedicated to building a community of cool kids that file Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and local public records requests. For previous year’s dubious winners (many of whom are repeat offenders), check out our archive at eff.org/issues/foilies. And without further ado…
Runner up: Reporter C.J. Ciaramella requested records from the Washington State Department of Corrections about Michael Forest Reinoehl, who was killed by a joint US Marshals task force. The Washington DOC apparently planned to produce the records—but before it could, the Thurston County Sheriff’s Department sued Ciaramella and the agency to stop the records from being disclosed.
THE DOXXER PRIZE
Forensic Examiner Colin Fagan In July 2020, surveillance researcher and Princeton Ph.D. student Shreyas Gandlur sued the Chicago Police Department to get copies of an electronic guide on police technology regularly received via email by law enforcement officers around the country. The author of the guide, Colin Fagan, a retired cop from Oregon, did not agree that the public has a right to know how cops are being trained, and he decided to make it personal. In a final message to his subscribers announcing he was discontinuing the “Law Enforcement Technology Investigations Resource Guide,” Fagan ranted about Gandlur for “attacking the best efforts of Federal, state, and local law enforcement to use effective legal processes to save innocent victims of horrible crimes and hold their perpetrators accountable.” Fagan included a photo of Gandlur, his email addresses, and urged his readers to recruit crime victims to contact him “and let him know how he could better apply his talents”—one of the most blatant cases of retaliation we’ve seen in the history of the Foilies. Fagan has since rebounded, turning his email newsletter into a “law enforcement restricted site.”
THE GOVERNMENT RETRIBUTION AWARD City of Portland, Oregon
People seeking public records all too often have to sue the government to get a response to their records requests. But in an unusual turn-around, when attorney and activist Alan Kessler requested records from the City of Portland related to text messages on government phones, the government retaliated by suing him and demanding that he turn over copies of his own phone messages. Among other things, the city specifically demanded that Kessler hand over all Signal, WhatsApp, email and text messages having to do with Portland police violence, the Portland police in general, and the Portland protests.
THE MOST SECRETIVE DOG’S BOLLOCKS Conan the Belgian Malinois
Back in 2019, what should’ve been a fluff story (or scruff story) about Conan, the Delta Force K9 that was injured while assisting in the raid that took out an Islamic State leader, became yet another instance of the Trump administration tripping over itself with the facts. Was Conan a very good boy or a very good girl? Various White House and federal officials contradicted themselves, and the mystery remained. Transparency advocate and journalist Freddy Martinez wouldn’t let the sleeping dog lie; he filed a FOIA request with the US Special Operations Command, aka SOCOM. But rather than release the records, officials claimed they could “neither confirm nor deny the existence or nonexistence of records,” the much dreaded “Glomar response” usually reserved for sensitive national security secrets (the USNS Hughes Glomar Explorer was a secret CIA ship that the agency didn’t want to acknowledge existed). Never one to roll over, Martinez filed a lawsuit against SOCOM and the Defense Department in June 2020. Just in time for Sunshine Week, Martinez got his records—a single page of a veterinary examination, almost completely redacted except for the dog’s name and the single letter “M” for gender. Conan’s breed and color were even
blacked out, despite the fact that photos of the dog had already been tweeted by Trump.
THE MOST EXPENSIVE COVER-UP AWARD
mation. A court rejected both claims, and also forced the government to cough up more than $120,000 in fees to the news organizations’ lawyers.
Small Business Administration
THE SECRET COVID STATISTICS AWARD
In the early weeks of the pandemic, the Small Business Administration (SBA) awarded millions of dollars to small businesses through new COVID-related relief programs—but didn’t make the names of recipients public. When major news organizations including ProPublica, The Washington Post, and The New York Times filed public records requests to learn exactly where that money had gone, the SBA dragged its feet, and then—after the news organizations sued—tried to withhold the information under FOIA Exemptions 4 and 6, for confidential and private infor-
Seeking a better understanding of the toll of COVID-19 in the early days of the pandemic, journalists in North Carolina requested copies of death certificates from local county health departments. Within days, officials from the state Department of Health and Human Services reached out to county offices with guidance not to provide the requested records—without citing any legal justification whatsoever. DHHS did not respond to reporters’ questions about why it issued that guid-
COURTESY THE ELECTRO NIC FRONTIER FOUNDAT ION AND MUCKRO CK NEWS
North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services
ance or how it was justified. Some local agencies followed the guidance and withheld records, some responded speedily, and some turned them over begrudgingly—emphasis on the grudge. “I will be making everyone in Iredell County aware through various means available; that you are wanting all these death records with their loved ones private information!” one county official wrote to The News and Review reporters in an email. “As an elected official, it is relevant the public be aware of how you are trying to bully the county into just giving you info from private citizens because you think you deserve it.”
THE IT’S SO SECRET, EVEN THE BULLET POINTS ARE CLASSIFIED AWARD Minnesota Fusion Center
Law enforcement and intelligence agencies are always overzealous in claims that disclosing information will harm national security. But officials with the Minnesota Fusion Center took this paranoia to new heights when they claimed a state law protecting “security information” required them to redact everything—including bullet points—in documents they provided to journalist Ken Klippenstein. And we quite literally mean the bullets themselves. Fusion centers are part of a controversial program coordinated by the US Department of Security to facilitate the flow of homeland security intelligence among agencies. Each fusion center is maintained by a state or regional agency; in this case, the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. Klippenstein tweeted that the agency wouldn’t provide document titles or any other information, all the while adding the dreaded black redaction bars to bulleted lists throughout the records. But if officials redacted the bullet points in earnest, we wonder: what is the security risk if the public learns whether Minnesota homeland security officials use the default bullet points or some more exotic style or font? Will the terrorists win if we know they used Wingdings?
THE JUKING THE FOIA STATS AWARD - Centers for Disease Control
The Minnesota Fusion Center redacted every character on the page, including the bullet points themselves. We’re dying to know if they used Wingdings.
The Wire, the classic HBO police drama, laid bare how police departments across the country manipulate data to present trends about crime being down. As ex-detective Roland Pryzbylewski put
it: “Juking the stats....Making robberies into larcenies. Making rapes disappear. You juke the stats, and majors become colonels.” The Centers for Disease Control seems to love to juke its FOIA stats. As the nonprofit advocacy organization American Oversight alleged in a lawsuit last year, the CDC has been systematically rejecting FOIA requests by claiming they are overly broad or burdensome, despite years of court decisions requiring agencies to work in good faith with requesters to try to help them find records or narrow their request. The CDC then categorizes those supposedly overbroad requests as “withdrawn” by the requester and closes the file without having to provide any records. So those FOIAs disappear, much like the violent crime reports in The Wire. The CDC’s annual FOIA reports show that the agency’s two-step juke move is a favorite. According to American Oversight, between 2016 and 2019, the CDC closed between 21% and 31% of all FOIA requests it received as “withdrawn.” The CDC’s closure rate during that period was roughly three times that of its parent agency, the Department of Health and Human Services, which on average only closed 6% to 10% of its FOIAs as withdrawn. After American Oversight sued, the CDC began releasing documents.
THE CAT FACE FILTER AWARD Federal Bureau of Prisons
Kids these days—overlaying cat faces on their videos and showing the Federal Bureau of Prisons how it should redact media sought by FOIA requesters. That was the message from an incredulous federal appeals court in March 2020 after the BOP claimed it lacked the ability to blur out or otherwise redact faces (such as those of prisoners and guards) from surveillance videos sought through FOIA by an inmate who was stabbed with a screwdriver in a prison dining hall. CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE
SFREPORTER.COM
• MARCH 17-23, 2021
13
The Foilies 2021
THE SAVE THE CHILDREN (IN A HIDDEN FOLDER) AWARD Louisville Metropolitan Police Department, Kentucky
The Louisville Metropolitan Police Department’s Explorer Scouts program was supposed to give teenagers a chance to learn more about careers in law enforcement. For two LMPD officers, though, it became an opportunity for sexual abuse. When reporters asked for more information on the perpetrators, the city chose to respond with further absurdity— by destroying its records. The case against the city and the Boy Scouts of America is scheduled to begin in April. The Courier-Journal in Louisville first asked LMPD in mid-2019 for all records regarding the two officers’ sexual abuse of minors. Louisville claimed it didn’t have any; they had been turned over to the FBI. Then the Courier-Journal appealed, and the city eventually determined that— well, what do you know—they’d found a “hidden folder” still containing the responsive records—738,000 of them, actually. Not for long, though. Less than a month later, they’d all been deleted, despite the ongoing request, a casualty of the city’s automated backup and deletion system, according to Louisville. At the end of 2020, the CourierJournal was still fighting the city’s failure to comply with the Kentucky Public Records Act. “I have practiced open records law since the law was enacted 45 years ago,
and I have never seen anything so brazen,” said Courier-Journal attorney Jon Fleischaker told the paper. “I think it an outrage.”
and feeling like what I’m doing really is every bit a part of journalism.”
