CII The Journal - Apr/May 2025

thejournal.cii.co.uk April – May 2025

GOLD RUSH With gold prices hitting record highs, discover how insurers handle the risks of this valuable asset

Evolving regulation

Pet project

Raising standards

Matt Brewis outlines new FCA strategy to support growth

Insurers must unite to tackle pet and equine sector challenges

Empowering insurance professionals in the Middle East

01 Cover_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 1

16/04/2025 15:32

CII Events

Save the date Registrations opening soon

Hear from and engage with industry leaders, gain important insights on emerging trends and network with other insurance professionals

Wednesday 1 October Central London cii.co.uk/future CII.May25_002.indd 2

14/04/2025 15:56

A P R I L - M AY 2 0 2 5

C O N T E N TS NEWS & OPINION

22

5 President’s opinion Nicola Stacey on the value of an international perspective

32–33 Professional Standards Aligning CII initiatives with Financial Conduct Authority’s evolving strategy

6-13 News UK and international news from the CII 35 Regulation Regulatory updates from the UK 50 Opinion A day in the life of a claims professional

44-45 Members CII local institute president on the value of giving back

17

SECTOR SPECIAL

24

FEATURES 14–16 Interview Matt Brewis on the Financial Conduct Authority’s strategic direction

28

37 Underwriting Community CII Underwriting Community chair Mandy Hunt 38-39 Underwriting – Technology Implementing machine learning in underwriting

17–19 Gold Global risks in insuring gold and fine art

3

40-41 Underwriting – Reinsurance A career journey in the reinsurance sector

20–21 Pet A new association for pet and equine insurance 22–23 Economy Spring Statement: Implications for insurers

28–29 International How the CII supports standards and learning in the Middle East

STUDY ROOM

32

42 Mentoring The benefits of face-to-face and online mentoring

24–25 Vehicles UK legal and liability issues around e-scooters

38

26–27 Professional Development Using the CII Professional Map to shape skills and behaviour

43 Exams Top tips to help to achieve exam success 49 Q&A Test your knowledge with 10 key questions

CONTACT US

The TheChartered CharteredInsurance InsuranceInstitute Institute 20 20Fenchurch FenchurchStreet, Street, London EC3M 3BY London EC3M 3BY Tel: Tel:(020) (020)8989 89898464 8464 The TheJournal Journalisisonline onlineatat www.thejournal.cii.co.uk www.thejournal.cii.co.uk

The TheJournal Journalisisthe theoffi official cialmagazine magazineofof the theChartered CharteredInsurance InsuranceInstitute Institute(CII).

(CII).

Views Viewsexpressed expressedby bycontributors contributorsor or advertisers are not necessarily those advertisers are not necessarily those ofofthe theCII CIIor orthe theeditorial editorialteam. team.The TheCII will no responsibility for any CII accept will accept no responsibility for any loss lossoccasioned occasionedto toany anyperson personacting actingor or refraining from action as a result refraining from action as a resultofofthe the material included in this publication. material included in this publication.

The Journal is online at www.thejournal.cii.co.uk Cover Image: Edited by Craig Zaduck

Chief Sian Fisher CEO: executive: Matthew Hill EDITORIAL Editor: Luke Holloway Editor: Luke Holloway (020) 7417 4778 luke.holloway@cii.co.uk luke.holloway@cii.co.uk Contributingeditor: editor:Liz LizBooth Booth Contributing

Redactive Publishing Ltd 9PUBLISHER Dallington Street, London Redactive Publishing Ltd., EC1V 0LN Street, 9 Dallington

Senior Designer: Will Williams DESIGN Picture editor: Claire Senior designer: WillEchavarry Williams Production: JaneAkin Easterman Picture editor: Falope Printing: GD Web Off set Cover illustration: Fran Labuschagne

London For EC1Vsales 0LNand advertising please contact us on cii-sales@redactive.co.uk or 020 7880and 7661advertising please contact For sales ISSN 4883 us on0957 cii-sales@redactive.co.uk or

Recycle your magazine’s plastic wrap – check Production: Jane Easterman your local LDPE facilities to find out how Printing: The Manson Group

020 7880 7661 © 2023 Chartered Insurance Institute ISSN 0957 4883 © 2025 Chartered Insurance Institute

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

3 Contents_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 3

16/04/2025 15:33

CII.May25_004.indd 4

14/04/2025 15:57

PRESIDENT’S OPINION

COLLABORATIVE CULTURE Nicola Stacey reflects on the value of connecting international insurance communities

I

SPEEDY ONBOARDING

have always regarded business travel as a highly valuable part of working in our industry. Not only does it enable you to take a break from the daily grind of Teams calls and allow yourself some thinking time, but it also gives you a chance to engage with the cultures of different regions. It was with great pleasure then that I boarded a flight to Dubai to visit Chaucer’s MENA office and took the opportunity to drop by the CII’s office in Dubai – my first visit to an international CII office.

Dubai is a vibrant city with a great café culture, providing so much opportunity to engage with peers, clients, brokers and competitors over excellent coffee.

‘Globalisation by localisation’ is a phrase often used, but that is because it makes sense. It is so important to embrace local cultures and ways of working to deliver the service and products the local markets need.

During my visit, I was fortunate enough to meet Gaenor Jones, CII regional director, Middle East, along with the rest of the team in Dubai.

I heard first-hand about regulatory developments in the region, including new legislation mandating professional qualifications for senior insurance representatives and outlining criteria for continuing professional development (CPD).

While these changes are currently targeted at corporates residing onshore, there is a feeling that once enacted, they will flow to offshore businesses, which could result in greater demand for the CII’s services in the future.

We also discussed a wide range of initiatives in the region, including professional development and accreditation.

In London this spring, it was a great pleasure to spend some time with some of our members at a speed mentoring event, which focussed on leadership and professional development skills.

The evening not only provided a forum for mentors to share stories of their personal career journeys and for mentees to ask questions in an informal environment, but it was also a great networking opportunity.

I also enjoyed supporting the CII’s Cycle Management workshop at the Institute’s London offices in March.

It was great to meet a mix of professionals as they continue their professional development in the light of changing market conditions and anticipation of how the market will adapt in future.

The course was guided by individuals who have led underwriting divisions through previous cycles and looked at cycle-based performance management systems and the role of artificial intelligence (AI) in measuring underwriting behaviours.

While we are all probably aware of the vast potential that AI has to aid the insurance market in terms of processing and analysis, using generative AI as a tool to provide real-time insights could open up a world of data-centred possibilities.

However, as an industry, it’s essential we ensure we’re using the tools correctly and feeding them with carefully curated and relevant information.

Given the importance of continuing professional development, I encourage you all to head over to the CII website to see whether there is training you could benefit from as an experienced professional or leader. ●

5

ILLUSTRATION: MATTHEW BRAZIER

IT IS SO IMPORTANT TO EMBRACE LOCAL CULTURES AND WAYS OF WORKING TO DELIVER THE SERVICE AND PRODUCTS THE LOCAL MARKETS NEED

Nicola Stacey is president of the CII

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

05 President_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 5

16/04/2025 15:34

NEWS

GUIDANCE

CII REPORT ON IMPROVING OUTCOMES FOR VULNERABLE CUSTOMERS

6

A CII roundtable report calls for a ‘coalition of the willing’ to move beyond identifying characteristics of vulnerability and put customers ahead of targets.

The Managing Vulnerability in Insurance Roundtable Summary Report says boards and senior leaders must ‘walk the walk’ by engaging directly with customer experiences, instead of delegating responsibility to compliance or customer service teams.

The report follows a CII roundtable in March at which representatives from the UK Financial Conduct Authority and Financial Ombudsman Service, joined representative bodies, sector leaders, academics and other experts to examine vulnerability management within insurance.

Panellists identified a lack of high-

● Vulnerability identification processes. ● Training and capability building across

all roles. ● Incorporation of vulnerability in product

and service design. ● Monitoring and evidencing

customer outcomes.

quality management information and the challenge of joining the dots between data, actions and outcomes as a key consideration.

The development of sector-wide standards is proposed in the report, that would set out baseline expectations for:

The CII plans to develop practical guidance for firms to address the issues identified in the report. The CII will further support the sector by hosting a follow-up session concentrating on data sharing across the distribution chain, a crucial element of Consumer Duty delivery and vulnerability management, as well as a webinar to delve deeper into the key discussions from this roundtable. → To read the full report, visit: bit.ly/4jtB4gE

GUIDANCE

CII NEW GENERATION GROUP FINDS ‘CERTAINTY’ IS KEY TO PUBLIC TRUST global and national events to identify three core principles through which the London market can help to build public trust in insurance: ‘Collaboration, Certainty and Creativity’.

The report, titled When uncertainty calls, how does insurance answer?, considers the reputational impact from the London market’s response to the war in Ukraine, IRA bombings and the Grenfell Tower disaster.

The report recommends that the London market should apply the principles of collaboration, certainty and creativity to evolving

risks such as systemic cyber risk to create solutions for consumers that build further trust in the insurance profession.

Commenting on the report, Matthew Hill, CII CEO, said: “The CII New Generation Programme provides an excellent opportunity for talented individuals at the start of their careers to demonstrate thought leadership and shape the future of our profession. Public trust is a vital component of insurance and I commend the New Generation group for examining these case studies, identifying the lessons we can all learn and helping to build and maintain public trust in the process.” → To read the full report, visit: bit.ly/4j2uZbd

SHUTTERSTOCK

The CII New Generation Programme 2023/24 London market group has published a new report that considers how the insurance profession can help to build public confidence. The group uses case studies of the sector’s response to previous

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

6-7 News_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 6

16/04/2025 15:35

NEWS

AWARDS

LAST CHANCE TO ENTER THE CII APPRENTICESHIP AWARDS 2025 Entries are due to close for the CII and Personal Finance Society (PFS) Apprenticeship Awards – the annual celebration of apprenticeships across insurance and financial services. The awards also recognise the vital role played by employers to support rising stars in our professions.

Applications are open to apprentices and employers across the UK until 31 May 2025.

The ceremony is an opportunity to showcase the development of outstanding talent, as well as commitment and innovation within the profession. Winners receive a cash prize, sponsored by the Worshipful Company of Insurers Charitable Trust, to reward their achievements and support continued development.

The awards categories include Insurance Practitioner Apprentice

of the Year, Insurance Professional Apprentice of the Year, Senior Insurance

Heledd Roberts with 2024 CII president Ian Callaghan

Professional Apprentice of the Year, Large Apprenticeship Employer of the Year, and Small Apprenticeship Employer of the Year.

On winning Insurance Professional Apprentice of the Year 2024, alongside her team at Farmers Union of Wales (FUW) Insurance Services winning Apprentice Employer of the Year, Heledd Roberts said: “The firm was hugely supportive throughout my apprenticeship. They put time aside for me to do the extra technical learning that comes with the apprenticeship. FUW gave me the opportunity and it is a fantastic way get into the profession. For anyone considering an apprenticeship, I can’t recommend it enough.” → For more information and to enter, visit: www.cii.co.uk/careers-in-insurance/ aspire-apprenticeships/apprenticeshipawards-2025

7

Q U A L I F I CAT I O N S

IUA TO SPONSOR CII QUALIFICATION PRIZES It has been announced that the International Underwriting Association (IUA) will provide sponsorship for two CII marine unit prizes. Beginning this year, the IUA will sponsor prizes for the M90 and M98 units, to be awarded as part of the CII’s annual prizegiving ceremony.

The IUA is the representative body for companies in London providing international and wholesale insurance and reinsurance coverage. The body has participated in sponsorship of CII qualification prizes since 1999, including the CII Diploma in Insurance prize. It will now also sponsor M90 – Cargo and Goods in Transit Insurances; and M98 – Marine Hull and Associated Liabilities.

All candidates who have successfully completed the units will be automatically entered. Each unit has an associated cash prize, which will be awarded to the candidate who achieves the highest overall score for the respective unit.

The CII awards 34 qualification prizes each year, which are sponsored by a wide range of insurance and personal finance organisations.

Nicola Mellor, qualifications director at the CII, said: “We are delighted that the IUA has committed to sponsorship of the CII single-unit marine prizes.

Our qualification awards are a wonderful opportunity to recognise exceptional

performance from our students, and encourage the pursuit of excellence within the insurance and personal finance professions.” → To find out more about CII qualification awards, visit: www.cii.co.uk/aboutus/initiatives/engagement/awards/ qualifications-awards

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

6-7 News_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 7

16/04/2025 15:35

NEWS

Q U A L I F I CAT I O N S

UAE CENTRAL BANK CITES CII ADVANCED DIPLOMA IN MANDATING INSURANCE QUALIFICATIONS

8

The United Arab Emirates (UAE) Central Bank has introduced new legislation that mandates professional qualifications for senior insurance representatives, and cites the CII Advanced Diploma as exemplary of the internationally recognised qualifications that will be required by CEOs and other similarly ranked management representatives.

Article 5 of the recently introduced Insurance Brokers’ Regulation stipulates under the need for sector professionals to meet the necessary qualifications, knowledge and experience requirements, and to have “a record of integrity, competence and financial soundness”.

The regulations also outline the

criteria for continuing professional development, including 15 hours for the insurance broker’s representatives, senior management and specialised employees.

Gaenor Jones, CII Middle East regional director, welcomed the new legislation and commented: “This will have a major impact on the sector’s credibility, with corporates and organisations’ senior teams now mandated to attain accredited qualifications which prove their robust knowledge and capabilities.

“We continue to work very closely with the central banks, not only in the UAE but across the Middle East and CSA region, to educate organisations about the importance of their employees pursuing

and attaining internationally recognised qualifications. This latest legislation firmly underpins the CII’s mission to boost professional standards. We look forward to working with a wealth of UAE corporate organisations to help them comply with the new legislation.”

Read our article on UAE insurance qualifications on page 28 of The Journal

LEARNING

The Financial Academy (FA) of Saudi Arabia has received accreditation from the CII as an Approved Professional Development Centre (APDC). Accreditation represents the FA’s adherence to the CII Code of Ethics, as well as best practice and principles in professional training and development.

The FA is a leader in training, career development and professional certification services for the financial sector in Saudi Arabia and has worked with the CII since 2020, when the Academy began hosting the CII’s internationally recognised qualifications.

The prestigious accreditation sees the FA reinforcing its position as a key player in shaping the future of the financial sector’s workforce in Saudi Arabia.

Existing CII-accredited APDCs in the region include the Al Ghad Training Institute, the Bahrain Institute of Banking & Finance, the Applied College in Saudi Arabia, Excellence Training Solutions in Bahrain, Phoenix Training Centre in Saudi Arabia, and the Training Plus Institute in Bahrain.

Mohammed Alhamazany, chief of capability development at the FA, commented: “The FA is truly honoured to receive recognition as an APDC by the CII. This accreditation reflects our longstanding commitment to upholding the highest standards of professionalism and our ongoing efforts to support the growth and development of those in the insurance and financial sectors.”

