LA+ Interdisciplinary Journal of Landscape Architecture University of Pennsylvania stuart weitzman School of Design Editor in Chief Karen M’Closkey Creative Direction Catherine Seavitt Issue Editor Azzurra Cox Art Director Colin Curley Production Team Tatum Phillips Nate Ramsey Phurit (Poom) Sheeranangsu Xingtong Yang Editorial Assistant Ainsley Rhodes Founding Editors Tatum L. Hands Richard J. Weller
www.laplusjournal.com laplus@design.upenn.edu Library of Congress data available upon request. World Rights: Available ISSN: 2375-4174 Proofreading by Jake Anderson Back cover illustration by Laurie Olin Copyright © 2026 University of Pennsylvania Stuart Weitzman School of Design All rights reserved. No part of this journal may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, mechanical, photocopying of microfilming, recording, or otherwise (except that copying permitted by Sections 107 and 108 of the U.S. Copyright Law and except by reviewers for the public press) without written permission from the publisher.
LA+ Journal, the Weitzman School of Design and the University of Pennsylvania endeavor to respect copyright consistent with their nonprofit educational mission. The journal has attempted to trace and acknowledge all sources of images used in this publication and apologizes for any errors or omissions. If you believe any material has been included in this publication improperly, please bring it to our attention. Recommended citation: LA+ Interdisciplinary Journal of Landscape Architecture, no. 24 (2026).
memory /ˈmɛm(ə)ri/ noun • senses relating to the action or process of commemorating, recollecting, or remembering: their memories, their singings, and their gifts. • the action of remembering; recollection, remembrance: all that had passed he recalled to memory, though I wished most earnestly to bury the prominent events in eternal oblivion. • an act or instance of remembrance; a representation in the memory, a recollection: he suddenly found himself remembering at least forty things about her—an overwhelming flood of memories. Oxford English Dictionary, 3rd Edition
In This Issue
4
Editorial AZZURRA COX
66
monumental dreams EVAN PAVKA
6
H.E.R.E. SAM CARTER-SHAMAI
74
on reimagining the specter of urban vacancy nia easley + daniela rosner
14
landscapes of rememory annie lynch
80
architectures of transmission in the jawlan nora akawi + eduardo rega calvo
20
up in the air emily schlickman
90
in conversation with andrea roberts azzurra cox
26
what memories lie at the bottom of the sea? justin dunnavant
98
a handful of dirt gwendolyn dora cohen
32
in conversation with elizabeth k. meyer leah kahler
102
in conversation mona smith, jewell arcoren + david malda
38
agents of memory emily bunker + selina cheah
108
memories in a temporal landscape micah stanek
46
extinctionscapes hannah stark
52
storytelling with coca: disturbing the archives sarah bolivar
60
heirloom gardens as living archives tessa lowinske desmond, hanna garth, christian keeve + justice madden
image credits Upcoming Issues
Above: Sinking and Scaffolding (2015) Diana Al-Hadid. Polymer gypsum, fiberglass, steel, plaster, gold leaf, pigment.
1 Pierre Nora, “Between Memory and History: Les Lieux de Mémoire,” Representations 26 (1989), 7.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 5
mEMORY editorial Landscape speaks by way of constant change, rooted in process and evolution: the marks of water along a shoreline, seasonal cycles of symbiosis, a forest floor over time. One could say that landscape actively remembers, across timescales from the microscopic to the geological. As an archive of itself, landscape is akin to a griot—an individual who acts as both storyteller and keeper of cultural traditions in some West African societies—in that it at once embodies and narrates its histories. Yet landscape is also particularly receptive—and generative—to our human narratives, individual and collective, and as such can be a powerful agent of memory. An inherently sensory realm, landscape offers a physical reality onto which to graft the mental maps of our lives. In ways large and small, it allows us to memorialize. Historian Pierre Nora foregrounds the sensory dimensions of memory, defining lieux de mémoire as where “memory crystallizes and secretes itself.”1 Nora also proposes that memory and history are in a constant state of opposition, and that memory can erupt through the frameworks of history when we least expect it. If memory is a slippery and potentially subversive force, the act of remembering offers some degree of agency. Originating from the Latin rememorari, or bring back to mind, the word centers the individual as the theater for memory – and, indeed, much narrative re-membering, the stitching together, unfolds there. But the act of remembering also manifests at collective, societal, and generational scales, rendering both the content and act of memory potent flashpoints in political discourse. Where does memory erupt in these charged times? What can we learn from emergent practices of remembrance and preservation? What can memory held in our environments—on street corners, in soils, in genetic material—teach us? This issue explores the power of memory in its many dimensions: physical and metaphysical, personal and collective, embodied and ephemeral. The issue opens with the ways we might choose to read and interpret source material to illuminate the past. Sam Carter-Shamai weaves family ephemera and his own homecoming journeys to understand how diasporic communities carry forward their vital traditions. Annie Lynch introduces the concept of “rememory” as a way for landscape architecture to reckon with sites of erasure. In the drylands of central California, Emily Schlickman illustrates how Indigenous legacies of burning as stewardship find their contemporary incarnation in our current ecological crisis. Archaeologist Justin Dunnavant writes of the liberatory potential in diving slave shipwrecks, arguing for a new approach to their memorialization. And in a case of land as record, Elizabeth K. Meyer offers a glimpse into efforts to engage ecological and cultural memory at the Morven Sustainability Lab in Central Virginia.
The next grouping of essays explores the frictions between memory and history, particularly how complex narratives can be flattened for political ends. Emily Bunker and Selina Cheah interrogate the frameworks undergirding the designation of heritage trees, proposing a system that values trees’ cultural and ecological dimensions as much as their quantitatively measurable benefits. Writing about the extinction of the thylacine (Tasmanian tiger), Hannah Stark exposes the racial undertones of the settlercolonial extinctionscape in Tasmania. The coca plant finds a voice in Sarah Bolivar’s multi-species testimonio, weaving a more nuanced, entangled history of Colombia. When memory and history are in direct opposition, powerful resistance can come by way of the land. Drawing from the Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project, Tessa Desmond, Hanna Garth, Christian Keeve, and Justice Madden bring us into the worlds of another plant species, the collard green, to argue for gardens as “sites for healing and reclamation.” Evan Pavka tells the story of the first gay grave and how it brought a battle for visibility to the ultimate landscape of memory, the cemetery. Nia Easley and Daniela Rosner’s essay on voids in contemporary Chicago reimagines a historical document as a tool to resist erasure today. And Nora Akawi and Eduardo Rega Calvo engage the landscape of the occupied Golan Heights, illuminating how Indigenous acts against the genocidal Israeli state “weave life-affirming refusal into the very fabric of the land.” This issue concludes with the ways in which both cultural and personal place-based memory can be rooted and preserved. Andrea Roberts speaks about the importance of “outsider preservationists” in claiming and keeping space for Black cultural legacies. Soil is a medium for memory in Gwendolyn Cohen’s literary and personal reflection. David Malda speaks with Mona Smith and Jewell Arcoren on their joint efforts to imagine the future of Owámniyomni (St. Anthony Falls), a sacred Dakota place. And Micah Stanek closes the issue with a reflection on the many ways we can make meaning through our experiences of landscape. If the act of remembering alludes to the mind, it is worth noting that the alternative Latin word for this concept is recordari, or to bring back to the heart. Memory seems to live between two realms, ignited and expressed by way of the physical world. The essays in this issue reflect a commitment to land as embodiment of and material for memory.
Azzurra Cox Issue Editor
H.E.R.E.
Sam Carter-Shamai
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 7
Sam Carter-Shamai is an urban planner and placemaker whose work explores land, memory, and community through an interdisciplinary approach to planning practice and public pedagogy. Drawing on a background in affordable housing development, cultural infrastructure, and participatory engagement, he has led research-creation projects that foreground land-based memory, critical geographies, and collective stewardship. Sam’s current work, including the H.E.R.E. Project, examines how diasporic communities sustain place and belonging across generations.
Urban Planning, Critical cartography
F
rom the 1890s through the 1920s, in the ghettos and shtetls of Eastern Europe, the Jewish Workers’ Bund emerged as a communal response to state violence, economic precarity, and antisemitism.1 The Bund articulated the principle of doikayt, or “hereness”: a commitment to building justice where one already lives through solidarity, shared responsibility, and collective action.2 Grounded in everyday practices—workers’ councils, schools, theaters, and kitchens—Bundist organizing wove together political struggle with cultural life, naming a justice that was local, relational, and made together. Around the turn of the 20th century, my mother’s people fled villages in what is now Lithuania and Ukraine for North America, carrying with them these social infrastructures forged at the intersection of culture and survival. Meanwhile, in the aftermath of the American Civil War, Black communities across the US South engaged in parallel struggles to secure land and collective selfdetermination under regimes of racial terror and segregation. In the generations following emancipation, my father’s people helped establish schools, churches, and institutions such as the Gloucester Land Building and Loan Association, a cooperative effort to pool resources and acquire land that laid the groundwork for long-term stability in Black communities of Gloucester County, Virginia. Across the Americas, such traditions of mutual aid and collective institution-building among marginalized people continue to bring together shared efforts in education, housing, and civic life. In the fall of 2023, I set out to retrace and map my family’s presence across North America. This effort became the H.E.R.E. (Homecoming Exchange + Regenerative Encounters) Project: an ongoing research-creation practice responding to Katherine McKittrick’s observation that “Black diasporic histories and geographies are difficult to track and cartographically map.”3 Drawing on institutional and community archives alongside deeply personal, place-based reflection, the Project looks to sites shaped by transatlantic slavery for radical approaches to land use, memory, and planning. At its core, H.E.R.E. asks how diasporic communities survive spatial violence by carrying forward traditions, habits, and rituals – the social technologies and cultural infrastructures that make hereness possible, even under conditions designed to deny it. Scholars Christina Sharpe and Saidiya Hartman remind us that the personal is a window into the specificity of societal and historical processes, and that personal perspectives can begin to counteract “the violence of abstraction” that can disconnect a Black sense of place from rootedness in the land.4 My approach to this research is influenced by two distinct but philosophically aligned lineages: the political and cultural organizing of my Ashkenazi ancestors, the Shamais and the Cohens; and the determined community stewardship of my Black American family, the Carters and the Johnsons of Gloucester County. I have grounded this research in my family’s history to present a specific and personal perspective – an experience that challenges and
H.E.R.E. 8
critiques the implicit biases and the violence of abstraction inherent in aggregate institutional memory. The connection between these two traditions came into focus around the Passover table in 2022, the year my father passed away. As we recounted the story of emancipation in Egypt, I reflected on how closely this ritual echoed the Homecoming traditions I know from summers with my family down in the South. Both are rooted in the shared impulse of a dispersed people to gather after time apart, to remember a history of enslavement and survival, and to reflect on what freedom has meant since. Both revolve around elaborate meals loaded with significance. And in each, there is an exchange of knowledge. Lessons for endurance, for joy, for care are passed from one generation to the next. What began as a conventional cartographic and historicalgeographic exercise has evolved into an interactive workshop series, experimental video installation, and ongoing photography practice. I am exploring the dialogue between here and there, urban and rural, homeland and diaspora. This work is about intergenerational cycles of departure and return, drawing on my family’s archives of letters, memoirs, oral histories, and photographs to position our pasts, presents, and futures in relation to the land and waters that sustain us. Following my father’s passing, questions of inheritance and cultural legacy snapped viscerally into focus. While this first effort is grounded in the Carter lineage, the viewpoint and starting philosophy strive to bring both sides of my heritage into conversation with one another. Beyond highlighting the ongoing significance of community rituals like Homecoming and Passover as land-based practices, the H.E.R.E. Project provides a lens through which to critique post-racial nationbuilding myths and offers a firsthand perspective on practices of intergenerational resilience in diasporic communities across North America. Homecoming as Land-Based Research There are two written accounts at the heart of the H.E.R.E. Project: family memoirs and personal correspondence, all records of my family’s rootedness and migration. I have a collection of letters authored by my father George, who left Gloucester, and an unpublished manuscript by my uncle Fred, who stayed firmly on the land. I will never live in Gloucester County Virginia again, but I’ve never forgotten that at one time I had a home. My home wasn’t all sweetness and light, but then again homes never are all sweetness and light.5
For those of us with family ties to the South, the tradition of Homecoming is an expression of community, collective memory, and connection to place. In the summer of 2023, I went to Gloucester on a homecoming trip of my own, at once joining the tradition of reunion between urban North and rural
South while also bringing my father’s remains back to rest among our ancestors. This trip would set in motion a process of historical-geographic inquiry, personal discovery, and research creation to honor the legacy of families, like my own, who had once been enslaved here on Carter’s Creek. In McKittrick’s foundational paper “On Plantations, Prisons, and a Black Sense of Place,” she emphasizes that “the plantation evidences an un-even colonial-racial economy that […] legalized black servitude while simultaneously sanctioning black placelessness and constraint.”6 McKittrick stresses that the underlying logics of the plantation economy rely on racial segregation, normalized Black dispossession, and a denial of entangled geographies of encounter. Further, she suggests that by adopting a Black sense of place, we can find useful anticolonial practices and narratives. Down in Gloucester, on the banks of Carter’s Creek, the ruins of Rosewell Plantation stand as a reminder of the legacy of slavery in America. For my family, “the plantation” is not an abstract reference or conceptual stand-in for the landscapes of racial violence; we know where our plantation was. This is land that my family now owns, which was once part of an 18thcentury farm known as Shelly, itself a subsidiary of Rosewell. How our family first acquired land is a story in itself. During the Civil War, my great-great-grandfather, Gabriel Carter, while still enslaved, took advantage of the chaos of war to quietly accumulate wealth. Sailing a small boat to Yorktown under the cover of night, he sold oysters, fish, and produce to Union supply officers, burying the gold coins he earned until the war’s end. With that money, he later purchased roughly 100 acres of the Shelly plantation when the Page family was forced to sell.7 I have spoken with elders and combed through nearly two centuries of property records and census information. According to both formal documentation and the family’s oral tradition, there have been Carters on Shelly for as long as any of us can remember. My uncle Fred was a pillar of the local community, a funeral director, pastor, and family historian. He used to love taking us out on his little boat, the Slow Dance, and telling stories about our family’s relationship to this place. When the [Rosewell plantation] house was being constructed, there was not sufficient revenue from the farm to complete it. Consequently, the Page family sold 700 acres of land and 200 slaves to pay for the completion of the lead roof. Many of these slaves were my relatives. The Carter family, the black Carter family, continued to live on Shelly and to this day owns a substantial portion of the land on which they had been enslaved. How they went from slavery to successful landowners is part of the family’s oral history.8
Built in the early 1700s, the Rosewell mansion was one of the grandest plantation homes in Colonial America.9 John Page had been a director in the Royal African Company, the monopoly slaving enterprise of the English Crown.10 For over
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 9
100 years, Rosewell was the ancestral seat of the Pages, one of the first families of Virginia and my family’s enslavers. In 1916, the mansion caught fire. When my great-grandfather James Andrew Carter—by this point a free man working his own farm across the creek—was asked to join the bucket brigade to douse the flames, his only response was “let it burn” as he turned back to tending his watermelon patch.11 My grandparents were important figures in the community and, in an understated way, made their marks on the tapestry of American history. My grandmother was the first Black woman admitted to William & Mary’s graduate programs. My grandfather was the inaugural chair of the local NAACP chapter and worked on several groundbreaking Civil Rights cases, including that of Irene Morgan, a young woman from Gloucester who had refused to move from her seat on a Greyhound bus bound for Baltimore.12 That lawsuit went all the way to the Supreme Court and was Thurgood Marshall’s first Supreme Court victory. Today, the Rosewell ruins are maintained as a tourist destination, where interpretive text describes a “place of grandeur and importance.”13 For my family, the history is a little more complex. McKittrick emphasizes the need to “undo the familiar analytical naturalization of violence” and look to these spaces of encounter for useful anti-colonial narratives and strategies.14 Yes, Shelly and Rosewell were plantations, the sites of generations of bondage, exploitation, and racialized violence. These are also sites of resistance and persistence, which can foster “co-operative human efforts,” like the formation of the Gloucester Land Building and Loan Association.15 In progressive planning spaces, we are constantly looking for new approaches to address housing insecurity and community development. But many of the solutions we so desperately need are not new. Over 100 years ago, through cooperative pooling of resources, the Gloucester Land Building and Loan Association enabled generations of Black farmers in Gloucester County to acquire and retain land. By 1910, less than 50 years post-emancipation, more than 95% of Black farmers in the county owned their farms, an astonishing figure that even surpassed White ownership rates.16 This was not simply an economic milestone but a remarkable act of social reconstruction: a community rewriting its relationship to land, wealth, and one another. Mapping a Black Sense of Place As a geographer and urban planner, I expected formal documentation (cartography, property records, master plans, policy schedules) to reveal the legacies of my ancestors’ organizing. Even if I had to read between the lines, surely the archive would offer clues. In some ways, the archival record is there if you know how to look, but McKittrick’s words ring true: Black geographies are hard to track. Over the decades, properties have changed hands many times, and where records do exist, they are often difficult to decipher. I spent days
in the Gloucester County clerk’s office poring over 100-yearold documents, trying to reconstruct chains of custody, lot severances, and development assemblies. It was an opaque, bureaucratic, and tedious undertaking, one I ultimately could not bring to a satisfying resolution. I had, perhaps naively, assumed that the deeds and records of the transactions facilitated by the Gloucester Land Building and Loan Association would contain clear descriptions, something I could translate onto a contemporary map or GIS platform. What I failed to anticipate was that, unlike fixed landmarks or coordinates, the parcel descriptions were almost entirely relational: written in reference to neighboring owners, many of whom are no longer there. For example: Thirty-two ⅔ acres of open land, and Six ½ acres of Sand Bar and Marsh, and is bounded as follows: On the North by the land of the said Gloucester Land, Building and Loan Association, inc., which was part of this tract of land; On the East by lands of W.C. Stubbs and Richard Wilkins, former Concord tract of land; On the South by land of Richard Wilkins; and on the West by the York River.17
I also noticed a similar relationality when asking for directions in Gloucester: people orient themselves around what used to be there. It is another reminder that the past is never that far behind. Even if the physical markers have been demolished, replaced, or redeveloped, people will tell you how to find a place based on landmarks tied more to memory than to anything that exists today. You can’t miss it – make a left at the corner where the general store used to be. What I have come to realize is that wherever we stand, the supposedly fixed reference points that anchor our conception of place may lose their significance: place, even its legal description, has always been malleable. The legacy of the Gloucester Land Building and Loan Association is transformative. But like the Tidewater landscape itself, crisscrossed with meandering waterways and coastlines shaped by daily tides, the memory of these radical efforts is transmutable, always at risk of fading if not actively maintained and passed along. And yet the values that sustained those efforts—mutual aid, cooperative stewardship, and a belief in the liberatory potential of land and community—continue to reverberate. I am a beneficiary of that legacy, not only materially but philosophically. The resulting access to land and rootedness created the foundation for enduring social infrastructures such as the Gloucester Land Building and Loan Association and our historic Black churches: social technologies that enable ways of being that resist extraction and offer living proof of alternative models of ownership and governance. They require action, and to resist the momentum of the colonial capitalist machine is a heavy order – but many hands make for light(er) work. More than a century later, as chair of the Neighbourhood Land Trust (NLT) in Toronto, I have worked in that same tradition of collective landholding: stewarding land in
H.E.R.E. 10
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 11
H.E.R.E. 12
common, for community benefit rather than profit. Incorporated in 2014, the Parkdale Neighbourhood Land Trust (PNLT) is Toronto’s first neighborhood-based Community Land Trust. PNLT is a membership-based, community-controlled non-profit organization. The Neighbourhood Land Trust is the charitable arm of the PNLT, which owns and stewards lands leased to other charitable partners to manage day-to-day operations, provides tenant support services for NLT’s affordable and supportive housing properties, and advances local economic development initiatives.18 When I joined the NLT board in 2021, we owned a community garden and a single roominghouse. Today, the NLT manages a portfolio of 85 residential properties across the downtown west side of Toronto, representing over 200 permanently affordable homes. These efforts, past and present, are not isolated experiments but part of a long continuum, sustained by intergenerational care and creative resistance. The H.E.R.E. Project is an attempt to surface and extend that lineage, treating land not as a commodity but as a relation, and community memory as both inheritance and invitation. H.E.R.E. and Back Again There is a peculiar experience I suspect is common among many of us children of immigrants born away from ancestral homelands: upon returning (if there is a place to return to at all), we are confronted with both familiarity and alienation. On my recent visits to Gloucester, I couldn’t escape the layered realities that coexist on the land. Here, in old Virginia, the first permanent English settlement in the Americas, colonial memory is alive and well. One can visit Colonial Williamsburg, preserved as a simulacrum of a 17th-century capital complete with parking lots, a Starbucks, and a Lululemon. Along the Colonial Parkway, interpretive signs mark Revolutionary and Civil War battlefields. Yet the traces of plantation violence that shaped this landscape are far less prominent, and mention of Indigenous genocide is fainter still. One day in particular stands out. I began by driving up to the University of Richmond to meet my cousin, Jonathan Stubbs, a legal scholar and theologian. After sharing some of this research with him and his students, the two of us spent the afternoon driving along back roads by the York River. As we passed through Capahosic, Jonathan described the reach of the Gloucester Land Building and Loan Association. We drove by the historic markers and visible remnants of radical Black community infrastructure: the Woodville Rosenwald School, the Moton Center, and the churches (Bethel Baptist, Antioch, Shepherdsville, and others). But these infrastructures are sometimes difficult to “read” on the land because what distinguishes them is less the physical structure than the social, cultural, and community bonds that have filled, and in many cases still fill, these buildings with life. As the late afternoon sun began to tint the world, Jonathan reflected on how things were, how they changed, and how they might be, and in turn, I began to understand this place
as it is held in our collective memory. These drives changed the research. They confirmed that I was no longer conducting a conventional cartographic project; instead, I had entered the terrain of emotional geography, chasing a landscape of longing and desire, a landscape held in memories more than in deeds. It is no accident that White histories are prioritized and Black histories systematically erased through formal heritage and planning policies. The infrastructures of settler colonialism require the preservation of the prevailing logics of capital, power, and private property. Through this work, I ask how we can start to create an understanding of a place that isn’t solely reliant on property lines, but on relationships. How can we move beyond the archive and property records to the entanglements of reciprocal community stewardship? Can we make room for geographies of grief, survival, and celebration in our planning and land-based design concepts? What is required are specific and empathetic narrative counterpoints. The H.E.R.E. Project has provided opportunities for members of the public to engage with each other’s family histories and our respective experiences of migration and relocation, using multimedia storytelling to illuminate the roles of social technologies and cultural infrastructure in community-building and placemaking. Inspired by Saidiya Hartman’s concept of “critical fabulation,” which she describes as “re-presenting the sequence of events in divergent stories and from contested points of view,” Fabulation Cartography workshops invite participants into a memory-mapping collage activity.19 Presented in dialogue with a film screening, group discussion, or audio-visual installation, the workshops provide an opportunity to explore counter-mapping as a method for reflecting on the stories that have shaped who we are and how we got here. By digging through piles of ephemera (locally sourced maps, cookbooks, magazines, travel guides, album covers, found photographs, etc.), I ask people to look for something familiar—a feeling, a recipe, a trace of self—and to reassemble these fragments into new representations of space, place, and identity. The resultant “maps” are about giving form to speculative cartographies of memory, movement, and meaning. Navigating Landscapes of Grief and Longing The Fabulation Cartography workshops further revealed that mapping is never only about place; it is also about longing, rupture, and return. In the layering of images, recipes, mementos, and half-remembered stories, participants assemble not just alternative geographies but the emotional residues that cling to them: grief for what was lost, gratitude for what was carried, and the quiet persistence of inherited traditions. What these workshops make unmistakable is that every map is a memorial. They also helped me understand this impulse to map lineage as a form of mourning, an attempt to gather what has been scattered and to hold it with care. In “Archaeology Under the Blinding Light of Race,” Michael Blakey highlights the fundamental role of burial practices as
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 13
some of the most ancient markers of the human condition.20 Referencing symbolic traditions of culture, food sharing, technology, and language as embryonic markers of community, Blakey offers an alternative descriptor for the human race. Rather than Homo Sapiens (the man who knows), he proposes Homo Reminiscens (the man who remembers). What if what really sets us apart is not wisdom or knowledge (official record), but memorial practices (collective memory)? The archival materials, speculative maps, and participatory elements that constitute the H.E.R.E. Project are not just documentation, but tools of resistance and radical imagination. They remind us how communities have always found ways to remain rooted, even when land was stolen, policed, or denied. These aren’t just stories from the past. Black-led community land stewardship continues today, in communities across the continent. In an age of privatization, economic inequality, and political fragmentation, these practices offer urgently needed alternatives. The H.E.R.E. Project demonstrates that memory work is planning work, that land stewardship is liberation work, and that our collective futures depend on how bravely we choose to remember, repair, and re-imagine together. Around many Passover tables, the ritual ends with the phrase, “next year in Jerusalem.” Around ours, especially in light of the ongoing occupation and genocide in Palestine, we pause to think about what we are truly wishing for. What I hope for, next year and every year, is peace and liberation, knowing that none of us are free until all of us are. That work begins where we are, in just relation with the land and with each other. And maybe, “next year in Virginia,” we could sit together by the creek and tell stories side by side. Remembrance is a collective act, and it needs all our voices.
1 Alain Brossat & Sylvia Klingberg, Revolutionary Yiddishland: A History of Jewish Radicalism (Verso, 2017), 23. 2 Doikayt is a Yiddish word that directly translates to English as hereness. For the Bund, this notion signifies a specific relation to time and place, and urgently demands a secular, culturally grounded commitment to one’s fellows and community. Pedro Beresin, et al., “Here-and-Nowness: Diaspora Tactics as Institutional Strategy at Casa do Povo,” Stedelijk Studies Journal, no. 12 (2023). 3 Katherine McKittrick, “On Plantations, Prisons, and a Black Sense of Place,” Social & Cultural Geography 12, no. 8 (2011): 984. 4 Christina Sharpe, In the Wake: On Blackness and Being (Duke University Press, 2016), 8. 5 George Carter to J.S., personal letter, Carter family papers, Toronto, Ontario (2017). 6 McKittrick, “On Plantations, Prisons, and a Black Sense of Place,” 984. 7 Fred Carter, A Gift of God, unpublished manuscript, Carter family papers, Newport News, Virginia (2015). 8 Ibid. 9 Fairfield Foundation, “Rosewell,” https:// fairfieldfoundation.org/rosewell/ (February 2026). 10 Carter, A Gift of God. 11 Ibid. 12 Spectrum Magazine, “Hidden Figures: Black Adventist Women Who Made a Difference (Part 2)” https://spectrummagazine.org/ culture/hidden-figures-black-adventistwomen-who-made-difference-part-2/ (accessed July 2025); Carter, A Gift of God. 13 Rosewell: America’s Magnificent Ruin, “History”, http://www.rosewell.org/history. html (July 2025). 14 McKittrick, “On Plantations, Prisons, and a Black Sense of Place,” 955. 15 Ibid., 960. 16 George F. Bagby, “William G. Price and the Gloucester Agricultural and Industrial School,” The Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 108, no. 1 (2000): 45–84. 17 Deed from Gloucester Land Building and Loan Association to W. G. Price, “Gloucester County Deed Book,” Gloucester County Clerk of Court, Gloucester County, Virginia, vol. 42, (1918): 249. 18 Parkdale Neighbourhood Land Trust, “About,” https://pnlt.ca/about (accessed January 2026). 19 Saidiya Hartman, “Venus in Two Acts,” Small Axe 12, no.2 (2008): 12–13. 20 Michael L. Blakey, “Archaeology under the Blinding Light of Race,” Current Anthropology 61, no. S22 (2020).
ANNIE LYNCH
LANDSCAPES OF REMEMORY
T
oni Morrison’s concept of “rememory,” introduced by the character Sethe in her 1987 novel Beloved, describes a dynamic memory process that calls into question the fixity of time in space: Some things just stay…places, places are still there. If a house burns down, it’s gone, but the place—the picture of it—stays, and not just in my rememory, but out there, on the world. The picture is still there and what’s more, if you go there— you who never was there—if you go there and stand in the place where it was, it will happen again; it will be there for you, waiting for you.1
Annie Lynch is a designer with the firm Studio Zewde. Her work focuses on monuments, memorials, and sites of memory. Annie holds a BA in art history from Williams College and a master of landscape architecture from Harvard University’s Graduate School of Design.
design, cultural studies
In what Morrison describes as an interaction with the past through place, a shadow landscape emerges that haunts apparently stable geographies. Within this notion of memory, the past is still occurring and ripe for confrontation and encounter. Rememory contends that memories are not solely held by individuals – memory is also an independent actor, operating freely in space and outside of mere psychological projection. The rememories are “waiting for you,” as Morrison describes, in the landscape. Her insistence on the materiality of rememories, their availability and situatedness, suggests that they are areas where people can connect and gather. Indeed, through this collective recognition, rememories are spaces where absences—the lost house—are made material and available for negotiation. Rememories retrieve a past that has been excluded from the dominant historical narrative via a process critical geographer Katherine McKittrick calls “sociospatial denial,” or a hegemonic act of deliberate erasure of subaltern pasts.2 Morrison’s notion brings us to an understanding of the American landscape as both shaped by and inexorably entangled with the persistent, collective memories cast out of history’s sweep. In the two centuries since the academic discipline was founded, landscape architecture has essentialized historic narratives, suppressing or ignoring physical spaces that fall outside of, or threaten, these mythologies. Landscape designers have relied on traditional geographic tools and representations of space that have neglected or erased the places and geographies produced by marginalized populations. The grave consequence
LANDSCAPES OF REMEMORY 16
of this reliance has entailed the physical destruction of these spaces, as well as the exclusion of places that resist geographic representation. The municipal violence of redlining, land seizure by eminent domain, and the razing of whole neighborhoods and communities are actions facilitated by cartography and a traditional geographic accountancy of space. Rememories call upon these seething absences in the landscape and reconstitute them: they re-member the collective landscape of erasure. Sites of rememory, then, persist, expand, and accumulate precisely because they evade geographic capture. How can landscape architecture design with these unruly geographies of rememory? When Ian McHarg published Design with Nature in 1968, he introduced a method for integrating ecological knowledge into landscape architectural practice. This new methodology helped practitioners understand the ecological processes at work in the landscape and encouraged designers to collaborate with them. In giving the field these tools, he transformed the discipline of landscape architecture into one poised to address a rapidly deteriorating environment. Just as McHarg revolutionized the discipline to meet the urgent demands of climate change, landscape architecture can remake itself in the 21st century to finally negotiate sites of erasure. Morrison’s concept is further suggestive of how designers might work with memory as a shared, collective material, and how the historical absences that rememory attends to may create sites of connection and convergence. Postcolonial landscape theorists offer landscape architects expanded spatial frameworks for thinking about these geographies of memory. The Martinican poet and postcolonial theorist Édouard Glissant describes this assessment in his “poetics of landscape,” where his formulation of landscape resists the airless fixity of geographic representation: What you can oppose to the facts of history. The night in full daylight and the filtered shadows. The root of the vine and its violet flower. The dense network of ferns. The primordial mud, impenetrable and primal…We come to a halt, not certain what slows us down at that spot with a strange uneasiness.3
Here, Glissant challenges the unitary vantage point of Western geography and calls us to recognize the landscape as a layered
archive of subaltern memory. The plants, the quality of light and shadow, the need to pause at a particular place are all registers of the past that continue to exert pressure on the present. In his “poetics,” Glissant proposes two key strategies for working with memory in place. Firstly, the cataloging of traces that Glissant describes (the “dense network of ferns…the root of the vine”) can be read as memory’s imprints that persist despite geographic erasure, furnishing the tools for working with memory as a material. Further, Glissant reminds us that working with memory requires an expanded archive, one that attends to embodied experience. The mud and ferns, the affectual qualities of space, are all aspects of an expanded landscape archive. The landscape architecture firm Studio Zewde, founded in 2018 by Sara Zewde, is developing a methodology that centers expanded notions of memory and landscape in its design of public spaces. In my six years at the firm, I have seen firsthand how this emergent methodology holds immense promise for crafting uniquely resonant spaces of convergence and fellowship. Three recent projects demonstrate how innovative design research practices and modes of public engagement have allowed collective remembrance to dictate the course of the design process. In the three cases presented, I demonstrate how archival research, the discovery and amplification of site traces, and rigorous community engagement methods are essential tools for the design of landscapes of rememory. Reunion with the Reservoir In 2021, The Discovery Center commissioned Studio Zewde to design a defunct Philadelphia reservoir that had, until the 1970s, served as a critical community space. The reservoir was the local high school’s track-and-field training ground, an afterschool hangout, and a place to spend hot summer days. In 1972, a fence was erected around the 37-acre water body, severing the community’s precious water access. When a not-for-profit group purchased the reservoir in 2018, the organization restored public access to the site. During those decades without access, generations of community members knew the reservoir only through stories. Since the reopening, the entrance had shifted and the site had become part of a wildlife preserve. Yet with
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 17
historic ties weakened, community members rarely visited the reservoir. It was through discussions with community elders that Studio Zewde located the reservoir’s lesser-known past as a beloved public space. After this discovery, the firm’s design work focused on reuniting the neighborhood with the reservoir. Central to this effort was connecting the memories of the site’s past to its potential future as a publicly accessible water body. A key challenge from the project’s outset was finding archival materials that illustrated senior residents’ oral histories of the old reservoir days. While the reservoir’s construction was welldocumented, its life through the middle of the 20th century was largely unrecorded and there was no geographic record of its social, communal use. After weeks of archival research, Studio Zewde unearthed a series of photographs showing neighborhood kids at the site on a 1960s summer’s day. Only then could community members of all ages begin to engage in cross-generational discussion over a shared vision—informed equally by past use and future imaginings—of spending time by the water. The project’s success ultimately relied upon performing this critical community memory work on-site. Studio Zewde partnered with local organizations to structure an event that honored the ways the community gathered and remembered together. On a July evening at the reservoir, over 100 community members gathered at an event called “Reunion with the Reservoir.” Local leaders discussed the former role of the reservoir in community life as children played by the water’s edge. After libations were poured to honor the neighborhood’s ancestors, community members of all ages decorated floating lanterns that were set out on the water at dusk. The lantern messages included further calls to the ancestors, remembrances of the reservoir’s past, hopes and aspirations for the future of the site, and expressions of love for the neighborhood. Our final design for the reservoir embraces the site’s presentday condition as a wildlife refuge while once again making it a place for the community to gather. We achieved this by reintroducing historic connections to the site and creating new spaces for people to come together and spend time by
the water. A new access point retraces a historic connection to the street grid and revives an entrance that community members often used prior to the 1972 closure. A redesign of the reservoir’s eastern edge makes it accessible and shaded, further bolstering its connection to the adjacent urban fabric. The eastern edge also features a new lookout point and spaces for picnics and barbeques, activities that community members told us they would most like to do by the water’s edge. Re-Tracing a Landscape In North Carolina’s Piedmont region, Studio Zewde undertook a project centered on a 300-year-old burial ground containing the remains of more than 100 enslaved individuals. The cemetery site sits in a wooded lot behind a hotel and a 20thcentury estate – both built atop the footprint of an 18thcentury agricultural homestead where enslaved people had lived and labored. Before the project began, the cemetery was largely unknown and inaccessible to the community. While some local residents had heard of it, most had never visited. The site was hidden from view by the estate’s landscaping, with no visible entry or path into the space. A single sign marked its presence, but it referenced only the burial of the homestead’s enslavers; there was no acknowledgment of the enslaved men, women, and children who were laid to rest just a few feet from them. Studio Zewde’s work sought to reintroduce the cemetery into the regional descendant community’s existing landscape of memory. The team directly engaged with descendant community members—all of whom trace their lineage to enslaved ancestors from the region—and collaborated with them to understand how memory was shared and practiced. This revealed two critical truths: first, that visiting and caring for ancestral burial sites was already a meaningful tradition for many families; and second, that genealogy was a central way the community preserved and told its own history. These insights shaped a design process rooted in existing memory practices. Many community members had dedicated their lives to recording family histories and relations through genealogical research. With this understanding at the fore, Studio Zewde
LANDSCAPES OF REMEMORY 18
designed its site research through a genealogical lens: by looking at the history of the town through the matrix of interconnected families, the past was animated by proud lineages that connected today’s community. This approach allowed the design team to share much of what we had heard in the community members’ oral histories and build the necessary trust to enter into the next phase of the project. Unable to find an existing map that showed either burial grounds of enslaved workers or small family cemeteries in the area, Studio Zewde scoured state records for descendant burial grounds in the region and mapped them. This exercise revealed that the burial grounds of enslaved people in the region were all connected through a system of waterways that ran throughout the county. The cemetery landscape bore traces that further connected it to enslaved burial grounds throughout the region: the growth of periwinkle, the dense canopy of evergreens, and the presence of field stone markers at grave sites drew it deeper into connection with those betterknown burial spaces nearby that bear nearly identical physical characteristics. By establishing the project site as part of a broader network of burials connected by regional hydrology, community members were invited to imagine a regional and interconnected landscape of remembrance. The design of the site finally centers around three key motivations: clarifying the presence and access to the burial ground, amplifying the interconnected nature of these spaces through water, and making the shared physical characteristics of these burial sites newly legible. We were able to achieve this by carving out a new pathway toward the cemetery that clarifies access to the burial ground and announces its presence, amplifying the cemetery threshold through a reflective water feature. Seating around the water scrim invites quiet contemplation before entering and upon leaving the cemetery. The presence of water further underscores the hydrologic connections that link this site with many similar burial sites throughout the region. The material palette for this design intervention pulls from the defining characteristics of the cemetery: the granite fieldstones, exposed red clay earth, and the periwinkle groundcover that blankets burial depressions. These design elements come together to create a new
threshold into both the burial site and the broader landscape of remembrance that connects burial sites throughout the region. Water Is Memory In 2021, the Dia Art Foundation commissioned Studio Zewde to redesign its Beacon, New York campus. For over 20 years, the museum’s southern landscape has given the public the impression of a vast, empty bathtub; its sunken nine-acre lawn was dutifully maintained, often flooded, and highly visible (though inaccessible) to museumgoers. With the site transitioning to public access, the museum community’s chief concerns were creating a singular landscape experience and managing an immediate threat: rising water. Studio Zewde’s early site research centered around the campus’s history as a key threshold for the Indigenous Wappinger community, on whose ancestral lands Dia Beacon rests. After speaking with Indigenous scholars who are experts in the Hudson Valley region, the firm learned that the site was once a portage, or river crossing, in the pre-contact period – a place perfectly designed for the movement of water and people. Since colonization and the introduction of the railway, however, the site had been cut off from the water’s edge and rigorously oriented along the north-south axis. The firm’s design took inspiration from the pre-contact portage crossing by introducing a berm stretching east-west across the site. This critical move carves out much-desired social space to the rear of the museum and addresses the museum community’s essential hydrological concerns. This reorientation is informed by the past, yet ultimately looks to the future and the inevitable return of water to the site. Conclusion Morrison’s rememory tells us that there are pasts waiting for us in the landscape. These collective hauntings present planes of enormous possibility for landscape architects. By treating memory as a design material and allowing it to inform the design process, the discipline can move beyond the reproduction of dominant historical narratives and toward a future where silenced pasts are rendered into visible spaces of convergence. The projects discussed here illustrate how memory can shape
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 19
contemporary practice. At the reservoir, archival research and intergenerational storytelling transformed a site of attempted erasure into a renewed commons, reconnecting neighbors through shared memory. In North Carolina, the act of mapping descendant cemeteries and engaging with the community’s genealogical traditions reframed a burial ground as part of a larger network of remembrance. For Dia Beacon, the reorientation of the site around its history as a portage crossing transformed an overlooked lawn into resilient infrastructure while restoring its pre-contact orientation. In each case, memory functioned as both a framework for research and engagement as well as a design material. To obliterate, from the Latin obliterare—to “cause to be forgotten”— is the ambition of sociospatial denial. Yet, as Morrison argues, obliteration is impossible: places beloved by communities may be obscured, neglected, or hidden, but they endure in collective memory and await reconstitution. Landscape architecture, when it turns toward these spaces, can become a discipline of retrieval. For landscape architects, to work with memory is not only to resist erasure but to open spaces of convergence and connection.
1 Toni Morrison, Beloved (Alfred A. Knopf, 1987), 36. 2 Katherine McKittrick, Demonic Grounds (University of Minnesota Press, 2006), 8. 3 Édouard Glissant, Caribbean Discourse (University Press of Virginia, 1989), 10–11.
Emily Schlickman
Emily Schlickman is an associate professor of landscape architecture and environmental design at UC Davis who studies wildfire adaptation with a focus on care and decolonization. She co-authored Design by Fire: Resistance, CoCreation, and Retreat in the Pyrocene (Routledge, 2023), curated the exhibitions Pyro Futures and Good Fire, and actively burns with crews across Northern California.
ecology, cultural studies
I
n Northern California, you smell fire season long before you see it. The sky might be blue, and the kids might be playing, unbothered, at the playground, but an unmistakable aroma instantly signals a shift. Barring past trauma, the smell might seem cozy, comforting even, stirring up memories of campfires in the mountains or backyard bonfires with neighbors. But that’s not what the smell reminds you of anymore. Now, it brings different imagery: a sun dimmed to an eerie orb, skies thick with haze. Smoke doesn’t just fill the air; it tints everything, like a warped version of rose-colored glasses. You see walls of fire illuminating the nighttime sky, cars melted into pools of metal, and rows of chimneys paying homage to the homes burned at their feet. When you take another breath, you realize that the same particles that conjured up these scenes are slowly eroding your ability to remember them in the first place.1
Smells are uniquely powerful in triggering memories and emotions because they travel directly to the region of the brain that directs these processes. They are deeply tied to place and can help us recall memories long buried, even revive images we thought had faded. While they can be portals to the past, repeated exposure to certain smells—like the intense wildfire smoke that we’re witnessing today—gradually dulls our recollections of the past. This smoke isn’t just obscuring our landscapes, it’s obscuring our minds, fundamentally shifting how we form and retrieve stories we tell ourselves about our lives. Smoke as Cleanser Yet smoke wasn’t always like this. Prior to colonization, smoke was something far more diverse and complex. It could take many forms, depending on where it came from and what it was meant to do.2 At times, it was even used for healing, to clear away what didn’t belong. Herbs, leaves, and roots were burned for distinct purposes: some to ward off illness, others to dispel
negative energy or restore balance. Rod Mendes, a member of the Karuk Tribe and fire chief for the Yurok Tribe, recalls how his grandmother would burn vegetation around their home – not out of fear, but to keep things clean in a spiritual sense.3 Interestingly, the English word smudge tends to carry the opposite connotation: it suggests a blemish, something damaged or imperfect. But in many Indigenous traditions, smudging is an act of care and renewal.4 Smoke literacy was also once a critical part of early education for many Indigenous tribes. Some children were taught to read smoke, not only by its shape and movement, but by its smell and color. In Tending the Wild, a multi-media series and documentary, Honorable Ron Goode, a North Fork Mono Tribal Chairman and cultural fire practitioner, urged: “Smell the smoke. Smell it. That’s a grass fire. Smell the smoke. That’s a house burning. Smell the smoke. That’s tires burning. That’s a wood fireplace burning. You should be able to smell every
Up in the aiR 22
single kind of smoke.”5 His words are a reminder that smoke carries the signature of whatever is burning and that those who spend time with fire learn to interpret its story through their senses. The color of the smoke offers additional clues about how far combustion has progressed and how intense the flames might become.6 Thick, white smoke that rises slowly and lingers often points to a cooler, smoldering burn. In contrast, dark, black smoke usually signals a fast-moving, high-intensity fire front. Learning to read these signals helps people understand what a fire is doing and, more importantly, anticipate what it might do next.
In August of 2020, I stepped outside my house in Davis, California, and saw large white flakes drifting down from the sky. A fire had been burning for days, largely unchecked, in the inner coastal range west of town. Still, it took a moment for the scene to register. My first thought was, “God, isn’t it beautiful?” I stood in awe, like a child seeing snow for the first time, as the world turned white. Then I looked up and saw the plume – massive, towering, unmistakable. It was thick and churning, visible for miles. A pyrocumulus cloud had formed and held so much heat and moisture that it had created its own weather system. It was simultaneously terrifying and mesmerizing.
Smoke as Reckoning
At the time, that moment felt fleeting. But I return to it often. The ash had blanketed everything, settling into sidewalk cracks, coating windshields, and collecting in the folds of patio furniture. Weeks after the flames were extinguished, I was still finding it. The fire had passed, but its residue remained. And as it settled across the landscape, it transformed the familiar into something foreign.
When Spanish colonists first arrived in California in the mid16th century, they found land so laden with smoke that they gave it smoky names – for instance, San Pedro Bay was originally called “Bahía de los Fumos.”7 That smoke was a sign of a carefully tended landscape, shaped by centuries of Indigenous burning. However, by the late 19th century, fire began to be cast as a threat rather than a tool. In the early 20th century, suppression became official policy, and agencies worked aggressively to extinguish every fire. The smoke largely disappeared, along with the fires that had once sustained many of California’s patchy, productive ecosystems. Over the past few decades, smoke has returned with vengeance. After more than a century of fire suppression, alongside the accelerating effects of climate change and unchecked expansion into the wildland-urban interface, the stage has been set for the extreme wildfire events we are witnessing today. In this new era, smoke has taken on an outsized role: no longer just a byproduct of fire, but a symbol of its reach. Once a familiar presence in certain landscapes, it now travels farther and lingers longer. It has become an oversimplified beacon of fear, a toxic carrier pigeon delivering the message of wildfire to places far removed from the flames themselves. Cities once untouched by smoke, like New York and Washington, DC, are now getting a taste, both literally and psychologically. In the news, this is the only kind of smoke being covered. The media fixates on bad smoke – smoke as a hazard and a symbol of destruction. Smoke that collapses distance, compresses time. Smoke that extends pyro-anxiety into unfamiliar territory, erasing the line between burn zones and everywhere else. Composed of fine particulate matter, it carries fragments of the places it came from. These are not just ashes but airborne archives. And as the smoke drifts, it tells a story: of what burned, how it burned, and what was lost along the way. Rarely do we hear about good smoke, smoke that once signaled renewal. And so, the fear compounds.
In the years since, I’ve come to appreciate how smoke (and what it leaves behind) is much more than just a symbol of loss. The tendency to see smoke only as a threat leaves little room for context or history – for the idea that not all smoke is the same and that some smoke is indicative of care, not destruction. To begin illustrating this nuance, I want to share three stories of good smoke, taken from my own work as a firelighter.8 These are small, grounded moments from the field, but each offers a glimpse into the broader potential of smoke as a restorative force. Smoke as Protector When I arrived at the burn unit near Middletown, California, the morning was still and golden. Massive old valley oaks, Quercus lobata, stood in a dry grassland, their wide canopies casting shade across the field. It was 8 am, and we were set to begin our briefing in half an hour. Around me, people chatted quietly, all dressed in the yellow Nomex gear worn during fire operations. The crew was a mix of CAL FIRE leadership, “hotshots” from hours away, local residents, and an Indigenous-led burn crew guiding the effort.9 I struck up a conversation with one tribal member, who gestured toward the field and pointed out something striking: while young oak seedlings were scattered beneath the older trees, there was a noticeable absence of middle-aged saplings. That entire generation was missing because too few seedlings had survived over time. The burn wasn’t meant for the present; it was for their grandchildren, so that one day, they too could gather acorns.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 23
Up in the aiR 24
During the briefing, participants were split into squads. Instructions were clear: avoid scorching the caged seedlings, and don’t let the oaks take on too much heat, but do let the smoke rise into them – they need it. I was placed on the holding squad, working off a Type 6 engine, tasked with keeping the fire within the boundaries of the unit and cooling it if it flared up. Since I wasn’t physically lighting fires, most of my time was spent observing, keeping my head on a swivel. As the eastern and western flanks of the unit merged, fire slipped beneath the oaks, sending a billow of smoke up into the canopy. This burn was timed not just to reduce fuel loads but to protect acorns. Light, low-intensity fire produces smoke that helps suppress acorn weevils, insects that bore into acorns and destroy them from within. These weevils lay their eggs in green acorns during late summer; by early fall, larvae emerge and drop to the soil to pupate. When burns coincide with this vulnerable phase, the heat and smoke interrupt the weevil’s life cycle, reducing infestations and safeguarding future harvests. For Indigenous communities like the Pomo and Wappo, healthy acorns are gathered, processed, and shared through intergenerational practices that include grinding, leaching, and cooking into dishes like mush or cakes. These traditions are accompanied by stories, songs, and ceremonies that reinforce relationships with the land and with each other. In this way, smoke protects more than just seeds; it protects cultural traditions. Smoke as Stimulator On a cool spring morning, I joined a burn crew preparing to light a steep, 28-acre unit on Howell Mountain, California. Pacific Union College, alongside the Land Trust of Napa County and CAL FIRE, had carefully thinned the forest in the months prior, removing dense understory growth that had accumulated over decades. Following extensive logging, livestock grazing, and fire suppression in the mid- to late 1800s, this forest had become overstocked with trees, crowding out light-demanding understory species and reducing habitat diversity for wildlife. Our plan was to reintroduce fire in a slow, deliberate way, starting at the top of the ridge and letting the flames back down the slope. The smoke rose in thin layers, hugging the hillside and seeping into the soil. Many native plants in California’s ecosystems, especially fire-followers, are adapted to respond to smoke. Chemical compounds in smoke, known as karrikins, act as triggers for germination. Seeds that have waited years or even decades in the soil seed bank awaken after a fire – not because they are scorched, but because they are stimulated by the smoke.
One of the species we hope to see return is Emmenanthe penduliflora, or Whispering Bells, a fire-follower known to germinate in response to smoke. Its seeds can lie dormant in the soil for decades, waiting for the chemical signals released by fire to trigger growth. Alongside other native wildflowers, Whispering Bells is part of a suite of plants adapted to disturbance and renewal. Burns like this one create the precise conditions these species need: open sunlight, cleared competition, and smoke-infused soil. In this way, smoke acts as a stimulator of biodiversity, unlocking dormant potential and creating space for rare and native plants to re-establish themselves across the forest floor. Smoke as Smotherer The 7-acre burn unit was nestled in the rolling hills just north of Capay, California, its late-season grasses shimmering in the morning sun. Our primary target was Avena fatua, or wild oat — a tall, wiry invasive grass now dominant across much of California’s coastal range. Introduced during the colonial era alongside sheep and cattle, this annual grass, with its twisting awns and shallow roots, quickly outcompeted native perennials and reshaped the region’s ecology. Fire-adapted native forbs and bunchgrasses once thrived here, but with the suppression of Indigenous burning and the onset of intensive grazing, species like Avena took over. Its thick mats of fine, easily ignitable fuels heighten fire risk while choking out other plants. For this burn, we wanted the fire to crawl slowly across the unit, producing a dense, lingering smoke layer. While some compounds in smoke stimulate the germination of firefollowing natives, others—like ethylene, acetaldehyde, and certain phenolics—can inhibit or disrupt the germination of shallow-rooted, non-native grasses. Seed burial depth plays a key role: while native seeds often rest deeper in the soil and are insulated from surface effects, invasive grasses like Avena germinate right near the top, where smoke and heat are most concentrated. By disrupting the seedbed at the surface, smoke helps interrupt the life cycle of these invasive grasses, reducing their spread over time. And while smoke isn’t able to clear the hillside in a single sweep, it helps catalyze a shift. Smoke as Choice Smoke has always been part of the California landscape, and it always will be. But today, we are faced with a critical choice: What kind of smoke do we want to live with? As environmental historian Jared Dahl Aldern asks, “Would you like your smoke a little bit at a time or all at once? Would you like a few scattered,
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 25
localized, intermittent showers of pulverized ash or a suffocating, life-threatening deluge that turns the Bay Area sky orange and threatens thousands of lives?”10
1 David Scieszka, et al., “Biomass Smoke Inhalation Promotes Neuroinflammatory and Metabolomic Temporal Changes in the Hippocampus of Female Mice,” Journal of Neuroinflammation 20, no. 192 (2023).
Across the American West, there is a growing movement to bring good fire—and good smoke—back to our landscapes. It’s happening at multiple scales: from federal and state agencies like the US Forest Service and CAL FIRE, down to communityled burn crews, Indigenous-led operations, and neighbor-toneighbor prescribed-burn associations. Together, these efforts are rebuilding a culture of tending that understands firelighting as a critical practice. Embracing this shift means remembering what smoke can be. Smoke is not always a sign of destruction; it can be alive, carrying nutrients, microbes, fungal spores, and even seeds. It can be regenerative, supporting landscapes that depend on fire to thrive. And in some places, it can be as familiar as a mountain on the horizon: a landmark, a daily reminder of people tending the land with intention and care.
2 For example, see Don Hankins, “Beyond the Plume of Smoke,” Bay Nature Magazine (June 23, 2001), https://baynature.org/article/ beyond-the-plume-of-smoke/.
But significant challenges remain. Public fear of smoke remains high. Air quality regulations and permitting processes are often rigid. And even the most carefully planned burns can be called off at the last minute if the weather slips outside the prescription. Still, the work continues because it must. We need to understand the nuances of smoke and learn how to read its various forms to better understand what kind of smoke we do (and do not) want to support in the future. We need new stories and metaphors to describe the novel, fiery conditions in which we are living, as well as words that have the potential to help us steward and tend to landscapes touched by too much or, perhaps, too little fire. Our future with smoke is uncertain. But as we venture further into the age of fire, the Pyrocene, we need to broaden how we talk and write about smoke – bestow it with new stories, new metaphors, and perhaps, new memories. For we cannot change, nor embrace, what we cannot name.
3 Jude Coleman, “Indigenous Knowledge Reveals History of Fire-Prone California Forest,” Nature (June 7, 2022), https://www. nature.com/articles/d41586-022-01232-x. 4 Hankins, “Beyond the Plume of Smoke.” 5 Goode discusses this in PBS SoCal, “Tending the Wild,” https://www.pbssocal.org/shows/ tending-the-wild (accessed June 30, 2025). 6 David W. Dodson, “The Art of Reading Smoke, Volume 1” https://www.fire-policeems.com/misc/da3900.shtml (accessed June 30, 2025). 7 Nathan Masters, PBS SoCal, “Why Did a 1542 Spanish Voyage Refer to San Pedro Bay as the ‘Bay of the Smoke’?” https://www. pbssocal.org/shows/lost-la/why-did-a1542-spanish-voyage-refer-to-san-pedrobay-as-the-bay-of-the-smoke (accessed June 30, 2025). 8 The term “firelighter” is used informally to describe people, often Indigenous cultural burners or prescribed fire practitioners, who plan, prepare, and carry out intentional burns. It appears to have emerged organically within practitioner communities rather than from any single formal source, making it difficult to attribute to one person or organization. 9 Hotshots, or hotshot crews, are highly skilled wildland firefighters. 10 Jared Dahl Aldern, “Where There’s Good Fire, There’s Good Smoke,” Bay Nature Magazine (September 30, 2020), https:// baynature.org/2020/09/30/where-theresgood-fire-theres-good-smoke/.
Previous: Views of the San Gabriel Fire, September 1924.
Justin Dunnavant
What memories lie Justin Dunnavant is an assistant professor in the Department of Anthropology at UCLA. His interdisciplinary research in the US Virgin Islands investigates the environmental impacts of slavery in the former Danish West Indies. In addition to his archaeological research, Justin is a co-founder of the Society of Black Archaeologists, a National Geographic Explorer, and was inducted into The Explorers Club as one of “Fifty People Changing the World that You Need to Know About.”
Archaeology
W
ords can’t explain the life-changing experience of diving on a slave ship. Many of us have tried.1 We’ve expressed seemingly contradictory feelings of pain, disorientation, peace, transformation, and pride. Diving these wrecks awakens the dueling emotions associated with the collective memory of millions of captive Africans and the present haunting of occupying an underwater sacred site. However, it is the necessary return to the slave ship—the site of trauma—that has allowed me to process my own relationship to slavery: remembering my ancestors’ dreams, hopes, and desires. Properly caring for these sites as sacred memoryscapes offers the ability to transform the abyss into a loophole, “a way out, an escape route, or a means of extricating oneself from a seemingly impossible situation.”2 As I have come to learn, the ocean floor is a seascape that holds both Black memory and possibility – a Black past and Black futures. Black history lives, among many other places, at the bottom of the sea. With more than 36,000 officially documented voyages across the Atlantic, slave ships formed a consistent part of the maritime seascape for nearly four centuries. They ventured as far as Mozambique and Brazil and enmeshed Africa, Europe, and the Americas in a new world order of colonial relations. The poet Derek Walcott reminds us that this transatlantic heritage is scattered along the seafloor, writing, “Where are your monuments, your battles, martyrs?/ Where is your tribal memory? Sirs,/ in that grey vault. The sea. The sea/ has locked them up. The sea is History.”3 But this is not a bygone era. We live with the enduring legacy of slavery. The physical remnants of these voyages, the ball and chain, corroded and gone green, serve as “underwater signposts” that mark Atlantic routes.4 Yet the documentation of slave shipwrecks remains grossly underexplored, with just over a dozen sites positively identified. Even with current efforts to locate these wrecks, led
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 27
by organizations like the Slave Wrecks Project (SWP), Diving With a Purpose (DWP), the National Association of Black Scuba Divers (NABS), and other academic endeavors, we are a long way from realizing the full scope of Black heritage resting at the bottom of the sea. As a Black underwater archaeologist myself, Walcott’s words serve as the clarion call that animates my search for subaquatic Black history. His interrogative poem encourages both introspection and exploration, as my colleagues and I grapple with both the personal experiences of diving and the collective memory of slavery and the Middle Passage. What would it mean to dive to the bottom of the sea and touch our monuments, recovering our tribal memory from that gray vault? How do we care for these memories and curate our submarine monuments? And more importantly, how can these memories guide us toward a reparative future? The Clotilda When archaeologists positively identified the wreck of the Clotilda in 2019, it brought international attention to the small community of Africatown, Alabama. Few people outside of the community knew the story of the last slave ship to enter the United States and the community of Africans who subsequently founded the nearby town. But this wasn’t always the case. Nearly a century earlier, anthropologist Zora Neale Hurston visited Oluale Kossola—believed to be the last living African-born, formerly enslaved person—at his home in Africatown, Alabama. Anthropologist Franz Boas and historian Carter G. Woodson sent Hurston down to Alabama with orders to record his story, knowing that she was best
equipped for the task.5 Having proven herself as a folklorist, writer, and anthropologist, Hurston used the latest technology of her day to record some of the earliest documentary videos of Black heritage. Kossola sat for several interviews as Hurston documented his memories of Africa, the Middle Passage, and his troubled life in Alabama. As Hurston left, Kossola imparted more than words; he gave her a tangible piece of his personal history. She immediately wrote to her friend and intellectual interlocutor, Alain Locke, at Howard University. In a letter dated May 10, 1928, she enclosed two vertebrae of prehistoric sea animals she thought would be of interest to the deep history of the US South and “[A] bit of wood is from the ship in Mobile Bay (Cudjoe Lewis).”6 Kossola never forgot the experience of the Middle Passage; for more than 60 years, he had kept a piece of the slave ship that carried him from his home in the port of Ouidah, in southern Benin, to Alabama. He knew that the ship lay in the marsh of Bayou Corne, visible for many years and now fully submerged.7 In his later years, he felt Hurston should steward that piece of history; she would know what to do with it. Maybe that piece of the ship is lost to history, but that memory was not – it merely lay dormant. Diving the Clotilda When Jay Haigler and Kamau Sadiki dove to the bottom of the Mobile River in 2022, they likely became the first African Americans to enter the hull of a slave ship in over 160 years. That night, Ayana Omilade Flewellen—a fellow archaeologist, diver, and long-time collaborator—and I sat with them for an interview as they described the dive in detail. They relayed a
at the bottom of the sea?
What memories lie at the bottom of the sea? 28
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 29
deeply sensorial experience. Despite the river’s murky water and low visibility, Jay noted the unusual ability to smell the pinewood of the ship through his mask, while Kamau initially felt disoriented but soon sensed an embracing, calming energy underwater.8 Both men described a profound peace and presence of something beyond themselves during the dive, a sensation echoed by divers on the Henrietta Marie decades earlier.9 It’s impossible to work on these sites and not be transformed. You never feel alone when doing this work. While there are elements that are traumatic, there are elements— equally as powerful—that are cathartic. This sensation is difficult to explain but may best be represented as rememory, or the memory of a memory.10 The subsequent feelings of tranquility and haunting experienced by the divers are the result of experiencing a collective memory that they didn’t personally live. “Perhaps one would say that a slave ship has come back,” argues anthropologist Shiela Walker, “or the ancestors have come back to tell their story because they didn’t get a chance to tell it before. They came back at a time when they thought we needed it, at a time when they thought we could use it.”11 The manner in which these collective subaquatic memories animate the present is perhaps best explained by epiphenomenal time. Epiphenomenal time, as articulated by Michelle Wright, draws from the principle of superposition in particle physics and suggests that the present moment, the “now,” is not solely the result of past events but a culmination of various past, present, and future events through which it is interpreted.12 It’s more than just a palimpsest of past experiences; it’s history as accumulation, a whole that is greater than the sum of its parts.13 Ayana Omilade Flewellen writes about the transformative practice of Black divers breathing underwater at the sites of slave shipwrecks. Taking seriously Melody Jue’s call for “thinking from the water column” and exploring Alexis Pauline Gumbs and Ashon Crawley’s conceptualization of breathing as producing alternative forms of Black ontologies, Flewellen considers how the sonic somatic practice of Black scuba divers breathing while underwater transcends linear time. They argue, “the sound of Black divers inhaling and exhaling as we dive into sites of enslavement ruptures time, pulling us closer to the 1.8 million
souls who perished, creating affective encounters with the past in the present that resonate sonically in the body.”14 Considering these slave shipwrecks in epiphenomenal time offers new possibilities of exploring how sites of trauma can be transformed into sites of healing. In other words, with proper curation and care, we have the ability to turn ruins into monuments. Underwater Monumentality In 1992, members of NABS and the Mel Fisher Maritime Heritage Museum installed one of the first permanent underwater memorials dedicated to the slave trade, 35 miles off the coast of Key West at the site of the Henrietta Marie. The Henrietta Marie was a 17th-century British slave ship that made several trips between England, West Africa, and the Caribbean before it wrecked off the coast of Key West in 1700. It was leaving the Caribbean on its return journey to England, carrying ivory and sugar, the remnants of the slave trade. Salvagers, searching for the more lucrative Nuestra Señora de Atocha wreck, first identified the wreck in 1972, but it wasn’t excavated until the early 1990s. After a series of underwater surveys, the wreckage uncovered the largest collection of enslaved shackles ever found. Years later, members of NABS and the Mel Fisher Museum navigated to New Ground Reef and lowered a concrete memorial at the site of the Henrietta Marie’s wreckage. The plaque reads, “In memory and recognition of the courage, pain, and suffering of enslaved African people. Speak her name and gently touch the souls of our ancestors. Dedicated November 15, 1992.” Lowering the concrete memorial to the bottom of the sea did more than honor those enslaved; it fixed their memory in place and converted a grave site into a point of reflection, reifying a Black geographic presence at the bottom of the sea. But plaques and memorials are only one form of acknowledgement. After working on several sites of slavery, I’m interested in how we can activate these memoryscapes to both honor those who were held captive and offer some form of redress in the present. How do we care for these memories, the stories of our ancestors that are locked up in the hold of a ship in the abyss?
What memories lie at the bottom of the sea? 30
Ayana Omilade Flewellen and I discuss both the impossibility of fully redressing slavery and the ability for heritage sites to nonetheless incite transformative repair. We offer the case of recovering the archaeological evidence of destructive coral mining used to build colonial structures in the Caribbean as the impetus for redressive work that has led to coral restoration.15 Restoring coral reefs helps to repair submarine ecosystems and counter the ecological loss that resulted from the slave trade. Furthermore, the cultivation of underwater coral gardens as memorials to the slave trade can challenge the notion of the seafloor and the abyss as sites of death by fostering life through ecosystem restoration. In the case of the Clotilda, I argue for a similar focus on the redressive power of cultivating life – and that the answer here lies not in the sea but on land. The Clotilda arrived on the shores of Alabama in 1860 on a bet. Enslaver and logger Timothy Meaher commissioned the illegal slaving voyage in 1859 to purchase Africans from Dahomey and transport them back to Alabama. He refitted a logging vessel for the slave trade and negotiated for the transport of 110 Africans. They arrived in Mobile Bay in 1960 under the helm of Captain William Foster and were sold to plantations and the local logging industry throughout the state. Thus, the story of the Clotilda is one that entraps environmental degradation—the clearing of Alabama’s old-growth forests to fuel the increasing need for lumber for shipping—with the degradation of people. The longleaf pine (Pinus palustris) once dominated southern Alabama’s old-growth forests. Now, even as the official state tree, their populations are only a shadow of what they used to be due to more than a century of extractive logging practices. How can the lessons from the Clotilda’s past illuminate these ecological histories and inform a restorative future? Revisiting the Clotilda as a memoryscape of slavery, the restorative possibilities are clear. One path toward restoring the humanity of those Africans who were brought to Alabama and invoking the state’s old-growth forests lies in the curation and cultivation of a sacred grove. Historically in West Africa, sacred groves have facilitated deeply spiritual and social interactions, serving as homes for deities while also fostering ecological biodiversity. Comprised of native longleaf pines, oaks, maples, beeches, black gums, and tulip poplars—as well as African teak,
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 31
kapok, baobab, and African mahogany trees—a sacred grove in southern Alabama would do the dual work of reaffirming the humanity of those enslaved there while simultaneously starting the process of renewing the region’s old-growth forests. It would serve as a living testament to a “Black sense of place” on the Alabama landscape and provide a physical location for commemoration, reflection, and ceremony. The opportunity to transform the Clotilda into a “loophole of retreat” reveals the power of our underwater monuments to both reshape our relationship to ecological histories on land and attend to redressing our collective memory.16 As archaeologists doing this cultural work, we must lean into our role as stewards of memory. Just as Hurston was tasked with stewarding the remnants of the Clotilda back in 1928, we, too, are tasked with holding these memories, even the painful ones that others would rather forget. We may never be able to fully explain the experience of diving a slave ship. It is disorienting, jarring, peaceful, and transformative. It’s also so much more. In the abyss lies the key to our collective salvation.
1 Michael H. Cottman, Spirit Dive: An African American’s Journey to Uncover a Sunken Slave Ship’s Past, 1st pbk. ed (Three Rivers Press, 1999); “Diving the Clotilda - Jay Haigler and Kamau Sadiki,” interview by author and Ayana Flewellen, May 9, 2022; Tara Roberts, Written in the Waters: A Memoir of History, Home, and Belonging (National Geographic, 2025); Ayana Omilade Flewellen, “An Aural Ethnography of Black Breath: Soundscapes at Submerged Heritage Sites of Enslavement,” Liquid Blackness 9, no. 1 (2025): 106–17, https://read. dukeupress.edu/liquid-blackness/articleabstract/9/1/106/401103. 2 Tina M. Campt, A Black Gaze: Artists Changing How We See (MIT Press, 2021), 146. 3 Derek Walcott, “The Sea Is History,” The Paris Review 74 (1978), https://www. theparisreview.org/poetry/7020/the-sea-ishistory-derek-walcott. 4 Édouard Glissant, Poetics of Relation, trans. Betsy Wing (University of Michigan Press, 1997), 6. 5 Zora Neale Hurston, Barracoon: The Story of the Last “Black Cargo” (HarperCollins, 2018). 6 Zora Neale Hurston, “Letter from Zora Neale Hurston to Alain Locke,” May 10, 1928, Moorland Spingarn Research Center. Box 38, Folder 28. 7 Zora Neale Hurston, “Cudjo’s Own Story of the Last African Slaver,” The Journal of Negro History 12, no. 4 (October 1927): 659, https:// doi.org/10.2307/2714041. 8 “Diving the Clotilda - Jay Haigler and Kamau Sadiki.” 9 Cottman, Spirit Dive, 168. 10 Toni Morrison, Beloved, First Vintage International Edition 2004, [Nachdr.] (Vintage, 2010). 11 Cottman, Spirit Dive, 136. 12 Michelle M. Wright, Physics of Blackness: Beyond the Middle Passage Epistemology (University of Minnesota Press, 2015). 13 Glissant, Poetics of Relation. 14 Flewellen, “An Aural Ethnography of Black Breath,” 111–12. 15 Ayana Omilade Flewellen, “The Biophysical Afterlife of Slavery Signaled through Coral Architectural Stones at Heritage Sites on St. Croix,” American Antiquity, 89, no. 4 (2024): 591–607. 16 Simone Leigh & Rashida Bumbray, Loophole of Retreat (Pacific Books, 2025).
IN conversation with
Elizabeth K. Meyer Elizabeth K. Meyer is the faculty director at the Morven Sustainability Lab and the Merrill D. Peterson Professor in Landscape Architecture at the University of Virginia (UVA). Since the late 1980s, Meyer has authored a substantial body of literature that challenges conventional design practice by questioning the separation of aesthetics and sustainability; race theory and urban topography; public space, living systems, and nonhuman species; and cultural landscape interpretation and innovative design. Following more than 40 years of teaching, Meyer started her current position at Morven, a place-based, pan-university teaching and research endeavor located on 2,900 acres of rural Piedmont land, 10 miles from the UVA grounds. She sat down with Leah Kahler, research assistant professor at Tulane University, to talk about her work at Morven.
+ First off, congratulations to you and your team on publishing the Morven Strategic Action Plan this summer (2025) - a milestone to be celebrated! Can you tell us about how you first encountered Morven and your role as the inaugural faculty director of the Morven Sustainability Lab?
The first encounter was so remote – both in time and in detail. Back in 1997, John Kluge, who owned Morven, began a conversation with UVA president John Casteen about donating Morven to the University. Our dean, Bill McDonough, said “Beth, John and I need your help. He needs a white paper about this potential gift.” Two of us— Hank Shugart, a forest ecologist, and I—were asked to propose ideas for a large rural historic landscape gift. I didn’t even get to see the land. I knew its size, its location, and its character, as communicated to me by the president’s staff. I wrote about it as having the potential to become something between the American Academy, Dumbarton Oaks, and Yaddo, arguing that this could be an amazing teaching and learning space for a pan-university landscape laboratory. Then I heard crickets for four years until the gift was announced. There were some fits and starts in between then and now, but what frustrated me was that these plans always resulted in more buildings, and nobody was discussing the fundamental issue. I was a broken record: “What about the land? The land is the thing.” Then, in November 2022, I was hired as the faculty director. At that point, the University had decided Morven was to be a sustainability lab. During the interview for the position, I argued that right now, sustainability isn’t very interesting or innovative. There are so many other universities with sustainability labs. In an era of climate crisis, I suggested sustaining something isn’t what we need to be doing. The events of the summer of 2017 in Charlottesville (the White supremacist rally) and the events of the summer of 2020 across the United States that catalyzed broader calls for racial reckoning gave me a new way of reading Morven. I came to understand it as a racialized topography. Earlier in the ’90s, I didn’t know that the deed and the survey undertaken in 1790 by Thomas Jefferson for his friend William Short described the property as Indian Camp. I realized that this racial reckoning was not only about the legacy of slavery in the Virginia Piedmont, but also about the significance of Morven’s beauty, fecundity, and value being shaped by the Monacans and their ancestors over thousands of years. I told the search committee that if we could imagine sustainability in this expanded way that recognizes the climate crisis, we could think more critically about resilience and adaptation, about the past as well as the future. If the deep socio-ecological history can actually be part of the mission and not something else, I’d take the job. That broader scope set up a longer strategic planning process that took two years. But I think it has also made the project more significant and more innovative in the long run and, frankly, more collaborative. The faculty is recognizing that we’re not the experts. There are a lot of other people who have knowledge and expertise outside of the academy related to that site. We want to co-curate Morven’s future, not lead it.
In conversation with Elizabeth K. Meyer 34
+ You have described the vision for sustainability at Morven as needing to “recognize land management contributions, question the needs of the present, and assure the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.” How does this parsing of sustainability differ from other sustainability initiatives and why is place-based transdisciplinary thinking so essential to Morven’s success?
The definition of sustainability used by the UVA Future of Morven task force was extremely limited. It conflated sustainability with the biophysical environment. Instead, my definition draws from the 1980s definition coming out of the UN’s Commission on the Environment, authored by Gro Harlem Brundtland, Prime Minister of Norway at the time. This definition is about meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Sustainability is a threelegged stool at the intersection of social equity, environmental health, and economic prosperity. I think it’s important, particularly for younger practitioners now, to realize that sustainability has always been a weak form of environmentalism. It’s not radical. It was actually a compromise between 1970s environmentalists and developers - between the idea of land as a resource and land as a source. The task force only talked about environmental sustainability, so I suggested that we draw from the full definition instead. That led me to pose the rhetorical question that anchors the strategic plan, in which I inserted my own background and interest in reading sites as a designer, reading land as an archive, using cultural landscapes as an approach into the kind of core of what we were doing at Morven. I wrote, “What about a sustainability ethic that acknowledges the contributions of the past to Morven’s beauty, fecundity, and value?” By the contributions of “the past,” we mean those who were caring for the land in the past, and by “the current,” we mean the beauty of the site, which is an outgrowth of that care. The actual economic value of the land is an outgrowth of that. But the fecundity, meaning its fertility (or infertility in this case because the site is degraded) was connected to past environmental changes - changes in land management, in types of labor, in climate conditions. We are asking questions about who was bringing knowledge, love, and labor. Where does evidence of that knowledge, love, and labor still exist in the landscape? How is it evident - in traces, fragments, artifacts, plant assemblages, road networks, place names? How does a thick description of Morven’s cultural landscape suggest future trajectories for land care and management? The last part of the ’80s three-part sustainability question requires us to determine what is actually necessary today to ensure the ability of future multi-species communities to flourish. We recognize that the land is not here simply to support human thriving, but that there are other forms of life that are dependent on and impacted by our actions they are co-curating the landscape whether we recognize it or not.
+ The strategic plan uses history as a scaffold, which allows you to articulate, contextualize, and site the future land uses. How is this approach distinct from a typical cultural landscape report?
This is the most exciting thing for me over the next two and a half years. The Morven landscape framework plan will include a whole range of things that use the site’s history, its stories, as a scaffold. The most important thing I can do before I step down is get us to that place. I want to make sure that the faculty and staff realize that streams like Lee Jones Creek or Indian Camp Branch are not just places for testing water quality or studying the impact of changing land use on erosion, but that they also have a commemorative and interpretive function. I have persuaded the University not to undertake a cultural landscape inventory or a cultural landscape report in the standard National Park Service format. We need a document that is nimbler, values the land’s history as a continuum without a “period of significance,” can be interpreted by a pan-university multidisciplinary audience, and is future-oriented. I’ve been inspired by the writing on landscape biographies that has come out of England and the Netherlands. I shared these ideas with colleagues, Rachel Lloyd, Louis Nelson, Andrea Roberts, and Thaïsa Way, during conversations and walks on site. They have helped me to think about an alternative scope with more than one consultant. We hope to build a team that includes a historian and archaeologist with deep local knowledge, a cultural landscape architect, student interns, and the Morven staff so that we can build an archive (physical and digital), inventory and identify sites of memory and significance, and then commission a
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 35
series of micro-histories on actors in the landscape - such as Indian Camp Branch, the Ancient Road, the Colonial Road, Lee Jones Creek, the Pine stands, the bridle paths, the metabasalt outcrop pillar field (seriously, we have one!). I’m happy to have buy-in for thinking through this process more creatively, so that everyone involved is focused on a future spatial imagination, not only the significance of interpreting the past.
+ What are some of the stories you’ve already uncovered?
There are several transects that have emerged, even without much research, that will be helpful ways into the landscape biography. Indian Camp Branch and the “Ancient Road” are shown on the 1790s survey, and we can tell they are tied to certain geological formations. The stream connects to Buck Island Creek and to the Rivanna River. This is important because the capital of the Monacan Nation, Rassawak, was located where the Rivanna intersects with the James River. We quickly realized that we want to inscribe the roads through minimal edits to the site and possible interpretation to encourage meditative and reflective walks. We want to take care that they are not subsumed by or erased by somebody’s unknowing siting of a future test plot or land lab. A later document, a beautiful 1947 pencil survey on trace paper of Morven’s fields, lays out (among other things) a creek that is called Lee Jones Creek. Lee Jones was an enslaved person who became a minister and community leader. He is an ancestor of Lenora McQueen, who you might know because she is advocating for the preservation of the Shockoe Hill African Burial Ground in Richmond. The creek once formed the property line between Morven and the adjacent plantation, Highland. According to a recent Highland Descendants Community oral history, the White owners of either Highland or Morven renamed Dick’s Creek as Lee Jones Creek in honor of Lee Jones, who hid the plantation horses so well that they were not stolen by the Union Army in Charlottesville in 1865. Jones took them to a place that he knew no one would see, which was probably a “hush harbor” or a social gathering space in the wooded stream bottoms between these two plantations. After Emancipation, Lee Jones bought somewhere between 30 and 40 acres along the creek. In this way, from a bit of preliminary research, including hearing the stories of community members, we know that there are two stream valleys and two roads, four transects that are important sites of memory—full spaces, to use Henri Lefebvre’s term—to be interpreted and protected in our landscape framework plan. They are not simply open spaces for ecological reimagination. We don’t have descendants of the Morven enslaved community identified yet, but we hope to collaborate with the UVA and Highland Descendants of the Enslaved Communities (DECs) to find a structure that supports and enriches these two established groups. There are so many other stories of the site. We recognize that the Monacan foodscape extends beyond the fields that were cleared by controlled burns for centuries. It extends into the woodlands full of pawpaw and walnuts. We now realize that a Colonial Revival formal garden designed by Annette Hoyt Flanders in the 1930s was built atop a previous garden. Thinking about these earlier versions of the garden raises questions about the future. There is a way of understanding the Morven formal garden as more complicated than an iconic 1930s garden built on a tabula rasa. It has a deeper history. The garden is full of memories in need of storytelling through design adaptations.
+ How do these stories change how and by whom the site is accessed?
In addition to collecting stories and interpreting sites of memory, the Morven Sustainability Lab is keen on discussing contemporary access and uses of Morven lands that the DECs and the Monacan Nation might desire. Some private landowners in New England and the Mid-Atlantic are exploring cultural use easements with Indigenous tribal leaders as they are sovereign nations. Over the next five years, we will research how cultural use easements work and what one might mean for
In conversation with Elizabeth K. Meyer 36
Morven. What land-care practices might be of interest (hunting, foraging, cultivating, socializing), in which areas of Morven, and during what seasons? This kind of access should be part of our landscape framework. These rights to use, care, and interpretation should be recorded in a legal document. Spatial equity is not a favor. To me, exploring how to be in relationship is an important aspect of our mission and goals, co-curation and community connection.
+ I’m curious about the scholarship on landscape biography you mentioned earlier - can you say a bit more about that body of work?
Yes, that was something I brought into the design research methods seminar I taught with Erin Putalik a few years back. We set up a frame in which we learned about the cultural landscape practice and laid out some of its problems before providing other lenses. We dealt with the land as archive and different methods for reading site, reading texts such as Lauret Savoy’s Trace: Memory, History, Race and the American Landscape, Tiya Alicia Miles’s All that She Carried, and Annie Ernaux, whose memoir, The Years, ends with an amazing conception of time as palimpsest. That course also tapped into the landscape biography literature from the 1970s by Marwyn S. Samuels (in D. W. Meinig’s The Interpretation of Ordinary Landscapes) that was refined in the last 20 years in the Netherlands by archaeologist Jan Kolen, urbanist Bruno Notteboom, and historical geographer Johannes Renes. We paired these writings with design-oriented site readings with a future-change perspective. The writing recognizes that there may be characters or actors within the landscape that have their own biography, and that the aim shouldn’t necessarily be a chronological history of layers of settlement by different owners. Instead, there could be biographies written about the evolution of a stream, or a pasture, or a fence enclosure, or a specific plant or plant habitat. It has been liberating to think about alternative ways of storytelling and to try to connect these biographies to experiences like walks and encounters, as well as to different narrative forms such as field guides, cultural landscape atlases, and micro-histories. The class was freeing and exhilarating. It also opened up new ways of thinking about my role as a landscape architect leading a pan-university sustainability lab. Site memories could be spatialized with narratives attached to spatial practices, such as walking, birding, resting, meditating, and species-inventorying. They could live beyond the cultural landscape report, sitting on a bookshelf.
+ I‘m curious about how the size of Morven will influence your team’s work. How must the cultural landscape approach adapt when applied to 2,900 acres?
That’s a great question. Given the history of pine timbering and the establishment of a new 1,000-acre experimental forest, it allows us to think at the scale of a forest’s history. You start to ask questions like: Why is there so much pine forest on one side of Route 795 and not on the other? That requires an analysis of geology and soil formations because Route 795 and Route 22 are the dividing lines between fertile soil above the Catoctin formation and the not-too-fertile shale soil above the Loudon formation across the road. A considerable amount of land on this shaley soil is planted in loblolly pine and timbered. But it is also the land that was made available to emancipated people in the late 19th century because it was not the most fertile. These mountains, their presidential plantations, equestrian estates, and small rural land holders, are as much a racialized topography as a plantation (think Dell Upton’s “White and Black Landscapes in Eighteenth-Century Virginia,” 1984). We have to be thinking about our large landscape management practices through the lens of landscape biographers as well as biodiversity inventories, carbon sequestration, and planting schema.
+ I appreciate the way that you’ve discussed being on site with a network of constituents, researchers, and costewards. What’s been the relationship between fieldwork and the archive in your initial forays into this place?
In the seminar I’m teaching now, we are undertaking documentation and fieldwork while learning how to work across, and through, an archive that is both land and paper. Students are focusing on one of five sites or transects: the Indian Camp Creek, the Ancient Road, the Colonial Road, the agricultural tenant fields, and the house (its approach and gardens). We schedule time together and alone on site to walk, to
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 37
experience, to develop a documentation practice. Once students have experienced the site and recorded it long enough to develop a thesis or a question, they are introduced to maps, drawings, photographs, and farm journals, as well as secondary source materials on local architectural, environmental, and social history. I am interested in how the archive, historical aerial photographs, and site descriptions inform our test plots within the experimental forests. One experiment I’m excited to see unfold is located in the central part of the pine forest that is being timbered. After planting with a traditional forestry planting of pines, we will do an early thinning to open up sun patches and then manage it with regular prescribed burns. In speaking with other field stations and environmental nonprofits, we have learned that if you are keen on establishing a Piedmont savannah, one of our rarest ecosystems, you should not start with the grasslands. You should start planting as if it’s a pine plantation again. It will be fascinating to see what emerges because there may be dormant seeds in the soils that will emerge after burning. But the site has been seriously disturbed by decades of industrial timbering, so I am curious about what is going to come back. We will use these test plots as a way of beginning to discern the impact of prior human and more-than-human changes in the land. Instead of comparing what the scientists think is going to happen versus what does happen, we are interested in making sure that these plots have scholars, students, and faculty from different disciplines monitoring them so that diverse insights and observations will emerge. Similarly, we suspect there are different seed banks in each and that the seed banks will also tell us more about the land changes. Some of the lessons about the land as an archive will come from observing and documenting how the landscape changes relative to what everyone thought was going to happen. The 100 years of red leather-bound Morven Farm Books are an inspiration for us. What should our 21st-century data collection format be?
+ Last, can you talk about how this place-based attention to site engenders alternative forms of responsibility to the land?
I am working to bring together a think tank, a brain trust, a kitchen cabinet that is involved in evaluating priorities and determining what projects make sense. I’m interested in having community members from both inside and outside the University on an advisory group focused on the cultural landscape that convenes often enough that they’re aware of what’s happening and can raise red flags or say, “Yes, let’s figure out a way to support this but also bring some other voices in.” That will be a creative task for me over the next couple of months. What advising structure is empowering and not burdensome? How can we compensate community members who participate, and not just ask for their free advice? The other part about responsibility is to recognize that it’s okay to start with small things, to make mistakes. That’s a little counter to the scale we have to work at with the forest, but for the rest of the site, I think it’s not a bad idea. We also want to be humble enough and collaborative enough to acknowledge that some of the most innovative ideas for altering the site’s future are going to come from local ecological knowledge and traditional ecological knowledge, and not only from some new technology or new form of systems thinking or digital world-making. We have a responsibility to ask who is at the table, what tools we are using, and how we are looking to the past and the present as we’re thinking about the future.
AGENTS OF MEMORY EMILY BUNKER + SELINA CHEAH
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 39
Emily Bunker works as a landscape architect with a decade of experience in fabrication and community design education. She holds a master of landscape architecture from the University of Pennsylvania and currently works for OLIN. Her strong interest in land art and material research led her to work as an artistin-residence at several programs, including the Frank Lloyd Wright School of Architecture at Taliesin West and the Raymond Farm Center for the Living Arts and Design. Selina Cheah is a designer, planner, and researcher with OLIN and OLIN Labs. She holds a joint master of landscape architecture and master of city planning from the University of Pennsylvania with a background in journalism. Her interests and past research work center around the intersection of climate resiliency, locality, and narrative storytelling.
ecology, public policy
O
n Sunday, March 10, 2024, a small group convened in Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR) Park in South Philadelphia to pay homage to a band of majestic maples at the field’s edge. This line of city-designated heritage trees served as a symbol for many more slated for removal to make way for a large restoration project that had been the source of intense debate. Shelley DePaul, a tribe member of the Lenape Nation of Pennsylvania, led the group through prayer, song, and ceremony, draping the megaflora with sachets of tobacco and encircling them with sage smoke in preparation for their felling. She shared a Lenape story of the maple tree and its relationship to the more-than-human world. The event was designed to hold space for collective mourning and to celebrate the trees and the memories that they held for those gathered. This moment at FDR Park, quiet yet ceremonial, situated the trees not merely as ecological infrastructure, but also as beings embedded in memory and relationship. It highlighted a fundamental tension in how we value trees today: between formal systems of measurement that prioritize quantifiable benefits, like carbon capture or canopy cover, and the lived, cultural, and historical meanings that trees carry for communities. Earlier traditions, on the other hand, primarily valued what historian Jared Farmer calls “relational age” – a tree’s significance through its ties to community and social cycles.
Contemporary urban forestry and environmental policy center around quantitative valuation, which increasingly leans on ecosystem services as the dominant framework. Ecosystem services are defined as contributions derived from ecosystems for human benefit, and they generally fall into four categories: provisioning, regulating, supporting, and providing cultural services.1 Ecosystem-services frameworks are designed to capture the diverse benefits trees provide – some quantifiable in monetary terms (like reduced energy costs), others in non-monetary terms (like ecological importance or religious significance). Lara Roman, a research ecologist with the US Forest Service, states that there has always been “an attitude of win–win–win” when it comes to planting trees.2 While in the 20th century the value of urban tree canopy was primarily derived from increased property prices, in the 21st century, the value framework has shifted to include compensatory value based on carbon storage, carbon removal, air pollution removal, and the reduction of energy costs.3 These ecosystem services demonstrate trees’ importance for urban climate adaptation. Yet, because they are framed through measurable outputs, often translated into monetary value, they narrowly define trees as ecosystem providers for human benefit and primarily within their individual lifespans. While ecosystem services dominate the technical and policy discourse today, trees are not absent from cultural frameworks of value. Although cultural services are
AGENTS OF MEMORY 40
included within the ecosystem-services framework, they are far less easily quantified than regulatory or provisioning functions. Recreation, heritage, or spiritual meaning are acknowledged but are often simplified into metrics like visitor counts or survey responses.4 Yet people experience trees in ways that resist such measures, whether through beauty, shade, memory, or solace: forms of value that cannot be fully captured by a measurable lens. In many cases, communities and individuals alike treat trees as vessels of memory by projecting stories, emotions, and historical associations onto them. Within these practices, trees become blank, though vaguely benevolent, surfaces onto which remembrance is grafted. In the field of memory studies, memories are “explorations of individual forms of remembrance, as well as the collective, heterogeneous ways of marking, interpreting, and erasing the past.”5 In this definition, memory is archival and rooted in halting certain moments as they occur, often filtering out details in the service of a subjective, cohesive narrative. Similarly, cultural approaches, such as commemorative plantings or memorial groves, frame trees as markers of past events. In these contexts, the body of the tree functions as a medium for recognition, commemoration, and remembrance. In parallel, trees hold intrinsic memory. Studies show that socialecological memory, the stored experiences and information of living beings with one another and within themselves, exists in trees, as does ecological memory, the capacity for trees to hold onto, communicate, and transmit experiences to future generations.6 The few ways in which the policies and cultural narratives that govern trees—whether through heritage designation or symbolic attachment—acknowledge or consider memory neglect to envision and protect trees’ dynamic future. A holistic sense of memory and all of its accumulation within a tree—spatial, temporal, relational, ecological—does not factor into decision-making about the built environment. This essay considers the value of memory in trees through current protection practices in the built environment, the cultural practices that link them to memory in the United States, and the developing body of knowledge related to functional ecological memory. How can we move beyond the dominant narratives of memory in, of, and about trees as rooted in the past and toward a value system inclusive of a future-oriented memory? The Codification of Memory One of the few ways memory is codified in planning and design policy today is through the designation of heritage trees. By and large, the evaluation criteria of heritage trees across various US cities and municipalities are the same: size, age, ecological significance, and/or historical significance. While trees in the built environment carry cultural implications—since planting, maintaining, and interpreting them are human actions—the heritage designation formalizes trees into cultural objects. Through municipal ordinances, protected statuses, and public
registries, trees are elevated from being regarded primarily as natural objects to being explicitly recognized as cultural entities. To justify this protection, cities, municipalities, and communities must articulate trees’ broader significance, which can draw on connections to local history, memory, and identity. Oregon was the first state to adopt a heritage tree program in 1995 under the auspices of the Travel Information Council, a state agency that manages programs related to travel and tourism. The designation, based on the National Registry of Historic Places, required that trees meet several of the following criteria: hold significance within a community or location, be associated with important historical events or people, or be of notable size, longevity, or species. An 800-year-old giant Sitka spruce at Kloochy Creek was the first designated heritage tree in Oregon’s Heritage Tree Program.7 Today, trees with heritage status are largely designated by city councils and protected by local ordinances, though some states maintain registries and programs dedicated to the cause. While heritage tree designations vary by city or municipality—in Philadelphia, for example, trees need only achieve a certain diameter at breast height (DBH) to be listed on the Department of Parks and Recreation’s heritage tree list—most programs include historical significance as a core factor.8 The National Recreation and Park Association describes ancient or heritage trees as “symboliz[ing] wisdom, longevity and a connection to the past, emphasizing the importance of preserving history amid urban development.”9 In Nebraska, heritage trees are considered to have served as living witnesses. To be granted heritage status, trees must be “figurative in legend, lore, or common perception”; stand at the home of significant individuals who played a role in Nebraska’s history; stand at or near significant events; or be illustrated in sketches, journals, photographs, or writings related to historical events.10 A master’s thesis on heritage tree criteria found that across 90 case studies, 76.1% of heritage tree programs deemed historical value as an important criterion for heritage designation, followed by historic person/memorial planting at 45.7%.11 These findings, alongside heritage tree terminology and other terms used in the naming of similar trees (champion, monumental, significant, veteran, witness, ancient), reveal the cultural value placed on trees as historical assets worth preserving for the representation or interpretation of placebased memory. However, other relational forms of memory remain less recognized. Beyond Commemorative Thinking Heritage tree designations reveal how memory is most often formalized through historical significance, casting trees as witnesses to events or symbols of the past while narrowing their meaning to commemorative roles. This treatment of trees echoes the logic of monuments, which are products of the cultural and political values of the generations that build
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 41
them. Monuments are often created decades or centuries after the events they commemorate to serve contemporary political purposes, rather than purely commemorative ones, and to use the past to legitimize present power structures. This is perhaps seen most clearly in the act of nation-building, ceremonies of possession, and the commemoration of certain individuals, events, and stories. Like monuments, trees “serve as places of collected memory, where diverse memories converge and are made tangible.”12 They are framed as embodied vessels of history, whether they have lived through events (witness trees) or were planted to represent events, persons, or collective memory. Famous recent examples include the Callery pear tree at the 9/11 site and the American Elm Survivor Tree at the site of the Oklahoma City bombing, while historic markers include the Penn Treaty Elm and its modern-day scions. While such trees may indeed be connected to meaningful events, their cultural value is frequently rooted in the act of symbolic preservation, rather than in the trees’ ongoing relationship to land, time, or change. This practice mirrors the limitations of traditional memorials by fixing meaning in the past. For example, while the Callery pear at the 9/11 site transformed from a common species into a sacred symbol of resilience and recovery, the tree’s significance is entirely derived from its proximity to tragedy. While the Callery pear may hold other cultural values—such as aesthetic appeal or negative associations as an invasive species—it has been reduced almost entirely to its commemorative role as a memorial. In this sense, the cultural memory attached to the Callery pear isolates one dimension of meaning—its role as witness—while overshadowing the ecological characteristics inherent to the species. This species has revealed its capacity for outcompeting native plants, altering habitats, and decreasing biodiversity since its introduction to the US at the Arnold Arboretum in Boston in 1908.13 Though our values around and knowledge of this species have shifted, the cultural importance of this specific tree at the 9/11 site continues to trump its ecological ramifications. Over the last decade, traditional practices of monumentbuilding have come into question. In 2020, 168 Confederate symbols and monuments were removed nationwide, revealing a cultural reckoning with both ideas and acts of commemoration.14 As non-profit organization Monument Lab notes, the contemporary discourse around monuments today favors healing, learning, and belonging.15 Commemorative practices around trees share origins with monuments and the history of monument making, but unlike monuments, they have not undergone the same cultural reckoning in how we imagine their future. Environmental historian Jared Farmer traces a generational change in tree culture, wherein he describes a “prior age of sentimentality” that was rooted in the “designation of ‘historic trees’ that had witnessed moments of national significance.”16 Often, this took the form of a kind of “arbonationalism,” in which trees
1 2005 Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, “Ecosystems and Human Well-being: A Framework for Assessment,” https://www. millenniumassessment.org/documents/ document.300.aspx.pdf (accessed August 20, 2025). 2 Lara Roman, interview by the authors, Philadelphia, July 9, 2024. 3 The USFS routinely publishes reports specifically designed to be used by local organizations for the advancement of urban forest policies, planning, and management. 4 Xin Cheng, et al., “Evaluation of Cultural Ecosystem Services: A Review of Methods,” Ecosystem Services 37 (2019): 100925. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoser.2019.100925. 5 Ben Bridges & Sarah Osterhoudt, “Landscapes and Memory,” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Anthropology (April 26, 2021), https://oxfordre. com/anthropology/view/10.1093/ acrefore/9780190854584.001.0001/acrefore9780190854584-e-304. 6 J. T. Ibarra, et al. “While Clearing the Forests: The Social–Ecological Memory of Trees in the Anthropocene,” Ambio 53 (2024): 1783–96, https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-024-02008-5. 7 Oregon Travel Information Council, “Sitka Spruce at Klootchy Creek,” https://oregontic. com/oregon-heritage-trees/sitka-spruce-atklootchy-creek/ (accessed June 23, 2025). 8 City of Philadelphia “The Philadelphia Code,” § 1–105(145), Heritage Tree, https:// codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/philadelphia/ latest/philadelphia_pa/0-0-0-288063 (accessed September 19, 2025). 9 Jernel Stevenson, “The Historical and Cultural Significance of Trees,” National Recreation and Park Association, https:// www.nrpa.org/parks-recreationmagazine/2024/may/the-historical-andcultural-significance-of-tree/ (accessed June 16, 2025). 10 Nebraska Forest Service, “About Champion and Heritage Trees,” https://nfs. unl.edu/about-champion-and-heritagetrees/ (accessed June 23, 2025). 11 Myles Ritchie, “Establishing Consensus Core Criteria for the Protection of Heritage Trees,” (Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Division of the University of Hawai’i at Mānoa, 2019), https://scholarspace. manoa.hawaii.edu/server/api/core/ bitstreams/34fe475f-8aa1-4118-8cb00064f97aa18a/content. 12 David Glassberg, “Afterword: Branching Out Further,” in Leah S. Glaser & Philip Levy (eds), Branching Out: The Public History of Trees (University of Massachusetts Press, 2025), 262. 13 Theresa M. Culley, “The Rise and Fall of the Ornamental Callery Pear Tree,” Arnold Arboretum, https://arboretum.harvard.edu/ arnoldia-stories/the-rise-and-fall-of-theornamental-callery-pear-tree/ (accessed September 22, 2025). 14 Southern Poverty Law Center, “2020 Confederate Symbol Removals,” https:// www.splcenter.org/2020-confederatesymbol-removals/ (accessed June 16, 2025).
AGENTS OF MEMORY 42
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 43
AGENTS OF MEMORY 44
became sites of contested memories and blank canvases for controversial histories, naturalizing acts of violence and war.17 While the contemporary monument debate has exposed the political nature of commemoration and an accompanying shift in cultural values, legislation protecting trees of cultural importance remains largely insulated from these critical conversations and remains solely fixed on specific histories that live on by association. Evaluating trees as “boundary stones of another age” exposes the inadequacy of fixed moments in the past as a cultural value.18 It also removes any trace of the hand or authorship of those who have created and assigned the history, while also downplaying any relational, functional, or ecological memory that trees may possess. What might a future-oriented heritage designation look like? Memory as a Practice of Care Reimagining heritage through a future-oriented lens requires moving beyond the symbolic function of trees as static memorials and considering their ecological memory. While cultural memory often imposes meaning onto trees from the outside—naming, framing, commemorating—ecological memory reveals how trees internally archive the conditions of their environments across time. This shift re-centers trees as agents of memory, not merely symbols of it. Jennifer Gabrys argues that forests—and, by extension, individual trees—embody a form of analog computation, whereby trees perform as computers by “processing environmental inputs, transforming them into outputs, bioindicating results, bending and remixing the inheritances of space–time, and enabling or reworking environments and environmental inhabitations.”19 From this perspective, trees are not just monuments to the past, but also living record-keepers, storing climatic and environmental data that inform our understanding of adaptation and resilience in the age of a changing climate. This view complicates the ecosystem-services framework. Rather than valuing trees solely for their benefits to humans, ecological memory foregrounds trees’ roles as active participants in environmental processes that ensure adaptation, resilience, and survival. As dependable climatic record-keepers, trees have historically served as the foundation for carbon dating. Dendrochronology, the science behind the dating of memory in trees, relies on the characteristic patterns of annual growth rings in tree trunks to date events, environmental change, and archaeological artifacts. These datasets offer scientists a baseline of comparison for understanding everything from the provenance of cultural objects to extreme events or weather patterns from other periods in history. Trees are carefully cored from bark to center, from which cylinders of woody matter are extracted, measured, and cataloged. Through various methods of observing the layers of trees, scientists can trace the adaptation of trees to abiotic and biotic stressors like wounding, disease, and climatic shifts.20
Beyond physical record-keeping, however, trees possess memory through physiological responses and epigenetic mechanisms. Scientists are learning that memories of recurring stress can be passed between generations of trees. Understanding Memory of UK Treescapes for Better Resilience and Adaptation (MEMBRA) is an ongoing study that examines the transmission of tree memories at the molecular level across 8,000 trees in several study plots. MEMBRA’s ongoing research studies tree resilience across generations in the context of climate change and evaluates how stress memory can provide new conceptual frameworks through which we might reconsider environmental ethics and the question of tree consciousness.21 A process called DNA methylation allows trees to adapt to recurrent abiotic stressors (e.g., heat, drought, and elevated CO2) by changing how genes are expressed. Memories are then transferred from tree to progeny by way of epigenetic markers, an offering of maternal inheritance in the name of resilience and survival. Memory here is not conscious but functional, guiding development, resilience, and adaptation. But just as important is the ability of trees to forget. Estrella LunaDiez, plant pathologist and principal investigator of MEMBRA, explains that severe trauma can cause trees to reallocate their resources and essentially stop growing to defend themselves against stressors.22 It is in the best interest of trees to move on and to reproduce, as stressful memories can be costly to trees’ survival. Memory transfer is strategic; forgetting is survival. The balance between memory and forgetting is dynamic; however, the underlying thrust of the argument is that allowing trees to remember stress is essential. Meanwhile, the current policies around conservation, preservation, and maintenance— especially in urban and managed landscapes—are often antithetical to the logic of epigenetic memory. Across cities, parks, and forests, maintenance protocols often dictate that damaged or stressed trees be removed. Removal is justified for a few main reasons: public safety (risk of falling limbs, instability), aesthetic expectations (canopy fullness, visual structure), and a perceived loss of ecological function (a tree that is no longer healthy is assumed to have lost its ecological value). In the design and landscape architecture fields, this rationale is often extended to include the felling of existing, mature trees in favor of newly planted saplings that align with a desire for a uniform aesthetic or a client’s vision. This logic of treating trees as discrete, static entities fixed in their current time discounts the value of ecological memory, which may be a critical strategy for survival in an era of rapidly changing climates. Recognizing and valuing biological and ecological memory challenges how we currently frame conservation and preservation. It invites a future-facing ethic and practice of care. Toward Memories of the Future How do we look to the future if our frameworks remain fixed in the past? Pierre Nora argues that “memory is a perpetually
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 45
actual phenomenon, a bond tying us to the eternal present.”23 If memory is to serve this role, it must extend beyond commemoration of the past and present and toward an orientation that also encompasses what is to come. Memory acts as a bond that brings trees into the realm of long time.24
15 Monument Lab, “About,” https:// monumentlab.com/about (accessed June 23, 2025).
Jared Farmer points to the prescientific-era concept of relational age—the relationship between trees and their built environment, people, cultural traditions—as a way to embody cyclical time and value trees’ role in memory and kinship. This mode of valuing emphasizes trees as cultural objects intertwined with human and ecological rhythms. In a similar vein, a fundamental shift in the lens of legal and conservation language is needed to align with the timescales and memory strategies essential to the survival of the future forest. Earlier ways of valuing trees, through kinship, cycles, and relational memory, need not be displaced by scientific measurement. Instead, they can expand our frameworks to hold all means of value – cultural, quantitative, and ecological.
18 Pierre Nora, “Between Memory and History: Les Lieux de Mémoire,” Representations 26 (1989): 12.
In an interview about the heritage trees at FDR Park, Shelley DePaul said, “Lenape people do not view the world as geographic units of individual human beings. … We consider these trees our elders.”25 Conservation and preservation are inherently political. Deciding which trees to preserve, designate, or plant shapes which futures come into being. The integration of concepts like ecological and epigenetic memory, maternal and relational inheritance, and resilience through forgetting allows us to move beyond seeing trees as static sites of commemoration and into seeing them as active participants in forming our collective futures.
16 Jared Farmer, “Taking Liberties with Historic Trees,” Journal of American History 105, no. 4 (2019): 815, 818. 17 Ibid., 816.
19 Jennifer Gabrys, “Forests that Compute,” in Jane Prophet & Helen V. Pritchard (eds), Plants by Numbers: Art, Computation, and Queer Feminist Technoscience (Bloomsbury Press, 2023). 20 Alex L. Shigo, Tree Basics (Shigo and Trees Associates, 2003). 21 Future of UK Treescapes, “UK Treescapes MEMBRA,” https://www.uktreescapes.org/ projects/membra/ (accessed June 16, 2025). 22 Estrella Luna-Diez, interview by the authors, April 2025. 23 Nora, “Between Memory and History,” 8. 24 Jared Farmer, “Lexicon for Slow Plants on a Burning Planet: A Companion to Elderflora,” https://jaredfarmer.net/elderflora (accessed August 26, 2025). 25 Massarah Mikati, “The City Is Removing 48 Heritage Trees from FDR Park. The Lenape Nation Will Be Honoring Them with a Ceremony,” The Philadelphia Inquirer (March 8, 2024), https://www.inquirer.com/news/ philadelphia/lenape-nation-fdr-park-heritagetrees-20240308.html?query=Mikati.
Just as human societies construct monuments to preserve certain memories, trees, too, hold histories of disturbance and stress – histories that are too often erased in the name of human safety, aesthetics, or order. Unlike built monuments, however, trees embody memory dynamically: they adapt, regenerate, and even “forget” in ways that enable survival. This ecological forgetting is not a denial of history but a strategy of renewal, offering a model for resilience that does not erase the past but transforms it into the possibility of future life.
Previous Left: The Endicott Pear Tree in 1969, after an episode of vandalism. Previous Right: William C. Endicott, Jr., and the Endicott Pear Tree in 1925.
Hannah stark
Hannah Stark is an associate professor of English at the University of Tasmania. She is the author of Feminist Theory After Deleuze (Bloomsbury, 2016), the co-author of The Theory of Love: Ideals, Limits, Futures (Palgrave Macmillan, 2021), and the editor of Deleuze and the Non/Human (Palgrave Macmillan, 2015) and Extinction and Memorial Culture: Reckoning with Species Loss in the Anthropocene (Routledge, 2023).
HISTORY, CULTURAL GEOGRAPHY
I
n Hobart, the capital city of a small island state at the bottom of Australia, there is a large green parkland on the edge of the city. This park, the Queen’s Domain, is referred to colloquially as “the domain” in an act of collective, unintended, and incomplete decolonization. Here, overlooking the Derwent River behind a large wire fence, lies a ruined zoo. The Beaumaris (Hobart) Zoo was open for 14 years in the interwar period between 1923 and 1937. It was once home to polar bears from Greenland, an elephant from Burma who would provide rides to children, a pair of zebras from South Africa, and leopards, including the cub, “Mike,” who was walked on a lead by the zookeeper’s eccentric daughter.1 It was also the place where the last known thylacine (Tasmanian tiger) was kept in captivity. Thylacines, the largest marsupial carnivores, once roamed throughout mainland Australia and New Guinea. For their final 2,000 years, their existence was believed to be confined to Lutruwita/ Tasmania.2 As part of the collateral of European colonial expansion, thylacines became extinct in Tasmania just 133 years after European invasion. Settler colonial pastoralists falsely believed thylacines to be a predator of sheep, and the government bounty placed on their head from 1888–1909, which paid one pound per adult and ten pence per young, ensured they were targeted for extermination.3 In 1936, the last thylacine died in its enclosure at the zoo. An economic work program in a depressed economy meant that people with no expertise in animal care were deployed as zoo workers, and on the freezing night of September 7th, the thylacine was shut out of its sleeping enclosure and likely died of exposure. The last known thylacine took its last breath just two months after the species became protected in Tasmania. The date of its death is now memorialized as National Threatened Species Day in Australia, and the thylacine has become an international symbol of extinction. The last captive thylacine from the 1930s would now be a fading memory in the minds of few living people. For most Tasmanians, the thylacine has always been an absent presence, known through stories, accounts, histories, museums, and collective memory. The Beaumaris Zoo’s significance as a commemorative site for extinction is symbolized by a set of iron gates at the entrance of the site. Designed by the Tasmanian artist Patrick Hall and installed to mark National Threatened
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 47
Species Day in 2000, these gates are adorned with a mournful menagerie of caged animals made from metal, and the text “The Ghosts of Fur and Feathers” is superimposed across a drawing of a thylacine and historical interpretive materials. While the original zoo gates reference the visual style of the carnival side-show, framing the zoo as entertainment, Hall’s gates depict the animals as cartoonish, charismatic, and sad. Within the zoo itself, there is no marker to show where the thylacines resided or where the last known animal died. Today, the site is a sloping piece of land marred by crumbling enclosures and covered in long grasses. The past is an amalgam of things remembered and forgotten, and memorials reveal the values of a given society at a particular historical moment. In this way, the Patrick Hall memorial shapes shared cultural memory in the Tasmanian community and tells us something about shifting attitudes to extinction and to animal life. It is significant that this is one of the very few commemorative acknowledgments of extinction, given that Australia has the worst mammal extinction rate in the world. The thylacine is a spectral figure that now haunts both the symbolic landscape of Lutruwita/Tasmania and its remote landscapes. The thylacine is an excellent example of what Audra Mitchell describes as a paradoxical feature of extinction whereby the disappearance of a species can also trigger its proliferation.4 For example, thylacines have a civic life on the state coat of arms and as part of the Tasmanian government logo. They are on car license plates to designate the island state; on the University of Tasmania’s ceremonial mace, which is used at every graduation ceremony; they are the symbol of Cricket Tasmania; and they appear on a range of commercial products, such as marketing for the local Cascade Brewery. However, thylacines also continue to be present through the regular sightings reported in Lutruwita/Tasmania and on mainland Australia, reaching as far north as the Cape York Peninsula in northern Queensland.5 Thylacine hunters continue to search in the isolated areas of Lutruwita/Tasmania, a remote and rugged Wilderness World Heritage landscape described by the Tasmanian Parks and Wildlife Service as “vast, wild and spectacular.”6 The death of the last captive thylacine likely did not mark the global extinction of the species but instead should be seen as part of what Baumsteiger and Moyle call the
1 Carol Freeman, “Once Upon a Zoo,” Forty South (November 19, 2022, updated February 28, 2023), https://www.fortysouth.com.au/ history888/once-upon-a-zoo (accessed March 4, 2025). 2 Lutruwita is the name for Tasmania in palawa kani, the revived language of the Tasmanian Aboriginal community. 3 Robert Paddle, The Last Tasmanian Tiger: The History and Extinction of the Thylacine (Cambridge University Press, 2002), 166. 4 Audra Mitchell, “Beyond Biodiversity and Species: Problematizing Extinction,” Theory, Culture & Society 33, no. 5 (2016): 31. 5 For example, the Tasmanian Department of Primary Industries, Parks, Water and Environment “Thylacine Sightings Reports – 1 September 2016 to 19 September 2019,” which officially records a number of thylacine sightings. See https://nre.tas.gov.au/ Documents/RTI%20025%20-%202019-20. pdf (accessed February 25, 2025). See also Elle Hunt, “‘Sightings’ of Extinct Tasmanian Tiger Prompt Search in Queensland,” The Guardian (March 28, 2017), https://www. theguardian.com/environment/2017/mar/28/ tasmanian-tiger-sighting-search-thylacinequeensland-australia. 6 Tasmanian Parks and Wildlife Service, “Southwest National Park,” https://parks. tas.gov.au/explore-our-parks/southwestnational-park (accessed March 4, 2025). 7 Jason Baumsteiger & Peter B. Moyle, “Assessing Extinction,” BioScience 67, no. 4 (April 2017): 358. 8 See Barry Brooks, et al., “Resolving When (and Where) the Thylacine Went Extinct,” Science of the Total Environment 877 (2023): 1–9. 9 Shane McCorristine & William M. Adams, “Ghost Species: Spectral Geographies of Biodiversity Conservation,” Cultural Geographies 27, no. 1 (2019): 105, https://journals.sagepub.com/ doi/10.1177/1474474019871645. 10 Thom van Dooren, Flight Ways: Life and Loss at the Edge of Extinction (Columbia University Press, 2014), 58. 11 Jack Ashby, “How Collections and Reputation Were Built out of Tasmanian Violence: Thylacines (Thylacinus cynocephalus) and Aboriginal Remains from Morton Allport (1830–1878),” Archives of Natural History 50, no.2 (2023): 250.
EXTINCTIONSCAPES 48
“gray extinction” zone – the uncertain space between being classified as endangered and becoming globally extinct.7 To date, however, no sighting of the elusive creature has been substantiated and recent research mapping credible thylacine sightings from 1910 onward places the likely global extinction of thylacines in the wild from the late 1980s to the early 2000s.8 “Disappearance,” as McCorristine and Adams write, “is a nonlinear and paradoxical process in that it leaves traces, signs, and clues, and can provoke recurring reappearances.”9 The appearance and disappearance of thylacines, in a range of settings, indicates a troubled legacy. In Australia, this might suggest the existence of environmental guilt, given the country’s high rate of extinction. Negative affect—shame, guilt, remorse—accrues around the story of the thylacine and does so because this extinction is understood to be anthropogenic in nature. The extinguishment of the thylacine occurred not through a single event but through many acts over many years, constituting what Thom van Dooren would call the “dull edge” of extinction.10 The spectral presence of thylacines is part of a broader haunting of the Tasmanian landscape in a context in which Aboriginal Tasmanians were massacred, displaced from their ancestral lands, and continue to experience intergenerational disadvantage because of colonization. Jack Ashby writes about the entwined history of extinction of the thylacine with that of Aboriginal Tasmanians, remarking that both were subject to rhetoric about extinction through the 19th and 20th centuries. The Aboriginal Tasmanian people, a vibrant living culture today, were falsely believed to have become extinct with the death of Truganini, considered at the time to be the last “full-blooded” Aborigine. Not only is there a shameful history of the use of government bounties for the extermination of thylacines as well as the use of bounties for the attempted genocide of Tasmanian Aboriginal peoples, but they also share problematic histories in relation to the collection, trade, and display of remains by museums. Ashby writes: As populations of both thylacines and Aboriginal peoples were diminished, demand for their physical remains in museums and private collections increased. Perhaps the
most symbolic of the parallels is that, in working to meet this demand, it was by the same ship, the clipper Ethel, that Allport sent both thylacine specimens and Aboriginal remains to collectors in Europe.11
Truganini’s skeleton, exhumed from her grave at the Female Factory in South Hobart and obtained by the Royal Society of Tasmania in 1878, was displayed in the Hobart Museum until 1948. Her remains were not returned to her community until almost 100 years later, in 1976. In 2021, the Tasmanian Museum and Art Gallery (TMAG) and the Tasmanian Royal Society (TRS) in Hobart formally apologized to the Tasmanian Aboriginal community in a joint ceremony.12 Thylacines have been displayed at TMAG since at least 1891, but their positioning as a cautionary tale about extinction is more recent. The narratives of the thylacine and of the Tasmanian Aboriginal people exist as problematic parallel histories of extinction and survival. It is critically important to acknowledge that Tasmanian palawa culture is a continuing culture and that the extinction of the Aboriginal Tasmanians is a historical myth. Reflecting on the Humber River in Toronto, Craig Fortier describes how “settler colonialism and settler historiography are death-making enterprises that are always in the process of constructing and enacting Indigenous peoples on these territories as dead or dying,” and this rings true in Lutruwita/ Tasmania.13 The rhetorical framing of Aboriginal Tasmanians as extinct couches genocide in the language utilized to describe natural and scientific processes. This is not to suggest that this comparison is uncomplicated; these histories are not the same and should not be treated as such. However, what is significant is that they are occurring simultaneously, and both implicate the state of Tasmania and its institutions as part of the colonial project. Ashby, who also notes this tension, helpfully describes the “interconnected nature of human, environmental and cultural genocide under colonization” and frames these histories as evidence of the extractive nature of colonialism.14 The project of decolonizing extinction in Lutruwita/Tasmania is one of acknowledging that narratives of extinction and survival are deeply rooted in the state’s history, and that these narratives remain unsettled.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 49
From the Southwest Wilderness to the ruined zoo on the edge of Hobart, the Tasmanian landscape can be read as what Bersaglio and Margulies call extinctionscapes. They describe these landscapes “as spaces where the memorialization of nonhuman life generates affective and commodifiable experiences with species loss through practices of absencepresence in physical landscapes.”15 The figuration of the extinctionscape builds on the idea of the deathscape. This term denotes a spatial understanding of aspects of death, dying, and mourning, including sites traditionally associated with death, such as the morgue or the cemetery, but also the way in which landscapes are affective. Maddrell and Sidaway write of deathscapes as “both the places associated with death and for the dead, and how these are imbued with meanings and associations: the site of a funeral, and the places of final disposition and of remembrance, and representations of all these.”16 While deathscapes are shaped by human histories and associations, Bersaglio and Margulies remind us that “nonhuman life and ecological relationships are fundamental to understanding deathscapes as places and processes; yet, the more-than-human nature of deathscapes has received little attention in geographical scholarship.”17 Shifting to the figuration of the extinctionscape is useful because it frames the landscape not just as a place inscribed with death and dying, but also with a more profound kind of finality. Extinctionscapes acknowledge the spatial and affective aspects of extinction as both a natural process and a phenomenon that has been massively accelerated by human activity. Not only is this an extinctionscape located on land of which the original custodians have been dispossessed, but the colonial project itself is also part of the extinctionscape of the thylacine. The extinctionscape is not just about how history resonates in landscapes; this expansive figuration of landscape can also be understood in relation to speculative and prospective futures. This is evident in the case of Lutruwita/Tasmania, where a regional council has set aside land for a potential thylacine re-wilding. The thylacine is now one of the celebrity species of de-extinction research, with biotech company Colossal Laboratories & Biosciences “determined to give the thylacine a second chance at life.”18 This venture capitalist company has partnered with Andrew Pask’s Thylacine Integrated Genetic
12 Tasmanian Museum and Art Gallery (TMAG), “Apology to Tasmanian Aboriginal People,” delivered by Brett Torossi, February 15, 2021, https://www.tmag.tas.gov.au/about_ us/apology_to_tasmanian_aboriginal_ people (accessed February 25, 2025); Royal Society of Tasmania “Apology by the Royal Society of Tasmania to the Aboriginal People of Tasmania,” delivered by Mary Koolhof, February 15, 2021, https://rst.org.au/wpcontent/uploads/2021/02/RST-2021-Apologyto-Tasmanian-Aboriginal-People-for-the-web. pdf (accessed February 25, 2025). 13 Craig Fortier, “The Humber is a Haunting: Settler Deathscapes, Indigenous Spectres, and the Memorialisation of a Canadian River,” Antipode 54, no 1 (2022): 261. 14 Ashby, 245. 15 Brock Bersaglio & Jared Margulies, “Exinctionscapes: Spatializing the Commodification of Animal Lives and Afterlives in Conservation Landscapes,” Social and Cultural Geography, 23, no. 1 (2021): 12. 16 Avril Maddrell & James D. Sidaway, “Introduction: Bringing a Spatial Lens to Death, Dying, Mourning and Remembrance,” in Maddrell & Sidaway (eds), Deathscapes: Spaces for Death, Dying, Mourning and Remembrance (Ashgate, 2010), 4. 17 Bersaglio & Margulies, 18. 18 Colossal Laboratories & Biosciences, “Thylacine,” https://colossal.com/thylacine/ (accessed February 25, 2025). 19 See TIGRR Lab, https://tigrrlab.science. unimelb.edu.au/ (accessed March 4, 2025). 20 Trophic downgrading is the impact on an ecosystem when an apex predator is eliminated. The removal of the top predator can alter food webs and species diversity and can change the way that the ecosystem functions. 21 As quoted in Nicolas Smith, “The Return of the Living Dead: Unsettlement and the Tasmanian Tiger,” Journal of Australian Studies 36, no. 3 (2012): 270. 22 City of Hobart, “Threatened Species,” https://www.hobartcity.com.au/City-services/ Environment/Threatened-species (accessed March 4, 2025). Acknowledgment This work was funded by the Australian Research Council DP200101877, Beyond Extinction: Reconstructing the Thylacine (Tasmanian Tiger) Archive.
EXTINCTIONSCAPES 50
Restoration Research (TIGRR) lab at Melbourne University to utilize the sequenced genome of the thylacine to create an embryo to be implanted into a surrogate fat-tailed dunnart for gestation.19 Part of Colossal’s argument for thylacine de-extinction is that the Tasmanian landscape is relatively unchanged since thylacines became extinct. In returning this apex predator to the landscape, it claims that it will reverse trophic downgrading and restore greater ecological balance to the environment.20 The conservation landscape reveals something about how settler colonialism is produced and reproduced. De-extinction is a biopolitical project concerned with the extraction of genetic material from animal remains and which relies on forced cross-species surrogacy. It is a technofix led by major venturecapitalist companies based in the United States. The discourse used to justify de-extinction is often biblical, and it reveals a problematic nostalgia for past landscapes and a denial of the profound impacts of colonialism on environments. We see this in the common use of terms such as “resurrection” and “redemption” in discussions of de-extinction. For example, Mike Archer, a previous head of the Australian Museum in Sydney and the champion of a previous and failed deextinction project between 2001 and 2005, has argued in many interviews that if an animal is extinct because of humans, we have an ethical obligation to bring it back. He described this project explicitly as one that could redeem humans because it would “reverse one of the great blots of the history of the colonization of Australia.”21 Within this logic of redemption, what is to be remembered and what is to be forgotten? The idea that the thylacine can be returned to a “relatively unchanged” environment signals a nostalgia for a pre-invasion landscape and can be read as evidence of settler-colonial anxiety about the history of genocide of the Tasmanian Aboriginal people and the anthropogenic diminishment of endemic wildlife. The abandoned zoo, the remote bushland in which people still hunt for thylacines, the museum, and the land reserved for the possibility of future thylacine populations form a complex and contested landscape in which life, death, and extinction are inscribed. But this is also a landscape of other extinctions and potential extinctions. In the Hobart region alone, there are
a number of threatened native animals, including the swift parrot, the eastern quoll, the masked owl, the grey goshawk, and the eastern barred bandicoot.22 Within the extinctionscape of the thylacines, and roughly 100 years after its opening, the ruins of the Beaumaris Zoo now provide refuge for the endangered eastern barred bandicoot - the high wire fences that surround the site and the memorial gates protect this species from cars, dogs, and the humans who use the jogging tracks that snake around this public space. That the extinction of endemic wildlife continues at pace in Lutruwita/ Tasmania is unsettling and suggests that remembering the thylacine as a story of extinction and looking for inscriptions of this history in the landscape is important political work. This extinctionscape, one in which the racial overtones cannot be ignored, reveals how colonialism and its aftermath subsist in the landscape and highlights the enduring place of extinction in the colonial project.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 51
Storytelling with Coca: Disturbing the Archives
Sarah Bolivar
Storytelling with Coca 54
Sarah Bolivar is an assistant professor of landscape architecture at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville. Prior to UTK, Bolivar practiced with AECOM and the Central Park Conservancy on projects ranging from waterfront resiliency to playground and planting design. Her work speculates how communities can craft more reciprocal human and more-than-human futures in the face of biodiversity loss and anthropogenic climate impacts.
Cultural Geography
A
s a Colombian child growing up in the United States, I rarely saw relatable characters and narratives reflected in American history. Even though women appeared in accounts of the suffrage movement, their voices were otherwise silenced. History transpired through military might, leaving little room for stories of solidarity movements. Linear history, as a way of measuring time, felt strange when seasons and cycles permeated daily life. Unable to engage with diverging narratives, it is far too easy to uncritically consume history as a universal reality, overlooking the richness of pluralities – or, as the Zapatistas describe it, “a world where many worlds fit.”1 Moving away from narrative tropes of linear progression and simplified heroes and villains, our stories might become murkier, yet also allow for beautiful and painful truths to coexist. To engage with history as a “human storytelling practice,” in anthropologist Anna Tsing’s words, is to ask that historical records embrace both memory and myth.2 It is also to invite the more-thanhuman narratives silenced in the making of human worlds. As designers and researchers reconstruct and reimagine historical archives, storytelling can reclaim history as living memory – one with ongoing ripple effects across space and time.
Reading in parallel, or acknowledging obscured counterparts to each dominant perspective, can transform and thicken our stories. In a conversation between designers Toni L. Griffin and Sara Zewde, they distinguish between narrative and storytelling, suggesting that stories open up built environments through fictional possibilities, whereas narratives “can be the projections that we associate with place.”3 I come from a place where one narrative—that of narcotrafficking—has reigned, sensationalized by Pablo Escobar films, shows, and their cultural offshoots. These media portrayals have offered audiences glimpses of glorified violence, obscuring an armed conflict spanning more than 50 years, one estimated to have left more than 250,000 dead between 1958 and 2018, a majority of them civilians.4 Much of the physical fighting, whether led by the military, guerrilla groups, drug cartels, or paramilitary groups, has taken place throughout the periphery, where Indigenous, Afro-Colombian, and Mestizo farming communities live. In Colombia, the periphery manifests through adjacencies with neighboring countries, rivers, forest preserves, and Andean mountain ranges, each of which complicates state surveillance and control.5 Spatially, these liminal zones thrive in their aerial illegibility and physical mutability, defying stable and fixed points for top-down state interventions. Political scientists might argue this peripheralization was made possible by the 16th-century Spanish encomienda system, which extracted Indigenous labor while investing resources into public institutions that benefited
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 55
White-majority populations – a system still paying dividends in urban centers five centuries later.6 Spanish enslavement of Africans to mine gold from river basins and the Pacific Chocó region further set in motion the economic poverty visible today in rural areas.7 Centuries of displacement, dispossession, ambiguous land tenure, and tenuous social infrastructure have inevitably shaped the precarious livelihoods at the margins. While the Colombian government and one of the dominant guerrilla groups, the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), signed a peace agreement in 2016, the conditions that have stymied political and economic resilience for rural populations largely persist. Post-World War II, a series of circumstances led to a rise in Colombian cocaine production: a legal coca commodity chain collapse in Peru; weakening rural land tenure and displacement policies in Colombia; volatile cash crop markets; and FARC infiltration in rural zones.8 Coca is portable and lightweight, befitting mule transport on steep terrain. While joint United States and Colombia anti-narcotrafficking operations have historically focused on targeting coca crops with pesticide aerial spraying and military prowess, cocaine markets have been fluid, prowling across geographies to meet international demand.9 Cocaleros, or coca growers, have been the main anti-narcotics targets, yet these farmers have few viable economic alternatives in the face of uneven global political economies.10 Coca growers cultivate coca and may crudely convert the leaf to coca paste with the aid of toxic substances, such as gasoline.11 Subsequent phases, such as processing coca paste into powder, transporting to ports, and exporting to primary consumers across the United States and Europe, are managed by drug cartel operations.12 While Colombian coca farmers might be pegged as criminals, it would be negligent to disregard the transboundary networks, frameworks, and forces that enable illicit economies to thrive by exploiting labor and pricing mechanisms within so-called developing countries. Coca has historically played a significant role in forging Indigenous alliances and partnerships across the Andes. From its exalted role as a transcendental source of vitality, coca has become vilified for its chemical properties. The simultaneously complex and oversimplified narrative about coca demands that storytelling open up spaces for communal healing and resistance. The testimonio is one such storytelling tactic that has become synonymous with Latin American women’s efforts to record their lived experiences and recollections. By centering the personal, testimonios allow multiple, often uncomfortable truths to comingle in the public consciousness. These memories may refract and unsettle a cohesive and linear history, yet they also expand trajectories and visions toward alternative futures. Anthropologist Zoe Todd, in her writings on petroleum as “fossil-kin,” entreats readers to reframe weaponized beings through their more-than-human relations and obligations.13 Inspired by this framing, I offer that deweaponizing the coca plant and attending to its complex entanglements can help uncover histories that weave together human and more-than-human relations. Understanding the lived realities of coca growers and tracing the coca plant’s story are integral to processes of peace and rebuilding. Environmental historians Emily O’Gorman and Andrea Gaynor have called for the expansion of more-than-human histories through the foregrounding of relationships, plural voices, and a “situated ethics and politics,” acknowledging how researchers’ social
1 A. Escobar, Designs for the Pluriverse: Radical Interdependence, Autonomy, and the Making of Worlds (Duke University Press, 2017), xvi. 2 A. L. Tsing, The Mushroom at the End of the World: On the Possibility of Life in Capitalist Ruins (Princeton University Press, 2015), 120. 3 “The Value of Place: Toni L. Griffin and Sara Zewde in conversation,” Deem Journal 4 (accessed February 25, 2025). 4 C. Romero, “262.197 Muertos Dejó El Conflicto Armado,” Centro Nacional de Memoria Histórica, https:// centrodememoriahistorica.gov.co/262-197muertos-dejo-el-conflicto-armado/ (August 02, 2018) (accessed February 25, 2025). 5 A. Huezo, “Contested Natures: Coca, the War on Drugs, and Ecologies of Difference in Colombia’s Afro-Pacific,” Journal of Political Ecology 26, no. 1 (2019), 311; UNODC, Executive Summary: Survey of Territories Affected by Coca Cultivation (2021): 2-3. 6 J. Faguet, C. Matajira & F. Sánchez, “Encomienda, the Colonial State, and LongRun Development in Colombia,” Documento CEDE No. 10 (2024), 29–33. 7 D. Acemoglu, C. García-Jimeno & J. A. Robinson, “Finding Eldorado: Slavery and Long-Run Development in Colombia,” Journal of Comparative Economics 40, no. 4 (2012). 8 J.S. Holmes, et al., “Economic Development Policies in Colombia (1960s–1990s) and the Turn to Coca in the Andes Amazon,” in P. Gootenberg & Liliana M. Dávalos (eds), The Origins of Cocaine Colonization and Failed Development in the Amazon Andes (Routledge, 2018), 118–26; D. Bushnell, The Making of Modern Colombia: A Nation in Spite of Itself (Univ. of California Press, 1993), 241. 9 J. D. Rosen, “The War on Drugs in Colombia: A History of Failure,” in M. W. Brienen & J. D. Rosen (eds), New Approaches to Drug Policies: A Time for Change (Palgrave Macmillan UK, 2015), 59–60. 10 I. R. Herrera & J. Dessein, “‘We are not Drug Traffickers, We are Colombian Peasants’: The Voices and History of Cocaleros in the Substitution Programme of Illicit Crops in Colombia,” Geoforum 141 (2023), 5. 11 T. Rhodes, et al., “Caring for Coca, Living with Chemicals: Towards Ecological Harm Reduction,” International Journal of Drug Policy 120 (2023): 6. 12 J. M. Toyne, “The Transformation of Coca to Cocaine: An Overview of Traditional Drug Use and Modern Drug Use,” The University of Western Ontario Journal of Anthropology 7, no. 1 (2011), 26; United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Global Report on Cocaine 2023: Local Dynamics, Global Challenges (UNODC, 2023): 25–40. 13 Z. Todd, “Fish, Kin and Hope: Tending to Water Violations in amiskwaciwâskahikan and Treaty Six Territory,” Afterall: A Journal of Art, Context and Enquiry 43 (2017): 107.
Storytelling with Coca 56
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 57
constructs shape their work.14 Reconceiving the archives through material traces, such as tree rings, or through oral histories, such as testimonios, can generate more nuanced understandings of how humans are bound to their surroundings.15 Representing an other-than-human experience requires acts of translation—and perhaps a suspension of disbelief—on the part of those who listen. Geographer Catherine Johnston, building on Tim Ingold’s work, posits that a more intimate understanding of how humans and more-than-humans dwell together might cultivate a “responsible and informed anthropomorphism.”16 While there are certainly risks in any attempt to edit, translate, or record another being’s experience, Lauren Tynan’s invitation to “feel the world as kin” offers an entry point into this exercise.17 An affective, relational approach might orient us toward more nuanced cycles, registers, and ways of both sensing landscapes and narrating histories. To tell the story of coca requires many stories, both human and more-than-human, entwined with the forces that have shaped it across the Andes and beyond. Engaging with playful risk, the following coca testimonio opens with ancestral practices alongside Indigenous communities, traversing the changing geopolitical landscape as its chemical properties are commercially exploited. It is then paired with memories from Yised Pecupaque, an Indigenous woman of the Nasa We’sx community, as she recounts her childhood growing up amidst poppy and coca fields. A Coca Story I was born across the Andes and the Amazon basin, where a hot sticky mass of air and water shrouded my limbs as I reached toward the sun. The Aymara people of the Andean highlands call me khoka, or “the tree.”18 For over 8,000 years, my caretakers cultivated my wild ancestors; in turn, I sustained them spiritually, socially, and physically.19 To this day, my life remains enmeshed with those rooted in their ancestral traditions. When they are hungry or in pain, I come to their aid. When honoring ancestors or forging friendships, I am present.20 And yet, most people now overlook my generosity, recognizing me solely for one alkaloid: cocaine – qué ridículo! My chemistry deters pesky herbivores and has helped me survive. While my tart cherries rarely tempt birds, it thrills me when bees visit my small, creamy flowers. I might have lived a quiet, peaceful life were it not for the day the bedraggled outsiders arrived on our shores. Once the swords and diseases swarmed, our lives were no longer in balance. I mourned the dead by breaking down their bodies, releasing them back to our soil kin. Those who survived were forced into labor in exchange for the cross; others fled into the embrace of the upland forests.21 Realizing that conquest wouldn’t be possible by depriving me of my caretakers, the outsiders rationed my leaves.22 Meanwhile, the cold metal of chains and rough bare feet brushed past me, whimpers and cries alerting me to their suffering. At daybreak, I sensed gold ores furtively buried beneath my branches, only to be unearthed again under moonlight. Discreetly and against all odds, those souls sought their freedom.23 For over three centuries, my roots absorbed the iron and salt of people forced onto these soils against their will. The 19th century marked an inflection point in our entangled history.24 My anesthetic potency was unveiled to the world; no longer would flesh alone touch me. Under the bright laboratory lights, they called me “Erythroxylum sp,” but my name was no
14 E. O’Gorman & A. Gaynor, “More-ThanHuman Histories,” Environmental History 25, no. 4 (2020): 721. 15 Ibid., 727. 16 C. Johnston, “Beyond the Clearing: Towards a Dwelt Animal Geography,” Progress in Human Geography 32, no. 5 (2008): 643. 17 L. Tynan, “What is Relationality? Indigenous Knowledges, Practices and Responsibilities with Kin,” Cultural Geographies 28, no. 4 (2021): 600. 18 A. S. Biondich & J. D. Joslin, “Coca: The History and Medical Significance of an Ancient Andean Tradition,” Emergency Medicine International 2016, no. 1 (2016): 1. 19 Toyne, “The Transformation of Coca to Cocaine,” 24; D. M. White, et al., “The Origins of Coca: Museum Genomics Reveals Multiple Independent Domestications from Progenitor Erythroxylum gracilipes,” Systematic Biology 70, no. 1 (2021): 1–4. 20 L. M. Valdez, J. Taboada & J. E. Valdez, “Ancient Use of Coca Leaves in the Peruvian Central Highlands,” Journal of Anthropological Research 71, no. 2 (2015): 233–34. 21 Faguet, Matajira & Sánchez, “Encomienda, the Colonial State, and Long-Run Development in Colombia,” 3. 22 Biondich & Joslin, “Coca,” 3. 23 E. Sánchez, “Población de Colombia: Esclavos y Cimarrones,” The Banrepcultural Encyclopedia, https:// enciclopedia.banrepcultural.org/index. php?title=Poblaci%C3%B3n_de_Colombia:_ esclavos_y_cimarrones (2020) (accessed August 28 2025). 24 P. F. Brain & G. A. Coward, “A Review of the History, Actions, and Legitimate Uses of Cocaine,” Journal of Substance Abuse 1, no. 4 (1989): 434–37. 25 LACMA, “Coca Chewing Paraphernalia,” https://www.lacma.org/guides/ portableuniverse/02 (accessed August 2, 2025). 26 G. A. Mejía Zapata, “Mama Coca Chronicles: Navigating Ancestral Heritage and Future Narratives,” Journal of Futures Studies 30, no. 1 (2025). https://jfsdigital.org/2025-2/ vol-30-no-1-september-2025/mama-cocachronicles-navigating-ancestral-heritageand-future-narratives-2/. 27 J. Burger & M. Kapron, “Drug Policy and Indigenous Peoples,” Health and Human Rights 19, no. 1 (Jun 2017): 270–71.
Opposite: Artifacts from the Medellín: Memories of Violence and Resistance exhibit at the Medellín Memory House Museum.
Storytelling with Coca 58
longer whispered with compassion. Rather, it rang with drops of greed that rather quickly gave way to disdain. Although my kind multiplied, we no longer interlaced with cousin or friendly neighboring roots. Instead, I spread across denuded hillsides, exposed to the sun’s hardened gaze, before being promptly packaged and shipped across seas. A salve throughout this hermetic misery is that my caretakers survived, and we would become one. The Arhuaco people of the Sierra Nevada of Santa Marta would tenderly hold my leaves and fire-roasted seashell remains alongside their cheek walls to reveal my gifts.25 Mountain and coast, land and water, merging to support both ritual and the everyday. Caretakers living in lowland areas combined my leaves with alkaline ash from sacred trees, enabling a state of meditation and communion with the universe.26 Yet our union was threatened in 1961, when I, along with poppy and cannabis, was criminalized.27 Our once faithful partners were pained by this vilification, which called for the banning of leaf chewing. Despite thousands of years together in ceremony, only a privileged few could now consume me without fear.28 In the 1970s and ’80s, the landscape grew turbulent. Collapsing legal coca markets paved the way for underground networks.29 Although my caretakers fed me, they also smothered me with poison to kill the muchira and looper caterpillars flanking my leaves. They couldn’t afford to lose us, and strangely, when they sprayed their poison against the wind, their bodies were equally soaked.30 Where I could not thrive, poppy ventured. She could endure near-freezing temperatures, whereas I clung to the warmer Andean foothills. The wind whispered that coffee no longer went to market, so poppy’s carmine petals unfurled across the cool hillsides.31 Where once I sensed distant bird calls, pigs roaming about, plantains thudding to the ground, children playing hide-and-seek beneath my branches, I now sensed only fear: feet scurrying in panic, mines exploding, bullets tangled in my roots, a rumble overhead followed by a sticky rain of chemicals. Above all, confusion and loss seeped throughout the land. Yised Pecupaque’s Story I was about six or seven years old, that’s as far back as I can remember.32 Everywhere I looked, there were poppy fields. Families in the area depended on those poppies to survive. Back then, the government was trying to get rid of the poppy fields by spraying them from planes. I remember seeing those planes. I suppose they were using glyphosate or something similar to kill the plants, and that’s why my parents decided to move to Cauca. But, since that city had extensive coca cultivation, we decided to return to Tolima. This time, we didn’t return to the Indigenous reserve. We returned to a rural farming area, which is where our coffee journey began. It was in 1996 that my community, the Nasa We’sx, signed a peace agreement with the FARC in Tolima.33 My father was part of the Indigenous Council. I remember it was July 26th, because they commemorate the signing every year on that date – and it’s also my birthday. What did the peace treaty allow? It affirmed that the guerrillas would respect Indigenous lands, and no armed groups were allowed to enter. This led to a slight decrease in violence within the community and a greater respect for the agreements they had signed.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 59
If coca or poppy could speak, it would say, like any plant, that its harmfulness depends entirely on how it’s used. Used for good, it does good; used for evil, it does evil – everything transforms. Our ancestors, like those in the Amazon, traditionally used plants for healing, not for poisoning or killing others. Reclaiming Coca Memory In Biopolitics of the More-than-Human, Joseph Pugliese examines how the morethan-human have been deprived of their voices and experiences, especially in conflict zones. Given that some humans have been deprived of their humanity while the morethan-human have been disregarded in historical archives, researchers must grapple with stories subsumed by dominant narratives. For many Latin Americans living in the shadows of dictatorships and territorial conquests, the testimonio has been a storytelling device helping to resist what writer Lauret Savoy calls “acts of oblivion (or amnesia)” in historical recordkeeping.34 Through this testimonio counternarrative, coca emerges both as “live matter” and otherworldly, its origins, evolution, and futures intertwined with Andean cosmologies and peoples.35 Giving coca a voice with whom the reader can empathize reclaims history as breathing and living, suffused with relationality and kinship among beings.
28 I. Bauer, “Travel Medicine, Coca and Cocaine: Demystifying and Rehabilitating Erythroxylum – a Comprehensive Review,” Tropical Diseases, Travel Medicine and Vaccines 5 (2019): 7. 29 S. Topik, C. Marichal & F. L. Zephyr, From Silver to Cocaine: Latin American Commodity Chains and the Building of the World Economy, 1500–2000 (Duke University Press, 2006), 344–46. 30 T. Rhodes, et al., “Caring,” 3–6. 31 A. G. Ospina, J. H. Tinajero & M. Jelsma, “Poppies, Opium, and Heroin: Production in Colombia and Mexico,” Transnational Institute, https://www.tni.org/en/publication/ poppies-opium-and-heroin-productionin-colombia-and-mexico (April 16, 2018): 11, (accessed August 28, 2025). 32 The text is based on an interview with Yised Pecupaque, conducted in Spanish on March 10, 2025. Interview and translation by author. Yised Pecupaque is an Indigenous Nasa We’sx leader in the Planadas, Tolima region of Colombia, where she cultivates her family coffee, Pecupaque Café. Carrying her family’s entrepreneurial spirit, Yised has also formed a women’s association called ASOMUWE’SX (Association of Women Weaving Life through Agroecology and Ancestral Knowledge Nasa We’sx). 33 Misión de Verificación de la ONU en Colombia, “Hace 28 Años Indígenas Del Cabildo Nasa Wesk Lograron Un Acuerdo de Paz Que Sigue Dando Frutos Hoy,” (September 10, 2024) https://colombia. unmissions.org/hace-28-a%C3%B1osind%C3%ADgenas-del-cabildo-nasa-wesklograron-un-acuerdo-de-paz-que-siguedando-frutos-hoy (accessed August 01, 2025). 34 L. Savoy, “Reconciling Sites of Memory and Loss: Place, a Poetics of Geology, and the Implicated Writer,” Environmental History 28, no. 1 (2023): 28. 35 R. S. Elkin, “Live Matter: Towards a Theory of Plant Life,” Journal of Landscape Architecture 12, no. 2 (2017).
Acknowledgment I want to express my deep gratitude to Yised Pecupaque for generously sharing her memories and insights with me, despite the many demands of her academic studies, professional life, and community leadership. I look forward to many more rich and inspiring conversations.
Heirloom Gardens as Living Archives 60
Heirloom Gardens as Living Archives Tessa Lowinske Desmond, Hanna Garth, Christian Keeve + Justice Madden
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 61
“Actually, it’s a secret art to growing collards.”¹ Tessa Lowinske Desmond is a research specialist at Princeton University’s School of Public and International Affairs where she studies grassroots movements in food and agriculture using oral history and communityengaged methods. Desmond also directs The Seed Farm at Princeton. Hanna Garth is an anthropologist at Princeton University, specializing in the anthropology of food. Her books include Food in Cuba: The Pursuit of a Decent Meal and the co-edited volume Black Food Matters: Food Justice in the Wake of Racial Justice. Christian Keeve is a PhD candidate in geography at the University of Kentucky and a Woodson Predoctoral Fellow at the University of Virginia. They are also a seedkeeper, chaotic gardener, and organizer with seed networks including the Ujamaa Cooperative Farming Alliance, Heirloom Collard Project, and Truelove Seeds. Justice Madden is a storyteller, facilitator, and organizer focused on preserving Black agrarian traditions, uplifting narratives of resilience, and building community capacity through landbased practices. She is a project manager at the Center for Cultural Landscapes at the University of Virginia’s School of Architecture.
FOOD Studies, ORAL HISTORY
G
ardens hold stories often left unspoken. Even the children and grandchildren of gardeners and farmers—who perhaps have enjoyed their bounty during holidays and Sunday meals—can be at a loss when asked to name a specific variety from their elders’ plots, or to recount why a particular plant was cultivated in their family. And yet, it is often singular varieties and lesser-known herbs that color and define cherished culinary memories. It is also the enduring value of such foodways that has long motivated the preservation and maintenance of specific varieties. In her book Cultural Memory and Biodiversity, anthropologist Virginia Nazarea argues, “in the long term, maintaining diversity is the only guarantee of stabilizing the intricate web of life, indeed, it is the key to our ecological integrity.”² The Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project (HGP) documents stories from farmers, gardeners, chefs, and seed-savers who have been preserving Black and Indigenous seed and foodways in the United States as a way to record and make visible the intimate and longstanding relationships between plants and their people. The narrators in the HGP archive speak those stories of gardens often left unsaid so that current and future gardeners can more easily trace cultural and botanical connections. In his oral history interview, Levi Grisset, Sr. walked interviewer Bonnetta Adeeb to a burial plot at the back of a property that had been in his family since the early 1800s. They stood together at the foot of a single gravestone sitting at the head of a double site edged with brick. The first grave had been occupied for nearly 16 years by his wife, Francis Grisset; the second would someday belong to Grisset, Sr. himself. As they approached, he read: Francis Marie McMillan Grisset, June the 15th, 1950 to March 9th. And, oh, there’s a lot that I can say about the collards. I would never start planting collards if it had not been for my wife. So, where I’m at today with the collards, first of all, because of God…cause collards will grow eight, eight feet tall. But, if it had not been for her asking me to plant the collards, I probably would have never even planted them, although I was planting stuff at the time.³
Adeeb asked: “Did you plant because she wanted collards?”⁴ “Yeah, of course she wanted,” Grisset, Sr. said, and continued: I didn’t miss a year for 36 years for planting collards. And I only missed two years after my wife passed, because it took me so far down the tube then I picked it up again and started planting again. But she, but she’s the one that wanted me to plant collards. She come, the first year I got married, she come out and said, why don’t you plant collards?⁵
For more than a decade after his wife’s passing, Grisset, Sr. has carried her with him in his annual planting of collards. He doesn’t eat them; he has never cared for their taste. Yet they are a raft to the past, a memorial act that also brings him into relationship with people who visit him to learn his methods and buy his greens. The collards are an artifact in the living archive of his garden, one that connects him to purpose and meaning in his community and to the memory of his wife and their life together. Another gardener who shared her story, Roxanne Masters, reflected on why she grows plants like hibiscus and taro, what she calls ancestral crops. “Sometimes you feel like you’re kind of just floating in the middle of the ocean trying to get an anchor somewhere,” she said, “It was just something that they did so trying to have more of the ancestral vows, we’ve called it ancestral gardening…and connecting
Heirloom Gardens as Living Archives 62
even though colonization has kind of broken the direct line.”⁶ Masters and her family use their garden as a living archive as well, where they try to recreate and embody practices of ancestral communities they’ve collected information about through research and family histories. There are limits to which crops Masters said she is willing to include in her ancestral garden: “There’s one thing I won’t grow is cotton. Bonnetta tried to get me to grow cotton for Ujamaa and I just—Daniel tried too, he brought home cotton seeds like ten years ago when we were in California—and I was like, you’ve got to be joking. I do know Black farmers that grow it and I give them kudos.”⁷ One of the primary cash crops of the South during enslavement, cotton is a site of ancestral trauma that Masters refused to revisit through gardening. Grisset, Sr., in eastern North Carolina, and Masters, now living south of Atlanta, reflected a tension shared by many of the Black seedkeepers, land stewards, and food advocates in the Southern United States who shared their oral histories with HGP. Ecologically, socially, and culturally, plants—and our relations with them—are indicative of the places where they grow. Often, they actively create the backdrops of memories through their visual characteristics, smells, tastes, and their varied uses. In the South, in particular, land and plants may conjure histories of Indigenous dispossession, exploitation of enslaved people, and the burdened land itself. These histories can produce overlapping and intersecting sediments of struggle with and against legacies of racial capitalism that remain present in Southern landscapes, environments, and politics today.⁸ Collard greens and cotton are a few of many crops tied to such encumbrances on Southern landscapes. These crops were written into place names and political formations across the region and embedded into the soil itself. Like indigo, cotton, sugarcane, and watermelon, some plants that make the South are ongoing symbols of trauma. However, people who work with plants have been reckoning with these histories and recovering ties with these crops in ways that highlight the potential of gardens to root both people and plants in renewed relationships with each other and to their places. HGP was established by collaborators at Princeton University, Spelman College, and the Ujamaa Cooperative Farming Alliance (UCFA) in 2021. To date, the project has collected and archived 140 oral histories across the South, including in Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Maryland, Mississippi, North Carolina, Virginia, and Washington, DC. The narrators who have shared their stories with HGP are chefs, gardeners, farmers, seed savers, and food advocates. They tend commonplace gardens and farms, forage, and cook in ways that maintain their regional, familial, and cultural heritages. Together, the interviews offer a pastiche of voices that not only tell stories of quotidian relationships with plants and land, but also weave together profound insights and experiences of reckoning with history. They are a resource for other gardeners who want to use their plots as living archives, as well as for the architects and artists who design and maintain more highly manicured institutional gardens, whether historical, botanical, or conservation-focused. Seeds are Janus-faced, their capsules holding both the living genetic record of past plant lives and the code to a new, never-before-lived plant life of the future. By way of seeds—planted, saved, and replanted each year—gardens constitute a living archive that can be constantly revised, edited, and adapted. Living archive gardens evolve with the intention and consciousness of the gardeners. We offer the framework of gardens as a living archive because, for the HGP narrators, gardens are spaces in which plants facilitate connections to the past and present in ways that link memories
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 63
of community, family, and comfort without covering over trauma and hardship. Gardens offer the people who tend and visit them the chance to reflect, process, grieve, and create. One of the narrators in the collection, Amyrose Foll, who identifies as Abenaki/Penobscot, recalled, “Food was used as a weapon of war to exterminate my ancestors. But food is also love, and it’s how I show that I care about my family. I love cooking for them. I love feeding people, anybody that comes to my house. When I was young, one of my grandmothers, there was just constantly food on the table. …And some of the best childhood memories were in her garden.”⁹ UCFA encourages gardeners to consider their garden designs and plant selections not only to optimize growth, but also to facilitate the cultural and personal stories that can unfold within the garden, which the gardeners themselves can revise each year. Many gardens hosted and maintained by institutions already offer windows into past growing practices, food cultures, and memory – but they often stop short of the living archive model, which emphasizes the agency of everyday people in using and shaping gardens, iterating and evolving with and through them. Increasingly, public and institutional gardens are incorporating stories of marginalized and oppressed people into their gardens and are beginning to reckon with tensions around race, history, and land to share often-overlooked insights about subsistence practices, botanical knowledges, and culinary creativity. Such gardens are also increasingly highlighting the botanical legacies of African Americans who lived at these places and the ecological inheritance that was stewarded by Indigenous people before colonialization. Incorporating oral histories and stories of contemporary gardeners who are tending ancestral varieties can deepen the resonance of such gardens, making them not just sites of documentation of the past, but also extensions of the practices and traditions by which culturally meaningful plants and foodways persist. Community-based oral histories, like those collected by HGP, are vital and important tools to uplift voices, stories, and texts from everyday people who continue to carry on the crops of their ancestors and to participate in the regeneration of related cultural practices. Cues from our narrators inform our approach to gardens as living archives. Here, both seeds and storytelling become modes for remembering the full range of life lived on land – land for which history and trauma may be vexed and unresolved, but that can still be a site for experimentation, adaptation, and flourishing. In this way, the narrators in the archive serve as architects, sharing memories of gardens that enable us to think critically and creatively about how community-based archival work can cultivate projects of reclamation and reparation. A consideration of collard greens—their history, diversity, and persistence as a culturally significant food—provides a useful example of how gardens become living archives. Collards (Brassica oleracea) are mentioned in the HGP archive more often than any other food crop. Collards, adapted from plants called coleworts (their Brassica ancestors), came into the plantation-era subsistence plots of enslaved peoples, who bred them over time by growing and selecting for desirable traits like resilience, taste, appearance, and nutrition.¹⁰ Collards exhibit typical Brassica cross-pollination habits, mixing easily with nearby stands and creating endless permutations, including color that ranges from dark green to lime and can present blues, purples, and even fuchsia. In terms of taste, they run the gamut from tender and sweet in the winter to spicy or bitter in the warmer months depending on weather and variety.¹¹ Many of our narrators, like Levi Grisset, Sr., recognized collards as the most important plants in their family gardens and farms. In their interview, Richard and Tammy
Heirloom Gardens as Living Archives 64
Crawford reflected on the role of collards in eastern North Carolina: “Well, like she said, in eastern North Carolina, collards was the number one plant, as far as in the garden. …I guess you say the king of the vegetables coming out of the garden and they have had a lot of cultural significance.”¹² For the Crawfords, the cultural significance of collards was quite personal. Tammy recounted her first date with Richard, in which she served him collards made by her mother: Her name is Rosa Lindsay Dixon, and she is known for her collards. We’ve had cousins that come from the city and say, can you just cook me some collards to take back with me? You know, and she would do that because she has a wonderful heart. She’s a wonderful person, but she’s known for her collards. And we, our first meal together, I got my mother to cook collards. I was trying to impress him. I got her to cook some collards for us. And she cooked them and he said, “Oh, they taste like my mama’s collards.” I was like, yeah, I know. But I said, “No, they’re my mom’s collards.” But that’s a fond memory we have.¹³
Like Tammy, many narrators in the HGP archive reflected on how collards connected them with family across generations and place. Shelby Johnson recounted how the taste of potlikker transported her back to her grandmother’s kitchen. The tone and cadence of Shelby’s voice changed as she recalled that her grandmother “always, always, always had a pot of greens going and one of the best parts was getting the potlikker. …There was only so much potlikker to go around. …The other medicine she gave us wasn’t good whether it was, you know, castor oil or whatever it was she was doling out but potlikker was good.”¹⁴ Smells, tastes, and the feeling of warmth emanating from the stove are the sorts of sensory memories that tether the gardens where collards are grown to kitchens and pots across generations. In such instances, collards are a material manifestation of care. Beyond connecting family and relations of care, collards also display a particular seasonality that requires gardening knowledge to unlock their full potential in the kitchen. As Vivian Fields noted: But I like to eat mine after September because it only takes me about a whole hour to cook the whole thing. And so I do it the same way I do, cook the ham first and take it out, and then put the collard greens in and let them cook about, from September to December, it only takes about 45 minutes to cook the whole thing. … Well, in the summertime, the collards out there with all that hot heat, and it makes them tough. So it takes longer to cook the collards in the summertime. But in the wintertime, the frost done struck ’em. That’s after September, Labor Day week. So it doesn’t take that long. You can wash them, cook them, and everything, and be done eating in two hours. In the summertime, you got to wait three or four hours before you can eat anything.¹⁵
Fields articulated the physicality of collards, specifically how weather affects their texture and how different ways of preparing them can bring out traits like bitterness and tenderness. Her observation that collards are sweeter and more tender after the frost helps to clarify why collards hold special significance during winter holiday gatherings. These ways of understanding the seasonality of collards speak to process: everything in its time, place, and season. Ira Wallace spoke of the importance of collards during the holidays in her oral history and noted that they were especially coveted at celebrations in the North as well as
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 65
the South. Wallace spoke of the Great Migration and the way that people traveled with collards, taking food, garden, and cultural traditions across geographies: Throughout many communities of color throughout the Southeast, collards were something special that even when people had gone up north with the Great Migration, they took collards with them, and there were truckloads of collards that were cut in the South and taken to cities like Chicago for the holidays. …This is a cultural food that people who don’t think they want to live in the South, they still want that part of the South in their lives.¹⁶
Collards thus become a way in which a culturally significant place, the South, could manifest in other spaces through food. Bonnetta Adeeb, one of the co-founders of the HGP, also talked in her own interview about the importance of collard season for food security:
1 Levi Grisset, Sr., interviewed by Tessa Desmond on September 20, 2023, Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project, Spelman College Archives. 2 Virginia Nazarea, Cultural Memory and Biodiversity (University of Arizona Press, 2005), 3. 3 Grisset, September 20, 2023. 4 Ibid. 5 Ibid. 6 Roxanne Masters, interviewed by Elizabeth Gowans on July 7, 2023, Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project, Spelman College Archives. 7 Ibid. 8 See, for instance, Lauret E. Savoy, Trace: Memory, History, Race, and the American Landscape (University of California Press, 2015).
The reason why collards is so important is because of their ability to provide green, fresh vegetables during the cold and winter months. And so, it just makes all the sense that after everything else has gone from the garden, what’s left standing? It’s those collard greens.¹⁷
9 Amyrose Foll, interviewed by Chris Keeve on July 27, 2023, Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project, Spelman College Archives.
Taken together, these reflections on collards and many more in the HGP archive reveal the multiple meanings the plants take on as essential and nutritionally rich food in these communities while also serving as an evocative presence that imbues the land with a particular sensory memory. Collards pepper the landscape of Southern gardens so much that when researchers Edward Davis and John Morgan were searching for collard seeds to increase the diversity of the USDA’s plant germplasm collection, they took a road trip through North and South Carolina, knocking on the doors of homes where collards were visible from the street and asking the residents if they would share seeds for the government’s collection.¹⁸
11 Ibid. See also The Heirloom Collards Project, “Collards,” https://heirloomcollards.org (accessed December 1, 2025).
While Adeeb’s question, “What’s left standing?” alludes to collards in winter, it also offers a larger question about culture and food after a garden is gone. We encourage an approach to garden design that not only preserves seeds, plants, and stories, but also uplifts growing spaces as living archives – of memory, food, land practices, plant relations, and more. Highlighting these layers of significance in the garden also helps us to remember that many hands have touched the seeds, guided the plant populations, and prepared the foods. The oral histories collected by HGP are only a small subset of the stories of relations between people and the plants in their gardens. We invite all gardeners to collect stories of their communities and to incorporate those stories into annual plantings as a way to carry forward cultural traditions along with the plants themselves. Treating gardens as living archives uplifts the way such spaces can hold, memorialize, and facilitate connections to kin and land. Such gardens can serve as embodied reminders that land and plants, themselves, are not perpetrators of trauma; they may, in fact, be important sites for healing and reclamation.
15 Vivian Fields, interviewed by Tessa Desmond on September 27, 2023, Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project, Spelman College Archives.
10 Edward H. Davis and John T. Morgan, Collards: A Southern Tradition from Seed to Table (University of Alabama Press, 2015).
12 Tammy and Richard Crawford, interviewed by Ayluonne Tereszkiewicz on September 27, 2023, Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project, Spelman College Archives. 13 Ibid. 14 Shelby Johnson, interviewed by Chris Keeve on April 24, 2023, Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project, Spelman College Archives.
16 Ira Wallace, interviewed by Chris Keeve on July 27, 2023, Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project, Spelman College Archives. 17 Bonnetta Adeeb, interviewed by Chris Keeve on July 26, 2023, Heirloom Gardens Oral History Project, Spelman College Archives. 18 Davis and Morgan, Collards.
Evan Pavka
Monumental Dreams
monumental dreams 68
Evan Pavka is a writer, editor, and assistant professor in the School of Interior Design at Toronto Metropolitan University. He currently serves as associate editor of the journal Interiors: Design/Architecture/Culture.
Queer Studies
T
ucked behind the entrance to New York’s Stonewall Inn, the landmark gay bar often cited as the locus of the 2SLGBTQIA+ rights movement, a framed black-and-white photograph of a headstone hangs on the wooden wall paneling. The grave in question belongs to Leonard Matlovich, the first openly gay serviceman in the United States military who became a significant voice for equality following his discharge, as well as a controversial figure whose publicity and politics were contested by others fighting for liberation. Its deliberate placement in a space enmeshed with the conflicting struggles and myths of the gay liberation movement in North America raises inevitable questions about the role these monuments play in shaping queer histories.1 Though the connection between a site of death and a site of liberation might initially seem disparate, cemeteries and the structures within them are riddled with values around religion and respectability, and therefore expectations around gender and sexuality. Urban or rural, gridded or picturesque, these inescapably cosmopolitan spaces extend the power structures and relations of life into death, rendering the cemetery a critical lens into the politics of memory and sexuality that permeate both. In recording the unfolding history of a given place, monuments, graves, mausoleums, and other architectures elevate some histories and conceal others by conveying whose memories are enshrined and whose are inevitably lost. As both containers of the dead and inadvertent archives, these commemorative works also construct normative ideas of gender and sexuality, with inscriptions and epitaphs frequently acting as confessions that affirm sexual orientation and its conformity to accepted standards, etched in stone for eternity. Additionally, monuments to those who lost their lives in wars, fires, and other traumatic events valorize masculine acts of bravery and sacrifice through their imposing visual presence, while gated family plots and the intentional positioning of bodies parallel the biological, sexual, and gendered spheres of the city. Beyond merely mirroring urban form, these cities of the dead reproduce the social order of the living metropolis—the same divisions that have resulted in histories of targeted violence against queer people and their subsequent activism— thus entangling urban and memorial landscapes. Just before 8:00 pm on Sunday, June 24, 1973, a fire broke out in the entranceway to the UpStairs Lounge, a two-floor gay bar in New Orleans’s French Quarter.2 The flames tore through the three-room space filled with nearly 90 men and women who had come for the weekly “beer bust” event, leading to the deaths of 32 patrons in what became the deadliest fire in the city’s history. Initially attributed to two disgruntled visitors who had been kicked out of the establishment, the fire was later revealed to have been set by still-unidentified arsonists who targeted the bar’s stairway, trapping the patrons inside the three-story building. Though the fire only lasted 16 minutes, the carnage and trauma were significant. Reports described “at least 20 bodies, all melted together,” with remains scattered along the barred windows, and three still caught in the frames long after the flames had subsided.3 The indistinguishable remains were eventually carried from the wreckage and placed on Iberville Street, while some bodies remained on the second floor for nearly four hours. Images of the charred architectural carcass, with eviscerated wall paneling and heaps of melted furniture, paralleled the blackened figures huddled together in the fetal position. After the horrific event and the stigma surrounding descriptions of the venue as a place “frequented by homosexuals,” numerous religious organizations refused to bury the deceased, while the New Orleans City Attorney blocked the Metropolitan
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 69
Community Church’s request to take authority for the internments.4 Many bodies went unclaimed and unidentified. Relatives and next of kin handled the remains of the 29 identified victims, resulting in interment in family plots and other sites across Florida, Illinois, Alabama, Kentucky, California, and Louisiana. Only one victim, Reverend William Larson, was interred in a local cemetery. Concealed behind the opaque white gates of the site, his ashes were eventually placed in a columbarium on the grounds of Saint Roch Cemetery after his mother declined to collect his remains. The remains of three men who lost their lives, two of whom were never identified— labelled simply as #18, #23, and #29—were transferred into city custody in early July 1973.5 By the end of the month, they were interred in unmarked graves in Resthaven Memorial Park, a potter’s field designated for the destitute on the city’s eastern outskirts.6 In this sense, the fire created a two-fold erasure: it destroyed the bar and the subcultural space it provided, while also removing any trace of the men from the city. This silence resounded in the public sphere, as neither then-Mayor Moon Landrieu nor the governor of Louisiana, Edwin Edwards, made any statements or comments concerning the attack. And though many victims received burials, the scattering of their remains to various locations throughout the nation removed, much like the anonymous interments, any traces of queer pasts, trauma, and situated violence from New Orleans’s burial grounds. Similarly, two years later, on April 12, 1975, the Aquarius Sauna in Montreal was firebombed. Arson was suspected, but police were unable, or unwilling, to identify those responsible. Three men died in the bathhouse during the attack, with two remaining unidentified by family members or the authorities. Both men subsequently received burials in unmarked pauper’s graves in Cimetière Notre-Dame-des-Neiges, the city’s Catholic burial ground. Pauper’s graves, also referred to as common graves or potter’s graves, are places of interment for those unable to afford burial plots in cemeteries or for those whose bodies have gone unidentified and unclaimed. While many of these burial sites are separate spaces, cemeteries occasionally contain such areas in otherwise undesirable locations on their grounds, distanced from sections reserved for more prominent or affluent individuals. Structures of commemoration in these spaces differ widely depending on time, place, and the institution responsible for the burial. From small wooden crosses destined to fade away and flat headstones with minimal inscriptions to nothing at all, this can be understood as the ultimate act of erasure – where, according to Thomas Laqueur, “biological and social deaths were simultaneous.”7 By the time of anonymous burial, “the pauper was already gone.”8 Collapsing manifold forms of effacement, the uncredited burials of the victims of the attacks at UpStairs and Aquarius carried identical connotations. Representing only a small fraction of historic and ongoing violence against queer people and the places they inhabit, these incidents nonetheless reveal a shared erasure of material space in life and death. The absence of a grave, a marker, and a name removed these men from a history constructed not only through official records and documents, but also through the structures of the cemetery. Following the progressive activism of the succeeding decades, erasure from civic and memorial landscapes became less common. As the phrase “Out of the closet, into the streets!” resonated in cities, this new visibility reverberated in the cemetery.
Previous: Hart Island, Bronx, New York.
monumental dreams 70
By the early 1990s, a section of DC’s Congressional Cemetery had adopted a de facto “gay corner” near the intersection of Ingle and Henderson streets. Here, a new category of funerary architecture emerged: the gay grave. The first tomb in the section, and arguably one of the first and most explicit gay graves, belonged to Technical Sergeant Leonard Matlovich. Matlovich had ascended into the public eye after being discharged by the military for disclosing his sexuality to a commanding officer in a 1975 letter. A very public legal battle for his reinstatement ensued over the next five years, ultimately landing Matlovich on the cover of Time magazine with the bold title “I’m a Homosexual.” In the corresponding cover story, Time asserted that he had become “one of the best-known gays in the country.”9 Opting to forgo a plot reserved for veterans in Arlington Cemetery, Matlovich acquired lots 161 and 162—for himself and a potential partner—in Range 20 of Washington’s Congressional Cemetery on November 26, 1984. Founded in 1807, this first widely accessible national public cemetery containing “the memory of the nation” was originally designated for the burials of “public men” and others associated with federal service.10 Over a century and a half later, the publicity surrounding Matlovich’s discharge had brought a distinctive visibility to his life, activism, and eventual death, challenging the initial articulation of which national memories and histories should be held within its grounds. Shortly after the purchase, Matlovich began directing the design of a structure to be completed the following year. Drawing on international monuments commemorating authors Gertrude Stein, Alice B. Toklas, and Oscar Wilde in Paris’s Cimetière Père Lachaise, the grave conflates the commemoration of Matlovich’s military accomplishments with the nuances of his personal life and sexual orientation. Indeed, three years later, following his death from an AIDS-related illness at age
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 71
44, obituaries published in national newspapers made numerous references to the tombstone and its inscriptions. The epitaph reads, “Never Again / Never Forget,” with a biographical note written in the first person: “When I was in the military, they gave me a medal for killing two men and a discharge for loving one.” Noticeably absent was any mention of the grave’s unique iconography. Two pink triangles in a rosy granite are set into the surface of the tombstone, appropriating a specific emblem of sexual persecution and forced confession for gay and bisexual men during the Holocaust.11 Additionally, borrowing from military symbolism, one triangle points down to signal defeat and the other up to signal victory. This icon, later adopted as a chief symbol by the advocacy group ACT UP (AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power), also appears on the “SILENCE=DEATH” lithograph from the same year. Far from replicating the order of the living, the grave’s pink triangle—a coded mark of death, silence, and erasure rewritten as a testament to queer visibility—seemingly anticipated its presence in the city. The edifice was further hewn from black granite as a reference to Maya Lin’s 1982 Vietnam Veterans Memorial. As a proud “Gay Vietnam Veteran,” the connected materiality was likely Matlovich’s attempt to draw a connection to shared service, just as the unified white marble stones in Arlington visually establish a fraternal order of patriotic sacrifice. In another intentional gesture, Matlovich’s name was not included on the face of the tombstone, appearing only at the foot of the granite border around the plot. His grave thus aimed to function as a monument to gay veterans past and present, rather than as an individual memorial. In light of the reception of Lin’s memorial as non-patriotic and even unheroic, another reading of Matlovich’s grave opens up.12 According to Marita Sturken, the sunken structure of Lin’s design rejects “the architectural lineage of monuments” and “refuses the closure and implied tradition” of war memorials, both condemning and justifying future architectures of remembrance.13 A similar reflection may be applied to Matlovich’s grave: a somber statement on the nuances of individual life that both condemns and inspires forms of commemoration through a deliberate rejection of previous aesthetic codes. The use of black granite and twin pink triangles leverages both a symbol of past persecution and the materiality associated with a civic memorial, gesturing toward collective methods of remembrance while subversively appropriating those same approaches. On the 30th anniversary of the UpStairs fire in 2003, a small bronze plaque was installed at 604 Iberville Street, immediately outside the former entrance, to commemorate the victims of the attack. The names of all 30 identified victims appear within the bounds of a relief triangle. For many of those recorded, this is the last vestige of their memory in a city they once called home. As ongoing acts of violence, including the 2016 attack on Pulse Night Club in Orlando, Florida, continue to underscore the need for spaces of commemoration, what might a reflection on the gay grave—its presence and absence in the dead city—offer in response to these monumentalizing landscapes? In their analysis of queer forms of remembrance in the wake of the HIV/AIDS crisis, Christopher Castiglia and Christopher Reed argue that the deliberate distancing from pre-pandemic sexual cultures and the spaces they moved through—whether bathhouses or bars—constitutes a form of “unmembering” and significant historic amnesia.14 Instead of this sanitation, genuine memory should be a process crafted in response to past inadequacies, resulting in a constructive relation to history. Sitting
1 For brevity, I employ the term “queer” to capture a range of desires, positions, and relations operating beyond heterosexuality and heteronormativity. Where appropriate, I leverage specific terminology relevant to the historic period discussed. 2 For further insight into the UpStairs fire, see Robert W. Fieseler, Tinderbox: The Untold Story of the Up Stairs Lounge Fire and the Rise of Gay Liberation (Liveright, 2018). 3 Roy Reed, “Flash Fire in New Orleans Kills at Least 32 in Bar,” New York Times (June 25, 1973), 1. 4 Ibid., 66. 5 Though identified by coroners after the fire, the family of Ferris LeBlanc only discovered his involvement in the attack and the eventual burial of his remains in 2014. However, due to improper records from the city and the cemetery, the location of his body on the Resthaven grounds has not been located. Ramon Antonio Vargas, “Family of veteran killed in 1973 New Orleans fire trying to recover remains,” The Guardian (June 26, 2023). 6 Current work to identify the remaining bodies suggests that the men may have been Larry Frost and Reginald Tubbs. 7 Thomas W. Laqueur, The Work of the Dead: A Cultural History of Mortal Remains (Princeton Architectural Press, 2016), 318. 8 Ibid. 9 Nick Carbone, “Gays on the March,” Time (September 8, 1975), 34. 10 Abby Arthur Johnson & Ronald M. Johnson, In the Shadow of the United States Capitol: Congressional Cemetery and the Memory of the Nation (New Academia Publishing, 2012), 1–2; Elmer Jacob Burket, History of the Congressional Cemetery (Government Printing Office, 1906), 4. 11 See Richard Plant, The Pink Triangle: The Nazi War Against Homosexuals (H. Holt & Co., 1988). 12 Sociologists Robin Wagner-Pacifici and Barry Schwartz draw this conclusion from their analysis of criticism following the monument’s unveiling. Robin Wagner-Pacifici & Barry Schwartz, “The Vietnam Veterans Memorial: Commemorating a Difficult Past,” American Journal of Sociology 97, no. 2 (1991): 395. 13 Marita Sturken, “The Wall, the Screen, and the Image: The Vietnam Veterans Memorial,” Representations 35 (1991): 122. 14 Christopher Castiglia & Christopher Reed, If Memory Serves: Gay Men, AIDS, and the Promise of the Queer Past (University of Minnesota Press, 2011), 36.
Opposite: Photograph of Technical Sergeant Leonard Matlovich’s grave in Congressional Cemetery.
monumental dreams 72
almost unnoticed in the cemetery until Matlovich’s declining health accelerated its significance, the mere presence of his grave rectified past absences produced by a litany of attacks, such as those at UpStairs and Aquarius. While appropriating tactics of collective forms of remembrance, its specificities—the commemoration of a single person—associate the site with a particular individual, caught in what theorist Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick has described as an “irreducible set of minoritizing and universalizing views on sexuality” where “people really are gay while simultaneously preserving that desire is inherently unstable.”15 The grave is at once minoritizing, relaying the specificities of a singular gay man, and universalizing, commemorating shared forms of institutional marginalization and discrimination. Yet many advocacy groups actively denounced Matlovich—a white, affluent, conservative, straight-passing, able-bodied, cisgender man who often championed heteronormative values of family and marriage—as a face of gay liberation because he represented a “white warrior masculinity” that countered the antimilitary ideology of those who could not reconcile gay equality with the oppression of others.16 As Simon Wendt notes, this image of military heroism was seen as reinforcing the social status quo of heteronormative masculinity.17 Desiring nothing more than a partner and family, Matlovich’s privileged homonormativity obscured the plurality of queerness and of those at the intersection of other marginalized identities. Alongside its influence on who gets remembered, the tomb thus raises questions of which stories are told and who is made representative of the histories of gay activism and liberation. While Matlovich had agency in intentionally encoding specific elements of his life into the future, the victims of UpStairs, Aquarius, and those whose lives form patches on numerous AIDS quilts were not afforded the same privilege. At the height of the HIV/AIDS crisis, medical prejudice and political silence echoed in the cemetery. In the mid-to-late 1980s and early 1990s, Hart Island—a small landmass and potter’s field in the Long Island Sound immediately west of the Bronx—served as the burial ground for thousands of individuals who died from the disease. Interred anonymously within a remote section on the island’s southernmost tip, the nuances of their lives and stories are absent from the cemetery’s historical record – an act of physical, social, and mnemonic sanitation exacerbated by the restricted access to the area. In this way, the burial ground became another kind of closet, where layers of earth cleansed the image of the city.18 Where media coverage and reporting in the early 1990s anonymized the approximately 100,000 lives lost to the disease, a parallel erasure took place in the cemetery, where simple markers often displayed only an identification number or date of death.19 As evidenced by Hart Island’s adjacency to City Island and Orchard Beach, abject things are never entirely eliminated. Instead, they are placed just beyond the sites they supposedly defile. Here, soil embodies numerous meanings, becoming the strata that produce visual and material clarity while simultaneously indistinguishable from the social and biological threat it contains. Embedded in this territory of erasure, the government-provided stones oscillate between the particular and the universal, between recollections of lost individual life and collective trauma. Akin to Matlovich’s grave, they encapsulate the social politics of the HIV/AIDS pandemic and its lasting associations with the privileges of space, whether in the city, the cemetery, or the newspaper page.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 73
To counter this overwhelming silence, the Hart Island Project—led by artist Melinda Hunt—has mapped the over 80,000 burial sites on the formerly restricted grounds and identified approximately 68,000 individuals laid to rest. The interactive drone scan of the site and corresponding crowd-sourced storytelling platform enables users to navigate the cemetery plots and expand the list of those interred—named and unnamed—in a given section. In addition to providing virtual access to once-inaccessible terrain, the navigable digital model adds room to attribute personal histories and information to each grave’s dedicated profile, with the hope of eventually stopping “the clock of anonymity.”20 Rather than canonizing heroic figures and romanticizing as well as mythologizing the histories of gay liberation, these digital records, coupled with the shifting panoramas of what remains above ground, relay the acute weight of loss and systemic prejudice experienced by the everyday people interred 14 feet below. As each unknown grave is symbolically exhumed, slowly eroding decades of medical and moral associations with infection, this immaterial, digital burial ground becomes an increasingly complex, nuanced, and accessible landscape of public memory. Its onceoverlooked monuments—witnesses to the lives bound to this deliberately concealed chapter of queer and collective histories—further resist the tendencies to render queer communities and sexualities as singular monoliths. Until then, Matlovich’s grave remains a testament to existence that offers space “not to idealize or to reinvent the past,” according to Reed and Castiglia, but “to think critically about what stories are credited.”21 As opposed to ephemeral or performative modes of recollection, its relative physical permanence, combined with its alternating readings, memorialize the privileges, power structures, and affordances of not only who is remembered, but how. Writing in the Advocate almost exactly a year before his death, Matlovich reflected on the indivisible connections between his tombstone, disease, sexuality, and memory: “As a person with AIDS, I have thought about this a great deal…When confronted with our own mortality, it has become common in our community to have our bodies cremated and our ashes thrown to the four winds. But with the wind goes an important part of our history. And also an important part of our future.”22 Like Lin’s memorial, his grave is both a condemnation and a beacon for future forms of remembrance that may help piece together fragments of a queer past. It is a reminder that the many small, complicated, and contested moments comprising individual lives are still worthy of monuments.