THE POWER OF THE TWEET AWARD THE ERIC CARTMAN RESPECT MY AUTHORITAH AWARD
Haskell Indian Nations University, Kansas When Jared Nally, editor-in-chief of The Indian Leader, the student newspaper at Haskell Indian Nations University in Lawrence, Kansas, started putting questions to his school’s administration and sending records requests to the local police department, he got a lot more than he expected: a directive from his school’s president demanding he cease his requests in the name of the student paper and henceforth treat officials with proper respect, lest he face disciplinary action. “Your behavior has discredited you and this university,” Haskell Indian Nations University President Ronald Graham wrote. “You have compromised your credibility within the community and, more importantly, you have brought yourself, The Indian Leader, Haskell, and me unwarranted attention.” Graham’s aggressive tactics against the college junior quickly rallied support for the student journalist, with the Native American Journalists Association, Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, and Student Press Law Center all calling for the formal directive to be rescinded. The school ultimately did back down, but the efforts left Nally shocked. “As a student journalist, I’d only been doing it for a year,” he told Poynter in an interview. “When somebody in authority says things like that about you, it really does take a hit.…I’d say I’m recovering from the gaslighting effects,
President Donald J. Trump
Secrecy nerds know that classification authority—the power to essentially mark some documents as secrets exempt from disclosure—resides with and is largely at the discretion of the president, who can then designate that authority as needed to agency personnel. So one expected upside of a loose-lipped president with an undisciplined social media habit was the ability to use the Tweeter in chief’s posts to target otherwise inaccessible FOIA requests. Case in point: Trump’s Oct. 6, 2020 tweet: “I have fully authorized the total Declassification of any & all documents pertaining to the single greatest political CRIME in American History, the Russia Hoax. Likewise, the Hillary Clinton Email Scandal. No redactions!” Hard to argue there’s ambiguity there. But when BuzzFeed News’ Jason Leopold flagged that order in his ongoing lawsuit for the materials, that’s exactly what the Department of Justice did. Based on their investigations, DOJ lawyers told the court, the posts “were not self-executing declassification orders and do not require the declassification of any particular documents.”
COURTESY TWITTER
The court wrote: “The same teenagers who regale each other with screenshots are commonly known to revise those missives by such techniques as inserting cat faces over the visages of humans.” The judge made clear that although “we do not necessarily advocate that specific technique,” the BOP’s learned helplessness to redact video footage is completely .
The court ultimately bought the argument that you can’t take what the then-president tweets too seriously, but Trump declassified other materials related to the FBI’s investigation...on his last day in office.
THE PHARAOH PRIZE FOR DEADLINE EXTENSIONS Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot, Illinois
With COVID-19 affecting all levels of government operations, many transparency advocates and journalists were willing to accept some delays in responding to public records requests. However, some government officials were quick to use the pandemic as an excuse to ignore transparency laws altogether. Taking the prize this year is Mayor Lori Lightfoot of Chicago, who invoked the Old Testament in an effort to lobby the Illinois Attorney General to suspend FOIA deadlines altogether. “I want to ask the average Chicagoan: Would you like them to do their job or would you like them to be pulled off to do FOIA requests?” Lightfoot said in April 2020, according to the Chicago Tribune, implying that epidemiologists and physicians are also
3811 Cerrillos Rd., Santa Fe, NM • (505) 933-6872 For dentist information visit ComfortDental.com. Services provided by a state licensed general dentist. Comfort Dental branded Dental practices are independent franchises owned and operated by State licensed General Dentists. 14
MARCH 17-23, 2021
•
SFREPORTER.COM
THE 30 DAYS OF NIGHT AWARD Hamilton County, Tennessee
It’s hard to imagine a more benign request than asking for copies of other public records requests, but that’s exactly what got Hamilton County officials in Tennessee so spooked they started a mass purge of documents. The shred-a-thon started after Chattanooga Times Free Press reporter Sarah Grace Taylor requested to examine the requests to see if the county’s policies for releasing materials were arbitrary. Originally, the county asked for $717 for about 1,500 pages of records, which Taylor declined to pay in favor of inspecting the records herself. But as negotiations to view the records commenced, records coordinator Dana Beltramo requested and received permission to update their retention policy to just 30 days for records requests. After Taylor’s continued reporting on the issue sparked an outcry, the county revised its policy once again and promised to do better. “What we did today was basically try to prevent the confusion of mistakes that have happened from happening again,” said Hamilton County Mayor Jim Coppinger. In other words, it’s all just a big misunderstanding.
THE HANDCUFFS AND PRIOR RESTRAINTS AWARD
Chicago Police Department and City of Chicago, Illinois In February 2019, a swarm of Chicago police officers raided the wrong apartment with their guns drawn. They handcuffed the resident, Anjanette Young, who was completely undressed, and they refused to let her put on clothes as she pleaded with them dozens of times that they had the
wrong house. Young sued the city in federal court and filed a request for body camera footage of the officers who invaded her home. The local CBS affiliate, CBS 2, also requested the body camera footage. The Chicago Police Department denied both requests, despite a binding ruling just months earlier that CPD was required to turn over body camera footage to people like Young who were involved in the recorded events. Young ultimately got the footage as part of her lawsuit, and her attorney provided them to the media. The city’s lawyers then took the extraordinary step of asking the court to order CBS 2 not to air the video, a demand to censor speech before it occurs called a “prior restraint.” The judge denied the city’s request. The city also sought sanctions against Young’s attorney, but the city withdrew its motion and Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot called the request “ill-advised” in a letter to the court. The judge decided not to sanction Young’s attorney.
THE THIN CRUST, WOOD-FIRED REDACTIONS AWARD US State Department
Former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo hosted plenty of controversial meals during his three-year tenure. There was the indoor holiday party last December and those bizarre, lavish “Madison Dinners” that cost taxpayers tens of thousands of dollars, including more than $10K for embossed pens alone. And while we know the full menu of Pompeo’s high-class North Korea summit in 2018 in Manhattan—filet mignon with corn purée was the centerpiece—the public may never find out two searing culinary questions about Mikey: What are his pizza toppings of choice, and what’s his go-to sandwich? On the pizza angle, the State Department let slip that Pompeo likes it thin and wood-fired, in emails released to NBC correspondent Josh Lederman. But the list of toppings was far too saucy for public consumption, apparently, and redacted on privacy grounds. Same for Pompeo’s sandwich of choice, which the State Department redacted from emails released to American Oversight. But we still know “plenty of dry snacks and Diet Coke” were on offer.
THE REDACTION MOST LIKELY TO MAKE YOUR BUBBE WEEP Federal Aviation Administration
When General Atomics proposed flying a new class of drone over the San Diego region to demonstrate its domestic sur-
COURTESY THE ELECTRO NIC FRONTIER FOUNDAT ION AND MUCKRO CK NEWS
the same people processing public records (they’re not). She continued: “I think for those people who are scared to death about this virus, who are worried every single day that it’s going to come to their doorstep, and I’m mindful of the fact that we’re in the Pesach season, the angel of death that we all talk about is the Passover story, that angel of death is right here in our midst every single day.” We’d just note that transparency is crucial to ensuring that the government’s response to COVID is both effective and equitable. And if ancient Egyptians had the power to FOIA the Pharaoh for communications with Moses and Aaron, perhaps they probably would have avoided all 10 plagues—blood, frogs and all.
The Federal Aviation Administration left just the greeting behind in this document, dubbed “The Redaction Most Likely to Make Your Bubbe Weep.”
veillance capabilities, Voice of San Diego Reporter Jesse Marx obviously wanted to learn how it possibly could have been approved. So he filed a FOIA request with the Federal Aviation Administration, and ultimately a lawsuit to liberate documentation. Among the records he received was an email containing a “little vent” from an FAA worker that began with “Oy vey” and then virtually everything else, including the employee’s four bullet-pointed “genuinely constructive thoughts,” were redacted.
THE SELF-SERVING SECRECY AWARD Niagara County, New York
Money talks. The New York legislature knew this when it passed the Ethics in Government Act in 1987, which required, among other public transparency measures, elected officials in 50,000 person-plus municipalities to complete financial disclosure forms each year. The public should be allowed to know who our leaders may be particularly keen to hear. Sixty-one of NY’s 62 counties generally accepted that the disclosure forms, created for public use in the first place, were meant to be disclosed, according to the New York Coalition for Open Government. Back in 1996, though, while everyone was presumably distracted watching the Yankees or Independence
Day, Niagara County found a quick trick to keep from sharing its officials’ finances: They made it illegal. By local ordinance, the records were made secret, and the county proceeded to reject any requests for access by claiming that releasing the information would be a violation of the law. This local law prohibiting access was itself, of course, a violation of the law, but Niagara County managed to keep it on the books for more than two decades, and it may have gotten away with it had it not been for the work of the NY Coalition for Open Government. In February 2020, the NYCOG, represented by the University of Buffalo School of Law Civil Rights & Transparency Clinic, sued Niagara County, alleging its ordinance was unlawful (because it was). This past fall, a court agreed. Five months later, in January 2021, the county began releasing records, ones that should have been available for the last 30+ years. The Foilies were compiled by Electronic Frontier Foundation Director of Investigations Dave Maass, Senior Staff Attorney Aaron Mackey, Frank Stanton Fellow Naomi Gilens, MuckRock News Co-Founder Michael Morisy, and Senior Reporter and Projects Editor Beryl Lipton, with further writing and editing by Shawn Musgrave. Illustrations are by EFF Designer Caitlyn Crites. Creative Commons Attribution - EFF/Muckrock News.
SFREPORTER.COM
•
MARCH 17-23, 2021
15
Friends OF THE REPORTER Friends OF THE REPORTER
N I W cklace!
e n s i th
THEIR FUTURE IS IN YOUR HANDS With the pandemic still raging across the country, the Santa Fe Animal Shelter has worked harder than ever to ensure thousands of lost, injured, abandoned, and homeless animals continue to receive the care they need and deserve. WILL YOU SUPPORT BRIGHTER FUTURES FOR HOMELESS ANIMALS IN NORTHERN NEW MEXICO AND BEYOND?
GIVE TODAY AT SFHUMANESOCIETY.ORG 100 CAJA DEL RIO RD • SANTA FE, NM 87507
Donate to FRIENDS OF THE REPORTER before MARCH 31 and get a chance to win this necklace from JANE HRUSKA ACCESSORIES. Every month, learn about a new giveaway just for our FRIENDS.
Support us at:
sfreporter.com/friends PO Box 4910, Santa Fe, NM 87502
16
MARCH 17-23, 2021
•
SFREPORTER.COM
OK, so we’re biased when it comes to press freedom, but we’d also point out that even in a country where a former president openly declared war on journalists, it’s much easier to do the job here than in countless countries around the world. In an upcoming panel hosted by the Human Rights Foundation, meet activist, blogger, and close friend of slain Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi, Omar Abdulaziz; documentarian Bryan Fogel; Al Jazeera journalist Ghada Oueiss; and the Committee to Protect Journalists’ Senior Africa Researcher Jonathan Rozen. Learn why taking journalism for granted is never the answer, and why you should probably send cookies to the people in your community doing the work. (ADV) An Invisible Threat: Press Freedom the Dangers of Spyware: Noon Thursday, March 18. Free. crowdcast.io/e/an-invisible-threat/register
COURTESY SANTAFESCHOOLOFCOOKING.COM
ONLINE WORKSHOP SAT/20 HOT STUFF Yeah, yeah, yeah—we’ve all picked up new skills during the pandemic, because what the hell else were we doing? Still, when it comes to something like cooking up that good New Mexcian food, there’s never enough knowledge. Enter the Santa Fe School of Cooking, which continues its slate of online classes in, well, all kinds of things. This week, the goal is traditional New Mexican food, and the class covers flour tortillas, carne adovada chile rellenos, calabacitas refritos and sopaipillas. At $82 a person, it might sound a little steep, but it’s a three-hour class. Besides, can you put a price tag on learning how to make the best stuff from the best regional cuisine anyplace? We think you can’t. (ADV) Traditional New Mexican Cooking with Santa Fe School of Cooking: 10 am Saturday, March 20. $82. santafeschoolofcooking.com
COURTESY INTERNATIONAL FOLK ART MARKET
ONLINE EVENT SUN/21 SNEAK PEEK While the Santa Fe summer market season barrels toward what’s looking more and more like an in-person series of events, the International Folk Art Market is still keeping its online offerings robust. This weekend, that comes in the form of a bid-free preview of its upcoming Spring Auction. We want to be clear this is a virtual thing and that the actual bidding doesn’t open until next week, but for those who’d like to earmark some amazing painting or learn more about the scads of artists scheduled to appear in one form or another this year, it’ll work like some kind of visual arts amuse bouche. Remember to be patient and cool and that if you do end up buying something next week, you’re directly supporting people who rely on markets just like IFAM. (ADV) IFAM Spring Auction Preview: 10 am-7 pm Sunday, March 21. Free. folkartmarket.org
COURTESY WHEELWRIGHT MUSEUM
SFR FILE PHOTO
FREEDOM OF THE PRESS
DIGITAL-ISH
SFRE PO RTE R .CO M /ARTS/ S FR P I C KS
ONLINE LECTURE THU/18
ONLINE ART OPENING FRI/19
Over the Borderline Wheelwright looks at the borderlands through the eyes of contemporary women artists The Wheelwright Museum of the American Indian’s Chief Curator Andrea Hanley has had her eye on artists Makaye Lewis (Tohono O’odham), Daisy Quezada Ureña (Mexican-American), M. Jenea Sanchez (Latinx), and Gabriela Muñoz (Latinx) for some time. “These are artists I’ve been watching since some were in school,” Hanley tells SFR. “They’re all powerhouses.” It’s why she jumped at a chance to feature all four in the upcoming exhibit Indigenous Women: Border Matters, a show built around them specifically, that simply couldn’t be derailed by COVID-19, and that examines issues faced by women of color who live, work and exist near the US/Mexico border. “They’ve thoughtfully addressed, I think, ways that are both very personal and very far-reaching,” Hanley explains. “They’re connecting and inspiring people who maybe don’t understand or don’t witness the uncertainties faced by a lot of women of color today.” This, of course, comes in many forms. Quezada Ureña’s porcelain garments, for example, reach a level of stunning detail while illustrating the histories of bodies on the move. When applied to the concept of crossing borders—be it the folks who do it regularly, or those in search of something better or different—the tone feels somber, even chilling.
Lewis’ linocut prints wow as well with bright yellows that subtly conceal more intense themes, some of which emerge within an instant. Others take a longer look. Elsewhere in the show, portraits by Muñoz eschew photo-realism for overall feel (you’ll be shocked by the emotion she conveys without erring into the overwrought), and a collaboration between Muñoz and Sanchez—similar portraits created on stacked adobe bricks—conjures reminders of building and tradition, but also impermanence, fragility and power. “These women are looking at ways to talk about equity and human rights for women of color,” Hanley adds. “It just shows how many women around the world try to contribute to the well-being of their communities, their sisters, their friends. That’s a really great thing.” Border Matters opens with a virtual event this Friday, which includes pre-recorded remarks from newly minted Secretary of the Interior Deb Haaland (Laguna Pueblo) and US Rep. Teresa Leger Fernandez. The show opens for in-person visits this Saturday. (Alex De Vore) INDIGENOUS WOMEN: BORDER MATTERS OPENING 6 pm Friday, March 19. Free. wheelwright.org
SFREPORTER.COM
•
MARCH 17-23, 2021
17
A&C
The Sound of Music Education
While basic Zoom limitations abound, remote learning lets teachers hear their students better
Choir director Marilyn Barnes warms up her students, in-person and virtual, through humming exercises.