SHUTTERSTOCK

FINANCIAL ACADEMY OF SAUDI ARABIA RECEIVES ACCREDITATION FROM CII

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

8-9 News 2_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 8

16/04/2025 15:36

NEWS

CHARTERED

INTRODUCING SIX NEWLY CHARTERED CORPORATE FIRMS

→ For more information on Chartered status and eligibility criteria, visit: www.cii.co.uk/membership/join-us/chartered

M AT T H E W H I L L , C E O

QUALIFIED SUCCESS We have all experienced those moments when someone makes an observation that encapsulates so clearly something you believe in so passionately that you can’t help but feel enthused and excited to get back to work the next day. I had one of those moments recently, when I attended the Insurance Institute of London gala dinner, held at the Tower of London.

It was a wonderful occasion, organised to an exceptionally high standard and supported by dozens of leaders from across our profession. In her speech, the Institute’s president, Lucy Clarke, gave a compelling analysis of the challenges facing the global economy.

Her conclusion resonated most with me and many others in the room: “We must drive through the importance of education, so we are equipped to deal with the challenges we face. We must make sure we are the most professional people in the world.” I couldn’t agree more.

It is therefore a welcome coincidence that so much of this edition of The Journal is dedicated to the advancement of education and professionalism. In particular, CII president Nicola Stacey discusses her recent visit to Dubai, which followed recent legislation by the UAE Central Bank mandating professional qualifications for senior insurance representatives. We are delighted that the legislation makes specific reference to CII qualifications, noting their internationally recognised quality. We have long argued that a similar approach should be adopted in the UK and, while Matt Brewis, director of insurance at the FCA, questions whether this would be appropriate in his interview with us, he acknowledges that the regulator’s expectation is that firms should uphold high standards without regulation.

If anything, that adds extra weight to the responsibility my colleagues and I feel towards the profession, with the benefits that our members and other aspiring professionals might gain from using our Professional Map. If you’re in any doubt, please read the article

by Ajay Mistry, a member of our Broking Community board, as he explains the personal benefits he and his team have experienced from using it.

Finally, we recognise that taking exams can be nerve-wracking, so we’ve put together a ‘top tips’ article to smooth the process for those taking our online assessments. If you are taking one of our exams soon, I wish you great success and I am delighted that we can help you to become one of “the most professional people in the world”.

9

PORTRAIT ILLUSTRATION: MATTHEW BRAZIER

Six insurance and financial planning firms achieved CII Chartered status in the first quarter of 2025. Chartered status is a symbol of technical competence and signifies a firm’s public commitment to professional standards.

In receiving Chartered status, firms declare their adherence to the CII Code of Ethics and commitment to supporting initiatives that build public trust, ongoing people development, a customer-centric approach and the development of the profession.

Firms that gained Chartered status between January and March 2025 are Sentio Insurance Brokers, Eva Capital Management, Ocaris Wealth Management, One Four Nine Wealth, Parker Kelly Financial Services, and Path Financial.

Nicola Stacey, president of the CII, said: “It is an honour to award Chartered status to six new firms, and welcome them to the Chartered community. Chartered status represents a public declaration of professional standards, supporting our collective mission of building public trust in the insurance and financial planning professions. We look forward to working alongside these firms to deliver excellent client service.”

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

8-9 News 2_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 9

16/04/2025 15:36

I N T E R N AT I O N A L N E W S

TURKEY

EMERGING OPPORTUNITIES IN TURKEY FOR PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS JORDAN

CII WELCOMES GOODWILL AMBASSADOR FOR JORDAN 10

The CII Middle East office has welcomed Mazen Nimri, FCII, as the new Goodwill Ambassador representing Jordan.

Nimri is deputy general manager at Jordan Insurance Company where he leads teams comprised of more than 200 professionals across Jordan, the United Arab Emirates and Kuwait.

He boasts more than 26 years of experience in the insurance profession, having begun his career as an agent, is a Fellow of the CII, and member of the life and health insurance committee at the Jordan Insurance Federation.

Nimri said: “It is a privilege and an honour to be selected as a Goodwill Ambassador of the CII and I am very excited to extend all the support needed to promote the insurance industry through the high standards and professional courses of the CII.” Gaenor Jones, regional director of the CII, Middle East and central & south Asia adds: “Mazen is a highly regarded senior figure in the insurance sector in Jordan and we are really looking forward to working with him. He boasts an extensive network in his home country and across other Gulf Cooperation Council nations. We know he will prove a very valuable asset to us in furthering our mission to boost professional standards across the region.”

The Middle East office continues to engage with major players in the Middle East insurance sector, particularly organisations representing an emerging and progressive market.

Recently, CII Goodwill Ambassador for Turkey, Kerem Erberk, met with the Insurance Association of Türkiye – one of the country’s leading industry bodies – amid rapid growth in economic development and financial services. The insurance sector is quickly gaining ground on banking, with new products and distribution channels emerging to meet evolving market needs.

The meeting focused on expanding opportunities and the value of collaboration in promoting professional qualifications for sector employees – key to raising standards and enhancing professionalism across the industry.

Those in attendance with the CII Middle East team, led by regional director, Gaenor Jones, included, Ozgur Obali, general secretary; Aysun Ozer, deputy secretary general; and Ugur Gulen, chair, all of the Insurance Association of Türkiye.

CEO Matthew Hill also met with Obali and Gulen at the Dubai World Insurance Congress event during his visit to the Middle East in April.

U Z E B E K I STA N

APEX INSURANCE NAMED AN IPPF The Uzbekistan operation of global firm Apex Insurance JSC has been accredited as an International Professional Partner Firm (IPPF). Based in Tashkent, the organisation offers a wide range of products and services across various sectors.

A few months ago, Apex’s senior team visited the CII’s London head office (pictured below with CII CEO, Matthew Hill) to explore the benefits of becoming an IPPF. The official certification was awarded recently.

Gaenor Jones, CII regional director of the Middle East and central & south Asia, commented: “Apex has demonstrated a strong commitment to the CII’s best practices and professional standards by supporting their employees in attaining CII qualifications and encouraging continuing professional development. It is the first privately owned company in Uzbekistan to be recognised for these efforts and we look forward to continued collaboration.”

Apex Insurance JSC is the leading insurance provider in Uzbekistan, holding the country’s highest gross written premium. The company employs 521 people, 317 of whom are based in Tashkent.

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

10 ME News_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 10

16/04/2025 15:37

I N T E R N AT I O N A L N E W S

HONG KONG

EMERGING TALENTS VISIT THE CII Two emerging talents from the Hong Kong Federation of Insurers (HKFI) Elite Talent Development Programme visited the CII Hong Kong office.

The participants met with the CII team to gain greater insight of the CII and its professional development initiatives in Hong Kong and the broader Asia-Pacific region.

During the meeting, Agnes Koon, chief executive of KSY Specialty and longstanding CII member, also shared her insights and experiences within the Hong Kong insurance profession.

VTC Board Committee

11

Allan Yu and Alpha Ho

l-r: Eugene Lau, Candy Au, Kenny Siu

HONG KONG

VTC MEETING FOR INSURANCE TRAINING

l-r: Kenny Siu, Agnes Koon, Candy Au and Eugene Lau

The 169th meeting of the Vocational Training Council (VTC) Insurance Training board took place in March.

Established in 1982, the VTC is the largest vocational and professional education and training provider in Hong Kong.

During the meeting, Alpha Ho, regional corporate development manager, represented the CII as a member of the Insurance Training board.

The meeting provided a platform for discussing key developments and initiatives aimed at advancing training and professional development within the insurance profession.

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

11 International News_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 11

16/04/2025 15:37

EVENTS

REGIONAL NEWS

8 M AY

UNDERSTANDING BROKERS → 12pm – 1pm Insurance Institute of Royal Tunbridge Wells www.localinstitutes.cii.co.uk/ royal-tunbridge-wells

8 M AY

CYBER INSURANCE → 1pm – 2pm Birmingham Insurance Institute www.cii.co.uk/ birmingham

14 M AY

COMPASSION FATIGUE – THE RISK TO PEOPLE WORKING IN INSURANCE → 12.30pm – 1.30pm Insurance Institute of Newcastle upon Tyne www.cii.co.uk/newcastle

BOURNEMOUTH

INSTITUTE HELPING TO SHAPE FUTURES, ONE CONVERSATION AT A TIME

12

The Insurance Institute of Bournemouth (IIB) recently had the pleasure of visiting Parkstone Grammar School in Poole to dive into the world of insurance, financial planning and apprenticeships with students, parents and local employers.

Institute president Jana Langdown, education officer Theo Chamberlain and Next Generation secretary Rachael Martin (both pictured) represented the IIB at the job fair and were kept busy talking to attendees and answering lots of questions.

Langdown commented: “The energy was incredible at the event. With so many curious minds asking thoughtful questions,

our team was certainly kept on our toes.

We hope we were able to leave a spark of inspiration for young talent to consider exciting careers in the insurance and financial services industries.

“If you are part of a school or college in the Bournemouth, Poole or Dorset area and you’re eager to spotlight career opportunities, we would love to visit and showcase the rewarding journeys in our sector. Let’s connect and make an impact together!” → For more information, visit: www.cii.co.uk/bournemouth

BRISTOL

BRISTOL CELEBRATES SUCCESS The Insurance Institute of Bristol’s annual dinner in March was the celebratory backdrop chosen to recognise the achievements of a select group of members.

Almost 400 attendees helped generate a special atmosphere at the city’s Ashton Gate football stadium, including special guests the Right Honourable Lord Mayor of Bristol, councillor Andrew Varney and 2024 CII president Ian Callaghan.

The focal point of the evening was the presentation of trophies and certificates to the institute’s highest achievers in the CII and PFS Certificate

and Diploma examinations.

The recipients were: ● Matt Beck of Chase de Vere for Excellence in Certificate Achievement in Financial Planning. ● Kyra Brake of the Old Mill Group for Excellence in Diploma Achievement in Financial Planning. ● Mark Lawford of Gallagher for Excellence in Diploma Achievement in Insurance. ● Emma O’Loughlin of NFU Mutual for Excellence in Certificate Achievement in Insurance.

The ceremony concluded with a special presentation for lifetime

achievement to Bristol council member and past president, Richard Smith.

Smith has served on a number of local institute councils over the years and is currently Local Institute national forum officer for the Southwest region, having recently also served on the CII’s Education and Learning Committee.

Bristol president, Nigel Taylor, said: “On behalf of the council, I would like to thank all our sponsors and guests for making the evening such an enjoyable event. We are already thinking about next year’s event, while focusing on

Emma O’Loughlin receives her award from Nigel Taylor and Lee Grainger of Aviva

Richard Smith accepts Insurance Institute of Bristol Lifetime Achievement Award

our comprehensive support programme for members for the rest of 2025.” → For more information, visit: www.cii.co.uk/bristol

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

12-13 Reg News_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 12

17/04/2025 10:14

REGIONAL NEWS

21 M AY

NEW ENERGY VECTORS – THE RISKS OF FUTURE TRANSPORT → 1pm – 2pm Insurance Institute of London www.iilondon.co.uk

27 M AY

THE RISE OF ERRORS AND OMISSIONS CLAIMS AGAINST BROKERS AND HOW THEY CAN BE MITIGATED → 1pm – 2pm Insurance Institute of York www.cii.co.uk/york

29 M AY

WHY UNDERINSURANCE OF CONTENTS & VALUABLES IS SO PREVALENT → 12.15pm – 1.15pm Insurance Institute of Norwich www.cii.co.uk/norwich

PODCAST

LOCAL INSTITUTE VOLUNTEERS FEATURE ON THE JOURNAL PODCAST Three council members from across the local institute network came together in March to record a dedicated ‘Local Matters’ episode of The Journal Podcast.

Danielle Ashmore, president of the Insurance Institute of Coventry, Sarah Hughes, communications officer for the Insurance Institute of Cardiff, and Kath Harvey, president of the Insurance Institute of Aberdeen, discussed their institutes’ ambitions and plans to engage their

membership in 2025.

The volunteers also consider what inspired them to become involved with volunteering for their institute, why they still give their time and what they enjoy most about giving support to others working in the profession. All three agreed that they continue to volunteer because they want to give something back to the next generation and help promote career paths within the financial industry.

→ Listen to the episode at thejournal.cii.co.uk/podcasts and find out more about becoming a volunteer at www.cii.co.uk/membership/ local-institutes

13

KENT

REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2025 The 12th annual Kent Regional Conference took place in April, with the theme ‘Growing in a World of Opportunities’, providing a day of learning, discussion and networking for more than 120 attendees.

Chaired by Ray Johnson, vicepresident of the Insurance Institute of Mid-Kent, the conference included a diverse range of speakers who helped delegates understand challenges and opportunities in different areas of the profession.

The opening speakers were: Beki Colyer, regional manager, RSA; David Sparkes, director, British Insurance Brokers’ Association; and Nick Smallcorn, managing director of corporate speciality at Clear Group.

They shared their perspectives on the implications of declining commercial rates and increasing capacity, set against the backdrop of ongoing

regulation and a shortage of experience in the market.

Tudor Price, of the Kent Invicta Chamber of Commerce, spoke next and demonstrated

his knowledge of the profession and the key challenges it faces. During an insightful talk packed with interesting statistics and information about businesses in Kent, Price stunned delegates by revealing that 97% of businesses in Kent employ less than 10 people.

Further sessions featured Elizabeth Stephens, who provided a talk on geopolitical risk, including a fascinating explanation of the power changes since World War II and what this means today; Jeff Heasman explaining human versus automation; and Reg Brown, chairman of the Insurance Museum, who held a fireside chat about the great history of insurance.

Kate Allatt concluded the day with a powerful account of her ongoing journey with Locked-In Syndrome, inspiring attendees through her honesty and resilience in adapting to the extraordinary challenges she has faced.

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

12-13 Reg News_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 13

17/04/2025 10:14

I N T E RV I E W – M AT T B R E W I S

REGULATION INNOVATION

Matt Brewis speaks to Luke Holloway about how the FCA is fostering a collaborative relationship with firms to evolve regulation in insurance and financial services and further enhance protection for consumers

14

to the entire FCA, including the insurance sector,” Matt Brewis, director of insurance at the FCA, tells us. “In recent years, we’ve made significant progress, particularly with the implementation of the Consumer Duty, which has strengthened our

focus on consumer protection. We are also nearing the completion of our biennial portfolio strategy, which outlines our key goals for the insurance sector with an emphasis on growth and innovation.”

The FCA is also exploring areas

ALICE MOLLON / IKON IMAGES

T

he UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) is evolving its priorities to meet the changing landscape of the insurance and financial services sectors. As this issue of The Journal is published, the FCA has unveiled its new strategy, which focuses on growth, innovation, tackling financial crime and becoming a more efficient regulator all with the intention of best supporting consumers.

“These priorities are central

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

14-16 Interview_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 14

16/04/2025 15:40

I N T E RV I E W – M AT T B R E W I S

where rules could be streamlined.

