Skip to main content

Advocacy in Action: A Practical Guide for Funders

Page 1

POLICY AND ADVOCACY

Advocacy in Action A Practical Guide for Funders

A Practical Guide for Funders | 1


Philanthropy also needs to ‘step up its game’ in the here and now, by raising its voice to advocate for policy outcomes related to our missions, and for the strengthening of democratic practices and institutions that transcend any single mission." — DANIEL KEMMIS Philanthropy and the Renewal of Democracy

2 | Advocacy in Action


Table of Contents Introduction..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 5 How to Use This Guide................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 7 Part 1: Why Advocacy Matters............................................................................................................................................................................................ 8 Part 2: Ways Funders Can Support Advocacy.......................................................................................................................................16 Part 3: Understanding the Rules of Advocacy................................................................................................................................... 26 Part 4: Building Board and Trustee Support for Advocacy.......................................................................................... 36 Part 5: Measuring Advocacy Impact — What is Success?.............................................................................................. 42 Resources..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................53

A Practical Guide for Funders | 3


4 | Advocacy in Action


Introduction Advocacy is a powerful tool philanthropy can use to create lasting change. While grants and programs help address immediate needs, advocacy works upstream to shape the policies, systems and public investments that affect communities every day. By supporting advocacy, philanthropy can help remove barriers, expand opportunity and ensure that the people closest to the challenges have a voice in the decisions that impact their lives. This guide explores how funders can engage in public policy advocacy and support grantees in advancing policy change. Whether through funding, convening, research, public education or direct advocacy, philanthropy has an important role to play in working alongside communities to shape a more equitable future. At Philanthropy Northwest, we work to demystify advocacy: Advocacy is not the same as political or partisan activity. Not all advocacy is lobbying. Most importantly, funders can legally support and participate in advocacy, including lobbying within established guidelines. Over the past decade, we have worked with our members to strengthen philanthropy’s capacity for policy advocacy. We have facilitated trainings, developed case studies, worked with boards, convened funders and supported advocacy strategy development across the region. Through this work, we’ve seen that effective advocacy often comes down to two things: investing flexible funding in the capacity of communities and organizations to advocate using their own voices, relationships and resources to advance change. For 50 years, Philanthropy Northwest has been grounded in the people and places of the Northwest. Across our region, our network shares a belief that philanthropy is strongest when it listens deeply, partners authentically and acts boldly alongside community.

A Practical Guide for Funders | 5


Our role is to catalyze lasting change by strengthening relationships, shifting systems and advocating for policies that expand access to resources in our region. We bring together funders, policymakers and community leaders, creating the conditions for philanthropy to act with courage, creativity and purpose. This guide reflects that commitment. It is designed to help funders better understand advocacy, explore the many ways philanthropy can engage in policy work and identify practical steps they can take to advance their mission and grow philanthropy’s capacity to redistribute resources and power in service of equity and racial justice. Together, we can use our collective voice, influence and resources to help create a future where every community has the opportunity to thrive.

6 | Advocacy in Action


How to Use This Guide This guide is designed as a practical resource for funders exploring how advocacy can advance their mission and support the communities they serve. Inside, you’ll find: • Why advocacy is a natural extension of philanthropic work • Different types of advocacy funders can support or engage in directly • Examples and case studies from philanthropy and nonprofit partners • Guidance for engaging boards and organizing leadership • An overview of what funders can legally do • Evidence of advocacy’s impact and why it is a powerful investment Whether you’re new to advocacy or looking to deepen your approach, we hope this guide provides useful tools, practical examples and ideas for action. This guide is also an invitation to continue the conversation with us. Philanthropy Northwest’s policy and advocacy team is here to support our network as you explore opportunities to learn, engage and advocate alongside community.

7


Part 1: Why Advocacy Matters

8


What You’ll Learn • How advocacy can help advance your mission and vision • Why advocacy can amplify the impact of philanthropic investments • How policy change can help create more equitable systems and outcomes

Questions to Consider • What public policies affect the communities you serve? • What policy changes would help advance your mission? • How does advocacy fit into your theory of change?

A Practical Guide for Funders | 9


Advocacy means taking action to create change. In this guide, we focus specifically on public policy advocacy — activities that help shape laws, regulations, budgets and public investments at the local, state, tribal and federal levels.

Advocacy Advances the Mission Every philanthropic organization exists to create change. Whether your focus is in education, housing, health, climate, arts and culture or economic opportunity, public policies shape the conditions that affect the communities you serve. Advocacy is one way to influence those conditions. It can take many forms, from funding research and community education to supporting advocacy organizations, convening stakeholders and engaging directly with policymakers. Because policy shapes how resources are distributed and opportunities are created, advocacy is often a natural extension of mission-driven work. Defining an organization’s mission, vision, desired outcomes and goals are choices that influence the direction of philanthropic resources. Public policies are impacted by philanthropic grantmaking and choices to varying degrees. Advocacy activities by grantmakers sit along a continuum from indirect to very involved ways of engaging in policy change.

9.5B

$

10 | Advocacy in Action

in philanthropic giving (six-state region)

Philanthropic giving represents just 14% of federal investment across our region


Philanthropy’s resources are significant, but they are small compared with public investments. In 2023, grantmakers in Alaska, Idaho, Montana, Oregon, Washington and Wyoming distributed $9.5 billion in giving. (Philanthropy Northwest, 2026, using data from Candid) By comparison, federal spending in those same states totaled more than $68 billion in 2023. (USAFacts, 2026) Put starkly, philanthropic giving is about 14% the size of federal support for the six states in the Philanthropy Northwest region. While philanthropy alone cannot meet every community need, advocacy can help influence the policies, programs and public investments that affect millions of people. By helping shape policy, funders can extend the impact of their investments far beyond a single grant or program. This is one reason many funders view advocacy as a powerful complement to grantmaking.