BY WILLIAM MELHADO w i l l i a m @ s f r e p o r t e r. c o m
T
hree weeks ago, Marilyn Barnes invited a student to the choir room and received a response that would have been shocking in the prepandemic world. “I don’t know where the choir room is,” the student told Barnes, director of choir and musical theater at Santa Fe High School. For new students, late February marked the first time they set foot in the building. “It’s like, wow, she’s been in choir for seven months but she doesn’t know the choir room,” Barnes tells SFR. “Most students who come into that program spend hours there every day.” The state expects schools to return to in-person learning in just over two weeks, and the partial return of music programming has teachers exuberant to perform with students again. With full reentry on the horizon, the end of online learning—a difficult proposition for all students and teachers, but especially so in music—nears. The Public Education Department issued guidance on resuming music programming last week, requiring coverings for wind instruments, masks for singers and outdoor-only practices. “We’re a little set back that they require it to be outside,” Maurice Howard, band director at El Dorado Community School, tells SFR. But “we’re appreciative that they’ve included us.” 18
MARCH 17-23, 2021
•
Before limited in-person music instruction resumed, the past year of online voice and instrument lessons faced challenges given the basic constraints of video conferencing. Despite poor sound quality and the dreaded Zoom lag, art educators discovered notes of clarity in their interactions with students. “It helps develop empathy in the teacher,” explains Bo Rogers, an elementary music teacher from Aspen Community School. “I know there’s some teachers who are like, ‘Argh that kid, I can’t stand that kid.’ But then you look in their house…” Having a greater understanding of students’ lives outside the classroom allows school staff to make more informed decisions when working with vulnerable young people, Rogers says. During normal times, music educators open doors to creative opportunities for their students—a crucial service. With the restrictions of online learning imposed on Barnes and her colleagues across the district, they were forced to substitute virtual performances for the real deal. “We did Disney Movie Magic this year and it’s going to be presented on March 27. And that was just hell,” Barnes says, laughing with exasperation over the amount of work it took to arrange solos and medleys, let alone corral the students to record their parts. For the school’s production of Schoolhouse Rock!, Barnes had each student visit the theater individually. Reed Meschefske, head of theater at SFHS, recorded each child’s part while Barnes sang
SFREPORTER.COM
all the other accompanying vocals—all while socially distanced. Their hard work is paying off. “I was very, very pleased with the performing arts program we have here because the theater still put on every show,” Joseph Romero-Kleve, a senior at Santa Fe High School, tells SFR. “Although it’s not traditional and not favorable, it’s still something.” Administrators also recognize the effort. “I feel like the teachers are being super hard on themselves,” says April Pickrell, the district’s music coordinator. “But they are reaching the students. I keep reminding them that there’s been kids that don’t go to any other classes, but they come to their music class.” By providing students technology at the onset of virtual learning, teachers say the district avoided a catastrophe. Online curricula adopted by elementary music teachers prior to the pandemic also helped soften the blow, Rogers tells SFR. But the Chromebooks every student received, while suitable for watching videos and joining virtual lessons, limit students’ capabilities to perform together. “The bandwidth does not yet exist to have that kind of situation happening with multiple users,” explains Rogers. Teaching proper embouchure and positioning remains one of the biggest challenges for music educators, Pickrell explains.“The camera angle has to be just right in order to see if they have the wrong hand position or if they have improper
S FR E P O RTE R .CO M / ARTS
posture,” she says. “It’s very detailed to make the kids successful and it’s harder to see online and to correct.” Student performances aired during the biweekly virtual school board meetings gave the public a glimpse into music teachers’ challenging work. The seemingly impossible task of manipulating a pupil’s posture through a computer screen means these emerging musicians are largely learning independently. And though there are challenges that come with the heightened visibility of students’ home environments, it has helped teachers develop a deeper understanding. “You see more, you know more,” Rogers says. One result will be a stronger teaching force that went through hell and back with their students. “I really appreciate teaching now,” he adds. As schools continue to shift toward something more recognizable, they must now make decisions about what to prioritize. “It makes perfect sense when we look at at-risk kids, when we look at poverty, when we look at lost learning, the arts is the perfect way to excite learning again, to engage,” Rep. Roger Montoya, D-Española, says of arts education. Montoya hopes to welcome students back and support arts education with House Bill 138. His work as an arts educator began in 1998 with Velarde Elementary School and grew into founding Moving Arts Española, which provided fine arts programming for 13 schools. The nationally recognized nonprofit received funding from the 2003 Fine Arts Education Act to reach students, convincing Montoya of the importance of supporting arts education. HB 138 would allocate almost $3 million for fine arts programming by giving fine arts a slightly larger share of schools’ programming budget. The money would restore funding lost in an unintended consequence of 2018 legislation, which defunded schools’ K-6 fine arts programs by the same amount. Santa Fe schools lost out on about $127,000. This funding could be coming to music and art classrooms next year if the Senate follows the House’s lead by passing HB 138 in the final days of the Legislature. At presstime, it was assigned to the Senate Finance Committee. For students returning to school in just over two weeks, teachers expect an emotional reunion. Rogers knows students will need support to process their feelings from the past year and music educators are ready to welcome their pupils back. “We deal with matters of the heart,” Rogers says, “so often it’s easier for kids to let that show.”
S FR E P O RTE R .CO M / FO O D
Smokin’ Up Rufina Street also became a completely self-taught chef. “I was getting to a point in my music career when I didn’t see a whole lot of savings in my future,” Thom tells SFR. “When I first said I wanted to open [a barbecue business], my wife must’ve thought BY RILEY GARDNER I was crazy.” a u t h o r @ s f r e p o r t e r. c o m Uncle DT’s is a hole in the wall if et’s start with a caveat: When you there ever was one. A former industrial come of age in the South, as I did, space turned mom-and-pop, it’s where you wind up spoiled by barbecue. you’ll find a cooler outside where you Very quickly one can determine whether pick up your food (not on ice—merely to something was smoked using charcoal or keep things insulated and contact-free) mesquite or oak. Outside of barbecue and a charming, down-to-Earth feel. country (which, I feel inclined to say, does Right off the bat, the space and locanot include your dad’s backyard), little tion nail it. Food-wise, things were more else compares. It’s a difficult culinary skill hit-and-miss. to do well, let alone master. We ordered the Big Boy ($10.99), an Back here in Santa Fe, Uncle affordable sandwich for one that holds a DT’s Smokehouse (3134 Rufina St., half-pound of rib meat. Fair warning— 707-337-5641; uncledt.com) is self- here’s where the snobbery begins. The described as “Texas-style beef and rib meat was perhaps a little overcooked. Carolina-style pork,” and in addition Though generous in size, it to plates, entrees, sandwiches and could’ve used a touch more sides, there’s an option to buy meat in smokiness and a bit more simmer-ready bags that can stay fro- of a zing. Rib meat is a zen up to two years. Originally working killer challenge, and out of a commercial kitchen starting in even barbecue 2018, owner David Thom expanded to chefs in the know Rufina Street in January of 2020—just in are known to time for COVID-19! But he’s been able to struggle. A touch stay strong and develop a rotating selec- more of the tion of specials, holiday briskets, turkeys sweet, a bit more and even pies. of the smoke, and Thom might be better known to some the sandwich would’ve as a bluegrass musician who swung later kicked ass. But then, this in life to the barbecue pit. He still plays is a preference thing, and with Kitty Joe Creek alongside local leg- Thom doesn’t use sugars in end Bill Hearne, but while he was laying his rubs. His f avorite option? down those sweet acoustic melodies, he “The brisket is what we’re
Uncle DT’s Smokehouse gets points for an unpretentious vibe
L
1330 Rufina Circle P: 505.231.7775 Monday - Saturday 10 am - 6 pm
known for,” he says. “But more times than not, I go for the pulled pork.” I prefer the sweeter types of barbecue myself. Flavors like smoked maple and brown sugar really work for me, so there is a good chance my palate didn’t mesh well with DT’s particular brand. But that’s not to say it won’t work for others. If there is anything to outright criticize, it would be that some of the food was a mite too dry, from the cornbread ($3.99 a slice, somewhat high for the small-ish serving) to the spare ribs ($6.98). But hey, the atmosphere, ease of ordering and casual feel makes up for most shortcomings. Besides, barbecue is a fickle beast and can change from day to day and dish to dish.
At the very least, you know you’ll get a big enough portion when you visit Uncle DT’s Smokehouse.
