County Pima
Parcel # 141-28-1990
Site Address 9168 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner Clutter, Jon
Co-Owner
Owner Address 9168 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Parcel Size 0.11 Acres (4,748 SqFt)
Town / Range / Section / Quarter 15S / 15E / 22 / SE / NW
Building Type
Subdivision / Plat Silver Pass Ph 02
Condo Name
Legal Lot / Block 331
Census Tract / Block 004074 / 1008
Jurisdiction Name Tucson
Land Use / Land Use Std 0133 - SFR GRADE 0103 RURAL SUBDIVIDED / 1001 - Single Family Residential
Assessed $17,309.00
Code (Tax Code Area) 2050
PASS PHASE II LOT 331
Vail Zoning Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential
Transfer Information
Loan Date: 03/03/2021 Loan Amt: $171,850.00 Doc Num: 810 Doc Type: Stand Alone Mortgage
Loan Type: Finance Type: New Conv Lender: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC
Rec. Date: 06/07/2017 Sale Price: $180,000.00 Doc Num: 1580213 Doc Type: Warranty Deed
Owner: Jon Clutter
Orig. Loan Amt: $176,739.00
Finance Type:
Grantor: MOTZKIN LORY M
Title Co: LONG TITLE AGENCY INC
Loan Type: FHA Lender: V I P MORTGAGE INC
Sentry Dynamics, Inc. and its customers make no representations, warranties or conditions, express or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of information contained in this report.
Sentry Dynamics, Inc. and its customers make no representations, warranties or conditions, express or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of information contained in this report. 07/16/2026 Prepared by: Becky Schueneman
Transfer Record(s) Found For: 141-28-1990 9168 E Muleshoe St, Tucson AZ 85747
Recording Date 03/03/2021 Sale Amount
Grantee Name JON CLUTTER Title Co Mtg 1 Loan Type 20 / New Conv
Grantor Name Doc # 810
Lender PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC
Recording Date 06/07/2017
Grantee Name JON CLUTTER Title Co LONG TITLE AGENCY INC
Grantor Name MOTZKIN LORY M Doc # 158.213
Lender V I P MORTGAGE INC
Recording Date 07/24/2015 Sale Amount
Grantee Name LORY M MOTZKIN Title Co FIDELITY
Grantor Name
Lender NOVA FINANCIAL & INVESTMENT CORP
Recording Date 07/17/2009
Grantee Name LORY M MOTZKIN Title Co METIA
Grantor Name ALI FRANCESCO Doc # 137.44
Lender GATEWAY FUNDING DIVERSIFIED MTG SVCS LP
Recording Date 06/15/2006 Sale Amount
Grantee Name FRANCESCO ALI Title Co TSTTI
Grantor Name
Lender AMERICAN MORTGAGE SPECIALISTS INC
Type 93 / Stand Alone Mortgage
1
Type 12 / FHA
Type 71 / Warranty Deed
1 Amount $115,000.00
1 Loan Type 20 / New Conv
Type 68 / Special Warranty Deed
/ Unknown
Recording Date 05/17/2006 Sale Amount Mtg 1 Amount $150,000.00
Grantee Name FRANCESCO ALI Title Co TSTTI Mtg 1 Loan Type 13 / Fannie/Freddie
Grantor Name Doc # 1247 Doc Type 93 / Stand Alone Mortgage
Lender MORTGAGEIT INC
Recording Date 01/20/2006 Sale Amount $65,000.00 Mtg 1 Amount
Grantee Name FRANCESCO ALI Title Co Mtg 1 Loan Type
Grantor Name KINKAID SANDRA E
Lender
# 13.1251
Type 15 / Cash Sale Deed
Recording Date 04/17/1996 Sale Amount $87,365.00 Mtg 1 Amount $50,000.00
Grantee Name SANDRA E KINKAID Title Co Mtg 1 Loan Type 20 / New Conv
Grantor Name DEL WEBBS COVENTRY HOMES OF TUCSON INC
# 475
Lender FIRST MUIRFIELD MTG
Type 20 / Corporation Deed
Recording Date 04/17/1996 Sale Amount
Mtg 1 Amount
Grantee Name DEL WEBBS COVENTRY HOMES CONST OF TUCSON Title Co FIRST AMERICAN TITLE Mtg 1 Loan Type
Grantor Name FIRST AMERICAN TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY
Lender
Doc # 473
Recording Date 04/17/1996 Sale Amount
Grantee Name DEL WEBBS COVENTRY HOMES OF TUCSON INC
Doc Type 71 / Warranty Deed
Mtg 1 Amount
Title Co FIRST AMERICAN TITLE Mtg 1 Loan Type
Grantor Name DEL WEBBS COVENTRY HOMES CONST OF TUCSON Doc # 474
Lender
Doc Type 20 / Corporation Deed
Sales Comparables Details
Criteria Selected:
Searched by Radius: 1 Mile
Date Range: 07/16/2025 to 07/16/2026
Land Use: Same as Subject Subject Property
Comp #1
Buyer: Mary Koenig & Cp Robert
Seller: MCCOLLOM WARRAN
Comp #2
Buyer: Zachary Hardy & Emily Batista
Seller: DEHLER JAMES
Comp #3
Buyer: Kaitlynn Maxon
Seller: WHITE CINTIA
Comp #4
Carlos Barajas
DIPAOLA DAVID JOSEPH
Comp #5
Site Address: 9369 E Yogo Sapphire LnSale Date: 02/27/2026
3 / 2
2001
Buyer: Nicholas Acker
Seller: SUE ACKER
Comp #6
Site Address: 7912 S Lennox Ln
Francisco & Oneida Corrales
Seller: BEVANS BRUCE
Comp #7
Site Address: 7881 S Lauder St
Paul Courchesne
Seller: GILLIE DAVID C
Comp #8
Site Address: 9489 E Lochnay Ln
1994
Buyer: Leslie Gonzalez & Javier Herrera
Seller: BR BST AZ I PKG 1 LLC
Comp #9
Address: 7871 S Kilbrennan Wy
Buyer: Nicholas Chillemi
Seller: BR BST AZ I PKG 1 LLC
Comp #10
Buyer: Wesley & Chelsea Davis