Advocacy Shapes Democracy Across the Northwest, direct participation in government has been a defining feature of the region’s culture. This tradition grew in part from the experiences of reformers around the beginning of the 20th century who moved to these new states from the East Coast. Seeking more transparent and responsive government, they helped shape new state constitutions to include strong initiative and referendum provisions. These tools of direct democracy continue to play a major role in shaping public policy. Because philanthropy operates within this broader civic landscape, the sector has an important role to play in sustaining and strengthening democratic participation. As Northwest civic leader Daniel Kemmis observed, philanthropy exists in a structure outlined by its legal and cultural relationship to government, suggesting it is “a bargain, in effect, between philanthropy and the larger society.” (Daniel Kemmis, 2016) Funders should think of this bargain as a compact that carries a responsibility to help strengthen democratic institutions and processes. Philanthropy can do this by supporting participation, elevating community priorities and helping build a more responsive and inclusive civic landscape.

Part 1: Why Advocacy Matters | 11


Increasingly, as an outgrowth of the bargain or compact, government relies on nonprofits to deliver services, shape public policy and relay valuable information on how programs and policies are impacting people on the ground. The philanthropic community, including nonprofits, cannot treat advocacy as an optional activity because policies that impact communities affect the very needs guiding philanthropy and the work it supports. Foundations and influential donors wield especially significant clout in shaping policy debates. With federal

The philanthropic community, including nonprofits, cannot

treat advocacy as an optional activity because policies that

impact communities affect the very needs guiding philanthropy and the work it supports.

tax policy changes and cuts to public budgets enacted in 2017 and 2025, foundations and high-net-worth individuals are increasingly dominant voices in the policy narrative. While charitable giving grew nominally in the most recent year tracked (2023), overall amounts declined (2.1% in inflation-adjusted terms). (Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy, 2024) High-net-worth individuals will continue to garner tax code benefits from charitable donations, while middle-and low-income Americans are not donating as much. (Candid, 2026) In a study by the Indiana University Lilly Family School of

66.2% 45.8%

Fewer americans are giving:

As philanthropy becomes concentrated among fewer donors, funders have an even greater responsibility to ensure community voices shape public policy.

2000

12 | Advocacy in Action

2024


Philanthropy (2024), the share of Americans giving to charities dropped from almost two-thirds (66.2%) in 2000 to less than half (45.8%) in 2024. This increasingly smaller set of donors will be even less diverse than the general population. Philanthropists must recognize the power and privilege their wealth conveys in shaping the public debate — and in doing so, consider ways to make space for and empower communities, particularly the most underinvested, to use their voices.

Advocacy as a Path to Equity and Racial Justice Many of the policies and systems that shape our communities today were built on the racist structures of our national founding documents. In some cases, explicitly. Oregon’s original state constitution, for example, prohibited people of color from entering the state, owning property or making contracts. As we reflect on our region’s civic and political traditions, it is equally important to uplift Indigenous histories, recognize the harms inflicted on Indigenous communities and celebrate

As we reflect on our region’s

the resilience and leadership that continue today. Many tribal

civic and political traditions,

nations have traditions of governance that practice deliberative,

it is equally important to

collaborative political decision-making. (Reedy et. al., 2020) The inequities philanthropy seeks to address did not emerge by accident. They are the result of policies, systems, and structures that have created unequal access to opportunity over

uplift Indigenous histories, recognize the harms inflicted on Indigenous

generations. While philanthropy can help address immediate

communities and celebrate

needs, grantmaking alone has limited ability to change the

the resilience and leadership

policies and systems that shape outcomes in education, housing, health, economic opportunity and other areas

that continue today.

critical to community well-being. Policy advocacy provides an opportunity to address these underlying conditions.

Part 1: Why Advocacy Matters | 13


At the same time, philanthropy must recognize its own relationship to power. Much of the wealth that sustains philanthropy was created within systems that perpetuate racial inequity. Even today, investments explicitly focused on advancing racial justice represent only a small percentage of overall philanthropic giving. (Philanthropic Initiative for Racial Equity, 2025) For Philanthropy Northwest, advocacy is a critical part of our work towards advancing equity and racial justice. Lasting change requires more than funding programs alone, it also requires examining and dismantling the laws and regulations that have contributed to the structural barriers that communities of color face. Ultimately, effective policy advocacy centers the voices, experiences and leadership of the communities with lived experience. It asks whether everyone—including Black, Indigenous, people of color and rural communities—feels they belong and has a meaningful opportunity to lift their voices in shaping the future of their communities.

Lasting change requires more than funding programs alone, it also requires

examining and dismantling the laws and regulations that have contributed to

the structural barriers that communities of color face.

Advocacy is about policy, not politics. Your voices are essential in public debate and discourse. As you consider your role, the question is not if policy shapes community outcomes. It does. The question is how philanthropy can use its resources, relationships and influence to help create a future where every individual can thrive. Understanding why advocacy matters is just the beginning. Our next step is identifying the policy outcomes you hope to influence, choosing the right tools for your foundation to contribute and boldly using advocacy to further your mission, vision and impact.

14 | Advocacy in Action


Key Takeaways • Policy advocacy is a powerful way to advance your mission. • Policy change can amplify the impact of philanthropic investments. Advocacy can help address the systems and structures that shape community outcomes. • Effective advocacy is grounded in community priorities and lived experience.

15


Part 2: Ways Funders Can Support Advocacy

16


What You’ll Learn • How funders can help create the conditions for effective advocacy • Different ways philanthropy can support policy and advocacy efforts • Examples of how funders across the Northwest are engaging in advocacy • How advocacy can complement grantmaking and strengthen community impact

Questions to Consider • What role is philanthropy best positioned to play? • Who is already leading this work, and how can we support them? • Where can our funding, relationships or voice add the greatest value? • How will we know our advocacy efforts are helping advance community priorities?

A Practical Guide for Funders | 17


This guide focuses on the ways funders and grantees can engage in public policy advocacy to support policy change. Understanding the range of advocacy strategies available can help funders identify where they are best positioned to contribute and how they can support community-driven efforts.

