E P I LO G U E
P E T E R M I TC H E L L
E P I LO G U E The demise of the Quarr y Hill Flats
RRB PHOTOBOOKS BRISTOL
“I photograph dying buildings and Quarry Hill was terminal by the time I got to it. Times change and I know there was no point in keeping Quarry Hill Flats. But what it stood for might have been worth keeping”
-Peter Mitchell
Quarry Hill was a large housing estate in Leeds built in the 1930s as part of a ‘great social experiment’ to accommodate an entire community of 3000 people. By the 1970s both the vision and the flats were crumbling and the decision was made to demolish. Though the notion of Utopia underpins the narrative of Quarry Hill, from its passionately visionary beginnings to its step-by-step decline and final end, there are no real morals or easy conclusions to be drawn. As Bernard Crick wrote, it was “small things, not any inherent fault in the grand design, which destroyed Quarry Hill.” It was more about timings than anything else - a sad ending. Peter Mitchell’s chronicles and photographs show what happens to utopias when they implode. Peter is quite a brillant chronicler of life: not just as a photographer but as a social historian and storyteller. Quarry Hill provided him with the perfect ingredients. He combined original documents, archival photographs and oral history with his own observations on life and his photographs into what has become a classic recipe for how to use different aspects to illustrate the complexities of change and failure. The original book, Memento Mori. The Flats at Quarry Hill, Leeds, was published by Peter in 1990 in an edition of 3000 paperbacks and 500 hardbacks. It was Peter’s first publication and had an introduction by Bernard Crick. There was a new edition of 1000 copies published in 2016 by RRB Photobooks. Peter provided a new afterword. Within the walls of photography scholarship there is a standard interpretation of Peter’s work as “charming”, best put by Martin Parr in his introduction to Strangely Familiar (2013): “The full charm of Mitchell’s work is embodied in images of shops and factories with owners or work force standing proudly in front of their businesses”. Peter’s work about Quarry Hill deviates from this standard interpretation and alters that particular interpretation of his achievements. Peter’s photographs of Quarry Hill are anything but charming, and they show a much more serious intent at work. Over the last few years Peter and I have been slowly working through his archive. It is not vast, maybe not more than 3000 in total over a 50year period. The majority of the negatives have never been printed in colour and only exist as small b/w contact prints. While we were looking for Leeds photographs for Early Sunday Morning we also discovered quite a few unpublished images from the Quarry Hill period. So this collection is really a personal selection of unpublished and previously published photographs that pays tribute to Peter the photographer. Rudi Thoemmes, Bristol 2021
5
The Kitson House telephone
7
Moynihan House
9
Thoresby House
11
Laundry
13
Kitson House
15
York House
17
Oastler House
18
Thoresby House
19
Thoresby and Victoria Houses
21
Moynihan House
23
Thoresby House
25
Wright House
27
Wright House
29
Wright House
31
Oastler House
33
Kitson House
35
Kitson House
37
Thoresby House
38
The Garden of Rest
39
Lupton House
41
Oastler and Priestley Houses
43
Moynihan House
45
Wright House
47
double page spread
‘I met a traveller from an antique land Who said: Two vast and trunkless legs of stone Stand in the desert … Near them, on the sand, Half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown, And wrinkled lip, and sneer of cold command, Tell that its sculptor well those passions read Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things,
50
Panorama of the estate
The hand that mocked them, and the heart that fed: And on the pedestal these words appear: “My name is Ozymandias, king of kings: Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!” Nothing beside remains. Round the decay Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare The lone and level sands stretch far away.’
— Percy Bysshe Shelley’s “Ozymandias”
51
52
Priestley House
55
Neilson House
57
Priestley House
59
Priestley House
61
York House
63
York House
64
York House
65
Boiler House, Refuse Disposal Plant
67
Laundry
69
Wright House
71
Moynihan House
73
Wright House
74
Everywhere!
75
Kitson House
77
Kitson House
79
80
Oastler House
81
Oastler House
Waste Disposal Block
83
Neilson House
85
Neilson House
87
Refuse Disposal Plant
89
Thoresby House
91
Moynihan House
93
St Mary’s Church?????? (Peter checking)
95
Victoria House
97
Epilogue Some years ago those with a lot of money and a craving for continental excitement would caper around the remains of ancient civilisations. Some would gain inspiration from these sites but most went for the local atmosphere, wine and exotic entertainment. The Grand Tour became a must-do event. Back in England architecture and landscape were transmogrified and, for those of lesser means, follies and grottos would still impress their neighbours. The being-impressed-by-architecture and replicating the wonder has always been there of course. Two recent constructions leap to mind. Frank Gehry’s Luma Arles in France (homage to Vincent van Gogh?) and at the other end of the scale The Marble Arch Mound, care of Westminster City Council at a cost of £6 million, was built just in time (if they fancied big mounds) to catch the tourists. And over at the Sir John Soane’s Museum they are running an exhibition entitled The Romance of Ruins. In Leeds by the 1930s the Quarry Hill Insanitary Area had been levelled and a young new Housing Director, fresh out of Manchester where he had worked on a very much smaller circular block of flats, took charge. R.A.H. Livett was his name. Fifty years later I was investigating the flats and thinking it was more cinema-style (I live near The Clock on Roundhay Road) and it was difficult to find a meaningful adjective for the whole estate. Hence the variety of titles and myths that stuck with it down the years. Leeds was a very back-to-back, brick sooty-black city, with outside toilets. Quarry Hill Flats were a dazzling white with sandy-coloured horizontal stripes and art deco concrete-cast three-feet-high owls over the lift housings at roof level. Leeds is proud of its owls. And for 3000 residents Leeds was right on their doorstep. Any finessing and original plans never happened because of the war, and an extensive re-furb in the 1960s lost many original details, including window boxes and the owls. It would appear that Yorkshire brickies had little experience of making concrete slabs and as time went on whiteness left the citadel, grubbiness set in and I got the feeling that Leeds has never liked flats, let alone ones on the scale of Quarry Hill. Yet it was obvious to me that they were something special and along with other large areas of Leeds it had the kiss of death right on the centre of its football pitch. York House one side Thoresby House opposite. Along with the rest of Leeds I began to photograph the ruins of homes and workplaces and this is what I still do. What really surprised me was the lack of interest in the removal of such an immense structure. Post war architects and foreign visitors from “all over the world” came to Leeds to inspect the new flats – and wonder. Leeds Housing Department kept a visitors’ ledger, two large red leather archives of press-cuttings and a meticulous photographic record of every stage of construction kept by the city architects’ office (via Pickards of Leeds). All of which went into the skip.
I sometimes ponder whether the Second Millennium arrived earlier than expected, with a lot of wrong-footing and running amok thrown in. Coming up from London and experiencing the strangeness of Leeds was a sort of clarion call to get cracking amongst the vast areas of the city that would soon be no more. One of those doomed deserts was Quarry Hill Flats, irresistible both as a symbol of the fate of all architecture and of the great clock in the heavens signalling everybody’s life span. I had no plans or schedule. The first to go was Jackson House demolished almost by hand because of the uncertainty of how the structure might fall. Some residents were still living in their flats whilst demolition carried on. Nibbling away would take years and even with cranes, bulldozers and flying balls the immense shadow of Oastler House still fell across the site five years later. Finally, as a gesture of respect, I flew a set of naval signal flags from the flag poles that had survived, but never used from the Great Crescent of Oastler House – G O O D B Y E W O R L D. Really finally I made Noel and his demo crew bunch up under the arch of Neilson House and saved for this photographic moment. Usually group occasions are happy events but this seemed gloomy to me. A fortnight later we all met up at The Lloyd’s Arms next door for the usual and a hand-out of photo prints. Outside the pub trucks were driving into the fenced-up site and dumping earth ready for landscaping the emerging car park. The brain shuddered. Walking back to leafy Chapeltown it was as if Quarry Hill was already forgotten. Wasn’t it all about affordable fair rents, decent rooms and spaces with a lack of cholera, an annual carnival for the kids, local shops with a post office, fish’n chips and a chemist. Didn’t Diana Dors make a soap called Queenie’s Castle there, what about the social centre and gigantic laundry and dryers and the market and Headrow right in front of you? How much rent do you pay these days? How long will you live in your house? Or is it your home? Quarry Hill Flats had a lot of answers but they remained unique, a one-off, and Richard Alfred Hardwick Livett went straight back to being normal. Yeah. I took your picture but you took my mind.
RRB Photobooks, December 2021 Photographs © Peter Mitchell Text © Rudi Thoemmes and Peter Mitchell Edit and Sequencing by Josephine Atkinson Design by Jessamine Thoemmes-Tondowski Production by Bread & Butter, Bristol UK Printed at Narayana Press, Denmark
ISBN 978-1-8382683-5-0 rrbphotobooks.com