A strong regulatory foundation is vital to maintaining the UK’s appeal as a business hub, says Brewis, however, there is a danger that if rules become too rigid, they could create challenges for insurers.

“When we introduced the Consumer Duty,” explains Brewis, “it unintentionally expanded its scope to cover corporate businesses that didn’t require the same level of protection as consumers. This created challenges for commercial insurers, who had to conduct fair value assessments for clients that didn’t need such protections.

“To address this, we are consulting on redefining the line between commercial and corporate insurance. It’s important to distinguish between businesses that can manage risks independently and those – like small and mediumsized enterprises (SMEs) – that need the level of support and protection provided by the Consumer Duty.

“We are also listening to industry feedback on fair value assessments,” he continues. “While these assessments are a vital part of our regulatory toolkit, conducting them annually has proven to be difficult for firms. It has become more of a compliance exercise than a valuable tool. We are looking to streamline the process and will be consulting on potential changes in May. “We want to ensure our regulatory

framework remains effective while removing or refining elements that aren’t providing value.”

KEY PROPOSALS At the start of 2025, FCA chief executive, Nikhil Rathi, wrote to the Prime Minister in response to

the UK government’s call to ensure regulators support growth. The letter outlined 50 key proposals for growth covering mortgage affordability, digital payments, removing redundant data returns, supporting international promotion of UK financial services, opening up to more innovative firms and cutting barriers between regulators.

Brewis says there is a significant opportunity for the FCA to collaborate with government and firms along with other regulators to turn these proposals into better ways of working for insurers and better outcomes for customers.

“For instance, in life insurance, it can take an average of two to three months for protection products to pay out after a death – that is far too long.

The government’s ‘tell us once’ system allows one notification of a death to inform multiple departments. If this data can be used efficiently by the government, why can’t we use it to speed up insurance processes?

“Similarly, insurers spend significant resources tracking down customers who have moved address.

HM Revenue & Customs has up-todate information, so why not use it to save costs and reconnect people with their long-term insurance products?

“These are areas where there’s a real opportunity. I’ve always advocated for a mature relationship between regulators and firms. While disagreements will arise, a parentchild dynamic isn’t productive. We aim to foster a collaborative relationship to improve insurance in the UK,” says Brewis.

OUR GOAL IS TO SUPPORT UK CONSUMERS AND BUSINESSES BY HELPING CREATE PRODUCTS THAT MEET THEIR NEEDS AND ENABLE THEM TO GROW

VITAL SUPPORT The important role insurance plays in society is one of the key reasons why it remains so essential, says Brewis.

It’s also why he is so passionate about his role at the FCA. “Insurance plays such a vital role in society. Take the pandemic, for example. One of the key actions the insurance sector took was ensuring the transfer of goods into the UK, so they could be stocked on shelves. During that time, the government had to step in to support trade credit insurance.

“Without insurance, goods simply wouldn’t move. When people had to suddenly adjust to new ways of working and living, a wide range of insurance types became crucial in supporting them. Insurance is there for people during their worst times, providing essential support,” says Brewis.

Unfortunately, there is still a large portion of the population that doesn’t have enough insurance when it’s needed most, especially among vulnerable groups.

“One thing I’m passionate about is how we can help those who truly need insurance coverage,” he says. “People in rental accommodation or social housing may lack contents insurance, leaving them unable to replace their possessions if something happens.

We’re working to address this as part of the financial inclusion task force set up by the Treasury, along with insurers, brokers and charities. Together, we’re trying to solve this issue so that people can help themselves and insurers can better support them.”

Brewis joined the financial services sector in 2001, initially working at the Bank of England and for most of the past decade with the FCA. “I started at the Bank and held many different roles across the organisation.

It’s a great place with lots of opportunities to move around. During the financial crisis, I was heavily involved in all aspects of the banking side of things, including the bailouts of RBS and Lloyds, as well as the Greek and Cypriot crises that followed.”

Brewis joined the FCA in 2016 5

15

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

14-16 Interview_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 15

16/04/2025 15:40

I N T E RV I E W – M AT T B R E W I S

countries,” says Brewis. “This type of insurance can trigger a claim if certain thresholds of rainfall are met in a specific area, helping farmers and communities with rapid financial support during natural disasters.

“While these issues aren’t as prevalent in the UK, the growth of parametric insurance in other markets could bring value here as well. It’s essential for us to learn from what works in other countries and assess where we can apply those lessons,” says Brewis.

In terms of professional learning, the United Arab Emirates has been the latest country to mandate qualifications for senior insurance professionals. Does Brewis think the UK insurance market could follow a similar path?

“I believe we have a well-developed insurance market, with the senior managers and certification regime in place along with the expectation that firms appoint individuals with

the necessary skills for their roles. Firms are already incentivised and required to ensure employees have the right qualifications and many firms require certain accreditations – such as CII qualifications – for these roles.

“Given the diversity of our market, a one-size-fits-all approach wouldn’t be effective. While we strongly support CII accreditation – many FCA team members hold CII qualifications and use its training materials – we expect firms to uphold high standards without making this a regulatory requirement,” says Brewis.

“The CII is important, particularly in terms of learning, training and qualifications, which are crucial for the sector. Since Matthew Hill became CEO, we have developed a great relationship.

The CII plays a key role and wherever our interests align, we’ll be happy to collaborate when the opportunity arises.”

BRIGHT FUTURE Looking forward, Brewis believes insurance will become even more crucial to the UK economy, with opportunities for growth to maintain the UK’s global position. To thrive, he says, insurers must remain profitable while ensuring they meet consumer needs and drive industry innovation.

“I believe there are opportunities for growth and I know there are areas where we, as regulators, can collaborate with firms, Lloyd’s, the London market, trade associations and the CII to help maintain the UK’s position as a dominant player in global insurance markets.

“This requires continuous innovation and a clear understanding of our role.

We must be mindful not to hinder progress while ensuring the UK remains competitive in the global market. For the sector to thrive, it’s essential that insurers are profitable. If they aren’t, they can’t provide the services people need.

“Our goal is to support UK consumers and businesses by helping create products that meet their needs and enable them to grow. We are working constructively with the industry and I am committed to continuing that positive relationship.” ● Luke Holloway is editor of The Journal

ALICE MOLLON / IKON IMAGES

16

when Andrew Bailey, then-deputy governor of the Bank, became CEO, working as his chief of staff throughout Bailey’s time at the regulator.

“I enjoyed my first role at the FCA and really connected with its mission of supporting consumers. I then moved into my current role as director of insurance. For the past five years, I’ve learned a great deal. Of course, within the first few months, the pandemic took hold and we found ourselves in the Supreme Court regarding the business interruption test case.

“I have certainly had a lot of interesting experiences and complex challenges always seem to find their way to me,” he says.

Though the FCA’s role is domestic, Brewis has found it valuable to engage in ongoing dialogue with international counterparts, with many challenges faced by the UK also experienced in other jurisdictions.

“I have learned a great deal from international experiences,” he says.

“Every country handles insurance differently due to its unique circumstances. There are examples – such as the Flood Re scheme – where insurance innovation in the UK has helped in other parts of the world.

He adds that it is also important to be aware of developments in other countries that could benefit the UK market. “For instance, there is significant growth in parametric insurance in some developing

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

14-16 Interview_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 16

16/04/2025 15:40

RISK

17

GOLD RUSH

FRAN LABUSCHAGNE

With the price of gold soaring and demand for its secure transport growing, Chris Shadforth discovers the risks involved in insuring the movement of gold around the world along with the challenges of insuring fine art

T

he Bank of England is one of the largest repositories of gold in the world, holding approximately 400,000 bars. While the physical movement of this precious commodity is rare, it has become more common in recent years as increasing numbers of investors seek safer havens in uncertain times.

Gold has long been seen as a secure investment, with its price rising during periods of economic or geopolitical instability.

5

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

17-19 Gold_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 17

16/04/2025 15:55

RISK

18

Following the Covid-19 pandemic, the price surged from £1,100 per troy ounce in 2019 to £1,500 by August 2020 amid economic uncertainty. After a brief dip, it climbed again following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. However, the most dramatic increase came in 2025, when it soared to more than £2,400 per troy ounce – a 50% rise in just one year, driven by inflation and political instability.

As demand for gold has risen, so too has the need for its transportation around the world. Ross Drabble, underwriting manager of fine art and specie at Liberty Specialty Markets, explains that one of the primary concerns when insuring gold is verifying its existence and authenticity. “It might sound ridiculous, but the first concern is ensuring the gold is actually there.

We sometimes bring in third-party services to confirm its presence, but only in extreme cases.”

Once it is established that the gold exists, its movement can occur in various ways, depending on the value and urgency of the shipment. “Smaller shipments, like commemorative coins, can be sent via common carriers such as FedEx or UPS. However, larger and more valuable shipments require more secure transportation methods.

A few years ago, for example, Poland shipped its entire gold reserves back from the Bank of England. The gold was transported with a police convoy, including a helicopter, to Heathrow Airport, then sent via a freight carrier to Poland, where it was met by the army. The total value of the gold was nearly £4bn and was completed in eight trips.”

REALITY VS EXPECTATION Transporting gold necessarily involves multiple parties, which must all be factored into the risk considerations.

“There might be a secure logistics carrier in London, an aeroplane, then a carrier on the other side as well.

So, who is insuring all of that? Are we comfortable with everyone involved?”

Using multiple parties and commercial airlines creates challenges

GOLD CAN SOMETIMES BE TRANSPORTED ON COMMERCIAL PASSENGER PLANES, MEANING IT COULD BE UNDERNEATH YOU WHEN YOU’RE FLYING

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

17-19 Gold_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 18

16/04/2025 15:55

RISK

ARTISTIC LICENCE

FRAN LABUSCHAGNE

THE IDEAL SCENARIO IS THAT THE GOLD MOVES FROM A TO B TO C VERY QUICKLY, BUT THE REALITY IS THAT SOMETIMES IT DOESN’T WORK LIKE THAT

for insurers. Drabble notes: “The ideal scenario is that the gold moves from A to B to C very quickly, but the reality is that sometimes it doesn’t work like that.

Gold can sometimes be transported on commercial passenger planes, meaning it could be underneath you when you’re flying. As a result, timings don’t always match up and the gold may end up in what we call ‘incidental storage’ for short periods of time. Understanding that risk is key.”

Despite the increased volumes in recent years, Drabble suggests that the risks have not changed significantly. “The key is ensuring that the gold remains in a secure environment throughout the journey, so we know that the gold that started in one location is the same when it reaches its destination.”

Given these challenges, it’s not surprising that specialist movers have carved out a niche in the market. This offers some comfort to those underwriting the risks involved in transportation.

“Carriers that regularly ship gold will have well-established operational procedures.

These procedures are reliable, ensuring that gold is transported securely every time. While each transit may vary in terms of destination, the procedures remain largely consistent.”

Despite careful planning, incidents and losses can still happen. Drabble recalls a case where gold shipped from South America to the US and Europe never fully arrived. While the insured carrier is responsible for the entire shipment, airlines have limited liability and less stringent procedures for gold transport.

Investigations followed, but a loss occurred, which had to be addressed.

In contrast to gold, art holds unique, subjective value to individuals, making insurance more complex. Drabble, also a specialist in fine art, points out that valuations can vary due to market trends, historical significance, or personal perceptions. “Certain commodities we insure have fixed prices, making it easy to determine their value. Cash, for instance, is insured at its face value. Art, however, is more complicated. The valuations can fluctuate based on the market, trends and individual opinions. It is a very challenging environment.”

To navigate these complexities, Drabble and his team rely on various data sources when pricing risk.

“We use market trends and data on sale prices for similar works, or for a particular artist. We typically consult third-party expert valuers to assess these pieces, as it’s impossible for insurers to cover the vast array of valuable goods and fully understand their valuations. From an insurance perspective, it’s essential that we insure art for as close to its market value as possible.”

The art market is known for its unpredictable twists and turns. Drabble recounts an interesting case involving a Banksy artwork. “We were once asked to insure the removal of a brick wall that featured a Banksy piece. For us, we insure art and gold, but we don’t cover the removal of walls and the associated risks. That said, we’ve also insured exhibitions of human bodies that have been plastinated. One situation involved a person fainting and falling into one of the exhibits, which was certainly a unique event.”

Like that member of the public, Drabble says he “fell” into his field of expertise, but he believes the niche nature of his work is what excites new talent. “It is a unique area of insurance, and it’s particularly interesting to new graduates and placement students.

They find it a very compelling area to learn about.” ●

19

Chris Shadforth is communications director of the CII

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

17-19 Gold_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 19

16/04/2025 15:55

PET AND EQUINE

T

he pet and equine insurance sector is at a crossroads. Rising claims costs, the affordability of cover, concerns around fraud and the lack of collaboration between insurers, veterinary professionals and consumer representatives have all contributed to a breakdown in trust.

If we want to ensure a sustainable future for the market, the industry must come together to address these issues proactively – before regulatory intervention forces change on us.

KEY CHALLENGES

20

Claims costs and pricing pressures In the past decade, veterinary fees have increased significantly, with some estimates suggesting a 48% rise since 2016. There are several factors driving this: ● The corporatisation of veterinary practices, leading to price variations and concerns about over-servicing. ● Prescription markups, which remain unregulated, often leaving consumers unaware of more cost-effective options. ● A growing reliance on insurance as the primary means of funding veterinary treatment, particularly where policyholders are unaware of the longer-term implications, can lead to increased claims. This is especially true when non-essential diagnostics or treatments are undertaken, potentially exhausting policy limits or contributing to higher renewal premiums.

These challenges are further compounded by a lack of transparency in veterinary fee pricing, making it difficult for consumers to compare costs, assess value, or understand how their claims behaviour may impact the future affordability of insurance.

Safeguarding vulnerable consumers Pet owners often make claims in highly emotional situations, with limited understanding of how insurance policies work, what exclusions apply and the impact of

PET PROJECT

Sharon Brown reveals the work of a new association that aims to tackle the challenges facing pet and equine insurance claims on renewal pricing. There is a risk that some consumers struggle to make informed decisions, particularly in urgent or emergency scenarios.

More needs to be done to educate policyholders, ensuring they understand their coverage, the costs of treatment and alternative options such as preventative care and telemedicine.

Increasing fraud risks The sector is facing growing concerns

around fraud, from exaggerated claims to misrepresentation at the point of sale. Some issues include: ● Policyholders misrepresenting pre-existing conditions to obtain cover. ● Inflated vet fees on insured treatments compared to self-paying clients. ● Organised fraud rings targeting pet insurance, including falsified claims for stolen or missing animals.

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

20-21_Pet and Equine_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 20

16/04/2025 15:41

PET AND EQUINE

communication on claims, pricing and policy coverage. ● Sustainability: addressing rising costs to ensure viable pet and equine insurance. ● Trust: Building mutual understanding and stronger relationships with vets and consumer representatives. ● Consumer education: supporting policyholders in making informed decisions. ● Fraud prevention: working towards better data-sharing and fraud detection measures.