Where Advocacy Happens Public policy decisions are made at every level of government, from local school boards and utility districts to state legislatures, tribal governments and Congress. While policy change may be the ultimate goal, advocacy often begins earlier by building relationships, increasing community participation and strengthening civic engagement. Philanthropy Active in Civic Engagement (PACE), a membership group of foundations, developed a civic engagement primer as a guide to how philanthropy can support activities that focus from the individual level to the systems level. (PACE, 2018) Advocacy can take many forms, from indirect efforts like supporting research to highly direct work like lobbying policymakers. Different approaches serve different purposes, and many are most effective when used together. Funders can assist their grantees in determining their competency in approaches along the advocacy continuum with tools like Bolder Advocacy’s Capacity Tool. (Alliance for Justice, 2023) The following examples illuminate approaches along a continuum from indirect influence on public policy to highly direct. Research helps build understanding of an issue. Policy translates research and community

insight into recommendations for change. Voice includes activities like public education, narrative, community engagement and coalition building that help shape public understanding and elevate community priorities.

Lobbying is the most direct form of advocacy and involves taking a position on specific legislation and seeking to influence lawmakers.

18 | Advocacy in Action


There are many forms of activity within each point on the advocacy continuum, and often, organizations use multiple tools together. For example, an organization might gather community input, conduct research, develop policy recommendations, educate the public and then encourage action on a specific policy proposal. The most effective advocacy efforts rarely rely on a single strategy. Instead, they combine different tools to build awareness, strengthen relationships and create momentum for change.

The continuum of advocacy

Research

Policy

Voice

Lobbying

INDIRECT

DIRECT

Research Research can help communities, policymakers and advocates better understand challenges, identify solutions and inform public decision making. By investing in research, funders can help build the evidence base needed to shape policy conversations and support long-term change. Foundations have long supported academic analysis, exploring the impact of climate change, economic policies and social policies, among other areas. For example, the Wyoming Community Foundation works with the Wyoming Survey and Analysis Center (WYSAC) to ensure the state’s data on children and family well-being are being collected and analyzed effectively. As Wyoming’s home to Kids Count, a national initiative of the Annie E. Casey Foundation, the organization provides non-partisan, evidence-based information that helps policymakers, researchers, media and community leaders better understand the issues affecting children and families.

Part 2: Ways Funders Can Support Advocacy | 19


Policy Development Research can inform both stakeholder understanding and policy solutions. In Montana, Headwaters Foundation supported the Montana Nonprofit Association in releasing a 2025 report, Potential Impacts of Federal Cuts to Montanans and Montana’s Economy. The report, developed in collaboration with Headwaters Economics, examines the potential impact of federal funding cuts on Montana communities and the state’s economy. The report helped inform public conversations about the role federal investments play in supporting communities across the state. Similarly, across Idaho, Montana, Oregon and Washington, organizations participating in the State Priorities Partnership—a network of 40 independent, nonprofit research and policy organizations—analyze state tax and budget policies and develop recommendations designed to expand opportunity and improve outcomes for residents. In some circumstances, litigation can be an effective strategy to shape policy. The Northwest Fund for the Environment (NWFE) invests in multiple advocacy strategies, including carefully targeted litigation to enforce environmental laws, block destructive projects and increase stakeholder engagement. NWFE has also used litigation to sue for the public right to know or the public right to participate in decisions that impact public resources. Convening is another way philanthropy can support policy change by bringing diverse participants together for dialogue, shared learning and collaborative problem-solving. For example, the Montana Nonprofit Association and the Kettering Foundation convened civic leaders to identify opportunities to strengthen civic culture across the state. A Philanthropy Northwest resource details how this approach of creating opportunities for government leaders to solve problems in a less partisan environment can help keep the common good at the center of policymaking. (2019) Using the 50th anniversary of Montana’s constitution as a catalyst, participants reflected on how effectively residents were governing themselves and identified opportunities to strengthen civic participation and democratic engagement.

20 | Advocacy in Action


Voice Democracy is strongest when every community has a voice. Empowering grantees to share their expertise, lived experience and perspectives can help shape public understanding and influence policy decisions to build a more resilient democracy. Voice can take on different forms, from educating the public and strengthening relationships (community engagement) to mobilizing people around an issue (community organizing). Often these actions are not lobbying–a type of activity we address later in this section and Part 3. The following examples illustrate how funders across the Northwest have supported community voice and public engagement as part of broader advocacy efforts.

Expanding Civic Participation: Seattle Democracy Vouchers

Funders must play a central role in improving democracy. They should consider support for both electorally focused civic participation activities and longer-term efforts to ensure broad and representative participation in democratic institutions. (National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy, 2016) In the Northwest, funders are supporting innovative programs, projects and practices to build grantee capacity for democracy work. In 2015, the Proteus Fund made a series of grants to Seattle-based groups supporting public education about the City’s Democracy Voucher program, with a particular emphasis on communities of color,

Campaign donors doubled More diverse participation Program renewed by voters in 2025

women and youth to boost their participation in the program. Research conducted after the 2017 primary and general elections demonstrated Seattleites’ participation as campaign donors doubled and there was increased political giving by people in the communities targeted by the

Part 2: Ways Funders Can Support Advocacy | 21


grants. (Win Win Network and Every Voice Center, 2017) Subsequent research tracking the 2023 election found that the voucher program continued to demonstrate more diverse representation than “traditional” cash donors. (Georgetown University, 2024) In 2025, Seattle voters overwhelmingly approved renewing the program.

Strengthening Coalition Voice: Montana Medicaid Coalition

Coalitions amplify voice in policy advocacy, and foundations can support the educational activities of these groups. In Montana, the Headwaters Foundation funded Montana’s Medicaid coalition to engage in messaging research to cut through the noise and gain a genuine understanding of those who benefit from public assistance programs. The report was sparked by conversation with the coalition leads, and then the Foundation worked with grant partners to provide examples from their clients. (Headwaters Foundation, 2024)

Supporting Collective Action: Oregon Freedom Funders

Several Oregon philanthropies have joined together as the Oregon Freedom Funders to help “protect, sustain and bolster our nonprofit sector amid uncertainty and growing threats to diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) efforts and vital services” for Oregonians. As federal judicial decisions and policies seek to curtail DEI initiatives, the collaborative is mobilizing funders and partners to help nonprofits navigate this changing landscape. Through education, coalition building, resource sharing and capacity support, Oregon Freedom Funders is strengthening organizations, shaping public discourse around DEI and advancing the conditions for effective legal and policy advocacy. Oregon Freedom Funders illustrates how philanthropy can amplify its impact by coordinating around a shared purpose. Its work is part of a broader multi-state effort that includes Washington, where Ile Kimoyo — a statewide collaborative of nonprofit leaders — is partnering with philanthropic organizations to strengthen racial justice efforts.

22 | Advocacy in Action


Shaping Public Understanding: Alaska Revenue Campaign

Funders can also support communications strategies that help communities, policymakers and the public better understand an issue. Storytelling, earned media, public education campaigns, opinion pieces and digital communications can all help raise awareness, shift narratives and build support for policy change. When grounded in community experience, these approaches can help ensure that the people most affected by an issue are a part of the conversation about solutions. For example, in 2019, Alaska funders rallied together to launch a statewide campaign to educate the public on the state’s revenue crisis. Their work included a variety of tools, including an open letter published in newspapers across the state.

Lobbying Lobbying is the most direct form of advocacy. It involves taking a position on specific legislation or ballot measures and encouraging policymakers or the public to support or oppose a particular outcome. Federal IRS requirements require close tracking of lobbying time and expenditures, and most states have their own accountability and transparency schemes. (Alliance for Justice, 2011) Philanthropy Northwest has worked with the Alliance for

Lobbying is the

most direct form of advocacy.

Justice’s Bolder Advocacy project to give guidance to members. Supporting a nonpublic charity 501(c)(4), (c)(5) (generally labor organizations) or (c)(6) (organizations like chambers of commerce) is another way to enhance advocacy. While these groups can conduct unlimited lobbying activities, they often also do 501(c)(3)-permissible work such as public education. Private foundations may support the educational and charitable work of non-501(c)(3) organizations but must exercise what is called “expenditure responsibility” when doing so. (Alliance for Justice, 2004) This type of support requires additional diligence by the foundation, and the grant cannot be used for lobbying. Additionally, foundations can support the creation of “multi-entity organizations” – ones that use more than one legal entity, a 501(c)(3), 501(c)(4), 501(c)(5), political action committees (PACs) or corporations – to advance policy change. (Alliance for Justice, 2022)

Part 2: Ways Funders Can Support Advocacy | 23


Building the Evidence for Change: KidsCount

The Annie E. Casey Foundation (AECF) has led the national KidsCount initiative for more than 35 years, including a network of grantees tracking measures of child well-being in every state in the Northwest. KidsCount grantees are expected to use the data they collect to influence policy debates. AECF supports grantee advocacy capacity in other ways, including pulling together policy discussions or convening grantees and policymakers to explore a topic. For example, a grantmaker might hold a day-long meeting exploring the best new research on early learning and hear from policymakers on how they might shape laws and regulations. AECF provides other capacity support, such as original communications research, policy fellowship programs and facilitating a variety of technical assistance providers.

24


Key Takeaways • Effective advocacy starts with investing in the people, organizations and communities leading the work. • Funders can support advocacy in many ways, including research, policy analysis, convening, communications, litigation and direct advocacy. • Different advocacy strategies serve different purposes and can be used together to advance policy goals. • Philanthropy’s role is not always to lead; often it is to support, connect and resource community-driven efforts. • The most effective advocacy efforts are grounded in community priorities and focused on long-term change.

Part 1: Why Advocacy Matters | 25


Part 3: Understanding the Rules of Advocacy

26


What You’ll Learn • The difference between advocacy and lobbying • How foundations can support and do advocacy within legal guidelines • Where to find trusted resources and additional support

Questions to Consider • Which advocacy tools are we already using? • Are there opportunities to support advocacy beyond grantmaking? • Do our staff and board understand what advocacy activities are legally permissible? • Where do we need additional guidance or expertise?

A Practical Guide for Funders | 27


Many funders are interested in advocacy but hesitate because they are unsure what is allowed. One of the most common misconceptions is that advocacy and lobbying are the same thing. Lobbying is one form of advocacy and a completely legal way of using one’s voice in democracy, but it is only one tool on a much broader continuum. Advocacy activities that shape public policy can include research, public education, community engagement, coalition building, communications, litigation and direct engagement with policymakers. Many of these activities do not meet the legal definition of lobbying. In Part 2, we described types of activities and examples along an advocacy continuum. This section illustrates how the law allows funders to use this variety of approaches.

28 | Advocacy in Action


What Kind of Advocacy Can Foundations Fund or Do? The key takeaway is simple: advocacy is legal, funders can support it and lobbying is only one part of a much larger advocacy toolkit. Flexible, long-term funding is one of the most effective ways funders can support nonprofits and grassroots advocacy. When communities and organizations have the resources to determine and advance their own priorities, they speak with authenticity and are best positioned to drive lasting change. In Oregon, Northwest Health Foundation’s Civic Health strategy is grounded in the belief that communities most affected by inequities should have a leading role in shaping public policy. President and CEO Jesse Beason explains, “Those facing the most barriers to health have to help lead policymaking.” (Northwest Health Foundation, 2024) To put this principle into practice, the Foundation makes sustained investments that help organizations strengthen the skills, tools and infrastructure they need to build lasting political power through multi-year cohorts and ongoing technical support. Foundations can support nonprofits that lobby. The Alliance for Justice’s Bolder Advocacy program offers easy-tounderstand resources including advocacy tools and technical assistance, to help funders and nonprofits navigate advocacy rules with confidence. Additional resources, including Alliance for Justice’s Investing in Change: A Funder’s Guide to Supporting Advocacy, provide detailed guidance on foundations’ roles in the advocacy process. The Council on Foundations provides clear explanations of advocacy activities and related rules. The bottom line is that policy advocacy looks different for every organization. A foundation’s legal structure influences the types of advocacy it can support or undertake directly, but all funders have opportunities to engage in ways that advance their mission and support stronger communities. The following chart demonstrates options by foundation type.