15 Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick, Epistemology of the Closet (University of California Press, 1990), 85. 16 For instance, the founders of Boston’s Gay Liberation Front had explicit antiwar beliefs, with members questioning Matlovich’s support of American imperialism. Historian John D’Emilio also notes how the antiwar views of many activists of his generation seemed unreconcilable with Matlovich’s rise as heroic “respectable” face of the community. See John D’Emilio, Sexual Politics Sexual Communities: The Making of a Homosexual Minority in the United States, 1940–1970 (University of Chicago Press, 1983). Letters between Matlovich and Frank Kamey, an astronomer who was dismissed from the army due to his sexuality and also buried in the Congressional Cemetery, reveal the tensions surrounding Matlovich’s conservative, heteronormative views; see Simon Hall, “Leonard Matlovich: From Military Hero to Gay Rights Poster Boy,” in Simon Wendt (ed.), Warring Over Valor: How Race and Gender Shaped American Military Heroism in the 20th and 21st Centuries (Rutgers University Press, 2018), 113–27. 17 Ibid., 120. 18 Henry Urbach, “Closets, Clothes, disClosure,” Assemblage 30 (1996): 62–73. 19 See, for instance, a reprinting of an article by the Associated Press: “U.S. Reports AIDS Deaths Now Exceed 100,000,” New York Times (January 25, 1991), 18. 20 See The Hart Island Project, www. hartisland.net (accessed June 30, 2025). 21 Castiglia & Reed, 71. 22 Matlovich, “Monumental Dreams,” 9.
On Reimagining the Specter of Urban Vacancy 74
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 75
Nia Easley + Daniela Rosner
On Reimagining the Specter of Urban Vacancy I
(Easley) grew up in Bronzeville, on the South Side of Chicago, in the ’80s and ’90s. Chicago is longer than it is wide, producing a firm North Side/South Side dichotomy. Bronzeville, which is the gateway to the South Side, is a predominantly Black neighborhood with a long history of racialized dispossession, as well as of recuperation and social vibrancy through the arts. The importance of Bronzeville as a 20th-century crucible for Black excellence cannot be overstated; indeed, it was known as Chicago’s Black Metropolis.1 Today, Bronzeville hosts the South Side Community Art Center, the Little Black Pearl Workshop, and various acclaimed murals, among other cultural touchstones.
Nia Easley is an artist, designer, and adjunct assistant professor at the School of the Art Institute of Chicago. Her work can be found in the Joan Flasch Artists’ Book Collection, DePaul University, Northwestern University, the University of Iowa Special Collections, and the Graphic Arts Collection at Princeton. Daniela Rosner is a professor in the Department of Digital Arts and Experimental Media (DXARTS) and the Department of Human Centered Design and Engineering (HCDE) at the University of Washington, where she serves as associate chair of External Affairs. She holds adjunct appointments in the Department of Gender, Women, and Sexuality Studies and the Allen School for Computer Science and Engineering.
Visual Arts, urban studies
I appreciated the geography of my childhood. There were limitations, but much of it felt like a place to play and have fun. We were close to the lakefront and lived on a large boulevard. There were many open spaces, big fields I could lose myself in. Some parts of the city lacked open space; in Bronzeville, it was accidentally abundant. It felt luxurious. Only as I grew older did it register that those spaces emerged because the neighborhood had emptied out, losing density and cultural capital. According to census data, Bronzeville lost about twothirds of its residents between 1970 and 2010. The most current census numbers represent approximately 11% of Bronzeville’s peak population of 300,000 residents during the 1950s.2 One day in 2015, while reading Isabel Wilkerson’s The Warmth of Other Suns: The Epic Story of America’s Great Migration, I learned of Victor H. Green’s The Negro Motorist Green Book, a guide for Black drivers to navigate the United States.3 The guide was published from 1936 to 1967, at the height of Jim Crow. The inaugural issue covered only New York, but it quickly spread across the entire United States and eventually into parts of Mexico, Canada, and the Caribbean. Coming from a Black family that moved during the 20th-century Great Migration from Tennessee to various cities in the north, I was shocked that I had not heard of the book before. Looking through the guides, which the New York Public Library had recently made freely available online, I first focused on the design. What do the graphic elements communicate? What do they occlude? I found a clear paradox enshrined within this
On Reimagining the Specter of Urban Vacancy 76
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 77
aspirational document. While advertising and celebrating a lifestyle of leisure, it also foregrounded the dangers of being a Black traveler with the tagline: “Carry your Green Book with you – you may need it!” In an article about travel by train aimed at its Black audience, the only representations of Black people are the porters working on the train. These kinds of absences serve to highlight the disparity between the aspirations of its readership and the everyday social structures they were fighting against. Eventually, I visited the book’s sites in Chicago, where I was in graduate school. Once I did, I began to recognize a pattern: most of the Chicago sites listed in The Green Book are now abandoned lots or empty buildings. Over the next three years, I pieced together a historiography of dispossession. I called it The Last Green Book. Questioning Remembrance The Last Green Book, an artist’s book Easley published in 2022, offers a look into what gets temporally elided. Across each of the locations listed in the original motorist guide—sites within and beyond Bronzeville—Easley encountered absence. One after another, she visited empty lots, boarded-up housing, and abandoned businesses. At times, the deserted locales sat even more starkly on blocks where every other lot appeared inhabited and buzzing. While considering the form this project might take, Easley recalled a set of postcards she had encountered during a recent visit to the DuSable Black History Museum, a South Side museum and cultural space started by famed African American artist Margaret Burroughs. The museum had dedicated a section to WWI and WWII military stories, including WWII postcards that pictured the opposite of the idealized cities one might imagine on a postcard. They depicted urban enclaves devastated in the wake of bombings, tanks, and adjacent military destruction. With this imaging of debris, the idea for the booklet coalesced: The Green Book and travel postcards, sharing a history. Easley brought photographer Maria Dunaevsky to the locations and documented the vacancies using a Hasselblad 500C/M, which captured the soft light and brought a certain asynchronous quality to the images. The images are taken
in the present and depict the present, but the camera and printing methods place them slightly in the past. By printing the photographs on postcards, she turned the image-catalog into a collection of 180 limited-edition artifacts. Each object comprised 10 postcards covered in a bright green screenprinted slipcase. Large, bold sans serif letters on the front read: “The Last Green Book.” Easley’s use of the term “last” hangs onto finitude, suggesting a kind of closure. But with the knowledge of partiality, the progressive timeline also suggests a chronic excess eliciting what is not recorded but continues to churn. The absence is a presence.4 It draws attention to what remains and what has always been, to the impermanence and unevenness permeating the Chicagoland neighborhoods. What was then and is not now—and what was not then and is now—becomes a collection of questions about remembrance itself.5 Walking Through and Beyond Housing Histories The Last Green Book arose out of a longer inquiry. Early in her research, Easley noticed several historically significant places that were never included in The Green Book, an exclusion that led to a broader Chicago settlement story. Research into the sites left unlisted by the guide led to Easley’s current neighborhood of Avondale, a sleepy residential area on the Northwest side of Chicago, lined with utilitarian brick bungalows that occasionally feature ornamental stainedglass windows. The current housing stock, built predominantly within the first half of the 20th century, overshadows an earlier history of farmland, prairie, and Black settlement that Easley sought to unravel. First encountering evidence of an African Methodist Episcopal church in the 1880s on the Northwest side of Chicago, Easley dug deeper. Turning to census records, she discovered a surprising shift. While 71 Black people resided in Avondale in 1880, representing two-thirds of the Black residents counted in Jefferson Township, only six remained by 1910, and only one by 1920.6 Easley went on to investigate the neighborhood’s history. She spoke with residents, amateur historians, and academics to gather data that contradicted the city’s better-known stories of segregation and Black settlement. Historians tend
On Reimagining the Specter of Urban Vacancy 78
to point to racist redlining and disinvestment practices that influenced the resettlement of Black Americans during the Great Migration, constraining them to the South and West sides of Chicago.7 The discovery of a settlement of Black Chicago residents outside of those areas thus comes as a surprise. With further research, Easley learned of Avondale’s Dawson subdivision. Named after Reverend John B. Dawson, the subdivision, along with the Allen Street settlement, comprised Avondale’s Black community. Dawson purchased seven acres of land across and beyond the current Avondale neighborhood during the 1870s, when the area was known as Jefferson Township. This oasis harbored the area’s first house of worship, the African Methodist Episcopal Allen Chapel, established in 1876, as well as the region’s first large Black settlement. The subsequent disappearance of the subdivision, along with its relatively hidden historiographic record, troubled Easley.
and began to read the names out loud. The group began to connect the land’s history to its present moment — meditating on the people, buildings, businesses, and experiences invisible but still present in space.
In response to this disappearance, Easley created neighborhood tours in the Dawson subdivision, raising awareness of this history to both Chicagoans and visitors. They started at a brick tavern off Wellington Avenue and made their way around and through the block to a series of landmarks that traced Chicago’s early years of settlement. This method of walking slowly through a space gave participants a somatic connection to the information being shared. Noticing the potency of this connection and observing the positive reception the tours received, Easley decided to incorporate the method of experiencing space and storytelling into The Last Green Book project as well. She led a walking tour in Bronzeville, well outside the historic district of Dawson, tracing sites listed in the book.
Enlivening the Blank Line
While walking, Easley showed her audience The Green Book and told stories of the places they visited: a historic YMCA building where Carter G. Woodson developed his idea for Negro History Week; a park that replaced a massive historic hotel; a WPA (Works Progress Administration) mural that depicts Black migrants arriving in Bronzeville during the Great Migration. At one point, she found almost an entire block of empty lots next to the South Side Community Art Center, the starting point of this tour. Easley referenced a 1950 Chicago Street Address Directory listing of all the people living or working on that block,
The names in the 1950 Chicago Street Address Directory suggest a greater diversity in Bronzeville than one might expect. As contemporary political leaders try to separate Chicago residents along categories of racialized difference, past stories urge a capacity for imagining what might be otherwise, then and now. How do residents already preserve beautiful stories from the past? How are Chicagoans transforming empty lots into vibrant new spaces? How might open fields work as temporary stages for theatrical play, communal sports, and nature exploration? These sites refuse a relentless churn of displacement occurring
The tours put the housing histories Easley catalogued in conversation with contemporary landscapes. In Avondale, they illuminated how a Northwest neighborhood became one of the first homes for Black Chicago residents immediately after the Civil War. Many of the touring residents knew Chicago as a city long-segregated along its northern and southern axes. Easley’s tour painted a more complicated picture. For Easley, The Green Book did not record these moments of transition, but neither did it overlook them. In their nonexistence, formations of displacement and segregation became part of a historical telling that Easley further unraveled through its remaking. In Bronzeville today, a giant chalkboard sign on Chicago’s 43rd Street reads: “I wish 43rd street was ____.” It sits on the wall of The Forum at 43rd and Calumet, underneath the Green Line elevated train tracks. The Forum, one of Chicago’s best dance floors and a landmark that has been shuttered for decades, recently began rehabilitation to prevent its demolition. On its own, the sign marks a possibility, a chance for pedestrians, spectators, or community members to fill in the blank, to share an aspect of urbanity yet to be, if only in thought. But the gap is also a presence. It gestures toward grounded memories of what no longer exists and what always remains, a present absence.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 79
under the pressures of racial capitalist disintegration: housing crises, depressed wages, and an unemployment rate in Black communities that is double the national average. Focusing on absence—what it means to build knowledge and action from land-based memories—Easley conjures connections between the there and here. Her projects rearrange the absentia. They build historical disruptions across the normative assumptions that accumulate in everyday life. The Last Green Book enlivens these ruptures. It lives within the lingering and forceful extractive logics long associated with US empire. Like the blank line on the 43rd Street sign, the Bronzeville photographs reveal spaces to be filled, but those spaces were also never empty. The sites exist in order to be held and transformed again.
1 Horace R. Cayton, Black Metropolis: A Study of Negro Life in a Northern City, Vol. 1 (The University of Chicago Press, 1970); Bo McMillan, “Richard Wright and the Black Metropolis: From the Great Migration to the Urban Planning Novel,” American Literature 92, no. 4 (2020): 65380; Amani C. Morrison, “Black Spatial Affordances and the Residential Ecologies of the Great Migration,” Environment and Society 13, no. 1 (2022): 4359. 2 The United States Census Bureau, https:// data.census.gov (accessed February 16, 2026). 3 Victor H. Green (ed.), The Negro Motorist Green Book: An International Travel Guide (Victor H. Green & Co., 1936–1966). See also Helen Anne Gibson, “Joyriding Across the Color Line: Automotivity and Citizenship in the United States, 1895 to 1939,” PhD diss., Freie Universität Berlin, 2021. 4 Nia Easley, The Last Green Book, (2022). https://books.google.com/books/about/The_ Last_Green_Book.html?id=N95xzwEACAAJ. 5 Saidiya Hartman, “Venus in Two Acts,” Small Axe: A Caribbean Journal of Criticism 12, no. 2 (2008): 114; Jessica Marie Johnson, “Markup Bodies: Black [Life] Studies and Slavery [Death] Studies at the Digital Crossroads,” Social Text 36, no. 4 (2018): 5779; Jihan Sherman, Romi Morrison, Lauren Klein & Daniela Rosner, “The Power of Absence: Thinking with Archival Theory in Algorithmic Design,” Proceedings of the 2024 ACM Designing Interactive Systems Conference, pp. 214–23 (2024). 6 Also see Mina Bloom, “Artist Explores Little-Known History of Avondale’s Black Settlers With New Walking Tours,” Block Club Chicago (2019), https://blockclubchicago. org/2019/09/05/fascinated-by-avondalesblack-settlers-artist-leads-tours-to-helpneighbors-feel-more-connected/. 7 Douglas S. Massey, “American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass,” American Journal of Sociology 96, no. 2 (1990): 329–57; Natalie Y. Moore, The South Side: A Portrait of Chicago and American Segregation (Macmillan, 2016).
Nora Akawi + Eduardo Rega Calvo
Architectures ofTransmission in the JawlAn
Architectures of Transmission in the JawlAn 82
Nora Akawi is a Palestinian architect and educator based in New York, currently an assistant professor at the Cooper Union. In her research and teaching, she studies bordering and ruination as the architectural project of settlercolonialism, and its refusal through anti-colonial spatial practices of land defense. Eduardo Rega Calvo is an architect and educator from the Canary Islands living in New York. He is a senior lecturer of architecture at the University of Pennsylvania’s Weitzman School of Design. His teaching and practice explore architecture’s militant potential to participate in social and environmental movements for justice.
Political Science, Cultural Geography
“W
e refuse the epistemicide that exists in our communities,” affirms Valiana Aguilar, co-founder of Colectivo Suumil Móokt’aan for defending land and food sovereignty. “In coming back to these communal ways of living,” she adds, “we are resisting, and we are refusing to forget.”1 For Aguilar, speaking from Yucatan during the conference “Palestine: Reimagining Solidarity” in May 2021, this refusal is a return to and insistence on transgenerational communalist ways of life, of food, of healing, and of collective learning: We are also trying to exchange our ancestral seeds, that have memories of 10,000 years, and that’s a way of refusing to forget who we are. And sometimes it’s hard, because this war has been waged against us for 500 years, […] but we also know that this long night of 500 years was a night where our grandparents used to pass their learnings and their knowledge in the dark. […] We know how to keep this knowledge, learning in communal ways, in our practices in the night. We say, that’s the way we walk.2
Aguilar explains that to move beyond solidarity, these learnings and practices must be shared. By extracting seeds, nurturing and sharing them, Palestinian farmer Yousef Abu Rabee, too, returned to the land in Beit Lahia during Israel’s latest genocidal onslaught in Gaza: We’re talking about a practical annihilation of the agricultural sector, whether livestock, crops, or local food industries. […] Many plots of agricultural land have been razed to the ground, huge swathes of land bulldozed. […] Today, as we return to cultivation, we’re back to ground zero. […] We went back to farming, my brother, father and myself - it’s in our blood to tend the land. Today, we source seeds from plant remains – we dry them and extract their seeds. [This] encouraged other farmers to return and attempt to make some of the land arable again. There was a return.3
Abu Rabee describes the nurturing of seedlings for the people of the besieged north in Gaza as a return and as resistance to Israel’s genocide and starvation. Before he was targeted and martyred near his nursery on October 21, 2024, Abu Rabee said in a widely distributed video that “despite all this destruction, people are still insisting on staying, planting, and wanting to rebuild again.”4 The practices of land and life defense described by Aguilar and Abu Rabee, taking place in and tending to “resistant ecologies,” are echoed across the world.5 In the following pages, we move through instances and architectures that hold both spectacular and day-to-day practices of refusal and land defense facing Israeli settler-colonialism in the occupied Jawlan (Golan Heights). The military technologies of genocidal devastation are an apparatus of a colonial time-and-space regime. Targeting all that defies and perforates colonial– capitalist futures on stolen lands, such technologies turn into rubble cities, towns, schools, hospitals, ports, and farms. Territorial land grabs and demarcations for military training deploy ruination on pasts, presents, and futures all at once. They are the toxification of environments and the poisoning of flesh, water, and soil. They are the prisons, borders, checkpoints, and other carceral infrastructures engineering family separation and exile. They are the archival, archaeological, and educational institutions and operations attempting to overwrite Indigenous claims to the land. They are the architectures of deprivation and denial of all
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 83
stages of living, aging, and death - in birth, in incubation, in childhood, in burial, and in commemoration. The architecture of Zionist settler-colonialism is exercised as a lethal force and as a mediatic construction attempting the annihilation of Indigenous life-worlds and the engineered homing of the settler. And yet, its technologies, however lethal, remain unable to contain native rootedness and futurity on the land. The defense of land and life as anti-colonial resistance—militant and otherwise—in Palestine and beyond erodes and breaks with the carceral time-and-space regime imposed by Israeli settler-colonialism and offers glimpses into futures where its oppressive architectures are dismantled. In this text, we refer to architectures of transmission as decolonial spatial and temporal operations that break out of colonial time by undoing, if temporarily, its mechanisms and technologies.6 “Transmission” comes from the Latin transmissiō, transmissionem.7 It refers to an act of sending across, discharging, releasing, or launching. Unlike terms such as “signaling” or “broadcasting,” which primarily denote communication, transmission is both communication and movement. In Arabic, transmission is both intilāq (launching, or discharging) and intiqāl (transitioning, transporting). In revolutionary discourse, we are reminded by Nasser Abourahmeh, Palestinian refugee camps were referred to as training sites or launching bases (qawa’id intilāq), “where the word intilāq connotes both a physical launching of a body or object into space and a start or beginning.”8 In the words of scholar and writer Adam HajYahia, “we must not mistake Palestinian return as something that will occur in the future.” He continues: Rather, it occurs and has been occurring throughout this present moment to enable a future - a future that escapes the economic speculation of racial capitalism into an indeterminate future that isn’t yet molded, one that could be retrieved, that could be emancipated from colonial financialization. With every shattered fence in Gaza, bombarded checkpoint in Jerusalem, clandestine escape from Tulkarm, surreptitious break out of the Gilboa prison, stealthy act of smuggling out of Jenin, and annual activations of Iqrith or Bir’im—physical, literal returns to places of dispossession despite military, legal and carceral prohibitions—we have been returning time and again, accumulating negative spells of time, no matter how short or fleeting they are, as returned beings. Some returns are spectacular revolutionary moments, others are conspicuous and modest in imagination, but they all bring us closer to liberation, feeding into one another.9
Architectures of decolonial transmission act as spatial-temporal interruptions and erosions of the colonial and carceral time-and-space regime. In the following pages, we move through architectures that hold both spectacular and day-to-day land-based practices of refusal and memory in the occupied Syrian Jawlan, involving actions such as un-appearances and withdrawals, launchings and ruptures, refusals and returns, reverberations and reenactments, hauntings and echoes. The Israeli occupation of the Jawlan is part of a dense Zionist settler-colonial project that continues to expand.10 In 1967, Israel occupied the western two thirds of the Jawlan and forcibly displaced nearly 130,000 inhabitants (95% of the population), their villages and farms systematically destroyed by the Israeli occupation forces.
Architectures of Transmission in the Jawlan 84
Occupied lands were declared “closed military zones” and their populations banned from returning to their homes. The small remaining population of Indigenous Syrian inhabitants was in the Alawite village of Ghajar, on the Lebanese border, and in four mostly Druze villages (Majdal Shams, Mas’ada, Buq’atha, and Ein Qiniya) along the south-east slopes of Jabal Al Shaikh (Mount Hermon).11 The Indigenous Syrian population in the Jawlan, around 28,000 inhabitants today, has struggled against an Israeli military occupation that affects all aspects of life, including the repression of Indigenous culture and education; the expanding land grab and suffocation of Syrian towns; environmental violence and resource exploitation; and the attempted erasure of collective memory and connection to the land. The occupied Jawlan is home to transgenerational practices of refusal and resistance, marked by the months-long general strike in 1982 against Israeli annexation and a collective rejection of the colonizer’s citizenship, as well as a persistent refusal of socalled borders; the creation of land-based educational and arts initiatives; archival retrievals and commemoration; and organized marches and festivals asserting Syrian Indigenous șumūd and defiance on their lands.12 Histories of Jawlani resistance resound in the collaborative, pedagogical, and curatorial project Antum Al-Saūt; Wa Nahnu Sadāh (You Are The Voice; We Are Its Echo). In its exhibition form, it features contributions from long-term collaborators, including a film, an art installation, and a reading room for collective study developed in collaboration with the Mapping Memories of Resistance project.13 The assembled documents in the reading room include transcribed conversations, sound archives, newspaper clippings, protest posters, videos, and a curriculum of books, articles, and films documenting and historicizing the lineage, continuity, and solidarity in resistance practices in the occupied Jawlan. According to a statement from Al-Marsad–Arab Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Golan, the Jawlani struggle against occupation is inseparable from the Syrian struggle against tyranny.14 In their essay “Jawlān,” Aamer Ibraheem and Adrien Zakar remind us of the words “You Are The Voice; We Are Its Echo,” which Jawlanis proclaimed in March 2011 during the nascent Syrian revolution. In the aftermath of the Israeli occupation of the Golan Heights in June 1967, “families were shattered, and the only way for them to communicate and maintain kinship ties was to stand on both sides of a valley crossed by the fortified ceasefire line, carrying binoculars and handheld megaphones […] holding lengthy conversations with friends and relatives.”15 As this echo, the reverberations of the struggle for liberation across the valley, “produces the repetition of a sound by the reflection of waves, Jawlanis’ actions become reflections of wor(l)ds, slogans and aspirations rippling through the border.”16 Such architectures of decolonial transmission, interrupting or dismantling the settlercolonial border regime in the occupied Jawlan, appear below in different forms: as rupture, as reverberation, and as refusal. Transmission as Rupture The infrastructures militarizing the so-called border in the occupied Jawlan have been consistently refused. Along the 1974 Ceasefire line near Majdal Shams is the Shouting Hill, or rather, the Valley of Tears, to capture the “emotional and psychological
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 85
wrenching that is counted in generations rather than years.”17 Jawlani activist and archivist Ayman Abu Jabal describes the surveillance, spyware, thermal sensors, and mines planted around the valley and along the illegally constructed, militarized wall, and its transgression in 2011. On May 15, 2011, marches of return were organized simultaneously from Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, and Egypt, as well as across occupied Palestine. Thousands of demonstrators marched toward the barbed wire in Majdal Shams’s Valley of Tears, which separates the occupied Jawlan from the rest of Syria. Protesters were mostly Palestinian and Syrian youth whose families had been forcibly displaced since 1948 and 1967. The crowds gathered in Majdal Shams, cheering, filming, and warning the protestors of the mines beneath their feet. Israeli border patrols opened fire, killing five protesters and injuring dozens. Overwhelming the occupation forces, hundreds of the protesters breached the fence and joined the crowds in Majdal Shams, where they were met with sweets, chants, and a march through the town in a collective liberatory rejection of the architectures of separations, and a synchronized chant for Palestinian and Syrian dignity, justice, and freedom. Here, we consider transmission as rupture, a spatial and temporal perforation of the colonizer’s map, where lifeworlds and kinships flow and flood, breaking settler enclosure. The few hours that the protesters spent in return expand to hold returned futures and practices of return past and present, both invisible and spectacular. “The protesters,” recalls Abu Jabal, “were protected by a human-chain created by the residents of Majdal Shams, and were able to cross back safely to Al Yarmouk refugee camp and other parts of Syria.”18 Transmission as Reverberation In the heart of Majdal Shams’s public square stands a transgenerational monument to anti-colonial struggle. In an essay on the politics of Jawlani art as Indigenous resistance against settler-state hegemony, Wael Tarabieh and Munir Fakher Eldine write: The 1982 popular mobilization against the Israeli colonial annexation of the Golan Heights left enduring impact on public spaces in the Jawlani villages. In the subsequent two decades, the main squares of Majdal Shams and Buq’atha won several sculptures that asserted the Jawlanis’ connection to the land and their national identity. Indirectly expressing the popular sentiment against the Israeli claim of sovereignty over the Golan, all these sculptures returned to the Syrian national memory of anticolonial fight, martyrdom, and quest for liberation from French colonial rule.19
Such activations of public space significantly took place through the framework of Rabitat al Jami’iyyin (Golan Academics Association—GAA), or Al-Rabita, a “democratic popular institution […] using volunteer work to educate and spread knowledge, and to offer community services.”20 Tarabieh and Fakher Eldin elaborate specifically about Al Masirah (“The March,” 1987), a sculpture by artist and then-Al-Rabita member Hassan Khater, and the first of such activations. The two central figures of the sculpture symbolize the “two pillars of the nation,” armed struggle and education.21 Sultan Basha al-Atrash, the leader of the Great Syrian Revolution against French colonial rule (1925–1927), raises his sword toward the colonizer; next to him stands a young man holding a book. Around them kneels a local religious man with his rifle, signaling Jawlani participation in the 1925 revolt, and a mother mourning over the body of a
1 Valiana Aguilar, First Movement in “Palestine: Reimagining Solidarity – A Conference of Butterflies” (May 23, 2021) transcribed and published in Capetillo: Journal for Crafting Futures/ Revista para tallerear futuros (Loudreaders Trade School and Women and Gender Studies, Universidad de Puerto Rico, 2025), 32. 2 Ibid. 3 Ali Dola & Said Alnajjar, “Seedlings of SelfSustenance in Famine-Stricken Gaza,” Mada Masr (September 25, 2024). 4 Yousef M. Aljamal, “Planting Seeds of Sovereignty in Gaza,” The Electronic Intifada (22 October 2024), https://electronicintifada. net/content/planting-seeds-sovereigntygaza/49561. 5 See Munira Khayyat, A Landscape of War: Ecologies of Resistance and Survival in South Lebanon (University of California Press, 2022). 6 See Rasheedah Phillips, Dismantling the Master’s Clock: On Race, Space, and Time (AK Press, 2025). 7 Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. transmission, Oxford University Press. For more on transmission as a theoretical framework, see Chapter 11 in Eduardo Cadava & Sara NadalMelsió, Politically Red (MIT Press, 2023). 8 Nasser Abourahme, “The Camp,” Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East 40, no. 1 (2020): 40. 9 Adam HajYahia, “The Principle of Return: The Repressed Ruptures of Zionist Time,” Parapraxis Magazine (April 7, 2024), https:// www.parapraxismagazine.com/articles/theprinciple-of-return. 10 Al-Marsad—Arab Human Rights Center in the Golan Heights, “Violations by Israeli Occupation Forces in Syrian Areas Occupied after the Fall of Bashar al-Assad’s Regime on December 8, 2024: February–June 2025,” AlMarsad, (November 6, 2025), https://golanmarsad.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/ February-June-2025.pdf. 11 Muna Dajani, Munir Fakher Eldin & Michael Mason, “Introduction: Representing the Occupied Jawlan/Golan,” in M. Dajani, et al. (eds), The Untold Story of the Golan Heights: Occupation, Colonization and Jawlani Resistance (Bloomsbury, 2022), 1–19. 12 See Bashar Tarabieh, “Education, Control and Resistance in the Golan Heights,” Middle East Report no. 194–95 (July/August 1995): 43–47. 13 Antum Al-Saūt; Wa Nahnu Sadāh (You Are The Voice; We Are Its Echo) is a co-produced group exhibition for the Chicago Architecture Biennial 5: This Is a Rehearsal, curated by The Floating Museum, Graham Foundation for Advanced Studies in the Fine Arts, Chicago, 2023 to 2024. Participants include Nora Akawi and Eduardo Rega [interim], Jumanah Abbas, Nadine Fattaleh, Muna Dajani (Mapping Memories of Resistance), Khaled Malas (Sigil Collective), Daniel Ruiz, Emad Madah, and Rami Nakhle.
Architectures of Transmission in the Jawlan 86
martyred fighter. Behind them stand three children holding a school briefcase and a pile of wheat, symbolizing the education and prosperity of future generations.22 In the film presented in Antum Al-Saūt; Wa Nahnu Sadāh, Ayman Abu Jabal, facing the sculpture, explains that “days after its inauguration, a bomb was planted on this sculpture and detonated at sunrise. Upon hearing the explosion, people gathered here.” He adds that “within less than twenty-four hours, artist Hassan Khater rehabilitated the structure with the protection of the people.”23 Education has been a critical site of struggle against colonial domination to protect the youth from the settler-state’s indoctrination strategies and maintain future generations’ ties to the land and collective memories of resistance. Artist and educator Wael Tarabieh explains that the occupation immediately introduced an especially designed curriculum for the Druze population of the Jawlan. Schools were heavily policed, and teachers and students were targeted. In response, Al-Rabita created kindergartens, weekly political and educational programs, guest lecturers, courses of art, drama and languages, book exhibits, and cultural events.24 Upholding transgenerational education and memory transmission, local organizations cooperated to create an even more ambitious project between 1985 and 1992: summer camps that performed as spaces for political education, where children and youth learned from the land through song and enacted traditions, ways of making home, healing, eating, and gathering. Architect Jumanah Abbas writes: Each camp, collectively representing appropriated Jawlani lands, would individually symbolize each of the destroyed villages. In each tent, children would learn about the history and the urban geography of the villages, as well as the history of expelled families, their roots, traditions, and socio-cultural practices. […] In each annual cycle, the names of the camps changed according to major events that were suppressed in school teaching.25
In 1988, when the Israeli police arrived to arrest the summer camp’s organizers, over a thousand people rallied to defend them.26 As the camps were targeted, educators and organizers created new ways to pass these learnings to future generations, most recently in programs like Al Marsad’s art education program, New Ways of Seeing, and the Jawlan Cultural Days festival.27 These practices of public art and education are spaces for studying, safeguarding, and reproducing histories of anti-colonial struggle and Indigenous connection to the land in the Jawlan and beyond. Transmission as reverberation, here, is the collective intergenerational practice of collective learning, piercing through colonial time and resisting epistemic erasure. Transmission as Refusal Colonial strategies for land dispossession are repetitive and predictable. They deploy design and construction toward the scorching of the earth and the annihilation of life-worlds. They include designations of closed military zones for archaeological excavations or military bases, often to be replaced with illegal settlements with vast areas for agricultural industries, natural reserves, ski resorts, or military training camps. In the Jawlan, as in the Naqab (South of Palestine), one of the main machineries of land dispossession is military training.28
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 87
In September 2025, Israeli occupation forces opened a new training compound in the Jawlan, pathologically dubbed “Little Lebanon” as the “northern counterpart to Little Gaza,” a “mock Palestinian village” in the Tze’elim base in the Naqab.29 It includes “four-story apartment blocks, single-story homes, narrow alleys, and a network of tunnels. Some areas have been deliberately reduced to rubble to resemble bombed-out neighborhoods, allowing soldiers to train in spaces resembling wardamaged villages.”30 The new training site is built on the ruins of the Syrian town of Za’oura, layered with the construction of “mock towns” to be later demolished in preparation for designed devastation and toxification elsewhere. Here, settlercolonial architecture, in its attempt to perpetuate the denialist direction of colonial time, emerges in its clearest form: a relentless, iterative machine for the expansion of designed destruction targeting Indigenous pasts, presents, and futures all at once. Yet these are consistently refused. Jawlanis often visit and activate the sites of destroyed and forcibly depopulated towns, villages, and farms, insisting on holding on to their ancestral connections and futures in these lands. For example, despite tightening military enclosures, beekeepers distribute beehive boxes across areas they can access for apiculture.
14 Al-Marsad, “Syria Is Free from the Rule of the Assad Family,” (December 12, 2024), https://golan-marsad.org/wp-content/ uploads/2024/12/Syria-is-free-from-the-ruleof-the-Assad-family.pdf. 15 Aamer Ibraheem & Adrien Zakar, “Jawlān,” Middle East Journal of Culture and Communication 15, no. 4 (November 2022): 364. 16 Ibid., 365. 17 Dajani, Eldin & Mason, “Introduction,” 4. 18 Interviewed in film by N. Akawi, E. Rega Calvo [interim] and D. Ruiz, as it appeared at the Graham Foundation in 2023–2024. 19 Wael Tarabieh & Munir Fakher Eldin, “Sculptures in Jawlani Public Spaces: Reflections on the Work of Identity” in The Untold Story of the Golan Heights, 87. 20 Ibid., 92. 21 Ibid., 87–104. 22 Ibid. 23 See note 18. 24 Tarabieh, “Education.”
A farmer and beekeeper interviewed for Antum Al-Saūt; Wa Nahnu Sadāh expresses his concern over a looming large-scale wind turbine project and its effects on the landscape’s ecosystems. Indeed, in violation of international law, Energix’s wind energy development in the occupied Golan Heights prolongs illegal occupation under the guise of climate-change mitigation. Masked by environmental rhetoric, wind farms in the Jawlan have operated as another tool for limiting Indigenous access to land.31 In addition to disturbing the local ecology and sonic landscape, the wind turbines’ development in the Jawlan was strategically located to operate as a kind of border, preventing the expansion of Arab towns.32 Protests and organizing against this project continue through social mobilization and legal avenues. As in Palestine, nature reserves in the Jawlan are also weaponized for land dispossession. Since 1967, in an act of greenwashing the occupation, the Israel Nature and Parks Authority has marked lands to be expropriated and designated as military zones and nature reserves. Water basins were extracted and streams diverted to disproportionately serve state-sponsored settler agriculture and tourism industries.33 Prior to the Israeli occupation in 1967, Omar Tesdell, Muna Dajani, and Alaa Iktash write that “Jawlanis were actively involved in shaping an agroecological landscape under autonomous conditions of resource use and management, adapting and adjusting their cropping selections and patterns based on climatic conditions, elevation, and accessibility to water resources.”34 In the 1950s, they explain, agriculture expanded in the Jawlan through a Hajmeh, a rush to the land, where farmers relied on local knowledge of available waterways and springs, as well as on collective efforts to bring water to the cultivated lands.35 Systematically deprived of adequate water access, Jawlani farmers respond with an autonomous water infrastructure to bypass apartheid restrictions, creating cooperative agricultural infrastructure and constructing tanks in farmlands to collect rainwater. With the criminalization of water collection, the farmers are fined and the tanks are targeted, even shot at and perforated by Israeli military forces. Despite that, and during Israeli holidays to avoid the fine collectors, a prefabricated water tank is
25 Jumanah Abbas, “Landscapes of Education in the Golan Heights,” Arab Urbanism (June 5, 2020), https://www.araburbanism.com/ magazine/landscapes-of-education. 26 Tarabieh, “Education.” 27 See Al-Marsad, “Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights Project” (October 29, 2025), https://golan-marsad.org/economic-socialand-cultural-rights/. 28 State Comptroller of Israel, State Comptroller’s Annual Report 71B, 2021, “Training Areas by IDF Unit 9900, May 2020,” in IDF Land Training Areas (English edition) (Office of the State Comptroller, 2021), https:// library.mevaker.gov.il/sites/DigitalLibrary/ Documents/2021/71B-Bitachon/2021-71BBitachon-Taktzirim-EN.pdf. 29 Yoav Zitun, “IDF Unveils ‘Little Lebanon’ Training Facility to Prepare for Future Hezbollah Battles,” Ynet News, (September 4, 2025), https://www.ynetnews.com/article/ r1cbbcp9ee. 30 Zein Khalil & Tarek Chouiref, “Israeli Army Opens Training Compound in Syria’s Golan Heights to Simulate Combat in Southern Lebanon,” Anadolu Agency (September 7, 2025), https://www.aa.com. tr/en/middle-east/-israeli-army-openstraining-compound-in-syria-s-golanheights-to-simulate-combat-in-southernlebanon/3680754. 31 See also Noura Alkhalili, Muna Dajani & Yahia Mahmoud, “The Enduring Coloniality of Ecological Modernization: Wind Energy Development in Occupied Western Sahara and the Occupied Syrian Golan Heights,” Political Geography 103 (May 2023): Article 102871. See also Al-Marsad, “Natural Resource Exploitation” (March 2025), https://golanmarsad.org/natural-resource-exploitation-2/.
Architectures of Transmission in the Jawlan 88
Clockwise from Top Left: Water tank in the Jawlan; Beehives in Za'oura; Birket Ram (Ram Lake) in the Jawlan; Film still of Al Masirah monument in Majdal Shams; Film still of the border wall in the Valley of Tears.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 89
installed in under 24 hours. In their refusal of settler infrastructures of destruction and enclosure, native farmers build more-than-human alliances for mutual support, defending futurities of Indigenous life and ecosystems in ancestral lands. Devastation, toxification, and containment are tools deployed by the settler-colonial machine in its targeting of native life-worlds. In the Jawlan, in the face of this lethal architecture of denial, Indigenous resistance and practices of land defense weave life-affirming refusal into the very fabric of the land. As Valiana Aguilar reminds us, these practices are an insistence on ancestral memory and communal ways of life against colonial and capitalist erasure. They are the rupture of the border wall; the beehive in the closed military zone; and the water tank built in a day. They are the reverberations of histories and futures of resistance in the town square and in the summer camp. These architectures of decolonial transmission are held together by human chains, interlinked to protect the organizers and educators of youth summer camps from arrest, surround the artist repairing the vandalized monument to anticolonial defiance, and defend the border-transgressing protestors from settler military violence. They are transmissions that pierce through the colonial matrix of power and its time regime, in defense of uncapturable and ungovernable native life on this land.36
32 See also Lawrence Abu Hamdan and Earshot, Zifzafa, digital project and installation, 2025. 33 Omar Tesdell, Muna Dajani & Alaa Iktash, “Being in Place: On the Jawlan Formation and the Agroecological History of Highlands,” The Untold Story of the Golan Heights, 161–75. 34 Ibid., 168. 35 Ibid., 161–75. 36 See Aníbal Quijano, “Coloniality of Power, Eurocentrism, and Latin America,” Nepantla: Views from South 1, no. 3 (2000): 533–80.
Acknowledgment The title of this paper and reflections on architectures of transmission in this text originate from a presentation titled “Scales of Transmission,” delivered by co-author Nora Akawi as part of the “Transmissions” panel of the Realtime Urbanism symposium organized by Farzin Lotfi-Jam at Cornell University in April 2023.
IN conversation with
Andrea Roberts Andrea Roberts is a planning historian, theorist, public humanities scholar, place preservationist, and educator. She is associate professor in Urban + Environmental Planning at the University of Virginia (UVA), where she is also the Director of the Center for Cultural Landscapes (CCL), an interdisciplinary center that conducts research and develops new models of innovative cultural landscape stewardship and critical perspectives on placemaking. Roberts’ public scholarship and research identify planning and historic preservation practices that sustain cultural resilience, with a specific focus on Black efficacy in these practices, grassroots planning history, and contemporary place-preservation practices with settlements founded by formerly enslaved Africans in the Americas. As a scholar activist, Roberts brings more than a decade of experience in community and economic development to her scholarship. Roberts is the founder of The Texas Freedom Colonies Project, a research and social justice initiative documenting placemaking history and grassroots preservation practices in the African Diaspora. She sat down with Azzurra Cox to talk about her recent efforts launching the Out(sider) Preservation Initiative.
+ Can you talk briefly about your role at UVA’s Center for Cultural Landscapes and how your scholarship more broadly relates to memory?
I’ve been on a journey of linking knowledge to action, of bridging theory to practice. The knowledge piece is local knowledge and knowledge-making that occur at the community level. How do we bridge that to where decisions happen? My background is in city government: I was a deputy budget director for the City of Philadelphia after I left Penn, and later for the City of Houston, I worked in finance, as well as housing and community development. Throughout those processes, I was looking at how public engagement was happening – who was showing up, who wasn’t being listened to and why. I was also really taken by the language people were using to describe their communities and their places, which wasn’t necessarily the language used to describe or classify the places within the planning processes. Those kinds of disconnects led me back to grad school. There was also a treasure trove of funeral programs that my grandmother had. Starting to explore those and my family history, I began to see a disconnect between what I was doing every day and the communities that were classified, organized, and named, such as my father’s home community of Riceville in Southwest Houston – a freedom colony. I had no consciousness of any of this until much later, and the way I came to that consciousness of our rootedness in places that we created was through ephemera. It was through personal archival memory. That’s how I came to understand the power of memory in place. That led to a deep exploration of how
in conversation with andrea roberts 92
people talk about place, which is usually through storytelling. There is a certain level of validity granted to that type of knowledge in urban planning, and that’s often to either contain it, enclose it, figure out how to manage it, or to make it a nice introductory paragraph to a very large document. And so I became very interested in how to make this knowledge and these places visible in planning processes. At the same time, while I was in grad school, some people in the eastern part of Texas invited me to the annual Purple Hull Pea Festival. There, I met Lareatha Clay, who introduced me to Shankleville, a freedom colony. I began to learn from them the ways that they were bridging their freedom colony to the worlds of tourism and community development. And as I was witnessing that, I found how central their origin story was to communicating who they were. Their origin story tells of two enslaved Africans reunited in Texas after the husband, who had run away from a slave holder in Mississippi, had crossed three great rivers to reconnect with his love. That story of love, tenacity, and reconnection is what drew descendants back; it also drew new people. The power of that story led to action and to real planning outcomes; it catalyzed commitments to historical markers, festivals, and homestead preservation. I saw the knowledge-to-action bridge and then got really interested in where else it is happening. How are the rest of those communities using those stories? + I appreciate the idea of using these origin stories and more ephemeral motivations to move toward real outcomes. One formative experience in how I think about memory in place is grounded in Seattle’s Africatown. When I lived in Seattle, I volunteered with K. Wyking Garrett, who is an incredible community leader and now a power broker in the city, to move the Africatown Community Land Trust from idea to action. Over the last eight years, I’ve witnessed this organization shift from imagining Africatown— collectively creating a vision for the Central District as a destination for diasporic Black Seattle—to, among other things, developing and building affordable housing in one of the most competitive housing markets in the country. I’m also interested in the family ephemera you found in your grandmother’s house. We’re living in a time of so much work around democratizing the archive. How have you encountered that in your work? I encounter it in my work in promoting the principle of co-creation. For example, I consider the work of The Texas Freedom Colonies Project Atlas to be the co-creation of an archive. Often, people look to the archive for validation. But if you’re co-creating the archive, then how valid is that? There’s sort of a psychological decolonization, if you will, inherent in the process that I’m trying to promote through the Atlas, where your addition is what makes the corpus. If you don’t add it, then it continues not to exist. Even though you intend for people to take their funeral programs and their homecoming programs and their family photos and their handwritten and typed stories to upload them along with the survey, they often can’t believe that adding or sharing all of that is real archival work; that it’s what really proves that a place existed. The Atlas seeks to subvert the notion that the archive is already complete and that if you aren’t there already, you aren’t legitimate and don’t belong there. + That resonates with Sam Carter-Shamai’s essay in this issue of LA+ – his observations on the limits of official archival and planning documents, and on all the powerful information that is contained in how people talk about and remember a place. You’ve already touched on this, but can you say more about the inception of the Out(sider) Preservation Initiative? What does this program hope to add to the field of preservation? And what are your goals for it? One of my passions is art, particularly Southern, African-American “outsider” or “intuitive” art that is divinely inspired. Fundamentally, it’s about people who have an almost missionary zeal and dedication to creativity that was not taught in an institution. I’ve found a lot of parallels between those individuals and the people
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 93
I’ve developed relationships with over time. For example, working with different communities on The Texas Freedom Colonies archiving projects, I noticed that these individuals were very similar in their mentality to those of the outsider artists. And I thought, these are outsider preservationists. They’re not formally trained in cultural resource management or preservation. They’re operating outside of institutions, some of them even outside of the existing grassroots institutions in their community. People say, well, all preservation is grassroots. It really isn’t. In many instances, there is baked-in elitism: expectations around assimilation, around compulsory heterosexuality, and the type of family stories that are okay to tell and not tell. There are built-in ideas about respectability politics and African-American preservation, especially among more established organizations. And so that is the other “outsider” piece that I wanted to capture, or make space for, in the historic preservation conversation. It’s not the mere fact of Blackness. It is how these people are challenging the object of preservation and the definition of expertise, what their approaches are, and thinking even more broadly about preservation for African Americans as being very much about conservation. I don’t think that is unique to historic Black settlements generally founded after the Civil War and before the Civil Rights movement, but it’s something that I’ve particularly dug into with their descendant communities. Broadly, the initiative is a Mellon-funded project launched in late 2023, with four components that feed into one another. The first component is to create a space for different collectivities by bringing people together. We held a symposium on East meets West descendant communities in 2023, for example, where people from Central Virginia counties met with people from Nicodemus, Kansas. These trainings and symposia form communities of practice and develop pedagogy, which is the second component. How do we show up and ask, what is it you need exactly? How do we develop a class tailored to what you need and what you can teach? And how is this a symbiotic process? The third component entails giving direct grants to outsider preservationists to discover best practices, understand general needs, have a more robust definition of what an outsider preservationist is, and really learn what that practitioner profile entails. And then the final component is the web portal, which holds a space for those communities of practice, showcases preservation pedagogy, and platforms the work of our grantees as an entryway into the world of descendant community place-preservation work. This portal builds on what we did with The Texas Freedom Colonies Project, but instead of making it about points on a map, it’s more about the people in the places and creating a mechanism for them to map it if they’d like. + One thing I learned from my work with Greenwood Cemetery, a historic Black cemetery outside of St. Louis, is that there are so many parallels between places and between efforts. At Greenwood Cemetery, 30 acres of a key historic, sacred site had been completely erased from the map due to neglect and market forces. Etta Daniels—again, thanks to seemingly divine inspiration and dedication—almost singlehandedly put this place back on the map. In the last decade or so, there’s been a whole local preservation association run by amazing individuals who are carrying that work forward. But I think the idea that this should not be lonely work, that it should not be dependent on one elder to dedicate decades of their life to keep these memories and these places alive, makes building this broader community so important. It is. I always tell people that, whatever capacity I’m working in, I have a spiritual contract to make the invisible visible. And that’s often literally what it’s about for these folks that I’ve been working with over time, because places are erased from the map. So how do you make them visible again? Their drive is often to ensure places aren’t forgotten, but they also intend to bridge the work to younger generations.
in conversation with andrea roberts 94
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 95
Sustainability is a big part of the Out(sider) Preservation Initiative. One of our grantees works between Houston and rural Crockett, Texas, conducting workshops in which elders share their memories with young people. We are centering artistic or creative approaches to place-based heritage to attract younger folks who might not ordinarily work in organizations or church groups that engage older generations. +The Out(sider) Preservation Initiative particularly highlights the role of culture, performance, and storytelling as a way to make the invisible visible. Can you say more about that focus and how alternative media have come to life in this first round of grantmaking? One example is the Pecan Project, a Texas-based project that tells the stories of trail riders. There is a long African-American cowboy tradition, and there are young people carrying it forward. Our grantee is doing what she calls reparative journalism to stake a claim to these communities and traditions. She is taking people on trail rides from major cities like Houston to East Texas, and she’s recording the trail rides to claim this cultural practice and take up space. It is this long memory of brothers and sisters on horses that she is elevating through these contemporary trail rides and gatherings. People are doing readings and sharing their art. I had photographs of my field work in freedom colonies exhibited at one of these gatherings. This is just one example of the way that people are engaging aspects of cultural performance. + Sounds like you’re describing a kind of embodied practice. Have you ever been to a Black rodeo? Yes, it was actually normal to grow up going to Black rodeo events, which doubled as R&B concerts. However, much later, as an adult, I learned that my great-grandmother on my father’s side married this man, John Sweeney, and they had the oldest Black rodeo this side of Mississippi.
+ I went to my first Black rodeo in Philadelphia this past summer. I saw a show that travels all over the country. It was so much fun, and also revelatory. I had never associated rodeos with Blackness before, and now I know that there’s this entire subculture that is very deeply rooted. It speaks to how powerful the whitewashing of culture can be, and how the response calls for claiming space, not only physically but also culturally. This brings me to the place-based focus of your work. This Out(sider) Preservation Initiative is highly place-based, yet Black descendant communities in this country tend to be highly diasporic. Can you talk about that tension and how memory lives deeply in place but also transcends geographic boundaries? And more practically, how are you going about selecting the particular geographies for each round of calls for proposals? The Texas Freedom Colonies Project Atlas is a virtual commemorative project. By extension, the Out(sider) Preservation Initiative web portal will also serve as a virtual commemorative platform. The idea is that by showcasing place-based work and adding a descendant-only facet of the portal, it becomes a virtual mecca for people to reconnect as descendants and to also be separated from the public gaze. We selected the different states by looking at where people came from before they moved to Texas, and where did they go after? Virginia was logical because just about all the White people who brought their enslaved with them at the inception of the Republic of Texas were of Virginia and Tennessee origins. Having included Virginia, and already working in Texas, we thought, how do we follow this Texas diaspora? From Virginia and then to Louisiana, often before Texas, and then from Texas or after enslavement, there was this movement to areas adjacent to plantations and the creation of freedom colonies. And then those freedom colony folks moved to large cities like Houston and Dallas, for example, and subsequently followed industries to places like Oakland, California.
in conversation with andrea roberts 96
So the pattern for the first round is to look at the cluster around Virginia, including North Carolina, Maryland, and DC; then at the cluster around Texas, including Louisiana; and then at California. We also included Nova Scotia as a more experimental look at the diaspora. There are over 50 historic Black freedom colonies founded by people who were from the Americas up in Nova Scotia, primarily founded between the late 18th and early 19th centuries. There were various opportunities for enslaved African Americans to fight for the British, and the British would, in exchange, give them land in Nova Scotia, which was hard and rocky and almost not viable. And so these folks said, you have this wonderful American experiment that you’re doing, and that’s really cool, but they’re giving us land and freedom right now, so see you later! So there’s a large number of folks, particularly from Virginia and Maryland, who went on to Nova Scotia.
I visited a community called Beechville. I went to their homecoming, interviewed folks, and had an opportunity to connect with them and learn their stories. They literally had a descendant from someone from Albemarle County, Virginia, which is where Charlottesville is. And they had t-shirts that traced their diasporic pattern, so they’re very conscious of this. They carry it on their t-shirts, mapping from here to here; in some cases, to Sierra Leone, to Jamaica, back to Nova Scotia. It’s a fascinating freedom-seeking story that we wanted to invest in as the next iteration of the diaspora, not directly tied to Texas. + Are you thinking of deepening your work in this geography, or do you want to expand or think about different links? Yes, we slightly expanded in the second round to South Carolina and Tennessee because people in their applications often referenced those geographies. We could do the whole United States, of course, but the idea is to look at places that are really not understood when we talk about Black placemaking, or not as foregrounded in our story. We have many Black placemaking stories about urban neighborhoods and urban centers, or about a homestead, and it’s your family story. But this other condition that entails the complete creation of a Black community or place, inclusive of all the institutions and decisions that accompany a town, is our focus. The work of the Out(sider) Preservation Initiative is how we look at the ways people have preserved and continue to preserve whole Black places, even when there is not much left. + That makes a lot of sense and is such a needed focus. Any initiative exists in an ecosystem of both efforts and places, and I’m curious how you would describe Out(sider) Preservation Initiative’s ecosystem. Where are you finding support and amplification? We get a lot of advisory support. We have a standing group of people we call freedom visionaries; people like Michelle Lanier, JT Roane, and Danielle Purifoy, who are exploring the areas of Black geographies, Black ecologies, and Black feminist landscape consciousness. Also important is looking at Black women’s emotional landscape, such as in Maia Butler’s work. These kinds of thinkers inform how we execute the project. And then we have our advisory board, which includes people like Jessica Marie Johnson, Julianne Chambliss, and other folks who are big in Black digital humanities, as well as Thaïsa Way and her exploration of the centrality of place. And of course, we have the Mellon Foundation and all the folks at the University of Virginia who are deeply engaged in descendant work. There is a large community of people in the region—either associated with the presidential homes or in some way tied back to these institutions and the numerous plantations—who are doing all manner of storytelling work, whether it be film or archival, so we’re in that cosmology as well.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 97
+ It strikes me that this community has made remarkable progress in the broadening of the archive in service of a more complete, painful truth. When I was growing up in Charlottesville in the late 1990s, unabashed adoration of Thomas Jefferson was alive and well; the full story of Sally Hemings was just starting to surface, and it was fairly controversial. As you talk about all the ways in which this ecosystem around activist history seems to be thriving, even in a place like Charlottesville, it reminds me of how far this work has come in the last 20 years. Yes, which is good to remember. At least it feels like there has been a flourishing. And now there is a backlash. The flourishing was precipitated in part by the murder of George Floyd, which sent a ripple throughout the world, academia, and cultural institutions. What I’ve been trying to do at the Center for Cultural Landscapes is, in everything we do, make sure we are confronting power, culture, land, and identity. That is our intention around the projects we decide to support and the types of scholarship we intend to produce. I have carried over most of my research projects, too, but we also host a range of guest speakers through the CCL Conversations series, which brings in scholars working on culture, land, identity, and power. We’ve had many great speakers come through just to cultivate community around cultural landscapes and the power of thinking at that scale. + We are living at a time of extremely and overtly racist revisionism of history. At the same time we’re fighting this backlash, there is an inevitable generational shift in which many of the memory-keepers and story-keepers in descendant communities are now elders. There is an urgent need for these stories to be passed down to the new generation of keepers, all while fighting against a nefarious and outrageous administration. So my last question is, is this affecting your work? Where are you finding hope? I think that the ways we’ve decided to prioritize geographies in our grantmaking also consider how repressive state governments are in those places, around public history and around school curriculum. So, while we don’t give directly to schools, we do invest in programs led by young people in those contexts. We find ourselves at a moment not only of repression, but of real opportunity to rethink what preservation is. The way I see this moment is that if you can pull the rug out from under an entire field by shutting down its regulatory complex, then you need to make your field about more than a regulatory complex. Seventy-five percent of what preservation is currently is regulation and regulatory enforcement. Those are good for something, but they are also part of a system of exclusion. And if your entire framework depends on only those components, it means that it wasn’t nimble or complex enough. I’ve been part of a conversation, and I’m putting together some writing, inviting folks to think through what we can rethink, from an outsider perspective, about preservation going forward. So I am very hopeful that we will get the lesson. If we don’t get the lesson and just put everything back the way it was, I don’t think that we’ve taken full advantage of the moment. But if we are willing to move toward the transformation of the field, I believe we will get there.
GWENDOLYN DORA COHEN
A HAndful of dirt Gwendolyn Dora Cohen is an assistant professor of landscape architecture at Auburn University. She holds a master of landscape architecture from the University of Virginia and a bachelor of fine arts from the Rhode Island School of Design. Her scholarship explores different ways that humans are connected to and by the ground. Through drawing, writing, and scientific collaborations, she explores stories that are embedded in soil.
LITERATURE
I
tend to collect dirt. Each handful of soil lives in a glass vial, labeled with a date and location. Each vial contains the memory of the moment I considered the ground beneath my feet and carefully, sometimes awkwardly, scooped a handful of it. Each vial displays different colors and textures; each vial contains the story of that specific soil, and it also contains my story.
Soil emerges through interactions of layered geological, biological, and cultural processes. Soil contains materials and organisms that “are so tightly coconstituted that there are no obvious ways of distinguishing where one entity ends and another begins.”1 The entities in this assemblage are bound together in a state of continuous generation.2 Soil is always forming and deforming, entangled with air, water, geology, plant roots, fungi, and microbes.3 Soils are relational. While soil is the literal ground beneath our feet, it is relatively invisible in our contemporary culture, often taken for granted or ignored.4 What does soil reveal when it appears in our stories, both lived and imagined? What does it mean to touch it and hold it in our hands? What memories does soil connect us to? Many cultural practices and creation stories are centered around soil, and deeply alter our relationship to it. In this essay, I reflect on moments in American fiction and memoirs where the author or characters form memories through the soil. Memories exist in the act of simultaneously being created and disappearing, forming “from associations of biological, mental, social, and material actors”; they are transitory and must be continuously recalled or practiced, or they are lost.5 On its own, a single memory, thought, or idea may not make sense, but our minds track the connections to make sense of the world around us.6 There are no precise ways to distinguish where memories end and begin because they, like soil, are relational. Stories, in turn, invoke our imagination and allow us to structure our memories and to share them with others.7 Our relationship to the soil beneath our feet changes throughout our lives. In childhood, dirt is often alive in our minds and is worthy of our touch and attention. In “Touching the Earth,” bell hooks reflects: When we love the earth, we are able to love ourselves more fully. I believe this. The ancestors taught me it was so. As a child I loved playing in dirt, in that rich Kentucky soil, that was a source of life.8
To hooks, the soil was a companion, and not yet a source of pain. Even in youth, the mysterious depth of the ground can be frightening. In Sarah Broom’s memoir, The Yellow House, she considers her relationship to the ground
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 99
A HANDFUL OF DIRT 100
while growing up in New Orleans. She recognizes that her “deep connection to this city’s soil” altered the way she thought about the world.9 During childhood games of hide and seek, Broom writes that, “Only the brave hide under Ms. Octavia’s house where the ground seems to be melting.”10 It is understood that no one will search there, as the perfect hiding place is “reserved for those more terrified of being ‘It’ than being eaten by the squishy earth.”11 She continues to reflect on this untrustworthy ground and how she and the other children in the neighborhood perceive it as an animate creature: “In our child-wise minds, the seal between deep ground and our present reality above that ground is string thin.”12 The duality between above and below did not exist in her world, where the ground is alive and she recognizes its agency in her above-ground life. In fiction, too, the soil holds memories. In Colson Whitehead’s alternative-history novel, The Underground Railroad, the young, enslaved protagonist, Cora, is introduced to the reader by way of a three-yard square patch of soil: “The dirt at her feet had a story, the oldest story Cora knew.”13 This soil and the garden it supports connect Cora to her grandmother, who claimed, tended, and protected the soil, and to her mother, who subsequently tended the same soil. When Cora’s mother vanishes, her grief removes the color from her world: “The first color to return was the simmering brown-red of the soil in her family’s plot. It reawakened her to people and things.”14 When Cora tends the garden, the dirt she removes from her fingernails is the same dirt the women who came before her touched. Cora’s relationship with the soil evolves as the novel progresses and the reimagined underground railroad offers her the potential for freedom. I don’t remember much about touching soil as a child. I remember the smell of the rain and watching lightning storms from the safety of a blue couch surrounded by books. I remember lightning bugs on summer evenings and impatiens seed pods bursting with the touch of a finger. If I ever played in muddy puddles, I don’t remember it. I probably wasn’t supposed to get dirty. I do remember when contractors dug a hole in our backyard: the soil was dark, and a thin white line of chalk ran through it. I picked out enough pieces of chalk to fill a small metal box. For many, the animacy of the ground disappears with adulthood, but there remains a desire to connect to place through touch. In the poem “Southern Song,” Margaret Walker longs to touch the soil, “To lay my hand again upon the clay baked by a / southern sun, to touch the rain-soaked earth and smell / the smell of soil.”15 This touch is not in the present; it is a memory and a desire. Walker wrote this poem in Chicago, away from the Southern landscape she invokes. In an interview, Walker recognizes her interconnectedness with the landscape, saying, “I am a part of this whole process of nature, that when we come together I am complete and it is complete because it is a part of me and I am part of it.”16 She also notes that in the
Southern landscape, the “social horror and the physical beauty are constantly there, and I talk about that in everything I write.”17 The memories of this soil are both beautiful and horrible; they contain opposing truths. Dirt is who we are: messy and complex, holding entire worlds. Our own microbiome is changed by touching soil, even if only briefly.18 In my early twenties, I first intentionally touched the ground. I was a student in a foraging workshop in a forest near Asheville, North Carolina. It was the first time that I began to learn the names of plants and recognize their differences. They became alive to me, no longer indecipherable green things, but things that give to the world. At the time, I felt trapped and alone. I was married to someone who suffered deeply from depression. We had moved to a town hours away from anyone we knew and he began to disassociate from the world. Delusions took over, and I tried to reason him out of them every night to keep our home safe, to keep our world from exploding, but I wasn’t able to make him better. During the foraging workshop, we were asked to lie on the forest floor to feel the forest. I was skeptical, and also afraid to allow myself to feel any emotions. But I did, and it brought me to tears. I felt the depth of the soil and the rock strata below that. I felt the roots below me. I felt the life that surrounded me and asked for nothing in return. The forest floor helped me decompose, and from there, I learned to forage and to garden. Eventually, I was strong enough to leave, and I continued to learn about grief and healing. I spent my days with dirt in my fingernails and my evenings reading. In the stories I read, I recognized pieces of myself reflected in the characters, and, over time, I discovered the stories of others who reached out and touched the dirt. In moments of grief and reconnection, we hold the soil in our hands, collect it, and immerse our bodies in it. It links us through time, as the particles and life in the soil become part of us. On the last page of The Good Earth by Pearl S. Buck, the protagonist Wang Lung picks up a handful of soil. He is near the end of his life—a life built from a deep respect for the land—and he overhears his sons planning to sell the land after his death. His reaction to this betrayal is deep and visceral; his sons catch him in their arms as he nearly falls over: The old man let his scanty tears dry upon his cheeks and they made salty stains there. And he stooped and took up a handful of soil and he held it and he muttered: ‘If you sell the land, it is the end.’19
In this moment of impending loss, Wang Lung holds in his hand both his memories and his deep connection to the living ground. In Octavia Butler’s speculative fiction novel, Parable of the Sower, the young protagonist, Lauren Olamina, returns to
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 101
her home after it was recently destroyed in an attack on her neighborhood. To her knowledge, her entire family is dead. She has returned to collect packets of money that had been hidden in the yard, but she also digs her hands into the soil. “First I spotted the hiding place, then I snatched up the money packet along with a hand full of dirt.”20 A few pages later, after she has left town, she “had a kind of tactile memory of grabbing the money packet and handful of dirt and stuffing both into my pack.”21 While the handful of dirt is not mentioned again in the novel, we can imagine that this last memory of her home endures. There are many times when a bare hand connecting to the soil is not enough. In her memoir, Reclamation, Gayle Jessup White recounts the moment she stepped into the original kitchen of Monticello after it had been unearthed by archeologists: Stooping to the ground, I rubbed my hands in the red clay and up my arms toward the sleeves of my yellow jacket, seeking an intimacy with the earth that my enslaved ancestors had once touched. Closing my eyes, I sense their struggle, their pride, their love, and their losses.22
The soil she touches has been covered for two hundred years, the same soil that would have been on the feet or in the fingernails of her ancestors. By covering herself in this meaningful dirt, Jessup White embeds herself with this past in the most direct way she can. Grief, beauty, and wonder exist incredibly close to each other, as everything decomposes in time. Soil and memories are constantly made and remade. I began collecting soil in my early thirties, four years after leaving the home I had made to study landscape architecture. The field fed my intertwined curiosities about plants, ground, and our complicated humanness. I became joyfully obsessed with the ground, with all its hidden life. As I found the ground, I found my footing – not entirely confident, but strong enough to explore. I also found someone willing to explore with me and grow with me. A year after I graduated, he gave me a box of small vials to hold my nascent soil collection. The edge of the lake, a hike, our tent sites, gardens, and construction sites – each handful of dirt touched, gathered, and labeled. Today, a decade later, there are about 200 vials, each representing a moment in time. On our wedding day, we collected soil from a place where we often paused during bike rides home, gazed at the moon, or watched fireworks. A few years later, on the day after my son’s first birthday, I collected a handful of soil when we planted bare-root trees together. At age two, my son helped me collect a handful of sand at the beach, but his handful doesn’t fill an entire vial. In time, his handfuls of soil will get bigger, until one day they will be the same size as mine.
1 Anna Krzywoszynska & Greta Marchesi, “Toward a Relational Materiality of Soils: Introduction,” Environmental Humanities 12, no. 1 (2020): 192. 2 Anne Therese O’Brien, “Ethical Acknowledgment of Soil Ecosystem Integrity amid Agricultural Production in Australia,” in ibid., 277. 3 Sara Jacobs & Taryn Wiens, “Breaking Ground: Sifting Soil Stories at Bos Park,” Journal of Architectural Education 76, no. 2 (2022): 173. 4 Krzywoszynska & Marchesi, “Toward a Relational Materiality of Soils,” 191. 5 Astrid Erll, “Travelling Narratives in Ecologies of Trauma: An Odyssey for Memory Scholars,” Social Research 87, no. 3 (2020): 539. 6 Michelle Thaller, “The Universe Is a Story That Exists From Start to Finish,” New York Times (December 8, 2022), https://www. nytimes.com/2022/12/08/special-series/thebig-question-why-do-we-tell-stories.html. 7 Amanda Gorman, “We Tell Stories Because We Are Human,” New York Times (December 8, 2022), https://www.nytimes. com/2022/12/08/special-series/the-bigquestion-why-do-we-tell-stories.html. 8 bell hooks, “Touching the Earth,” Belonging: A Culture of Place (Routledge, 2008), 34. 9 Sarah M. Broom, The Yellow House (Grove Press, 2019), 301. 10 Ibid., 123. 11 Ibid. 12 Ibid. 13 Colson Whitehead, The Underground Railroad (Doubleday, 2016), 12. 14 Ibid., 11. 15 Margaret Walker, “Southern Song,” For My People (Yale University Press, 1942), 18. 16 Lucy M. Freibert & Margaret Walker, “Southern Song: An Interview with Margaret Walker,” Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies 9, no. 3 (1987): 56. 17 Ibid. 18 Gwynne Á. Mhuireach, Kevin G. Van Den Wymelenberg & Gail A. Langellotto, “Garden Soil Bacteria Transiently Colonize Gardeners’ Skin After Direct Soil Contact,” Urban Agriculture and Regional Food Systems 8, no. 1 (2023): 1. 19 Pearl S. Buck, The Good Earth (Albatross, 1947), 292–93. 20 Octavia E. Butler, Parable of the Sower (Grand Central Publishing, 2019), 162. 21 Ibid., 175. 22 Gayle Jessup White, Reclamation: Sally Hemings, Thomas Jefferson, and a Descendant’s Search for Her Family’s Lasting Legacy (Amistad, 2021), 242.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 103
MONA SMITH JEWELL ARCOREN DAVID MALDA
IN CONVERSATION S
ince 2020, Mona Smith, Jewell Arcoren, and David Malda have been a part of the Owámniyomni project, a Dakota-led initiative in Minneapolis. Mona, SissetonWahpeton Oyate, is a multi-media artist, educator, and co-founder of Allies: media/art and the Healing Place Collaborative in Minneapolis. Jewell, Sisseton-Wahpeton Oyate, is a therapist in Chaska, Minnesota, and focuses on the intergenerational historical trauma experienced by both the American Indian and non-Native communities. David is a principal at the landscape architectural practice GGN, based in Seattle, Washington. The Owámniyomni project is focused on healing five acres of land at Owámniyomni (St. Anthony Falls) as a place of restoration, education, and connection. Owámniyomni is a sacred Dakota place on the Mississippi River desecrated through decades of colonization and industrialization. Today much of the water is controlled by a series of locks and dams that were preceded by the city’s milling industry. In 2015 the lock closed to navigation, and the surrounding property is in the process of being conveyed from the US Army Corps of Engineers to Owámniyomni Okhódayapi, a Dakota-led non-profit. The organization has centered Dakota leadership and connected design consultants with Dakota Knowledge Keepers to ensure Dakota values guide the work. The dialogue that follows is edited from a series of conversations reflecting on this ongoing collaboration. David Malda: Throughout the years we’ve known each other, the word “relationship” has been central to our conversations. At Owámniyomni, there are generations and generations of connection to this place. The place has been changed through its industrialization - its desecration. And yet, the deeper connections—those foundational relationships—persevere despite all of that. I’d like to talk about this relationship with the land as it relates to memory. Jewell Arcoren: In our work, often intersecting with Mona and Allies: media/art, we have been highlighting Dakota stories and history through interviews with people in Dakota language revitalization circles. We have been bringing people—from Crow Creek, Sisseton, Canada, even—back to Minnesota, to Bdote down below, which used to be a concentration camp in the 1860s. They said they felt a connection beyond even a visceral level - it was like a blood memory. A vibration. They felt it deeply, that connection to place. It surprised me not that they remembered, or that they felt something. What surprised me was how effectively the government, through
IN CONVERSATION: MONA SMITH, JEWELL ARCOREN + DAVID MALDA 104
the education system and other policies, disconnected us from this place. And so, we began to regather that collective memory, to reconnect people by bringing them to Bdote. The work we were doing was awakening blood memory, awakening a connection to place. People were saying, “I feel so at home, wow, this was missing.” All the things that they were able to express or articulate were about the connection so deeply felt to these places. That collectively began to spread. For instance, a lot of people would say rice was Ojibwe food because they forgot it was something that we Dakota had harvested. When we send that food back to our relatives up in the Dakotas it is so cherished, it is loved. It awakens a memory. DM: This is something that is felt throughout our many discussions: the connection and relationship to the land that is so fundamental and deep that it’s in us. I’ll say this: even though I haven’t lived in Michigan for years, when I go back to the lake, I feel something fundamentally different. JA: Yes, it’s an energy, it’s a vibration: I’m home. DM: I was born in Michigan. My grandparents were born in Michigan. That is only a couple of generations. What strikes me is that you’re talking about this depth and fundamental connection that is felt even for folks who were born elsewhere and come back to Bdote, to this ancestral land. That says something about the connection between people and land that is bigger than any individual. JA: You might feel a vibration or a physical sensation sometimes, but you don’t know what to do with that feeling. You don’t know how to name it. You don’t know how to articulate it. That is part of the disconnect. Sometimes it’s easier not to feel those feelings and the tension that can come with them. We don’t have to listen to our memory, that blood memory that we all must carry as human beings. We can use the example of food and memory. We all had lifeways that connected us to place and to food that was perfect for our DNA, which fed us on that energy level. Memory can be awakened by doing something as simple as paying attention to the feeling after I eat buffalo and I feel energized, or after I eat this rice and it feeds my spirit. That land and all the memories held by it are wrapped up in that. Just as we talk about how we carry these intergenerational traumas inside us, this deeper connection with the land is also there. We don’t often articulate it; we don’t pull it out and unravel it and examine it. Sometimes it’s easier not to remember, because the disconnect is lodged in us, and we get stuck. DM: Many people struggle to feel that connection. I always come back to a very modern idea: we think we are completely unencumbered by the world around us. We can move anywhere, and anything can go anywhere. But as a result,
we’re incredibly disconnected from the land and increasingly aware of how deep the impacts of that mindset run, even if we can’t put it into words. JA: Absolutely. DM: But we can start to help people build connections with the land where we are. We can’t all go back to our ancestral lands—I’m not going to move back to the Netherlands, where my great-grandparents came from, or even to Michigan, where I grew up—but the potential for me to learn through your experience and your knowledge of the land can also be healing. I’ve seen this happening throughout the Owámniyomni project. Rather than jumping right into what should come next, as is often the case with engagement, there has been a focus on understanding this place from a Dakota perspective. This has helped our design team, city partners, and community members to orient and connect with this specific moment in the site’s evolution through that understanding, which is not the narrative most often told in history books or in the site’s interpretative signage. I would argue that this is really the point of this project. We’ve often talked about the idea of “restoring relationships.” We can’t undo all that has happened here, but we can take steps to restore those foundational relationships with the water, land, and all the life they support. That’s a Dakota approach, but it benefits everyone. The design for the project is rooted in the mindset that everyone can participate in the place through moments of learning, art, storytelling, and involvement with the restoration of the land and water as essential “programs.” This is how the physical landscape design and Owámniyomni Okhódayapi’s leadership in this place are entirely integrated. Mona Smith: There is a lot of talk in Indian Country about how the Earth holds memory in rocks. Rocks are a very important memory tool; they remember. And so, that is also what happens when people come back and they feel a familiarity with this place. The Earth is saying, “I know you.” DM: Jewell, I love how you have used the word “forgotten” in relation to this discussion of memory. Often, we talk about remembering or forgetting based on our direct personal experience. You’re talking about something deeper than that, and something that precedes any individual’s experience. By saying we’ve forgotten, you highlight that these connections are already there, but we’ve lost them or covered them up. MS: Right, and when people come back and feel familiar, it means we and the Earth are reconnecting. Because the last few hundred years have been trying to sever that connection, fairly successfully. DM: That is a theme we’ve heard repeatedly in the work with Owámniyomni Okhódayapi. This isn’t about building yet another new thing here in response to the colonization and
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 105
industrialization of the past centuries. As Wakinyan LaPointe described early in the process, this is about restoring a disrupted story. It’s about connecting and restoring those relationships that were severed through these last centuries of “contamination.” As a design team, we’ve worked to understand how the water once connected through this place - not just mapping where it was, but how the water shaped the land above and below the Falls. We’ve spent a lot of time understanding the layers of sandstone and limestone that are still below the surface and their role in supporting a diversity of life from the top of the bluff to the River’s edge. The design began by exploring how these qualities of the place could once again be present and then how people might relate to them. We situated this approach in a much longer timeline of the place and highlighted that it is a process that will be ongoing. You could say it’s a process of remembering. MS: Yes, it is. Re-membering. Putting it back together again. Healing this place. JA: I’m listening to you both talking about this transformation that happens in people. But what is the process? It’s fascinating to see people begin to understand that we are not separate from the land - we are part of it. In relation to landscape architecture, what comes to mind is how designers try to contain things and make them look neat and pretty, but when you’ve built relationships and connected with others, things begin to shift. You realize that we are all interconnected with the land and that we’re just very, very small human beings in the whole universe. MS: So how do we develop these relationships? It isn’t about deciding and designing what goes where. It is about really getting to know how something grows, how it has existed. Listening to it, if you will, across generations and generations. The scientific world seems to be discovering how mushrooms communicate with each other and how there are relationships among trees. The trees are more in relationship than we ever thought. So mitskuye owás’iŋ (we are all related). DM: A lot of modern design practice has been focused on the new great idea that replaces the last great idea. And that is how we prove our worth. It strikes me how destructive that mindset can be in seeking to replace what came before it, rather than relating to what is already there. It favors discontinuity and disruption. MS: Yes. It also strikes me that listening goes further than the ears. It’s also about sensing, about feeling the energy. We need to learn to connect in ways other than verbally. We’re all born with that skill, but it is removed slowly, or not so slowly. It’s a decision we make, and we spend our lives doing it. I remember what Amos Owen, a Dakota elder, said a hundred years ago. It has been reassuring to me, and it seems like a call to action: “We’re always children on this planet.”
DM: A lot of times in a project we’ll try to understand the place where we are working, and then we’ll move forward to design for what comes next. In our work with Owámniyomni Okhódayapi, there have been points along the way where, suddenly, we have come to understand something about the land we didn’t know before. We’ve learned something about what is under that parking lot, or other relationships of land and water that were present before. These learnings have guided us to revisit things that you typically wouldn’t revisit during the design of a project - letting us stay children, in a sense. I think it has led us to feel at ease with adding less in the “designed” aspects of the place and instead focusing on engaging, through design, those relationships that are already there but were buried and disrupted. This mindset has also helped us to reframe the idea of the project away from a more traditional architectural model of analysis, design, construction, and programming toward an ongoing process of restoration that will center Dakota leadership for years to come. We aren’t making a place; we are participating in a place that already exists. This means we can keep learning and adapting as we go. As with so many aspects of this effort, when we reframe our role in relation to the larger ideas, it opens a different approach to design. As designers, we wouldn’t have been able to do this without the Dakota leadership and collaboration. MS: Very often, learning is about the eyes. It is reading, and it is looking. But you have to let learning in in ways you don’t initially understand and then allow time for listening. JA: As it relates to the idea of disruption, I’ve been using the words “pivoting” and “shifting.” Because, as Vanessa Andreotti has observed, we’ve all developed harmful ways of existing. We’ve been colonized; we’ve been disconnected. Those traumas have happened. How do you begin to shift and pivot back to a healthier way that is connected – a way that allows you to listen and be in connection not only with each other as human beings, but with all the other energies that exist in this place we call home? And that is what I’m learning landscape and landscape architecture can be. Instead of designing a very contained and developed place, it’s a way to begin to reconnect to place. That is my sense of what is happening with Owámniyomni Okhódayapi. There’s a story there, a place that has existed for thousands of years. This project is doing the work of reconnecting. DM: You said it beautifully. We are working to support those places and processes of reconnection. Simply building something here, whatever it might be, could never be enough. But supporting ways for people to connect with the broader stories of this land can be very powerful. We just need to take the time to open up to it and see what we’ve been missing or overlooking. That means a different kind of timeline for a project, and even a different understanding of time. First, it means that we are only seeing a very small moment within a much greater scale of time, and second, that we need to
IN CONVERSATION: MONA SMITH, JEWELL ARCOREN + DAVID MALDA 106
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 107
change our approach to design to build those relationships ourselves before anything else. Not every project timeline is set up for that, and I really believe that was a big difference in this effort. Owámniyomni Okhódayapi as an organization is focused on how its programming and restoration leadership here grow the potential for that reconnection. MS: There is a verb in there, and maybe that is the work of landscape architecture: to reconnect. DM: I’m with you! And there are other means of connecting. Jewell, I am curious about your counseling work. How does land come up in those conversations? JA: It’s an expansive approach that we call being grounded, grounding yourselves. Go land, sit on the ground, put your feet in the water, put out your hand. We suggest techniques to rebalance ourselves, to reset, and to gain another sense of connectedness. It could be other things that ground you, but in that sense, it is very literal. DM: I love that. The first step that we often talk about in our practice at GGN is what we think of as grounding. It is building up an understanding of the “ground” that comes before us. This is in relation to Robin Dripps’ writing about ground as both the physical stuff that’s out there and our diverse collective and individual understandings of that stuff. As we begin, we need to understand what’s already there - not just what we can see, but also what’s below the surface, how it came to be that way through time. The first part of our work—really, the bulk of our work—is learning to see that ground that’s so much bigger than us and know that it is many things. We make that legible to others and to ourselves. If we can start to understand all of that, then we’re not just talking about a parking lot next to a dam like at Owámniyomni. There’s a whole lot more. Once we start to have a way of relating, we can connect through that place and to that place. JA: That’s probably the lens that I as a Dakota person bring to the table - how we are open to understanding that shift or pivot that happens when you meet others. When you’re in relationship or in connection, you are able to feel those vibrations in that silence, and the power of what little, tiny beings we are. And it really drives home that we’re all related, we’re all connected. That is the very humbling and powerful piece of this process. How do you live your life in connection? That is a challenge these days. MS: There’s a difference between the way you’re talking about it, David, and the way Jewell approaches it. For you, the visual, the seeing, is more about the brain, whereas the grounding that she’s talking about is not about seeing the dirt - it’s about feeling what is there. So maybe landscape architects would do well to do what she does, get folks lying or sitting on the ground.
I used to have people lie down in the room when I showed my multimedia piece, Cloudy Waters: Dakota Reflections on the River, so that they would be in a different position that does not privilege the visible - so that their whole body would connect to the sound. JA: There you go. See how powerful that is? It’s a kind of seeing that is about fully sensing in your body when you are connecting and you are grounding yourself. You are recentering. DM: I appreciate the ways you’ve both described an approach to working in landscape that is different from how many in the design world have been trained to think. It’s not just an academic exercise of research and invention. It starts with opening ourselves up to that bigger land of which we are a tiny part. If our work is about reconnecting and “re-membering,” as you’ve described, then we need to give a lot more attention to the life of a place that precedes us. It also shifts the focus away from design establishing the appearance of a place to the designer’s role in supporting the life of a place. It really is a more relational approach. And speaking from my own experience working with Owámniyomni Okhódayapi and the two of you over the past five years, this can be very powerful and transformative.
“In the tradition of early Hawai’i, the demigod Māui used a net to snare the sun as it crossed the sky above Haleakalā, slowing it down so that his mother, Hina, could have time to dry her kapa cloth.”1
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 109
memories in a temporal landscape Micah Stanek Micah Stanek bridges storytelling and environmental design as STIMSON’s Media, Communications + Research Director. Drawing from film studies at Northwestern University and graduate studies in architecture and landscape architecture at Washington University in St. Louis, Micah enjoys cultivating environmental awareness through teaching, research, writing, and landscape architecture practice. Emblematic experiences on this path include working on a conservation farm in India and co-creating a community butterfly garden in a disinvested neighborhood in St. Louis.
ecology, sensory studies
T
he island of Maui emerged from the ocean floor around two million years ago, when volcanic rock formed underwater, shaped by dramatic temperature changes and currents long before the erosion of wind and colonization of plants. The volcano that formed this landscape, Haleakalā, is still active today. There have been numerous eruptions in the last 30,000 years; 10 of them occurred within the last 1,000 years or so, the same timescale of Hawaiian people’s presence in Maui.2 Haleakalā is a wahi pana (sacred place) that holds mana (spiritual power) and connects Native Hawaiians to their past and future.3 Today, recent eruptions, high-elevation winds, and arid climate have left this landscape almost barren of life – except for one ubiquitous plant that sparkles across the terrain. ‘Ahinahina—also known as Mauna Kea silversword, or Argyroxiphium sandwicense ssp. Macrocephalum—flourishes in the volcanic landscape and is associated with resilience because it has adapted to cold temperatures, punishing sun, and arid soil. The seedling sprouts, collects nutrients, grows only long enough to bloom, and then dies. If conditions are
MEMORIES IN A TEMPORAL LANDSCAPE 110
favorable, the plant can bloom after just one year; alternatively, this can take 90 years.4 This adaptable biological clock seems tied entirely to the pocket of earth where it grows and how much rainfall it catches. ‘Ahinahina appears to dutifully wait, and then one season it sprouts a striking stalk that triples the plant’s height, bearing dozens of maroon flowers that produce thousands of seeds. The wind or water disperses the seeds, allowing the next generation to settle in niches best suited for survival. Out of all plant species with airborne seeds, this aster found a way to situate, adapt, and thrive in this landscape. This unfolded over one to five million years.5 Mom and Maui As long as I can remember, my mother dreamed of visiting Hawai’i. Perhaps she hatched this dream while growing up on a farm in a small town in southern Illinois. Part of the first generation glued to the television, Mom was six years old when the news featured stunning images of Hawai’i’s volcanic mountains and pristine beaches as the archipelago’s residents voted to become the 50th state of the US. This is how I imagine my impressionable young mother encountering this pivotal moment. Of course, time has revealed a much more contentious story.6 In Mom’s memory, my father promised to take her to Hawai’i someday. They could not afford it when they married in 1980, and it did not happen before they separated two decades later. My siblings and I have always struggled to coalesce around travel plans, until it’s almost too late. But in the summer of 2018, we learned Mom’s cancer was spreading throughout her body. So, at the end of that year, we went to Maui: Mom, my brothers Nathanael and Caleb, my sister Rebekah and brotherin-law Josh, and me, stuffed into a rented condo up the coast from Lahaina. Mom figured that if we could experience as many astonishing landscapes as possible, these shared experiences would build up to something unforgettable. Carving precious time together had always been important to her, but seemed even more vital now. Deep Time, Life Time “[T]ime acts as a count or marker, as the content of unfolding ecological processes, or as the creation or closure of opportunity.”7 Before the trip, I had been thinking a lot about how we form impressions of landscapes, particularly the way we register novel patterns, assemblages, and conditions that emerge as a result of geological and ecological processes over deep time.8 I had planned to teach a new landscape architecture studio on this subject, which would ask students to map and uncover how the many-layered memories embedded in their sites inform anticipated futures. One prompt was to take up a long-standing
thread in landscape architecture concerning sublime experiences of geology and puzzle through how these primordial pasts bear on our understanding of present sites.9 A second prompt was to tune in more closely to the lifeways of plants and insects at the ground plane, learning about the trajectories of living, evolving beings with unique senses and cycles of time. The final prompt was to ask the students to factor in their personal impressions and politics – to ponder their own time scales. What happens to this place when you are only a memory?
Charting a new set of unknowns through this studio framework felt heavy, heavier than usual. Maybe it was because, back home, I was also researching local industrial sites where slow catastrophes were intersecting with the ubiquitous presence of climate change.10 And, to say the least, my mother’s health was a constant pressure under the surface. So, as we moved through Maui, collecting these irreplaceable days as a family, my mind was already primed by the sense of landscapes woven with time. Looking back, I am glad that I formed new personal memories through this lens because I never taught this studio in the end. Haleakalā On the morning of New Year’s Eve, we drove up the winding Haleakalā Highway – ascending 10,000 feet over 20 miles to reach the volcano’s summit within an hour. Initially, my attention fell on the road itself. The National Park Service had recently resurfaced it, and the fresh black asphalt and minimal wooden guardrails were hypnotic. I was struck by how these quiet designed conditions—road, guardrail, painted stripes, and trails—aid in landscape preservation and frame our experience of the place. That day, the road felt like a kind of datum: fragile, temporal, yet anchoring all the same.
When the road ended in a parking lot nestled into the dramatic topography of the summit, we emerged from the car and began to viscerally land in this uncanny landscape. I noticed how the plant life slowly thinned. As we stepped into an otherworldly place made of red and brown soil and rocks, I thought momentarily that there was no plant life at all. On closer inspection, I saw small plants dotting the slopes, shimmering in the sun.
Later, when grounding this experience of Haleakalā and ‘ahinahina, I learned of the plant’s crucial relationship with the yellow-faced bee, or nalo meli maoli (Hylaeus anthracinus) – one of only a few pollinators who braves the windy, arid, high-altitude environment of Haleakalā.11 At the summit, ‘ahinahina blooms and nalo meli maoli forages during brief windows of warmth and sunlight in an otherwise cold, cloudy alpine landscape, where even a few degrees or minutes can determine the success of pollination and reproduction. This
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 111
precision evolved over nearly one million years in isolation, forging a symbiotic reliance that has made both species particularly vulnerable to human-generated pressures.12 While this landscape and plant captivated me, most of us struggled to adapt to the high elevation and unstable climate. We descended into the erosional depression from the summit, aided by gravity as we took in the landscapes. When it was time to hike back up, several of us struggled to breathe the thin air. Mom, between chemotherapy treatments, was remarkably resilient. At a ledge overlooking the valley, we paused for a while and took some photos. I took portraits of Mom as she offered her signature smile, unmoving and available for several takes. When I asked for a silly one, she laughed at my request but then obliged. In the quiet moments between shots, I watched her take in the landscape with a different kind of attention. I wondered, was she registering how this place was working on her body – the way the altitude altered her breathing, the way the ground felt different under her feet than other ground she had known? On the Hāna Highway That same day, we wound our way back down to Maui’s central valley and north to the Hāna Highway, which cuts through the wetter side of the volcano, called Mauna Kahālāwai (House of Water). This landscape is a mixture of rainforest woven with shrublands, varying from upland to mesic and lowland zones, where life adapts to the driest of cliffs and pockets of montane bogs. Hundreds of streams here have eroded deep valleys over thousands of years, which is recent relative to the two-millionyear-old volcano into which this place is carved. Thousands of plant species thrive here, including 18 that are endemic.13 The famous highway clings precariously to steep terrain, winding around ridges and over dramatic waterfalls with one- or two-lane bridges cropping up around nearly every bend. At times, intermittent creeks simply trickle across the road, making it a constant negotiation of erosion and repair. My memories of this volatile landscape began to blur, as if my mind could not quite keep pace with what I was experiencing. As I drove, I noticed how little space there was to move through this thick landscape. When the waterfalls were small, there was no parking or shoulder where we could stop and place our feet on the ground. As we approached more dramatic waterfalls, the road bulged to accommodate a few cars or even a small parking lot, outgrowths of our desire to get closer to the spectacle. Our last planned stop before the town of Hāna was Wai’ānapanapa, a black sand beach where the volcano and this rich ecosystem
1 A Traditional Hawaiian story, as told in: Richard W. Hazlett & Donald W. Hyndman, Roadside Geology of Hawai‘i (Mountain Press Publishing Company, 2005), 130. 2 US Geological Survey, “Haleakalā,”https:// www.usgs.gov/volcanoes/haleakala, (accessed June 15th, 2025). 3 Ed Kanahele, “Wahi Pana: Sacred Places,” National Park Service, “Kuahiwi nui Haleakalā” oral history project, https://storymaps.arcgis.com/ stories/188ac0b2ed564c0d92708ea27c6f24c1, (accessed September 7, 2025). 4 National Park Service, “Haleakalā Silverswords,” https://www.nps.gov/hale/ learn/nature/silversword.htm (accessed June 15, 2025). 5 Bruce G. Baldwin & Michael J. Sanderson, “Age and Rate of Diversification of the Hawaiian Silversword Alliance (Compositae),” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 95, no. 16 (1998): 9402–06. 6 For example, see a history of the colonization of Hawai’i by the National Park Service as compared to a people’s history: National Park Service, Hawai’i “European Contact and Colonization,” https:// www.nps.gov/locations/hawaii/colonization. htm (accessed July 19, 2025); Trask HaunaniKay, “The Struggle for Hawaiian Sovereignty – Introduction,” Cultural Survival Quarterly 24, no. 1 (April 2, 2010). 7 Steward T. A. Pickett, “Three Kinds of Time in Ecological Science,” LA+ Interdisciplinary Journal of Landscape Architecture, no. 8 (2018): 89. 8 Rod Barnett, Emergence in Landscape Architecture (Routledge, 2013), 8. 9 Robert Smithson, “Frederick Law Olmsted and the Dialectical Landscape,” in Jack Flam (ed.), Robert Smithson: The Collected Writings (University of California Press, 1996), 157–71. 10 Eli Chen, “Granite City Art Exhibition Draws Inspiration from Local Environmental Disasters,” St. Louis Public Radio (March 15, 2019), https://www.stlpr.org/health-scienceenvironment/2019-03-15/granite-city-artexhibition-draws-inspiration-from-localenvironmental-disasters. 11 Christophe Girot, “Four Trace Concepts in Landscape Architecture,” in James Corner (ed.), Recovering Landscape: Essays in Contemporary Landscape Architecture (Princeton Architectural Press, 1999), 58–67. 12 Phoebe Redfield, “Island Buzz: How Hawaiian Pollinators Sustain Biodiversity,” Pollinator Partnership Blog (August 15, 2024), https://www.pollinator.org/blog/archived/ hawaiian-pollinators. 13 Mauna Kahālāwai Watershed Partnership, “About the Mauna,” https://www. maunakahalawai.org/mauna-kahalawai-westmaui-mountains (accessed June 15, 2025).
MEMORIES IN A TEMPORAL LANDSCAPE 112
meet the sea. It struck me how this edge once limited life on the planet, until 700 million years ago, when plants began to colonize land. Now, many of the plants who evolved in this rainforest encounter the ocean as a barrier to their further spread. We explored the lava tubes, blow holes, arches, basalt cliffs, and the magnetic sand. I remember being mesmerized by a blanket of green set against the dark, rocky landscape. The air was thick with a disorienting mix of light rain and ocean spray. It occurred to me that we had achieved a stunning feat, starting at the northwest coast, climbing to the top of Haleakalā, and returning to the ocean on another shore. I expected a sense of catharsis at the beach, but the relentless waves battering the rocky coast made me uneasy. I climbed the black cliff to a precipice, seeking the relief that comes when physical exertion silences an anxious mind. Looking down, I saw my mother on the beach, following her intuition to stay on level ground, and the separation brought some sadness. I climbed down to hear her impressions of the remarkable beach, but it was already time to go; so we organized a group photo near the shoreline, where we were nearly claimed by a wave. By the time we reached the town of Hāna, it was time to turn around and retrace our steps to where we were staying near Lahaina. We discussed visiting one more nearby destination, a red beach called Kaihalulu, but Mom was concerned about losing light. She decided we should all head back. We split into two cars, my brothers with Mom, and Rebekah and Josh with me. Back on the road, we decided to steal time and detoured to experience sunset at Kaihalulu after all. I began to feel extremely tired, perhaps unfit to drive. The rental car was registered in my name, with all the liability that entailed, so I attempted to bottle up my concern. We discussed whether Mom would be upset that we had strayed off plan to see the red beach without her. After a stretch of silence, I still could not shake the feeling of upsetting her. I opened my mouth to suggest how best to communicate our decision to Mom, when the most unexpected thing happened. “We can tell her, tell her,
tell her,
tell her
tell her, tell her tell her tell her tell her, tell her, tell her, tell her tell her tell her, tell her tell her.” tell her,
tell her
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 113
MEMORIES IN A TEMPORAL LANDSCAPE 114
These words looped silently in my head, like a broken record. For several seconds, I was physically unable to stop the repetition, nor could I finish the thought. I immediately felt the stress of faulty communication, with the additional alarm of not knowing what was happening.
and we weighed the options together. His clarity and quiet insistence gave me the nudge I needed to ask Josh to drive us to the emergency room. I spent the rest of New Year’s Eve at Maui Memorial Medical Center.
After the loop finally halted, I looked at my sister, but I could not speak. She noticed my glance and asked me what I was thinking. I smiled – partly to acknowledge her question, but also because it felt absurd that at that moment, I was simply unable to speak. I am rarely speechless. Checking inward, I noticed that my inner voice was gone, too. Somehow, I knew that I was driving and responsible for that. Rebekah, sitting in the passenger seat, noticed my silence. As I remember, she smiled back, surprised as well.
That night and the days that followed, I put on a brave face for Mom, my siblings, my partner, and my friends. Confronted with the realization that I am more fragile, and perhaps acutely temporary, than I imagined, I was at a loss about how to feel or what to think. Sometime on New Year’s Day, I wandered from my hospital bed and discovered a stunning mountain view.
Rebekah and Josh communicated their concern to each other and began asking me questions to discover what was happening. I could hear them speaking but could not comprehend what they were saying. Each time I detected one of their questions, I heard a different one. When, after a few minutes, my voice returned, I tried to repeat the question I thought I heard, but instead I asked a different one. When Josh asked, “Do you know where you are?” I hesitated and answered, “What time is it?” Somehow, I knew that this was wrong. Frustration mounted as I continued to misunderstand. For several minutes, communication continued to fail. I was unable to understand their words, nor could I respond in a useful way; and I could not really hear an inner voice telling me how I should act. Still, I understood that I had to grasp the wheel, steer the car, and watch the road. Without a voice in my head guiding me, I searched for the elusive shoulder on the Hāna Highway. During this silent drive, which lasted around 15 minutes, I remember the darkness of the road at twilight. Tall trees towered overhead. To the left loomed the volcano; to the right, the ground cascaded down to the Pacific. It was a meandering tunnel, with breaks in the trees revealing the dim, dramatic space beyond. I carefully watched the steel guardrail and yellow and white painted lines on the road. Finally, I found a place to pull over, and my brother-in-law took the driver’s seat. We agreed that I should continue in silence. This helped, and gradually I noticed my inner voice returning; I began to recognize the sounds and the words I attempted to form in my head. One hour later, as we neared the end of the Hāna Highway, we emerged from the rainforest and our mobile phones regained signal. I called my partner, Siqi, who was at home in St. Louis,
Aphasia
The need to determine the underlying cause of what had happened quickly halted my Maui trip. Siqi flew to Hawai’i to be with me and to help me return to St. Louis. I encouraged my family to continue the rest of the trip, to slow down time together, and to make memories with Mom. After visiting several doctors back at home, it became clearer that the aphasia was caused by inflammation in the temporal lobe of my brain and that recovery would be a long road. In the years since, emotions have surfaced. Only by writing this story and reliving these memories have I recognized how earthshaking, disorienting, and frightening this experience was for me. Aphasia affects a person’s ability to speak and understand language, and the temporal lobe plays a central role in how we perceive and remember time. Humans can organize memories in time because neurons, known as “time cells,” in the medial temporal lobe fire at specific moments during memory tasks.14 This brain region takes its name from the Latin tempus (time) because of its location at the temple, where gray hair first appears as a sign of aging. Disorder in the temporal lobe can cause aphasia—from Greek aphatos, meaning “speechless”— disrupting communication broadly and altering our relationship with memories experienced in time. After the turn of the year, I was granted a medical leave, which is why I never taught the “Deep Time, Life Time” studio. My ability to speak fluidly eventually returned, along with listening comprehension and writing ability. Sometimes I mix up words, revealing associations I had never noticed before. As for my memory, it is difficult to compare how I formed impressions before and now, because memory is always a layered, personal, and temporal process – just like the contexts in which we form it. But losing my ability to speak and verbally think forced me to attend to other ways of being. Over time, this experience helped me gain a perspective on what it means to be a person who thinks, speaks, listens, reads, and writes – but also a person who has experienced temporary, but total, speechlessness.
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 115
My memory of aphasia reminds me that what is lived and felt through the body matters, and that this embodied knowing deepens and expands how we pay attention to our environment. When landing in a landscape, I find it is important to suspend narrative thinking, even briefly, to have an embodied experience. Landscapes are layered with memories: some hidden, others revealing themselves to the senses with time. When grounding our experience through research, it is important to dig deeply and try to decenter our personal, anthropocentric position in the landscape. If “ecological awareness is about a sense of intimacy, not the intimacy of belonging to something bigger – a sense of being close, too close to other lifeforms,” then we must hone our ways of attunement.15 If we learn to slow down our perception and decenter our inner voice, I wonder, is it possible to learn how to better speak for the voiceless?
14 C. J. MacDonald, et al., “Hippocampal ‘Time Cells’ Bridge the Gap in Memory for Discontiguous Events,” Neuron 71, no. 4 (2011): 737–49. 15 Timothy Morton, Hyperobjects: Philosophy and Ecology after the End of the World (University of Minnesota Press, 2013), 139.
Time and Memory Although our trip was cut short, my family gained many of the experiences we sought. Mom experienced Hawai’i. We slowed down our days to spend time together. Even then, there were physical signs that traveling was becoming challenging for Mom. Still, after this, she traveled to Montana to see Caleb, bonding over their shared experience working at Yellowstone National Park. She visited Nathanael in California, where he was working with endangered turtles, and in Florida, where he was relocating a natural history collection. In St. Louis, Rebekah, Josh, and I were able to spend quality time with her routinely. Wherever she went, she sought out friends and nature preserves. Mom seemed to sense that she may not have much time left, and she became increasingly interested in being present, paying attention, and communing with landscapes that brought her a sense of meaning. I return again and again to Haleakalā in memory – its dramatic layered red-brown hues, its vast valley stretching beyond sight, dotted with ‘ahinahina shimmering in the sun. Against this ancient volcanic backdrop, the ‘ahinahina carries its own profound relationship with time – both oriented toward an uncertain lifespan and dedicated to ending the clock exactly when the moment is right. For decades, the plant grows slowly, storing energy and responding to subtle cues in light, temperature, and rainfall. It waits, relatively motionless, in the relentless alpine winds. Throughout its lifetime, its silver leaves sparkle in the harsh sunlight. And when the time comes, ‘ahinahina releases its energy in a single, luminous bloom – a radiant farewell that quietly closes its story. Acknowledgment This essay is in memory of my mother, Roberta “Birdie” Stanek (1953–2021).
image credits
Endpapers
Monumental Dreams
The Decline of the Carthaginian Empire (1817) by J.M.W. Turner. Courtesy of Tate.
p. 66: Image by Caitlin Van Dusen, courtesy of City Lore, used with permission. p. 70: Image by dbking (CC by 2.0) via Wikimedia Commons.
Editorial p. 4: Sinking and Scaffolding (2015) by Diana Al-Hadid, used with permission. Photograph by Joshua White.
H.E.R.E. p. 6: Image by Sam Carter-Shamai, used with permission (cropped). p. 10-11: Images by Sam Carter-Shamai, used with permission.
Landscapes of Rememory p. 14: Image by Roman Denisenko (altered), via Unsplash license.
Up in the Air p. 20: Image by Emily Schlickman (cropped), used with permission. p. 23: Views of the San Gabriel Fire, September 1924. Images courtesy of the Observatories of the Carnegie Institution for Science Collection at the Huntington Library, San Marino, California.
On Reimagining the Specter of Urban Vacancy p. 74: Collage by Xingtong Yang using image from The New York Public Library digital collections https://digitalcollections.nypl.org/items/9ab2e8f01a73-0132-95bd-58d385a7bbd0?canvasIndex=0 and image by Nia Easley, used with permission. p. 76: Collage by Xingtong Yang using images by Nia Easley, used with permission.
Architectures of Transmission in the Jawlan p. 80: Image by Daniel Ruiz, used with permission. p. 88: Images by Daniel Ruiz, used with permission. p. 88: Images by Nora Akawi, Eduardo Rega Calvo, and Daniel Ruiz, used with permission.
In Conversation with Andrea Roberts p. 90: Collage by Tatum Phillips using images from the USGS, public domain. p. 94: Images by Yordanos Haile and Annalie Juan, used with permission.
What Memories Lie at the Bottom of the Sea? p. 26-27: Image by Justin Dunnavant, used with permission.
A Handful of Dirt
p. 28, 30: Diagram of a slave ship from the Atlantic slave trade. Public domain via Wikimedia Commons.
p. 99: Images by Gwendolyn Dora Cohen, used with permission.
In Conversation with Elizabeth K. Meyer p. 32: Images by Elizabeth K. Meyer, used with permission. p. 32: Image by Rebecca Deeds, used with permission.
Agents of Memory p. 38: Image courtesy of Danvers Archival Center, Danvers, MA, used with permission. p. 42: Image by Richard B. Trask, used with permission. p. 43: Image courtesy of Danvers Archival Center, Danvers, MA, used with permission.
Extinctionscapes p. 46-51: Image by Nate Ramsey, used with permission.
Storytelling with Coca: Disturbing the Archives p. 52: Image by Tatiana Arocha, used with permission. p. 56: Images by Sarah Bolivar, used with permission.
Heirloom Gardens as Living Archives p. 60: Collage by Xingtong Yang using images provided by Madeline Gray, used with permission.
In Conversation p. 102: Image by David Malda/GGN, used with permission. p. 106: Image by David Malda/GGN, used with permission.
Memories in a Temporal Landscape p. 108: Haleakalā National Park, Maui, Hawaii, July 23, 2013. Image by Forest & Kim Starr (CC by 3.0) via Wikimedia Commons (altered). p. 113: Haleakalā National Park, Maui, Hawaii, May 28, 2010. Image by Forest & Kim Starr (CC by 3.0) via Wikimedia Commons (altered).
LA+ MEmory/fall 2026 117
IN THE NEXT ISSUE OF The concept of utopia has been revisited time and again in literature, social theory, philosophy, architecture, and urban planning. Utopian ideas serve not only as a critique of current societal structures but also to inspire radical speculation about what could and should change in our world. In some cases, these visions lead to concrete responses that are meant to address urgent social issues. In other cases, they remain deliberately fictional, showing that what seems natural or inevitable is actually open to change. In LA+ utopia, contributors from various disciplines—including social and political theory, geography, and landscape architecture—explore the many ways people have envisioned a place for “no place.”
Jayna Brown Liz Camuti S.D. Chrostowska Annette Fierro Ursula K. Heise Kathleen John-Alder Leah Kahler Philipp Lehmann Zhongjie Lin Martina Merlo Garrett Dash Nelson Ben Barsotti Scott Rebecca Sibinga Mathias Thaler Tim Waterman Phillip E. Wegner
OUT SPRING 2027
wild
pleasure
TYRANNY
SIMULATION
IDENTITY
RISK
IMAGINATION
TIME
DESIGN
ICONOCLAST
VITALITY
GEO
COMMUNITY
CREATURE
GREEN
SPECULATION
INTERRUPTION
BEAUTY
BOTANIC SPRING 2024
SENSE SPRING 2025
exotique fall 2024
LA+ JOURNAL
LA+ JOURNAL
LA+ JOURNAL
ENVIRONMENT FALL 2025
MEMORY FALL 2026
LA+ JOURNAL
InterdisciplinaryJournal of Landscape Architecture
MEDIA SPRING 2026
utopia spring 2027
CAPITAL FALL 2027
LA+ brings you a rich collection of contemporary thinkers and designers in two issues each year. To subscribe follow the links at www.laplusjournal.com.
24 Sam Carter-Shamai Annie Lynch Emily Schlickman Justin Dunnavant Elizabeth k. Meyer Leah Kahler Emily Bunker Selina Cheah Hannah Stark Sarah Bolivar Tessa Lowinske Desmond Hanna Garth Christian Keeve Justice Madden Evan Pavka Nia Easley Daniela Rosner Nora Akawi Eduardo Rega Calvo Andrea Roberts Azzurra Cox Gwendolyn Dora Cohen Mona Smith Jewell Arcoren David Malda Micah Stanek