Issuu

L E C

S S E

Featuring Residential, Business, Property Sales & Related Services VOLUME 32 • NO. 9

SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

S A N I B E L & C A P T I VA , F L O R I DA . . .

Find a Digital Copy at SanibelRealtors.com

r ' e s m m u FINAL GLOW.

ECRWSS RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMER

Photo by Angelika Geerlof

FORT MYERS, FL PERMIT NO. 40

PAID

U.S. POSTAGE

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

SANIBEL CAPTIVA

We're

COMMUNITY BANK

All In on Sanibel

A local bank, invested in the success of Sanibel and the businesses that shape it. Committed to the long-term strength of our island community. Sanibel Captiva Community Bank's responsiveness, flexibility and continued support have been invaluable. Our partnership with them provided us with stability and confidence during a very challenging time, and we are sincerely grateful for their commitment to our community. JR Ramirez, Jr. General Manager

Madison Banks Director of Operations

239-472-6100 | sancapbank.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

IS YOUR WATERFRONT READY FOR WHAT’S NEXT?

Protect your investment. Preserve your waterfront. Elevate the way you live.

EXCLUSIVE WATERFRONT OFFERS FREE INSPECTION

ONLY $1,000 DOWN

STORM PREP INSPECTION DOCK + SEAWALL

ON A NEW WATERFRONT PROJECT

Get a FREE professional dock and seawall inspection (a $499 value) to help identify potential problems early.

Put your plans in motion with just a $1,000 deposit on your new dock, seawall, boat lift, or dredging project.

Coupon must be presented at the time of service and/or contract signing. Limit one coupon per customer and property address. Restrictions may apply. See Crocker Marine Services for details. Offer Valid Through October 31, 2026.

BEFORE

AFTER

DOCKS • SEAWALLS • BOAT LIFTS • DREDGING • SERVICE • INSPECTIONS

YEARS

Protecting SWFL Shorelines

Community Driven

True Price Guarantee

SCAN TO SCHEDULE

2101 McGregor Blvd., Ste. 201, Fort Myers, FL 33901 (239) 841-9674 • Info@CrockerMarineServices.com LICENSE #CBC1266139 — FULLY INSURED

SERVING SOUTHWEST FLORIDA FROM MARCO ISLAND TO SARASOTA & EVERYWHERE IN BETWEEN

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

SANIBEL’S LEADING REAL ESTATE BROKERAGE. Proven Leadership. Trusted Results. Deep Community Roots. At Pfeifer Realty Group, we combine deep local expertise, proven results, and a genuine dedication to the communities we serve. While markets evolve and trends shift, our focus stays the same; guiding our clients with integrity, insight, and unmatched market knowledge. Whether you’re buying, selling, or simply staying informed, you deserve a team that knows this market inside and out, and has the results to prove it.

BY THE NUMBERS:

TOP 10

265+

$483K+

Brokerage on Sanibel

Producing Team SWFL

Families Helped Year-to-Date

Invested in Community

BOUTIQUE OFFICE, BIG RESULTS P F E I F E R R E A L T Y G R O U P | S A N I B E L ’S M A R K E T L E A D E R 239.472.0004 | PfeiferRealtyGroup.com 1630 Periwinkle Way, Unit I | Sanibel, FL 33957

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

One Island Condo at a Time. TENNISPLACE, UNIT: E22

BLINDPASS, UNIT: G206

Move-In-Ready Condo with Canal Views 2 BR / 1 BA - $345,000

Second Floor Unit with Open Layout, Close to Beach 2 BR / 2 BA - $549,000

BLINDPASS, UNIT: G102

SANIBEL MOORINGS, UNIT: 212

Newly Renovated Unit with Rental Income 2 BR / 2 BA - $649,000

BLINDPASS, UNIT: E109

Ground Floor Unit with Open Concept Layout 2 BR / 2 BA - $589,000

Second Floor Unit with Abundant Natural Light 1 BR / 1 BA - $412,500

SANIBEL MOORINGS, UNIT: 1521

Newly Renovated, Canal Side, Ground Level Unit 2 BR / 2 BA - $699,000

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

One Island Home at a Time. 3359 BARRA CIRCLE

4209 OLD BANYAN WAY

Updated Pool Home, Short Walk to Beach 3 BR / 3 BA - $999,999

Gulf Pines Home with Privacy & Short Walk to Beach 3 BR / 2.5 BA - $1,195,000

974 GREENWOOD COURT S

Updated East-End Townhome with Abundant Natural Light 3 BR / 2.5 BA - $639,000

970 SAND CASTLE ROAD

Modern Coastal Living in The Dunes 3 BR / 2 BA - $869,000

BLINDPASS, UNIT: D202

Second Floor Unit with Split Floor Plan 2 BR / 2 BA - $429,000

SUNDIAL, UNIT: 208H

Second Floor Retreat with Open Concept 1 BR / 1 BA - $490,000 - PENDING

Kelly Huguenin

Realtor®, SCIS, ABR, AHWD, C2EX, Island Resident C: 423.903.4684 Kelly@PfeiferRealtyGroup.com KellySellingSunshine.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

we are kingfisher!

Phaidra McDermott - Broker/Owner “The Closer” 239-898-3778 Phaidra@GoKingfisher.com

Sue Plein - Realtor® “The Navigator” 239-560-8265 SuePlein@gmail.com

Kate Stone Pujol - Realtor® “The Expeditor” 239-209-0620 Kate@GoKingfisher.com

Valerie Tutor - Realtor® “The Negotiator” 239-834-8141 Valerie@ValerieTutor.com

Julia Melvin - Realtor® “The Facilitator” 239-980-3129 Julia@GoKingfisher.com

Robyn Moran - Realtor® “The Strategist” 239-728-1971 Robyn@GoKingfisher.com

Pegge Ford Realtor® 239-850-5200 PeggeFord@aol.com

Bill Tomlinson - Realtor® “The Chief ” 239-464-1200 BillT.Realtor@gmail.com

(239) 472-4411

Mary Bondurant - Realtor® “The Matchmaker” 239-839-3633 Mary@GoKingfisher.com

Liz Podolsky - Broker Associate “The Consultant” 239-331-5049 LizPodolsky@gmail.com

Fred Bondurant - Broker Associate Brooke Brownyard - Realtor® “The Investigator” “The Captain” 239-281-4179 239-281-5356 SanibelBrooke@aol.com Fred@thebrg.net

Lisa Lauther Realtor® 239-338-7070 Lisa@GoKingfisher.com

Kelsey Wider - Realtor® “The Guide” 443-204-1910 Kelsey@GoKingfisher.com

John Bondurant - Realtor® “The Chef ” 239-822-2627 John@GoKingfisher.com

Deb Stone Realtor® 239-770-7253 dstone174@gmail.com

Dave Saunders - Realtor® “The Specialist” 239-910-6508 CaptivaDave@frontier.com

Mike Billheimer - Realtor® “The Native Son” 239-565-2322 mbillhe349@aol.com

Kiersten Royal Capo - Realtor® “The Advisor” 239-284-5847 Kroyalcapo@gmail.com

KingfisherRealEstate.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Exceptional Agents, Superlative Results

3517 West Gulf Dr | $11,500,000 Phaidra McDermott

16777 Captiva Dr | $9,450,000 Phaidra McDermott

4369 West Gulf Dr | $7,900,000 Phaidra McDermott

16886 Captiva Dr | $6,900,000 Sue Plein & Phaidra McDermott

16632 Captiva Dr | 5,699,000 Sue Plein

3507 West Gulf Dr | $5,000,000 Phaidra McDermott

4717 Rue Belle Mer | $3,695,000 Phaidra McDermott

1 Sunset Captiva Lane | $3,498,000 Phaidra McDermott & Sue Plein

2402 Palm Ridge Rd. Sanibel, FL 33957 | 11528 Andy Rosse Ln. Captiva, FL 33924

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Kingfisher Real Estate

4641 Rue Belle Mer | $3,375,000 Kate Stone Pujol

3127 West Gulf Dr 101 | $3,195,000 Phaidra McDermott & Brooke Brownyard

2302 Wulfert Rd | $2,925,000 Phaidra McDermott

924 Kings Crown Dr | $2,750,000 Phaidra McDermott & Brooke Brownyard

16785 Captiva Drive | $2,695,000 Phaidra McDermott

1163 Seagrape Lane | $2,450,000 Brooke Brownyard

3145 West Gulf Drive 102 | $2,399,000 Phaidra McDermott

1602 Lands End Village | $1,259,000 Phaidra McDermott

(239) 472-4411

KingfisherRealEstate.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 11

There Is No Place Like Home

2445 W Gulf Dr 44E | $1,995,000 Deb Stone & Pegge Ford

1337 Caloosa Dr | $1,940,000 Kiersten Royal Capo

5135 Joewood Dr | $1,799,000 John Bondurant & Mary Bondurant

15123 Captiva Dr 103 $1,499,000 | Sue Plein

2445 W Gulf Dr 4E | $1,650,000 Deb Stone & Pegge Ford

1172 Kittiwake Cir | $1,449,000 Phaidra McDermott & Mary Bondurant

1406 Sanderling Cir | $1,425,000 Mary Bondurant & John Bondurant

1341 Middle Gulf Dr 5C | $1,399,000 Kate Stone Pujol

2402 Palm Ridge Rd. Sanibel, FL 33957 | 11528 Andy Rosse Ln. Captiva, FL 33924

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Kingfisher Real Estate

1360 Jamaica Dr | $1,365,000 Robyn Moran

283 Palm Lake Dr | $1,345,000 Pegge Ford & Deb Stone

2445 W Gulf Dr 45A | $1,330,000 Deb Stone & Pegge Ford

15411 Captiva Drive 3B | $1,295,000 Phaidra McDermott & Sue Plein

255 Periwinkle Way 5B | $1,250,000 Phaidra McDermott & Brooke

2445 W Gulf Dr A25 | $1,225,000 Deb Stone & Pegge Ford

5669 Baltusrol Ct 2A | $1,155,000 Phaidra McDermott & Robyn Moran

1056 S Yachtsman Dr | $1,150,000 Mary Bondurant & John Bondurant

587 Carlos Cir FMB | $1,149,000 Pegge Ford & Deb Stone

2548 Wulfert Road | $1,095,000 Phaidra McDermott & Liz Podolsky

6062 Dinkins Lake Rd | $1,089,000 Phaidra McDermott

5669 Baltusrol Ct 2B | $1,048,000 Phaidra McDermott

625 Nerita St 2C | $996,000 Brooke Brownyard

4534 Bowen Bayou Rd | $989,000 Phaidra McDermott & Mary Bondurant

2619 Wulfert Rd 3 | $959,000 Mike Billheimer

4037 Coquina Dr | $950,000 Phaidra McDermott

3235 Avocado Dr | $925,000 Kiersten Royal Capo

11940 Oakland Dr | $898,000 Mary Bondurant & John Bondurant

2402 Palm Ridge Rd. Sanibel, FL 33957 | 11528 Andy Rosse Ln. Captiva, FL 33924

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 13

Going Above & Beyond

2721 W Gulf Dr 212 | $780,000 Mary Bondurant & John Bondurant

589 Rabbit Rd | $784,000 Phaidra McDermott & Kelsey Wider

1813 Long Point Ln | $750,000 Kate Stone Pujol & Kelsey Wider

200 Periwinkle Way 111 | $548,000 Phaidra McDermott & Mary Bondurant

1440 Middle Gulf Dr 4C $530,000 | Robyn Moran

2840 W Gulf Dr 4C | $785,000 Mary Bondurant & John Bondurant

2840 W Gulf Dr #25 | $510,000 Mary Bondurant & John Bondurant

401/393 Raintree Pl $500,000 | Valerie Tutor

5633 Baltusrol Ct | $449,000 Phaidra McDermott

5648 Baltusrol Ct | $419,000 Phaidra McDermott

5642 Baltusrol Ct | $429,000 Phaidra McDermott

3407 Cancun Ct | $365,000 Kiersten Royal Capo

2812 12Th St SW | $349,000 Kate Stone Pujol

1610 Middle Gulf Dr A5 $335,000 | Kate Stone Pujol

2008 NW 24th Place $304,000 | Lisa Lauther

12621 Kelly Sands Way 307 $279,000 | Kate Stone Pujol

4263 Island Cir Unit D | $235,000 Kiersten Royal Capo

22 Ashe Street | Alva $105,000 | Sue Plein

(239) 472-4411

KingfisherRealEstate.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Brooks Selby Realtor®