Part 3: Understanding the Rules of Advocacy | 29


Advocacy Options by Foundation Type Public Foundations & Community Foundations

Private Foundations Can support advocacy?

Yes

Yes

Can support organizations that lobby?

Yes, through general operating support or carefully structured project grants that do not exceed the non-lobbying portion of a project’s budget

Yes

Can make grants specifically earmarked for lobbying?

Generally no, due to excise tax rules and other restrictions

Yes, within applicable lobbying limits (the expenditure is double counted against the lobbying limits of both the public foundation and the public charity receiving the grant)

Can fund 501(c)(4) organizations?

Yes, for charitable and non-lobbying purposes, and compliant with private foundation expenditure responsibility rules

Yes, including support for lobbying activities, subject to the foundation’s own lobbying limits and avoiding grant funds for partisan political activities

Can engage in lobbying directly?

Yes, but very limited; direct lobbying can trigger tax consequences

Yes, within legal lobbying limits

30 | Advocacy in Action


Private Foundations

Public Foundations & Community Foundations

Key considerations

Structure grants carefully to avoid prohibited lobbying expenditures

Monitor lobbying expenditures and ensure compliance with lobbying limits

Common advocacy approaches

General operating support, research, public education, convening, capacity building, policy analysis and community engagement

Research, public education, convening, direct lobbying, coalition support, policy campaigns and community engagement Guidance courtesy of Alliance for Justice

Part 3: Understanding the Rules of Advocacy | 31


What This Means for Funders Both private and public foundations can play meaningful roles in advocacy. The primary difference is not whether they can support advocacy, but how they must structure that support. Private foundations often focus on funding research, education, community engagement and general operating support that helps advocacy organizations build capacity over time. Public foundations and community foundations have additional flexibility to engage in lobbying and support lobbying activities within established legal limits. Regardless of foundation type, advocacy can be an effective tool for advancing mission and supporting community priorities.

Case Study: How Alaska Funders Shaped Public Dialogue In 2019, the state of Alaska faced an immense gap between the cost of continuing to provide state services and revenue projections. In addition to massive cuts proposed for public institutions, experts projected that an all cuts budget would cost Alaskans 13,000 jobs. Alaska funders, concerned about how this would impact the quality of life in communities across the state, came together to run a sustained campaign to educate state legislators about the impact of cuts through a wide variety of tools. These efforts were not lobbying — they didn’t include a call to action on any specific legislation. But they were influential in shaping the debate and encouraging policy makers to avoid an all-cuts solution.

32 | Advocacy in Action


Case Study: Using Public Education to Influence Policy Foundations can do a tremendous amount of advocacy that isn’t lobbying. In this example, the Raikes Foundation placed an op-ed in The Hill, an influential Washington, DC, newspaper, educating policymakers about the need to fund homeless students. The author, a Raikes Foundation program officer, discusses pending legislation, reviews research and calls for policy changes. “Last year, both the House and Senate took up reauthorization of the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act. The House version would ultimately ban the practice of detaining status offenders. The Senate bill would not. Advocates argue that failing to include a ban would be damaging to young people for generations to come.” The foundation has a clear perspective on the issue, however, this is not “lobbying,” because the op-ed doesn’t contain a call to action that urges leaders to contact legislators on a specific piece of legislation.

Part 3: Understanding the Rules of Advocacy | 33


34 | Advocacy in Action


Key Takeaways • Advocacy and lobbying are not the same thing. • Lobbying is one tool along a broader advocacy continuum. • Funders can legally support and participate in many forms of advocacy. • Different foundation structures have different rules and opportunities for engagement. • Understanding the rules can help funders participate with greater confidence and clarity.

Part 1: Why Advocacy Matters | 35


Part 4: Building Board and Trustee Support for Advocacy

36


What You’ll Learn • Why board and trustee support is important for successful advocacy • Common concerns and misconceptions about advocacy • Strategies for building confidence and alignment around advocacy • Examples of how boards have engaged in advocacy to advance mission

Questions to Consider • How does advocacy connect to our mission and strategic goals? • What questions or concerns do board members have about advocacy? • Where could board members add values through their relationships, expertise or voice? • What support would help our board engage more confidently? • What would it take to make advocacy a more consistent part of our organizational culture?

Part 4: Building Board and Trustee A Practical Support Guidefor forAdvocacy Funders | 37


Board and trustee support is often one of the most important factors in successful advocacy. Yet many organizations encounter hesitation when advocacy enters the conversation. That hesitation is understandable. Advocacy is often misunderstood, and many board members have been taught to avoid anything that feels political. Building buy-in from your board is essential for at least two reasons. First, advocacy is a mission-driven activity. It helps organizations address the structural and systemic barriers to equity critical to organizations advancing racial justice. Second, board members can be valuable partners in advocacy efforts. They bring relationships, expertise, credibility and lived experience that can help elevate issues, strengthen partnerships and inform policymakers about community needs. As ambassadors for their organizations, boards must “stand for the mission” by informing policymakers about the impact of decisions on their communities. In fact, if board members are not involved in advocacy, policymakers will wonder why leaders of organizations responsible for a related mission are sitting on the sidelines. Building support for advocacy often starts with helping board members understand that advocacy and partisan politics are not the same thing. It also means creating opportunities for board members to see how policy decisions affect the issues they care about and the communities they serve. Organizations such as BoardSource recognized the need to be more direct in their guidance and demonstrate that nonprofit advocacy is now considered mainstream and a best practice. BoardSource, BoardSource, Campion Advocacy and Philanthropy Northwest have developed resources and strategies to help boards engage more confidently in advocacy. Common approaches include: • Starting the conversations with nonprofits and their board members about how advocacy can advance their mission and is worth their time • Getting over the “taboo” of talking about advocacy as if it is synonymous with politics

38 | Advocacy in Action


• Discussing how advocacy can complement fundraising, grantmaking and program work • Providing practical examples of how board members can participate The Stand for Your Mission initiative offers discussion guides, success stories and board resources that can help organizations build a culture where advocacy is viewed as a core part of advancing mission.

Case Study: How a Foundation Built a Culture of Advocacy The Whatcom Community Foundation has long engaged in advocacy, even acknowledging that the Foundation was doing advocacy before labeling it as such., The organization shifted into a stance of what FSG, a social impact consulting firm, terms “catalytical community leadership.” Graduating from more passive public policy support, board members are now actively involved in advocacy efforts. Recent examples include: • Championing the inclusion of equity values and principles into economic development, land use and other foundational community planning documents. • Working with the Washington Budget and Policy Center to advance the concept of a statewide Child Savings Account (CSA) program for the state of Washington. CSAs yield benefits to physical and emotional health as well as educational achievement, earning potential and financial literacy skills. • Playing a leadership role in advocating for a fair, complete, accurate and safe 2020 Census. As one board member observed, “We can’t fulfill our mission and vision without it.”

Part 4: Building Board and Trustee Support for Advocacy | 39


40 | Advocacy in Action


Key Takeaways • Advocacy is a mission-driven activity that can help organizations create lasting change. • Board members can be valuable partners in advocacy efforts through their expertise, relationships and influence. • Building board support often begins with addressing misconceptions about advocacy and lobbying. • Creating a culture of advocacy takes time, education and ongoing conversation. • Organizations that connect advocacy to mission and community impact are often more successful in building long-term support.

Part 4: Building Board and Trustee Support for Advocacy | 41


Part 5: Measuring Advocacy Impact — What is Success?

42 | Advocacy in Action


What You’ll Learn • How advocacy impact can be measured and evaluated • Why advocacy requires different evaluation approaches than direct service programs • Practical ways to assess progress, learning and long-term impact • Tools and resources to support advocacy evaluation

Questions to Consider • What change are we trying to create through advocacy? • What signs of progress would tell us we are moving in the right direction? • How can we measure both short-term and long-term outcomes? • Are our evaluation methods flexible enough to reflect changing conditions and opportunities?

A Practical Guide for Funders | 43


One of the most common questions funders ask about advocacy is: Does it work? The answer is yes. Advocacy has contributed to significant policy, systems and social change across a wide range of issues. But measuring impact requires a different approach than evaluating a direct service program. Programs often have predictable inputs, activities and outcomes. Given the dynamic, public nature of advocacy work, where success often requires more adaptive capacity and responsive actions, “success” itself will depend on the opportunities within a specific environment and moment in time. Progress is rarely linear, and meaningful change often happens over years rather than months. That doesn’t mean advocacy can’t be measured. It means funders need evaluation approaches that reflect how policy and systems change actually happen.

What Success Looks Like Successful advocacy isn’t limited to passing a bill or changing a regulation. Often, important progress happens long before a policy change occurs. Examples of meaningful outcomes include: • Building stronger coalitions and partnerships

• Strengthening community voice and participation

• Developing new champions and community leaders

• Improving organizational advocacy capacity

• Increasing public awareness or support for an issue

• Preventing harmful policy changes

• Shifting narratives and public understanding These outcomes can be important indicators that an advocacy effort is building momentum and creating conditions for future change. (Resource: A comprehensive report for the Annie E. Casey Foundation, A Guide to Measuring Advocacy and Policy.)

44 | Advocacy in Action


Measuring Progress Along the Way Several approaches can help funders understand whether advocacy efforts are making progress. Use a Theory of Change for aligning around approaches, expectations, and outcomes: While advocates may change their messages, who they are trying to influence or their tactics, they often do so within a particular

understanding about how policy change happens. A theory of change can help clarify what to measure and where to find proof of progress. (Resource: Pathways for Change.) Look Beyond Policy Wins. Policy change is important, but it is rarely the only measure of success. When

engaging in a longer-term advocacy effort, it can be important to track a variety of types of progress. For example, have influential or additional champions been developed? Is there greater public will around the issue? Have key partnerships been developed and strengthened? Is the narrative and public sentiment aligned with your aims? These kinds of intermediate outcomes can be important steps toward later outcomes of policy change and the resulting social or environmental changes those policies seek. (Resource: A comprehensive report for the Annie E. Casey Foundation, A Guide to Measuring Advocacy and Policy.) Recognize Different Types of Impact. Impact can mean creating a positive change, speeding up progress or

preventing a system from getting worse during a crisis. Liz Ruedy at the Democracy Fund argues there are six different ways in which philanthropic dollars might achieve impact (2018): 1. Transformative: This is the traditional impact model, in that systems have a measurable positive change. Without the intervention, the system is stuck in the status quo.

2. Proactive: Systems without intervention might be making positive change, but a boost of investment can accelerate the pace.

3. Opportunistic: This model invests in the means and tools for change, but is dependent on context (politics, cultural change, economic shifts, etc.). If something in the environment changes, the groundwork laid by ongoing advocacy work is ready for a punctuated period of change.

Part 5: Measuring Advocacy Impact — What is Success? | 45


4. Stabilizing: Sometimes, advocacy must prevent systems from being taken apart (think budget cuts or protecting civil rights). It might be hard to measure the impact in policy change or population-level impacts. 5. Preventative: Work to ensure vulnerabilities in systems are addressed is a valuable pursuit. This type of advocacy might include crisis communication to ensure that the public understanding of a program doesn’t rapidly turn negative because of a high-profile event. 6. Palliative: During a recession, or a crisis like COVID-19, systems advocacy is imperative to ensure less precipitous declines.

Choosing the Right Evaluation Approach What are you trying to learn?

Evaluation approach

Are we making progress?

Progress tracking

Did advocacy contribute to change?

Process tracing

Are relationships and partnerships strong?

Ecosystem assessment

Are grantees learning and adapting?

Theory of change and reflection

There is no single way to evaluate advocacy. The most useful approach depends on what you are trying to learn, measure or improve.

