Is20140622 이슈리포트 해외재난대응사례

2014. 06. 22

해외의 재난 후 진상규명위원회 사례 미국∙일본∙호주의 사례와 세월호 특별법 제정을 위한 시사점

06 2001 14 2005 21 2011 35 2009

9.11

( 1

)

(

( )

)

(

)

1

차례 I. 2001 1.

9.11

(

)

6

2.

6

3. 9.11

11

4.

II. 2005

(

1.

13

)

14

2.

14

3.

4.

19

6.

20

5.

7.

III. 2011 1.

19

1

(

20

)

21

2. 5

21

3.

23

4.

26

5.

31

6.

7.

IV. 2009 1.

2. 2009 3.

V. 2

4.

(

)

(

)

32 33 35 35 37 38 39

15

요약

2014 2014

4

16 ,

6

475

22

171 , '

.

.

․

,

292 ,

,

,

12

.

.

․

'

. .

9.11

(The National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon

the United States, 9/11 Commission)

(Select Bipartisan

Committee to Investigate the Preparation for and Response to Hurricane Katrina), ,

1

,

,

(2009 Victoria Bushfires Royal Commission)

.

.

.

. <

> 2009 )

(9.11

1

(州) (州)

(州)

3

2001

(

)

9

11

2005 8 23~30

2002 11 27 ( 20 )

2005 ( 5

10 10

(

15

) 11

(

2

3

2011 ( 7

12 )

(

)

.

, ,

)

,

11

,

,

,

)

,

,

38 1,167 400

,

3 10,633 , 2,415

2,000

,

,

,

,

50

,

,

1

3

:

州

)

14 1,256 26 .

1,300 .

7

17

,

,

2 (5 ) 4

.

,

, ,

,

.

.

,

, ,

(

,

1

~2

2009 2 16 ( 17 )

10 .

9

, ,

2009

8

, .

,

12

1,200 250 ․

9

2011

,

.

11 ,

9 .

.

11

I. 2001년 9.11 테러 (미국)

1. 배경

2001

9 11

( 3,000

.

),

(war on terror)

.

100

(security state) . 2001

10

26

(Patriot Act: Uniting and

Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism)

.

2. 미국에 대한 테러 공격에 관한 국가위원회 (The National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States, 9/11 Commission) 1)

107-306 .

2)

2001

9

2002

18

2004

11

5

2004

(

27

27 7

: www.9-11commission.gov

9.11

26

.3

)

2002

107-306

9.11

.

11

.

2001

9

,

,

11

, 9.11

.

3 Public Law 107-306, Title VI. National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States, Section 601. Establishment of Commission

5

.

,

3)

(

10 )

1

1

2

2

2

2

4)

5

(

),

2002

12

<9.11 · · · ·

.

,

, .

6

. .

,

,

,

>

Thomas Kean : Lee H. Hamilton Richard Ben-Veniste Max Cleland :

:

, :

,

,

,

,

, 2003

Fred F. Fielding : , , Jamie Gorelick : , Slade Gorton : , Bob Kerrey : , New School University Max Cleleand . · John F. Lehman : , · Timothy J. Roemer : , Representative from the 3rd District of Indiana · James R. Thompson : , *

,

15

· · · ·

5)

,

80

.

8

,

12 , 9.11

.

, - Democrat, former U.S.

.

,

· 9.11 ·

,

·

,

.

(

)

.

· · · · ·

,

.

6)

,

1,100

300

2004

3

15 FBI

19

.

.

.

, 10 PENTTBOM4

,

,

.

.

.

W.

,

.

.

.

3

.

· Dick Cheney : .

250

.

. Dick Cheney

10

1,500

1,200

110

· George W. Bush : 1

.

.

107-306

7)

.

.

· George John Tenet : · Colin Powell :

· Donald H. Rumsfeld :

4 PENTTBOM 4,000

FBI

2001

9.11

3,000

.

. FBI

7

· Condoleezza Rice :

.

.

· Richard Armitage : · Paul Wolfowitz : · Tom Ridge :

,

· John Ashcroft :

· Bill Clinton :

.

.

· Al Gore :

.

.

.

.

· Madeleine Albright : · William Cohen : · Sandy Berger :

· Richard A. Clarke : · Janet Reno :

· Sibel Edmonds :

FBI

8)

,

.

,

,

<9.11

.5 >

1. 2003 9.11

3

31 -4

, 2. 2003

1 .