(239) 292-7533 BSelby@JohnRWood.com.com

FULLY REMODELED, CUSTOM-BUILT, AND OFFERED FULLY FURNISHED TURNKEY

AMAZING OPPORTUNITY TO BUILD YOUR DREAM BEACH HOUSE

327 Palm Lake | $650,000 • • • • •

• • • • • •

SOLD

RARELY AVAILABLE & IDEALLY TUCKED AWAY ON A QUIET CUL-DE-SAC

CLASSIC WATERFRONT SANIBEL ISLAND RETREAT

1133 Golden Olive Court | $3,780,000 4 Bed | 3.5 Baths 1/2+ acre Meticulously remodeled Direct deep-water access Private boat dock , Seawalled canal Large pool & spillover spa Brazilian cherrywood floors

2 Bed | 2.5 Baths Private island retreat feel Palm-lined winding drive Bayou & Gulf sunsets Direct water access Private dock

SOLD

MASTERPIECE OF DESIGN & CRAFTSMANSHIP IN THIS ESTATE ON SANIBEL

• • • • • • •

5801 Sanibel Captiva Road | $1,500,000

Royal Palms lining the property Steps to the Beach Spacious vacant lot Overlooking Lake Best vacant land value

5427 Osprey CT, | $1,795,000 • • • • • •

Waterfront property on Clam Bayou Expansive water and sunset views Private dock with boat lift and fishing boat Elevated home with unfinished lower level 2025 aluminum roof, new gutters, 2023 dock, saltwater pool, impact windows/shutters Offered fully furnished

14380 Hampton Lake Ct | $449,000 • • • • • • •

3 Bed/ 2 Bath Wide lake views, no rear neighbors 2018 roof Kitchen w/ pantry & reclaimed wood bar Screened pool + lanai Outdoor deck dining Pool bath

WHAT CLIENTS ARE SAYING - Brooks Selby goes above and beyond in customer service. He is professional, easy to work with and timely. Thank you very much!

- Brooks was great, went above and beyond to make the transaction go smoothly. Made us feel welcomed to the community. I would recommend him highly to anyone.

-“Brooks Selby has been my broker for many transactions because of his knowledge, professionalism, and ability to ease any concerns throughout the buying or selling process. His approachable personality makes every transaction smooth and enjoyable. I highly recommend Brooks and admire the pride he takes in representing his company.”

Brooks Selby - Recently Ranked in the Top 1.5% of All Agents Nationwide* *in Sales Volume by Real Trends **MLS Statistics for Lee & Collier county

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 15

The Perfect Home!

East End!

Investment Property!

Pending! $1,100,000

$980,000

$750,000

3 bed | 2 bath | 3131 sf 9007 MOCKINGBIRD DR., Sanibel

3 bed | 2 bath | 1698 sf 1417 CAUSEY CT., Sanibel

4 bed | 2 bath | 1280 sf 746 CARDIUM ST., Sanibel

Gumbo Limbo

Spanish Cay F5

Fort Myers Beach

$680,000

$525,000

$699,700

3 bed | 2 bath | 1464 sf 1737 SERENITY LN., Sanibel

2 bed | 2 bath | 1130 sf

1610 MIDDLE GULF DR., Sanibel

3 bed | 2 bath | 1584 sf 260 STERLING AVE., Ft. Myers Beach

Blind Pass Condo!

Lucaya

Custom Built In 2024

Pending!

Pending! $470,000

$420,000

$2,100,000

2 bed | 2 bath | 1207 sf 5117 SEABELL RD. A-201, Sanibel

3 bed | 2 bath | Den | 1842 sf 10436 PESO DEL RIO DR., Fort Myers

4 bed | 3.5 bath | 2958 sf 1044 FISH CROW RD., Sanibel

Spacious Corner Lot

Create Your Dream!

Build Your Dream!

$450,000

$430,000

$375,000

3 bed | 2 bath | 1293 sf 1683 ATLANTA PLAZA, Sanibel

2 bed | 2 bath | 888 sf 1653 ATLANTA PLAZA, Sanibel

The Sanctuary at Wulfert 2349 WULFERT RD., Sanibel

Sarah Ashton Chris Kirchner Kathy Waite Sue Harrison

2440 Palm Ridge Rd. #5, Sanibel, FL 33957 ● 239-230-2404

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Where Paradise Meets Paradise

5.15-ACRE: THREE ADJOINING LOTS. ONE LEGACY PROPERTY WITH WATER ACCESS OFFERED AT $4,995,000

11525 ANDY ROSSE LN CAPTIVA SUPERIOR RENTAL IN CAPTIVA VILLAGE OFFERED AT $3,250,000

1146 GOLDEN OLIVE CT SANIBEL RARE DIRECT ACCESS TO OPEN WATER OFFERED AT $2,795,000

1114 SEAGRAPE LN SANIBEL EFFORTLESS BEACH ACCESS OFFERED AT $2,695,000

5810 PINE TREE DR SANIBEL LUXURIOUS WATERFRONT ESTATE OFFERED AT $1,795,000

2539 COCONUT DR SANIBEL DIRECT ACCESS DEL SEGA HOME OFFERED AT $1,380,000

NEW LISTING

NEW PRICE

NEW LISTING

19070 HINKLEY DR ESTERO BETTER THAN NEW OFFERED AT $684,000

1248 FRANK WHITEMAN BLVD NAPLES BEACH BUNGALOW OFFERED AT $675,000

1700 DON AVE LEHIGH ACRES SPACIOUS MOVE-IN READY OFFERED AT $330,000

PENDING 2026 SOLD BY BABS 2285 SUNRISE BLVD FORT MYERS 6120 HENDERSON RD SANIBEL 2499 HARBOUR LN SANIBEL

16813 CAPTIVA DRIVE CAPTIVA 2451 BLIND PASS CT SANIBEL 520 TARPON BAY RD SANIBEL 813 ANGEL WING DR SANIBEL

6401 PINE AVE SANIBEL 6407 PINE AVE SANIBEL 6450 PINE AVE SANIBEL 6408 PINE AVE SANIBEL

1040 EDGEMERE DR FORT MYERS RIVER & GULF ACCESS POOL HOME OFFERED AT $695,000

5398 OSPREY CT SANIBEL CREATE YOUR OWN PARADISE OFFERED AT $280,000

REPRESENTED BUYERS AND/OR SELLERS

2449 HARBOUR LN SANIBEL 23180 WHISPERING RIDGE DR 1025 PERIWINKLE WAY SANIBEL 8362 BAMBOO DR FORT MYERS 1133 GOLDEN OLIVE CT SANIBEL

Babs Maughan

broker associate

AGENT • SANIBEL SALES VOLUME

scis

1.5%

TOP 1.5% OF REAL ESTATE AGENTS NATIONWIDE

239-314-4800 BabsMaughan@JohnRWood.com 1019 PERIWINKLE WAY SANIBEL FLORIDA 33957

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 17

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 19

1177 Causeway Blvd., Sanibel, FL 33957

Anchored In Service, Driven By Results

Grow With Portside

One company. Three divisions. Multiple opportunities to grow. Sales. Rentals. Property Services. One platform designed to help professionals grow their business and their opportunities.

Sales & Investments

Rental Management

Property Services

Team Opportunities

investors throughout

opportunities through

clients beyond the closing

sales and are actively

Southwest Florida while

seasonal and annual

through ongoing property

seeking professionals

building long-term client

rentals while expanding

care, inspections, and

interested in rentals,

relationships.

your network of property

homeowner support.

operations, client

Help buyers, sellers, and

Generate additional

Stay connected with

owners.

We’re growing beyond

services, and property management.

Multiple Ways. One Team.

At Portside, we believe successful real estate professionals build relationships across multiple aspects of the business. Our integrated model creates opportunities in sales, rentals, property management, and client services, helping our team grow stronger, more sustainable businesses.

Who We’re Looking For

◆ Experienced REALTORS® ◆ Newly licensed agents looking for mentorship ◆ Rental & Property Management professionals ◆ Client Service & Operations professionals ◆ Team members who value relationships over transactions

Grow With Portside

Whether you’re building a real estate career, expanding into rentals, or looking for a full-time opportunity within a growing company, we’d love to start a conversation.

Let’s Talk!

Scan to explore opportunities with Portside.

Aron Hubers

Managing Partner & REALTOR®

Polly Bellmer

Cell 239.250.9300 a.hubers@portsidepg.com

Office 239.472.3334 p.bellmer@portsidepg.com

Office & Operations Manager

Sales & Investments | Property Services | Rental Management 1177 Causeway Blvd., Sanibel, FL 33957

portsidepg.com

All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and subject to change without notice.

PRICE HIGH TO LOW!!!

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

C A LL K R IS FOR EXCEPTIONA L SERV ICE

SOLD!

865 BIRDIE VIEW PT SANIBEL 4 BED + DEN • 4.5 BATH • $1,750,000

SOLD!

734 SAND DOLLAR DR SANIBEL 3 BED • 3.5 BATH • $1,520,000

SOLD!

PRICE ENHANCEMENT

15010 PUNTA RASSA RD 305 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $270,000

5943 BAKER CT FORT MYERS 4 BED • 3 BATH • $849,000

PUNTA R A SSA

8310 WHISKEY PRESERVE CIR 212 2 BED • 2 BATH • $221,500

941 PECTEN CT SANIBEL 3 BED • 2 BATH • $1,435,000

PRICE ENHANCEMENT

EXCLUSIVE WATERFRONT COMMUNITY WHERE THE CALOOSAHATCHEE MEETS THE GULF THE FIVE ACRES ARE METICULOUSLY MAINTAINED & BEAUTIFULLY LANDSCAPED WITH MANY AMENITIES

15021 PUNTA RASSA RD 903 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $559,900

NEW LISTING

PRICE ENHANCEMENT

15021 PUNTA RASSA RD 401 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $530,000

15031 PUNTA RASSA RD 1002 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $530,000

15031 PUNTA RASSA RD 1105 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $525,000

15011 PUNTA RASSA RD 403 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $518,000

PRICE ENHANCEMENT

NEW LISTING

PRICE ENHANCEMENT

NEW LISTING

15011 PUNTA RASSA RD 601 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $449,000

15021 PUNTA RASSA RD 402 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $410,000

15011 PUNTA RASSA RD 103 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $372,000

Kris Cardinale Realtor® CONTACT ME TODAY EXCEPTIONAL SERVICE • EXCEPTIONAL MARKETING

239-464-1225

KCardinale@JohnRWood.com • www.KristineCardinale.com Kristine Cardinale, P.A. 1019 Periwinkle Way Sanibel Florida 33957

15010 PUNTA RASSA RD 108 FORT MYERS 2 BED • 2 BATH • $315,000

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 21

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

SANIBEL ISLAND

White Sands-Beach Frt

T o t a l l y

N E W

R e m o d e l

Protect your home with Rubicon Flood Barriers. No more sand bags!  Easy to deploy

 Engineered for Florida

Locally owned, licensed & Insured

(239) 330-8888 rubiconflood.com

2311 West Gulf Drive #13

Selling SANIBEL & CAPTIVA Since 1979!

New everything and one of the first units completely reimagined from the inside out. A designer kitchen and an open-concept living & dining areas open to an expansive lanai with wide Gulf front views & breezes. Offering two spacious bedrooms that each bath feature bathrooms with elegant vanities, designer tile and glass-enclosed showers. The entry Den/Flex space adds functionality as another guest room or an office. A beautiful beach-side swimming pool and beach pathway, PickleBall-Tennis Court and large owner storage unit. You need to see it! Super Rental Income & only14 units! Price: REDUCED $995,000

BOB & SEAN RADIGAN

theradiganteam@gmail.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 23

4577 WATERS EDGE LANE SANIBEL 4 BEDROOMS | 4 FULL BATHS | $5,200,000

241 VIOLET DRIVE SANIBEL 3 BEDROOMS | 2 FULL & 1 HALF BATHS | $1,385,000 $100,000 PRICE REDUCTION

1835 ARDSLEY WAY SANIBEL .55 ACRE VACANT RESIDENTIAL LOT | $499,000

760 SEXTANT DRIVE 1051 SANIBEL 2 BEDROOMS | 2 FULL BATHS | $488,000

Cecilia Jane Liichow Realtor®

309-883-9907

CLiichow@johnrwood.com 1019 Periwinkle Way Sanibel Florida 33957

FALL IS ALL ABOUT HOME

Sincerely working for you

Cathie Lewis

4988 JOEWOOD DRIVE

1610 MIDDLE GULF DR, #2B

NEW LISTING

Spanish Cay: Enjoy the peaceful water views with direct beach access across the street. 2 BR / 2 BA - $510,000

SOLD

ACCOMPLISH YOUR REAL ESTATE GOALS THIS FALL.

Cathie Lewis, Realtor® M: 239.745.7367 cathie@allabouthome.life

Spacious and private home just steps to the beach. Built in 2017 with resiliency in mind. 4 BR / 4 BA - $1,950,000

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Bondurant

FAMILY TEAM

Kingfisher Real Estate 1406 SANDERLING CIR 1,42 5,000 |3BD 2.5B A

SE A SHELLS OF SANIBEL 25 510,000 |2BD 2BA

Nestled in The Dunes, this lakeside sanctuary offers panoramic preserve views, spectacular sunsets, a private pool, and effortless access to island recreation and world-renowned beaches.

Completely renovated in 2025, this move-in-ready Sanibel condominium offers stylish modern comfort, deeded beach access just steps away, and the soothing sounds of the Gulf from its peaceful screened lanai.

PENDING

$1,799,000

$1,449,000

$1,195,000

5135 JOEWOOD DR SANIBEL 4 BD 2.5 BA | PREMIER COMMUNITY

1172 KITTIWAKE CIR SANIBEL 5VIRTUALLY BD 3 BA | STAGED SWEEPING VIEWS

253 DANIEL DR SANIBEL 3 BD 2.5 BA | COASTAL BREEZES

$1,150,000

$780,000

$898,000

1056 S YACHTSMAN DR SANIBEL 3 BD 2 BA | CANAL & POOL HOME

2721 W GULF DR 212 SANIBEL 2 BD 2 BA | BEAUTIFUL UPDATES

11940 OAKLAND DR BOKEELIA 3 BD BONUS 2 BA | RESORT STYLE

SOLD 2026 490 MARIAN RD SANIBEL 330 EAST GULF DR SANIBEL 11931 OAKLAND DR BOKEELIA 1712 SE 28TH ST CAPE CORAL 1611 SAND CASTLE RD SANIBEL 576 W FENWAY DR HERNANDO

2659 W GULF DR B101 SANIBEL* 1537 SAND CASTLE RD SANIBEL 279 FERRY LANDING DR SANIBEL 561 PERIWINKLE WAY E4 SANIBEL 11306 SUNSET PRESERVE DR LEHIGH Represented Buyers and/or Sellers *Co-Listed with Phaidra McDermott

Fred Bondurant

Mary Bondurant

John Bondurant

Broker Associate

Realtor

239-281-5356

239-839-3633

Fred@GoKingfisher.com Mary@GoKingfisher.com

239-822-2627

John@GoKingfisher.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 25

Canalside 2nd ﬂoor 1 bedrm, gulf & pool across street—$299,999

2nd ﬂoor 2/2 with easy on‐site oﬃce/rentals—$649,000 furnished

Gulf‐facing 2/2 income‐producer with bookings—$899,000 furnished

Top‐ﬂoor corner 2/2 plus den with new glass—$999,000 furnished

Gumbo Limbo 3/2 with pool, on cul‐de‐sac & lake—$899,000

Spacious remodeled lagoon‐side 3/3, steps to beach—$999,000

Friday real estate blogs at SanibelSusan.com

Susan Andrews Broker

Like‐new Gulf Shores 3/3 with waterside pool—$1,250,000 furnished

239‐565‐3128 Susan@SanibelSusan.com

David Anderson Realtor

Lisa Murty Realtor

239‐851‐0786 239‐410‐2378 FindSanibel@gmail.com LisaMurty@comcast.net

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

SUAREZ collection Curated Real Estate Across the Gulf Coast

Rendering to show potential development!

Buck Key

16770 Captiva Dr

Captiva

$4,900,000

$13,000,000

$9,700,000

Pristine ±14 Acre Island

102' Gulf Frontage

$4,850,000

Captiva, Beach Front Beach Home 24 4 Bed, Designer appointments $1,900,000

Captiva, Beach Front 2122 Gulf Beach Villas Reimagined 2 Bed+loft $1,450,000

Fort Myers Beach, Gulf Access 282 Delmar Ave 3 Bed, Elevator, Boat slip $570,000

Captiva, Beach Villas 2623 Beach Villas 1 Bed, Direct Gulf-front

$4,749,000

Captiva, Bay Views 15160 Captiva Dr 6 Bed, Reverse floor plan

Beach Home 19 Premium Gulf Front $3,695,000

$4,200,000

Captiva, Direct Gulf Captiva, Beach Front 1071 S Seas Plantation Rd Beach Home 25 3 Bed, Elevated, Panoramic views 4 Bed, Reconstructed, Gulf views

$1,845,000

$1,650,000

$1,450,000

Captiva, Sunset Captiva 33 Urchin Ct 3 Bed, Furnished, Gulf to Bay

Captiva, Gulf Front 1408 Beach Cottages 2 Bed, Superior craftsmanship

Fort Myers Beach, Gulf Access 276 Delmar Ave 3 Bed, Elevator, Boat slip

$1,049,000

$665,000

$650,000

Captiva, Beach Front 2121 Gulf Beach Villas 3 Bed, Motivated seller

Cape Coral, Gulf Access 5310 Bayshore Ave 5 Bed, Turn-key, Boat dock

$299,999

$290,000

Sanibel, Sanctuary at Wulfert 2486 Wulfert Rd 0.34 acres, Vacant lot (Virtual Rendering)

Fort Myers, Parker Lakes 15068 Cloverdale Dr 3 Bed, Resort style amenities

Fort Myers, Colonial Farms 12351 Caisson Ln 5acres, Raw land, Central location (Virtual Rendering)

Captiva, Bayside Villas 1 Bed, Furnished waterfront 5232 Bayside Villas $494,900 5132 Bayside Villas $445,000

LeAne Taylor Suarez Vice President, BROKER 239.872.1632 LeAne@LeAneSUAREZ.com

Captiva, Captiva Resort Villas Captiva, Captiva Resort Villas 1 Bed, Extended Lanai, Courtyard 2 Bed loft floor plan, Furnished 3221 Captiva Resort Villas $350,000 3132 Captiva Resort Villas $624,000 3222 Captiva Resort Villas $350,000 3233 Captiva Resort Villas $595,000

Alec Suarez & Austin Suarez REALTOR® 239.322.0243 Alec@LeAneSUAREZ.com

LeAne & The Suarez Brothers

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 27

SOLD PENDING PENDING SOLD

PENDING

Honesty. Knowledge. Trust. Professionalism. Friendship. Big things. And all the little things that make buying or selling with Milissa uniquely better. MilissaSprecherRealtor.com. Text or Talk 239.414.6044 MS@MilissaSprecherRealtor.com

Yes. Different is better.

UNREAL ESTATE View All

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

1332 Eagle Run

Island neighbors. Real estate guides.

5 BD | 5 BA | $2,650,000

FOR SANIBEL HOMEOWNERS

Whether to sell. When. What your home might bring. Some of our best conversations start with those questions — long before any For Sale sign. 2179 Starfish Ln

3 BD | 4 BA | $1,470,000

We’re easy to talk to, whenever you’re ready. “Susan and her team provided excellent guidance and support from start to finish, giving us the confidence we needed to navigate the sale process from out of state.” – Michael H., Google review

1238 Par View Dr

3 BD | 3 BA | $1,299,000

1401 Sand Castle Rd

4 BD | 5 BA | $1,199,000

Scan for photos & details:

Susan McCallion, Licensed Broker • Jim McCallion, Marketing

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 29

1076 Captains Walk

1012/1014 East Gulf Dr

1919 Olde Middle Gulf Dr 401

2265 W Gulf Dr 210F 2 BD | 2 BA | $839,000

4 BD | 2 BA | $799,000

5117 Sea Bell Rd E103

5117 Sea Bell Rd D204

1340 Middle Gulf Dr 8A

736 Donax St

5117 Sea Bell Rd A102

200 Periwinkle Way 132

2 BD | 2 BA | $1,099,000

2 BD | 2 BA | $850,000

3 BD | 3 BA | $730,700

2 BD | 2 BA | $625,000

4 BD | 2 BA | $899,000

3 BD | 2 BA | $725,700

2 BD | 2 BA | $525,000

2737 W Gulf Dr 238

2 BD | 2 BA | $899,000

4546 Buck Key Rd

2 BD | 2 BA | $699,000

2 BD | 2 BA | $499,000

WWW.McCALLIONREALTY.COM | 239·472·1950 | 1640 PERIWINKLE WAY, SANIBEL, FL 33957

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

THE SITTON TEAM IS YOUR KEY TO THE ISLANDS!

SUNDIAL E408

2 Beds + Den | 2 Baths | $1,450,000

SUNDIAL EAST R405

2 Beds + Den | 2 Baths | $1,430,000

710 BIRDIE VIEW PT

4 Beds | 3 Baths | $1,375,000

SUNSET SOUTH 14C

2 Beds | 2 Baths | $988,500

3 Beds + Den | 3.5 Baths | $1,695,000

1251 PAR VIEW DRIVE

KINGS CROWN 213

2 Beds | 2 Baths | $799,000

SANDALFOOT 3A1

2 Beds | 2 Baths | $779,000

BRAD SITTON REALTOR , CAM ®

239.823.2604

BradSitton.royalshellrealestate.com 959 Periwinkle Way • Sanibel, FL 33957 | 15050 Captiva Drive • Captiva, FL 33924 jbsitton55@comcast.net

CINDY SITTON BROKER ASSOCIATE, MA, GRI, SCIS

239.810.4772

CindyOnSanibel.com CindyOnSanibel@comcast.net

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 31

239 - 770 - 2683

www . P R A Florida . com

Robert Coscia, Broker | Owner | Realtor

1019 Periwinkle Way | 239-233-9544

‰

Navigating Your Dream Home with an Island Boating & Real Estate Expert.

