Skip to main content

The Canal That Changed America: The lively history, unique communities, and vital economic and socia

Page 1

Credits

On the Cover

Mike Kilian DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE Jon Glass S.I. NEWHOUSE SCHOOL OF PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS AT SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY

TOP ROW, FROM LEFT: TINA MACINTYRE-YEE / DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE TINA MACINTYRE-YEE / DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE

USA TODAY

TINA MACINTYRE-YEE / DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE

DIRECTOR OF COMMERCE OPERATIONS Kate Ellsworth

KELCI SHERMAN / DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE

BOOK EDITORS Andy Harper Gene Myers E-COMMERCE SPECIALIST Clarissa Shine PARTNERSHIPS & MARKETING ASSOCIATE Rivka Holler PROJECT COORDINATOR Andy Harper

SUPPORT TEAM DESIGNERS Lee Benson, Joey Schaffer PROOFREADER Heather Hewitt SPECIAL THANKS WRITERS & PHOTOGRAPHERS: Ankit Bandyopadhyay, Kayla Breen, Julia Carden, Daniel DeLoach, Shawn Dowd, Jesús Feliciano-Batista, Ella Fling, Alicia Hoppes, Kiran Hubbard, Zach Krahmer, Kendall Luther, Arthur Maiorella, Tina MacIntyre-Yee, Justin Murphy, Madeleine Oliveros, Samantha Olander, Brycen Pace, Amanda Paule, William Ramsey, Cassie Roshu, Kelci Sherman, Sky Shuyang Zhuang, Surya Vaidy, Ally Watkinson, Ike Wood, C.W. Woodward. RESOURCES: Oneida County Historical Society, Rochester Public Library, Whitesboro Historical Society, Syracuse University, Chris Fenison and Pediment Publishing.

COPYRIGHT © 2026 BY DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE • ALL RIGHTS RESERVED • ISBN: 978-1-63846-211-8 No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the copyright owner or the publisher. Published by Pediment Publishing, a division of The Pediment Group, Inc. • www.pediment.com • Printed in Canada. 2 • THE CANAL THAT CHANGED AMERICA

BOTTOM ROW, FROM LEFT: DANIEL DELOACH / UTICA OBSERVER-DISPATCH TINA MACINTYRE-YEE / DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE TINA MACINTYRE-YEE / DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE TINA MACINTYRE-YEE / DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE

BACK COVER: DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE


Contents Foreword

���������������������������������������������������������������������������

Canal History

�����������������������������������������������������������������

5 7

Art and Architecture

53

Social Change

85

Canal Paddles

99

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

BELOW: Mist rises off the Seneca River that passes through Lock E-24 of

the New York State Barge Canal system in Baldwinsville.

SURYA VAIDY / SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY

INTRODUCTION • 3


4 • THE CANAL THAT CHANGED AMERICA


Foreword BY JON GLASS AND MIKE KILIAN

canal’s living legacy. Over the course

with newspapers in upstate New

confined to textbooks or museum

of more than a year, student report-

York that are part of what’s now

exhibits.

PA RT OF THE ERIE CA NA L’S

ers developed stories with help from

called USA TODAY Co. Their work

Rather, the canal’s saga continues

genius has always been how it draws

dozens of other student editors,

for the Rochester Democrat and

to unfold in the towns, industries

people in — immigrants, merchants,

photojournalists and designers that

Chronicle and the Utica Observer-

and traditions it made possible.

activists and, two centuries later, a

explored canal culture, historical

Dispatch helped prompt D&C photo-

That a rising generation of journal-

new generation of storytellers. The

impacts and the communities de-

journalist Tina MacIntyre-Yee to un-

ists chose to spend their formative

arrival of the storied waterway’s

scended from the original builders

dertake 60 miles of canal paddling

reporting experiences walking the

bicentennial in the mid-2020s pro-

and settlers.

in her kayak during 2025. You’ll see

towpaths and interviewing the de-

vided the perfect opportunity to il-

Student photographers and vid-

in ensuing pages the canal up close

scendants of canal families speaks

luminate all those people, past and

eographers traveled the corridor’s

through her lens like you never have

to something enduring in the wa-

present.

locks and towns to capture images,

before.

terway’s pull.

A s the 200th anniversar y ap-

while a companion podcast series

Syracuse University’s digital canal

The pages that follow highlight

proached, dozens of student journal-

profiled the people committed to

project, “Unlocking New York,” much

their efforts and honor both legacies:

ists from the S.I. Newhouse School of

keeping the canal’s spirit alive after

of it included in this book, is less a

the canal that changed America, and

Public Communications at Syracuse

200 years.

history lesson than a rediscovery.

the storytellers still f inding new

It’s proof that the canal’s story is not

ways to tell its story.