5

.

,

.

,

,

22 -23

5 Public hearings of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States, http://govinfo.library.unt.edu/911/hearings/index.htm

8

, 9.11 3. 2003 “

,

,

4. 2003

5. 2003 ,

9

10

“

“

7

“

.

8

”

.

1

26-27

8. 2004

3

23-24

4

8

.

9. 2004

.

,

,

.

.

,

,

.

7. 2004

.

.

,

12

.

”

19

”

6. 2003

”

14

11

,

,

.

,

,

.

,

1998

.

8

2001

9

11

Condoleeza Rice 10. 2004

4

13-14

11. 2004

5

18-19

9.11

2001

9

12. 2004 9.11

11

6

.

16-17

,

9.11

9.11

.

,

9.11

.

.

.

: Public hearings of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States

9) 9

19

15

.

.

.

.

2

9.11

.

9.11

.

,

,

,

(National Counter- terrorism Center, NCTC)

41

,

,

, FBI

2011 9.11

“10

:

(Tenth Anniversary Report Card: The Status of the 9/11

commission recommendations)”

.

,

.

9.11

Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act)

2004

12

17

.

(Intelligence

3. 9.11 국가위원회 활동의 의의와 한계

9.11

.

9.11

(Family Steering Committee for the

9/11 Independent commission)6 .

9.11

(Jersey Girls)

4

6 Family Steering Committee for the 9/11 Independent Commission, http://www.911independentcommission.org/index.html 9.11

.

http://peacefultomorrows.org/) 10

2005

9.11

9.11

12

2

9.11

13

(Peaceful Tomorrow, .

.

.

9.11

9.11

.7

Whistleblowers Coalition)

.

9.11

FBI,

,

.

(Henry Kissinger) ,

9.11

1

2

.

,

. . 9.11

(Philip D. Zelikow)

1

.

(Karl Rove)

.

CIA

7 9.11

2008 CIA

1 , NBC

Security

.8

(National

.

‘

.

, 9.11

. 9.11

.

”

“2001

(failure of imagination)'

.

4/1

7 St. Petersburg Times, Angry widow calls for new 9/11 panel, 12 August 2005, http://www.sptimes.com/2005/08/12/Worldandnation/Angry_widow_calls_for.shtml

8 National Security Whistleblowers Coalition, The 9/11 Commission: A Play on Nothing in Three Acts, 5 September 2006, http://www.nswbc.org/Press%20Releases/NSWBC-911Comm.htm

11

.

9.11

(Thomas Kean)

Hamilton

(Lee Hamilton) .

“Without Precedent: The Inside Story of the 9/11 Commission” ,

,

300

,

.

4. 세월호 진상규명에 던지는 시사점 : 9.11

.

.

.

9.11

9.11

.

9.11

,

.

,

,

.

,

․

,

W. .

14

.

12

,

.

․

107-306

.

.

,

II. 2005년 허리케인 카트리나 (미국)

1. 배경

2005

8

23 ~30 , 80%

250km .

.

,

300

1,836

135

.

.

1,080

.

50

.

2. 정부 대응

.

.

.

. .

.9

.

4

,

4

.

105

7,200

.

Emergency Management Agency, FEMA)

.

3~4

.

9 2006

.

10

(Congressional Budget Office)

(Federal

236

2001

9.11

.

3,200

13

10

2006

10 ,

‘

(the Post-Katrina Emergency Management Reform Act)11

.

2001

9.11

(Department of Homeland Security)

. 1973

FEMA

’

1979

.

3. 미국 허리케인 카트리나에 대한 준비 및 대응 진상조사를 위한 초당파적 위원회(Select Bipartisan Committee to Investigate the Preparation for and Response to Hurricane Katrina) 1)

2005

9

15 , .

(

2006

2

)

439

15 ,

.

: katrina.house.gov

( 11 )

2)

11 ,

.

Tom Davis

10 1973 ·

·

2001

·

9 ,

20

9.11

:

1995 ~2008

4

, 2014

5

.12

(FEMA)

‘ .

,

5

5

19

.

’

(CRS) ”

2007 . (

1979 3

. ,

. , 9·11

“

...

http://www.hani.co.kr/arti/international/japan/637887.html)

11 The Post-Katrina Emergency Management Reform Act https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/109/s3721

:

12 Charlie Melancon, Gene Taylor, William J. Jefferson, Cynthia Mckinney, Shelia Jackson Lee 14

439

1

.

(

: Harold Rogers ( /

34

)

), Christopher Shays (

), Steve Buyer (

Thornberry ( (

/

/

/

/

), Kay Granger(

), Bill Shuster (

,

), Sue Myrick (

/

(

5

.

,

,

,

,

?

,

?

?

500,000

5)

3

,

,

), Jeff Miller (

/

)

,

.

,

9

9

,

,

. ,

,

?

,

?

4)

), Mac

), Charles W. “Chip” Pickering

,

,

/

/

.

50

,

), Henry Bonilla

.

3)

/

?

?

. .

15

,

,

.

,

,

,

Investigation Overview

,

,

,

.

.13

<

> 1. 2005

9 22 , . ? ? (http://katrina.house.gov/hearings/09_22_05/witness_list092205.html)

?

2. 2005 9 27 , (FEMA) (http://katrina.house.gov/hearings/09_27_05/witness_list092705.html) 3. 2005 10 19 , (Michael Chertoff) (http://katrina.house.gov/hearings/10_19_05/witness_list101905.html) 4. 2005

10

27 ,

,

,

/

/

(http://katrina.house.gov/hearings/10_27_05/witness_list102705.htm) 5. 2005 11 2 , (http://katrina.house.gov/hearings/11_02_05/witness_list110205.htm) 6. 2005 11 9 , (http://katrina.house.gov/hearings/11_09_05/witness_list110905.htm) 7. 2005 12 6 , (http://katrina.house.gov/hearings/12_06_05/witness_list_120605.htm) 8. 2005 12 7 , (http://katrina.house.gov/hearings/12_07_05/witness_list_120705.htm) 9. 2005 12 14 , (http://katrina.house.gov/hearings/12_14_05/witness_list_121405.htm) :

(http://katrina.house.gov/)

6)

,

,

. 2006

1

.

67

29

13 Live Multimedia Stream: http://www.c-span.org/search/?sponsorid[]=61128 16

19

.

,

,

,

.

,

,

,

,

,

7)

.

.

,

,

,

,

5

9.11

. .

.

,

,

,

,

, ,

,

,

,

.

.

.

.

.

,

, ,

, ,

.

.

, ,

17

,

,

.

,

.

.

4. 카트리나 하원 특별위원회 활동의 의의와 한계

. 9.11

.

.

.

,

,

.

,

,

5. 카트리나 재해에 대한 민관 대응 비교14 * -

HCA: :

* -

*

, ,

/ :

18

.

,

,

,

,

. ,

.

*

*

20

,

* -

,

Charity hospital: .

HCA

: ,

,

,

.

-

(FEMA)

. (

)

/ , ,

* -

* FEMA, FAA, /

/

* (

)

/

,

,

*

.

.

6. 기타 진상조사 활동

2006

2

23 ,

Learned)

2006

.16

.15

5

(The Federal Response to Hurricane Katrina: Lesson (Frances Fragos Townsend) .

2 ,

.

.

.

.

7. 세월호 진상규명에 던지는 시사점 :

.

: .

14 Public

and

Private

Responses

to

Katrina,

The

Independent

Institute,

.

20

October

2005,

http://www.independent.org/printer.asp?page=%2Fnewsroom%2Farticle%2Easp?id=1589, Steven Horowitz, Doing the Right Thing: The Private Sector Response to Hurricane Katrina as a Case Study in the Bourgeois Virtues, George Mason University Working Paper, August 2009

15 The White House, The Federal Response to Hurricane Katrina: Lesson Learned, 23 February 2006, http://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/reports/katrina-lessons-learned/

16 Homeland Security Digital Library, Full Senate report titled Hurricane Katrina A Nation Still Unprepared, 2 May 2006, https://www.hsdl.org/blog/view/s_1884

19

III. 2011년 후쿠시마 제1원자력 발전소 사고 (일본)

1. 배경

2011 .

11 ,

9.0

1

,

)

3

.

.

.

(International Nuclear Events Scale, INES)

7(

2. 5개의 사고조사위원회

‧

,

.

.

· (東京電力福 島原子力発電所に おける 事故調査 ・ 検証委員会)

) /

5

(畑村洋太郎

(東京電力福島原子 力発電所事故調査 委員会)

/

(黒川清)

17

.

(福島原発事故独 立検証委員会)

(福島原子力事故調 査委員会)

(北澤宏一) /

(山崎雅男) / ( )

‘

,

.

,

1 (東京電 力福島第一原子力 発電所事故に関す る調査委員会) (田中知) / ( ,

’

17

20

․ ,'

事故調査委員会)',

1

4

(National Diet Library)

(福島第一原発事故と4つの

(Issue Brief) 756 (2012. 8.

)

,

,

[

] ,

772 ]

[

(

[

]

[

2012

7

1167

]

23

·

]

[

300

]

600

,

,

2012

.

-

7

,

,

,

,

5

2012

2

27

2011

12

2

2013

3

27

2012

6

20

2014

3

8

,

, ,

,

7

:

50

‘

’

,

,

,

,

, 25

,

(humanity)

-

2011 12 26

)

),

[ ,

,

(truth), (independence

,

No. 756

,

4

.

,

,

·

, .

·

23) http://dl.ndl.go.jp/view/download/digidepo_3526040_po_0756.pdf?contentNo=1 (

,

,

,

3

, 2014. 6. 21) 21

,

.

. .

,

(off site center) ,

“

.

, .

,

”

,

(SPEEDI)

,

.

3. 정부조사위원회 1)

2011

5

24

閣官房, Cabinet Secretariat) ‧

‧

‘

,

(内

(東京電力福島原子力発電所における事故調査·検証委員会)’

1

1 ,

8 ,

,

.

.

18

,

(古川道郎)

,

.

. ,

.

19

► ► ►

18

22

畑村

1

: 畑村洋太郎 (

8 · 尾池和夫 (

1

)(

: 柳田邦男 (

)

,

2014. 6. 21)

,

,

,

,

,

) ,

,

http://www.cas.go.jp/jp/seisaku/icanps/ (

,

.

.

)

· 柿沼志津子 (

,

· 高須幸雄 ( (IAEA · 高野利雄 ( · 田中康郎 ( · 林陽子 (

· 古川道郎 ( ►

· 吉岡斉 (

2 · 淵上正朗 (

, ))

, ,

► · 堀井秀之 ( ) ( )

,

,

,

,

,

· 安部誠治 (

► 1 · 小川新二 (

,

)

(

)

,

·

)

)

,

,

)

) (

,

)

) ,

)

,

,

· 中曽根祐司 (

,

· 片田敏孝 ( · 矢守克也 ( · 関谷直也 (

,

2) 7

23

2011

,

20

)

,

· 大井川宏之 ( )

19

)

,

· 越塚誠一 (

, 2012

)

,

· 城山英明 (

)

,

,

,

,

,

,

6

.

,

,

7 ,

, ,

,

20

)

,

.

) (

)

)

. 2011

.

,

12

26

,

http://www.cas.go.jp/jp/seisaku/icanps/2011/07/03/member.pdf ( )(

)

http://www.cas.go.jp/jp/seisaku/icanps/post-2.html (

2014. 6. 21)

2014. 6. 21)

23

.

“

·

” ·

.

7

8

”

”

·

田 調書)’ )

”

, 2011

90%

7

772

22

.

11

“

“

’

,

.

6

22

, ‘

.

29

13

. ’

“

.

21

11

1,479

‘

.

A4

16 (

1

.

.

400

1.9

)

, 2011 "

"

21 22

23

24

12

7

.

, 2012

7

·

23

·

·

,

.

.

26

.

.

3)

8

. ‘

.

23

(

(吉

25

,(

,

·

2

http://www.cas.go.jp/jp/seisaku/icanps/2011/07/13/0708gaiyou-No2.pdf ( “日

(2011. 7. 8)

2014. 6. 21)

http://www.asahi.com/special/yoshida_report/ ( 90%

http://asahikorean.com/article/newclear_disaster/AJ201405200075 (

2014. 6. 21)

” (2014. 5. 20)

2014. 6. 21)

)

7

‘

·

’ .

SPEEDI

,

,

,

.

.

4. 국회조사위원회24 1)

.

2011

9

30 ,

178

.

‘

京電力福島原子力発電所事故調査委員会)’

2011

12

’

1

, 10

. ’

.

25

賀 禮子) .

. .

2008

(東

‘ ‘ ,

,

.

2 ,

,

9 .

(蜂須

1

,

.

.

24

25

2012

10

(

30

)

http://warp.da.ndl.go.jp/info:ndljp/pid/3856371/naiic.go.jp/index.html (

.

(http://naiic.go.jp/) .

2014. 6. 21)

http://warp.da.ndl.go.jp/info:ndljp/pid/3856371/naiic.go.jp/about/commissioners/ (

2014. 6. 21) 25

, .

26

,

,

,

1 )

: 黒川清 (

► 9 · 石橋克彦 ( · 大島賢三 ( · 櫻井正史 (

,

· 田中耕一 (

)

,

(2012

· 児玉龍彦 (

2

9 ,

,

· 八田達夫 (

2011

, 26

"

12 ."

,

)

. 2011

,

12

4

19

)

) )

)

) ) )

. . (東京電力福島原子力発電所事故調査委員会法)

,

ttp://warp.da.ndl.go.jp/info:ndljp/pid/3856371/naiic.go.jp/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/fa7348863ec730fa7f

06fff1c0b71fcd.pdf ( 26

.

,

)(

)

)

)

,

8

,

)

,

· 蜂須賀禮子 ( ► 3 · 木村逸郎 (

,

,

· 野村修也 ( · 横山禎徳 (

, ,

,

· 田中三彦 (

.

,

,

· 崎山比早子 (

/

,

►

,

.

.

2)

,

2014. 6. 21)

9

7

,

10

5

’

USTREAM( .

.

.

2011 1,167

.

,

27 28

21)

10,633 ,

·

),

,

TV .

,

,

2,000 .

10

13,000

400

28

.

,

2,415

80

.

,

12

900

19

‘

.

,

1

2012

,

,

.

.

,

.

,

6

27

60

.

.

38 3

.

17

. .

(

) ,

http://warp.da.ndl.go.jp/info:ndljp/pid/3856371/naiic.go.jp/about/(

http://warp.da.ndl.go.jp/info:ndljp/pid/3856371/naiic.go.jp/resources/(

2014. 6.

2014. 6. 21) 27

,

,

·

,

3)

2012

7

5

(

,

‘

’

‘

,

7

)

.

·

’

.

2

16

,

.

‘ 29

,

7 ’

,

.

, △

, △

, △

·

,

, △

29

2 ‘

,

.

28

,

,

,

,

,

1

,

’ 16 (Cliff Edge) ,

,

, ,

,

,

,

,

,

, △

,

,

, △

, △

30

• •

.

. "

'

•

'

"

"

.

「

,

.

,

.

,

,

, ,

' . ,

.

.

.

"

"

, ."

.

'

,

'

,

•

,

,

.

•

30

·

,

」,

•

•

"

.

•

,

3

,

.

•

•

1

.

,

.

,

,

. "

.

,

"

"

'

"

, .

http://warp.da.ndl.go.jp/info:ndljp/pid/3856371/naiic.go.jp/blog/reports/main-report/ (

,

2014. 6. 21) 29

.

.

.

•

.

,

.

5. 민간조사위원회

橋洋一)

2011 31

RJIF

9

.

(福島原発事故検証委員会)

‘

(Rebuild Japan Initiative Foundation,

. RJIF

. ‘ ’

1)

30

.

► ►

1 : 北澤宏一 ( 6 · 遠藤哲也 ( , ) · 但木敬一 (

· 野中郁次郎 ( · 山地憲治 (

· ( ) 黒川清 (

)

32

,

(WG)

.

,

,

)

,

,

· 野中郁次郎 (

►

,

, ,

(船

1

. ,

RJIF)

,

)

,

) (

) )

, ,

,

)

20 秋山信将、井形彬、砂金祐年、大塚隆、開沼博、勝田忠広、菊池弘美、北澤桂、佐々木一如、塩崎

彰久、信田智人、菅原慎悦、鈴木一人、戸崎洋史、友次晋介、中林啓修、藤代裕之、藤吉雅春、堀

尾健太、村上健太、山口孝太

31

32 30

http://rebuildjpn.org/about-us/

http://rebuildjpn.org/project/fukushima/committee/

.

2)

RJIF

“

”

”

.

,

.

33

400

"

2012

3)

‘

34

2

,

27

(

,

·

,

,

.

2012

3

.

"

34

(Human Error)' ”

14

.

. “

‘

, “

’ ,

.

.

,

·

)”

3

.

'

’

(FEMA)

33

,

, 2012

,

,

(OB)

.

,

,

300

,

,

,

.

“

.

.

”

,

“

http://rebuildjpn.org/project/fukushima/hearing/ http://rebuildjpn.org/project/fukushima/report/

31

" ", "

,

(

", "

" ", "

)

", "

,

.

(北澤宏一)

.

"

"

"

.

" ,

.

6. 일본 사고조사위원회의 의의와 한계 1

.

5

(

3 .

19

. ,

.

,

)

.

17 ,

. .

,

.

.

.

. .

32

.

’

. ‘

.

7. 세월호 진상규명에 던지는 시사점(국회 조사위원회를 중심으로) ,

,

(

.

:

,

‘

.

’

. )

17

19

.

.

.

33

IV. 2009년 빅토리아 산불 (호주)

1. 배경

2009

4,000

1

2009 .

.

173

3,500

2

2

7

2009

10,000 , 414

, 45

600 2

.

7 .

300

, 2,030

.

,

2. 2009 빅토리아 산불 왕립위원회 1)

(州)

2009 .

2009

8

17

(州)

(2009 Victoria Bushfires Royal Commission) 2010

88 B35

.

.

7

16 31

.

(Executive Committee)

(Terms of Reference)

: http://www.royalcommission.vic.gov.au/Home

Hon. Bernard Teague AO .

(州)

2

,

( 3 )

2)

2009

.

: 20

2008

35 Section 88B of the Victorian Constitution Act 1975 : The Governor in Council has, and is to be taken always to have had, the power to issue a commission to a person or persons to make an inquiry into such matters as are specified by the Governor in Council. (

34

.)

Ron McLeod AM

Susan Pascoe AM

,

2009

,

,

2)

,

2009

3

. 1958

12

:

.

3)

: 2003

2006

,

, ,

3)

2009

4

,

1)

,

,

.

9

,

,

4)

26

18

.

.

14

1,256

1,700 .36

.

.

9

,

,

60

,

180

.

. .

5)

36

37

2009

,

3

,

,

,

16

2009

.

5

. .

18

1,260

.37

: http://www.royalcommission.vic.gov.au/Community-Consultations

: http://www.royalcommission.vic.gov.au/Submissions

35

6)

38

209

2009

.

155

4

.

. 100

20

2010

5

26

.

9

23

434

.

.

.39

,

7

51

1

2

7)

83

2009

2009

11

24

8

.

.

17

.

40

,

. 1)

3)

4)

67

,

2) ,

(country fire authority), .

.

, ,

3. 호주 빅토리아 산불 왕립 위원회 활동의 의의와 한계

38

39 40

36

.

: http://www.royalcommission.vic.gov.au/Hearing-Schedule

Leave to Appear :

http://www.royalcommission.vic.gov.au/Hearing-Schedule/Leave-to-Appear :

http://www.royalcommission.vic.gov.au/Commission-Reports

.

.

.

.

.

,

4. 세월호 진상규명에 던지는 시사점

:

26

:

.

17

. .

: :

.

,

.

2

.

37

V. 결론

. .

.

.

.

.

미국에 대한 테러 공격에 관한 국가위원회 (9.11 국가위원회) : 9.11

.

.

.

9.11

9.11

.

9.11

,

.

,

,

.

,

․

,

W. .

14

.

38

,

.

․

107-306

.

.

,

허리케인 카트리나에 대한 준비 및 대응 진상조사를 위한 초당파적 위원회 :

.

: .

.

도쿄전력 후쿠시마 제1원자력발전소 사고 진상조사를 위해 각각 설립된 정부, 국회, 민간 사고조사위원회 ,

,

(

.

,

’

:

‘

. ) 19

17

.

.

.

.

2009 빅토리아 산불 왕립위원회

:

26

:

.

. .

:

.

.

,

2

:

39

17

.

해외의 재난 후 진상규명위원회 사례를 통해 본 세월호 특별법 제정을 통한 국민참여형 진상규명국가위원회 설립 원칙41

:

,

,

/

,

,

,

: :

40

,

:

:

41

,

『

5 ”

,

. 2014

, 5

』

1 “

28 , http://www.peoplepower21.org/Solidarity/1163011

참여연대 이슈리포트 해외의 재난 후 진상규명위원회 사례 2014. 06. 22

Copyright ⓒ

02-723-5051 pspdint@pspd.org , 2014 ※

0%,

02-723-5300

110-043

www.peoplepower21.org

.

02-723-4251 9 16 (

)

.