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

We make it easy. You make it home®. MANY OF THESE PROPERTIES ARE ALSO INCOME-PRODUCING INVESTMENTS. ASK US HOW.

CAPTIVA ISLAND

FORT MYERS RIVERFRONT

16730 CAPTIVA DR., CAPTIVA

5 BR, 2 Story, Beachfront, Gulf Views $10,900,000

Mike McMurray, McMurray & Members

13230 LINTON RD., FORT MYERS RS165455

239.850.7888

CATALPA POINTE

15400 CATALPA COVE LN., FORT MYERS

4 BR + Private Den, 4,400 S.F. $3,549,000

Mike McMurray, McMurray & Members

RS163286

239.850.7888

SOUTH SEAS ISLAND RESORT

2030 GULF BEACH VILLAS, CAPTIVA

3 BR, 2 BA Directly on The Gulf $1,500,000 Mary Ann Cowart

RS163362

239.851.6447

BEACHVIEW CC ESTATES

1264 PAR VIEW DR., SANIBEL

Renovated 3 BR + Den, Beach Access, Golf Course $1,147,000 RS162547 Becky Mulka

239.887.0855

2-Acre Caloosahatchee River Estate $8,500,000

Mike McMurray, McMurray & Members

RS166815

239.850.7888

BEACHVIEW CC ESTATES

Cindy Sitton

RS165473

239.810.4772

BEACHVIEW CC ESTATES

Spacious, Golf Course View w/Pool, Beach Access $1,200,000 RS161460

239.887.0855

MARINER POINTE

RS165112

239.850.7888

3 BR, 3.5 BA + Den, Stunning Views, Beach Access $1,625,000 RS160739 Becky Mulka

239.887.0855

NATOMA PARK

5539 NATOMA DR., FORT MYERS

Exceptional Waterfront Retreat $1,149,000

Mike McMurray, McMurray & Members

RS166781

239.850.7888

SANDALFOOT

760 SEXTANT DR. #321, SANIBEL

3 BR, 2 BA, Canal, Pier Near Pool, Dock Available $799,999 RS161322 Becky Mulka

Mike McMurray, McMurray & Members

5438 SHEARWATER DR., SANIBEL

1286 PAR VIEW DR., SANIBEL

Becky Mulka

Bud Lawrence Built, Near Beach Home $4,350,000

HERONS LANDINGS I

710 BIRDIE VIEW PT., SANIBEL

Luxury Near Beach Home $1,695,000

CAPTIVA ISLAND

15161 WILES DR., CAPTIVA

239.887.0855

671 E. GULF DR. #3A1, SANIBEL

2 BR, 2 BA w/Gorgeous Gulf & Pool Views $779,000 RS166145 Cindy & Brad Sitton

239.810.4772

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 33

LOGGERHEAD CAY

PINK PELICAN COTTAGE

979 E. GULF DR. #D452, SANIBEL

Corner Lanai w/Gulf View $719,000 Cathy Rosario

RS163447

239.464.2249

PALM LAKE

Deeded Beach Access, 2 Lots from W. Gulf Drive $499,000 RS161501

239.464.2249

SANIBEL BAYOUS

Becky Mulka

239.887.0855

Sanibel River Views - Vacant Lot $445,000 Mary Ann Cowart

Ready to Build, High & Dry, .35 Acres, Utilities in Place $330,000 RS155492

239.691.3319

1501 MIDDLE GULF DR. #F105, SANIBEL

Completely Remodeled & Updated - Top to Bottom $549,000 RS166041 Tracy Walters

239.994.7975

TENNISPLACE

1331 PAR VIEW DR., SANIBEL

1250 TENNISPLACE CT. #C25, SANIBEL RS162990

239.851.6447

MAJESTIC PALMS

2090 WILD LIME DR., SANIBEL

Sally Davies

5 Minute Bike to Beach, Surprisingly Spacious Layout $664,000 RS161367

BEACHVIEW CC ESTATES

231 PALM LAKE DR., SANIBEL

Cathy Rosario

SUNDIAL OF SANIBEL

1657 ATLANTA PLAZA DR., SANIBEL

Stunning Water Views, Direct Deep Water, Beach Access $425,000 RS162194 Jason Lomano

239.470.8628

MAJESTIC PALMS

11621 NAVARRO WAY #1905, FORT MYERS

11620 NAVARRO WAY #2404, FORT MYERS

Sally Davies

Lakefront 2 BR, 2 BA + Den/3rd BR, Near Beaches $289,300 RS163268

239.691.3319

Light, Bright & Airy To Floor Unit $264,900

RS165384

239.691.3319

RENTAL OWNERS DESERVE PERFORMANCE, NOT PROMISES. REVENUE STRATEGY | DYNAMIC PRICING | 24/7 SUPPORT Royal Shell Vacations delivers full-scale vacation rental management backed by on-island operations, professional marketing, and integrated real estate expertise. From revenue optimization to maintenance response, we protect value and drive income.

Maximize your property’s potential. 239.472.9111 100,000+ Annual Guests. Local Offices. On-island Teams.

Offices in Florida and North Carolina

RSEarnMore.com

239.347.0563 | RoyalShellRealEstate.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 35

JULY 2026 MARKET REPORT SANIBEL STATS July

Residential Key Metrics

2025

2026

Year to Date % Change

Thru 7-2025 Thru 7-2026

-52.6%

New Listings

Pending Sales

+20.0%

% Change

283

195

-31.1%

109

165

+51.4%

161 148

+14.7%

Closed Sales

-23.1%

Days on Market Until Sale

157

191

+21.7%

107 129

+50.5%

Median Sales Price*

$1,062,599

$1,122,500

+5.6%

$1,100,000

$1,175,000

+6.8%

Average Sales Price*

$1,273,738

$1,203,000

-5.6%

$1,387,421

$1,559,280

+12.4%

Percent of List Price Received

90.9%

93.5%

+2.9%

91.6%

92.0%

Inventory of Homes for Sale

197

134

-32.0%

---

-54.7%

---

Months Supply of Inventory

16.1

Condo

7.3

July

+0.4%

Year to Date % Change

Key Metrics

2025

New Listings

-57.1%

192

113

-41.1%

Pending Sales

+100.0%

+41.0%

2026

Thru 7-2025 Thru 7-2026

% Change

Closed Sales

+100.0%

+33.3%

Days on Market Until Sale

187

241

+28.9%

124

187

+50.8%

Median Sales Price*

$600,000

$750,000

+25.0%

$719,000

$762,500

+6.1%

Average Sales Price*

$662,000

$778,400

+17.6%

$781,476

$836,696

+7.1%

88.8%

92.9%

+4.6%

93.0%

92.4%

-0.6%

---

Percent of List Price Received Inventory of Homes for Sale

157

130

-17.2%

---

Months Supply of Inventory

22.7

12.2

-46.3%

---

Key Metrics

2025

2026

% Change

Thru 7-2025

Thru 7-2026

New Listings

+100.0%

-40.0%

Pending Sales

0.0%

+50.0%

Closed Sales

+50.0%

6 3

9 8

+166.7% +64.9%

Residential

CAPTIVA STATS

Year to Date

July

% Change

184

233

+26.6%

151

249

Median Sales Price*

$2,056,000

$3,100,000

+50.8%

$1,600,000

$3,112,500

+94.5%

Average Sales Price*

$2,056,000

$5,125,000

+149.3%

$1,674,000

$4,306,250

+157.2%

+2.2%

85.2%

88.0%

+3.3%

---

Days on Market Until Sale

Percent of List Price Received

82.4%

84.2%

Inventory of Homes for Sale

-15.2%

---

Months Supply of Inventory

25.7

16.8

-34.6%

---

2025

2026

% Change

New Listings

Pending Sales

+150.0% -25.0%

Condo Key Metrics

July

Year to Date Thru 7-2025 Thru 7-2026

% Change

0.0%

+160.0%

Closed Sales

+25.0%

+150.0%

Days on Market Until Sale

220

-64.5%

249

126

-49.4%

Median Sales Price*

$457,500

$905,000

+97.8%

$737,500

$580,000

-21.4%

Average Sales Price*

$513,750

$1,230,000

+139.4%

$993,500

$932,660

88.6%

96.2%

+8.6%

88.2%

-6.1%

Percent of List Price Received

94.0%

+6.6%

Inventory of Homes for Sale

-23.9%

---

Months Supply of Inventory

20.9

12.0

-42.6%

---

*Source: Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of REALTORS® Multiple Listing Service as of August 10, 2026. The Association nor its MLS guarantees or is in any way responsible for its accuracy. Data maintained by the Association or its MLS may not reflect all real estate activity in the market.

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Thinking Real Estate?

Let’s Talk!

“Mike McMurray”

CAPTIVA ISLAND

CAYO COSTA

SANIBEL ISLAND

CAPTIVA ISLAND

16512 CAPTIVA DR ADDRESS

1000 CAYO COSTA ADDRESS

16730 CAPTIVA DR ADDRESS

3767 W GULF DR ADDRESS

$7,950,000 PRICE

$3,250,000 PRICE

$10,900,000 PRICE

$8,895,000 PRICE

•FEATURES Estate w/Main & Guest House • 100’+ of Frontage on Gold Coast • Beachfront Pool, Screened Lanai • European Style, Wood & Shell Stone Floors

•FEATURES 1.8 Acres in 2,500 Acre State Park • 3 BR, 3 BA, Amazing Kitchen, Dock • Boat to Cabbage Key, Useppa & More • Feels Like Private Island, Gulf/Bay Views

•FEATURES 5 BR, 2 Story, Beachfront, Gulf Views • Private Boardwalk to Beach • Elevated w/Tons of Natural Lighting • Estate Zoned & Fully Landscaped

GOLD COAST BEACHFRONT

CAPTIVA ISLAND

• Gulf Front, 6,640 S.F. Living Area FEATURES • Fully Furnished w/Custom Pieces • Huge Pool & Spa Area w/Beach Views • 3 Levels of Deck Space

SANIBEL ISLAND

CAPTIVA ISLAND

16530 CAPTIVA DR ADDRESS

16280 CAPTIVA DR ADDRESS

5105 JOEWOOD DR ADDRESS

15899 CAPTIVA DR ADDRESS

$12,500,000

$12,000,000 PRICE

3,750,000

$5,250,000

•FEATURES Island Estate w/ Private Tennis Court • 2 Acre Lot w/ 200 Ft of Beach Frontage • Private Beach Bungalow & Caretakers Quarters • Two Adjacent Properties Also Available!

PRICE

•FEATURES 2 Acre Vacant Lot, 150’ Beach Frontage • Located on High Ridge Dune Setting • Opportunity to Build • One of Captiva’s Highest Elevations

•FEATURES 5 BRs, 5,200+ S.F. Living • Elevated w/3 Story Screened Pool • Tons of Deck Space w/Gulf Views • Large Lot w/Tropical Landscaping

PRICE

•FEATURES Elevated Beachfront w/Dock • 4 BRs, 3 Baths, 2,900 S.F. • Private Balcony w/Gulf Views • Home Generator & Impact Windows

PRICE

FOR PROPERTIES OF PRESTIGE & & PREFERENCE PREFERENCE Follow Us On On Social SocialMedia Media At: At:@McMurrayandMembers @McMurrayandMembers Follow Us McMurrayandMembers.com | Info@McMurrayandMembers.com | Mike: 239.850.7888

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 37

35+ Years of Industry Experience & Local Knowledge

Selling the Best Requires the Best!