University set out to document the

Two of those students interned

OPPOSITE: The Erie Canal Museum is located in the 1850 Syracuse Weighlock Building that originally served as a weigh station collecting tolls on cargo being transported on the waterway. K AYLA BREEN / SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY INTRODUCTION • 5


6 • THE CANAL THAT CHANGED AMERICA


CHAPTER ONE

Canal History

OPPOSITE: A view of the Erie Canal in the early 1900s, when it flowed through downtown Rochester along what is now Broad Street. DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE CANAL HISTORY • 7


A Timeline of the Canal WHEN AMERICA WAS FOUNDED,

of people and goods was a canal, one

Some key dates along the way, with

Rochester: Past, Present and Future"

roads at best were made from dirt

that wound up transforming America

information researched from the

by Thomas X. Grasso (2010 publication

and logs. Travelers were subject to

and New York state and boosting new

Little Falls Historical Society Museum;

of the Central Library of Rochester

headaches ranging from deep mud

early 19th century communities such

the Erie Canal Museum in Syracuse;

and Monroe County); and from previ-

to water crossings without bridges.

as Utica, Syracuse, Rochester and

the Erie Canalway National Heritage

ous Democrat and Chronicle report-

The answer for smoother movement

Buffalo.

Corridor; from "The Erie Canal and

ing by Justin Murphy.

Late 18th Century

1810s

1812

1817

Navigation Co. builds canals

and New York state’s most influential

Genesee River in what is now Rochester.

incorporated. Population is

The Western Inland Lock

and locks enabling boat travel westward from Schenectady to Central New York. One such canal helped boats

traverse an area of Little Falls where a waterfall had served as a barrier to navigation on the Mohawk River.

DeWitt Clinton, arguably New York City’s politician of the era, becomes a champion for building a canal connecting the

First permanent settlers near the

Village of Rochesterville is about 1,000 people.

Hudson River (and by extension New York City) and the Great Lakes. He serves for

many years on a commission that helped make the case for the waterway. The

state Legislature gives its backing to the plan eventually, leading to the start of canal construction between Utica and

Rome in early July 1817, a month when Clinton also was seated as the state’s governor.

8 • THE CANAL THAT CHANGED AMERICA

DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE


1817-1825

1836-1862

Erie Canal construction takes

Mid-1820s to mid-1830s

Champlain Canal is being built

Chemung, Chenango, Crooked Lake and the Oswego canals.

eight years. Simultaneously, the connecting the Hudson River and Lake Champlain. Both canals are

built at a depth of four feet and a width of 40 feet.

New York builds new canals including Cayuga-Seneca,

Upstate cities along the canal such as Utica, Syracuse and Buffalo all boom in population and commerce. Rochester

becomes known as “The Young Lion of the West” and also, because of its mills, as “The Flour City.”

The Erie Canal is

deepened and widened

to a depth of seven feet

1847

Locks are also enlarged

population of about

and a width of 70 feet. in a project that took more than 25 years.

Syracuse, with a

15,000 becomes a city.

1823

1825

1834

1842

completed across

called The Seneca Chief takes a container of water from

population exceeding

the Genesee River, south of the 1823

the Genesee River.

The 363-mile long Erie Canal opens in October. A boat

Lake Erie all the way to the edge of the Atlantic Ocean in New York Harbor, where Gov. DeWitt Clinton helps pour it out. “This solemnity, at this place, on the first arrival of vessels from Lake Erie, is intended to indicate and

commemorate the navigable communication, which has

been accomplished between our Mediterranean Seas and

the Atlantic Ocean,” Clinton says at the start of his speech.

Rochester, with a

12,000, becomes a city.

A new aqueduct is completed across aqueduct and straightening out a tricky turn. This aqueduct today

supports the Broad Street Bridge and is planned to become the basis of a

new pedestrian park in Rochester in the 2020s.

C.W. WOODWARD / DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE

First aqueduct

Impact: Canal boats could carry far more than a wagon on

a road could, reducing the cost of shipping a ton of goods by about 90 percent. And goods and people got where

they were going in far less time. Once the Erie Canal was

finished, one could travel from Albany to Buffalo in about a week — blazingly fast by 19th-century standards, but still a significant amount of time. Boats on long hauls seldom

docked, instead keeping passengers and crew bottled up on board for long stretches.

Syracuse is incorporated as a village.

CANAL HISTORY • 9


1918

1890s

Lengthened lock chambers allow two boats to pass through a lock together.

The New York State Barge Canal system is

completed as the last major enlargement of the Erie, Champlain, Oswego and Cayuga-Seneca canals.

1880

1882

Early 1900s

Canal cargo reached.

ended.

envisioned and planned, one that

Peak tonnage for Erie

Canal tolls

10 • THE CANAL THAT CHANGED AMERICA

A vastly larger canal system is

allows larger and self-propelled boats.

DANIEL DELOACH / UTICA OBSERVER-DISPATCH


1959

The St. Lawrence Seaway is christened, providing a direct and wider route from the Atlantic Ocean to the Great Lakes. This results in big declines in commercial traffic in the Barge Canal system.

2000

2025

help preserve and interpret New York State’s historic canal system and the

occasion, a replica of the Seneca Chief in early autumn travels the canal from

The United States creates the Erie Canalway National Heritage Corridor “to communities along its banks.”

Communities along the Erie Canal celebrate its bicentennial. In honor of the Buffalo to Waterford and then the Hudson River south to New York Harbor.

At each stop, plantings of a tree important to Haudenosaunee culture — the eastern white pine — were made. In Haudenosaunee culture, the white pine is a symbol of peace.

ARTHUR MAIORELLA / SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY

KELCI SHERMAN / DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE CANAL HISTORY • 11


12 • THE CANAL THAT CHANGED AMERICA


The mother of cities: The rise and fall of New York cities mirrors the growth of the Erie Canal that created them BY NATE HARRINGTON

said Jose Torre, a professor at SUNY

unprecedented, and does not in-

The combination of the invention

Brockport.

clude already established cities like

of the steamboat — which allowed

W ITHOUT THE ERIE CA NA L ,

The Erie Canal sparked the growth

Albany and New York City (ranked

boats to travel upriver — and the

Syracuse, Utica and Rochester might

and development of western New

as the 10th and first most populous

better ability to manufacture made

not exist. Buffalo might not still be in

York, and its influence didn’t stop

cities in 1850, respectively).

the Erie Canal’s impact all the more

the top 100 most populated cities in

there. Much of the development of

America, and a city other than New

America hinged on the transporta-

York City might have capitalized on

tion benefits and possibilities that

its port to become the nation’s center

the canal brought. Not only did the

of trade.

Erie Canal arguably mother several

The canal’s influence on the up-

cities in New York and beyond, but

state region cannot be overstated,

its influence can still be felt today

as demonstrated by its impact on

in things like the state’s population

population.

distribution, politics and infra-

The earliest major American in-

“The canal brought them their community, commercial existence and viability.” BRAD UTTER, NEW YORK STATE MUSEUM SENIOR HISTORIAN

structure projects.

frastructure project was ridiculed

In 1820, Cleveland, Rochester and

Before the Erie Canal, “everything

expansive. The cities could manu-

a s “Clinton’s Ditch,” “Clinton’s

Syracuse were not yet defined as

was limited to the Hudson River,

facture household goods (like cloth

Folly,” and more, as the investment

cities; Buffalo, Detroit and Utica all

between New York City and Albany,”

and leather) and send them inland,

of $7 million (roughly $165 million

had populations of less than 3,000.

said Brad Utter, a senior historian

while farmers could send potatoes

today) was unfathomable to the

By 1850, a ll those cities were

and curator at the New York State

and wheat back to the cities to feed the growing population.

early American public.

among the top 40 most populous cit-

Museum. “There were some limited

But, the project “opened up the

ies in America, except for Cleveland,

trade routes out in western New

This revolution, both in transpor-

entire western New York region,”

which was 41st. This growth was

York, but (the Canal) kicked it off.”

tation and manufacturing, made

OPPOSITE: Horses draw a barge across the Genesee River on the Erie Canal aqueduct in Rochester, in this undated photo. D EMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE CANAL HISTORY • 13


RIGHT: A photo from the early 20th

century of the old Erie Canal in downtown Utica. The canal occupied the site for more than 100 years — 1819 to about 1925 — until it was abandoned, filled in, paved and named Oriskany Street. The canal contributed much to the early growth and development of the Upper Mohawk Valley Region from Rome to Utica to Little Falls. TICA OBSERVER-DISPATCH U

the Erie Canal ever more powerful

(ranked 52nd) being ranked in the top

boom came from “New Englanders

in transforming the country into the

35 most populous cities, and Buffalo,

colonizing western New York. … Places

global superpower it was starting to

Cleveland and Detroit all in the top 20.

l i ke Con nect icut , Ma ssa chuset ts,

During this time, New York City ce-

Rhode Island, you know, they were

mented its place as the most populous

out of land for a while.”

become. In the 1880s, the original Erie Canal reached its peak, Utter said. The de-

14 • THE CANAL THAT CHANGED AMERICA

and prosperous American city.

T he Er ie C a n a l’s c a r g o i ndu s -

cade saw the continued growth of ca-

While there were some immigrants

try also had its peak at the time. In

nal corridor cities, with all but Utica

who took the Erie west, Torre said this

1880, the canal had an all-time cargo


LEFT: The Erie Canal Aqueduct, looking west, circa 1897 in downtown Rochester. The Aqueduct Building is to the right of the canal in the middleground. ROCHESTER PUBLIC LIBRARY

LOCAL HISTORY & GENEALOGY DIVISION

tra nspor tation high, ca rr y ing 4.6

Ocean through the Hudson River to the

a hub for everything: manufacturing,

million tons on its waters. The 1880s

Great Lakes, and through various ca-

transportation, trade and people.

decade average was 3.6 million tons

nals connects to the Mississippi River,

Having a robust transportation system

of cargo per year. These figures are

to the Gulf of Mexico, to the Atlantic

meant New York City could sustain

made all the more impressive when

Ocean,” Torre said. “Now you’ve got a

itself through the farmlands in close

you consider the canal season is only

huge, huge transportation system that

proximity to the canal.

half the year.

hinges on the canal itself.”

“The canal connects the Atlantic

As a result, New York City became

“All of that trade came funneling in through the canal and down into CANAL HISTORY • 15


transported. But the canal would not be rendered obsolete, as it was still carr ying millions of tons of cargo throughout a majority of the late 19th and early 20th century. And the cities, stimulated by the increasing spider web of train tracks on top of the continuous use of the Erie Canal, prospered even more. By 1910, Buffalo (10), Cleveland (6), Detroit (9) and New York City (1) were all in the top 10 most populous cities. By the 100th anniversar y of the completion of the canal, however, the smaller cities it helped establish and grow had begun to show signs of decline, at least relative to other places in the country. By 1920, upstate cities had dropped in the city population rankings. Rochester ranked 25th, Syracuse 34th and Utica 73rd, while Albany, New York state’s capital, had fallen all the way to 50th. Cargo also took a step back, with the Erie Canal having less than a million tons of cargo transported on it. The diminishing importance of the ABOVE: The old Erie Canal was only

four feet deep when it first opened in 1825, but it brought prosperity to communities it passed through. This view of Utica circa 1895 is from Hotel Street looking west toward the bridge over Seneca Street and the lift bridge over Washington Street. Today, you would be looking toward Utica’s police HQ and the Memorial Auditorium. COURTESY OF THE ONEIDA COUNTY HISTORICAL SOCIETY

16 • THE CANAL THAT CHANGED AMERICA

New York City,” Utter said. “Railroads

Initially, trains “had tolls put on so

canal meant that other cities could

followed that and also contributed to

that they’d be competitive with the

gain increasing relevance, as train

the continuation of that monopoly on

canal,” Utter said. “What the railroads

transportation and freighting became

the western trade.”

would do is in the boating season, they

overwhelmingly dominant, carrying

The largest city in America would

would lower their fees and then in the

over 1 billion tons in freight nationally.

only grow, but the smaller cities’ peaks

wintertime, they would jack them up

would be short-lived, as trains, which

when the canal is closed.”

This trend would not be able to reverse itself as westward expansion

were being built across A merica ,

These tolls wouldn’t be imposed

and settlement let other cities over-

would encroach on the intercontinen-

for e ve r, a nd t he t r a i n i ndu s t r y

take the once-titans of transportation

tal business of the canal.

slowly overtook the canal in cargo

that found themselves so because of


the canal. Later in the 20th century, other factors like white flight and deindustrialization would compound the lack of purpose that canal cities found themselves facing. Now the only New York cities to remain in the top 100 most populous cities in America are Buffalo and New York City. Detroit is now 26th, and Cleveland is 53rd. While this crisis wasn’t only found in cities fostered by the Erie Canal, the rapid growth followed by subsequent decline in Albany, Buffalo, Cleveland, Detroit, Rochester, Syracuse and Utica seemed unfathomable, as the major arteries of the entire American economy had once run through them. For those still living around the Erie Canal and the cities it helped create, though, “the canal brought them their community, commercial existence and viability,” Utter said. The decline of the Erie Canal’s prominence is understandable: It has seen nearly every major American conflict and event, and has been open for 80% of the country’s life. Cargo rates have declined, the cities built by the waterway have declined, and in the 1960s, New York state — for the first

miles of the canal. The waterway is

time since the canal opened — stopped

still an economic force in the state,

being the most populous state in the

bringing in $6.2 billion in non-tourist

the “Mother of Cities” fading in na-

nation.

economic activity and $1.3 billion in

tional prominence, the Erie Canal

transportation predecessor. Despite the cities brought to life by

Still, the canal’s inf luence is un-

tourism-related revenue. And I-90,

irrevocably formed not only upstate

deniable, as 80% of New York state’s

a major east-to-west highway, runs

New York, but the nation.

upstate population lives within 25

through the same canal corridor as its

ABOVE: In 1903 the Erie Canal lay where Broad Street is today. Boys played hockey on it, and the Aqueduct Building (right background) at the west end bore the names of two companies that became parts of Lawyers Cooperative Publishing Co. ROCHESTER TIMES-UNION

CANAL HISTORY • 17


18 • THE CANAL THAT CHANGED AMERICA


The ups and downs of the Erie Canal BY KIRAN HUBBARD

at least 74,000 lockings, or passages

to the wider Erie Canal. Many of

Canal project came to be known

of boats — one or multiple at a time

these engineers had not received

as the f irst practical A merican

C O N C R E T E , G R AV I T Y A N D

— through the locks, during the sea-

formal training before working on

school of civil engineering, accord-

planks of wood might not seem like

son last year. Canal locks remain

the project.

ing to the Erie Canalway National

much to work with, but in the hands

pivotal to the functionality of the

of the right engineers, this was a

waterway.

“It wa s ver y much a sor t of

Heritage Corridor. The first formal

‘learning on-the-job’ process. And

civ i l eng ineer ing universit y in

recipe for one of the greatest infra-

Canal locks essentially work as

to me, it’s amazing that this thing

the United States, the Rensselaer

structural feats of the 19th century.

elevators, lifting or lowering ve-

worked because they really didn’t

Polytechnic Institute — originally

Scattered throughout New York

hicles through areas of elevation

understand the hydraulics,” said

called Rensselaer School — was es-

are critical pieces of state history

change along the canal. Two gates,

Sam Clemence, an SU engineering

tablished in 1824, according to the

in the form of lock structures from

one on the higher ground and one

the original Erie Canal. From those

below, enclose the vessel in the lock

protected as monuments to others

while water pumps either in or out.

lost to the wilderness, New York’s

Gravity drives this process: Slats in

explosion onto the global economic

the bottom of the gate open to allow

stage can be traced back through

water to either flow in and raise the

time to these artifacts.

interior water level, or flow out and

While the Erie Canal may not be

lower the water level, depending on

the industrial powerhouse it once

the direction the vehicle is traveling.

was, it still sees frequent use during the “open” season — between May

A new era of engineering

“It’s amazing that this thing worked because they really didn’t understand the hydraulics.” SAM CLEMENCE, SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR EMERITUS

professor. “The Canal leaked three

American Society of Civil Engineers.

and November, weather permitting

The canal was a groundbreaking

or four inches of water every day

Cofou nders A mos Eaton a nd

— from recreational and commer-

development in transportation and

just because they didn’t have good

canal commissioner Stephen Van

cial interests alike.

infrastructure when it was finished

waterproofing techniques.”

Rensselaer opened the school in 1825

According to Patrick Stenshorn,

in 1825. To tackle the project, en-

The f requent tria l a nd er ror

the education program manager for

gineers took inspiration from nar-

during the canal’s construction

the Erie Canalway National Heritage

rower English canals, adapting the

turned out to be such an effective

The unprecedented scale of the

Corridor, the canal system reported

mechanisms they observed overseas

method of education that the Erie

canal required 83 locks, each 90 feet

after most of the work on the canal was completed.

OPPOSITE: The Lock 60 historic site in Macedon sits just a few feet north of the Erie Barge Canal, or third version of the waterway that includes enlarged sections and different routes in places. Z ACH KRAHMER / SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY CANAL HISTORY • 19


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
The Canal That Changed America: The lively history, unique communities, and vital economic and socia by Pediment Publishing - Issuu