Seller: ZEBBY MILES
This information is provided as a courtesy only, “as is,” without warranty of any kind, either express or implied, including without limitations any warranty of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. In supplying this information, the provider is making no representation or warranty that the information contained herein is complete, current, or free from error, nor should the information be considered as rendering legal, tax or other professional advice. As such, the provider does not assume, and expressly disclaims, any liability and/or responsibility to any person or entity for loss or damage caused by errors or omissions in, or reliance on, this report. You should verify any information provided herein for currency and/or accuracy if the information is of importance to you.
The information contained in this report is delivered from your Title Company, which reminds you that you have the right as a consumer to compare fees and serviced levels for title, escrow, and all other services associated with property ownership, and to select providers accordingly. Your home is the largest investment you will likely make in your lifetime, and you should therefore make all inquiries you deem appropriate.
Parcel ID: 141-28-1990
Sentry Dynamics, Inc. and its customers make no representations, warranties or conditions, express or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of information contained in this report.
representations, warranties or conditions, express or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of information contained in this
Sentry Dynamics, Inc. and its customers make no
report. 07/16/2026 Prepared by: Becky Schueneman
Neighborhood 100’ Repo
Subject Parcel: 9168 E Muleshoe St
Parcel ID: 141-28-1990
Site Address: 9168 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Clutter, Jon
Mail Addr: 9168 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Assessed Value: $173,086
Sale Dt: 06/07/2017
Sale Price: $180,000
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 331
Parcel ID: 141-28-1990
Tax Acct: 141281990
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Lot Sq Ft: 4,748 SqFt
Bldg Sq Ft: 1,264 SqFt
Year Built: 1996
Beds: 3
Baths: 2
1. 9141 E
Parcel ID: 141-28-2140
Site Address: 9141 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Roman, Julio
Mail Addr: 9141 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
2. 9150 E Muleshoe St
Parcel ID: 141-28-2140
Tax Acct: 141282140
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Lot Sq Ft: 4,892 SqFt
Bldg Sq Ft: 1,569 SqFt
Assessed Value: $198,863 Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 08/04/2017
Sale Price: $183,000
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 346
Parcel ID: 141-28-2020
Site Address: 9150 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
3
2.5
Parcel ID: 141-28-2020
Tax Acct: 141282020
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Owner: Camppillo-Herber, Monica M Herber, Randy L Cp Lot Sq Ft: 4,992 SqFt
Mail Addr: 9150 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747 Bldg Sq Ft: 1,510 SqFt
Assessed Value: $189,736
Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 12/07/2017 Beds: 3
Sale Price: $165,000 Baths: 2.5
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 334
Ironbark St
3. 9163 E
4. 9162 E
Parcel ID: 141-28-1510
Site Address: 9163 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Jordan, Christopher
Mail Addr: 9163 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Parcel ID: 141-28-1510
Tax Acct: 141281510
Acreage: 0.13 Acres
Lot Sq Ft: 5,715 SqFt
Bldg Sq Ft: 1,264 SqFt
Assessed Value: $173,086 Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 08/25/2017 Beds: 3
Sale Price: $161,900 Baths: 2
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 0283
Parcel ID: 141-28-2000
Site Address: 9162 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Parcel ID: 141-28-2000
Tax Acct: 141282000
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Owner: Shercase Properties 1 LLC Lot Sq Ft: 4,835 SqFt
Mail Addr: Bldg Sq Ft: 2,055 SqFt
Assessed Value: $234,884 Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 10/07/2022
Beds: 4
Sale Price: $297,000 Baths: 3.5
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential
Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 332
Muleshoe St
Muleshoe St
5. 9181 E
Parcel ID: 141-28-1540
Parcel ID: 141-28-1540 Tax Acct: 141281540
Site Address: 9181 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Griner, Thomas Kara, Cp
Mail Addr: 9181 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Assessed Value: $253,875