15261 CAPTIVA DRIVE

15867 & 15879 CAPTIVA DRIVE

SAWGRASS PLACE

NATOMA PARK

PELICAN LANDINGS

PALM GARDENS

CAPTIVA GULF TO BAY ESTATE

SECLUDED OASIS ON CAPTIVA

• 4 Br, 4.5 Bath, Deep Water Dock W/lift 1240 COCONUT DR ADDRESS • Stofft Cooney Design, Waterfront Oasis •• Custom Designed by Stofft Heated Pool W/infinity Spa, Cooney Estate Lot FEATURES Retreat W/ Loft •• 7Master BR, 8.3 BA, Gym, Guest House •$11,499,000 Gated w/2 Access Roads, 7 Car Garage

• Main house 3 BR, 3.5 BA, 4,000 S.F. 5539 NATOMA DR •ADDRESS Spacious 3 BR, 3 BR Guest Cottage ••FEATURES ExceptionalBay Waterfront Retreat Panoramic Views, Deep Water Dock Expansive •• Stunning 3 BR, 4 BA, ~4,000Gulf S.F.Views, Pool/Spa •$11,700,000 Gourmet Kitchen & Custom Finishes

• Enormous Pool/Jacuzzi w/ Water Views!

• Poo/Spa & Private Boat Lift

11559 LAIKA LANE $13,300,000 PRICE

3304 SAINT KILDA ROAD $1,149,000 PRICE

FT MYERS RIVERFRONT

NEAR BEACH

• Iconic, Modern, Gulf Front Estate, 4,730 S.F. • Rooftop Terrace, Floor to Ceiling Windows • Open Concept Kitchen, Double Islands, Chef’s Dream • 2 Master Suites, Perfect 13230 LINTON RD Home & Vacation Rental ADDRESS $7,500,000

• Possible Gulf Views From Piling Home • Private, Lake View Setting • Location Off West Gulf Drive • Great Building Site 12061 SANTALUZ DR #201 ADDRESS $599,000

$8,500,000 PRICE

$399,000 PRICE

• 2-Acre Caloosahatchee River Estate FEATURES • Private Lagoon & Quick Gulf Access • Caribbean-Coastal Inspired Luxury • Rooftop Deck With Sunset Views

•FEATURES Golf Course & Pond Views • 2nd Story condo over 2300 SQ FT • Newer Construction • Great Amenities & optional social / golf memberships

ALVA

SAWGRASS OF SANIBEL

THE SANCTUARY

• 1 Address. 2 Private Clubs. • 3 Golf Courses & Resort Living

• Resort Style Pool + Outdoor Kitchen • Oversized Garage + Impact Doors/Windows

• New 2020 Construction, Incredible Golf Course Setting N OLGA •18090 4 Bedroom/4.5 Bath DR Open Great Room Floor Plan ADDRESS ••Spectacular Outdoor w/Fireplace Oversized Lot , 750’Space of River Frontage & Kitchen FEATURES Pool & Spa w/Sun Splash Area Over 6,200 S.F., 6+ Bedrooms $• 2,100,000

• Incredible Building Site on West Gulf Drive 3761 CREEK •ADDRESS BeachBAY Access DirectlyDR Across Street ••FEATURES Extraordinary Corner Lot offWaterfront West Gulf Estate Drive •• 10’ 5 BRElevation | 6 BA + Den | ~7,000 S.F. $949,000

15138 WILES DRIVE $4,990,000 PRICE

GATEWAY

MODERN, ICONIC, BEACHFRONT ESTATE

5633 BALTUSROL COURT

16280 CAPTIVA DRIVE $3,850,000 PRICE

CAPE CORAL

CAPTIVA BEACH FRONT

BALI HI TROPICAL PARADISE GETAWAY!

•FEATURES 4 BRs w/ 2100+ SqFt Living Area • 2022 Built Open-Concept Layout • Oversized Lanai w/ Heated Pool & Spa • Prime Location Close to Amenities!

FEATURES • Soaring Ceilings + Screened Pool • Fantastic Neighborhood • Community Pool, Tennis, Basketball, Playground

• 102 Feet Of Premier Gulf Frontage • Comfort Meets Luxury W/ 6 Br 5.5 Ba 4611 Sqft • Private Oasis, Pool, Putting Green 5002 AGUALINDA BLVD $6,495,000 ADDRESS

• 6 Br, 6 Ba, 4,402 S.f Tropical Paradise • Main & Guest House W/ Many Entertaining Areas • Large Lanai, Pool & Spa, Private Beach W/ Beautiful Sunsets •12330 ExcellentMCGREGOR Rental PotentialWOODS CIR ADDRESS $8,900,000 • 4 BR, 3 BA, Pool, 4,500+ S.F.

$695,000 PRICE

$659,000 PRICE

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

SanibelIsland ISLAND BEACH CLUB #320C • 2265 WEST GULF DRIVE

Step into this beautifully remodeled 2-bed, 2-bath coastal retreat where everyday stress melts away. A stunning natural cypress accent wall anchors the living space, adding warm coastal charm reminiscent of an Ernest Hemingway Key West escape. Sold decorator-furnished and fully turnkey, this pet-friendly Sanibel gem features soothing coastal décor, LVP ﬂooring, ensuite bedrooms, custom walk-in closet shelving, screened lanai, impact glass windows, new roof, HVAC, and convenient storage. Perfectly positioned for seasonal rentals, it’s an eﬀortless island escape and smart investment. Paradise awaits! 2 bedroom • 2 bathrooms $1,200,000

2026 SALES 717 Gopher Walk Way 565 Birdsong Place 5639 Balt�srol Cour� 1202 Sand Castle Road *

239. 233. 6364

1490 Sand Castle Road * Sanibel Shores A1 1245 Fer�� Road * 4560 Brainard Bayou Road Sanddollar B303

S �� B �� P �� @gmail.com

Captains Walk E2 Sandalfoot 3C3 3366 Bar�a Circle 918 Kings Crown Drive *Selling Agent

2 3 9 .2 3 3.6364

S �� B �� P �� .��

P F E I F E R R E A LT Y G R O U P • 1630- I P E R I W I N K L E WAY • S A N I B E L , F L 3 3 9 5 7

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 39

C: 239.292.4944 Kerri@PfeiferRealtyGroup.com PfeiferRealtyGroup.com

REAL ESTATE SALES

SBL REALTY GROUP Rob Pailes Broker, GRI

Carly Price Realtor®

& VACATION RENTALS

Trust Us to Guide You Home

Loggerhead Cay 242 Sanibel, FL 33957 $795,000

Spanish Cay D5 Sanibel, FL 33957 PENDING

Charlie Hartley Realtor®

SBL REALTY GROUP Real Estate Sales

SANIBEL VACATIONS Vacation Rentals

2330 Palm Ridge Road #14 Sanibel, FL 33957

2330 Palm Ridge Road #12 Sanibel, FL 33957

239-312-4706 info@sblrealtygroup.com

239-579-0348 stay@sblvacations.com

www.SBLRealtyGroup.com | www.SBLVacations.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Two Days. Exceptional Homes. Endless Possibilities.

SUMMER SHOWCASE

THE

A Gulf Coast Event | Saturday & Sunday, August 22-23

Experience one of the Gulf Coast's largest OPEN HOUSE events across Pinellas, Manatee, Sarasota, Charlotte, and Lee counties. Whether you're searching for your next home, a waterfront retreat, or simply seeing what's available, this is your opportunity to tour exceptional homes across the Gulf Coast—all in one weekend.

Your dream home could be just a visit away!

SCAN FOR OPEN HOUSES

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 41

SANIBEL 2605 W Gulf Drive | 1.21 Acre Lot Deb Gleason, 239.770.5249 | 2026013291 | $2,800,000

FORT MYERS BEACH 18323 Cutlass Drive | 2 Beds 2 Baths | 2,908 Sq. Ft. Deb Smith, 239.826.3416 | 2026018870 | $1,488,000

SANIBEL 497 E Gulf Drive #4 | 2 Beds 2/1 Baths | 1,162 Sq. Ft. Arika Bjorkedal, 239.410.1706 | 2025021457 | $1,450,000

CAPTIVA 11400 Old Lodge Lane #1C | 2 Beds 2 Baths | 1,200 Sq. Ft. Karen Bell, 239.851.0168 | 225011517 | $1,375,000

CAPTIVA 905 Marina Villas #905 | 2 Beds 2 Baths | 861 Sq. Ft. Evan duPont, 239.462.1817 | 2026025412 | $1,179,000

SANIBEL 1550 Wilton Lane | 3 Beds 2/1 Baths | 3,076 Sq. Ft. Arika Bjorkedal, 239.410.1706 | 2026001559 | $1,150,000

SANIBEL 1149 Periwinkle Way #2 | 4,521 Sq. Ft. Evan duPont, 239.462.1817 | 2025018917 | $1,100,000

SANIBEL 658 Donax Street | 3 Beds 2 Baths | 1,519 Sq. Ft. Evan duPont, 239.462.1817 | 2025007346 | $1,095,000

239.472.5187 1560 Periwinkle Way | Sanibel, FL

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

SANIBEL 6092 Sanibel Captiva Road | 2 Beds 2 Baths | 1,291 Sq. Ft. Evan duPont, 239.462.1817 | 2026001344 | $995,000

SANIBEL 702 Pyrula Avenue | 3 Beds 2 Baths | 1,552 Sq. Ft. Karen Bell, 239.851.0168 | 224104948 | $895,000

SANIBEL 979 E Gulf Drive #191 | 2 Beds 2 Baths | 1,184 Sq. Ft. Charles Sobczak, 239.850.0710 | 2026016027 | $847,555

SANIBEL 1986 Wild Lime Drive | 3 Beds 2 Baths | 1,548 Sq. Ft. Karen Bell, 239.851.0168 | 2026024240 | $799,000

FORT MYERS 15210 Portside Drive #402 | 2 Beds 2 Baths | 1,584 Sq. Ft. Deb Smith, 239.826.3416 | 2026029039 | $699,000

FORT MYERS 12281 Mcgregor Palms Drive | 3 Beds 2 Baths | 2,130 Sq. Ft. Karen Bell, 239.851.0168 | 2026030438 | $689,000

SANIBEL 5117 Sea Bell Road #B101 | 2 Beds 2 Baths | 1,207 Sq. Ft. Deb Smith, 239.826.3416 | 225034203 | $599,000

FORT MYERS 17827 Saddlebunch Key | 3 Beds 2/1 Baths | 2,014 Sq. Ft. Jayne Lumley, 239.872.2546 | 2026005100 | $595,000

Nowhere but here. MICHAELSAUNDERS.COM | 888.552.5228 Licensed Real Estate Broker

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 43

FORT MYERS 8794 Pigeon Key | 3 Beds 2 Baths | 1,761 Sq. Ft. Jayne Lumley, 239.872.2546 | 2025026130 | $587,500

FORT MYERS 8306 Sumner Avenue | 4 Beds 2/1 Baths | 2,601 Sq. Ft. Connie Walters, 239.841.4540 | 2026007722 | $439,000

FORT MYERS 833 N Town And River Drive | 3 Beds 2 Baths | 1,884 Sq. Ft. Deb Smith, 239.826.3416 | 2026025005 | $430,000

SANIBEL 6095 Dinkins Lake Road | 1.01 Acre Lot Charles Sobczak, 239.850.0710 | 2026028352 | $359,555

FORT MYERS 11620 Marino Court #204 | 3 Beds 2 Baths | 1,729 Sq. Ft. Deb Smith, 239.826.3416 | 2026022486 | $324,000

FORT MYERS 9270 Bayberry Bend #202 | 2 Beds 2 Baths | 1,461 Sq. Ft. Deb Smith, 239.826.3416 | 2026018298 | $308,000

FORT MYERS 7863 Lake Sawgrass Loop #5512 | 3 Beds 2/1 Baths | 1,491 Sq. Ft. Evan duPont, 239.462.1817 | 2026023199 | $269,900

FORT MYERS 12191 Kelly Sands Way #1518 | 2 Beds 2 Baths | 1,280 Sq. Ft. Bob Berning, 239.699.9597 | 2026021123 | $248,500

239.472.5187 1560 Periwinkle Way | Sanibel, FL

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Direct Access Canal

Exceptional Sanibel Sanctuary

Waterfront retreat on serene western end. Bay access, sunlit, open interiors. pool, spa and private 26’ dock. Reduced to $1,399,000

This home offers privacy, natural beauty, 3-bed, 2.5-bath main home, separate 1/1 guest house and resort-style pool. Now $1,100,000 For more information

Talk or Text 239.851.2301 Wendy.Humphrey@PremierSir.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 45

FEATURED PROPERTIES NEW PRICE

3324 SAINT KILDA ROAD | Offered for $3,250,000 NEW CONSTRUCTION coastal estate with deeded beach access and over 11,000 sq ft (4,400 under air). Built with ICF for strength and efficiency, featuring 4 bedrooms + office, 4.5 baths, pool, spa, and elevator. Incredible chef’s kitchen with premium appliances and finishes and a luxurious primary suite with enormous closet, steam room, and spa-style bath. NEW PRICE

1428 ALBATROSS ROAD | Offered for $1,295,000

1653 BUNTING LANE | Offered for $325,000

Beautiful elevated Key West–style home built in 2016. Open floor plan with high ceilings, wrap-around verandas, and quality finishes throughout, including wood flooring, cypress ceilings, and a custom tile backsplash. Split-bedroom layout with spacious primary suite, elevator to loft with two offices, and impact-resistant construction. Overlooks conservation land for peaceful views.

Corner .55-acre lot in Gumbo Limbo, mostly cleared with existing pool. No impact fees. Approved plans available for a 3 bed/3.5 bath home with 2-car garage. Walkable location near shops, dining, and the Causeway.

ISLAND RESIDENT, TRUSTED REALTOR ®

Carolyn Tongyai Realtor® SCIS, AHWD, ABR®

(239) 691-2551

Carolyn@CTongyai.com

1019 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel FL. 33957

239-691-2551 Carolyn@CTongyai.com TheIslandsandBeyond.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

SANIBEL & CAPTIVA ISLAND

Agents

As the #1 Brokerage in SWFLA we offer expert guidance and unrivaled market knowledge. Call us for all your real estate needs.

MAUREN AHMED 239-900-6275

ANDRE ARENSMAN 239-233-1414

TRISH BIEHL 239-414-9109

KRIS CARDINALE 239-464-1225

TONY DIBIASE 239-839-4987

DANA FOSTER 239-989-2136

MELANY HOLAWAY 239-233-9544

BETSY KIMREY 443-223-3399

CECILIA LIICHOW 309-883-9907

BABS MAUGHAN 239-314-4800

BROOKS SELBY 239-292-7533

JIM SENKELESKI 908-507-8881

ELISE STARR 239-209-3960

LEANE SUAREZ 239-872-1632

KEN SUAREZ 239-313-8044

ALEC SUAREZ 239-322-0243

AUSTIN SUAREZ 239-322-0242

CAROLYN TONGYAI 239-691-2551

Jay Richter

Managing Broker on the Islands over 30 Years Trusted Advisor BARRY WADDELL 239-464-4888

MELISSA WIENS 239-460-7403

239-233-3520 JRichter@JohnRWood.com

1019 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel | 11499 Andy Rosse Lane, Captiva JOHNRWOOD.COM

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 47

KINZIE ISLAND

COMMERCIAL

SPANISH CAY

55+ COMMUNITY

503 E. Gulf Drive #A $3,500,000

2440 Palm Ridge Road $2,700,000

1610 Middle Gulf Dr. #A3 $380,000

9626 Windsor Club Circle $280,000

Sanibel | 4 BD | 4.5 BA 2-unit condo building Stunning gulf views Private beach boardwalk Private Boat Slip 4-car tandem garage Pool, tennis/pickleball courts & fitness room

Sanibel | 2-Story Building Pelican Place Shopping Center First Floor Leased 173' Frontage along Palm Ridge Road Retail and Mixed Use Architectural drawings for 2nd floor

Sanibel | 1 BD | 1 BA Beach Access across the street Completely renovated Quartz counters, stainless appliances & sleek cabinets Glass-enclosed lanai Fishing decks & community pool

Fort Myers | 3 BD | 3BA Pine Ridge of Fort Myers Village 2-story | 1,360 sq. ft. 20-acre lake with walking path 40x80 heated commnity pool Clubhouse, tennis & pickleball Active Social Calendar

TINA DICHARIA

REAL ESTATE PROFESSIONAL ABR | RSPS | E-PRO | SCIS

239-340-5636 | tina@dicharia.com TinaDiCharia.PfeiferRealtyGroup.net

1630 Perwinkle Way Sanibel, FL 33957

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

License #CGC1525552

Luxury Interior & Exterior Renovations | Rot/Structural Repairs | Window and Door Replacement | Decks, Landings, and Stairs |

AVOID INSURANCE CLAIM REJECTION! PRE AND POST STORM DOCUMENTATION AVAILABLE EMAIL US FOR MORE INFORMATION *MUST BE SIGNED UP PRIOR TO STORM FORMATION*

GUIDING YOU THROUGH YOUR REMODELING JOURNEY

As experienced remodeling professionals, it is our mission to bring your visions and dreams to life. Your home is a reflection on our reputation.

www.RemodelingSanCap.com Office: (239) 207-2195 Office email: Heidi@LB-R.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 49

2807 West Gulf Drive, Sanibel

Sanibel Homesite

Near-Beach homesite!

Allows weekly rentals

Located in Resort District Seller Financing Available! 15% down to a qualified buyer!

$679,900 Build Your Dream Home!

246 Christofer Court, Sanibel

485 Peachtree Road, Sanibel

Sanibel View 206, Fort Myers

Seagull Estates

Perfect Island Getaway!

Lake View!

$1,379,000

Call Susan Dunn 239-671-6381

Three bed, two 1/2 bath ● 2208 sf

$950,000

$398,000

Three bed, three bath ● 1990 sf

Two bed, two bath ● 1591 sf

Ann Gee, Broker Certified Negotiator

RealtorAnn22@gmail.com

239-850-0979

GeeSanibelRealty.com

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 51 If you want it done right the first time...

DISCOVER THE DIFFERENCE

If you want it done right the first time . . . 239-472-5187 x 227

A DAV E M A K E S 800–794–3107 239–472–5021 Cell 239–565–3186 Discover the Difference A DAVE MAKES

239-472-5187 x 227 | 800-553-7338 x 227 | Evenings 239-466-0514 | |

NEW LISTING

580 Sea Oats Drive

Pointe Santo #E43

NEW LISTING

800-553-7338 x 227 Oceans Reach #1D1 Evenings 239-466-0514

PRICE ADJUSTMENT

CANAL FRONT ENCHANTMENT

WEST ISLAND GEM

Located a short stroll from Sanibel’s white sand beaches, this 4 bed 3 bath beauty is ideal for entertaining or as a quite island retreat. It features a large wrap around screened lanai accessible from the primary bedroom and great room and overlooks the heated pool and spa. There’s an outdoor shower for rinsing off the sand before relaxing in the indoor jetted tub. The kitchen has a built-in desk area, small island and breakfast bar for informal dining. The great room has a dining nook, tile flooring and numerous windows allowing natural light to flow through the living space. Latticed under building area is perfect for parking your car, golf cart, LOTboat or any other beach toys you may have. Bonus: Ground-level enclosed storage area. 4 Beds / 3 Baths

Oﬀered at $1,395,000

Pointe Santo #B44

PENTHOUSE

Spectacular Gulf & sunset views can be yours! This beautiful two bedroom two bathroom penthouse has a private rooftop sundeck overlooking 500 feet of amazing Sanibel beachfront. This unique and updated offering is one of only two top floor units with this floor plan featuring a den area for additional entertaining space. Pointe Santo is a family friendly complex with a Gulf front pool and spa, and recreational program for children. Hurry this condo will sell quickly! UNDER CONTRACT

2 Beds + Den / 2 Baths

Oﬀered at $1,200,000

Direct Gulf access home with spectacular canal LIFE IS BETTER ATintersecting THE BEACH! views. Western exposure Decorated with tranquil ocean colors, providescottage magical sunset vistas. designer coastal furniture, exquisite sea glass light fixtures Experience the best in trueand a custom seascape mural,island you living will feel indoor-outdoor like you have truly stepped at this estate located foot in a in paradise. Firstprestigious, floor corner next east location end cul-deto a natural preserve allows additional sac your location. privacy to enjoy vacation while still

only being steps away from the beach. 1743 Venus Drivethe screened Direct Gulf views from lanai and master bedroom will enhance 4 Beds / 3.5 Baths your experience. Raised ceilings, $1,680,000 Bosch appliances, custom kitchen cabinets, porcelain tile, heavy pocket doors, plantation shutters and large screen JUSTTVs. SOLDFuture bookings are strong and will continue to provide excellent rental income for a new owner.

2 Beds / 2 Baths

Pointe Santo #D41

SOLD

Oﬀered at $1,090,000

5071 Joewood Drive

PRIVATE PARADISE WITH DOCK

GULF VIEW SANIBEL ESCAPE

CLASSIC SANIBEL STEPS FROM THE SAND

Attention boaters and fishermen! Direct Gulf access double canal lot located in a secluded upscale community perfect for the most discerning Buyer. Parcel has over 180’ of canal frontage with a dock. All you need is a boat and a dream to start living the Sanibel lifestyle!

Contemporary interiors meet tranquil Gulf and lagoon views in this coastal cool condominium. This west end beachside bungalow is just seconds from the sand, sun, heated pool, hot tub, tennis and more.

Sparkling Gulf views and lush tropical grounds greet you at this tastefully remodeled beach retreat. In just steps, enjoy world class shelling along Sanibel’s white sand beaches. Convenient east end location provides easy access to shopping and fine dining. Pet friendly.

5821 Pine Tree Drive

Pointe Santo • 2445 West Gulf Drive #B23

Construction Financing Available

Sanibel Surfside • 610 Donax Street #225

2 Beds / 2 Baths

$549,000

FIRST COME FIRST SERVE!

2 Beds / 2 Baths

Fully Furnished for $799,000 FORSold THE BUYER WHO WANTS IT ALL!

Sold Fully Furnished for $774,900

GULF FRONT HOME IN EXCLUSIVE GULF RIDGE

This spectacular Gulf View fourth floor This highly sought after fourth floor penthouse has it all! Updated and beautifully Built on 20-foot-high concrete pilings, this VIP REALTY GROUP, INC. DAVID L.condo SCHULDENFREI 2 bedroom two bath Penthouse furnished. Enjoy your very own private property offers sweeping Gulf views while ® 1560 Periwinkle Way · Sanibel, Florida 33957 sundeck boasting CRS, GRI, SCIS, with private a Realtor newly renovated rooftop sundeck with still being nestled in your own private spectacular panoramic view of the Gulf expansive Gulf views. Pointe Santo tropical oasis. The primary bedroom of Mexico and Sanibel’s world-famous allows one small pet for owners. Superior opens to an oversized lanai and has two white sand beach is now available as weekly vacation rental income. First come separate master bathrooms for you and Visit Usbath, Online: SCHULDENFREI.COM Email first serve for this two bedroom two a family vacation property or Us: income DAVIDS@SCHULDENFREI.COM your spouse to enjoy. Other notable spectacular Gulf and sunset view fourth producing gem.Just open the sliders in features include a large office, bunk floor penthouse with private rooftop the bright and spacious primary bedroom room, whole house generator, elevator, sundeck! Updated and beautifully and let the sound of the ocean waves outdoor kitchen and outdoor shower to furnished with minimal hurricane damage. lull you to sleep. Pointe Santo is a One of the most sought after complexes allow you to enjoy time having fun in the family friendly complex with BBQ on Sanibel Island, perfect for that quiet sun while being able to work from home grills, tennis, volleyball, pickleball, get away or your next family gathering. or enjoy time with your extended family. gulf front pool and spa. 2 Beds / 2 Baths

Oﬀered at $1,100,000

2 Beds / 2 Baths

Oﬀered Turnkey at $1,100,000

GOPHER ENTERPRISES OF SANIBEL & CAPTIVA ISLANDS CORP PO Box 186 • Sanibel, Florida 33957 Visit Us Online:

schuldenfrei.com

Email Us:

4 Beds / 5 Baths / 2 Half Baths

DAVID L. SCHULDENFREI CRS, GRI, SCIS, Realtor®

davids@schuldenfrei.com

Yours for $4,950,000

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

YOU MAKE IT HOME, I MAKE IT EASY. Your path to paradise is virtually at MrListr.com.

Buy or build a cozy new home at a comfortable price.

My comprehensive website features premier properties in all of Lee County.

Your home should be your safe haven against the stresses of the world. That’s why LMCU and I want to make homeownership less anxiety inducing. We’ll help you buy or build for as little as 15% down.*

Buying or selling, make your first visit to my website. It has all the tools you need to navigate the Southwest Florida real estate market.

Just get comfy and give me a call — I’ll get moving on the paperwork, so you can kick back.

Contact Dan Krispinsky Mortgage Loan Originator (239) 850-9232 Dan.Krispinsky@LMCU.org

TRACY WALTERS REALTOR®

NMLS #422448

239.994.7975 | 959 PERIWINKLE WAY, SANIBEL Email: tracyw@sanibelcaptivaproperties.com

SCAN TO VISIT WEBSITE

*For well qualified borrowers. LMCU NMLS #442967

246 Christofer Court

MTG_2026_14681 2026 Sanibel Real Estate Guide 4.2x5.7875 September:October_v2.indd 1

SEAGULL ESTATES 3 BEDROOMS

2.5 BATHROOMS 2 CAR GARAGE 2,808 SQFT

1,379,000

A Deal Call me today for ...

Right!

SUSAN DUNN 239.671.6381 susandunnre @gmail.com

8/19/26 1:11 PM

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 53

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 55

IT’S THE EXPERIENCE!

Kim Herres

“PROFESSIONAL REAL ESTATE SERVICES ON SANIBEL-CAPTIVA ISLANDS AND SW FLORIDA” OVER 49 YEARS ISLAND RESIDENT/REALTOR - RE/MAX INTERNATIONAL HALL OF FAME

REALTOR®

C 239.233.0252 O 239.472.5187 F 239.472.0996 KimHerres @michaelsaunders.com

1560 Periwinkle Way Sanibel, FL 33957

KimHerres.michaelsaunders.com

LITTLE LAKE MUREX

This near beach 4/4 +, 3000 sq ft lakefront pool home features NEWLY remodeled kitchen, private elevator, impact glass and doors plus 3 screen enclosed lanais and low exterior maintenance. A short stroll to beach access and community amenities.

$995,000

CAPTIVA 11523 Andy Rosse Lane | 5 Beds 5/1 Baths | 3,555 Sq. Ft. Evan duPont, 239.462.1817 | 2025014469 | $3,795,000

SANIBEL 3131 W Gulf Drive Unit 305 | 3 Beds 3/1 Baths | 2,642 Sq. Ft. Jayne Lumley, 239.872.2546 | 2025017652 | $2,695,000

SANIBEL 1656 Hibiscus Drive | 4 Beds 3/1 Baths | 3,216 Sq. Ft. Dan Wexler, 202.997.3404 | 225017153 | $2,635,000

SANIBEL 865 Birdie View Point | 4 Beds 4/1 Baths | 4,117 Sq. Ft. Karen Bell, 239.851.0168 | 225006203 | $1,849,000

BUILDABLE ISLAND HOMESITES

• $450,000 East Rocks -Waterfront with Utilities On-site • $475,000 South Capers -Near Beach Cul-de-sac Setting • $529,000 Beachview CC Estates-Waterfront on Golf Course

STEVE FISHER, Broker-Associate

239-470-6910 Steve@sanibelcaptivarealtors.com

MASTIQUE RESORT-STYLE COMMUNITY SANIBEL 734 Sand Dollar Drive | 3 Beds 3/1 Baths | 2,340 Sq. Ft. Evan duPont & James Hetmanek, 239.462.1817 | 2025020027 | $1,595,000

STAY CLOSE TO SANIBEL!

12601 Mastique Beach Blvd #401 3BR / 3BA

699,000

12601 Mastique Beach Blvd #502 3BR / 2BA

12601 Mastique Beach Blvd #1901 $

1,150,000

SANIBEL 716 Rabbit Road | 3 Beds 2/1 Baths | 2,236 Sq. Ft. Karen Bell, 239.851.0168 | 2025018371 | $1,099,000

12701 Mastique Beach Blvd #504

3BR / 3BA

649,000

239.472.5187 $ 1560 Periwinkle Way | Sanibel, FL

MICHAELSAUNDERS.COM | 888.552.5228

d ce duice e R Pr

Licensed Real Estate Broker

12601 Mastique Beach Blvd #1103 3BR / 2BA

ed uc e d Re Pric

SANIBEL 1062 S Yachtsman Drive | 3 Beds 3 Baths | 1,624 Sq. Ft. Karen Bell, 239.851.0168 | 225060522 | $1,299,000

Nowhere / 3BAbut here. 845,000 3BR

FORT MYERS BEACH 18141 Old Pelican Bay Drive | 5 Beds 3/1 Baths | 3,590 Sq. Ft. Debbie Ringdahl, 239.691.6029 | 224080974 | $1,449,000

689,000

12601 Mastique Beach Blvd #1603 3BR / 2BA

699,900

12701 Mastique Beach Blvd #1504 2BR / 3BA / DEN

789,900

3BR / 2BA

Carolyn & Ted

Ted A. Benjamin REALTOR®

239.900.7323

719,900

tedtalksrealestate@yahoo.com

599,000

s Clo

15206 Parkside Dr #201 2BR / 2BA

3BR / 2BA

s Clo 12601 Mastique Beach Blvd #1102

12601 Mastique Beach Blvd #1202

175,000

12601 Mastique Beach Blvd #1601 3BR / 3BA

780,000

Odin

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Superior Title

Superior Title Services of Sanibel is a locally owned & operated, full-service Title Insurance Company and Owner & Operator, Amanda Curran, has over 20 years’ experience in the Title Insurance industry. Her dedicated team of professionals has received multiple awards & accolades for productivity, professionalism & service, and they are eager to exceed your expectations!

Professional, Knowledgeable and Superior Service.

Services:

• Real Estate Closings • Refinancing • 1031 Exchanges • FIRPTA Requirements • Last Deed of Record • Remote Online Notarizations Download our Mobile App with Closing Cost Estimator on the App Store or Google Play for iPhone or Android device. Just search “Superior Title of Sanibel”

Amanda Curran President Licensed Title Agent

Dustyn Corace Vice President

Chelsea Aiello Processor/Closer Licensed Title Agent

Mollie Donaghy Processor

Suzanne Johns Receptionist Hospitality Specialist

Daisy Aiello Intern

Corporate Office: 1101 Periwinkle Way, Suite 102 • Sanibel, FL 33957 P: (239) 579-0681 • F: (239) 579-0682 Satellite Office: 9220 Bonita Beach Road, Suite 116 • Bonita Springs, FL 34135 P: (239) 390-9507

www.superior-title.com

Bodie Corace VP Customer Relations Company Morale Specialist

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 57

Buying or Selling? Ring BELL For Service

S LI

COCONUT CREEK

SANIBEL’S LIGHTHOUSE POINT

CAPTIVA CASPIAN

BEACHVIEW ESTATES • Near Beach 3 BR/2.5 BA Home

• Steps to the Beach!

• 3 BR/2 BA Condo

• Heated, Saltwater Pool & Spa

• 4 BR/4 BA Custom Beach Home

• Impact Windows & Doors

• Beautiful Details

• Private Elevator & Gas Fireplace

• Screened Heated Pool

• Metal Roof / 2-Car Garage

• Great Amenities

• Many “New” Upgrades!

• Sold Furnished

• Fenced Backyard / Pool & Spa

• Sold Furnished

• 3 Bedroom/2 Bath/Plus Den • .56 Acre Corner Lot

$689,000

SANIBEL BAYOUS BEAUTY

$695,000

CAPTIVA COTTAGE

$$1,595,000

• Located in the Village!

$1,895,000

THE SANCTUARY

DONAX VILLAGE

• Remodeled 3 BR/2 BA Home

• True Island Cottage

• .57 Acre Building Site

• Remodeled & Near Beach

• Large Lot on Sanibel’s “High Ridge”

• 4 BR/3 BA Home

• Located on a Cul-De-Sac

• 2 BR/2 BA, Plus Loft Condo

• Newly Furnished / No Storm Claims

• Heated Pool & Spa

• Best & Largest Lot Available

• Elevated above FEMA FLOOD Elev.

• Private Elevator

• Steps from the Beach

• Arthur Hills Golf Course

• Amenities: Pool & Tennis/Pickleball

$799,000

$1,999,000

$650,000

$649,000

Karen Bell, Broker Associate Realtor

John Bates, Realtor

239.851.0168

1560 Periwinkle Way | Sanibel, FL 33957 Visit Online

TheBellTeam.com

Holly Peeples, Admin/Marketing Coordinator

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

S A N I B E L & C A P T I VA P R O P E R T I E S

BEACH HOME 27 $4,790,000 South Seas Resort Beachfront 5-Bedroom, 4.5 Bathroom, 2-Story Residence. MARTY STOKES | 239.560.5958

BEACH HOME 3 $2,795,000 South Seas Resort Beachfront 5-Bedroom, 4.5 Bathroom, 2-Story Residence. MARTY STOKES | 239.560.5958

JONI STOKES | 239.560.5959

D I S C O V E R W H AT ’ S N E X T — C O N TA C T U S T O D AY. 1 4 8 3 0 C A P T I VA D R I V E C A P T I VA , F L O R I D A 3 3 9 2 4

S O U T H S E A S R E A L E S TAT E .C O M

239.579.1490

South Seas Sanibel Captiva Properties, LLC | Timbers FL Real Estate Company LLC Pricing and availability subject to change at any time without notice.

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 59

S A N I B E L & C A P T I VA P R O P E R T I E S

$749,000

$775,000

$1,395,000

3234 Captiva Resort Villa | South Seas Marty Stokes 239.560.5958

470 Sawgrass Place | Sanibel-Vacant Land Marty Stokes 239.560.5958

2236 Beach Villa | South Seas Marty Stokes 239.560.5958

$1,475,000

$1,549,000

$1,895,000

1647 Lands End Village | South Seas Marty Stokes 239.560.5958

6153 Starling Way | Sanibel Island Marty Stokes 239.560.5958

1656 Lands End Village | South Seas Jerry Burden 970.274.3663

$2,795,000

$4,495,000

Beach Home 3 | South Seas Marty Stokes 239.560.5958

Beach Home 27 | South Seas Marty Stokes 239.560.5958

D I S C O V E R W H AT ’ S N E X T — C O N TA C T U S T O D AY. 1 4 8 3 0 C A P T I VA D R I V E C A P T I VA , F L O R I DA 3 3 9 2 4

S O U T H S E A S R E A L E S TAT E .C O M

239.579.1490

South Seas Sanibel Captiva Properties, LLC | Timbers FL Real Estate Company LLC Pricing and availability subject to change at any time without notice.

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 61

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 63

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

360-Degree Gulf and Bay Views CAPTIVA, FLORIDA | $6,995,000 | EUR €6,116,943

Fully Remodeled Canal Home on East End SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $2,450,000 | EUR €2,091,326

Six-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath home situated on the southernmost tip of Captiva Island. Beyond the gated entrance, it features beamed ceilings, multiple fireplaces, grand living room, resort-style pool and spa, lush landscaping and a private dock with boat lift. Weekly rentals make this great for investors.

Four-bedroom plus den, three-bath remodeled home with 180 feet of canal frontage offering panoramic water views. Property features include chef’s kitchen, lush tropical landscaping, impact windows and doors, screenenclosed pool, and a private boat dock with lift. Short distance to the private footbridge to the beach.

Bella Luna CAPTIVA, FLORIDA | $18,900,000 | EUR €15,903,972

180-degree Canal and Basin Views on Bay Drive SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $2,999,000 | EUR €2,623,567

An architecturally significant Captiva estate designed by renowned Wayne Visbeen of Visbeen Architects and recipient of the 2021 AIBD American Residential Design Award. Built as a concrete-and-steel fortress with hospitality-inspired design, this nationally recognized residence blends exceptional craftsmanship, innovative architecture, and refined livability into a true masterpiece.

Three-bedroom, two-bath stunningly remodeled home with 24-inch tile floors, wood inlaid ceilings, walnut cabinets, Cristallo countertops, and a stunning primary suite with fireplace, sitting area and private loft. Private pool, spa, boat dock, two lifts and direct access to the bay.

Over 150 Feet on the Gulf with Full-size Tennis/Pickleball Court

Remodeled on Direct-Access Canal SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,999,000 | EUR €1,748,072

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $6,289,000 | EUR €5,292,067

Four-bedroom-plus-den, two-and-a-half-bath home situated on approximately 1.4 acres of beachfront. Endless views from every room, Australian Cypress pine flooring, vaulted beadboard ceilings, handcrafted cabinetry, wraparound porches, rooftop sundeck, and a private beachside pool.

Three-bedroom, four-bath plus office completely remodeled tranquil oasis featuring an elegant fireplace, open kitchen, large primary suite, spa-like baths, and a screen-enclosed pool. A deep-water canal with 100 feet of seawall, wraparound dock, and 16,000lb lift make this a boater’s dream.

Custom Remodel on Andy Rosse Lane CAPTIVA, FLORIDA | $4,995,000 | EUR €4,367,996

Rebuilt from the original concrete structure, Xanadu features all-new construction with impact windows, modern systems and luxury finishes. In the heart of Captiva’s historic Village, enjoy a resort-style pool and spa, outdoor kitchen, carriage house with two guest suites, smart home technology and walkable access to the beach, waterfront dining and sunset celebrations.

Newly Built Coastal Home SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,699,000 | EUR €1,467,229

Five-bedroom, three-bath home inside the gates of Butterknife. Features include: new standing-seam metal roof, impact windows/doors, private elevator, vaulted ceilings, a rooftop observation deck with views of the Gulf, and just 344 feet from the deeded beach access. Community amenities include pool, tennis, and pickleball.

Your Local Experts with a Global Reach. C a l l u s a t 2 3 9.4 6 4. 2 9 8 4 S c a n t h e Q R c o d e t o v i e w o u r l i s t i n gs Sotheby’s International Realty® and the Sotheby’s International Realty logo are registered service marks used with permission. Each office is independently owned and operated. Equal Housing Opportunity. Property information herein is derived from various sources including, but not limited to, county records and multiple listing services, and may include approximations. All information is deemed accurate.

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 65

10 Remodeled Home in Beachview

Newer Construction With Gulf Views

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,150,000 | EUR €991,336

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $2,199,000 | EUR €1,894,268

Four-bedroom-plus-den, three-and-a-half-bath home on almost one acre of land built with hurricane-rated concrete construction, impact windows and a standing seam metal roof. The reverse floor plan captures Gulf views. Additional features include private elevator, pool, and near the deeded beach access.

11 Elevated Home on Clam Bayou

Three-bedroom, two-bath partially elevated home with vaulted ceilings, redesigned kitchen, stunning golf course views, elevated private pool and just minutes from the deeded beach access with private parking.

12 Remodeled with Golf Course Views in Beachview

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,199,000 | EUR €1,016,674

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $849,000 | EUR €719,897

Three-bedroom-plus-den, two-and-a-half-bath home with sunset and Gulf views over Clam Bayou. Inside the gates of Heron’s Landing, amenities include kayak launch, fishing pier, beach access, community pool and tennis/pickleball court.

Three-bedroom-plus-den, two-bath home with open floor plan featuring updated kitchen, two spacious living areas, vaulted ceilings with exposed beams, fireplace and an elevated and covered private pool and deck.

13 Direct-Access Canal Home With Bay View

14 Golf Course Views in the Dunes

Three-bedroom, three-and-a-halfbath fully remodeled home with oak wood floors, Cambria quartz countertops, new composite deck, fully mitigated and private pool and spa. This boater’s dream has a private 60-foot dock, new seawall and 28,000-pound lift.

Situated on a premium golf course lot in the Dunes, this Sanibel Island home blends modern luxury with Florida charm. Newly remodeled living spaces open seamlessly to an expansive lanai featuring a resort-style pool, spa, and outdoor kitchen.

15 Gulf-Front Home on Sanibel’s East End

16 Bay and Long Canal Views

Stunningly remodeled four-bedroom-plus-den, four-bath home in gated Colony Beach Estates. Features breathtaking Gulf views, wood floors, multiple lanais, private elevator, pool, spa, and a spacious top-floor primary suite with fireplace, walk-in shower, soaking tub and Gulf-front patio.

Four-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath home situated on a corner lot with water views from every window. The reverse floor plan provides 180-degree views of the bay and direct access canal. Large open kitchen, soaring ceilings, elevator, pool, and private boat dock.

17 Remodeled Home on Over an Acre

18 Hidden Gem Ready for New Owners

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $3,195,000 | EUR €2,809,532

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,335,000 | EUR €1,153,796

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $3,200,000 | EUR €2,777,343

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $2,999,000 | EUR €2,563,850

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,899,000 | EUR €1,639,945

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $599,000 | EUR €516,357

Five-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath home features hardwood floors, quartz countertops, custom finishes, two primary suites, a rooftop deck with Gulf views, and an attached guest house with two separate guest apartments. Golf cart included in sale.

Three-bedroom plus den, two-and-a-half-bath home on a private and peaceful lot. Home features abundant windows, vaulted and beamed ceilings, formal dining area, fireplace and one of the island’s largest residential pools.

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

Feet of Periwinkle Frontage, Restaurant 19 200 and Multiple Residential Lots

20 Lime Tree Center 5

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $369,000 | EUR €324,244

Commercial

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $2,999,000 | EUR €2,584,509

21 Seascape of Sanibel 201

22 Atrium 306

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,999,000

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,650,000

23 Heron at the Sanctuary 3B

24 Pointe Santo E6

25 1659 Lands End Village

28 Sanibel Moorings 1641

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,100,000

Condominiums

Gulf Beach 203 and 204 SANIBEL, FLORIDA $1,095,000 EACH

29 Loggerhead Cay 441

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $769,000

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,095,000

White Sands 13 SANIBEL, FLORIDA $995,000

30 Cottage Colony West 127

CAPTIVA, FLORIDA | $465,000

CAPTIVA, FLORIDA | $1,099,000

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $780,000

31 Tennisplace D-33

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $349,900

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026 67

32 Riverfront home in Fort Myers

33 Remodeled Waterfront Home

Four-bedroom-plus-den, two-and-a-half-bath home with panoramic river views. Features include chef’s kitchen, large primary suite with private fitness area and spa-like bath, media room, covered lanai and pool overlooking the river, large backyard with mature mango, lemon, orange and star fruit trees.

Four-bedroom-plus-den, four-bath home designed for effortless entertaining. Features include reclaimed architectural elements, a chef’s kitchen and distinctive wine-tasting room, blending craftsmanship, character and modern luxury. Private boat dock/lift, a commercialscale tiki with outdoor kitchen, TVs, fire pit, hot tub and lush landscaping. 130 feet of seawall, 50-foot dock, and two minutes to the river.

Fort Myers

FORT MYERS, FLORIDA | $1,950,000 | EUR €1,653,474

Renovated on 34 Completely McGregor Corridor FORT MYERS, FLORIDA $895,000 | EUR €760,637

Home 35 Riverfront in Catalpa Cove

and Golf Course Views 36 Lake in Crown Colony

FORT MYERS, FLORIDA $3,175,000 | EUR €2,736,950

FORT MYERS, FLORIDA $739,500 | EUR €639,125

Three-bedroom, three-bath home blending timeless charm with high-end design and craftsmanship. Features include vaulted ceilings with cypress beams, a gourmet kitchen, and a luxury outdoor space with a custom pool and hot tub. New impact windows, roof, and more.

Five-bedrom-plus-den, five-and-a-half-bath home in the gated riverfront community of Catalpa Cove. Property boasts unobstructed River views, soaring ceilings, chef’s kitchen, attached guest house, saltwater infinity edge pool, firepit, and a private boat dock with 16,000lb lift.

Four-bedroom-plus-den, three-bath home thoughtfully redesigned for modern living. The home features a stunning kitchen, spa-like primary suite, covered lanais, and a screened outdoor living area with in-ground spa and water feature. Gated community just minutes from Sanibel Island and Fort Myers Beach.

Half-Acre Lot 37 Almost in Seagull Estates

Direct-Access 38 1.3-Acre Lot on the West End

from the Gulf 39 3inParcels Gulf Pines

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $399,000 | EUR €338,326

Land

FORT MYERS, FLORIDA | $1,299,000 | EUR €1,122,682

40 20 Acres along Bay Drive SANIBEL, FLORIDA $2,500,000 | EUR € 2,187,035

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $1,195,000 | EUR €1,104,870

41 Multifamily Opportunity SANIBEL, FLORIDA $5,999,000 | EUR €5,105,748

SANIBEL, FLORIDA | $775,000 | EUR €669,135

42 Nearly One Acre on Clam Bayou SANIBEL, FLORIDA $ 849,000 | EUR €746,229

REAL ESTATE GUIDE TO SANIBEL & CAPTIVA - VOL 32 ISSUE 9, SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026

David Lowden -

Vice President, Private Client Relations, NMLS #1303162

Kim Nyberg -

Vice President, Professional & Executive Banking, NMLS #543733

TIMELY LOANS. ATTENTIVE SERVICE. Sanibel Office

Our seasoned professional bankers offer expedited local decision-making and customized mortgage loan products tailored to our customers’ needs. Backed by a 5-Star Superior Rating from Bauer Financial for over a decade, we are financially strong and ready to lend at competitive low rates. If you are looking for a loan to buy, refinance or improve your home, or finance a business opportunity, visit Bank of the Islands, your island bank, winner of more than 50 “Best of the Islands” Awards.

Captiva Office

BankoftheIslands.com 239.472.7211

We Make Banking About You!

Equal Housing Lender | Member FDIC | Bank of the Islands is an office of Edison National Bank.