www.railpro.co.uk
THE BUSINESS RESOURCE FOR RAIL
Moving Together, Unlocking Potential
SAFETY & SECURITY The Case of the Crumbling Concrete
SEPTEMBER 2026 | ISSUE 325 | £7.95
How an integrated approach is unlocking greater value from ports, rail and materials handling
STATION REFURBISHMENT Engineering Passenger Information
INTERVIEWS
Conversations with business leaders from across the industry
Safety tailored solutions, designed with your employees and their wellbeing in mind With over three decades of safety-critical expertise, the OPC delivers bespoke solutions that strive to improve people performance, identify talent and nurture a safer culture.
Our expert psychologists help to: Discover top talent through specialised recruitment support and role profiling.
Improve performance using Non-Technical
Skills and safety initiatives.
Develop best practices, stand-out safety
leaders, and deliver post-incident support for a safer culture. Partnering with the OPC means collaborating with a dedicated team focused on safety and people performance. Trust us for tailor-made solutions from pre-selection to employment. We prioritise safety and strive to enhance your processes to go beyond industry standards.
Email us today
to see how we can help enhance your performance
admin@theopc.co.uk 2
+44 (0)1923 234646 www.theopc.co.uk One Wellstones, Watford, WD17 2AE
www.railpro.co.uk
THE BUSINESS RESOURCE FOR RAIL
Moving Together, Unlocking Potential
SAFETY & SECURITY The Case of the Crumbling Concrete
SEPTEMBER 2026 | ISSUE 325 | £7.95
How an integrated approach is unlocking greater value from ports, rail and materials handling
STATION REFURBISHMENT Engineering Passenger Information
EDITOR’S NOTE
INTERVIEWS
Conversations with business leaders from across the industry
railprofessional @railpromag
PUBLISHER RAIL PROFESSIONAL LTD Lakes Innovation Centre, Lakes Road, Braintree, Essex, CM7 3AN
EDITORIAL EDITOR Sam Sherwood-Hale editor@railpro.co.uk DISPLAY ADVERTISING Jamie Tregarthen sales@railpro.co.uk RECRUITMENT ADVERTISING recruitment@railpro.co.uk SUBSCRIPTIONS subscriptions@railpro.co.uk ADMINISTRATION Cherie Nugent info@railpro.co.uk Lisa Etherington admin@railpro.co.uk DESIGN & PRODUCTION Lukasz Saczek production@railpro.co.uk
COVER PortRail Group
Rail Professional welcomes contributions in the form of articles, photographs or letters, preferably by email. Original photographs may
One thing that caught my eye this month was a policy paper from the Chartered Institution of Railway Operators, CIRO’s Operational Agenda for Great British Railways. Developed by a panel of CIRO Fellows chaired by Ben Rule, Railway Operations Director at East West Rail, it sets out seven recommendations for GBR, covering a national operating framework, investment in operational leadership, national targets focused on customer outcomes, governance that balances local and national needs, a transparent access framework, a national technology and data strategy, and a long-term approach to workforce reform. Rule’s point is that structural reform on its own will not be enough, and that success depends on the people running the railway day to day being equipped and trusted to make decisions. This issue is also our preview of InnoTrans, with Kerstin Schulz, Director of InnoTrans, on the exhibition’s 30th anniversary and this year’s global framing, and Jorge Aldegunde of DNV on why cybersecurity has to be built in from the design stage rather than bolted on afterwards. We also have a bumper run of interviews this month, from Richard Schofield of Project Leaders on why major programmes lose their way, to Mike Tuffy of Optimas International on preparing for Great British Railways, to Elena Romanova of Scott Bader on the shift to closed-mould composite processes and the growing appetite across Europe for lightweight composite solutions in rail. On the infrastructure side, HS2 reached a milestone this summer with progress on the platforms at Old Oak Common, a useful marker of where the project actually stands. Elsewhere we are focused on station refurbishment and safety, with Graham Kelly of Caledonian Sleeper telling us about the new Meeting & Events Centre at Perth station, and Dr Stephen Fletcher of the Occupational Psychology Centre setting out what the best safety leaders do. SAM SHERWOOD-HALE EDITOR
be submitted, but, while every care will be exercised, neither the editor nor the publisher take responsibility for loss of, or damage to, material sent. Submission of material to Rail Professional will be taken as permission for it to be published in the magazine and online. ISSN 1476-2196 © All rights reserved. No part of this magazine may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the copyright owners. The views and opinions expressed in this publication are not necessarily those of the publisher, nor does it accept liability for any printing errors or otherwise which may occur.
3
4
CONTENTS | ISSUE 325 | SEPTEMBER 2026
In this issue 8
NEWS
19
All the latest from Network Rail, HS2, Transport for London, Great Western Railway, British Transport Police, AtkinsRéalis, RIA and RSSB
INTERVIEW 11 Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Alice Barrett,
Partnerships and Standards Manager at AssessTech, about why effective competence management is about far more than compliance
STATION REFURBISHMENT Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Graham Kelly, Managing Director at Caledonian Sleeper, about the operator’s new Meeting & Events Centre at Perth station, early demand from businesses and community groups, and where the venue sits within the company’s wider growth plans
INTERVIEW 20 Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Elena Romanova, Global Market Manager for Rail and Land Transport at Scott Bader, about the shift from hand lamination to closed-mould composite processes, the growing role of bio-based fire resistant resins and why UK rail’s conservatism sets it apart from a fast-moving European market
24 Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Jim Flatman, COO of PortRail
Group, about the integration of JST Services and RFS Works, unlocking modal shift, fleet optimisation across 200 sites, and where the business sees its next phase of growth
28 Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Richard Schofield, CEO of
Project Leaders, about why major programmes lose their way when process replaces accountability, why rail keeps losing talent to nuclear, and what two decades on HS1, the London 2012 Olympics and Crossrail have taught him about complexity, culture and people
32 Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Mike Jenkinson, Managing 14
LAYING DOWN THE LAW Managing the New Trade Union Right of Access to the Workplace
INTERVIEW 16 Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Cory Smith,
Project and Sales Manager at ROMIC, about sourcing and exporting locomotives and rolling stock to operators around the world
Director at Booth Industries, about tightening assurance requirements, standardising doors across major infrastructure schemes, and what Old Oak Common demands of a specialist supplier
36 Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Lee Pounder, Regional Managing Director Scotland & Ireland at SPL Powerlines UK, about the company’s expansion into Ireland’s rail electrification market, its diversification into high-voltage energy infrastructure, and why a rolling programme of investment is essential to delivering decarbonisation across the network
40 Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Mike Tuffy, CEO of Optimas
International, about the Exponent acquisition, preparing for Great British Railways, and the growing appetite for component standardisation across the rail supply chain
21st CENTURY SURVEYING SOLUTIONS FOR THE RAIL INDUSTRY For more information visit www.abasurveying.co.uk or call 01483 797111
5
Site support for rail resilience works
Temporary accommodation and site facilities for drainage, earthworks, flood defence and trackside projects.
Welfare units
Site offices
Storage
Drying rooms
CONTACT US TODAY 0800 51 55 55 | www.wernick.co.uk | contact.hire@wernick.co.uk 6
Power & setup
Find out more Scan the QR code
CONTENTS | ISSUE 325 | SEPTEMBER 2026
43 STATION REFURBISHMENT
Two major station schemes have opened or begun this year, backed by tens of millions of pounds in investment. But a parliamentary debate and a new industry report both argue that lifts and bridges are only part of the answer
44 INNOTRANS
69 SAFETY & SECURITY
PPE must meet defined technical and regulatory requirements, but compliance does not necessarily mean equipment will work equally well for every person wearing it
71
Suramya Nevatia, Chairman & Managing Director of Hirect, on the company’s expanding global footprint and what to expect from the business at InnoTrans 2026
46 INNOTRANS
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Jorge Aldegunde, Global Head of Railway Services at DNV, about embedding cybersecurity into the Santiago de los Caballeros monorail from the design stage, trialling the draft IEC 63452 standard on a live project, and why GoA4 automation raises the stakes of a successful attack
51
INNOTRANS InnoTrans 2026 set to be the most international edition yet, as the Berlin exhibition grounds prepare to welcome more than 3,000 exhibitors and around 170,000 trade visitors from 22 to 25 September
73 SAFETY & SECURITY
When newly finished concrete on a flagship London rail project began to deteriorate, the de-icer took the blame. EcoGrit MD Gareth Ellis turned detective and found the real culprit was walking in every day
76 TICKETING TECHNOLOGY
Peter Jarvis, CEO of Raspberry Software and specialist in rail revenue protection software, explains why the future of tackling ticketless travel successfully requires a data-led approach
78 SAFETY & SECURITY FOR PERIMETERS
It may be surprising that although technology is rapidly developing, the issues facing the rail network remain the same: trespass, vandalism and ever-decreasing budgets
54 STATION REFURBISHMENT
Why specifying technologies built to last is becoming the defining challenge for modern railway passenger information systems
INTERVIEW 57 Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Chris Kantaris, Managing
Director of Railway Assurance, about the company’s CPD accredited CSM and interoperability training course, the development of its ARMOR hazard management tool and why early engagement with system safety specialists remains critical to delivering safe railway projects
61
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Ronan Finnegan, cofounder of Spacebands, about building a wearable that monitors hand-arm vibration syndrome, noise and proximity hazards
64 SAFETY & SECURITY
As the railways in Great Britain undergo significant change, strong safety leadership has never been more important. Dr Stephen Fletcher, joint CEO at the Occupational Psychology Centre (OPC), explores eight characteristics of the most effective safety leaders and the role they play in shaping safety culture
SAFETY & SECURITY Proximity detection technology addresses the growing risk of high-voltage line contact, with PENTA Electrical Safety Products’ SKY RADIO 3 giving operators real-time warnings before a hazardous situation develops
81
HEALTH & SAFETY RJW Engineering has developed a fully non-conductive replacement for metal road pins, addressing a longstanding safety risk on the electrified rail network
82 IN CONVERSATION
With Emilia Ferenc, Managing Director, and Stuart McRobb, Operations Director, at Perfect Clean Ltd
BUSINESS PROFILES 87 Wernick Group Ltd (Hire Division) 88 DCA Design International 90 Totalkare 93 Ellis Patents Limited 94 PEOPLE Cathy Pianon, Jonathan Goring, Mandy Duncan, Jonathan Sharrock, Damien Chabas, Suzanne Grant, Tom Bousfield, Brenda Maguire, Simon Scott
For more information visit www.abasurveying.co.uk or call 01483 797111
7
NEWS
Raspberry Software Launches New TIPS Fraud Module Raspberry Software, a specialist in rail revenue protection software has announced the launch of a new TIPS Fraud Module, a dedicated case management solution designed to help train operating companies (TOCs) investigate and resolve fare fraud through a single, connected platform. Developed in collaboration with the wider rail industry, the TIPS Fraud Module addresses these challenges by providing a centralised digital solution for managing fraud investigations. With fare fraud estimated to cost the UK rail industry around £1 billion each year, the module helps TOCs bring investigation data together in one place, ensuring cases are managed consistently while reducing manual administration and improving visibility throughout the investigation process. Built as both a standalone software, and something that can be integrated with Raspberry’s existing TIPS platform, the Fraud Module provides a structured, auditable process for managing cases from initial investigation through to settlement or prosecution. It brings together evidence, correspondence, data and financial information in one place, helping teams work more efficiently while supporting stronger, court-ready case files where required. Peter Jarvis, CEO of Raspberry Software, says: ‘Rail fraud is rising almost daily and becoming increasingly complex. While
train operating companies are successfully investing in larger inhouse fraud teams to tackle the issue, investigations are often still managed using fragmented processes. The evolution of digital technology brings greater opportunities to identify and investigate fraud. Many offenders leave a digital footprint that can support investigations, when the right tools are in place. We have developed the TIPS Fraud Module to solve these very real challenges. Our aim is to help operators reduce revenue loss, improve consistency and give teams the tools they need to manage cases more efficiently and with greater confidence.’ The configurable module enables operators to tailor fraud categories, evidence requirements and correspondence to their own processes, while built-in automation helps improve data security and support GDPR compliance. The launch strengthens Raspberry Software’s TIPS platform, providing train operators with a practical solution to improve fraud management as the rail industry continues to evolve. The TIPS platform is Raspberry Software’s integrated rail revenue protection and case management system, helping train operating companies manage incidents, investigations and prosecutions through a single, secure platform.
AtkinsRéalis Appointed to Six Lots on TfL’s Professional Services Framework 3 AtkinsRéalis has been appointed to six of the seven lots on Transport for London’s (TfL) Professional Services Framework 3 (PSF3), making it one of the most broadly appointed suppliers on the framework. The three-year framework, with an option to extend for a further year, will support TfL in planning and delivering major investment and renewal programmes across London’s transport network, including trains, buses and road infrastructure. AtkinsRéalis will provide services across six lots: project, programme and portfolio management; programme office and project controls; planning and scheduling; procurement and commercial management; risk and opportunity management; and quantity surveying and estimating.
Scott Kelley, Managing Director of Complex Projects at AtkinsRéalis, said the framework would allow TfL to draw on the breadth of expertise the company brings to support delivery of its investment and renewal programme, and pointed to the company’s long-standing relationship with TfL built through years of collaboration. The appointment builds on a relationship with TfL stretching back more than 20 years. Under previous iterations of the framework, AtkinsRéalis provided estimating and commercial support for the £1.5 billion programme introducing the next generation of Piccadilly line trains, and commercial services for the programme replacing the Docklands Light Railway (DLR) fleet with 54 new trains.
The company also supported signalling upgrades across the Circle, District, Hammersmith & City and Metropolitan lines under the Four Lines Modernisation programme, and played a role in delivering the Elizabeth line, now operated by TfL. It is currently supporting the DLR extension to Beckton Riverside and Thamesmead, and in late 2025 a new entrance opened at Battersea Power Station Underground station, for which AtkinsRéalis delivered concept and detailed design. PSF3 replaces TfL’s previous professional services framework and is its primary route for accessing external project, programme and commercial expertise across the organisation.
New RSSB Sustainable Rail Apprentice Programme Launching This October A new rail-specific sustainability programme, delivered in partnership with RSSB, is due to launch this October. The Sustainable Rail Apprentice Programme is designed to build sustainability skills across the wider rail workforce and is open to employees in any role, not only those in dedicated sustainability 8
positions. The first cohort has already attracted strong interest, with candidates from organisations including Avanti West Coast, LNER, GTR, Hitachi and Amey. The programme is open to RSSB member organisations based in England and is fully funded by the growth and skills levy.
NEWS
First Look at Latest Thorpe Park Rail Station Plans for Shorter Journeys Across Leeds People can have their say on the latest plans for a new railway station that will create a link between east Leeds and the city centre. Thorpe Park Rail Station will be built next to Thorpe Park Business Park, between Cross Gates and Garforth, on the Leeds to York section of the TransPennine railway line, with journey times to Leeds Station of 10-12 minutes. The scheme will be delivered by Network Rail in partnership with the West Yorkshire Combined Authority, in consultation with Leeds City Council. The accessible station has been designed to provide faster journeys, easier access to offices, shops and restaurants at The Springs, and park and ride journeys for commuters. Thorpe Park will have two train platforms, enabling a minimum of two services per hour in each direction, to
Leeds and to York, and Leeds to Hull. Plans include a lift and footbridge for step-free access, ticket machines, cycle parking, and a 300-space car park including electric vehicle charging points, disabled bays, and a drop-off and pick-up point. There will be room to expand the car park if needed in future. The scheme forms part of the West Yorkshire Mayor’s Weaver Network, a transport system intended to connect trains, buses, a future mass transit system, walking, wheeling and cycling across the region. West Yorkshire Mayor Tracy Brabin said reliable transport was essential for people, communities and businesses to thrive, and that the new station would deliver faster commutes, boost the economy and reduce road congestion. The West Yorkshire Combined Authority has already delivered new stations at Low Moor, Kirkstall Forge
and Apperley Bridge, and has built or upgraded ten bus and rail stations, investing £111 million in the region. Jason Hamilton, Route Director for Network Rail N&E, and Councillor Peter Carlill, Executive Member for Transport and Planning at Leeds City Council, both welcomed the plans as a boost for east Leeds connectivity. John Handley, Managing Director for Redrow Yorkshire, and Adam Varley, Development Director for Scarborough Group International, also expressed support, noting the station’s potential to support housing development and business growth in the area. The full business case will be submitted later this year, with construction set to start in 2027. The consultation is open until the end of Tuesday 15 September.
Elevated thinking, underground
For more than 25 years, Gall Zeidler Consultants has delivered world-class tunnel consultancy and design services. Our specialists apply state-of-the-art construction and rehabilitation methods, combining proven technologies with innovative solutions to create exceptional results for our clients. With more than 580 kilometres of tunnels completed across the globe, we are trusted leaders in our field. We see challenges not as risks, but as opportunities — to innovate, to excel, and to redefine what’s possible underground.
London . Washington DC . New York . San Francisco . Toronto Salzburg . Santiago de Chile . New Delhi . Singapore . Adelaide
www.gzconsultants.com 9
J O I N U S AT I N N O T R A N S 2 0 2 6 Berlin • 22 - 25 September 2026 Discover our latest Li - ion battery solutions for rail , designed to deliver superior reliability , efficiency , and performance for rolling stock and rail infrastructure .
10
Meet our experts and explore how next - generation energy solutions are powering safer , more sustainable rail networks . Hall 15.1 | Booth 290
INTERVIEW
Alice Barrett Partnerships and Standards Manager at AssessTech Ltd.
AssessTech is a railway safety partner specialising in Developmental Competence Management, combining training, technology (ACMS and AssessBook) and consultancy to help rail operators manage workforce competence with confidence.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Alice Barrett, Partnerships and Standards Manager at AssessTech, about why effective competence management is about far more than compliance 11
INTERVIEW
‘A standard is only useful if it is understood and applied consistently’
SSH: How did you get started in the industry? When did you join the company? AB: I joined AssessTech six years ago straight out of university, with no previous rail experience. Coming into a traditionally maledominated sector has not always been easy, but it has become a strong motivator. My background in psychology has also given me a different perspective, helping me understand people and the behaviours behind competence and compliance beyond the technical requirements. SSH: What is your role within AssessTech? AB: My role as Partnerships & Standards Manager is to strengthen collaboration with our partners and ensure our products and services continue to align with the standards that rail operators need to meet. Strong partnerships are built on shared commitment, accountability and a collective responsibility for railway safety. I monitor changes to industry standards and work across the business to identify where we can refine and improve what we offer, helping our partners apply those requirements effectively in practice. SSH: When you describe AssessTech as a railway safety partner, what does that actually mean in practice? AB: For me, being a railway safety partner means recognising that effective competence management is bigger than any single system, training course or assessment. It is about how technology, standards, people, operational processes, training and assurance work together. Our role is to work alongside operators across their competence management framework, helping them translate safety requirements into practical ways of working that support day-to-day railway operations. SSH: What is the relationship between effective competence management and railway safety? AB: Effective competence management supports railway safety by giving operators confidence that people performing safetycritical work have the skills, knowledge, and fitness to carry out their duties safely. When it is treated mainly as a compliance 12
exercise, the focus can become proving that assessments have been completed rather than understanding what they are telling you. A more proactive approach gives operators greater visibility into workforce capabilities, behaviours, development needs, and emerging risks, helping them act earlier and manage safety more effectively. SSH: How does working in partnership with operators help improve safety outcomes in a way that a traditional supplier relationship cannot? AB: Working in partnership helps operators improve safety outcomes by making sure competence management reflects the real operational risks they are trying to manage. Our starting point is understanding the challenge, the people and processes involved, and how that risk presents itself in practice. From there, partnership brings together shared commitment, responsibility and accountability, combining the operator’s operational insight with our expertise in competence management, standards, technology, training and assurance. That collaboration not only helps strengthen individual approaches, but also contributes to wider learning, continuous improvement, and greater consistency across the industry. SSH: Why are consistency and standardisation important from a railway safety perspective? AB: In a safety-critical environment, having a standard is only useful if it is understood and applied consistently. If different assessors interpret the same competence requirement differently, or different parts of an organisation operate different processes, it becomes harder to have confidence in the overall picture of competence. The same principle extends across competence processes. Consistent criteria, workflows and evidence create a more dependable picture of workforce competence, and therefore a stronger foundation for managing safety risk. SSH: What role do standards play in turning safety requirements into something that works operationally? AB: Standards support better safety outcomes by creating a clear and consistent basis for how competence should be managed, assessed and evidenced. Our role is to understand what those standards mean in practice and help operators translate them into competence frameworks, processes, training and assurance that reflect the realities of railway operations. By working with partners to embed those requirements consistently, we can help strengthen the management of competence, reduce variation in interpretation, and support greater confidence that safetycritical expectations are being applied effectively.
SSH: How can competence data help operators identify safety risk before it becomes an incident? AB: Competence data can support better safety outcomes by giving operators greater visibility into where strengths, development needs, and potential areas of risk lie across the workforce. Rather than looking at assessments in isolation, organisations can use evidence of grading, development plans, incident history and gap analysis to identify patterns. That evidence helps managers target development and assurance more effectively, supporting a more proactive approach to managing competence and safety risk. SSH: Can you give an example where AssessTech’s partnership with an operator has directly strengthened its approach to a specific safety risk? AB: One partner wanted to better prepare frontline colleagues for situations involving stranded passengers and the use of evacuation bridges. We worked with them to understand the operational risk, review the relevant standards and identify what staff needed to know and be able to do in practice. That collaboration led to a bespoke training course and supporting refresher material developed in a live railway environment with operator representatives and a Network Rail Mobile Operations Manager. By grounding the intervention in the real operational scenario, the partnership helped strengthen preparedness for a safety-critical situation where confident, competent decisionmaking is essential. SSH: Looking across AssessTech’s Technology, Training and Consulting offering, how do those three areas work together to create better safety outcomes? AB: Developmental Competence Management (DCM) is the concept that underpins all our services. Rather than relying on simple tick-box compliance, DCM shifts ownership to the individual, building personalised, continuous development journeys that focus on individuals’ growth areas. Our training ensures individuals have the knowledge, skills and behaviours to safely carry out their duties. Our technologies (ACMS & AssessBook) provide tools for digitally recording and managing development journeys, while our consultancy work gives the assurance that standards and competence processes are being applied effectively. Bringing those three areas together creates a continuous cycle of evidence, development and improvement, helping operators manage competence more consistently and with greater confidence.
Improve performance
reduce incidents
Competence management goes beyond meeting standards. It improves operational safety by giving your people the tools, visibility and support they need to perform safely and effectively every day.
Manage all elements of safety critical competence and fitness Accredited and nonaccredited expert-led training
Digital solutions that connect learning and competence, giving railway organisations clear visibility of workforce competence and the support to strengthen safe, effective performance
Our training solutions focus on: • Skills development to close competency gaps • Engaging, interactive learning experiences for better retention • Certification & assessment support to maintain compliance • Upskilling railway professionals for career progression
Encompasses all elements of workforce competence, essential to safe operations.
A flexible, scalable learning platform designed for railway training and compliance.
Our solutions help organisations to: • Identify risks before they become issues • Track and manage compliance • Optimise workforce training based on data insights • Improve decision-making with analytics
Practical consultancy to strengthen competence frameworks and improve assurance Our consultancy services provide: • Personalised competence management strategies • Risk assessments to prevent safety incidents • Compliance support to navigate evolving regulations • Change management solutions for digital transformation
Your partner in rail safety and competence Get in touch
13
VIEWPOINT
LAYING DOWN THE LAW by Martin Fleetwood
Managing the New Trade Union Right of Access to the Workplace
Martin Fleetwood is a Consultant at Addleshaw Goddard’s Transport practice. The Rail Team has over 30 lawyers who advise clients in both the private and public sectors across a wide range of legal areas. As well as contractual issues, the team advises on operational matters, franchises, concessions, finance, regulatory, property, employment, environmental and procurement issues.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before acting on any of the information given.
During its 200-year history, the rail sector’s workforce has had significant union representation
T
he fragmentation of the rail sector following privatisation reduced the involvement of unions and, in some companies, this involvement became non-existent. However, the trade union reforms of the Starmer Government introduced through the Employment Rights Act 2025 provide a new trade union right to access the workplace, which comes into force in October 2026 and will impact on many employers in the transport sector. The new right of access allows trade unions to apply for access to the workplace to meet, support, represent, recruit and organise workers. Given its unionised history, it is expected that trade unions will be targeting employers in the rail sector to increase their memberships. Access rights can be claimed against employers both where union recognition agreements do not currently include rights of access to the workplace and where trade unions are seeking access to non-unionised workforces with a view to achieving recognition. Employers will have limited time to respond to requests and little scope to refuse access outright.
Getting to grips with the new rights
The right of access applies to all employers with 21 or more employees and is expected to take effect from 30 October 2026. It gives trade unions a statutory right of access to the workplace to communicate with workers in person as well as digitally via an IT platform (such as an employer’s intranet) to meet, support, represent, recruit and 14
organise workers (whether or not they are members of a trade union) and to facilitate collective bargaining. The Government’s recently updated statutory ‘Code of Practice: Right of trade unions to access workplaces’ (the Code) sets out practical guidance on how the statutory right of access should operate in practice. While the Code itself will not impose legal obligations on an employer’s failure to follow its guidance, such failure may be taken into account in any relevant proceedings by a court or tribunal or the Central Arbitration Committee (the CAC) regarding a trade union’s access to workers. The CAC is an independent, nondepartmental public body that resolves collective employment disputes between employers and trade unions. The Code establishes that there are now three general types of access that a trade union may have in a workplace: 1. Voluntary arrangements agreed between a trade union and an employer without the involvement of the statutory process. 2. Access arrangements agreed through negotiation between the trade union and the employer through the statutory process and notification to the CAC. 3. Access arrangements initiated through the statutory process and determined by the CAC following an unsuccessful negotiation between the trade union and the employer. Only access arrangements in scenarios 2 and 3 above will be regarded as statutory access agreements.
How will obtaining access to employees work in practice?
The Code recommends that both trade unions and employers should maintain records of access requests and responses that can be used to demonstrate when they were made and received. This is in part because there are time limits set out in the Code. The timetable for access requests is as follows: • Trade union access request – the request is submitted to an employer, including as much information as possible to help with subsequent negotiations. Trade unions are encouraged to use the Code’s standardised template request form but it is not compulsory. • Employer’s response – required within 15 working days from the day an access application is given to the employer – not when first seen by the relevant team within the employer. Employers are encouraged to use the Code’s response template. The response period can be extended by agreement between the parties. • Both parties to negotiate – a negotiation period of 25 working days for the parties to agree the terms of an access agreement follows the day on which the response notice is given. Parties should approach negotiations in good faith. Negotiations can continue beyond the 25-day period where positive. • Agreement to access – if the employer agrees to the terms of the request, they
VIEWPOINT
notify acceptance to the trade union, and both parties should notify the CAC to record the agreement. • Parties unable to agree access – if the parties cannot agree on the form of access agreement by 55 working days after the original access request was made either may apply to the CAC for a decision on the form of access agreement. In certain circumstances the CAC can extend the negotiating period to 70 days. • CAC refusal to grant access – the Code sets out circumstances where the CAC can refuse access requests, including where: (i) the employer already recognises an independent trade union for that specific group of workers; (ii) there is an ongoing statutory recognition process at the workplace covering those workers; or (iii) an employer has received at least one other access request that is still live. There are certain limitations to statutory access requests. They must provide the employer with at least five working days’ notice before the first access takes place, no access agreement will last longer than two years and access will be refused if it would prejudice national security or the investigation or detection of offences.
How will access rights be enforced?
If there is a breach of an access agreement or a third party has taken steps to prevent access, the Code allows trade unions and employers to make complaints to the CAC. Third party issues may occur where an employer requires the cooperation of a third party e.g. a security company employs security staff for a workplace managed by a different employer, but the security company is expected to facilitate access to its workers. Enforcement follows a two-step process: (i) an initial complaint where a breach is proven and (ii) further proven breaches which incur penalty fines and possible cumulative fines. The penalties for breaching an access agreement are significant, ranging from up to £75,000 for a first penalty to up to £500,000 for a third and subsequent breaches. It is anticipated that this process will be reviewed in the spring of 2027 looking at (i) the effectiveness of the enforcement regime; (ii) whether the levels of fines are proportionate and sufficient to encourage compliance; and (iii) the scope of access to workplaces, including the 21-worker threshold.
What should employers do to prepare?
Unions may focus on employers already recognising trade unions to increase their membership or target those employers who do not currently recognise unions with a view to achieving recognition. With limited response times and little scope to refuse access requests, employers should be considering how they would manage such access requests.
In particular, employers can review existing employee engagement strategies – a well-integrated approach to employee engagement may reduce the impact of the trade union right to access to the workplace, as employees feel listened to without union representation. Employers can also plan what access could look like – give some thought to what level of access could be granted for each employee group and the parameters for access. Consider: • Frequency of access – the Code suggests that weekly access would be a reasonable frequency level. Employers should assess whether such frequency would be feasible. • Working patterns – consider how a trade union would communicate with employees on non-typical working patterns. The level of access should be broadly equivalent to those with normal shift patterns. • Existing visitor arrangements – trade unions will need to comply with existing arrangements, including any health and safety and security arrangements. • Privacy – employers are required to respect the privacy of access meetings. This may mean informing trade unions of any recording equipment in a physical space (e.g. CCTV) and potentially switching off such equipment for union meetings. • Digital access – consider practically how digital access to the workforce would be permitted. • Locations for access – the Code suggests that trade unions can submit a single request covering multiple workplaces. • Third-party premises – the Code suggests that where employees are working at locations owned and managed by thirdparties, employers will be expected to take reasonable steps to facilitate access, including liaising with such third parties. • Map current physical and digital locations – have an accurate understanding of where trade unions may seek access and assess what level of access may be feasible. Employers should also define who in the business will be responsible for each stage of the process. They should understand their specific roles and relevant timelines to act within.
Managing the changing landscape
The implementation of the Code represents a step change in the industrial relations landscape. Trade unions are likely to be identifying potential employers and considering where access to employees can be most beneficial for the union and the workforce. Employers should be considering their employee engagement arrangements and thinking about how they might want to respond to any access requests arriving from October 2026 onwards.
NE WS IN BRIE F OKEHAMPTON INTERCHANGE STATION OFFICIALLY OPENS Okehampton Interchange station officially opened on 31 July, ahead of passenger services starting on 1 August. Senior representatives from Network Rail, Great Western Railway (GWR), Devon County Council and West Devon Borough Council attended the opening. The station is the newest addition to the Dartmoor Line, providing improved access to rail services connecting communities in West Devon, Torridge and North Cornwall with Exeter and the wider rail network. It complements the existing Okehampton station and builds on the reopening of the Dartmoor Line in 2021, which saw daily passenger services return more than 50 years after regular services were withdrawn; passenger demand exceeded projections, with over half a million journeys recorded in the first two years. The new station features a 200-space car park, sheltered cycle storage and a covered bus interchange, with electric vehicle charging points to follow, and step-free access throughout via ramps, lifts and a footbridge. It is an £18 million investment, made possible through £13.5 million of UK Government funding following a successful bid by West Devon Borough Council, with support from Devon County Council. Network Rail oversaw delivery through contractor Octavius, while Devon County Council led walking, cycling and bus facilities on Hameldown Road, constructed by Kennford Tarmacadam, with environmental work through consultants WSP. Research cited in the release suggests railway stations across the South West could support up to 238,000 jobs and contribute £14.25 billion to the economy by 2035, with Okehampton Interchange and Marsh Barton station, which opened in 2023, together projected to generate around 1,500 permanent jobs and approximately £112 million annually for the local economy over the next decade. Rail Minister Lord Peter Hendy said the station would make it easier for people to get to work, education and leisure while supporting jobs, homes and economic growth in west Devon. Joanna Grew, Network Rail and GWR Route Strategy Director, said the Dartmoor Line had already made a real difference since services returned in 2021, and that the new station marked another step in improving accessibility across the region.
15
INTERVIEW
Cory Smith
Cory Smith is a young, dedicated and results-oriented project and sales manager, who has gained a lot of experience throughout his career so far.
Project and Sales Manager at ROMIC Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Cory Smith about sourcing and exporting locomotives and rolling stock to operators around the world, the engineering and logistics work involved in getting a fleet export-ready, and what long-term support looks like once equipment enters service with a new operator SSH: How did you come to work in the rail industry, and what does your role as Project and Sales Manager at ROMIC involve day to day? CS: I came into the rail industry through an interest in engineering and international business. Rail is a unique industry because it combines engineering with long-term customer relationships and projects that have a real impact on transport networks around the world. As Project and Sales Manager at ROMIC, I work with railway operators, contractors and industrial customers across the globe, helping them source locomotives and rolling stock that meet their operational requirements. My role covers everything from identifying opportunities and developing technical proposals to coordinating logistics and overseeing projects through to delivery. 16
A large part of my work involves exporting locomotives internationally, so no two projects are ever the same. Every country has different operational needs, regulations and commercial requirements, which makes the role both challenging and rewarding. I particularly enjoy working with customers from different parts of the world and helping deliver solutions that support their railway operations. SSH: You have mentioned that you have been close to the rail sector for most of your life. Has that background shaped how you approach your work, and what keeps you motivated in what can be a complex industry to operate in? CS: Yes, definitely. ROMIC is a familyrun business, so I’ve been around the international rail industry for most of my life. Seeing first-hand what it takes to
deliver successful projects and international exports has given me a real appreciation for the importance of reliability, attention to detail and building strong relationships with customers. What keeps me motivated is the variety. Every project is different, whether it’s a new market, a unique customer requirement or a complex export. It’s rewarding to see a project through from the initial enquiry to a locomotive arriving with its new operator, knowing you’ve helped make that happen. SSH: Can you give us a sense of the scale of the project you have recently completed? CS: This has been a particularly special project for us, not only because of the scale of the export, but because of its wider significance. The locomotives are heading to Ghana, where this is the first time since 1962 that the country has invested in new
INTERVIEW
rolling stock, and the first time standard gauge locomotives will operate within its rail network. Projects like this are about much more than supplying locomotives, they are about supporting future growth and creating opportunities. With Ghana focused on building a stronger economy that creates jobs, encourages investment and supports long-term growth, we believe this is the beginning of something very exciting. We are proud to have played our part in supporting that progress through the rail industry. SSH: How did this particular deal come about, and how long did it take from initial enquiry to the point where the locomotives were ready to ship? CS: The project began when ROMIC was approached by the Ghana Railway Development Authority in February, with an initial Teams call to their CEO and his team, who set out their goals and what locomotives and wagons they thought they needed. They had a clear vision of what they required and, importantly, a very tight timeframe to work within. From the initial enquiry through to export, the entire process was completed in approximately four and a half months. Considering the scope of work involved, sourcing the locomotives and wagons, completing refurbishment, carrying out maintenance requirements and managing the export process, it was a fantastic turnaround. This was a true team effort, requiring close coordination between our suppliers, maintenance partners and the customer to ensure everything was delivered safely and on schedule. Sourcing the wagons was a particular challenge for me personally, since that side of the business was new territory, it’s always mainly been locomotives. I was thrown in at the deep end, so I spoke to a few industry contacts who pointed me in the right direction, which ultimately came down to Freightliner. We’ve got good contacts there, and the contractors who helped get the wagons ready really helped me understand what we should and shouldn’t be looking for. We did have the option of sourcing wagons from Europe, but I wanted UK stock so it would be compatible with the UK rolling stock without any modification.
where required. The driver cabs were fully refurbished to the customer’s requested standards, and we worked closely with the client to develop their new locomotive livery. The container wagons were also repainted and fitted with new decals featuring the customer’s freight branding. We also adapted a number of details specifically for Ghana. The speedometers were changed to kilometres per hour, and the data plates on the side of each locomotive, which show details like weight and maximum speed, were updated to match the units used in-country. Whatever work the customer wanted, whether cab modifications, painting, or converting the speedos and data plates, we made sure it was done ahead of export. They inspected the locomotives a week or two before departure and signed everything off, so we knew they’d be happy on arrival. Managing the process was challenging, particularly given the tight timeframe, but through strong teamwork and close coordination with our suppliers, contractors and the customer, we were able to keep the project on schedule. SSH: What does the logistics chain look like in practice, from moving the locomotives to port through to loading and securing them aboard the vessel? CS: The logistics process is a major part of any locomotive export and requires detailed planning well in advance. We typically identify and plan the export location months ahead, allowing us to coordinate the operational requirements, transport arrangements and port activities so we are as prepared as possible when the day of export arrives. For this particular project, we utilised Solent Gateway at Marchwood, which has direct rail access. This was a significant advantage as it removed the need for additional road transport movements and avoided unnecessary double handling of the locomotives and wagons. The final stage of the process involves working closely with specialist heavy-lift shipping partners who have the experience and equipment required to safely load and secure rail assets for international transport. Their support, along with the coordination between all parties involved, is critical to ensuring a successful export operation.
SSH: What engineering or modification work was required before the locomotives were ready for export, and how do you manage that process?
SSH: What are the most technically demanding parts of that process, and where do things most commonly go wrong?
CS: The preparation process involved a comprehensive programme of inspections, maintenance and refurbishment to ensure the locomotives and wagons were ready for their new operating environment. Both locomotives underwent B examinations, wheel turning and load testing, along with bodywork repairs
CS: The most technically demanding part of an export project is ensuring every stage is carefully planned and coordinated, as there are many moving parts involved. Unlike a standard freight movement, locomotives require specialist handling, detailed engineering checks and close coordination between multiple parties.
The biggest challenges usually come from timing and communication. With projects involving refurbishment, maintenance, transport, port operations and shipping schedules, even a small delay in one area can have a knock-on effect across the entire project. This is why early planning, strong relationships with suppliers and regular communication with all stakeholders are so important. SSH: Once the locomotives arrive incountry, what does the handover and commissioning process involve, and does that extend to driver and workshop training for the new operator? CS: The handover and commissioning process is something we agree with the customer at an early stage of the project, so everyone has a clear understanding of what will happen once the locomotives and wagons arrive and the transition into service is as smooth as possible. Following arrival, there are a number of initial checks and preparations required, including assessing whether the locomotive batteries need charging depending on the length of the sea voyage, and refuelling the locomotives, as all fuel is removed prior to shipping. Our engineers then carry out a detailed inspection over two to three days, completing checks in line with our internal standards to confirm the locomotives are ready for testing, followed by multiple test runs to verify performance. We also provide driver and workshop training as part of our support to the new operator, tailored to the existing experience and capability of their teams. In Ghana’s case, the client’s team spoke excellent English, so there were no language gaps, and a number of them had experience from the country’s existing metre gauge line, though not as much as we’d typically look for. We built a team around them with people from ROMIC who could teach and support them, keeping the training basic without overloading them, while giving them plenty to learn. That included accepting wagons into the railhead, checking for leaks and that the brakes work, and running fitness to run checks before departure, so they know each time they let stock leave the head that it’s fit to make the return journey too. SSH: What does the ongoing support and parts supply arrangement look like after delivery, and how long does ROMIC typically remain actively involved? CS: Our involvement does not end once the locomotives arrive and enter service. We see the long-term support of our customers as a key part of the relationship, and we work with each operator to understand their ongoing operational and maintenance requirements. This can include parts supply, technical support, troubleshooting assistance and guidance throughout the life of the asset. 17
INTERVIEW
The length of our involvement depends on the customer and project requirements, but our aim is always to build long-term partnerships rather than simply complete a one-off transaction. On this project, the customer has asked us to provide a technical and operational support package for the next four to five years, which is currently going through sign-off with our directors. I think it speaks volumes that they’ve asked us to continue working with them rather than going elsewhere. We’ve been operating for around 40 years, and building relationships like this is a big part of that.
and the operator’s objectives. From there, we can identify potential opportunities, whether that involves a direct sale, refurbishment or preparing the equipment for a new operating environment. Our global network and knowledge of different markets allows us to match the right assets with the right customers. For any operator holding surplus rolling stock, the first step is simply to start a conversation. Many companies are unsure where to begin, but early engagement allows us to understand the available assets and explore the best options.
SSH: ROMIC describes itself as having buyers waiting with specific requirements. How does the fleet disposals side of the business work in practice, and what would you say to an operator sitting on surplus rolling stock that is unsure where to start?
SSH: Gauge, power systems and homologation requirements vary considerably between countries. How early in the sales process do those in-country technical requirements start to shape what you are looking for, and how do you manage the engineering work required to bring a locomotive up to specification?
CS: The fleet disposal side of the business is built around understanding both sides of the market. We work with operators who have surplus rolling stock and connect them with customers who are actively looking for specific locomotive and wagon requirements. The process starts with understanding the asset, its condition, history, specification
CS: In-country requirements are considered from the very beginning of any project. Before we start looking for suitable rolling stock, we work closely with the customer to fully understand their operational requirements, including gauge, power systems, axle load limitations, loading gauge
restrictions, regulatory requirements and any local standards that need to be met. This information is critical because it allows us to identify the right assets from the outset and avoid challenges later in the process. Once a suitable locomotive is identified, we manage the required engineering work through a combination of internal knowledge, trusted suppliers and specialist contractors to ensure the locomotive is modified, refurbished and prepared to meet the customer’s requirements. SSH: ROMIC has been building a charter and hire fleet alongside the export business. Is that a deliberate strategic diversification, or did it develop more organically? CS: Our charter and hire fleet developed organically. It gave us the opportunity to make productive use of stock that hadn’t yet been exported, while also demonstrating our ability to diversify the business and successfully operate within the UK market. At the same time, it has helped keep the much-loved HST in service on the UK railway, something that has been widely welcomed and appreciated by operators, enthusiasts and the wider rail industry.
““
WORLDWIDE SALES OF USED & OVERHAULED LOCOMOTIVES & ROLLING STOCK ”Yard to port to final destination, and everything in between” www.romicgroup.com sales@romic.co.uk
18
STATION REFURBISHMENT
Meeting and Events Centre at Perth Station Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Graham Kelly, Managing Director at Caledonian Sleeper, about the operator’s new Meeting & Events Centre at Perth station, early demand from businesses and community groups, and where the venue sits within the company’s wider growth plans
C
aledonian Sleeper has opened a new Meeting & Events Centre at Perth railway station, converting part of the historic building into a multipurpose venue for business and community use. The centre offers four adaptable spaces: an auditorium for up to 80 people, a dedicated training room, hot desks for individual working, and breakout areas with a lounge. All rooms have audiovisual technology, interactive displays and complimentary Wi-Fi, with on-site staff support. Tea, coffee and water are provided in all rooms, and larger scale catering can be arranged through local Perth suppliers. The spaces are available to hire by businesses for board meetings, training and workshops, and by community groups for clubs, classes and support groups. SSH: What has the early response been like from businesses and community groups since the centre opened? GK: We’ve just announced the opening of the Meeting & Events Centre and are now beginning to actively market the space to businesses, organisations and community
groups. We’re looking forward to seeing how the venue is received and hearing from people across Perth and beyond about how they could make use of the space. SSH: Are there plans to add similar Meeting & Events Centres at other stations beyond Perth? GK: At this stage, our focus is very much on understanding the level of demand for the Perth facility. We don’t have any immediate plans to open additional centres elsewhere. SSH: How does the Perth venue fit into Caledonian Sleeper’s wider growth plans, particularly following the new Birmingham International services? GK: We’re always looking for creative opportunities to develop the business and generate additional revenue, just as we did by introducing Birmingham International as a new calling point. The Meeting & Events Centre in Perth is a good example of that approach – we have an existing space within the station that can be put to productive use, alongside a Caledonian Sleeper service that already calls at Perth.
As a business, we’re constantly looking at how we can make the most of the assets and opportunities we have available to us, while continuing to look for new ways to grow and strengthen the business. SSH: Is there a typical customer profile you’re expecting, more corporate bookings or community use, and how are the four spaces likely to be split between the two? GK: The space is accessible to everyone, and we’re deliberately looking to offer something that can meet a range of needs, including somewhere to co-work or for hot desk space rental. We expect to welcome corporate clients using the rooms for meetings, training sessions and other business events, alongside local businesses, organisations and community groups looking for somewhere to meet, learn and connect. The four spaces give us the flexibility to accommodate different types and sizes of events, so we’re not looking to restrict the venue to one particular customer or use. We’re excited to see the variety of bookings that come through the door.
19
INTERVIEW
Elena Romanova Global Market Manager for Rail and Land Transport Elena Romanova oversees global strategy, technology development and market planning for the sector. She has also served for six years on Scott Bader’s Global Members’ Board, representing colleagues across France, Italy, Spain and Germany.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Elena Romanova, Global Market Manager for Rail and Land Transport at Scott Bader, about the shift from hand lamination to closed-mould composite processes, the growing role of bio-based fire resistant resins and why UK rail’s conservatism sets it apart from a fast-moving European market SSH: Tell us about your career journey and how you came to your current role at Scott Bader? ER: My journey into the composites industry began in 2001 as Sales Director for Scott Bader’s exclusive distributor in Russia. After ten successful years developing the business, I was offered the opportunity to join Scott Bader directly, which led me to relocate from Russia to France. During my first decade in the industry, I was involved in expanding sales across a wide range of composite markets. I worked closely with Scott Bader’s management and technical teams to develop business opportunities in the railway and commercial vehicle sector, particularly with fire-resistant composite solutions, as well as in building and construction, automotive, swimming pools, pipe relining and several other industries. From the very beginning, I was impressed by the professionalism, expertise and supportiveness of the Scott Bader team. What also stood out was the company’s employee-owned structure and strong values, which are genuinely reflected in the way the business operates. This creates a positive and collaborative culture that continues to make a real difference, both for employees and customers. 20
When I moved to France to join Scott Bader directly, I already spoke English and German, but I had to learn French from scratch. Immersing myself in a new language and culture was both a challenge and a rewarding experience, and within around six months I was able to work confidently in French. I joined the company as Regional Sales Manager for the CIS countries, with responsibility for managing key direct accounts while continuing to develop and strengthen our distribution network across the region. The role gave me the opportunity to build on the relationships and market knowledge I had developed over the previous decade, while becoming fully integrated into Scott Bader’s international team. One of the most significant challenges throughout my career has been keeping pace with the rapid development of the composites industry. In the early 2000s, composites were being adopted at speed across a wide range of sectors, creating constant opportunities to learn and adapt. My responsibilities expanded considerably over the years, requiring me to develop both commercial and technical expertise. Much of my knowledge of composites and structural adhesives was gained through hands-on involvement in launching new production lines and
supporting newly established manufacturing facilities. This involved sharing technical know-how, helping customers implement new technologies and working closely with engineering and production teams to ensure successful project delivery. As for leadership, my experience has perhaps been different from what some might expect. In Eastern European markets, women in management positions within the composites industry have long been a familiar and accepted part of the business environment. Throughout my career, I have been fortunate to be judged on my expertise, results and ability to build strong relationships with customers and colleagues. Looking back, these experiences helped me develop a broad understanding of both the technical and commercial aspects of the industry, which continues to be invaluable in my role today. SSH: What was the biggest difference between your current role and what you were doing before, when you first made the switch three years ago? ER: Three years ago, I moved into the role of Global Market Manager for Rail and Land Transport, a position that I find both challenging and rewarding. Strictly speaking, the role is not rail-focused alone, as I am
INTERVIEW
responsible for the global land transport industry as a whole, with rail as a high-focus segment because it is the sector driving the fire, smoke and toxicity requirements that shape much of the wider business. In my previous role I was responsible for sales across a specific region. Moving into the market manager role gave me a broader scope, exposing me to multiple cultures and a genuinely global footprint, working with teams across the business worldwide. It gave me a more strategic perspective, covering not just the market view but the wider strategy, market assessment and planning, and the technology and resource decisions needed to meet the industry’s requirements over the next five to ten years. What I enjoy most is the opportunity to work closely with commercial, R&D, technical and business development teams across the world, while also helping to shape the future direction of our rail business. Over the last 12 months, one of the key successes has been advancing the development and accreditation of nextgeneration composite and adhesive solutions for the rail industry. These innovations help designers and manufacturers meet increasingly demanding requirements by delivering lightweight structures, reducing CO2 emissions, providing high structural performance and meeting the most stringent fire safety standards. The rail sector continues to evolve globally, and while different standards exist across various regions, EN 45545-2 has become the benchmark that drives much of the industry and is increasingly adopted by major rail OEMs worldwide. Supporting customers in achieving compliance while also delivering performance and sustainability benefits has been a particularly rewarding aspect of my role. For me, success is measured by more than sales figures alone. It is reflected in the successful introduction of new technologies, the approval and adoption of innovative materials by customers, the strength of long-term partnerships and ultimately the positive impact our solutions have on making rail transport safer, more sustainable and more efficient. SSH: How much potential do you think rail has to take advantage of the benefits of lightweight composite solutions? ER: That is already the case in the industry. There are several trends shaping where the rail industry is going, particularly in Europe with high-speed and very highspeed trains. The main trend is a change in process, moving from hand lamination into closed-mould processes, including resin transfer moulding, pultrusion and infusion. This shift is not only about a better surface finish or a lighter part through reduced thickness, but also about the CO2 savings this brings. Lightweight structures also allow more passengers on board, alongside better maintenance and a longer life cycle.
There are multiple advantages to structural lightweight composites: higher mechanical performance, better and faster parts, lower CO2 emissions and higher passenger capacity. The volume of contracts being signed across Europe, particularly by Alstom but also by SNCF, Trenitalia and others, has been considerable, and the market is set to expand and grow rapidly over the next ten years. Train manufacturers are actively seeking new partners with hightech pultrusion and infusion capability, not only for interiors and exteriors but for more complex shapes such as front ends produced through vacuum infusion. The scale of government investment in rail infrastructure is considerable and will expand the number of qualified partners across Europe over the next five to ten years. SSH: When did this trend start, do you think? ER: A significant number of recent contracts have been signed from around the fourth quarter of 2025. The industry was already operating at a high scale in Europe, but there is a lot of old infrastructure that needs to be renewed, alongside a need to move people more quickly between countries, so highspeed infrastructure is expanding rapidly. Even the Eurostar fleet, for example, is not new and has already been signed off for replacement within the next couple of years. Alongside this market growth there has also been a change in processing and a high focus on sustainability, with direct discussions taking place between Scott Bader and OEMs on the technology needed to support their own sustainability goals. SSH: In the UK, the rail industry is seen as quite conservative, with everyone sticking in their own silos. Is this an example of Europe being more forward-thinking? ER: The UK rail industry has traditionally had a more established and conservative approach, with a strong focus on proven technologies and processes. At the same time, it has a very strong community of engineers and fire safety specialists. Scott Bader meets many of these experts each year at the Fire Protection Conference, which takes place in different locations across Europe. The UK is also a somewhat different market compared with mainland Europe, particularly given the age and scale of its rail infrastructure. One of the major programmes that has been under discussion for many years, and is now moving forward again, is the HS2-Hitachi programme, involving Alstom and Hitachi. In many respects, the UK is an exception within the wider European rail landscape. The majority of the key OEMs designing and manufacturing trains are headquartered in Europe, alongside global players such as Hitachi and CRRC. These companies serve
not only the European market but customers around the world, which gives Europe a particularly strong influence on global rail design, engineering and manufacturing standards. A good example is the European standard EN 45545-2, covering fire, smoke and toxicity requirements, which is now widely referenced internationally. Scott Bader works with partners across Asia-Pacific, the Middle East, Australia, America, and India who manufacture components to these requirements. We are also seeing an interesting shift in manufacturing, with some projects and capabilities that were traditionally more concentrated in Asia increasingly being developed in Europe. This is being driven by the rapid growth of the rail market, evolving performance and quality requirements, and the move towards more advanced manufacturing techniques such as vacuum infusion. This is an area where European companies have developed significant expertise and are well positioned to support the next generation of rail projects globally. SSH: What do you think needs to happen for the UK to adopt this mentality? ER: I think this is ultimately more a question of investment and long-term strategy than of mentality. What we are seeing across Europe is a move towards higher-end, more technology-driven specifications in the rail industry, with innovations and trends from the wider composites sector being increasingly adopted in rail applications. The UK market has some areas where there is still an opportunity to accelerate this transition. At the same time, train manufacturers are continuing to expand their use of composites, including replacing traditional materials such as metal with composite solutions, and moving from conventional plywood flooring towards new lightweight structural flooring systems using bio-sourced resins, PET and recyclable foams. These developments demonstrate the potential for the UK market to benefit from the same innovations already gaining momentum across the wider European rail industry. SSH: You also mentioned bio resin and the sugarcane source in your JEC presentation. Could you explain that in simple terms? ER: Sustainability is becoming increasingly important across every industry, and composites are no exception. At Scott Bader, the launch of the Crestafire Bio portfolio represents a significant step forward. These next-generation fire-resistant resins, meeting EN 45545-2 HL3 and designed for closed-mould manufacturing processes, contain up to 100 per cent bio-based resin content and demonstrate how innovation 21
INTERVIEW
can support both performance and environmental responsibility. The bio-content is derived from bioethanol taken from the sugarcane extraction process, effectively a waste product that would otherwise be burned, so no additional crops or CO2 emissions are involved. This type of resin supports the highest specification, HL3, which applies mainly to metro systems and trains running through long tunnels. HL3 requirements currently account for around 10 per cent of the European market, with India, as the world’s most populous country, a particularly significant market given its extensive metro programmes. I expect HL3 requirements in Europe to grow substantially, reaching at least 50 per cent within the next five years. SSH: How does Crestafire Bio compare with the phenolic resin systems still widely used in the UK? ER: Crestafire Bio has potential as a direct replacement for phenolic resin systems, which are more hazardous to handle and require low storage temperatures. Crestafire Bio offers a much longer storage life while achieving the same fire, smoke and toxicity performance through a similar curing profile. There are simply more customers using phenolic-type chemistries in the UK than across the rest of Europe. SSH: You’ve worked across Russia, France and now globally. How do you compare those experiences? ER: I work best in multicultural environments, and I have been exposed to a lot of different cultures. I enjoy working with people from various mindsets and thinking processes, as it gives me an extra pattern to explore. The more you are exposed to different cultures, the better you can operate within them. SSH: Is that something you discovered about yourself when you first moved to France? ER: What stood out to me was the Commonwealth structure and what it represents: a strong emphasis on shared values, responsibility and giving employees a voice in the future of the business. Being part of that environment encourages you to discover your own sense of responsibility and the contribution you can make beyond your day-to-day role. It makes you think differently about what it means to be part of a company — not simply as an employee, but as someone who has a voice and can help shape its future. The timing of this interview was particularly significant as it coincided with the 75th anniversary of the Commonwealth — a milestone that reflects not only the company’s history, but the enduring importance of employee ownership to Scott Bader’s identity and culture. 22
‘AI will be a significant topic of discussion at the next InnoTrans conference in Berlin this year’ SSH: Does the employee ownership element of Scott Bader change how you work day to day? ER: I think so. When the company celebrated its centenary five years ago, employees across the globe were interviewed on camera and consistently spoke of the same values, thinking and transparency. There is a specific governance structure, including representatives of employees across the globe and a specific body assembled ahead of group board meetings, reflecting a high level of transparency and responsibility. Scott Bader operates under one of the oldest constitutions in the field of employee-owned companies. One aspect of my career that I am particularly proud of is being part of that unique employee-owned culture. Scott Bader is one of the oldest employeeowned companies in the UK and remains exceptional in that its founder, Ernest Bader, transferred ownership of the business to its employees in 1951. Today, the company’s shares are held by the Scott Bader Commonwealth, a charitable trust that safeguards the organisation’s long-term values and purpose. It was a great honour to serve for six years on the Global Members’ Board, representing colleagues across France, Italy, Spain and Germany. This experience provided invaluable exposure to the strategic and governance aspects of the business and allowed me to work closely with senior leadership on matters that affect both the company and its employees worldwide. It strengthened my leadership skills, broadened my understanding of corporate governance and reinforced the importance of balancing commercial success with longterm responsibility. I strongly believe in the principles of Scott Bader’s Constitution, which continues to guide the company according to employee ownership values. It creates a culture of accountability, collaboration and shared purpose that I believe is one of the company’s greatest strengths. SSH: Sustainability came up in your JEC presentation. What does it actually mean to you, and what do you want the industry to achieve? ER: Across the industry, we are seeing a strong shift towards bio-sourced raw materials and a reduced dependence on fossil-based resources. However, for me, sustainability goes beyond simply increasing bio-content in materials or choosing lowercarbon modes of transport such as highspeed rail.
Much of how the rail industry views sustainability centres on recyclability, and this remains an active area of discussion with OEMs and train manufacturers, with our global sustainability manager, Steven Brown, closely involved in that dialogue. Composites also extend a train’s life cycle by several decades compared with plywood, metal and other traditional structures, alongside offering a much higher fire, smoke and toxicity performance. True sustainability is about creating longterm value for society. It means developing materials and technologies that are safer, more efficient and more environmentally responsible, while helping to build a future in which our communities can thrive. In the rail sector, this includes enabling lightweight designs, reducing emissions, improving energy efficiency and maintaining the highest standards of safety. Ultimately, it is about ensuring that the decisions we make today contribute to a safer, cleaner and more sustainable world for future generations. SSH: Attracting and retaining skills comes up a lot in the UK too, with more skilled employees lost than trained and brought in. Is that a similar issue in France, and does the idea of a skills crisis match your own experience? ER: Speaking beyond France alone, as Scott Bader is a global company, it is not unusual to find employees with 30 or more years of service, including one UK technical department colleague recently celebrated for 50 years with the company. People do not tend to move on easily from the company. This reflects the pull of the company’s core values, its democratic industrial structure and the passion people have for the business and the technology. It is more difficult to find people who want to work in the production plants manufacturing the chemicals themselves, which is a different type of challenge. In areas such as Ariège in France, links with local institutes and students continue to provide a strong talent pipeline. The industry as a whole is moving and transforming, and new trends will appear, but the difficulties are ones the industry will overcome. SSH: Do you see people coming behind you following the same route, in terms of training and the path you’ve taken? ER: The company offers a lot of training programmes. Alongside serving for six years on the Global Members’ Board, I have taken part in HR-led training including the Women in Leadership and RISE programmes, among
INTERVIEW
others delivered to teams across the globe. The company is broadly supportive of women in leadership roles, and is working to increase representation at both top and middle management level. I have had the chance to grow both my expertise and my leadership experience through this company. SSH: You mentioned alignment across multiple stakeholders as one of the industry’s big challenges. Who is hardest to get on the same page? ER: This is very much a work in progress. On one side you have companies such as SNCF, SBB ordering high-speed and very highspeed trains across Europe, then partners such as Alstom, Stadler and CAF designing those trains, and companies such as Scott Bader proposing innovative solutions for train interiors, exteriors and front ends, with a long accreditation process running through the chain. One of the key areas where closer alignment can make a real difference is between material suppliers and the design engineering teams at the train manufacturers. These teams bring a wealth of expertise in train design and engineering, often drawing on experience
from a range of sectors, including aerospace, while composites can require a somewhat different approach to design and structural integration. This creates an exciting opportunity for collaboration. Scott Bader is in ongoing discussions with OEMs to share knowledge and work closely with their design teams on how composite structures can be incorporated effectively into future train designs, helping them maximise the benefits of lightweighting, performance, and design flexibility. Ultimately, it is about bringing together the different areas of expertise across the value chain to develop the next generation of more efficient and innovative trains.
metal-to-metal and metal-to-GRP (glassreinforced plastic) assembly. A number of other OEMs are following Alstom’s approach. Others remain more focused on steel and metal structures but are gradually moving towards lighter and more electric trains. The attitude to different applications varies significantly by OEM, with different solutions required for manufacturers such as Stadler, Skoda and Alstom, each with their own perspective on sustainability and design.
SSH: How long do you think it will be before most people doing this design work have more experience with composite materials?
ER: AI will be a significant topic of discussion at the next InnoTrans conference in Berlin this year, though it is more applicable to different parts of rail infrastructure and train operation than to the chemical industry itself, where it is not yet widely used. It is more a topic of discussion for train infrastructure and maintenance than within composite material development.
ER: Manufacturers are already on this journey, and Alstom is probably the best example, as the biggest global OEM using a substantial amount of composite structures alongside Scott Bader’s MMA (methyl methacrylate) structural adhesives for
SSH: You also mentioned AI and predictive maintenance in the technology question. Is that something customers raise with you, or more a topic of debate at conferences?
23
INTERVIEW
Jim Flatman
Jim Flatman is Chief Operating Officer of PortRail Group, the multimodal bulk handling business formed through the merger of JST Services and RFS Works.
COO, PortRail Group Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Jim Flatman, COO of PortRail Group, about the integration of JST Services and RFS Works, unlocking modal shift, fleet optimisation across 200 sites, and where the business sees its next phase of growth SSH: PortRail Group brings together two established businesses under one brand following the merger of JST Services and RFS Works last year. How has the merger taken shape, and what has the integration looked like at ground level? JF: Bringing the businesses together has been about much more than a change of name. JST and RFS each had outstanding reputations in their respective fields, and our focus has been on creating a single company that’s greater than the sum of its parts, combining our complementary strengths while keeping the customer experience seamless. At ground level, integration has centred on people, structure and optimisation. 24
We’ve brought together teams with decades of specialist expertise, aligned processes and invested time in sharing best practice across the business. That means our rail loading teams, port handling specialists and engineering expertise are now working closely together. For example, we can now look at an entire supply chain rather than a single part of it. Customers increasingly want partners who understand how different links in the chain interact, and that’s exactly what PortRail Group provides. We’ve retained the specialist knowledge that made both businesses successful, and we now have greater scale, flexibility and resilience to deliver integrated solutions.
SSH: PortRail Group is still a relatively new name in the market. How would you describe the business today, and what makes it different from other providers in the rail and port logistics sector? JF: Put simply, we’re the UK’s leading provider of multimodal bulk handling solutions. Across England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland too we’re handling around 15 million tonnes of material every year through more than 200 operating locations. We employ nearly 200 highly skilled people and we have a trading heritage that stretches back to 1978. Nobody else has that scale. But really what makes us different is that we don’t simply provide equipment or labour. We optimise the movement of
INTERVIEW
efficiency and helping customers adapt to changing market conditions. Rail freight depends on reliability. When you’ve worked together successfully over decades, trust becomes a genuine operational advantage. SSH: You have a huge machinery fleet across more than 200 loading points. How do you manage that scale and optimise plant utilisation while keeping response times down?
bulk commodities through ports and rail infrastructure by combining specialist knowhow, market knowledge and one of the largest, most diverse machinery fleets in the sector. Our customers are looking for partners who can improve productivity, reduce carbon emissions and solve operational challenges, not simply move material from A to B. Because we understand road, rail and marine environments, we’re able to design solutions that unlock greater value from existing assets while supporting lowercarbon freight. Basically we make complex supply chains work better. SSH: Given both sides on the business have complementary service offerings, what opportunities are there to crossdeploy capability, or do the two sides – port and rail – still largely serve distinct customer bases? JF: There will always be customers who only require a single service, but we’re seeing increasing opportunities to offer more integrated solutions. Many bulk producers are looking more closely at how they move materials from source to customer. Rather than viewing port operations, rail loading, inland handling and haulage as separate activities, they’re looking for a joined-up approach that improves efficiency across the whole supply chain. That’s where the combined PortRail business comes into its own. Our teams work together from the outset to identify opportunities to reduce handling, improve asset utilisation, shorten turnaround times and support greater use of rail and marine where it makes commercial and environmental sense. The more integrated we become, the greater value we can deliver. That doesn’t mean every customer needs every service, but it does mean they have access to a much broader range of expertise from a single trusted partner.
SSH: The Group brings together expertise from across rail, ports and material handling. How does your integrated approach benefit customers compared with more traditional service models? JF: Traditional models often involve several contractors, each responsible for one part of the operation. While each may perform well individually, there isn’t always someone looking at the bigger picture. Our approach is different. Because we understand the interfaces between ports, rail freight and materials handling, we can optimise the entire operation rather than individual stages. That reduces complexity for customers, improves communication and creates opportunities to increase productivity while lowering cost and carbon emissions. It also means we’re able to respond more quickly when circumstances change, whether changing production schedules or customer demands. As supply chains become more complex, customers increasingly value partners who can provide integrated thinking as well as operational delivery. SSH: As RFS you worked with the Freight Operating Companies for more than 40 years. What does a long-term relationship with a FOC actually look like, and how does it differ from a project-by-project engagement? JF: Long-term relationships are built on consistency. FOCs know they can rely on us to deliver safely, professionally and efficiently, day in, day out. Over many years you develop a detailed understanding of how each customer operates, their network, their traffic flows and the pressures they face. That allows us to anticipate issues, improve planning and continuously refine the way we work together. It’s much more collaborative than simply responding to individual contracts. We’re sharing ideas, identifying opportunities for
JF: Planning is fundamental, but so is local knowledge. Our national footprint gives us significant flexibility to deploy equipment where it’s needed, while our local teams understand the operational requirements of individual sites and customers. We continually review fleet utilisation, maintenance schedules and customer demand to ensure we’re making the best possible use of our assets. Technology also plays an increasing role, allowing us to monitor equipment performance, improve maintenance planning and respond quickly when customer requirements change. Ultimately, scale only becomes an advantage if it’s managed effectively. Our aim is always to have the right equipment, with the right operator, in the right place at the right time. SSH: Modal shift away from road has been a long-standing ambition that has been difficult to realise at scale. What would need to change for rail to take a meaningfully larger share? JF: The opportunity for rail is significant, but unlocking it requires long-term thinking. One priority is protecting the strategic infrastructure we already have. Rail-connected urban terminals and marine wharves are national assets. Once they’re lost to alternative development they’re difficult, and often impossible, to replace. Our trade bodies have consistently highlighted the importance of safeguarding this infrastructure if the UK is serious about growing rail freight and reducing transport emissions. Commercially, customers also need confidence to invest. Rail freight often requires longer-term planning than road transport, so policy stability and continued investment in network capability are important. There also needs to be earlier engagement when major industrial, construction and infrastructure projects are being planned. Too often rail is considered after key logistics decisions have already been made. If rail is designed into projects from the outset, it can often deliver significant reductions in carbon emissions, congestion and overall logistics costs. The prize is much bigger than simply moving freight differently. Greater use of rail supports economic growth, improves resilience and helps the UK achieve its environmental ambitions. 25
INTERVIEW
SSH: With around 200 people across the combined PortRail business, many in specialist roles, how are you thinking about skills, retention and recruitment? JF: It’s a cliché but our people are our biggest asset. The specialist skills required to operate safely in ports and on the railway, and the strategic expertise supports that, isn’t developed overnight, so investing in people is absolutely essential. Retention starts with creating a business where people feel valued, have opportunities to develop and can build long-term careers. We’re working to bring together expertise from across both legacy businesses, with a view to creating opportunities for people to broaden their experience while sharing knowledge across teams. We’re also committed to attracting new talent into the industry. As technology continues to evolve, we’re looking for people with a wide range of technical, engineering and operational skills. Developing that next generation will be vital, not only for PortRail Group but for the wider freight sector. SSH: What are the operational priorities for PortRail Group over the next 12 to 18 months? JF: First and foremost, it’s about continuing to deliver safely, efficiently and consistently across our broad operational footprint. Alongside that, we’re focused on driving innovation and supporting sustainable development, both within our own business and throughout our supply chain. That includes investing in new equipment, improving fuel efficiency, embracing new technologies and continually reviewing how we can reduce emissions while
maintaining the high levels of service our customers expect. We’ll also continue strengthening the integration of the business so customers increasingly benefit from the full breadth of our capabilities across ports, rail and materials handling. SSH: Technology is transforming every part of the rail freight and logistics sector. Which operational innovations are making the biggest difference to your business today? JF: Some of the biggest gains come from applying technology intelligently rather than chasing shiny new tech for its own sake. We’re investing in newer, more fuel-efficient equipment, improving fleet management and using data systems to optimise maintenance and deployment. That improves reliability, reduces downtime and helps lower emissions. We’re also seeing benefits from better operational planning and digital communication between teams, enabling us to respond more quickly to changing customer requirements. Innovation doesn’t always have to be revolutionary. Continuous improvement, backed by experienced people who understand the operation, often delivers the greatest long-term value. SSH: Many businesses talk about resilience in supply chains. From your perspective, what does resilience really mean, and how does PortRail Group help customers achieve it? JF: Resilience is about giving customers options and reducing dependency on any single part of the supply chain. Our business
model is built around helping customers create more flexible logistics networks by making better use of rail, ports and multimodal operations. That can improve overall capacity, reduce exposure to single points of failure and provide alternative routing when disruption occurs. Because we operate nationally and understand multiple modes of freight, we’re often able to help customers adapt quickly as circumstances change. The events of recent years have shown that resilient supply chains aren’t accidental. They are designed, planned and continually improved, and that’s where we believe we add real value. SSH: Are there particular sectors or types of projects where you see the greatest opportunities for growth over the next five years? JF: Major infrastructure projects are an obvious area where we’ve always had a role to play. At the moment we’re supporting nationally significant programmes including HS2 and Sizewell C, demonstrating the value that integrated rail and materials handling can bring to complex construction projects. Looking ahead, we see significant opportunities in offshore wind, energy infrastructure and the wider transition to a lower-carbon economy. These sectors require the movement of large volumes of bulk materials, often through ports and by rail, which aligns well with our capabilities. There’s also growing interest in supporting domestic manufacturing and reindustrialisation. If the UK is serious about strengthening industrial supply chains, efficient freight logistics will be a key enabler. One lesson we’ve learned repeatedly is that early engagement matters. The sooner logistics specialists are involved in project planning, the more opportunity there is to design efficient, sustainable supply chains from the outset. SSH: Looking ahead, in years to come what would you hope people across the rail industry would be saying about PortRail Group and the impact it has made? JF: I’d like people to say we helped raise the standard for integrated freight logistics. Not simply because we were the biggest, but because we demonstrated that bringing together expertise across ports, rail and materials handling creates better outcomes for customers and for the wider industry. I’d also like PortRail Group to be recognised as a business that consistently delivered on its promises. At the end of the day, if we’ve played a meaningful role in making rail freight more competitive, supporting sustainable economic growth and encouraging greater use of lowercarbon logistics, then we’ll have made a positive contribution well beyond our own business.
26
Handling Innovation Combining the capabilities of RFS Works and JST Services, PortRail is an integrated bulk logistics powerhouse. We use the latest technology and expertise to deliver innovative, carbonefficient solutions for port operators, freight companies, materials producers and infrastructure contractors. Our expert team has worked with the rail industry across the UK and Europe for almost 50 years. Backed by one of the largest, most diverse and advanced machine fleets, we have the proven capacity to tackle every material handling challenge.
PortRail Group is the leading UK provider of integrated services for bulk material handling, logistics and heavy mobile equipment solutions.
We manage bulk handling projects from conception to completion, including rapid rail loading and unloading, wagon clear-outs, intermodal operations, terminal management and logistics services, keeping foundation industries moving.
PHONE EMAIL WEBSITE
0330 123 4422 info@portrailgroup.com www.portrailgroup.com
27
INTERVIEW
Richard Schofield CEO, Project Leaders Richard Schofield is CEO of Project Leaders. He spent his career on the client and operator side of the rail industry before joining the company, including roles as Network Rail General Manager on HS1, leading rail operations for the London 2012 Olympics, and chairing the Trial Running Mobilisation Board for Crossrail.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Richard Schofield about why major programmes lose their way when process replaces accountability, why rail keeps losing talent to nuclear, and what two decades on HS1, the London 2012 Olympics and Crossrail have taught him about complexity, culture and people SSH: You have spent your career at the operational centre of some of the most demanding programmes in UK rail: running HS1 as Network Rail General Manager, leading rail operations for the 2012 Olympics, and chairing the Trial Running Mobilisation Board for Crossrail. What did that accumulation of experience teach you about where project delivery succeeds or fails? RS: There isn’t a single answer, but looking back across those projects, some you’d characterise as having overrun and gone over budget, others as successes, though history doesn’t always match the experience of actually delivering them. The Olympics is generally seen as a triumph because it opened on time, even though it cost considerably more than expected. The Elizabeth line is often described as late and over budget, yet people now come from all over the world to see what is arguably the best urban metro built anywhere in the last twenty years. So the struggles within a project don’t necessarily translate into how history judges it. But some consistent challenges stand out. The first is underestimating complexity, and the over-optimism that comes with it – assuming a project will be relatively straightforward or believing we’ve learned all the lessons from the past and this will be the one that lands on time. There’s also a political dimension, particularly on major government schemes. Sometimes you have to be overly optimistic to get something started at all. If anyone had said HS2 would cost £100 billion, it would never have got off the ground. What tends to happen is the opposite: an early, unrealistic budget and schedule that gets things moving, even though it was never really achievable. 28
The other major factor is people, and with people comes culture. Projects that run for decades develop their own subcultures, and organisations can lose sight of what they’re actually trying to achieve as a result. The culture may be wanting to be the best in the world, be at the cutting edge of technology or being different – without always keeping proper track of what that ambition will cost or how long it will take. There’s also a continuity problem. Some people stay on major projects in rail, power, defence or others for over a decade, which gives valuable continuity, but raises a real question: how can the people who specified a project also be the right people to procure it, and then to deliver it? Nobody would claim to be an expert in procurement, specification, delivery, testing, commissioning and assurance all at once, yet projects tend not to swap in the right people for the right phase. Rather like a football club needing to change its manager and its squad relatively often, but instead they tend to keep the same group with a few changes, and then are surprised when things go wrong. Crossrail is a well documented example: it was led by civil engineers for a long time (I say that as a civil engineer myself) who were understandably excited by the tunnelling and the concrete, and who could measure progress precisely because you can deliver tunnelling at a fixed rate per day. Systems engineering is a completely different world of rework cycles and bugfixing, and civil engineers aren’t necessarily the best people to manage a project at that stage. But because they’d been so good during the tunnelling phase, the assumption was that the same team should keep leading. Projects don’t swap people out enough.
SSH: Project Leaders describes itself as a delivery partner rather than an advisor. In practice, when you are engaged on a programme, where does your team’s accountability begin and end? RS: It’s a good question, because we’re generally engaged in one of two ways. Often we’re asked to come in and ‘sort something out’, and in that case the accountability is reasonably clear: a deep diagnostic, followed by solutions and interventions, then delivery. In other cases we have teams embedded for the longer term. On Crossrail, for example, Project Leaders was brought in to fix the planning and get testing and commissioning done; that work is finished, but we still have a team on the Elizabeth line today, four years after Crossrail opened, planning and helping deliver outstanding works and ongoing upgrades such as the track upgrades. So our accountability sometimes shifts from ‘fix this’ to ‘now it’s fixed, can you help make sure it doesn’t break again’. On HS2 I’ve had four or five distinct roles over a couple of years: first working with a small team to give a view on the realistic schedule and cost, then developing the detailed delivery plans, then helping to fix specific issues, and now working with the systems team on getting the rail systems plans robust. So our accountability is sometimes very clearly defined, and sometimes more fluid and I quite like that, because it’s about helping the client work out what’s going on and fix things as you go, provided both sides are clear on the boundaries. Our approach is to come in, help the client understand what’s wrong, help them fix it, prove it’s right, and then go. Throughout, we have to stay honest
INTERVIEW
and detached from the culture of the organisation. People often want to explain the history of why a project is where it is, and while that’s of some interest, we’re there to make things better in future, not to explain the present. So as long as we remain independent, outcome-focused, and give an honest view of what needs fixing, I think that’s the right approach. SSH: Project Leaders was brought into the Crossrail recovery to manage construction blockades and integrate Trial Running and Trial Operations across a complex stakeholder environment. What did that intervention reveal about why large programmes get into serious difficulty in the first place? RS: Towards the end of any major project, you end up with a set of competing needs. Crossrail is a good example: in the final two or three years they were always going to be testing and commissioning the railway, but they were also still finishing construction on elements that were running late, and because it’s a technically complex railway, there were software bugs that needed fixing too, reliability growth alongside everything else. Everyone believes their need is the most pressing: if you’re responsible for the trains, you need to get them out on the track
‘I actually enjoy that end phase of a project most... by the end of each week you’re in a slightly better place than you started.’ and prove they can run reliably for eighteen hours a day; if you’re finishing a piece of construction, you want the contractors off site as quickly as possible because they’re costing you money; if you’re testing and commissioning, you want repeatable access every day. Our role on Crossrail was essentially to build a detailed plan working out who needed to do what, where and when, and to help make the hard priority calls. Recognising, for instance, that finishing a particular piece of construction was important, but not as important as getting a train out on the track the next day. We’ve seen exactly the same pattern more recently on a major defence project: testing, commissioning, finishing construction and managing costs all competing at once. I’d also say, in defence of the Elizabeth line, that although it opened later than planned and was over budget (albeit
not significantly), it has gone on to be astonishingly successful. I actually enjoy that end phase of a project most. I joined HS1 with about three years to go, saw it open, and then ran it for a few years; I joined Crossrail in 2017 when it was meant to have a year left, and it ended up taking four more. That period is chaotic, but it can be planned, and you can see progress so by the end of each week you’re in a slightly better place than you started, even if it’s still not finished. SSH: Your model requires people with genuine technical depth in signalling, track and power alongside programme management capability. Is the industry producing and retaining enough of those people? RS: Our business model relies on a small number of exceptional people who can move mountains, surrounded by good project managers and less experienced people who can grow into those roles. I think the rail industry is reasonably good at producing that talent, but not so good at retaining it, and the fragmentation of the rail industry makes it harder to find fully rounded people. We’ve seen a real exodus towards nuclear power, Sizewell and Hinkley in particular have drawn in a lot of railway engineers
Leadership Excellence for Complex Infrastructure Project Leaders has earned a reputation for bringing clarity, control, and confidence to complex infrastructure programmes. Adopting an integrated approach which spans advanced planning, assurance, programme leadership, risk integration and delivery systems enabling clients to drive change and efficiency on major schemes.
Runway East Bloomsbury 24-28 Bloomsbury Way, London WC1A 2SL Built on expertise, integrity and major programme experience
www.projectleaders.co.uk info@projectleaders.co.uk 29
INTERVIEW
‘People come from all over the world to see what is arguably the best urban metro built anywhere in the last twenty years.’ and project managers, partly because rail project management skills transfer well: people used to working within possessions and short delivery windows adapt easily to the shutdown-driven environment of defence and nuclear work. That means we’re constantly looking at who might be about to move on from a project or infrastructure operator, or who might be considering a return to the UK after some years working abroad, and working out whether we can bring them in even without immediate work lined up, because if the market knows we’ve got them, they’ll come to us. It’s a fine balance, but there is a genuine shortage of very good people at the moment, and it will take time for the next generation to come through. SSH: After twenty years and programmes ranging from Thameslink to TRU, are the delivery problems you encounter today fundamentally the same as when the company was founded, or has something shifted? RS: I think the fundamental issues are broadly the same, but two things stand out as having changed. The first is technology, which moves at such a pace that a ten-year project specified on day one bears little resemblance, technologically, to where it ends up. Think about what technology looked like in 2010 compared with 2026, I remember getting my first iPhone and being amazed it could take a photograph; that seems pathetic compared to what we have now. Even something like a document management system specified at the start of a current live project has already been replaced twice. Every aspect of a project, how you survey, how you capture information, the technology underpinning how trains move, changes at pace. Technology has helped too, arriving at the right moment to solve problems that previously had no solution. But it’s also a genuine burden: on HS1, which I joined in 2002, the project ran on a single document control system throughout, with documents in perhaps two formats rather than multiple. I started out in a drawing office with no email so that has all changed within my working life. The second big change is the sheer number of stakeholders. With devolution of 30
both the rail industry and of politics more broadly, there are now far more stakeholder groups who either need to be kept informed or who have an active role, and projects need substantial stakeholder and sponsorship functions to manage that. That complexity plays out differently depending on the stakeholder. HS2 is a good example: the stakeholders in London are quite different from those in Birmingham, where the project is more of an economic driver for the region, whereas London stakeholders are more focused on the benefit for commuters or business travellers or indeed the faster link to Birmingham Airport. Detailed stakeholder mapping, live management as politicians and governments change, identifying key decision-makers, people who need to be kept informed, and potential disruptors are all now as important as any other part of the project. SSH: The governance structures around major rail programmes are designed to assign accountability, yet large programmes still overrun and fragment. What is the gap between how accountability is structured on paper and how it functions when a programme is under pressure? RS: Accountability is something I feel strongly about, and I think it’s often lacking, and it doesn’t always equate to finishing on time, but rather to clarity over who is doing what. A big failing of major projects is that accountability gets replaced by process and governance. If I were in charge of a major project, I could introduce enough process and governance to stop people doing things they shouldn’t but in practice it also stops them doing the things they should be doing. What matters is very clear accountability at the top, clear lines of accountability running through the organisation, and clarity for each person or team about what they’re responsible for delivering and by when, along with the resources to actually do it. On government projects in particular, process and governance often become a proxy for accountability, and end up having the opposite effect: they slow a project down and become a barrier to swift decisionmaking. Too often, process and governance slow things down, which causes delays, which then prompts the introduction of yet more process and governance and before long the whole thing is grinding along at not much more than a crawl, and everyone is thoroughly frustrated. Clear accountability, paired with efficient process and robust governance, is close to a panacea. SSH: Your model depends on embedded expertise. As the company grows and takes on more commissions simultaneously, what is the hardest thing to scale? RS: It’s the deep expertise and experience that’s hardest to scale. A lot of our work
comes from people we’ve worked with before, and often it’s a specific name they want. So we need to keep growing more of those names, which is a multi-year undertaking. We surround those experts with good project managers and more junior people who can grow into the role, which works well, but only if the client doesn’t insist on the name alone. Our approach is to place the name within a team and gradually let the name step back, leaving the team in place, our continuing presence at TfL, four years on from Crossrail, is a good example. SSH: You joined Project Leaders as CEO after a career spent largely on the client and operator side. What has running a business in this space shown you that you could not see from the other side of the table? RS: I love it. Running a smaller company means I see the cash flow and the outstanding payments directly. I know exactly how much is in the bank on any given day, and there have been times I’ve had to go back to a client and say the bill really does need paying now. That’s an added layer of stress, but it also means I can trace a direct line between the work being done and the value it’s creating for the client, right through to what we’re actually paid. There’s a level of jeopardy in that which I think is genuinely valuable. I couldn’t now see myself going back to a large organisation, where you’re simply one part of a much bigger machine. SSH: Looking at the programmes currently in the pipeline what is the most underestimated challenge facing the industry over the next decade? RS: Obsolescence, across the board, from LSPH starting its renewals, which makes me feel old, to GSM-R and fleet renewals, on top of the challenge of doing all of that while also upgrading and building new infrastructure. For a company like ours, diversification matters just as much: being active in enough sectors that if one contracts, it can be managed. Being entirely reliant on rail was the initial challenge we faced, and the control period cycle means the market can swing between feast and famine. SSH: Where is Project Leaders in ten years, and what would have to change in the wider industry for the kind of work you do to be valued differently than it is today? RS: I’d like to think we’re still built around the same ethos, expertise, an outcome focus, a small number of brilliant people, and enough experience across different industries that our learning is broader still. But I’d like the balance to shift more towards helping projects avoid the pitfalls in the first place, rather than being brought in to help dig them out.
STAY ON TRACK BY AVOIDING CRITICAL BOLTING FAILURES Norbar is a UK manufacturer of battery, electric, pneumatic and manually operated torque multipliers, wrenches, torque measurement equipment and bespoke torque control solutions specially developed for the rail industry
Contact Norbar and speak to The Voice of Torque Control
www.norbar.com rail@ rail @norbar.com 31
INTERVIEW
Mike Jenkinson Managing Director at Booth Industries Mike Jenkinson is Managing Director at Booth Industries, a UK specialist in fire, security and blast-rated doors for the rail sector. He joined the business during the Crossrail programme and has since overseen the company’s work on the Northern Line Extension, HS2 and Old Oak Common, alongside its long-term maintenance contract with TfL on the Elizabeth line.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Mike Jenkinson, Managing Director at Booth Industries, about tightening assurance requirements, standardising doors across major infrastructure schemes, and what Old Oak Common demands of a specialist supplier 32
INTERVIEW
SSH: What is driving the demand for increasingly high-performance safetycritical products from where Booth sits? MJ: The products we supply need to meet the railway’s demands, which can mean a design life of up to 100 years. That is shaping different behaviour across the marketplace, and it is very much about buying the right product, rather than the cheapest one. SSH: How different is that to where things stood five years ago? MJ: When Crossrail was underway, the industry was in the midst of a broader tightening of assurance requirements. Previously, test houses had more scope to assess different criteria on a discretionary basis. Following Grenfell, that approach was tightened, with a much greater emphasis on hard evidence and testing rather than judgement calls. At Booth, we go through a thorough set of checks, and test evidence to back everything up before entering contracts. Assessments based on judgement alone are not an option unless there is direct evidence to support them. That has meant more upfront planning and more work with customers at the outset to help them understand what they can and cannot have. That is a key message we push: engage with us from the beginning, and we can help tailor solutions, identify gaps and fill them. SSH: Is that a fair position for Booth to be in, given how well prepared you were for a shift that is now expected and largely required? MJ: It makes the industry safer for everybody, because it reduces the scope for judgement calls to favour a particular solution. There is far less subjectivity. You need solid, evidence-based testing directly linked to the products you are selling, which then goes into the assurance pack. The industry is in a much stronger place as a result. From our perspective, we are well placed to respond to that because we invest heavily in R&D, spending upwards of £1 million a year on new product development, future products and assurance. That level of investment sets a high bar for competitors and creates a clear point of difference for Booth. Customers come to us because they know they are getting a competent contractor with fully proven solutions, and that combination is quite rare in the market. SSH: Rail infrastructure projects in the UK have a difficult reputation for delays and cost overruns, with HS2 the most prominent example. As a specialist supplier, how do you insulate your business from that kind of slippage upstream?
MJ: Delays come with the territory, so it is about being agile and having the right contractual framework and relationship with the end user in place. A lot of our contracts now allow us to manufacture ahead of time, which gives us continuity internally. That is our main driver: keeping work flowing consistently through the factory smooths out the peaks and troughs that infrastructure projects can otherwise create. We work with tier ones, including HS2, to manufacture at a pace that suits us, which occasionally means holding completed units in storage. That gives the client a flat, consistent draw-down on cash, and gives us reliable, predictable revenue. It takes some of the unpredictability out of the business. We are seeing customers increasingly value that arrangement, because they know we are insulated against changes and hold stock they can draw on quickly when needed, rather than the pressure falling on the supply chain at short notice. That is often when things become difficult: a delay occurs, and suddenly everyone needs the work done twice as fast. Because we have already done the work upfront, we are ahead of the curve. SSH: Are you hopeful this model will be adopted more widely on future projects? MJ: Where possible, yes, although there are occasions where it is not always practical, particularly where a lot of different products are involved and manufacturing needs to wait for design and construction to catch up. Wherever we can, we look to put those relationships in place. Having enough of that type of work at any one time helps insulate us against delay and makes the rest more manageable, because we have something to fall back on where we are already ahead on other jobs. So it is applied wherever possible, rather than universally. SSH: Booth has been part of almost every major UK rail infrastructure project of the last two decades, including Crossrail, the Northern Line Extension, HS2 and now Old Oak Common. How has that accumulation of project experience changed how you engineer and deliver? MJ: It comes back to early engagement. Some of that now happens at pre-tender stage, where we offer advice with no obligation on anyone to use Booth afterwards. All our jobs are won on competitive tender, on the basis of technical merit and price. But we advise on things like opening sizes, how to maintain openings within tolerance, ensuring the right materials are specified, ensuring assurance meets the relevant requirements, and how doors interface with other elements on site, such as cladding. We take the approach that time spent at the front end helps prevent risks further down the line, and that has been one of the biggest lessons for us. On Crossrail, I had just joined the business, and some
of the challenges we encountered there were already underway before we could influence them. But we carried a lot of that learning into the Northern Line Extension, built on it further, and took it into the HS2 CPD contract and now into Old Oak Common. It was clear from conversations with the tier ones, including Balfour Beatty VINCI Systra (BBVS), our main customer on Old Oak Common, that they valued us bringing that learning with us and were keen to embed it within their own team too. SSH: What specifically did you learn from Crossrail that you have applied to Old Oak Common? MJ: There was a lot of variation in the doors across the different areas of Crossrail, which was delivered by multiple tier ones and architectural practices, each bringing their own approach to how something should look and be delivered. On Old Oak Common, we have worked to build in more consistency. Instead of having, say, 900 completely different door sets, we have a selection of doors that account for different requirements, hardware and sizes, but standardise as much as possible. Excessive customisation tends to create delays, inefficiency and added cost, so we have batched things into sizes, advised BBVS on what the openings need to be, and worked with them so they can guide the civil contractors accordingly. It is very much about standardisation and reducing unnecessary variation across the scheme wherever possible. SSH: Do you think people would be surprised by how much variance there was, given that Crossrail had multiple different designers effectively specifying for the same job? MJ: HS2 leadership past and present would tell you, if asked, that the variance across the door packages on Crossrail presented real challenges and they would not want to see that repeated. When he visited Booth around 2021, Mark Thurston made a similar point: standardise the doors, and avoid ending up with many different types across every station with multiple variants of each. Everyone involved has been keen to make sure that is not repeated. Looking back, people might ask why it happened in the first place, and it really comes down to how decentralised Crossrail was structurally, with different teams each taking their own approach. We are trying to bring more shared learning and consistency to prevent that recurring, though you can never fully avoid it. There have been several recent cases where we have spotted synergies between different door packages and suggested a variant that removes a significant amount of testing, because we had already done that work for another contractor. That has worked well and let us help guide the process. 33
INTERVIEW
SSH: Is that kind of variance something you think could return, given there may have been legitimate reasons for it at the time? MJ: The reasons were more about structure and how things were set up, than anything else. There will always be different performance requirements, but typically a door will meet around 80 per cent of them. The lesson has been that where the remaining requirements are not essential, it can be better to standardise on the same door as elsewhere. I think there is now enough knowledge and experience across the industry to prevent that happening as often, and we see it as part of our role, as the specialist in this area, to help guide tier ones and contractors towards better outcomes. We worked closely with BBVS from the outset on this. It benefits everyone: more repeatability, less risk for the tier ones, and more consistency for the end user in terms of service, maintenance and spare parts. SSH: On HS2, cross passage doors had to meet what was described as a world-first combination of performance criteria: two hours of fire integrity alongside pressure cycling from trains passing at speed. How do you approach an engineering problem with no existing benchmark? MJ: We were in a fairly fortunate position. Having worked on fire doors for many years, we understand what performs well in fire conditions. We also have a side of the business dealing with blast protection, which involves pressure. That meant we could combine our experience of fire performance with our understanding of how repeated pressure affects fatigue over time, which is a different kind of load to a single blast event but repeated over millions of cycles. There are established methods for calculating how that stresses a door and how it needs to be built to withstand a worstcase scenario, so we were able to develop the solution from our existing door designs. What we arrived at is novel in several respects, but draws on design principles from previous work. Our ability to demonstrate that through the assurance process was one of our key strengths going into this. We gave HS2 a clear plan for how to demonstrate fatigue performance, both physically and theoretically, and I think that has helped set a benchmark for how to approach this going forward. HS2 have been through that process with us and have confidence that the end result will meet the requirements of the railway. SSH: Do you expect that combination of requirements to become more standard going forward? MJ: Yes, I think we will see more of it. It is starting to come through in European and American tunnel projects, though not always at the same pressure levels we have 34
dealt with. Certain aspects of the design can be adapted and applied more widely, and we are seeing encouraging conversations around that, including interest from further afield. We expect to take what we have developed for this project into the international market. SSH: Is there enough being said publicly about these successes on HS2, and the kinds of unique challenges British suppliers are solving? MJ: I don’t think we shout about it enough, and that’s probably true of the industry more broadly. When we attended a tunnelling conference in America a couple of weeks ago, it was clear the US is roughly where the UK was before Crossrail, with a lot of learning still ahead and some of the same challenges the UK worked through first. Some major businesses operate across the UK, America and other markets and can carry that experience with them, but the specialist skills are still developing there. UK businesses have a great deal to offer internationally, and I think there’s more we could do to promote that. SSH: The Northern Line Extension required a large number of unique door types, with almost no two doors alike. How do you make bespoke manufacturing at that volume economically viable? MJ: It is challenging, and we won’t pretend otherwise. We don’t operate in the same way as some high-volume manufacturers, but we are continually refining our approach and improving year on year on standardisation. As mentioned, we want to avoid repeating the scale of variation we saw on Crossrail and the Northern Line Extension, so we are now in a good position to give customers what they need and end users what is required for the railway, while reducing unnecessary variability. There is a natural cost consideration across these contracts: we need to remain sustainable and the end user needs value for money, so there has to be a balance, and that’s what we’ve been working towards. Assurance requirements mean we have less flexibility on variables than before, and that is expected to tighten further, with additional assessment routes being phased out from 2029. The market and regulatory environment are moving towards more standardisation, and we are adapting to deliver as much as is economically viable within that. SSH: Does that shift in assurance play into the TfL contract for the Elizabeth line, which is a maintenance contract? Do you see that as a shift from delivery into asset management? MJ: Assurance works a little differently in the maintenance space. What TfL were looking for was a partner who understood
the doors well, which are more technically demanding to maintain than a standard fire and security door because they operate in a tunnel environment with a number of specific requirements. They wanted a company they could rely on for spare parts, who understood the demands of working on a live railway, and who could respond quickly, for example getting an engineer into a tunnel within a few hours if an issue arises. That has meant making that side of the business more agile and responsive, with a strong focus on building long-term relationships. Everyone joining the after-sales team is paired with an experienced colleague for a period and works through a competency framework before working unsupervised on a live railway. I think that’s what customers value: a direct Booth employee, backed by colleagues with years of experience, and a business that takes health and safety, quality and customer service seriously. We’re consistently told we are among the best performing contractors TfL has on service and maintenance. SSH: Is that success down to how well you have applied the lessons from the larger contracts over the last five years? MJ: Very much so. Had we approached this in the same way as a standard fire and security door or roller shutter, we wouldn’t be applying the same level of care, planning or understanding of what’s required to work on a live railway, including risk assessments, method statements, and health and safety and quality requirements. That’s a direct result of what we’ve learned from previous projects. SSH: Old Oak Common will be one of the UK’s busiest interchange hubs. What does delivering for a station of that scale and public profile demand of a specialist supplier? MJ: Old Oak Common is going to be a demanding project for everyone involved. It’s one of the largest rail hubs developed in a long time, with a wide range of performance requirements and an ambitious schedule. From our perspective, that means building strong relationships with BBVS, planning well ahead of time, and identifying risks that may emerge over that period. We need to stay agile, which comes back to the earlier point about holding pre-made stock ready to go, allowing us to respond quickly and adapt to changing circumstances. On any construction project, there are always unforeseen issues, and how you handle them is what sets an experienced contractor like Booth apart from one approaching this kind of project for the first time. It’s a genuinely challenging environment to work in.
www.booth-industries.co.uk enquiries@booth-industries.co.uk
35
INTERVIEW
Lee Pounder Regional Managing Director Scotland & Ireland at SPL Powerlines UK
SPL Powerlines is a system provider of electrification solutions for local mass transit and mainline rail infrastructure, offering services from consulting and engineering to installation, maintenance, product development and sales.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Lee Pounder about the company’s expansion into Ireland’s rail electrification market, its diversification into high-voltage energy infrastructure, and why a rolling programme of investment is essential to delivering decarbonisation across the network SSH: Why is now the right time for SPL Powerlines to move into Ireland, and what’s the first tangible piece of work you expect to deliver there? LP: Now is the right time for SPL Powerlines to establish a presence in Ireland because the country is entering a major phase of infrastructure investment, with significant programmes such as DART+, CACR and wider rail decarbonisation initiatives creating demand for proven electrification expertise. Ireland’s ambition to deliver sustainable growth, improve connectivity and support a growing population aligns closely with our specialist capabilities in rail electrification and the long-term investment commitment of our parent group, Equans. In terms of tangible delivery, our main focus is to support Ireland’s rail electrification programme through the design, installation and energisation of overhead line architecture. We are already engaging with key stakeholders to share our experiences and look forward to 36
contributing practical expertise that helps accelerate the delivery of a more sustainable, resilient and future-ready railway network. SSH: You’ll be building a workforce and supply chain presence from a standing start. Are you bringing expertise and technical differentiation in from the UK operation, hiring and training locally, or both? LP: We see it as a combination of both. SPL Powerlines UK&I will bring proven rail electrification expertise, systems, and project delivery experience from our established UK and European operations, whilst also building a strong local workforce and supply chain in Ireland. Our objective is not simply to deliver projects in Ireland, but to create a sustainable, long-term capability that supports the ambitious growth of the rail sector. Ireland is entering a significant period of infrastructure investment and delivery, and success will depend on strong collaboration,
skills development, and resilient supply chains. We intend to work closely with local partners, recruit and train local Irish talent, and create opportunities for knowledge transfer from our highly experienced multidiscipline teams. By combining international specialist expertise with local capability, we can help deliver rail electrification projects efficiently while contributing to the wider economic and workforce benefits that major infrastructure programmes bring. SSH: Where do you see SPL Powerlines UK&I sitting in five years’ time in Ireland? LP: In five years’ time, we aim for SPL Powerlines UK&I to be recognised as a trusted long-term partner in Ireland’s rail infrastructure sector, playing a significant role in the delivery of rail electrification and transport decarbonisation programmes. Building on the strength of the Powerlines Group and Equans, our ambition is to establish a strong local presence, develop Irish skills and supply chains, and contribute
INTERVIEW
to the delivery of sustainable, resilient transport infrastructure that supports Ireland’s economic growth, connectivity, and climate objectives. Ireland has one of the most exciting rail investment pipelines in Europe. If funding commitments translate into sustained delivery programmes, the benefits will extend far beyond individual projects. It will create skilled jobs, attract investment into local supply chains, improve connectivity and support economic growth across the country. For organisations prepared to invest early and support that journey, the opportunity is significant. SSH: What has the investment and support from Powerlines and Equans enabled you to do in Ireland? LP: The support and investment from Powerlines and Equans has enabled us to establish a purposeful presence in Ireland at exactly the right time, bringing together international scale, long-term financial commitment, and specialist rail electrification expertise. This backing allows us to invest in local talent and capability, build key relationships with industry stakeholders, develop Irish supply chain partnerships, and position ourselves to support major rail modernisation and decarbonisation programmes. More importantly, it gives our clients the confidence that we can combine proven delivery experience from across Europe with a long-term commitment to Ireland’s infrastructure ambitions. SSH: SPL Powerlines only recently moved into high-voltage energy infrastructure in the UK, alongside its rail work. Is Ireland a rail-only entry for now, or could that energy infrastructure capability follow the same path there? LP: Our initial focus in Ireland is rail, where there is a clear opportunity to support major electrification and decarbonisation programmes with the specialist expertise that SPL Powerlines UK&I is known for. However, as part of the Powerlines Group and Equans, we also see significant potential in the Irish energy infrastructure market. The growth in rail, renewable energy, grid reinforcement and wider electrification objectives are all very closely linked, so we will continue to explore opportunities where our high-voltage transmission and energy infrastructure capabilities can add value alongside our rail offering. SSH: Ireland’s rail network is far less electrified than the UK’s. Does that earlier stage of development change the kind of work on offer in the short term, are you looking at new electrification schemes, renewals, or something else entirely? LP: Ireland’s rail network is at an earlier stage of electrification, which creates
significant opportunities across the full asset lifecycle. We see potential in supporting new electrification schemes, network enhancements, renewals, and the development of the infrastructure needed to enable long-term rail decarbonisation. Drawing on our multi-discipline experience across the UK and Europe, our focus is on working collaboratively with all stakeholders to help deliver a modern, sustainable and future-ready railway, whether that involves new-build projects, upgrades to existing assets, or supporting the wider electrification strategy. SSH: Rail electrification in the UK has often stalled and restarted depending on government funding cycles. How does a specialist contractor like SPL Powerlines plan for growth when the pipeline of work can be so politically dependent? LP: As a specialist electrification contractor, our approach is to focus on the long-term fundamentals of the market rather than individual project cycles. Demand for rail decarbonisation, network modernisation, and sustainable transport continues to grow, and these are long-term trends that require specialist capability and investment. We therefore plan for growth by maintaining a strong pipeline across different stages of project development, investing in people and skills, and leveraging the breadth of experience and stability provided by the wider Powerlines Group and Equans. This enables us to take a long-term view and support our clients consistently as programmes progress from planning through to delivery. The reality is that rail electrification becomes significantly more expensive when programmes stop and start. Continuity allows clients and contractors to retain skilled resources, invest in innovation, optimise supply chains and drive productivity improvements over time. A rolling programme is not just better for the supply chain; it ultimately delivers better value for taxpayers. SSH: You’ve recently moved into battery EMU-enabled partial electrification in Scotland rather than full electrification throughout. Is that hybrid approach, wires for some sections, batteries for others, becoming the norm, or still a compromise driven by cost? LP: Battery-electric and partial electrification solutions are becoming an increasingly important part of the industry’s toolkit, but they are not a replacement for electrification. The focus today is less about choosing one technology over another and more about selecting the most appropriate solution for the specific route, operational requirements, and whole-life value. From SPL Powerlines’ perspective, our expertise lies in delivering electrification infrastructure, and we see a strong future
‘I believe wider strategic considerations such as energy independence will become just as influential as carbon reduction in driving future investment decisions.’
for both conventional and targeted electrification schemes. In some cases, battery EMUs supported by strategically electrified sections can provide an efficient pathway to decarbonisation, particularly where they accelerate benefits, reduce disruption, or address route-specific challenges. In others, full electrification remains the optimum long-term solution in terms of performance, capacity, and operational efficiency. Ultimately, the industry should avoid viewing battery technology and electrification as competing solutions. The most successful decarbonisation strategies are likely to combine both, using each where it delivers the greatest operational and economic benefit. What is increasingly clear across the industry is that decarbonisation is not a one-size-fits-all challenge. The priority is delivering reliable, sustainable railways, and that means combining infrastructure, technology, and operational expertise to achieve the best outcome for passengers, operators, and taxpayers. SPL Powerlines is well positioned to support that transition through the design and delivery of electrification solutions across the full spectrum of rail projects. SSH: You achieved a longer maximum OLE span length through trials on the Midland Main Line, allowing fewer structures and lower costs on future projects. Are innovations like that being adopted industry-wide, or does each contractor still have to prove things out independently? LP: Innovation in rail electrification adds the most value when it moves beyond a single project and becomes part of accepted industry practice. The Midland Main Line trials demonstrated that longer OLE spans can be delivered safely and efficiently, providing the evidence needed to support future schemes with fewer structures, lower material use, reduced installation costs, and a smaller environmental footprint. 37
INTERVIEW
While any significant innovation must be supported by robust engineering assurance and client approval, the industry’s objective is to avoid repeatedly proving the same concept over and again. Once innovations are thoroughly tested and validated, the benefits can be adopted more widely through standards, technical guidance, and best practice. The 95-metre span trial is a good example of how collaborative innovation can create lasting value for future electrification programmes across the network. At SPL Powerlines, we see innovation as a way to make electrification more efficient, affordable, and deliverable at scale. Working closely with our clients, stakeholders and industry partners, our focus is on developing solutions that not only solve project-specific challenges but also help improve the delivery of future rail electrification schemes across the sector. SSH: SPL Powerlines has recently expanded from rail electrification into high-voltage energy infrastructure. Is that diversification a response to a slowing rail pipeline, or a genuine belief that the two markets are converging? LP: Our expansion into high-voltage energy infrastructure is driven by a genuine belief that the rail and energy sectors are becoming increasingly interconnected through the wider electrification and decarbonisation agenda. Rail electrification, grid reinforcement, renewable energy integration, and network resilience all rely on many of the same engineering disciplines, delivery models, and specialist capabilities. As part of the Powerlines Group, we have long-standing expertise across both rail and energy infrastructure, so this is a natural evolution rather than a response to any single market cycle. It enables us to support clients more broadly as they tackle the challenge of delivering the infrastructure needed for a lower-carbon future.
existing workforce. We are actively engaging with schools, colleges, and universities through STEM initiatives to attract new talent into the industry, while planning to develop a training academy that will help build long-term capability and future-proof the skills pipeline. We’ve also had success looking beyond traditional recruitment channels. Working with education providers, community organisations and employment programmes, we’ve demonstrated that there is a wealth of untapped talent available if the industry is prepared to invest in training and create meaningful career pathways. The challenge is not simply finding people; it is creating opportunities that attract them into rail and supporting them throughout their development. The industry’s future depends on sustained investment in people as much as infrastructure. By combining experienced specialists with structured training and career development pathways, we’re helping to drive positive change and build a stronger, more resilient workforce for the years ahead. SSH: Looking five or ten years out, do you see rail electrification in the UK as a maturing market with a natural ceiling, or is there still a long runway of new schemes to come?
SSH: Skills shortages come up constantly in rail infrastructure. What does SPL Powerlines’ own experience of the labour market look like right now, are you struggling to recruit specialist OLE engineers, or is the pipeline healthier than the industry’s reputation suggests?
LP: I don’t see rail electrification as a mature market approaching a natural ceiling. The UK and Ireland still have a significant proportion of railway infrastructure that is not electrified, while the industry’s longterm goals around decarbonisation, capacity enhancement, performance improvement, and operational efficiency continue to support the case for further electrification. Industry bodies such as RIA and the Rail Forum, alongside infrastructure owners, operators and contractors, consistently highlight the need for a sustained, rolling programme of electrification rather than a series of stop-start schemes. Looking five to ten years ahead, the opportunity is likely to be broader than just new electrification routes. It will include renewals, network upgrades, integration with alternative traction technologies, and the infrastructure needed to support a more sustainable railway. I believe electrification will become increasingly important not only because of
LP: Skills availability remains one of the biggest challenges facing the rail industry, and specialist OLE engineers are in high demand right across the market. Like many in our sector, we see recruitment pressures, particularly for experienced electrification professionals. However, the solution is not simply competing for the same pool of talent; it’s about creating the next generation of rail engineers. At SPL Powerlines UK&I, we’re investing heavily in apprenticeships, graduate development, and the upskilling of our
‘Rail electrification becomes significantly more expensive when programmes stop and start’
38
‘The industry should avoid viewing battery technology and electrification as competing solutions.’
decarbonisation targets, but also because of energy security, operational resilience and whole-life cost efficiency. Recent volatility in global energy markets has reinforced the importance of reducing reliance on imported fossil fuels. Electrification provides a pathway to a more resilient railway and, in time, I believe wider strategic considerations such as energy independence will become just as influential as carbon reduction in driving future investment decisions. From SPL Powerlines’ perspective, there remains a substantial pipeline of work ahead, particularly where innovation, cost efficiency, and long-term planning can help accelerate UK and Irish rail decarbonisation ambitions. SSH: If you had to name one thing the rail industry gets wrong about how it plans and procures electrification work, what would it be? LP: If I had to identify one issue, it would be the industry’s continued reliance on short-term funding cycles to deliver what is fundamentally a long-term infrastructure challenge. Across the industry, there is broad recognition that stop-start electrification programmes increase costs, reduce productivity, makes skills retention more difficult, and discourages investment in people, innovation, and supply chains. By contrast, a consistent, rolling programme allows clients, stakeholders and contractors to plan with greater certainty, build capability, and deliver projects much more efficiently over time. From SPL Powerlines’ perspective, the most successful electrification programmes are those that create continuity, encourage collaboration, and enable the industry to invest confidently in skills, technology, and delivery capability. That approach not only improves value for money but also supports the long-term decarbonisation, modernisation and resilience of the railway. The evidence is now overwhelming. Countries that commit to long-term rolling programmes consistently deliver electrification at lower cost and greater efficiency than those procuring projects in isolation. If the UK and Ireland are serious about rail decarbonisation, the focus should be on creating certainty, continuity and confidence throughout the supply chain.
#ELECTRIFYING TRANSITIONS
WWW.POWERLINES-GROUP.COM/UK 39
INTERVIEW
Mike Tuffy CEO, Optimas International Mike Tuffy is CEO of Optimas International, a global supplier of fasteners and supply chain solutions to the rail and transportation sectors. He joined the business at 16 on the warehouse floor and has spent 40 years within the organisation, progressing through roles in procurement, supply chain and international business development across the UK, Europe and the United States before being appointed CEO in 2022.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Mike Tuffy, CEO of Optimas International, about the Exponent acquisition, preparing for Great British Railways, and the growing appetite for component standardisation across the rail supply chain SSH: How did you get started in the industry, and when did you join the company? MT: I joined the business when I was just 16, starting on the warehouse floor picking, packing and shipping products. That handson experience at the heart of our business was invaluable and gave me the solid foundation on which I’ve built a 40-year career within the same organisation. In the four decades since, I’ve progressed through a number of leadership roles across procurement and supply chain, commercial leadership and international business development. I’ve spent much of my career leading teams across the UK, Europe and the United States, helping grow the business while building long-term partnerships with customers and suppliers. In 2022, I was appointed CEO of Optimas International. Having spent my entire career within the organisation, I bring a unique perspective to the role. I’ve seen firsthand how much both our organisation and the industry has evolved, and how the partnerships that endure are built on trust earned over many years. My experience gives me a deep understanding of the operational realities and strategic challenges our customers face, and that perspective is particularly important as we continue to invest in high-growth markets like rail, where relationships and programmes often span decades. 40
‘Rail is a long-term industry. Customers need stability as much as they need capability.’ SSH: What does the Exponent acquisition change for your UK rail and transportation customers in concrete terms? MT: The Exponent acquisition doesn’t change the day-to-day experience for our existing rail and transportation customers. Our people, relationships and commitment to delivering for our customers remain the same. What is changing is happening behind the scenes. Backing from Exponent gives us greater financial strength and supports long-term investment. We’re investing in our engineering capability, technology, inventory and people so we can continue to be well positioned to help customers simplify increasingly complex supply chains as programmes grow in scale. Rail is a long-term industry. Customers need stability as much as they need capability. The combination of local expertise, global scale and long-term
investment puts us in an even stronger position to support the sector well into the future. SSH: As Great British Railways consolidates the network, do you expect procurement and supplier relationships to shift, and how is Optimas preparing for that? MT: Great British Railways represents one of the biggest changes to the UK rail industry in decades. I expect procurement to become more coordinated, with greater emphasis on long-term value, supply chain resilience and standardisation. Suppliers will need to demonstrate not just competitive pricing, but quality, traceability, engineering expertise and the ability to support programmes throughout their lifecycle. The industry estimates that around twothirds of GBR’s spending will flow through the supply chain. Suppliers who can prove quality, traceability and value over the life of an asset will come out ahead as preferred partners. That’s where Optimas International is incredibly strong. We’re RISQS registered, members of the Railway Industry Association and we already help customers simplify supply chains through standardisation, managed inventory and rigorous quality processes. As the industry evolves, those capabilities become even more valuable.
INTERVIEW
SSH: What have your rail partnerships taught you about how manufacturers approach component standardisation, and is that appetite for rationalisation growing across the sector? MT: Without question, the appetite for standardisation and rationalisation is growing. Every rail manufacturer we speak to is looking for ways to simplify. As fleet lifespans continue to extend, product ranges become more complex and part numbers accumulate, managing that complexity comes at a cost. It impacts procurement, inventory management, maintenance efficiency and the ability to respond quickly to operational demands. Standardisation has become a strategic priority. Manufacturers are looking beyond the individual component and considering value to the wider supply chain. I expect this shift to accelerate as fleets continue to age and budgets tighten. We helped a UK rail customer rationalise and standardise its fastener range by 75 per cent, halve the number of product picks and saved them around €800,000 across the programme life, all without compromising engineering performance. That’s a strong example of how relatively small components can have a significant impact when you combine technical expertise, data analysis and supply chain knowledge to understand where standardisation can create the greatest impact. SSH: Where does managed inventory genuinely move the needle for a rail contractor or OEM, and where is it still being undersold? MT: Managed inventory delivers the greatest value wherever downtime, a stopped line or a delayed overhaul carries significant cost. In rail, that’s almost every programme. A missing clip or bracket may be inexpensive, but it can hold up a whole build or a depot turnaround. Where managed inventory is still underestimated is that it’s often seen
‘For us, sustainability isn’t about being perfect, it’s about making measurable improvements, being transparent and taking responsibility for the impact we have across our operations and supply chain.’
as purely a stock management solution. However, the real value is much broader. Our vendor-managed inventory (VMI) programmes, delivered through OptiTech®, improves continuity, reduces supply chain risk, simplifies planning and supports assets that remain in service for decades. Kitting is another area where our customers see
immediate value. Delivering pre-picked, fully sequenced kits reduces handling, improves productivity and allows engineers to focus on higher-value work. In essence, managed inventory keeps the right parts at the right point of use with real-time visibility, so production and maintenance don’t stop moving. When a 41
INTERVIEW
2.2 billion parts a year, and ‘A quality issue doesn’t haveWea supply zero-defect culture, so quality is simply built in to how we operate. We just affect the cost of help customers rationalise part numbers, a single component. It standardise across platforms and manage allowing them to reduce cost creates rework, delays, inventory, without compromising on quality. In a safety-critical sector, it’s less a balancing increased downtime act and more about aligning quality with and unnecessary risk.’ efficiency and long-term performance. fleet stays in service for 30 or 40 years, planning parts availability across its entire lifecycle is worth far more than simply reducing inventory levels today. SSH: How do you balance zero-defect supply standards against the commercial pressure your customers are under to reduce total cost of ownership? MT: I don’t see these objectives as competing, instead I believe they’re closely connected. A quality issue doesn’t just affect the cost of a single component. It creates rework, delays, increased downtime and unnecessary risk. Getting it right the first time is one of the most effective ways to reduce total cost of ownership.
42
SSH: When a rail project in the UK requires internationally sourced components, how do you manage the compliance and certification requirements specific to the British market? MT: Global sourcing gives our customers choice and value, but every part still has to meet the necessary UK rail standards. In practice that means rigorous quality control, material certification standards and full batch traceability from source through to platform. We are RISQS registered, members of the Railway Industry Association, and hold ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 certification. Our principle is simple. Our customers benefit from a global supply base and gain the confidence that every component is fully compliant with UK market requirements. We act as the control point and deliver on both at once.
SSH: How passionate are you about sustainability in the rail sector, and how do you go about sourcing the materials for your products? MT: Sustainability is an important part of how we deliver long-term value for our customers. Our approach is based on measurable progress. We’re committed to achieving Net Zero before 2050, with targets validated by the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi). Last year 60 per cent of our facility-based people worked at ISO 14001-certified sites, we diverted 73 per cent of waste from landfill and 60 per cent of our electricity came from renewable contracts. Responsible sourcing is equally important. Every supplier signs our Code of Conduct, and we audit the top 80 per cent of our spend against sustainability criteria. For us, sustainability isn’t about being perfect, it’s about making measurable improvements, being transparent and taking responsibility for the impact we have across our operations and supply chain. That means working with the right partners, making informed sourcing decisions and continuously working to reduce our overall environmental impact.
STATION REFURBISHMENT
Is the System Ready? Two major station schemes have opened or begun this year, backed by tens of millions of pounds in investment. But a parliamentary debate and a new industry report both argue that lifts and bridges are only part of the answer
R
ail’s accessibility problem is, on one level, a simple engineering one. Old stations were built with steps, narrow platforms and no lifts, and disabled passengers, older people and parents with buggies have paid the price ever since. On that front, progress is visible. Work has started on a £4.3m scheme to make Swinton station stepfree, part of a wider £100 million programme by Transport for Greater Manchester to remove barriers across the network. The project will deliver a new passenger lift, an accessible toilet and baby changing facilities, with the station remaining open throughout construction until completion in spring 2027. Bev Craig, Mayor of Greater Manchester, was blunt about what the old stations have meant in practice. ‘It’s not right that people need to travel miles to a different station or find another way to get around, just because they can’t get up the station stairs’ she said. Swinton is the latest of four stations currently being upgraded, following work already completed at Daisy Hill and Irlam. Eaglescliffe has just finished a comparable journey. A £14.5 million scheme funded jointly by Tees Valley Combined Authority, Network Rail and the Department for Transport has delivered a 56-metre footbridge, three new lifts and a 100-space car park, replacing a route that previously forced disabled passengers onto a steep ramp or a lengthy diversion. The scheme was formally opened by Tees Valley Mayor Ben Houchen alongside Baroness Tanni GreyThompson, a regular user of the station’s direct London services. ‘For too long, stations like Eaglescliffe have been difficult to navigate’ GreyThompson said. ‘These improvements make a real difference, helping people travel with confidence, independence and dignity.’ Between them, Swinton and Eaglescliffe make the case that sustained capital investment works, if it’s sustained. But two other interventions this year suggest that physical works, however welcome, are not the whole story. In March, Ruth Cadbury MP, Chair of the Commons Transport Committee, used a debate to press ministers on the findings
of the Committee’s Access Denied report. Her argument was not about missing lifts but about missing enforcement. ‘Disabled people often have rights on paper that do not translate into real experiences’ she told the House. ‘Enforcement relies on individual passengers pursuing complaints or court cases. This is unrealistic, expensive and often ineffective.’ The Government has yet to accept the Committee’s call for regulators to be given stronger powers, and Cadbury noted that a promised inclusive transport strategy has slipped past its original 2025 timeline. That argument is echoed, from a different angle, in a new Discovery Report from Community Rail Network and RNIB, part of a project funded by the Motability Foundation. Drawing on research, surveys and focus groups with disabled passengers, the report concludes that disability awareness training, while widespread across the industry, is not sufficient on its own. Staffing levels, communication between teams, the reliability of information and organisational culture all shape whether a journey is genuinely accessible, alongside the physical design of stations and trains. ‘This report highlights the importance of looking beyond training alone and considering the wider systems, environments and cultures that shape people’s experiences of rail travel’ said Chris Birks, Community Rail Network’s Director of Policy and Communications. Both organisations stressed that disabled people need to be involved in shaping services and decisions, not consulted after the fact. Capital schemes such as Swinton and Eaglescliffe are tangible, fundable and popular with local politicians keen to be photographed beside a new lift. Enforcement reform and cultural change inside operators are slower, harder to announce and, on the evidence of Cadbury’s exchange with the Minister for Aviation, Maritime and Decarbonisation Keir Mather, still some way from a firm timetable. Government engagement on a planned Accessibility Charter was welcomed in the debate, but Cadbury was clear it ‘must be more than a restatement of existing duties.’
NE WS IN BRIE F LIVE FACIAL RECOGNITION TRIAL AT TRANSPORT FOR LONDON STATIONS British Transport Police (BTP) has launched a trial of Live Facial Recognition (LFR) technology at selected Transport for London (TfL) stations, supported by TfL, as part of efforts to improve safety across the network and tackle sexual violence, harassment and intimidation. The technology generates alerts only for individuals on an authorised BTP watchlist linked to serious and highharm offences including robbery, knife crime and sexual assault; images of people who are not a match are not retained. Stations for the trial are chosen based on operational intelligence and crime data analysis, with the first deployment taking place at Victoria Underground station on 11 August. The trial follows TfL research involving over 3,000 women, girls and parents across London, which found that 77 per cent of 13- to 16-yearold girls surveyed had experienced unwanted sexual behaviour on a journey involving public transport in the previous 12 months, and 40 per cent of women surveyed said they had avoided a journey because they felt unsafe. Siwan Hayward, Director of Security, Policing and Enforcement at Transport for London, said tackling violence against women and girls remained a key priority, and that LFR had the potential to be a powerful additional tool in helping police identify those wanted for high-harm offences. TfL will monitor and assess the impact of the trial over the next four months.
43
STATION REFURBISHMENT INNOTRANS
Global Ambitions Suramya Nevatia, Chairman & Managing Director of Hirect, on the company’s expanding global footprint and what to expect from the business at InnoTrans 2026
The recent milestones point the way: as we continue to scale our electric locomotive business, we have now secured our first trainset order, covering the complete train electrics and our first IGBT-based MEMU propulsion order. Trainsets are where Indian Railways is heading, and we intend to be at the centre of that transition. Alongside India, we are building a global business. We manufacture in India and France, we have incorporated a subsidiary in Dubai to serve Europe, the Middle East and Africa, and we have recently concluded business in the United States that expands us both regionally and by application. I expect our company to grow its revenues and relevance exponentially and globally over the next few years. SSH: Tell us about Hirect’s role in the rail sector and how the business has evolved over recent years? SN: Hirect has grown alongside Indian Railways for almost seven decades, first as a major supplier of transformers and rectifiers for its locomotives, and progressively as a power electronics company, as indigenous electric traction technology matured. Today Hirect holds the leading market share in traction transformers, serving a network that is now almost fully electrified, clean and efficient, in a country home to 18 per cent of the world’s population. In recent years we have made great strides in power electronics for rail applications and are shipping high-power IGBT converters, auxiliary power supplies and SiC battery chargers, along with traction motors and HVAC systems, to Indian Railways. The future looks brighter still: our locomotive propulsion system has completed acceptance, and we have secured our first trainset orders: the complete power and control systems for Mainline Electric Multiple Unit (MEMU) and Vande Metro (Namo Bharat) passenger trains. SSH: What are your ambitions for the business over the next few years? SN: Our ambition is to complete the shift from component manufacturer to vertically integrated systems and solutions provider. 44
SSH: You’ve recently completed a significant test of your in-house propulsion system in the US. What did that milestone mean for Hirect? SN: The announcement covered our success in powering Indian Railways locomotives with a propulsion system designed and produced entirely in-house. Beyond the obvious revenue growth opportunity, this technical qualification under a rigorous test regime is a testament to Hirect’s engineering, manufacturing and quality management systems. SSH: This year’s InnoTrans marks the show’s thirtieth anniversary, with a lot of the programme built around global growth, digitalisation and decarbonisation across the industry. How does Hirect’s own story fit into that wider narrative? SN: Decarbonisation is the challenge of our times, and we feel privileged to play a part in this transformation. That the technology also makes commercial sense is not incidental, it is a requirement for the transition to succeed, and we expect to grow alongside the market and our fellow contributors at InnoTrans 2026. Hirect’s role sits squarely in the supply chain for this shift: propulsion and power conversion equipment that enables the move from diesel to hybrid, electric and alternative energy sources such as hydrogen.
With manufacturing in India and France, we are also part of the industry’s global growth story, serving one of the world’s fastest-expanding rail markets while building a European footprint. We have started catering to business opportunities from different regions such as EU, Africa, East Asia and USA. And as rail systems become more digital, the intelligence built into our converters and chargers is increasingly as important as the power electronics themselves. SSH: InnoTrans is such a significant moment for the industry. What can visitors expect to see from Hirect this year? SN: InnoTrans is both a forum for discussion and the most important marketplace for the world’s key rail technologists, financiers, planners and visionaries. Our contribution to the show is bigger than ever: we are bringing all of our latest products like the High Power converters, Variety of Power Modules, our Traction Motor and assorted electronic products along with a large contingent from R&D, engineering, procurement, manufacturing, sales and marketing, along with our executive team, to teach, to learn and to celebrate our industry. SSH: What are you hoping to get out of the show, in terms of conversations, partnerships, or new markets? SN: Exposure, obviously – and we expect plenty of business as a result of our attendance – but the nuts and bolts of brand management, lead generation and product presentation are not the only reason to attend a show. What I look forward to most is the unexpected: the unanticipated compounding of opportunity that happens whenever smart people with converging interests get together. SSH: Is there anything you’re particularly looking forward to at this year’s event, whether that’s your own stand or the wider show? SN: I’m deeply thankful for the great relationship we have developed with Indian
INNOTRANS
Railways, and I believe the products and technologies we have created under their guidance are more than ready to satisfy the burgeoning worldwide demand for highpower electronics systems. I’m particularly looking forward to meeting international customers whose needs we can fulfil with our products and expertise. SSH: You’ve recently brought copper conductor manufacturing in-house at a new plant. What was behind that decision, and what does it add to your capability as a manufacturer? SN: Being a reliable, high-quality manufacturer is front and centre at Hirect, and we saw copper wire availability for our motors and transformers as a key supply chain risk. By controlling our copper, we control our destiny for these product lines – and it doesn’t hurt that we now control cost and quality too. We also have limited excess capacity that we’re willing to share, offering the same benefits to a small number of companies with similar goals.
SSH: Hirect designs and builds a lot of its technology in-house, from power electronics through to control software, rather than licensing it in. How would you describe your approach to engineering and product development? SN: We take – I take – responsibility for every promise we make at Hirect, from delivery guarantees to product quality, and further into the implied promise of fair treatment and ethical behaviour that a long-term business relationship requires. Part of that is making sure we have the tools and systems in place to deliver on those promises, and sometimes that means having complete control – as we do over our power engineering, our electronics and electrical systems manufacturing, and even the dielectric coating on our copper wire. We even make our PCBs in-house, at the factories of Elventive – in Mumbai, India and La Ferté-Bernard, France. SSH: As the business grows quickly and moves into new markets, how do you go about maintaining consistency and quality across your manufacturing? SN: There is no more pressing need, nor more important investment, at Hirect than product quality. Quality starts in R&D, with the design of products that can be manufactured in volume to a high standard, and that ethos extends through to engineering and manufacturing and into our after-sales service. I don’t think there is any alternative to making significant investments in people, skills, systems & processes and software – and that is what we have done and will continue to do.
45
STATION REFURBISHMENT INNOTRANS
Jorge Aldegunde Global Head of Railway Services at DNV
Jorge Aldegunde is Global Head of Railway Services at DNV, where he leads the company’s systems assurance and cybersecurity work across the rail sector. He sits on the working group drafting IEC 63452, the emerging international rail cybersecurity standard, and is DNV’s cybersecurity representative for NB-Rail, the European association of notified bodies responsible for conformity assessment in rail.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Jorge Aldegunde about embedding cybersecurity into the Santiago de los Caballeros monorail from the design stage, trialling the draft IEC 63452 standard on a live project, and why GoA4 automation raises the stakes of a successful attack SSH: The Santiago de los Caballeros monorail is being delivered to GoA4, the highest automation grade, running fully driverless. Does that level of automation change the cybersecurity brief compared with a driver-operated system? JA: In cybersecurity, much as in safety, we use a risk-based approach built on likelihood, exposure, attack surface and consequence. Because the system is designed from the outset to run at GoA4, fully automated, the severity of any disruption caused by a cyber attack will be far greater than it would be under GoA2 or conventional driver-based operation, even where that operation is supported by technical assistance systems. GoA4 isn’t new in itself. It’s part of a broader trend in the automation and digitalisation of transport systems, a logical consequence of how much these systems 46
now rely on technical infrastructure. But there’s a key difference from functional safety. In safety, the question is essentially whether an incident can occur. In cyber, the question is when an attack will succeed, not if. So the analysis isn’t really focused on the attack surface itself, it’s focused on consequence. That’s why we take a holistic approach: the technology layer, but also process and procedure. Preparedness needs to be in place before commissioning, so that once the system is in full operation there are known routines for how to respond. Alongside that sits protection at component level, system level and supply chain level. In a system built to run automatically, with passengers on board trains and in stations, the key question becomes what happens when an issue affects a train, a station, or the Operations Control Centre, where control is centralised, or when the
attack is at system level rather than a single point. In safety, consequences are measured in damage to technical systems and assets, and harm to people, including injuries or casualties. In cybersecurity, we’re also weighing impact on system availability and reliability, since that’s a core part of what a successful attack can take away. SSH: Cybersecurity has traditionally been treated as something added on to rail projects rather than built in from the start. Is that changing? JA: Yes, and I think this project is a good illustration of it. In systems engineering more broadly, you’d typically look at reliability, availability, maintainability and safety (RAMS), alongside things like life-cycle costing, electromagnetic compatibility and fire safety. Cybersecurity has traditionally sat outside that, treated
INNOTRANS
as something complementary rather than integrated into the full life cycle. What we’re now seeing in emerging regulation is the same risk-based, lifecycle approach that underpins safety, from concept through to acceptance, then operations and maintenance, being applied to cyber for the first time. That’s the real change. On Santiago de los Caballeros, DNV started out as the systems assurance provider under a RAMS-style, conceptto-acceptance scope. We then proposed to the different project stakeholders, systems integrators, contractors and the end customer that cybersecurity be incorporated as part of that same scope from the start, rather than being disconnected or only partially connected. As part of that, we chose to work with IEC 63452, a cybersecurity standard for rail that’s still in draft form but is expected to become an international railway cybersecurity standard, potentially in early 2027. Our reasoning was that if this was going to be the benchmark within six months or so, it was worth trialling it now, on a live, greenfield project, so we could learn firsthand what applying it actually means, and feed that experience back into the standard. Aligning stakeholders around this took time and effort, and it’s still ongoing. It isn’t only a matter of using the same terminology, though that matters too. Different stakeholders come to cyber from different backgrounds: some move across from signalling and safety because of the safety implications, some come from an IT background and are still building their connection to OT, and a smaller group come from OT itself. They don’t all weight the same things as the dominant risk factor, whether that’s supply chain, the human factor, or the purely technical side, which tends to be the instinct for people with a signalling and safety background. Being a greenfield project helps in one sense, since every component, from telecoms and signalling to rolling stock, is new rather than legacy. But it also means not every stakeholder or contractor started out with the same level of cyber maturity or the same cyber goals, and that alignment remains one of the main challenges of bringing this in from day one. SSH: The contract runs across design, construction, integration and testing for the monorail. At what point does DNV’s involvement typically end? JA: Our base proposal mirrors our classical systems assurance, RAMS-style engagement: concept through to systems acceptance. That’s where our baseline scope currently concludes, in the same way it would on a conventional RAMS contract. Beyond that, we’ve proposed a flexible, optional package to define what a Security Operations Centre (SOC) for the system might look like after commissioning:
the technology layers, such as endpoint protection systems, intrusion detection systems, and SIEM (security information and event management) platforms, together with the process and procedure layers and the qualifications needed for the people running it. We’re vendor- and technologyagnostic in that proposal. The point isn’t to promote a particular brand or component, but to set out what’s available in the market and how it could be used as a postcommissioning layer. The rationale is that cybersecurity doesn’t really end at commissioning. If you take a snapshot of the system’s cybersecurity case at that point and treat it as settled, it can become obsolete almost immediately once any change is made to switches, routers, firewalls, signalling devices or OCC-related systems, however small. Given that in an OT system the data flowing through the network tends to stay largely consistent over time, there’s also real value in being able to build up a picture of what a normal pattern looks like, and by extension what an attack pattern might look like, which supports the case for continuous monitoring rather than a one-off assessment. There’s also scope to scale this SOC beyond the monorail itself. The same Operations Control Centre also serves a cable car system already operating in the city, so a SOC built for the monorail could potentially extend to cover both. The operational and contractual model for this post-commissioning phase isn’t yet fully defined, which is part of the complexity, and the optional scope may or may not ultimately involve DNV operating it directly. The aim is to define what the SOC needs to look like regardless of who eventually operates it. SSH: Cybersecurity has been named one of InnoTrans’ headline themes this year, alongside AI and autonomous public transport. What’s changed since previous editions to earn it that billing? JA: I’ve been attending InnoTrans more or less continuously since around 2008, so I’ve seen the trends evolve. The last two years in particular have shown a real change with respect to digital transformation in rail, with cyber and related topics starting to connect as part of a wider picture rather than sitting in isolation. Cyber is, in a way, coming of age. It’s still a niche area within rail, much as OT is a niche area generally, but there’s a growing level of maturity among stakeholders. Two years ago, there was often little alignment in these discussions, and in some cases not even recognition of the need for it. Conversations could go on without reaching anything close to agreement, more like disconnected satellites than a shared conversation. Cybersecurity regulation is evolving now, and even though that regulatory picture is still complex, you can see stakeholders coming together around
it, along with related questions like what cybersecurity by design means for a large enterprise versus an SME, and the human factor as a weak link in the supply chain. AI is part of the same shift. Narrow applications, such as machine vision used to detect anomalies or isolated objects at stations via CCTV, have existed for a long time, and machine learning has already been used for use cases like maintenance. What’s newer is generative AI and more fully AI-enabled applications, and there’s a cyber dimension to that too: what happens when AI is applied by attackers, and what happens when it’s applied by those defending systems. There’s also a growing recognition, partly driven by regulation, that cybersecurity isn’t only a cost, but can also be a source of value, and that regulation brings liabilities that sit with senior management, not just with a technical team. The Cyber Resilience Act, for example, applies to products with digital elements, which by now is almost every product. And we’re operating in a geopolitically complex environment, where conflict increasingly takes hybrid forms across multiple operating scenarios at once. For critical sectors like transport, that’s no longer something that can be treated as background noise. Two years ago it wasn’t quite as prominent in these discussions. Now it can’t be skipped. SSH: InnoTrans has framed this year’s edition around mobility on a global scale, with infrastructure increasingly planned and delivered across borders. Are client standards and delivery teams genuinely crossing borders on a single project when it comes to cybersecurity? JA: European rail wasn’t originally designed to interoperate. That came later, and it’s how the industry ended up building interoperability, and everything linked to it around safety, into a shared framework. You see similarly large-scale, cross-border projects in other regions too, the GCC in the Middle East being one example. Cyber, for cross-border projects, is still at an early stage by comparison. You could say we’re seeing the tip of the iceberg, with what’s underneath still largely unaddressed. Different regions apply different standards, often with different levels of detail and sometimes describing different things: the US has one applicable set of horizontal regulation, Europe another, Australia its AS7770 standard, and these need to be reconciled and interpreted against each other. Emerging vertical rail standards should help provide more of a common denominator. IEC 63452 is a genuinely international IEC standard rather than a European one; roughly 150 professionals are involved in drafting it, from countries including Japan and Korea as well as across Europe. Even once contracts in different geographies are asking for adherence to 47
STATION REFURBISHMENT INNOTRANS
‘If you take a snapshot of the system’s cybersecurity case at that point and treat it as settled, it can become obsolete almost immediately once any change is made to switches, SSH: Will DNV have a presence at routers, firewalls, InnoTrans this year, and what’s the focus? signalling devices or JA: DNV carries a lot of value as a brand, and that’s something we lean on. The OCC-related systems, core message we want to bring is that we’re alongside stakeholders through the however small.’ the same standard, there will still be plenty to interpret and contractual requirements will still differ, but a shared standard base should help. Cross-border cyber alignment remains a challenge, partly because cross-border rail projects are already challenging without a cyber dimension. We see that in projects across the Middle East, including the UAE and Saudi Arabia, where different parts of a programme can sit at very different levels of maturity. Europe is somewhat more straightforward, since the EU’s cybersecurity agency ENISA and the European Union Agency for Railways already work together.
current transformations in rail, not only on safety, but on smart solutions, smart supply chains, smart stakeholders, smart contracts and smart railways more broadly. We’re pitching as an entity that’s there to listen and understand the pain points across different clients, rather than only delivering assurance or systems engineering. Our offering in rail is holistic: we act as a thirdparty certification entity, but we also want to be present on the digital side and help introduce innovation. 48
Santiago de los Caballeros is a good example of that approach in practice. We’re not there to run a formal assessment against IEC 63452, since it isn’t yet a published standard. We’re there to work out how best to apply it, both to improve the standard itself and to improve cyber resilience on that project.
We also want to reinforce our position close to the operators and owners actually running these assets, and our focus on asset performance and sustainability, both being central to DNV’s wider vision and mission beyond rail specifically. That matters in an industry where assets can remain in service for up to 50 years. Beyond our established position in third-party risk and safety management, we’d like to be seen as engaged in the wider conversation around AI governance and the ethical use of AI in rail, in line with existing and emerging regulation, but grounded in a pragmatic approach to how assets actually perform. SSH: How much of DNV’s rail work now is about meeting the regulatory bar set by rules like NIS2 and the Cyber Resilience Act, as opposed to driving genuine operational risk reduction? JA: We made an internal effort to understand this regulation in depth, position ourselves at the leading edge of it, and work out where the gaps are that will affect its implementation. Talking to people who sit on the technical groups drafting this regulation, the common theme is that the real difficulty emerges once you try to bring it down to a specific contract. That’s where the discussion gets complicated, and it’s where we’ve tried to work. That effort runs across three areas. The first is cyber risk scouting, understanding
INNOTRANS
what’s actually available in the market, within Europe and beyond. The second is participating directly in the regulatory frameworks themselves. Alongside our role in the IEC 63452 working group, DNV is the cybersecurity representative for NB-Rail, the European association of notified bodies responsible for conformity assessment in rail, covering both interoperability and safety-related aspects. That puts us in a position to bridge between other conformity assessment bodies, industry bodies such as UNIFE, and the wider sector. The third is finding practical projects, Santiago de los Caballeros being the clearest example, where we can trial application of the regulation, encourage stakeholders to be among the first to use it, and identify where the regulation itself may still need fixing or isn’t fully adjusted to reality. We also share what we learn, internally and externally. Since DNV’s new strategy began on 1 January 2026, cyber has become a core element within the business, not confined to rail. It runs across maritime, our classical industry, energy systems and industrial services more broadly, of which rail is part. On the specific instruments: NIS2 targets operators of critical infrastructure, while
the CRA targets products and introduces mandatory manufacturer obligations, and there are working groups trying to work out what that means specifically for rail, without full consensus yet on some points. Our aim is to ground that regulation in the practical realities of rail: long life cycles, existing contracts, and delivery dates that clients are already working towards, rather than dealing with it only at the level of headlines.
‘In safety, the question is essentially whether an incident can occur. In cyber, the question is when an attack will SSH: Do you think the maturity of cybersecurity regulation and AI regulation succeed, not if.’ are running in parallel? JA: Cybersecurity is more advanced. AI regulation remains more open, closer to a ‘wild west’, even though the potential of AI is huge. That creates a real tension between the right governance approach, the right ethical use, and how you assure AI itself against the range of innovations being built on it, something DNV sees regularly in its own work and in dealing with contractors. Combining cybersecurity and AI raises further questions: how AI can be used for more dynamic protection of assets and for cyber resilience, but equally how it might be used by attackers, including AI-led tools already being marketed that claim to help identify unprotected points
in a system. Historically, use cases in emerging technology tend to arrive first, with regulation trying to catch up and anchor them afterwards, and there’s no reason to expect AI’s development to be any different. Cyber regulation already assigns liability directly to individuals in management positions within a company. It’s likely something similar will develop for AI, including in Europe’s AI Act, though that will take time given how geopolitically charged the debate around AI already is.
DELIVERING SAFER, SMARTER AND SECURE RAILWAYS Independent assurance, certification and advisory services acroiss the rail lifecycle.
Safety and risk management
Assurance and Certification
Cybersecurity and digital trust
Asset performance and sustainability
Independent expertise
Your rail challenges. Our expertise. Meet us at InnoTrans 2026, CityCube, Hall A #250
49
Transport Benevolent Fund CIO
All about people...
people working in public transport
Help and support for you, your live-in partner and dependent children during times of need
A comprehensive range of health, welfare and financial support for less than 20p per day.
JOIN ONLINE TODAY www.tbf.org.uk
Registered charity: England and Wales 1160901, Scotland SC047016.
50
INNOTRANS
InnoTrans 2026 Set to Be the Most International Edition Yet InnoTrans marks its 30th anniversary this year with what organisers describe as its most international edition to date, as the Berlin exhibition grounds prepare to welcome more than 3,000 exhibitors and around 170,000 trade visitors from 22 to 25 September
D
elegations from 18 countries and exhibitors from around 60 nations will attend with this year’s opening theme Mobility on a global scale reflects that international dimension. The opening ceremony will feature political leaders and senior executives from France, Greece, the Czech Republic, India and Germany, while a new EU-Africa Transport Dialogue will take place on 23 September, bringing together European and African partners for the first time. Strong US and Chinese participation Participation from the United States is particularly strong this year, with around 50 exhibitors including Progress Rail, Wabtec and Amsted Rail. The California High-Speed Rail Authority will present its own stand for the first time, having previously sent trade visitors to Berlin without formal exhibition space. Delegations from DB E.C.O. North America, the Federal Railroad Association and the Commuter Rail Association are also expected. China will be represented by major industry players including CARS, CAMET and CRRC, alongside large delegations from across the Asia-Pacific region. The Malaysia National Pavilion will sit alongside the Australasian Railway Association joint stand,
while South Korea, Japan and Taiwan will each have dedicated national presences. European representation remains strong, with joint stands from the UK’s Railway Industry Association, Spain’s Mafex, and national pavilions from Portugal, Denmark, Hungary, Belgium, Finland and the Czech Republic, among others. France will be represented by Alstom, Business France and the SNCF.
Tunnel and infrastructure segments converge
The Tunnel Construction and Railway Infrastructure segments continue to grow closer together, with nearly 600 exhibitors occupying more than 32,000 square metres, a five per cent increase in exhibitor numbers compared with the 2024 event. Major names in this segment include FOGTEC, Orascom Construction, Vossloh, Pandrol and Plasser & Theurer. ‘Tunnels are far more than just transport structures’ said Professor Roland Leucker, Managing Director of industry association STUVA. ‘They are key to sustainable mobility and help to improve quality of life and conserve land.’ STUVA will run two International Tunnel Forums during the event, focusing on sustainable mobility and the use of artificial
intelligence in tunnel construction and operation. The event will also host the launch of the European Network of Infrastructure Managers on 23 September.
New additions mark the milestone year
The anniversary edition introduces several new features, including the AI on Track Hackathon, in which more than 50 programmers will compete on real industry challenges, and a Young Generation Round Table designed for younger professionals attending the show. A dedicated roundtable will also recognise long-standing InnoTrans exhibitors who have shaped the exhibition since its early years. Night trains receive a dedicated focus for the first time, with new overnight rail concepts on display. Thibault Constant, a winner of the 2024 Railway Influencer Awards, returns to InnoTrans as part of an exhibitor group presenting a new night train concept. Looking ahead, InnoTrans Asia will make its stage debut with its own stand this year, ahead of its launch in Singapore from 7 to 9 September 2027.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Kerstin Schulz, Director of InnoTrans, about the exhibition’s 30th anniversary, this year’s global framing, and the new additions marking a milestone edition. 51
STATION REFURBISHMENT INNOTRANS
Kerstin Schulz Director of InnoTrans
KS: Over the years, InnoTrans has evolved into a much larger and more international event, now bringing together more than 3,000 exhibitors and around 170,000 trade visitors. At the same time, it has become a reflection of the industry’s defining trends: digitalisation, automation, cybersecurity, alternative propulsion systems, autonomous public transport and, more recently, artificial intelligence. When InnoTrans first opened its doors 30 years ago with just 172 exhibitors, no one could have predicted that it would develop in this direction. SSH: This year’s opening theme is Mobility on a global scale What’s driving that global framing specifically for 2026? KS: The rail industry thinks and operates internationally. Many of today’s and tomorrow’s major infrastructure projects are planned and delivered across national borders. The fact that we welcome trade visitors from 128 countries underlines this international dimension. Our opening ceremony reflects the same approach, featuring political leaders and senior executives from France, Greece, the Czech Republic, India and Germany. The title of the opening event is intended to acknowledge the increasingly global nature of our industry. SSH: AI, autonomous public transport and cybersecurity are all headline themes this year. Which of those do you expect to generate the most genuinely new content on the show floor, rather than just conference discussion? KS: InnoTrans has always been about creating fresh momentum, and much of that comes from the personal exchange between our international visitors. Visitors will also 52
experience genuine innovations first-hand through a wide range of world premieres, which have long been one of the trademarks of InnoTrans. Artificial intelligence will gain an additional practical dimension through the premiere of the AI on Track Hackathon. More than 50 programmers from around the world will collaborate on real industry challenges, with the most innovative solutions being recognised at the end of the competition. This demonstrates that innovations are not only presented at InnoTrans. They are also created here. SSH: Night trains have a dedicated focus this year. What’s behind that renewed interest from exhibitors? KS: The guiding principle of InnoTrans has always been The Future of Mobility, and night trains are very much part of that future. The concepts visitors will see this year are genuinely innovative and demonstrate how overnight rail travel can become even more efficient, attractive and comfortable. I am particularly pleased that Thibault Constant, one of the winners of the 2024 Railway Influencer Awards, will return to InnoTrans, this time as part of an exhibitor group presenting a new night train concept. SSH: The new Hackathon and Young Generation Round Table are both firsttime additions. What gap were you looking to fill with them? KS: I have already spoken about the Hackathon, where I believe a very special dynamic will emerge. The Young Generation Roundtable pursues a similar objective. InnoTrans has always been a place where the industry comes together to network and exchange ideas. Since we welcome many young professionals to the exhibition, we wanted to create a dedicated format designed specifically for them.
We are also introducing a roundtable for InnoTrans pioneers—people who have helped shape the exhibition from the very beginning and have accompanied us throughout its development. Our anniversary provides the perfect opportunity to recognise their long-standing commitment as well. SSH: With several major companies represented by new CEOs attending their first InnoTrans, has that changed the tone of the conversations you’re having in the run-up to the event? KS: Quite the opposite. The discussions leading up to this year’s event have been characterised by the same mutual appreciation as always. Over the years, we have built an exceptional level of trust with many of our exhibitors. Most industry representatives have known InnoTrans for many years. As we often say within the rail sector: ‘Once you’re in rail, you’re always in rail.’ SSH: What would you say is the single biggest difference visitors will notice at this edition compared with 2024? KS: This year’s InnoTrans will be a very special edition as we celebrate our 30th anniversary with a range of dedicated activities. For example, we have produced a limitededition anniversary T-shirt, which has already become highly sought after. Another highlight will be the Anniversary Night – InnoTrans Goes Asia. While celebrating our anniversary, the event will also look ahead to the future with the launch of InnoTrans Asia, which will take place for the first time in Singapore in September 2027. In this way, we are not only celebrating our history but also building a bridge towards the next chapter of the InnoTrans story.
IMAGE CREDIT :MESSE BERLIN
SSH: InnoTrans is marking its 30th anniversary this year. Looking back over three decades, what’s changed most about the event itself?
Expert rail insight. Practical solutions. Lasting impact. Rail is facing increasingly complex challenges, from improving safety and performance to delivering sustainability goals, managing change and embracing new technologies. RSSB’s consultancy services combine deep industry expertise, evidence-based insight and practical experience to help organisations solve problems, reduce risk and make informed decisions with confidence. Whether you’re shaping strategy, delivering projects or responding to emerging challenges, our specialists can help you turn knowledge into action. Discover how RSSB consultancy can help your organisation.
Talk to our experts: www.rssb.co.uk/services-and-resources/rail-consultancy-services 53
STATION REFURBISHMENT
Engineering Passenger Information
P
Why specifying technologies built to last is becoming the defining challenge for modern railway passenger information systems
assenger Information Systems (PIS) and Customer Information Systems (CIS) have become one of the defining elements of the modern railway experience. Every day, passengers rely on digital information delivered through ticket vending machines, ticket gateways, interactive wayfinding totems, platform displays and on-board information systems to travel with confidence. Whilst expectations for real-time information continue to increase, the infrastructure supporting those journeys is expected to remain operational for far longer. Railway stations and rolling stock are designed with service lives measured in decades, meaning the technologies specified today must continue to deliver reliable performance long after today’s software, communications standards and passenger expectations have evolved. This presents an important challenge for OEMs, system integrators and infrastructure providers. The question is no longer simply whether a technology meets today’s specification, but whether it will continue to support tomorrow’s operational demands, accessibility requirements and digital capabilities without introducing unnecessary redesign, disruption or lifecycle cost. The most successful passenger information systems are no longer those built around individual products. They are built around technologies that remain reliable, adaptable and supportable throughout the life of the infrastructure.
Longevity begins during specification
Every technology decision made during the design phase has long-term consequences. Selecting components with short commercial lifecycles can introduce unnecessary engineering effort when redesigns become unavoidable. Equally, specifying technologies designed for industrial applications can significantly reduce future risk by providing extended product availability, consistent performance and greater supply chain stability. 54
Display technology is a good example. Unlike consumer displays, Industrial TFT Displays are developed for continuous operation in demanding environments, offering high brightness, wide operating temperature ranges and long-term availability. For railway applications, this provides engineers with greater confidence that passenger information systems can continue operating reliably whilst reducing the likelihood of costly hardware changes during the lifetime of the project. As railway programmes increasingly focus on reducing total cost of ownership, selecting technologies with proven longevity has become as important as selecting the highest technical specification.
Intelligent passenger information requires intelligent architecture
Passenger information has evolved well beyond displaying departure times. Modern railway stations increasingly operate as connected digital environments, where multiple information sources are expected to work together seamlessly. Ticket vending machines, passenger information displays, interactive wayfinding, station management systems and remote monitoring platforms all contribute to a single passenger experience. As this ecosystem grows, embedded computing is becoming central to the architecture supporting it. Rather than deploying separate display and computing platforms, many system designers are now adopting integrated solutions such as the LITEMAX Transportation Panel PC range. Combining industrial display technology with embedded computing within a single platform simplifies integration whilst providing the processing capability required for realtime information, remote diagnostics, cybersecurity, content management and future software enhancements. This integrated approach also provides greater flexibility as passenger information systems continue to evolve, allowing new functionality to be introduced without fundamentally changing the underlying hardware architecture.
Reliability is engineered into every layer
Passengers notice when information is unavailable, but the reasons behind system failures are often hidden beneath the surface. Long-term reliability depends upon far more than display quality. Environmental conditions, vibration, changing temperatures, moisture and continuous operation all place significant demands on railway equipment. Technologies such as VacuBond® optical bonding play an important role in improving display performance by reducing internal reflections, enhancing readability in bright ambient light and helping protect displays from the effects of condensation. Whilst largely invisible to passengers, these engineering decisions contribute significantly to long-term operational reliability. The same principle applies to power architecture. Stable and resilient power conversion underpins every passenger information system, yet is rarely seen by the end user. Solutions such as the AUTRONIC HFC150-W/G DC/DC converter, with its ultra-wide input voltage range, help manufacturers standardise designs across multiple international railway voltage systems, simplifying engineering whilst supporting reliable operation throughout the service life of the equipment. When considered together, display technology, embedded computing, optical bonding and power architecture form the foundation of dependable passenger information infrastructure.
Engineering for accessibility and sustainability
Passenger information must be designed for everyone. Accessibility is no longer viewed as a separate design consideration but as an integral part of delivering a better passenger experience. High-contrast graphics, excellent readability, wide viewing angles and clear presentation all contribute towards making information easier to understand for every passenger, regardless of age or ability. At the same time, sustainability is influencing how new infrastructure is deployed. Reducing energy consumption
STATION REFURBISHMENT
and extending equipment life are becoming increasingly important objectives across the railway sector. This is creating opportunities for alternative display technologies in specific applications. Ultra-low power solutions such as the LITEMAX IEPA-1330-RKC3-WGLD dual-screen ePaper platform suitable for Bus stations offer an innovative approach for passenger information in remote or temporary locations. Because ePaper only consumes power when content changes, it enables battery-powered or solar-assisted installations where providing continuous mains power may be impractical or prohibitively expensive. Whilst conventional high-brightness displays remain the preferred choice for many real-time passenger information applications, emerging technologies such as ePaper demonstrate how different engineering approaches can help address changing operational requirements.
The value of engineering partnership
Technology alone does not guarantee long-term success. As railway projects become increasingly complex, engineers are often balancing performance, lifecycle expectations, environmental requirements, accessibility objectives and future upgrade paths within a single project. This makes
technology selection a collaborative process rather than a simple purchasing decision. Working with engineering partners who understand the interaction between display technology, embedded computing and power architecture can simplify specification, reduce development risk and help ensure that today’s decisions continue delivering value throughout the operational life of the system. Ultimately, successful passenger information is not defined by the latest display, the fastest processor or the newest software feature. It is defined by selecting technologies that remain reliable, maintainable and adaptable for many years after installation.
Looking beyond today’s requirements
The railway industry has always invested with the future in mind. Passenger information should be no different. Artificial intelligence, edge computing, predictive maintenance and increasingly connected transport networks will continue to reshape how passengers receive information throughout their journeys. However, these innovations will only realise their full potential if the underlying technologies are capable of supporting continuous evolution rather than repeated replacement.
For organisations specifying passenger information systems today, perhaps the most important question is not: ‘Does this technology meet today’s requirements?’ Instead, it is: ‘Will this technology still be supporting passengers ten years from now?’ The answer to that question will increasingly determine not only the resilience of railway infrastructure, but also the quality, accessibility and reliability of the passenger experience for years to come.
Address: FORTEC TECHNOLOGY UK LIMITED Osprey House, 1 Osprey Court Hinchingbrooke Business Park Huntingdon, PE29 6FN Tel: +44(0)1480 411600 Email: info@fortec.uk Visit: www.fortec.uk
Long product lifecycles
Reliable displays and embedded computing for PIS & CIS systems
Rugged technologies (optical bonding) engineered for 24/7 performance
Power solutions that keep systems running
Built for the future
55
ASSURANCE & RISK MANAGEMENT FOR OPERATIONAL RAILWAYS REVOLUTIONISING HAZARD MANAGEMENT
Built by railway professionals, ARMOR brings hazard management into one practical platform, specifically for rail. Designed from real railway experience to deliver a smarter, simpler approach to hazard management. railwayassurance.com enquiries@railwayassurance.co.uk
ARMOR is part of Railway Assurance's Ltd assurance and risk management services.
CSM-RA & INTEROPERABILITY TRAINING COURSE
Ideal for Project managers, Engineers, Safety professionals, Sponsors and Stakeholders.
THE UK'S ONLY CPD-CERTIFIED COURSE OF ITS KIND
CSM-RA principles and legislation
A one-day course that combines theoretical and practical approaches and regulatory knowledge with real-world railway application
Significance Assessment
A fantastic opportunity to earn 6 hours of CPD and an official CPD certificate to aid in your professional development.
Independent Assessment (AsBo) requirements
Hazard Identification and Management Risk Acceptance Principles
Interoperability Requirements NTSNs, Authorisation and Verification Roles and Responsibilities across project lifecycles
56
Courses held throughout the year, in various locations across the UK
railwayassurance.com enquiries@railwayassurance.co.uk
INTERVIEW
Chris Kantaris Managing Director of Railway Assurance Ltd
Chris Kantaris is Managing Director of Railway Assurance Ltd, a specialist provider of the Common Safety Method (CSM) and Interoperability, supporting the rail industry for over 25 years. Railway Assurance provides independent safety and systems assurance support across the rail industry, working across light and heavy rail and high-speed networks. They support clients throughout the engineering lifecycle, providing expertise in areas including CSM-RA and Interoperability, hazard and risk management, safety verification, HAZID and HAZOP workshops, and compatibility assessments. Their focus is on helping clients understand and manage safety and assurance requirements in a practical way, ensuring they are effectively integrated into project delivery from early development through to implementation and authorisation onto the railway.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Chris Kantaris, managing director of Railway Assurance, about the company’s CPD accredited CSM and Interoperability training course, the development of its new ARMOR hazard management platform, and why early engagement with system safety specialists remains critical to delivering safe railway projects across the UK SSH: When is the next course running, and what does it cover? CK: The next course is on Monday 14th September at the Institution of Engineering and Technology (IET) in London. It’s a full day course offering six hours of CPD accredited training, and it’s the only CPD accredited CSM and Interoperability course in the country. Our course provides a foundational understanding of what the regulations are, why they are in place and what value they add. CSM, the common safety method, is called that because it’s a common approach to safety across European nations, which is why it was originally an EU regulation. Some countries were good at safety, some were not, so a common approach was needed.
We go through the whole CSM process starting from significance, the production of documentation and running workshops, to producing and managing the hazard record, transferring risks, closing out hazards and making submissions to Approving Bodies. We spend time on each of those stages. It’s interactive throughout the day, rather than death by PowerPoint, with activities focused on re-iterating and understanding each topic, such as how to run a HAZID workshop or how to identify real risks rather than things that only seem like risks. The only way to really learn CSM and Interoperability is to go through the process, and our course prepares you to do that as efficiently as possible.
SSH: What level of prior understanding do delegates need? CK: None! Because we start from the fundamentals, we are the ideal course for those wishing to start from scratch, or those wishing to fill in the gaps. The course is most beneficial to individuals within the railway sector such as project managers, engineers, sponsors and programme managers, as they are ultimately the ones responsible for delivering the process. SSH: What happens after delegates complete the course? CK: After the course has finished, delegates will receive a CPD-certified certificate for the training day. From then on, we are available 57
INTERVIEW
to all our delegates for advice and support. We’re open and flexible, and we can support projects. We encourage questions and conversations on any projects underway. As an example of course aftercare, we trained Northern Rail employees, then went on to produce all of their CSM and interoperability standards and templates, verified by the Office of Rail and Road (ORR) which are now implemented within their Safety Management System. Training staff internally allowed Northern Rail to develop its own in-house capability, with Railway Assurance forming part of their new Northern Assurance Panel, as advisors. (equivalent of a Network Rail Assurance Panel) It took two years to get to that stage, but Northern Rail are now fully selfsufficient.
through real examples from projects they’re currently on, to help them see how it all comes together. The real issue is that people don’t always understand the implications of not following the process properly. It’s fine while everyone is ticking boxes and the project reaches commissioning, but when an accident occurs, that’s the point at which you go back and realise something was missed. A properly followed CSM process should identify those key risks that need controlling before that happens. As an industry, we tend to be reactive: once an accident occurs, we find out what went wrong, update our standards and include lessons learned, but that doesn’t identify the risk in the first place, which is where the value lies in getting it right from the outset. Early engagement with the process is essential.
SSH: How did the training programme itself develop?
SSH: In your recent presentation, you said ARMOR was built by system safety professionals rather than software engineers, out of frustration with Excel. What was the breaking point that led you to build your own platform?
CK: Whilst working on the Transpennine Route Upgrade (TRU) programme, I was part of SRP (System Review Panel), and as part of that we went into partnership with NCB (National certification body) and trained around 400 staff across the London North East region, around 6 years ago. From then, Railway Assurance slowly became a known supplier for delivering this kind of training. The training became more focused and attacked more complex projects that were emerging. The more people understand why these processes exist and what they’re for, the more chance there is of people identifying hazards and risks and preventing accidents on the railway. Ultimately, that’s our goal: to make the railway safer. Working on the TRU programme in partnership with Jacobs as CSM and interoperability lead for around four years was a realisation of just how limited understanding of these processes was within the industry, which is what led us into training. We developed that training with the project and engineering managers of the time, and it made a real difference, because one individual cannot manage a project’s risk on their own. We would support a project through the process and help produce documentation and manage risk, but we can’t manage it for them. Engineers need to apply the controls and work out what scope needs to change because it’s unsafe. We take them through that journey, but they need to understand the fundamentals of why they’re doing it, and most do, they simply need educating on the steps required to get to the end goal. SSH: Is take-up quick, given how much the course covers in a day? CK: It’s quite an intense course, and there’s a lot to take in, which is why our door is always open afterwards for followup conversations. I also give delegates the opportunity during training to work 58
CK: It was the sheer inconsistency across the industry. Before developing the tool, we had our own internal templates as part of our safety management system, which we applied to the projects we worked on. The problem is that every client has its own safety management system and processes, and while the fundamentals and the columns in a hazard record look similar, how it looks and feels, how data is entered and the language used is completely different from one client to another, from one project to the next, and dependent on the style of the engineer who is leading it. That becomes a real problem when you come to close out a project, because assessors are used to seeing things presented a certain way and instead get something else. We would end up going round in circles with assessors and engineers just trying to get the language, formats and templates right, which is inefficient and, more importantly, takes the focus away from actually managing the risk. Instead of concentrating on the risks themselves, you end up focused on the paperwork trail and the logistics around it. We built ARMOR as system safety specialists, initially to help ourselves. It wasn’t originally intended as a tool to supply to the industry as best practice; it was built to make our own lives easier and to provide efficiencies to our clients, so they know that the data they’re inputting and the process they’re following is properly managed. It isn’t just a hazard record system: it manages submissions, assessor findings and everything else in one place. Other systems exist, but they tend to be requirements management tools, essentially glorified spreadsheets that capture information without adding real value, or tools that help you create an initial hazard record but don’t help you manage the process, so you
end up exporting to Excel and are back to square one. The way CSM and Interoperability is currently managed through Excel is fundamentally flawed, whereas a database system that forces you to follow the correct steps in the correct order adds real value. Because we’re not an IT company and didn’t develop this through an IT market, it’s easy to use. What we didn’t anticipate was how much interest there would be in the industry once we showcased it. We’ve had a great deal of interest since, with people asking how the tool works and how they can get hold of it. At the moment it isn’t for sale as standalone software; it’s a tool we provide to our own clients, but that’s the direction things are heading in because of the value it adds. If it can help the industry manage processes properly and, ultimately, save lives, then that is exactly where we want to take it. SSH: Could you talk through some of the tool’s functionality? CK: Every publicly available Network Rail, RSSB and Light Rail standard is uploaded into the system: at the time of our conversation, that included 1,068 Network Rail standards, 62 LRSSB standards and 239 RSSB standards, along with the relevant National Technical Specification Notices (NTSNs), and these can be downloaded directly from within the tool. Within a project, the dashboard shows an overview of hazards and their status, and the system won’t let you close out a hazard until the right steps have been taken and evidence is in place, so a risk that hasn’t genuinely been managed cannot simply be marked as closed. There’s also an AI assistant, which sits as one feature within the wider system rather than being central to it, and it’s currently offered as a beta feature. When analysing a risk, it reads the uploaded standards and reviews previous hazard records from other projects to identify relevant safety requirements, for example flagging where a safety requirement or measure is missing, and it cites the specific standard and clause it believes is relevant. Suggestions can be opened and reviewed against the standard itself before a decision is made on whether to import them. Even then, the system doesn’t simply add suggested items automatically: they go into a review queue and must be formally accepted by a competent individual with the appropriate access rights. The intention throughout is that the AI assistant supports the person using it rather than replacing their competency or judgement. The tool also allows data to be exported to Excel and, once changes have been made in the familiar spreadsheet format, synced back in, with the system identifying exactly what has changed before those changes are applied, so nothing is imported without review.
INTERVIEW
It can also generate an initial hazard record from a system definition document or other project documentation, reading the document, cross-referencing it against other hazard records and the uploaded standards, and proposing hazards for review and import, again requiring signoff before anything is formally added. The same process can be used to extract hazards from meeting notes, such as design review minutes, and there’s a duplicatematching feature that flags where hazards captured separately may in fact be the same underlying issue, so they can be consolidated rather than duplicated. At project level, the system automatically generates a report covering version history, the number of hazards open and closed, risk levels, a full hazard listing, assessor and assessment body findings and action items, all produced within seconds rather than compiled manually. Every change in the system is logged in a journal showing what was changed, when and by whom, against each individual hazard and at project level, so the audit trail is fully traceable. There’s also a restore point created every 30 minutes while a project is being actively worked on, accessible to administrators, in case of errors. SSH: How complicated was the tool to build? CK: Very. The linking between different elements and the underlying logic was a significant undertaking, and I built it myself. Once I had developed the first foundation of the database I found it very difficult to step away from, working extremely long hours over the course of about a month to get the core logic right, because once a process like this is mapped out in your head, losing track of where you are risks losing the whole structure. SSH: What needs to happen for a tool like this to become an industry standard? CK: An organisation such as Network Rail, or a body like the RSSB or the ORR, would need to recognise the value of this kind of tool and build the functional requirements into their standards, without necessarily mandating a specific product. The aim would be consistency across the industry in terms of the functions a tool needs to deliver, rather than everyone working to different systems. We’ve had serious interest from infrastructure managers in adopting our platform as their standard for managing CSM and Interoperability projects. Handling that kind of step up as an SME is both exciting and daunting, since it would mean supporting the tool at a much larger scale than we originally envisaged when we built it purely for internal use. We’ve also been approached by an IT company working in nuclear and military sectors, who pointed out that with relatively minor changes the
tool could be adapted for those industries too, since fundamentally risk is managed in the same way across sectors, even if the terminology and documentation differ. The reason there’s this level of interest, I think, is that the tool has been developed by people with direct experience of the processes involved, rather than commissioned from a specification handed to an IT company.
involved from an early concept stage right through to commissioning, and took the Approving Bodies along the journey with us throughout, so there were no surprises when it came to commissioning. That’s in contrast to jobs where we’ve been brought in later, after a station has already been built without adequate justification in place, requiring retrospective work to put that right, which is far more difficult.
SSH: Is there a particular project you’re most proud of?
SSH: What message would you want to give to clients on the back of that experience?
CK: I’m proud of all of our projects, and that comes down to how we operate as an SME. I don’t hire people for existing experience or knowledge in rail specifically; I hire for work ethic, dedication and drive, because anyone can be trained. A number of my staff came from completely different industries. Not every project has run perfectly smoothly, but we’re always quick to address issues as they arise, and we take a firm view on delivering to the commitments we make rather than seeking variations along the way. In terms of specific projects, examples like Perry Barr Station and Wolverhampton Station stand out, where we were
CK: Early engagement. Find a tool that keeps your process consistent, but engage with your CSM and Interoperability specialist, and with your Approving Bodies, as early as possible in a project. It’s often cheaper in the short term to bring in specialist support only in the final stages of a project rather than throughout its life, but there’s only so much that can be resolved properly in the final months. Getting the right advice and structure in place early ultimately supports better outcomes, both in terms of safety and, over the longer term, cost. 59
60
INTERVIEW
Ronan Finnegan co-founder of Spacebands
Spacebands is a UK-based safety technology company that makes a multi-sensor wearable for monitoring hand-arm vibration, noise and proximity hazards in real time, helping employers reduce exposure-related injury and stay compliant without relying on estimated exposure records or outdated technology that requires manual tool tagging.
Sam Sherwood-Hale spoke to Ronan Finnegan, co-founder of Spacebands, about building a wearable that monitors hand-arm vibration syndrome, noise and proximity hazards SSH: What does Spacebands do and where does it fit in the safety and security landscape? RF: We’ve built a device that reduces long-term exposure to workplace hazards. Primarily we’re focused on reducing exposure to noise and vibration, but we also offer coverage for proximity-based hazards, such as machine-to-person proximity, unauthorised access zoning, and certification checks in particular areas, though noise and vibration remain our primary focus. These hazards are difficult to protect against without technology as they are invisible, yet they have a high impact on people’s lives. One loud bang won’t make you go deaf, but repeated exposure over months or years inevitably will. The same is true of vibration: you’ll get white finger or arthritis as a result of long-term exposure, but one heavy use of a drill isn’t going to do much damage. So thoughtful employers track these hazards in order to reduce their impact. We’ve been working on this device for the past three and a half years and our business has been around for six years. We started
want of a better term. We’re also speaking or working with Southeastern Rail, Colas Rail, Southwestern Railway and Transport for Wales. Our product works particularly well for rail because Spacebands devices operate completely offline. Users can go onto site, or onto the tracks, without needing an internet connection: no 4G, no 5G, no Wi-Fi. The devices offer immediate protection, and when they go on charge, that’s when the data uploads to the dashboard for health and safety managers or operational teams. That means the system has no downtime whatsoever, whereas a competitor product that relies on a connection simply won’t work if you’re on a rail track under a bridge somewhere.
to get real traction within the construction sector, and we’ve since moved into rail and infrastructure through relationships we’d built in construction. Our first entry point into rail was through Network Rail, where we started on one site and are now operating on nine, with more than twenty planned shortly: a land-and-expand approach, for
SSH: You’ve built Spacebands into a device covering HAVS, noise, proximity and certification checks in one wearable. What was the thinking behind bringing all of that together rather than solving one problem at a time? RF: We started the business in 2020 selling a completely different product: a device that beeped and vibrated when two people 61
INTERVIEW
infringed a two-metre social distance, a contact-tracing device for the Covid-19 pandemic. As a team of two working out of a spare bedroom, we sold 20,000 of those initial devices. That gave us direct interaction with health and safety managers in large organisations, who were the ones left responsible for Covid-19 compliance. So when we decided to pivot the business, we turned to those same customers and asked what they’d like us to make. They told us that current health and safety technology had a poor user experience, it often required manual input from the end user during tasks and it often relied too heavily on an internet connection. An example of poor user experience is when a system requires the user to log which heavy drill they’re using during a vibration event. With our device, you just wear it and get immediate protection: our ease of use and the lack of any need for a connection that gives us a unique position in the market. We started with no knowledge of the health and safety industry. As we worked within Covid, we built up an understanding of the general workflows of a health and safety manager: how to talk to them, where they felt regulation was followed to the letter and where they felt it was outdated or impractical. So we had an understanding of the sector, but not of health and safety itself. The Spacebands product is entirely different from the Covid device; we didn’t reuse any of the code or design, we started again from scratch. But we carried across knowledge of how to build, warehouse and ship a product, even if there wasn’t a direct technical crossover. We heard time and again that existing products on the market weren’t fit for purpose, largely because they’d been built by health and safety managers or academics in that field, based on one individual’s preferences. We had no preferences of our own to impose, so we were entirely reliant on asking hundreds of health and safety managers what they wanted: battery life, size, which features to add, which hazards to cover. That made things harder at the outset, but it means the device was built around user feedback from its very first inception. Health and safety isn’t a glamorous sector; it’s very regulation-focused, and that’s not the fast-paced, ad-driven world a lot of entrepreneurs want to build in. I spend a lot of time reading academic research and speaking with regulatory bodies like the HSE. Health and safety managers are also often an overlooked job title: if you’re a CEO, or a journalist, you get approached constantly, but health and safety managers are frequently left to the wayside. That worked in our favour, because they were unusually receptive to being asked what they actually wanted. We heard consistently that people disliked systems requiring manual input, and that end users would often refuse to 62
comply, because those systems primarily served the health and safety team, not them. They didn’t want to log which drill they were using or what time they arrived at work; they just wanted to wear a device and have it work. So we built a product with no reliance on human input, because any missing data, even 10% of the time, makes the whole dataset unreliable. SSH: Your Network Rail case study talks about high adoption, operatives choosing to wear it as part of their kit. What’s made the difference there compared with older monitoring approaches? RF: Network Rail had previously been using a system that required tool tagging; where you pick up a watch on arrival and have to tap in every time you use a tool to log what you’re using and for how long. Their team found this frustrating: either they didn’t tap, and were reprimanded by the safety team, or the tool tag itself had fallen off. They were happy to be tracked, but not happy with the manual input requirement. Because our operatives don’t have to do anything beyond arriving on site, adoption has been particularly high. We’re now on several Network Rail sites as a result, alongside a corresponding reduction in noise and vibration exposure. SSH: How does Spacebands change the conversation between a safety team and the board when it comes to justifying investment in monitoring? RF: We track data across several severity thresholds: for noise, for example, we can flag when someone has hit 80, 85, 90 or 100 decibels, and different magnitudes of vibration exposure. That means the data is always fully compliant and reliable, whatever we build on top of it in future. Customers have used this data both to defend against regulatory fines and investigations, and to assess liability claims, including false claims, where someone alleges hearing loss caused by their workplace. We’ve seen the data support businesses on both sides of that. When a body like the HSE or ORR arrives on site to investigate, our data can show accurately whether the environment is hazardous. As long as the regulator can see the safety team taking appropriate action in response, whether that’s better PPE, reduced hours on a task, or job-sharing, they’re satisfied. It’s not about eliminating hazards entirely, since noise and vibration are inherent to an industry like rail; it’s about demonstrating a response to them. Because the UK is a strongly regulationfocused market, a lot of our customers purchase Spacebands primarily as a commercial safeguard against regulatory fines, investigations and liability claims, and secondarily to keep staff safe, which wasn’t the sales conversation we expected to be having when we built the product purely with worker safety in mind.
‘Any missing data, even ten per cent of the time, makes the whole dataset unreliable.’ SSH: RISQS approval and SSIP membership matter a lot in rail procurement. What did it take to get there, and how has it changed the conversations you’re able to have with rail clients? RF: We’ve become members of governing bodies like SSIP, NEBOSH-related bodies and RISQS now that we have the commercial traction and data to validate that the product does what we say it does. A year ago we had customers using the product, but not yet enough data to demonstrate impact. These bodies have since invited us to join, which adds credibility to our work, and we now meet with them to discuss regulatory developments, including changes like the recent ISO/TS 22270:2026 approval, which allows for HAVS monitoring via wristworn devices. With the HSE specifically, we have a good relationship, though they can’t formally endorse any product and have to remain impartial. Even so, the entire spacebands system has been built around their guidance: our point system for scoring severity of exposure is based on HSE standards, which are also used as a regulatory guideline internationally in other jurisdictions. SSH: What does a typical rollout look like for a contractor bringing Spacebands onto a live site? RF: We do very little outbound sales; 90% of our business comes from people finding us and reaching out. Lots of our customers also arrive in our inbox after poor experiences with other providers, since many have previously been let down by tool-tagging systems that staff stopped using over time. Typically, a business will start with 10 or 20 devices to verify that the product does what we say and that their team will actually wear it. Once that’s proven, they tend to scale from those initial devices to around 100, a full site, and from there expand across multiple sites. We’ve seen this happen within a few months in many cases, once they’ve proven the system on one site and realised it’s low-friction and simply works. SSH: Beyond the sensors themselves, how much of the value sits in the dashboard and the data, in terms of what a safety manager can actually do with it? RF: When a vibration event points threshold is met on a device, this is flagged to the wearer in the moment and on the dashboard as an EAV (exposure action value) and ELV
INTERVIEW
(exposure limit value). The action value indicates a worker should consider stopping a task; the limit value means they’ve reached their threshold. The dashboard notification gives the health and safety manager a prompt to take action: a conversation about training, better PPE, or job-sharing a task rather than one person doing it repeatedly. So the system doesn’t just generate data, it prompts the steps needed to prevent recurrence, which is where we see our biggest impact. The system has deliberately been built with the end-users’ privacy in mind, we are not a ‘big brother’ tool. Its sole purpose is safety. The device only alerts when hazards events are raised, we do not track anything else. We were asked early on whether we could add GPS tracking, so businesses could monitor where employees were on site, or their start and finish times, but we made a conscious decision to build a system that doesn’t infringe on privacy. We don’t record conversations, track location, or log work hours; the system only registers when a hazard threshold has been crossed. For noise, that means logging time and date against thresholds of 80, 85, 90 and 100 decibels; the same applies to vibration and proximity. SSH: You’re two founders who started this from a flat share. What’s changed most about the business since those early days? RF: The business has matured, and we now have a team, which means we can spend time listening to customers rather than just making assumptions and building as fast as possible with two people. In the early days we were working around the clock, seven days a week, as there was simply so much to
do. Nowadays, we work hard, but not quite to this same excess! We’ve since raised more than £2 million in investment, we’ve worked with thousands of businesses globally, and we’re starting to win recognition, including government contract tenders. SSH: Where do you see the biggest opportunity for Spacebands in rail specifically over the next few years? RF: We’re starting to build credibility within the sector. Getting our foot in the door was difficult. It is quite a closed network. But we’re gaining notoriety with organisations like Network Rail, where we’re now on several sites, though that takes time to establish. We’re also developing a new device behind the scenes that will offer extended hazard coverage. This is particularly relevant to some of the dangers faced on rail sites, and we’re spending a lot of time at rail conferences and in conversation with people in the sector to make sure the product serves those needs. SSH: Machinery-related incidents still account for a meaningful share of workplace accidents. How does proximity warning change behaviour on site, rather than just recording it after the fact? RF: We monitor proximity using a secondary device we call a beacon, placed on the edge of a track or on a nearby bollard or pillar. When a worker’s device comes within a customisable distance of the beacon, it beeps and vibrates to warn them they’re entering a danger zone; when they step back outside that distance, the alert stops. That
data, including who crossed the boundary and when, is logged, so health and safety managers can identify individuals who may need further training on rail safety. The beacons, like the wearables, operate entirely offline. SSH: If you had one message for rail infrastructure clients still relying on manual logs and spot checks, what would it be? RF: Step away from tool-tagging systems, or any system that requires manual input to log when a task is being carried out. Most of our customers come to us from businesses using those systems, having found the data unreliable, and when it comes to a regulatory hearing or liability claim, tooltagging systems don’t hold up as a reliable record. That’s part of why regulation is moving in this direction. The HSE has focused heavily on noise and vibration over the past two years, which coincided well with Spacebands’ development. Because these are ‘blind’ hazards, regulatory bodies previously had no reliable way to track exposure; investigations happened sporadically, based on spot surveys. A new standard, ISO/ TS 22270:2026 (Mechanical vibration — Practical guidance and requirements for the monitoring and measurement of handtransmitted vibration on the hand, wrist or forearm), has recently been published, providing guidance on monitoring handarm vibration exposure using wrist- or hand-worn devices. Since this approval, Spacebands has seen a marked increase in enquiries from businesses previously relying on manual tracking, and has been invited to tender for government contracts.
63
STATION REFURBISHMENT SAFETY & SECURITY
What the Best Safety Leaders Do As the railways in Great Britain undergo significant change, strong safety leadership has never been more important. Dr Stephen Fletcher, joint CEO at the Occupational Psychology Centre (OPC), explores eight characteristics of the most effective safety leaders and the role they play in shaping safety culture
T
Be authentic
The first pillar is authenticity – essentially, walking the talk. A strong safety leader does not promote safety only when it is convenient. Safety remains a priority even when there are competing demands, and leaders consistently demonstrate through their own behaviour that safety matters. ‘Good safety leaders walk the talk on safety constantly’ says Dr Fletcher. ‘They 64
demonstrate integrity and honesty around safety, and they encourage the people who work for them to demonstrate that authenticity too.’ Employees notice what leaders do, not simply what they say. Consistency builds credibility and reinforces safety as part of everyday behaviour.
Prioritise safety
Leaders inevitably have competing priorities. The challenge is ensuring that safety does not become diluted by them. For Dr Fletcher, effective safety leaders make safety a constant part of the organisational agenda and a key priority. In rail and other safety-critical industries, commercial and operational pressures can all compete for attention. Effective safety leaders ensure these pressures never drown out safety messages or override safe decision-making.
‘Safety should remain an important priority, even when there are pressures to focus on speed, cost, or other demands from work or people around you. That commitment can be demonstrated in simple but powerful actions, like putting safety first on meeting agendas or talking about it consistently and visibly recognising good safety practice in team meetings. When leaders demonstrate that safety really matters to them, it is much more likely it will remain a priority throughout the organisation.’
Create psychological safety
For people to raise safety concerns, report mistakes and share what is really happening, they need to feel safe doing so. Psychological safety means creating an environment where people can speak openly about worries, near misses, their own errors and difficult issues
IMAGE CREDIT: ISTOCK
he rail industry is entering a new era of public ownership and significant change. As the future shape of GB Rail evolves, organisations are managing transformation while continuing to deliver safe, reliable and efficient services every day. The UK rail industry is recognised as one of the safest in the world, but that is not a reason for complacency. Maintaining high safety performance requires continued learning and improvement. For Dr Stephen Fletcher, strong safety leadership is a key part of that picture. His experience of working with safetycritical organisations has shown him that the way leaders behave and the priorities they set can have a significant influence on safety culture – and, ultimately, on safety performance. ‘Safety leadership is increasingly important at a time when the industry is going through such significant change’ he says. ‘The basic essentials of safety performance are absolutely critical, and that safety performance is strongly influenced by good, effective safety leadership.’ Dr Fletcher describes it as the capacity of leaders to mobilise people around safety challenges and influence behaviour. ‘Leaders have a key role to play because they are in a position of authority’ he explains. ‘They can mobilise their people to be safe, or, if safety leadership is weak, they can have the opposite effect.’
SAFETY & SECURITY
‘In a safety-critical industry like rail, silence is never neutral; it is a risk in itself.’ without fear of reprisal. It is closely linked to effective safety leadership. ‘If employees don’t feel safe to speak to their senior leader or line manager about an issue, or a mistake they’ve made, then we are failing in terms of safety’ says Dr Fletcher. ‘Because at that point, we are not just losing vital learning information, we may also lose the opportunity to prevent something far more serious happening. In a safety-critical industry like rail, silence is never neutral; it is a risk in itself.’ People are unlikely to provide honest feedback if they do not feel safe enough to do so. Good safety leaders make themselves approachable and encourage people to speak up, even when the subject is difficult.
Demonstrate servant leadership
The fourth pillar challenges a more traditional view of leadership, seeing it as a responsibility to enable and support others rather than simply directing them. For Dr Fletcher, servant leadership is a mindset: ‘I’m here to serve my people, to enable them to do their jobs as safely and effectively as possible. My role as a safety leader is to facilitate that. ‘Servant leadership actually turns the organisation on its head’ he says. ‘It gives power to frontline operational roles. Some managers find that deeply uncomfortable; others see it as very liberating.’ The principle is simple: look after your people, and they are better placed to look after each other, the organisation, and its safety performance. In practice, this means listening, understanding the pressures people face and giving them the support and autonomy to work safely and effectively. It requires courage, authenticity and compassion, and it represents a significant loosening of the traditional grip of authority. In Dr Fletcher’s experience, leaders who genuinely adopt this mindset can bring about significant organisational change.
‘One of the challenges as you become more senior in an organisation is that you can develop a distorted view about what is really going on’ says Dr Fletcher. ‘People around you may tell you what they think you want to hear.’ The OPC’s experience of working with safety-critical organisations has highlighted the importance of communication in both directions. While communication down an organisation can often be well established, upward communication can be much less effective. As one Asian client memorably put it, communication in their organisation was ‘flood downwards but trickle up’. This is something organisations can test. One of the twelve blocks of the OPC’s Safety Culture Questionnaire (SafeQ) explores how well employees feel their views are heard on safety matters, providing insight into whether communication is really flowing upwards.
Act and deliver
Gathering feedback is only part of the process. In Dr Fletcher’s experience, rail organisations are often good at listening to their people and acting on the issues raised. Where there can be a missed opportunity is in closing the feedback loop and communicating what has happened as a result. ‘We often implement changes and improvements, but we may not necessarily go back and communicate that, or share it more widely across teams’ says Dr Fletcher. ‘It’s about showing our employees that we’ve listened; we’ve heard and we value their contribution, and, importantly, that we’ve acted.’ Communicating changes and learning more widely helps people see the impact of their contribution and ensures useful learning is shared across teams. Where immediate action isn’t possible, a prompt update can still keep people informed. For Dr Fletcher, this follow-through supports both employee engagement
‘The link between strong safety leadership and safety culture has an impact on safety performance,’ says Dr Fletcher. ‘They are inextricably linked’ and organisational learning: ‘If people can see that you’ve listened, acted and then communicated what you’ve done, it reinforces the value of speaking up. Without action, employees can sometimes become disengaged assuming there is little point in raising concerns.’
Be courageous
Safety leadership sometimes requires the courage to challenge decisions or ‘push back’ when things don’t feel right, including questioning those who may be more senior. It means being prepared to say: ‘No, I believe this is wrong’ or ‘I disagree with this.’ ‘Without that courage’ says Dr Fletcher, ‘we could create an organisation where people see things being implemented that they know are wrong, but they don’t feel able to challenge it.’ Courage also means acknowledging your own mistakes. Leaders who are willing to admit when they have got something wrong show they do not expect perfection from themselves or others. ‘Saying you’ve made a mistake or done something wrong takes real courage, particularly if you are in a position of authority’ says Dr Fletcher. ‘But it can also be one of the most powerful ways to encourage others to acknowledge and report their mistakes. It shows that you are human and fallible, and that it is OK for others to take the same path.’
IMAGE CREDIT: ISTOCK
Seek out feedback
Effective safety leadership also requires leaders to actively seek feedback – particularly from those closest to the operational ‘frontline’. Leaders need to understand what frontline employees think and feel and the safety issues they are experiencing, as well as any improvement opportunities they see. This requires more than a communication channel; leaders need to spend time with frontline teams, listening and observing. 65
STATION REFURBISHMENT SAFETY & SECURITY
As Paul Allen, cofounder of Microsoft, put it: ‘In my experience, each failure contains the seeds of your next success… if you are willing to learn from it.’
As Paul Allen, co-founder of Microsoft, put it: ‘In my experience, each failure contains the seeds of your next success… if you are willing to learn from it.’ For safety leaders, this means having the curiosity and courage to look honestly at what has happened and turn mistakes and near misses into opportunities to improve, rather than simply moving on. A great safety leader is not simply a custodian of existing safety practices. They are a pioneer and an innovator – continually looking ahead, challenging the status quo and helping their people find safer and better ways of working.
Safety leadership belongs to everyone Seek continuous improvement
Leadership that shapes safety
The eight pillars are not new leadership concepts. What matters is how deliberately they are applied to safety, every day. Many
Tel: 01923 234646 Visit: www.theopc.co.uk Email: admin@theopc.co.uk
IMAGE CREDIT: ISTOCK
The final pillar is continuous improvement, always seeking a better way of doing things. ‘This is about leaders constantly looking for creative or new ways to do things better’ says Dr Fletcher. ‘Never accepting the status quo and always encouraging their people to look for continuous improvement in what they do, too.’ This does not have to mean major organisation-wide programmes. It can be small, practical changes that improve safety, informed by everyday experience, mistakes or near misses. But learning needs to be shared. Good safety leaders create ways for teams to capture, share and embed what has been learned. That means asking: What happened? What did we learn? Who else needs to know? And what do we need to do differently as a result? This helps valuable insights reach beyond those who experienced them and become part of wider organisational learning.
Safety leadership is not confined to senior managers, HSE specialists or those with direct operational responsibility. ‘Everyone is responsible as a safety leader’ says Dr Fletcher. ‘Whether you are working in operations, HR, audit or finance, there is a role to play in making our operations safer.’ The OPC has helped many nonoperational leaders recognise how their decisions can affect frontline safety, sometimes years later on. The safety impact of an architect’s choice of flooring for a depot, for example, or a financial decision affecting staffing or workload, may not be realised within the business until many years later. The challenge is recognising those connections. For organisations to develop a mature safety culture, everyone needs to understand the part they can play.
rail professionals will recognise some of these behaviours in others, and perhaps themselves. Giving them a name and a framework helps us recognise what good safety leadership looks like and where we could each do more. ‘The link between strong safety leadership and safety culture has an impact on safety performance’ says Dr Fletcher. ‘They are inextricably linked.’ As railways in Great Britain undergoes significant change, maintaining that focus will be essential. For Dr Fletcher, safety leadership needs to be visible in everyday decisions, conversations and behaviours – from the boardroom, across every function and on to the frontline. ‘Excellent safety leaders don’t treat safety as something separate from the business. They embed it in how the organisation thinks, decides and acts every day. When safety leadership is done well, it lifts the whole organisation, and that in turn drives better safety culture and performance.’ In an industry where the consequences of getting safety wrong can be so significant, safety leadership is a responsibility we all share. If you would like to explore how the OPC can support stronger safety leadership or safety culture in your organisation, get in touch with our friendly team.
66
Quality by Design
Contact us with your requirements
67
SAFETY HELMETS
THIS IS MY COMFORT ZONE
For over a century, ABUS has been driven by one goal: to make life a little safer. Today, we bring that expertise into PPE, combining advanced helmet technology with comfort, design, and reliability. Our SCATOR and SPECTOR ranges are engineered to meet the demands of rail, infrastructure, and construction environments, delivering dependable protection, all-day comfort, and compliance for both everyday tasks and specialist work at height.
Both helmet styles available in:
ABUS | UK abus.com/uk | Phone: +44 (0) 117 204 7000 68
SAFETY & SECURITY
Between Compliance and Protection PPE PPE must meet defined technical and regulatory requirements, but compliance does not necessarily mean equipment will work equally well for every person wearing it
F
it, adjustment and compatibility can all affect how effectively it performs in use. Adam Evans, Managing Director, ABUS UK & Ireland, considers why fit deserves greater attention in the rail sector. The issue becomes more apparent when PPE provision is based heavily around standardisation. A common range can simplify purchasing, stock management and replacement, but a standard issue does not necessarily accommodate a standard workforce. Alongside gender, people differ in size, shape and physical characteristics and these differences can affect how PPE fits and functions. Where suitable alternatives are not available, workers may adjust equipment themselves, tolerate discomfort or repeatedly alter the fit during the working day or they may not wear PPE at all. These responses can affect the way equipment performs and the level of protection it provides. Fit also needs to be considered across the combination of PPE being worn. Equipment selected individually may meet its own requirements but create problems when used alongside other items. Procurement needs to consider how products work together, as well as whether each item is suitable for the individual wearer.
Looking beyond standard provision
The issue becomes particularly relevant as the rail industry seeks to attract and retain a more diverse and inclusive workforce. The Chartered Institute of Building’s #PPEthatfits campaign has highlighted inequalities in PPE provision, including concerns around whether equipment is sufficiently inclusive for different users. Providing suitable PPE should not require an individual to compromise safety, comfort or dignity because the available equipment has been designed around a narrower range of users. Inclusive provision is part of getting PPE selection right rather than a separate consideration from technical safety.
Designing for the wearer
The same principle applies to other aspects of PPE provision. Workers need access to appropriate sizes and configurations, equipment needs to be adjustable where required, and there needs to be a straightforward way to report when something does not fit or work as intended.
Making fit part of procurement
Procurement decisions can determine how much flexibility workers have when PPE does not fit correctly. A tightly standardised range may be efficient to manage, but limited choice can leave individuals with equipment that is technically compliant but unsuitable in use. Repeated adjustment, discomfort, interference between items or difficulty using equipment for tasks should prompt a review of the specification and available range, with the experience of those using the equipment informing that process. BS 30417:2025, Provision of inclusive personal protective equipment (PPE) – Guide, provides a framework covering selection, procurement, fitting, adjustment, maintenance, replacement and training. It places fit within the wider process of providing and managing PPE rather than treating it as a one-off purchasing decision. Fit becomes part of assessing whether equipment is suitable for the individual as well as the hazard it is intended to address.
The focus on fit is influencing PPE design, with greater attention being given to ergonomics, adjustability and stability. Equipment needs to remain correctly positioned and usable throughout the working period rather than relying on the wearer to continually compensate for a poor fit. ABUS has applied this approach to its SCATOR and SPECTOR safety helmet ranges for rail, infrastructure and construction environments, combining protection and compliance with attention to fit, stability and all-day wearability. Industrial and climbing helmets are built to meet the relevant European standards with design decisions to focus on comfort, durability, and ease of integration with other PPE systems, helping teams carry out work at height safely and confidently. In summary, for rail organisations, the question is ultimately how well PPE performs once it is being worn. Certification establishes equipment meets defined requirements, but selection also needs to account for the individual, the combination of equipment being worn and the conditions in which it will be used. Fit should sit alongside specification, certification and compatibility when PPE is selected and reviewed. Equipment needs to meet the required standard, suit the task and work for the person wearing it. That is what makes PPE genuinely fit for purpose.
Tel: 0117 204 7000 Email: info@abus-uk.com Visit: www.abus-uk.com
69
/ CTS
CTS SHORTLISTED Best Use of Technology – North
Cable and Wire Tension Measuring System
Spotlight Rail Awards 2026
Designed for fast measurement of cable and contact wire mechanical tension from ground level, the CTS simplifies inspections without heavy access equipment and provides instant data via the app.
Scan to discover more about the CTS.
Ground-level measurement
Instant data
Robust & portable
/ M TAG
1 - 69 kV Voltage Detector Designed for fast and reliable proving dead on distribution systems between 1 kV and 69 kV, MTAG combines clear audible and visual indication with a robust design for demanding field operations. Scan to discover more about the MTAG.
Audible indication
Operating reliability
Visual indication
SUPPORTING SAFER, MORE EFFICIENT RAIL AND CATENARY MAINTENANCE
Discover all our solutions on our website www.pentaesp.com
26 Cover_Layout 1 e2 26 15:02 Pag t 1 14/04/20
26 Cover_Layou
Years s YeYearars
est.1976
est.1976
est.1976
ID:000888
7.00am - 5.30pm - 5.30pm 7.00am - 5.30pm 7.00am
70
7.00am - 5.00pm 0pm 7.00am - 5.0 7.00am - 5.00pm
SAFETY & SECURITY
Staying Clear of Live Lines Proximity detection technology addresses the growing risk of high-voltage line contact, with PENTA Electrical Safety Products’ SKY RADIO 3 giving operators real-time warnings before a hazardous situation develops
W
orking near energised overhead power lines continues to present one of the most significant safety challenges for companies operating cranes, concrete pumps, aerial work platforms, agricultural machinery and other high-reach equipment. Accidental encroachment into the minimum safe approach distance can result in serious injury or fatalities, costly damage to machinery, project delays, regulatory investigations and increased operational costs. As construction, utility and infrastructure projects become more complex, businesses are under increasing pressure to improve operator safety while maintaining productivity. To reduce these risks, many organisations rely on operator training, site planning, physical barriers, warning signage and established safe working procedures. While these measures remain essential, they depend heavily on human awareness
and judgement in constantly changing working environments. Operators can face restricted visibility, challenging weather conditions and varying site layouts, making it difficult to accurately judge the distance between machinery and overhead power lines. These limitations highlight the need for an additional layer of protection that provides continuous, real-time monitoring of machine proximity to energised electrical infrastructure. SKY RADIO 3 has been developed to address this challenge by providing an advanced proximity detection solution that actively assists operators in maintaining a safe working distance from overhead power lines. The system uses multiple sensors, configured to suit the specific machine application, to continuously monitor the distance between moving equipment and nearby high-voltage conductors. As the machine approaches a predefined risk zone, SKY RADIO 3 immediately issues both
audible and visual warnings, allowing the operator to take corrective action before a hazardous situation develops. The detection distance is configurable between three and six metres (10–17 feet), enabling the system to be adapted to different applications and site requirements without compromising productivity. SKY RADIO 3 is suitable for installation on concrete pumps, loader cranes, auxiliary cranes, aerial work platforms, agricultural machinery, fire and rescue vehicles, and other equipment operating at height. By combining configurable sensing technology with real-time operator alerts, SKY RADIO 3 provides organisations with an effective means of reducing the risk of accidental contact with overhead power lines, helping to improve workplace safety, protect valuable assets and minimise costly downtime. PENTA Electrical Safety Products UKI is an expert manufacturer of electrical safety solutions, driven by a commitment to ensuring your safety in every intervention. PENTA Electrical Safety Products is trusted by Linesmen, Maintenance Technicians, and Electrical Engineers working across global electricity generation, transmission, and distribution networks and rail and electrified industries. PENTA safeguards your operations with cutting-edge safety technology designed to meet the highest standards in the most demanding environments. Count on PENTA Electrical Safety Products: where safety meets innovation! SKY RADIO 3 is available in the UK from PENTA Electrical Safety Products. For further information, get in touch via the contact information below. Email: sales@pbwel.com Visit: www.PentaESP.com
71
ECOGRIT
CONCENCRATE Don’t slip up this winter! The safe alternative to rock salt
or 20kg bags
72
SAFETY & SECURITY
The Case of the Crumbling Concrete When newly finished concrete on a flagship London rail project began to deteriorate, the de-icer took the blame. EcoGrit MD Gareth Ellis turned detective and found the real culprit was walking in every day
W
hen a cold snap hit London in early January, engineers on one of the capital’s largest rail construction programmes did exactly the right thing: they treated the finished concrete structures with a granular de-icer to keep walking routes safe. Weeks later, site operatives noticed a cement slurry forming on the surface, the top layer roughened and aggregate beginning to show. The de-icer was the obvious suspect. The contractor raised a query with the supplier, EcoGrit Ltd, attaching photographs of the damage and asking a perfectly reasonable question: had the product been misapplied, and could the manufacturer clarify the correct method? Many suppliers would have replied with a datasheet and a disclaimer. EcoGrit’s Managing Director Gareth Ellis instead treated it as what it was: a challenge to the integrity of a product he had spent years testing, and a mystery worth solving properly. His response was to ask for evidence like photographs of the pallet and the bags, samples of the slurry and the loose material for independent laboratory analysis, the slab’s pour dates and quality records, and, decisively, a site visit so he could see the concrete for himself.
First, trace the product
The first thread to pull was the supply chain. The contractor’s purchase order had gone through a components distributor, and EcoGrit’s records showed no direct sale to that company at all. That mattered, because EcoGrit deliberately keeps its reseller network small and its order records meticulous precisely so that any bag bearing its name can be traced back to a batch and verified as genuine and untampered. Within days the order had been located, the batch confirmed, and one possible explanation counterfeit or contaminated product eliminated before anyone set foot on site. Gareth could also bring some hardwon concrete knowledge to bear. Years of
Granular and effective to −20 °C — EcoGrit at its recommended 10–15 g/m² spread rate.
handling de-icers around freshly laid slabs had taught him what finished, properly cured concrete can and cannot suffer in a few weeks. Photographs showing exposed aggregate raised immediate questions about surface finishing and curing conditions and one thing he was confident of from the start: no correctly applied de-icer damages sound, cured concrete that quickly. Something else was going on.
The damage followed the footprints
The answer came the moment Gareth walked the structure with the contractor’s site engineer. The deterioration wasn’t where the de-icer had been spread. It was where people had been standing. The worst-affected area was the spot where morning team briefings were held, with dozens of workers standing and shuffling in one place while the day’s activities were set out. A second worn line ran directly to the smoking shelter a route walked slowly, repeatedly, all day long. A third traced the slab edge used as a cut-through between levels of
the site, a shortcut for workers heading to the area where phone calls were made and taken. Yet other areas of the same slab, treated with the same product at the same time but rarely walked on, were in perfect condition. Then came the clinching detail. Opening the grit bins around the wider site, Gareth found them stacked with bags of traditional brown rock salt used extensively everywhere except the finished structure itself. Rock salt is a coarse grit that embeds in boot treads and travels. Every worker arriving at the briefing point or the smoking shelter was unknowingly delivering rock salt straight onto the finished concrete, where it sat grinding and dissolving into the surface with every shuffle of a boot. EcoGrit is grit by name only. The product is granular, does not embed in footwear, and contains no rock salt, which is exactly why the treated but untrafficked areas were unmarked. The picture was complete: the de-icer hadn’t damaged the concrete. The concrete was mapping the site’s foot traffic, and the foot traffic was carrying someone else’s salt. 73
STATION REFURBISHMENT SAFETY & SECURITY
because the product works by preventing ice from bonding rather than by brute chemical force. Applying more is simply wasteful: if it rains, the excess washes away. The same properties explain Gareth’s confidence under scrutiny. Whole pallets and loose piles of EcoGrit are routinely stored directly on concrete floors at the company’s Suffolk base, and in years of doing so have never marked a surface. A product tested that thoroughly, in that much day-to-day contact with concrete, earns the right to be defended — and the obligation to investigate properly when questioned.
What this means for the rail estate
Rock salt embeds in boot treads and travels — straight onto finished concrete.
FINISHED CONCRETE STRUCTURE (treated with EcoGrit) surface damage
smoking shelter
foot traffic
D
damage zones undamaged
C
treated, untrafficked — undamaged
A
B access from lower level
access route
Wider site — traditional rock salt in grit bins throughout
Damage map from the site investigation — deterioration (A, B, C) matchedthe boot-traffic routes; untrafficked concrete (D) was unmarked.
Clearing the name, fixing the problem
The findings were reported openly to the contractor whose response says much about how the relationship was handled on both sides. Far from defending a position, the contractor’s team confirmed they had never doubted the product: their own materials specialists had recommended it in the first place, senior colleagues had used it on other major London rail programmes, and the query had only ever been about application method. Samples still went off for independent laboratory analysis, because when your name is on the bag, ‘probably fine’ is not a standard. Gareth’s recommendations were immediately practical. Restrict foot traffic on finished concrete where possible. Install boot-wash troughs at access points during the winter season, dosed with EcoGrit, so the wash water itself cannot freeze. Substitute the wider site’s rock salt with a less aggressive marine salt as a minimum. Or, simplest of all, standardise on a single de-icer that is kind to finished surfaces across the whole site, so there is nothing harmful to transfer in the first place. 74
Chloride attack from transferred rocksalt roughened the finished surface.
Grit by name only
The episode is a neat demonstration of why the product exists. EcoGrit contains no rock salt: its formulation is biodegradable, safe around pets and planting, and effective down to minus 20 degrees Celsius. It is also remarkably economical: the recommended spread rate – printed on the back of every bag – is just 10 to 15 grams per square metre to prevent or remove ice. That is a small fraction of typical rock salt application,
For the rail environment the case for leaving rock salt behind is stronger still. Rock salt attacks reinforced concrete, corrodes steelwork, fixings and signalling apparatus, damages station surfaces and harms trackside planting and drainage. Platforms, footbridges, depots, car parks and walkways all carry the same hidden cost every winter and this investigation vividly displayed that salt does not stay where it is spread. It travels on every pair of boots, from the car park to the concourse, from the compound to the finished slab. For asset owners and contractors alike, the lessons are simple. Choose a de-icer that cannot harm what it lands on, because it will end up in places it was never spread. Buy through traceable channels, so what arrives is what was tested. And when something unexpected happens, work with a supplier who will come to site, look for themselves, and put their findings in writing whichever way they fall. Winter is never far away. If your infrastructure deserves better than rock salt, EcoGrit’s team is happy to talk and, as one London contractor discovered, they will stand behind their product all the way to site.
The Saw Mill, Brooms Barn Coney Weston IP31 1HQ, United Kingdom Tel: 0800 193 6466 Email: gaz@ecogrit.co.uk Visit: www.ecogrit.co.uk Social: Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn Instagram
Empowering Industry with High Quality Fluid Power Components
STAUFF Line
Pantograph systems Door operating systems, Door handles
Air horn systems, Wash wipe systems
Inter-car hose assemblies Waste disposal, Full pneumatic pipework systems Seating framework, Grab rails and luggage racks Body to bogie pipework, Levelling valve systems Braking systems, Sanding HOSES
A comprehensive range of quality products and innovative services, delivered to production line side for rolling stock OEMs. Presented in kit form, tested and ready for immediate installation, reducing logistic, production and inventory costs.
The STAUFF Line process is adopted by STAUFF Line global OEMs to successfully achieve cost savings in rolling stock manufacture. Presented in kit form, tested and ready for immediate installation, reducing logistic, production and inventory costs.
The STAUFF Line process is adopted by global OEMs to successfully achieve cost savings in rolling stock manufacture.
Sheffield Tel: 0114 251 8518 Aberdeen Tel: 01224 786166 Email: uk.sales@stauff.com Corporate Social Email: uk.absales@stauff.com
Ireland Tel: 02892 606900 Email: uk.irsales@stauff.com
A comprehensive range of quality products and innovative services, delivered to production line side for rolling stock OEMs.
www.stauff.co.uk Responsibility Award Winners 2024
75
STATION REFURBISHMENT TICKETING TECHNOLOGY
Rail Reform Gives Us a Rare Opportunity to Rethink Fare Fraud Peter Jarvis, CEO of Raspberry Software and specialist in rail revenue protection software, explains why the future of tackling ticketless travel successfully requires a data-led approach
T
he rapidly progressing rail reform presents the industry with an opportunity to rethink the industry’s operational strategy and the way it tackles fare fraud. Rail fraud has become increasingly sophisticated and remains one of the biggest challenges faced by revenue protection teams. For years, our industry has treated fare fraud as a ticketing problem. Today, it is increasingly an intelligence problem. Rail fraud is more sophisticated, evidence is more complex and investigators need connected systems to identify repeat offending and build consistent, defensible cases. As the railway moves through a period of reform, we have a genuine opportunity to rethink not just who operates our railways, but how we protect the revenue that keeps them running. The Office of Rail and Road (ORR) review concluded that revenue protection practices across the rail sector could be improved to create a more consistent, transparent and fair network while still enabling train operators to tackle deliberate fare evasion effectively. It also estimated that fare evasion and ticket fraud costs Britain’s railways £350 to £400 million every year in lost revenue; money that could otherwise be invested back into services, infrastructure and the overall passenger experience. For me, this reinforces a critical point. Revenue protection also protects confidence in our railway system, supports honest passengers and ensures that deliberate fraud is dealt with appropriately and consistently. The biggest causes of revenue loss remain the same. Traditional offences such as ticketless travel, short ticketing and railcard 76
misuse remain widespread, but digital ticketing has introduced new forms of fraud including QR code duplication, screenshot sharing, altered tickets and refund abuse. Tackling this effectively requires more sophisticated investigation and better data. Investigation processes, regardless of the type of fraud committed, need to be able to identify repeat behaviour and give revenue protection teams the information they need to take appropriate, fair action. Through our work with the UK’s leading train operating companies, we’ve seen a shift in the complexity of fraud investigations. Increasingly, the challenge is connecting multiple incidents, recognising repeat behaviour and managing growing volumes of digital evidence while building robust, legally defensible cases without adding unnecessary administration for revenue protection teams. Technology has transformed almost every aspect of the railway. Passengers buy tickets digitally. CCTV systems are more sophisticated. Journey information is richer than ever before. Investigators have access to more evidence and more data than at any point in the industry’s history. Yet many fraud investigations are still managed using a combination of spreadsheets, emails and paper records: disconnected systems and processes that only ever give revenue protection professionals part of the picture. Today’s rail fraud teams are not simply processing individual incidents. They are managing digital evidence, correspondence, financial information, legal documentation and repeat offending data across multiple journeys. And they are still expected to demonstrate consistency, fairness and clear governance.
We see revenue protection teams achieving impressive results despite increasingly complex workloads, a continually changing environment, and outdated systems. If these challenges could be mitigated, imagine the impact it could have on rail fraud reduction across the sector and the country.
Reform is the right time to modernise
Much of the conversation around rail reform has naturally focused on structures, ownership and organisational change. There’s an equally important operational conversation to be had. As we move toward a more unified railway, we have a once in a generation opportunity to review the way revenue protection is implemented before today’s fragmented approaches become tomorrow’s national standard. That doesn’t mean starting again. Some of the most effective revenue protection practices already exist within train operating companies. Decades of operational knowledge, legal expertise and practical experience have been built across the industry. Preserving and building on that expertise while creating greater consistency should be one of our biggest revenue protection priorities to keep the industry moving forward, and this requires a joined-up approach. It also requires collaboration between operators, suppliers and policymakers. We are already seeing an increased appetite to collaborate, more transparent conversations between train operating companies around best practice, and a real recognition that information sharing will play an essential role in identifying repeat offenders and ensuring processes and
TICKETING TECHNOLOGY
‘Fare evasion and ‘Many fraud ticket fraud costs investigations are Britain’s railways £350 still managed using to £400 million every a combination of year in lost revenue’ spreadsheets, emails and paper records’ penalties are consistent across the network. These are incredibly positive developments and closely reflect the direction recommended by the ORR.
Better data creates better outcomes
Reliable data improves overall fairness across the network just as much as it improves enforcement capabilities. Access to joined-up information helps investigators identify genuine patterns of offence while also ensuring honest mistakes are managed consistently and proportionately. It means managers can continually review trends, improve governance and demonstrate that revenue protection is being conducted fairly across the network. As the ORR review highlighted, revenue protection needs to be able to better distinguish between deliberate fare evasion and genuine passenger error. Striking that balance is crucial to maintaining public trust and confidence in the rail network, while taking firm and consistent action against those who intentionally avoid paying the correct fare. To make this work in practice, TOCs need access to accurate, reliable, countrywide data alongside secure systems, clear standards and trusted processes.
that can either be adopted as a standalone software platform or incorporated within existing TIPS systems. The fraud module provides a structured, auditable process for managing cases, from initial investigation through to settlement or prosecution by bringing together evidence, correspondence, data and financial information. It has been designed to tackle the very real challenges rail fraud teams face daily, reduce the administrative burden, and help fraud teams to build stronger, courtready case files where required.
Looking beyond reform
I believe a joined up, data-driven approach presents a crucial step forward in the way we tackle fraud as an industry. If we simply transfer today’s fragmented processes into GBR and the railway of the future, we will have missed a significant opportunity for change. But if we use this period to combine the expertise that already exists across the industry with better information, consistent processes and modern investigation tools, we can create a revenue protection system that’s fairer for passengers, more effective for operators and better equipped to deal with fraud challenges as they evolve.
Supporting investigators, not replacing them
The evolution of AI means that when we look at incorporating technology into daily practices, there can be an assumption that it’s about replacing people. I think the opposite is true. Historically, revenue protection has relied on experienced professionals applying judgement, understanding legislation and considering the individual circumstance of every case. No software could ever replace that expertise. The role of technology is much simpler. It removes unnecessary administration and gives access to important data across the entire rail network. In turn, this strengthens governance, enables evidence to be securely managed and helps investigators build stronger cases more efficiently.
Embracing innovation
Our TIPS platform helps revenue protection professionals make the most of data. Recognising the complexities around tackling rail fraud and built in conjunction with insight from TOCs across the country, we have introduced a new fraud module
Tel: 01394 387386 Email: sales@raspberrysoftware.com Visit: www.raspberrysoftware.com
PETER JARVIS is CEO of Raspberry Software.
NE WS IN BRIE F TFW FFEIBR CONNECTS SOUTH WALES INTO MAJOR DATA CENTRE CAMPUS Transport for Wales’ ffeibr has linked South Wales directly into one of Europe’s largest data centre campuses, connecting Cloud Centres and Vantage Data Centres to create a high speed route giving local businesses fast, reliable connectivity for cloud services, AI workloads and other digital applications typically found only in the UK’s largest metropolitan hubs. The connection is the latest step in ffeibr’s development since it launched in November 2024. Cloud Centres Networks was ffeibr’s first commercial contract, connected in partnership with Cardiff University in 2025. Having since extended its network into the heart of the city, ffeibr has now linked that facility directly to Vantage, deepening its presence across South Wales’ data centre corridor. The full-fibre network is being built in parallel with the electrification of the Welsh Core Valley Train Lines.
RIA ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2026 The Railway Industry Association (RIA) has unveiled the agenda and confirmed speakers so far for its Annual Conference 2026, themed Connected for Change: Shaping Tomorrow’s Railway. Taking place on 4 and 5 November in London, the conference will hear from Network Rail CEO Jeremy Westlake, DfT Operator CEO Alex Hynes, Shadow Transport Secretary Richard Holden MP, Office of Rail and Road Interim CEO Feras Alshaker, and several other industry and political figures, with a keynote from the Rt Hon Baroness Neville-Jones on cyber security and infrastructure. A dedicated Nations & Regions discussion will feature the Mayors of South Yorkshire, West of England and the East Midlands. RIA has introduced a broader range of ticket options this year, including flexible two-day and one-day passes, with reduced prices for SMEs. RIA Chief Executive Darren Caplan said the conference had become one of the most important gatherings in the UK rail calendar, and that the association was offering its most flexible and competitively priced packages to date.
77
STATION REFURBISHMENT SAFETY & SECURITY FOR PERIMETERS
Safety-critical Perimeter Security It may be surprising that although technology is rapidly developing, the issues facing the rail network remain the same: trespass, vandalism and ever-decreasing budgets
T
hose budgets quite rightly prioritise safety, yet many safety issues have their roots in physical security. To understand why safety depends on security, consider what happens when a physical trackside perimeter fails. It removes the boundary between a controlled railway environment and the public, creating an immediate safety risk. Railway operations rely on the assumption that the line is clear of people and obstructions. When that perimeter is breached, trains must be slowed or stopped while visual inspections are carried out, causing significant disruption across the network. Across the UK rail network, there are around 19,000 incidents of trespass each year, resulting in approximately 750,000 minutes of train delays and costing taxpayers around £75 million annually. These delays represent not only a significant financial burden but also demonstrate how quickly a security failure can become a safety issue. Delay minutes often attract the headlines because of their commercial impact, but the greatest concern is the risk to life. Trespassers face obvious dangers from highspeed trains and overhead line equipment, while route crime such as cable theft can disrupt signalling and other safetycritical infrastructure. Items thrown onto the railway or at moving trains also put passengers, train crews and offenders at risk. Without effective security, safe and reliable rail operation is not possible. The focus should not simply be on responding to intrusions, but preventing them from happening in the first place. As train frequencies increase and expectations around network performance continue to grow, preventing unauthorised access has become just as important as responding effectively when an incident occurs. Perimeter security should therefore be considered as part of the wider rail safety strategy, rather than simply a boundary marking the edge of the railway. 78
Providing effective protection across such a large and often remote estate is not straightforward. Traditional boundary demarcations, such as chain-link and timber post-and-wire fencing, were designed to define boundaries rather than resist modern security threats. Today, many of these legacy systems no longer meet operational requirements. They can be breached using basic hand tools and often require more maintenance over time. Even traditional steel palisade fencing, widely used for security, has its limitations. Fixings can be removed to slide pales aside before being returned to their original position, leaving little visible evidence of a breach. This creates a safety risk because someone could be inside the railway boundary without being detected, while confirming a breach often requires manual inspection. Handheld power tools continue to become smaller and more powerful, making traditional chain-link systems increasingly vulnerable. At the same time, CCTV and drone technology are being used more widely to inspect and monitor rail infrastructure. Perimeter systems therefore need to resist modern methods of attack
while making damage or attempted breaches easy to identify. Technology and operational practices continue to evolve, so perimeter security must do more than meet minimum compliance. Increasingly, specifiers are looking beyond security ratings alone. They also consider how a system performs throughout its service life, including inspection, maintenance and long-term durability. For many rail applications, expanded metal mesh is well suited to these requirements, combining high security performance with long-term reliability. Inspection is also becoming a more important part of the specification process. Perimeter systems should support CCTV, drone surveys and routine visual inspections by making damage or attempted breaches easy to identify. This improves maintenance planning and reduces the amount of time engineers spend trackside. Expanded metal mesh is particularly effective in this respect, providing clear visibility for CCTV and routine inspections. A range of perimeter systems are used across the rail network, each with characteristics that should be
SAFETY & SECURITY FOR PERIMETERS
considered during specification. Security performance is only one part of the decision. Durability, corrosion protection, maintenance requirements and suitability for the operating environment are equally important. Expanded metal mesh has several characteristics that suit demanding rail environments. Its diamond-shaped pattern limits toe and finger holds, making climbing more difficult. Because it is formed from a single piece of metal rather than welded together, there are no welded joints that can become weak points. It also takes longer to cut through because more material has to be cut, increasing the time needed to breach the perimeter and the likelihood of detection. Expanded metal mesh may have a higher initial purchase cost than some comparable alternatives, initial purchase costs are not the only thing that should be taken into account. With Network Rails budgets being increasingly directed towards maintaining its existing estate, it is essential that whole life performance is considered. Systems that require little maintenance and continue performing for many years can reduce future interventions, minimise workforce exposure and provide better long-term value. The rail environment presents unique installation challenges. Work is often
carried out during short possession windows, on steep embankments or in remote locations with limited access. Every visit trackside introduces both cost and risk, so perimeter systems should be quick to transport, install, inspect and maintain. Reducing the time engineers spend on or near the railway improves both safety and efficiency. Design also has an important role to play. Modular construction makes materials easier and safer to handle, while systems that can rake over uneven ground reduce the need for stepping and the additional work required to close gaps beneath the fence line. Where access behind the fence is restricted by adjacent landowners, dense vegetation or difficult terrain, the ability to install and maintain a system entirely from within the rail boundary offers clear operational advantages. Installation itself introduces another important safety consideration. Moving fencing materials down steep cuttings or through narrow access points can create significant manual handling risks. Smaller, more manageable mesh panels or pales help reduce those risks while lowering the chance of materials falling onto the line. They can also make installation quicker and more efficient, helping to minimise the time spent working trackside.
As a specialist manufacturer of accredited expanded metal mesh perimeter fencing, gates and security systems for the rail industry, ExMesh Engineering has seen these challenges first-hand. That experience has shaped the development of systems designed around the practical realities of the rail environment, supporting both security performance and safer installation practices. As rail networks increase train frequencies, adopt higher operating speeds and transition towards automated signalling and electrification, the tolerance for trackside intrusion continues to reduce. Perimeter security can no longer be viewed as a simple boundary or a passive barrier. It is a safety-critical asset that protects people, infrastructure and the reliable operation of the railway. Choosing the right perimeter security is not simply about improving security. It is about creating a safer, more resilient and more reliable railway.
Tel: 01429 867 388 Email: contactus@exmesh.co.uk Visit: exmeshengineering.com
DESIGNED FOR SPEED When time, terrain and security matter, Fastrack Trio delivers. This fencing system was engineered specifically for rail environments, keeping your projects on track without compromise. • Small panels for quick install • Handles sloping ground with ease • Made from heavy-duty, anti-climb mesh
for Scan tails e d e mor
exmeshengineering.com 79
80
HEALTH & SAFETY
Why Are We Using Metal Road Pins on a Network Driven by Electricity? RJW Engineering has developed a fully non-conductive replacement for metal road pins, addressing a longstanding safety risk on the electrified rail network
T
his was the question presented to NWR, and the answer was simply: we don’t know! So RJW Engineering was tasked with overhauling this old and antiquated system that has danger written all over it. Currently, metal road pins are either driven into the ground (cat scan required), driven into sandbags that lose the sand once pierced, or as can be seen, wedged between bricks or logs or whatever can be found lying around. There is no set system: it’s whatever goes. The safety netting is often left loose, just falling over, therefore resulting in little to no protection. Let’s address the main issue, metal road pins! Why…? This will seriously injure or kill someone if it strikes a cable, please scan the QR code and see the NWR safety video as it explains all. We decided immediately to move away from a conductive material, the metal road pins. If these were to be driven into the ground then we need to make them nonconductive. Our trials soon showed the recyclable plastic road pin with its cross-section design was very effective, we then replaced the sharp point of the metal road pin with a much safer rounded bull nose. The way the netting was hung over the hook was also questioned, this has now been replaced with a unique slotted end allowing the netting to be located within the road pin, this also added a big advantage when storing and transporting the pins, now taking up far less room and not becoming tangled with each other. We now have a replacement for the metal road pin, but know it’s not always going to
be driven into the ground. The sandbags currently used are a disposable commodity, and the use of bricks, logs or whatever can be found is totally unacceptable. Staying with a recyclable plastic, we designed a tapered base so it can be turned to accommodate a flat or sloping surface. A central slot was added to locate the road. Given the storage and transport has been improved for the road pin, we then added a small locating boss and recess to the new non-conductive base enabling them to be stacked on top of each other and held in place, now giving compact easy storage alongside the non-conductive road pins. This new patented system is now fully non-conductive, easier to store, transport and deploy. Each and every pin deployed is a uniform system across the board, and will meet health and safety standards. An additional lighting system is available that is located in the slotted end of the road pin. In conjunction with Birmingham University this system is now ready and available, creating a safe working environment for staff, workmen and customers.
Tel: 01384 442852 Email: RJWEng@BTinternet.com Visit: www.rjwengineering.co
NE WS IN BRIE F FULL-LENGTH PLATFORM ACCESS RESTORED AT PAIGNTON STATION FOLLOWING JULY FIRE Network Rail and Great Western Railway (GWR) have confirmed that full-length access to Platform 2 at Paignton station was restored from the start of service on Monday 24 August, enabling ninecarriage trains to return four days earlier than expected. The milestone marks a further step in recovery from the fire that caused extensive damage to the station on 21 July. The station reopened to passengers a week after the fire, with temporary access arrangements meaning longdistance trains were initially unable to call, though local stopping services could use the far end of Platform 2. Access to the platform continues via a temporary route through the station car park, with an additional gated entrance now also available. The ticket office, main station entrance and footbridge remain closed while rebuilding work continues, with a temporary ticket office in place. Network Rail route infrastructure engineer Daniel Parkes said reinstating full-length access ahead of schedule was the result of a huge team effort, and that work was now focused on restoring the station canopy, footbridge and other facilities.
81
STATION REFURBISHMENT IN CONVERSATION
in transport and rail. That includes everything from routine train cleaning to more technical and sensitive interventions where specialist training, discretion and fast response are essential. Our team understands that when a client comes to us, they are often under pressure themselves, so our job is to make the process easier, not harder. The reason we have been able to grow is that we focus on being useful in a very practical sense. Clients value clear communication, reliable delivery and the ability to handle both planned work and unexpected events. In a busy sector like rail, that mix is extremely important.
EMILIA FERENC MANAGING DIRECTOR AT PERFECT CLEAN LTD
STUART MCROBB OPERATIONS DIRECTOR AT PERFECT CLEAN LTD
Emilia Ferenc leads the company’s growth as a specialist cleaning partner to the rail industry.
Stuart McRobb oversees service delivery, standards and reporting across the company’s rail contracts.
How did you get started in the industry?
communication between teams and how to make sure standards are not only set, but actually maintained. In a sector like rail, that experience becomes especially important because everything is time-sensitive, highprofile and closely linked to safety and customer perception. What attracted me to Perfect Clean was that it is a business that understands both the detail and the bigger picture. You need a team that can clean to a very high standard, but you also need one that understands schedules, access windows, reporting, communication and the wider commercial realities of the rail environment. That balance between operational precision and client service is what makes the work interesting to me.
EF: My route into the industry was very much driven by an interest in how operational services can genuinely support other businesses rather than simply sit alongside them. I was always drawn to roles where organisation, reliability and trust matter, because those are the things that make a service genuinely valuable in the long term. Over time, that naturally led me into cleaning and facilities services, where the quality of delivery can have a direct impact on customer experience, safety and the reputation of the client. What I found early on was that this industry rewards consistency. It is not enough to be good once; you have to be dependable every day, often under pressure, with different site conditions, different client expectations and very different levels of urgency. That really shaped the way I approach the business now. I have always believed that if you want to build something sustainable, you need a strong operational culture, clear standards and a real understanding of the people and sectors you are serving. McR: My background is rooted in operational delivery, so I’ve always been focused on how services work in practice, not just how they look on paper. I’ve spent much of my career looking at how to make things more efficient, how to improve 82
Tell us about Perfect Clean. EF: Perfect Clean has grown into a business that supports clients across a wide range of sectors, but our approach has always been the same: deliver a professional service that is dependable, responsive and tailored to the specific environment. We do not treat cleaning as a commodity. We see it as part of a wider operational system, especially in rail, where the quality of the service can affect safety, reputation, passenger experience and even the efficiency of the wider operation. Over the years we have developed from a cleaning provider into a specialist partner for more complex environments, particularly
McR: I would describe Perfect Clean as an operationally driven service business with a strong specialist edge. The rail sector in particular demands a level of discipline that goes beyond standard cleaning, and that is where we have built real credibility. We understand that operators need more than a contractor who turns up and does a job; they need a partner who can integrate into their processes, work within tight timeframes and help them protect both service quality and commercial performance. One of the strengths of the business is that we have continued to evolve with the market. We’ve invested in our people, our procedures, our reporting and our ability to respond to different types of work. That has allowed us to support clients not only with the visible side of cleaning, but also with the less visible but equally important operational aspects, such as data capture, service tracking, quality assurance and continuous improvement. Which sectors do you work in? EF: We work across a number of sectors, including commercial, public sector and transport, but rail is one of the areas where our specialist capability really stands out. The requirements in rail are different from most other environments because the operational context is so demanding. You are dealing with limited turnaround times, passenger-facing assets, strict safety expectations and an environment where reliability matters every single day. Within transport, we support both standard and more specialist requirements. That means train cleaning, deep cleans, bio-wash and response work following incidents, but also premium environments where presentation is especially important. The Royal Scotsman is a good example of that. It shows how different rail work can be depending on the operator, the asset and the customer experience being delivered. McR: I would add that rail is not just one sector for us; it is a set of very different operating environments. A commuter service, a heritage or luxury service, depot cleaning and incident response all require different approaches, different timings and
IN CONVERSATION
different levels of detail. That complexity is one reason we enjoy the sector. It forces you to stay sharp and to think operationally at every level. We also work in environments where there is a strong link between cleaning, compliance and reporting. That means the work is not just about appearance. It is about maintaining standards, supporting asset longevity and giving clients confidence that the service is being delivered consistently. In rail, that confidence is incredibly valuable. What is your Unique Selling Point? EF: Our USP is the combination of specialist capability and operational reliability. A lot of companies can offer cleaning services, but not every company can step into a rail environment and understand the pressures, the timings and the need for precise coordination. We have built our business around being able to do that well, and that is especially important in work that is sensitive, urgent or technically demanding. Another part of our USP is the way we work with clients. We do not just arrive, complete a task and leave. We try to understand the operational context, the constraints and the outcome the client is trying to achieve. That allows us to offer solutions that are practical rather than generic. In this sector, that makes a real difference. McR: From an operations point of view, our USP is that we bring structure to complexity. In rail, many of the challenges are not just technical; they are logistical, commercial and reputational. We are very focused on making sure the service is not only delivered to a high standard, but delivered in a way that supports the client’s own objectives. That includes response times, reporting, cost control and quality assurance. We also bring a level of consistency that clients can rely on. Whether the job is routine or highly unusual, the expectation from us is the same: communicate clearly,
‘It is not enough to be good once; you have to be dependable every day.’ Emilia Ferenc
work safely, deliver exactly what has been agreed and leave the client with confidence in the result. What types of products and services do you offer? EF: Our core offer includes professional cleaning services, but in practice our work is much broader than that. In rail, we provide train cleaning, deep cleaning, specialist bio-wash, decontamination support and response services for highly sensitive incidents. We also handle environments that require a more tailored approach, such as premium rolling stock and assets that need extra care because of their materials, finish or customer profile. The important thing is that each service is adapted to the setting. We do not believe in a one-size-fits-all model. A routine service train, a prestige sleeper service and an incident response all require different methods, different products and different levels of supervision. That is why specialist knowledge matters so much. McR: On the operational side, I would say our services fall into three broad groups. First, there is planned maintenance cleaning, where consistency and scheduling are key. Second, there is specialist cleaning, where the environment or the asset requires technical expertise. Third, there is responsive work, where speed, discretion and control matter most. That third category is especially important in rail. There are times when a train or part of the network needs to be recovered quickly after a serious incident, and that is when a specialist partner really proves its value. The job is not just to clean. It is to help the operator recover service, manage risk and restore confidence as quickly as possible. How have the products and services you offer developed over the years? EF: Our services have become more specialised as client expectations have changed. In the early days, the focus was much more on traditional cleaning delivery, but over time the market has demanded more technical capability, more flexibility and more accountability. That has pushed us to develop services that are much more closely aligned with operational needs, especially in rail. We have also placed more emphasis on understanding the wider commercial impact of cleaning. A poor service can affect passenger perception, asset condition and even revenue performance if it causes disruption or delays. So our development as a business has really been about becoming more strategic, not just more technical. McR: I’ve seen a big shift toward data-led and process-led service delivery. Clients want to know not only that the work was done, but how it was done, when it was
done, what issues were identified and what the trend lines look like over time. That has changed the way we operate. We have had to improve our reporting, our tracking and the way we use operational data to support decisions. It has also made us more cost-conscious in a positive sense. Efficiency now matters at every level, from labour planning to materials usage to route planning and mobilisation. The businesses that succeed in this market will be the ones that can deliver quality while also showing clear value. What are some standout projects you’ve been involved in over the years? EF: Two projects that stand out are our work with Hitachi Rail and our involvement with the Royal Scotsman. They represent very different sides of the rail sector, but both are important examples of the kind of standard we aim to deliver. With Hitachi Rail, the focus is on supporting a major operator with services that help keep trains clean, safe and ready for service. With the Royal Scotsman, the expectation is even more exacting in terms of presentation, care and attention to detail. We are also proud of the work we do in more sensitive and difficult circumstances, including cleanups after serious incidents. Those projects are not something we talk about lightly, but they matter because they show how important specialist cleaning is to rail operations behind the scenes. These are often situations where the public only sees the disruption, not the specialist work required to restore the asset and move the operation forward. McR: Standout projects are often the ones where complexity is highest and tolerance for error is lowest. The rail environment can be very demanding, and some of the most challenging work comes from situations where speed, discretion and absolute professionalism are essential. That can include work after traumatic incidents, including terror-related events, where we support the recovery of the asset without discussing the incident itself in detail. Those are the kinds of projects that really show the difference between a standard cleaning contractor and a specialist operator. They require strong procedures, trained people, clear leadership and a calm approach under pressure. What types of companies do you collaborate on projects with? EF: We collaborate with rail operators, rolling stock partners, transport brands, and organisations that need specialist support in sensitive or high-pressure situations. The best collaborations are the ones where there is a shared understanding of quality, timing and communication. In rail especially, the relationship has to be built on trust because the work can be operationally critical. 83
STATION REFURBISHMENT IN CONVERSATION
We also work closely with clients who need more than one layer of service. For example, they may need routine cleaning, but they may also need incident response, enhanced reporting or extra support during peak periods. That is where collaboration becomes very practical, because we are helping the client solve a real operational problem. McR: We work best with organisations that understand the value of a reliable partner. In rail, that often means operators, manufacturers, depot teams and other suppliers within the delivery chain. A lot of our success depends on being able to fit into a wider operational system and make it stronger, rather than simply adding another layer of complexity. Good collaboration also helps with cost control. If everyone understands the priorities, the access arrangements, the reporting requirements and the response expectations, then you reduce waste, avoid duplication and improve service efficiency. That benefits the whole chain.
‘If you cannot measure the service properly, you cannot manage it properly.’ Stuart McRobb
What are some of the biggest challenges this sector currently faces?
and everyone understands their role. That includes access arrangements, product supply, safety requirements, reporting lines and expectations around turnaround times. We spend a lot of time making sure those elements are clear before the work even begins. The better the coordination, the better the outcome. It sounds simple, but in rail, good planning saves time, reduces risk and improves the quality of the final result.
EF: One of the biggest challenges is balancing high standards with operational pressure. Rail operators need services that are not only excellent, but also delivered at speed, in difficult conditions and often within very tight windows. That creates a lot of pressure on scheduling, labour planning and quality control. Another challenge is that expectations keep rising. Passengers expect clean, comfortable environments, while operators expect reliability, transparency and evidence of performance. Meeting all of those expectations consistently is not easy, which is why specialist partners play such an important role.
McR: From my side, I would say supply chain management is one of the most underrated parts of service delivery. Materials, staffing, scheduling, access and reporting all have to work together. If one part is weak, it affects the whole operation. That is why we are very focused on building stable relationships and making sure we have the right systems in place to support predictable delivery. It also helps with cost control. When the supply chain is managed properly, you reduce unnecessary movement, avoid lastminute inefficiencies and get much better visibility on where money is being spent. That makes the business more resilient and more scalable.
McR: I would add that the rail sector is also under constant pressure to demonstrate value. Everyone is looking closely at cost, but cost reduction cannot come at the expense of safety, quality or reliability. That means service providers have to be much smarter in how they plan work, use resources and measure performance. A further challenge is incident recovery. When something serious happens, especially an event involving animals, people or even terror-related incidents, the response has to be swift, professional and discreet. The public may only see delays or disruption, but behind the scenes there is often a lot of complex work required to restore the asset and support the operator.
What is your view of the future of security within the rail sector?
How do you work with the supply chain within this sector?
McR: I agree, and I think we will also see greater use of data and reporting to support security-related decision making. Operators need visibility. They need to know what happened, what was done, how long it took, what the outcome was and whether there are
EF: We see the supply chain as part of the service, not separate from it. In rail, you can only succeed if communication is good 84
EF: Security will become even more connected to operational readiness. In the future, the sector will need to think not just about visible security measures, but also about response capability, recovery and resilience. That is where specialist cleaning and incident support become part of the wider security picture. I also think there will be much more emphasis on standards, documentation and the ability to prove what has been done and when. That is increasingly important in a sector where accountability matters so much.
recurring patterns. That kind of information helps with both prevention and response. Security is not only about physical barriers or cameras. It is also about having the right operational partners in place, with the right procedures, the right people and the ability to act quickly when needed. How do you ensure trains are always returned to service looking spotless and ready for passengers? EF: The answer is a combination of standards, routine and attention to detail. We start by understanding the asset, the service pattern and the client’s expectations. Then we make sure our teams are briefed properly, have the right equipment and understand exactly what ‘ready for service’ means in that environment. For passenger-facing rail assets, the details matter enormously. It is not just about removing visible dirt. It is about leaving a train in a condition that reflects well on the operator and supports the passenger experience. That requires consistency and pride in the work. McR: Operationally, this comes down to planning and verification. We need a clear process, clear ownership and a way to check that the job has been completed to the right standard. In rail, it is very important that the service is not just done, but done in a way that supports punctual return to service. We also think carefully about efficiency. The cleaner and more organised the process, the less time is wasted, the easier it is to manage labour, and the lower the risk of avoidable cost. Good cleaning is not only about appearance. It is about throughput, reliability and operational value. What does bio-wash involve in rail operations, and why is it such an important part of keeping services moving? EF: Bio-wash is a specialist service that deals with situations where a train or rail environment needs careful, controlled recovery after contamination or a sensitive incident. It is important because it helps restore the asset safely and quickly, which in turn supports service continuity. For operators, that can make a big difference to performance, customer confidence and operational resilience. It is also a service where the human side really matters. These are not routine cleans. They are situations that require professionalism, discretion and a calm approach, because the circumstances can be difficult for everyone involved. McR: From an operational standpoint, bio-wash is about recovery and risk management. You need the right procedures, the right materials and the right people, but you also need the ability to respond quickly
IN CONVERSATION
and report clearly. The faster and more effectively you can recover the asset, the sooner it can return to service and the less impact there is on the wider operation. It is also one of the areas where good reporting matters. Clients need to know what was found, what was done, what resources were used and when the asset was cleared. That data helps with accountability, performance tracking and future planning. How do you support operators after highly sensitive incidents, while maintaining discretion and professionalism? EF: The most important thing is to understand that you are being trusted in a very difficult moment. That means acting calmly, communicating clearly and never losing sight of the fact that there are people, families and operational teams affected by the incident. Our role is to support the operator by taking care of the specialist recovery work in a way that is respectful and efficient. In those circumstances, discretion is not optional. It is a fundamental part of the service. We work in a way that protects the client, the staff involved and the wider public conversation around the event.
McR: This is one of the areas where experience really matters. Sensitive incidents require a very disciplined response, because the operational pressure is high and the emotional context can be significant. We have to be fast, but we also have to be careful. We have to be effective, but we also have to be respectful. I would also say that reporting and communication become even more important in these situations. The client needs clarity, the teams need instructions, and the wider operation needs confidence that the issue is being handled professionally. That balance is what specialist support is really about. How does cleaning for a premium service like Royal Scotsman differ from standard rolling stock cleaning? EF: It is a very different experience. Royal Scotsman is a premium, highly distinctive rail product, so the expectations are about far more than basic cleanliness. You are dealing with a service where presentation, heritage, comfort and detail all matter, so the cleaning has to reflect that. It requires care, the right materials and a deep understanding of the asset itself.
There is also a strong expectation around consistency. When guests step into a premium rail environment, every surface and every touchpoint contributes to the experience. That means our team has to work with real precision. McR: From my perspective, premium rail cleaning is one of the clearest examples of how cleaning can influence brand value. You are not just keeping a vehicle clean. You are helping protect the feel, the reputation and the commercial positioning of the service. That means the standard has to be exceptionally high, but also repeatable. It is a good example of how our work supports the wider business outcome. The cleaner and more carefully maintained the environment, the more the operator can deliver the experience their customers expect. How important is rapid response when dealing with animal strikes or other traumatic incidents on the rail network? EF: Rapid response is absolutely critical. In rail, delays have a knock-on effect very quickly, so the sooner a specialist team can intervene, the better the chance of restoring
SPECIALIST CLEANING FOR RAIL SECTOR
FATALITY INCIDENTS TRAIN CLEANING BIO WASH
DEEP CLEAN
DECONTAMINATION GUANO CLEAN
GRAFFITI REMOVAL
EMERGENCY TRAUMA 0800 0431 744
perfectcleanltd.co.uk
CLEANING
85
STATION REFURBISHMENT IN CONVERSATION
the service efficiently. These incidents are also sensitive, so response has to be fast without ever becoming careless. The other important factor is confidence. The operator needs to know that once we are on site, the matter will be handled properly and the asset will be brought back into a safe, serviceable condition. McR: I would say rapid response is one of the most important parts of the entire specialist service model. When you are dealing with serious incidents, including animal strikes or other traumatic events, the pressure is not just about cleaning. It is about getting the operation moving again with as little disruption as possible. That is why planning, readiness and reporting are so important. If your team is well prepared, you can respond quickly, work safely and give the operator a clear picture of progress. That reduces uncertainty and helps the wider network recover faster. What training and procedures are essential for teams working on specialist rail cleaning tasks? EF: Specialist work needs specialist training. Teams have to understand the environment, the risks, the client requirements and the standards they are expected to meet. They also need to know how to work calmly under pressure and how to communicate appropriately in sensitive situations. Procedures matter just as much as training. Without a clear process, you cannot maintain consistency or protect quality. In our world, both people and process have to be strong. McR: I would add that the procedures need to be practical, not just theoretical. It is easy to write a policy; it is much harder to make it work on the ground when access windows are tight, conditions change or an incident needs to be handled quickly. That is why we focus so much on operational readiness, escalation routes, verification and feedback loops. We also use reporting to strengthen training. If the data shows repeated issues, delays or variations, that gives us something concrete to improve. That makes the whole team more effective over time. How has the rail cleaning market changed in recent years, and where do you see demand growing? EF: The market has become more professional and more demanding. Clients want evidence of quality, stronger reporting and a much clearer understanding of the value they are getting. At the same time, they are more open to specialist support because they recognise that not every challenge can be handled in-house or by a general contractor. I think demand will continue to grow in areas where cleaning intersects 86
with recovery, resilience and passenger experience. That includes bio-wash, incident response and premium asset care. McR: I see growth being driven by three things: operational pressure, data visibility and the need for cost efficiency. Operators are under more pressure than ever to control spend, but they also need high standards and rapid response capability. That means they are looking for partners who can do more than clean. They want partners who can help them make better operational decisions.
‘Discretion is not optional. It is a fundamental part of the service.’ Emilia Ferenc
Data and reporting will be central to that. The more the sector adopts measurable performance management, the more valuable specialist providers become, because they can show exactly what they are delivering and where the value sits.
What are your biggest priorities when it comes to reporting, data and cost control? EF: For us, reporting is not a box-ticking exercise. It is part of the service. Good reporting gives the client visibility, helps us understand where we are performing well and shows where we can improve. That might include job completion records, exception reporting, service checks or trend analysis, depending on the contract. Cost control is linked to that. If you have accurate data, you can make better decisions about staffing, materials, timing and workload. That means you are not cutting corners; you are improving efficiency. In a sector like rail, that kind of discipline matters because the margins for error are small and the expectations are high. McR: I would put it even more strongly: if you cannot measure the service properly, you cannot manage it properly. We look at data to understand labour productivity, sitelevel performance, repeat issues, response times and cost drivers. That lets us spot patterns and make improvements before they become bigger problems. It also helps when we are working with clients who need a clear commercial picture. They want to know where money is being spent and what outcomes they are getting. Good reporting creates trust, and trust is what allows longer-term partnership. In practice, that means better planning, fewer surprises and a stronger return on the service investment.
What do you think will matter most to rail operators in the next 5–10 years? EF: I think the biggest priorities will be reliability, flexibility, data-led accountability and the ability to maintain strong passengerfacing standards even under operational pressure. The rail sector will continue to evolve, but those fundamentals will remain central. Operators will want partners who can react quickly, communicate clearly and support the business in a measurable way. McR: I agree, and I’d add cost optimisation as a major theme. The future is going to be about doing more with better insight, not simply spending more. That means better systems, better reporting, better labour planning and better use of data to identify inefficiencies before they become expensive problems. For us, that is where specialist cleaning and operational support really meet. If you can help the client improve service quality, reduce disruption and control costs at the same time, then you become much more than a supplier. You become part of the rail operation itself.
PERFECT CLEAN LTD Perfect Clean Ltd is a UK cleaning and facilities services provider specialising in rail, offering everything from routine train cleaning to specialist decontamination and incident response.
Want to know more about Perfect Clean? Tel: Email: Visit:
BUSINESS PROFILE
Why Temporary Facilities Matter Rail drainage and earthworks are central to the long-term resilience of the railway
A
s weather patterns change, the rail network faces increasing pressure from heavy rainfall, flooding, ground movement, embankment instability, heat and coastal exposure. These risks can affect track beds, cuttings, slopes, bridges and other critical infrastructure. That makes drainage and earthworks projects a major part of resilience planning across the industry. The engineering challenge is clear. But the working environment behind these projects is equally important.
Challenging environments need practical support
Drainage and earthworks projects often take place in locations where conditions are already difficult. Teams may be working beside embankments, near flood-prone areas, in cuttings, on rural routes or in exposed locations where access to existing facilities is limited. Ground conditions may be wet, uneven or changeable. Weather can have a direct impact on how the work is delivered.
For site teams, these practical factors matter
A joined-up site setup
A suitable welfare setup provides space for breaks, washing and changing. Drying rooms can help teams working in wet or muddy conditions. Site offices give supervisors and engineers a place to coordinate activity, hold briefings and manage documentation. Secure storage keeps tools, PPE and equipment close to the work area. These facilities do not remove the challenges of the location, but they help teams manage them more effectively.
A working site may need more than cabins alone. Power, access steps, ramps, foundations, furniture, alarms, lighting, water and waste arrangements can all affect how practical the accommodation is once it is on site. Considering these elements together can make the overall setup easier to manage and better suited to the project. This is particularly useful on rail works, where access, timing and location can already create delivery pressures.
Fixed and moving works
Supporting essential rail works
Not every drainage or earthworks project has the same accommodation requirement. Some works are fixed for a longer period, such as embankment stabilisation, retaining structures or major drainage upgrades. These projects may need a more established compound with welfare units, offices, storage and supporting services. Other works may move between locations, such as inspection, maintenance or smaller drainage interventions. These may require a more flexible setup, including mobile facilities and secure storage that supports teams as the work progresses. Choosing the right approach depends on the programme, the team size, the location and the duration of the works.
Drainage and earthworks are not always the most visible parts of rail infrastructure, but they are essential to keeping the network resilient. For contractors delivering these works, temporary facilities help support the people, equipment and site coordination needed to get the job done. Wernick Hire provides temporary accommodation and site facilities for rail projects across the UK, including welfare units, site offices, storage, drying rooms, power and wider site setup support. By matching the setup to the work, contractors can create more practical environments for teams delivering essential drainage and earthworks programmes.
Storage and drying space should not be an afterthought
On drainage and earthworks projects, storage and drying space can be just as important as standard welfare. Specialist tools, pumps, barriers, PPE and materials all need to be stored securely and kept accessible. Without suitable storage, teams may spend more time moving equipment between locations or working around limited space. Drying rooms can also play an important role, particularly where teams are working in wet, muddy or exposed environments. Providing dedicated drying space can improve comfort and help keep welfare areas more usable throughout the programme.
Tel: 0800 51 55 55 Email: contact.hire@wernick.co.uk Visit: www.wernick.co.uk
87
STATION REFURBISHMENT BUSINESS PROFILE
Building Confidence in Human-centred Rail Design Using flexible digital mannequins to reduce uncertainty, test real user needs and manage design risk in complex projects When the detail starts to matter
Figure 1: DCA has developed the EVERYBODY digital mannequin system – customisable 3D models designed to represent a wider range of real human body types and more realistic movement.
G
ood ergonomic design is often invisible when done well, but it is fundamental to safe, comfortable, and efficient use of a product or service. In the rail industry, detailed standards precisely define important dimensions and features in passenger areas and the cab, but there is far less prescriptive guidance available for areas accessed by the crew. When designing catering facilities, crew control points and maintenance areas, designers and human factors specialists need to develop their own design specifications from first principles. Where there is no prescribed dimensional requirement to work to, the question becomes whether a real person can complete the task safely and confidently: connecting a large high-voltage shore supply cable while reaching into a maintenance area; operating a pneumatic isolation valve under an access 88
skirt; or manoeuvring an atlas cart into a confined galley. Physical mock-ups and testing with real users are invaluable and remain an important part of the process. There is also huge value in explicitly considering the human ‘fit’ earlier in the design process, but to do this, human interactions often need to be represented digitally. This can be complex, as people not only vary in shape and size, but also move in nuanced ways that many traditional design tools cannot fully represent. To address this, DCA has developed a system of digital mannequins known as EVERYBODY. These customisable 3D models are designed to represent a wider range of real human body types and more realistic movement, allowing ergonomic considerations to be brought more directly and earlier into the design process.
Ergonomic assessment is most valuable when the answer is not obvious. If a task is clearly achievable, or clearly not, in-depth analysis is not usually necessary. Ergonomic models tend to be used for the cases which are closer to the boundary, where small differences in posture, body position, or available clearance can affect whether a task can be completed safely. Many existing models are by necessity based on simplified biomechanics and standardised body dimensions. These form a valuable foundation and support compliance with regulations and technical specifications, but they often lead to conservative assumptions in borderline cases. This is where a more precise representation of human movement can help narrow the uncertainty. A person may be able to reach further by twisting through the trunk or raising the shoulder, but this is difficult to account for accurately using simplified reach envelopes. In a tightly constrained equipment bay or underframe access area, for example, the position of a large high-voltage shore supply connection may already be shaped by surrounding equipment (such as the couplers), reliability requirements (such as prevention of dust ingress), structural interfaces and cable routing. Where there is limited scope to reposition the connector without compromising other requirements, a more detailed digital assessment can help show whether the task can be completed safely and assess whether the ergonomic risk has been reduced as far as reasonably practicable. The EVERYBODY mannequins support this more nuanced approach by allowing designers to explore more realistic postures and movements within the CAD environment. They can show how a user might position themselves, including subtleties of trunk and shoulder movements, to handle a stiff cable in the available space. This gives teams a more detailed basis for judging whether a design is workable, especially where the task is close to the limit of what is practical.
BUSINESS PROFILE
user groups. This is especially useful where the design is close to a go/no-go decision, or where a simplified assessment would have to be deliberately conservative. This does not remove disagreement entirely, but it does tend to make conversations more focused. It becomes easier to explain why a particular task is considered achievable, where the remaining risks reside and whether a design change would materially improve the outcome.
A balance of digital and physical methods
Figure 2: A male digital mannequin with 95th percentile stature (i.e. height) and 50th percentile build (i.e. torso depth; hip breadth), from 2020 British data, inspecting a bogie.
Alongside realistic movement, the system can also account for a wider range of body shapes and more recent anthropometric data. This is useful in compact staff areas such as galleys, where small differences in stature or build can affect reach and manoeuvring space. For example, it may help identify which atlas cart bays are easiest to access with heavier or more frequently used carts, whether the swing of a door restricts movement, or whether the position of equipment such as a coffee machine is likely to cause avoidable difficulty in day-today use. In these cases, a relatively simple change can make a noticeable difference to comfort, efficiency, and day-to-day usability.
Bringing ergonomics into the design process
One of the more practical advantages of this mannequin-based system is how it fits into existing workflows. The mannequins sit directly within the same CAD environment as the product or vehicle being designed, which means ergonomics can be considered
constantly as the design develops, rather than as a separate step. This is particularly useful in rail projects, where space constraints are often tight and multiple requirements need to be balanced. Because the models are easy to position and adjust, they can be used repeatedly throughout a project. Designers can compare different options, revisit earlier decisions, and explore alternatives without needing to step outside the design environment.
Supporting clearer decisions
A recurring challenge in rail design projects is that different stakeholders, such as passenger representatives, operating crew, maintenance technicians and manufacturers, all have their own priorities and may, therefore, have different views on which solutions work best. Tools like the EVERYBODY mannequins help make these discussions more evidencebased and rational. Instead of relying purely on subjective judgement, teams can look at how a design performs for specific tasks and
Figure 3: A female digital mannequin with 5th percentile stature (i.e. height) and 95th percentile build (i.e. torso depth; hip breadth), from 2020 British data, refilling a coffee machine in a train galley.
DCA continues to use a mix of tools and methods, including Rapid Entire Body Assessments (REBA) and reach assessments (using both 2D and 3D data), ergonomic rigs, virtual reality (VR) models, and fully representative mock-ups, each suited to different stages of a project, and always testing with real users where possible. The addition of flexible 3D mannequins makes it easier to explore human movement earlier and in more detail. By representing posture, reach, shoulder movement, and trunk twisting more precisely, digital assessments can move closer to the kind of task insight that would traditionally only come from practical assessment with a physical mock-up. They can also be used with different body types and statures, allowing options to be compared for a broader range of users before physical testing begins. This can make later mock-ups more focused. Rather than using them to explore every possible issue for the first time, project teams can use them to confirm and refine decisions that have already been assessed digitally.
Validating design decisions by representing real movement
Established standards and regulations provide the baseline for safe, accessible, and compliant rail design. They are essential, but they do not cover everything. Where prescriptive guidance does not exist, ergonomics need to be assessed from first principles. By representing realistic movement and current anthropometric data within the CAD design environment, tools like the EVERYBODY mannequins can give project teams clearer evidence about how real tasks are likely to be carried out. That evidence helps reduce uncertainty, avoid unnecessary redesign, lend focus to practical rig and mock-up assessments, and support better decisions for the people using, operating, and maintaining the various elements of a rail system.
Email: transport@dca-design.com
89
STATION REFURBISHMENT BUSINESS PROFILE
What Should You Look for in a Railway Lifting Jack? Like most bits of kit in a depot, a set of railway lifting jacks is a serious investment
S
o if you’re looking to upgrade or replace your current rail lifting equipment, you need to know the features that matter – to futureproof your investment and get the most bang for your buck. Here’s what you need if you’re investing in railway lifting jacks (and why these modern features matter for your workshop).
Futureproof capacity
For most rail depots, train lifting jacks are a core piece of their toolkit – so it makes sense to invest in something that can last for years 90
or decades ahead. That means high-quality equipment that’s durable and robust. But it also means thinking ahead to how the needs of your business could change in the future. Before you buy, you should think about: • The types of trains you service (and their weights). • The types of trains you might expand into in the future. • The longest chain of carriages you need to service. • The length of chains you might service in the future.
Some depots buy rail lifting equipment based only on the present: the trains they service now, and the lifting capacities they need. But as your business grows and demand evolves, you could end up needing more, with new types of trains with higher weights, or longer chain of carriages that you service all at once. So like most types of equipment, it’s better to over-spec than under-spec. With a set of railway lifting jacks with a higher capacity, you’ll be ready for the future without new upgrades, and your initial investment will last even longer.
BUSINESS PROFILE
locations along the track, you can also group up the jacks in different configurations, giving you more lifting capacity (and allow for longer chains of carriages). Totalkare Railway Lifting Jacks, for example, can be synchronised in groups from four up to 132 – giving you a potential maximum lifting capacity of 6.6 million kg. Small groups of lifting jacks for smaller carriages with large groups (up to 132) for long chains of carriages.
Remote control
Flexible configuration
Fixed railway lifting jacks are great for consistency and high-volume servicing, especially if they’re built into an existing rail inspection pit. But a set of mobile railway lifting jacks can give you so much more flexibility. As well as the ability to lift trains at different
LIFTING
SERVICING
TRAINING
MOBILE RAIL LIFTING JACKS HEAVY DUTY SYNCHRONISED
If you’re lifting long chains of carriages, you’re looking at dozens of railway lifting jacks, often stretching 50 metres or more in your depot. That’s a lot of area to cover, and it can be difficult to safely supervise the lifting operation. So if you’re buying a train lifting system for longer trains, it’s essential that you choose one with remote control. With a centralised control unit with a Wi-Fi remote that records and stores events, your teams can have complete control over the entire operation, and physically inspect and check the full length of your railway lift without leaving the controls behind.
Rail lifting jacks with an IP rating
As well as the mechanical servicing of the trains you lift, your teams also need to be able to wash and clean the underside of the
RAIL LIFTING JACKS & PIT EXPERTS
carriages. That makes it essential to choose a train lifting jack with the right IP rating (Ingress Protection) to keep your equipment safe from the dust and water involved in the cleaning process. With Totalkare railway lifting jacks, that means an IP rating of 55 which gives you partial protection against dust and particulates, and protection against lowpressure jets of water.
Need some advice?
Upgrading your depot is a serious investment and Totalkare’s railway equipment experts are ready to help. You can see Totalkare’s full range of rail depot equipment in the online shop (including railway lifting jacks and bogie lifting platforms) or start a chat with one of the company’s experts to talk about the options that make sense for your depot.
Tel: 0121 585 2724 Email: sales@totalkare.co.uk Visit: www.totalkare.co.uk
RAIL INSPECTION PITS INCREASE PRODUCTIVITY SAFE QUALITY LIGHTING
RELIABLE
For more information or to request a site visit:
91
Pre-fabricated Rail Pits
Transforming Rolling Stock Maintenance and Inspection. • Welded construction to ensure a water tight finish
MAINTENANCE PITS
• Quicker installation time compared to precast concrete
WASHDOWN & ASH COLLECTION PITS
• High quality finish • All internal service ducts fitted prior to installation
SAFETY COVERS
• Easy to clean
PIT ACCESSORIES
• Rail attachments fitted prior to installation
Premier Pits has led the way in pit manufacturing for over 40 years, supplying workshops worldwide. From inspection and maintenance to ATF, rail, and wash pits, we don’t just manufacture - our experienced Installations Teams handle the complete fitment, ensuring your pit is installed safely, efficiently, and with total peace of mind.
www.premierpits.com
+44 (0)1775 821222
info@premierpits.com
AUDIT READY. REDUCE FOD RISK. TOTAL ACCOUNTABILITY. SCAN TO SEE Tool control solutions for safer, more accountable rail maintenance.
92
BUSINESS PROFILE
Why Specifying the Right Cable Hanger Matters Rail infrastructure depends on thousands of metres of power, signalling and communications cables, but the importance of the systems supporting those cables is often overlooked
IMAGE CREDIT: ANCHOR SYSTEMS INC
C
hoosing the correct cable hanger is critical to ensuring long-term reliability, safety and ease of maintenance throughout the life of a rail asset. Different rail environments present different challenges. Tunnel installations, trackside routes and station upgrades all require cable management solutions capable of withstanding conditions such as vibration, moisture, corrosion and UV exposure. As a result, a one-size-fits-all approach to hanger specification is rarely appropriate. With more than 60 years of engineering and manufacturing experience, Ellis has supported rail projects worldwide by providing cable hanger solutions designed to meet these varied requirements. The company’s newly launched hanger brochure showcases one of the most comprehensive ranges available, including the Pegasus®
Ellis Pegasus GRP Post Fix system installations.
composite cable hanger system, Hercules heavy-duty hangers, retrofit hangers, multifix hangers and GRP post-mounted systems. Each has been developed to solve specific installation challenges while delivering longterm performance. Particularly important in today’s rail environment is flexibility. Whether supporting new infrastructure or upgrading existing cable routes, asset owners increasingly need solutions that can accommodate future expansion while minimising installation time and maintenance requirements. Composite and polymer-based hanger systems offer significant advantages through their lightweight, yet strong, construction, corrosion resistance and ease of installation. As rail networks continue to modernise, specifying the right cable management solution from the outset can help improve
reliability, reduce whole-life costs and support safer operations. Backed by decades of rail industry experience, Ellis continues to help engineers and contractors select the most appropriate hanger solution for every application.
Tel : 01944 758 395 Email: sales@ellispatents.co.uk Visit: www.ellispatents.co.uk
93
PEOPLE
RIA appoints Simon Scott as Technical & Innovation Director The Railway Industry Association (RIA) has appointed Simon Scott as its new Technical & Innovation Director, ahead of the sector’s transition to Great British Railways. Simon’s career spans some 35 years across organisations including British Rail, Network Rail, Amey and Fujitsu. Cambridgeshire and Peterborough appoints new Executive Director of Transport The Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Combined Authority has appointed Tom Bousfield as its new Executive Director of Transport. Tom joins from South Yorkshire Combined Authority, where he serves as Executive Director, and previously held civil service roles across HM Treasury, the Prime Minister’s Implementation Unit and the National Infrastructure Commission.
Suzanne Grant named Interim Managing Director of Merseyrail Suzanne Grant has been appointed Interim Managing Director of Merseyrail while current Managing Director Neil Grabham undertakes an interim assignment as Managing Director at East Midlands Railway. Suzanne has been with Merseyrail for more than a decade, joining as Marketing Manager in 2012 before becoming Chief Commercial Officer and Deputy Managing Director in 2024.
High Speed Rail Group strengthens Board with two appointments The High Speed Rail Group (HSRG) has appointed Mandy Duncan, Managing Director, Rail and Aviation at Kier Infrastructure, and Jonathan Sharrock, Senior Account Director at Arcadis, to its Board of Directors. 94
LRSSB appoints new NonExecutive Director The Light Rail Safety and Standards Board (LRSSB) has appointed Damien Chabas, Managing Director of KeolisAmey Metrolink, as a Non-Executive Director, strengthening operator representation on its board. Damien has been Managing Director for KAM since July 2023, having previously worked at Yarra Trams in Melbourne. Logistics UK appoints Northern Ireland Policy Lead Logistics UK has appointed Brenda Maguire as its Northern Ireland Policy Lead, operating out of the organisation’s Belfast office. With over 16 years’ experience in policy and campaigning, Brenda has previously represented major health charities, retail and hospitality businesses and the banking sector across Northern Ireland. Alstom appoints Chief Communications Office Alstom has appointed Cathy Pianon as Chief Communications Officer, effective 1 October 2026. Reporting to Chief Executive Officer Martin Sion, she will lead the Group’s global communications function across more than 60 countries.
Amey appoints Executive Advisor Amey has appointed Jonathan Goring as Executive Advisor to support the company’s next phase of growth. He brings senior leadership experience across Capita, Morgan Sindall, PA Consulting, Mott MacDonald and Systra, including roles on HS2 and NEOM.
Asset Management Specialists Delivering innovative solutions for every asset management challenge - no matter the scale. www.geoaccess.co.uk
Asset Inspections Access Solutions Bespoke Projects Enabling Works
95
If you have a safety concern, make the right call and report it. Tell your supervisor, or contact us in complete confidence. Call 0800 4 101 101 or download our CIRAS reporting app.
Scan me 96
We find safety in listening.