46 | Advocacy in Action


If you want to understand progress over time… Track progress against advocacy goals at regular intervals, such as throughout a legislative session or campaign. This can help funders and grantees reflect on what changed, what opportunities emerged and how strategies adapted along the way. It can also help identify whether success comes from advancing a policy goal, preventing harmful changes or building momentum for a future policy change. (Resource: When the Best Offense is a Good Defense, ORS Impact, 2019)

If you want to understand how advocacy contributed to an outcome… Advocacy rarely happens in isolation. Methods such as process tracing can help funders understand how different organizations, activities and external factors contributed to a policy or systems change. Rather than asking, “Did this grant cause the outcome?,” these approaches explore how advocacy efforts influenced the result. (Resource: Applying Process Tracing to Policy Advocacy Evolution, ORS Impact, 2024)

If you want to understand the strength of your advocacy ecosystem… Many funders support networks of organizations working towards a shared goal, including grassroots organizers, grasstops advocates, data/research partners and more. Evaluating the health of these relationships and the ecosystem’s ability to respond to changing conditions can provide valuable insight into long-term impact and resilience. (Resource: Unique Methods in Multi-Stakeholder Advocacy Evaluation, ORS Impact, 2017)

If you want to strengthen learning and adaptation… Some funders support grantees in developing theories of change and simple reflection practices that help teams assess progress and adapt strategies over time. These tools can support ongoing learning and help organizations identify which approaches are most effective in changing conditions. (Resource: A Guide to Measuring Advocacy and Policy Change, ORS Impact for the Annie E. Casey Foundation, 2007)

Part 5: Measuring Advocacy Impact — What is Success? | 47


• Funders do not have to start from scratch when it comes to evaluating advocacy. Over the past two decades, practitioners, researchers and philanthropic organizations have developed tools and frameworks that can help you measure progress, learn from your investments and adapt your strategies. The National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP) developed an analysis describing the return on investment for foundations that invested in grantees with a policy change objective. (2012) Additionally, NCRP led work measuring the impact of philanthropic resources supporting community engagement, organizing, policy and advocacy efforts in a variety of regions. (2011) • In the Stanford Social Innovation Review, Steven Teles and Mark Schmitt discuss the importance of taking the long view on advocacy and methods that can be used to evaluate their impact in The Elusive Craft of Evaluating Advocacy. Advocacy (2011) • Atlantic Philanthropies describes how effective evaluation frameworks must assess organizational capacity, relationship-building, strategic leadership, and defensive successes, such as blocking harmful policies, rather than solely focusing on legislative wins. (2018)

48 | Advocacy in Action


Case Study: How Advocacy Investments Produced Results in Montana Researchers working with the National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy analyzed multi-year efforts in four states, including Montana. The focus was on policy impacts achieved with foundation support during a five-year period (2005-2009). In Montana, the analysis focused on organizations working on voting reforms, women’s and children’s health, immigrant rights, environmental protection and clean energy. The report highlights the following examples of impact: • Adoption of state water standards for rivers protecting them from pollution associated with coal bed methane development.

• Expansion of eligibility for Medicaid and Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP)

from 175 to 250% of the federal poverty level. This policy change resulted in covering up to 30,000 more children.

• Creation of same-day voter registration and “no-fault” absentee ballots. The use of absentee ballots increased from 29% in 2006 to 43% in 2008, which accompanied higher voter turnout rates—from 64% in 2006 to 74% in 2008.

30K

more children eligible for CHIP

43%

74%

absentee voting

voter turnout

from 29%

from 64%

Part 5: Measuring Advocacy Impact — What is Success? | 49


50 | Advocacy in Action


Key Takeaways • Advocacy works, and its impact can be measured. • Advocacy requires different evaluation approaches than direct-service programs. • Progress often includes intermediate outcomes such as stronger partnerships, increased public support and greater community engagement. • Success may mean advancing change, accelerating progress or preventing harmful outcomes. • Effective evaluation supports learning, adaptation and longterm impact.

Part 2: Ways Funders Can Support Advocacy | 51


52 | Advocacy in Action


Resources Part 1: Why Advocacy Matters Data on the Size of Philanthropy, Charitable Giving and Public Resources

• Philanthropy Northwest. (2025). Power of practice. practice https://philanthropynw.org/power-practice • Giving USA Foundation. (2024). Giving USA 2024: The annual report on philanthropy for the year 2023. 2023 https://www.givingusa.org • Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy. (2024). The giving environment: Giving during times of uncertainty. https://scholarworks.indianapolis.iu.edu/bitstreams/a3d0a238-6a9a-4b27-8aa0897c7a9210a9/download

Philanthropy and Democracy

• Kemmis, D. (2016). Philanthropy and the renewal of democracy: Is it time to step up our game? Philanthropy Northwest & Kettering Foundation. https://philanthropynw.org/system/files/ documents/2026-07/2016_Philanthropy-and-Renewal-of-Democracy.pdf

• Reedy, J., Orr, R., Spicer, P., Burbank, A., Del Campo, F. M., Brekke, J., Pratt, K., Parker, M., & Moss, M. P. (2020). Deliberative democracy and historical perspectives on American Indian/Alaska Native political decisionmaking practices. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, Communications 7, Article 16. https://doi.org/10.1057/ s41599-020-0506-4

Resources | 53


Racial Justice

• Philanthropic Initiative for Racial Justice. (2025). Derailed: Rising attacks and retreating resources for racial justice. https://racialequity.org/derailed • Echoing Green, & The Bridgespan Group. (2020). Racial equity and philanthropy: Disparities in funding for leaders of color leave impact on the table. https://www.bridgespan.org/insights/disparities-nonprofitfunding-for-leaders-of-color

Part 2: Ways Funders Can Support Advocacy Policy Advocacy Basics

• Philanthropy for Active Civic Engagement. (2018). Civic engagement primer. https://www.pacefunders. org/civic-engagement-primer • Alliance for Justice. (2023). Advocacy capacity tool. tool https://afj.org/resource/advocacy-capacity-tool-act • Coen, S., & Cotsoradis, S. (2014). Reflections on building the advocacy capacity of nonprofit organizations. https://www.gih.org/files/FileDownloads/Building_Advocacy_Capacity_KansasHealthFdn_July_2014.pdf

Research

• Brookings. (2009). Climate change policy: Recommendations to reach consensus. consensus https://www. brookings.edu/articles/climate-change-policy-recommendations-to-reach-consensus • Wyoming Community Foundation. (2025). Kids count—Wyoming data profile. profile https://wycf.org/index. php?p=actions/asset-count/count&id=26944 • Petegorsky, D. (2016). A both/and approach to civic participation funding. funding https://ncrp.org/2016/08/aboth-and-approach-to-civic-participation-funding

