Skip to main content

Trust Alliance Group CAM Report 2023

Page 1


CAM2023 Consumer Action Monitor

Introduction

Trust: firm belief in the reliability, truth, or ability of someone or something.

Following a global pandemic, and now feeling the effects of an economic crisis, plus political instability, it’s understandable that the UK currently has a trust problem. Trust is in short supply, and it remains vital to sustainable consumer relationships. Building that trust back up now is critical and is wholly dependent on a company’s ability to strengthen that bond and start to display transparency, honesty, and dependability.

As part of the newly formed Trust Alliance Group’s (TAG) purpose of building and maintaining trust between consumers and businesses, we want to develop new capabilities to help tackle consumer detriment, including developing greater technological and data capabilities that will help us better support the consumer journey.

We support consumers and businesses independently and fairly without favouritism or discrimination by…

• striving to have a deeper understanding of consumer behaviour

• helping suppliers improve service, change culture, and build confidence

• helping industries resolve systemic industry-wide issues

• using technology and analysing data to improve services and reduce detriment

Now in its ninth year, the Consumer Action Monitor (CAM), the most comprehensive multisector survey of its kind in the UK, provides an ongoing measure of consumer opinion from a robust and representative sample of 4,000+ consumers in England, Scotland, and Wales, twice a year.

Focussing on three key areas: consumer trust, behaviour and their understanding and feelings towards the green agenda, this year’s edition highlights topics such as the decrease in trust in the energy and communications sector, the change in customer service since pre-pandemic times, the reasons for consumer complaints and the expectations after making one, and the responsibility to achieve net zero.

CAM provides invaluable insight into consumer feelings and trends in behaviour and our hope is that this report will help us deliver more effective services in the future. Consumers will always be at the heart of TAG’s business, and we’ll continue to invest in improvements to our systems, processes, and services, with the aim to build that trust and confidence again.

Methodology & audience breakdown

Methodology

Now in its ninth year, the Consumer Action Monitor provides an ongoing measure of consumer opinion from a robust and representative sample of 4,000+ UK consumers in England, Scotland and Wales, twice a year. Research is carried out via a mixed-mode online and telephone approach to ensure a robust and representative sample of consumers.

Each wave of the Consumer Action Monitor, a quota sampling approach is used to survey a representative sample of adults in England, Scotland and Wales, with data weighted to be reflective of the overall population. Our overall sample size of 4,346 for November 2022 has a 95% confidence interval of +/-1.5%.

Note: As this survey cannot be claimed to be purely random, significance testing is indicative only. The report commentary throughout therefore refers to where a figure might, indicatively, be statistically different from other subgroups of the wider population.

Socioeconomic group

Trust

We live in a world of unprecedented change. People, businesses, and the industry bodies that govern us, are being challenged from all sides. In this fast-changing and challenging world, trust is critically important. But trust between individuals, between people and businesses, and trust in those who govern and regulate us, is under threat.

Something needs to be done to repair, protect and build it.

Trust in companies

Over the last two years, the proportion of consumers who say that they trust energy suppliers, broadband providers and mobile networks less is on the rise.

Trust in companies to treat consumers fairly

Three quarters of consumers say that they trust their mobile network, two thirds trust their broadband provider, while just over half trust their energy supplier to treat them fairly. Trust in energy companies has declined significantly over the last two years.

Low levels of trust in energy suppliers are much more marked amongst younger consumers , with just 43% of 18-24’s trusting their supplier compared to 73% consumers aged 75+.

% who trust companies to treat consumers fairly

Reasons for complaint

For energy suppliers, broadband providers and mobile networks, price rises are a top reason for complaining. Poor service and connectivity issues also drive a large number of complaints.

Organisations made a complaint to in last six months

Over a quarter of consumers have made a complaint to their energy, mobile or broadband provider in the six months prior to taking part in this research.

% complaining to organisations in last six months

Change in customer service since pre-pandemic

Significantly more consumers believe customer service is worse than pre-pandemic than those who think it is better. This is especially true for energy suppliers, with over a quarter thinking that customer service is worse now than before the pandemic.

Change in customer service

Complaint behaviour

As well as exploring perceptions of energy suppliers, broadband providers and mobile networks, the Consumer Action Monitor provides an ongoing measure of broader consumer complaint behaviour and attitudes towards complaining.

Over the past two years, the proportion of consumers who have thought about, or actively made a complaint, is on the rise. In the latest wave of the survey, six in ten consumers have at least thought about making a complaint, with four in ten making a complaint, including 13 percent who took their complaint to a third party.

Proportion making a complaint at each level

Base: All respondents (4,346). Q. would like you to think about situations during the pandemic over the last 12 months when you did, or could have, complained about a product or

Mean number of complaints per person in last 12 months

Following a drop in complaints at the height of the pandemic, numbers have steadily risen since June 2021, with consumers making an average of 3.4 complaints per year in the latest wave.

Those with a higher number of complaints per person are:

• Younger people

• Ethnic minorities

• Higher SEG’s

• Higher levels of education

• Living in London

• Confident internet users

Those with a lower number of complaints per person are:

• Older people (45+)

• Retired people

• Lower SEGs

• People in North East England

• Unconfident internet users

Reasons to avoid complaining

Among those who thought about complaining about a product or service over the past two years, the main reason for not taking it further was the perceived hassle. The perception that it is not worth the hassle is on the rise.

Reason for not taking complaint further

Not worth the hassle

Given amount paid, not worth the time

Couldn’t be bothered Not serious complaint

Impossible to get through to companies

There is no point

Willing to be more lenient due to Covid-19

Don’t trust companies to put things right

Got a satisfactory answer

Base: All thinking about complaining (2,251) Q. You mentioned that you thought about complaining or spoke to family/friend about a complaint but did not take it any further. Why did you not take your complaint any further than this?

Taking legal action would be too expensive Legal action too daunting & no other route

While the mean number of complaints per person is highest amongst younger people, consumer apathy is significantly higher amongst those who have faced issues but decided not to complain.

‘I couldn’t be bothered’ as a reason for not complaining (by age)

Third-party complaints

Thirteen per cent of consumers had taken a complaint to a third party, with social media being the main route used to complain, followed by an Ombudsman. The proportion of consumers taking their complaint through the courts is at the lowest point in the last two years.

As we might expect, younger consumers are more vocal about their complaints on social media than older people (56% of 18–24’s vs. 10% of those aged 65+).

Social media

An Ombudsman Another organisation An ADR supplier

The Small Claims Court

Base: All complaining to a third party (594) Q. You mentioned that you took a complaint to a third party. Which third party did you take the complaint(s) to? Government department was not asked for previous waves.

Media to tell my story

Expectations as a result of complaint

If a consumer receives poor service from a provider or suppliers, as a minimum, they expect an apology and reassurance it will not happen again.

Receiving an apology

Receiving reassurance that steps would be taken to prevent this happening again

An improved service

Receiving financial compensation for any losses

Receiving financial compensation for any inconvenience

To be able to express your frustration at the situation

To know that this would not happen to anyone else

Perception of complaining & customer service

Getting customer service and complaint handling right has a significant impact on perception of products and service providers.

Four in five (82%) say that a well-handled complaint increases their loyalty.

Furthermore, there are high expectations of products and service providers with 82% saying it should not be difficult to get a product or service right first time

and a further 79% saying they want to hold businesses to account for poor customer service.

Consumers are not necessarily seeking financial remuneration (just 23% agreeing this means a successful outcome) but the amount of investment in an item does dictate whether a complaint is likely to be made or not for half (56%).

The expense of an item determines whether I complain or not

The idea of complaining fills you with dread

Would not really know where to take a complaint if it wasn’t sorted by supplier/provider

Complaining is a waste of time

Should not be hard to get a product or service right first time

Want to hold businesses to account for poor customer service

Expect more of companies than in the past

AI should allow companies to predict and act on my complaint without further consumer involvement

Complaint is only successful if you come out financially ahead

A well-handled complaint increases my loyalty to a product or service provider

Companies take too long to resolve issues

You can only get a result from a complaint if you kick up a big fuss

Expect an instant response if you complain

Politicians should hold energy & broadband suppliers to account for poor service

Politicians don’t care enough about consumer rights

Legal system favours big companies/companies act as though they are above the law

Don’t trust Ombudsmen to do the right thing/ don’t trust they can be truly independent

Four in five (79%) agree that politicians should hold energy suppliers and broadband providers to account. At the same time, over three quarters of consumers (78%) agree that politicians don’t care enough about consumer rights, an increase from 63% in November 2021.

Base: All respondents (4,346). Q. Thinking generally about compliant situations, to what extent do you agree or disagree with each of the following statements?

Base: All respondents (4,346) Q. Which of the following best describes the minimum you would expect to happen if you received poor service from a company?

The green agenda

In this section we explore issues related to the green agenda, including the importance of utility providers green credentials, responsibility to achieve Net Zero and attitudes towards electric and hybrid vehicles.

Importance of utility providers green credentials

The majority of consumers believe it is important for organisations to be as environmentally friendly as possible.% of consumers saying is important for each sector.

Women are significantly more likely than men to say that green credentials are important.

% of consumers saying is important for each sector

Familiarity with Net Zero

Six in ten consumers (60%) have heard of the term Net Zero and know what it means, but just seventeen percent know exactly what it means.

I have not heard of it

I have heard it but don’t know what it means

I have heard it & know a little about what it means

I have heard it & know exactly what it means

Base: All respondents (4,043)

Base:
(4,346).

Know at least a little about what Net Zero means

Male consumers are significantly more likely to claim to know ‘at least a little’ about what Net Zero means, as are older consumers. Younger consumers and those in rented accommodation are the least likely to know what the term Net Zero means.

Responsibility to achieve Net Zero

Consumers believe that government, businesses and individuals all have a responsibility to achieve Net Zero. Six in ten feel that the government has the primary responsibility to achieve Net Zero.

Younger consumers are more likely to place the onus on the government to achieve Net Zero than older consumers.

Older consumers are more likely than younger consumers to place the onus on individuals.

Whose responsibility do you think it is to achieve Net Zero?

Electric & hybrid vehicle status

One in five consumers surveyed have or are currently considering switching to an electric or hybrid vehicle. Just over half would consider it in the future, including 28% who are held back by affordability. One in five (19%) say that they would never consider having one.

Barriers to owning electric & hybrid vehicle

The main barrier to owning an EV is the perceived cost and concerns over the charging infrastructure that would be available to them.

Already have one

Currently considering

Considering, but they are currently unaffordable

Was considering switching but rising electricity costs have changed my mind

Not considering switching at the moment, but might in the future

Would never have one

Don’t know

I am considering switching to one

Perhaps linked to the cost-of-living crisis, the proportion of consumers who are currently considering switching to an electric or hybrid vehicle has fallen over the last two years.

% considering (over time)

Older consumers are the most likely to outright reject owning a hybrid or electric vehicle.

% would never have one (by age)

Costs associated with buying/ leasing electric/hybrid vehicles

Cost of charging vehicle at home

Concerns around where to charge on the go (away from home)

Cost of charging vehicle on the go

Concerns around the volume of charging points

Time taken to recharge on the go

Costs associated with maintenance /running an electric /hybrid vehicle

Process of installing charging kit at home

Time taken to recharge at home

Process of paying for charging on the go

Process of setting up electric vehicle electricity supply tariff at home

Unable to get a charger fitted at home

I don’t need a new vehicle

Lack of clarity about who to go to when things go wrong

Lack of clear and consolidated information around owning an electric/hybrid vehicle

Base: All excluding those happy with/no opinion of EV (3,645). Q. What are the key barriers to switching to an electric/hybrid vehicle?

Base: All respondents Q. Electric & hybrid vehicles are becoming more popular in the UK. Which statement best describes your opinion?

Summary

The key objective for CAM is to continuously monitor consumer attitudes to complaining and how these influence trust in key suppliers. Historically we have used this information to influence how we can better support consumers who need to use our services but equally how we can support suppliers to improve their service levels and embed this trust.

This year’s report has therefore taken a step change and now includes :

Consumer Attitudes to Complaining and Trust

Having dropped to their lowest levels since the CAM report began in 2014, complaint volumes seem to have increased back to the levels experienced pre 2020. With Covid being the only explanation, we are now monitoring this on a monthly basis to identify whether other factors can influence consumer behaviour.

Despite this increase, only 70% of consumers would complain to their supplier if they had received poor service. The silent minority should definitely be cause for concern.

Among those who did consider complaining, the hassle factor was by far the most common reason for not doing so and, of those that did take their complaint to a third party, only 27% had taken a complaint to an ombudsman, with social media still being the most popular channel. We also believe that work still needs to be done on better signposting for the 34% who wouldn’t know where to take a complaint if it wasn’t sorted by their supplier.

Trust in companies has remained relatively stable as has the attitude that a well-handled complaint increases loyalty. With the majority of consumers claiming that the minimum they would expect is an apology and a reassurance that the experience won’t be repeated, it demonstrates the need for open and easy to use channels of communication.

Covid-19

The majority (53%) of consumers felt the pandemic made it harder to complain and get customer service. Notably this was the experience of those with a disability more than those without.

Whilst the majority of organisations performed well in supporting consumers throughout the pandemic, 15% of respondents felt that their energy provider has underperformed in this area, as well as 12% feeling this way about their broadband provider

There was a clear indication that consumers expected faster complaint resolutions with more nstant responses to their enquiries (55%). There was a significant uplift in the belief that the eight week rule for resolving complaints before escalation was fair compared to last year which could indicate that the pandemic has increased an attitude of leniency in consumers Less affluent socio economic groups were more accepting of the response timescales than those of more affluent groups and men were marginally less patient with the timescale than women.

Continued monitoring of the impact of Covid-19 and, with restrictions starting to lift, a review of the overall impact it had.

More insight into green issues, in particular some of the key factors that influence us all today.

Improved demographics to support our focus on increasing our consumer reach to ensure that our services are accessible to all.

Improved profiling of consumers as persona groups that will help us and suppliers to improve trust levels in the market.

The Green Agenda and Net Zero

One of the most significant changes highlighted in this report was the significant increase in the importance of providers’ green credentials. Unsurprisingly, consumers felt that Energy suppliers’ commitment to the environment was of highest importance (84%), with mobile and broadband providers at 74%.

There was a surprising lack of understanding around the term ‘net zero’ with only 11% of consumers fully understanding the term. There is clearly a need for education in this area as 63% stated that they had heard of ‘net zero’ but didn’t understand it.

When it came down to the crunch, it was clear that the majority of consumers considered the financial implications as the main reason for not upgrading to an electric vehicle or upgrading their heating system to be more green

Demographic trends

This year we have gained a far better understanding of how a consumer’s demographics might impact their attitude towards complaining.

We now understand that those with a higher number of complaints per person tend to include younger people, ethnic minorities, higher socio-economic groups, those with a higher level of education and those who are confident internet users.

Men are more likely to seek financial compensation and women display a greater sense of social consciousness in their hopes that poor service would not be experienced by others as a result of their complaint.

Men prefer to use the phone to make a complaint 8% more than women, 10% more share this preference from Black ethnicities than white. Women are an average of 27% more comfortable with email and webchat than their male counterparts.

This demographic information has been used to evolve our consumer personas from those identified following the 2020 survey. We will use these in conjunction with our new ways of working to ensure that consumers stay at the centre of everything that we do. We will also take learnings from the survey to make our services more accessible.

Research conducted and report designed by DJS Research.

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Trust Alliance Group CAM Report 2023 by Trust Alliance Group - Issuu