Our initial governance framework is in place, with committees on regulation, membership and finance being formed to drive these efforts forward. The website will launch in May, providing a resource hub for members and stakeholders.

21

HOW INSURERS CAN HELP

their expertise is undervalued. ● Claims processes – vet practices often struggle with insurance paperwork, creating delays and additional admin burdens. ● The lack of a shared industry voice – unlike other regulated sectors, there is no unified industry body advocating for sustainable solutions.

Greater data-sharing and collaboration between insurers and veterinary professionals could be key to tackling fraud while ensuring fair outcomes for genuine claims.

Lack of collaboration There is an urgent need for better engagement between insurers, vets and consumer representatives.

The disconnect between these groups has led to mistrust, inefficiencies and frustration, particularly around the following: ● The cost of treatment – insurers question rising fees, while vets feel

THE ROLE OF THE PEIA

SHUTTERSTOCK

Join the Pet and Equine Insurance Sustainability Network on LinkedIn at: www.linkedin.com/ groups/13078306 For more information, email: sharon.brown@ nutshellconsultancy.com

The Pet and Equine Insurance Association (PEIA) was established to address these challenges by providing a dedicated forum for discussion, collaboration and reform. It is a notfor-profit organisation that exists to support its members – insurers, managing general agents (MGAs), brokers and service providers – ensuring their voices are heard while engaging with veterinary bodies, regulators and policymakers.

Following its first steering group meeting, the PEIA has set out its priorities. ● Transparency: encouraging clearer

This is a critical moment for the industry. Insurers, brokers, MGAs and service providers must come together to shape the future of pet and equine insurance rather than waiting for regulators to step in.

There are several ways to contribute: ● Get involved in the PEIA – membership is open to those committed to working towards a sustainable future for pet and equine insurance. ● Engage with the conversation – share insights, data and expertise to help tackle the biggest challenges. ● Support consumer education – ensure policyholders understand their coverage and options.

There is no quick fix but by working together, we can restore trust, drive meaningful change and secure a sustainable future for pet and equine insurance.

If you’d like to be part of the conversation, get in touch.● Sharon Brown is CEO and founder of the PEIA, board director MGAA and CEO of Nutshell Consultancy

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

20-21_Pet and Equine_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 21

16/04/2025 15:41

ECONOMY

A

gainst a backdrop of economic uncertainty, Chancellor Rachel Reeves delivered her highly anticipated Spring Statement at the end of March, outlining her vision for the UK’s financial future.

Meanwhile, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) released its

latest economic forecasts, offering a sobering assessment of the challenges ahead, alongside areas of potential opportunity for the insurance and personal finance professions.

While the announcements did not introduce specific measures directly targeting the insurance sector, several broader initiatives and ongoing regulatory developments are likely to influence the operating environment for insurers in the UK while financial services as a whole remained a key focus on several fronts.

Cuts were announced to government departments, with the Chancellor calling for greater efficiency and

22

SPRING LOADED

The Chancellor’s Spring Statement signaled economic shifts that will impact both insurance and financial services. Liz Booth looks at the pros and cons of what the government announced thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

22-23 Spring Bud_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 22

16/04/2025 15:41

ECONOMY

arguing that the country could no longer afford bloated bureaucracies. She also proposed a shake-up of welfare benefits, claiming that getting more people back to work would improve the country’s budget outlook in the future.

Responding to the Chancellor’s announcement, the Personal Finance Society (PFS) stated: “The Spring Statement underlines how global events have put new demands on already stretched welfare budgets.

Many people will have questions about what this spending pressure will mean for them – not just around disability, but more widely around long-term care and other areas where they may have been counting on support from the state. Now, more than ever before, individuals will need a strong, long term financial plan to see them through difficult times.”

The UK Financial Conduct Authority has reported that more than seven million people in the UK are already struggling to pay bills or manage debt and many would find it difficult to cope with a financial shock.

The PFS agreed with the regulator that innovative and competitive financial services are essential to improving the finances of many.

To succeed, providers of these products and services must ensure they are tailored to each individual’s needs, helping every customer achieve the best possible outcomes.

Given these financial pressures, the insurance sector will also need to adapt to ensure consumers are adequately protected.

GETTY

PROS AND CONS Most of the news contained both positive and negative aspects – exemplified by the push for more construction. Insurers know that more construction will bring opportunities throughout the building process and beyond, but also new risks regarding where these houses are built.

Hannah Gurga, director general of the Association of British Insurers, said: “Certainty and stability are crucial for economic growth and we support the

approach the government has set out in its Spring Statement to deliver this.

“The insurance and long-term savings sector has a vital role to play in the growth mission, including through the commitment to invest £100bn in UK productive finance in the next 10 years.

This includes infrastructure, the transition to green energy and building new homes.

“We support the government’s planning and infrastructure reforms but it is vital that new homes are fit for the future, able to withstand adverse weather and are not built in areas at risk of flooding.”

Of course, this is also dependent on whether house builders have confidence that the economy is robust enough for potential homeowners to afford these new houses and whether mortgage providers are confident enough to lend.

“As a provider of mezzanine finance to this market, we know how this sector is still battling cost overruns, high prices for materials, long lead times and expensive labour in a market that might be best described as mixed,” David Norman, of Davon Investments, told us.

“Potential investors in small to medium enterprise residential developments remain cautious. That goes for the developers themselves, equity investors and banks, as well as other first-tier lenders and second-tier lenders such as us. Also, with higher interest rates on savings on offer, many are content to leave their cash in safer places, rather than risk it on speculative ventures.”

The insurance sector will continue to play a key role in providing warranties and coverage for these new developments. As the housing market navigates economic headwinds, insurers must assess how increased borrowing costs and shifting demand could affect property-related risks and claims.

The government also unveiled a £3.25bn transformation fund aimed at modernising public services through digital technology and artificial intelligence. This initiative seeks to enhance efficiency and effectiveness in public service delivery.

Looking at government ambition to reduce red tape across many sectors, Insurtech UK CEO, Melissa Collett, said:

“Insurtech UK echoes the government’s ambition for a regulatory system that encourages new investment, innovation and growth. Commitments to review and refine authorisation processes are a welcome response to issues we have been raising directly with both government and regulators alike.

“Accessing regulatory approvals should help, not hinder, a startup or scaling company’s growth. Delays impact funding runways and a firm’s ability to progress, whether they affect smaller steps like opening a bank account or present significant barriers in securing further investment.”

Collett concluded: “It is a shared goal with government that innovative insurtechs have an accessible and achievable route to regulatory approval here in the UK.” Meanwhile, insurers have expressed a mixed reaction to the government’s focus on pothole repairs. While road improvements may ultimately reduce claims and benefit insurers, in the short term they might lead to more claims elsewhere. Roadworks often involve diversions, sometimes more than 50 miles in rural areas, increasing the likelihood of accidents as drivers navigate unfamiliar routes. As a result, the net effect on claims could be minimal.

Wider reactions to the overall statement vary depending on political views but there are concerns, for example, that the rise in National Insurance costs for employers, combined with higher minimum pay levels, could lead to more unemployment. This may impact insurers offering income protection cover.

As the UK economy adjusts to these policy shifts, insurers must remain agile – balancing risk, innovation and regulatory compliance. Whether through digital transformation, evolving consumer protection strategies, or infrastructure investments, the industry’s role in economic stability will be more important than ever. ●

23

Liz Booth is contributing editor of The Journal

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

22-23 Spring Bud_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 23

16/04/2025 15:42

E-SCOOTERS

RIDING WITH RISK Molly Burchell examines the legal status and liability challenges of e-scooters in the UK, along with potential long-term consequences for users

I

were originally due to conclude by November 2021 but the deadline has been extended several times.

At present, the trials are due to run until May 2026, with a view to gathering additional data.”

Riders must be at least 16 years old and hold a provisional or full driving licence. Rental e-scooters can be used on roads and cycle lanes but are prohibited from pavements. Insurance is provided through the rental schemes, covering third-party liability but not personal injury.

Riders of rental e-scooters must comply with traffic laws, adhering to speed limits and avoiding mobile phone use while riding. Failure to comply may result in fines, penalty points or vehicle seizure.

Allchorne adds: “The government has indicated that it intends to legalise the use of private e-scooters on UK roads but has said this will not happen during the current parliamentary session. We do not yet know what obligations will be required of users.”

LIABILITY LIMBO E-scooter accidents present significant challenges. For privately owned e-scooters, which cannot be insured for public use, riders are personally liable for damages. This makes recovering costs for victims difficult.

Rental e-scooters offer thirdparty liability insurance, but liability can still be complex if the rider is negligent, such as failing to follow road rules or riding on pavements.

In such cases, the rider could be personally liable for damages beyond the coverage provided by the rental operator’s insurance.

Allchorne notes: “If the motorist is found liable, the e-scooter user’s claim could be substantial. Many e-scooter users do not wear any sort of protection and there is no mandatory requirement to wear a helmet. Injuries sustained can be severe, with head, neck and upper-back injuries making up the majority.”

If the e-scooter user is liable, the motorist will have to rely on the Motor Insurers' Bureau (MIB) Uninsured Drivers or Untraced Drivers Agreements for compensation. As the number of privately owned e-scooters used illegally on UK roads continues to rise, this negatively impacts motorists more generally, as all motor insurers are required to pay into the general levy that funds the MIB.

UNEASY RIDERS The rise of e-scooters, especially among young riders, has created legal and financial risks. Many are unaware that using privately owned e-scooters on

DAVOR PAVELIC / IKON IMAGES

24

n recent years, the UK has seen a significant rise in e-scooter usage, driven by their convenience and eco-friendly nature. Despite their popularity, concerns around insurance coverage, legal responsibilities and the impact of illegal riding by minors are growing.

Many cities trialling e-scooters are reducing their numbers and limiting providers to better regulate their use. To the public, however, the regulations, legal implications or appropriate insurance coverage may not be clear.

The legal status of e-scooters in the UK remains complex. Privately owned e-scooters are classified as motor vehicles under the Road Traffic Act 1988, requiring registration, insurance and compliance with technical standards. However, meeting these requirements is currently unfeasible for privately owned e-scooters, making their use illegal on public roads, pavements and cycle lanes. They can only be ridden legally on private land with the landowner’s permission.

Rental e-scooter trials, launched in 2020, are ongoing in select regions across the UK. Pete Allchorne, head of strategic advisory at law firm DAC Beachcroft, explains: “The trials

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

24-25 E Scooters_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 24

16/04/2025 15:42

E-SCOOTERS

£100 fine for riding through a red light. If a rider is found to be riding with excess alcohol, the penalties are the same as if they were driving a car.”

Allchorne highlights: “An IN10 will stay on a person's record for four years, even before they have a licence, and will likely result in a sharp increase in insurance premiums, as much as 15%-20%.

For young drivers, this will add extra costs to an already hefty premium.”

Police can seize illegally ridden e-scooters, issue fines and add penalty points to a rider’s licence but McCabe feels people – particularly younger riders – are still lacking in knowledge on where the law stands. “A widespread public information campaign and clearer guidance from sellers on the law would help reduce illegal use and related injuries,” he says.

25

SAFETY CONCERNS

AN IN10 WILL STAY ON A PERSON'S RECORD FOR FOUR YEARS, EVEN BEFORE THEY HAVE A LICENCE, AND WILL LIKELY RESULT IN A SHARP INCREASE IN INSURANCE PREMIUMS

public roads is illegal, leading to an IN10 endorsement for driving without valid insurance. This stays on their record for four years, raising motor insurance premiums and making future coverage harder to obtain. Repeated offences can result in further penalties, including a driving licence ban.

Michael McCabe, researcher at DAC Beachcroft, says: “An IN10 endorsement carries a £300 fine and six points on your licence for riding without insurance. Riders can face a fixed penalty notice and £50 fine for riding on a pavement; £200 fine and six points for using a mobile phone while riding; and a fixed penalty notice and

Fires caused by e-bikes and e-scooters in London have doubled in three years, with 120 injuries and three fatalities recorded between 2022 and 2024 – more than anywhere else in the UK. McCabe warns: “Whatever the government decides to do, it would be better to act soon. Years of inaction, coupled with confusion about e-scooter laws, have worsened the situation. What’s needed now is a clear decision and a public education campaign.”

E-scooters are growing in popularity but riders must understand their legal obligations.

While rental schemes are regulated, privately owned e-scooters remain illegal on public roads. Young riders face risks like IN10 endorsements and higher insurance premiums.

Clearer legal frameworks and ongoing education are needed to ensure safer use and reduce longterm consequences. ● Molly Burchell is communications executive of the CII

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

24-25 E Scooters_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 25

16/04/2025 15:42

PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT

26

In the first of our series on how the Professional Map can shape both behaviours and technical expertise at every career level, Ajay Mistry explains how the Map can support personal development, empower your team and drive growth in your business

A

JOHN HOLCROFT / IKON IMAGES

MAPPING SUCCESS

s a founder and leader in a fastpaced broking environment, it’s easy to focus on immediate priorities like delivery and growth.

But recently, I’ve found real value in stepping back to reflect on my personal development and how I can better support my team in doing the same.

The CII Professional Map – particularly at Band 4 – provided an effective framework for this.

I have encountered many frameworks, processes and models throughout my career, but what I appreciated most about the Professional Map was how relevant and practical it felt. It is particularly useful for those working across different areas of the insurance profession.

It’s straightforward and focuses on real-world skills, behaviours, and knowledge that are directly applicable.

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

26-27 Map_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 26

16/04/2025 15:43

PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT

Professional Map is as a development tool for so many people.

BENEFITS AT BAND 4

HELPING OTHERS GROW

RECOGNISING MY OWN GAPS The biggest takeaway for me was how clearly the map highlighted areas where I needed to improve. As a relatively new broker – we only launched a year ago – I naturally gravitated towards areas where I felt most confident – such as relationships, vision and delivery – but I realised I wasn’t paying enough attention to the systems and processes that underpin everything.

Some operational processes I had used in previous roles were being overlooked and I knew I needed to address that. The Map gave me the nudge I needed to prioritise these areas.

Since then, I’ve worked closely with my brokers and our head of commercial, Luke Perkins, to realign our internal systems – especially the broking process.

This shift has had a positive impact on the business and it wouldn’t have happened as quickly without that initial reflection.

Building on that, I wanted my team to experience the same benefits.

I encouraged everyone to use the Professional Map and now it is a tool we regularly reference in one-to-ones.

It’s a great way to discuss where individuals are now and where they want to go. The Map goes beyond just technical knowledge – we’ve had some great discussions about communication, confidence and managing upwards.

Additionally, through my work with the Insurance Cultural Awareness Network (iCAN), we have run successful sessions across the country in partnership with the CII. I have now seen firsthand how effective the

WHETHER YOU ARE THINKING ABOUT YOUR PERSONAL DEVELOPMENT, SUCCESSION PLANNING, OR HOW TO GET THE BEST OUT OF YOUR TEAM, THE PROFESSIONAL MAP PROVIDES A CLEAR AND VALUABLE STARTING POINT

At Band 4, you are expected to think and operate strategically – shaping culture, setting the tone and taking a long-term view. What I particularly appreciate about the Map is that it doesn’t just focus on business results; it also emphasises values.

Competencies such as customer focus, inclusivity, ethics and a drive to deliver aren’t just buzzwords – they are central to how I run my business.

These values matter just as much as meeting targets. The Map helps you understand how these areas fit into your wider leadership responsibilities, reminding you that good leadership isn’t just about being effective – it is about doing the right thing, consistently.

27

SIMPLE TOOL THAT MAKES A BIG IMPACT If you’re in a leadership role and haven’t explored the Map yet, I highly recommend it.

Whether you are thinking about your personal development, succession planning, or how to get the best out of your team, the Professional Map provides a clear and valuable starting point.

For me, it’s not something you use once and forget about. It is something I’ll revisit regularly as my business grows and my role evolves. It has helped me stay focused, hold myself accountable and ensure I am putting the right strategies in place for the long term.

Sometimes, we just need a bit of structure to help clarify where we are and what we need to work on. The Professional Map does exactly that – so why not give it a try today?

To access the Professional Map selfassessment tool, visit: www.ciigroup. org/professional-map/individuals/ self-assess-your-skills ● Ajay Mistry is the co-founder and Co-Chair of iCAN and member of the CII Broking Community board

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

26-27 Map_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 27

16/04/2025 15:43

I N T E R N AT I O N A L

RAISING STANDARDS IN THE MIDDLE EAST 28

F

or several years, the CII has been working closely with the United Arab Emirates (UAE) regulator with the aim of mandating professional qualifications across the country, helping to raise professional standards and trust in the insurance sector.

In February, the UAE Central Bank announced the introduction of new legislation requiring professional qualifications for senior insurance representatives, while citing the CII’s Advanced Diploma as an exemplary internationally recognised qualification necessary for CEOs and other senior management representatives.

The new regulations also establish criteria for continuing professional development (CPD). This will require 15 hours of CPD for insurance brokers, representatives, senior management, and specialised employees.

“Leaders within the sector must attain and demonstrate internationally recognised qualifications, an objective the CII has been striving towards for many years,” says Gaenor Jones, CII regional director of the Middle East and central south Asia. “Since these rules are being

implemented from the top down, they will encourage more junior employees to invest in their professional development, either independently or with employer support, to enhance their skills.

“Professional qualifications from recognised bodies like the CII ensure advisers are competent and marketready, benefiting consumers with expert advice. CPD requirements will also transition from optional to a mandatory industry standard,” says Jones.

EVOLVING LANDSCAPE As economic, regulatory and business landscapes evolve, these measures will be key in tackling emerging challenges, with increased regulation expected to further boost consumer confidence in the insurance profession.

The mandate may also influence other Gulf nations to adopt similar policies. The CII is actively collaborating with regulators and semi-governmental institutions across the Middle East, central and south Asia to drive these initiatives.

Recent events, such as the Covid-19 pandemic and last year’s floods in

the UAE and Middle East, along with new regulations, have elevated the insurance sector's profile, making it a national priority.

Jones tells us: “Other initiatives encouraging collaboration with the CII include the International Professional Partner Firm (IPPF) initiative, which continues to thrive and has strong support from prominent corporations in the region. IPPFs demonstrate a commitment to upskilling their employees through CII or other professional qualifications while adhering to our Code of Ethics and best practices.

“Additionally, the CII collaborates with various training organisations through its Approved Professional Development Centres, ensuring that these institutions meet the robust accreditation standards developed by the CII. This initiative has been widely welcomed across the region. The CII frequently deploys trainers to support corporate in-house training, either on-site or online. These sessions cover revision training, technical knowledge and soft skills, and are available in both English and Arabic to meet market demand,” says Jones.

SHUTTERSTCOCK

As new legislation is announced mandating insurance qualifications in the UAE, the CII is playing a key role in shaping a more skilled and trustworthy profession in the Middle East.

Luke Holloway speaks to Gaenor Jones to find out more

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

28-29 Middle East_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 28

16/04/2025 15:44

I N T E R N AT I O N A L

29

VALUABLE SUPPORT Much of the CII’s work in the region is based on initiatives originally developed in the UK, particularly in London, which are then adapted to the Middle East market.

“To further support accessibility, we have translated study materials and exams to remove language barriers,” says Jones. “We have also broadened our learning content by minimising references to UKspecific entities, such as the Bank of England or the UK Financial Conduct Authority, in favour of more globally relevant terminology.

“Another key initiative is our Goodwill Ambassadors programme.

These ambassadors – who are highly qualified professionals in senior leadership positions within the sector – offer valuable support and guidance to students across the region. In the UAE alone, we have three goodwill ambassadors actively mentoring and advising aspiring professionals,” says Jones.

The Professional Map is another significant way in which the CII is helping insurance professionals in the Middle East to identify training

needs, prepare for appraisals, enhance career development and advance within their organisations.

“The Map is central to our efforts, assisting students in achieving workplace success and driving positive business outcomes,” says Jones. “To facilitate ongoing learning, we also provide strong digital learning resources for our members, including webinars, workshops and insightful learning sessions, all of which have been well received in the region. We also actively participate in forums, webinars and roundtables with senior stakeholders to share best practices and explore how the CII can support local initiatives.”

TALENT IS KEY The CII is expanding efforts to support talent acquisition in the Middle East’s insurance sector, with a strong focus on local retention. In the UK, structured work experience, apprenticeships and internships help attract young talent to the profession.

However, these practices are not yet widely recognised in the Middle East, making this an area of great interest and as well as opportunity for growth.

“We emphasise to corporate leaders the value of investing in employee learning and development, which serves as both a workforce incentive and a means to foster loyalty,” Jones says.

“We are also working closely to develop and offer relevant qualifications tailored to both general insurance providers and niche operators specialising in areas such as marine and aviation.

Moreover, the CII is actively involved in supporting government nationalisation programmes aimed at securing long-term employment opportunities for local populations.

We provide training and CII qualifications to Emirati students in financial planning and insurance sectors, helping to build a skilled workforce and enhance talent retention.”

These collective efforts reinforce the CII’s commitment to professional excellence, ensuring that the insurance sector in the UAE and the broader Middle East market continues to grow and thrive. ● Luke Holloway is editor of The Journal

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

28-29 Middle East_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 29

16/04/2025 15:44

LEARNING

A new course developed by the CII and the University of Greater Manchester aims to give students a thorough understanding of the growing Islamic insurance sector

30

I

n February, the CII and the University of Greater Manchester (UGM) announced the launch of a new Executive MBA in Islamic Insurance and Risk Management, developed in collaboration with the Islamic Insurance Association of London, and the Centre for Islamic Finance.

The course supports a comprehensive understanding of Islamic financial products, the operations of Islamic insurance and in-depth knowledge of Takaful insurance. Its structure is designed to help prepare students for senior positions in organisations that provide or require Shari’ah-compliant or Takaful insurance.

INCREASED AWARENESS UGM has a history of developing industry-relevant degree programmes, collaborating with professional bodies and industry partners. In the development of the programme, UGM liaised with contacts in the Islamic insurance industry and developed ideas with the CII on how the insurance sector could be best served with an increased awareness of Islamic insurance.

With input from the Centre for Islamic Finance, the programme is based on the Greater Manchester Business School’s MBA, with two of the general modules replaced by specialist modules on Islamic Insurance (Takaful) and Islamic Financial Risk Management. Specialist tutors contributed to the production of course materials, drawing on the latest theory and practice, to provide an academically rigorous yet professionally relevant programme.

The Takaful module will provide a critical understanding of its philosophy, concept, origin and development, including the key

TAKING THE LEAD The programme comes at a time when the London and UK market is actively examining how it can deliver Shari’ahcompliant insurance and reinsurance to support not only international Islamic risks, but also the provision of products to meet the needs of the rising Islamic population in the UK. While the UK government is keen to further the country’s position as a leading provider of Islamic financial services, the insurance sector has yet to fully develop in this area, despite the huge potential opportunities.

To do so, the market needs the expertise and understanding of how Islamic reinsurance products should be structured and delivered.

In launching the programme now, UGM and the CII are positioning themselves at the forefront of a dynamic and rapidly growing sector, providing valuable opportunities for professional development and contributing to the advancement of Islamic finance and insurance.

For further information on the programme, please email Professor Abdel Haq at: mohammed.abdel-haq@bolton.ac.uk ● Dr Chris Grant is head of centre for independent academic units, and Professor Mohammed Abdel-Haq is director of the centre for Islamic finance, both at the University of Greater Manchester, while Jon Guy is secretary general of the Islamic Insurance Association of London

SHUTTERSTOCK

ADVANCING ISLAMIC INSURANCE

maxims of Islamic jurisprudence related to Islamic insurance. In the Islamic Financial Risk Management course, students will study the unique nature of Islamic financial products and operations, to establish an understanding of the sources of the unique nature of Islamic financial risks. As well as the two specialist modules, students take modules in financial management and decisionmaking, marketing and operations, strategic management and leadership, and strategic human resource management.

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

30 Manchester_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 30

16/04/2025 15:45

Supporting insurance people when they need us most ˊ˘ ˢ˙˙˘˥ Ёˡ˔ˡ˖˜˔˟ ˦˨ˣˣˢ˥˧ ˔ˡ˗ ˣ˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ guidance to current and former insurance people in the UK and Ireland.

info@theinsurancecharity.org.uk 020 7606 3763 (UK) | 1800 812 933 (ROI) theinsurancecharity.org.uk The Insurance Charity is the working name of The Insurance Charities, a registered charity in England and Wales (206860) Ireland (20200129) Scotland (SC047527) and Isle of Man (1230), and a company limited by guarantee, ˥˘˚˜˦˧˘˥˘˗ ˜ˡ ʸˡ˚˟˔ˡ˗ ˔ˡ˗ ˊ˔˟˘˦ ʛʪʧʧʩʤʜʡ ˅˘˚˜˦˧˘˥˘˗ ˢ˙Ё˖˘ʭ ʦ˥˗ ʹ˟ˢˢ˥ʟ ʥ ˆ˧ ʴˡ˗˥˘˪Ϟ˦ ʻ˜˟˟ʟ ʿˢˡ˗ˢˡʟ ʸʶʧˉ ʨʵˌ ˔ˡ˗ ˜ˡ ˧˛˘ ʼ˦˟˘ ˢ˙ ˀ˔ˡ ʛʣʣʩʣʬʫʹʜʭ ʤʬʠʥʤ ʶ˜˥˖˨˟˔˥ ˅ˢ˔˗ʟ ʷˢ˨˚˟˔˦ʟ ʼˀʤ ʤʴʹ

CII.May25_031.indd 31

14/04/2025 15:57

P R O F E S S I O N A L STA N D A R D S

O

32

ne of the CII’s key strategic ambitions is to be increasingly seen as a valued partner by stakeholders across the insurance and financial planning professions, both here in the UK and internationally. We have been making steady progress on this front during the past year, reigniting existing relationships with a number of stakeholders and establishing many new ones.

We know that having a strong relationship with the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) is essential to achieving our domestic mission. It is therefore pleasing that Matt Brewis, director of insurance of the FCA, describes the “great relationship” that has been established between the Institute and the FCA in recent months, as well as the importance of our organisation for the sector, in his interview in this edition of The Journal.

As one of the newest members of the CII’s executive leadership team – having joined in early March 2025 – I am working on several emerging initiatives that are closely aligned with the ambitions contained in the FCA’s new five-year strategy. It is particularly notable that the regulator has put ‘deepening trust’ in the financial services profession at the top of its list

of strategic goals – which, of course, is also central to the achievement of our Royal Charter mission. Brewis additionally notes in his interview that while a “strong regulatory foundation is vital to maintaining the UK’s appeal”, rules can become “too rigid”.

GUIDANCE AND SUPPORT We recognise our role in supporting the regulator by ensuring our members uphold the highest professional standards. Our goal is to strengthen and enhance the visibility of our work in this area. With the support of our active and dedicated Professional Standards Committee, we plan to develop a range of additional resources in the coming months. These will provide guidance and support for our members and the wider sector, helping to foster the right behaviours and reinforce our commitment to building trust.

Aligned with this, we continue to develop our thought leadership strategy to elevate the profile of both the Institute and our membership.

Fundamentally, our goal is to establish a clear approach that positions us as a trusted source of knowledge, insight and opinion. We already do a great deal from a public affairs and policy perspective, and through stakeholder engagement, as evidenced by our recent programme of roundtables

on consumer trust and managing vulnerability in insurance. However, we also recognise that we can play a more impactful role. This will be achieved through effective horizon scanning, identification of emerging trends and responding promptly to opportunities generated by third parties that arise, as well as what we pick up through active engagement with our closest stakeholders. This will enable us to consider how we can better support our members and the wider sector moving forward.

A critical factor in achieving our thought leadership ambitions is the role of research and insight. If we are to succeed in delivering meaningful impact through our thought leadership strategy, it is essential that we are able to draw on robust evidence to support and verify what we’re saying. We already have an established approach to gathering insight through research activity, engaging with a breadth of stakeholders and other measures, such as our Public Trust Index, and we intend to leverage this range of activity more effectively in future. We will also be developing further research and insight initiatives that will help to support our thought leadership ambitions.

The success of all that work relies, to a great extent, on the relationships we form with other organisations.

Adam Harper explains how CII initiatives align with the Financial Conduct Authority’s new strategy for 2025-30

XXXXXXXX XXXX X XXXX XX / IKON I KON IMAGES IMA ES IMAG

LEADING THE PROFESSION thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

32-33 Standards_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 32

16/04/2025 15:45

P R O F E S S I O N A L STA N D A R D S

FABIAN GILBERT / IKON IMAGES

33

While, as the FCA’s Brewis recognises in his interview, we have historically served the insurance and financial planning professions well through our learning, training and qualifications, we want to create a value proposition that is much more comprehensive and speaks to the needs of senior leaders as well as the people that we’re talking to in human resources and learning and development.

We have begun exploring engagement on topics such as customer success and measuring fair value, aligning with the FCA’s focus on consumer protection and increasing access to insurance and financial advice. Crucially, we are not starting from scratch, but there is still much more we plan to do to support our members in navigating both current and future challenges faced by our professions.

INTERNATIONAL STRATEGY The FCA’s strategy highlights its ambition to be an “international regulator for an international market”. As an established international professional body, we see a tremendous opportunity for the CII to expand beyond our successful hubs in the Middle East and Hong Kong. We are currently developing an international strategy to guide our growth, recognising that we cannot do everything at once. However, we believe we have the potential to support stakeholders in strengthening consumer trust and confidence in our professions on a broader scale.

We believe this is supported by

evidence from other jurisdictions.

For instance, in February this year, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) Central Bank introduced new legislation requiring senior insurance representatives to hold professional qualifications, specifically referencing the CII’s Advanced Diploma as an example of an internationally recognised qualification. Indeed, the UAE’s approach raises the question of whether the UK should follow suit.