54 | Advocacy in Action


Policy

• Philanthropy Northwest. (2019). Montana bright spot: Convenings of civic leaders to strengthen democracy. https://philanthropynw.org/resources/pnw/stories/montana-bright-spot-convenings-civicdemocracy leaders-strengthen-democracy • Montana Nonprofit Association. (2025). Potential impacts of federal funding cuts on Montanans and Montana’s economy. economy https://mtnonprofit.org/mna-resources/impacts-of-federal-funding-cuts-onmontanas-economy/ • State Priorities Partnership. https://statepriorities.org

Voice

• Headwaters Foundation. (2024). Supporting our neighbors: Understanding who receives public assistance in Montana, for how long, and why? https://www.headwatersmt.org/wp-content/ uploads/2024/10/Supporting-Our-Neighbors-Report.pdf • Oregon Freedom Funders. (n.d.). Oregon Freedom Funders. Funders https://oregonfreedomfunders.org • Philanthropy Northwest. (2020). Alaska funders rallied together around major state budget cuts proposed in 2019. 2019 https://philanthropynw.org/news/alaska-funders-rallied-together-around-major-statebudget-cuts-proposed-2019 • Heerwig, J. A., & McCabe, B. J. (2023). Participation and representation: Results from the Seattle Democracy Voucher Program in 2023. 2023 Georgetown University. https://georgetown.app.box.com/v/ mccabe-democracy-voucher • Win Win Network, & Every Voice Center. (2017). First look: Seattle’s Democracy Voucher Program. Program https:// www.proteusfund.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/FINAL-Seattle-Post-Election-Report-1-Nov2017.pdf

Resources | 55


Lobby

• Beason, J. (2024). The origins of the Civic Health C4 Power Program. Northwest Health Foundation. Foundation https://www.northwesthealth.org/news/the-origins-of-the-civic-health-c4-power-program • Alliance for Justice. (2022, May 19). Best practices for foundations supporting multi-entity work. work https://afj. org/resource/best-practices-for-foundations-supporting-multi-entity-work

Part 3: Understanding the Rules of Advocacy • Alliance for Justice. (2018). Investing in Change: A Funder’s Guide to Supporting Advocacy. Advocacy https://afj.org/ resource/investing-in-change-a-funders-guide-to-supporting-advocacy • National Council of Nonprofits. (2026). Federal Law Protects Nonprofit Advocacy & Lobbying. Lobbying https:// www.councilofnonprofits.org/federal-law-protects-nonprofit-advocacy-lobbying • Council on Foundations. (n.d.). Rules of advocacy & lobbying. lobbying https://cof.org/content/rules-advocacylobbying • Trupin, C. (2018, January 8). We must work to end America’s youth homelessness problem. The Hill. Hill https://thehill.com/opinion/civil-rights/368593-we-must-work-to-end-americas-youth-homelessnessproblem/

56 | Advocacy in Action


Part 4: Building Board and Trustee Support for Advocacy • BoardSource. (2026). Stand for your mission. mission https://standforyourmission.org • Prosperity Now. (2016-2025). CSA state of the field reports. https://www.prosperitynow.org/news-andinsights/csa-state-of-the-field-report • Kramer, M. (2009). Catalytic philanthropy. philanthropy FSG. https://www.fsg.org/resource/catalytic-philanthropy

Part 5: Measuring Advocacy Impact — What is Success? • ORS Impact. (2007). A guide to measuring advocacy and policy: A comprehensive report for the Annie E. Casey Foundation. https://www.orsimpact.com/directory/Guide-to-Measuring-Advocacy.htm • Center for Evaluation Innovation, & ORS Impact. (2013). Pathways for change: 10 theories to inform advocacy and policy change efforts. efforts https://evaluationinnovation.org/publication/pathways-for-change10-theories-to-inform-advocacy-and-policy-change-efforts • Democracy Fund. (2018). Six models for understanding impact. impact https://democracyfund.org/idea/sixmodels-for-understanding-impact • ORS Impact. (2019). When the best offense is a good defense. defense https://www.orsimpact.com/ DirectoryAttachments/4232020_123618_15_Defensive_Advocacy_ORS_Impact.pdf • ORS Impact. (2024). Applying process tracing to policy advocacy evolution. evolution https://www.orsimpact.com/ DirectoryAttachments/2142024_103652_355_FINAL_Deep_Dive_-_Applying_Process_Tracing_to_Policy_ Advocacy_Eval_-_Feb_2024.pdf

Resources | 57


• Gase, L. (2018). When collective impact has an impact: A cross-site study of 25 collective impact initiatives. Spark Policy Institute & ORS Impact. https://www.orsimpact.com/blog/When-Collective-Impactinitiatives Has-Impact-A-Cross-Site-Study-of-25-Collective-Impact-Initiatives.htm • National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy. (2010). Strengthening democracy, increasing opportunities: Impacts of advocacy, organizing, and civic engagement in the Northwest region. region https:// ncrp.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/GCIP-NW-Report-exec-summary.pdf • Teles, S., & Schmitt, M. (2011). The elusive craft of evaluating advocacy. Stanford Social Innovation Review. https://ssir.org/articles/entry/the_elusive_craft_of_evaluating_advocacy • The Atlantic Philanthropies. (2024). Advocacy for impact. impact https://www.atlanticphilanthropies.org/insights/ insights-books/advocacy-for-impact

58 | Advocacy in Action


Resources | 59


Acknowledgements Remy Trupin, primary author Asha Hossain, graphic design with review from current and former Philanthropy Northwest public policy committee members: Mike Halligan Mauri Ingram Omni Romero Erin Switalski and content contributed by: Quyen Tu, Bolder Advocacy Program at Alliance for Justice Sarah Stachowiak, ORS Impact And Daniel Kemmis, whose thought leadership set a foundation for this resource.

60 | Advocacy in Action


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook