E¶.A¶. A¶.TO¶. TO¶.AYT. AYT.¶EP. ¶EP.AN. AN./ R.DEC. / R.DEC.ADM. ADM.LOC. LOC.DEV. DEV.REG. REG./ R. / R.DEC. DEC.LOC. LOC.GOV. GOV.REG. REG.DEV. DEV. E¶.
The costs and benefits of positive GENTRIFICATION Definition, Types ofof Intervention, The costs and benefits positive illusions
Definition, of intervention, illusions ConcernsTypes of Gentrification Spyros Makridakis * and Andreas Moleskis Concerns Spyros Makridakis * and Andreas Moleskis 1,2,3
1
1,2,3
1
1 Economics and Business, Neapolis University of Pafos, Pafos, Cyprus, 2 Decisions Sciences, INSEAD, Fontainebleau, 3 Decision Sciences, INSEAD, Singapore, Singapore France, Economics and Business, Neapolis University of Pafos, Pafos, Cyprus, 2 Decisions Sciences, INSEAD, Fontainebleau,
1
France, 3 Decision Sciences, INSEAD, Singapore, Singapore
Edited by: Edited by: isa Takemura, a Takemura, versity, Japan
ersity, Japan
Reviewed by: eviewed by: Keiko Ishii, KeikoJapan Ishii, versity, ersity,Rombs, Japan Elvyra vyra Rombs, versity, Japan
ersity, Japan
espondence: os Makridakis, spondence: rsity of Pafos, Makridakis, , Pafos 8042, sity of Pafos, Pafos Cyprus 8042, kis@nup.ac.cy
Cyprus s@nup.ac.cy
alty section: s submitted to lty section: e Psychology submitted to Measurement, Psychology of the journal easurement, n Psychology
of the journal 2 March 2015 Psychology 10 June 2015
30 June2015 2015 March 0 June 2015 Citation: 0 June 2015 eskis A (2015)
fits of positive
Citation: illusions. skis A (2015) sychol. 6:859. s of positive g.2015.00859 illusions. ychol. 6:859. 2015.00859
By Mr. George-Sp. C. ATHANASOPOULOS Harvard University, Graduate School of Design, Student, Positive illusions are associated with unrealistic optimism about the future and an inflated Positive illusions are associated with unrealistic about theC. future and an inflated By optimism Mr. George-Sp. ATHANASSOPOULOS Architect assessment of one’s abilities. They are prevalent in normal life and are considered of the of Architecture assessment of one’s abilities. They are prevalent in Student normal life andSchool are considered essential for maintaining a healthy mental state, although,Technical there are University disagreements to essential for maintaining a healthy mental state, although, there are disagreements toof Crete the extent extenttotowhich whichpeople people demonstrate these positive illusions and whether they are the demonstrate these positive illusions and whether they are 1. Introductory approach: Defining the concept beneficial orornot. not.But Butwhatever whatever situation, is hard to dismiss their existence beneficial thethe situation, it the is ithard to dismiss their existence and and 1. Introductory approach: Defining concept ANTISTHENIS, the ancient Greek philosopher, (444 BC 370 BC, Athens), their positive and/or negative influence on human behavior and decision in their positive and/or negative influence on human behavior and decision makingmaking in ANTISTHENIS, the ancient Greek philosopher, (444 BC 370 BC, Athens), among other wise heritage he left us, he established a great “principle”: the general. Prominent Prominentamong among illusions is that of control, is tendency “the tendency for people general. illusions is that of control, that that is “the for people among other wise heritage he leftthe us,definition he established a greatof“principle”: the acquisition of their knowledge with ofdescribes thedescribes content concepts. to overestimate tostarts control events.” ThisThis paper positive illusions, overestimate theirability ability to control events.” paper positive illusions, acquisition of knowledge starts with theindefinition of the content of concepts. Based, therefore, on this “principle” a first, if not final, approach, the term their benefits but also quantifies theirtheir costs in five specific fields fields (gambling, their potential potentialtherefore, benefits but also quantifies in not five final, specific (gambling, 1 (and urban Based, on this “principle” inindicated acosts first, if approach, the term gentrification) is (in the area of Planning) (or gentrification stock and other markets, new firms andand startups, preventive medicine and wars). It 1 stock and other markets, new firms startups, preventive medicine and It gentrification (and urban gentrification) indicated (in thefrom areathis, of Planning) (or Sociology as well), as the “refining” of a cityisarea, the removal (inwars). various is organized into three parts. First the psychological reasons giving rise to positive isways), organized into three parts. First reasons giving rise Sociology as well), as the “refining” ofpsychological a city area, removal fromthere this,to (inpositive various of social groups, usually of the low-income andthe the placement of artists, illusions are described and their likely harm andand benefits stated. Second, theirthere negative ways), of social groups, usually of low-income and the placement of artists, illusions are described and their likely harm benefits stated. Second, their negative the operation of art galleries, restaurants, etc. However this “change”, regardless of consequences areofpresented andrestaurants, their costs are quantified in five areas seriously the operation art galleries, etc. However this “change”, regardless consequences areconsequences presented andhas, theirresults costs also are quantified in fiveprices areas (and seriously whatever other rising of land theof affected with emphasis to those related has, to the illusion of control that seems toprices dominate whatever other consequences also land (and the potential relative speculation). affected with emphasis to those related toresults the illusion ofrising controlof that seems to dominate those of unrealistic optimism. The costs involved are huge and serious efforts must be potential relative speculation). The gentrification found at first in the in early 1960s and it refers to those of term unrealistic optimism.isThe costs involved areUK huge and serious efforts must be undertaken to understand their enormity steps to avoid them in theand future. The term gentrification iswealthy foundand atpeople first intaken the UK in early 1960s itareas refersofto the then observed trend of to buy property in poor undertaken toa understand their enormity steps taken to them in the future. Finally, there is concluding section where theand challenges to avoid positive illusions are the then observed trend of wealthy people torelated buy property in poor areas of London, upgrade them, stay themselves sometimes there and thus old residents Finally,and there is a concluding section where the challenges related to positive illusions are noted directions for futurestay research are presented. London, upgrade them, themselves sometimes there and thus old residentsare are being indirectly “squeezed”. noted and directions for future research are presented. being indirectly “squeezed”.
A description of this phenomenon is included in the work of Sociologist Ruth A description of this phenomenon is included in the work of Sociologist Ruth
Keywords: illusion of control, illusions, better that average symptom, cost/benefits of illusions, gambling fallacy, self rated health (SRH), planning fallacy, preventive medicine
GLASSillusion at theofsame whilethat similar were recorded in gambling other major Keywords: control,period, illusions, better averagesituations symptom, cost/benefits of illusions, fallacy, GLASS at(SRH), the same period, while situations were recorded in other major self ratedinhealth planning fallacy, medicine cities Western countries, bypreventive othersimilar Researchers.
cities in Western countries, byunrealistic other Researchers. Since then, issue with has preoccupied several scholars andanfor its more Positive illusions arethe associated optimism about the future and inflated Since then, the issue has several scholars andthe forand its more assessment of one’s abilities (Kruger etare al.,preoccupied 2009). Such illusions are prevalent in from normal life comprehensive approach being summarized below, Positive illusions are associated with unrealistic optimism about the future and anvarious inflated comprehensive approach are being summarized below, from the can be considered useful in some cases for maintaining a healthy mental state (Taylor and Brown,various interpretations the phenomenon gentrification, assessment of one’sof abilities (Kruger et al., of 2009). Such illusionsthe arefollowing: prevalent in normal life and 1988, although,ofthere is disagreement toofthe people demonstrate these interpretations the phenomenon the following: In1994), a sense, the phenomenon isfor due togentrification, a extent trendatohealthy ofwhich a new category of social can be considered useful in some cases maintaining mental state But (Taylor andgroups Brown, positive illusions and whether they are beneficial or not (Colvin and Block, 1994). whatever to “return” to the city, leaving the purlieus forextent several reasons: highinfluence costs inonmoney 1988, 1994), italthough, is their disagreement to the toand/or whichnegative people demonstrate these the situation, is hard to there dismiss existence and their positive positive illusions anddecision whether they are beneficial or not (Colvin and Block, 1994). But and time to travel from the purlieus to downtown, where work lackwhatever of the human behavior and making in general. Prominent among illusions isplace that ofis,control the situation, it isLanger hard todistributed dismiss their existence their1912-1940. positive and/or negative influence onin term comes from Ruth GLASS, Ruth GLASS was born that is 1. defined by asSociologist “an expectancy of aand personal success probability higher than thebetter sense ofThe safety at the(1975) residencies outside town centres, search for Berlin, where she made her making first studies. In 1932 she published an important study entitled: human behavior and decision in general. Prominent among illusions is that of control objective probability would warrant” (p. 313). She also claims that “while people may pay lip service services of health, education, entertainment “at the heart of the city”,movements (possibly)for Youth Unemployment. The same year she leftevents Germany andsuccess after continuous to theisconcept of by chance they behave as “an though chance subject to control” (p. 311). that defined Langer (1975) as expectancy of a are personal probability higher than the lower living cost of, “withdrawal” from private car easier access to markets, etc.where studies and research in Geneva, Prague, London and New York she came back to London, This article describes positive illusions, talks about their potential benefits but also quantifies objective probability would warrant” (p. 313). She also claims that “while people may pay lip service in According 1943 she published studies regarding cityphenomenon planning. In 1950 sheto became teacher in the to another approach, the isnew due aand systematic and their in College five specific fields (gambling, stock and other markets, startups, to University thecosts concept of chance behave as though chance events are subject tofirms control” (p. 311). of they London, where she continued her social research. Her public action and long-term informal effort by organized groups, manufacturers, brokers of buying preventive medicine and wars). It is organizedfor into three See parts. FirstCOLLINS the psychological reasons This article positive talks about theiralso: potential benefits but also quantifies her work are describes characterized by aillusions, passion justice. ENGLISH DICTIONARY. and selling real estate, etc., for the depreciation initially of part of the urban web, in giving rise to positive illusions are described and their likely harm and benefits stated. Second, their 10th edit. Wil. COLLINS SONS AND Co Ltd. London 2009. WIKIPEDIA: The Free Encyclopedia: their costs in five specific fields (gambling, stock and other markets, new firms and startups,
G. ALEXANDRI: http://www.uncanny.net/ wetzel/gentry.htm a Gentrification: varietymedicine of ways, inwars). orderItAbstract. to achieve the three “assisted”, “voluntary”, (actually preventive and is organized into parts. First the psychological reasons giving rise to positive illusions are described and their likely harm and benefits stated. Second, their 22 2521 11 www.frontiersin.org 1 June 2015 | Volume 6 | Article 859
www.frontiersin.org
1
June 2015 | Volume 6 | Article 859