Asis 4 Tigers

o

a.-

c

c

"fo g[gt'?q ^c 5PG(9clLqf,)P6, s06orcs C f- \fO T-C COC. oP,8" 19:?[9 sact?cDicc \ c .ro o c r-C clgocJ8il oJrs?3 e

olgro)3o)cD lgo%f3ocr8 rYO OC. C

?e)e mg)6o16.l scc 3aGq)?6p36f3 a,p moraroSo3c8r d oegc6eo:e 6 coo \ "ro qcDcJoS ol9t36 3ao3aog%q 3a8"

cl6 gpn g q gu5mfl Ism erm E g$ eil8eeorEg oeqc rilQ a

oce ococs t

c

c "fo coc" cD8' 8[9['?cJP tcc

d."$

c a?cco2oJ"36Ps

occoc

q6o4

G6DcO?3cDJcD flG$8cJPil c -- c c c "fo coPs?o)c/lclgrccDP3 g[gt'?tg

o

ccr6C-COC oo)cJcD[g3 elusrve csaf clgc? qflqt C: C r- Of_' c

ocDacJE O

3aqrq cg?qlgcJPil

C

C a)r.corcDe3

.ro

O\O

c Tc?"? c c

o

C \

qco.rrcqo

c

c

Sg[3?q aoo)oso 3af escoJ3aO)c3

qfleor8 EF96$E}a>d $E6,1,' sacosaro?r

.et$,)E EE-€'

saGqsa?o s?g,-'S lEast Asian

Miracle) <4eft oic6 g;E eo::E oi 6

613(D?3r

c oc qlfloDqccor

c

c oc

c

c

occDfor

" G(.r)fcGcDaccDcil 3aoal3 O3of8cqg .fO

C

8t9t,?19

C

C

ao(})oso saf

qlO fO OC"

C

6

C

C

PscoJ3ao)c

C O

3

CO

fcc6P3 3"aocf? GTcDocJ?s .occt-.ocoor--.

8{9l3tg3

6ltBf'cg"aoe)Pm a)lg ??ccoc cJPil q)c3co3.d?3 3af oGtl cDJ"sGco3 cc.lT-cc

ccD"c@co8s collgcJgil s)cocD

qE

{io{

qfl)-d

el$rrd

g(})

3?

ol["G

.r

or.c

lgocOrcoo

cr" o g?fl

c

c oP3

e

qdsop'{ O C C q:ormqoS ${$[s

sao911'floii edlcuB COC\

l-C "fO

or eolao@opQ sa8;p,ro:pQ' sa:o c co c c n o o

o)l(|3-oJ23i9 %f,eJll'flo or3?.q ooc" c "r-c c "ro

mJgQ3l9c3a)e TiccoP3 ocr-ccor."_cc

o c oc. .n3?%cD fcco)cDi

8[93aoi9

3

aJ?o)icacJg9

C\ c n aocBqsosol3(t

oplc$ e,-,,sa6cu1c6ficcp!'

a) [3c go

$E

pgTEeg@ad

saeco:,^6saQcrp,cBcopQ' g[9]'E'$Ee .fO \ C "fO C " OC" oP39 o[g[3o safP3aos scc

r-ca-c

c

crp'ccp! SQmeqEoqE o,4o5opQ coccc sa%m 3?o3Egp3f,)8 o8orcoo8l

e[91't+€ Slqpg es'em'qp8'ef sae@:E'qE'";r,"r3 5pegeg@ad

cDJaocsc6ls

.fo o

8[9['?'o)m?? c o

cf-cct--co cD ooclgcalcD 6o3lqcJPil 3?alt c ooc. c oc" c cDoJ83 qicc()P:6rl tccccls ofo

c a c "to 3ao83oP3o qql3c6l3 olqo6Psu)?Ne3

qeorcclrp' EE-d' .fO C T-C C goa)eil g[g[3?t9

6

o3cD3€613

g$F

3aclgrc 3qc3 oao'es' pE'6

cDsocDqlgc3611 3a6cD

qesa:E

o

?

icop$copi' {$E

c,c$E

6

o,p'

c oc c oPr5tc6ilr3 3)@3 ocDocorslg

cc$,, o:or3,edE' ep:c6$r'ol o:aiEedE,crp, gr ee1' o:'b@cc$,' ()16

o rc q3?[9c ?lg' T-_ C

0 c c

OOC" C coscc_6P3€r

3?clq)c3op3cDco??

1?clp)d

c

oo)ocor3cocJ8

F86eq'r

E,cn'ee1' ogE66

op'e@"i-$' pEcc$' $Eef c 'ro O)3o)cDa o ' -"'e,ilesacE oo)c 819[3 [9o ro

c

[g["oos

c

a)B

oc

oc/

a

3a6or?c3 3aalf (cesol

ct:E'o3sac'c,7'c,S 2o 1q6op')qE 6 c oc. c c60

lcc cTofoa)8

3?cDc6lo 6qo?caJr

Spmeepo gE o.n;f

deo$cup!'

EE'-d el$L,{'-dgd

"7'

$Ee6leo o$6ea;,, {q$*€; 0 cgar:cSc r-- c o c 60

-€q

619?9TccJ? 3omcqoolo C

"

r-

"fO

\OC"

6cDJ9 O

?,f)8 3al9r, o[g[3osccoJ?3cD E$Edqs ei$m "EEq$,.i,.,, Cr-C \ CO ocDr

cf?cDlgf

C

aoclf,)8?oc c%91

$EeeE o16 c c ,ro o c " cDJ9T3?cJ?c7Jc

elccpQ,,oro$ 88cnee1E

o

q

f-c

rcc

c

Slgl3(r)eo)cD?

19oGOriccJeqca)f

o

3?g?3aeoq

cops {$b6op,cn oory:$e@:E' Cf-\T-CCOf-CCo

cJff)Ga) g?lgrsco*,, co3algc (})csoD

c6

c oT-cr- c c c srr o3o.)3cT oloq gflg}etc\?lcc)P3 occccc

3ao3qel oc6q)cn

ocD(e(-y)?

(government intcrventions) og! co c c oP3l9r3cJ8r? GcD6t3)Pil oco?)(i oc" Q o

sccGrr o8(_))8cqr

c oc"oc

mp%c icc?c

E'o'ee1' o76c$'ffi'.p' (gE'doe 5l

Linked Corporation)oE! ea8m cococ

3aai8(Jf flcf3JPil 3?ceD 3acDl3o.) oQccccr(Jp3[g?3 3ao3qcrl oc c6pcr) Ecncscro

c cJB

"rO ol9[3

r- oc"

c

c oo

3al9"3ecc6p3o)c oJc3coa) O

C

O)3o]c0? t-.- c

T- c

c

co3?cg]lc3 6P:Glg?ccDP3

c cDcs

edq' $Edcrp,ear'c,g:g18o.p'm occT-rcr-cc 3 ocDoc msgllSc L9occD.DPil

..:-'':ri:E'''q'tT.drgFr 6Of cc scc cJ:8({r3cDP3 cosc c .

_oP36

.fO O C (9[913

oP3eil T-C

9PT(),P3

c

O

of3cncD(u?o(? 3aqt

Eo5o8or'@o$,

c

oc. Q "ro o c o icc611 819[rq,o)m?q c c c

occDfo oc c oo)ocof3l9cJPil 3acD83aoo.) $Eeo, saco6 .8g$i$E.r .Tdfl \

C

C OC. C ?1?33.?(JP3c)ecD83 oc cD?osc c crr

oq'"r$i

OCO C r)PC 3a(J1q. oJc

3

$$o,

OCor--Cr6

iccllloLg:

C

o

" T- T-c c f- T"ro o)3?o)B 8l9[3?q lgfcDgGlgrlg cr6 00 00c. c c c O)colgs 6()o0

occD?o

icc%ccDP3 \ O.rO r-C C 016 OC o?T 8[9['?orp' lgo%t3coc\?lg3r 3? oJl sagp!,c c-Esaor8' g[$pp' $Eesaao8

o

3?

co o co c cTcDOsf)scocDOE oolao3soPs

cDo?soas

oo qa

$Ee618ecuccpi,,

oc c o c oo)ocorF?6J"3 oca)? c (})c3scc6Ja3Glr c oc" c.ro ro oc"

oro T-C 'Y\ (9[9[3Qt ol9o6olJ)

arpQ eg'em'cu,1oE SeEeorop!,, o

o1sa51 E$-q3lL, sacrp'sap:' .

OC CO C r

6 C GfcocoqcnosJg saaao(r) 3agpc

f-

o[9l3lg3

l9)3coP3

scc

c o cf-c co -c 3aao9 Q cuJclgfg" c6PmflqD3q[9c3 c c c co c --c clr 3aclgfcsclceoplfg oo)cJcDc\?

6C GO)? ?Pe)8 a)G3)rco?:_6P3 c-ooe"oc6P33alg)3 afllgGcJsGalir

O CO C Cr T-C 3r03q€ll o30)36Tf (})ooJ (3aq3e)gg o,vSoo>,rSo Itltff,ott

mcor)orE edl?uE o5ls

o.1r'o;oc6p'' c

C

o:c6@gr

T--C

Emom?G|grg

O\O

-tfi-@€ EE-€ . cor..-. c NJmfl|gcJ8il

cQea:E cr:E,eaores,o 3a6ps?

c

oa o c 6 cJP 3aeoor 3ao36l()P3clr o3of3cq3 .r o a c coc. c

GOloJo?ol3oP3i9 3aGfrmicccl|.pef9 6 C C C6o siba;1o6op oq$o;!

(Govemance)

\rrJr,f o8co ccocu)eTcosccSm

op,argl', o?c6lscJ o@:ecc*8m c o c oc" o occD"\?icc aa6J[3a)r3 o.)BncD dq6q e6lZu8 gSlsemp8'c'S 0060 sa6ocb cfiegccnnoo$ (Kishore

Y"n:lo""P "T"l'-€ 1nfl:"fl ooromQ eeoe8'6l,oco' {g"t,i cco coc S,, ccerS o)o?sq oo)c\?mqa)[-.ccf-cc

a)r 3 cJ o

aJ

cDop3 aD 3?

rr

grsoP)slc

6P3

i9

,?,c 8o5o8o:',r,$qr EE-80 /t c c ct-oc c

oJcDaoccDo3 o)cgo?cDqorf)8il

E-1,

ceg? ?tE ege@' c f-a c Lgog' e fo3alq" Joot5 ?iog" eq'en' i o gQ oaorE'd'$Eop!u 3a?flro?

r-cr6

oEeep,rS

c To?Q cqfle

co DoJrrPJgal

josrF

orqdpJg

c

o)c[g*D3a)PP3acsFa

rr

c

"o

.lL

c 3a"6lcDP:cr.Jr:f g

r 'ro \ oc o ratS gaSm 3al9]' g[9['o fcccp S'E:'a;cfi p e JE'eo:Ep€' qo$*g a-c

c

o

cDcfP6']

[goe)P? ca c

e

on

?3-J?lmc

3aT()

r

c

6$)c3ol3o)c cTcD3co?33J8il 9c3cr) ororo c Coc. c (9[9[3[93 oJos 3)f cr8 c c oJr33a%c,] ]s

ceoc.ce sa6cD)sacJc e?6qol 8(9Jc3cJ8 .lCCOOO G

alc

36o?coJ"3? clflcocr7)? oc)a),

\rO oro calil oGsr?cDP: oc36ll93 (9i9r6o o coc. c c s?og%ccr" ff cJ3a)8 lccoP:3./13 c6 .ro o c c c o Gaooo olg[3o)3oocDcJ8 3?o9Q o

c

C

C

CO C f- C \ C G6Pmflcaa?c 619)c3co6'lfcD"3 cr- c c c c 3ac6orf q'fltc comHc/r3J8

nccocc

6orc3co?coP3 cDsaocJPq a?cn GTCJzSOOl

c

@8elf f

3CC'J

c

oc

c

ocDBm3rB

nc

Garc

C\

Gol%f

c

3co?coP3

C C 3?e)8?c\J8' l?cD c c 06

G6l3cJ)3

6

e

oofscJPil co

c

CJeil sa)Os)CDCOC

ca. c

c

€cD?cqq3oJ"3%c

c

c

c

oo)oJ[())8r occr-D?%c cD%oo? c oc c e c o

orqlo)?cco %c cF c c oc

alooJcqsr

coc o

c

or$o)ge%c cDlGsl"c(9f%3)8 c c o c oc. o o ()Jc3%Grl fcc oPr? q)3q)cn .rO

C

8[9[363.d?c

c

r-

q'lg"

coc

r- C \

'P

ocr3cao?cfc1?oJe

c^

c

GAOfCsolcCOC

C

clgrc 3cccsarc c . f-ca..lgolgcr8q co

6T3J"3 OO"3CJeCrl

c

c%qa)Pr (.

C

Cf-\

C

saoocD%c Go?lg?3)g 3?€fl. c oc. c ccoPecDc sa"fl cDPsccDsGcD?c f rr .ro o r-c c c coc 8[9[3?q [9o6ol63a2c 8o3co"cfc :

C

C OC

OC

C

C

?3)8 ()Jc3o)g|r calcs€6ofcoJ"3f9 c cro t ( ooa)cDlg3 GO?c" 3ol36tc"-negarc66l oc.crc sas)c 3 cJ3 cJol9co"3 3J8il ()@(J

.

C

OOC"

O

'aorerlG8 (s u rJ.

O

TfccoP3q .ro cT3oJcDjo? f-- c rro co gLgF? c'rosclgPcscorcr cTmSl esdo8 ecl:tqs8e<-,'bop5 e5l8'esor8

cr6

c

co

c6 (Go Keng

c1;<.r$$Ee

e'8;ead plp8

oglglsa;loecrnba

Swee)arp! r

C \

C

C

op' d'o:,^6 p$-'-r"tq$ c f-c o oc c clsrop3 lgosJco c,lJrcDlgoT3coe3 c c c r-c c s?coolt GcD"c3ooPs lgocJeq c oc. o c o c f- c

El'-'

Hgcclgrc3cQGT a)cD3oP3 c)8 . o cf€ o c mg"3aiQ 3r?36qrcDl93 cDss)cD

Toell

o,4oScD' o;o$

c r-c oJeGcDJ3?199

cqcHo)Tro iccc'r oce oco c o re qmecrPoJ"scD (I)l93r oqcDP e

e \

O

CO

Ce

a)8oj?8q ooJal?Go)a)Pil ?mf 03 ccc^cc o.DcDP3 Q32qc $ocolcs olo6P c

ccDJ2cD

coc.

c@.ro o

qjoticc G oo)oqq3

c cD3s)c/f

C C\ C eT-f-c cT%m ceo?c8cDa3r8 GooJ l9[9c r- C \ O C OC" clg"c3cD6q3 oo?3(il?3o?oc icc c.co c

@ffn?

saGcD?c3@3

ecoco:o8gp' c o c e

l8rf?oJ2,q

88$EeoS sa.E cf-rc

3?6119 qc,r8ca?"c 19il9c a?T3aJ . r

C C C Oo a(}?cDJg c)8C tPsc'ro8oP3m T3?1?

o?mfrqlgEcs r-ccco c6'l3cJ"3@?3crPq c%fl l9oe)8? c o o cc 3Jeil cDceocD ooq)@l saeq9Dfl oc. ac c c mP3iccoJ"sg 6orc36s"coP3i9

eJlEreo:Eop,c{ c6

cDPs mG9PcD

c

c

GcDcJeil

eg:c6nr

c*cc6a,1c6meor3

. 5E'eao:E crp'e.'S orgco'p:' {$Ee c c c c c r.c 3J8 3a e3c e)pof oP,l99 os) crcn

o

c

ccccc"

ocG6PcD 8m(9m? 3at83T3 . c c o o o oo 3a?,6'lolrq TqcJP? a(ta)Pil mecn:E'o:@E oe g;trr5i $66erp*cr 4CCrCec Galc36ao?c oJ"e3JE] cDci3coo) .YC

srGco3Sacal 32cr?g)ao0J?3Grl c o O O" re OC. C sccGolaig soso3ocD ?a5lgr c c oc" c ac 6arc366o?copsf)P iccooo?

C

r

f-C

C

o

c

c[?GcD6Tsao)cD sa@a 3aaf 3cDclo

c o

c o

.f-

c c o? 6]a)PqcJ8q qmPOP,

o

.- c c oc ()?EgcJ8 3aqc3

c

cD}j,

ccccc

3a€cD?csrooPGo? 6ao"c8()) \-CO-COC q3aBc cDcl3caq) ?llergrr oc" o coc" c

3aco3a"6t ecc

3"6(Jqmf

c co c c ac icccrP C 6P33aO?cD OOl6"Cr)

oP3(, GAlC3GeOf

c

\.rO

O

CO

C

sc c aaoPs?ig cr)c Sof €rr ge.t/-oP3m c c" f-c c cDcDaoo?319[93 -16 lgoc.)Pil coJ3cDc/) ccrCOO

oprg Galc3GO2caP3Grl 3?Tc .rgn$op';€ c,oEoc8p* eooc6p saa;c6op'{ )-d c oE5p'opQ cac o c

r-c

ooc.

.lc

e

Vogel) c'\ ?dflc64 eoo8,dl,q8 c.l 0c c c cr

o66g:o:opc6 gq'a$"ea6oop'

c seu

c

that encouraged public compliance with thefu decisions and thus helped to provide a stable base ofsupport for their govemments ... Concem

mP3

f&id -q€c c

c3r-Dc/lolsa?c3 co8e)c 3 co"lgco"3

o

-cfo

32o36lcc/)?c3 TOP?? l9olgrCC\CC coJsc?lDfg .oil349po83%c

c

oePfl c croq)srr 3?G5lsra"fl ncecc

oc. ic c

cr)og8lgo lgs saco?aos co?cD"?Q cc$ c,g:,.p eac8Eegpo,.S 6zra

ce r-c

3amlrflo8 326P0P3q

4CCCC.IO Galc36aolcGcD?c3op3crl 3?G6'13ul?cr)

c a c 6 Gao?c3ol3cDc cDc9PcD

c c

o:eo'!op' epd

f6

in

m

o (9+o)3&coP c 6 ()c

c

gave them unquestioned legitimacy

on

co

saqpQsaa;E'oE

OC.

The bureaucratic system,

m a)'r 0il34 g9? o g3 3) m

oo

gloJe cs?goo?3a)8q c%FlcrP[

c

elPil 3aTol

€@?cqTor23 scc lgocoJa)eil o c ocr-c c c c ccecDes saq)aa croc3lgoqooPs e@:$an qoSeoE oFE'EE, o[patropQ, cXo$c'i g$p4,coc6g o oo o oc. .ro c cD (]()9) scc (9lot363?crJcD ccDcD? outrt o t t t \c(.CC ?qoPq o8rfl c 6J"3m 6cD"o?aJcD a;@eco erpl'' saG ff .,c5l$$ o darc6

C OO

c c c oocJcDlg3 co3@?33J8 ?o)aJct) c o c4 0c T-c c o)o?q c3a2cDolsa?c3 lgtco8 erc g)c19ocr)3cJPil

Csfc

c oJ3ryJm

cT6P%c arD6jm3) 8[)[:q3o)m(e6lt

Galc36o)c oPscJP

C

cf6

c : 6 c "3JBm oocff)Gorr o?l!!Prrc]'r

its modern form, played a critical role in industrialization .....

The fact that they were selected by meritocratic measure. were reputed to be highly moral, and lived without conspicuous display

oJ23?

a-c

ecce-'ol

?or3(JJ23cDcD83

c\COCCOC

-Efl oc. c Qqq,a;$8, r-

fl

q'@d466 E'ngE,{ q?o5c,?c6rrd o c oc or-r-c

L

cocD?

a)cq??cJ8il Q6D? orcs%cre C\COc GcpcD? c)c(I??a)8oP8q oooq

q3a%mclg"ccoP3 scc

cra,op'ccp! q8rde.r?'

c coc' 5 co6ot cJPg saGf"cD+ccoJ"3sr r G

c

oJcsoDe)P SzlgcDGo 3aq83aca)3

GoqJ

ccco

cr8

tcEf li![3o63lgccD3Jeil q3a[9c cOCf\C

tcc Cr

o?of 83cil?3r 1cP3oP?oP3T

c

3?mJ[33aBo)6P3q iccsa%c3 q+48-d Tt?6? gacS,c3' 5o:' oc c r-o crc o r-c

C OC" "fO

C

cJr6J o38o3c6l3

qflclr

ggrH O lgocofccaa"c cs?c8cD??oJ23q \ C CefC 6e)oj?g) co?clJ]?q o)og3lgocr8il 6r-r-C r- C \ C rc