While Brewis notes in his interview that the FCA currently does not support such a move, this is an area we would be keen to explore further in the future. ● Adam Harper is executive director of strategy, advocacy and professional standards at the CII

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

32-33 Standards_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 33

17/04/2025 10:15

¾P1 !¾U!P1!h jUH1ɷ± ÝUvI Þ©U±¾ ±¾ v(

Help before you know you need it The Acticheck life-saving wristband isn’t just there for when there’s an emergency. By using predictive analytics, ics, it could detect a possible health issue before it becomes es a real problem.

For example, a restless night could mean a UTI, or reduced d movement during the day could mean the wearer’s in more pain than usual. Combined n usual with Acticheck’s unique I’m OK checks, there really isn’t a better system available for ensuring the wellbeing of older or vulnerable people.

NEW Predictive Analytics Detect possible health issues before they escalate

Fall alert Monitors for severe falls

Unique I’m OK checks ¾ľĞ Ğóơǔ ǎóǔ ƭŲ ĐŲŦȊƙŤ ǔŲƵʀƙĞ ŲŘ in the morning and before bed

SOS Alert Just squeeze to call for help

24/7 uninterrupted protection in your home, garden and beyond – it has a one year battery life and Ńơ ǎóƭĞƙƭŃķľƭɏ ơŲ ŦŲ ŦĞĞė ƭŲ ƭóŘĞ Ńƭ Ųȅ

4.8 (702 reviews) This system delivers as promised.

I purchased this for myself as I live alone and it saves my family having to check up on me every day. The ‘I’m OK’ checks work exactly as I set up… the set up is relatively easy, and the customer support is brilliant.

0345 25 75 080 | acticheck.com CII.May25_034.indd 34

14/04/2025 15:57

R E G U L AT I O N

SETTING STANDARDS

Dr Matthew Connell reflects on the FCA’s new five-year strategy alongside its recent consultation on the Consumer Duty

I

n March, the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) released its five-year strategy for 2025 to 2030. The document was notably more focused on promoting growth than previous plans. In relation to general insurance, the FCA even committed to growing the retail market, stating: “By 2030 we will be able to report an increase in the proportion of consumers who hold certain key products (general insurance, pensions in accumulation, day-to-day accounts, savings accounts), indicating people are better able to withstand a change in circumstances or shocks.”

The FCA pledged to be predictable, purposeful, and proportionate, as well as efficient and effective in carrying out its work.

It identified four key external factors influencing its strategy: ● the need for growth; ● the development of artificial intelligence; ● global uncertainty; and ● the UK’s ageing population.

The strategy appears to have aligned well with government priorities, as Nikhil Rathi was reappointed for a second term as FCA chief executive on 10 April.

SHUTTERSTOCK

CONSUMER DUTY CONSULTATION Alongside its strategy, the FCA also published a feedback statement in response to its consultation on the Consumer Duty, which began in July 2024. One idea it proposed to explore in more detail was the removal of the rule requiring individuals working in insurance to complete 15 hours of ongoing training each year.

While the proposal may appear to lower standards of competence, it is important to note that the FCA’s core requirement – that individuals working in insurance must “possess appropriate knowledge and ability to complete their tasks and perform their duties adequately” – remains unchanged. As such, the regulator still expects insurance professionals to take all necessary steps to maintain their competence.

The FCA’s rationale for the proposed rule change is not that professionals are spending too much time updating their knowledge and skills, but rather that it would ease firms’ recordkeeping burdens.

In response to the FCA’s proposals, the CII emphasised the importance of education and training in delivering high-quality goods and services.

It highlighted that continuous professional development (CPD) is a vital component of professionalism, enabling individuals to adapt to a constantly evolving technological, economic, and social landscape. The CII noted thatCPD provides structure to the learning process by: ● setting objectives; ● identifying relevant learning opportunities; and ● reflecting on learning outcomes to shape future development.

35

The CII also explained that, as a professional body, it has always had the ability to set its own standards for its members – typically above the regulatory minimum. Its standards for professional competence are informed by its Professional Map, qualification syllabuses and a requirement for members to complete 35 hours of CPD annually.

It said: “There will always be a balance to be struck between rules and regulations, and the responsibility on professionals to do the right thing. By supporting our members to do just that, we give the FCA the freedom to focus on creating and enforcing detailed rules where competitive pressures make other voluntary arrangements difficult to sustain. We have no plans to alter our CPD expectations for our members.” ● Dr Matthew Connell is director of policy and public affairs at the CII

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

35 Reg_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 35

16/04/2025 15:46

THE INSURANCE CHARITY

The Insurance Charity has rebranded this year and refocused how it supports insurance people in their time of need, as Aamina Zafar discovers

36

F

or decades, The Insurance Charity has been a lifeline for insurance professionals facing hardship, offering crucial support when they need it most. Now, with a rebrand and expanded offerings, the charity is evolving to reach even more people, proving that change is not just necessary, it is transformational.

As well as launching a new website and a slight change to its working name from The Insurance Charities to The Insurance Charity, the organisation can now provide financial support to anyone who has worked in the insurance profession and is suffering misfortune and hardship, irrespective of their length of service.

READY FOR THE FUTURE Chairman Joshua Brekenfeld says he hopes the changes will allow the charity to reach more people in need.

“As a charity, we wanted to future proof ourselves and make sure we are reaching the insurance community as best we can,” he says. “We undertook a project to figure out what is the best way to make sure the profession that we support knows about us. We went through some extensive research, exploring how people access the charity and peoples’ perceptions of the organisation. The refreshed brand feels

much more welcoming, engaging, and a real reflection of the work the charity does.”

The Insurance Charity is no stranger to change. In fact, it can trace its roots back to 1902 when The Insurance Clerks Orphanage supported widows and orphans. A century later, in 2004, the charity merged with The Insurance Benevolent Fund and became known as The Insurance Charities.

It now employs eight staff but is largely supported by volunteers, which includes its board of directors, three committees and volunteer ‘visitors’ who help the charity assess people who have applied.

The financial support and practical guidance it offers includes common issues such as redundancy, ill health and disability, as well as more complex matters including domestic abuse, loss of a loved one, depression and even the breakdown of a relationship.

The charity can also support the dependants of eligible insurance people such as partners and children.

This generosity has seen it award £1.4m across the UK and Ireland during the 2023-2024 financial year.

This was an increase from £1.3m the previous year.

PROVIDING ASSURANCE “Unfortunately, we do see the need increasing,” Brekenfeld tells us.

“It’s the world that we are living in at the moment. Following the pandemic, there are cost-of-living challenges as well as the normal business cycle of redundancies.

Financial misfortune comes to people unexpectedly and in all manner of ways. It’s at those moments, when people who on any other day would be financially sound and secure, all of a sudden aren’t because of an event or situation. We can fill that gap between that person being on stable footing, to them immediately having to respond to something they are not equipped to deal with.

We provide that assurance.”

Unlike most charities, its focus is not on fundraising, thanks to generous donations from insurance firms, CII members and other member organisations who list it as their charity partner when hosting events and fundraisers.

A key objective of the charity is to raise awareness of its services so it can help as many insurance people in need as possible. The charity will be delivering its annual awareness week between 23 and 27 June this year and hopes CII members will get involved however they can.

The charity’s new CEO Helen Sanson concludes: “We will be looking at new ways of supporting the insurance community, including new partnerships to offer specialist expertise where needed. We want everyone who works, or has worked in the insurance profession, to know about The Insurance Charity and understand we are here for them when they need us most.”

For more information, visit: www.theinsurancecharity.org.uk ● Aamina Zafar is a freelance journalist

SHUTTERSTOCK

SAFETY NET

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

36 Charity_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 36

16/04/2025 15:46

UNDERWRITING COMMUNITY

T

he insurance profession is a force for good – both in the role it plays in society and in the comfort it offers when things go wrong.

Underwriters play an important role by accepting risks from individuals and businesses, allowing them to transfer that risk and, in turn, enabling

FORCE FOR GOOD

XXXXXXXX / IKON IMAGES

Mandy Hunt reflects on why insurance professionals should be proud of how they help to get people’s lives back on track when they need it most

businesses to thrive and prosper. And when something happens that requires insurers to step in and handle a claim, the way we approach it should leave the policyholder with a sense of being supported and cared for.

Four years ago, my husband, Neil, suffered a stroke and it was then that the critical illness cover premiums we’d paid truly paid off. Making the claim was emotionally difficult and gathering all the paperwork was time-consuming. We had a few calls to clarify details and provide evidence, but within 12 weeks, we received the payment. Throughout the process, the empathy shown to us was exceptional.

When my husband was able, the insurer’s nurses called for two more years to check in and offer support.

It was a positive experience and we are truly thankful for the outcome.

On the tough days, I think of how the profession I love showed up for my husband when it mattered most.

That experience should be the norm for everyone. It doesn’t mean every risk is accepted or claim paid, but it does mean we’ve listened and adapted to our customers’ vulnerabilities.

When regulation focuses on delivering good outcomes and considers these vulnerabilities, I truly believe every policyholder will have a similar experience to ours.

PROTECTING WHAT IS IMPORTANT None of this happens without the amazing people employed across our profession. Every product, whether commercial or personal, starts with a need – a risk that insurance can protect against. Product developers begin the process by thinking about the market they want to protect and building a product around that. Pricing

actuaries then develop pricing tools and ratings to support these products. As we see today, expertise in data, artificial intelligence and machine learning is essential as sophistication in pricing continues to evolve.

Insurance companies have a wealth of expertise, from lawyers, claims handlers, and underwriters who assess risks and offer quotations, to sales experts, operational specialists, and professionals from various fields, such as medical experts, surveyors and engineers. Leadership teams also include representatives from finance, human resources, marketing, communications, and compliance.

This is just a glimpse of the roles within an insurer – and then there’s the reinsurance market, which shares similar expertise but also includes areas like catastrophe modelling and worldwide placements.

We offer so many different roles in our wonderful profession and each one plays a part in leaving someone like my husband feeling heard, supported and helped when the unexpected happens.

The next time someone asks why they work in insurance; we should remember the good it does. We should stop saying we “fell into it” because, every day, we show up and choose to help customers and people get their lives, businesses and homes back on track – or support them in the worst of circumstances. We choose to do that and it might not always be perfect, but is there a better focus for humans than helping others?

I hope you enjoy the articles from the CII Underwriting Community in this issue of The Journal. The board is passionate about helping you all by sharing their knowledge and expertise.

To find out more, visit: www.cii. co.uk/membership/professionalcommunities/your-professionalunderwriting-community ●

37

Mandy Hunt is chair of the CII Underwriting Community

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

37 Chair_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 37

16/04/2025 15:47

UNDERWRITING

38

As AI becomes more embedded in insurance, the idea of machines replacing humans feels less far-fetched – and may carry unintended risks, as Liz Booth explores

T

FABIEN GILBERT / IKON IMAGES

RISE OF THE ROBOTS

he use of artificial intelligence (AI) polarises opinion – some fully embrace all that it can bring, while others have some serious doubts about how far it should really go.

In terms of insurance, one of the key questions is around empathy – can computers deliver that, particularly in the claims environment? There are also questions around the staffing of insurance firms – in an industry that repeatedly warns it does not have enough fresh talent, can computers fill the gap?

It seems that there are already changes afoot, with companies using machines for varying purposes. However, Charlotte Halkett, senior consultant with Milliman, cautions that people often confuse data analytics and machine learning with AI: “The definition of AI is becoming wider and wider – AI is

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

38-39 Robots_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 38

16/04/2025 15:47

UNDERWRITING

actually beyond machine learning but the phrase is used more and more. Most of what people perceive is AI is really smart data processing.”

But is there a risk that true AI could become embedded in companies and gradually reduce the jobs available for humans?

In the US (usually a harbinger of things to come in the UK), Aura Intelligence’s March Job Report reveals two contrasting trends in the labour market. AI hiring remains strong, expanding into new sectors, while the broader US job market is showing signs of slowdown. Meanwhile, in the UK, Reuters reports that Britain’s jobs market slowed in February, as hiring figures dropped.

The Recruitment and Employment Confederation says its measure of growth in starting pay for people hired to permanent roles hit its lowest since February 2021. Appointments to permanent jobs have declined for the last 29 months in a row, although the drop in hiring was smaller in February than in January.

The BBC chimes in too, reporting that companies are planning to cut jobs or recruit fewer people ahead of rises to National Insurance payments and wages. According to the study by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), more than a third of the 2,000 firms it spoke to said they planned to reduce their headcount through redundancies or by recruiting fewer workers.

AI IN INSURANCE As the job market cools, AI adoption in insurance is accelerating as businesses optimise processes to improve outcomes while streamlining headcounts, with claims

the relationships, which remain the hallmark of the insurance sector.”

USEFUL TOOL AI AND SMART TECHNOLOGY Other Underwriting Community board CAN MAKE INSURANCE members are at varying stages of AI RELEVANT INTO THE FUTURE. and machine learning developments. one says: “Ours was rolled out INSURANCE IS NOT A GIVEN – As about 18 months ago as a tool for PEOPLE CAN SELF-INSURE AND underwriters to use to garner general on publicly available data GOVERNMENTS CAN STEP IN. analysis and information. It does not replace WE HAVE TO KEEP RELEVANT. any specific underwriting analysis or tools and cannot replace the nonTECHNOLOGY IS ALWAYS public information that proposers MOVING ON are requested to give as part of the

in particular being impacted.

As a result, despite a year where the sector saw record profits, vacancies have fallen by 11.7% in 2024 compared to the year before, with claims in particular heavily impacted. This is according to the latest UK Insurance Labour Market Trends report by Harrison Holgate and labour market data analysts Vacancysoft. It shows that underwriting performed best, growing by 12.1% to 2,174 vacancies and increasing its share from 14.6% to 19.7%. Meanwhile, in a sign of how the industry is transforming, IT is the leading skill in demand, accounting for a 36.6% share of all jobs in the sector.

Not everyone is keen to see rapid change. Sophie Ezadkhasty, a member of the CII Underwriting Community board, admits: “I am of the school of thought that worries about the pace of change.”

She says that she works in a niche area and believes it is important for juniors to learn from their peers but also from doing much of the risk research themselves. Ezadkhasty does, of course, use technology and is delighted to do so, with information recorded digitally and much easier to access.

“The risk for me,” she says, “is that someone can learn to use the technology but at the expense of their soft skills and potentially of

submission.”

That note of caution is reflected by another board member, who adds: “I have used and seen types of AI in use in different settings and aim to keep up to date. It is a useful tool but understanding how to use it, what its capabilities are in different settings and related governance is important, especially when considering current legislation.”

And yet another says: “I would add that we are still in the development stage but are looking at AI to read survey reports. We also use it for general administration, such as chasing quotes, premiums, and so on.”

Milliman’s Halkett, however, welcomes the moves towards embracing more technology: “I believe technology can enrich the sector and will not take anyone’s jobs.

The world has changed, consumers have changed and risks have changed.

“AI and smart technology can make insurance relevant into the future.

Insurance is not a given – people can self-insure and governments can step in. We have to keep relevant.

Technology is always moving on.

“In my career we have seen astonishing changes, from basic computers to AI. People should not view it as a threat but as another tool.

Our jobs might change but we will still have jobs.” ●

39

Liz Booth is contributing editor of The Journal

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

38-39 Robots_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 39

16/04/2025 15:47

UNDERWRITING

BREAKING INTO REINSURANCE Tim Groves talks to Gen Re’s Janice Ketchell about the role of reinsurance and what a career in the sector looks like

40

R

einsurance plays a crucial but often overlooked role in the insurance profession. While many professionals spend their careers in insurance, few transition into the specialised world of reinsurance. Janice Ketchell is an insurance professional who made that very move and here, she discusses her career journey and the evolving landscape of the industry.

Ketchell’s career began in 1985 when she joined Prudential as an underwriter.

Through the years, she gained experience across different sectors, including broking, before moving to RSA in 1990. She spent nearly 24 years at RSA, primarily in underwriting, before joining Gen Re 11 years ago.

“At its core, reinsurance is just insurance for insurance companies.

We help insurers manage their risks and capital, enabling them to underwrite more policies and take on challenging risks,” Ketchell tells us.

Reinsurance provides insurers with the capacity needed to manage largescale risks. “We support insurers with catastrophe scenarios – whether it is weather-related, or risks like aviation, or significant liability risks such as asbestos claims,” Ketchell explains.

“Without reinsurance, insurers might struggle to cover major losses.”

Even for individual policyholders, reinsurance plays a crucial role.

“Take home insurance, for example,”

Ketchell says. “If a single storm damages thousands of homes, the insurer will rely on reinsurance to manage the financial impact.”

The reinsurance industry, like the broader insurance sector, is constantly evolving. Some of the biggest trends shaping the future of reinsurance are climate change, technological advancements and economic factors.

“Emerging risks are a major challenge,” Ketchell notes. “Climate change is leading to more frequent and severe natural disasters. For example, wildfires and hailstorms are becoming bigger issues, yet they remain non-modelled perils at the moment.

We don’t fully understand them enough yet, which makes pricing and risk assessment difficult.

“Solar energy is certainly a growing area of concern. We’ve seen a significant increase in the use of solar panels, and with that comes fire risks, particularly if they aren’t maintained to good standards.

“There was a conference on catastrophe modelling last week that covered these topics. Wildfire modelling is in its early stages, with companies using satellite images to assess risks. There is a lot of investment going into helping better understand these emerging threats.”

THE UNKNOWN UNKNOWNS ARE ALWAYS THE HARDEST TO PREDICT, BUT THAT IS WHAT MAKES REINSURANCE SO FASCINATING. WE ARE CONSTANTLY LEARNING AND EVOLVING

ECONOMIC CHALLENGES The current economic climate also presents significant challenges for the reinsurance market. Inflation and

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

40-41 Reinsurance_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 40

16/04/2025 15:48

GETTY

UNDERWRITING

supply chain disruptions have led to an increase in cases of underinsurance, where policyholders may not have adequate coverage because of rising costs. Ketchell notes: “Times are tough and sums insured aren’t always being reassessed properly, leading to gaps in coverage.”

The impact on reinsurance varies by segment. “Excess-of-loss reinsurance can be particularly affected,” Ketchell explains. “When insurers are writing business from the ground up, there is more certainty in the loss settlement.

When writing high excess business

there can be more volatility due to economic factors and legal disputes.”

Technology has been continuously evolving within the insurance industry. As Ketchell recalls: “When I joined, we had no computers, no Excel. We built the rates manually, using actuarial data.” The shift has been dramatic and now, with artificial intelligence (AI) and data analytics, underwriting and risk assessment have transformed significantly.

Modern technology enables underwriters to access a wealth of information instantly. “You can Google a risk anywhere in the world,” says Ketchell. “Data from clients is easier to utilise and understand, while AI assists us with many tasks. Technology allows us to find data more efficiently, so we spend more time assessing rather than searching for information.”

Despite technological advancements, scepticism remains crucial. “AI and models provide insights but we must question assumptions,” Ketchell explains.

“Incorrect assumptions can lead to poor decisions. Underwriters still need to critically evaluate data.”

A successful relationship between insurers and reinsurers is built on trust, responsiveness and transparency.

“No one likes surprises – brokers and insurers included,” Ketchell explains. “Strong partnerships involve communication and treating each other as collaborators, not just suppliers and customers. If the insurer has a loss, we have a loss – that shared outcome fosters a true partnership.”

She also notes that reinsurers provide valuable insight when evaluating complex risks, helping insurers refine their approach to pricing and risk assessment.

For those interested in a career in reinsurance, curiosity to explore and ask questions, and analytical thinking, are essential. “You need to be good at questioning things, not just taking data at face value,” Ketchell advises.

Relationship-building skills are also key, as the industry remains deeply people-oriented. “This is why AI won’t

Janice Ketchell

completely replace underwriters – it is still a people business.”

For insurance professionals considering a move into reinsurance, Ketchell’s journey offers valuable insight: “You don’t have to start in reinsurance to end up here. If you’re open to learning and adapting, there are many opportunities.”

LOOKING AHEAD Reinsurance will continue to adapt to new challenges, from climate risks to economic uncertainties.

“The unknown unknowns are always the hardest to predict,” Ketchell says.

“But that is what makes reinsurance so fascinating. We are constantly learning and evolving.”

After nearly four decades in the industry, Ketchell remains highly engaged. “I love nearly everything about it. I enjoy winning business, providing solutions and hearing clients say: ‘Thanks, we were able to do this because of you.’”

She also values the complexity of reinsurance. “We deal with fascinating, non-standard risks every day. It keeps things interesting and even after so many years, I still encounter risks I’ve never seen before.”

Technology is transforming reinsurance, but at its core, the profession remains about expertise, relationships and trust. While AI and predictive models provide powerful tools, the human element remains indispensable in making the right decisions. ●

41

Tim Groves is programme development and partnership manager at the CII

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

40-41 Reinsurance_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 41

16/04/2025 15:48

MENTORING

Simon Webster examines respectively the pros and cons of mentoring virtually or in-person

A

42

s a consequence of the Covid-19 pandemic, there has been a rise in hybrid working, with many people now splitting their time between office and homebased work. Virtual meetings via video have become commonplace and caused people to ask which is better – e-mentoring or face-toface mentoring?

Research shows that online meetings with up to four participants are perceived as efficient by the participants. This is because they can see and hear one another clearly and interact naturally. Online meetings also save on travel time and make document sharing easier.

Drawing on this research, it seems that mentoring, which typically involves two people, can work well online. The geographical location of the mentor and mentee no longer matters, while mentoring sessions can be scheduled more quickly, as travel time no longer needs to be factored into the mentor’s and mentee’s schedules.

RELATIONSHIP BUILDING However, mentoring requires both the mentor and mentee to build and cultivate a relationship – but can such a relationship be built online? The simple answer is yes, though there are certain elements that both parties need to consider.

Online conversations often miss the niceties of face-to-face interaction.

When we physically walk into a meeting, we typically ask questions like “How is your day?” or “How was your weekend?” These side conversations can reveal what’s important to the person and help build rapport by identifying shared interests or approaches. Therefore, the mentor may want to incorporate this into the start of the meeting.

Another consideration is non-verbal

Simon Webster is membership marketing manager of the CII

CONNECT The CII’s digital mentoring platform Visit www.cii.co.uk/connect now to participate in our mentoring platform and put this learning into practice.

Connect is ready to welcome: ● New users: looking for their first mentee or mentor ● Returning users: to update their profile and be involved again.

SHUTTERSTOCK

ONLINE OR FACE TO FACE?

communication. One of the most well-known research projects on non-verbal communication was led

by Dr Albert Mehrabian, professor emeritus of psychology at the University of California, Los Angeles.

This study, which took place in the 1960s, identified that conveying a message was 7% verbal, 38% vocal and 55% visual – so a whopping 93% is non-verbal communication. This is no different whether the conversation is in person or online.

Traditionally, non-verbal communication can be broken down into voice, facial expressions, head movements, hand gestures, posture, fidgeting and physical distance, as well as physical appearance – such as how we’re dressed or whether we’ve made an effort to brush our hair. However, in online conversations, non-verbal communication expands to include additional factors. These include the physical background – is it appropriate for a professional environment and is it tidy? The angle and distance of the camera – does it allow the other person to see our facial expressions and hand gestures? And are background noises minimised?

In summary, online mentoring can be just as effective as in-person mentoring, with the added benefits of greater efficiency and availability.

However, both the mentor and mentee need to ensure they allocate the time and respect the meeting requires to achieve optimal results. ●

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

42 Connect_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 42

16/04/2025 15:49

EXAMS

W

e realise that exams are by their nature often stressful and occasionally high-stake events, where you need to be able to focus on performing to your best abilities, not worrying too much about process or technology.

Like other professional bodies, we are always looking at how we can better help candidates prepare for their remotely-invigilated exams to ensure a smooth and efficient exam-day experience.

In most cases, candidates have a choice between sitting exams remotely or at one of 88 centres in the UK and more than 700 worldwide (almost double the number of venues available previously).

Since the first Covid-19 lockdown in 2020, we have delivered more than 230,000 exams in the UK and internationally – more than 107,000 of them remotely. This year, we have delivered more than 11,000 already, 40% of which have been conducted remotely, including both on-screen written and multiple-choice formats.

We continue to take feedback from candidates to improve the experience.

Any unnecessary obstacle to a candidate having a successful exam is unacceptable, so we have implemented a number of improvements to simplify processes and guidance, taking insights directly from candidates, complaints trends, survey feedback, best practice, and local institute volunteers.

JENS MAGNUSSON / IKON IMAGES

TOP TIPS The majority of issues that candidates face when taking exams remotely could be avoided or mitigated by following these simple tips: 1. Do not use a corporate laptop or company Wi-Fi. Laptops provided by your employer will typically include security software and protocols that will conflict with the remote invigilation software. You may also not have administrative rights to install the secure browser or disable prohibited programmes.

EXAM READY

As more candidates take CII exams online, Becky Del Prado shares top tips for maximizing your chances of success 2. Check your computer passes the system compatibility check in good time before your exam. Please note it will not detect ‘prohibited programs’, firewalls or other network restrictions. The system check is generic and not bespoke.

Please ensure that you leave plenty of time on your exam day and you have administrative rights to close any background applications.

3. Once you have booked your exam, you will be able to launch a tutorial that allows you to experience the launch of an exam as it will be on the day.

4. Take time to try the familiarisation test so you can get used to the exam interface. Note that there are different familiarisation tests for the multiple-choice and on-screen written exams.

5. Double check you have fully read and followed the detailed instructions for your exam. Some exams require different processes

43

and software, for example, candidates taking R06 should be aware that different procedures apply from earlier R0 units.

6. Prepare your exam environment well in advance, following all our guidance on room setup, including making sure that any other household members are aware you are not to be disturbed.

7. Connect to your router with an ethernet cable rather than relying on Wi-Fi. By following these simple tips, we hope that most candidates can focus on studying to perform at their best in their exam.

Full guidance for exam candidates, including our exam user guides, can be found at: www.cii.co.uk/ learning/qualifications/ assessment-information ● Becky Del Prado is qualifications and assessment manager at the CII

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

43 Exam Prep_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 43

16/04/2025 15:49

LOCAL INSTITUTES

THE POWER OF VOLUNTEERING Each local institute is led by a group of dedicated volunteers from the profession. Michelle South, president of the Insurance Institute of Leicester, speaks with Matt Ward about her experience

TELL US ABOUT YOUR LIFE IN INSURANCE

44

I began my insurance career with Norwich Union in 2001 as a commercial underwriter in Leicester.

During my time at Aviva (formerly Norwich Union), I was fortunate to gain various development opportunities in underwriting, operations and leadership, before transitioning into broking.

In 2014, I joined Willis Towers

Watson as a development director, managing schemes and underwriting facilities in London – a role I thoroughly enjoyed before taking the opportunity in 2018 to bring my skills closer to home as schemes director at BHIB Insurance Brokers.

Following the acquisition of the firm by Clear Group in 2022, which included Brokerbility, I was offered the chance to lead Brokerbility alongside the managing director. In the past two

years, I’ve worked to reinvigorate our offering, ensuring we stay relevant to our members and the future of broking.

Most recently, I’ve been appointed schemes governance director for Clear Group while continuing my role as market management director at Brokerbility. I’m fortunate to work with an exceptional team, which has allowed me to grow and thrive. My ambition has always been – and will always be – to be the best I can in everything I do.

WHAT DRIVES YOU TO VOLUNTEER FOR YOUR LOCAL INSTITUTE? I volunteer because I have been incredibly fortunate to have supportive people in my life – people who encourage me, believe in me and help me achieve my goals. That kind of support fuels my determination to succeed and I see volunteering as a way to give back.

I first joined Leicester council in 2002, but frequent work assignments across the UK made it difficult to fully contribute. However, I always intended to return and, in 2023, I rejoined the council and was warmly welcomed back by new and familiar faces.

My focus now is to champion others in our community – encouraging and nurturing new talent while celebrating the wonderful Institute that I’m privileged to be part of. thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

44-45 Local In_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 44

16/04/2025 15:50

LOCAL INSTITUTES

people businesses. Local institutes will continue to champion these connections while embracing technology to enhance accessibility and engagement. I also hope to see a continued focus on inclusion and diversity, ensuring the profession is welcoming to individuals from all backgrounds.

TELL US ABOUT YOUR LIFE OUTSIDE OF INSURANCE

TELL US ABOUT THE INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF LEICESTER The Insurance Institute of Leicester is a vibrant, professional community where members support one another.

Our council is welcoming and encourages engagement at all levels.

Many of our council members have won CII national awards, and lifelong friendships and professional alliances have been forged through the years.

It’s a truly nurturing environment.

Our council offers a comprehensive education programme with diverse training courses for all levels. We’re also working hard to raise awareness of insurance as a career, with our Next Gen Committee launching an engagement programme with schools and colleges this year. Additionally, we have a strong programme of sports and social events to foster networking and attract new council members. Our well-attended annual dinner provides a fantastic opportunity to bring everyone together and celebrate members’ achievements.

During my presidential year, I aim to engage more with the insurance and financial services community in Leicestershire, introducing them to the many ways our Institute can support them. I also hope to collaborate with

likeminded organisations to expand our reach locally.

WHAT ARE THE CORE VALUES OF THE LOCAL INSTITUTES? Local institutes play a vital role in fostering community, collaboration and professional support.

They offer members numerous benefits, including: Community building: Creating a sense of belonging through networking, knowledge-sharing and relationship-building.

Skills development: Providing workshops, training sessions and mentorship opportunities to help individuals grow in their fields.

Representation and advocacy: Amplifying members’ voices in regional and national conversations.

Access to resources: Offering tools and information that may be difficult to obtain independently.

Career opportunities: Connecting members with job openings, internships and professional partnerships.

As technology advances, it’s easy to become disconnected from human interaction. However, insurance and personal finance have always been

I’m a passionate equestrian and have owned and competed with several wonderful horses across the UK, including at national championships – regularly placing in the top five.

I specialise in dressage and have ridden competitively for British Dressage.

I also became a qualified landscape gardener years ago (though I probably should have been studying for my CII exams instead!).

Outside of my interests, I have a 17-year-old son who is currently studying for his A-Levels and an amazing partner who is incredibly supportive in helping me juggle my hectic life.

45

HOW WOULD YOU ENCOURAGE CII MEMBERS TO GET INVOLVED LOCALLY? I’d encourage everyone to engage with their local institute – whether by attending a training session, joining a social event, or becoming part of the council. You’ll meet incredible people and have fun along the way.

It doesn’t have to be a huge time commitment; you can contribute as much or as little as your schedule allows. Any involvement is valuable and appreciated. As the CII evolves to stay relevant, your contribution can help shape its future and strengthen your professional community.

For more information on the Insurance Institute of Leicester, visit: www.cii.co.uk/leicester For contact details of your local institute, visit: www.cii.co.uk/local ● Matt Ward is regional membership manager of the CII

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

44-45 Local In_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 45

16/04/2025 15:50

EDI

W

46

ith Neurodiversity Celebration Week having taken place in March, it is an opportune moment to reflect on the importance of embracing neurodiversity in the workplace. GAIN – the Group for Autism, Insurance, Investment and Neurodiversity – is dedicated to creating employability opportunities for neurodivergent individuals within the financial and professional services sector.

Guided by its members, the results of GAIN’s recent Annual Individual Member Survey provide invaluable insights into the current landscape and highlight the strides being made towards a more inclusive and supportive work environment.

The findings reveal key trends and challenges faced by neurodivergent professionals, emphasising the need for continued efforts to foster inclusivity and support.

THE FINDINGS Demographics often seem like mere statistics, but they are crucial in understanding the diverse backgrounds and experiences of neurodivergent individuals. Neurodiversity intersects with various aspects of identity, making it essential to consider these factors in our efforts to create inclusive workplaces.

Representation of the wide range of neurotypes is vital. However, many neurodiverse individuals face challenges in obtaining a formal diagnosis, which can hinder their representation. The annual survey revealed that more than 70% of those pursuing a diagnosis encountered significant obstacles, with accessibility being the most common issue.

Empowering individuals to selfdiagnose and shape their lives based on their understanding of self is crucial, as attested by the high percentage of latediagnosed members of GAIN. Neurodivergent individuals often struggle to identify clear career paths and navigate professional growth – sometimes referred to as ‘navigational nebula’. It can feel like there exists a ceiling, despite our skills and experience. Workplaces are encouraged to provide clarity on career paths and transparency on salary to help employees advance professionally and feel valued in their roles. Behavioural expectations can significantly impact an individual’s ability to perform professionally. Traditional criteria for ‘fitting in’ may not always align with the needs of neurodivergent employees. Emphasising a sense of belonging and representation of differences can enhance the efficacy of corporate values and create a more inclusive environment.

Employee resource groups (ERGs) play a crucial role in driving actionable change. These groups, often led by individuals close to the cause, can raise awareness and advocate for practical policies. Involvement across the hierarchy and educational efforts are essential to ensure that everyone, regardless of their degree of connection to the topic, understands and supports neurodiversity.

Neurodiversity role models significantly influence workplace culture and employee engagement.

Results from the survey show that 73% of GAIN members can identify neurodiversity role models, correlating with higher perceptions of inclusivity. Senior leaders advocating for cognitive diversity can foster a culture of understanding and respect, empowering employees and enhancing overall engagement.

Flexibility and workplace agility are highly valued by neurodivergent individuals. Common adjustment requests include remote or flexible working, adjustments to in-office locations and the use of personal comfort items. These adjustments address sensory environment issues and other challenges, making the workplace more accommodating.

Masking or concealing one’s neurodivergence is a significant issue for many employees. The data

EMBRACING NEURODIVERSITY Following March’s Neurodiversity Celebration Week, Dr Vina Theodorakopoulou reflects on the importance of creating a path to inclusive workplaces

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

46-47 EDI_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 46

16/04/2025 15:50

EDI

MARIE MONTOCCHIO / IKON IMAGES

shows that 56% of respondents mask their neurodivergence, leading to exhaustion and negative impacts on mental health and productivity.

Creating a culture where differences are embraced can alleviate this psychological burden and allow neurodivergent individuals to thrive. Meanwhile, neurodivergent individuals are more likely to experience workplace bullying.

Respectful curiosity and awareness of biases are essential in creating a safe and inclusive environment.

The presence of neurodivergent role models can significantly impact perceived safety and support in raising complaints about mistreatment.

Possibly, if we treat meaningful change as chasing a chimera. The 3.5% rule suggests that a small portion of the population can bring about significant change. This principle underscores the importance of collective action in supporting differences (both visible and invisible traits). By working together, we can create a more inclusive and supportive environment for all.

Reframing recruitment practices to focus on core skillsets and qualifications is crucial. Flexible working, salary transparency and inclusive recruitment practices can attract and retain diverse talent.

By implementing a transparent and accommodating recruitment process, employers can gain a competitive edge.

The insurance profession is encouraged to join forces with the CII and GAIN to commit to fostering inclusive workplaces where cognitive polymorphy is both nurtured and utilised. To stay ahead of the curve, we need to think outside the box, and rise above labels and stereotypes. ● Dr Vina Theodorakopoulou is supervisory board member and individual member lead at GAIN

POSITIVE CHANGE As a sector, we have some purposeful mileage to cover towards creating thriving workplaces for all our employees. Does measurable change appear unfeasible?

47

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

46-47 EDI_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 47

16/04/2025 15:51

HISTORY

48

Sarah Begley explores the historic working relationship between the insurance sector and the legal profession

T

he law and the insurance industry have enjoyed a long working relationship, which can be traced as far back as the 16th and 17th centuries, particularly in Europe.

In the early days of insurance, merchants would create rudimentary and rather informal contracts to protect themselves against the risk of shipwrecks, piracy and similar perils.

But as trade grew, business needs became more complex, requiring more formalised legal structures.

And thus, lawyers were brought in to ensure contracts were legally binding.

It was in the 19th century that insurance law became a specialised field. Lawyers began to play a central role in drafting policies, ensuring legal compliance, interpreting insurance contracts, regulating the industry and handling disputes in claims.

By the 20th century, the role of lawyers in insurance was essential

to the functioning of the modern insurance industry, a role that continues to evolve as new challenges and regulations continue to arise.

HISTORIC RELATIONSHIP The Forum of Insurance Lawyers (FOIL) is the professional membership organisation representing those engaged in handling insurance-related claims. The Insurance Museum (IM) has been chosen as FOIL president Howard Dean’s nominated charity for 2025.

FOIL’s decision to support the goals of the IM as its charity of the year for 2025 acknowledges the historic relationship.

Reg Brown, chairman of the IM, says: “As a former liability underwriter at Lloyd’s and a past president of the British Insurance Law Association, the marriage between insurance and the law has been with me throughout my career. I am therefore delighted that FOIL’s president, Howard Dean, has chosen the Insurance Museum as his charity for 2025.”

FASCINATING STORY One of the ambitions of the IM is to attract talent into the industry, by sharing the fascinating story of insurance and showing what an exciting industry it is to work in.

As Dean explains: “The industry is evolving rapidly and it’s crucial that we don’t miss out on the next generation of leaders. By dispelling these misconceptions, we can help young people see that a career in insurance and insurance law is dynamic, varied and rewarding – just like the risks we aim to manage.”

The IM can only achieve its aims through sponsorship and donations from the wider insurance community.

In the next three years, the IM will need £600,000 to deliver the education and careers programme, as well as the collections development.

We are applying for grant funding but will need extra sponsorship to matchfund those grants.

If you would like to get involved through sponsorship, membership or making the IM your charity of the year, visit: insurance.museum, or follow the IM on LinkedIn, to learn more. ● Sarah Begley of OB Brand Consulting

KOIVONICK / IKON LOWDNES IMAGES / IKON IMAGES

PROUD PAST, FUTURE TALENT

One of the key reasons Dean chose the IM as his charity of the year is the value it places on educating the public, particularly the young, to correct misconceptions about the insurance industry – and the law’s role within it – with a view to attracting new talent.

He writes in a recent issue of Insurance Edge: “Careers in insurance and insurance law are far more diverse and rewarding than many realise.

Too often, young people dismiss them due to a lack of understanding about the industry’s depth. Insurance is all about managing risk – an exciting, dynamic and integral part of almost every industry and aspect of life.

We need to challenge misconceptions to ensure we attract the best talent to secure the future of our industry.”

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

48 IM_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 48

16/04/2025 15:51

Q&A STUDY ROOM

This set of questions, courtesy of online CII training package Insurance Assess, will test your knowledge of relevant learning topics. Answers are at the bottom

QUESTION 1

QUESTION 6

QUESTION 9

On which basis are claims under a horse and pony policy settled?

New for old Reinstatement Replacement Indemnity

What is the minimum age above which a horse can be insured?

14 days 25 days 31 days 50 days

QUESTION 2

QUESTION 7

In the motor industry, what is meant by the term ‘connected car’?

A car fitted with advanced driverassistance system technology A car that is being towed A car that is towing a trailer or caravan A car that is connected to external sources of data

Which of the following should be included in a firm’s assessment of whether it is delivering good outcomes for customers?

The overall cost of a firm's products and services New and emerging risks relating to good consumer outcomes How the firm sets its profit margins for each product and service Known risks relating to the firm's aims and objectives

Which of the following is a monitoring and governance requirement under Consumer Duty? Monitor and regularly review...

Staff opinion surveys Sales and cancelations Monitor and regularly review profit Losses

QUESTION 3 In respect of critical illness insurance underwriting, which of these completes a GP report?

Any medical doctor The patient The patient’s GP The patient’s medical specialist

QUESTION 10 What are the territorial limits under the theft and straying section of a pet insurance policy?

England and Wales England, Wales and Scotland The United Kingdom The United Kingdom and Europe

49

QUESTION 8 What name is given to the form where more than one immediate care plan provider can quote using common data?

Care fees plan questionnaire Factfind questionnaire Request for quotation questionnaire Underwriting questionnaire

YOUR SCORE » 1–3 POOR 4–6 GOOD

7–8 VERY GOOD 9-10 EXCELLENT

QUESTION 4 What is the initial exclusion period for claims in respect of veterinary fees as a result of illness?

14 days 21 days 28 days 7 days

QUESTION 5 Which of these organisations regulates the motor fleet insurance industry?

The Association of British Insurers The Financial Conduct Authority The Financial Ombudsman Bureau The Financial Services Authority

in the first 14 days of cover.

to good consumer outcomes.

4A Policies exclude illnesses arising

2B New and emerging risks relating

policies of indemnity.

1D Horse and pony policies are

patient’s own GP. 3C A GP report is completed by the

5B The Financial Conduct Authority. 8A Care fees plan questionnaire.

6C No younger than 31 days.

9D Connected to external sources 7A Monitor and regularly review staff of data. opinion surveys.

10C It applies only to the UK.

SHUTTERSTOCK

ANSWERS

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

49 Quiz_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 49

16/04/2025 15:52

OPINION

LAURA ECCLES

A DAY IN THE LIFE While no two days are the same in claims, Laura Eccles offers a glimpse of what a day at work often involves

F

or my final edition of this blog series, I wanted to share a recent day in my role. Although there is no such thing as a ‘typical’ workday for me because my role is so varied, it certainly keeps my days interesting.

Below is an example of what my day often looks like.

12:30 – Report preparation: During downtime between meetings and lunch, I undertake some analysis of large loss reserve developments for an internal reporting pack. This is interrupted by a call from a claims handler who requires support, as they have received a data-sharing request from another insurer on a claim we are currently investigating due to fraud concerns.

7:30 – Dog walk: Today I take my dog Ivy on a route that goes to Brandon Hill, which has great views over Bristol and is one of my favourites. It is made even better as it’s the first walk in a long time with a blue sky and a glimmer of warm sun.

8:30 – Early morning preparation: I respond to some emails and prepare ahead of my 9:00am meeting.

9:00 – Regulatory reporting handover meeting: My colleague Coby is taking over responsibility for submitting a regulatory report, which I completed last year. We are meeting so that I can answer any queries he has about the process.

ALTHOUGH THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS A ‘TYPICAL’ WORKDAY FOR ME BECAUSE MY ROLE IS SO VARIED, IT CERTAINLY KEEPS MY DAYS INTERESTING

10:00 – Colleague Engagement Forum strategy meeting: My colleague Kat and I are leading the forum this year and meet to discuss initiatives.

We have a solution to address comments raised in the recent colleague survey, which involves encouraging the teams to sit at different desks when they are in the office, as new ways of working have reduced the opportunity to build relationships with colleagues in other teams.

11:00 – Complaints root cause analysis meeting: I meet with Michele in compliance to review complaint trends and themes from our recent complaint data. We identify that some customers may benefit from additional guidance to support their understanding of the claims journey for certain claim

14:30 – Team support: After lunch, I have a catch-up with my new team member, James, who is our new fraud investigator. He is immersing himself in the day-to-day operations to understand existing processes and tools, as well as meeting other key stakeholders within the company.

It is great to hear him speak enthusiastically about his analysis and plans.

15:30 – Claims Risk Council preparation: The remainder of the day is spent preparing for this meeting, which is scheduled a fortnight from now. As chair, I need to ensure that the relevant papers will be prepared and that guest attendees have slots for their agenda items. Before logging off, I also share some claims data analysis requested by our external comms team, who want to include this in an article they are publishing.

18:00 – Gym: I unwind by listening to an interesting, if not slightly disturbing, history podcast on the life of Lord Byron, while I’m on the stair climber at the gym. ● Laura Eccles is claims risk and performance manager at Ecclesiastical and a Chartered insurer

ILLUSTRATION: MATTHEW BRAZIER

50

types. We agree to get advice from our marketing team around suggestions for making these documents as customer-friendly as possible.

thejournal.cii.co.uk / The Journal / April - May 2025

50 Blog_APR MAY 25_Cll The Journal.indd 50

16/04/2025 15:52

TALKS & TOURS

DISCOVER THE INCREDIBLE STORY OF INSURANCE For info / booking enquiries, visit: www.insurance.museum/talks-tours Annual IM founder membership: £50 Discounted to £40 for CII & WCI members Use promo code IMCII2024 / IMWCI2025

CII.May25_051.indd 51

www.insurance.museum Registered charity 1188138

14/04/2025 15:57

Explore the CII eLibrary today Accelerate your learning by using our eLibrary to search and access eBooks, electronic articles, reports and other online resources.

Visit www.cii.co.uk/elibrary (and login with your CII email or PIN and password)

CII.May25_052.indd 52

14/04/2025 15:57