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Sq Ft: 4,800 SqFt
Sq Ft: 2,055 SqFt
1996 Sale Dt: 04/04/2023
4 Sale Price: $350,000
3.5
6. 9180 E Muleshoe St
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 286
Parcel ID: 141-28-1970
Site Address: 9180 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Mollette, Monica Renee Mollette, Dow Michael D Jt
Mail Addr: 9180 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Parcel ID: 141-28-1970
Acct: 141281970
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Sq Ft: 4,765 SqFt
Sq Ft: 1,569 SqFt
Assessed Value: $198,863 Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 01/06/2021 Beds: 3
Sale Price: $240,000
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 329
2.5
Muleshoe St
7. 9159 E Ironbark St
Parcel ID: 141-28-2170
Site Address: 9159 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
Parcel ID: 141-28-2170
Tax Acct: 141282170
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Owner: Gallo, Linda Gallo, Robert Jt Lot Sq Ft: 4,861 SqFt
Mail Addr: 9159 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747 Bldg Sq Ft: 1,569 SqFt
Assessed Value: $198,863 Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 07/08/2011
Sale Price: $106,000
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 349
8. 9169 E Muleshoe St
2.5
Parcel ID: 141-28-1520
Parcel ID: 141-28-1520 Tax Acct: 141281520
Site Address: 9169 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Cpi Amherst Sfr Program II Owner LLC
Mail Addr: 5001 Plaza On The Lk Ste 200 Austin TX 78746
Assessed Value: $195,906
Acreage: 0.12 Acres
Sq Ft: 5,349 SqFt
Bldg Sq Ft: 2,055 SqFt
Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 07/12/2021 Beds: Sale Price: $3,478,791 Baths: 3.5
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 284
Parcel ID: 141-28-2180
Site Address: 9165 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Baf Assets 5 LLC
Mail Addr: 5001 Plaza On The Lk Ste 200 Austin TX 78746
Assessed Value: $150,504
Sale Dt: 08/30/2022
Sale Price: $14,925,700
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 0350
Parcel ID: 141-28-2150
Site Address: 9147 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Redpath, Debra Lynn
Parcel ID: 141-28-2180
Tax Acct: 141282180
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Lot Sq Ft: 4,966 SqFt
Bldg Sq Ft: 1,264 SqFt
Year Built: 1996
Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Parcel ID: 141-28-2150
Tax Acct: 141282150
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Lot Sq Ft: 4,818 SqFt
Mail Addr: 9147 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747 Bldg Sq Ft: 1,264 SqFt
Assessed Value: $173,086
Sale Dt: 12/08/2016
Sale Price: $152,000
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 0347
Year Built: 1996
Beds: 3
Baths: 2
9. 9165 E Ironbark St
10. 9147 E Ironbark St
11. 9156 E Muleshoe St
Parcel ID: 141-28-2010
Site Address: 9156 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Parcel ID: 141-28-2010
Tax Acct: 141282010
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Owner: Rue, Thomas P Rue, Esther G Jt Lot Sq Ft: 4,953 SqFt
Mail Addr: 9156 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Assessed Value: $173,086
Sale Dt: 02/22/1996
Sale Price: $85,200
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 0333
Sq Ft: 1,264 SqFt
Year Built: 1996
Beds:
Baths: 2
12. 9187 E Muleshoe St
Parcel ID: 141-28-1550
Site Address: 9187 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Parcel ID: 141-28-1550
Tax Acct: 141281550
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Owner: Warner, Calvin Lot Sq Ft: 4,687 SqFt
Mail Addr: 9187 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Assessed Value: $208,681
Sale Dt: 08/26/2016
Sale Price: $178,000
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 287
Sq Ft: 1,404 SqFt
Year Built: 1996
Beds: 3
Baths: 2
13. 9174 E
14. 9193 E
Parcel ID: 141-28-1980
Site Address: 9174 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Krzysik, Doreen M
Mail Addr: 9174 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Assessed Value: $163,466
Parcel ID: 141-28-1980
Tax Acct: 141281980
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Lot Sq Ft: 4,761 SqFt
Bldg Sq Ft: 1,152 SqFt
Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 09/30/1998 Beds:
Sale Price: $82,686
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 0330
Parcel ID: 141-28-1560
Site Address: 9193 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Fritz, Jacob R Julia, M Cp
Baths: 2
Parcel ID: 141-28-1560
Tax Acct: 141281560
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Lot Sq Ft: 4,630 SqFt
Mail Addr: 9193 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747 Bldg Sq Ft: 1,569 SqFt
Assessed Value: $180,374
Sale Dt: 01/09/2024
Year Built: 1996
Beds: 3
Sale Price: $317,000 Baths: 2.5
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 0288
Muleshoe St
Muleshoe St
15. 9153 E Ironbark St
Parcel ID: 141-28-2160
Site Address: 9153 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
16. 9135 E Ironbark St
Parcel ID: 141-28-2160
Tax Acct: 141282160
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Owner: Zimmerman, Tarah Lot Sq Ft: 4,805 SqFt
Mail Addr: 9153 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
Bldg Sq Ft: 1,264 SqFt
Assessed Value: $173,086 Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 02/04/2009
Sale Price: $147,900
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 348
Parcel ID: 141-28-2130
Site Address: 9135 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
3
2
Parcel ID: 141-28-2130
Tax Acct: 141282130
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Owner: Giblin, Robert J Jr Lot Sq Ft: 4,931 SqFt
Mail Addr: 9135 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
Assessed Value: $198,863
Sq Ft: 1,569 SqFt
Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 01/19/2021 Beds: 3
Sale Price: $233,000 Baths: 2.5
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 345
17. 9175 E Muleshoe St
Parcel ID: 141-28-1530
Site Address: 9175 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
18. 9186 E Muleshoe St
Parcel ID: 141-28-1530
Tax Acct: 141281530
Acreage: 0.12 Acres
Owner: Freeman, Kourtney Todd, Cp Lot Sq Ft: 5,014 SqFt
Mail Addr: 9175 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747 Bldg Sq Ft: 1,946 SqFt
Assessed Value: $226,389 Year Built: 1996
Sale Dt: 07/02/2020 Beds: 4
Sale Price: $257,900
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 0285
Parcel ID: 141-28-1960
Site Address: 9186 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: Br Bst Az I Pkg 1 LLC
3.5
Parcel ID: 141-28-1960
Tax Acct: 141281960
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Lot Sq Ft: 4,796 SqFt
Mail Addr: 4221 N Calle Vista Ciudad Tucson AZ 85750 Bldg Sq Ft: 2,055 SqFt
Assessed Value: $231,363
Sale Dt: 04/04/2022
Year Built: 1996
Beds: 4
Sale Price: $357,000 Baths: 3.5
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 328
Parcel ID: 141-28-2190
Site Address: 9171 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
Owner: James, Wendall
Mail Addr: 9171 E Ironbark St Tucson AZ 85747
Assessed Value: $180,805
Sale Dt: 05/29/1998
Sale Price: $95,000
Zoning: Tucson-R-3 - High Density, Residential
Legal: SILVER PASS PHASE II LOT 0351 Sentry Dynamics, Inc. and its customers make no
Parcel ID: 141-28-2190
Tax Acct: 141282190
Acreage: 0.11 Acres
Lot Sq Ft: 4,735 SqFt
Bldg Sq Ft: 1,404 SqFt
Year Built: 1996
Beds:
Baths: 2
School Report
Subject Parcel
Site Address 9168 E Muleshoe St Tucson AZ 85747
Parcel 141-28-1990
School District 20 Vail
Assigned Primary School Desert Willow Elementary School
Assigned Middle School Desert Sky Middle School
Assigned High School Cienega High School
Primary School
Mesquite Elementary School
Desert Willow Elementary School
School
Sky Middle School
Pima County
School Cienega High School
Sentry Dynamics, Inc. and its customers make no representations, warranties or conditions, express or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of information contained in this report. 07/16/2026 Prepared by: Becky Schueneman
School #1
School District Vail Unified District (4413) Dist From Subject 0.45 miles
School Mesquite Elementary School Site Address 9455 E Rita Rd City Tucson Zip 85747
School #2
School District Vail Unified District (4413) Dist From Subject 0.61 miles
School Desert Willow Elementary School Site Address 9400 E Esmond Loop City Tucson Zip 85747
Sentry Dynamics, Inc. and its customers make no representations, warranties or conditions, express or
as to the accuracy or completeness of information contained in this report. 07/16/2026 Prepared by: Becky Schueneman
School #3
School District Vail Unified District (4413) Dist From Subject 0.90 miles
School Desert Sky Middle School Site Address 9850 E Rankin Loop City Tucson Zip 85747 Type 1-Regular school
School #4
School District Vail Unified District (4413) Dist From Subject 5.77 miles
School Cienega High School Site Address 12775 E Mary Ann Cleveland Way City Vail Zip 85641 Type 1-Regular school Students 1872 Charter No
Sentry Dynamics, Inc. and its customers make no representations, warranties or conditions, express or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of information contained in this report. 07/16/2026 Prepared by: Becky Schueneman
