Skip to main content

Epaper_26-11-12 ISB

Page 1

In partnership with

Profit

18 terrorists killed, 10 policemen mArtyred After kohAt Anti-gold mining operAtion Thursday, 12 November, 2026 | 1 Jumada ul Sani, 1448

g

DSP HAIDAR ZAMAN AMONG 10 POLICEMEN MARTYRED IN DARABUKACH ATTACK, KP POLICE CONFIRMS

POLICE SAY 18 MILITANTS NEUTRALISED AS ATTACKERS AMBUSH TEAM RETURNING FROM JOINT OPERATION

g

RESCUE 1122 SHIFTS 12 INJURED POLICEMEN TO HOSPITAL; GOVERNOR SEEKS DETAILED REPORT

ATTACK FOLLOWS CRACKDOWN ON ILLEGAL PLACER GOLD MINING, INCLUDING BAN ON EXCAVATORS AND OPEN SALE OF FUEL

A g

g

Rs 20.00 | Vol XVII No 229 | 8 Pages | Islamabad Edition

PESHAWAR

STAFF REPORT

T least 18 terrorists were killed while 10 policemen embraced martyrdom when a police party was ambushed on its way back after completing an operation against elements involved in illegal gold mining in Kohat’s Darabukach locality, police confirmed on Wednesday. “The police party was returning after completing a joint operation against illegal gold mining with the local civil administration in Kohat’s Darabukach locality when Fitna al-Khawarij attacked the police party at the behest of criminal elements,” said a statement issued by the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Police Public Relations Directorate. “Police personnel fought the attackers with great bravery and courage, as a result of which 18 khawarij were sent to hell,” the statement said, adding that 10 KP Police personnel “embraced martyrdom while fighting bravely”. The state has designated the term Fitna al-Khawarij for terrorists belonging to the outlawed Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP). According to photographs shared by KP Police on its X account, those martyred in the attack included Deputy Superintendent of Police Haidar Zaman. In its statement, the KP Police said the “mutual nexus between criminal elements at the behest of external forces and

Fitna al-Khawarij and the joint attack on the police party is clear evidence that the criminal mafia and Fitna al-Khawarij maintain organised connections”. “This incident once again proves that Fitna al-Khawarij has no connection with Islam and Pakistan. These elements are working together with the criminal mafia for their nefarious purposes,” it said. The police vowed that “all possible action will be taken against criminal elements working with foreign backing and Fitna alKhawarij”, asserting that facilitators of terrorists and criminal mafias would not be spared under any circumstances. ‘SACRIFICES WILL ALWAYS BE REMEMBERED’ The statement said the policemen

Ch Salik confirms Maryam’s Rs5b defamation notice, vows to ‘stand by’ corruption claims LAHORE

STAFF REPORT

Minister for Overseas Pakistanis and PML-Q leader Chaudhry Salik Hussain on Wednesday confirmed that he had received a legal notice from Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz and would submit a reply soon, while reiterating that he stood by his allegations of corruption in Punjab. In a post on X, Ch Salik confirmed receipt of the legal notice and said he would respond to it shortly. “Transparency is never meant to exist behind closed doors,” he wrote. Last week, Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz served a Rs5 billion defamation notice on Hussain for allegedly making corruption allegations against her government and demanded that he retract his remarks. Earlier on Wednesday, the minister for overseas Pakistanis reiterated that he considered reality to be reality and stood by his “allegations of corruption” in Punjab. “Reality is reality. I stand by it and will continue to,” he said while speaking to a television channel. Ch Salik said he had not hesitated to make the remarks despite his brother being a minister in the Punjab cabinet, adding that he would present evidence to substantiate his allegations before the court while submitting his response to the chief minister’s defamation notice.

ATC reissues arrest warrants for ‘now-dismissed’ KP CM in Radio Pakistan arson case PESHAWAR

STAFF REPORT

The Anti-Terrorism Court (ATC) Peshawar on Wednesday reissued arrest warrants for now-dismissed Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Chief Minister Sohail Afridi and a PTI activist in the case relating to vandalism and arson at the Radio Pakistan Peshawar building during the May 9-10, 2023 unrest. ATC Judge Wali Muhammad Khan presided over the proceedings and extended the interim pre-arrest bail of PTI leaders and former provincial ministers Taimur Saleem Jhagra and Kamran Bangash, as well as the party’s Peshawar president Irfan Saleem, until November 17. The three leaders appeared before the court on Wednesday along with their counsels, Ali Gohar Durrani and Barrister Sarwar Muzaffar Shah. Advocate Ali Zaman, counsel for Sohail Afridi, informed the court that his client's whereabouts remained unknown. He alleged that Afridi had been taken away from the Chief Minister's House on October 11, following the imposition of emergency and governor's rule in the province, but his arrest had not been formally reflected in the record. The defence sought additional time to prepare the case. Accepting the request, the court adjourned the hearing until November 17. It also reissued arrest warrants for Afridi and PTI activist Amir Khan Chamkani after the earlier warrants, issued on October 28, were returned unserved The court is currently conducting the trial of 75 accused, including serving and former lawmakers, in the case registered at the East Cantt police station on May 10, 2023, on the complaint of then Station House Officer Arbab Naeem Haider under various provisions of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) and the Anti-Terrorism Act.

martyred in the incident belonged to KP, particularly Kohat, and that their “sacrifices will always be remembered”. Earlier, Rescue 1122 spokesperson Jawad Afridi said in a video message that the rescue service had shifted 12 injured policemen to a hospital after “an incident where the police party came under fire”. The attack came a day after the Kohat deputy commissioner imposed a 60-day ban on parking excavators within the limits of Block-C and Block-D of the placer gold mining area and adjacent mining zones. The order issued by the deputy commissioner’s office stated that certain individuals, groups and local residents had parked excavators at their homes near the mining areas, where the machinery

Kh Asif sees ‘alternative political setup’ behind Salik’s corruption allegations ISLAMABAD

STAFF REPORT

could easily be used for unauthorised placer gold extraction. It said that despite several operations by the district administration to clear areas of illegal mining, the continued presence of excavators in residential areas was facilitating and encouraging such activities, posing a grave threat to public order and the state’s interests. The administration said it had been compelled to take stringent measures to prevent the misuse of excavators, which had become a key tool in facilitating unlawful placer gold extraction. Through a separate order, the administration had also banned the sale, purchase and supply of petroleum products in open containers and bottles for use in unauthorised gold mining in the district. GOVERNOR SEEKS DETAILED REPORT ON INCIDENT KP Governor Faisal Karim Kundi expressed grief over the martyrdom of the policemen and sought a detailed report on the incident, according to an official statement issued by his office. While the police statement said the attack took place after the operation had been completed, the governor’s statement said the police party came under attack during the operation against illegal mining. “This cowardly act by terrorists is highly condemnable,” Kundi was quoted as saying, vowing that the attackers would be brought to justice.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif on Wednesday alleged that Minister for Overseas Pakistanis Chaudhry Salik Hussain’s recent corruption allegations against the Punjab government were part of an attempt to lay the groundwork for an “alternative arrangement” in the country’s political landscape. He made these remarks during a television programme when asked about his earlier statement suggesting that Salik’s allegations could be “part of some future political agenda — to target Maryam Nawaz’s government and carve out space for himself in Punjab and at the Centre to secure his political future”. Elaborating on his assessment, the defence minister alleged that Salik’s accusations “are part of setting the stage for some post-period”. “This statement was given selectively against Punjab. Corruption is prevalent everywhere in the country and I have tweeted about it many times,” he added. Asif went on to suggest that there was an attempt to discredit the incumbent leadership to pave the way for an alternative political setup. “There is an attempt to create an alternative arrangement — to discredit incumbent people so that a fresh team can be presented. Whoever is behind this, that is what I was signalling to. Please do not ask me anything more than this; I can share my personal assessment,” he said. He also alluded to the involvement of “some wealthy people”, describing them as “carpetbaggers” who had been active in this regard for the past six to eight months in anticipation of a “political crisis”. Asked whether the proposed “alternative arrangement” was confined to Punjab or had a nationwide scope, Asif clarified that it was not a countrywide development. “No, no. Some people are positioning themselves behind it; it is not something that is happening across the country,” he said. “These people believe that the incumbent elsewhere may also become a party to the plan, but explaining it would be premature. […] This is my assessment for now; in the long run, the plan could be dropped as well,” he added.

PM showcases Pakistan’s 22GW ‘solar revolution’ at COP31, backs global clean energy pledge ANTALYA/ISLAMABAD SALEEM JADOON

Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Wednesday reaffirmed Pakistan’s full support for the ‘35-by-35 Global Electrification Pledge’, highlighting the country’s rapid solarisation drive as “an extraordinary transition” during the COP31 climate summit in Türkiye, where world leaders have gathered to discuss collective measures to combat climate change. Addressing a high-level dialogue on clean energy transition, titled ‘35 by 35: Powering the Future’, the prime minister said Pakistan had already “undergone a remarkable transformation in its energy sector.” “In my country, an extraordinary transition has already taken place.” “In just two years, Pakistan has added nearly 22 gigawatts of rooftop solar capacity — a quiet revolution by ordinary citizens seeking affordable power and a cleaner, more predictable future,” he said. He reaffirmed Pakistan’s full support for the ‘35-by-35 Global Electrification Pledge’, under which participating countries aim to raise electricity’s share of total final energy consumption to around 35 per cent by 2035, in line with global climate objectives. This year’s summit is focused on the transition towards a low-carbon future. Delegates from nearly 200 countries are meeting in the Mediterranean resort city of Antalya as global greenhouse gas emissions show little sign of declining, while wars, inflation and other crises continue

to compete for political attention. The prime minister also recalled the recent inauguration of a “key section” of Pakistan’s seventh nuclear power plant, Chashma-5, referring to the placement of its dome. He said the project would add 1,200 megawatts of clean energy to the country’s energy mix. “A second transformation is now underway on our roads and highways. Clean sources now provide nearly 55pc of our energy mix,” he declared. Highlighting the government’s efforts to promote electric mobility, PM Shehbaz said Pakistan’s newly drafted auto policy built on the country’s target of having 30pc of all new vehicles run on electricity by 2030, offering incentives through lower tariffs. “All future government buses and motorcycles will be electric. This year, for the first time, more than one in every 10 motorcycles sold in Pakistan was electric,” he said. “The momentum is real and it is accelerating,” the prime minister remarked, while cautioning that “momentum without finance cannot be sustained”. “Our grids must expand quickly and reliably. Storage must keep supply steady. New technologies must be affordable for all. Yet, this burden falls on countries already under heavy debt,” he emphasised. He pointed out that Pakistan alone needed around $138 billion by 2035 for low-carbon power, with another $50 billion required to replace coal with solar energy.

CONTINUED ON PAGE 03

CONTINUED ON PAGE 03

– steps up diplomatic outreach at COP31, meets top world leaders to deepen ties ANTALYA, TÜRKIYE STAFF REPORT

CONTINUED ON PAGE 03

Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Wednesday held a series of informal engagements with prominent world leaders on the sidelines of the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31) in Antalya, Türkiye, with discussions focusing on strengthening bilateral relations, regional developments and the challenges posed by climate change. During the interactions, the prime minister and the world leaders underscored the need to highlight at the global level the mounting challenges confronting countries most severely affected by the adverse impacts of climate change.

days of speeches by heads of state and government. However, expectations of major breakthroughs at the COP31 negotiations, which continue until November 20, remain low as countries grapple with an oil price shock and geopolitical tensions fuelled by the US war with Iran and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Since agreeing for the first time in 2023 to transition away from fossil fuels, the main drivers of climate change, nations have struggled to make meaningful progress towards that goal at successive annual UN climate conferences. Addressing his final COP summit before stepping down in December, Guterres said governments could not continue expanding fossil fuel production while simultaneously claiming to support the fight against climate change.

“Fossil fuels must go the way of the dinosaurs, but that won’t happen on its own. The dinosaurs did not have a lobby, but fossil fuels do,” he said, delivering another forceful rebuke to an industry he has long accused of fuelling climate chaos. “Their strategy is simple: Distort the science. Delay the policy. Delay the action. Delay the accountability. It’s time to kick the habit — and end the fossil fuel addiction,” he said to sustained applause. CLIMATE SILENCE The summit, however, is being marked by the absence of several major world leaders, with British Prime Minister Andy Burnham the only leader from a G7 country scheduled to address the gathering. “Since the start of this year, climate change has disappeared from speeches and documents from our global leadership,” recently re-elected Brazilian

As part of his engagements, the prime minister met Saudi Arabia’s Minister of Energy Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman Al Saud, Bangladesh’s Prime Minister Tarique Rahman and Secretary-General of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) Hissein Brahim Taha. He also met Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Mustafa and reaffirmed Pakistan’s unwavering support and solidarity with the Palestinian people. PM Shehbaz reiterated that the government and people of Pakistan stood firmly with Palestine and would continue to raise their voice at international forums against the atrocities being committed against Palestinians.

CONTINUED ON PAGE 03

Guterres takes aim at fossil fuel lobby, urges world to consign oil and gas to history at COP31 ANTALYA

AGENCIES

UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres launched a scathing attack on the oil and gas lobby on Wednesday, urging world leaders to consign fossil fuels to history, declaring they “must go the way of the dinosaurs” as a major climate summit opened amid the absence of several prominent global leaders. The two-week COP31 climate talks began in Türkiye this week, with governments under mounting pressure to address climate change following a year of scorching heatwaves and wildfires across Europe and deadly floods in Nepal. “The brutal truth is that the climate crisis is outrunning us,” Guterres told dozens of world leaders gathered in the Mediterranean city of Antalya for two

President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva told fellow leaders. “We’ve turned to talking more about arms and tariffs than the survival of future generations,” he said. Climate campaigners welcomed Lula’s election victory, after he defeated right-wing rival Flavio Bolsonaro last month. Lula has overseen a dramatic reduction in deforestation in the Amazon. “Brazil is back to defend the continuity of a healthy planet,” he said. While European Union chief Ursula von der Leyen addressed the summit in Antalya, French President Emmanuel Macron, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni were among the European leaders absent from the gathering.

CONTINUED ON PAGE 03


02 NEWS

Thursday, 12 November, 2026 | ISLAMABAD

PAKISTAN TEXTILE COUNCIL WARNS HIGH TAXES, ENERGY COSTS AND COTTON SHORTAGES EXPORT COMPETITIVENESS

T

PROFIT

web Desk

HE Pakistan Textile Council (PTC) has raised concerns over high taxation, rising energy costs, declining cotton production and weakening competitiveness in key international markets, warning that structural challenges continue to constrain Pakistan's textile industry despite exports reaching $18 billion in FY2025-26. In its first Annual Export Performance Report, covering July 2025 to June 2026, the council urged the government to introduce tax reforms, ensure competitive energy prices, accelerate refunds and revive domestic cotton production to protect the sector's export performance. The report showed that textile and apparel exports increased by just 0.3% from $17.95 billion to $18 billion during the fiscal year, their highest level in four years. The modest growth came as Pakistan's overall exports declined by 5.9% from $32.04 billion to $30.14 billion. Consequently, textiles accounted for approximately 60% of national exports, highlighting the country's continued dependence on the sector for foreign exchange earnings.

Pakistan's oil production rises 6%, gas output increases 9% YoY in October 2026

g

COUNCIL RECOMMENDS CUTTING CORPORATE TAX TO 15%, ENSURING COMPETITIVE ENERGY TARIFFS, EXPEDITING TAX REFUNDS, EXPANDING EXPORT FINANCING, SECURING PREFERENTIAL MARKET ACCESS AND REVIVING DOMESTIC COTTON PRODUCTION

The council identified Pakistan's taxation structure as a major competitive disadvantage and recommended reducing the corporate income tax rate from 29% to 15%. It also raised concerns about Super Tax exposure for exporters falling below the 80% export-ratio threshold, arguing that the combined tax burden places Pakistani manufacturers at a disadvantage against regional competitors. Delayed sales tax and income tax refunds were identified as additional constraints on exporters' liquidity. The council called for faster processing of sales tax and deferred sales tax refunds, automated income tax refunds and integration of provincial refund mechanisms with the Federal Board of Revenue. Energy affordability and reliability were also highlighted as critical challenges, with the council seeking regionally competitive tariffs and uninterrupted supplies to improve industrial efficiency and export competitiveness. The report further identified deteriorating cotton production as a structural weakness affect-

ing the industry's domestic supply chain. Pakistan's cotton crop fell to 5.5 million bales last season, its lowest level in three decades, compared with a peak of 14.8 million bales in FY2011-12. The shortfall has increased the textile industry's reliance on imported cotton, adding pressure to production costs and supply chains. Reflecting these challenges, exports of raw materials and intermediate textile products under Harmonised System Chapters 50–60 declined by 3.4% to $3.03 billion, their lowest level in five years. These exports stood at $4.50 billion in FY2021-22. In contrast, value-added textile exports continued to dominate the sector's performance. Exports of apparel and made-up textile articles under Chapters 61–63 increased by 1.1% to $14.98 billion, accounting for 83.2% of textile exports, compared with 77% in FY2021-22. Woven apparel exports recorded the strongest growth, rising 3.9% to a record $4.295 billion. Exports of other made-up textile articles increased by 0.6% to $5.705 billion, while knitwear exports de-

clined by 0.7% to $4.979 billion. The council also highlighted weakening performance in important overseas markets. The European Union remained Pakistan's largest textile export destination, although shipments declined from $7.248 billion to $7.103 billion. Six of the ten leading products exported to the bloc recorded declines, indicating challenges in maintaining market competitiveness. Textile exports to the United Kingdom fell to $1.730 billion, with the report highlighting growing competitive pressure following India's tariff-free access under the UK-India trade agreement. The United States performed comparatively better, with exports reaching $4.853 billion and seven of the ten leading product categories recording growth. Exports to China and Bangladesh, both important destinations for raw materials and intermediate textile products, stood at $644 million and $620 million, respectively. To improve access to international markets, the PTC recommended maintaining

KSE-100 sheds 251 points as late selling wipes out intraday gains g

BENCHMARK INDEX RISES MORE THAN 1,400 POINTS INTRADAY BEFORE REVERSING COURSE IN LATE-SESSION TRADING PROFIT

Country records one oil discovery and one dry well in October as exploratory drilling rises 25% to 9,055 metres, while development drilling falls 37% to 2,242 metres

news Desk

The Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) witnessed a highly volatile trading session on Wednesday, with the benchmark KSE-100 Index shedding 251 points at close after surrendering its mid-session gains. According to the PSX website, the benchmark index opened on a weak note, falling more than 600 points in the early minutes of trading. The market remained volatile for most of the session before buying activity picked up after 1pm, pushing the KSE-100 Index to an intraday high of 180,769.21 points, up more than 1,400 points. However, the index failed to sustain its upward momentum as late-session selling wiped out the gains, dragging it down to 179,083.80 points at close. The benchmark ended the session 251.44 points, or 0.14%, lower than its previous close.

PROFIT

news Desk

Pakistan's crude oil production increased 6% year-on-year to 67,200 barrels per day, while natural gas output rose 9% to 2,997 million cubic feet per day, according to Topline Research's October 2026 oil and gas exploration activity report. On a month-on-month basis, crude oil production declined 2%, while natural gas output remained unchanged. Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) production stood at 2,132 tonnes per day, increasing 8% yearon-year but falling 5% from the previous month. The brokerage attributed the yearon-year improvement in oil and gas production to disruptions in regasified liquefied natural gas (RLNG) supplies. The exploration sector recorded one oil discovery during October at the Aassu West-1 well, operated by United Energy Pakistan (UEP). The month also saw one dry well, Ratana-6, operated by Orient Petroleum Inc (OPI), with Oil & Gas Development Company Limited (OGDCL) holding a 25% working interest and Pakistan Oilfields Limited (POL) holding 4.5%. Exploratory drilling increased 25% month-on-month to 9,055 metres from 7,270 metres in September. However, development drilling declined 37% to 2,242 metres from 3,587 metres. Seismic exploration activity also increased, with two-dimensional seismic acquisition rising 13% to 36.19 line kilometres, while threedimensional seismic acquisition grew 33% to 138.58 square kilometres. Provincial production data showed that Khyber Pakhtunkhwa accounted for the largest share of crude oil output at 49%, followed by Sindh at 35%, Punjab at 15% and Balochistan at 1%. Sindh remained the largest natural gas-producing province, contributing 59% of national output, followed by Balochistan at 21%, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa at 17% and Punjab at 3%. Meanwhile, the government granted a three-year renewal for OGDCL's Toot field until October 30, 2028, and a fiveyear renewal for Pakistan Petroleum Limited's Kandhkot Additional field until January 23, 2031. Dewan's Rodho field also received a five-year extension until January 22, 2031.

This downfall followed a strong rally on Tuesday, when easing geopolitical tensions and US President Donald Trump's remarks on the possibility of peace helped improve investor sentiment. The benchmark KSE-100 Index had surged 5,448.56 points, or 3.13%, on Tuesday to close at 179,335.24 points, supported by broad-based buying across the market. Meanwhile, Asian stock markets advanced on Wednesday as strong financial results from Nvidia-backed CoreWeave eased concerns over excessive investment in artificial intelligence, even as higher-than-expected US inflation pushed global bond yields higher and strengthened expectations of a larger Federal Reserve interest rate increase next month. The rally followed an 8% surge in CoreWeave shares during after-hours trading after the artificial intelligence infrastructure company reported strong third-quarter revenue growth and pro-

jected profitability in the first half of 2028. The positive sentiment extended to US and European equity futures. Nasdaq futures climbed 1.4%, while S&P 500 futures gained 0.6%. European stock futures also rose 0.7%, indicating a stronger opening for regional markets. Across Asia, MSCI's broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares increased 1.9%, extending its winning streak to three consecutive sessions. Taiwan's stock market gained 3%, South Korean equities advanced 2.6%, and Japan's Nikkei rose 1.5%. Oil prices steadied on Wednesday near the previous session's two-month lows, as traders weighed hopes for a de-escalation in the US-Israeli war with Iran against concerns about continued attacks on shipping in the Strait of Hormuz. Brent futures were up 19 cents, or 0.2%, to $91.68 a barrel at 0911 GMT. US West Texas Intermediate crude was down 6 cents, or 0.1%, at $85.98.

Gold rebounds to $4,057 after sharp selloff as US rate hike expectations limit gains g

BULLION RECOVERS FROM NEARLY 3% DECLINE, BUT STRONGER-THAN-EXPECTED US INFLATION AND FEDERAL RESERVE SIGNALS REINFORCE EXPECTATIONS OF A DECEMBER INTEREST RATE INCREASE PROFIT

reuters

Gold prices recovered on Wednesday after suffering a nearly 3% decline in the previous session, although gains remained limited as stronger-than-expected US inflation data reinforced expectations that the Federal Reserve would raise interest rates in December. Spot gold increased 0.6% to $4,057.33 per ounce by 0637 GMT, recovering from Tuesday's decline to $4,017.21. US gold futures for December delivery rose 0.9% to $4,065.40. The rebound followed a sharp selloff triggered by US consumer price data showing that inflation accelerated more than anticipated in October, prompting investors to increase their expectations of further monetary tightening. According to the CME FedWatch tool, traders were pricing in a 100% probability of a Federal Reserve interest rate increase in

December, compared with 84% before the inflation figures were released. Market expectations of a larger, half-percentage-point increase also strengthened following the data and comments from Federal Reserve officials indicating their willingness to tighten monetary policy further. Analysts attributed Wednesday's recovery largely to technical buying and profit-taking by traders who had positioned themselves for falling prices. Matt Simpson, senior market analyst at StoneX, said the recovery reflected a technical rebound following Tuesday's losses, while stronger inflation data and restrictive signals from the Federal Reserve continued to weigh on market sentiment. Although gold is generally regarded as a hedge against inflation, higher interest rates make non-yielding assets such as bullion less attractive compared with interest-bearing investments. Fed-

eral Reserve Vice Chair for Supervision Michelle Bowman reiterated on Tuesday that reducing inflation remained the central bank's principal priority. Philadelphia Federal Reserve President Anna Paulson also indicated that additional interest rate increases would be necessary to bring elevated inflation under control, favouring a gradual approach to monetary tightening. Geopolitical developments in the Middle East remained another factor influencing the outlook for precious metals. Soni Kumari, an analyst at ANZ, said progress towards easing tensions in the region could support gold by reducing inflationary pressures, although the broader near-term economic environment remained unfavourable for bullion. Other precious metals also recorded gains on Wednesday, with spot silver rising 2.9% to $53.01 per ounce and palladium advancing 2.5% to $1,050.05.

long-term continuity of the European Union's GSP+ preferences and pursuing additional trade agreements, including free trade agreements with the United States and United Kingdom. It also called for greater budgetary allocations for export financing schemes, relaxed eligibility requirements for small and medium enterprises and the extension of financing facilities to indirect exporters. Shipping costs and delivery times were identified as further areas requiring government intervention. The council recommended structured engagement with shipping lines to secure competitive freight rates and shorter shipment lead times. It also proposed strengthening the Pakistan National Shipping Corporation's capacity to meet exporters' requirements in major international markets. To address the domestic raw-material shortage, the council urged the government to introduce an integrated national cotton strategy focused on improving seed quality, digitising farmers and establishing traceability systems to rebuild cotton production.

Tankers continue to burn in Middle East despite hopes for de-escalation PROFIT

reuters

Despite market bets on a de-escalation in the Iran war, new evidence has emerged in recent days of strikes on tankers in the Strait of Hormuz and on energy infrastructure in the Middle East. On Tuesday, crude prices hit two-month lows after US officials downplayed the need for additional military action against Iran, with analysts noting President Donald Trump's more conciliatory tone since the Republicans' defeat in the November 3 midterm elections. However, there is little sign of attacks abating in November, after 37 ships were attacked in October, the highest monthly total since the start of the war, according to data from the Washington Institute for Near East Policy. Videos posted on social media on Sunday and verified by Reuters showed a Navig8 tanker on fire near the coast of Oman. An image captured by the European Union's Copernicus Sentinel-2 satellite on Sunday showed a large cloud of black smoke at the same location. It was one of three tankers hit on Sunday for using "unauthorised routes" through the strait, Iranian state broadcaster IRIB reported, citing the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps Navy. The vessel is managed by Navig8, majority owned by ADNOC Logistics & Services. Neither replied to emailed Reuters requests for comment. At the same time, US forces continued to enforce a naval blockade of Iranian ports. In the latest incident, a US military aircraft fired on and disabled a St Kitts-flagged cargo vessel that tried to depart regional waters after visiting an Iranian port on Saturday, US Central Command said. Attacks in the strait have caused environmental damage, with oil leaking from damaged tankers. A video shared on social media on Monday, and verified by Reuters, showed oil reaching the shores of Oman, while satellite imagery showed oil spills off the coast of Oman and UAE. The Omani government did not respond to Reuters request on Tuesday for comment on the video of oil reaching Omani shores. Elsewhere in the region, energy infrastructure and civilian facilities have also come under attack. Iran and its regional allies have struck targets including the offices of Saudi Aramco, the world's largest oil company. Video verified by Reuters showed damage to Aramco's office building in Riyadh, following Houthi-claimed missile strikes on November 8. The Saudi Energy Ministry said that a building belonging to Aramco in Riyadh had been targeted in an attempted attack, with debris causing limited damage to the building with no injuries or fatalities. The International Maritime Organization has confirmed 130 incidents, most of them attacks, in the region since the conflict began in late February, with at least 25 seafarers killed. Another tanker was struck northeast of Oman's Lima, the United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations (UKMTO) agency said on Tuesday.

PMO directs task force to finalise proposal for industrial electricity tariffs for telecom sector PROFIT

Monitoring report

The Prime Minister's Office (PMO) has directed a special task force to finalise recommendations for extending industrial electricity tariffs to cellular operators, including the financial implications and a mechanism for absorbing the tariff differential. A task force headed by the Secretary of the Ministry of Information Technology and Telecommunication (MoIT&T) was constituted on June 29, 2026, to examine industrial electricity tariffs, smart-grid solutions and dedicated power feeders for the sector. Its first meeting was held on August 4. According to a report by BR, the task force will prepare its recommendations in consultation with the Power and Finance Divisions for consideration by the federal government. The directive follows a joint letter to Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif from the chief executives of Jazz, CMPak

g

JAZZ, ZONG, UFONE, TELENOR AND PTCL SEEK LOWER POWER RATES, CITING A 197% TARIFF HIKE, 300% RISE IN FUEL COSTS AND 22% DECLINE IN AVERAGE REVENUE PER USER SINCE 2018, ALONGSIDE A 5% WITHHOLDING TAX; OPERATORS WARN RISING COSTS THREATEN $2 BILLION IN PLANNED DIGITAL INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT

(Zong), PTMIL (Ufone and Telenor) and PTCL, seeking government intervention to reduce electricity costs for telecommunications infrastructure. The operators argued that despite being recognised as an industry under government policies and tax legislation, the telecom sector continues to pay higher commercial electricity tariffs. According to the companies, commercial electricity tariffs for telecom sites have increased by approximately 197% since 2018, while fuel costs have risen by around 300%. During the same period, average revenue per user (ARPU) declined by approximately 22%, alongside an additional 5% withholding tax burden.

The operators said the rising costs were threatening investment in digital infrastructure, particularly as the industry has committed approximately $2 billion over the next three years towards 5G network deployment and fibre expansion. Companies are also investing in AI-ready Tier-III data centres. The telecom companies cited the Mobile Cellular Policy, 2004, and a subsequent government notification recognising telecommunications as an industry. They also referred to the Finance Act, 2021, which included PTA-licensed telecom operators within the definition of an industrial undertaking for taxation purposes. The operators proposed extending indus-

trial electricity rates to cellular towers, base transceiver stations, switching centres, exchanges, data centres, fibre-to-the-home (FTTH) nodes and network operating centres. Corporate offices, customer service centres, franchises and retail outlets would remain excluded, with the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) responsible for certifying eligible infrastructure. Alternatively, the companies suggested creating a dedicated Digital/Telecom Infrastructure consumer category with electricity rates equivalent to industrial tariffs. The operators argued that lower grid electricity costs could also benefit distribution companies (DISCOs) by discouraging telecom operators from shifting towards

solar and other off-grid power sources. Industry estimates suggest the proposed tariff change could reduce the growth of offgrid solar operations from 15% to 5–7% and increase grid electricity consumption by 15– 20%, potentially offsetting revenue losses for DISCOs within two to three years. These projections have not been independently verified. The companies also pledged to reinvest savings from lower electricity tariffs into 5G deployment, rural connectivity and FTTH expansion. They have requested a federal policy directive implementing the revised tariff arrangement, along with instructions for DISCOs to adopt it within a defined timeframe.


NEWS 03

Thursday, 12 November, 2026 | ISLAMABAD

SENATE PANEL SAYS $18B ‘UNCONSTITUTIONALLY' SPENT OVER ON SUBJECTS DEVOLVED TO PROVINCES UNDER 18TH AMENDMENT

T

PROFIT

Monitoring report

g

HE federal government has spent more than Rs5 trillion, or $18 billion, on ministries operating in areas devolved to the provinces since the passage of the 18th Constitutional Amendment, according to expenditure records presented to the Senate's Functional Committee on Devolution, which termed the spending ‘unconstitutional’ and directed an immediate halt to further funding, The Express Tribune reported. The subcommittee, chaired by Senator Zamir Hussain Ghumro, reviewed figures submitted by the office of the auditor general covering federal expenditure between 2011 and 2026. Ghumro said the amount exceeded $18 billion, compared with approximately $15 billion borrowed from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) during

Over 4,000 vehicles allegedly transferred using fake biometric verification, forged documents in Punjab; inquiry ordered against 11 excise officials LAHORE

Monitoring report

The Punjab Excise, Taxation and Narcotics Control Department has ordered an inquiry against 11 serving officers and officials over allegations that more than 4,000 vehicles were transferred to other individuals through fraudulent biometric verification and forged documents, The News reported. The inquiry follows audit observations highlighting suspected financial irregularities, procedural violations and the use of forged powers of attorney in vehicle ownership transfers. Under an inquiry order issued by Secretary Excise, Taxation and Narcotics Control Masood Mukhtar, Director (BS-19) Muhammad Asif has been appointed inquiry officer under Sections 5 and 9 of the Punjab Employees Efficiency, Discipline and Accountability (PEEDA) Act, 2006. The inquiry officer has been directed to complete proceedings and submit a detailed report with recommendations within 60 days. The allegations emerged from an Audit Inspection Report covering two periods, January 1 to March 7, 2024, and March 8 to August 20, 2024. The audit found that several Motor Registering Authorities (MRAs) and Excise and Taxation Inspectors (ETIs) allegedly processed hundreds of vehicle ownership transfers without referring the cases to the designated Divisional Committee, in violation of standard operating procedures issued on March 7, 2024. Under these procedures, cases involving Alternate Dispute Resolution (ADR) and designated ownership transfers were required to undergo scrutiny by the Divisional Committee before approval. Auditors also identified vehicle transfers allegedly processed using forged powers of attorney purportedly issued by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Excise and Taxation Inspector Ghulam Mohyuddin of Region-C, Lahore, has been appointed as the departmental representative to assist the inquiry and provide relevant official records.

PAC seeks delay in power companies' privatisation over Rs624b in unvalued assets PROFIT

Monitoring report

The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has proposed delaying the privatisation of stateowned power companies, scheduled for January, after auditors revealed that fixed assets worth Rs624.47 billion had not been revalued, Dawn reported. The proposal came during a meeting of the committee to examine the Power Division's audit reports for 2024-25, where Auditor General of Pakistan Maqbool Ahmad Gondal raised concerns over the government's reliance on outdated asset valuations. The committee observed that the management of power companies had failed to reassess the value of machinery, land and other properties, raising concerns about potential losses to the national exchequer if privatisation proceeded without updated valuations. Auditors also pointed out that the companies had failed to tag their assets despite directives from the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA). The Auditor General's office warned that inaccurate valuations of property, plant and equipment could distort companies' financial statements and affect assessments of their overall financial position. PAC Chairperson Shahida Begum stressed that the assets must be properly categorised and assigned their current market values before the privatisation process moves forward. She called for a follow-up meeting in three weeks to review the proposed privatisation and assess whether the necessary valuations had been completed. The committee directed the Privatisation Commission and Power Division to submit detailed reports at the next meeting.

AUDITOR GENERAL'S RECORDS SHOW OVER RS5TRN SPENT BETWEEN 2011 AND 2026, EXCEEDING $15B BORROWED FROM IMF DURING PERIOD; SENATE PANEL ORDERS HALT TO FURTHER FUNDING AND GIVES PM OFFICE FINAL DEADLINE TO WIND UP 17 MINISTRIES

the same period. He argued that Pakistan could have avoided IMF programmes had the federal government stopped spending on responsibilities transferred to the provinces. The committee directed the Ministry of Finance, the Auditor General and the Accountant General to stop releasing funds to ministries it considers to be operating outside the federal government's constitutional jurisdiction. According to the expenditure details, the largest amount was spent on the Ministry of Education at Rs1.1 trillion, followed by Water Resources at Rs935 billion, Railways at Rs687 billion and Health at Rs651 billion. Other expenditure included Rs398.4 billion on Housing, Rs313 billion on Industries, Rs270 billion on National Food

Security and Rs185 billion on Planning. The federal government also spent Rs51.7 billion on Inter-Provincial Coordination, Rs48.8 billion on Climate Change, Rs35 billion on Narcotics and Rs32 billion on Petroleum. During Tuesday's proceedings, the committee gave the Prime Minister's Office a final deadline to issue orders winding up 17 federal ministries and divisions operating in devolved areas, warning that a formal notice could follow if the government failed to comply. The panel had previously given the government two weeks to wind up ministries and divisions dealing with health, education, national food security, water resources, climate change, housing, special initiatives, culture and heritage, railways, industries, statistics,

petroleum, inter-provincial coordination, narcotics, and planning and development. Cabinet Division Secretary Kamran Afzal informed the committee that a summary seeking action on its directions had been forwarded to the Prime Minister's Office, but no instructions had been received. He defended the continued existence of certain federal ministries on practical grounds, citing international coordination requirements and difficulties in transferring responsibilities to provincial governments. Afzal said the federal government had been trying for two years to transfer Sheikh Zayed Hospital in Lahore and two health institutions in Rawalpindi to the Punjab government, but the province had declined to

PM showcases Pakistan’s 22GW ‘solar revolution’ at COP31, backs global clean energy pledge CONTINUED FROM PAGE 01

The prime minister said the ‘35 by 35’ clean energy target could only be achieved “if finance flows at the speed of ambition through concessional capital and the transfer of affordable technology”. “Let us resolve to power our economies without impoverishing our people and light up our homes without darkening our planet. That is the promise of 35 by 35, and it is a promise we must deliver together and under all circumstances,” he said. He thanked Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, whose country holds the COP31 presidency, for convening the “important dialogue”. Earlier in the day, PM Shehbaz was received by President Erdogan and United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres upon his arrival at the summit venue, the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) said. The prime minister and other world leaders subsequently gathered for a group photograph. According to the PMO, PM Shehbaz’s address at the Antalya Leaders’ Summit would focus on Pakistan’s climate priorities, the urgent need for enhanced global climate action and stronger international cooperation to mitigate the adverse impacts of climate change. The Foreign Office (FO) said the prime minister would also highlight “Pakistan’s steps towards rapid solarisation and expansion of its renewable energy capacity, as part of its transition towards a cleaner and more resilient economy, along with its efforts to strengthen disaster preparedness and early-warning systems”. He would call for predictable, adequate and accessible climate finance to enable developing countries to strengthen their resilience and pursue sustainable development, it added. The PMO said a “Pakistan Pavilion” had also been established at the COP31 venue, where 54 events would be held on various themes.

TURKIYE’S ERDOGAN HIGHLIGHTS GAZA ‘ECOCIDE’ Dozens of world leaders were scheduled to address the summit’s high-level segment on Wednesday and Thursday, including Turkish President Erdogan, Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian and Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula

da Silva, whose country hosted last year’s climate talks. “Nature — no less than people — is also paying a heavy price for armed conflicts. The starkest example of this is Gaza… what has taken place in Gaza is not only a genocide, but it is also an ecocide,” Erdogan said, drawing applause. Turkiye did not invite Israel to COP31, The Jerusalem Post reported. “As the host country for the leaders’ summit, we did not send an invitation to Israel,” it quoted Turkish Environment Minister Murat Kurum as saying. “Of course, we will discuss the climate and climate justice here. We say that there can be no climate justice where peace does not prevail.” European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, Chinese Vice President Han Zheng and United Kingdom Prime Minister Andy Burnham were also scheduled to speak on Wednesday. The United States, the world’s largest historical emitter, has stayed away from the talks for the second consecutive year after President Donald Trump — who has described global warming as a hoax — withdrew the country from climate cooperation following his return to office in 2025. Negotiators from nearly 200 countries are seeking agreement on a plan to increase electricity’s share of global energy consumption and revive stalled efforts to move away from fossil fuels. As the third day of the summit began, UN Secretary-General Guterres warned world leaders that the slow international response to climate change had put the planet on a path towards destruction. He urged governments to step up efforts to protect the planet for future generations, setting a stark tone for two days of speeches by world leaders. “The brutal truth is that the climate crisis is outrunning us. This is the path to mutually assured destruction,” Guterres said, pointing to rising emissions, global temperatures and increasingly severe climate-driven disasters. “But science is not telling us to surrender. It is telling us to fight harder,” he added.

PM MEETS WORLD LEADERS On the sidelines of the summit, the prime minister held meetings and informal interactions with leaders of various countries and international organisations. PM Shehbaz and his delegation

also held a separate meeting with Iranian President Pezeshkian and his team. The meeting focused on “bilateral relations and the promotion of mutual cooperation between Pakistan and Iran”, as well as the regional situation and matters concerning regional peace, the PMO said. In a post on X, the prime minister said he was “delighted to meet my brother”. Reaffirming the “deep and enduring bonds” between the two neighbouring countries, he said he had “conveyed Pakistan’s deep concern over the prolonged conflict in our region”. “Dialogue, restraint, de-escalation and sustained diplomacy are the only path to lasting peace,” he stressed. “Building on the understandings reached under the Islamabad MoU, Pakistan continues to play a sincere and constructive role for peace and stability in the region and beyond,” he added. The prime minister also met Kuwaiti Prime Minister Ahmad Al-Abdullah Al-Ahmad Al-Sabah, with the two leaders discussing the longstanding fraternal ties between their countries. They “reaffirmed their resolve to further strengthen cooperation in a range of areas of mutual interest, including trade, investment, energy, development cooperation and people-to-people exchanges”, the PMO said. The two premiers expressed hope that the recent ratification of the Pakistan-Kuwait defence agreement would “further promote bilateral cooperation”. They also exchanged views on international developments and challenges to regional peace. According to the PMO, PM Shehbaz also held informal meetings with Bangladesh Prime Minister Tarique Rehman, Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Mustafa, Saudi Energy Minister Abdulaziz bin Salman Al Saud, Saudi State Minister for Foreign Affairs Adel bin Ahmed al-Jubeir and Syrian President Ahmed al-Sharaa. He also met Organisation of Islamic Cooperation chief Ismail Ould Cheikh Ahmed, World Bank President Ajay Banga and Türkiye’s First Lady Emine Erdoğan. The PMO statement said the meetings also underscored the importance of highlighting at the international level the challenges confronting countries most vulnerable to climate change.

take responsibility. The committee chairman rejected these explanations, maintaining that administrative difficulties could not justify retaining ministries whose functions had been devolved under the Constitution. Ghumro argued that international coordination was the responsibility of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, while coordination between provinces fell within the mandate of the Council of Common Interests (CCI), headed by the prime minister and comprising the four provincial chief ministers. He also maintained that provincial governments could enter into international agreements under Article 173 and that international commitments did not provide constitutional grounds for retaining ministries in devolved areas.

Guterres takes aim at fossil fuel lobby, urges world to consign oil and gas to history at COP31 CONTINUED FROM PAGE 01

The leaders of Canada, Japan and India are also expected to skip the event, while Chinese President Xi Jinping, who rarely attends COP summits, was represented by Vice President Han Zheng. US President Donald Trump, who withdrew the United States from the Paris Agreement, is also absent.

FOSSIL FEAR Climate activists singled out two of Wednesday’s prominent speakers — European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese — for failing to mention fossil fuels by name in their speeches. Marshall Islands President Hilda Heine, whose Pacific island nation faces an existential threat from rising sea levels, warned that continued fossil fuel extraction threatened her country's future. “Every new oil well drilled, every new piece of coal extracted is a threat to my country’s future,” she said. “The discovery of new fossil fuel resources is not something to celebrate, but something to fear,” she added. Her warning stood in sharp contrast to Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who earlier this week announced the “good news” that his country had discovered new oil fields. In his address on Wednesday, Erdogan called for a “fair” energy transition that “takes into account the energy security and different development needs of different countries”. Saudi Arabia’s Energy Minister Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman also cautioned against pursuing carbon neutrality at the expense of energy security. “The quest for carbon neutrality without guaranteeing energy security can undermine our efforts,” he warned. “The measures that are aimed at protecting the climate should not constitute barriers facing countries and impede their achievements of economic development,” he said. Meanwhile, Finland announced concrete plans to phase out fossil fuels, becoming only the fourth country after France, Germany and the Netherlands to do so. COP31 host Türkiye is promoting a voluntary initiative to accelerate the electrification of transport, buildings and industry, setting a target of increasing electricity’s share of global energy consumption to 35 per cent by 2035. The European Union has stressed that electrification must be “clean”, a position that could trigger debate over the role of oil, gas and coal in the Turkish proposal.

18 terrorists killed, 10 policemen martyred after Kohat anti-gold mining operation CONTINUED FROM PAGE 01

“The supreme sacrifices made by the police personnel will not go in vain,” he said, adding that the martyrs’ sacrifices were a “source of pride” for the nation. “In this difficult and sorrowful time, I fully share the grief of the families of the martyrs,” he said. He also reiterated his condolences in a post on X. Parliamentary Affairs Minister Tariq Fazal Chaudhry also expressed grief over the “loss of human lives” caused by “firing by terrorists” on the police team. “The sacrifices of the police against terrorism and criminal elements are a source of pride for the entire na-

tion,” he said in a post on X. “The government and relevant institutions should bring the elements involved in this cowardly act before the law as soon as possible so that they may be brought to justice,” he added. Last week, two policemen were martyred and another injured when unidentified gunmen opened fire on them in KP’s Mohmand district. Last month, a police officer was martyred after terrorists attacked a police post in Bajaur. On October 20, an additional station house officer (SHO) of the Miranshah police station was martyred in firing by unidentified individuals near Miranshah Bypass Road in North Waziristan.

On October 7, seven policemen were injured when terrorists attacked a police checkpost in Kohat. According to the Pakistan Institute for Conflict and Security Studies, the country’s security environment remained volatile from October 30 to November 5, with renewed terrorist activity in parts of KP and the former tribal districts, alongside intensified counterterrorism operations and shifting patterns of militant violence. It is pertinent to mention that KP has been under governor’s rule and emergency since October 11, when the federal government imposed the measures, citing the PTIled provincial government’s “deliberate disengagement” from the counterterrorism fight.

PM steps up diplomatic outreach at COP31, meets top world leaders to deepen ties CONTINUED FROM PAGE 01

In response, the Palestinian prime minister expressed gratitude to the government and people of Pakistan for their consistent support for the Palestinian cause and for effectively highlighting the plight of the Palestinian people at the global level. The prime minister also held meetings with Türkiye’s First Lady Emine Erdogan, Syrian President Ahmed al-Sharaa, Saudi Arabia’s Minister of State for Foreign Affairs Adel bin Ahmed Al-Jubeir and World Bank President Ajay Banga.

PAKISTAN, KUWAIT AGREE TO STRENGTHEN BILATERAL TIES, EXPAND ECONOMIC COOPERATION Meanwhile, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and his Kuwaiti counterpart, Ahmad Al-Abdullah Al-Ahmad Al-Sabah, on Wednesday reaffirmed their resolve to further strengthen bilateral relations, with particular emphasis on expanding trade, investment and business cooperation.

The two leaders held a bilateral meeting on the sidelines of the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31) in Antalya, Türkiye, and discussed avenues for expanding cooperation in areas of mutual interest, including trade, investment, energy, development cooperation and people-to-people exchanges, according to separate statements issued by the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO). During the meeting, the two prime ministers highlighted the longstanding fraternal ties between Pakistan and Kuwait and expressed their determination to translate their excellent political and diplomatic relations into stronger economic and business partnerships. They also exchanged views on regional and international developments, particularly challenges relating to peace and security, the adverse impacts of climate change and the need for enhanced international cooperation to promote sustainable development. Welcoming the recent ratification of

the defence cooperation agreement by both countries, the two leaders expressed hope that the development would provide fresh impetus to bilateral cooperation. They agreed to work together to advance mutual prosperity, promote regional stability and strengthen sustainable development, reaffirming their shared commitment to taking Pakistan-Kuwait relations to new heights. The meeting reflected the shared desire of the two brotherly countries to deepen their longstanding partnership and broaden mutually beneficial cooperation across diverse sectors.

PM, PRESIDENT PEZESHKIAN REAFFIRM CLOSE, LONGSTANDING TIES BETWEEN PAKISTAN, IRAN On the other hand, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and Iranian President Dr Masoud Pezeshkian on Wednesday reaffirmed the close and longstanding relations between Pakistan and Iran and stressed the need to further strengthen bilateral cooperation

across all areas of mutual interest. The two leaders also exchanged views on the evolving regional situation. The prime minister met the Iranian president on the sidelines of the Leaders’ Summit of the UNFCCC COP31, currently underway in Antalya, Türkiye, the PMO said. Minister for Information and Broadcasting Ataullah Tarar and Senator Sherry Rehman, along with senior officials from both sides, were also present at the meeting. Prime Minister Shehbaz expressed deep concern over the prolonged conflict and emphasised the need for dialogue, restraint, de-escalation and sustained diplomatic engagement to achieve lasting peace and stability in the region. He also stressed the importance of building on the understandings reached under the Islamabad MoU of June 2026 and reaffirmed Pakistan’s readiness to continue playing a sincere and constructive role in promoting regional peace and stability, the PMO added.


04 COMMENT

Punjab’s PIVOT moment

Can Pakistan export cars?

t

From potential to transformation

The engineering ecosystem does not exist

HE new automotive policy has set the ambitious target of exporting cars. indeed, there are some exports (planned for the future, not in the here and now). a report in the latest edition of this newspaper’s Profit magazine looks at the proliferation of choice in the Pakistani market, and highlights the main reason this may be a pipedream: the lack of local parts in what are essentially assembled vehicles. Without putting locally manufactured parts in these vehicles, there is no incentive for importers. after all, why should importers buy Pakistani assembled cars when they can buy directly from the manufacturers directly? the only possible reason is that the manufacturers do not have the capacity for production. this means that, to exploit this rather unlikely situation, local assemblers will have to keep a close watch on the production capacity of their principals. Besides, most of the export markets have got local manufacturers of their own, which means Pakistani assemblers will find themselves negotiating a tariff minefield, beside other problems of selling. the problem all stakeholders seem to be shying away from is the need to develop the local market. at the moment, imported completely built-up units are preferred by consumers to vehicles locally assembled from equally imported completely knocked down kits. the first problem is the localization of parts is glacial, and consumers have developed the idea that local parts are inferior. Parts manufacturers have their own problems. the first is that they are not guaranteed sufficient orders needed to invest in the necessary dies. then they have to obtain certifications from the manufacturers. the proliferation of assemblers here does mean that there are more opportunities for parts makers, but there is no guarantee that their parts will fit all brands. Most of all, local industry does not have the engineering capacity to handle the back-end that they need. ideally, the country should not be looking at making parts, but making a car brand of its own. However, as first Japan,and then south korea and Japan have shown, successful brands develop from a number of local industries, backed by a strong industrial background and engineering depth. the hope that assemblers can make the leap to independent manufacturing is not just forlorn, but misguided. another obstacle to the growth of the automotive industry is the lack of a suitable car financing model. Price matters, but it is more important to put the wherewithal to buy crs into more pockets.

P

Dr MuhaMMaD Bilal Tahir

akistan’s economic debate has too often been dominated by a short-term question: how do we manage the crisis in front of us? the more important question is how we redesign the economy so that tomorrow’s opportunities become larger than today’s challenges. this is what makes the Punjab innovation for Value, Opportunity and transformation (PiVOt) Plan 2026–29 particularly significant. Launched under the leadership of Chief Minister Maryam nawaz sharif, PiVOt represents an attempt to move beyond isolated development schemes towards a more integrated model of economic transformation. its announced scale is ambitious. the programme envisages nearly Rs2 trillion in combined public and private investment, with targets including increased exports, new employment opportunities, skills development and improved livelihoods. Yet its real importance lies not merely in the numbers, but in its underlying philosophy: government should facilitate economic activity, while industry and enterprise lead growth. that represents an important shift. Pakistan has never lacked projects. What it has often lacked is integration. industry needs affordable finance. Businesses need predictable regulations. Young people need skills connected to real jobs. Farmers need access not only to production inputs but also to storage, processing and markets. Universities need stronger connections with industry and innovation. PiVOt attempts to bring these components into a single framework— linking industry, investment, agriculture, skills, technology, energy, digitalization and exports. the central economic objective is clear: Punjab must move from simply producing more to creating more value. a province that produces agricultural commodities can generate far greater economic returns through processing, packaging, branding and exports. similarly, manufacturing becomes more competitive when businesses move towards better technology, international standards and higher-value products. this transition— from production to value addition— may ultimately be one of PiVOt’s most important contributions. the immediate objective should not simply be to create new enterprises. it should also be to help existing businesses grow, modernize and compete.

Dedicated to the legacy of late Hameed Nizami

Arif Nizami (Late) Founding Editor

Beyond bilateralism M. A. Niazi

Babar Nizami

Editor Pakistan Today

Editor Profit

Pakistan’s emerging role in collective regional security

T

NaveeD SafDar

HE dynamics of Middle Eastern and south asian security are undergoing a profound structural shift as Pakistan redefines its diplomatic and defense posture. Following a high-level quadripartite diplomatic engagement held in tehran on October 26, bringing together senior security officials from Pakistan, iran, saudi arabia, and türkiye, regional strategic discourse has moved from local deterrence to broader civilizational alignments. Proposed by Field Marshal syed asim Munir during his initial visit to tehran on October 20, this consultative initiative marks an intentional pivot in how Pakistan articulates its security parameters across West asia. By presenting the deepening strategic, intelligence, and defense partnership between india’s ruling Hindutva doctrine and israel before major regional powers, Field Marshal Munir has elevated islamabad’s bilateral concerns into a collective strategic dialogue for the wider Muslim world. the tehran talks brought together Field Marshal Munir, iranian national security Councul secretary Mohsen Rezaei, saudi Defence Minister Prince khalid bin salman, and turkish intelligence Director ibrahim kalin to address West asian instability and advocate for an independent regional security structure. iranian state television later confirmed the briefing’s strategic weight. speaking on iRiB, Mr Rezaei validated that Field Marshal Munir articulated the growing ideological and military alignment between new Delhi and tel aviv, framing it as a shared threat to stability across the Muslim world rather than a strictly Pakistani concern. the premise of Field Marshal Munir’s argument relies on the documented evolution of indo-israeli ties. What began in 1992 as standard diplomatic normalization has accelerated into a special strategic partnership anchored by formal bilateral treaties. these agreements span advanced defence technology transfers— such as the co-development of surface-to-air missile systems and specialized unmanned aerial vehicles— institutionalized channels for cybersecurity and intelligence sharing, and joint initiatives in artificial intelligence and autonomous mili-

tary systems. this security convergence reflects a profound ideological overlap between india’s prevailing political ethos and israel’s national security doctrine. By outlining these capabilities before key regional actors, Field Marshal Munir highlighted that defence hardware and strategic intelligence cultivated in West asia directly impact the balance of power in south asia. the implications of Field Marshal Munir’s initiative are twofold. First, the strategic focus encompasses defence technology transfers, missile systems, UaV manufacturing, and joint technological co-development that alter the tactical balance in both south and West asia. second, the intelligence component involves counter-terrorism data sharing and signal surveillance integration, creating expanded monitoring capabilities across regional maritime and air spaces that counter alternative minilateral platforms. Field Marshal asim’s diplomatic drive introduces a proactive posture into Pakistan’s foreign policy. Rather than remaining a passive observer of West asian developments, islamabad has utilized its strategic position to foster institutional dialogue among ankara, Riyadh, tehran, and islamabad. the reaction across the international press underscores the weight of this development. Major indian news outlets, including The Times of India, have covered Field Marshal asim’s assertions extensively.

Punjab’s agricultural strength is undeniable. However, the future of agriculture cannot be measured only in tonnes produced. it must increasingly be measured in value created per tonne. this is why the focus on agro-processing and value addition is strategically important. the same principle applies to Punjab’s established industrial sectors. textiles, garments, sports goods, leather, pharmaceuticals and other industries can benefit from technological upgrading, better testing and certification facilities, stronger supply chains and greater access to international markets. the goal should not merely be industrial expansion. it should be industrial upgrading. the deepest transformation, however, will depend on Punjab’s ability to connect industry, skills and innovation. the economy of the next decade will increasingly be shaped by artificial intelligence, automation, advanced manufacturing, renewable energy, digital commerce, smart agriculture and emerging technologies. Punjab’s universities and technical institutions must therefore become more than degree-awarding centres. they should become partners in economic development. the ideal ecosystem is transformation from University Research → applied innovation → industry Partnership → Commercialization → Economic Value. this is where PiVOt could become truly transformative. if universities, researchers and industries begin working within a common innovation ecosystem, Punjab could move from being primarily a consumer and adopter of technology towards becoming a creator of technology-based solutions. the principles behind PiVOt have parallels in some of the world’s successful economic transformations. south korea combined strategic state support with industrial competitiveness and export orientation. the key lesson is that incentives work best when linked with measurable performance. For Punjab, the question should not simply be how much support is given to industry, but what that support produces: more exports, better jobs, higher productivity and technological advancement. singapore demonstrates another important principle: government does not need to replace the private sector. it must create an efficient environment in which businesses can succeed. Effective institutions, efficient regulation, infrastructure and skills become economic assets. Malaysia, meanwhile, offers lessons in moving from primary commodities towards manufacturing and higher-value participation in global supply chains. Punjab cannot simply copy these countries. But the lesson is universal: sustainable prosperity requires

I

Karachi – Ph: 021-32640318 I

moving towards higher-value capabilities. What makes PiVOt particularly noteworthy is its political ownership. Under Chief Minister Maryam nawaz sharif, Punjab’s policy conversation is increasingly connecting governance with investment, innovation, industry, employment and competitiveness. the ambition is not limited to launching individual projects. the larger question being asked is: What kind of economy should Punjab become? that is precisely why the word PiVOt is significant. Punjab is being invited to pivot: n. From raw production to value addition. n. From administrative friction to digital facilitation. n. From isolated schemes to integrated economic ecosystems. n. From dependence to competitiveness. n. the Real test is Delivery Of course, announcing a transformation plan is easier than delivering one. investment announced is not necessarily investment realized. Jobs promised are not necessarily jobs created. Export targets are not exports earned. the ultimate success of PiVOt will therefore depend on implementation, institutional coordination and transparent measurement. a public performance dashboard tracking investment, employment, exports, industrial growth and other key indicators could make this initiative a powerful example of evidence-based governance. if implementation matches ambition, Chief Minister Maryam nawaz sharif’s PiVOt initiative could become more than another government programme. it could mark an important shift in Punjab’s economic direction— from managing potential to transforming it into productivity, opportunity and prosperity. Punjab has always possessed potential. the challenge now is to convert that potential into a coherent economic future. PiVOt may be the beginning of that journey. The writer is Director, Institute of Physics, Khwaja Fareed University of Engineering and Information Technology, Rahim Yar Khan, Pakistan

If implementation matches ambition, Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz Sharif’s PIVOT initiative could become more than another government programme. It could mark an important shift in Punjab’s economic direction— from managing potential to transforming it into productivity, opportunity and prosperity.

While media commentary does not equal official policy acknowledgment from new Delhi, the prominent coverage demonstrates that Pakistan’s framing has penetrated india’s strategic debates, forcing new Delhi to navigate how its strategic alignment with tel aviv is perceived across key capital cities in West asia. Despite these diplomatic advances, the national consensus faces internal friction. Portions of Pakistan’s domestic opposition— specifically narratives aligned with the Pakistan tehreek-e-insaf— have echoed critical framing emerging from indian media platforms. in competitive political environments, domestic polarization can obscure broader state achievements. When domestic political rivalries adopt external narratives targeting military and diplomatic leadership, they risk undercutting the state’s diplomatic leverage precisely when regional coordination is taking shape. national security discourse requires a clear distinction between partisan political critique and the defense of core sovereign interests on the international stage. Field Marshal Munir’s initiative in tehran marks a shift in Pakistan’s regional outreach. By contextualizing the india-israel partnership within a wider regional framework, islamabad has urged influential regional states to re-examine their long-term strategic posture. as West asia continues to undergo realignment, the move positions Pakistan not merely as a localized actor in south asia, but as a central contributor to broader security dialogues across the regional expanse. The writer can be naveedsafdar13@gmail.com

reached

at

Field Marshal Munir’s initiative in Tehran marks a shift in Pakistan’s regional outreach. By contextualizing the IndiaIsrael partnership within a wider regional framework, Islamabad has urged influential regional states to re-examine their long-term strategic posture. As West Asia continues to undergo realignment, the move positions Pakistan not merely as a localized actor in South Asia, but as a central contributor to broader security dialogues across the regional expanse.

Lahore – Ph: 042-36300938, 042-36375965

Thursday, 12 November, 2026

Islamabad – Ph: 051-2204545

I

Editor’s mail

Send your letters to: Letters to Editor, Pakistan today, 4-Shaarey Fatima Jinnah, Lahore, Pakistan. E-mail: letters@pakistantoday.com.pk Letters should be addressed to Pakistan today exclusively

Healing family ties

FaMiLY conflicts often start with a small misunderstanding, a harsh word, or an unmet expectation. But when ignored, these little issues can grow into a silent poison that slowly destroys love, peace and trust at home. Psychologists say that most problems come from poor communication, lack of patience and unrealistic expectations. When family members stop listening to each other and try only to prove themselves right, emotional distance grows. this leads to feelings of loneliness and mental stress even within a house full of people. the good news is: this can be prevented. start by talking and listening regularly, even about small things. Be patient during disagreements, and accept that everyone has strengths and weaknesses. Use kind words like “i understand” or “i’m sorry” to build bridges, not walls. also, make time for fun and togetherness. shared moments bring hearts closer and reduce negativity. Disagreements are natural but solving them with love, respect and understanding is the real strength of a happy family. Don’t let silence ruin what love has built. ARONA SAGHIR KARACHI

Nuclear past repeats

FOR more than 30 years, the world has avoided slipping back into the dangerous cycle of escalation that defined the Cold War era. after the superpowers realised how close they had come to nuclear catastrophe, they slowly built a system of restraint. arms-control treaties, verification mechanisms, and a shared understanding of mutual destruction pushed nuclear testing into history. this long period of relative calm makes today’s renewed talk of testing all the more worrying. against this backdrop, United states President Donald trump’s recent directive to Pentagon to explore new nuclear test possibilities appears historically tone-deaf and strategically short-sighted. it overlooks the hardearned lessons of the Cold War. at the time, both the United states and the erstwhile soviet Union believed that strength came from building bigger and more destructive weapons. But each new test only provoked another response, pushing both sides closer to the edge. it was a dangerous game where one misstep could have meant annihilation. the world eventually stepped back from the brink, not because of luck, but because leaders finally recognised that nuclear one-upmanship had no winners. today’s world is far more complex than the bipolar Cold War order. instead of two major powers, there is now a multipolar rivalry involving the Us, China, Russia and several emerging nuclear states. Reintroducing nuclear tests in such an environment is like lighting a match in a room full of fuel barrels. there are more players, more tensions, and fewer rules. the old armscontrol framework — the one that helped stabilise the Cold War — has weakened over the years. key treaties have collapsed, verification has eroded, and trust among major powers is at its lowest point in decades. in essence, bringing back a Cold War-era practice now risks replaying the darkest chapters of the 20th century, but this time without the safety nets that once kept competition in check. a single test by one country could trigger a chain reaction, pushing others to respond with tests of their own. such a spiral would make diplomatic restraint harder, and strategic miscalculations more likely. supporters of new testing argue that it strengthens deterrence, but this argument ignores the fact that modern nuclear technology does not require explosive testing to remain credible. instead, political signalling becomes the real motive — and that is precisely what makes the situation so dangerous. Using nuclear tests as symbols of power invites others to do the same. the world cannot afford to treat nuclear weapons as tools of political theatre. the lessons of history are clear: once the cycle of testing begins, it becomes difficult to stop. What kept the world safe for three decades was not louder threats, but quieter diplomacy and strong global norms. Reviving nuclear testing would not make any nation safer. it would simply drag the world back towards an era of fear — an era we worked so hard to leave behind. SANAULLAH MIRANI DAHARKI

Web: www.pakistantoday.com.pk

I

Email: editorial@pakistantoday.com.pk


COMMENT 05

Ukraine and the return of great-power politics Thursday, 12 November, 2026

Harking back to Yalta

T

Dr muHammaD akram ZaHeer

HE prospect of a broader security agreement between the USA and Russia has opened a new debate about the future of European security. What initially appeared to be an effort to end the war in Ukraine is now raising questions about NATO’s position, Europe’s strategic autonomy and Russia’s ambitions to regain influence over the countries that once formed part of its political and strategic neighbourhood. The controversy intensified after US President Donald Trump met Russian presidential envoy Kirill Dmitriev at the White House on November 5. Trump suggested that an agreement with Moscow could extend beyond Ukraine and involve the wider European continent. Although he offered few details, his remarks immediately attracted attention in European capitals. The possibility that Washington and Moscow might negotiate a new security arrangement without the full participation of European governments has created considerable unease among the USA’s traditional allies. The proposed initiative comes at a critical moment. The war in Ukraine has fundamentally altered Europe’s security environment, exposed divisions within the Western alliance and revived questions about the limits of US commitments to European defence. For Moscow, the conflict has also become an opportunity to challenge the post-Cold War security order, particularly NATO’s expansion into Central and Eastern Europe. Russia has consistently argued that NATO enlargement threatens its national security. Before launching its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, Moscow demanded restrictions on NATO’s expansion and changes to the alliance’s military presence in Eastern Europe. Its demands included a rollback of military deployments and weapons systems in countries that joined NATO after 1997. These proposals

A

were rejected by Washington and its European allies, who maintained that sovereign states have the right to determine their own security arrangements. The emerging US initiative has therefore raised an important question: is Washington prepared to accommodate some of Russia’s longstanding security demands in exchange for an agreement ending the war in Ukraine? European governments are particularly concerned that negotiations could gradually establish a new understanding of European security based on the interests of major powers rather than the sovereign rights of individual states. Countries such as Poland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Romania regard NATO membership as the foundation of their national security. Any arrangement restricting the alliance’s military presence or future expansion would have direct consequences for their strategic calculations. The concern is not simply about NATO’s military deployments. It is also about the political principle underpinning Europe’s postCold War order. Since the dissolution of the USSR in 1991, countries in Central and Eastern Europe have sought closer political, economic and security relations with Western institutions. Their decision to join NATO and the European Union reflected their own national preferences, not merely the strategic calculations of Washington or Brussels. Allowing Moscow a determining role in these decisions would raise serious questions about the sovereignty of smaller European states. It could also establish a precedent in which powerful countries claim special rights over the foreign and security policies of their neighbours. For Vladimir Putin, a revised European security arrangement could provide an opportunity to secure strategic concessions that Russia has been unable to obtain through diplomatic negotiations or military pressure. Moscow may seek limitations on NATO’s eastern presence, restrictions on Ukraine’s future military cooperation with the West

and recognition of Russian security interests in neighbouring countries. However, the US position remains less clearly defined. The Trump Administration presents its initiative as an attempt to address the security concerns of all parties and create conditions for a lasting settlement. Jared Kushner, who is involved in the diplomatic effort alongside US special envoy Steve Witkoff, has identified post-war security guarantees, economic recovery and mechanisms to prevent renewed conflict as important elements of the negotiations. The immediate test will come at the planned trilateral talks between the USA, Russia and Ukraine in Abu Dhabi on November 10 and 11. The discussions are expected to address the termination of

The question facing Washington is therefore not simply how to reach an agreement with Moscow, but what kind of European order that agreement would create. A settlement that ends one war at the expense of the security and independence of other countries may leave the foundations of another crisis firmly in place.

William H. JaneWay

BOUT a year ago, the idea that speculative investment has created an “AI bubble” began to take hold and soon became conventional wisdom. Since bubbles always burst, the fear now is that time is running out for this one. The interplay between AI deployment and financial speculation can be analyzed independently of the debate between doomers and accelerationists over whether generative AI will liquidate humanity or usher in a golden age of abundance. In fact, the boom and the bubble could both be over before that debate is resolved. In a recent blog post, Noah Smith examined how massive investments in AI infrastructure and training are reshaping the relationship between the real economy and the financial system. As hyperscalers increasingly rely on borrowed money to finance those investments, he observed, they will have to generate ever larger revenues and cash flows to justify them. That makes this a good time to look beyond the current AI boom and adopt a longerterm perspective on financial bubbles. In my 2018 book Doing Capitalism in the Innovation Economy, I propose a framework for understanding the dynamics that drive bubbles and their potential consequences. The first “law” of bubbles is that any tradable asset can become the object of speculation. Speculative demand can drive the valuation of any asset to levels decoupled from the cash flows—past, present, or prospective—that represent its fundamental value. This phenomenon can be traced to the dynamics of financial markets populated by investors who do not know and cannot know the future. Recognizing that no one else can know, either, market participants watch what others do and follow suit. Each investor rationally tries to anticipate their peers’ behavior, producing the collective exercise in irrationality we call a bubble. John Maynard Keynes famously captured this dynamic in his metaphor of the beauty contest: “Professional investment may be likened to those newspaper competitions in which the competitors have to pick out the six prettiest faces from a hundred photographs, the prize being awarded to the competitor whose choice most nearly corresponds to the average preferences of the competitors as a whole; so that each competitor has to pick, not those faces which he himself finds prettiest, but those which he thinks likeliest to catch the fancy

and reduce their reliance on US security guarantees. This could reshape relations within NATO even without any formal change to the alliance. Ultimately, the future of European security cannot be determined solely by an agreement between Washington and Moscow. Ukraine must have a meaningful role in decisions concerning its territory and security, while European countries must participate in negotiations affecting their collective defence. Ending the war is an important objective, but the terms of peace will matter as much as the cessation of fighting. An agreement that recognises national sovereignty and establishes reciprocal security commitments could help reduce tensions. One that divides Europe into competing spheres of influence would risk reviving the very political conditions that the continent sought to leave behind after the Cold War. The question facing Washington is therefore not simply how to reach an agreement with Moscow, but what kind of European order that agreement would create. A settlement that ends one war at the expense of the security and independence of other countries may leave the foundations of another crisis firmly in place.

gorithms made it viable. This is where the history of earlier general-purpose technologies offers a lesson for today’s AI boom. It is not too early to conclude that generative AI will deliver meaningful productivity gains across a wide range of applications. In other words, we can expect the current frenzy to be remembered as a productive bubble. But will those gains arrive soon enough, and will they be big enough, to justify the enormous investments already being made in AI infrastructure, let alone the hundreds of billions in commitments that have been announced? We are now in a period of trial-and-error experimentation, of the kind Geoffrey A. Moore described during the IT revolution a generation ago. Identifying worthwhile applications, let alone world-beating ones, takes time, and complementary inventions are needed to adapt general-purpose technologies to particular uses. Another potential cause of delay is the need to insure against the risks of using AI across numerous domains, from medicine to autonomous vehicles. In fact, another factor slowing the buildout is the need to insure data centers and supporting power stations.

ing has become increasingly complex and leveraged. So-called “circular financing,” exemplified by Nvidia funding both the hyperscalers and their customers, the developers of large language models, provides ample grounds for concern, so much so that it now has its own Wikipedia entry. The growing reliance on private credit to fund today’s buildout, with lenders themselves borrowing from banks, is bringing the AI bubble closer to the core of the financial system. The AI bubble may still deflate rather than burst. In that case, evidence of slowing growth among LLM providers, especially Anthropic and OpenAI, along with delays and cancellations in data-center construction, may paradoxically be good news for the system as a whole. The radical shift in public attitudes toward data centers is also dampening the irrational exuberance that greeted ChatGPT’s launch four years ago. Nevertheless, the risk of a sudden, destabilizing collapse remains. The Trump administration’s track record so far inspires little confidence in its ability to handle an AI bust. Investors would do well to remember the words of Bernard Baruch, the iconic mid-20th-century speculator and presidential adviser. When asked how he made his fortune, he replied, “By selling too soon.”

The writer is Assistant Professor Pakistan Studies at Imperial College of Business Studies Lahore. He can be reached at muhammad.akram@imperial.edu.pk

When the AI bubble bursts Productive bubbles are just as certain to burst as unproductive ones. Sooner or later, economic fundamentals assert themselves

PROJECT SYNDICATE

hostilities, security guarantees, humanitarian arrangements and the future of Ukraine. European representatives are also seeking involvement, arguing that decisions affecting the continent’s security cannot be taken without their participation. The debate inevitably recalls the Yalta Conference of 1945, when the USA, Britain and the UUSR discussed the political arrangements of postwar Europe. The historical circumstances are considerably different, but the comparison highlights a familiar concern: whether major powers can determine the future of smaller states through negotiations conducted largely among themselves. There is, nevertheless, a distinction between accommodating legitimate security concerns and accepting a sphere of influence. Arms-control arrangements, military transparency, crisis communication and reciprocal reductions in tensions could contribute to European stability. Such measures would not necessarily undermine NATO or compromise the sovereignty of its members. The problem would arise if these arrangements imposed restrictions on countries that were not parties to the negotiations. Europe, meanwhile, faces an uncomfortable strategic reality. Its dependence on American military capabilities has become a subject of renewed debate. If Washington pursues a separate understanding with Moscow, European governments may accelerate efforts to strengthen their own defence capabilities

of the other competitors, all of whom are looking at the problem from the same point of view.”

TWO-DIMENSIONAL BUBBLES Neither regulatory changes nor technological advances have altered this basic dynamic. But while bubbles are ubiquitous, not all of them are the same. I have found it useful to distinguish bubbles along two dimensions, illustrated by the figure below. The first dimension is the focus of speculation. Can the assets whose deployment is being financed by speculative investment expand the economy’s productive capacity? This was the case with the 19th-century railway manias, the bull market of the “Roaring Twenties” that financed the buildout of the US electricity grid, and, most recently, the dot-com bubble that funded the internet’s global deployment at the end of the 20th century. By contrast, the Dutch tulip bubble of the 1630s revolved around tulip bulbs, which were decidedly unproductive. After some 15 years of experimentation and hype, much the same can be said of crypto. Real estate, both commercial and residential, has also repeatedly been the subject of speculative booms. The great credit boom of 2005–08, amplified by modern mathematical finance through seemingly endless varieties of derivative credit structures, is the most recent example of a thoroughly unproductive bubble. AI-generated content already accounts for half the articles published online, and not even digital forensics experts can tell what’s real anymore. Can those still offering a humanistic vision of online life make themselves heard over the din? Productive bubbles are just as certain to burst as unproductive ones. Sooner or later, economic fundamentals assert themselves. As the cash flows implicit in asset valuations fail to materialize, more and more investors recognize that the valuations cannot be sustained until a tipping point is reached. The collapse may be triggered by a high-profile failure, like that of Jay Cooke & Co. in New York in 1873. Or it may follow a less dramatic but ultimately decisive conviction that “enough is enough,” as happened in the spring of 2000. Either way, the bubble bursts. The second dimension of bubbles is the locus of speculation, which becomes especially important when bubbles pop. Was the bubble financed principally through the relatively unleveraged equity and high-yield bond markets? Or did the speculation penetrate the core banking system that finances the working capital of businesses and the real estate that accounts for much of the net

worth of workers and consumers? In a 2015 paper, Òscar Jordà, Moritz Schularick, and Alan M. Taylor examined 140 years of historical financial data, concluding that “what makes bubbles dangerous is the role of credit.” Their findings are consistent with the distinction highlighted by former Federal Reserve Governor Frederic Mishkin and other policymakers in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis. Whereas “pure, unleveraged ‘irrational exuberance’ bubbles” may “pose a limited threat to financial stability or the macroeconomic outlook,” rising asset prices and increasing leverage reinforce one another during “credit boom bubbles.” When credit boom bubbles burst, Mishkin explained, “the resulting deleveraging depresses business and household spending, which weakens economic activity and increases macroeconomic risk in credit markets.” This was very much the story of the 2008 crisis and the Great Recession. Indeed, when the dot-com bubble burst in 2000, WorldCom and Global Crossing—the two leading builders of the fiber-optic networks that carried internet traffic—went bankrupt, and WorldCom’s senior executives were even jailed for fraud. But these investments in infrastructure had been funded by junk bonds, not bank credit. The economic consequences were thus limited and could be managed through conventional monetary policy.

THE SEARCH FOR AI’S KILLER APPS Historically, when productive bubbles burst, the infrastructure they funded remained in place. No one tore up the railroad tracks, dismantled the electricity grids and power stations, or dug up the fiberoptic cables. While the first movers of each era lost vast amounts of their investors’ capital, those who followed eventually developed the killer applications and reaped the rewards. For the railroads, the killer app was mail-order retail, pioneered by Montgomery Ward and Sears Roebuck in the 1880s and made possible by the development of Railway Express. Electrification took much longer, with 50 years passing between Edison’s launch of the first electricity-generating station in 1882 and the point when the electrification of manufacturing produced the fastest productivity growth in American history. In between came the buildout of regional electricity networks and the invention of the unit-drive motor. Similarly, the fiber-optic backbone laid down during the telecom boom of the 1990s found its killer app in streaming, but only after broadband access became commonplace and advances in data-compression al-

SLOWING THE RACE FOR RETURNS Because timing is everything for productive and unproductive bubbles alike, keeping track of leverage is critical for AI investment. Encouragingly, many observers are doing just that, and there are signs that financial markets are beginning to pay attention. CoreWeave’s recent selloff is a case in point. As investment has surged, AI financ-

William H. Janeway is Distinguished Affiliated Professor in Economics at the University of Cambridge and author of Doing Capitalism in the Innovation Economy (Cambridge University Press, 2018).

REPUBLICANS PRIVATELY URGING TRUMP TO NOT BE PRESIDENT LEADING UP TO MIDTERMS SATIRE

S

THE ONION

AYING the gesture would boost his party’s electoral prospects at a crucial moment, Republicans have been privately urging President Donald Trump to not be president in the run-up to next week’s midterms, sources confirmed today. “We tactfully suggested that Republicans up and down the ticket would benefit from someone else being commander-in-chief, at least through Tuesday of next week,” said a GOP insider who did not wish to be named for fear of retaliation, adding that strategists

had assured Trump he would be re-sworn into office the moment all the votes had been tallied. “We just thought it would be advantageous for candidates to forge an identity separate from Trump and be able to say, at a town hall, ‘The president’s a private citizen now, and I’m focused on the future,’ or, ‘Let’s not dwell on my ties to a man who’s no longer president and hasn’t even been in the White House since last Thursday.’ I’m certain he realizes that a quick, short-term resignation would pay massive dividends for both his allies and, of course, himself.” At press time, the plan had reportedly been scrapped after panicked Republicans realized that JD Vance would immediately assume the presidency in Trump’s place.


06 NewS

RUSSIA AND UKRAINE AGREE ON PRISONER EXCHANGE AS PEACE TALKS MAKE LIMITED PROGRESS

R

ABU DHABI AGENCIES

USSIA and Ukraine have agreed to a major prisoner-of-war exchange following two days of USmediated negotiations in Abu Dhabi, although disagreements over territory and mutual distrust continue to obstruct efforts to end the conflict. The discussions, which concluded on Wednesday, marked the first direct peace negotiations between Moscow and Kyiv in nine months. Both sides acknowledged progress on certain issues but announced no significant breakthrough beyond the prisoner exchange. US envoy Jared Kushner, who participated alongside fellow negotiator Steve Witkoff, said the lack of trust between the two countries remained a major obstacle, particularly when addressing territorial disputes. Russia continues to demand that Ukraine relinquish control of the remaining parts of the eastern Donbas region, a condition Kyiv has rejected. With negotiations over territory making

Thursday, 12 November, 2026 | ISLAMABAD

little headway, American mediators have increasingly focused on potential post-war security guarantees, reconstruction and broader European security arrangements. Kushner expressed confidence that further negotiations could produce an agreement, although he acknowledged that some issues would require considerably more discussion. The American delegation is scheduled to travel to Moscow on Thursday for talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin, where the possible inclusion of European representatives in future negotiations will be discussed. Kushner and Witkoff are subsequently expected to meet Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy during a visit to Ireland. Ukrainian negotiator David Arakhamia described the Abu Dhabi discussions as difficult, saying the Russian delegation had arrived with firm negotiating instructions. Nevertheless, he indicated that the meetings had created momentum towards resolving outstanding issues before the end of the year. Arakhamia also called for future negotiations to include European governments rather than remaining limited to Russia,

Ukraine and the United States. Although European and NATO representatives held separate meetings with American and Ukrainian officials in Abu Dhabi, the Russian delegation declined to engage with them. Moscow’s chief negotiator, Vladimir Medinsky, confirmed that some understanding had been reached but questioned what European Union representatives could contribute without presenting new proposals. The Kremlin nevertheless indicated that Putin remained open to contact with the European Union. European officials have argued that wider discussions about regional security should follow a ceasefire and that Russia should not be allowed to determine Europe’s security arrangements as a consequence of its invasion. The negotiations took place against a backdrop of continued military attacks by both sides. Ukrainian officials reported that Russian forces struck six major electricity substations in central Ukraine, while an attack on a market in the Odesa region killed three people. Russian authorities separately reported that a Ukrainian drone strike killed one per-

son in the Belgorod region. More than four years after Russia launched its full-scale invasion in February 2022, the battlefield remains largely static, with Russian forces controlling approximately one-fifth of Ukrainian territory, including areas occupied before the invasion. Moscow has continued targeting Ukrainian cities and energy infrastructure, while Kyiv has intensified strikes against Russian

oil refineries and other facilities. US President Donald Trump has repeatedly expressed optimism about securing a peace agreement and has increased pressure on Ukraine to accept a negotiated settlement. However, the latest round of discussions has produced no public indication that Moscow is prepared to withdraw its territorial demands or that Kyiv is willing to accept them.

Nvidia loses $430b in market value amid scrutiny over China chip ties, CeO's affair PROFIT STAFF REPORT

Nvidia has lost approximately $430 billion in market value over two trading sessions as allegations involving CEO

Jensen Huang's relationship with a Chinese businesswoman suspected of espionage intensified scrutiny of the company's governance and chip exports to China. The chipmaker's shares have fallen 9.5% since reports of the relation-

ship emerged, amid allegations that the woman, identified as Alice Huang, helped facilitate at least $7.5 billion worth of Nvidia chip shipments to China. According to a report by The Information, Alice Huang, also known as Huang Le, used her connections with Nvidia to secure approximately 240,000 H100, H200 and A100 chips, including models subject to US export restrictions. Some of the chips reportedly reached Chinese technology companies, including Alibaba and Tencent, as well as smaller artificial intelligence laboratories. Reuters said it could not independently verify the allegations. The controversy has prompted Nvidia's independent directors to appoint outside legal counsel to investigate the matter, while the FBI is separately examining

Singapore to offer gold storage for foreign central banks in 500tonne vault

PROFIT (STAFF REPORT): Singapore will introduce a gold storage service for foreign central banks and other sovereign institutions, using a national currency vault with capacity for 500 metric tonnes of bullion, as part of efforts to strengthen its position in the international precious metals market. The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) announced the initiative on Tuesday, alongside plans to extend existing tax relief to additional wholesale gold market services and develop new trading infrastructure. The vaulting service will allow foreign central banks, international financial institutions and sovereign entities to hold bullion reserves in Singapore's national currency vault.

whether Huang was targeted by a foreign intelligence operation. Nvidia said its board had no reason to believe that US national security or company secrets had been compromised. Huang has committed to cooperating with the internal investigation. The company has retained Joon Kim, a former acting US Attorney for the Southern District of New York and a partner at Wachtell Lipton, to lead the review. The allegations have also triggered political pressure in Washington. Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer demanded a full accounting of President Donald Trump's handling of the matter and called for tighter restrictions on semiconductor exports to China.

Karachi: Syed Hassan Raza, son of Syed Raza Akbar, secured second position in First Class with distinction in the M.Sc. Applied Physics examinations 2026, conducted by the University of Karachi. On this occasion, the then Vice Chancellor of the University of Karachi, Dr. Khalid Iraqi, awarded him the degree and a certificate of distinction.


NEWS 07

Thursday, 12 November, 2026 | ISLAMABAD

CORPORATE CORNER

ChildLife Foundation treats more than 95,000 children with pneumonia in 2026 ISLAMABAD

STAFF REPORT

The ChildLife Foundation has treated more than 95,000 children with pneumonia in its Emergency Rooms across Pakistan in 2026 as pneumonia remains the world’s leading infectious cause of death among children. According to a 2025 UNICEF report, a child dies from pneumonia every 43 seconds somewhere in the world and the toll is also severe in Pakistan. This year’s theme, “A New Era of Pneumonia Control,” recognizes advances in vaccines, diagnostic tools and treatments. In a message on World Pneumonia Day 2026 the ChildLife Foundation is calling for urgent action to prevent these deaths and ensure every child can access timely diagnosis and treatment. “Pneumonia can become life-threatening, but children can survive when they receive the right care in time,” said Dr. Irfan Habib, Medical Director at ChildLife Foundation. He added that families should take breathing difficulties seriously, and health systems must ensure that quality diagnosis and treatment are within reach for every child. Children facing malnutrition are especially vulnerable. Wasting, when a child is too thin for their height, has been associated with 54% of pneumonia cases. Indoor air pollution from solid fuels and outdoor air pollution can also increase children’s vulnerability. Preventing pneumonia takes more than one intervention. Children need routine immunization, adequate nutrition, breastfeeding, safe water, sanitation, and hygiene. When a child becomes ill, early diagnosis and timely treatment are essential. Dr. Habib stated that ChildLife Foundation’s Emergency Rooms follow standardized protocols for treating pneumonia in children. All 16 Emergency Rooms are equipped to manage severe cases. They can provide interventions such as oxygen therapy, bubble CPAP (a noninvasive form of respiratory support), and antibiotics when clinically indicated.

Rana Sanaullah distributes Rs4m cash awards among Asian Squash Champions ISLAMABAD

STAFF REPORT

Minister for Inter-Provincial Coordination and President Pakistan Sports Board (PSB) Rana Sanaullah Khan on Wednesday distributed cash awards of Rs1 million each among four members of Pakistan's gold medal-winning men's squash team in recognition of their historic triumph at the 23rd Asian Team Squash Championships 2026. The award distribution ceremony was held at the Pakistan Sports Board, Islamabad, to honour the national players for their outstanding performance in the continental championship, held at the Mushaf Squash Complex from November 3 to 7. The four players receiving cash awards were Noor Zaman, Muhammad Asim Khan, Nasir Iqbal and Ashab Irfan. Each player received Rs1 million, taking the total cash awards to Rs4 million. Secretary Ministry of Inter-Provincial Coordination Mohyuddin Ahmad Wani, Director General Pakistan Sports Board Yawar Hussain and Secretary General Pakistan Squash Federation Group Captain (Retd.) Amir Nawaz also attended the ceremony. On the occasion, Rana Sanaullah congratulated the players, coaches and management of the national team, describing their achievement as a matter of immense national pride. He appreciated the players' dedication, discipline and determination, which enabled Pakistan to clinch the prestigious Asian title on home soil.

inDrive trains 750 children in AI and coding skills KARACHI

STAFF REPORT

inDrive, a global mobility and urban services platform, has partnered with the CIRCLE Women Association and Tech Valley to launch a comprehensive, free STEM and artificial intelligence education programme for the children of its driver community. Against the backdrop of Pakistan's broader educational landscape, there are roughly 25 million children between the ages of 5 and 16 who are not in school, marking the second largest out-of-school population in the world. Providing accessible, high-quality learning opportunities has never been more urgent. To bridge this divide, the initiative delivers targeted training through two specialized pillars. Launched in September, 2026, the programme is an exclusive benefit for drivers enrolled in the platform’s Platinum and Legend loyalty tiers, the initiative provides over 750 children across Pakistan with professional training in coding, digital citizenship, and generative AI. Awais Saeed, Country Manager for inDrive Pakistan, highlighted the core motivation behind the initiative, stating, "Our drivers are the true backbone of inDrive, working tirelessly every day to keep our communities connected. This initiative is a direct investment in their children's future. By collaborating with trusted leaders like CIRCLE Women and Tech Valley, we are proud to offer this benefit to our drivers, equipping the next generation with the tech and AI skills to thrive in tomorrow's economy." Sadaffe Abid, Founder and CEO of CIRCLE Women, commented, "A child who can build an app sees the world differently than a child who can only use one.

CM MARYAM INAUGURATES JHELUM CATH LAB, VOWS ANGIOPLASTY WITHIN 24 HOURS g

PUNJAB CM SAYS PATIENTS WILL NO LONGER NEED TO TRAVEL TO OTHER CITIES FOR CARDIAC TREATMENT LAHORE

SALEEM JADOON

Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz on Tuesday inaugurated a cardiac catheterisation laboratory (Cath Lab) at District Headquarters Hospital and the restoration project of the Gymnasium and Sports Complex in Jhelum, declaring that patients would no longer need to travel to other cities for cardiac treatment. During her visit to the hospital, the chief minister inspected the wards, semimodular unit and operation theatre and checked the quality and expiry dates of medicines and injections. She also witnessed a live angiography procedure from the control room and interacted with patients recovering after undergoing angioplasty. A Dubai-based driver, Shehzad Naveed, told the chief minister that he had returned to Pakistan to receive free cardiac treatment after developing a heart condition. He said he had initially been

given an appointment in Faisalabad after a week's wait but, on his sister's advice, opted for Jhelum, where he underwent immediate angioplasty. Taking notice of delays in cardiac treatment, CM Maryam directed that no patient requiring angioplasty at any hospital in Punjab should have to wait more than 24 hours. She said the Cath Lab, equipped with angiography, angioplasty, ECG, a modern operation theatre and ventilators, had so far provided treatment to 2,400 patients. Later, the chief minister visited Zahida Bibi at her newly constructed fourmarla house in New Abadi Islam Pura, Jhelum, built through a loan under the Apni Chhat Apna Ghar scheme. She formally inaugurated the house alongside the beneficiary and her family. Sharing her experience, Zahida Bibi told the chief minister that her family had worked day and night to complete the house, with labourers working during the day and family members taking over the

work at night. She became emotional while expressing her gratitude, saying the scheme had finally enabled her family to own a roof over their heads. The chief minister interacted with the family and children and conveyed greetings from PML-N President Nawaz Sharif. She was also served traditional saag, potato bhujia and homemade roti, which she appreciated. Maryam Nawaz said providing people with homes of their own brought her immense satisfaction. Describing Apni Chhat Apna Ghar as Punjab's largest lowcost housing project, she said its features and impact were receiving international recognition.

RESTORATION PROJECT OF JHELUM GYMNASIUM AND SPORTS COMPLEX Meanwhile, Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz inaugurated the restoration project of the Gymnasium and Sports Complex in Jhelum. Upon her arrival at the gymnasium, players accorded the chief minister a warm and enthusiastic welcome. Young girls holding posters greeted her, while she responded affectionately and exchanged high-fives with them. Young girls also paid tribute to the chief minister by singing the popular folk song “Teriyan Reesan Kaun Kare”. Maryam Nawaz joined in the sporting activities, playing badminton with a female player and applauding a chess player to encourage her.

Azma Bokhari slams Salik Hussain, tells him to quit ministerial posts and go home LAHORE

Opening ceremony of 30th CNS Open Golf Championship 2026 held at Karachi Golf Club

STAFF REPORT

Punjab Minister for Information and Culture Azma Bokhari, reacting strongly to Ch Salik Hussain’s statement, said his remarks suggested that he had lost his senses, adding that the Chaudhry family had first been put to the test by Moonis Elahi and was now facing another challenge because of Salik Hussain. Azma Bokhari said the two incompetent youngsters had badly tarnished the Chaudhry family’s longstanding legacy of dignified and graceful politics. She said they had repeatedly betrayed the very Sharif family that had helped establish their political identity as Chaudhrys. She added that Salik Hussain’s choice of words increasingly reflected street-corner rhetoric rather than the measured language expected of a serious political leader. The provincial information minister said those who ridiculed and demeaned women could not

KARACHI

claim to uphold dignified political values. She said Salik Hussain had failed to respond to Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz’s notice for a week and, if he was unable to respond, he should resign from his ministerial positions and go home. Azma Bokhari said that, on the one hand, they continued raising the issue of corruption while, on the other, they kept seeking funds from the government. "How can anyone pursue such a contradictory political approach?" she asked. She said the development

projects delivered by Maryam Nawaz in Gujrat were beyond what her political opponents could accomplish in three generations. Azma Bokhari further said Maryam Nawaz had given Gujrat its due rights, something that Zahir Elahi, Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain and Pervaiz Elahi had failed to deliver over the past 50 years. "Instead of delivering lectures on television, they should resign and sit on the opposition benches. Only then will they realise the realities of political life," she added.

CDA Chief holds open court in Park Enclave ISLAMABAD

STAFF REPORT

Chairman Capital Development Authority (CDA) and Chief Commissioner Islamabad Sohail Ashraf held an open kutcheri in Park Enclave on Wednesday. Member Estate Muhammad Zaman Wattoo, Member Building Asmat Sharif Dhillon, Member Environment Abdullah Khurram Niazi, relevant Director Generals, other relevant senior officers as well as a large number of citizens participated in the event. The purpose of holding the open kutcheri was to listen to the suggestions and issues of the allottees and residents of Park Enclave. On this occasion, the residents of Park Enclave placed before Chairman CDA their issues relating to the repair of boundary wall, sanitation system, public parks, security, electricity supply in Park Enclave Phase Two and Three and other basic facilities. Chairman CDA Sohail Ashraf directed that the sanitation system in Park Enclave be improved under modern solid waste manage-

The opening ceremony and media brief of 30th Chief of the Naval Staff (CNS) Open Golf Championship 2026 was held at Karachi Golf Club (KGC). The championship is scheduled from 11 to 15 Nov 2026. Commander Karachi and President KGC, Vice Admiral Muhammad Faisal Abbasi, graced the occasion as Chief Guest and formally inaugurated CNS Open Golf Championship 2026. The Golf Championship will be played in Professionals, Senior Professionals, Junior Professionals, Ladies Professionals, Senior Amateurs, Junior Amateurs, Ladies Amateurs, Veterans and Pro-Amateurs categories. A large number of professional golfers from across the country are participating in the tournament. There are awards and cash prizes in various categories including special prize for ‘Hole in One’.

SAP Identifies SMEs, AI and Skilled Workforce as Key Drivers of Pakistan's Digital Economy KARACHI

STAFF REPORT

ment services, and that work be carried out regarding the repair of a boundary wall to improve security in Phase One. On the identification of the issue of the remaining work on Park Enclave's central mosque and the parking problem, Chairman CDA directed that the construction work of the mosque be completed and the parking issue be resolved immediately. Chairman CDA said that the BUP issue present in Park Enclave will also be resolved soon. He directed that the electricity supply issue in Phase Two and Three be resolved on a priority basis. He directed that the remaining development work in Phase Three be

Saudi Prince attends dinner reception hosted by Aqeel Dhedhi at Arkadians KARACHI

STAFF REPORT

STAFF REPORT

His Highness Prince Mansour bin Abdullah Al Saud Chairman Saudi-Pakistan Business Council attended an exclusive dinner reception hosted in his honour by AKD Group Chairman Mr Aqeel Karim Dhedhi at The Arkadians, DHA Phase VIII, Karachi. The distinguished gathering was attended by Governor Sindh Mr Nehal Hashmi, Sindh Ministers Syed Nasir Hussain Shah and Saeed Ghani, Advisor to the Chief Minister Sindh on Investment Syed Qasim Naveed Qamar, and Chairman Arif Habib Group Mr Arif Habib, along with other prominent personalities from the business, political and social sectors. CEO Creek Developers Ms Ayesha Karim Dhedhi highlighted the salient features of their flagship real estate project The Arkadians in presence of the distinguished guests. During the reception, Governor Sindh Mr Nehal Hashmi highly appreciated.

completed soon and said that issues related to sewage, water supply and up-gradation of parks should also be resolved on a priority basis. Chairman CDA Sohail Ashraf directed that the handing over of possession of plots be ensured through a QR Code. He directed that the process of giving possession in Park Enclave be made transparent and easy. Chairman CDA said that the commercial areas of Park Enclave be developed entirely on modern lines. He said that modern and beautiful street lights be installed on a permanent basis on the boulevard (service) road.

IG Railways Police Shahzada Sultan Receives Warm Welcome on Assuming Charge LAHORE

STAFF REPORT

Shahzada Sultan has formally assumed charge as the 30th Inspector General of Pakistan Railways Police. Upon his arrival at the Central Police Office (CPO), Lahore, the IG Railways Police was accorded a warm and enthusiastic welcome by senior officers and CPO staff. A smartly turned-out contingent of Railways Police presented him with a guard of honour. The IG Railways Police also laid a floral wreath at the Martyrs' Memorial and offered Fateha for the departed souls.

Artificial Intelligence (AI), small and mediumsized enterprises (SMEs), education and workforce development are emerging as key drivers of Pakistan’s digital transformation. As businesses increasingly embrace digital technologies; strategic adoption and investment in skills development will be essential to maximizing the benefits of this transformation and building a future-ready workforce. Speaking at a media roundtable held alongside SAP Innovation Day, Saqib Sabah, Head of MEA North Growth Cluster at SAP, highlighted Pakistan's potential to contribute to the regional and global technology ecosystem through its skilled workforce and growing technology capabilities. “Pakistan has good education, talent and, more importantly, ambition.

NBP Steps Forward to Boost Pakistan Hockey ISLAMABAD

STAFF REPORT

In an encouraging development for Pakistan's national game, a delegation from National Bank of Pakistan (NBP) visited the Pakistan Sports Board in Islamabad to establish its Hockey Team. The delegation included Mr. Mudassir Inamullah, Senior Vice President and Divisional Head, Strategic Marketing Division; Mr. Shahid Afridi, NBP Sports Consultant; Mr. Muhammad Shahid Islam, Deputy Director General, Pakistan Sports Board; and other senior officials. The initiative aims to effectuate the Prime Minister’s directives on providing young Hockey players with valuable opportunities, including employment and incentives, so they can pursue the sport professionally. Federal Secretary, Ministry of Inter-Provincial Coordination, Mr. Mohyuddin Ahmad Wani, commended NBP’s initiative, terming it a significant contribution towards the promotion and development of sports in Pakistan. He appreciated NBP as a major national institution, which has come forward to field its Hockey team and welcomed NBP's institutional support for rebuilding Pakistan Hockey and securing a sustainable future for the country's young talent.


JI ANNOUNCES FRESH RALLIES, REFUSES TO END PROTESTS OVER PETROLEUM LEVY

Thursday, 12 November, 2026

PRAYER TIMINGS

NEWS

J

LAHORE

STAFF REPORT

AMAAT-E-ISLAMI (JI) chief Hafiz Naeemur Rehman on Wednesday announced fresh public rallies in Quetta and Lahore as his party vowed to continue nationwide demonstrations until the government abolishes the petroleum levy. Addressing a press conference at the party’s headquarters in Mansoora, Rehman said JI would hold a rally in Quetta on November 22, followed by a gathering at Minar-e-Pakistan in Lahore on November 29. Similar demonstrations are also planned in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Karachi. He maintained that negotiations with the federal government would continue alongside the protests, insisting that recent reductions in fuel prices and the introduction of targeted subsidies did not adequately address the financial burden on consumers. The JI chief said nine rounds of negotiations had taken place between the party and government representatives, during which the government linked the petroleum levy to commitments under the International Monetary Fund programme. Rehman criticised the limited scope of the government’s fuel relief scheme, saying officials had informed JI that approximately 15 million people

were benefiting from the arrangement. He demanded that the subsidy be extended to vehicles with engine capacities of up to 1,300cc instead of the existing 800cc threshold, arguing that salaried and middle-income households also relied on larger vehicles. The party also wants tractors and public transport vehicles included in the relief programme to reduce operating costs for farmers and commuters. Rehman proposed increasing import duties on vehicles with engines exceeding 1,800cc and placing a greater share of the petroleum levy on owners of larger vehicles rather than ordinary consumers. He also called for restrictions on government officials using vehicles with engine capacities above 1,300cc, alongside reductions in official expenditure and

privileges. Questioning the distribution of fuel-related revenue, Rehman claimed the government collected approximately Rs150 billion every month through the petroleum levy while providing only Rs26 billion to Rs30 billion in relief. He argued that the subsidy remained insufficient, particularly for motorcycle users, claiming that more than 25 million motorcyclists were not adequately covered by the existing arrangements. The JI chief also credited his party’s protest campaign with pressuring the government to reduce fuel prices, although he maintained that the reductions did not justify ending the demonstrations. Turning to provincial matters, Rehman criticised the Punjab government’s agriculture and education policies, alleging that wheat growers were not re-

ceiving appropriate compensation for their produce. He also questioned the performance of the education system, referring to reports that 52% of ninth-grade students had failed their examinations. Rehman further accused businesses in the oil refining, sugar, gas, flour and power sectors of engaging in cartel-like practices that increased costs for consumers. JI began its campaign against the petroleum levy in August, organising demonstrations and sit-ins in several cities. Protesters gathered outside governors’ residences in provincial capitals on August 16 before the party expanded its activities to other parts of the country. The federal government and JI agreed in early September to establish technical committees to examine proposals for reducing petroleum prices and the levy. However, subsequent negotiations failed to resolve the dispute, prompting the party to announce a long march towards Islamabad. The march began on September 20 but was later suspended after Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif contacted Rehman and requested additional time for negotiations. JI subsequently gave the government 10 days to abolish the levy and provide further relief, warning that the march towards Islamabad could resume in mid-November if its demands remained unmet.

Power supply-demand gap widens to 1,500MW amid declining hydel generation PROFIT AHMAD AHMADANI

Pakistan's electricity supply-demand gap widened to 1,500MW on Wednesday as declining hydropower generation and limited gas-based power availability constrained supplies against peak demand of 16,000MW, according to the Independent System and Market Operator (ISMO). The power system recorded peak demand of approximately 16,000MW against available generation of around 14,500MW, leaving a shortfall of nearly 1,500MW. The gap reflected constraints on the generation side, particularly reduced hydropower output and limited availability of gas-based electricity generation.

Hydropower generation from Tarbela Dam remained around 800MW below its normal level, with output averaging approximately 1,200MW in line with water releases under the Indus River System Authority (IRSA) indents. The reduction in water availability followed higher-than-usual releases after the incident at the Tarbela 5th Extension Hydropower Project. However, Tarbela's generating units had not been completely shut down, and the reduced output was linked to water availability for electricity generation. Generation conditions at Mangla Dam had improved, with two units that had earlier experienced outages restored to operation. Similarly, the Jamshoro coal-fired power plant had also returned to operation, adding to electricity generation available to the national grid.

Centre deducts Rs35b from provinces under first-of-its-kind revenue arrangement PROFIT

STAFF REPORT

The federal government has deducted Rs34.839 billion from the four provinces during the first two months of FY2027 under a revenue-sharing arrangement introduced for the first time in Pakistan's history. The News reported, citing senior Finance Division officials, that the amount was collected as provincial grants under Article 164 of the Constitution and recorded as non-tax revenue against the federal government's annual target of Rs1.035 trillion. The Centre and the four provincial governments had agreed ahead of the FY2027 budget that the provinces would contribute grants from their National Finance Commission (NFC) shares to help meet federal financial obligations under Pakistan's $7 billion International Monetary Fund (IMF) programme. The federal government plans to direct the receipts towards water infrastructure projects, including the Diamer-Bhasha and Dasu hydropower projects and Karachi's K-IV water supply scheme. The Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) approved a Rs275 billion technical supplementary grant for water sector projects on November 4, with funding expected to be provided in phases. Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb had earlier indicated that the arrangement for provincial contributions would continue over the medium term, although he did not specify its duration in the absence of a new NFC Award.

Limited availability of re-gasified liquefied natural gas (RLNG) had also affected the generation mix during the earlier part of November. Between November 1 and 6, distribution companies had managed electricity demand for one to two hours during non-solar periods to conserve RLNG for power generation. The Independent System and Market Operator said the additional generation shortfall was being managed through residual fuel oil (RFO)-based power plants to bridge the gap between electricity demand and available supply. Regarding electricity load management, the operator clarified that distribution companies were following their existing schedules of approximately 1.5 to two hours, with no additional loadmanagement schedule introduced in response to the latest system position.

Load management had reached up to three hours on November 10 amid temporary generation constraints involving Tarbela, Jamshoro coal generation and two Mangla units. The affected Mangla units have since been restored. The system-wide generation deficit of 1,500MW should not be interpreted as uniform additional load-shedding across the country. Actual electricity outages vary according to distribution companies' existing schedules and local system conditions. The latest position highlights the importance of hydropower availability and adequate fuel supplies for thermal power plants in maintaining electricity generation, particularly during evening peak hours when solar output declines and the power system increasingly relies on other generation sources.

FAJR SUNRISE

ZUHR

ASR MAGHRIB ISHA

6:25

1:30

4:00

5:50

5:10-

CDF Munir calls shooting proficiency hallmark of professional soldier RAWALPINDI

STAFF REPORT

Chief of Defence Forces (CDF) and Chief of Army Staff (COAS) Field Marshal Syed Asim Munir on Wednesday underscored that shooting proficiency was a hallmark of a professional soldier, stressing that mastery of small arms must remain a core component of basic military training. The CDF made these remarks while addressing the closing ceremony of the 46th Pakistan Army Rifle Association (PARA) Central Meet, held at the Army Marksmanship Unit (AMU), Jhelum. The mega shooting event, conducted from October 7 to November 11, 2026, brought together participants from across the country for a major marksmanship competition, said a news release issued by th e Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR). Chief of the Naval Staff (CNS) Admiral Naveed Ashraf, NI, NI (M), T Bt, attended the ceremony as the Guest of Honour and, alongside the COAS and CDF, presented trophies and medals to the winners and runners-up in various categories. More than 1,500 shooters from the Army, Navy, Air Force, Civil Armed Forces, including Rangers (Sindh and Punjab), GilgitBaltistan Scouts, and teams from Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Balochistan, the Federal Rifle Association and civilian participants took part in the competition. In the 4th Inter-Services Combat Shooting Championship, the Pakistan Army clinched the championship trophy, while the Army Marksmanship Unit of the Pakistan Army won the Prime Minister’s ‘Skills at Arms’ Big Bore National Challenge Match. The highest military shooting honour, the ‘Master at Arms’ Trophy (Doli Cup), was awarded to Havildar Fazal Rehman of the Punjab Regiment. The regiment also secured victories in the Unit Firing Proficiency Match and the Infantry Squad Match. Interacting with the participants, Field Marshal Asim Munir lauded the shooters for their exceptional marksmanship and precision, reiterating that shooting proficiency was a hallmark of a professional soldier. Earlier, upon his arrival, the COAS was received by the Inspector General Training and Evaluation (IG T&E) and Commander Rawalpindi Corps.

Pakistan reduces petrol price to Rs335, diesel to Rs364 per litre ISLAMABAD

STAFF REPORT

Ogra allows four refineries to export 165,000 tonnes of furnace oil in November PROFIT

STAFF REPORT

The Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority (Ogra) has permitted four Pakistani refineries to export a combined 165,000 tonnes of furnace oil in November, allowing them to manage surplus inventories amid changing domestic demand for the fuel. Pak-Arab Refinery Limited (Parco) has received the largest export allocation of 60,000 tonnes, followed by Pakistan Refinery Limited (PRL) and Cnergyico PK Limited (CPL), which have each been authorised to export 50,000 tonnes. National Refinery Limited (NRL) has been permitted to export another 5,000 tonnes, bringing the total approved volume to 165,000 tonnes. The permissions follow an assessment of domestic furnace oil requirements, with refineries seeking overseas markets for surplus production as the country's electricity generation mix continues to

evolve. Pakistan exported 307,368 tonnes of furnace oil during the first quarter of FY2027, comprising high-sulphur furnace oil (HSFO), low-sulphur furnace oil (LSFO) and medium-sulphur furnace oil (MSFO). HSFO accounted for the largest share, with exports reaching 246,417 tonnes during July– September. Monthly shipments stood at 29,853 tonnes in July, increased sharply to 123,269 tonnes in August and declined to 93,295 tonnes in September. LSFO exports totalled 52,597 tonnes, including 26,411 tonnes in July and 26,186 tonnes in September. No LSFO shipments were recorded in August. Pakistan also exported 8,354 tonnes of MSFO, entirely during July, while naphtha exports amounted to 22,282 tonnes during the quarter. No exports of verylow-sulphur furnace oil (VLSFO) were recorded. Despite the substantial export volumes, domestic furnace oil consumption for electricity gener-

ation increased significantly in September. Power generation from furnace oil rose 171% year-on-year to 263 gigawatt-hours (GWh) in September 2026, compared with 97 GWh in the corresponding month of the previous year. The increase coincided with reduced electricity generation from regasified liquefied natural gas (RLNG), as the closure of the Strait of Hormuz disrupted supplies from Qatar and affected the availability of imported gas in Pakistan. Furnace oil remains an important component of the country's power generation mix, although its consumption varies according to electricity demand, fuel prices and the availability of alternative energy sources. Greater reliance on other fuels in recent years has reduced the demand for furnace oil at certain times, leaving refineries with surplus stocks that can constrain storage capacity and increase inventory holding costs.

The federal government on Wednesday announced another reduction in petroleum prices, cutting petrol by Rs3 per litre and high-speed diesel (HSD) by Rs7 per litre for November 12. According to a notification issued by the Petroleum Division, petrol will now be available at Rs335 per litre, compared with the previous rate of Rs338, while diesel will cost Rs364 per litre, down from Rs371. The latest adjustment marks the second consecutive day of reductions, following Tuesday’s decision to lower petrol prices by Rs8 per litre and diesel by Rs7 per litre. Combined, the two revisions have brought petrol prices down by Rs11 per litre and diesel by Rs14 per litre. The reductions come as the government continues to implement its daily petroleum pricing mechanism, introduced on July 17 to replace the previous weekly review system. The change was made in response to volatility in international oil markets and concerns about fuel supplies amid the conflict involving the United States, Israel and Iran. Earlier this month, the government announced an arrangement requiring domestic oil refineries to absorb approximately Rs15 billion in monthly costs, allowing petrol to be sold at Rs15 per litre below international market levels. The government has also introduced targeted fuel subsidies to reduce the financial burden on lower-income consumers. Under a relief programme announced by Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif in September, eligible motorcycle owners, three-wheeler operators and motorists using cars with engines of up to 800cc were offered a subsidy of Rs100 per litre. The scheme was designed to cover approximately 11.8 million beneficiaries, including 10 million motorcycle users, 800,000 threewheeler operators and one million small-car owners. Motorcycle and three-wheeler users were allocated subsidised fuel on up to 20 litres per month, providing maximum monthly relief of Rs2,000.

Govt spends only Rs104b of Rs1tr development budget in four months PROFIT STAFF REPORT

Pakistan's development spending reached just Rs103.876 billion during the first four months of FY2027, accounting for 10.4% of the Rs1 trillion federal Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP), despite the government authorising Rs412.294 billion for development projects. According to data released by the Ministry of Planning, Development and Special Initiatives on Tuesday, the authorised amount represented 41.2% of the annual PSDP allocation, while actual expenditure accounted for approximately 25.2% of the funds authorised during July–October 2026. The federal development budget includes Rs682.485 billion for ministries and divisions, Rs312.515 billion for corporations, Rs4 billion for project liabilities and Rs1 billion for new initiatives under the

7:00

China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) 2.0. Among federal ministries and divisions, the Water Resources Division received the highest authorisation of Rs90.804 billion against its annual allocation of Rs103.086 billion. However, actual spending stood at Rs18.726 billion. The Cabinet Division was allocated Rs64.080 billion, of which Rs60.378 billion was authorised, while expenditure remained at Rs59.99 million. For provinces and special areas, the government authorised Rs59.796 billion against an allocation of Rs233.386 billion, with Rs23.808 billion spent during the period. The Railways Division utilised Rs4.655 billion against authorised funds of Rs14.230 billion and an annual allocation of Rs40.658 billion. The Higher Education Commission (HEC) spent Rs4.715 billion out of Rs13.800 billion authorised against its Rs46

billion allocation, while the Federal Education and Professional Training Division utilised Rs6.877 billion against authorised funds of Rs12.709 billion and an allocation of Rs36.312 billion. The National Health Services, Regulations and Coordination Division recorded expenditure of Rs6.609 billion against Rs9.639 billion authorised, with an annual allocation of Rs16.065 billion. Meanwhile, the Planning, Development and Special Initiatives Division spent Rs2.152 billion against Rs6.788 billion authorised from its Rs22.626 billion allocation. The Information Technology and Telecommunication Division, which has an annual allocation of Rs19.580 billion, including Rs9.801 billion in foreign assistance, spent Rs1.450 billion against Rs5.874 billion authorised. The Interior Division utilised Rs714.21 million against Rs6.547 billion authorised,

while the Housing and Works Division spent Rs422.90 million against authorised funds of Rs1.918 billion. Among corporations, the National Highway Authority (NHA) recorded expenditure of Rs13.296 billion against Rs78.580 billion authorised. Its annual allocation stands at Rs224.515 billion, including Rs59.250 billion in foreign assistance. Power sector entities NTDC and PEPCO spent Rs15.925 billion against Rs30.800 billion authorised, with an annual allocation of Rs88 billion, including Rs76.608 billion in foreign assistance. Other ministries and divisions also recorded relatively limited spending during the four-month period. The Defence Division utilised Rs462.10 million against Rs2.816 billion authorised from its Rs10.903 billion allocation, while the Revenue Division spent Rs366.61 million against Rs3.471 billion authorised from

Published by Asad Nizami at Plot # 7, Al-Baber Centre, F/8 Markaz, Islamabad, for PT Print (Pvt) Limited. Ph: 051-2204545. Email: newsroom@pakistantoday.com.pk

its Rs11.570 billion allocation. The Industries and Production Division recorded expenditure of Rs649.03 million against Rs2.330 billion authorised, while the National Food Security and Research Division spent Rs64.94 million against Rs1.352 billion authorised. The Science and Technological Research Division utilised Rs154.89 million against Rs1.070 billion authorised, and the Information and Broadcasting Division spent Rs42.58 million against Rs471.61 million authorised. The Climate Change and Environmental Coordination Division recorded spending of Rs259.19 million against Rs667.22 million authorised, while the Law and Justice Division utilised Rs109.87 million against Rs841.05 million authorised. The Maritime Affairs Division spent Rs138.72 million against authorised funds of Rs623 million during July–October FY2027.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook