THE ARIZONA REPUBLIC
F R I D AY , J A N U A R Y 9 , 2 015
C R E AT E D B Y R E P U B L I C M E D I A C U S T O M P U B L I S H I N G
NH1
" & ) 0 2 * " ( ) $ ! ( * 2 "% * + - 2 ' 0 "% 0 1 ! # ' 0 ) $ ! ( * 2 / 0 1 * " 2 $ & % + / ) $ ! ( * & , * - .
$@6>@,5 A201 &67,+5D71/:B76:5 ,, '>:C83,?
!'*"#$ &%$&)(
,9 *,CB/:B@< C>,1
$@6>@,5 A20-
'/$>"&%;<"
-#!%;> (;B6&
'/$>"&%;<"
%2I%397E 6 '386D.@5976CE
) *::7EE3,5 +@,@+7E
/ !C367 E>,1@:7E
/ + 2 ) 0 - ", / ) +
.3"0!1
'202:.G724<C $( #'* &$%#'
&.72 #3:@C3, "@.E
()7:? 3>C C)7E7 )3C 678 :399>6BCB7E
'BE:3;7, 8)7,7 678 )397E @,7 =7B6+ =>B<C
"22 G@D2 ,F
"22 G@D2C A?/
'/$>"&%;<"
"<E3;<3E@: @45 :3E97CB: :)@6+7E -.50.5(5%* ,1' /%.*01,356,(501 2,4% 70&. 802% 01%+0#+,+451' 5A .!$&6 ,$!6A
=
Vd! OMdVOQi dO C?? .OORi CQ? BCd!.OORi@ AOQL=.d "C.C"=i CQ? RCT= C %OO. MSCQ d.aSI OQ=jO'jCjTVQ?@ Vd/i QO KOQ?=. d!Cd d!= SVid O' ?=AViVOQi ACQ '==S OL=.K!=SRVQ" 'O. C !OR=BaI=.: 6ad Vd ?O=iQ/d !CL= dO B=: X!= d.VAT@ =JM=.di iCI@ Vi VQ ?=AV?VQ" K!Cd/i .=CSSI VRMO.dCQd CQ? RCTVQ" d!= BV" ?=AViVOQi &.id:
#2EC.4@: 52;=C=.4C `QOKVQ" K!=d!=. dO C?? C ACiVdC O. =Jd=Q? C MCdVO AOR=i ?OKQ dO M=.iOQCS M.='=.=QA= ( 'CRVSV=i d!Cd !CL= OS?=. A!VS?.=Q K!O C.= CBOad dO S=CL= d!= Q=id RV"!d Mad RO.= =RM!CiVi OQ 'aSSI AOQdCVQ=? "a=id iaVd=i Ci OMMOi=? dO d.C?VdVOQCS B=?.OORi@ 'O. =JCRMS=: ^=CQK!VS=@ iOR= Q=K MC.=Qdi RV"!d KCQd dO ?VL=.d d!=V. Ba?"=d dO ?a.CBS= %OO.VQ" CQ? OM=Q MSCI C.=Ci 'O. d!=V. IOaQ"id=.i: 5E= iVd KVd! Oa. BaI=.i CQ? KO.T KVd! d!=R d!.Oa"! CSS d!= ?=AViVOQi@3 iCV? Ya= ,OO?.VA!@ LVA= M.=iV?=Qd O' iCS=i 'O. 4CA!=d +OR=i: 5E= CiT 1K!Cd/i ROid VRMO.dCQd7/ CQ? SOOT Cd d!= id.aAda.CS ?=AViVOQi &.id: E= "=d d!Oi= .V"!d Oad O' d!= KCI iO d!=I ACQ i== d!= ?OSSC. CROaQd CQ? d!=Q K= ROL= dO d!= AOiR=dVA OMdVOQi:3 "<E3;<3E@: ;B.=;2C 6OQai .OORi@ VQjSCK iaVd=i CQ? RO?V&=? "C.C"= idCSSi C.= AORROQ =S=R=Qdi O' dO?CI/i Q=Kj!OR= %OO. MSCQi: X!=i= id.aAda.CS OMdVOQi "VL= BaI=.i d!= OMMO.daQVdI dO BaVS? C !OR= =JCAdSI d!= KCI d!=I KCQd@ AaidORVH=? 'O. d!= KCI d!=I SVL=: 0JM=.di iCI d!Cd BaI=.i SOOTVQ" dO "=d d!= ROid Oad O' d!=V. !OR= Ba?"=d i!OaS? idC.d KVd! i=S=AdVQ" id.aAda.CS OMdVOQi: X!Cd/i B=ACai= !OR=OKQ=.i ACQ A!CQ"= d!=V. TVdA!=Q AOaQd=.dOMi O. C?? Q=K ACBVQ=d !C.?KC.= KVd!Oad dOO RaA! 'aii: 6ad C??VQ" C BCd!.OOR O. dKO@ =JMCQ?VQ" KCSSi O. BaVS?VQ" C ACiVdC I=C.i ?OKQ d!= .OC? RV"!d B= C RaA! dOa"!=. M.OU=Ad dO dCATS=: 5X!= id.aAda.CS OMdVOQi ( .OOR C??VdVOQi@ .OOR =JMCQiVOQi@ ACiVdCi ( C.= Vd=Ri IOa ACQ/d ?O SCd=. CQ? IOa .=CSSI KCQd dO ?O KVd! d!= !OR=BaVS?=.@3 iCV? `=LVQ ZOiVQiTV@ ?VLViVOQ LVA= M.=iV?=Qd 'O. XOSS 6.Od!=.i:
@$&%C><$C
*976BC5D,B:) :399>6BCB7E 4 *724=<H?E=;B :=+2C<H:2 -3,11%' )022&15(5%* /.0$5'% .%*5'%1(* "5(8 , $,.5%(7 0# 35#%*(73% 0/(501* ,1' %!/%.5%1)%*
!
5A 16?3C *6!?C3%
d/i CSS CBOad d!= CR=QVdV=i: *Q?==?@ K!=d!=. C RCid=.jMSCQQ=? AORRaQVdI '=Cda.=i i=L=.CS !OR=BaVS?=.i SVT= 0id.=SSC VQ d!= YOad!K=id FCSS=I O. C iVQ"S= BaVS?=. SVT= [aSd=,.OaM/i 8Qd!=R Cd ^=..VSS ZCQA! VQ d!= YOad!=Cid FCSS=I@ d!= CR=QVdV=i ( iaA! Ci !VTVQ" d.CVSi@ KCSTVQ" MCd!i@ "OS' AOa.i=i@ ASaB!Oai=i@ iKVRRVQ" MOOSi@ d=QQVi AOa.di@ MVATS=BCSS AOa.di@ &dQ=ii A=Qd=.i CQ? RO.= ( CAAOaQd 'O. RaA! O' d!= CMM=CS dO M.OiM=AdVL= BaI=.i: 58 RCid=.jMSCQQ=? AORRaQVdI Vi RO.= SVT= C iRCSS AVdI@3 iCV? YAOdd Xa.Q=.@ d!= ?V.=AdO. O' AORRaQVdV=i 'O. [aSd=,.OaM@ K!VA! ?=L=SOM=? 8Qd!=R Cd ^=..VSS ZCQA! VQ [VQCS 4OaQdI VQ bGG$: 5*d/i RaA! RO.= d!CQ !Oai=i Q=Jd dO =CA! Od!=.: E!Cd K= ACSS 1CR=QVdVHCdVOQ/ O'd=Q AOR=i KVd! C idC'' O' SV'=idIS= CQ? &dQ=ii ?V.=AdO.i K!O !=SM IOa 'CAVSVdCd= d!= SV'=idIS= IOa KCQd:3
.&%36!!C
'.OR N@bN) dO c@gf# i9aC.=j'==d CQ? idC.d Cd >NPP@GGG: Y!=C +OR=i O''=.i CAdVL= SV'=idIS= AORRaQVdV=i <M.VRC.VSI 'O. d!= CAdVL=jC?aSd $$jMSai RC.T=d; ACSS=? 5X.VSO"I3 * 17< 2<& 5% / "=4D:2?>3=:52E ;.7734=<=2C KVd!VQ 0QACQd=..C Ci K=SS Ci KVd!VQ FVidCQAVC@ C '/86<:,!0/%%<" RCid=.jMSCQQ=? AORRaQVdI VQ ]O.d! [=O.VC d!Cd 8Qd!=R Cd ^=..VSS ZCQA! '=Cda.=i !OR=i BaVSd BI [aSd=,.OaM =JASaiVL=SI ( [aSd= +OR=i VQ $#''4%56& 58 6# CSiO '=Cda.=i C QaRB=. O' C??VdVOQCS BaVS?=.i: d!= CSSjC"=i [C.TiV?= i=AdVOQ CQ? 2=S E=BB ^=CQK!VS=@ ^OaQdCVQ 6.V?"= VQ QO.d!=Cid '/2< 84:< /00 +OR=i VQ C"=j.=id.VAd=? YaQ 4VdI: Xa.Q=. iCV? ^=iC '=Cda.=i !OR=i BaVSd OQSI BI 6SCQ?'O.? #; 67< <0<'<%68 +OR=i: 8 'CLO.Vd= CR=QVdI CROQ" ^OaQdCVQ d!Cd d!= ROid MOMaSC. CR=QVdV=i VQ [C.TiV?= VQASa?= d!= \SIRMVAjiVH= iKVRRVQ" MOOS 5% 67< $#''4%56& 6.V?"= .=iV?=Qdi Vi d!= B.V?"= d!Cd AOQQ=Adi Ci K=SS Ci d!= KCd=. MC.T@ VQ?OO. ASVRBVQ" d!= AORRaQVdI CQ? CSSOKi .=iV?=Qdi dO =QUOI ;0#) 6#9<67<: KCSS@ MSCI".OaQ? CQ? Q=K iO'dBCSS CQ? iOAA=. AVdI SV"!di CQ? ROaQdCVQ LV=Ki '.OR d!.==j 5% / $#7<853< &=S?i: *Q YaQ 4VdI@ ?=iV"Q=? 'O. BaI=.i C"= idO.V=i !V"!@ iCV? 0.VA EVSSVCRi@ iCS=i RCQC"=. ;/875#%- 5%"5$/65%9 'O. 6SCQ?'O.? +OR=i 5Z=iV?=Qdi ACQ KCST@ $$ CQ? OL=.@ d!= "OS' AOa.i= Vi C BV" ?.CK@ Ci C.= d!= d=QQVi AOa.di@ MVATS=BCSS AOa.di CQ? BVT= CQ? ?.VL= OQ d!= B.V?"= CQ? O'd=Q =QUOI 67#4976;40%<88 BOAA= BCSS AOa.di: [C.TiV?= !OR=i .CQ"= '.OR MSCQQ=? CAdVLVdV=i d!=.=@3 != iCV?: \d!=. /%" $/:< .<75%" MOMaSC. CR=QVdV=i VQASa?= d!= ^OaQdCVQ 6.V?"= N@#)G dO b@gG# i9aC.=j'==d CQ? C.= M.VA=? '.OR 67< "<859%+( >Ncc@PPG: YaQ 4VdI !OR=i .CQ"= '.OR N@$gc \KQ=.i 4SaB@ !Oid dO C !=Cd=? MOOS@ iMC@ &dQ=ii -!=::=@7 $:C.48 dO b@$N# i9aC.=j'==d CQ? C.= M.VA=? idC.dVQ" 'CAVSVdV=i@ d=QQVi AOa.di@ =L=Qd SCKQi@ MC.Ti CQ? %2I:@45 (.7734=<=2C Cd >Ng#@PPG: SV'=idIS= CAdVLVdV=i: +OR=i VQ ^OaQdCVQ 6.V?"= 0QACQd=..C VQ YCQ XCQ FCSS=I O''=.i OQSI .CQ"= VQ iVH= '.OR N@c$N dO $@b#$ i9aC.=j'==d !OR=i BaVSd BI Y!=C +OR=ih OQ= O' d!= CQ? idC.d VQ d!= >bGGi: AORRaQVdI/i MOMaSC. CR=QVdV=i Vi Vdi CQQaCS iM.VQ"dVR= 5,OO? <8^0]*XDjZ*4+ 4\^^W]*X*0Y@ AOQdVQa=? OQ MC"= ]+Nb; _V'= -=idVLCSi3 '=Cda.VQ" 'CROai .OAT BCQ?i 'CRVSVC. dO 6CBI 6OOR=.i: X!=i= K=SSjCdd=Q?=? AOQA=.di dIMVACSSI Cdd.CAd CBOad NG@GGG 'CQi dO C iM.CKSVQ" Oad?OO. AOQA=.d L=Qa=: X!Vi I=C./i !=C?SVQ= BCQ?i VQASa?= -O.=V"Q=.@ ZVAT YM.VQ"&=S? CQ? d!= 6=CA! 6OIi@ iCV? +CS _OOQ=I@ M.=iV?=Qd O' Y!=C +OR=i 8AdVL= _V'=idIS= 2VLViVOQ O' 8.VHOQC: 6ad _OOQ=I iCV? 5d!= !=C.d CQ? iOaS O' 0QACQd=..C3 Vi d!= fG@GGGji9aC.=j'OOd ASaB!Oai= K!VA! !Ci CQ VQ?OO.eOad?OO. =J=.AVi= MOOS@ SCM MOOS@ Od!=. !=CSd! CQ? &dQ=ii CR=QVdV=i CQ? C BVid.O: +OR=i VQ 0QACQd=..C .CQ"= VQ iVH=
"<@E< >2B=45 <B2 I@::C \QA= !OR=OKQ=.i !CL= i=ddS=? OQ d!=V. id.aAda.CS OMdVOQi@ d!=I !CL= C SOQ" SVid O' ?=AO.CdVL= i=S=AdVOQi dO RCT= VQASa?VQ" ACBVQ=di@ %OO.VQ" CQ? SV"!dVQ": XO CMM.OCA! d!Vi SVid O' ?=AViVOQi@ idC.d '.OR VQiV?= d!= KCSSi CQ? "O Oad: 5YdC.d KVd! K!Cd/i B=!VQ? d!= ?.IKCSS@3 ,OO?.VA! iCV?: 5* CSKCIi d!VQT CBOad MSaRBVQ" CQ? QCda.CS "Ci OMdVOQi ( Vd/i ?V'&AaSd dO "O BCAT CQ? C?? d!Cd SCd=.: *' IOa d!VQT VQ d!= 'ada.= IOa KCQd C "Ci .CQ"=@ SCaQ?.I iVQT O. C &.=jMVd VQ d!= BCATIC.?@ IOa KCQd Vd dO B= MSaRB=?:3 <YXZW4XWZ8_ 8]2 4\Y^0X*4 4+8],0Y@ AOQdVQa=? OQ MC"= ]+Nb;
0#!%6*3;#9
)/6C (;B6&
1;#2 (;6&</!63 4;3 @63 3C:;+175 8&&;<$C%6&