COC cr)g)ic

c o "ro o gLgl,q'o)m?g o T- c o oc.

fmq{c

6lg"c3cQcT a)o"8c{"3Grr

\

6cDcD?3.O

olog2GO3ocD %oJ$t?o3Gcc? c oe. c c ocm2(i? icc qc@"c1?oP3%c c6 4 C r-C C O o)oe33aol3?oc goa)8 ?o()J

<!Erro3rorcrSocoE edl8roo:EooS ollt L tto

n.r-c

t

6CC

gaS6l eo:E'61'orE saSm cr to t aoat\ s:,,9,S

3?GTol?19ocl8ll

4c

occ,?o(i Golcsco"cops

Ticc cf-cf6

0

e

c

Gsa"clgc83gcr" 3??3q ?oallocq3 o6ccf-c crJl[f]cDc6.lo QsTsorc aa€o9199 c ct-c . f-c c Tq*oP* a+3aot3c ' aqcPP' lgoa)gl' SqBq oc,r:'raq raecaS Ts1?ops the brighte$cfcc:

c ce.

c

a$o':'p, $86{ cFc c

EoaJloocrcocr8 ofolgocr8il

a;E oE oreo'pp'$$

c

c r-e

c

6.Poo3otsaof,)8 oto€lg?gcDg' ccccc

ocoJ2cDq"ccJeil saqP3aoJc3oo o:eo'dcrp'e@:€ ogogs"r$'q8

forthe overall social forthe overall

social order led officials to be sensitive to problem of inequality

early in the process of industrialization and to make eflorts to spread income opportunities to all parts of society. (Vogel 1991 ,

es) o. c lff ailoPcor?

cr-ocr-

c a c

Goq)cD?co 3aGl93?f co3?q

\

c

o' ca>:Et6l*of

GO3accDcJPCD 32Tol

5'Pcrl

olclg

co:*opScB c-oo6lcrp5ll eaeo8mS

o

co 33rBq G%s'l$8', c co c o (J8cioc T6ocD)cr Jc T?%c C C r-C CO C OC. "rO 8l9F? lgo%t'(i.'lf sccco)"fg c

GqscJ?3@f

oc.

c

c o cf-

c

3amJr s3?8PoP3T c r a)rcD?ocL9rG3afc lqOcolscaa"c c c coc o c o ocYoic Ta)P? oP)9c()psig orr$pf qcp' o,'55cor@o$,,

o)o?O)P8cD

-c

c

c

o c c olc())ctl 4 os,tEo-E oJlsr fslcDTflc cc c o o o c ocDoo?c? ?8lcD(,P3cD

sao$'.gc6gop'g[ eaeq'6lg{ ."or.6$; ad$E6cp'q8 ed8'e

6

Gao?c 3or3oc cDG

sae$ saeq e cncE,crp'o8cu g!t <s$o3'

e<Q$'eoee'1' cnE ets"Ee

G

orscDcDsr

{fr6oer€c'S

o$

saof8' a7'o6poo:'op!u r.rcoo o'a;<rSrer

{$Eecp'{

co8'e@:E'e6li{" "qrdfi erro8 eor8rg8eo'}o$ e JE'eo:E op, (cu8'm dco6 etites? ?tfi$' ocE'{o,S $E6cp'{

e[$ft

-d) -d

OC\OC.T.C\"1-O

ofloPme?

Glg"cscoGT 8lgrcT

icc

-$gr$ a;oo'@a; {saa;c6o$ EEE-f' c O O eO

sagc6 $E'pgo

op' c

"fO cDcDcDc aa6oqcDqmfl 8[9ro

op'9 eSlE'eao:Ecrp,tQ

c 3?olcDlgooPq ere " %rF' s?S6l 3J8 cBeg'po:noe$cn eor8'6l,qE $E

A

I

eeyocro:rccplu

qo3w q'oEa;c69: sa{61 eJE'eao:Eq:'oS sap:' $Eecp'fi ro oc" "ro )JEoclsE GcrJQ)?( ggrlgs rur r . lcc6J23c

ecm8'a:pQ{

qp' oe.,rr8'op!{

u,-Sa:pQ 3'a6c9s.a@

nc eaco:o[$9 3?Gq.34"fl

EE-d' "S6oororE t' Cu o \

C . cO "fO cilo+ sa6o?€o3 Gao)o 8l9r?c)8

oc.

c /666

c

r-

e

+cc€l (oJ3o%c ogPcarscr

oc

saoJf

gad -gr%E saeoQm$p'co,,18 . oe. r-c c c o ?cD(}) \

\.fO

3aoJ"3o3 f-C

sccs{go 6lo@P

C

e

C

C

?a) g[gt'? [9o%f363.r"c GO"cScu )a:$ 1$'o16 'op* oirr:c16rrrop',3

3acql.s?"gl cDpsGcDs6cmE eo,7cu:

oe\COc

sJqr 3a?co8:

979ofl$ qc)8ll

ogagp eacribeeppocb (Ezra

epocaqsatjccp!

o$elgcice'

Vogel) c,\ gda;.Ec,! eao:E'61'g8

o66g:cccoic6 gq'ofsaEoop'

err"c86lea{E' copQoE' et6$o:,

oe<-,pcrSe;o,ccpQ'. eaepQsaal8'oE

-du

o':ec'!crp'e@c$ cu*sa gpaop!'qE c c. o ca.d"cDT36t6PP flGf QcP3coP3

After World War II, only the government of South Korea and Singapore consciously studied the Japanese experience in detail, but the main outlines of the Japanese strategy were well understood by al1 four of little dragons. They all knew that Japan began with laborintensive indushies and'used the income from exports in this sector to purchase new equiment, while upgrading its training and

technology in sectors where productivity gains would allow higher wages. They all saw the crucial role of govemment in guiding these changes. Having the Japenese model provided both the

confidence that they too could succeed and a perspective on how to proceed. (Vogel 1991,91) or-CC.Ce

qsagc aa6q,3a"fl%c saoats o3o?3 .ro o c rc ere

cT

Sjglsqs@cD?oP; l9o%f'19'

o:Eaqct:p' sa8rr:' @ gotcurarp$ COC" coc. / a-O orqlo)fcc (€loSrco3ocD otlo)fcc C C c 666 C C O re Gil oJ3oc)8 oJotq GmPsf38o'g'

-":iTi-t9;?s ?ff%E 61EB eacrp:q:

td1

$be[gbap'o$)

.rrrcodr

o8cm,;o'S

O\C

oP3cDccDcu??3)8q

eo

cq3cJ?3 co"seJeq c4

c

e

GOTC3OIsOC CDGfl"CD

saqpisaa,l8, 6co,;E qsaoQsaor$'

$0":'co"$E"r$ occoc qflcD"cr8il

q)c3oD

sagfsaeqsop:

3]8 q?67

orffi ;$ qpuo.sao$oEcp,sa@' ccureq)

EA#

f'o:'eo'@o$

-%f *$i"o'":--:ion'T

cDo)lso"sf9lg9 %19"'[!P,t"'?q

saeqar.rloQ ecorcnlcl

es) o. c

Cn C

i?sallopGoT

6

Gao?c8ol8qc cDGfPc,)

easScprco saepsaq

ec,'g{ o:Ep

coc'a:plcf eq"qopQu saeoflm$ meq8-.8-.'5g0 FE6%E argo:

ogo:

fro8cuc6oc,E

"gr$"'td

e-..6$io$' a)os).fOme18 o

C

C

O

C

C

djl3ocDcre ofss)cD 8[9[33J8 qsa$"saopQrup:c{ eSl8'eaoc8 ecn:E'q:, p,eaor8ccp$ saQ,qop' r-c c oe oc c saegl$9 qG@"c fccDgo8q

C \OC. 6O&CcoP3s)C €

e6loo$'et.q' saq.6.uE!

e,s"Ees,oE'4{ Ed a;16ecn:E' oi$ocic'\

..nE

Afica

Govemance Initiative dc8 saggpt

cnr @1'u6,co,1cE fl@ocoerp!' r Ref : From Confucius To Kennedy : Principles of East Asian G

overnance,

K is

horc Ma h buban i,

l4/orld Bank East Asia, Visions Volume, January 2007