Your CBD Wellness Experts 2020
Enhance Your Health and Wellbeing through Hemp, Herbs and Essential Oils
Free Consultations No One Knows Our Products Better No Medical Card Needed Open to All! Locally Woman Owned & Operated Free Easy Parking
Hempapotheke.com
Aromaland.com
Now carrying
HOST DEFENSE medicinal mushroom
FOOD
For example, we also sampled the Old Pecos smoked chicken ($13.99). A paprikabased rub makes up the bulk of the flavor profile, and Thom cooked the chicken so well, it ended up being our favorite dish. On the sides front, classic options like cowboy baked beans and coleslaw, here known as Cousin Vicki’s Killer Slaw, added robust touches. A little extra sweetness might have made the slaw more pleasing, too, and its satisfyingly crispy texture was tempered by a turn too far into the vinegary side. The beans were wonderfully spicy and properly baked, however, and never overpowering. Some barbecue joints can go a little wild with their baked beans (they know who they are), and my only wish is that the serving had been larger—alas, the limitations of to-go dining. If you lean more into the tangier side of barbecue, DT’s would make a wonderful take-out or picnic option as we head into spring. Kids will certainly appreciate the sandwiches, and adults can get into the more sophisticated items, like the Pojoaque Pork Spare Ribs ($18.99 half rack, $28.99 full rack) or the smoked brisket plate ($18.99). Regardless, there is evident potential, and I can’t say enough good things about Uncle DT’s downhome feel. Food wrapped in foil, good serving sides and potato chips shoved into the corner of the container? Those are all pure summer vibes available four days a week (11 am-2 pm and 5-8pm, Wednesday-Saturday). For the barbecue snobs—be aware. It can be hard to satisfy us, but one can’t ignore DT’s unpretentious vibe and killer location in a flourishing part of town.
Santa Fe’s Largest Range of CBD Brands • CBD Tinctures • CBD Vape • CBD Pet Care • CBD Topicals • CBD Edibles • CBD Bath • CBD Infused Skin Care • CBD Nano Technology • Herbal Detox Formulas • Hush Kratom • Fortifying Mushrooms & Much More... All Products Third Party Tested Contaminant Free!
Since 1986
Santa Fe’s Largest Selection of Terpene-Rich Essential Oils All Essential Oil Bath & Beauty Products available in Gallon Sizes at Wholesale Prices!
Don’t miss out! HELP US CONTRIBUTE TO A SUSTAINABLE PLANET!
SFREPORTER.COM
•
MARCH 17-23, 2021
19
RATINGS BEST MOVIE EVER
The Vigil Review Director Keith Thomas’ debut brings Jewish ghost lore to the mainstream
10 9 8
You can delve into any culture on the planet and find a rich canon of ghost and demon lore, but there’s something that hits deeper about the ancient ones. In director Keith Thomas’ debut The Vigil, we catch a glimpse into the Jewish concept of mazzikim—what we might call a mid-tier ghost or demon that, within the confines of the film, feeds off the pain of mortals. There’s more to unpack there as far as the real-world lore goes, but here we just know the entity is malevolent. We join Yakov (Dave Davis), a young Jewish man who left a more devout lifestyle and community following tragic events. He struggles with money and mental health, so when someone from his old life shows up with $500 and asks him to perform shomer duties (a Jewish tradition whereupon someone must sit with a newly dead body through the first night following the death to protect a departing soul from evil forces). Yakov reluctantly agrees, but creepy stuff ensues as something begins stalking him, toying with his mental illness and forcing him to question his own sanity and beliefs.
6 5 4 3 2 1 WORST MOVIE EVER
BREAKING NEWS IN YUBA COUNTY ++ FUNNY; COMPLICATED IN A GOOD WAY
-- CLIMAX FEELS HASTY
By the time we join Breaking News in Yuba County’s Sue Buttons (Allison Janney), she’s having a pretty rough day. It’s her birthday, her coworkers forgot, the cake she was forced to buy herself reads “Happy Birthday Suc!” and her husband Karl (Matthew Modine), a banker, is on the phone with some mysterious woman who asks if he’s stroking his cock right now. He isn’t—not in that moment —but he’s still a scumbag. Sue feels overlooked, unappreciated, unimportant. Those feelings fester. Elsewhere, Karl’s brother Petey (Westworld’s Jimmi Simpson) attempts to leave a life of crime behind following news that his live-in girlfriend (Samira Wiley) is pregnant with twins. The bored but funny business owner who hired him (Wanda Sykes) needles Petey about forming a crime partnership, while the mobbed-up Mina (Akwafina) pressures him to get Karl to launder money. Still with us? OK. It’s complicated, but director Tate Taylor (The Help) so masterfully and gradually sets up the powder keg that when the disparate storylines and characters clash together in a violent but hilarious ballet of misconceptions, misunderstandings and missed opportunities, it’s almost perfect. Karl suddenly disappears, which thrusts Sue into the high-profile world of press conferences and local news appearances courtesy of some twee human interest reporter (Juliette Lewis) and Sue’s own sister (Mila Kunis), a lesser journo. Janney nails it as the put-upon wife finally getting some attention—even if it’s bad attention. She knows what really happened to Karl, but isn’t spilling so long as the camera crews keep turning up. Eventually, she starts to believe her own lies just as the peripheral mad20
MARCH 17-23, 2021
•
7 ++ PRETTY SCARY;
BY ALEX DE VORE a l e x @ s f r e p o r t e r. c o m
7
7
MOVIES FRESH IN PLACES -- BEWILDERING CLIMAX; STALE IN OTHER PLACES
The Vigil scores major points in the lighting, pacing and atmosphere departments. Much of the film takes place in one living room. The house, where the deceased Rubin Litvak (Ronald Cohen) lived with his wife (Lynn Cohen), is oppressively dark and unsettling, and numerous lamps fail to cast light beyond their own immediate vicinity. It seems Rubin may have brought something with him back from the Buchenwald concentration camp following WWII, and Mrs. Litvak roaming the halls and popping up now and again doesn’t help. Somehow worse, the being begins assuming the voice or appearance of those Yakov trusts and tries to reach by phone for help. No, thanks. Davis is a wonder in the darkness, all pins and needles and pained expressions driven not only by the imminent ghost peril, but haunted by the tragedy which shook his faith (no spoilers). Carrying a film on one’s own is hard work, doing it with minimal dialogue seems even harder. And so it goes,
ness topples in on all the central players. From there, Yuba County starts to lose its momentum. Regina King sings as the dogged detective convinced Sue is hiding something, though her screen time is sadly limited. Ellen Barkin’s in the mix, too, but barely—and, in the end, one wonders why Janney or Akwafina aren’t in every single scene even if Simpson has often proved a capable and funny performer and doesn’t disappoint here. Still, the ending feels rushed and shoehorned with a lot of dark ideas that didn’t quite fit elsewhere in the complex plot. From a relatively new writer like Amanda Idoko, though, Yuba County feels like a big breakthrough. Surely her next film’s narrative will feel even more refined, and this one is so fun to watch, its shortcomings feel far less important than its many strengths. (Alex De Vore) Amazon, R, 96 min.
LUCKY
5
++ RESPONDS TO A MAJOR ISSUE -- INCONSISTENT DIRECTION; CINEMATOGRAPHY SEEMS DISCONNECTED
It’s a bumpy road until Lucky finds its groove. When it does, though, there’s far more to admire in what it wants to be rather than what it actually becomes. Like a mash-up of Get Out and Promising Young Woman, Lucky plants a flag in a gray area where passion drives the writing, but nothing seems to guide everything else. May (Brea Grant, who also penned the script) is a self-help author who encourages women to go it alone on their paths to success. Her days are filled with book signings and publishing meetings, but her nights are ripped from nightmares. When darkness falls, a masked man enters her home and tries to kill her. Every time, she takes him down—only to have him vanish moments later. Her
SFREPORTER.COM
with Yakov jumping at each new discovery that appears throughout the longest night ever and Davis’ masterful performance keeping us rapt. As debuts go, Thomas excels in most areas. There’s a high bar of entry here for those unfamiliar with Jewish traditions or stories—and even for those with a passing knowledge. It would have been nice to dig deeper into those ideas, though perhaps there’s something to be said about the thing you don’t know being the scariest thing of all. Still, the language of scares is fairly universal, and The Vigil’s most intense moments are almost always its most unique. Here’s hoping Thomas keeps going with horror and here’s hoping any fans of the genre don’t skip this one, even if it’s not the scariest movie ever.
circle of friends describe her as “lucky” to survive, acknowledging her terror but always brushing it off like brunch gossip. Lucky isn’t so much about the home invasions as it is about how others react. Such films are some of the best within horror genre nowadays; evolving from torture porn (sorry, Saw fans) to metaphors about the terrors that already exist in our society. Lucky isn’t technically impressive, but it never feels like a gimmick, despite the repetitiveness of May’s nightly battles. Grant’s script is heavy with the critiques about society’s responses to male violence against women, while director Natasha Kermani (Imitation Girl) leans too heavily on the screenplay’s content. Lucky‘s pacing is grating, the blocking dull—the actors often stand in the frame and don’t budge. Grant’s performance is also deadly serious while the other performers go for camp. Could that have created an effective contrast? Yes, but it’s hard to detect any noticeable tone that would’ve made that aspect worthwhile. Outside of the technicalities, Lucky‘s smartest plays are the metaphors. Preachy? Sure, but an audience needs a brimstone sermon every now and again. Too bad it feels so cheap. (Riley Gardner) Shudder, NR, 83 min.
TOM AND JERRY
2
++ MERCIFULLY ENDS -- UGLY AND LOUD; THE DUO DON’T EVEN DRIVE THE PLOT
I laughed twice during the 101 minute runtime of Tom and Jerry: Once in disbelief over the rapping pigeons who open the film with a version of A Tribe Called Quest’s “Can I Kick It?” in borderline racist Dumbo crow fashion, and the other when a character admitted to committing white collar crime. Ugh. But then, this isn’t the first time we’ve been
THE VIGIL Directed by Thomas With Davis and Cohen Amazon, PG-13, 89 min.
burned by the angry animated cat and his outrageously violent mouse frenemy. In 1992, Tom and Jerry: The Movie released. It broke the cardinal sins of having the two speak and relegating them to the background—this iteration repeats the terrible, horrible, no good, very bad idea of giving r eal-life humans Chloë Grace Moretz and Michael Peña (neither of whom are bad a ctors, but who have the charisma of sandpaper here) the main story and pushing the animated stars to the side. How, Kevin Costello, did you write this? And why? You can try to hide behind writing creds for William Hanna and Joseph Barbera on IMDb, but we still know what you did. It’s especially alarming given that your 2017 film Brigsby Bear at least had a cool central idea (look it up). In Tom and Jerry, though, there’s a “how do you do, fellow kids?” tone throughout, especially in its constant and painful rap jamz. See also an electric scooter chase, Tom and Jerry drinking booze, thinking in emojis and setting up an Instagram page together; dialogue is mainly complaints about millennials; Colin Jost’s prehistoric jawline is present. We might argue kids are easily entertained, but here’s the thing—we can’t say Tom and Jerry is actually for kids. It requires knowledge of economic angst, Gen-Z humor, media criticism and even Bollywood to grasp the basic movements of the plot. In the end, Tom and Jerry isn’t bad because it’s a derivative property. It’s bad because it’s disingenuous and has no interest in entertaining kids. It feels like a dad trying to hang out with his kid’s college-aged friends. Your children will hate you if you try to pass this off on them, and they should. Oh, and don’t think we don’t see you, director Tim Story. You made Barbershop, man…shouldn’t you know better? Maybe cinema should die after all. (RG) HBO Max, PG, 101 min.
SFR CLASSIFIEDS 2 Ways to Book Your Ad!
JONESIN’ CROSSWORD by Matt Jones
CALL FELINES & FRIENDS
Pres t
36
44 46 51
52
53
54
56
59
58 61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
57 Serious symptom of a cold, maybe 1 Texting format 59 Quadruped up in the sky? 4 Iran’s leader, once 60 ___-Bissau (African country) 8 Counts with margins of error 61 Actor shown in “One does 13 Deviation in a rocket’s course not simply ...” memes 14 Prefix meaning “end” 63 Nod, e.g. 15 Prove to be successful 64 “At Last” singer James 16 Winter road clearer 65 Tree on Connecticut’s quarter 18 Purport 66 Negatives from Nijinsky 19 D&D enemy 67 Holder of many a merit badge 20 Grass cutter that might 68 Toots and the Maytals genre use a battery DOWN 22 Feeling of guilt 23 Used up 1 Early online admin 24 The “A” in PTA, for short 2 Genre for “One-Punch Man” 25 Test that might be “open” 3 Given an oath, with “in” 27 Composer ___ Carlo Menotti 4 Longtime NASCAR sponsor 29 Acquire a second time 5 Assists, as with entering a 34 Mountain Dew energy drink tall pickup truck 37 First name in fabric stores 6 Knocked for ___ 38 Made a pit 7 “This Is ___ Do It” (Montell 39 Fu Mingxia, for one Jordan hit) 41 Boston team, for short 8 It’s good for at least a few dates 42 Group in Santa Fe or 9 Checked out for a bit Sacramento 10 Chain that merged with 45 “Switched-On Bach” synthesizer AMC Theatres 46 “Mr. Robot” network 11 Equipment used in Winter 47 “Quantum of Solace” Olympics actress Kurylenko 12 Back of a yacht 50 Rice wine used in 15 Title ender of a 1974 film that Japanese cooking distinguishes it from an earlier 53 Hard work Best Picture Oscar winner
www.FandFnm.org
FOSTER HOMES URGENTLY NEEDED FOR ADULT CATS OF VARIOUS AGES
60
ACROSS
55
17 Photographer William who depicts Weimaraners with human hands 21 Keep occupied 26 Old detergent brand that used to sponsor radio shows 28 Lake Titicaca’s locale 29 Morning beverages, informally 30 Rude sound from a spectator 31 Invoice add-on 32 Samuel Barber’s “___ for Strings” 33 Clean out completely, as a building 34 “Selma” director DuVernay 35 Ran into 36 Cautionary beginning? 40 Place for a nursery rhyme trio 43 Garfield, for one 44 Gardening headwear 45 Fridge ornament 47 Hammond B-3, notably 48 Pretty dang bad 49 False front 51 Deceptive ploys 52 “___ Kick Out of You” 54 Cookies with a recent Lady Gaga-themed variety 55 “Wicked Game” singer Chris 56 Sri ___ 58 “... three French ___ ...” 62 “Yeah, probably not”
SANTA FE CATS not only supports the mission of FELINES & FRIENDS from revenue generated by providing premium boarding for cats, pocket pets and birds, but also serves as a mini-shelter for cats awaiting adoption. For more information, please visit www.santafecats.com
The Forest Service intends to cut most of the trees on 21,000 acres and then burn 43,000 acres, repeatedly, in the Resiliency Project, from Tesuque to Glorietta. Get the facts!
OnceAForest.org URGENT! Save our forests! Only we can stop this! Call your elected officials today. CROSSWORD PUZZLE SPONSORED BY:
NEW ARRIVALS! THE SOUL OF A WOMAN by Isabel Allende Hardcover, Non-Fiction $22.99 WEATHER by Jenny Offill Softcover, Fiction $16.00
202 GALISTEO STREET 505.988 . 4226 CWBOOK STORE .COM
SOLUTION
S T E R N
50
L U G E S
49
L O E W S
45
Lots of kittens available for adoption! If you are interested, please fill out an application on our website:
H O W W E
43
40
A M P V E R A T E
42
39
G U T
38
57
35
S M S Y A W S N O W O G R E P A N G M O B T A J O A N S O X
33
L A N K A
32
I S A A K
31
28
O R E O S
27
P O A N L L M O A A N N D I E N S A T U N B A H
26
37
48
34
24
RETA delivered her 5 kittens only a few days before the family was transferred to F&F from a shelter in southern NM, where they were facing euthanasia for space. All of her kittens have found homes and now it is her turn. RETA is a little shy at first but is warming up nicely to attention from volunteers She gets along well with other cats and is very playful. She would do best in a home without dogs or young children, but does get along well with other cats. RETA is a petite girl that is approximately 1.5 years old. She is available for viewing by appointment.
P A E R N T G I A I G E S U N H A T S
23
21
SNOWSHOES is a gorgeous Snowshoe Siamese senior male kitty, who came to us previously declawed. He was taken in by his previous owner as a feral kitten 10 years ago and lived his whole life with her. His owner moved into assisted living and SNOWSHOES spent several weeks alone in his home, until F&F brought him into our care. He is very nervous and shy, but once he feels safe, he is a sweet boy. SNOWSHOES is looking for a patient adopter, or foster, to give him a chance at a quiet home. It may take a few months for him to adjust, but with patience he will come around. He is available for viewing by appointment.
I G E T A
22
47
12
R U S E S
20
41
11
18
19
30
10
15
17
25
9
S H A T E L P L O P O S P R I I N A D N S T A O O G M I H C O E A N T S
8
M A G N E T
7
14
16
29
6
G U I S E
13
5
L O U S Y
4
O R G A N
3
316-2281
AT
City of Santa Fe Permit #21-005
on
POWERED BY 2
EMAIL: Robyn@SFReporter.com
BE MY FUR-EVER FRIEND!
“Not Quite!”—looks can be deceiving.
1
CALL: 505.988.5541
© COPYRIGHT 2021 JONESIN’ CROSSWORDS (EDITOR@JONESINCROSSWORDS.COM)
SFREPORTER.COM
•
MARCH 17-23, 2021
21
SFR CLASSIFIEDS 2 Ways to Book Your Ad!
CALL: 505.988.5541
EMAIL: Robyn@SFReporter.com
MIND BODY SPIRIT MIND BODY SPIRIT
ACUPUNCTURE Rob Brezsny
Week of March 17th
ARIES (March 21-April 19): Poet Ocean Vuong speaks of the Hawaiian word kipuka. It refers to a patch of earth that doesn’t get covered with lava when an active volcano exudes its molten material. “Before the lava descended,” Vuong writes, “that piece of land was insignificant, just another scrap in an endless mass of green.” But now that piece of land is special, having endured. I encourage you to identify your metaphorical equivalent of kipuka, Aries. It’s an excellent time to celebrate the power and luck and resilience that have enabled you to persevere.
LIBRA (Sept. 23-Oct. 22): “A balance that does not tremble cannot weigh. A person who does not oscillate cannot live.” So wrote biochemist Erwin Chargaff, who did crucial research leading to the discovery of DNA’s double helix structure. Since you’re the zodiac’s expert on balance and oscillation, and because these themes will be especially meaningful for you in the coming days, I’ll ask you to meditate on them with extra focus. Here’s my advice: To be healthy and resilient, you need to be aware of other possibilities besides those that seem obvious and simple and absolutely true. You need to consider the likelihood that the most correct answers are almost certainly those that are paradoxical and complicated and full of nuance.
TAURUS (April 20-May 20): “Extraordinary things are always hiding in places people never think to look,” writes Taurus author Jodi Picoult. Luckily for you, Taurus, in the near future you’ll be prone to look in exactly those places—where no one else has thought to look. That means you’ll be extra likely to find useful, interesting, even extraordinary things that have mostly been hidden and unused. You may also discover some boring and worthless things, but the trade-off will be worth your effort. Congratulations in advance on summoning such brave curiosity. GEMINI (May 21-June 20): “When we ask for advice, we are usually looking for an accomplice,” said Gemini author Saul Bellow. So if you have come here today to read my horoscopes, it’s possible that you’re seeking an accomplice to approve of you making a decision or a move that you have already decided to do. OK. I’ll be your accomplice. But as your accomplice, the first thing I’ll do is try to influence you to make sure your upcoming actions serve not only your own selfish interests (although there’s nothing wrong with that), but also serve the interests of people you care for. The weeks ahead will be a favorable time to blend self-interest and noble idealism. CANCER (June 21-July 22): A character in Barbara Kingsolver’s novel The Lacuna is told to “go rub his soul against life.” Now I’ll advise you to do the same. Why? While it’s true that you have a beautiful soul, you sometimes get in the habit of hiding it away or keeping it secret. You feed it a wealth of dreams and emotions and longings, but may not go far enough in providing it with raw experience out in the messy, chaotic world. In my judgment, now is one of those times when you would benefit from rubbing your soul against life. Please note: I DON’T mean you should go in search of rough, tough downers. Not at all. In fact, there are plenty of pleasurable, safe, educational ways to rub your soul against life.
SCORPIO (Oct. 23-Nov. 21): In her poem “Sandra,” Scorpio poet Ariana Reines testifies that she has too many feelings—and that’s not a problem. On the contrary. They are her wealth, she says, her “invisible splendor.” I invite you to regard your own “too many feelings” in the same way, especially in the coming weeks. You will have opportunities to harness your flood of feelings in behalf of transformative insights and holistic decision-making. Your motto: Feelings are healing. SAGITTARIUS (Nov. 22-Dec. 21): Historian and author Thomas Berry described “wildness” as the source of our “authentic spontaneities.” He said it’s “the wellspring of creativity” at the root of our lust for life. That’s a different definition from the idea that wildness is about being unruly, rough, and primitive. And Berry’s definition happens to be the one that should be central to your work and play in the coming weeks. Your assignment is to be wild: that is, to cultivate your authentic spontaneities; to home in on and nourish the creative wellspring of your lust for life.
Go to RealAstrology.com to check out Rob Brezsny’s Expanded Weekly Audio Horoscopes and Daily Text Message Horoscopes. The audio horoscopes are also available by phone at 1-877-873-4888 or 1-900-950-7700. © CO P Y R I G H T 2 0 2 1 R O B B R E Z S N Y MARCH 17-23, 2021
•
Ayurvedic Astrology brings balance to mind, body and spirit. When all the 3 bodies are balanced then disease cannot take over. Some diseases are brought in by a past life occurrence and we look to heal that from the root of the issue. Book your appointments today. $108 for an hour consultation. 505 819 7220. 103 Saint Francis Dr.
ARE YOU A THERAPIST OR HEALER? YOU BELONG IN MIND BODY SPIRIT! ROBYN@SFREPORTER.COM
CAPRICORN (Dec. 22-Jan. 19): Some of the great discoveries in the history of physics have been made while the trailblazing physicists are lolling in bed or in the bathtub. They have done the research and carried out the rigorous thinking, and are rewarded with breakthroughs while relaxing. I think that will be your best formula for success in the coming weeks. Important discoveries are looming. Interesting innovations are about to hatch. You’re most likely to gather them in if you work intensely on preparing the way for them, then go off and do something fun and rejuvenating.
AQUARIUS (Jan. 20-Feb. 18): My typical horoscope is an average of 108 words long. In that limited space, I can’t possibly tell you all the themes and threads that will be active for you during the upcoming phase of your LEO (July 23-Aug. 22): If you love the work of selfcycle. I have to make choices about what to include and help author Paulo Coelho, you might be inclined to adopt his motto as your own: “Being vulnerable is the what not to include. This time I’ll focus on the fact that best way to allow my heart to feel true pleasure.” But you now have an opportunity to deepen your relationship with your sense of smell—and to purposefully maybe you wouldn’t want to adopt his motto. After nourish your sense of smell. Your homework: Decide on all, what he’s suggesting requires a great deal of courage and daring. Who among us finds it easy and at least five scents with which you will cultivate an intinatural to be soft and receptive and inviting? And yet mate, playful, delightful connection in the coming days. (PS: You may be surprised at how this practice will according to my analysis of the astrological omens, deepen your emotional connection with the world.) this is exactly what your assignment should be for the next two weeks. To help motivate yourself, PISCES (Feb. 19-March 20): No one had ever proven remember the payoff described by Coelho: the possi- that there was such a thing as electromagnetic waves bility that your heart will feel true pleasure. until Piscean physicist Heinrich Hertz (1857–1894) did so in 1886. He was the innovator who first transmitted VIRGO (Aug. 23-Sept. 22): Virgo author Michael and received controlled radio waves. Alas, he didn’t Ondaatje celebrates “the hidden presence of others think his breakthrough was useful. In 1890, he conin us—even those we have known briefly. We contain fessed, “I do not think that the wireless waves I have them for the rest of our lives, at every border we discovered will have any practical application.” But cross.” As you approach your own upcoming borderother scientists were soon capitalizing on his work to crossing, dear Virgo, I encourage you to tune into communicate long distances. Radio broadcasts were memories about seven specific people who over the born. I will encourage you not to make a Hertzian-type course of your life have provided you with the most mistake in the coming months. Always follow through joy and the most interesting lessons. Close your eyes on your initial labors. Have faith that the novelties you for 20 minutes and imagine they are all gathered dream up will eventually have practical value. together with you in your favorite sanctuary. Homework: If you believed everything you see in the “news,” Remember in detail the blessings they bestowed on you. Give thanks for their influences, for the gifts they you’d be so full of despair you couldn’t move. Describe gave that have helped you become your beautiful self. how you protect yourself. Truthrooster@gmail.com
22
DR. JOANNA CORTI, DOM Powerful Medicine, Powerful Results. Homeopathy, Acupuncture. Micro-current (Acupuncture without needles.) Parasite, Liver/ cleanses. Nitric Oxide. Pain Relief. Transmedium Energy Healing. Worker’s Compensation and Auto Accidents Insurance accepted 505-501-0439
ASTROLOGY
SFREPORTER.COM
PSYCHICS
LOVE. CAREER. WHAT DOES THE FUTURE HOLD? Psychic/Tarot Readings and Spiritual Counseling. Evening appointments and phone readings now available. For more information call 505-982-8327 or visit www.alexofavalon.com
MASSAGE THERAPY
TANTRA MASSAGE & TEACHING Call Julianne Parkinson, 505-920-3083 Certified Tantra Educator, Professional Massage Therapist, & Life Coach LIC #2788
THE BEST
r a d n e l a c E ONLIN in Santa Fe
Just like most beloved events, our calendar is now completely online and updated regularly with virtual events from across the city. Find all the gallery openings, book readings and live-streamed concerts you could ever desire at
sfreporter.com/cal
SFR CLASSIFIEDS 2 Ways to Book Your Ad!
MARKETPLACE SERVICE DIRECTORY FURNITURE
CHIMNEY SWEEPING
BED full/queen size — beautiful oak carved headboard and footboard from the 1880s. Gorgeous wood, pristine condition, bought in PA from antique store. The real deal! Sue 763-479-9834
MISC FOR SALE FOR SALE: four important books and one 2013 Guitar World magazine about guitar master and blues legend Stevie Ray Vaughan, excellent condition, sold as a set. $150 or BO Sue 763-479-9834
Breathtaking, turn of the century, hand-blown heavy blue cobalt glass BOWL. BIG 9.5” tall x 18” diameter. Pristine condition. Best offer. Mark 505-249-3570
CASEY’S TOP HAT CHIMNEY SWEEP Thank you Santa Fe, earning your Trust for 43 years. With this coupon save $20.00 on cleaning your fireplace or wood stove during the month of March 2021 Rated AAA with the BBB. Call Today: 988-5775 -------------------------------$20 off coupon for fireplace or wood stove cleaning.
CONSTRUCTION & CONTRACTORS
LEGAL NOTICE TO CREDITORS/ NAME CHANGE
TOO MUCH JUNK IN THE TRUNK? SELL IT HERE IN THE MARKETPLACE! CALL: 988.5541 TO PLACE YOUR AD TODAY!
We power people. Together we power change. Get your FREE custom quote to OWN a SOLAR ENERGY power system Call Eric (575)779-7958 Email: esalcido@ionsolar.com
Safety, Value, Professionalism. We have grown to become the largest, best trained, best equipped, top rated chimney service company in New Mexico. We sell, service, inspect, restore, and troubleshoot fireplaces, wood stoves and chimneys. Free check-up of your fire extinguishers, smoke and CO alarms, and dryer vents with every chimney cleaning. CSIA, NFI and CDET Certified. Worker comp coverage for all employees. GB-98 commercial and residential contractor license #392671. Baileyschimney.com. Call Bailey’s today 505-988-2771 $25 discount off of Chimney Cleanings
ROBYN@ SFREPORTER.COM
STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT IN THE MATTER OF A PETITION FOR CHANGE OF NAME OF MIGUEL JOSE MARTINEZ Case No.: D-101-CV-2021-00480 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF NAME TAKE NOTICE that in accordance with the provisions of Sec. 40-8-1 through Sec. 40-8-3 NMSA 1978, et seq. the Petitioner Miguel Jose Martinez will apply to the Honorable Maria Sanchez-Gagne, District Judge of the First Judicial District at the Santa Fe Judicial Complex, 225 Montezuma Ave., in Santa Fe, New Mexico, at 10:45 a.m. on the 21st day of April, 2021 for an ORDER FOR CHANGE OF NAME from Miguel Jose Martinez to Michael Joe Martinez. KATHLEEN VIGIL, District Court Clerk By: Marina Sisneros Deputy Court Clerk Submitted by: Miguel Jose Martinez Petitioner, Pro Se
Drop Your Card Here. Who fishes for your card in a bowl when you do that? Nobody. A business card ad in The Santa Fe Reporter gets results that will have you swimming in business. Purchase a “biz-card” sized ad in SFR’s classified pages. Contact Classifieds • Robyn@sfreporter.com
Adopt Me please!
DO YOU HAVE A GREAT SERVICE?
Santa Fe Animal Shelter
ADVERTISE
100 Caja Del Rio Road, Santa Fe, NM 87507
IT HERE IN
505-983-4309
sfhumanesociety.org
THE SERVICE
TERRANCE is a handsome and sweet 13.5 pound, 4-year-old domestic shorthaired male cat who came to SFAS when his guardian could no longer care for him. Since being in our care here at SFAS Terrance has been very open with his personality and is very vocal when he wants attention and a real cuddler!
DIRECTORY! SFR CAN PROCESS ALL OF YOUR LEGAL
SHANNON is a lovely 1-year-old mixed-breed girl who currently weighs about 40 pounds. She came to SFAS as a transfer from another shelter. Here at the shelter, Shannon has been very friendly and loves going to playgroup! We believe she is ready for a new home. If you have another dog at home, we encourage you to bring them in for a meet ‘n greet.
ART THE CHIMNEY SWEEP 17 years serving Northern New Mexico. Full service Chimney Sweep/Dryer Vents. We will beat any price! 505-982-9308
EMAIL: Robyn@SFReporter.com
LEGALS
A Premium Solar Provider
SPACE SAVING FURNITURE Murphy panel beds, home offices & closet combinations. 505-470-8902 or wallbedsbybergman.com
CALL: 505.988.5541
NOTICES FOR THE MOST AFFORDABLE
These and other animals are available for adoption from the Santa Fe Animal Shelter at 100 Caja del Rio Road.
PRICES IN THE
The Shelter’s adoption hours during the pandemic are from 11 am to 5 pm daily and is by appointment only. Please call 505-983-4309 to schedule an appointment.
SANTA FE AREA.
For updated COVID-19 shelter policies, visit SFHumaneSociety.org Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram SPONSORED BY
Mookie and the Road Gang SFREPORTER.COM
ROBYN@ SFREPORTER.COM •
MARCH 17-23, 2021
23
WE BUY DIAMONDS GOLD & SILVER
MOVIES R ESSENTIAL
GRADUATE GEMOLOGIST THINGS FINER Inside La Fonda Hotel 983-5552
JEEP MAINTENANCE & REPAIR. ALL ISSUES RESOLVED. MODERN AUTOWORKS. 1900 B CHAMISA ST. 505-989-4242.
BASE PRICE: $25 (Includes 1 LARGE line & 2 lines of NORMAL text) CUSTOMIZE YOUR TEXT WITH THE FOLLOWING UPGRADES: COLOR: $12/Line (Choose RED ORANGE GREEN BLUE orVIOLET)
Fri-Mon 12-6pm VIDEO LIBRARY 839 P de P 983-3321
ADDITIONAL LINES: $10/Line | CENTERED TEXT: $5/AD
CHECK OUT WEIRDNEWS.INFO
DEADLINE 12 NOON TUESDAY
BOLDED LINE:$10/Line | HIGHLIGHT $10
ROBYN@SFREPORTER.COM 505-988-5541
new online newspaper
UNCLE DT’S SMOKEHOUSE
I LOVE TO ORGANIZE
FREE DLVRY WEDS BOIL-IN-BAG BBQ 4 HOME UNCLEDT.COM
Experience References Sue 231-6878
Medical Card Consults
Newagemedicalsf.com 505-469-8581 calls returned within 24hrs
TAKEOUT, DELIVERY? Let the community know about your takeout and delivery service here on the Sana Fe Reporter’s backpage! ROBYN@SFREPORTER.COM 505-988-5541
Diamonds and GOLD WE BUY AND SELL
Amata Chiropractic
SILVER • COINS JEWELRY • GEMS
505.988.9630 826 Camino De Monte Rey, Suite A-3 • Santa Fe, NM 87505
TOP PRICES • CASH 3 GEMOLOGISTS ON STAFF Earthfire Gems 121 Galisteo • 982-8750
TEXTILE REPAIR 505.629.7007 VIRTUAL PIANO LESSONS Experienced with Masters Degree Children and Adults. 575-973-1621
TURNING 65?
New to Santa Fe? Need help with prescription drug costs? Call Brent 505 412 0491
XCELLENT MACINTOSH SUPPORT 30+yrs professional, Apple and Network certified. xcellentmacsupport.com • Randy • 670-0585
Eavesdropper
Hear something around town? Get it in the paper...
r po
t Lo
cal Jour
PUBLISH YOUR LOGO HERE!
na li
sm
Su p
Send your Overheard in Santa Fe tidbits to: eavesdropper@sfreporter.com
CONTACT ROBYN@SFREPORTER.COM
sfreporter.com/friends ESTABLISHED 1965
Shop our GREAT selection of Saltillo Tiles!
www.artesanos.com
24
DECEM BER 18-31, 2019
•
SFREPORTER.COM